Skip to content

verification-issue-16.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
50 lines (38 loc) · 2.11 KB

verification-issue-16.md

File metadata and controls

50 lines (38 loc) · 2.11 KB

Verification Report — PR #19 (docs/issue-16-readme)

Result

REQUEST_CHANGES

Checklist

1) git diff main...docs/issue-16-readme --stat

README.md                                | 197 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-
scaffold/pm-api/src/mcp-tools/standup.ts |  57 ++++++++-
scaffold/pm-api/src/mcp.ts               |  22 +++-
scaffold/pm-api/src/routes/v2-standup.ts |  57 ++++++++-
4 files changed, 323 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-)

2) Verify all 5 CLI commands documented

  • init ✅
  • hydrate ✅
  • deploy ✅
  • migrate ✅
  • doctor ✅

All 5 are documented in README command reference and expanded command details.

3) Verify --platform option documented

  • --platform=<id> is documented in Options ✅
  • Dedicated --platform section with supported IDs (claude-code, codex, gemini) ✅
  • Usage examples provided ✅

4) Only README.md modified (no code changes)

FAILED ❌

Files changed include non-doc code files:

  • scaffold/pm-api/src/mcp-tools/standup.ts
  • scaffold/pm-api/src/mcp.ts
  • scaffold/pm-api/src/routes/v2-standup.ts

So this is not a README-only/docs-only PR.

5) 3+ potential issues

  1. Scope violation (blocking): PR includes 3 non-README source code files, conflicting with the stated purpose (“README docs update for issue-16”).
  2. Reviewability risk: Mixing docs expansion and runtime code changes in one PR makes validation and rollback harder (docs issue should be isolated or code should be moved to separate PR).
  3. Troubleshooting platform inconsistency: Troubleshooting section says “Restart Claude Code” in MCP context, while README now supports multi-platform adapters (codex, gemini). Guidance should be platform-neutral or include alternatives.
  4. Potential over-assertion in migrations troubleshooting: “duplicate column/already exists is expected and safe to ignore” can hide real migration faults if error cause is not actually idempotency-related; wording should be more guarded.

6) APPROVE or REQUEST_CHANGES

REQUEST_CHANGES

Primary blocker: requirement #4 failed (non-README files modified).