Skip to content

milestone has no edit/rename — parity gap with issue update / knowledge edit (renaming forces delete+recreate, which renumbers) #79

Description

@magnificentlycursed

The gap

crosslink milestone supports create / list / show / add / remove / close / delete — but has no edit/rename. This is a parity gap, not a design stance: crosslink edits in place everywhere else —

  • crosslink issue update --title … --description … --priority … (issue rename is first-class)
  • crosslink knowledge edit (updates a page in place)

Only milestones can't be corrected in place. The sole CLI path to fix a milestone's title is delete + recreate, which (a) renumbers — breaking any ordinal id mapping a consumer maintains — and (b) drops the milestone's attached issues.

Consumer instance

Our estate maps milestone ids to a clean build-ordinal sequence: #7 = Engine, #8 = Slice 1, … #14 = Slice 7. Milestone #14 is mislabeled — "Slice 7 — The cost crate", where the cost crate was retired and the slice is now "the efficiency insight engine". It's empty (0/0), so there's nothing to lose to a recreate — but a recreate lands Slice 7 at #15 with a #14 gap, trading a cosmetic label-wrong for a structural-numbering-wrong. So the correct fix (retitle in place) isn't reachable, and we're deferring the rename rather than disturb the sequence.

Generic primitive

Any consumer will occasionally need to correct a milestone's title or description — a typo, a scope re-name, a retired term — without disturbing its id or its attached issues. That's exactly the in-place edit issue update and knowledge edit already provide; milestones should have the same.

Shape ask (mechanism yours)

A crosslink milestone edit <id> --title <…> [--description <…>] (or update/rename), mirroring the issue update pattern — id and attached issues preserved. Whether it's edit, update, or rename is yours.

Filed by the vsdd-cli estate as a generic primitive per our raise discipline; shape-tier.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions