From 5217d5f38d1edc61953b447da0301bb63f417b86 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: mozi Date: Sun, 18 Oct 2026 02:03:50 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] Bound gravity-only witnesses for dark matter (issue 3) --- CORRECTIONS.md | 5 +++++ README.md | 6 ++++-- notes/gravity-witnesses.md | 37 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ tests/checks.mjs | 14 +++++++++++++- witness-map/model.js | 16 +++++++++++++++- 5 files changed, 74 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) create mode 100644 notes/gravity-witnesses.md diff --git a/CORRECTIONS.md b/CORRECTIONS.md index d32c28f..3148313 100644 --- a/CORRECTIONS.md +++ b/CORRECTIONS.md @@ -15,3 +15,8 @@ Claims made during the exploration that did not survive it, kept so the record s checking the grain size. 4. **"Within a factor of 3" of the Joos–Zeh table.** Stated for all three environments. Sunlight is within a factor of 4.4; the afterglow and air are within 3. + +5. **"Dark matter has no witnesses at any gap or particle mass."** Too strong. It holds for wave (fuzzy, + ~1e-22 eV) dark matter, which has no gravity-only witnesses besides a black hole horizon. For particle + (~100 GeV) dark matter, gravitational scattering off passing stars is a strong witness at kpc gaps + (W ~ 10^42), so heavy dark matter superpositions cannot persist across galactic scales. Issue 3. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 739a9c0..5dbdbcd 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -56,8 +56,10 @@ What it shows: 1. The four objects seen acting as waves in experiments all land on the wave side. 2. Mass enters through the wave clock. Silence the witnesses and big things can cross: a virus in a 4 K vacuum scores W ≈ 0.04. -3. Dark matter has no witnesses at any gap or particle mass, which is part of what makes a galaxy-sized - dark matter wave possible. +3. Wave (fuzzy) dark matter has no witnesses at any gap, which is part of what makes a galaxy-sized + dark matter wave possible. Particle (heavy, ~100 GeV) dark matter is different: at kpc separations + stellar gravitational scattering is a strong witness (W ~ 10^42), so heavy dark matter + superpositions cannot persist across galactic scales. See notes/gravity-witnesses.md. 4. A black hole horizon is a real witness (Danielson, Satishchandran and Wald, 2022) but a feeble one: ten horizon radii from the Milky Way's black hole, a wave dark matter particle split by 1 µm waits about 10¹⁷⁰ years to be recorded. diff --git a/notes/gravity-witnesses.md b/notes/gravity-witnesses.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ba3ca65 --- /dev/null +++ b/notes/gravity-witnesses.md @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +# Gravity-only witnesses for dark matter (issue 3) + +Dark matter's only witness in the model is a black hole horizon. What other +gravity-only witnesses exist, and how strong are they? + +## Candidates and bounds + +1. **Gravitational scattering off passing stars and gas clouds.** A passing mass M + at impact parameter b imprints a phase `dphi = G M m dx / (hbar v b)` on a + particle of mass m superposed by dx. Integrating over encounters (saturated + where phase >= 1) gives a rate. For the solar neighbourhood + (n ~ 0.1 pc^-3 stars, M ~ 1 Msun, v ~ 200 km/s, out to ~1 kpc): + + - Fuzzy (wave) dark matter, m = 1e-22 eV: W ~ 10^-7 at a 1 kpc gap, ~10^-62 + at 1 um. Negligible. The "no witnesses" claim holds for wave dark matter. + - Particle (WIMP) dark matter, m = 100 GeV: W ~ 10^42 at a 1 kpc gap. + Stellar gravity is a strong witness at galactic scales; heavy dark matter + superpositions cannot persist across kpc separations. + + Gas clouds (GMCs) give comparable or smaller rates. + +2. **Soft graviton emission without a horizon.** A particle in a superposition + is not accelerating in the sense needed for gravitational radiation; any + emission rate scales as G m^2 omega^3 / (hbar c^5) with omega ~ hbar/(m dx^2), + which is astronomically small for both masses. Negligible. + +3. **Tidal fields of the galaxy.** A classical tidal field is a c-number: it + does not become entangled with the particle and records no which-path + information. Only quantized (graviton) tides would, which is case 2. + Negligible as a witness. + +## Conclusion + +Only stellar gravitational scattering matters, and only for particle (heavy) +dark matter at galactic (kpc) separations. Wave (fuzzy) dark matter retains +no gravity-only witnesses besides a black hole horizon, so the model's "dark +matter has no witnesses" statement applies to wave dark matter specifically. diff --git a/tests/checks.mjs b/tests/checks.mjs index 367ce69..068feba 100644 --- a/tests/checks.mjs +++ b/tests/checks.mjs @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ import { createRequire } from 'node:module'; const require = createRequire(import.meta.url); const W = require('../witness-map/model.js'); -const { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, BH_M, RS } = W; +const { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, gravScatter, BH_M, RS } = W; let fails = 0; const fmt = x => (x === 0 ? '0' : x.toExponential(2)); @@ -55,5 +55,17 @@ check('Dark matter has no witnesses without a black hole', ['fdm', 'wimp'].every check('Planck integral gives the CMB photon density', Math.abs(planckIntegral(2.725, 1, () => 1) / 4.11e8 - 1) < 0.02, `n = ${fmt(planckIntegral(2.725, 1, () => 1))} per m^3 (expected 4.11e8)`, 'standard value, 411 per cm^3'); +// 6. Gravity-only witnesses for dark matter (issue 3): stellar gravitational scattering. +const starN = 0.1 / Math.pow(3.086e16, 3); +const fdmG = gravScatter(1.78e-58, C.kpc, starN, C.Msun, 2e5, C.kpc); +check('Fuzzy dark matter (1e-22 eV): gravity witnesses negligible at 1 kpc', fdmG.W < 1, + `W = ${fmt(fdmG.W)} from stellar scattering`, 'model (issue 3)'); +const wimpG = gravScatter(1.78e-25, C.kpc, starN, C.Msun, 2e5, C.kpc); +check('Particle dark matter (100 GeV): stellar gravity is a witness at 1 kpc', wimpG.W > 1, + `W = ${fmt(wimpG.W)} from stellar scattering`, 'model (issue 3)'); +const fdmGsmall = gravScatter(1.78e-58, 1e-6, starN, C.Msun, 2e5, C.kpc); +check('Fuzzy dark matter (1e-22 eV): gravity witnesses negligible at 1 um', fdmGsmall.W < 1, + `W = ${fmt(fdmGsmall.W)} from stellar scattering`, 'model (issue 3)'); + console.log(fails ? `\n${fails} check(s) failed` : '\nall checks pass'); process.exit(fails ? 1 : 0); diff --git a/witness-map/model.js b/witness-map/model.js index ec76670..13e6e08 100644 --- a/witness-map/model.js +++ b/witness-map/model.js @@ -101,7 +101,21 @@ const tWave = o.m * dx * dx / C.hbar; return { parts, gamma, tWave, tau: 1 / gamma, W: gamma * tWave, bhNote }; } + // Gravity-only witness for a dark matter particle superposed by dx: gravitational scattering off + // passing masses M (density n, speed v), out to bmax. Phase per encounter at impact b: + // dphi = G M m dx / (hbar v b). info = 1 when b <= bsat (= phase 1) or in the strong regime + // (b <= G M / v^2); otherwise (dphi)^2, integrated logarithmically. + function gravScatter(m, dx, n, M, v, bmax) { + const bsat = C.G * M * m * dx / (C.hbar * v); + const bstrong = C.G * M / (v * v); + const satEnd = Math.min(Math.max(bsat, bstrong), bmax); + const sat = Math.PI * n * v * satEnd * satEnd; + const log = (satEnd < bmax) ? (2 * Math.PI * n * (C.G * M * m * dx) * (C.G * M * m * dx) / (C.hbar * C.hbar * v)) * Math.log(bmax / satEnd) : 0; + const gamma = sat + log; + const tWave = m * dx * dx / C.hbar; + return { gamma, tWave, W: gamma * tWave, bsat, bstrong }; + } const BH_M = 4.3e6 * C.Msun, RS = 2 * C.G * BH_M / (C.c * C.c); - const api = { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, BH_M, RS, DEFAULT_LOG_GAP: Math.log10(2.5e-7) }; + const api = { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, gravScatter, BH_M, RS, DEFAULT_LOG_GAP: Math.log10(2.5e-7) }; if (typeof module !== 'undefined' && module.exports) module.exports = api; else root.WM = api; })(typeof window !== 'undefined' ? window : globalThis);