diff --git a/.github/workflows/test.yml b/.github/workflows/test.yml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..315280d --- /dev/null +++ b/.github/workflows/test.yml @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +name: test + +on: + push: + branches: [main] + pull_request: + +permissions: + contents: read + +concurrency: + group: ${{ github.workflow }}-${{ github.ref }} + cancel-in-progress: true + +jobs: + test: + runs-on: ubuntu-latest + strategy: + matrix: + node-version: [18, 20, 22] + steps: + - uses: actions/checkout@3d3c42e5aac5ba805825da76410c181273ba90b1 # v7.0.1 + - uses: actions/setup-node@949feb2413d6458794dcd2491c4babbbce0c15c1 # v7.1.0 + with: + node-version: ${{ matrix.node-version }} + - run: npm test + - run: node witness-map/table.mjs + - run: node witness-map/table.mjs 1e-6 cryo + - run: node notes/bh-lensing.mjs diff --git a/CORRECTIONS.md b/CORRECTIONS.md index da1ee6a..c2798e7 100644 --- a/CORRECTIONS.md +++ b/CORRECTIONS.md @@ -72,3 +72,35 @@ Claims made during the exploration that did not survive it, kept so the record s 11. **Not consulted.** Schlosshauer's 2007 book and Joos and Zeh's 1985 paper were not available. The comparisons use Schlosshauer's own open copies of his book's timescale table (2014, 2019) and four copies of the 1985 table by Joos and by Kiefer. Anything in the book that is not in those copies is unchecked. + +## 16 October 2026: the gravitational atom (issue #4) + +12. **Atoms as little solar systems.** Claimed (README, and issue #4): "Atoms are not little solar systems ... Except + in one case, where they are", the one place where that picture "becomes literally true". Too strong. In the + gravitational atom the light particles form a wave cloud with hydrogen's shapes and levels; nothing in it moves + on an orbit. What carries over from a solar system is the force, gravity, and for a heavy hole the size: in + Baumann, Chia and Porto's 2019 example the 211 cloud is most likely found 1.4 AU out. The README now says + gravity builds a real atom. +13. **"The same energy levels as a hydrogen atom."** Means the same pattern, falling as 1/n², not the same + energies. In the same example the levels are 2×10¹⁹ times closer together than hydrogen's, and the pattern + holds only to leading order in α: there the first correction to the 211 level is −11%, against about 10⁻⁵ in + hydrogen. + +## 16 October 2026: the crowd wave (issue #2) + +14. **Dark matter's missing witnesses and the galaxy-sized wave.** Claimed (README and page): having no witnesses + "is part of what makes a galaxy-sized dark matter wave possible". Too strong, and it points the wrong way. The + galaxy-sized wave is a crowd, about 10⁹³ particles to each lump of the wave near the Sun for a 10⁻²² eV + particle, acting as one classical wave. Its lumps, about 10⁵ Suns each, are recorded by every star they pass, + through gravity. The wave survives because recording a classical wave does not erase it, not because nothing + watches it. What the per-particle result does say is that nothing knocks single particles out of the wave. + See "The crowd wave" in the README. + +## 16 October 2026: black hole and wave dark matter lensing (issue #1) + +15. **Superradiance as a second route.** Issue #1 said a spinning black hole amplifying very light particles into a + cloud was not ruled out as a way for a galaxy's central black hole to shape wave dark matter where lensing looks. + For a 10⁻²² eV particle and a 10⁸ to 10⁹ M☉ black hole it is ruled out: the cloud would take 10²⁶ to 10³⁴ years + to grow, and at its radius the galaxy, not the black hole, holds the particles. Any cloud these black holes can + grow within the age of the universe, at any particle mass, peaks within about 0.1 pc. See + [notes/bh-lensing.md](notes/bh-lensing.md). diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 8af79ae..943d87f 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -12,10 +12,11 @@ with Claude (Anthropic), for [Foundation0](https://github.com/Foundation-0/f0). - **Atoms are not little solar systems.** An electron does not follow an orbit; it has a spread of possible positions, and that spread does not shrink with better instruments. Planets show nothing like it. The two follow different equations. -- **Except in one case, where they are.** Very light particles around a spinning black hole settle into - a cloud with the same energy levels as a hydrogen atom, with gravity in place of electric attraction - (the "gravitational atom"). The same equation, a wave held by a pull that weakens with distance, gives - the same solution at any scale. The nesting lives in the equations, not the objects. +- **Except in one case, where gravity builds a real atom.** Very light particles around a spinning black + hole settle into a cloud with the same shapes and the same pattern of energy levels as a hydrogen atom, + with gravity in place of electric attraction (the "gravitational atom"). It is still a wave cloud, not + planets on orbits. The same equation, a wave held by a pull that weakens with distance, gives the same + solution at any scale. The nesting lives in the equations, not the objects. - **Quantum paths are fractal.** A free quantum particle's path has fractal dimension 2, against 1 for a classical trajectory (Abbott and Wise, 1981), the same roughness as a pollen grain jostled by molecules. - **Cosmic structure is fractal only up to a point.** Galaxies cluster in a fractal-like way on small @@ -56,25 +57,139 @@ What it shows: 1. The four objects seen acting as waves in experiments all land on the wave side. 2. Mass enters through the wave clock. Silence the witnesses and big things can cross: a virus in a 4 K vacuum scores W ≈ 0.04. -3. Dark matter has no witnesses at any gap or particle mass, which is part of what makes a galaxy-sized - dark matter wave possible. +3. A lone dark matter particle has no witnesses at any gap or particle mass. That is a statement about one + particle. The galaxy-sized wave of wave dark matter is a crowd, and its lumps are watched by every star they + pass (see [The crowd wave](#the-crowd-wave-where-the-map-stops) below). 4. A black hole horizon is a real witness (Danielson, Satishchandran and Wald, 2022) but a feeble one: ten horizon radii from the Milky Way's black hole, a wave dark matter particle split by 1 µm waits about 10¹⁷⁰ years to be recorded. Interactive version: **https://foundation-0.github.io/fractals/** (`index.html` at the root of this repository, served by GitHub Pages; it loads `witness-map/model.js` directly). +## The crowd wave: where the map stops + +The map asks about one particle at a time. Wave dark matter in a galaxy is never one particle. If its particle +weighs 10⁻²² eV, each lump of the wave near the Sun is shared by about 10⁹³ particles. So many particles in one +wave act together as an ordinary (classical) wave, the way countless photons make one radio wave (Hui, Ostriker, +Tremaine and Witten 2017). The crowd keeps its own clocks. + +**The lumps.** The wave interferes with itself into lumps (granules), seen in simulated halos (Schive, Chiueh and +Broadhurst 2014; Schive et al. 2014). For particle mass m and speed spread σ, the density is correlated over +ƛ = ħ/(mσ) (Bar-Or, Fouvry and Tremaine 2019, eq. 62), and a lump is about half a de Broglie wavelength, πħ/(mσ), +across (Hui et al. 2017). Each lump pulls like one body of mass π^(3/2)·ρ·ƛ³, where ρ is the local density +(Bar-Or et al. 2019, eq. 59). + +**Three clocks.** + +1. *Lump lifetime, ħ/(mσ²).* The lumps fade and re-form as parts of the wave drift past each other. The density + at a point forgets itself on this time (Bar-Or et al. 2019, eq. 62), and simulations measure the same + (Veltmaat, Niemeyer and Schwabe 2018). It is exactly the map's wave clock at a gap of ƛ: m·ƛ²/ħ = ħ/(mσ²). +2. *The core's beat.* At a halo's centre the wave settles into one standing wave, the core or soliton (Schive, + Chiueh and Broadhurst 2014). Its wave turns over every 2πħ/|E|, where E is its energy level: about 120 million + years for a core of 0.1 Suns per cubic parsec (Schive, Chiueh and Broadhurst 2020). It also breathes: the + central density swings by more than a factor of two at f = 10.94 (ρ_c / 10⁹ Suns per kpc³)^(1/2) per billion + years, and the swing hardly fades over the halo's life (Veltmaat et al. 2018, eq. 16). Stars inside a core feel + it: the beat would heat the old star cluster at the centre of Eridanus II (Marsh and Niemeyer 2019), and the + core's wandering can tear that cluster apart within about a billion years (Schive, Chiueh and Broadhurst 2020). +3. *Stirring time.* Passing lumps tug on stars and on each other. The stirring (relaxation) time is how long the + tugs take to change a star's speed by as much as the halo's own spread of speeds: + 3m³σ⁶ / (16π²G²ρ²ħ³ ln Λ), with ln Λ ≈ ln(2r/ƛ) at distance r from the centre (Bar-Or et al. 2019, eqs. 61 + and 85). Hui et al. (2017, eq. 32) give the same form; Bar-Or et al. find the true rates 2 to 11 times slower. + The dark matter's own relaxation, which grows the core, runs on a time of the same form (Levkov, Panin and + Tkachev 2018). + +`node witness-map/table.mjs` prints these for three places: + +| | Milky Way, Sun's orbit, 10⁻²² eV | Same place, 3×10⁻¹⁹ eV | Core of a dwarf like Eridanus II, 8×10⁻²³ eV | +|---|---|---|---| +| Size | lumps 370 pc across | lumps 0.12 pc across | core 0.7 kpc in radius | +| Mass | 10⁵ Suns per lump | 1.2 Earths per lump | 5×10⁸ Suns | +| Particles sharing it | 10⁹³ | 10⁷⁹ | 10⁹⁷ | +| Fastest clock | lumps live 0.7 million years | lumps live 240 years | wave turns over every 110 million years, breathes every 260 million | +| Stirring time | 5×10¹² years, 340 times the age of the universe | 5×10²² years | not modelled | +| Kick from one lump on a star | 44 m/s | 5 µm/s | not modelled | + +Inputs. The Sun is 8.18 kpc from the centre (GRAVITY Collaboration 2019). The circular speed there is 229 km/s +(Eilers et al. 2019), and σ = 229/√2 = 162 km/s, as in an isothermal halo (Bar-Or et al. 2019, eq. 63). The local +dark matter density is 0.4 GeV/cm³ (de Salas and Widmark 2021 review: 0.3 to 0.6). The age of the universe is +13.8 billion years (Planck 2018). The dwarf is the simulated Eridanus II-like halo of Schive, Chiueh and +Broadhurst (2020), with core radius 0.7 kpc. The 3×10⁻¹⁹ eV particle is the lowest mass allowed (at 99% confidence) by the +stars of two ultrafaint dwarf galaxies, which the lumps would stir (Dalal and Kravtsov 2022); the Lyman-α forest requires +more than 2×10⁻²⁰ eV (Rogers and Peiris 2021). Both rule out the 10⁻²² eV benchmark used by the map and by most of +the papers above, if wave dark matter is all of the dark matter. Heavier particles make smaller, lighter, +shorter-lived lumps: lump mass falls as m⁻³ and stirring time grows as m³. + +**One particle against the crowd.** + +- *One particle has no witnesses. The crowd has many.* Nothing in the map records where one particle is (W = 0). + A lump is about 10⁹³ particles pulling together, so its pull is 10⁹³ times one particle's. As a lump passes a + star near the Sun, it changes the star's speed by about 2G·m_lump/(ƛσ) ≈ 44 m/s (impulse estimate), and the star + meets a fresh lump about every 0.7 million years. A change of tens of metres per second in a star's motion is + enormous by quantum standards, so the star holds a record of where the lump was. Summed over near and far lumps, + these kicks give Bar-Or et al.'s stirring time to within a factor of 3 (checked in `npm test`). Allali and + Hertzberg (2020, 2021) compute gravitational records of this kind, with the galaxy's gas as the recorder, for + dark matter put in two places at once. In the Milky Way, a superposition of where the dark matter is does not + survive, while a superposition of the wave's phase does, since the phase shows up in gravity only as faint, fast + ripples. +- *The crowd's wave survives being watched.* It is a classical wave. Recording the shape of a classical wave does + not erase it, any more than measuring a sea wave flattens the sea. Witnesses erase superpositions of different + shapes, and the lumps are interference inside one shape. So the records keep the halo in one definite pattern, + and that pattern keeps its lumps (Allali and Hertzberg 2020: dark matter condensates decohere fast and are well + described by classical field theory). Bar-Or et al. (2019) make the same point from the other side: their + calculation is classical field theory, with quantum mechanics entering only through the way the wave spreads. +- *What W = 0 does say.* Nothing knocks single particles out of the crowd. A particle's whole momentum in the wave + is about mσ = ħ/ƛ, tiny. A hit from any photon or gas atom, whose wavelength is far shorter than ƛ, would carry + much more (ħk ≫ ħ/ƛ) and throw the particle out of the wave. Where W is not zero, the per-particle witness rate + is the rate at which particles leave the crowd. + +**Where the map stops applying.** + +1. *When particles share their wave.* If one lump holds more than one particle, a lone particle's W does not + describe what is seen. Wave dark matter always shares: 10⁹³ particles per lump at 10⁻²² eV, 10⁷⁹ at + 3×10⁻¹⁹ eV. Near the Sun the crowd thins to one particle per lump only for particles heavier than about 20 eV + (model; Bar-Or et al. 2019: "a few tens of eV"). The map's heavy dark matter particle, at 100 GeV, has 10⁻³⁹ + particles per lump: for it, the per-particle picture is the right one. +2. *For the galaxy-sized wave.* The pattern renews every lump lifetime whatever witnesses do, and its lumps are + watched by every star. W = 0 is silent on both. +3. *For gravity's witnesses.* The map counts a black hole horizon as gravity's only witness, and only for one + particle. For the crowd, every star is a witness too. Gravity-only witnesses of a single particle are + [issue #3](https://github.com/Foundation-0/fractals/issues/3). + +**Does the crowd belong on the map?** Yes, but not on the W axis. W asks whether one object can be in two places a +gap apart. The crowd's wave is classical, so that is not its live question, and a crowd W would put two different +things on one scale. The interactive page has a separate panel below the map, marked "not a witness number", with +the crowd's clocks set against the age of the universe. In code: `crowd()` and `CROWDS` in `witness-map/model.js`, +a separate table in `node witness-map/table.mjs`, and checks in `npm test`. + +**What the crowd model leaves out.** Each place is treated as a uniform patch of halo: no orbits, no tides. The +stirring time needs the orbit to be much larger than a lump (Bar-Or et al. 2019), so it fails near the centre. The +core is taken at the size found in one simulation. The breathing period is Veltmaat et al.'s fit; a rough +first-principles estimate (the gap between the core's two lowest energy levels in its own frozen gravity) gives a +frequency 36% higher. + +## Does a black hole shape wave dark matter? + +A spinning black hole can grow a cloud of very light particles with hydrogen-like levels (superradiance). For wave +dark matter at 10⁻²² eV around a galaxy's central black hole of 10⁸ to 10⁹ Suns, it cannot in practice: the cloud +would take 10¹⁶ to 10²⁴ times the age of the universe to grow, and out where it would sit the galaxy, not the black +hole, holds the particles. The black hole can still squeeze the galaxy's dense dark matter core by plain gravity, +but only within about 100 pc of the centre, too far in for the lensed images to feel. Details, the lens systems +with anomaly and black hole data, and a reshaped test: [notes/bh-lensing.md](notes/bh-lensing.md) (issue #1). + ## Run it -Needs Node 18 or later, nothing else. +Needs Node 18 or later, nothing else. The checks run on every pull request, on Node 18, 20 and 22. ``` npm test # checks the model against published numbers -node witness-map/table.mjs # every object at a 250 nm gap +node witness-map/table.mjs # every object at a 250 nm gap, then the crowd node witness-map/table.mjs 1e-6 cryo # 1 µm gap, everything in a 4 K vacuum +node notes/bh-lensing.mjs # every number in the black hole note ``` -`witness-map/model.js` is the whole model. It loads in Node (`require`) and in a browser (`window.WM`). +`witness-map/model.js` is the whole model, including `gravAtom` for the black hole note. It loads in Node +(`require`) and in a browser (`window.WM`). `npm test` also checks `gravitational-atom/atom.js` (second study, +below). ## Checks @@ -94,10 +209,22 @@ node witness-map/table.mjs 1e-6 cryo # 1 µm gap, everything in a 4 K vacuum | Photons given off while the visibility halves (Hackermüller et al. 2004) | one to two | 1.4 | | C₇₀ glow at 2,500 K: photons above 1.6 eV in a 4 ms transit | about 3 | 0.09 (DIFF) | | C₇₀ glow power at 3,000 K | 1.1×10⁴ eV/s | 770 eV/s (DIFF) | +| Crowd: lump mass, isothermal halo at 200 km/s, 1 kpc out (Bar-Or et al. 2019, eq. 64) | 1.03×10⁷ Suns | 1.03×10⁷ | +| Crowd: stirring time × ln Λ, same place (eq. 104) | 2.08 billion years | 2.08 | +| Crowd: stirring time over Hui et al.'s relaxation time (2017, eq. 32) | 2 to 11 (Bar-Or et al.) | 8.1 | +| Core peak density, 10⁻²³ eV, 1 kpc core (Schive et al. 2014, eq. 4) | 1.9 Suns per pc³ | 1.94 | +| Core mass inside the core radius (same paper, eq. 3) | 5.5×10⁹ Suns | 5.4×10⁹ | +| Core wave period at 0.1 Suns per pc³ (Schive et al. 2020) | ~120 million years | 121 million | +| Core breathing frequency (Veltmaat et al. 2018, eq. 16) | 0.16 per (Gρ_c)^(-1/2) | 0.22 (frozen-gravity estimate) | +| Coupling α, 3 M☉ black hole and 10⁻¹² eV particle (Baumann, Chia and Porto 2019, eq. 2.6) | 0.02 | 0.022 | +| Cloud growth time at their smallest growing α, 0.005 (eq. 2.14) | the age of the universe | 1.2×10¹⁰ years | +| Largest α that grows at spin 0.8 (same paper) | 0.25 | 0.252 | +| Heaviest particle M87*'s spin can grow (Davoudiasl and Denton 2019) | 4.6×10⁻²¹ eV | 4.7×10⁻²¹ eV | The published tables give powers of ten only, so agreement within a few times is as close as the comparison can go. The tolerance is ×5: half a power of ten for rounding, and a little more for inputs the tables do not -state. +state. The crowd rows compare formulas and fits, so they agree more closely; the core is solved here from +first principles (the ground state of the Schrödinger–Poisson equations), not taken from the fits. What the re-check found (issue #5, details in CORRECTIONS.md): two coefficient errors, now fixed; a molecule's glow that is fitted, and gets the onset of decoherence right but the light wrong; and four places where the @@ -109,7 +236,8 @@ tables. - Objects sit still. Fast motion, internal structure and spin are ignored. - W is per particle. Wave dark matter's galaxy-wide wave is a crowd effect, enormous numbers of particles - sharing one wave, which is not modelled. + sharing one wave. Its clocks are sketched in [The crowd wave](#the-crowd-wave-where-the-map-stops); it gets no + witness number. - Gravity's only witness is a black hole horizon. Nudges from passing stars are treated as zero. - Molecules glow through one fitted number and no electronic gap. The fit puts the loss of C₇₀ interference at the measured temperature, but real C₇₀ gives off no light below 1.6 eV and its glow rises as T¹¹, against T⁵ @@ -118,6 +246,57 @@ tables. would add as much again as its own glow. - Every number is good to a factor of a few. +## Second study: the gravitational atom + +Hydrogen and a gravitational atom drawn side by side at the same scale: +**https://foundation-0.github.io/fractals/gravitational-atom/** (`gravitational-atom/index.html`, which loads +`gravitational-atom/atom.js`, the whole model; `window.GA` in a browser, `require` in Node). + +A particle of mass μ held by a pull that weakens as 1/r has levels E = μc²(1 − α²/2n²), a Bohr radius +a₀ = ħ/(μcα), and the same wave shapes in units of a₀. Hydrogen: α = e²/(4πε₀ħc) ≈ 1/137. A black hole of +mass M and a boson of mass μ: α = GMμ/(ħc), the hole's size over the particle's wavelength, so a₀ = r_g/α² +(Baumann, Chia and Porto 2019, eqs. 2.5 to 2.9). + +In their example, 5 million Suns and a boson of 10⁻¹⁷ eV: + +- α = r_g/λ_c = 7.4×10⁹ m ÷ 2.0×10¹⁰ m = 0.37, against 0.0073 for hydrogen. +- a₀ = 0.35 AU, 10²¹ times hydrogen's 0.529 Å. The 211 cloud is most likely found 4a₀ = 1.4 AU out. +- The ground state is bound by 7.0×10⁻¹⁹ eV, 5×10⁻²⁰ times hydrogen's 13.6 eV, but that is 7% of the + particle's rest energy against 27 parts per million for hydrogen. So relativity matters more: the first + correction to the 211 level is −11% (their eq. 2.10). +- The horizon at the centre has radius 0.16a₀ at spin 0.99. A proton is 1.6×10⁻⁵a₀. The horizon is not a wall: + a state whose pattern turns slower than the horizon grows by taking the hole's spin (superradiance), the + rest drain in. Here both 211 and 322 can grow; at leading order 211 grows by a factor e every 45 years, + 322 every 31,000 years. + +### Checks + +| Check | Published | Model | +|---|---|---| +| Hydrogen binding, fixed proton (CODATA 2022 Rydberg energy) | 13.605693 eV | 13.605693 eV | +| Bohr radius (CODATA 2022) | 0.529177 Å | 0.529177 Å | +| Hydrogen ionization energy, proton allowed to recoil (NIST ASD) | 13.598435 eV | 13.598287 eV; the gap is mostly fine structure | +| α for 3 Suns and 10⁻¹² eV (BCP 2019, eq. 2.6) | ≈ 0.02 | 0.0224 | +| α for 5×10⁶ Suns and 10⁻¹⁷ eV (BCP 2019, sec. 4.3) | ≈ 0.37 | 0.374 | +| Gravitational waves from a real-field cloud (BCP 2019, eq. 4.1 and sec. 4.3) | 484 Hz per 10⁻¹² eV; ≈ 5 mHz | 483.6 Hz; 4.84 mHz | +| Largest α at which 211 grows, spin 0.8 (BCP 2019, sec. 2.2, from Dolan 2007) | 0.25 | 0.252 | +| Most likely radius, n²r_g/α² (BCP 2019, eq. 2.9) | 4a₀ and 9a₀ | 4.000a₀ and 9.000a₀ | +| 211 e-folding time, 10 Suns, α = 0.3, spin 0.9 (Arvanitaki, Baryakhtar and Huang 2015, Table I) | ~10⁻⁴ years | 4×10⁻⁴ years | +| Fastest 211 growth, spin 0.99, α = 0.42 (Dolan 2007) | 1.5×10⁻⁷ c/r_g | 9.3×10⁻⁹ c/r_g, 16× too slow | +| Bosons in a 10-Sun cloud that took 0.1 of the spin (ABH 2015, eq. 8) | ~10⁷⁶ | 8×10⁷⁶ | + +The two growth-rate rows show where the model stops: growth rates use the leading-order formula (Detweiler 1980, +as corrected in BCP 2019, eq. 2.12), which is good at small α and several times too slow near the fastest +growth. The page says so next to every growth time. + +One bound in the sources is looser than the formula behind it. BCP 2019 give α < 0.5 as the upper limit +for 211 growth, "assuming an initial BH spin of ã = 0.99" (eq. 2.14). Their own condition (eq. 2.1) gives +about 0.44 at that spin; 0.5 is the limit for a maximally spinning hole (as in Arvanitaki, Baryakhtar and +Huang 2015, eq. 6). + +What the gravitational-atom model leaves out: everything past leading order in α; the cloud's own gravity +and the hole's loss of mass; interactions between the particles; anything else near the hole. + Mistakes found along the way are in [CORRECTIONS.md](CORRECTIONS.md). Open questions are the [issues](https://github.com/Foundation-0/fractals/issues). @@ -140,9 +319,38 @@ Mistakes found along the way are in [CORRECTIONS.md](CORRECTIONS.md). Open quest - M. Bild et al., *Schrödinger cat states of a 16-microgram mechanical oscillator*, Science (2023). https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.00449 - L. F. Abbott and M. B. Wise, *Dimension of a quantum-mechanical path*, Am. J. Phys. 49, 37 (1981). - M. Scrimgeour et al., *The WiggleZ Dark Energy Survey: the transition to large-scale cosmic homogeneity* (2012). https://arxiv.org/abs/1205.6812 -- D. Baumann, H. S. Chia and R. A. Porto, *Probing ultralight bosons with binary black holes*, Phys. Rev. D 99, 044001 (2019). +- D. Baumann, H. S. Chia and R. A. Porto, *Probing ultralight bosons with binary black holes*, Phys. Rev. D 99, 044001 (2019). https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.03208 +- R. Brito, V. Cardoso and P. Pani, *Superradiance: New Frontiers in Black Hole Physics*, Lect. Notes Phys. 971 (2020). https://arxiv.org/abs/1501.06570 +- A. Arvanitaki, M. Baryakhtar and X. Huang, *Discovering the QCD axion with black holes and gravitational waves*, Phys. Rev. D 91, 084011 (2015). https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.2263 +- S. Detweiler, *Klein-Gordon equation and rotating black holes*, Phys. Rev. D 22, 2323 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.22.2323 +- S. R. Dolan, *Instability of the massive Klein-Gordon field on the Kerr spacetime*, Phys. Rev. D 76, 084001 (2007). https://arxiv.org/abs/0705.2880 +- CODATA 2022 recommended values of the fundamental physical constants, NIST. https://physics.nist.gov/constants +- NIST Atomic Spectra Database: ionization energy of hydrogen and the 2p and 3d transition rates. https://physics.nist.gov/asd +- A. Prša et al., *Nominal values for selected solar and planetary quantities: IAU 2015 Resolution B3*, Astron. J. 152, 41 (2016). https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.09788 +- Planck Collaboration, *Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters*, Astron. Astrophys. 641, A6 (2020), for the age of the universe, 13.8 billion years. https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.06209 +- D. J. Griffiths and D. F. Schroeter, *Introduction to Quantum Mechanics*, 3rd ed. (Cambridge, 2018), sec. 4.2, for the hydrogen wavefunctions. +- H. Davoudiasl and P. B. Denton, *Ultralight boson dark matter and Event Horizon Telescope observations of M87\**, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 021102 (2019). https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.09242 - A. Amruth et al., *Einstein rings modulated by wavelike dark matter from anomalies in gravitationally lensed images*, Nature Astronomy (2023). https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09895 +The crowd wave: + +- L. Hui, J. P. Ostriker, S. Tremaine and E. Witten, *Ultralight scalars as cosmological dark matter*, Phys. Rev. D 95, 043541 (2017). https://arxiv.org/abs/1610.08297 +- B. Bar-Or, J.-B. Fouvry and S. Tremaine, *Relaxation in a fuzzy dark matter halo*, ApJ 871, 28 (2019). https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.07673 +- H.-Y. Schive, T. Chiueh and T. Broadhurst, *Cosmic structure as the quantum interference of a coherent dark wave*, Nature Physics 10, 496 (2014). https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.6586 +- H.-Y. Schive et al., *Understanding the core-halo relation of quantum wave dark matter from 3D simulations*, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 261302 (2014). https://arxiv.org/abs/1407.7762 +- H.-Y. Schive, T. Chiueh and T. Broadhurst, *Soliton random walk and the cluster-stripping problem in ultralight dark matter*, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 201301 (2020). https://arxiv.org/abs/1912.09483 +- J. Veltmaat, J. C. Niemeyer and B. Schwabe, *Formation and structure of ultralight bosonic dark matter halos*, Phys. Rev. D 98, 043509 (2018). https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.09647 +- D. G. Levkov, A. G. Panin and I. I. Tkachev, *Gravitational Bose-Einstein condensation in the kinetic regime*, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 151301 (2018). https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.05857 +- I. Allali and M. P. Hertzberg, *Gravitational decoherence of dark matter*, JCAP 07 (2020) 056. https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.12287 +- I. J. Allali and M. P. Hertzberg, *General relativistic decoherence with applications to dark matter detection*, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 031301 (2021). https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.15892 +- D. J. E. Marsh and J. C. Niemeyer, *Strong constraints on fuzzy dark matter from ultrafaint dwarf galaxy Eridanus II*, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 051103 (2019). https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.08543 +- N. Dalal and A. Kravtsov, *Excluding fuzzy dark matter with sizes and stellar kinematics of ultrafaint dwarf galaxies*, Phys. Rev. D 106, 063517 (2022). https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.05750 +- K. K. Rogers and H. V. Peiris, *Strong bound on canonical ultralight axion dark matter from the Lyman-alpha forest*, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 071302 (2021). https://arxiv.org/abs/2007.12705 +- P. F. de Salas and A. Widmark, *Dark matter local density determination: recent observations and future prospects*, Rep. Prog. Phys. 84, 104901 (2021). https://arxiv.org/abs/2012.11477 +- A.-C. Eilers, D. W. Hogg, H.-W. Rix and M. K. Ness, *The circular velocity curve of the Milky Way from 5 to 25 kpc*, ApJ 871, 120 (2019). https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.09466 +- GRAVITY Collaboration, *A geometric distance measurement to the Galactic Center black hole with 0.3% uncertainty*, A&A 625, L10 (2019). https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.05721 +- Planck Collaboration, *Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters*, A&A 641, A6 (2020). https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.06209 + ## Licence Apache License 2.0. diff --git a/gravitational-atom/atom.js b/gravitational-atom/atom.js new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7efcb32 --- /dev/null +++ b/gravitational-atom/atom.js @@ -0,0 +1,136 @@ +/* Gravitational atom beside hydrogen: one wave equation, two scales. Leading order in alpha. No dependencies. + * Part of https://github.com/Foundation-0/fractals. Loads in Node (require) and in a browser (window.GA). + * + * A particle of mass mu held by a pull V = -alpha hbar c / r has, for alpha << 1, + * levels E_n = mu c^2 (1 - alpha^2 / 2n^2) (binding mu c^2 alpha^2 / 2n^2) + * Bohr radius a0 = hbar / (mu c alpha) + * shapes psi_nlm = R_nl(r / a0) Y_lm, the same functions in units of a0 + * Hydrogen: alpha = e^2 / (4 pi eps0 hbar c), about 1/137; mu = the electron. + * Gravitational atom: alpha = G M mu / (hbar c) = r_g / lambda_c, so a0 = r_g / alpha^2 + * (Baumann, Chia & Porto 2019, eqs. 2.5-2.9, arXiv:1804.03208). + * Spin chi = a/M: horizon r+ = r_g (1 + sqrt(1 - chi^2)), angular velocity Omega_H = chi c / (2 r+). + * A level grows (superradiance) only if omega / m < Omega_H (BCP 2019 eq. 2.1); otherwise it drains into the hole. + * Constants: CODATA 2022 (NIST). Solar mass parameter GM_sun: IAU 2015 Resolution B3 (Prsa et al. 2016). + */ +(function (root) { + 'use strict'; + const C = { + hbar: 1.054571817e-34, c: 2.99792458e8, e: 1.602176634e-19, eps0: 8.8541878188e-12, + me: 9.1093837139e-31, mp: 1.67262192595e-27, rp: 8.4075e-16, G: 6.6743e-11, GMsun: 1.3271244e20, + au: 1.495978707e11, ly: 9.4607304725808e15, + }; + const HBARC = C.hbar * C.c / C.e; // eV m + + // An atom is a particle (rest energy muEV, in eV) and a pull strength alpha. Everything else follows. + function make(name, muEV, alpha, extra) { + return Object.assign({ name, muEV, alpha, a0: HBARC / (muEV * alpha), E1: muEV * alpha * alpha / 2 }, extra); + } + // recoil: use the electron-proton reduced mass instead of a fixed proton. + function hydrogen(opts) { + const m = opts && opts.recoil ? C.me * C.mp / (C.me + C.mp) : C.me; + return make('Hydrogen', m * C.c * C.c / C.e, C.e * C.e / (4 * Math.PI * C.eps0 * C.hbar * C.c), { core: C.rp }); + } + // M in solar masses, mu in eV, chi = dimensionless spin (0 to 1). + function grav(Msun, muEV, chi) { + const GM = C.GMsun * Msun, rg = GM / (C.c * C.c), lambdaC = HBARC / muEV; + const hz = horizon(chi); + return make('Gravitational atom', muEV, rg / lambdaC, + { M: Msun, chi, rg, lambdaC, Mkg: GM / C.G, rPlus: hz.r * rg, OmegaH: hz.omega * C.c / rg, core: hz.r * rg }); + } + const level = (atom, n) => atom.muEV * (1 - atom.alpha * atom.alpha / (2 * n * n)); // total energy, eV + const binding = (atom, n) => atom.E1 / (n * n); // eV + + // Kerr horizon in units of r_g, and its angular velocity in units of c / r_g. + function horizon(chi) { const r = 1 + Math.sqrt(Math.max(0, 1 - chi * chi)); return { r, omega: chi / (2 * r) }; } + // Frequency of level n in units of c / r_g: omega r_g / c = alpha (1 - alpha^2 / 2n^2). + const omegaRg = (n, alpha) => alpha * (1 - alpha * alpha / (2 * n * n)); + // Can level (n, m) grow around a hole of spin chi? BCP 2019 eq. 2.1, with the leading-order frequency. + const grows = (n, m, alpha, chi) => m > 0 && omegaRg(n, alpha) < m * horizon(chi).omega; + // Largest alpha at which level (n, m) still grows at spin chi. + function alphaMax(n, m, chi) { + const target = m * horizon(chi).omega; let lo = 0, hi = n * Math.sqrt(2 / 3); // omegaRg rises on [0, hi] + if (omegaRg(n, hi) <= target) return hi; + for (let i = 0; i < 80; i++) { const mid = (lo + hi) / 2; if (omegaRg(n, mid) < target) lo = mid; else hi = mid; } + return lo; + } + // Spin left when level (n, m) has grown until it stops: BCP 2019 eq. 2.2, ignoring the small loss of mass. + function spinAfter(n, m, alpha) { const w = omegaRg(n, alpha); return 4 * m * w / (m * m + 4 * w * w); } + // Next-order shift of the gravitational atom's frequency, in units of mu (BCP 2019 eq. 2.10: relativistic, + // fine and hyperfine terms). Returned with its size relative to the leading-order binding. + function nextOrder(n, l, m, alpha, chi) { + const a4 = Math.pow(alpha, 4); + const d = -a4 / (8 * Math.pow(n, 4)) + (2 * l - 3 * n + 1) * a4 / (Math.pow(n, 4) * (l + 0.5)) + + (l > 0 ? 2 * chi * m * Math.pow(alpha, 5) / (Math.pow(n, 3) * l * (l + 0.5) * (l + 1)) : 0); + return { dOmega: d, relBinding: d / (alpha * alpha / (2 * n * n)) }; + } + // A cloud of a real field radiates gravitational waves at twice its frequency: f = mu c^2 / (pi hbar) (BCP 2019 eq. 4.1). + const gwFrequency = muEV => muEV * C.e / (Math.PI * C.hbar); + // Growth (> 0) or drain (< 0) rate of level (n, l, m), in units of c / r_g: Detweiler's small-alpha result with the + // factor of 2 corrected, as written in BCP 2019 eqs. 2.12-2.13. Leading order only: near alpha ~ 0.3-0.4 it is several + // times too slow (compare Arvanitaki, Baryakhtar & Huang 2015, Table I, and Dolan 2007; see tests/gravitational-atom.mjs). + function growthRate(n, l, m, alpha, chi) { + const hz = horizon(chi); let prod = 1; + for (let j = 1; j <= l; j++) prod *= j * j * (1 - chi * chi) + Math.pow(chi * m - 2 * hz.r * alpha, 2); + const Cnl = Math.pow(2, 4 * l + 1) * fact(n + l) / (Math.pow(n, 2 * l + 4) * fact(n - l - 1)) * + Math.pow(fact(l) / (fact(2 * l) * fact(2 * l + 1)), 2) * prod; + return 2 * hz.r * Cnl * (m * hz.omega - omegaRg(n, alpha)) * Math.pow(alpha, 4 * l + 5); + } + // Bosons in a level that has taken spin dChi from the hole: N = G M^2 dChi / (m hbar c), the angular momentum given up + // divided by m hbar per boson (Arvanitaki, Baryakhtar & Huang 2015, eq. 8). + const occupation = (Msun, dChi, m) => C.GMsun * Msun * (C.GMsun * Msun / C.G) * dChi / (m * C.hbar * C.c); + + // ---------- shapes: hydrogen wavefunctions, in units of a0 ---------- + const fact = k => (k <= 1 ? 1 : k * fact(k - 1)); + function laguerre(k, a, x) { // generalised Laguerre polynomial L_k^(a)(x) + if (k === 0) return 1; + let p0 = 1, p1 = 1 + a - x; + for (let i = 1; i < k; i++) { const p2 = ((2 * i + 1 + a - x) * p1 - (i + a) * p0) / (i + 1); p0 = p1; p1 = p2; } + return p1; + } + function radial(n, l, x) { // R_nl at r = x a0, in units of a0^(-3/2) + const rho = 2 * x / n, norm = Math.sqrt(Math.pow(2 / n, 3) * fact(n - l - 1) / (2 * n * fact(n + l))); + return norm * Math.exp(-rho / 2) * Math.pow(rho, l) * laguerre(n - l - 1, 2 * l + 1, rho); + } + function legendre(l, m, x) { // associated Legendre P_l^m(x), m >= 0 (sign convention irrelevant: only squares are used) + const s = Math.sqrt(Math.max(0, 1 - x * x)); let pmm = 1; + for (let i = 1; i <= m; i++) pmm *= (2 * i - 1) * s; + if (l === m) return pmm; + let pm1 = x * (2 * m + 1) * pmm; + for (let k = m + 2; k <= l; k++) { const p = (x * (2 * k - 1) * pm1 - (k + m - 1) * pmm) / (k - m); pmm = pm1; pm1 = p; } + return pm1; + } + function angular2(l, m, theta) { // |Y_lm|^2; theta from the spin (z) axis + const am = Math.abs(m), p = legendre(l, am, Math.cos(theta)); + return (2 * l + 1) / (4 * Math.PI) * fact(l - am) / fact(l + am) * p * p; + } + // |psi_nlm|^2 at r = x a0, in units of a0^-3. It does not depend on the azimuth, so the cloud is a ring around the z axis. + const density = (n, l, m, x, theta) => { const R = radial(n, l, x); return R * R * angular2(l, m, theta); }; + + // Lines of equal density for a "circular" state (l = n - 1, |m| = l; 211 and 322 are both). Their density is + // |psi|^2 / peak = [u e^(1-u) sin(theta)]^(2l), u = r / r*, r* = n l a0 (the peak, on the equator), + // so the line at fraction f of the peak solves u e^(1-u) = f^(1/2l) / sin(theta). Returns the right-hand lobe as + // [x, z] points in units of a0 (the left lobe is its mirror image). + function contour(n, f, steps) { + const l = n - 1, rStar = n * l, q0 = Math.pow(f, 1 / (2 * l)), N = steps || 48; + const th0 = Math.asin(q0), pts = [], inner = []; + const solve = (q, outer) => { // root of ln u + 1 - u = ln q on the inner (u < 1) or outer (u > 1) branch + let lo = outer ? 1 : 0, hi = outer ? 4 - 2 * Math.log(q) : 1; + for (let i = 0; i < 60; i++) { const mid = (lo + hi) / 2, g = Math.log(mid) + 1 - mid - Math.log(q); + if ((g > 0) === outer) lo = mid; else hi = mid; } + return (lo + hi) / 2; + }; + for (let i = 0; i <= 2 * N; i++) { // theta from pi - th0 up to th0, packed near the ends where the branches meet + const t = i / N - 1, d = (Math.PI / 2 - th0) * (1 - Math.abs(t)) * (1 - Math.abs(t)); + const th = t >= 0 ? th0 + d : Math.PI - th0 - d; + const q = Math.min(1, q0 / Math.sin(th)); + const uo = solve(q, true), ui = solve(q, false); + pts.push([rStar * uo * Math.sin(th), rStar * uo * Math.cos(th)]); + inner.push([rStar * ui * Math.sin(th), rStar * ui * Math.cos(th)]); + } + return pts.concat(inner.reverse()); + } + + const api = { C, hydrogen, grav, level, binding, horizon, omegaRg, grows, alphaMax, spinAfter, nextOrder, gwFrequency, + growthRate, occupation, radial, angular2, density, contour }; + if (typeof module !== 'undefined' && module.exports) module.exports = api; else root.GA = api; +})(typeof window !== 'undefined' ? window : globalThis); diff --git a/gravitational-atom/index.html b/gravitational-atom/index.html new file mode 100644 index 0000000..51e42c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/gravitational-atom/index.html @@ -0,0 +1,485 @@ + + +
+ + + + + + + +Hydrogen, and a cloud of very light particles around a spinning black hole. Drawn at the same scale they have the same shapes and the same ladder of levels. Gravity does the pulling instead of electric charge, and the centre is a horizon that can feed the cloud or swallow it.
+Exploration, not peer reviewed, no new result claimed. By Aska Digital with Claude (Anthropic) for Foundation0. Model, checks and open questions: Foundation-0/fractals. First study: the Witness Map.
+Each panel is a slice through the axis. In three dimensions each state is a doughnut around that axis. One Bohr radius, a₀, is the same length on screen in every panel; only what a₀ means in metres changes.
+ + +Both ladders follow E = μc²(1 − α²/2n²): the particle's rest energy μc², less a binding energy that falls as 1/n². Drawn in units of each atom's own ground-state binding, the two ladders are the same.
+ +Everything runs live in this page from gravitational-atom/atom.js, the same file npm test checks. It is the leading order in α: hydrogen's formulas with gravity's α.
Sources: Baumann, Chia & Porto 2019 · Brito, Cardoso & Pani, Superradiance (2020) · Arvanitaki, Baryakhtar & Huang 2015 · Detweiler 1980 · Dolan 2007 · CODATA 2022 · NIST Atomic Spectra Database · IAU 2015 nominal solar values
+Every row above asks about one particle. Wave dark matter in a galaxy is never one particle. Its wave breaks into lumps, and each lump is shared by so many particles that together they act as one ordinary wave, the way countless photons make one radio wave. The crowd keeps its own clocks, and they are measured against the age of the universe, not against a gap.
+And the crowd is watched. One particle's pull is far too weak to leave a record, but a lump is a vast number of particles pulling together, and every star it passes is nudged. A nudge of that size is enormous by quantum standards, so the star now holds a record of where the lump was. The wave survives anyway: recording the shape of an ordinary wave does not erase it, any more than measuring a sea wave flattens the sea.
+ +Order of magnitude, like the map. Lump lifetime ħ/(mσ²), lump mass π3/2ρ(ħ/mσ)³ and stirring time from Bar-Or, Fouvry & Tremaine 2019; the core is the ground state of the Schrödinger–Poisson equations, checked against Schive et al. 2014 and 2020; breathing from Veltmaat et al. 2018. Inputs and derivations: README.
+Everything runs live in this page from first principles. Treat the numbers as order-of-magnitude: the method is good to within a factor of a few, and the map spans more than 150 powers of ten.
@@ -248,30 +265,32 @@npm test). Mistakes and disagreements found along the way are in CORRECTIONS.md.npm test). Mistakes and disagreements found along the way are in CORRECTIONS.md.Code: Foundation-0/fractals · open questions
-Sources: Joos & Zeh 1985 · Danielson, Satishchandran & Wald 2022 · Dürr, Nonn & Rempe 1998 · Bild et al. 2023 · Riedel & Zurek 2010 · Hackermüller et al. 2004 · Hornberger et al. 2005 · Schlosshauer 2019
+Sources: Joos & Zeh 1985 · Danielson, Satishchandran & Wald 2022 · Dürr, Nonn & Rempe 1998 · Bild et al. 2023 · Riedel & Zurek 2010 · Hackermüller et al. 2004 · Hornberger et al. 2005 · Schlosshauer 2019 · Hui, Ostriker, Tremaine & Witten 2017 · Bar-Or, Fouvry & Tremaine 2019 · Allali & Hertzberg 2020