diff --git a/tests/bh-lensing.mjs b/tests/bh-lensing.mjs index 03a7806..be50aa2 100644 --- a/tests/bh-lensing.mjs +++ b/tests/bh-lensing.mjs @@ -41,24 +41,49 @@ check('Any cloud that grows within the age of the universe around 1e8 to 1e9 Msu `largest clouds ${biggest.map(r => (r / PC).toPrecision(2)).join(' and ')} pc`, 'model'); // 2. The same algebra lives in gravitational-atom/atom.js (the second study's page). The two copies use slightly -// different constants (G M_sun 1.3275e20 here, 1.3271e20 there), so they agree to a few parts in 10^4 in alpha -// and to about 1% in the rate, which goes as alpha^9. A change to one copy that is not made in the other fails here. +// different constants: G M_sun differs by 0.0252%, giving <0.03% differences in alpha, radius and speed. +// The alpha^9 rate amplifies this to at most 0.198% for the cases below; allow 0.21%. +// The dimensionless threshold uses identical constants, so only floating-point roundoff is allowed. const GA = require('../gravitational-atom/atom.js'); const pts = [[3, 1e-12, 0.99], [10, 1e-12, 0.7], [5e6, 1e-17, 0.99], [1e8, 1e-19, 0.9]]; const pairs = pts.map(([m, mu, a]) => ({ m, mu, a, here: gravAtom(m * C.Msun, mu, a), there: GA.grav(m, mu, a) })); const relA = Math.max(...pairs.map(p => Math.abs(p.here.alpha / p.there.alpha - 1))); -check('alpha agrees with gravitational-atom/atom.js', relA < 1e-3, `largest difference ${fmt(relA)} over ${pts.length} black holes`, 'cross-check'); +check('alpha agrees with gravitational-atom/atom.js', relA < 3e-4, `largest difference ${fmt(relA)} over ${pts.length} black holes`, 'cross-check'); +// Locate the 211 radial-probability peak using the separate wavefunction implementation. +// This is r^2 |R_21|^2, not the spatial-density peak (which lies at 2 a0). +const radialProbability = x => x * x * GA.radial(2, 1, x) ** 2; +let lo = 0, hi = 12; +for (let i = 0; i < 80; i++) { + const a = lo + (hi - lo) / 3, b = hi - (hi - lo) / 3; + if (radialProbability(a) < radialProbability(b)) lo = a; else hi = b; +} +const cloudPeak = (lo + hi) / 2; +// The virial theorem gives kinetic energy = binding energy, hence v = sqrt(2 E_binding / mu). +for (const [name, expected] of [ + ['rBohr', p => p.there.a0], + ['rCloud', p => cloudPeak * p.there.a0], + ['vBohr', p => Math.sqrt(2 * GA.binding(p.there, 2) * GA.C.e / (p.mu * GA.C.e / GA.C.c ** 2))], +]) { + const rel = Math.max(...pairs.map(p => Math.abs(p.here[name] / expected(p) - 1))); + check(`${name} agrees with gravitational-atom/atom.js`, rel < 3e-4, + `largest difference ${fmt(rel)} over the same black holes`, 'cross-check'); +} const relR = Math.max(...pairs.map(p => { const there = GA.growthRate(2, 1, 1, p.there.alpha, p.a) * C.c / p.there.rg; return Math.abs(1 / p.here.tGrow / there - 1); })); -check('211 growth rate agrees with gravitational-atom/atom.js', pairs.every(p => p.here.superradiant) && relR < 0.01, +check('211 growth rate agrees with gravitational-atom/atom.js', pairs.every(p => p.here.superradiant) && relR < 0.0021, `largest difference ${fmt(relR)} over the same black holes, all growing`, 'cross-check'); +// Match alpha and r_g to remove the rounded-GM offset and test the rate algebra itself. +const relMatchedRate = Math.max(...pairs.map(p => Math.abs( + (1 / p.here.tGrow) / (GA.growthRate(2, 1, 1, p.here.alpha, p.a) * GA.C.c / p.here.rg) - 1))); +check('211 growth rate agrees at matched alpha and r_g', relMatchedRate < 1e-12, + `largest difference ${fmt(relMatchedRate)} over the same black holes`, 'cross-check'); const relT = Math.max(...[0.5, 0.8, 0.99].map(a => { const here = edge(x => gravAtom(M3, muFor(x, M3), a).superradiant, 0.01, 0.6); return Math.abs(here / GA.alphaMax(2, 1, a) - 1); })); -check('Largest alpha that grows agrees with gravitational-atom/atom.js', relT < 1e-3, `largest difference ${fmt(relT)} at spins 0.5, 0.8 and 0.99`, 'cross-check'); +check('Largest alpha that grows agrees with gravitational-atom/atom.js', relT < 1e-12, `largest difference ${fmt(relT)} at spins 0.5, 0.8 and 0.99`, 'cross-check'); console.log(fails ? `\n${fails} check(s) failed` : '\nall checks pass'); process.exit(fails ? 1 : 0);