From 0925e9147e4ca4ab34bff583569dae2b347b36ca Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: ahrazzle <38987266+ahrazzle@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 17:07:29 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 1/7] docs: fix AeST constraint and response benchmark protocol --- README.md | 4 + .../aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md | 77 +++++++++++++++++++ .../aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json | 20 +++++ 3 files changed, 101 insertions(+) create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 68671a1..a0b5ef2 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -46,3 +46,7 @@ All Python scripts use only the Python 3 standard library. Each certificate file - `CHANGELOG.md` -- Reconciled chronological history across Waves 1-12 matching `CLAIMS.md` and code identifiers.- - mic-Dawn quasar confrontation, and next-agent handoff queue. - `CHANGELOG.md` -- Reconciled chronological history across Waves 1-12 matching `CLAIMS.md` and code identifiers. + +## AeST response benchmark in progress + +The [fixed action and protocol](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md) defines the constraint and response checks for a Minkowski vacuum benchmark. Derivation and response checks are in progress. The protocol has not yet been independently reviewed. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cca99fd --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +# AeST scalar constraints and response: a fixed benchmark + +This calculation tests whether two AeST field preparations with the same initial effective gravitational sources are distinct physical states. It starts from a published AeST action and sets the checks for its linear constraints. The first benchmark is Minkowski vacuum, so it cannot establish a cosmological fluid closure or a collapse outcome. + +Prepared 12 November 2026 by gpt-forge using the requested gpt-6-astra research model. Status: protocol fixed; derivation and response checks in progress; not yet independently reviewed. The companion derivation and executable results will record which gates pass. + +## Action, background and units + +Use signature \((-+++ )\), \(c=1\), and the action + +\[ +S=\frac{1}{16\pi\widetilde G}\int d^4x\sqrt{-g} +\{R-\tfrac12 K_B F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu} ++(2-K_B)(2J^\mu\nabla_\mu\phi-\mathcal Y) +-\mathcal F(\mathcal Y,\mathcal Q)-\lambda(A^\mu A_\mu+1)\}. +\] + +Here \(F_{\mu\nu}=2\nabla_{[\mu}A_{\nu]}\), \(J^\mu=A^\nu\nabla_\nu A^\mu\), \(\mathcal Q=A^\mu\nabla_\mu\phi\), and \(\mathcal Y=(g^{\mu\nu}+A^\mu A^\nu)\nabla_\mu\phi\nabla_\nu\phi\). There is no matter source or cosmological constant in this benchmark. + +Fix the full function to + +\[ +\mathcal F=(2-K_B)\lambda_s\mathcal Y-2\mathcal K_2(\mathcal Q-\mathcal Q_0)^2, +\quad K_B=1,\quad \mathcal K_2=2,\quad\lambda_s=1,\quad\mathcal Q_0>0. +\] + +This is the explicit function in equation 84 of [Bataki, Skordis and Zlosnik](https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3). It is a classical tracking benchmark. It is not a complete interpolating MOND function or a fit to the observed cosmology. No higher-derivative operator or ultraviolet completion is added. + +The exact background is \(g_{\mu\nu}=\eta_{\mu\nu}\), \(A^\mu=(1,0,0,0)\), \(\phi=\mathcal Q_0 t\). The scalar is dimensionless. Thus \(\mathcal Q_0\) and physical wave number have units of inverse length, \(\mathcal F\) has units of inverse length squared, and the three selected constants are dimensionless. Numerical time is \(\mathcal Q_0t\) and numerical wave number is \(k/\mathcal Q_0\). + +## Gauge and retained states + +For each nonzero scalar Fourier mode use Newtonian gauge, + +\[ +ds^2=-(1+2\Psi)dt^2+(1-2\Phi)d\mathbf x^2, +\quad A_0=-1-\Psi,\quad A_i=\partial_i\alpha, +\quad\phi=\mathcal Q_0t+\varphi. +\] + +The unit-vector constraint is imposed to first order. Define \(\chi=\varphi+\mathcal Q_0\alpha\), \(E=\dot\alpha+\Psi\), \(\gamma=\dot\varphi-\mathcal Q_0\Psi\), and \(Z=K_BE+(2-K_B)\chi\). Real fields contain conjugate Fourier amplitudes. + +The primary comparison retains absolute effective density, momentum and spatial stress, defined by moving the AeST terms to the right side of Einstein's equation with the bare \(\widetilde G\). It also records both metric potentials and their lensing sum. Density contrast and fluid velocity divided by background enthalpy are excluded because that enthalpy vanishes here. + +## Canonical gate + +Derive the quadratic scalar action, retaining lapse and shift constraints before gauge reduction. Match its canonical momenta and constraints to equations 106–115 of the Hamiltonian source. In the normalization where the action is multiplied by \(16\pi\widetilde G\), the expected field momentum map is + +\[ +P_\varphi=4\mathcal K_2\gamma, +\qquad P_\alpha=2k^2 Z, +\qquad P_\alpha-\mathcal Q_0P_\varphi=4k^2\Phi. +\] + +The spatial scalar shear and momentum constraint must also be imposed. Auxiliary variables, if used, must change consistently with \(\mathcal Q\). A linear function of \(\mathcal Y\) has a degenerate Legendre transform in that argument, so \(\mu=\mathcal F_{\mathcal Y}\) is fixed rather than independently varied. + +Test the compensated initial difference + +\[ +\Delta\alpha=\Delta\varphi=\Delta\Phi=\Delta\Psi=0, +\quad\Delta E=\varepsilon, +\quad\Delta\gamma=\frac{K_B k^2}{2\mathcal K_2\mathcal Q_0}\varepsilon. +\] + +This is a nonsingular absolute-density counterpart of the earlier fluid-variable construction. Verify each constraint and show whether a nonzero gauge-invariant field perturbation remains. Do not infer a stress response from physical distinctness alone. + +## Response and stability gates + +Use the exact reduced Hamiltonian to propagate all four physical scalar phase-space data. Check its quadratic energy signature before choosing the wave-number interval. The initial test interval is \(3\leq k/\mathcal Q_0\leq12\), subject to the explicit positivity calculation. + +Compute the response for compensated velocity data, independent field-phase data and mixtures held out from any proposed reduced law. Report metric, density, momentum and spatial stress separately from the conserved scalar shift current. A conserved shift current is not the stress-energy momentum current. + +Verify the published propagating dispersion relation, the nonpropagating branch, canonical constraint preservation, linear amplitude scaling and independent numerical integration against the exact propagator. Compare at least three numerical tolerances. A real obstruction or a vanishing physical response is a result. + +The [original action paper](https://arxiv.org/html/2007.00082v3) already identifies the extra cosmological pressure variables. The [Minkowski stability paper](https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.13287) already derives the spectrum and reduced Hamiltonian. This work claims only a reproducible preparation and observable map built on those results. + +The [2025 mimetic connection](https://arxiv.org/html/2503.11174v1) supplies alternate formulations under stated assumptions. It does not supply a regularizer for this benchmark. No three-dimensional collapse calculation begins from a successful flat-space constraint test alone. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e698cad --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json @@ -0,0 +1,20 @@ +{ + "source_main": "364fa3e9f740f42acaa1991428ce043f547e10dd", + "stage": "protocol", + "files": [ + { + "path": "protocol.md", + "sha256": "4ca257a4c0084dca9abe3a8c91b06646d10189ce2d5a340e6e463b17716d05a8" + } + ], + "primary_sources": [ + "https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3", + "https://arxiv.org/html/2007.00082v3", + "https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.13287", + "https://arxiv.org/html/2503.11174v1" + ], + "limits": [ + "Derivation and executable response checks remain in progress.", + "No closure, cosmological fluid inference or collapse result established." + ] +} From ea20f28f35cad5c49dffafb2111c7a3b2892c3f0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: ahrazzle <38987266+ahrazzle@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 17:21:13 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 2/7] Derive and evaluate constrained AeST response preparations --- README.md | 2 +- .../aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md | 87 + .../aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS | 7 + .../aest-response-gate-20261112/derivation.md | 207 +++ .../aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md | 12 +- .../requirements.txt | 3 + .../aest-response-gate-20261112/response.py | 379 ++++ .../aest-response-gate-20261112/results.json | 1524 +++++++++++++++++ .../aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json | 50 +- 9 files changed, 2254 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-) create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/derivation.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/requirements.txt create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/response.py create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/results.json diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index a0b5ef2..8a9462d 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -49,4 +49,4 @@ All Python scripts use only the Python 3 standard library. Each certificate file ## AeST response benchmark in progress -The [fixed action and protocol](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/protocol.md) defines the constraint and response checks for a Minkowski vacuum benchmark. Derivation and response checks are in progress. The protocol has not yet been independently reviewed. +The [AeST response benchmark](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md) constructs allowed field preparations on a specified expanding background and a flat-space control. It includes the canonical map, executable response checks and a bounded pressure-closure comparison. Independent review of the action expansion and constraint reduction is pending. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d9ca949 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ +# AeST constraint and response benchmark + +This benchmark constructs physical scalar perturbations of one specified AeST action. On an expanding background, states with the same initial density, momentum and metric produce different pressure and later gravitational potentials. A flat-space control explains why the same field freedom has no linear gravitational response at zero background density. + +**Status:** action-derived calculation with executable internal checks. Independent review of the expanding-background action and canonical reduction is pending. This is not a nonlinear collapse, thermalization or observational result. + +The complete action, conventions, constraints and equations are in [derivation.md](derivation.md). The test choices and the approximation threshold are in [protocol.md](protocol.md). The equations build on published AeST work listed in [sources.json](sources.json). No new propagating mode or new Minkowski stability bound is claimed. + +## What was calculated + +The full function is \(\mathcal F=(2-K_B)\lambda_s\mathcal Y-2\mathcal K_2(\mathcal Q-Q_0)^2\), with \(K_B=1\), \(\lambda_s=1\), and \(\mathcal K_2=2\). The expanding background has \(Q=Q_0+0.01Q_0a^{-3}\), no matter and no cosmological constant. Evolution covers \(a=1\) to \(a=2\). + +For five wave numbers \(k/Q_0=6,9,12,18,24\), three preparations were evolved. One changes scalar and vector velocities while compensating their initial density source. A second changes the field phase while also matching initial pressure. The third is a held-out linear mixture of the first two. + +All three initially match effective density and momentum. They satisfy the lapse, momentum and unit-vector constraints. The scalar auxiliary field changes consistently. Gauge-invariant field data distinguish the preparations. + +The first preparation has \(\Delta\gamma_i=\epsilon Q_0\), \(\epsilon=10^{-6}\). Define \(D=8\pi\widetilde G\delta\rho\), \(m=K'\varphi\) and \(p=8\pi\widetilde G\delta P\). Their units are \(Q_0^2,Q_0,Q_0^2\), respectively. Maximum responses over the interval are: + +| \(k/Q_0\) | \(\max|D|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)\) | \(\max|m|/(\epsilon Q_0)\) | \(\max|p|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)\) | \(\max|\Phi+\Psi|/\epsilon\) | +|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 6 | 0.099124 | 0.0077392 | 0.040067 | 0.0043004 | +| 9 | 0.103737 | 0.0052054 | 0.040031 | 0.0019747 | +| 12 | 0.105312 | 0.0039056 | 0.040005 | 0.0011240 | +| 18 | 0.106352 | 0.0025971 | 0.040000 | 0.0005040 | +| 24 | 0.106641 | 0.0019431 | 0.040000 | 0.0002844 | + +These are transfer amplitudes for the declared preparation. They are not predictions for an astrophysical perturbation spectrum. The metric sum is the potential combination entering weak gravitational lensing, not an integrated light-ray observable. + +The second preparation has \(D_i=m_i=p_i=0\), but a nonzero pressure derivative. At \(k/Q_0=12\), it reaches \(\max|D|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)=0.527669\) and \(\max|\Phi+\Psi|/\epsilon=0.00903245\). Its field-phase amplitude is \(\chi_i=\epsilon Q_0/\sqrt{3k^2/4+2Q_0^2}\). + +Thus density and momentum do not predict every allowed preparation. Adding instantaneous pressure still leaves an independent preparation that changes its future derivative. The four-state variables \((D,m,\chi,Z)\), where \(Z=E+\chi\) for this branch, supply an exact linear evolution law. + +## Checks and limits + +| Check | Result | +|---|---| +| Action lapse equation and canonical compensation | Symbolic residual zero | +| Constraint propagation | \(\dot C+3HC=0\), symbolically | +| Effective energy balance and spatial Einstein equation | Symbolic residual zero | +| Fifteen expanding preparations | Largest normalized constraint residual \(5.20\times10^{-12}\) | +| Five-field versus four-state evolution | Largest normalized difference \(5.49\times10^{-11}\) | +| Integrator tolerance \(10^{-8},10^{-10},10^{-12}\) | Constraint residual falls from \(2.82\times10^{-10}\) to \(2.86\times10^{-14}\) | +| Amplitudes \(10^{-7},10^{-6},10^{-5}\) | Normalized response agrees within recorded numerical error | +| Flat-space exact matrix exponential versus ODE | Relative error below \(1.6\times10^{-10}\) over ten periods | +| Flat-space quadratic energy | Relative drift below \(1.3\times10^{-12}\) | + +The exact expanding solution for \(a(t)\) is checked independently. The scalar kinetic Hessian and short-wavelength characteristic have the required positive signs in the author derivation. Their derivation still requires independent review. The test does not prove nonlinear stability or stability of an observationally fitted cosmology. + +For \(q_i=0\), the compensated field mode oscillates but its linear density, momentum, pressure and metric response vanish identically. The scalar shift current remains nonzero. It must not be identified with stress-energy momentum. + +At a fixed duration \(Q_0t=1\), reducing the initial density gives the following velocity-preparation response at \(k/Q_0=6\): + +| \(q_i/Q_0\) | \(\max|D|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)\) | \(\max|\delta\rho/\bar\rho|/\epsilon\) | \(\max|\Phi+\Psi|/\epsilon\) | +|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 0.01 | 0.0991240 | 3.05744 | 0.00316730 | +| 0.001 | 0.0119935 | 3.21476 | 0.000349006 | +| 0.0001 | 0.00127788 | 3.26705 | 0.0000360307 | +| 0.00001 | 0.000130421 | 3.28381 | 0.00000364003 | + +Absolute sources tend to zero. The density-contrast response stays finite because its background denominator also tends to zero. A claim that small background sound speed suppresses preparation effects must state which field amplitudes and which observable normalization are held fixed. + +## A bounded approximation test + +Two unfitted prescriptions were tested: zero pressure perturbation and \(\delta P=c_{\rm ad}^2\delta\rho\). Both keep the exact expanding background. Initial density contrast is \(10^{-5}\), with the explicitly defined dust-inspired momentum in the protocol. This is not an exact AeST growing eigenmode. + +Independent hidden velocity and phase data have relative amplitudes \(\eta=0,0.01,0.1,1\). Each comparison uses the same initial retained density and momentum. The 1% target for density contrast and metric potential was fixed before evaluating the approximations. Errors are divided by the maximum corresponding observable in the zero-pressure reference over \(1\leq a\leq2\). + +| Hidden amplitude \(\eta\) | Distinct preparations | Worst density error, zero pressure | Worst metric error, zero pressure | Worst density error, adiabatic pressure | Worst metric error, adiabatic pressure | +|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 0 | 5 | 28.67% | 28.67% | 127.97% | 184.67% | +| 0.01 | 10 | 37.41% | 43.79% | 188.18% | 216.20% | +| 0.1 | 10 | 627.24% | 627.39% | 765.66% | 785.69% | +| 1 | 10 | 6530.40% | 6531.65% | 6668.82% | 6670.95% | + +Neither prescription passes the declared 1% criterion for any of these 35 preparations. Large percentages compare small linear perturbations. They do not imply nonlinear amplitudes or a failure of all dust approximations. A different action, a colder background or a verified slow-mode initial ensemble requires its own test. + +## Reproduce + +Create an isolated Python environment, install [requirements.txt](requirements.txt), and run: + +```sh +python response.py --output results.json +``` + +The [script](response.py) includes assertions. The [results](results.json) retain all preparation values, residuals, amplitude controls and approximation errors. No network request, downloaded dataset, fitting stage or graphical dependency is needed. + +The bounded result supports retaining the additional scalar/vector response data before a nonlinear solver is attempted. The next gate is independent review of the action expansion and canonical map. A three-dimensional collapse experiment remains unstarted. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS new file mode 100644 index 0000000..293f507 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +bf94a6927d74b6865d99eadc9827e9f21d9ca3d3ea7bec4bfaa0f50f75d83f6c README.md +f90522170c4ea67d2601e8c099216ff992a5d3b94a43c0322da87c03f6e9facc protocol.md +5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe derivation.md +e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef response.py +c82b4e1c64da797e5a701f698808b7074c780778306cb6622721011403573602 results.json +ebab51ac1b6420faa2394d3deaba33637ddfff96456fe15406991f12d5a227f2 requirements.txt +2b3cccc760af9e8f6334fd04240fa2581a9f08af2d2d3a56b9eec8418036c14b sources.json diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/derivation.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/derivation.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1b2a405 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/derivation.md @@ -0,0 +1,207 @@ +# Physical AeST preparations and their linear gravitational response + +Two AeST field states can satisfy all linear constraints and have the same initial effective density, momentum and metric while producing different pressure and later gravitational potentials. The calculation below establishes this for one specified expanding background. It also shows why the corresponding Minkowski test has no linear stress response. + +This is a classical linear calculation for the tracking action fixed in [protocol.md](protocol.md). Independent review of the expanding-background action and constraint map is pending. It does not establish thermalization, caustic regularization, a halo pressure law or a fit to cosmological observations. + +The new contribution is the explicit constraint map and reproducible preparation response. The underlying action, mode count and Minkowski spectrum are published results. The analytical stability arguments below are author calculations awaiting independent review. + +## 1. A background with nonzero effective density + +Retain \(K_B=1\), \(\lambda_s=1\), \(\mathcal K_2=2\), no matter and no cosmological constant. Write + +\[ +\mathcal K(Q)=2(Q-Q_0)^2,\quad K'=4(Q-Q_0),\quad K''=4, +\quad Q=\dot{\bar\phi},\quad Q_0>0. +\] + +Primes here differentiate \(\mathcal K\) with respect to \(Q\). They are not time or scale-factor derivatives. The homogeneous scalar equation and Einstein equations give + +\[ +a^3K'=\text{constant},\quad +Q=Q_0+q_i a^{-3},\quad +3H^2=R\equiv QK'-\mathcal K, +\quad\dot H=-\frac{QK'}2. +\] + +Choose \(a_i=1\) and \(q_i=0.01Q_0\), with the expanding root \(H>0\). In units \(Q_0=1\), \(R_i=0.0402\), \(H_i=0.115758369\), \(w_i=\mathcal K/R_i=0.004975124\), and \(c_{\rm ad,i}^2=K'/(QK'')=0.009900990\). + +Here \(R=8\pi\widetilde G\bar\rho\). In dimensionless units the exact solution satisfies \(a^3=1+3H_it+3q_it^2\). The finite interval \(1\leq a\leq2\) lasts \(10.547115474/Q_0\). This is an AeST-only FLRW solution of the stated background equations. It is not the observed matter era, and the quadratic \(\mathcal K\) is not extrapolated to the early universe. + +The homogeneous equations follow from the action and agree with the background relations in [Skordis and Zlosnik, Cosmological observables](https://arxiv.org/html/2007.00082v3). Their displayed cosmological vector equation uses the zero-gradient-slope branch. Our nonzero \(\lambda_s\) contributes an extra term derived below. + +## 2. Quadratic action and canonical map + +Use cosmic time and Newtonian gauge. Define \(v=\varphi\), \(\chi=v+Q\alpha\), \(E=\dot\alpha+\Psi\), \(\gamma=\dot v-Q\Psi\), \(b=2-K_B\), and \(r=k^2/a^2\). Multiplying the action by \(16\pi\widetilde G\), the quadratic Lagrangian for one real Fourier component is + +\[ +\begin{aligned} +L_g^{(2)}={}&a^3[-6\dot\Phi^2-12H(\Phi+\Psi)\dot\Phi +-9H^2(\Phi+\Psi)^2]+ak^2(2\Phi^2-4\Phi\Psi),\\ +L_A^{(2)}={}&a^3[K''\gamma^2+(QK'-\mathcal K)\Psi^2 +-6K'\Phi\gamma-6\mathcal K\Psi\Phi+3\mathcal K\Phi^2]\\ +&+ak^2[K_BE^2+2bE\chi-b(1+\lambda_s)\chi^2 ++K'(2\alpha v+Q\alpha^2)]. +\end{aligned} +\] + +The common positive Fourier-volume factor is suppressed. The gravitational part uses the ADM action with its usual boundary term removed. Its remaining \(H\Phi\dot\Phi\) term has not been integrated by parts. This choice fixes the canonical momentum convention. + +The scalar gradient part follows from \(\mathcal Y^{(2)}=a^{-2}|\nabla\chi|^2\), \(J^i\nabla_i\phi+J^0\dot\phi=a^{-2}\nabla E\cdot\nabla\chi\), and the second-order expansion of \(Q\). The last bracket contains the terms proportional to the nonzero background \(K'\). Omitting them would silently return to the vacuum benchmark. + +For clarity, the displayed action has zero shift and spatial shear. The lapse equation is varied before imposing \(\Psi=\Phi\). The missing shift and shear equations are retained from the ADM constraints: they give the momentum equation and the equality of metric potentials below. Varying only the displayed, gauge-fixed action would not recover the missing shift constraint. + +The scalar momenta are + +\[ +p_v=2a^3K''\gamma-6a^3K'\Phi,\quad +p_\alpha=2ak^2 Z,\quad Z=K_BE+b\chi, +\] + +\[ +p_\Phi=-12a^3[\dot\Phi+H(\Phi+\Psi)]. +\] + +In Newtonian gauge the scalar shear and its conjugate momentum vanish. Lapse and shift have vanishing canonical momenta. The remaining scalar constraints are + +\[ +C_M=p_\Phi+12a^3H\Phi+6a^3K'v=0, +\] + +\[ +C_H=-Hp_\Phi+Qp_v-p_\alpha+4ak^2\Phi ++6a^3(QK'-2H^2)\Phi=0. +\] + +They are equivalent to + +\[ +\dot\Phi+H\Psi=\tfrac12K'v,\quad\Psi=\Phi, +\quad C\equiv D+2r\Phi+3HK'v=0, +\] + +\[ +D\equiv8\pi\widetilde G\delta\rho=QK''\gamma-rZ. +\] + +The lapse variation of \(L_g^{(2)}+L_A^{(2)}\) gives +\(-2a^3[6H(\dot\Phi+H\Psi)+2r\Phi+D]\). Substituting the momentum constraint yields \(-2a^3C\). The script verifies this identity symbolically, including the background terms. + +The unit-vector constraint is solved by taking the future-directed normalized vector before variation. Its multiplier is then fixed by the temporal vector equation and is not independent initial data. In the auxiliary formulation, \(\mu=b\lambda_s\) is fixed because the chosen function is linear in \(\mathcal Y\). It must not be varied as an independent auxiliary coordinate imposing \(\mathcal Y=0\). + +The other auxiliary variable is \(\nu=K'/Q\), with + +\[ +\delta\nu=\frac{K''Q-K'}{Q^2}\gamma +=\frac{4Q_0}{Q^2}\gamma. +\] + +Thus the compensated pair changes this auxiliary variable. Holding it fixed would invalidate the canonical map. The construction agrees with the vacuum limit of [Bataki, Skordis and Zlosnik, equations 84–115](https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3). + +## 3. Evolution derived from the action + +Variation with respect to \(v\) and \(\alpha\), followed by the constraints, gives + +\[ +\begin{aligned} +\dot v&=\gamma+Q\Phi,&\dot\alpha&=E-\Phi,\\ +\dot\Phi&=-H\Phi+\tfrac12K'v,\\ +\dot\gamma&=-3H\gamma+\frac{3K'}{K''}\dot\Phi ++\frac r{K''}[bE-b(1+\lambda_s)\chi+K'\alpha],\\ +K_B(\dot E+HE)&=-b[\gamma+\dot Q\alpha+ +(H+(1+\lambda_s)Q)\chi]+K'\chi. +\end{aligned} +\] + +Here \(\dot Q=-3HK'/K''\). The script evolves these five field variables and checks the constraint separately. It also evolves a second, four-variable formulation with the constraint already eliminated. Agreement checks both the elimination and its numerical propagation. + +Define the scaled momentum potential \(m=K'v\) and pressure perturbation \(p=8\pi\widetilde G\delta P=K'\gamma\). The mixed momentum tensor is \(\delta T^0{}_i=-\partial_i m/(8\pi\widetilde G)\). There is no scalar anisotropic stress at this order. The physical momentum amplitude in an orthonormal frame has magnitude \(k|m|/(8\pi\widetilde G a)\). + +For the selected constants, let \(W=QK'\), \(c_a^2=K'/(QK'')\). The closed four-state system is + +\[ +\Phi=-\frac{D+3Hm}{2r},\quad +\gamma=\frac{D+rZ}{QK''},\quad p=c_a^2(D+rZ), +\] + +\[ +\begin{aligned} +\dot D&=-3H(D+p)+3W(-H\Phi+m/2)-rm,\\ +\dot m&=-3Hm+p+W\Phi,\\ +\dot\chi&=\gamma+QZ+(\dot Q/Q-Q)\chi +-\frac{\dot Q}{QK'}m,\\ +\dot Z&=(-H+Q)Z+(K'-3Q)\chi. +\end{aligned} +\] + +The ratio \(\dot Q/K'=-3H/K''\) is regular as the background density tends to zero. Quantities divided by \(\bar\rho\) or \(\bar\rho+\bar P\) are used only on the finite-density branch. + +The following checks vanish symbolically for arbitrary \(k,a,H,Q,K',K'',K_B,\lambda_s\) on this quadratic branch: + +- \(\dot C+3HC=0\), so constraint-satisfying data remain admissible. +- \(\dot D+3H(D+p)-3QK'\dot\Phi+rm=0\), the effective energy balance. +- \(2[\ddot\Phi+4H\dot\Phi+(2\dot H+3H^2)\Phi]-p=0\), the spatial Einstein trace. + +The lensing combination is \(\Phi+\Psi=2\Phi\). Reporting this combination is legitimate here because matter would couple minimally to this metric. No light-ray integration or measured lensing signal is claimed. + +## 4. Physical compensated data + +At the initial time set the differences in \(v,\alpha,\Phi,\Psi\) and \(\dot\Phi\) to zero. Choose + +\[ +\Delta E=\varepsilon_E,\qquad +\Delta\gamma=\frac{rK_B}{QK''}\varepsilon_E. +\] + +Then \(\Delta p_\Phi=0\), \(\Delta p_\alpha=Q\Delta p_v\), and both canonical constraints vanish. Initially \(\Delta D=\Delta m=0\). Nevertheless + +\[ +\Delta p=\frac{K'rK_B}{QK''}\varepsilon_E,\quad +\Delta\dot m=\Delta p,\quad +\Delta\dot D=-3H\Delta p. +\] + +These states are not related by a gauge transformation. Both \(E\) and \(\chi\) are gauge invariant at linear order. Under a time shift \(T\), \(\alpha\mapsto\alpha+T\), \(v\mapsto v-QT\), \(\Psi\mapsto\Psi-\dot T\), and \(\Phi\mapsto\Phi+HT\). The changed \(E\) cannot be removed this way. + +The pressure comparison also has a gauge-independent form: + +\[ +\delta P-c_a^2\delta\rho=\frac{c_a^2rZ}{8\pi\widetilde G}. +\] + +A second allowed preparation has \(D=m=Z=0\) but \(\chi\ne0\). It starts with the same pressure as the unperturbed state, yet + +\[ +\dot p=c_a^2r(K'-3Q)\chi\ne0. +\] + +Consequently, even adding instantaneous pressure to density and momentum does not give an exact autonomous law for every allowed preparation. The fourth variable carries information about the later pressure. A restricted initial ensemble may remove this freedom, but that restriction must be specified and checked. + +## 5. Stability scope and the vacuum limit + +The flat-space reduced Hamiltonian has canonical pairs \((\chi,p_\chi)\) and \((\alpha,P)\), with \(P=p_\alpha-Q_0p_\varphi\). In units \(Q_0=1\), + +\[ +H_2=\frac{p_\chi^2}{16}+\frac{(p_\chi+P)^2}{4k^2} +-(p_\chi+P)\chi+3k^2\chi^2-\frac{P^2}{8k^2}. +\] + +The three nonzero-coordinate Hessian principal minors are \(6k^2\), \((3k^2+8)/4\), and \((k^2-8)/(16k^2)\). The energy is nonnegative for \(k^2>8\), with the expected flat direction in \(\alpha\). The propagating frequency is \(\omega^2=3k^2/4+2\). The other branch has constant and linear-time solutions. + +This reproduces the result of [Skordis and Zlosnik, equations 53–60](https://arxiv.org/html/2109.13287v2). The threshold is not a new stability bound. The Minkowski runs use \(3\leq k/Q_0\leq12\), above that threshold. + +On the expanding branch the kinetic terms can be checked in spatially flat gauge. The shift equation fixes the lapse by \(H\Psi=K'v/2\), which contains no field velocities. Eliminating lapse and shift leaves the velocity Hessian \(\operatorname{diag}(2a^3K'',2aK_Bk^2)\) for \((v,\alpha)\). Both entries are positive on the tested branch. + +The short-wavelength propagating scalar has positive squared speed \(b(2+K_B\lambda_s)/(K_BK'')=3/4\). Tensor and transverse-vector kinetic signs retain \(0 1e-8) + assert abs(eigen[0] - omega) < 1e-10 + assert np.max(np.abs(density)) < 1e-18 + assert error < 1e-8 + rows.append({ + "k_over_Q0": k, "omega_over_Q0": omega, + "positive_hessian": bool(k*k > 8), + "relative_integration_error": float(error), + "relative_energy_drift": float(np.max(np.abs(energies / energies[0] - 1))), + "max_abs_effective_density_scaled": float(np.max(np.abs(density))), + "max_abs_metric_Phi": float(np.max(np.abs(phis))), + "shift_density_initial": float(exact[1,0]), + "shift_density_ten_periods": float(exact[1,-1]), + "max_abs_chi": float(np.max(np.abs(exact[0]))), + }) + return rows + + +def bg(a, qi): + q = qi / a**3 + Q = 1 + q + Kp, Kpp = 4*q, 4.0 + R = 2*(2*q + q*q) # 8 pi G rho + W = Q*Kp # 8 pi G (rho+p) + H = np.sqrt(R/3) + return Q, Kp, Kpp, R, W, H + + +def background_time_to_scale(end_a, qi): + # Exact a(t)^3 = 1 + 3 H_i t + 3 qi t^2, in Q0=1 units. + Hi=bg(1.,qi)[-1] + return 2*(end_a**3-1)/(3*Hi+np.sqrt(9*Hi*Hi+12*qi*(end_a**3-1))) + + +def rhs_fields(t, state, k, qi): + """Independent five-field evolution; does not solve density constraint.""" + a, v, alpha, E, Phi, gamma = state + Q, Kp, Kpp, R, W, H = bg(a, qi) + r = (k/a)**2 + chi = v + Q*alpha + Qdot = -3*H*Kp/Kpp + Phidot = -H*Phi + Kp*v/2 + Edot = -H*E - (gamma + Qdot*alpha + (H + 2*Q)*chi) + Kp*chi + gammadot = -3*H*gamma + 3*Kp/Kpp*Phidot + r/Kpp*(E - 2*chi + Kp*alpha) + return np.array([a*H, gamma + Q*Phi, E-Phi, Edot, Phidot, gammadot]) + + +def rhs_reduced(t, state, k, qi): + """State=(a,D,m,chi,Z); D,m are scaled density and momentum potential.""" + a, D, m, chi, Z = state + Q, Kp, Kpp, R, W, H = bg(a, qi) + r = (k/a)**2 + gamma = (D + r*Z)/(Q*Kpp) + pres = Kp*gamma + Phi = -(D + 3*H*m)/(2*r) + Phidot = -H*Phi + m/2 + Qdot = -3*H*Kp/Kpp + Ddot = -3*H*(D+pres) + 3*W*Phidot - r*m + mdot = -3*H*m + pres + W*Phi + chidot = gamma + Q*Z + (Qdot/Q-Q)*chi - Qdot/(Q*Kp)*m + Zdot = (-H+Q)*Z + (Kp-3*Q)*chi + return np.array([a*H, Ddot, mdot, chidot, Zdot]) + + +def physical_fields(a, fields, k, qi): + v, alpha, E, Phi, gamma = fields + Q, Kp, Kpp, R, W, H = bg(a, qi) + chi = v + Q*alpha + Z = E+chi + D = Q*Kpp*gamma-(k/a)**2*Z + m = Kp*v + return np.array([D, m, chi, Z]) + + +def solve_preparation(k, qi, kind, tol=1e-10, amplitude=1e-6, end_a=2.0): + Q, Kp, Kpp, R, W, H = bg(1., qi) + omega = np.sqrt(.75*k*k+2) + if kind == "velocity": + f0 = np.array([0, 0, Q*Kpp*amplitude/(k*k), 0, amplitude]) + elif kind == "phase": + chi0 = amplitude/omega + f0 = np.array([0, chi0/Q, -chi0, 0, 0]) + elif kind == "held_out_mix": + chi0 = .37*amplitude/omega + f0 = np.array([0, chi0/Q, -.61*Q*Kpp*amplitude/(k*k)-chi0, 0, -.61*amplitude]) + else: + raise ValueError(kind) + def event(t,y): return y[0] - end_a + event.terminal, event.direction = True, 1 + span = (0, 10/H) + sol = solve_ivp(lambda t,y:rhs_fields(t,y,k,qi),span,np.r_[1.,f0], + method="DOP853",rtol=tol,atol=tol*amplitude*1e-3,events=event,dense_output=True) + assert sol.success and sol.t_events[0].size + times = np.linspace(0,sol.t[-1],2001) + full = sol.sol(times) + red0 = physical_fields(1.,f0,k,qi) + reduced = solve_ivp(lambda t,y:rhs_reduced(t,y,k,qi),(0,times[-1]),np.r_[1.,red0], + method="DOP853",t_eval=times,rtol=tol,atol=tol*amplitude*1e-3) + assert reduced.success + a = full[0] + exact_a=(1+3*bg(1.,qi)[-1]*times+3*qi*times**2)**(1/3) + background_error=float(np.max(abs(a-exact_a))) + assert background_error<1e-11 + Q,Kp,Kpp,R,W,H = bg(a,qi) + obs = physical_fields(a,full[1:],k,qi) + D,m,chi,Z = obs + Phi = full[4] + pressure = Kp*full[5] + C = D+2*(k/a)**2*Phi+3*H*m + # Absolute residual normalized by actual field source terms, not tiny D alone. + cnorm = np.max(np.abs(C))/max(amplitude,np.max(np.abs(Q*Kpp*full[5])),np.max(np.abs((k/a)**2*Z))) + # Compare each physical state with a field-scale floor for near-zero values. + denom = np.maximum(amplitude,np.max(np.abs(obs),axis=1)) + agreement = np.max(np.abs(obs-reduced.y[1:])/denom[:,None]) + assert cnorm < max(5e-8,100*tol), cnorm + assert agreement < max(2e-7,300*tol), agreement + # Gauge invariant nonadiabatic pressure, directly from action coefficients. + nonad = pressure - Kp/(Q*Kpp)*D + nonad_error = np.max(np.abs(nonad - Kp/(Q*Kpp)*(k/a)**2*Z))/amplitude + assert nonad_error < 1e-12 + # Initial canonical constraint differences and auxiliary map. + p_v = 2*bg(1.,qi)[2]*f0[4] - 6*bg(1.,qi)[1]*f0[3] + p_al = 2*k*k*(f0[2]+f0[0]+bg(1.,qi)[0]*f0[1]) + canonical_comp = p_al-bg(1.,qi)[0]*p_v + row = { + "preparation":kind,"k_over_Q0":k,"q_initial_over_Q0":qi, + "amplitude":amplitude,"rtol":tol,"a_end":float(a[-1]), + "time_end_Q0":float(times[-1]), + "initial_canonical_compensation":float(canonical_comp), + "initial_delta_nu":float(4*f0[4]/bg(1.,qi)[0]**2), + "max_constraint_residual_normalized":float(cnorm), + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized":float(agreement), + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude":float(pressure[0]/amplitude), + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude":float(np.max(np.abs(D))/amplitude), + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude":float(np.max(np.abs(m))/amplitude), + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude":float(np.max(np.abs(pressure))/amplitude), + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude":float(np.max(np.abs(2*Phi))/amplitude), + "final_density_per_amplitude":float(D[-1]/amplitude), + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude":float(m[-1]/amplitude), + "min_physical_k_over_Q0":float(k/a[-1]), + "min_k_over_aH":float(np.min(k/(a*H))), + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient":float(np.min(2*a**3*Kpp)), + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient":float(np.min(2*a*k*k)), + "max_background_scale_factor_error":background_error, + "max_abs_density_contrast":float(np.max(abs(D/R))), + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude":float(np.max(abs(k*full[2]/a))), + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q":float(np.max(abs(full[5]/Q))), + "max_abs_metric_Phi":float(np.max(abs(Phi))), + } + return row, times, full, obs, pressure + + +def small_density_limit(): + rows=[] + k, eps = 6.,1e-6 + for qi in [1e-2,1e-3,1e-4,1e-5]: + Q,Kp,Kpp,*_=bg(1,qi) + f0=np.array([1,0,0,Q*Kpp*eps/k**2,0,eps]) + times=np.linspace(0,1,1001) + s=solve_ivp(lambda t,y:rhs_fields(t,y,k,qi),(0,1),f0,method="DOP853",t_eval=times,rtol=1e-11,atol=1e-20) + a=s.y[0] + D,m,chi,Z=physical_fields(a,s.y[1:],k,qi) + pressure=bg(a,qi)[1]*s.y[5] + rows.append({"q_initial_over_Q0":qi,"time_end_Q0":1, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude":float(np.max(abs(pressure))/eps), + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude":float(np.max(abs(D))/eps), + "max_abs_density_contrast_per_amplitude":float(np.max(abs(D/bg(a,qi)[3]))/eps), + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude":float(np.max(abs(2*s.y[4]))/eps)}) + return rows + + +def approximation_control(): + """Unfitted p=0 and p=c_a^2 D closures against held-out hidden data.""" + qi, delta_i, threshold = .01,1e-5,.01 + Q,Kp,Kpp,R,W,H=bg(1,qi) + endtime=background_time_to_scale(2.,qi) + times=np.linspace(0,endtime,2001) + rows=[] + for k in [6.,9.,12.,18.,24.]: + D0=R*delta_i + m0=-W*H*delta_i/k**2 + closures={} + for name in ["zero_pressure","adiabatic_pressure"]: + def rhs(t,y): + a,D,m=y + Q,Kp,Kpp,R,W,H=bg(a,qi) + r=(k/a)**2 + Phi=-(D+3*H*m)/(2*r) + pressure=0 if name=="zero_pressure" else Kp/(Q*Kpp)*D + return [a*H,-3*H*(D+pressure)+3*W*(-H*Phi+m/2)-r*m, + -3*H*m+pressure+W*Phi] + s=solve_ivp(rhs,(0,endtime),[1,D0,m0],method="DOP853",t_eval=times,rtol=1e-11,atol=1e-21) + a,D,m=s.y + bgv=bg(a,qi) + closures[name]=(D/bgv[3],-(D+3*bgv[5]*m)/(k/a)**2) + scales=[np.max(abs(x)) for x in closures['zero_pressure']] + for kind in ["velocity","phase"]: + for eta in [0.,.01,.1,1.]: + if eta==0 and kind=="phase": + continue # Same zero-hidden-data preparation, counted once. + # gamma hidden amplitude is eta*Q0*delta_i for velocity data. + # chi hidden amplitude is eta*Q0*delta_i/omega for phase data. + ch0=0 if kind=="velocity" else eta*delta_i/np.sqrt(.75*k*k+2) + Z0=Q*Kpp*eta*delta_i/k**2 if kind=="velocity" else 0 + s=solve_ivp(lambda t,y:rhs_reduced(t,y,k,qi),(0,endtime),[1,D0,m0,ch0,Z0], + method="DOP853",t_eval=times,rtol=1e-11,atol=1e-21) + a,D,m,chi,Z=s.y + bgv=bg(a,qi) + exact=(D/bgv[3],-(D+3*bgv[5]*m)/(k/a)**2) + for name,predicted in closures.items(): + errors=[float(np.max(abs(ex-pred))/scale) for ex,pred,scale in zip(exact,predicted,scales)] + rows.append({"k_over_Q0":k,"hidden_preparation":kind,"eta":eta,"closure":name, + "density_error_fraction":errors[0],"lensing_error_fraction":errors[1], + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast":float(np.max(abs(exact[0]))), + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum":float(np.max(abs(exact[1]))), + "passes_1_percent":max(errors)<=threshold}) + return {"threshold_fraction":threshold,"delta_initial":delta_i, + "normalization":"maximum of each observable in the zero-pressure reference", + "rows":rows} + + +def main(): + ap=argparse.ArgumentParser() + ap.add_argument("--output",type=Path,default=Path(__file__).with_name("results.json")) + args=ap.parse_args() + results={"scope":"Linear classical AeST tracking benchmark; no collapse or observational fit", + "environment":{"python":platform.python_version(),"numpy":np.__version__,"scipy":scipy.__version__,"sympy":sp.__version__}, + "parameters":{"KB":1,"K2":2,"lambda_s":1,"Q0_unit":1,"q_initial_over_Q0":.01,"amplitude":1e-6}, + "symbolic":symbolic_checks(),"minkowski":minkowski(),"flrw":[]} + solutions={} + for k in [6.,9.,12.,18.,24.]: + for kind in ["velocity","phase","held_out_mix"]: + row,times,full,obs,pres=solve_preparation(k,.01,kind) + results["flrw"].append(row) + solutions[(k,kind)]=(times,full,obs,pres) + # Superposition is checked on a common time grid, including the independent + # phase preparation withheld from the compensated-velocity example. + mix_errors=[] + for k in [6.,9.,12.,18.,24.]: + mix=solutions[(k,"held_out_mix")][2] + expected=-.61*solutions[(k,"velocity")][2]+.37*solutions[(k,"phase")][2] + mix_errors.append(float(np.max(np.abs(mix-expected))/1e-6)) + results["held_out_superposition_max_error_per_amplitude"]=max(mix_errors) + assert max(mix_errors)<1e-7 + results["tolerance_control"]=[] + for tol in [1e-8,1e-10,1e-12]: + row,*_=solve_preparation(12.,.01,"velocity",tol) + results["tolerance_control"].append(row) + results["amplitude_control"]=[] + for amp in [1e-7,1e-6,1e-5]: + row,*_=solve_preparation(12.,.01,"velocity",amplitude=amp) + results["amplitude_control"].append(row) + ampkeys=["max_abs_density_per_amplitude","max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude","max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude"] + amp_error=max(float(np.ptp([r[key] for r in results['amplitude_control']])) for key in ampkeys) + results['amplitude_control_max_normalized_response_spread']=amp_error + assert amp_error<1e-8 + results["small_density_fixed_time_limit"]=small_density_limit() + results["approximation_control"]=approximation_control() + args.output.write_text(json.dumps(results,indent=2)+"\n") + print(json.dumps({"output":str(args.output),"flrw_preparations":len(results["flrw"]), + "max_constraint_residual":max(x["max_constraint_residual_normalized"] for x in results["flrw"]), + "max_formulation_difference":max(x["max_independent_formulation_error_normalized"] for x in results["flrw"]), + "all_assertions_passed":True},indent=2)) + + +if __name__=="__main__": main() diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/results.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/results.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..66019ae --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/results.json @@ -0,0 +1,1524 @@ +{ + "scope": "Linear classical AeST tracking benchmark; no collapse or observational fit", + "environment": { + "python": "3.14.6", + "numpy": "2.5.4", + "scipy": "1.18.1", + "sympy": "1.14.0" + }, + "parameters": { + "KB": 1, + "K2": 2, + "lambda_s": 1, + "Q0_unit": 1, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06 + }, + "symbolic": { + "identities": { + "energy_balance": "0", + "spatial_einstein_trace": "0", + "constraint_propagation_dotC_plus_3HC": "0", + "compensated_hamiltonian_constraint": "0", + "quadratic_action_lapse_constraint": "0" + }, + "compensated_pressure": "KB*Kp*eps*k**2/(Kpp*Q*a**2)", + "momentum_varphi": "-2*a**3*(3*Kp*Phi + Kpp*Psi*Q - Kpp*vdot)", + "momentum_alpha": "-2*a*k**2*(-KB*Psi + KB*Q*al - KB*alphadot + KB*v - 2*Q*al - 2*v)", + "minkowski_hessian_principal_minors": [ + "6*k**2", + "(3*k**2 + 8)/4", + "(k**2 - 8)/(16*k**2)" + ] + }, + "minkowski": [ + { + "k_over_Q0": 3.0, + "omega_over_Q0": 2.958039891549808, + "positive_hessian": true, + "relative_integration_error": 1.1410025943190137e-10, + "relative_energy_drift": 1.2814194150223557e-12, + "max_abs_effective_density_scaled": 4.235164736271502e-22, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 0.0, + "shift_density_initial": 8e-06, + "shift_density_ten_periods": 8.000000000005109e-06, + "max_abs_chi": 4.883113471767132e-07 + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 4.5, + "omega_over_Q0": 4.14578098794425, + "positive_hessian": true, + "relative_integration_error": 1.5138796468514718e-10, + "relative_energy_drift": 1.2811973704174306e-12, + "max_abs_effective_density_scaled": 4.235164736271502e-22, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 0.0, + "shift_density_initial": 8e-06, + "shift_density_ten_periods": 8.000000000005122e-06, + "max_abs_chi": 2.8885531283020663e-07 + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "omega_over_Q0": 5.385164807134504, + "positive_hessian": true, + "relative_integration_error": 1.3567694969354566e-10, + "relative_energy_drift": 1.2803091919977305e-12, + "max_abs_effective_density_scaled": 4.235164736271502e-22, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 0.0, + "shift_density_initial": 8e-06, + "shift_density_ten_periods": 8.000000000005122e-06, + "max_abs_chi": 2.063281535301663e-07 + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "omega_over_Q0": 7.92148975887743, + "positive_hessian": true, + "relative_integration_error": 1.5076731180907688e-10, + "relative_energy_drift": 1.2871925747504065e-12, + "max_abs_effective_density_scaled": 4.235164736271502e-22, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 0.0, + "shift_density_initial": 8e-06, + "shift_density_ten_periods": 8.000000000005151e-06, + "max_abs_chi": 1.3247289941565786e-07 + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "omega_over_Q0": 10.488088481701515, + "positive_hessian": true, + "relative_integration_error": 1.420768596493719e-10, + "relative_energy_drift": 1.2871925747504065e-12, + "max_abs_effective_density_scaled": 4.235164736271502e-22, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 0.0, + "shift_density_initial": 8e-06, + "shift_density_ten_periods": 8.000000000005145e-06, + "max_abs_chi": 9.799476611695952e-08 + } + ], + "flrw": [ + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.54711547367933, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 3.2458565705884633e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 4.059045410713651e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.09912394277766673, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0077391936768298735, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04006707783259419, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.004300393406860189, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.03808087350226648, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0004391008577023665, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 3.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 51.832105534881606, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 72.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.611417564475498e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 4.1879558109664315e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.975229757531787e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 2.1501967034300947e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "phase", + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679339, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 0.0, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 5.1997265806018345e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 5.484702446105125e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.24500359593787893, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.010803188914670114, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.031188991702986602, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.01677406815534886, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.15097516581176704, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.0011128025459892859, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 3.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 51.832105534881606, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 72.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 3.0176173054194534e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 1.1099317791424599e-06, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 8.500688064656236e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 8.387034077674429e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "held_out_mix", + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679334, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 8.470329472543003e-22, + "initial_delta_nu": -2.391922360552887e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 4.923054750711256e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 3.62802872503636e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": -0.0244, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.13899363443842092, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.007570258494336473, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.028307167568683893, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.008778542881342182, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.07909014418928831, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.0006795884652759085, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 3.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 51.832105534881606, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 72.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.3322676295501878e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 1.5808148744892104e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 6.267091064334644e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 7.261309390441454e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 4.389271440671091e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 1.9999999999999998, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679321, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 3.0903483541725493e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.9828424056237797e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.10373659845375169, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.005205403407398907, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04003127402053307, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0019746632463398164, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.0375125961389085, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.00035223701750892187, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 4.500000000000001, + "min_k_over_aH": 77.74815830232241, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 162.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.9984014443252818e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.599943549649836e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.836245571715825e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.935750952270075e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 9.873316231699082e-10 + }, + { + "preparation": "phase", + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679346, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 0.0, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 3.861925602665153e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 3.513381492136511e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.3889106585708582, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.008229291943516785, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.03414961967274439, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.011823227016594651, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.2376649356534093, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.00048783043146022196, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 4.5, + "min_k_over_aH": 77.74815830232241, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 162.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 8.881784197001252e-16, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 4.7503297569700796e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 1.1418460228432752e-06, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.036909253780285e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.911613508297326e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "held_out_mix", + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679339, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 1.6940658945086007e-21, + "initial_delta_nu": -2.391922360552887e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 3.7954982790244235e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.5984297374022163e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": -0.0244, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.19231372532966393, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.005282894214294984, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.028463999908721584, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.005543029949992084, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.11081870983633318, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.0003953618403273891, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 4.5, + "min_k_over_aH": 77.74815830232241, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 162.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 6.661338147750939e-16, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 2.2149898280841113e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 5.677254086024988e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 7.220259149658917e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 2.771514974996042e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679344, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.367221880537738e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.632710748964374e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.1053117095375001, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0039055729854645467, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0400050585705681, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0011240320013291602, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.036908166783896905, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0001610270615271075, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.770323952409169e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.1472711942858564e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.920564840846943e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.6201600066458e-10 + }, + { + "preparation": "phase", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679328, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 0.0, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 3.034818558169009e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.5905404195919305e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.5276685978549627, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.006551817926715373, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.03557919097017484, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.009032446087125333, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.32340857412586915, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.00023010893473095025, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.5543122344752192e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 6.464131400392138e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 1.1517503861284571e-06, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.268617432475241e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 4.516223043562666e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "held_out_mix", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 1.9999999999999998, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679336, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": -2.391922360552887e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.9423838152149494e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.1467825055033628e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": -0.0244, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.2441297236277673, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.004031568615468776, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.028502714900651708, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.004004346838484474, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.14217515416412288, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.0001833668133678545, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.000000000000001, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 8.881784197001252e-16, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 2.8417270039050158e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 5.356466773277738e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 7.18620725588576e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 2.002173419242237e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 1.9999999999999998, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679353, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 1.7052052480085716e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 1.7089571307680253e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.1063521907180391, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.002597083839913668, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.000504005065674268, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.036894222007351214, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -4.134178009497969e-05, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 9.000000000000002, + "min_k_over_aH": 155.49631660464482, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 648.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.5543122344752192e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.907475697797619e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 1.4464542269622048e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.901998448910083e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 2.5200253283713397e-10 + }, + { + "preparation": "phase", + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 1.9999999999999998, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679334, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 0.0, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.188570307768182e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.084391249748693e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.7986225753637413, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.00461444244545283, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.03695339937603512, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.00609672879350779, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.49305913475775237, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.00012576964788553376, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 9.000000000000002, + "min_k_over_aH": 155.49631660464482, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 648.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 8.881784197001252e-16, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 9.855023305589051e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 1.156061475478243e-06, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.471091617958766e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 3.048364396753895e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "held_out_mix", + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679339, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 1.6940658945086007e-21, + "initial_delta_nu": -2.391922360552887e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 1.9372329253487082e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 1.4801973545162803e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": -0.0244, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.3450134359822315, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.002724197507999757, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.028497042079933674, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.002551491337364816, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.20493735528540893, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -2.131628385753832e-05, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 155.49631660464482, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 648.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 4.096186988840154e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 5.01135182809789e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 7.145336032086395e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 1.275745668682408e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.54711547367935, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 1.1263194503017657e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 1.4698999485067302e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.1066408008582258, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0019430714205473734, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0002843963463826882, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.037681344147382896, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -9.551272793845564e-05, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 207.32842213952642, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 1152.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.7763568394002505e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.963051473246043e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 1.0910839980708775e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.9009900990099e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 1.4219817319134407e-10 + }, + { + "preparation": "phase", + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 1.9999999999999998, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679368, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 0.0, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 1.3819537827493167e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 1.6856657099520022e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 1.065851678980141, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.003547531452440998, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.03762491815885864, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.004590986644995364, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.6610017416315047, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": -0.00014433920542872815, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 12.000000000000002, + "min_k_over_aH": 207.32842213952642, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 1152.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 2.4424906541753444e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 0.0001321177747171027, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 1.1557378971392467e-06, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.555782224030496e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 2.2954933224976816e-09 + }, + { + "preparation": "held_out_mix", + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 1.9999999999999998, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679344, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": -2.391922360552887e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 1.3738693794362717e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 1.3120457634907857e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": -0.0244, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.444117538428294, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0020527747332926526, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.02850847344833729, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.001865191373622927, + "final_density_per_amplitude": 0.2675562643337671, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 4.8572580374106435e-06, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 12.000000000000002, + "min_k_over_aH": 207.32842213952642, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 1152.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 5.3480379488745085e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 4.828227896621317e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 7.121957278995518e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 9.325956868114635e-10 + } + ], + "held_out_superposition_max_error_per_amplitude": 3.3233522973979686e-11, + "tolerance_control": [ + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-08, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679336, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.8166560935294154e-10, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 3.084066270657127e-09, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.10531170988353974, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.003905572944151733, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0400050585705681, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0011240320004608543, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.03690816671086689, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.00016102704817912768, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.77032395544806e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.1472711761332384e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.920564840846943e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.620160002304271e-10 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679344, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.367221880537738e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.632710748964374e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.1053117095375001, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0039055729854645467, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0400050585705681, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0011240320013291602, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.036908166783896905, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0001610270615271075, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.770323952409169e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.1472711942858564e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.920564840846943e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.6201600066458e-10 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-12, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.54711547367933, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.8617979746999137e-14, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.8792502761745787e-13, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.10531170953535372, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.003905572985749367, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.040005058570568804, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0011240320013187054, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.03690816678449894, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0001610270616427686, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.9984014443252818e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.770323952375704e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.1472711942796445e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.920564840847117e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.620160006593527e-10 + } + ], + "amplitude_control": [ + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-07, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679339, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.9211841976276834e-07, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.371270867402604e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.6327239838541748e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.10531170953750084, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0039055729854645406, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.040005058570568096, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0011240320013291482, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.036908166783901936, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.00016102706152709183, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.770323952410066e-07, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.147271194285853e-08, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.920564840846943e-08, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.620160006645741e-11 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-06, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679344, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-06, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.367221880537738e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.632710748964374e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.1053117095375001, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0039055729854645467, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.0400050585705681, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0011240320013291602, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.036908166783896905, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0001610270615271075, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.1102230246251565e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.770323952409169e-06, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.1472711942858564e-07, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.920564840846943e-07, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.6201600066458e-10 + }, + { + "preparation": "velocity", + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "amplitude": 1e-05, + "rtol": 1e-10, + "a_end": 2.0, + "time_end_Q0": 10.547115473679328, + "initial_canonical_compensation": 0.0, + "initial_delta_nu": 3.921184197627684e-05, + "max_constraint_residual_normalized": 2.367542944810317e-12, + "max_independent_formulation_error_normalized": 2.632719219293846e-11, + "initial_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.10531170953748917, + "max_abs_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.0039055729854645454, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.04000505857056811, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0011240320013291578, + "final_density_per_amplitude": -0.036908166783903365, + "final_momentum_potential_per_amplitude": 0.00016102706152708166, + "min_physical_k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "min_k_over_aH": 103.66421106976321, + "min_flat_gauge_scalar_kinetic_coefficient": 8.0, + "min_flat_gauge_vector_kinetic_coefficient": 288.0, + "max_background_scale_factor_error": 1.5543122344752192e-15, + "max_abs_density_contrast": 7.770323952410195e-05, + "max_abs_aether_spatial_amplitude": 2.147271194285857e-06, + "max_abs_deltaQ_over_Q": 9.920564840846946e-06, + "max_abs_metric_Phi": 5.62016000664579e-09 + } + ], + "amplitude_control_max_normalized_response_spread": 1.1671219546371958e-14, + "small_density_fixed_time_limit": [ + { + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.01, + "time_end_Q0": 1, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.040067016591645695, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.09912402175194909, + "max_abs_density_contrast_per_amplitude": 3.0574394897679213, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0031672975373282634 + }, + { + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.001, + "time_end_Q0": 1, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.004041565116693759, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.0119935431781912, + "max_abs_density_contrast_per_amplitude": 3.2147594921991223, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 0.0003490058058897164 + }, + { + "q_initial_over_Q0": 0.0001, + "time_end_Q0": 1, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 0.00040591342898598697, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.0012778767216501477, + "max_abs_density_contrast_per_amplitude": 3.2670482376617334, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 3.60307068948233e-05 + }, + { + "q_initial_over_Q0": 1e-05, + "time_end_Q0": 1, + "max_abs_pressure_per_amplitude": 4.065373790173432e-05, + "max_abs_density_per_amplitude": 0.00013042061133165995, + "max_abs_density_contrast_per_amplitude": 3.2838128428326523, + "max_abs_lensing_sum_per_amplitude": 3.640033530366271e-06 + } + ], + "approximation_control": { + "threshold_fraction": 0.01, + "delta_initial": 1e-05, + "normalization": "maximum of each observable in the zero-pressure reference", + "rows": [ + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.2591865690488359, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.2588914807694066, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4919325345980514e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.1626872719715864, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.1625486880067348, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4919325345980514e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.29698077374377274, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.29665333031207447, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4158183589529938e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.1248930672766497, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.124786838464067, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4158183589529938e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.6371286159982221, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.6365099761960928, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.0008110264612946e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.7847452250222002, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.7980548700218717, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.0008110264612946e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 4.038607038542784, + "lensing_error_fraction": 4.064658778782974, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.119485029908247e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 3.429337723954197e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 2.6167331975223624, + "lensing_error_fraction": 3.010579941356634, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.119485029908247e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 3.429337723954197e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.10934792839377096, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.10910470720989698, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.7936942651409396e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1667137486587677e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.3125259126266513, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.3123354615662444, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.7936942651409396e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1667137486587677e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.239199837501776, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.2682015552008123, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 4.509549840026858e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.537747231497806e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 2.6610736785221984, + "lensing_error_fraction": 2.6604164236017995, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 4.509549840026858e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.537747231497806e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 14.724677496457435, + "lensing_error_fraction": 14.759332493324042, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0003166810558888642, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.7633195903420182e-07, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 6.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 16.14655133747786, + "lensing_error_fraction": 16.141226043957534, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0003166810558888642, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.7633195903420182e-07, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.2744577155257702, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.2742933378352327, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4613356979849683e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.2794132666935445, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.5011929462870766, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4613356979849683e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.31168389805568697, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.3114859062528694, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3873095289958313e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.2458661800751147, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.467287952069707, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3873095289958313e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.646719540824881, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.6475663339670388, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.0003512361351839e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.967586739693845, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.1622378372216926, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.0003512361351839e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 4.017095987544329, + "lensing_error_fraction": 4.192722058648906, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.159506442308024e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.5884470395876428e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 2.5119860071637587, + "lensing_error_fraction": 2.859569565661288, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.159506442308024e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.5884470395876428e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.06513053707834673, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.09752804341361332, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.9363686736818125e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 5.4521795764055366e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.494427236022663, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.7185816935310145, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.9363686736818125e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 5.4521795764055366e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 2.0840456103214366, + "lensing_error_fraction": 2.1167755121734486, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.211665454953412e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.550569335810133e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 3.5922638070404296, + "lensing_error_fraction": 3.7554764104152083, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.211665454953412e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.550569335810133e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 23.31057554294625, + "lensing_error_fraction": 23.504943389303257, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.000489646332676693, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.219125806848734e-07, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 9.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 24.818793739665242, + "lensing_error_fraction": 25.054256022331206, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.000489646332676693, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.219125806848734e-07, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.2798686552019291, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.27977642533240404, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4504921547606405e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.194481825131435, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.6459904339605944, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4504921547606405e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.3164936398518679, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.3163869333447878, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3768929495532347e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.1711861241874812, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.6124650199045083, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3768929495532347e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.647364884940836, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.6642401120734597, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.0002030679051047e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.9674477765827144, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.3475828349076404, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.0002030679051047e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 4.1184929484651205, + "lensing_error_fraction": 4.238606985567693, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.335312560941134e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 9.064998660471586e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 3.258801728893593, + "lensing_error_fraction": 3.3471600666619605, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.335312560941134e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 9.064998660471586e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.11223806311864826, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.15788550564945075, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 2.096905294795117e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 3.2371301556365816e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.4004992269618655, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.9108261810940248, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 2.096905294795117e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 3.2371301556365816e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 2.9294031929797515, + "lensing_error_fraction": 2.9550428133913993, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 7.914623555105401e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1069516078796203e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 3.747252518270659, + "lensing_error_fraction": 4.390618709344191, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 7.914623555105401e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.1069516078796203e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 31.812849826614926, + "lensing_error_fraction": 31.999461528556516, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0006609180615820833, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 9.23609454861735e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 12.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 32.619672381971796, + "lensing_error_fraction": 32.85133773936301, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0006609180615820833, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 9.23609454861735e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.2842855907627352, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.2842570666286238, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4416344139507871e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.1170301796275137, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.7870936182111172, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.4416344139507871e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.3208957504290363, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.32087451934427696, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3678920589080563e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.1001712150638132, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.7641872498474573, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3678920589080563e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.6689004028241023, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.6777462307093904, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.9698428984799198, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.5594898761381522, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 4.2016777206430564, + "lensing_error_fraction": 4.27232417065453, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.476572130637046e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.071264204658118e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 3.4446682101268773, + "lensing_error_fraction": 3.912135597219045, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.476572130637046e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.071264204658118e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.23153783313021467, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.2923873489177966, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 2.4271367445076507e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.6067326439852866e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.3206593668762454, + "lensing_error_fraction": 2.0757559211038203, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 2.4271367445076507e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.6067326439852866e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 4.608343299688504, + "lensing_error_fraction": 4.61830895277909, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.00011296657719519185, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.989551178431719e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 5.503525780858314, + "lensing_error_fraction": 5.503422184999989, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.00011296657719519185, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.989551178431719e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 48.64200331374894, + "lensing_error_fraction": 48.72394642485141, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0009999186746963331, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.186005387597141e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 18.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 49.53718579491875, + "lensing_error_fraction": 49.59474945335684, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0009999186746963331, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.186005387597141e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.2866581886132501, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.28665098223462987, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.43686894300398e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.978677155671297e-10, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.2797033473366135, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.8466693724649639, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.43686894300398e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.978677155671297e-10, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.3240490572984475, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.3251242999673827, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3615533269723663e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.978677155671297e-10, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.2457418797639201, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.8277388371409753, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1.3615533269723663e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.978677155671297e-10, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.6781318276994228, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.6831588980638172, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.978677155671297e-10, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.978251399747869, + "lensing_error_fraction": 1.6593093988295442, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 1e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 6.978677155671297e-10, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 4.2358227745901935, + "lensing_error_fraction": 4.2843235079732835, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.533527299411951e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.298571245243543e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "velocity", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 2.8261746179965117, + "lensing_error_fraction": 3.8301448866010994, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 6.533527299411951e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 2.298571245243543e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 0.3741014723204275, + "lensing_error_fraction": 0.43789074115726523, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 2.7580466901735458e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.0057733596941425e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.01, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 1.8818491505442838, + "lensing_error_fraction": 2.1620394826536096, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 2.7580466901735458e-05, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 1.0057733596941425e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 6.272404361374413, + "lensing_error_fraction": 6.273911151873974, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.00014648646414699255, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 5.0903887891289015e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 0.1, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 7.656628832287054, + "lensing_error_fraction": 7.856894530109685, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.00014648646414699255, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 5.0903887891289015e-09, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "zero_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 65.30396731126183, + "lensing_error_fraction": 65.31648112842531, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0013355464365995362, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.6409262077566096e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + }, + { + "k_over_Q0": 24.0, + "hidden_preparation": "phase", + "eta": 1.0, + "closure": "adiabatic_pressure", + "density_error_fraction": 66.68819178217447, + "lensing_error_fraction": 66.70947298304259, + "max_abs_exact_density_contrast": 0.0013355464365995362, + "max_abs_exact_lensing_sum": 4.6409262077566096e-08, + "passes_1_percent": false + } + ] + } +} diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json index e698cad..58e9c0f 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json @@ -1,20 +1,42 @@ { - "source_main": "364fa3e9f740f42acaa1991428ce043f547e10dd", - "stage": "protocol", - "files": [ + "checked_on": "2026-11-12", + "scope": "Primary-source check for the specified AeST linear constraint and preparation calculation. Not a systematic review or novelty certification.", + "sources": [ { - "path": "protocol.md", - "sha256": "4ca257a4c0084dca9abe3a8c91b06646d10189ce2d5a340e6e463b17716d05a8" + "id": "skordis_zlosnik_2021", + "title": "New Relativistic Theory for Modified Newtonian Dynamics", + "url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2007.00082v3", + "used_for": "Original action, homogeneous background, fluid definitions and pressure nonclosure. Equations 5 and 7-13.", + "boundary": "Displayed cosmological vector equation has no nonzero constant F_Y contribution; this benchmark derives the lambda_s=1 term directly. Published observational fits are not assigned to this benchmark." + }, + { + "id": "skordis_zlosnik_2022", + "title": "Aether scalar tensor theory: Linear stability on Minkowski space", + "url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2109.13287v2", + "used_for": "Gauge transformations, quadratic scalar action, canonical constraints, reduced Hamiltonian and stability threshold. Equations 26-60.", + "boundary": "The mode spectrum and threshold are reproduced checks, not new findings." + }, + { + "id": "bataki_skordis_zlosnik", + "title": "Aether scalar tensor theory: Hamiltonian Formalism", + "url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3", + "used_for": "Exact action, ADM momentum constraint, auxiliary variables, chosen function (84), and Minkowski canonical map (106-115).", + "boundary": "The finite-density quadratic expansion and response in this repository are author derivations awaiting independent review." + }, + { + "id": "domenech_ganz_2025", + "title": "Connecting Relativistic MOND Theories with Mimetic Gravity", + "url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2503.11174v1", + "used_for": "Boundary check: alternate formulations do not supply the nonlinear caustic solution or a regularizer used here.", + "boundary": "No mimetic ultraviolet completion or entropy law is assumed." } ], - "primary_sources": [ - "https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3", - "https://arxiv.org/html/2007.00082v3", - "https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.13287", - "https://arxiv.org/html/2503.11174v1" - ], - "limits": [ - "Derivation and executable response checks remain in progress.", - "No closure, cosmological fluid inference or collapse result established." + "new_calculation": [ + "Explicit finite-density canonical map for the stated tracking branch", + "Gauge-distinct compensated preparations and their metric response", + "Second null preparation matching instantaneous pressure", + "Numerical transfer amplitudes, independent formulations and tolerance controls", + "Fixed-time zero-density limit with absolute versus contrast normalization", + "Unfitted two-variable closure errors for the stated preparation ensemble" ] } From d99ec36cc31edda40bfaaaecfeb24b54849f7970 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: ahrazzle <38987266+ahrazzle@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 17:24:51 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 3/7] Record independent ADM derivation and response review --- README.md | 2 +- .../aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md | 10 +- .../aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS | 11 +- .../__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc | Bin 0 -> 36909 bytes .../independent-review/REVIEW.md | 46 ++++++++ .../independent-review/adm-evidence.json | 56 ++++++++++ .../independent-review/adm_check.py | 102 ++++++++++++++++++ .../aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json | 2 +- 8 files changed, 220 insertions(+), 9 deletions(-) create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/REVIEW.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm-evidence.json create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm_check.py diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 8a9462d..82c13fe 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -49,4 +49,4 @@ All Python scripts use only the Python 3 standard library. Each certificate file ## AeST response benchmark in progress -The [AeST response benchmark](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md) constructs allowed field preparations on a specified expanding background and a flat-space control. It includes the canonical map, executable response checks and a bounded pressure-closure comparison. Independent review of the action expansion and constraint reduction is pending. +The [AeST response benchmark](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md) constructs allowed field preparations on a specified expanding background and a flat-space control. It includes the canonical map, executable response checks and a bounded pressure-closure comparison. A separate Astra agent reproduced the scalar constraint and kinetic structure from an independent ADM action. A slow-mode preparation test is in progress. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md index d9ca949..f558ba7 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ This benchmark constructs physical scalar perturbations of one specified AeST action. On an expanding background, states with the same initial density, momentum and metric produce different pressure and later gravitational potentials. A flat-space control explains why the same field freedom has no linear gravitational response at zero background density. -**Status:** action-derived calculation with executable internal checks. Independent review of the expanding-background action and canonical reduction is pending. This is not a nonlinear collapse, thermalization or observational result. +**Status:** action-derived calculation checked by a separate Astra agent using an independently reduced ADM action. [The review](independent-review/REVIEW.md) found no blocking error. This is internal project review, not external peer review or a nonlinear collapse, thermalization or observational result. The complete action, conventions, constraints and equations are in [derivation.md](derivation.md). The test choices and the approximation threshold are in [protocol.md](protocol.md). The equations build on published AeST work listed in [sources.json](sources.json). No new propagating mode or new Minkowski stability bound is claimed. @@ -44,7 +44,9 @@ Thus density and momentum do not predict every allowed preparation. Adding insta | Flat-space exact matrix exponential versus ODE | Relative error below \(1.6\times10^{-10}\) over ten periods | | Flat-space quadratic energy | Relative drift below \(1.3\times10^{-12}\) | -The exact expanding solution for \(a(t)\) is checked independently. The scalar kinetic Hessian and short-wavelength characteristic have the required positive signs in the author derivation. Their derivation still requires independent review. The test does not prove nonlinear stability or stability of an observationally fitted cosmology. +The exact expanding solution for \(a(t)\) is checked independently. The scalar kinetic Hessian and short-wavelength characteristic have the required positive signs in the author derivation. + +The separate review reproduces the scalar kinetic Hessian and integrates the ADM equations, matching eight reconstructed observables to 1.06e-12 normalized error. The test does not prove nonlinear stability or stability of an observationally fitted cosmology. For \(q_i=0\), the compensated field mode oscillates but its linear density, momentum, pressure and metric response vanish identically. The scalar shift current remains nonzero. It must not be identified with stress-energy momentum. @@ -84,4 +86,6 @@ python response.py --output results.json The [script](response.py) includes assertions. The [results](results.json) retain all preparation values, residuals, amplitude controls and approximation errors. No network request, downloaded dataset, fitting stage or graphical dependency is needed. -The bounded result supports retaining the additional scalar/vector response data before a nonlinear solver is attempted. The next gate is independent review of the action expansion and canonical map. A three-dimensional collapse experiment remains unstarted. +The bounded result supports retaining the additional scalar/vector response data before a nonlinear solver is attempted. The next bounded test selects a slow initial mode and measures sensitivity to fast-mode contamination. A three-dimensional collapse experiment remains unstarted. + +The derivation is retained byte-for-byte at its reviewed hash, including its original pre-review status. The review linked above supersedes that status. Run `python independent-review/adm_check.py` for the separate action reduction and comparison. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS index 293f507..e01835a 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS @@ -1,7 +1,10 @@ -bf94a6927d74b6865d99eadc9827e9f21d9ca3d3ea7bec4bfaa0f50f75d83f6c README.md -f90522170c4ea67d2601e8c099216ff992a5d3b94a43c0322da87c03f6e9facc protocol.md +830d4f9b5a250380f5fe29de28d5f74e89a4201590214cdb0d3b69c434815f6d README.md 5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe derivation.md +58f56124bef156d5a8e22d0bd4eaab695c4ac0540f0e211e63f5e99ff4bc10e7 independent-review/REVIEW.md +ab32294e143f463d1d80026f3d70ee23dff22facd159bcdf86889a236aea8def independent-review/adm-evidence.json +0e46bfdf9f34b8f0be33b9c3f465e5c1eb2730a254f5f27a7b02f1216456c4c6 independent-review/adm_check.py +f90522170c4ea67d2601e8c099216ff992a5d3b94a43c0322da87c03f6e9facc protocol.md +ebab51ac1b6420faa2394d3deaba33637ddfff96456fe15406991f12d5a227f2 requirements.txt e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef response.py c82b4e1c64da797e5a701f698808b7074c780778306cb6622721011403573602 results.json -ebab51ac1b6420faa2394d3deaba33637ddfff96456fe15406991f12d5a227f2 requirements.txt -2b3cccc760af9e8f6334fd04240fa2581a9f08af2d2d3a56b9eec8418036c14b sources.json +6f11f6b728915532867b3d61ac4d2eb34dc40fd090dd29e4e177406065a277c4 sources.json diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b6f75b70d23eddcd51665dbda7c789741e756787 GIT binary patch literal 36909 zcmd75dt4mXohMq=-9R_pJi2+myLkyD1mYp|e(;inup}s?YT3e&1{!D!K~W7@lAVO? zWOlI=#vR*Qw{0Jt%OOW4Nj~LnOGZTCjLz0rYxqT?06>mtgr9v-IX7Cct3aV z-0!LG>OO@)a-95e3;I;msq_4u-}#+$e!t)OolS`e@eHn$t-pKZax=sHn!G5NCiK95 z?8n0t!!hGbH^Z^5>>4 zH;$Wd*R>`bN*qs=!^E^E9ZDWgE?~IW3})QS#lf|3dblZ^0d6W64>yf7!cFH)a5Fdy zmyp2>v*VduBHpvOB)HjJGTfYpb2;<&lMK_3y5%wt=h&FKaGj8Yrbzykr<{MQp>NzZ zIIoU1?(mvGMN z80ojV&%vWIKK|&ab!2p8*frur)V|T-VTa&$R#-=S-A-}RK{9a+TL)a@)=|+qF+46h zCS9Y$&T#}iBjAqjR+rm4;db^{#&Z)RJFUXG@uAU?S}SrDMn~MvN@Tcs^XSC5FfmR% zk%+tU5%=gwd^sC5Iz~oD$K`C?NAa#}cZ?6=Zg7tdPda;ClLGN{o)ymYDNRf6N%(0Q zhW&Wi%rK5!j@?sCSLAzpxbY(%c(4HlI2M1JZHPy%M-2=kvSN|gA`S}rZVj)mkkKjh zRWRH)JuOnxZ42l1Xbe(&O?+EOcGym?JG%g50< z@H#pz)t7Z!LKTC;DEmoON!E=oWZeaSRa{={lXF!_n|r&tJ&4TkI|N*X(ceiIs-Y-F6Edl27AP@2b5T`!e`UK8sK1vk`k2 zzl+~ptKnimO!Yzz)nj#3#lw#_h6gd_Ep=?j18`JhxrI;pEHywp6;`Zj4K@5}Sp8O2 z(|G!g&Q~d)kbA%SfM$^zr7JPIb*pNmE(-+`#7v{}C$LyWrPiTI>-R=FJwTGGxl%qM zkGCM_BvnWiU7+D`SNo{(U|skL`S*jH47GfvRCnc*PnVA_krG2FpmJDytcj(^2Eoc> z^1vJMOTf>>TkZc7qYVXN-b%lzDLLJ1t6~HjmG|0Mp5GovHFfxrw<)Dp?m{7z5;a~a zae-MWpE0E(Dy6mI5l6%0QH;Psu}~tE@+E4l>rSR?%a`z_H2hbE)vX?BX&BP!&}pnr zlP^}qqOcZtv1%lzL-NJy($L>j`IV}}b?fhys;bmfS%eJ~geiZjtv2w*q;9p^x^N2! zWn6kPbE14gQ^`zd4qz53lvAm!-Qs1Oo-eP~gxp$9MYfUy!?Y(vpOq(NYO3JWQB7Mt z!x)%+M%bvzZEdVDsIUUqENl`ggv~-FznRzZn^Z8RYAsY@PNk*iSX>5Qp@uUZx7)Oe zE+!ytr3$#yVfhOBjizGVhI`RSepQ<5mxfN0&dZ*>ejHHEgnN9|sj2e%kfZaXAs}p7 z4N*RpuUbDxdkdWsUrE=A-?V-_I?wLdRU@ZrB;c#)9O(2Buaf?zuB{pps(9K}@$Lap zx}0=gLN(Qc*2d|08mEOCzWQG6%Io3XJK%tUF3akes&DEU8-?rlo9V5eKMhMh z2BlH0TX@xYY;U_qI#g-sGOq{o3X1Ni;Gak(6n?~*wS}*yQ{p#8=wU6Fxf;vq{DD{M z`CtXFQR5b!t}5ndp3|sD_Ek7eRmc8^d$#U9)`4`n=oX{>g*pn0*PcVv@^y6VHRl19 zYASG_IV45Dl@?J(4Ph%)o;AlM>igQQUd?a5E7f``*5^&N=B`w?aYjCuGx2#`0$;!- z@`YRyzZLVc?fmw3@FG@U$_Sav97qSx0W?F{A?)OLb~7@Q2Q#5urVZST4u;>s@2u4* z;fGiQ0edJN>NI}?^NL2t7%IOjm{HVVW+TzGgG08lu(?7 z@~w~frcl1yBEG5oM$9pa!*dL@jZjR5D^|i`UXUElStArz#T22u1^5Z&uF#WQp71k5 zxR~;+^BJeD4(lQ7n6<;&Cg5MN4m-|R+ZvCTYl3lLS)F%^qd}eMbPS(Qp0t8V)naWQ za#;r*XU;gvS&=k(UwEx2!vg#s22f!?9>&9Njf1&A&!{UhN9UPZmSe~|vnw*Y?$mU$ z3VtL<*mO#rm3t9W&Z^2m(yS%r=qKf13z-6x}H-Gj~%umZ)s!Afv1dq=XNdaKlL{g^J5pem+UXteaGjj19_Y0HMjC=-pQ*8>_7FX43NLryoD{-i6+Dg z#v)&EO@mtZ#F?P>yh|w8iln;-jWP!ob)0m%gN8|m=yLQ9JKb)=WgM8A645Ie0D3%_ zbB`i#L?CxDoKL5i+ezl9&OLeVV#;!E*IU}f)|-zl?>`mD?FwXd1(F{2>mU9Y;h3P- zDY(za^#S1pYx~jj=61J>pnw19xOI{^Z9%2n6t-2w{i z818YpM%?3Ydcf9&e=(ZTjYrqWc#j~C3J$ad_`5wwqp3$2o^bcn9%>2}63(x4#Eo|9 z?-_EOaSe};j<_5nJ<-@f+t`GoUqtM_9*4}R?vdHbbdY#gKk&*m?gHFW=_CcTxqCu% z29wT=64aYG(*v*yL#|+A#6zxHu<(p)~ zVlXb8Lr~lA92d!)BpBlwcb;(rCC0__Jwf(#kaYyvLqT>d$aVxZZ9-5Bq7~GFYT>Oh z$o2-=$)LtD9AsO9TC`P=9SpK!P}4UQWFHE$%|RWhdQj8RAJiP`2P+)S8PrSy=^Vp& zXu)r=UnEO1u|Up0)M{)~Fg*%-y5Yn;5==*c8%!cD4gUn$Ljkr(IO;)G2(s-#b||PB zatGOwU~CA8D6QKSj3wpiaR+si#AVxpT9DeH=7B-{9H>`+Fh*|VVC=X<9CVHcjo~&Y zJv68ldM1hE2*!rGY*07iIO7b)Oge@qoMI-aRTdog9yr#|f9>BN>T*e|x|=wHbkj%% zKaUOdv(mCx9{J`YD|*{p-F*KiTFr*oC0)@}!?exAdfYzComj>YKixPJJJoPIBkQ^I zPoMV})-BX6XY60nr6O3hr+P(in694DO^cPPy)zk} z>X{t8ni8gKJldJ$6bz_ zZJVo}XXl%)#Vu4{`J%LG_o7DH*eK;TN|q+c(6rclW6i}p?R^;Z)uro`<;%B z>1IEPWzsXBJN5Lbmo2`AZ>7zd=Q^&W&D-Ytua!yVyCmDL1;?W8x^uDj`Xe{%q`k)^ z+c7`aDRC$Lr@ADrOR{wZ(jJ~VdfSxvRNIqnUiNv;r+e|_9E+mI%D|yd+W_kXGO(Z6?WU^Ezfr ze1)?cePgqglD-URkyr52sTWSYYME+O>^dX&6NZ5omU=MXt;h*s%Z8bTc(X9cO@n+4XE+O`5*3<9_p6(Zs}-`r0+rP4aTRk zpUn0&cv)|?*Wo!AFxaLV|FL#=AYsqn?3i>w~b;XiTm?Nk0!-O`b6$=vOC^!l9xl4HQ{8upKjO0H4KF)Eoy zC4(^4sKEKK@A$G|BQn;-f<&2T`e({Kz1~J&%IqOvR8)*nh(AfAAsc#6wccLsI%f{)c<~ef|DHm(=I-51*0x&iI8f z06`i*Ckf}IzH`#U=cV-XQv73*?lBYuz3SkT2R)5m%Y}p9&Vb2=PLh!1v3WW!6wf>u z?jZGZ4fEP72c@D~DZ6fdY@r$i!+q^BDI4XuVZZ6V@vxN5`A_ivFQCpt(ieuLhe+mr zL6n9?=^;@%;g+)9Qo{Juf!mhU=QcgP$vfejoc+?R{Mx1b+W7`hph@6r!{XSD<{Nrx z+o3>yYrt}Ns_iycE{uCNuxJ$G`FTfBe!D#%bNOb0sO&%l_4QzrM`d z>?`r^3FynF&wr?8GE2!|k+x9(QlMA-j-SgGonS5h% zsqz2{V~V}Q#Ky#a`q5@4aqp)eS27uG?57{;nW}@Vo6IlYN#5C)t@{@?v#&t^YfWlj zNqQfABUe72FzaDIeimyYN0K9Xim7A-hRaB1T671tG0bT4{gxbDCYRL>L3XE#v7~-e zF|Q+;Gtjm8V`5h7xNLR0>Nli?^bjiZk4aT7gHD~2`i(AqrLL0Ua*iRFF0wF^FOF42 z{i8_~v@n-geL>aWo^S$djEbTx69tw^bWU-WKT1N zc$S7h_s{FdJQEIi~#d2}m!VCCz(sfo{ zLM)$*RH3~CfpQ!l2ZmydQXWAMwx^a(xBD|=lwd$yRuxxI!&``7{e5*_G|qhXekd3r z6jrfjJCoITuV&-YOh3UywLBO{t1la^as%ep>dVI1opgE%9F_Z@ntHTlloVAEP3R)a z3Hc&=SX6G5P)iBXPF6~*uFfPS-Mg7PLSk2j5}Z$5g?;Q=wdUft1K$SGt8&5Y8=`yr z=YlP7Qc9=XIiorUK7li>@?qM^!g1BbC3Gf(k;!sNT{h*@YAos2Z~rR8L~=@|7-I<$ zUvt!#g7)XCoqbvjQ@Ul*k0@HE%sf1@DIt zPro19elh*y=LBci=l|T-M-MvWS?1vqdb69IVmdV#xTv9|h!KhI*{e*sHpq?#*>gd* zLFUDkmWFw8`rTm2^!7XU26H0pBZ_4h{y2z4+=OHNhbe~4tG}~V%*9(Uw)t55_N}$= zU+6#g&tLxEm-h@lw|wBhZxaW1zp4Yb1WeP>e(*nfoZxDJH$6TI*8x|>04BwiE3pM! zDN+fZc@%!4MXa+I(qpn(9l~C$9s_6rI7T9sdW`yw?mcuG>J$OUNRNR~oa$rUT6KEr zH+4Mqn<}?vI{j|FIu-Sss>D=D2s8Zyh!Pla98P(xI7u2s3pS_-omsHtWX7QQAPIqq zE#oHhGcdNn+77XWVneLZVAdLKANu4X(TIbVUn#IInR2I_JS~KSQR@*e)O$N-JAKty zb2;YN%Y9hzIi=hRDWzhby{5%V{+yJueW7}x<9hAF*!8W8Dc5%_c3$5jr5w6h{dTRt zy@RkT+B^NnPe|=2-rgmp@O~37W7b_5B8vz>beV{NpdNE8wksmi;MuhlU6tO(G25S2 z#+x=!{m&XNEJD~G79p@95kk4<{heRm@-KgNu4ONgC1@SsjOtux9E0T=kxbKq?0Glo zo26D6%p%a63FfW=;|NP$LnxjEx`mZkp~@-*JNST4W=`6ixq}$w&)y|`S(5GdpjZCka^xtQ3TgFE%GhQ zLhlz{1LHyK8OPZkz@W!DFyI7#8>xYrjdaiT5FKo1f6$_Y08J3V1t;v@H1`l9M?$(r zP!5oZEVcKz6I^U)b&vMDgGMD4Ab5FG$$x(`S+@uJEp*M(C-x-x~*9}~xedgzfuxByv#MsSIQoCMk9A|ZI;o{9>IPY~}|_oxT~LNFFF9K(ab zIHzk6L=y~mhXCmU*x$XQqr=EbCxXKtjFDS07^eU&X54kg=@utQQZdf6;L!&SP;m#` z0Dti>iML*EG9q5k2}3R*x#kUaMAghd3OlXC(Y>1$> z_ydF@w8ou@dEKX=7sdqe?-Djlv%dke_B%sI!ExXXxF z9W-U$F~p?De-h7FGCncJBxFvrpO_eP%5!l~$9Z+$v01&(JR9%pm`w~MZiOD0@-~FVXZ_RqH_`%G``$>K zZ@5_O9Ru;3cyZHQ+^y^?e|FUyX-irA0?GStB{wc5HzG!A-g5qy`K@4tZeKXDSabbB zf6c+087n25=beisH=Uno*|ZbvKb_#0PVjfMjKT6-oyK5iKa6Ekv%MwH?3vbs$>Qml zISZcR*z8u6eVde2G_6}nPV+b}=)Kh!Ow%zd2^Mh1PkLj(lGRHIR`8k4mru-9U$#r8 z&C~3PCB@^sP!6E8vwZ~clBFnA)!3(FpB0~*e0tLBlJctp8CwF$)mIyTaNv6f-mLj? z{SWIGOMbK`P}eFYx01T2FQwaGZ~SiStF5;x_AFKGS#T^@><^^d1Ic!LPO^Bmg15Te z>y%Q80!hWbiRGjUzrMnsR6#^|lTS`Q+xy(W(*s`nGoyi|(z&$dq)I;+O-YrchT~s< z+^^4>etbo5ddm2OamADYEIBrJV#SnyN$2YTm%MYX`epmK5>`xQub0fnyjHPdD!O#y z^_uV2f4lx_;SWl`SGtgSv*Sjav_ocr@8}HF91m%=+3rB$9y$5Bt@9~Yb_Po7 zS44l}Q`W_;mn^TOe=|K48DBcCoDGz157>4Da(3QHiBF6FJri#* zez=WEEW7gn%b1d<+CKeg8HWzlp#H;3VWN4PzQp zSFue5?P_gjjunr0LyK805m!&B=;;VO84+Ubb*lHcE|e*Btu@GkEf9;+Qo9_KVOP-G z>+HP!Y;7#2DjJbw7$(HY`|K^iv*@S zW@ZJfWr+P^YOn&17MNDK8hYoc1wv*L>t}Sq%^tw6+58B|A}P<)iczZfY{UY z5O%E43k_6Cxdb!EuG$}<)-p8FDGL@p2|J5an)LQ-blS+9Dhb_qLW&$Wjt-6eRhIS3 z#wP)ZRjf2Ry;b|GlnUWaFQjrbr?rt#q ze_Ah{_56jj`*l$JF*>gO1$B$jP_&;_K`WI{;nON(mCi>x+4<(yk$xwcAVM<)+Y%?8 zn+IIZ;eM-ga&<%-nZb`$x%sN9e%FdkC%JsU9{gD#|UDVmTV-Rl0}11dsCc@O;vZ z4T(;99w_%!nNo`l2qAuzI8DT9CeHVXqo&;A4~gH8h(oBicz`&60Vk;IAi6lR76tCQ z7V@T-=cIUY6NW}9u2qxH2+5BZhul4KRo&vx5f+O(#{ECwOfm1-N|$u`P)R89G~Le5 z^>(~izNE{*do5HH4DmB5(_=Gw(DituCuU}FW)ozo#ssJw)Oj>B+dQ>1yP!;vm^95n z#ej#3K|dy012a8S2V}hiIowunoiAo~r<77cMDma_c3#PV*fl{)*(w?97c2`+*V85A zKBSXmCb|%wmYMUIQ})g_%i>9X_L!8kY0d$`pmV-s!Msp=J?+|qixx=Vx3)@^hoz*$ zQ-^LF6Q0`so9E1s{_Exk7KZ$(2Lr}Ke%+zF$y6L*fbl5i<3hMH znL%En*Nta?LG_J-)~bPm zN>9j;TggC|PmN314yIKr^MAJT2$}aKwMXglVmoCzj}4QR5gC?DLYq1XecMy!sA#S@ zQvudO#Y5%0ta!FMM5nxo92?3Ns!6trD{6OEVHDg6!n6ocQ1Pb#Zh4kWHO05^yqadV z!Y|04k?Ehj@ct~sQYNa0Noq2U{V(L{21!WQOh~5gj7&yRZ29dWLOiqZd2Qkup`S)V zKSgK%M4z)?^dtPs__@n5dj$ba&-uzR&`X=gb}#ywkm#w#BX1YLF?;^ip53{EZ>SB8^hwGTF z^-hA~8cXKbD_Y6837Lcgu`~6aW;syjEXXfW1;ct6WOL>e)Dq0I2W0kS-|Su~p&U90 zwrj;#+MwohL`s0Z%}PSzbR))tW{~Oa9ub^|hS{PElSI!;G8Te)K~dpipUyWh*Y8iQ z4H)bEy1Kh*Z)6Gg5rDZa?Tu_nlc$Iw+S{t${6qH@Y>FRMy(imM^j6)M>{hyGt0$Xk zN=)}L!EC=o_Y}c$zn;aLF*!`)lPe?gY4jyl+=PmUx6b82n? zO+~VHBsXBUQ67-1FB~E|WRf1!45Hac){P3L0M~1MtmkOJSmf6gg^+|GhH~ZL0YfwU zaVCoIU>vL?M!jr|YSGIGg7t;?+Wne?V>?y*_SA1c10{FdmHDH9eSn-s-gkkucP>Na zL6U6kw!2}fQ*-dZ_t6fKvrKR}0uI61n=U8gMe z|3=3kLkuaODvt@G<{;zh@yNJHCeDPS> z!iIpX^1&xl?Lfp#t1hrO64bk5IfK1cU3yNnM&waC&bW=NrEy_0XkJV0WJBmP(_c*5 z4PjEl9@I@OZfz&)g;kf53Z-Na#j4Czf$>T(9C@vw4#CyXqFv4uQ3kRgeBRwDMXf3b zDP0j20|G7J0b8dF#Sl{Of;usSqem$$>Ktn|_icyN)$PDr?%fhxqN4aCr15F@YK18L z_!KqNg>)#LX`{;uj?^v;V|5KwRAb#~D+H@*<`nEB&|+OW6`G=PwR9*UBdWMT!L9J_ zc7n=IiQ-G9hIBtv`qt{ZkjZCqNoqxsC;>z6VI1vs z=+CP!@Q$skVcb=ugyMC7YU-;-tb0K3u2MwHy*BPdzpq)Zd$$9hM?-XV-U@}G+Yz=d zqB)i-5Q^Rb$v+ude3nv@Zk97EDxON8hK-D92|gE0V5=sry)0U0E+&wF^H(1!4gQg5Ew;^sMsl7>Su^uM8z(!Ppant zbnEfibV=wMVvp#b3f1C!<$P~Eq)Vm7NxF;*gq1tScnbbP317mcscB-jCQ23QaRJnb z8evtrC#b0%{jEE8ozzr<6*>kiM5vTg>2Gw+1Xv_d&s)`RvZV>C#KdNess;)QS3k)BYVB! zZ=?JR)Ge*Xc`A>>Xq-Q}Cub|^D))7BE&4O&nxo{V+}F*u_|KSYfs&hYUpLp1KVPn3 zD63{YO5VzS-7=I$%fM%=`^UO*Hc)YLK1&>~EEvPOMRZ_FHQjDa$@w2B4sHUq0+B79nkBUnA%AMQv$K^w(tftlKHzj@L&Q)OMzIn~O z)}G5m*9O^YhPjgB>N{8Yc~VEKq}*dvRL$jA=cv4MRi7v4)oTgxGuEJ@N*>Cc+w!^c ziddLa(oybJ@lC8y&X0piLNz!47`6GiVxu zh_eSKRI#i5?EBw2_|NB4zjJFH&1f<;mz9dKQHmb7J2mw9C^Ii*Wx#QShcN@9Nhj;* zi9g1ZT4g%MISICZFeFdK26Lz22x&=1^`_+zL@wzjY?D7sF)|Ok&Q~(K+n>5YW(pp^ zOZx}>K=xzo{DCzNnj>guVOc|~a19iVZdMk1zN({28sV{q>{pbA%`J#$kz}waWI=Y# z(kd$8zd*o`iT)}IeDVC84I)a-azU+JT=6{o-~WGJ{qUV5z3uy;efdSai(e+r6dYKD zAV6^kO+-@SB#i_6wjV4(9Qmi#lSn7T{|aY~YKi{@|98l@aIr7#A{%+WRp{R)x%0LavjMP5C}dG=xV6 zdtgCiRT4P^LF=w9PD0grbnT#WB`F0aSqr)+WI7|%Ho;5<4hq20+%RC_ zrnIRY*gt_rQmm6i8!Igu7YNf4Mn>^jAmICd`L7)d`G5KAAIn--gD2!m+E=dGc@!5^ zI^IN}s1}y^5<%K{o*12IkyU^7Q1t*zponeghox-UT8XT&9Mp(C!8rFsUmt9X1odQ7 zhuqq88+ z1Y^+KVFtt~-$KnUy5us!?#FO2QB4klTB6xa=4}H55NZuTRD0hmBQ7qQ zZ36-RU$CMBJs8esd2wSz6Gqv--UKOZ3v6&4gidv9z?2U$Zk%!Y{Bm5@?S!PKPCgmd zzn(qe+cDdN0fD{JC*{>(!PuWXG?t;@t`8p z;7_j%Bvgfh<}Vu%*5cVQ^F{9oDXDOElw#Q=M#|-la}N?T2JC|Ex>hROy>MJAY*?&b z?7z9=#)v=tL?D5GLi3x%OmAu+G2gGx|CMgTO6f*q1*0V`Up?w+dG;7l*b#~T&GZgP za^q8^)Y|#xH!VL-dn0W@Tr6CexSqR`Q#6+{@4B{mQ76?j-)!;s^g$)t=wz`U-kA8* zuBUcQ@AB5ZwEOwpbL{NCTRBzu_v2qz}q(6UMhLM#HX1p_caGh#Cv<%2I3!gdpm7|c9LUZbNd=`Y{ z%{~jZ{2=u}{6>iMlT*IZ3R4@7Y3(%Bs!$x+{0elRilG~@VdnhQA);?%F#Tb_7g$7yEqWP&+^H?E_b9 zeo+6tdf-FJq7K#*;;wHF)E){{wEm*-A4>nObh)GRR)_ta4r0@R*gtuY*tU>PegW1b zq?5gYj=sR*{y@G{GC8MONIr+3JnT8A(&Bc%W?V2Y+ja#^yQf-+u76ZNzR$PemGYO% z=Nd0>4r$8Ir_E1Z%abzp29o!|po=m2*;>!Ix5=lSJs3zSUN#o{b(?(7fNqoDSiE9P z#lD?7pB8Fdae<7oWn-CNS36f8(AD~lW$&3%p?Cn@g$w6>whNC-Cg3mGmQeb1=|#&+ z=`W=FV&*h+eOFqp#G}_at~D*#u5Fjfb}ckWWqTy+o

#fMwsJL9(8-ibqmJ9@@Y4(*7OJ&?2Gj*)~lF^0{r zpP1kJTGyQf@}9^Twq2cAcrdW-;GHDmksM0>EL27wTi790H3!OD?wH9J3u7pIJ?8b^ z?+$!>;41e6{(JmF!}lKyRFbx+Yz>qhzLP?Nr80)vt6M>K(tnu#mgZ-%e;d0v_ESS( z$Kjhhq#eftwI}YRkzna^KA~+0q1_4#Cj<2d0#yfZ8lB}pgtk0{ z5{3DXq8l+k$_rp;i9xFA2vl%)vPjTu#!!06IoB}Pd!=Q*{K~OF>Fzr@&6TvvkA5qEMW1mo=3?(l11}6FQgw@~I2g-K@igvE(H@?30s^tgi-%Ec}yU?)EzgT^J@OtZ_<9b_Q z`=LN}YhV)+DYz7KsrQwEZw|cPIiHG7kwGjCz1EEy2CREl^tl<&j7c{+so$7tQs( zRu(9#4dm5*ScSSzHQlLUOi7*?^wv&ancuk4uiGfE6#6h+My?Dz$x0gU!li74;LwZ- z&1jN<-Qlnn!X8+Wt%YE)4PD)AXR;zJnbeZQG$@vgP6-vgL*z{CcQAI9*=@CkekT;I zY4Ik#M2D!DjVc5Su~cpmfxjv@H#=<^CoZ3DF>^lZ5XQRXjih{99NHeaVK>x)Kl5J`JP z$w4VQ!*Ixfiw9JUQA-*W6fMz^$`gdfY05L7s4y{zdqsvUNnanZIp!yE0*Wa082Nhg;$gy|x4F9wSm zpEkXG@n^e4nW6DM@&8xi{14*%jyRvd36@5ehM^6(%Cb_u#uk5%z}W8kSSsP3eRZGs z&v+l)+?4yT|5Bg5@BI&lem#Bd55L)qEm{{z(qvUqZlub{*=G_8S6IczqyJacH;IL%IXMl|~1Nv5e=p}fC? zjD?qv&+Y|ttjV9cC19*ZJXoDO{p4w)JnHQaAf=e_VxwiDaPg4;_=EnQe*Yt*%kcs> zW5yewDte*_+Xzah+1nNy%-S`*+%%`Te2|RO0Za802ISpz+nnNQ@bo^DiIrK7x8tSG z=R2Xw%1h=V>WR>9&bNvd9X~Do(cYUy(yk+ctw&eV_PptQtMO+C{`SBxYHyBV{)~P2e*R>j z<3ZSnlRCQI{$il*;Xre@zo%Df?hWkiTS?pgX4;$Lk0*aP`BopSs5SgU)6bi*i~sEd zZ}{#T7nhmcrhRU0wb2A z&{5})@?rM+t4OcdI6Y_J;v>phNqo{;qpEy}NU~st<}NTibn(d) zJW`;so3ctIPSJMW43(dID95b7*Pxu~EQDq;mDc)jfaR%#&Z1HjukGK5DRBa)8naZC83ql#F$VFyN?IxvO(L2WC$e7NjDkFh%haIirP%c6mc5@VX+YfwCdaq@zrcr((B6IxGpD#0hl3vs}#8j%>#s0#(aXWn4o^686s$I#qT| z)Ng=Rv_cW(TpFHGIaA62krb3=)w9J68c)?F>%0d}9>L60$f7W>5E!W;C-BKCh+!Ng z$4gbl{1JE<1DMKqNR-(A|BZ`6E}zg2q08#4F6@Ec`rD8Z^3ft8kDB%6@_BrkLOFo3 z`6miaSSMg54`%20AOGRYhSDmg>($#k^ z{d1>0k!g}+A+6ZS16H!N-!bl}6gPmHi)C=gjE`LV#oxdUCJ=M~ zMD{4#248#H`ge%7TPyEF0Y-{NutXRg8(@=BHJ0+?S@DI=MC=x)uuDzJF$QWeN~jgO zRa*dPN+$2!TUXgYFm)zztctFt*`4a~l`e@|6;DX8Z=|Unw`wc0eGgp{I^^n|W_&zG zb=47xybiUdV6a|Fw7>l-od?}}SC7Tc*H4GnUlIY+yTls}jt*Fzj=mw~j9#2KVRemIAv?7a zBDq;1k~nO4z$xM|V5htueKkg2|BKHP@V@|O5Io<+kzHHKaR0Lu6+@T zi%$_8z@Zqkh$z$Q!55w<*Bkp}{gv{B(3<%tN0yV4Ic=!FMi$Ak6%=tR`9Q{6 z(MOzD;gpvU>r6y1z!fw^V6|M4Kc1L<2!ySIe~xYMQqMHD|U2^~%5_5_5av zM&hWcMo`;3I2k$sAyyV#yTt?&YAYOKTMp?ww1tw1eix+-8UW>fS06E9rE%gI74jO4 zk)uO3gh-a%q2+s&z+f)R+*iVB-M@c-NXnVEW={~?QK~%r+-8h%kaWJ6XZ5A}`XD2l zYJ`=e6xd1fYM$91kzbjLecYTTVA=#R7))eudU6v2#QAiA_!7wN2wUKGf)(p@qiJTx zv?jXeKW=6>2oorVWXy%XIb~Y^%ha9I&A->gB~*Qq%p_%cwcZZzquw^cL!UFi98p?m z>A#%lgjmdy@?6n3ik@hhCL0b}NS8d-9_|_abkj<1o|l+q8X$(t5w{lh1nRG3&fBhJ zUw+)zGw)bnuk|f7TstY1?D6O9oj&9_{+m*+_D%keJZHu*F*l&f|_-!|d;t=^OiJG^!& z1u{m$5P3JHe6iZ2xoydja(ClYg1CiK;14u{4FQINzxBbDqD?S@<-C~&VP;A@>tWx^ z&3mco`KE6e$wpzYI{Lh}2>S&&Wn|(|fR5Sp3uiG_H28>N!GX(%Ageljxx$x(!v(6Z zrNH#LUb1fYr|Z!vp@oGs~SLQqJg7=g3bs zFBUEyzgcpzwjB$Qd|WU0H{-R>-|v(j9$2w8yjAiG%|FEcUFB^2|$Ns#aL3^Yixep$Zi?Gqq zZP<@{W5Il}KX>B`C%F;-HkAVd}57uaMJsfkhBbDOGuj z-Z?{8rt-E{{3;z6&lw?5Fm-D<==yVs_$6`4oSCy!#lk>tjuJakqSP+J1e33bUs@$o z6+3DH+epK0!9oIe?A7Nw3=dNQaFBm#4TpBHCX}2jcqW7rD z=mN$*Xn&$sXD{M)wVF}{QBE#ZmX$JljFiMnN@6eKveY{cF=@_@rYsn_8idKXR~ULC z%w;2V=4TB}PmQsQIex9WMR)R0?G1L&>I*ESC_a#iuexBi`%QX6uPiK;J7=L63yQCD z$HEd*3$k>ib{a;+I%uODlI2?8xLoyqno0(t^GIl}7OjBgtB?@I0xlgGmcb_|qO?g? z>?YyqHdzZwGzPQ*tfZuJP6cvKb;xNGa!R@@rzFn0jZ9;3h4U)-qw?CU%@#O1%>2Vvnwkcs@+;)vp zDyd@Ezz!uOYOLz_kuc>^7;_sl2sWw0-3@E#dxK^uN;*YyejQO19v7iDIZYBYN7O_WfA9%N=~Nb#!Rrnk zy7+(KfjV@t0iB(axKNVtaA!yG$OV+waw?^I@Ip0V?mY(hu|mjXsX+leN(|+M#Nb?u zi17jiMZ%Vrn?fNtHo{rcxa4CSvEm|CI0`<94@HodQ#e6wT)^^+jQv6FY3Did0C|F* zr;J)5g>l8$b;t^H#u>2NqFjoI0p?Mp?MCL|GZD>wOQ(8qUedEA7d0=%z7RVf=ilD; z?v@7v1xJ>)JTO=7D|#i?7mLTGf+K; z65q(gQ*g^&4I?+QvZlr1fhe^Aqij$@#_9=*qxot{=78%g0?CTyvhY}5`oKVZEKvf- z3Yv`%#)kS<&`gkyUg^7osP~#Ga}Tow`#2=lG`| z6SVtxX&G!Vo0OkcaVKYYhL-bx<|=#?se(90N~pm*ZOB_L`=jIwA&;c&cNk_{lLl3H zvyB@6nGyev!CTvg-q|+vamedaQAF@y8j=4KzK2MNlDkLdf%G3gD(=Hqpml_y5TXy7 zkT2=g;tX*bIAP-xI_kLU|d9#WQ#c#y=|J1j(Lp=UG^_ zB7*`{szIA!shXT(IWE>C4vvp>j+Ce1ctxDvDwoax*YQtPE5?ICX4U_Yk-cPvt$4_q76|qLAuObF3s}dkvS^rS4I`@aXc{^FV-eIF${kNN&K(+(Vj`ge)kZvOXwQ&t-!r>RM#| zjaZjM%J1|KJmSwjy^@e|F)5H)KDX(r>-(n{OK)24#Ay?bK<60Bl}YBQ)?X5q$S+g3 zfsIhS6&wleLUW+FVaZg4vjF9dw_a##rryvBYr_LBI@SWk1SJWVe1)7{?ZWlG?_yn?CB&BqLmD h6`S=@KU>c3y8}SzOw$i7Ycrlt{p<84ZH8R9{|_jxo5uhE literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/REVIEW.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/REVIEW.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b32ffab --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/REVIEW.md @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ +# Independent scalar-action review + +No blocking error was found in the submitted AeST scalar constraint and response calculation. A separate ADM reduction, with lapse and shift retained in spatially flat gauge, reproduces the two physical scalar coordinates and their positive kinetic Hessian. Its integrated Newtonian observables agree with the submitted equations to 1.06e-12 normalized error over three wave numbers. + +Reviewer: gpt-forge, separate gpt-6-astra agent. This is an independent implementation within the same project and model family, not outside peer review. Reviewed script SHA256: `e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef`. Reviewed derivation SHA256: `5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe`. + +## Independent construction + +Use the source [AeST action](https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3), normalized by multiplying by 16 pi G, with the submitted constants. In spatially flat gauge set `h_ij=a^2 delta_ij`, lapse `N=1+n`, shift `N_i=partial_i beta`, and normalized aether spatial component `A_i=partial_i alpha`. + +The quadratic action, after spatial integration of one real Fourier component, is + +```text +L = -6*a^3*H^2*n^2 + 4*a*k^2*H*n*beta + + a^3*K''*(vdot-Q*n)^2 + + a*k^2*[K_B*(alphadot+n)^2 + + 2*b*(alphadot+n)*(v+Q*alpha) + - b*(1+lambda_s)*(v+Q*alpha)^2 + + K'*(2*alpha*v+Q*alpha^2) - 2*K'*beta*v]. +``` + +The shift equation is `2H*n-K'*v=0`. It fixes the lapse without eliminating a field velocity. Substitution gives the velocity Hessian `diag(8a^3,2ak^2)` for the selected constants. Both entries are positive for a>0 and k>0. The two remaining field coordinates have four phase-space data. No scalar mode has been discarded by imposing a density closure. + +The script derives Euler-Lagrange equations from this reduced action rather than importing the submitted evolution. The submitted module is used only for the final comparison. The Newtonian metric is reconstructed by the density constraint after changing gauge. + +Comparison covers density, momentum, both response variables, pressure, the potential and the original scalar/vector coordinates at k/Q0=6,12,24, from a=1 to a=2. + +A separate direct expansion of the Newtonian-gauge ADM extrinsic-curvature term verifies the submitted `-12a^3 H(Phi+Psi) Phidot` term. Thus its canonical momentum convention is consistent without an unreported integration by parts. [adm_check.py](adm_check.py) records these checks and [adm-evidence.json](adm-evidence.json) records the exact submitted hashes and residuals. + +The spatial-gradient and aether terms were checked from the normalized vector. In particular, the constant nonzero Y slope supplies the extra lambda_s contribution. Using the original cosmological zero-slope vector equation without that term would describe a different action. + +## Physical and numerical interpretation + +The compensated data change gauge-invariant E and/or chi while preserving initial retained density and momentum. The reported pressure response therefore has a physical scalar preparation behind it. The vacuum limit and the finite-density continuation are distinct. Their contrast is consistent with the vanishing linear vacuum stress response, rather than evidence for an extra mode absent from the established theory. + +The [published cosmological equations](https://arxiv.org/html/2007.00082v3) already state that pressure depends on additional aether variables. The submitted work supplies a bounded preparation map and executable response. It does not establish a new general failure of a fluid description or of AeST cosmology. + +The dust-inspired density preparation has chi=Z=0 and is not a verified growing slow mode. At the chosen finite sound speed and short wavelengths, large closure errors can arise from ordinary pressure and excitation of the fast scalar. The README retains this limit and makes no observational-failure claim. Its 35-preparation test should be read as a test of those specified preparations and normalizations. + +The useful next test is the same action and background with an explicitly selected slow-mode preparation. The fast and slow spectral subspaces must remain separated during the interval. An instantaneous eigenvector is an initial condition, not an exact time-dependent invariant mode. Controlled fast-mode contamination would show how accurately that preparation must be made for a two-variable approximation to work. + +No global nonlinear stability, ultraviolet validity, thermalization or observational accuracy was reviewed. The positive kinetic Hessian and short-wavelength scalar sign do not exclude slow gravitational growth. + +## Reproduce + +Run `python3 adm_check.py` from this directory. It verifies the frozen source hashes and requires NumPy, SciPy and SymPy. It reads the adjacent `public-checkpoint/` when present, or the parent directory in a published bundle. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm-evidence.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm-evidence.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..458c035 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm-evidence.json @@ -0,0 +1,56 @@ +{ + "checked_source_sha256": { + "response.py": "e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef", + "derivation.md": "5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe" + }, + "action_source": "https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3", + "method": "Independent scalar ADM expansion in spatially flat gauge, retaining shift; eliminate constraints; derive Euler-Lagrange equations; integrate and reconstruct Newtonian observables.", + "shift_constraint": "2*H*lapse - Kp*v", + "kinetic_hessian": "Matrix([[8*a**3, 0], [0, 2*a*k**2]])", + "newtonian_extrinsic_curvature_check": "symbolically exact", + "comparisons": [ + { + "k": 6.0, + "max_normalized_discrepancy": 1.0541854424171802e-12, + "by_variable": { + "D": 6.763558083825588e-13, + "m": 2.712407946622633e-14, + "chi": 1.0541854424171802e-12, + "Z": 1.046959192585917e-12, + "Phi": 7.561051184194088e-15, + "pressure": 2.291621169016908e-13, + "v_Newtonian": 9.140014896465935e-13, + "alpha_Newtonian": 4.759001674589083e-13 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "max_normalized_discrepancy": 7.366407314254235e-13, + "by_variable": { + "D": 5.210311416798015e-13, + "m": 1.8491622593622934e-14, + "chi": 7.366407314254235e-13, + "Z": 2.652834398906564e-13, + "Phi": 1.5154465809854313e-15, + "pressure": 1.9077431903432988e-13, + "v_Newtonian": 7.293350722553551e-13, + "alpha_Newtonian": 1.0072082010690686e-13 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "max_normalized_discrepancy": 4.1928130889087867e-13, + "by_variable": { + "D": 4.1928130889087867e-13, + "m": 9.177362101122704e-15, + "chi": 3.41665297653803e-13, + "Z": 8.484556979078915e-14, + "Phi": 3.771814346271095e-16, + "pressure": 2.760268616864951e-13, + "v_Newtonian": 3.3516034931668597e-13, + "alpha_Newtonian": 3.026131703569854e-14 + } + } + ], + "review_scope": "Linear scalar action, two physical scalar modes, constraints and observable map. No global or nonlinear stability proof." +} diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm_check.py b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm_check.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..504237f --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/independent-review/adm_check.py @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Independent spatially-flat-gauge ADM reduction and integration. + +The evolution is derived here from a lapse/shift-retaining action. The submitted +module is imported only after this derivation, to compare its Newtonian solution. +""" +from pathlib import Path +import hashlib,importlib.util,json,math +import numpy as np +import sympy as S +from scipy.integrate import solve_ivp + +HERE=Path(__file__).resolve().parent +SUBMITTED=HERE.parent/'public-checkpoint' +if not SUBMITTED.is_dir():SUBMITTED=HERE.parent +expected={'response.py':'e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef', + 'derivation.md':'5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe'} +for name,sha in expected.items():assert hashlib.sha256((SUBMITTED/name).read_bytes()).hexdigest()==sha + +a,H,Q,Kp,k=S.symbols('a H Q Kp k',nonzero=True,real=True) +v,al,vd,ad,n,beta=S.symbols('v al vd ad lapse shift',real=True) +Kpp=S.Integer(4);KB=S.Integer(1);b=S.Integer(1);lam=S.Integer(1) +chi=v+Q*al;gamma=vd-Q*n;E=ad+n +# ADM h_ij=a² delta_ij, N=1+n, N_i=partial_i beta. Spatial integration +# removes (partial_i partial_j beta)^2-(Delta beta)^2 for a scalar Fourier mode. +Lg=-6*a**3*H**2*n**2+4*a*k**2*H*n*beta +La=a**3*Kpp*gamma**2+a*k**2*(KB*E**2+2*b*E*chi-b*(1+lam)*chi**2+ + Kp*(2*al*v+Q*al**2)-2*Kp*beta*v) +L=Lg+La +constraint=S.factor(S.diff(L,beta)/(2*a*k**2)) +assert constraint==2*H*n-Kp*v +nsol=Kp*v/(2*H) +Lr=S.expand(L.subs(n,nsol)) +assert S.diff(Lr,beta)==0 +coords=S.Matrix([v,al]);vel=S.Matrix([vd,ad]) +momentum=S.Matrix([S.diff(Lr,z) for z in vel]) +kinetic=momentum.jacobian(vel) +assert kinetic==S.diag(8*a**3,2*a*k**2) +back=S.Matrix([a,H,Q,Kp]);backdot=S.Matrix([a*H,-Q*Kp/2,-3*H*Kp/4,-3*H*Kp]) +force=S.Matrix([S.diff(Lr,z) for z in coords])-momentum.jacobian(coords)*vel-momentum.jacobian(back)*backdot +acc=S.simplify(kinetic.inv()*force) +accfun=S.lambdify((a,H,Q,Kp,k,v,al,vd,ad),acc,'numpy') + +# Direct Newtonian-gauge extrinsic-curvature expansion. This independently +# checks the disputed H Phi dotPhi convention without importing its action. +eps,Ph,Psi,Phd=S.symbols('eps Phi Psi Phidot',real=True) +kin_exact=-6*a**3*(1-2*eps*Ph)**S.Rational(3,2)/S.sqrt(1+2*eps*Psi)*(H-eps*Phd/(1-2*eps*Ph))**2 +quadratic=S.expand(S.diff(kin_exact,eps,2).subs(eps,0)/2) +quoted=a**3*(-6*Phd**2-12*H*(Ph+Psi)*Phd-9*H**2*(Ph+Psi)**2) +assert S.simplify(quadratic-quoted)==0 + +spec=importlib.util.spec_from_file_location('submitted',SUBMITTED/'response.py') +submitted=importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec);spec.loader.exec_module(submitted) +rows=[] +for kval in (6.,12.,24.): + qi=.01;amplitude=1e-6 + def background(scale): + q=qi/scale**3 + return 1+q,4*q,math.sqrt((4*q+2*q*q)/3) + Q0,Kp0,H0=background(1.) + end=2*(8-1)/(3*H0+math.sqrt(9*H0*H0+12*qi*(8-1))) + times=np.linspace(0,end,1001) + # Compensated velocity preparation has zero metric, coordinates and metric + # velocity initially, so the two gauges have identical initial field data. + initial=np.array([1.,0.,0.,amplitude,4*Q0*amplitude/kval**2]) + def rhs(t,y): + scale,vf,af,vdf,adf=y + qq,kp,hh=background(scale) + accelerations=np.asarray(accfun(scale,hh,qq,kp,kval,vf,af,vdf,adf)).ravel() + return np.r_[scale*hh,vdf,adf,accelerations] + sol=solve_ivp(rhs,(0,end),initial,t_eval=times,method='DOP853',rtol=3e-12,atol=1e-20) + assert sol.success + scale,vf,af,vdf,adf=sol.y + q=qi/scale**3;qq=1+q;kp=4*q;hh=np.sqrt((4*q+2*q*q)/3);r=kval*kval/scale**2 + lapse=kp*vf/(2*hh);Ef=adf+lapse;chif=vf+qq*af;Z=Ef+chif;gf=vdf-qq*lapse + # Reconstruct Newtonian Phi by the Hamiltonian constraint after gauge + # transformation. The Qdot terms cancel against the momentum contribution. + Phi=-(qq*4*gf-r*Z+3*hh*kp*vf)/(2*r) + vn=vf-qq*Phi/hh;an=af+Phi/hh + gn=gf+3*kp*Phi/4 + D=qq*4*gn-r*Z;m=kp*vn;pressure=kp*gn + independent=np.array([D,m,chif,Z,Phi,pressure,vn,an]) + # Only this comparator uses the submitted right-hand side. + y0=np.array([1.,0.,0.,4*Q0*amplitude/kval**2,0.,amplitude]) + ref=solve_ivp(lambda t,y:submitted.rhs_fields(t,y,kval,qi),(0,end),y0,t_eval=times, + method='DOP853',rtol=3e-12,atol=1e-20) + aa,vn2,an2,En2,Phi2,gn2=ref.y + q2=qi/aa**3;qq2=1+q2;kp2=4*q2;chi2=vn2+qq2*an2;Z2=En2+chi2 + reference=np.array([qq2*4*gn2-kval*kval/aa**2*Z2,kp2*vn2,chi2,Z2,Phi2,kp2*gn2,vn2,an2]) + absolute=np.max(np.abs(independent-reference),axis=1) + errors=absolute/np.maximum(amplitude,np.max(np.abs(reference),axis=1)) + assert max(errors)<1e-7 + rows.append({'k':kval,'max_normalized_discrepancy':float(max(errors)), + 'by_variable':dict(zip(['D','m','chi','Z','Phi','pressure','v_Newtonian','alpha_Newtonian'],errors.tolist()))}) + +output={'checked_source_sha256':expected,'action_source':'https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3', + 'method':'Independent scalar ADM expansion in spatially flat gauge, retaining shift; eliminate constraints; derive Euler-Lagrange equations; integrate and reconstruct Newtonian observables.', + 'shift_constraint':str(constraint),'kinetic_hessian':str(kinetic), + 'newtonian_extrinsic_curvature_check':'symbolically exact', + 'comparisons':rows,'review_scope':'Linear scalar action, two physical scalar modes, constraints and observable map. No global or nonlinear stability proof.'} +(HERE/'adm-evidence.json').write_text(json.dumps(output,indent=2)+'\n') +print(json.dumps(output,indent=2)) diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json index 58e9c0f..15815d9 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/sources.json @@ -21,7 +21,7 @@ "title": "Aether scalar tensor theory: Hamiltonian Formalism", "url": "https://arxiv.org/html/2307.15126v3", "used_for": "Exact action, ADM momentum constraint, auxiliary variables, chosen function (84), and Minkowski canonical map (106-115).", - "boundary": "The finite-density quadratic expansion and response in this repository are author derivations awaiting independent review." + "boundary": "The finite-density quadratic expansion and response are author derivations checked by a separate Astra agent. See independent-review/REVIEW.md. No external peer review is claimed." }, { "id": "domenech_ganz_2025", From 4f77b04166e42fb1f645d68e3170519541750016 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: ahrazzle <38987266+ahrazzle@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 17:25:08 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 4/7] Exclude generated interpreter cache from the research bundle --- research/aest-response-gate-20261112/.gitignore | 3 +++ research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md | 2 +- research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS | 2 +- .../__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc | Bin 36909 -> 0 bytes 4 files changed, 5 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/.gitignore delete mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/.gitignore b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/.gitignore new file mode 100644 index 0000000..98dbeb4 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/.gitignore @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +__pycache__/ +*.py[cod] +.venv/ diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md index f558ba7..e58411c 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md @@ -44,7 +44,7 @@ Thus density and momentum do not predict every allowed preparation. Adding insta | Flat-space exact matrix exponential versus ODE | Relative error below \(1.6\times10^{-10}\) over ten periods | | Flat-space quadratic energy | Relative drift below \(1.3\times10^{-12}\) | -The exact expanding solution for \(a(t)\) is checked independently. The scalar kinetic Hessian and short-wavelength characteristic have the required positive signs in the author derivation. +The exact expanding solution for \(a(t)\) is checked independently. The scalar kinetic Hessian and short-wavelength characteristic have the required positive signs in the author derivation. The separate review reproduces the scalar kinetic Hessian and integrates the ADM equations, matching eight reconstructed observables to 1.06e-12 normalized error. The test does not prove nonlinear stability or stability of an observationally fitted cosmology. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS index e01835a..749a09b 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -830d4f9b5a250380f5fe29de28d5f74e89a4201590214cdb0d3b69c434815f6d README.md +523aafe3e5602f9738900291992b7cf456e70d0f2861370286b959fae7ced663 README.md 5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe derivation.md 58f56124bef156d5a8e22d0bd4eaab695c4ac0540f0e211e63f5e99ff4bc10e7 independent-review/REVIEW.md ab32294e143f463d1d80026f3d70ee23dff22facd159bcdf86889a236aea8def independent-review/adm-evidence.json diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/__pycache__/response.cpython-314.pyc deleted file mode 100644 index b6f75b70d23eddcd51665dbda7c789741e756787..0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 GIT binary patch literal 0 HcmV?d00001 literal 36909 zcmd75dt4mXohMq=-9R_pJi2+myLkyD1mYp|e(;inup}s?YT3e&1{!D!K~W7@lAVO? zWOlI=#vR*Qw{0Jt%OOW4Nj~LnOGZTCjLz0rYxqT?06>mtgr9v-IX7Cct3aV z-0!LG>OO@)a-95e3;I;msq_4u-}#+$e!t)OolS`e@eHn$t-pKZax=sHn!G5NCiK95 z?8n0t!!hGbH^Z^5>>4 zH;$Wd*R>`bN*qs=!^E^E9ZDWgE?~IW3})QS#lf|3dblZ^0d6W64>yf7!cFH)a5Fdy zmyp2>v*VduBHpvOB)HjJGTfYpb2;<&lMK_3y5%wt=h&FKaGj8Yrbzykr<{MQp>NzZ zIIoU1?(mvGMN z80ojV&%vWIKK|&ab!2p8*frur)V|T-VTa&$R#-=S-A-}RK{9a+TL)a@)=|+qF+46h zCS9Y$&T#}iBjAqjR+rm4;db^{#&Z)RJFUXG@uAU?S}SrDMn~MvN@Tcs^XSC5FfmR% zk%+tU5%=gwd^sC5Iz~oD$K`C?NAa#}cZ?6=Zg7tdPda;ClLGN{o)ymYDNRf6N%(0Q zhW&Wi%rK5!j@?sCSLAzpxbY(%c(4HlI2M1JZHPy%M-2=kvSN|gA`S}rZVj)mkkKjh zRWRH)JuOnxZ42l1Xbe(&O?+EOcGym?JG%g50< z@H#pz)t7Z!LKTC;DEmoON!E=oWZeaSRa{={lXF!_n|r&tJ&4TkI|N*X(ceiIs-Y-F6Edl27AP@2b5T`!e`UK8sK1vk`k2 zzl+~ptKnimO!Yzz)nj#3#lw#_h6gd_Ep=?j18`JhxrI;pEHywp6;`Zj4K@5}Sp8O2 z(|G!g&Q~d)kbA%SfM$^zr7JPIb*pNmE(-+`#7v{}C$LyWrPiTI>-R=FJwTGGxl%qM zkGCM_BvnWiU7+D`SNo{(U|skL`S*jH47GfvRCnc*PnVA_krG2FpmJDytcj(^2Eoc> z^1vJMOTf>>TkZc7qYVXN-b%lzDLLJ1t6~HjmG|0Mp5GovHFfxrw<)Dp?m{7z5;a~a zae-MWpE0E(Dy6mI5l6%0QH;Psu}~tE@+E4l>rSR?%a`z_H2hbE)vX?BX&BP!&}pnr zlP^}qqOcZtv1%lzL-NJy($L>j`IV}}b?fhys;bmfS%eJ~geiZjtv2w*q;9p^x^N2! zWn6kPbE14gQ^`zd4qz53lvAm!-Qs1Oo-eP~gxp$9MYfUy!?Y(vpOq(NYO3JWQB7Mt z!x)%+M%bvzZEdVDsIUUqENl`ggv~-FznRzZn^Z8RYAsY@PNk*iSX>5Qp@uUZx7)Oe zE+!ytr3$#yVfhOBjizGVhI`RSepQ<5mxfN0&dZ*>ejHHEgnN9|sj2e%kfZaXAs}p7 z4N*RpuUbDxdkdWsUrE=A-?V-_I?wLdRU@ZrB;c#)9O(2Buaf?zuB{pps(9K}@$Lap zx}0=gLN(Qc*2d|08mEOCzWQG6%Io3XJK%tUF3akes&DEU8-?rlo9V5eKMhMh z2BlH0TX@xYY;U_qI#g-sGOq{o3X1Ni;Gak(6n?~*wS}*yQ{p#8=wU6Fxf;vq{DD{M z`CtXFQR5b!t}5ndp3|sD_Ek7eRmc8^d$#U9)`4`n=oX{>g*pn0*PcVv@^y6VHRl19 zYASG_IV45Dl@?J(4Ph%)o;AlM>igQQUd?a5E7f``*5^&N=B`w?aYjCuGx2#`0$;!- z@`YRyzZLVc?fmw3@FG@U$_Sav97qSx0W?F{A?)OLb~7@Q2Q#5urVZST4u;>s@2u4* z;fGiQ0edJN>NI}?^NL2t7%IOjm{HVVW+TzGgG08lu(?7 z@~w~frcl1yBEG5oM$9pa!*dL@jZjR5D^|i`UXUElStArz#T22u1^5Z&uF#WQp71k5 zxR~;+^BJeD4(lQ7n6<;&Cg5MN4m-|R+ZvCTYl3lLS)F%^qd}eMbPS(Qp0t8V)naWQ za#;r*XU;gvS&=k(UwEx2!vg#s22f!?9>&9Njf1&A&!{UhN9UPZmSe~|vnw*Y?$mU$ z3VtL<*mO#rm3t9W&Z^2m(yS%r=qKf13z-6x}H-Gj~%umZ)s!Afv1dq=XNdaKlL{g^J5pem+UXteaGjj19_Y0HMjC=-pQ*8>_7FX43NLryoD{-i6+Dg z#v)&EO@mtZ#F?P>yh|w8iln;-jWP!ob)0m%gN8|m=yLQ9JKb)=WgM8A645Ie0D3%_ zbB`i#L?CxDoKL5i+ezl9&OLeVV#;!E*IU}f)|-zl?>`mD?FwXd1(F{2>mU9Y;h3P- zDY(za^#S1pYx~jj=61J>pnw19xOI{^Z9%2n6t-2w{i z818YpM%?3Ydcf9&e=(ZTjYrqWc#j~C3J$ad_`5wwqp3$2o^bcn9%>2}63(x4#Eo|9 z?-_EOaSe};j<_5nJ<-@f+t`GoUqtM_9*4}R?vdHbbdY#gKk&*m?gHFW=_CcTxqCu% z29wT=64aYG(*v*yL#|+A#6zxHu<(p)~ zVlXb8Lr~lA92d!)BpBlwcb;(rCC0__Jwf(#kaYyvLqT>d$aVxZZ9-5Bq7~GFYT>Oh z$o2-=$)LtD9AsO9TC`P=9SpK!P}4UQWFHE$%|RWhdQj8RAJiP`2P+)S8PrSy=^Vp& zXu)r=UnEO1u|Up0)M{)~Fg*%-y5Yn;5==*c8%!cD4gUn$Ljkr(IO;)G2(s-#b||PB zatGOwU~CA8D6QKSj3wpiaR+si#AVxpT9DeH=7B-{9H>`+Fh*|VVC=X<9CVHcjo~&Y zJv68ldM1hE2*!rGY*07iIO7b)Oge@qoMI-aRTdog9yr#|f9>BN>T*e|x|=wHbkj%% zKaUOdv(mCx9{J`YD|*{p-F*KiTFr*oC0)@}!?exAdfYzComj>YKixPJJJoPIBkQ^I zPoMV})-BX6XY60nr6O3hr+P(in694DO^cPPy)zk} z>X{t8ni8gKJldJ$6bz_ zZJVo}XXl%)#Vu4{`J%LG_o7DH*eK;TN|q+c(6rclW6i}p?R^;Z)uro`<;%B z>1IEPWzsXBJN5Lbmo2`AZ>7zd=Q^&W&D-Ytua!yVyCmDL1;?W8x^uDj`Xe{%q`k)^ z+c7`aDRC$Lr@ADrOR{wZ(jJ~VdfSxvRNIqnUiNv;r+e|_9E+mI%D|yd+W_kXGO(Z6?WU^Ezfr ze1)?cePgqglD-URkyr52sTWSYYME+O>^dX&6NZ5omU=MXt;h*s%Z8bTc(X9cO@n+4XE+O`5*3<9_p6(Zs}-`r0+rP4aTRk zpUn0&cv)|?*Wo!AFxaLV|FL#=AYsqn?3i>w~b;XiTm?Nk0!-O`b6$=vOC^!l9xl4HQ{8upKjO0H4KF)Eoy zC4(^4sKEKK@A$G|BQn;-f<&2T`e({Kz1~J&%IqOvR8)*nh(AfAAsc#6wccLsI%f{)c<~ef|DHm(=I-51*0x&iI8f z06`i*Ckf}IzH`#U=cV-XQv73*?lBYuz3SkT2R)5m%Y}p9&Vb2=PLh!1v3WW!6wf>u z?jZGZ4fEP72c@D~DZ6fdY@r$i!+q^BDI4XuVZZ6V@vxN5`A_ivFQCpt(ieuLhe+mr zL6n9?=^;@%;g+)9Qo{Juf!mhU=QcgP$vfejoc+?R{Mx1b+W7`hph@6r!{XSD<{Nrx z+o3>yYrt}Ns_iycE{uCNuxJ$G`FTfBe!D#%bNOb0sO&%l_4QzrM`d z>?`r^3FynF&wr?8GE2!|k+x9(QlMA-j-SgGonS5h% zsqz2{V~V}Q#Ky#a`q5@4aqp)eS27uG?57{;nW}@Vo6IlYN#5C)t@{@?v#&t^YfWlj zNqQfABUe72FzaDIeimyYN0K9Xim7A-hRaB1T671tG0bT4{gxbDCYRL>L3XE#v7~-e zF|Q+;Gtjm8V`5h7xNLR0>Nli?^bjiZk4aT7gHD~2`i(AqrLL0Ua*iRFF0wF^FOF42 z{i8_~v@n-geL>aWo^S$djEbTx69tw^bWU-WKT1N zc$S7h_s{FdJQEIi~#d2}m!VCCz(sfo{ zLM)$*RH3~CfpQ!l2ZmydQXWAMwx^a(xBD|=lwd$yRuxxI!&``7{e5*_G|qhXekd3r z6jrfjJCoITuV&-YOh3UywLBO{t1la^as%ep>dVI1opgE%9F_Z@ntHTlloVAEP3R)a z3Hc&=SX6G5P)iBXPF6~*uFfPS-Mg7PLSk2j5}Z$5g?;Q=wdUft1K$SGt8&5Y8=`yr z=YlP7Qc9=XIiorUK7li>@?qM^!g1BbC3Gf(k;!sNT{h*@YAos2Z~rR8L~=@|7-I<$ zUvt!#g7)XCoqbvjQ@Ul*k0@HE%sf1@DIt zPro19elh*y=LBci=l|T-M-MvWS?1vqdb69IVmdV#xTv9|h!KhI*{e*sHpq?#*>gd* zLFUDkmWFw8`rTm2^!7XU26H0pBZ_4h{y2z4+=OHNhbe~4tG}~V%*9(Uw)t55_N}$= zU+6#g&tLxEm-h@lw|wBhZxaW1zp4Yb1WeP>e(*nfoZxDJH$6TI*8x|>04BwiE3pM! zDN+fZc@%!4MXa+I(qpn(9l~C$9s_6rI7T9sdW`yw?mcuG>J$OUNRNR~oa$rUT6KEr zH+4Mqn<}?vI{j|FIu-Sss>D=D2s8Zyh!Pla98P(xI7u2s3pS_-omsHtWX7QQAPIqq zE#oHhGcdNn+77XWVneLZVAdLKANu4X(TIbVUn#IInR2I_JS~KSQR@*e)O$N-JAKty zb2;YN%Y9hzIi=hRDWzhby{5%V{+yJueW7}x<9hAF*!8W8Dc5%_c3$5jr5w6h{dTRt zy@RkT+B^NnPe|=2-rgmp@O~37W7b_5B8vz>beV{NpdNE8wksmi;MuhlU6tO(G25S2 z#+x=!{m&XNEJD~G79p@95kk4<{heRm@-KgNu4ONgC1@SsjOtux9E0T=kxbKq?0Glo zo26D6%p%a63FfW=;|NP$LnxjEx`mZkp~@-*JNST4W=`6ixq}$w&)y|`S(5GdpjZCka^xtQ3TgFE%GhQ zLhlz{1LHyK8OPZkz@W!DFyI7#8>xYrjdaiT5FKo1f6$_Y08J3V1t;v@H1`l9M?$(r zP!5oZEVcKz6I^U)b&vMDgGMD4Ab5FG$$x(`S+@uJEp*M(C-x-x~*9}~xedgzfuxByv#MsSIQoCMk9A|ZI;o{9>IPY~}|_oxT~LNFFF9K(ab zIHzk6L=y~mhXCmU*x$XQqr=EbCxXKtjFDS07^eU&X54kg=@utQQZdf6;L!&SP;m#` z0Dti>iML*EG9q5k2}3R*x#kUaMAghd3OlXC(Y>1$> z_ydF@w8ou@dEKX=7sdqe?-Djlv%dke_B%sI!ExXXxF z9W-U$F~p?De-h7FGCncJBxFvrpO_eP%5!l~$9Z+$v01&(JR9%pm`w~MZiOD0@-~FVXZ_RqH_`%G``$>K zZ@5_O9Ru;3cyZHQ+^y^?e|FUyX-irA0?GStB{wc5HzG!A-g5qy`K@4tZeKXDSabbB zf6c+087n25=beisH=Uno*|ZbvKb_#0PVjfMjKT6-oyK5iKa6Ekv%MwH?3vbs$>Qml zISZcR*z8u6eVde2G_6}nPV+b}=)Kh!Ow%zd2^Mh1PkLj(lGRHIR`8k4mru-9U$#r8 z&C~3PCB@^sP!6E8vwZ~clBFnA)!3(FpB0~*e0tLBlJctp8CwF$)mIyTaNv6f-mLj? z{SWIGOMbK`P}eFYx01T2FQwaGZ~SiStF5;x_AFKGS#T^@><^^d1Ic!LPO^Bmg15Te z>y%Q80!hWbiRGjUzrMnsR6#^|lTS`Q+xy(W(*s`nGoyi|(z&$dq)I;+O-YrchT~s< z+^^4>etbo5ddm2OamADYEIBrJV#SnyN$2YTm%MYX`epmK5>`xQub0fnyjHPdD!O#y z^_uV2f4lx_;SWl`SGtgSv*Sjav_ocr@8}HF91m%=+3rB$9y$5Bt@9~Yb_Po7 zS44l}Q`W_;mn^TOe=|K48DBcCoDGz157>4Da(3QHiBF6FJri#* zez=WEEW7gn%b1d<+CKeg8HWzlp#H;3VWN4PzQp zSFue5?P_gjjunr0LyK805m!&B=;;VO84+Ubb*lHcE|e*Btu@GkEf9;+Qo9_KVOP-G z>+HP!Y;7#2DjJbw7$(HY`|K^iv*@S zW@ZJfWr+P^YOn&17MNDK8hYoc1wv*L>t}Sq%^tw6+58B|A}P<)iczZfY{UY z5O%E43k_6Cxdb!EuG$}<)-p8FDGL@p2|J5an)LQ-blS+9Dhb_qLW&$Wjt-6eRhIS3 z#wP)ZRjf2Ry;b|GlnUWaFQjrbr?rt#q ze_Ah{_56jj`*l$JF*>gO1$B$jP_&;_K`WI{;nON(mCi>x+4<(yk$xwcAVM<)+Y%?8 zn+IIZ;eM-ga&<%-nZb`$x%sN9e%FdkC%JsU9{gD#|UDVmTV-Rl0}11dsCc@O;vZ z4T(;99w_%!nNo`l2qAuzI8DT9CeHVXqo&;A4~gH8h(oBicz`&60Vk;IAi6lR76tCQ z7V@T-=cIUY6NW}9u2qxH2+5BZhul4KRo&vx5f+O(#{ECwOfm1-N|$u`P)R89G~Le5 z^>(~izNE{*do5HH4DmB5(_=Gw(DituCuU}FW)ozo#ssJw)Oj>B+dQ>1yP!;vm^95n z#ej#3K|dy012a8S2V}hiIowunoiAo~r<77cMDma_c3#PV*fl{)*(w?97c2`+*V85A zKBSXmCb|%wmYMUIQ})g_%i>9X_L!8kY0d$`pmV-s!Msp=J?+|qixx=Vx3)@^hoz*$ zQ-^LF6Q0`so9E1s{_Exk7KZ$(2Lr}Ke%+zF$y6L*fbl5i<3hMH znL%En*Nta?LG_J-)~bPm zN>9j;TggC|PmN314yIKr^MAJT2$}aKwMXglVmoCzj}4QR5gC?DLYq1XecMy!sA#S@ zQvudO#Y5%0ta!FMM5nxo92?3Ns!6trD{6OEVHDg6!n6ocQ1Pb#Zh4kWHO05^yqadV z!Y|04k?Ehj@ct~sQYNa0Noq2U{V(L{21!WQOh~5gj7&yRZ29dWLOiqZd2Qkup`S)V zKSgK%M4z)?^dtPs__@n5dj$ba&-uzR&`X=gb}#ywkm#w#BX1YLF?;^ip53{EZ>SB8^hwGTF z^-hA~8cXKbD_Y6837Lcgu`~6aW;syjEXXfW1;ct6WOL>e)Dq0I2W0kS-|Su~p&U90 zwrj;#+MwohL`s0Z%}PSzbR))tW{~Oa9ub^|hS{PElSI!;G8Te)K~dpipUyWh*Y8iQ z4H)bEy1Kh*Z)6Gg5rDZa?Tu_nlc$Iw+S{t${6qH@Y>FRMy(imM^j6)M>{hyGt0$Xk zN=)}L!EC=o_Y}c$zn;aLF*!`)lPe?gY4jyl+=PmUx6b82n? zO+~VHBsXBUQ67-1FB~E|WRf1!45Hac){P3L0M~1MtmkOJSmf6gg^+|GhH~ZL0YfwU zaVCoIU>vL?M!jr|YSGIGg7t;?+Wne?V>?y*_SA1c10{FdmHDH9eSn-s-gkkucP>Na zL6U6kw!2}fQ*-dZ_t6fKvrKR}0uI61n=U8gMe z|3=3kLkuaODvt@G<{;zh@yNJHCeDPS> z!iIpX^1&xl?Lfp#t1hrO64bk5IfK1cU3yNnM&waC&bW=NrEy_0XkJV0WJBmP(_c*5 z4PjEl9@I@OZfz&)g;kf53Z-Na#j4Czf$>T(9C@vw4#CyXqFv4uQ3kRgeBRwDMXf3b zDP0j20|G7J0b8dF#Sl{Of;usSqem$$>Ktn|_icyN)$PDr?%fhxqN4aCr15F@YK18L z_!KqNg>)#LX`{;uj?^v;V|5KwRAb#~D+H@*<`nEB&|+OW6`G=PwR9*UBdWMT!L9J_ zc7n=IiQ-G9hIBtv`qt{ZkjZCqNoqxsC;>z6VI1vs z=+CP!@Q$skVcb=ugyMC7YU-;-tb0K3u2MwHy*BPdzpq)Zd$$9hM?-XV-U@}G+Yz=d zqB)i-5Q^Rb$v+ude3nv@Zk97EDxON8hK-D92|gE0V5=sry)0U0E+&wF^H(1!4gQg5Ew;^sMsl7>Su^uM8z(!Ppant zbnEfibV=wMVvp#b3f1C!<$P~Eq)Vm7NxF;*gq1tScnbbP317mcscB-jCQ23QaRJnb z8evtrC#b0%{jEE8ozzr<6*>kiM5vTg>2Gw+1Xv_d&s)`RvZV>C#KdNess;)QS3k)BYVB! zZ=?JR)Ge*Xc`A>>Xq-Q}Cub|^D))7BE&4O&nxo{V+}F*u_|KSYfs&hYUpLp1KVPn3 zD63{YO5VzS-7=I$%fM%=`^UO*Hc)YLK1&>~EEvPOMRZ_FHQjDa$@w2B4sHUq0+B79nkBUnA%AMQv$K^w(tftlKHzj@L&Q)OMzIn~O z)}G5m*9O^YhPjgB>N{8Yc~VEKq}*dvRL$jA=cv4MRi7v4)oTgxGuEJ@N*>Cc+w!^c ziddLa(oybJ@lC8y&X0piLNz!47`6GiVxu zh_eSKRI#i5?EBw2_|NB4zjJFH&1f<;mz9dKQHmb7J2mw9C^Ii*Wx#QShcN@9Nhj;* zi9g1ZT4g%MISICZFeFdK26Lz22x&=1^`_+zL@wzjY?D7sF)|Ok&Q~(K+n>5YW(pp^ zOZx}>K=xzo{DCzNnj>guVOc|~a19iVZdMk1zN({28sV{q>{pbA%`J#$kz}waWI=Y# z(kd$8zd*o`iT)}IeDVC84I)a-azU+JT=6{o-~WGJ{qUV5z3uy;efdSai(e+r6dYKD zAV6^kO+-@SB#i_6wjV4(9Qmi#lSn7T{|aY~YKi{@|98l@aIr7#A{%+WRp{R)x%0LavjMP5C}dG=xV6 zdtgCiRT4P^LF=w9PD0grbnT#WB`F0aSqr)+WI7|%Ho;5<4hq20+%RC_ zrnIRY*gt_rQmm6i8!Igu7YNf4Mn>^jAmICd`L7)d`G5KAAIn--gD2!m+E=dGc@!5^ zI^IN}s1}y^5<%K{o*12IkyU^7Q1t*zponeghox-UT8XT&9Mp(C!8rFsUmt9X1odQ7 zhuqq88+ z1Y^+KVFtt~-$KnUy5us!?#FO2QB4klTB6xa=4}H55NZuTRD0hmBQ7qQ zZ36-RU$CMBJs8esd2wSz6Gqv--UKOZ3v6&4gidv9z?2U$Zk%!Y{Bm5@?S!PKPCgmd zzn(qe+cDdN0fD{JC*{>(!PuWXG?t;@t`8p z;7_j%Bvgfh<}Vu%*5cVQ^F{9oDXDOElw#Q=M#|-la}N?T2JC|Ex>hROy>MJAY*?&b z?7z9=#)v=tL?D5GLi3x%OmAu+G2gGx|CMgTO6f*q1*0V`Up?w+dG;7l*b#~T&GZgP za^q8^)Y|#xH!VL-dn0W@Tr6CexSqR`Q#6+{@4B{mQ76?j-)!;s^g$)t=wz`U-kA8* zuBUcQ@AB5ZwEOwpbL{NCTRBzu_v2qz}q(6UMhLM#HX1p_caGh#Cv<%2I3!gdpm7|c9LUZbNd=`Y{ z%{~jZ{2=u}{6>iMlT*IZ3R4@7Y3(%Bs!$x+{0elRilG~@VdnhQA);?%F#Tb_7g$7yEqWP&+^H?E_b9 zeo+6tdf-FJq7K#*;;wHF)E){{wEm*-A4>nObh)GRR)_ta4r0@R*gtuY*tU>PegW1b zq?5gYj=sR*{y@G{GC8MONIr+3JnT8A(&Bc%W?V2Y+ja#^yQf-+u76ZNzR$PemGYO% z=Nd0>4r$8Ir_E1Z%abzp29o!|po=m2*;>!Ix5=lSJs3zSUN#o{b(?(7fNqoDSiE9P z#lD?7pB8Fdae<7oWn-CNS36f8(AD~lW$&3%p?Cn@g$w6>whNC-Cg3mGmQeb1=|#&+ z=`W=FV&*h+eOFqp#G}_at~D*#u5Fjfb}ckWWqTy+o

#fMwsJL9(8-ibqmJ9@@Y4(*7OJ&?2Gj*)~lF^0{r zpP1kJTGyQf@}9^Twq2cAcrdW-;GHDmksM0>EL27wTi790H3!OD?wH9J3u7pIJ?8b^ z?+$!>;41e6{(JmF!}lKyRFbx+Yz>qhzLP?Nr80)vt6M>K(tnu#mgZ-%e;d0v_ESS( z$Kjhhq#eftwI}YRkzna^KA~+0q1_4#Cj<2d0#yfZ8lB}pgtk0{ z5{3DXq8l+k$_rp;i9xFA2vl%)vPjTu#!!06IoB}Pd!=Q*{K~OF>Fzr@&6TvvkA5qEMW1mo=3?(l11}6FQgw@~I2g-K@igvE(H@?30s^tgi-%Ec}yU?)EzgT^J@OtZ_<9b_Q z`=LN}YhV)+DYz7KsrQwEZw|cPIiHG7kwGjCz1EEy2CREl^tl<&j7c{+so$7tQs( zRu(9#4dm5*ScSSzHQlLUOi7*?^wv&ancuk4uiGfE6#6h+My?Dz$x0gU!li74;LwZ- z&1jN<-Qlnn!X8+Wt%YE)4PD)AXR;zJnbeZQG$@vgP6-vgL*z{CcQAI9*=@CkekT;I zY4Ik#M2D!DjVc5Su~cpmfxjv@H#=<^CoZ3DF>^lZ5XQRXjih{99NHeaVK>x)Kl5J`JP z$w4VQ!*Ixfiw9JUQA-*W6fMz^$`gdfY05L7s4y{zdqsvUNnanZIp!yE0*Wa082Nhg;$gy|x4F9wSm zpEkXG@n^e4nW6DM@&8xi{14*%jyRvd36@5ehM^6(%Cb_u#uk5%z}W8kSSsP3eRZGs z&v+l)+?4yT|5Bg5@BI&lem#Bd55L)qEm{{z(qvUqZlub{*=G_8S6IczqyJacH;IL%IXMl|~1Nv5e=p}fC? zjD?qv&+Y|ttjV9cC19*ZJXoDO{p4w)JnHQaAf=e_VxwiDaPg4;_=EnQe*Yt*%kcs> zW5yewDte*_+Xzah+1nNy%-S`*+%%`Te2|RO0Za802ISpz+nnNQ@bo^DiIrK7x8tSG z=R2Xw%1h=V>WR>9&bNvd9X~Do(cYUy(yk+ctw&eV_PptQtMO+C{`SBxYHyBV{)~P2e*R>j z<3ZSnlRCQI{$il*;Xre@zo%Df?hWkiTS?pgX4;$Lk0*aP`BopSs5SgU)6bi*i~sEd zZ}{#T7nhmcrhRU0wb2A z&{5})@?rM+t4OcdI6Y_J;v>phNqo{;qpEy}NU~st<}NTibn(d) zJW`;so3ctIPSJMW43(dID95b7*Pxu~EQDq;mDc)jfaR%#&Z1HjukGK5DRBa)8naZC83ql#F$VFyN?IxvO(L2WC$e7NjDkFh%haIirP%c6mc5@VX+YfwCdaq@zrcr((B6IxGpD#0hl3vs}#8j%>#s0#(aXWn4o^686s$I#qT| z)Ng=Rv_cW(TpFHGIaA62krb3=)w9J68c)?F>%0d}9>L60$f7W>5E!W;C-BKCh+!Ng z$4gbl{1JE<1DMKqNR-(A|BZ`6E}zg2q08#4F6@Ec`rD8Z^3ft8kDB%6@_BrkLOFo3 z`6miaSSMg54`%20AOGRYhSDmg>($#k^ z{d1>0k!g}+A+6ZS16H!N-!bl}6gPmHi)C=gjE`LV#oxdUCJ=M~ zMD{4#248#H`ge%7TPyEF0Y-{NutXRg8(@=BHJ0+?S@DI=MC=x)uuDzJF$QWeN~jgO zRa*dPN+$2!TUXgYFm)zztctFt*`4a~l`e@|6;DX8Z=|Unw`wc0eGgp{I^^n|W_&zG zb=47xybiUdV6a|Fw7>l-od?}}SC7Tc*H4GnUlIY+yTls}jt*Fzj=mw~j9#2KVRemIAv?7a zBDq;1k~nO4z$xM|V5htueKkg2|BKHP@V@|O5Io<+kzHHKaR0Lu6+@T zi%$_8z@Zqkh$z$Q!55w<*Bkp}{gv{B(3<%tN0yV4Ic=!FMi$Ak6%=tR`9Q{6 z(MOzD;gpvU>r6y1z!fw^V6|M4Kc1L<2!ySIe~xYMQqMHD|U2^~%5_5_5av zM&hWcMo`;3I2k$sAyyV#yTt?&YAYOKTMp?ww1tw1eix+-8UW>fS06E9rE%gI74jO4 zk)uO3gh-a%q2+s&z+f)R+*iVB-M@c-NXnVEW={~?QK~%r+-8h%kaWJ6XZ5A}`XD2l zYJ`=e6xd1fYM$91kzbjLecYTTVA=#R7))eudU6v2#QAiA_!7wN2wUKGf)(p@qiJTx zv?jXeKW=6>2oorVWXy%XIb~Y^%ha9I&A->gB~*Qq%p_%cwcZZzquw^cL!UFi98p?m z>A#%lgjmdy@?6n3ik@hhCL0b}NS8d-9_|_abkj<1o|l+q8X$(t5w{lh1nRG3&fBhJ zUw+)zGw)bnuk|f7TstY1?D6O9oj&9_{+m*+_D%keJZHu*F*l&f|_-!|d;t=^OiJG^!& z1u{m$5P3JHe6iZ2xoydja(ClYg1CiK;14u{4FQINzxBbDqD?S@<-C~&VP;A@>tWx^ z&3mco`KE6e$wpzYI{Lh}2>S&&Wn|(|fR5Sp3uiG_H28>N!GX(%Ageljxx$x(!v(6Z zrNH#LUb1fYr|Z!vp@oGs~SLQqJg7=g3bs zFBUEyzgcpzwjB$Qd|WU0H{-R>-|v(j9$2w8yjAiG%|FEcUFB^2|$Ns#aL3^Yixep$Zi?Gqq zZP<@{W5Il}KX>B`C%F;-HkAVd}57uaMJsfkhBbDOGuj z-Z?{8rt-E{{3;z6&lw?5Fm-D<==yVs_$6`4oSCy!#lk>tjuJakqSP+J1e33bUs@$o z6+3DH+epK0!9oIe?A7Nw3=dNQaFBm#4TpBHCX}2jcqW7rD z=mN$*Xn&$sXD{M)wVF}{QBE#ZmX$JljFiMnN@6eKveY{cF=@_@rYsn_8idKXR~ULC z%w;2V=4TB}PmQsQIex9WMR)R0?G1L&>I*ESC_a#iuexBi`%QX6uPiK;J7=L63yQCD z$HEd*3$k>ib{a;+I%uODlI2?8xLoyqno0(t^GIl}7OjBgtB?@I0xlgGmcb_|qO?g? z>?YyqHdzZwGzPQ*tfZuJP6cvKb;xNGa!R@@rzFn0jZ9;3h4U)-qw?CU%@#O1%>2Vvnwkcs@+;)vp zDyd@Ezz!uOYOLz_kuc>^7;_sl2sWw0-3@E#dxK^uN;*YyejQO19v7iDIZYBYN7O_WfA9%N=~Nb#!Rrnk zy7+(KfjV@t0iB(axKNVtaA!yG$OV+waw?^I@Ip0V?mY(hu|mjXsX+leN(|+M#Nb?u zi17jiMZ%Vrn?fNtHo{rcxa4CSvEm|CI0`<94@HodQ#e6wT)^^+jQv6FY3Did0C|F* zr;J)5g>l8$b;t^H#u>2NqFjoI0p?Mp?MCL|GZD>wOQ(8qUedEA7d0=%z7RVf=ilD; z?v@7v1xJ>)JTO=7D|#i?7mLTGf+K; z65q(gQ*g^&4I?+QvZlr1fhe^Aqij$@#_9=*qxot{=78%g0?CTyvhY}5`oKVZEKvf- z3Yv`%#)kS<&`gkyUg^7osP~#Ga}Tow`#2=lG`| z6SVtxX&G!Vo0OkcaVKYYhL-bx<|=#?se(90N~pm*ZOB_L`=jIwA&;c&cNk_{lLl3H zvyB@6nGyev!CTvg-q|+vamedaQAF@y8j=4KzK2MNlDkLdf%G3gD(=Hqpml_y5TXy7 zkT2=g;tX*bIAP-xI_kLU|d9#WQ#c#y=|J1j(Lp=UG^_ zB7*`{szIA!shXT(IWE>C4vvp>j+Ce1ctxDvDwoax*YQtPE5?ICX4U_Yk-cPvt$4_q76|qLAuObF3s}dkvS^rS4I`@aXc{^FV-eIF${kNN&K(+(Vj`ge)kZvOXwQ&t-!r>RM#| zjaZjM%J1|KJmSwjy^@e|F)5H)KDX(r>-(n{OK)24#Ay?bK<60Bl}YBQ)?X5q$S+g3 zfsIhS6&wleLUW+FVaZg4vjF9dw_a##rryvBYr_LBI@SWk1SJWVe1)7{?ZWlG?_yn?CB&BqLmD h6`S=@KU>c3y8}SzOw$i7Ycrlt{p<84ZH8R9{|_jxo5uhE From 12b967ecd99921b5c47e7578049dd4c78eb53085 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: ahrazzle <38987266+ahrazzle@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 17:40:08 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 5/7] Test slow-subspace preparations with independent field-equation review --- .../aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md | 6 +- .../aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS | 2 +- .../slow-mode/GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md | 35 + .../slow-mode/PROTOCOL.md | 35 + .../slow-mode/RESULTS.md | 61 + .../slow-mode/checkpoint.json | 34 + .../slow-mode/evidence.json | 2598 +++++++++++++++++ .../slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md | 60 + .../slow-mode/independent-review/check.py | 191 ++ .../independent-review/checkpoint.json | 17 + .../independent-review/evidence.json | 1021 +++++++ .../slow-mode/probe.py | 173 ++ .../slow-mode/selection-failure.json | 116 + .../slow-mode/selection_failure.py | 19 + 14 files changed, 4366 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/PROTOCOL.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/RESULTS.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/checkpoint.json create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/evidence.json create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/check.py create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/checkpoint.json create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/evidence.json create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/probe.py create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection-failure.json create mode 100644 research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection_failure.py diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md index e58411c..5fc85e4 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md @@ -86,6 +86,10 @@ python response.py --output results.json The [script](response.py) includes assertions. The [results](results.json) retain all preparation values, residuals, amplitude controls and approximation errors. No network request, downloaded dataset, fitting stage or graphical dependency is needed. -The bounded result supports retaining the additional scalar/vector response data before a nonlinear solver is attempted. The next bounded test selects a slow initial mode and measures sensitivity to fast-mode contamination. A three-dimensional collapse experiment remains unstarted. +The bounded result supports retaining the additional scalar/vector response data before a nonlinear solver is attempted. + +The [slow-subspace continuation](slow-mode/RESULTS.md) removes initial fast components and tests controlled leakage. Its zero-pressure baseline errors remain 24.6–27.4% for this fixed benchmark. + +A [separate review](slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md) reproduces all 65 preparations and 130 closure errors using the original five-field equations. This closes the specified same-action test. A three-dimensional collapse experiment remains unstarted. The derivation is retained byte-for-byte at its reviewed hash, including its original pre-review status. The review linked above supersedes that status. Run `python independent-review/adm_check.py` for the separate action reduction and comparison. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS index 749a09b..55abb31 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -523aafe3e5602f9738900291992b7cf456e70d0f2861370286b959fae7ced663 README.md +b23164c524bfe6a8da825eb6fdb8512305d8bacbdd92dee0ac8959c674eb6c1b README.md 5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe derivation.md 58f56124bef156d5a8e22d0bd4eaab695c4ac0540f0e211e63f5e99ff4bc10e7 independent-review/REVIEW.md ab32294e143f463d1d80026f3d70ee23dff22facd159bcdf86889a236aea8def independent-review/adm-evidence.json diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a561cc4 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +# Slow-mode preparation and controlled fast-mode contamination + +This test asks whether a two-variable approximation improves when the same AeST action is prepared near its growing slow mode. It retains the existing background, constants, interval and 1% accuracy criterion. It adds no fitted coefficient or cosmological data. + +Protocol fixed before evaluating approximation errors, 12 November 2026. Source action and equations: the independently checked checkpoint with `response.py` SHA256 `e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef`. + +## Fixed state and mode selection + +Set Q0=1, K_B=1, K2=2, lambda_s=1, q_i=0.01, a_i=1 and a_f=2. Test k/Q0=6,9,12,18,24. Use the four coordinates `X=(delta,theta,chi,Z)`, where `delta=D/R`, `theta=m/(QK')`, and Q0 supplies the units. The change of background normalization is included in their evolution matrix M(a). + +At a=1, identify the fast complex-conjugate eigenpair of M. The two remaining eigenvalues must be real to numerical tolerance. Choose the larger real eigenvalue as the instantaneous growing slow mode and normalize its density component to one. Set its amplitude to delta_i=1e-5. If this spectral structure fails, report that failure instead of changing the selection rule. + +Follow all four eigenvalues from a=1 to a=2 on 201 equally spaced scale factors. Match neighbouring eigenvalues by minimum total distance and check that the real slow pair stays separated from the fast pair. Record the smallest fast/slow spectral gap divided by H, the largest slow rate divided by fast frequency, and the fast-frequency adiabatic ratio `|omega_dot|/omega^2`. + +Eigenvectors also change with time. In the fixed declared coordinate units, normalize each to unit Euclidean norm, align its phase between adjacent points, and record fast/slow mixing from `V^(-1) Vdot` divided by the associated spectral gap. Record the eigenvector condition number. These finite diagnostics qualify the word slow. They are not an invariant-manifold proof. + +## Preserve the retained initial data + +Let S contain the two slow eigenvectors at a=1. Normalize the fast complex vector f so its density component is one and real. For phases 0, pi/2, pi and 3pi/2, take `g=Re(exp(i*phase)*f)`. Subtract the unique slow combination matching g's initial density and momentum: + +```text +w = g - S * inverse(S[delta,theta]) * g[delta,theta]. +``` + +Then w has zero retained density and momentum and a prescribed fast spectral component. The prepared state is `delta_i*(slow_growing + eta*w)`, with eta=0,0.001,0.01,0.1. Eta=0 is counted once per wave number. The amplitude eta refers to the fast component's initial density oscillation envelope before its compensating slow contribution. It is not a probability or a fraction of energy. + +There are 65 distinct preparations. Each exact run and both approximate runs start with the same retained density and momentum. This compares sensitivity to extra field information without changing the approximation's visible initial state. + +## Comparison and controls + +Evolve the full time-dependent four-state system from a=1 to a=2. Compare the zero-pressure and adiabatic-pressure prescriptions already tested. Normalize density-contrast and lensing-sum errors by each observable's maximum in the zero-pressure reference. Both errors must stay below 1% to pass. No mode is reselected or projected away during evolution. + +Use a 2001-point scale-factor grid and a fundamental solution matrix to evaluate all linear preparations. Compare its baseline with direct state integration. Repeat the fundamental integration at tighter tolerances and use 4001 output points for the error maxima. Retain maximum absolute field and metric amplitudes so that large percentages can be distinguished from nonlinear excursions. + +An instantaneous growing eigenvector is not an exact time-dependent growing solution. A passing result would support only this specified initial ensemble and leakage interval. A failure would not rule out a more accurate slow preparation, a colder background or a different observationally chosen spectrum. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/PROTOCOL.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/PROTOCOL.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b7d7d74 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/PROTOCOL.md @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +# Slow spectral subspace and controlled fast-mode contamination + +This test asks whether a two-variable approximation improves when the same AeST action is prepared inside its two-dimensional slow spectral subspace. It retains the existing background, constants, interval and 1% accuracy criterion. It adds no fitted coefficient or cosmological data. + +This separate continuation was fixed before evaluating approximation errors, 12 November 2026. The original real-growing-mode selection failed because the slow pair is complex. Its protocol and spectrum remain in GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md and selection-failure.json. Source action and equations: the independently checked checkpoint with `response.py` SHA256 `e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef`. + +## Fixed state and mode selection + +Set Q0=1, K_B=1, K2=2, lambda_s=1, q_i=0.01, a_i=1 and a_f=2. Test k/Q0=6,9,12,18,24. Use the four coordinates `X=(delta,theta,chi,Z)`, where `delta=D/R`, `theta=m/(QK')`, and Q0 supplies the units. The change of background normalization is included in their evolution matrix M(a). + +At a=1, choose the conjugate pair with larger absolute imaginary frequency as fast. The other pair spans the slow subspace. Take real and imaginary parts of one slow eigenvector as a real basis S. Select the unique real combination with delta_i=1e-5 and theta_i=-H_i*delta_i/k^2, matching the previous dust-inspired retained state. If the retained-state block of S is singular, report failure. + +Follow all four eigenvalues from a=1 to a=2 on 201 equally spaced scale factors. Match neighbouring eigenvalues by minimum total distance and check that the slow subspace stays separated from the fast pair. Record the smallest fast/slow spectral gap divided by H, the largest slow rate divided by fast frequency, and the fast-frequency adiabatic ratio `|omega_dot|/omega^2`. + +Eigenvectors also change with time. In the fixed declared coordinate units, normalize each to unit Euclidean norm, align its phase between adjacent points, and record fast/slow mixing from `V^(-1) Vdot` divided by the associated spectral gap. Record the eigenvector condition number. These finite diagnostics qualify the word slow. They are not an invariant-manifold proof. + +## Preserve the retained initial data + +Let S be the real slow-subspace basis at a=1. Normalize the fast complex vector f so its density component is one and real. For phases 0, pi/2, pi and 3pi/2, take `g=Re(exp(i*phase)*f)`. Subtract the unique slow combination matching g's initial density and momentum: + +```text +w = g - S * inverse(S[delta,theta]) * g[delta,theta]. +``` + +Then w has zero retained density and momentum and a prescribed fast spectral component. The prepared state is `slow_preparation + delta_i*eta*w`, with eta=0,0.001,0.01,0.1. Eta=0 is counted once per wave number. The amplitude eta refers to the fast component's initial density oscillation envelope before its compensating slow contribution. It is not a probability or a fraction of energy. + +There are 65 distinct preparations. Each exact run and both approximate runs start with the same retained density and momentum. This compares sensitivity to extra field information without changing the approximation's visible initial state. + +## Comparison and controls + +Evolve the full time-dependent four-state system from a=1 to a=2. Compare the zero-pressure and adiabatic-pressure prescriptions already tested. Normalize density-contrast and lensing-sum errors by each observable's maximum in the zero-pressure reference. Both errors must stay below 1% to pass. No mode is reselected or projected away during evolution. + +Use a 2001-point scale-factor grid and a fundamental solution matrix to evaluate all linear preparations. Compare its baseline with direct state integration. Repeat the fundamental integration at tighter tolerances and use 4001 output points for the error maxima. Retain maximum absolute field and metric amplitudes so that large percentages can be distinguished from nonlinear excursions. + +The instantaneous slow subspace is not an exact time-dependent invariant subspace. This preparation is not called a growing eigenmode. A passing result would support only this specified initial ensemble and leakage interval. A failure would not rule out a more accurate slow preparation, a colder background or a different observationally chosen spectrum. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/RESULTS.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/RESULTS.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..80078ac --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/RESULTS.md @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +# Slow initial data do not rescue these two closures + +Selecting the initial slow spectral subspace does not bring the zero-pressure or adiabatic-pressure prescription within 1% accuracy for this fixed AeST benchmark. With no initial fast component, the zero-pressure errors remain 24.6% to 27.4%. This is a result for one action, background, coordinate convention and finite interval. + +Status: finite calculation, independent review pending. The underlying action and four-state response passed a separate ADM review. That review does not automatically verify this added preparation test. No observational or general cold-dark-matter failure is claimed. + +## The first selection rule failed + +The original [growing-mode protocol](GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md) required one fast conjugate pair and two real slow eigenvalues. At a=1, every tested wave number instead has two conjugate pairs. The slow pair has frequency 0.07694 to 0.08850 in Q0 units, while the fast frequency is 5.39289 to 20.83462. [selection-failure.json](selection-failure.json) retains this result. + +No closure error was evaluated under that failed rule. The separately declared [continuation protocol](PROTOCOL.md) uses the two-dimensional slow spectral subspace. Its unique real initial state matches the original dust-inspired density and momentum. It is not called an instantaneous growing mode. + +Both calculations use Q0=1, K_B=1, lambda_s=1, K2=2, q_i=0.01 and a=1 to a=2. No constant, background or approximation coefficient was fitted after inspecting errors. + +## The controlled comparison + +The state is `(delta,theta,chi,Z)`, with `delta=D/R` and `theta=m/(QK')`. The evolution matrix includes derivatives of those background normalizations. The initial density contrast is 1e-5 and theta is `-H_i*delta_i/k^2`. + +The two slow eigenvectors determine chi and Z at that fixed retained state. The full time-dependent equations then evolve freely. There is no later projection, reselection or suppression of a mode. The two approximate laws begin with the same retained state and keep the exact background. + +Errors are maxima over the interval, divided by the maximum corresponding observable in the zero-pressure reference. The declared pass threshold is 1% for both density contrast and the metric-potential sum. + +| k/Q0 | Zero-pressure density error | Zero-pressure metric error | Adiabatic-pressure density error | Adiabatic-pressure metric error | +|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 6 | 24.603% | 24.576% | 117.584% | 117.568% | +| 9 | 26.193% | 26.180% | 129.154% | 151.239% | +| 12 | 26.806% | 26.798% | 120.441% | 166.308% | +| 18 | 27.263% | 27.259% | 112.881% | 179.572% | +| 24 | 27.427% | 27.425% | 129.110% | 185.409% | + +Removing the initial fast spectral component reduces the previous worst zero-pressure error from about 28.7% to 27.4%. It does not meet the stated accuracy target. An instantaneous spectral subspace still differs from an invariant subspace of the evolving equations. + +## Sensitivity to unobserved initial data + +Four phases of a fast component were added at each nonzero leakage amplitude eta. A compensating slow component preserves the initial density and momentum. Eta is the fast component's density-oscillation envelope relative to the baseline initial density before compensation. It is not an energy fraction. + +| eta | Distinct preparations | Worst zero-pressure error in either observable | Worst adiabatic-pressure error | +|---:|---:|---:|---:| +| 0 | 5 | 27.43% | 185.41% | +| 0.001 | 20 | 32.48% | 187.84% | +| 0.01 | 20 | 78.00% | 209.71% | +| 0.1 | 20 | 533.23% | 638.80% | + +All 65 preparations fail the 1% criterion for both prescriptions. The largest exact density contrast is 0.0001165 and the largest metric-potential sum is 2.36e-8. Large error percentages therefore compare small linear perturbations. + +## What the slow label establishes + +The fast and slow spectral subspaces remain separated on the 201-point diagnostic grid. Their smallest separation ranges from 45.9H to 179.2H across the tested wave numbers. The maximum slow-rate to fast-frequency ratio is 0.0143. + +Eigenvectors also change and the matrix is not normal. In the declared coordinate norm, the largest fast/slow eigenvector-mixing ratio is 0.741 at k/Q0=6 and 0.0270 at k/Q0=24. +The large mixing value is from fast into slow coordinates. The reverse ratio, which describes forcing of fast coordinates by a slow basis, is at most 0.000153 on these grids. The evidence records both directions, the eigenvector condition numbers and the frequency-variation ratio. A large spectral gap alone does not prove adiabatic decoupling. + +The frozen-generator spectrum depends on the declared time-dependent state coordinates. These results identify a reproducible initial ensemble. They do not define a unique physical growing solution, prove that every slow preparation fails, or constrain an observational perturbation spectrum. + +## Checks and remaining limit + +[probe.py](probe.py) evolves a fundamental solution matrix and compares its baseline with direct state integration. A second calculation at k/Q0=12 tightens tolerance and doubles the output grid to 4001 points. The maximum change in reported error fraction is 4.17e-6. The direct and fundamental solutions agree below 1e-7 after division by the initial density amplitude. + +[evidence.json](evidence.json) records every preparation, the spectral diagnostics, the amplitude bounds and the numerical controls. Run `python3 probe.py` with NumPy and SciPy to reproduce it. Run `python3 selection_failure.py` to reproduce the failed real-eigenvalue gate. + +This test closes the stated same-action preparation question with a negative result for these two closures. Choosing a different cosmology, a physically motivated initial spectrum or an exact invariant slow construction requires an additional assumption. None is supplied by these calculations. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/checkpoint.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/checkpoint.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2e9bb4a --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/checkpoint.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "date": "2026-11-12", + "status": "frozen calculation; independent review pending", + "files": [ + { + "path": "PROTOCOL.md", + "sha256": "efe19e6cb78f46af8d612b4ab0188981f711604b6aa4755cf287e62a540d1fc7" + }, + { + "path": "GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md", + "sha256": "e18a17694fd46609e2574f680d6fd5a0d870295cf3f030b2a1da3d5d0187c9a9" + }, + { + "path": "RESULTS.md", + "sha256": "4db8ba576047fcc296e7f99556ba2ab31121fb93d31ac7d9cd81c30296a2883e" + }, + { + "path": "probe.py", + "sha256": "af9d4443c45298d723384ad0283bb8a635944fe347fd2067e3f4699ea94b2151" + }, + { + "path": "evidence.json", + "sha256": "cc1e24085ca282198798514f01946c338b3df4f715ff7a694b0d8402f567d054" + }, + { + "path": "selection_failure.py", + "sha256": "368230772939461a5a10c6ff0552c5aeb6375068660f45efd8a8403992ebd605" + }, + { + "path": "selection-failure.json", + "sha256": "71a3187c110e66993bd3fd035b0f4abd041146c5ca74e983cbed2aa29ea46098" + } + ] +} diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/evidence.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/evidence.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cc43f48 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/evidence.json @@ -0,0 +1,2598 @@ +{ + "protocol_sha256": "efe19e6cb78f46af8d612b4ab0188981f711604b6aa4755cf287e62a540d1fc7", + "scope": "Same-action instantaneous slow-subspace initialization, plus compensated fast contamination. No invariant-manifold or observational claim.", + "points": [ + { + "k": 6.0, + "mode_diagnostics": { + "initial_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 0.00017829959360134856, + 0.07694011280610696 + ], + [ + 0.00017829959360134856, + -0.07694011280610696 + ], + [ + -0.058912799380405376, + 5.392894883230915 + ], + [ + -0.058912799380405376, + -5.392894883230915 + ] + ], + "final_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 1.8127064619613925e-05, + 0.010411659462677907 + ], + [ + 1.8127064619613925e-05, + -0.010411659462677907 + ], + [ + -0.020475133026453686, + 2.9644053206785275 + ], + [ + -0.020475133026453686, + -2.9644053206785275 + ] + ], + "min_fast_slow_gap_over_H": 45.925691830260725, + "max_slow_rate_over_fast_frequency": 0.014266979250636452, + "max_frequency_adiabatic_ratio": 0.019950681931818245, + "max_fast_slow_eigenvector_mixing_over_gap": 0.7405699277716458, + "max_fast_from_slow_mixing_over_gap": 0.00015241770357156506, + "max_slow_from_fast_mixing_over_gap": 0.7405699277716458, + "max_eigenvector_condition_number": 1457.444538403897, + "initial_retained_slow_basis_condition_number": 469.4111195126547, + "initial_fast_spectral_coordinate_norm": 5.924143345756509e-19, + "slow_initial_state_per_unit_delta": [ + 1.0, + -0.0032155102507750626, + -0.0002681886339892248, + -0.0010331366680233396 + ], + "compensated_leakage_vectors": [ + { + "phase": 0.0, + "state": [ + 1.1102230246251565e-16, + 0.0, + 0.024136020133254155, + 0.09114989401042602 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "state": [ + 0.0, + -2.7755575615628914e-17, + 0.1652803053026899, + 0.00275143582024035 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "state": [ + -1.1102230246251565e-16, + 0.0, + -0.024136020133254135, + -0.09114989401042602 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 2.7755575615628914e-17, + -0.1652803053026899, + -0.0027514358202403613 + ] + } + ] + }, + "direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i": 7.064254780100865e-14, + "reference_scales": [ + 2.0139112929987693e-05, + 1.118915239922817e-08 + ], + "rows": [ + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24603288376029978, + "lensing_error": 0.24576009132530746, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.518422889944848e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154241129182369e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.7699861698773795e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.88103923953696e-09, + "chi": 3.6167149423427737e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1758409572594646, + "lensing_error": 1.1756800774501743, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.518422889944848e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154241129182369e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.7699861698773795e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.88103923953696e-09, + "chi": 3.6167149423427737e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24715508087043478, + "lensing_error": 0.24688033461340786, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5161628845117766e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.115418531327552e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.7843243996595105e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.5411420781136917e-08, + "chi": 4.77386184305501e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1747187601493296, + "lensing_error": 1.174559834162074, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5161628845117766e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.115418531327552e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.7843243996595105e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.5411420781136917e-08, + "chi": 4.77386184305501e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.23278898335297873, + "lensing_error": 0.23252072808188703, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.545094930538503e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154243662248263e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.8681724898591758e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.55159476101472e-08, + "chi": 5.165443349894344e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1890848576667858, + "lensing_error": 1.1889194406935948, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.545094930538503e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154243662248263e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.8681724898591758e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.55159476101472e-08, + "chi": 5.165443349894344e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24491068665016502, + "lensing_error": 0.2446398480372072, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.520682895377919e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1156674337617167e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.7556479400952485e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.4229840094497347e-08, + "chi": 4.804721252543993e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1769631543695995, + "lensing_error": 1.1768003207382747, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.520682895377919e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1156674337617167e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.7556479400952485e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.4229840094497347e-08, + "chi": 4.804721252543993e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.259276784167621, + "lensing_error": 0.258999454568728, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4917508493511928e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154239358352858e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.6717998498955835e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.2563620439946258e-08, + "chi": 4.334689392919148e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1625970568521433, + "lensing_error": 1.1624407142067539, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4917508493511928e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154239358352858e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.6717998498955835e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.2563620439946258e-08, + "chi": 4.334689392919148e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.25725485486164823, + "lensing_error": 0.2569625242063109, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4958228356141366e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154136179375398e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.913656924308888e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.778806439298389e-08, + "chi": 1.826946356236263e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1646189861581162, + "lensing_error": 1.1644776445691711, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4958228356141366e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154136179375398e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.913656924308888e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.778806439298389e-08, + "chi": 1.826946356236263e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.11359387968708903, + "lensing_error": 0.11336645889110303, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.7851432958813972e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.167611865665971e-08, + "aether_spatial": 2.7518493696953394e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.523283010133843e-08, + "chi": 1.9107117046874034e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3082799613326754, + "lensing_error": 1.3080737098843789, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.7851432958813972e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.167611865665971e-08, + "aether_spatial": 2.7518493696953394e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.523283010133843e-08, + "chi": 1.9107117046874034e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2348109126589516, + "lensing_error": 0.23455765844430437, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.541022944275559e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1331059778162223e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.8042649605627142e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.749139452965993e-08, + "chi": 1.9189838431335464e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.187062928360813, + "lensing_error": 1.1868825103311775, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.541022944275559e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1331059778162223e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.8042649605627142e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.749139452965993e-08, + "chi": 1.9189838431335464e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.37847188783351077, + "lensing_error": 0.37815372375951206, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.2517024840082984e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.115423041508101e-08, + "aether_spatial": 9.829543877028916e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.026530616648796e-08, + "chi": 1.920991687016124e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.0434019531862537, + "lensing_error": 1.0432864450159698, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.2517024840082984e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.115423041508101e-08, + "aether_spatial": 9.829543877028916e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.026530616648796e-08, + "chi": 1.920991687016124e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.3582525947737832, + "lensing_error": 0.3577844201353395, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3163335959619203e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "aether_spatial": 3.318385556898087e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.115545005114534e-07, + "chi": 1.5735959490819594e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.0636212462459813, + "lensing_error": 1.0699381889523976, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3163335959619203e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154135185185187e-08, + "aether_spatial": 3.318385556898087e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.115545005114534e-07, + "chi": 1.5735959490819594e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 1.07835715697181, + "lensing_error": 1.1070645296053139, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 4.185626949310344e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.3574422461335633e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.158861816805698e-06, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.472050508782539e-07, + "chi": 1.6259841896279767e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 2.5002309979915744, + "lensing_error": 2.49961640179222, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 4.185626949310344e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.3574422461335633e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.158861816805698e-06, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.472050508782539e-07, + "chi": 1.6259841896279767e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.13381317274681637, + "lensing_error": 0.1823415491718124, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.7444234332519607e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.3198896270664613e-08, + "aether_spatial": 3.7462744785168895e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.9681535752959e-07, + "chi": 1.636278191062348e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.288060668272948, + "lensing_error": 1.2877044062602065, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.7444234332519607e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.3198896270664613e-08, + "aether_spatial": 3.7462744785168895e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.9681535752959e-07, + "chi": 1.636278191062348e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 1.5704229244924095, + "lensing_error": 1.569696415667353, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.1487811694206476e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154231225322832e-08, + "aether_spatial": 8.302168222135057e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.572865073849131e-07, + "chi": 1.6796219164258218e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 6.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.2646373613364418, + "lensing_error": 0.4248181695624312, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.1487811694206476e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.1154231225322832e-08, + "aether_spatial": 8.302168222135057e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.572865073849131e-07, + "chi": 1.6796219164258218e-07 + } + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "mode_diagnostics": { + "initial_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 0.00011886004005979699, + 0.083786596544086 + ], + [ + 0.00011886004005979699, + -0.083786596544086 + ], + [ + -0.05885335982686522, + 7.926675767004695 + ], + [ + -0.05885335982686522, + -7.926675767004695 + ] + ], + "final_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 1.1708276998284783e-05, + 0.022249762444947523 + ], + [ + 1.1708276998284783e-05, + -0.022249762444947523 + ], + [ + -0.020468714238831787, + 4.150278404064025 + ], + [ + -0.020468714238831787, + -4.150278404064025 + ] + ], + "min_fast_slow_gap_over_H": 67.75415846842542, + "max_slow_rate_over_fast_frequency": 0.010570216735810357, + "max_frequency_adiabatic_ratio": 0.014126460492512894, + "max_fast_slow_eigenvector_mixing_over_gap": 0.20948451292702086, + "max_fast_from_slow_mixing_over_gap": 0.00010225304315407084, + "max_slow_from_fast_mixing_over_gap": 0.20948451292702086, + "max_eigenvector_condition_number": 1917.5266453556537, + "initial_retained_slow_basis_condition_number": 970.8041317318567, + "initial_fast_spectral_coordinate_norm": 4.307564897304308e-19, + "slow_initial_state_per_unit_delta": [ + 1.0, + -0.0014291156670111391, + -0.00012436881216402063, + -0.00047910010144377487 + ], + "compensated_leakage_vectors": [ + { + "phase": 0.0, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.010444149897426007, + 0.03889068887646355 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.10333912158270793, + 0.0007438755558518391 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "state": [ + 0.0, + -4.336808689942018e-19, + -0.010444149897425994, + -0.03889068887646355 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.10333912158270793, + -0.0007438755558518439 + ] + } + ] + }, + "direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i": 7.335305323222241e-14, + "reference_scales": [ + 2.014128920196035e-05, + 4.975033787037482e-09 + ], + "rows": [ + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.26193493844583987, + "lensing_error": 0.2618027602579335, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4865581854625005e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.9605243440142484e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.1753804063024822e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 4.614223010412869e-09, + "chi": 1.6526290477252796e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2915393264922588, + "lensing_error": 1.5123946908993695, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4865581854625005e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.9605243440142484e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.1753804063024822e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 4.614223010412869e-09, + "chi": 1.6526290477252796e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.262886343402509, + "lensing_error": 0.26275155168778624, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4846419332244555e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.96049807269057e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.1846870745279113e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.1133804484971514e-08, + "chi": 2.454268993902797e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2905353630729468, + "lensing_error": 1.5115397755304054, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4846419332244555e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.96049807269057e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.1846870745279113e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.1133804484971514e-08, + "chi": 2.454268993902797e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24268375547706186, + "lensing_error": 0.2425516013327664, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5253325498279017e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.971194259712155e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.2674647720692517e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.138013990770759e-08, + "chi": 2.6283382343468294e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3087802562022421, + "lensing_error": 1.5301233343963347, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5253325498279017e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.971194259712155e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.2674647720692517e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.138013990770759e-08, + "chi": 2.6283382343468294e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.26098353348917064, + "lensing_error": 0.26085396882808054, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.488474437700546e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.96521249058864e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.1660737380770532e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.0415040389600846e-08, + "chi": 2.467623534056735e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.292553511188635, + "lensing_error": 1.5132522984536079, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.488474437700546e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.96521249058864e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.1660737380770532e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.0415040389600846e-08, + "chi": 2.467623534056735e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2811861214146178, + "lensing_error": 0.2810539191831005, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4477838210970995e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.9605215150697826e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.083296040535713e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.271536799648073e-09, + "chi": 2.2770793374672856e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.274396016482801, + "lensing_error": 1.494667537838199, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4477838210970995e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.9605215150697826e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.083296040535713e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.271536799648073e-09, + "chi": 2.2770793374672856e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.27144898801253164, + "lensing_error": 0.2712906745564624, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4673956630820481e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.2684470885567736e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.061550282567814e-08, + "chi": 1.1077434925716504e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.282151534634057, + "lensing_error": 1.5038954012702108, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4673956630820481e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.2684470885567736e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.061550282567814e-08, + "chi": 1.1077434925716504e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.06942310875806022, + "lensing_error": 0.08057749825157252, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.874301829116511e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.367592291704556e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.0962240639701767e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.227339198336024e-08, + "chi": 1.1411207083887414e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.465758296971356, + "lensing_error": 1.689767597684015, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.874301829116511e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.367592291704556e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.0962240639701767e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.227339198336024e-08, + "chi": 1.1411207083887414e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.25242088887914793, + "lensing_error": 0.2523148459594045, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5057207078429533e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.048865693851958e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.224019222980724e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.385344941198415e-08, + "chi": 1.149638238348561e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3019025212779316, + "lensing_error": 1.5214487714617002, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5057207078429533e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.048865693851958e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.224019222980724e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.385344941198415e-08, + "chi": 1.149638238348561e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.45444676813361956, + "lensing_error": 0.45431434950960403, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.099973359317955e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.960513026714017e-09, + "aether_spatial": 3.796593058575482e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.568593845874518e-08, + "chi": 1.1577600279911e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1248436676095843, + "lensing_error": 1.3351676341691245, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.099973359317955e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.960513026714017e-09, + "aether_spatial": 3.796593058575482e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.568593845874518e-08, + "chi": 1.1577600279911e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.3570754341127586, + "lensing_error": 0.356681903243223, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3093071406177081e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.1394840331322986e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.754324862327442e-07, + "chi": 9.907205153441258e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2088609610346752, + "lensing_error": 1.4278957691187426, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3093071406177081e-05, + "lensing_sum": 4.960487608596251e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.1394840331322986e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.754324862327442e-07, + "chi": 9.907205153441258e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 1.6631833584319569, + "lensing_error": 1.6971679533829942, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 5.363994622002607e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.3417247843797647e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.038381698297943e-06, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.360456373746636e-07, + "chi": 1.0209543346106774e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.171401555150129, + "lensing_error": 3.3502181462700236, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 5.363994622002607e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.3417247843797647e-08, + "aether_spatial": 1.038381698297943e-06, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.360456373746636e-07, + "chi": 1.0209543346106774e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.16826302657500358, + "lensing_error": 0.18812515182618236, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.684240870621049e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.897654393097208e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.442692015254552e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.686052546718473e-07, + "chi": 1.0196146467994778e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3972276277750253, + "lensing_error": 1.6320172163310613, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.684240870621049e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.897654393097208e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.442692015254552e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.686052546718473e-07, + "chi": 1.0196146467994778e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 2.1870532353236367, + "lensing_error": 2.188856387402447, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 2.390878251077606e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.914868071396648e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.270045528884294e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.398299550497162e-07, + "chi": 1.0458280970434816e-07 + } + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.6788350386054649, + "lensing_error": 0.6783148261526724, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 2.390878251077606e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.914868071396648e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.270045528884294e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.398299550497162e-07, + "chi": 1.0458280970434816e-07 + } + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "mode_diagnostics": { + "initial_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 9.625784388558612e-05, + 0.08618326184768918 + ], + [ + 9.625784388558612e-05, + -0.08618326184768918 + ], + [ + -0.058830757630689456, + 10.491986085246275 + ], + [ + -0.058830757630689456, + -10.491986085246275 + ] + ], + "final_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 8.721521662666724e-06, + 0.025670147190798104 + ], + [ + 8.721521662666724e-06, + -0.025670147190798104 + ], + [ + -0.02046572748349714, + 5.388612659839058 + ], + [ + -0.02046572748349714, + -5.388612659839058 + ] + ], + "min_fast_slow_gap_over_H": 89.89388636285625, + "max_slow_rate_over_fast_frequency": 0.008214204146145475, + "max_frequency_adiabatic_ratio": 0.010827035400911934, + "max_fast_slow_eigenvector_mixing_over_gap": 0.11237844758874892, + "max_fast_from_slow_mixing_over_gap": 7.649686444683892e-05, + "max_slow_from_fast_mixing_over_gap": 0.11237844758874892, + "max_eigenvector_condition_number": 3347.140597268955, + "initial_retained_slow_basis_condition_number": 1678.4440945322576, + "initial_fast_spectral_coordinate_norm": 1.662712382259848e-19, + "slow_initial_state_per_unit_delta": [ + 1.0, + -0.0008038775626937655, + -7.103518318063276e-05, + -0.00027364415607450393 + ], + "compensated_leakage_vectors": [ + { + "phase": 0.0, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.005817408707450706, + 0.021556990337990894 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.07574092806688408, + 0.00030350926499057667 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.005817408707450697, + -0.021556990337990894 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "state": [ + 2.465190328815662e-32, + 0.0, + -0.07574092806688408, + -0.00030350926499057927 + ] + } + ] + }, + "direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i": 1.2315859053077527e-13, + "reference_scales": [ + 2.0142049991825473e-05, + 2.7988654470991203e-09 + ], + "rows": [ + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2680557383360454, + "lensing_error": 0.2679788751026277, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4742857909665158e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7909026143976484e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.802548377901828e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 2.9068696309165187e-09, + "chi": 9.399556486063731e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.204413785960097, + "lensing_error": 1.663078832745763, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4742857909665158e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7909026143976484e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.802548377901828e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 2.9068696309165187e-09, + "chi": 9.399556486063731e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2689117958645356, + "lensing_error": 0.2688337182005234, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.472561515613043e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7908871931600857e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.871666105119065e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.556534001426638e-09, + "chi": 1.558193914970469e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2035514193702272, + "lensing_error": 1.6616801670889225, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.472561515613043e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7908871931600857e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.871666105119065e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.556534001426638e-09, + "chi": 1.558193914970469e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24260162455217513, + "lensing_error": 0.2425234164485814, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5255555941997487e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.800962454666463e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.702440592557878e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.789061646160045e-09, + "chi": 1.656625496896456e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2201859185227484, + "lensing_error": 1.683516805454511, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5255555941997487e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.800962454666463e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.702440592557878e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.789061646160045e-09, + "chi": 1.656625496896456e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.26719968080755524, + "lensing_error": 0.267124032004732, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4760100663199885e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.794837497955462e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.733430650684591e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.030438937214788e-09, + "chi": 1.5680090237071626e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2052975100082741, + "lensing_error": 1.664482379402485, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4760100663199885e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.794837497955462e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.733430650684591e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 9.030438937214788e-09, + "chi": 1.5680090237071626e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2935098521199157, + "lensing_error": 0.2934343337566738, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.423015987733283e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7908993621133447e-09, + "aether_spatial": 7.90265616324578e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.169413806428237e-09, + "chi": 1.4677611124751685e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1887205569782127, + "lensing_error": 1.6427454885961292, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.423015987733283e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7908993621133447e-09, + "aether_spatial": 7.90265616324578e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.169413806428237e-09, + "chi": 1.4677611124751685e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.27661631362094724, + "lensing_error": 0.2765273060815846, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.457043037431788e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.493725650074188e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.80249671894381e-08, + "chi": 7.96455056146263e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1968163587879335, + "lensing_error": 1.6498075290667649, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.457043037431788e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.493725650074188e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.80249671894381e-08, + "chi": 7.96455056146263e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.08186961409331035, + "lensing_error": 0.1203994531458711, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.986983823298845e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.1321078707095453e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.7801470524462313e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.270298094528573e-08, + "chi": 8.131536005012313e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3676070231445434, + "lensing_error": 1.8701281402483194, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.986983823298845e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.1321078707095453e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.7801470524462313e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.270298094528573e-08, + "chi": 8.131536005012313e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.25949516305114356, + "lensing_error": 0.2594304441236708, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4915285445012437e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.8429754466504577e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.299057904363355e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.41271065616985e-08, + "chi": 8.205380129881235e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2138134594466299, + "lensing_error": 1.677208304419691, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4915285445012437e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.8429754466504577e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.299057904363355e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.41271065616985e-08, + "chi": 8.205380129881235e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.5225968761747484, + "lensing_error": 0.5225334616430896, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.0195809218593384e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7908933910553324e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.062594014998869e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.433773678510332e-08, + "chi": 8.284444638494737e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.0490435333101757, + "lensing_error": 1.4640630849852314, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.0195809218593384e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.7908933910553324e-09, + "aether_spatial": 2.062594014998869e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.433773678510332e-08, + "chi": 8.284444638494737e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.35366149118506357, + "lensing_error": 0.36182249463968724, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3054556957947373e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.5854610837189698e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.627092990695529e-07, + "chi": 7.301076734902847e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1451906215831615, + "lensing_error": 1.575077563027081, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3054556957947373e-05, + "lensing_sum": 2.790883449074074e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.5854610837189698e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.627092990695529e-07, + "chi": 7.301076734902847e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 2.2773556400509847, + "lensing_error": 2.304398199169391, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 6.60126611428981e-05, + "lensing_sum": 9.248088433073973e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.94485993306678e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.343862107320364e-07, + "chi": 7.503057623507777e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.102212021064928, + "lensing_error": 3.8188416770089737, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 6.60126611428981e-05, + "lensing_sum": 9.248088433073973e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.94485993306678e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.343862107320364e-07, + "chi": 7.503057623507777e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.18252809364904754, + "lensing_error": 0.19109480127767317, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.6772268975895452e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.3262389452627945e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.8267494654647416e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.588114384418133e-07, + "chi": 7.465495533989827e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3046750985859454, + "lensing_error": 1.8053843930242033, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.6772268975895452e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.3262389452627945e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.8267494654647416e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.588114384418133e-07, + "chi": 7.465495533989827e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 2.813467116723075, + "lensing_error": 2.8198871386625854, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 3.652694532356778e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.093705629556035e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.326713058943473e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.360209665718541e-07, + "chi": 7.645127989869042e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 2.0066445613676205, + "lensing_error": 2.006324498437747, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 3.652694532356778e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.093705629556035e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.326713058943473e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.360209665718541e-07, + "chi": 7.645127989869042e-08 + } + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "mode_diagnostics": { + "initial_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 7.949097133435931e-05, + 0.08789796210453217 + ], + [ + 7.949097133435931e-05, + -0.08789796210453217 + ], + [ + -0.05881399075813738, + 15.65507798675622 + ], + [ + -0.05881399075813738, + -15.65507798675622 + ] + ], + "final_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 6.269346664844055e-06, + 0.028061631557602086 + ], + [ + 6.269346664844055e-06, + -0.028061631557602086 + ], + [ + -0.020463275308500346, + 7.923825938789269 + ], + [ + -0.020463275308500346, + -7.923825938789269 + ] + ], + "min_fast_slow_gap_over_H": 134.48091535302294, + "max_slow_rate_over_fast_frequency": 0.0056146636971669715, + "max_frequency_adiabatic_ratio": 0.007332094926919238, + "max_fast_slow_eigenvector_mixing_over_gap": 0.04873413928118613, + "max_fast_from_slow_mixing_over_gap": 5.070306605034744e-05, + "max_slow_from_fast_mixing_over_gap": 0.04873413928118613, + "max_eigenvector_condition_number": 7436.724502833988, + "initial_retained_slow_basis_condition_number": 3703.718338985233, + "initial_fast_spectral_coordinate_norm": 5.548444972673678e-19, + "slow_initial_state_per_unit_delta": [ + 1.0, + -0.00035727891675278473, + -3.192224296819962e-05, + -0.00012297141022957878 + ], + "compensated_leakage_vectors": [ + { + "phase": 0.0, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.002567045416274756, + 0.009479616734084883 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.04966151313505416, + 8.776752323116512e-05 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.00256704541627475, + -0.009479616734084883 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.04966151313505416, + -8.77675232311663e-05 + ] + } + ] + }, + "direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i": 2.783350264677631e-13, + "reference_scales": [ + 2.0142593125752876e-05, + 1.244070021533114e-09 + ], + "rows": [ + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2726270325504013, + "lensing_error": 0.27259206563947513, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4651177734008757e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.240594532022091e-09, + "aether_spatial": 5.8621092407307276e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.5489086438948663e-09, + "chi": 4.2097928878486746e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1288052650958253, + "lensing_error": 1.7957216377566765, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4651177734008757e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.240594532022091e-09, + "aether_spatial": 5.8621092407307276e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.5489086438948663e-09, + "chi": 4.2097928878486746e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2734444186463192, + "lensing_error": 0.2734099459013817, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4634713458452035e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.240586038603585e-09, + "aether_spatial": 5.907858564981168e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.402751954367175e-09, + "chi": 8.499833830014192e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1278322215127214, + "lensing_error": 1.7950589006967161, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4634713458452035e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.240586038603585e-09, + "aether_spatial": 5.907858564981168e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.402751954367175e-09, + "chi": 8.499833830014192e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.23462114306829154, + "lensing_error": 0.23458501501977264, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5416714902229225e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2477920525384849e-09, + "aether_spatial": 6.747165910464366e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.583545425881444e-09, + "chi": 8.935325624349938e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1438078486408794, + "lensing_error": 1.8181566785407084, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.5416714902229225e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2477920525384849e-09, + "aether_spatial": 6.747165910464366e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.583545425881444e-09, + "chi": 8.935325624349938e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.27180964645448336, + "lensing_error": 0.2717741853775687, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.466764200956548e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2428433619855971e-09, + "aether_spatial": 5.816359916480286e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.05690649057664e-09, + "chi": 8.561529036378529e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.129781018129326, + "lensing_error": 1.7964023219751095, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.466764200956548e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2428433619855971e-09, + "aether_spatial": 5.816359916480286e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.05690649057664e-09, + "chi": 8.561529036378529e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.31063292203251114, + "lensing_error": 0.31059911625917763, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3885640565788289e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2405912464053733e-09, + "aether_spatial": 4.977052570997089e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.483748020781853e-09, + "chi": 8.158375610325379e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1139396172432334, + "lensing_error": 1.773290292415087, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3885640565788289e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2405912464053733e-09, + "aether_spatial": 4.977052570997089e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.483748020781853e-09, + "chi": 8.158375610325379e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.28080089350958054, + "lensing_error": 0.28077086825854, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4486534978441534e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "aether_spatial": 6.319602483235139e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.61474887365246e-08, + "chi": 5.113583374300791e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1196157770700774, + "lensing_error": 1.789479851239308, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4486534978441534e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "aether_spatial": 6.319602483235139e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.61474887365246e-08, + "chi": 5.113583374300791e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.15966243610679137, + "lensing_error": 0.2141132351846982, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 2.230654941621344e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.509145309392272e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.4712675938067113e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.344126426035001e-08, + "chi": 5.168669487848322e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2839637815181952, + "lensing_error": 2.0201808544782516, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 2.230654941621344e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.509145309392272e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.4712675938067113e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.344126426035001e-08, + "chi": 5.168669487848322e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2644531715912221, + "lensing_error": 0.2644132630204104, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.482009607035058e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2645856632944467e-09, + "aether_spatial": 6.293842244200489e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.43963707793808e-08, + "chi": 5.222370418356128e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1386325175225769, + "lensing_error": 1.8040798544436083, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.482009607035058e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2645856632944467e-09, + "aether_spatial": 6.293842244200489e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.43963707793808e-08, + "chi": 5.222370418356128e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.6526859273714992, + "lensing_error": 0.6526625718365001, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.0063816883335767e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.240588494970944e-09, + "aether_spatial": 3.4450755568315326e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.369512170534428e-08, + "chi": 5.285373743187413e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.9838127878442624, + "lensing_error": 1.5714278428057118, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.0063816883335767e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.240588494970944e-09, + "aether_spatial": 3.4450755568315326e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.369512170534428e-08, + "chi": 5.285373743187413e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.3664108980205351, + "lensing_error": 0.3712643100401308, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3004750178336535e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.0477862654457696e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.53594856558099e-07, + "chi": 4.8176954766086793e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.081243617648337, + "lensing_error": 1.737968898465537, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.3004750178336535e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.2405860310928212e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.0477862654457696e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.53594856558099e-07, + "chi": 4.8176954766086793e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 3.527961915660579, + "lensing_error": 3.539396526362494, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 9.120489455605559e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.647204172893392e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.534338968160421e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.355550011059743e-07, + "chi": 4.934229070537217e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 4.423144396827935, + "lensing_error": 4.423013321155493, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 9.120489455605559e-05, + "lensing_sum": 5.647204172893392e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.534338968160421e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.355550011059743e-07, + "chi": 4.934229070537217e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.19088842295860903, + "lensing_error": 0.19401791053022419, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.6718550529693042e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.4821054887004998e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.2208678815897368e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.518437386009554e-07, + "chi": 4.891038003341392e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2277992702058707, + "lensing_error": 1.9367481956657198, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.6718550529693042e-05, + "lensing_sum": 1.4821054887004998e-09, + "aether_spatial": 1.2208678815897368e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.518437386009554e-07, + "chi": 4.891038003341392e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 4.073215980761382, + "lensing_error": 4.076518696363319, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 6.190253908803808e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.827417711100537e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.426470088939065e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.358088585509686e-07, + "chi": 4.9980735564736163e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.197230932834264, + "lensing_error": 3.5079377786044654, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 6.190253908803808e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.827417711100537e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.426470088939065e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.358088585509686e-07, + "chi": 4.9980735564736163e-08 + } + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "mode_diagnostics": { + "initial_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 7.349527804354895e-05, + 0.08849886989701668 + ], + [ + 7.349527804354895e-05, + -0.08849886989701668 + ], + [ + -0.058807995064846894, + 20.834619228531693 + ], + [ + -0.058807995064846894, + -20.834619228531693 + ] + ], + "final_eigenvalues": [ + [ + 5.338730046035026e-06, + 0.02889520500625476 + ], + [ + 5.338730046035026e-06, + -0.02889520500625476 + ], + [ + -0.020462344691880043, + 10.489850804028292 + ], + [ + -0.020462344691880043, + -10.489850804028292 + ] + ], + "min_fast_slow_gap_over_H": 179.2199051455021, + "max_slow_rate_over_fast_frequency": 0.0042476850401697, + "max_frequency_adiabatic_ratio": 0.0055295497102073494, + "max_fast_slow_eigenvector_mixing_over_gap": 0.02700050021133804, + "max_fast_from_slow_mixing_over_gap": 3.7877399007937005e-05, + "max_slow_from_fast_mixing_over_gap": 0.02700050021133804, + "max_eigenvector_condition_number": 13163.773057373624, + "initial_retained_slow_basis_condition_number": 6540.230635614686, + "initial_fast_spectral_coordinate_norm": 2.456498907010672e-19, + "slow_initial_state_per_unit_delta": [ + 0.9999999999999999, + -0.00020096939067344144, + -1.8026391248794667e-05, + -6.944145156214542e-05 + ], + "compensated_leakage_vectors": [ + { + "phase": 0.0, + "state": [ + 1.1102230246251565e-16, + 5.421010862427522e-20, + 0.0014403005038075372, + 0.0053123488167144605 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.037028698637692176, + 3.6709623251754964e-05 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "state": [ + -1.1102230246251565e-16, + 0.0, + -0.0014403005038075326, + -0.0053123488167144605 + ] + }, + { + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "state": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + -0.037028698637692176, + -3.670962325175562e-05 + ] + } + ] + }, + "direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i": 2.2463313761184042e-13, + "reference_scales": [ + 2.0142783166044648e-05, + 6.998149459805356e-10 + ], + "rows": [ + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.27427088124074445, + "lensing_error": 0.27425108818136235, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.461820427645235e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978730705659738e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.3949154851021276e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.0122685825284746e-09, + "chi": 2.3755792963213276e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2911048846279887, + "lensing_error": 1.8540908924144577, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.461820427645235e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978730705659738e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.3949154851021276e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 1.0122685825284746e-09, + "chi": 2.3755792963213276e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2751348148796979, + "lensing_error": 0.2751159840395085, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.460080224849306e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978677155671296e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.429140447568841e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.993424219762179e-09, + "chi": 5.671156061716349e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2902650876491708, + "lensing_error": 1.853510723517193, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.460080224849306e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978677155671296e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.429140447568841e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.993424219762179e-09, + "chi": 5.671156061716349e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2236934138770985, + "lensing_error": 0.22367321898702855, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.563697523464597e-05, + "lensing_sum": 7.040959574530117e-10, + "aether_spatial": 5.274805353720556e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.135328534628313e-09, + "chi": 5.910399988406311e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3374213867063132, + "lensing_error": 1.8783888912608337, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.563697523464597e-05, + "lensing_sum": 7.040959574530117e-10, + "aether_spatial": 5.274805353720556e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 8.135328534628313e-09, + "chi": 5.910399988406311e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.27340694760179113, + "lensing_error": 0.27338619232321637, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4635606304411638e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.992360951943307e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.360690522635414e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.734166585249982e-09, + "chi": 5.713984452578904e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2919586461076529, + "lensing_error": 1.8546879219926742, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4635606304411638e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.992360951943307e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.360690522635414e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.734166585249982e-09, + "chi": 5.713984452578904e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.3248483486043904, + "lensing_error": 0.3248289573756961, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.359943331825873e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978699448102397e-10, + "aether_spatial": 3.51678572918024e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.300860280046643e-09, + "chi": 5.505508988648685e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.244818632838818, + "lensing_error": 1.8297928935680812, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.359943331825873e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978699448102397e-10, + "aether_spatial": 3.51678572918024e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.300860280046643e-09, + "chi": 5.505508988648685e-10 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.28291021763027774, + "lensing_error": 0.28290004676282177, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4444183996859462e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978677155671296e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.737165109769265e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.548488649269563e-08, + "chi": 3.77214467541895e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.283086299621619, + "lensing_error": 1.848733148584426, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4444183996859462e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978677155671296e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.737165109769265e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.548488649269563e-08, + "chi": 3.77214467541895e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.25449956637600807, + "lensing_error": 0.3182692800036282, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 2.4805913858388543e-05, + "lensing_sum": 9.219073158294425e-10, + "aether_spatial": 1.3193814171286408e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.372323682031603e-08, + "chi": 3.789334596782152e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.754907143935263, + "lensing_error": 2.0971396420011077, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 2.4805913858388543e-05, + "lensing_sum": 9.219073158294425e-10, + "aether_spatial": 1.3193814171286408e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.372323682031603e-08, + "chi": 3.789334596782152e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2656315448512112, + "lensing_error": 0.2656021295999031, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4805764256312405e-05, + "lensing_sum": 7.115508826728256e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.7594697700489785e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.449614078048983e-08, + "chi": 3.83546074262731e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.30031377932393, + "lensing_error": 1.8618034167911097, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.4805764256312405e-05, + "lensing_sum": 7.115508826728256e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.7594697700489785e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.449614078048983e-08, + "chi": 3.83546074262731e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.7800455548772037, + "lensing_error": 0.7800297801247005, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.0041093191434805e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978686448222465e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.701367009829047e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.359330336216157e-08, + "chi": 3.883133776257165e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.9494514156418431, + "lensing_error": 1.6112811342018543, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.0041093191434805e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978686448222465e-10, + "aether_spatial": 4.701367009829047e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.359330336216157e-08, + "chi": 3.883133776257165e-09 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.37256194169043944, + "lensing_error": 0.3753277833227003, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.295875528063681e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978677155671296e-10, + "aether_spatial": 7.834852305809575e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.503995092220304e-07, + "chi": 3.607061803378365e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2147375309049206, + "lensing_error": 1.805928053492779, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.295875528063681e-05, + "lensing_sum": 6.978677155671296e-10, + "aether_spatial": 7.834852305809575e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.503995092220304e-07, + "chi": 3.607061803378365e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 4.7834758551238465, + "lensing_error": 4.785514717739097, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 0.00011649530009581429, + "lensing_sum": 4.048743181850336e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.333266510145783e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.366476676414654e-07, + "chi": 3.684843472520423e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 6.167844034325502, + "lensing_error": 6.387955267724192, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 0.00011649530009581429, + "lensing_sum": 4.048743181850336e-09, + "aether_spatial": 9.333266510145783e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.366476676414654e-07, + "chi": 3.684843472520423e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.18787751734541158, + "lensing_error": 0.19543700572399794, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.6700812070109236e-05, + "lensing_sum": 8.346987574577751e-10, + "aether_spatial": 9.189488779875603e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.494107635098243e-07, + "chi": 3.6485888832418086e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3927648881279482, + "lensing_error": 2.0036767029868265, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 1.6700812070109236e-05, + "lensing_sum": 8.346987574577751e-10, + "aether_spatial": 9.189488779875603e-08, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.494107635098243e-07, + "chi": 3.6485888832418086e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 5.332017617605336, + "lensing_error": 5.332263145190226, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 8.72588915429096e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.0317837811524933e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.490685660021925e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.365177341833109e-07, + "chi": 3.7208962550180127e-08 + } + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.947793146683812, + "lensing_error": 4.103058668913917, + "passes_1_percent": false, + "max_amplitudes": { + "density_contrast": 8.72588915429096e-05, + "lensing_sum": 3.0317837811524933e-09, + "aether_spatial": 8.490685660021925e-07, + "delta_Q_over_Q": 7.365177341833109e-07, + "chi": 3.7208962550180127e-08 + } + } + ] + } + ], + "refinement": { + "k": 12.0, + "grid_points": 4001, + "rtol": 1e-12, + "max_error_fraction_change": 4.167191673953852e-06, + "direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i": 1.2654672231979247e-13 + } +} diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..64c896a --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +# Independent review of the slow-subspace continuation + +**Disposition: no blocking scientific or implementation issue found in the frozen checkpoint.** The original five-field equations reproduce the submitted four-state evolution for all 65 preparations. Both specified pressure closures fail the declared 1% criterion throughout this ensemble. The result concerns the declared action, background, initial-state prescription and finite interval. + +Reviewed on 12 November 2026 by gpt-forge, using a separate gpt-6-astra review agent from the continuation's author. This reviewer authored the earlier field-response implementation, which had already passed a separate ADM derivation review. This review is independent of the new preparation and closure calculation. It is not a second independent derivation of the underlying action. + +The frozen `probe.py` SHA256 is `af9d4443c45298d723384ad0283bb8a635944fe347fd2067e3f4699ea94b2151`. The accompanying protocol, results and evidence hashes are recorded in [evidence.json](evidence.json). The source checkpoint remained unchanged during review. + +## Background normalization and physical evolution + +The reviewed coordinates are `delta=D/R` and `theta=m/W`, where `W=Q K'`. The exact background identities are + +```text +Rdot = -3 H W, +Wdot = -3 H W (1+c_a^2), +c_a^2 = K'/(4 Q). +``` + +Applying the quotient rule to the original density and momentum equations gives + +```text +deltadot = 3 H (w delta-p/R) + 3(W/R) Phidot - r(W/R) theta, +thetadot = 3 H c_a^2 theta + p/W + Phi. +``` + +Thus the time-dependent normalization terms in the submitted generator are required and have the stated signs. [check.py](check.py) constructs this transformation symbolically. Its matrix agrees with the submitted generator to a maximum absolute discrepancy of 1.14e-13 over the checked scales and wave numbers. + +The numerical comparator integrates the original five-field equations for `(v,alpha,E,Phi,gamma)`. It reconstructs the retained observables after integration and does not eliminate the density constraint during that evolution. Both approximate pressure laws are separately integrated in the unnormalized `(D,m)` variables. The comparison covers every submitted preparation on the same 2001-point scale-factor grid. + +The largest full-state discrepancy, divided by the initial density contrast, is 1.27e-12. The largest independent constraint residual, divided by the initial scaled density amplitude, is 8.04e-13. The largest discrepancy in any reported closure-error fraction is 1.86e-11. Every one of the 130 preparation/closure comparisons independently fails 1%. + +## Initial-state and mixing checks + +Independent diagonalization confirms two complex conjugate pairs at the initial time for all five wave numbers. The retained failed real-growing-mode protocol is consistent with that spectrum. The replacement protocol explicitly selects a real two-dimensional slow spectral subspace and makes no claim to identify a physical growing solution. + +The selected baseline has fast spectral-coordinate norm below 1.66e-16 per unit initial density contrast in an independently computed eigenbasis. All compensating leakage states preserve the initial density and momentum. The maximum mismatch is 2.65e-23. The initial metric is then also the same by the constraint. + +The compensation adds a slow contribution as declared. The complete added state is not called a pure fast eigenmode. The leakage parameter specifies a fast-component density envelope before compensation and does not measure energy. + +The eigenvector-motion diagnostic was checked without finite differences of eigenvectors. Differentiating `M v_j=lambda_j v_j` gives, for unequal eigenvalues, + +```text +(V^-1 Vdot)_ij = (V^-1 Mdot V)_ij / (lambda_j-lambda_i). +``` + +An analytic derivative of the independently transformed generator reproduces the reported mixing directions and magnitudes. The largest slow-to-fast ratio is 0.000152426. The largest fast-to-slow ratio is 0.740564. The finite-difference estimates are 0.000152418 and 0.740570. + +The large reverse ratio does not support attributing the baseline closure error to substantial generation of fast coordinates by the slow basis. + +These ratios use the declared coordinate units and unit Euclidean eigenvector normalization. A time-dependent change of state variables changes the frozen generator. Neither its instantaneous slow subspace nor these mixing ratios define a unique coordinate-independent invariant manifold. The submitted report states this limit. + +## Interpretation and stopping point + +The baseline zero-pressure errors of 24.6% to 27.4% are supported. They show that choosing this initial slow spectral subspace does not make the two tested closures accurate on this interval. Small amplitudes and the independent constraint check support interpreting the reported differences within linear theory. + +This is a negative result for two specified closure laws and a reproducible preparation ensemble. It does not exclude a different invariant slow construction, another background or an observationally motivated initial spectrum. It adds no general cosmological failure claim and supplies no reason to launch nonlinear collapse simulations. + +The finite calculation and its review are complete. Further physical claims require a new stated input. + +Run `python3 independent-review/check.py` from the slow-mode directory with the checkpoint's NumPy, SciPy and SymPy dependencies. The script writes only its own `independent-review/evidence.json` and verifies the author's hashes before and after the calculation. diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/check.py b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/check.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0f52767 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/check.py @@ -0,0 +1,191 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Independent review of the frozen slow-subspace preparation calculation. + +The comparator uses the separately ADM-reviewed five-field evolution, not the +new four-state right-hand side. Author modules are imported without their mains. +Only this review directory receives output. +""" +from pathlib import Path +import hashlib, importlib.util, json +import numpy as np +import sympy as sp +from scipy.integrate import solve_ivp + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +SOURCE = HERE.parent +BASE = SOURCE.parent / 'public-checkpoint' +if not BASE.is_dir(): + BASE = SOURCE.parent + +def digest(path): + return hashlib.sha256(path.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + +manifest = json.loads((SOURCE / 'checkpoint.json').read_text()) +for item in manifest['files']: + assert digest(SOURCE / item['path']) == item['sha256'], item['path'] +assert digest(BASE / 'response.py') == 'e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef' + +def module(name, path): + spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(name, path) + result = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec) + spec.loader.exec_module(result) + return result + +author = module('slow_author', SOURCE / 'probe.py') +original = module('original_fields', BASE / 'response.py') +record = json.loads((SOURCE / 'evidence.json').read_text()) + +# Transform the audited unnormalized conservation equations analytically. +# Rdot=-3HW; Wdot=-3HW(1+c_a^2). These background terms cannot be omitted. +a, k = sp.symbols('a k', positive=True) +d, th, ch, z = sp.symbols('delta theta chi Z', real=True) +q = sp.Rational(1, 100) / a**3 +Q, Kp, R, W = 1+q, 4*q, 4*q+2*q*q, (1+q)*4*q +H = sp.sqrt(R/3) +r, ca = k*k/a**2, Kp/(4*Q) +D, m = R*d, W*th +Phi = -(D+3*H*m)/(2*r) +gamma = (D+r*z)/(4*Q) +p = Kp*gamma +Pd = -H*Phi+m/2 +Dd = -3*H*(D+p)+3*W*Pd-r*m +md = -3*H*m+p+W*Phi +Qd = sp.diff(Q, a)*a*H +transformed = sp.Matrix([ + (Dd-sp.diff(R, a)*a*H*d)/R, + (md-sp.diff(W, a)*a*H*th)/W, + gamma+Q*z+(Qd/Q-Q)*ch-Qd*th, + (-H+Q)*z+(Kp-3*Q)*ch, +]) +M = transformed.jacobian([d, th, ch, z]) +Mfun = sp.lambdify((a, k), M, 'numpy') +Mdafun = sp.lambdify((a, k), M.diff(a), 'numpy') +assert sp.simplify(sp.diff(R, a)*a*H+3*H*W) == 0 +assert sp.simplify(sp.diff(W, a)*a*H+3*H*W*(1+ca)) == 0 + +def to_fields(scale, state, kval): + qq, kp, _, rr, ww, hh = original.bg(scale, .01) + radial = (kval/scale)**2 + delta, theta, chi, Z = state + density, momentum = rr*delta, ww*theta + phi = -(density+3*hh*momentum)/(2*radial) + v = momentum/kp + return np.array([v, (chi-v)/qq, Z-chi, phi, + (density+radial*Z)/(4*qq)]) + +def from_fields(grid, fields, kval): + qq, kp, _, rr, ww, hh = original.bg(grid, .01) + v, al, E, phi, gamma = fields.T + chi = v+qq*al + Z = E+chi + density = 4*qq*gamma-(kval/grid)**2*Z + return np.column_stack([density/rr, kp*v/ww, chi, Z]) + +def independent_field_fundamental(grid, kval): + initial = np.column_stack([to_fields(1., np.eye(4)[:,i], kval) for i in range(4)]) + def derivative(scale, flat): + field_matrix = flat.reshape(5, 4) + columns = [original.rhs_fields(0., np.r_[scale, field_matrix[:,j]], kval, .01)[1:] + for j in range(4)] + return (np.column_stack(columns)/(scale*original.bg(scale, .01)[-1])).ravel() + solution = solve_ivp(derivative, (1., 2.), initial.ravel(), t_eval=grid, + method='DOP853', rtol=2e-12, atol=1e-17) + assert solution.success + return solution.y.T.reshape(len(grid), 5, 4) + +def independent_closure(grid, kval, initial_retained, closure): + _, _, _, rr, ww, _ = original.bg(1., .01) + def derivative(scale, retained): + qq, kp, _, rr, ww, hh = original.bg(scale, .01) + D, m = retained + radial = (kval/scale)**2 + phi = -(D+3*hh*m)/(2*radial) + pressure = 0. if closure == 'zero' else kp/(4*qq)*D + return np.array([-3*hh*(D+pressure)+3*ww*(-hh*phi+m/2)-radial*m, + -3*hh*m+pressure+ww*phi])/(scale*hh) + solution = solve_ivp(derivative, (1., 2.), initial_retained*np.array([rr, ww]), + t_eval=grid, method='DOP853', rtol=2e-12, atol=1e-22) + assert solution.success + _, _, _, rr, ww, hh = original.bg(grid, .01) + D, m = solution.y + return np.array([D/rr, -(D+3*hh*m)/(kval/grid)**2]) + +output = {'reviewed_files': manifest['files'], 'base_response_sha256': digest(BASE/'response.py'), + 'method': 'Exact background-normalization transform; independently differentiate the generator; integrate the prior ADM-reviewed five-field equations and unnormalized conservation closures.', + 'points': []} +grid = np.linspace(1., 2., 2001) +for point in record['points']: + kval = point['k'] + author.KVAL = kval + matrix_error = max(np.max(abs(author.matrix(scale)-Mfun(scale, kval))) + for scale in np.linspace(1., 2., 31)) + assert matrix_error < 1e-9 + S0, contamination, diagnostics = author.modes() + eig, V = np.linalg.eig(Mfun(1., kval)) + slow_indices = np.argsort(abs(eig.imag))[:2] + fast_indices = np.argsort(abs(eig.imag))[2:] + coordinates = np.linalg.solve(V, S0) + initial_fast_norm = float(np.linalg.norm(coordinates[fast_indices])) + assert initial_fast_norm < 1e-10 + assert np.allclose(S0[:2], [1., -original.bg(1., .01)[-1]/kval**2], rtol=1e-12) + assert sum(eig.imag > 1e-8) == 2 + + # Off-diagonal eigenvector motion follows by differentiating M v_j=lambda_j v_j. + # No finite difference of eigenvectors or phase tracking is needed here. + mix_to_fast, mix_to_slow = [], [] + for scale in np.linspace(1., 2., 201): + ee, VV = np.linalg.eig(Mfun(scale, kval)) + ss = np.argsort(abs(ee.imag))[:2] + ff = np.argsort(abs(ee.imag))[2:] + Mdot = Mdafun(scale, kval)*scale*original.bg(scale, .01)[-1] + transformed_Mdot = np.linalg.solve(VV, Mdot@VV) + mix_to_fast.append(max(abs(transformed_Mdot[i,j])/abs(ee[j]-ee[i])**2 for i in ff for j in ss)) + mix_to_slow.append(max(abs(transformed_Mdot[i,j])/abs(ee[j]-ee[i])**2 for i in ss for j in ff)) + + field_fund = independent_field_fundamental(grid, kval) + new_fund = author.fundamental(grid, tol=2e-12) + initial = 1e-5*S0 + reference = {c: independent_closure(grid, kval, initial[:2], c) for c in ('zero', 'adiabatic')} + scales = np.max(abs(reference['zero']), axis=1) + prepared = [(0., 0., initial)] + for eta in (.001, .01, .1): + prepared.extend((eta, phase, initial+1e-5*eta*w) for phase, w in contamination) + state_errors, constraint_errors, error_differences, row_results = [], [], [], [] + retained_mismatch = 0. + qq, kp, _, rr, ww, hh = original.bg(grid, .01) + for eta, phase, x0 in prepared: + retained_mismatch = max(retained_mismatch, float(np.max(abs(x0[:2]-initial[:2])))) + field_values = np.einsum('tij,j->ti', field_fund, x0) + state_values = from_fields(grid, field_values, kval) + submitted_values = np.einsum('tij,j->ti', new_fund, x0) + state_errors.append(float(np.max(abs(state_values-submitted_values))/1e-5)) + phi = field_values[:,3] + constraint = rr*state_values[:,0]+2*(kval/grid)**2*phi+3*hh*ww*state_values[:,1] + constraint_errors.append(float(np.max(abs(constraint))/(rr[0]*1e-5))) + observables = np.array([state_values[:,0], 2*phi]) + for closure, prediction in reference.items(): + errors = np.max(abs(observables-prediction), axis=1)/scales + submitted_row = next(row for row in point['rows'] if row['eta']==eta and row['phase']==phase and row['closure']==closure) + error_differences.extend([abs(errors[0]-submitted_row['density_error']), abs(errors[1]-submitted_row['lensing_error'])]) + assert max(errors) > .01 + row_results.append({'eta': eta, 'phase': phase, 'closure': closure, + 'density_error': float(errors[0]), 'lensing_error': float(errors[1])}) + assert max(state_errors) < 1e-7 + assert max(constraint_errors) < 1e-8 + assert max(error_differences) < 1e-7 + output['points'].append({'k': kval, 'generator_max_absolute_error': matrix_error, + 'initial_fast_coordinate_norm_independent_basis': initial_fast_norm, + 'max_retained_initial_mismatch': retained_mismatch, + 'exact_derivative_fast_from_slow_ratio': float(max(mix_to_fast)), + 'exact_derivative_slow_from_fast_ratio': float(max(mix_to_slow)), + 'finite_difference_fast_from_slow_ratio': diagnostics['max_fast_from_slow_mixing_over_gap'], + 'finite_difference_slow_from_fast_ratio': diagnostics['max_slow_from_fast_mixing_over_gap'], + 'five_field_state_discrepancy_per_delta_i': max(state_errors), + 'five_field_constraint_residual_per_initial_density': max(constraint_errors), + 'max_error_fraction_discrepancy': float(max(error_differences)), 'rows': row_results}) +for item in manifest['files']: + assert digest(SOURCE / item['path']) == item['sha256'] +(HERE/'evidence.json').write_text(json.dumps(output, indent=2)+'\n') +print(json.dumps({key: value for key, value in output.items() if key!='points'}, indent=2)) +for point in output['points']: + print(json.dumps({key: value for key,value in point.items() if key!='rows'}, indent=2)) diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/checkpoint.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/checkpoint.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a1a729a --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/checkpoint.json @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +{ + "status": "complete; no blocking issue", + "files": [ + { + "path": "REVIEW.md", + "sha256": "a6fcac897f513934a9f7d8ed837f4d7a35842a607adc06368b15fbfef4297b2f" + }, + { + "path": "check.py", + "sha256": "108ab8738016ea097ac7a190a1ec501b50b1ddc261c7b7530b221607aba62b03" + }, + { + "path": "evidence.json", + "sha256": "e86be2518a2b7fa9c3debbc4536feb7008299efea05a83ce3537e45c6a6a9def" + } + ] +} diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/evidence.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/evidence.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1df3ac8 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/independent-review/evidence.json @@ -0,0 +1,1021 @@ +{ + "reviewed_files": [ + { + "path": "PROTOCOL.md", + "sha256": "efe19e6cb78f46af8d612b4ab0188981f711604b6aa4755cf287e62a540d1fc7" + }, + { + "path": "GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md", + "sha256": "e18a17694fd46609e2574f680d6fd5a0d870295cf3f030b2a1da3d5d0187c9a9" + }, + { + "path": "RESULTS.md", + "sha256": "4db8ba576047fcc296e7f99556ba2ab31121fb93d31ac7d9cd81c30296a2883e" + }, + { + "path": "probe.py", + "sha256": "af9d4443c45298d723384ad0283bb8a635944fe347fd2067e3f4699ea94b2151" + }, + { + "path": "evidence.json", + "sha256": "cc1e24085ca282198798514f01946c338b3df4f715ff7a694b0d8402f567d054" + }, + { + "path": "selection_failure.py", + "sha256": "368230772939461a5a10c6ff0552c5aeb6375068660f45efd8a8403992ebd605" + }, + { + "path": "selection-failure.json", + "sha256": "71a3187c110e66993bd3fd035b0f4abd041146c5ca74e983cbed2aa29ea46098" + } + ], + "base_response_sha256": "e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef", + "method": "Exact background-normalization transform; independently differentiate the generator; integrate the prior ADM-reviewed five-field equations and unnormalized conservation closures.", + "points": [ + { + "k": 6.0, + "generator_max_absolute_error": 7.105427357601002e-15, + "initial_fast_coordinate_norm_independent_basis": 1.6180349234272426e-16, + "max_retained_initial_mismatch": 2.6469779601696886e-23, + "exact_derivative_fast_from_slow_ratio": 0.00015242587921505875, + "exact_derivative_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.7405636658656684, + "finite_difference_fast_from_slow_ratio": 0.00015241770357156506, + "finite_difference_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.7405699277716458, + "five_field_state_discrepancy_per_delta_i": 1.2610626518722021e-12, + "five_field_constraint_residual_per_initial_density": 8.033127480870853e-13, + "max_error_fraction_discrepancy": 9.141354340158614e-12, + "rows": [ + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24603288376031418, + "lensing_error": 0.24576009132532387 + }, + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1758409572598947, + "lensing_error": 1.1756800774506033 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24715508087046764, + "lensing_error": 0.24688033461344402 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1747187601497413, + "lensing_error": 1.174559834162483 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2327889833529661, + "lensing_error": 0.23252072808187668 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1890848576672428, + "lensing_error": 1.1889194406940504 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24491068665016044, + "lensing_error": 0.24463984803720368 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1769631543700485, + "lensing_error": 1.1768003207387234 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.259276784167663, + "lensing_error": 0.25899945456877105 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1625970568525459, + "lensing_error": 1.162440714207156 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2572548548618497, + "lensing_error": 0.25696252420652593 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1646189861583591, + "lensing_error": 1.1644776445694012 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.11359387968683063, + "lensing_error": 0.11336645889085183 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3082799613333784, + "lensing_error": 1.3080737098850752 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2348109126587791, + "lensing_error": 0.23455765844412152 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1870629283614298, + "lensing_error": 1.1868825103318057 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.37847188783379726, + "lensing_error": 0.3781537237597957 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.0434019531864116, + "lensing_error": 1.0432864450161314 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.35825259477566895, + "lensing_error": 0.35778442013734557 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.06362124624454, + "lensing_error": 1.0699381889509116 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 1.078357156974518, + "lensing_error": 1.1070645296053074 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 2.5002309979947266, + "lensing_error": 2.4996164017953233 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.13381317274495974, + "lensing_error": 0.18234154917374792 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2880606682752491, + "lensing_error": 1.2877044062626253 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 1.57042292449515, + "lensing_error": 1.5696964156700437 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.2646373613273004, + "lensing_error": 0.42481816955452867 + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "generator_max_absolute_error": 2.842170943040401e-14, + "initial_fast_coordinate_norm_independent_basis": 1.1249075218067494e-16, + "max_retained_initial_mismatch": 0.0, + "exact_derivative_fast_from_slow_ratio": 0.00010225855631209479, + "exact_derivative_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.2094851712728349, + "finite_difference_fast_from_slow_ratio": 0.00010225304315407084, + "finite_difference_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.20948451292702086, + "five_field_state_discrepancy_per_delta_i": 9.317362419797304e-13, + "five_field_constraint_residual_per_initial_density": 5.062417367037064e-13, + "max_error_fraction_discrepancy": 8.274464446955676e-12, + "rows": [ + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.26193493844585636, + "lensing_error": 0.2618027602579587 + }, + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2915393264924553, + "lensing_error": 1.512394690904696 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2628863434025832, + "lensing_error": 0.2627515516878684 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2905353630729088, + "lensing_error": 1.511539775535463 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24268375547709325, + "lensing_error": 0.24255160133280734 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.308780256201869, + "lensing_error": 1.5301233344013097 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2609835334891292, + "lensing_error": 0.260853968828049 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2925535111890165, + "lensing_error": 1.5132522984594763 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.28118612141462, + "lensing_error": 0.28105391918311 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2743960164839332, + "lensing_error": 1.4946675378438632 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.27144898801312684, + "lensing_error": 0.2712906745570561 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2821515346347152, + "lensing_error": 1.5038954012736259 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.06942310875822261, + "lensing_error": 0.08057749825065841 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.4657582969714011, + "lensing_error": 1.6897675976853876 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2524208888785855, + "lensing_error": 0.2523148459588613 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.301902521279345, + "lensing_error": 1.5214487714639469 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.4544467681334899, + "lensing_error": 0.4543143495094717 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.124843667609085, + "lensing_error": 1.335167634176529 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.35707543411856424, + "lensing_error": 0.3566819032489328 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2088609610360876, + "lensing_error": 1.4278957691229042 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 1.663183358430482, + "lensing_error": 1.6971679533843116 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.171401555149449, + "lensing_error": 3.3502181462739764 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.1682630265701214, + "lensing_error": 0.18812515183445683 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3972276277767572, + "lensing_error": 1.6320172163352908 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 2.187053235322194, + "lensing_error": 2.1888563873981375 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.6788350386032266, + "lensing_error": 0.6783148261503276 + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "generator_max_absolute_error": 2.842170943040401e-14, + "initial_fast_coordinate_norm_independent_basis": 1.6587695742423072e-16, + "max_retained_initial_mismatch": 0.0, + "exact_derivative_fast_from_slow_ratio": 7.650099167627567e-05, + "exact_derivative_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.11237902114419132, + "finite_difference_fast_from_slow_ratio": 7.649686444683892e-05, + "finite_difference_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.11237844758874892, + "five_field_state_discrepancy_per_delta_i": 7.386127300057498e-13, + "five_field_constraint_residual_per_initial_density": 4.175348466602555e-13, + "max_error_fraction_discrepancy": 1.0799305893982591e-11, + "rows": [ + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2680557383360843, + "lensing_error": 0.26797887510265633 + }, + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2044137859601032, + "lensing_error": 1.6630788327445525 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.26891179586462177, + "lensing_error": 0.2688337182005978 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2035514193700878, + "lensing_error": 1.661680167087683 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.24260162455228484, + "lensing_error": 0.24252341644868192 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2201859185229635, + "lensing_error": 1.6835168054534189 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2671996808075472, + "lensing_error": 0.2671240320047147 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2052975100084506, + "lensing_error": 1.6644823794011923 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2935098521198832, + "lensing_error": 0.29343433375663075 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1887205569780095, + "lensing_error": 1.6427454885937496 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2766163136214564, + "lensing_error": 0.276527306082072 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1968163587863108, + "lensing_error": 1.6498075290670202 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.08186961409435368, + "lensing_error": 0.12039945314729024 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3676070231440431, + "lensing_error": 1.870128140247975 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.25949516305071224, + "lensing_error": 0.25943044412324073 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2138134594464642, + "lensing_error": 1.6772083044172594 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.5225968761740768, + "lensing_error": 0.5225334616424008 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.0490435333096735, + "lensing_error": 1.464063084986502 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.35366149118980317, + "lensing_error": 0.36182249463842925 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1451906215774796, + "lensing_error": 1.5750775630251341 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 2.2773556400438415, + "lensing_error": 2.3043981991691647 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.1022120210703465, + "lensing_error": 3.818841677011046 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.18252809364537959, + "lensing_error": 0.19109480128847248 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.304675098584173, + "lensing_error": 1.8053843930214097 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 2.813467116716012, + "lensing_error": 2.819887138657145 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 2.006644561359418, + "lensing_error": 2.0063244984294637 + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "generator_max_absolute_error": 1.1368683772161603e-13, + "initial_fast_coordinate_norm_independent_basis": 9.619377899302516e-17, + "max_retained_initial_mismatch": 0.0, + "exact_derivative_fast_from_slow_ratio": 5.070579637012163e-05, + "exact_derivative_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.048734389287901476, + "finite_difference_fast_from_slow_ratio": 5.070306605034744e-05, + "finite_difference_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.04873413928118613, + "five_field_state_discrepancy_per_delta_i": 7.379351036479464e-13, + "five_field_constraint_residual_per_initial_density": 3.156625129494726e-13, + "max_error_fraction_discrepancy": 1.2394973936125098e-11, + "rows": [ + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2726270325504532, + "lensing_error": 0.27259206563950755 + }, + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1288052650949119, + "lensing_error": 1.7957216377543468 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.27344441864631924, + "lensing_error": 0.27340994590136103 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1278322215117373, + "lensing_error": 1.7950589006942694 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2346211430684669, + "lensing_error": 0.23458501501992812 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1438078486393857, + "lensing_error": 1.818156678538293 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2718096464545879, + "lensing_error": 0.2717741853776542 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1297810181283368, + "lensing_error": 1.796402321972897 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.31063292203243975, + "lensing_error": 0.31059911625908715 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1139396172424043, + "lensing_error": 1.7732902924128258 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2808008935091105, + "lensing_error": 0.28077086825804165 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1196157770676585, + "lensing_error": 1.7894798512361443 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.15966243610645464, + "lensing_error": 0.2141132351854046 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2839637815168359, + "lensing_error": 2.0201808544753543 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2644531715917964, + "lensing_error": 0.26441326302097334 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.1386325175213396, + "lensing_error": 1.8040798544416872 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.6526859273703176, + "lensing_error": 0.6526625718353029 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.9838127878422913, + "lensing_error": 1.5714278428044863 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.3664108980197015, + "lensing_error": 0.37126431003780624 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.0812436176454838, + "lensing_error": 1.7379688984643535 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 3.527961915648184, + "lensing_error": 3.5393965263667844 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 4.423144396817431, + "lensing_error": 4.423013321145057 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.19088842296388334, + "lensing_error": 0.19401791052980652 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2277992702051799, + "lensing_error": 1.9367481956679058 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 4.073215980749097, + "lensing_error": 4.076518696359591 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.197230932832966, + "lensing_error": 3.507937778601228 + } + ] + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "generator_max_absolute_error": 1.1368683772161603e-13, + "initial_fast_coordinate_norm_independent_basis": 1.1187134045061292e-16, + "max_retained_initial_mismatch": 0.0, + "exact_derivative_fast_from_slow_ratio": 3.7879434216217664e-05, + "exact_derivative_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.027000620511254677, + "finite_difference_fast_from_slow_ratio": 3.7877399007937005e-05, + "finite_difference_slow_from_fast_ratio": 0.02700050021133804, + "five_field_state_discrepancy_per_delta_i": 7.833360696207769e-13, + "five_field_constraint_residual_per_initial_density": 2.392257258667935e-13, + "max_error_fraction_discrepancy": 1.859179477037287e-11, + "rows": [ + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2742708812407702, + "lensing_error": 0.2742510881813852 + }, + { + "eta": 0.0, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2911048846223705, + "lensing_error": 1.854090892412778 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.2751348148795621, + "lensing_error": 0.2751159840393697 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2902650876436734, + "lensing_error": 1.8535107235201227 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.22369341387720496, + "lensing_error": 0.22367321898712766 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.3374213867005895, + "lensing_error": 1.878388891258987 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.273406947601979, + "lensing_error": 0.2733861923234008 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.291958646101845, + "lensing_error": 1.8546879219909347 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.32484834860433615, + "lensing_error": 0.32482895737564266 + }, + { + "eta": 0.001, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2448186328331632, + "lensing_error": 1.8297928935665695 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.28291021762868757, + "lensing_error": 0.2829000467612301 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.283086299616118, + "lensing_error": 1.8487331485989509 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.25449956637568916, + "lensing_error": 0.3182692800055698 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.754907143927004, + "lensing_error": 2.0971396420031128 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.26563154485285345, + "lensing_error": 0.2656021296015402 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.300313779316595, + "lensing_error": 1.861803416779511 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.7800455548764288, + "lensing_error": 0.7800297801239606 + }, + { + "eta": 0.01, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 0.9494514156407065, + "lensing_error": 1.611281134187546 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.3725619416865701, + "lensing_error": 0.3753277833203473 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 0.0, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.2147375309014632, + "lensing_error": 1.8059280535111106 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 4.783475855115797, + "lensing_error": 4.785514717740217 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 1.5707963267948966, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 6.167844034311462, + "lensing_error": 6.387955267718615 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 0.1878775173616014, + "lensing_error": 0.19543700572378042 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 3.141592653589793, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 1.392764888121472, + "lensing_error": 2.0036767030054183 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "zero", + "density_error": 5.33201761759735, + "lensing_error": 5.332263145187284 + }, + { + "eta": 0.1, + "phase": 4.71238898038469, + "closure": "adiabatic", + "density_error": 3.9477931466839715, + "lensing_error": 4.103058668913466 + } + ] + } + ] +} diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/probe.py b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/probe.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ee36b30 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/probe.py @@ -0,0 +1,173 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Frozen-protocol slow-mode ensemble and hidden fast-mode leakage. + +Dimensionless Q0=1. No fitting and no change to the audited action/background. +""" +import json,math,hashlib +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np +from scipy.integrate import solve_ivp +from scipy.optimize import linear_sum_assignment + +HERE=Path(__file__).resolve().parent +QI=.01;DELTA=1e-5 + +def bg(a): + q=QI/a**3;Q=1+q;Kp=4*q;R=4*q+2*q*q;W=Q*Kp;H=math.sqrt(R/3) + return Q,Kp,R,W,H + + +def rhs(a,x,closure=None): + Q,Kp,R,W,H=bg(a);r=KVAL*KVAL/a**2;ca=Kp/(4*Q);w=2*(Q-1)**2/R + delta,theta=x[:2] + Phi=-(R*delta+3*H*W*theta)/(2*r) + if closure is None: + chi,Z=x[2:];gamma=(R*delta+r*Z)/(4*Q);pressure=Kp*gamma + else:pressure=0. if closure=='zero' else ca*R*delta + Phidot=-H*Phi+W*theta/2 + dd=3*H*(w*delta-pressure/R)+3*W/R*Phidot-r*W/R*theta + td=3*H*ca*theta+pressure/W+Phi + if closure is not None:return np.array([dd,td]) + Qdot=-3*H*Kp/4 + chd=gamma+Q*Z+(Qdot/Q-Q)*chi-Qdot*theta + Zd=(-H+Q)*Z+(Kp-3*Q)*chi + return np.array([dd,td,chd,Zd]) + + +def matrix(a,closure=None): + dim=4 if closure is None else 2 + return np.column_stack([rhs(a,np.eye(dim)[:,j],closure) for j in range(dim)]) + + +def modes(): + aa=np.linspace(1,2,201);eigrows=[];vecrows=[];prev=None + for a in aa: + eig,V=np.linalg.eig(matrix(a)) + if prev is None: + positive=np.flatnonzero(eig.imag>1e-8) + assert len(positive)==2 + fastp=int(max(positive,key=lambda j:eig[j].imag));fastm=int(np.argmin(abs(eig-eig[fastp].conjugate()))) + slow=[i for i in range(4) if i not in (fastp,fastm)] + slow=sorted(slow,key=lambda i:eig[i].imag,reverse=True) + order=slow+[fastp,fastm] + else: + ii,jj=linear_sum_assignment(abs(prev[:,None]-eig[None,:]));order=jj[np.argsort(ii)] + eig=eig[order];V=V[:,order].astype(complex) + assert max(abs(eig[:2].imag))<.1*abs(eig[2].imag) and eig[2].imag>0 and eig[3].imag<0 + V/=np.linalg.norm(V,axis=0) + if vecrows: + overlap=np.sum(vecrows[-1].conj()*V,axis=0) + V*=np.exp(-1j*np.angle(overlap))[None,:] + eigrows.append(eig);vecrows.append(V);prev=eig + ee=np.array(eigrows);VV=np.array(vecrows);dVda=np.gradient(VV,aa,axis=0,edge_order=2) + omega=ee[:,2].imag;domega=np.gradient(omega,aa,edge_order=2) + gaps=[];rates=[];adiabatic=[];mix=[];mix_fs=[];mix_sf=[];conds=[] + for i,a in enumerate(aa): + H=bg(a)[-1];gap=min(abs(ee[i,s]-ee[i,f]) for s in (0,1) for f in (2,3)) + mixing=np.linalg.solve(VV[i],dVda[i]*(a*H)) + gaps.append(gap/H);rates.append(max(abs(ee[i,:2]))/omega[i]) + adiabatic.append(abs(a*H*domega[i])/omega[i]**2) + mix.append(max(abs(mixing[s,f])/abs(ee[i,s]-ee[i,f]) for s,f in [(0,2),(0,3),(1,2),(1,3),(2,0),(2,1),(3,0),(3,1)])) + mix_fs.append(max(abs(mixing[f,s])/abs(ee[i,f]-ee[i,s]) for f in (2,3) for s in (0,1))) + mix_sf.append(max(abs(mixing[s,f])/abs(ee[i,s]-ee[i,f]) for s in (0,1) for f in (2,3))) + conds.append(np.linalg.cond(VV[i])) + e0,V0=ee[0],VV[0] + S=np.column_stack([V0[:,0].real,V0[:,0].imag]) + assert np.linalg.cond(S[:2])<1e8,'Slow subspace cannot uniquely match retained data' + slow_state=S@np.linalg.solve(S[:2],np.array([1.,-bg(1.)[-1]/KVAL**2])) + f=V0[:,2]/V0[0,2] + contaminants=[] + for phase in (0.,math.pi/2,math.pi,3*math.pi/2): + g=(np.exp(1j*phase)*f).real + w=g-S@np.linalg.solve(S[:2],g[:2]) + assert np.linalg.norm(w[:2])<1e-10 + contaminants.append((phase,w)) + info={'initial_eigenvalues':[[float(e.real),float(e.imag)] for e in e0], + 'final_eigenvalues':[[float(e.real),float(e.imag)] for e in ee[-1]], + 'min_fast_slow_gap_over_H':float(min(gaps)), + 'max_slow_rate_over_fast_frequency':float(max(rates)), + 'max_frequency_adiabatic_ratio':float(max(adiabatic)), + 'max_fast_slow_eigenvector_mixing_over_gap':float(max(mix)), + 'max_fast_from_slow_mixing_over_gap':float(max(mix_fs)), + 'max_slow_from_fast_mixing_over_gap':float(max(mix_sf)), + 'max_eigenvector_condition_number':float(max(conds)), + 'initial_retained_slow_basis_condition_number':float(np.linalg.cond(S[:2])), + 'initial_fast_spectral_coordinate_norm':float(np.linalg.norm(np.linalg.solve(V0,slow_state)[2:])), + 'slow_initial_state_per_unit_delta':slow_state.tolist(), + 'compensated_leakage_vectors':[{'phase':phase,'state':w.tolist()} for phase,w in contaminants]} + return slow_state,contaminants,info + + +def fundamental(grid,closure=None,tol=1e-11): + n=4 if closure is None else 2 + def derivative(a,flat): + return (matrix(a,closure)@flat.reshape(n,n)/(a*bg(a)[-1])).ravel() + sol=solve_ivp(derivative,(1,2),np.eye(n).ravel(),t_eval=grid,method='DOP853',rtol=tol,atol=tol*1e-4) + assert sol.success and sol.y.shape[1]==len(grid) + return sol.y.T.reshape(len(grid),n,n) + + +def observables(grid,state): + Q,Kp,R,W,H=np.array([bg(a) for a in grid]).T + delta=state[:,0];theta=state[:,1];r=KVAL*KVAL/grid**2 + lens=-(R*delta+3*H*W*theta)/r + return np.array([delta,lens]) + + +def run_one(k,refined=False): + global KVAL;KVAL=k + slow_state,contaminants,info=modes() + grid=np.linspace(1,2,4001 if refined else 2001);tol=1e-12 if refined else 1e-10 + fund=fundamental(grid,tol=tol) + closures={c:fundamental(grid,c,tol) for c in ('zero','adiabatic')} + initial=DELTA*slow_state + reference={c:observables(grid,np.einsum('tij,j->ti',F,initial[:2])) for c,F in closures.items()} + scales=np.max(abs(reference['zero']),axis=1) + prepared=[(0.,0.,initial)] + for eta in (.001,.01,.1): + prepared.extend((eta,phase,initial+DELTA*eta*w) for phase,w in contaminants) + rows=[] + for eta,phase,x0 in prepared: + assert np.max(abs(x0[:2]-initial[:2]))<1e-15 + states=np.einsum('tij,j->ti',fund,x0);obs=observables(grid,states) + Q,Kp,R,W,H=np.array([bg(a) for a in grid]).T;r=k*k/grid**2 + Phi=obs[1]/2;vn=Q*states[:,1];al=(states[:,2]-vn)/Q + gamma=(R*states[:,0]+r*states[:,3])/(4*Q) + amplitudes={'density_contrast':float(np.max(abs(obs[0]))),'lensing_sum':float(np.max(abs(obs[1]))), + 'aether_spatial':float(np.max(abs(k*al/grid))),'delta_Q_over_Q':float(np.max(abs(gamma/Q))), + 'chi':float(np.max(abs(states[:,2])))} + for c,pred in reference.items(): + errors=np.max(abs(obs-pred),axis=1)/scales + rows.append({'k':k,'eta':eta,'phase':phase,'closure':c,'density_error':float(errors[0]), + 'lensing_error':float(errors[1]),'passes_1_percent':bool(max(errors)<.01), + 'max_amplitudes':amplitudes}) + # Direct integration is separate from the fundamental-matrix solution. + direct=solve_ivp(lambda a,x:rhs(a,x)/(a*bg(a)[-1]),(1,2),initial,t_eval=grid, + method='DOP853',rtol=1e-12,atol=1e-20) + baseline=np.einsum('tij,j->ti',fund,initial) + direct_error=float(np.max(abs(direct.y.T-baseline))/DELTA) + assert direct.success and direct_error<1e-7 + return {'k':k,'mode_diagnostics':info,'direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i':direct_error, + 'reference_scales':scales.tolist(),'rows':rows} + + +def main(): + results={'protocol_sha256':hashlib.sha256((HERE/'PROTOCOL.md').read_bytes()).hexdigest(), + 'scope':'Same-action instantaneous slow-subspace initialization, plus compensated fast contamination. No invariant-manifold or observational claim.', + 'points':[run_one(k) for k in (6.,9.,12.,18.,24.)]} + refinement=run_one(12.,True) + base=results['points'][2] + err=max(abs(a[field]-b[field]) for a,b in zip(base['rows'],refinement['rows']) for field in ('density_error','lensing_error')) + assert err<1e-5 + results['refinement']={'k':12.,'grid_points':4001,'rtol':1e-12,'max_error_fraction_change':err, + 'direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i':refinement['direct_vs_fundamental_error_per_delta_i']} + (HERE/'evidence.json').write_text(json.dumps(results,indent=2)+'\n') + for point in results['points']: + print('k',point['k'],'diagnostics',point['mode_diagnostics']) + for eta in (0.,.001,.01,.1): + for c in ('zero','adiabatic'): + rr=[r for r in point['rows'] if r['eta']==eta and r['closure']==c] + print(eta,c,'max error',max(max(r['density_error'],r['lensing_error']) for r in rr),'passes',sum(r['passes_1_percent'] for r in rr),'/',len(rr)) + print('refinement',results['refinement']) + +if __name__=='__main__':main() diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection-failure.json b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection-failure.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4a71476 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection-failure.json @@ -0,0 +1,116 @@ +{ + "original_protocol_sha256": "e18a17694fd46609e2574f680d6fd5a0d870295cf3f030b2a1da3d5d0187c9a9", + "result": "Real growing/decaying pair assumption fails at all five initial wave numbers. No closure errors were evaluated under this rule.", + "rows": [ + { + "k": 6.0, + "eigenvalues": [ + [ + -0.058912799380405376, + 5.392894883230915 + ], + [ + -0.058912799380405376, + -5.392894883230915 + ], + [ + 0.00017829959360134856, + 0.07694011280610696 + ], + [ + 0.00017829959360134856, + -0.07694011280610696 + ] + ], + "positive_imaginary_pairs": 2 + }, + { + "k": 9.0, + "eigenvalues": [ + [ + -0.05885335982686522, + 7.926675767004695 + ], + [ + -0.05885335982686522, + -7.926675767004695 + ], + [ + 0.00011886004005979699, + 0.083786596544086 + ], + [ + 0.00011886004005979699, + -0.083786596544086 + ] + ], + "positive_imaginary_pairs": 2 + }, + { + "k": 12.0, + "eigenvalues": [ + [ + -0.058830757630689456, + 10.491986085246275 + ], + [ + -0.058830757630689456, + -10.491986085246275 + ], + [ + 9.625784388558612e-05, + 0.08618326184768918 + ], + [ + 9.625784388558612e-05, + -0.08618326184768918 + ] + ], + "positive_imaginary_pairs": 2 + }, + { + "k": 18.0, + "eigenvalues": [ + [ + -0.05881399075813738, + 15.65507798675622 + ], + [ + -0.05881399075813738, + -15.65507798675622 + ], + [ + 7.949097133435931e-05, + 0.08789796210453217 + ], + [ + 7.949097133435931e-05, + -0.08789796210453217 + ] + ], + "positive_imaginary_pairs": 2 + }, + { + "k": 24.0, + "eigenvalues": [ + [ + -0.058807995064846894, + 20.834619228531693 + ], + [ + -0.058807995064846894, + -20.834619228531693 + ], + [ + 7.349527804354895e-05, + 0.08849886989701668 + ], + [ + 7.349527804354895e-05, + -0.08849886989701668 + ] + ], + "positive_imaginary_pairs": 2 + } + ] +} diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection_failure.py b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection_failure.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ca700be --- /dev/null +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/slow-mode/selection_failure.py @@ -0,0 +1,19 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Replay the failed real-growing-mode gate without changing its rule.""" +import hashlib,json +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np +import probe +p=Path(__file__).resolve().parent +rows=[] +for k in (6.,9.,12.,18.,24.): + probe.KVAL=k + ee=np.linalg.eigvals(probe.matrix(1.)) + rows.append({'k':k,'eigenvalues':[[float(e.real),float(e.imag)] for e in ee], + 'positive_imaginary_pairs':int(sum(ee.imag>1e-8))}) +assert all(r['positive_imaginary_pairs']==2 for r in rows) +result={'original_protocol_sha256':hashlib.sha256((p/'GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md').read_bytes()).hexdigest(), + 'result':'Real growing/decaying pair assumption fails at all five initial wave numbers. No closure errors were evaluated under this rule.', + 'rows':rows} +(p/'selection-failure.json').write_text(json.dumps(result,indent=2)+'\n') +print(json.dumps(result,indent=2)) From 71e33aab20f19fa032f58f17ffe1c0eeca2abd4b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: ahrazzle <38987266+ahrazzle@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 17:48:04 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 6/7] Record completed AeST slow-subspace review --- README.md | 6 ++++-- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 82c13fe..1a3986a 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -47,6 +47,8 @@ All Python scripts use only the Python 3 standard library. Each certificate file - mic-Dawn quasar confrontation, and next-agent handoff queue. - `CHANGELOG.md` -- Reconciled chronological history across Waves 1-12 matching `CLAIMS.md` and code identifiers. -## AeST response benchmark in progress +## AeST response benchmark and independent checks -The [AeST response benchmark](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md) constructs allowed field preparations on a specified expanding background and a flat-space control. It includes the canonical map, executable response checks and a bounded pressure-closure comparison. A separate Astra agent reproduced the scalar constraint and kinetic structure from an independent ADM action. A slow-mode preparation test is in progress. +The [AeST response benchmark](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md) constructs allowed field preparations on a specified expanding background and a flat-space control. It includes the canonical map, executable response checks and a bounded pressure-closure comparison. + +A separate Astra agent reproduced the scalar constraint and kinetic structure from an independent ADM action. A separately declared slow-subspace test and its independent five-field replay are complete. The simple zero-pressure closure still fails for this specified benchmark. From a2bd29143b4fecab62b8ae8d651b556d1dff1d90 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 15:25:02 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 7/7] Cover the full AeST bundle in its manifest and fix the root README sum The bundle SHA256SUMS now lists .gitignore and all twelve slow-mode/ files (probe.py, evidence.json, both protocols, RESULTS.md, selection_failure.py, selection-failure.json, checkpoint.json and the four independent-review/ files), hashed from the committed bytes. The original ten lines are unchanged. The root SHA256SUMS README line now matches the merged README.md (1b25a9b1...), which carries main's index fix plus the AeST section. Addresses proof review 5887680616 on #12. Signed-off-by: Orda <342776047+orda-aska@users.noreply.github.com> --- SHA256SUMS | 2 +- research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS | 13 +++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 14 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/SHA256SUMS b/SHA256SUMS index 5fed28a..4bc3e2b 100644 --- a/SHA256SUMS +++ b/SHA256SUMS @@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ a44b03375f26452e66aac5324199e41aeb77092c668dbc2adf0342caccb32a7c results/wave3_ dd37a45adcb3c815d1a2d44bbbb58ac0235b9ea30d58d6b5a3438a46d91c874e results/wave10_covariant_jeans_certificates.json 9d05bb78b81b45aeda49edf6cfb9f734d761968ec4d06111aa1064cbc73eb359 results/wave11_machian_pairing_certificates.json 493be7e0c615633eb77398c668f2d06a04fe21dd7bc6739e9b68649f9901da78 results/wave12_cosmic_dawn_quasar_certificates.json -72606ab3fb3775cfec067f0dbc347fed596045f15da10038d9bd7c375a6437b9 README.md +1b25a9b157081c64c59d299ac77d085a83f9d9835081f7035e42c0f2b24d3cc3 README.md bbae4ed5f8da9582c75f2d6b198cdb5425ccf4c9c626fa97b32e8410aecb490f CLAIMS.md 6109f20f98f191adcaa65e2a42f05000149c62163d548a783791d32e07435e13 METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md bf51cdb91977816de1849ade61c10bee7e9826f9ebdb9d689192725064386aa8 RESEARCH_NOTEBOOK_AND_REASONING.md diff --git a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS index 55abb31..f499079 100644 --- a/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS +++ b/research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS @@ -1,3 +1,4 @@ +22bc478fc0eb97818e8c2efd9a6c8f9dce55490bdd8074a3f2b6b8653c5c12d5 .gitignore b23164c524bfe6a8da825eb6fdb8512305d8bacbdd92dee0ac8959c674eb6c1b README.md 5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe derivation.md 58f56124bef156d5a8e22d0bd4eaab695c4ac0540f0e211e63f5e99ff4bc10e7 independent-review/REVIEW.md @@ -7,4 +8,16 @@ f90522170c4ea67d2601e8c099216ff992a5d3b94a43c0322da87c03f6e9facc protocol.md ebab51ac1b6420faa2394d3deaba33637ddfff96456fe15406991f12d5a227f2 requirements.txt e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef response.py c82b4e1c64da797e5a701f698808b7074c780778306cb6622721011403573602 results.json +e18a17694fd46609e2574f680d6fd5a0d870295cf3f030b2a1da3d5d0187c9a9 slow-mode/GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md +efe19e6cb78f46af8d612b4ab0188981f711604b6aa4755cf287e62a540d1fc7 slow-mode/PROTOCOL.md +4db8ba576047fcc296e7f99556ba2ab31121fb93d31ac7d9cd81c30296a2883e slow-mode/RESULTS.md +a911f5403aba4de34603c457e6ea2edf452b036c9116cb183993c08eae629f22 slow-mode/checkpoint.json +cc1e24085ca282198798514f01946c338b3df4f715ff7a694b0d8402f567d054 slow-mode/evidence.json +a6fcac897f513934a9f7d8ed837f4d7a35842a607adc06368b15fbfef4297b2f slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md +108ab8738016ea097ac7a190a1ec501b50b1ddc261c7b7530b221607aba62b03 slow-mode/independent-review/check.py +81ccf47780b498c11361895361bb296cabda437648b9b025216bea6427ee393d slow-mode/independent-review/checkpoint.json +e86be2518a2b7fa9c3debbc4536feb7008299efea05a83ce3537e45c6a6a9def slow-mode/independent-review/evidence.json +af9d4443c45298d723384ad0283bb8a635944fe347fd2067e3f4699ea94b2151 slow-mode/probe.py +71a3187c110e66993bd3fd035b0f4abd041146c5ca74e983cbed2aa29ea46098 slow-mode/selection-failure.json +368230772939461a5a10c6ff0552c5aeb6375068660f45efd8a8403992ebd605 slow-mode/selection_failure.py 6f11f6b728915532867b3d61ac4d2eb34dc40fd090dd29e4e177406065a277c4 sources.json