Empty Contracts

[Nicole4Fox]

It seems like contracts like https://github.com/MetaTrustLabs/GPTScan-Top200/blob/dev/0x0ef39e52704ad52e2882bbfa6781167e1b6c4510_poly/Bora20v2.sol do not contain any content. Is this intentional?

[Nicole4Fox]

Also some contracts seem to be duplicates (e.g. 0x0b3f868e0be5597d5db7feb59e1cadbb0fdda50a_poly and 0x0b220b82f3ea3b7f6d9a1d8ab58930c064a2b5bf_poly)

[IzaiahSun]

It seems like contracts like https://github.com/MetaTrustLabs/GPTScan-Top200/blob/dev/0x0ef39e52704ad52e2882bbfa6781167e1b6c4510_poly/Bora20v2.sol do not contain any content. Is this intentional?

Hi, we have updated it.

[IzaiahSun]

Also some contracts seem to be duplicates (e.g. 0x0b3f868e0be5597d5db7feb59e1cadbb0fdda50a_poly and 0x0b220b82f3ea3b7f6d9a1d8ab58930c064a2b5bf_poly)

Yes, these two contracts are exactly the same on PolygonScan. We did not do deduplication on the dataset.

[Nicole4Fox]

Hello @IzaiahSun thank you for the response. (At least) The following contracts are also missing:

• 0x2b591e99afe9f32eaa6214f7b7629768c40eeb39_eth
• 0x4ddc2d193948926d02f9b1fe9e1daa0718270ed5_eth
• 0x4e3fbd56cd56c3e72c1403e103b45db9da5b9d2b_eth
• 0x6b175474e89094c44da98b954eedeac495271d0f_eth
• 0x9eaac1b23d935365bd7b542fe22ceee2922f52dc_avax
• 0x37b608519f91f70f2eeb0e5ed9af4061722e4f76_avax
• 0x50b7545627a5162f82a992c33b87adc75187b218_avax
• 0x92d6c1e31e14520e676a687f0a93788b716beff5_eth
• 0x596fa47043f99a4e0f122243b841e55375cde0d2_avax
• 0x88128fd4b259552a9a1d457f435a6527aab72d42_avax
• 0xabc9547b534519ff73921b1fba6e672b5f58d083_avax
• 0xbf2179859fc6d5bee9bf9158632dc51678a4100e_eth
• 0xc3048e19e76cb9a3aa9d77d8c03c29fc906e2437_avax
• 0xd586e7f844cea2f87f50152665bcbc2c279d8d70_avax
• 0xda10009cbd5d07dd0cecc66161fc93d7c9000da1_arbi
• 0xfcf8eda095e37a41e002e266daad7efc1579bc0a_eth

Was the version without deduplication and missing contracts also used for the benchmark in the paper?

[IzaiahSun]

We will fix them as soon as possible. Thanks for you notice. For the paper, we were using the benchmark that have no missing files and without deduplication.

[Nicole4Fox]

Thank you very much @IzaiahSun. I also noticed that sometimes the first characters of files and folder names are missing for example the folder "contract" is often called "ontract" and in e.g. 0xf34960d9d60be18cc1d5afc1a6f012a723a28811_eth the files lack the first character e.g. afeMath.sol should be SafeMath.sol making it not easily possible to run the benchmark to verify results without manually renaming and rechecking those files and folders. This happens in multiple folders.