diff --git a/app/Platform/Actions/GetUserProgressionStatusCountsAction.php b/app/Platform/Actions/GetUserProgressionStatusCountsAction.php
index e3aea11671..deded2dea9 100644
--- a/app/Platform/Actions/GetUserProgressionStatusCountsAction.php
+++ b/app/Platform/Actions/GetUserProgressionStatusCountsAction.php
@@ -18,14 +18,14 @@ class GetUserProgressionStatusCountsAction
     /**
      * @return array{
      *     avgCompletionPercentage: float,
-     *     systemProgress: array<int, array{unfinishedCount: int, beatenSoftcoreCount: int, beatenHardcoreCount: int, completedCount: int, masteredCount: int, systemId: int}>,
+     *     systemProgress: array<int, array{unfinishedCount: int, beatenSoftcoreCount: int, beatenHardcoreCount: int, completedCount: int, masteredCount: int, lastPlayedAt: string|null, systemId: int}>,
      *     topSystemId: int|null,
      *     totalCounts: array{unfinished: int, beatenSoftcore: int, beatenHardcore: int, completed: int, mastered: int},
      *     totalHardcoreAchievements: int,
      *     totalSoftcoreAchievements: int,
      * }
      */
-    public function execute(User $user, ?int $recentSystemId = null): array
+    public function execute(User $user): array
     {
         // Subsets are identified by their core achievement set being linked to another game as a non-core type.
         $subsetExistsSubquery = "EXISTS (
@@ -47,6 +47,7 @@ public function execute(User $user, ?int $recentSystemId = null): array
         $results = $this->buildQualifyingGamesQuery($user)
             ->selectRaw("
                 games.system_id,
+                MAX(player_games.last_played_at) as last_played_at,
                 SUM(player_games.achievements_unlocked_hardcore) as total_hc_achievements,
                 SUM(GREATEST(0, CAST(player_games.achievements_unlocked AS SIGNED) - CAST(player_games.achievements_unlocked_hardcore AS SIGNED))) as total_sc_achievements,
                 SUM(mastery_hc.id IS NOT NULL) as mastered_count,
@@ -100,6 +101,7 @@ public function execute(User $user, ?int $recentSystemId = null): array
             $beatenHc = (int) $row->beaten_hc_count;
             $beatenSc = (int) $row->beaten_sc_count;
             $unfinished = (int) $row->unfinished_count;
+            $lastPlayedAt = $row->last_played_at?->format('Y-m-d H:i:s');
 
             $systemProgress[$systemId] = [
                 'unfinishedCount' => $unfinished,
@@ -107,6 +109,7 @@ public function execute(User $user, ?int $recentSystemId = null): array
                 'beatenHardcoreCount' => $beatenHc,
                 'completedCount' => $completed,
                 'masteredCount' => $mastered,
+                'lastPlayedAt' => $lastPlayedAt,
                 'systemId' => $systemId,
             ];
 
@@ -120,16 +123,29 @@ public function execute(User $user, ?int $recentSystemId = null): array
             $totalSoftcoreAchievements += (int) $row->total_sc_achievements;
         }
 
+        $avgCompletionPercentage = $this->calculateAvgCompletionExcludingSubsets($user);
+
+        // topSystem is the most recent valid system where the user has earned achievements.
+        $topSystemId = null;
+        $latestTimestamp = null;
+
+        foreach ($systemProgress as $systemId => $progress) {
+            if ($progress['lastPlayedAt'] === null) {
+                continue;
+            }
+
+            $timestamp = strtotime($progress['lastPlayedAt']) ?: 0;
+
+            if ($latestTimestamp === null || $timestamp > $latestTimestamp) {
+                $latestTimestamp = $timestamp;
+                $topSystemId = $systemId;
+            }
+        }
+
         // Add counts for "orphan badges" - badges for games not in the main query.
         // This handles demoted games, games with < 6 achievements, etc.
         $this->addOrphanBadgeCounts($user, $systemProgress, $totalCounts);
 
-        $avgCompletionPercentage = $this->calculateAvgCompletionExcludingSubsets($user);
-
-        $topSystemId = ($recentSystemId !== null && isset($systemProgress[$recentSystemId]))
-            ? $recentSystemId
-            : array_key_first($systemProgress);
-
         // Sort: topSystem first, then by total games played descending.
         uasort($systemProgress, function ($a, $b) use ($topSystemId) {
             if ($a['systemId'] === $topSystemId) {
@@ -159,7 +175,7 @@ public function execute(User $user, ?int $recentSystemId = null): array
      * Finds badges for games not included in the main query and adds them to the counts.
      * This handles edge cases like demoted games, etc.
      *
-     * @param array<int, array{unfinishedCount: int, beatenSoftcoreCount: int, beatenHardcoreCount: int, completedCount: int, masteredCount: int, systemId: int}> $systemProgress
+     * @param array<int, array{unfinishedCount: int, beatenSoftcoreCount: int, beatenHardcoreCount: int, completedCount: int, masteredCount: int, lastPlayedAt: string|null, systemId: int}> $systemProgress
      * @param array{unfinished: int, beatenSoftcore: int, beatenHardcore: int, completed: int, mastered: int} $totalCounts
      */
     private function addOrphanBadgeCounts(User $user, array &$systemProgress, array &$totalCounts): void
@@ -223,6 +239,7 @@ private function addOrphanBadgeCounts(User $user, array &$systemProgress, array
                     'beatenHardcoreCount' => 0,
                     'completedCount' => 0,
                     'masteredCount' => 0,
+                    'lastPlayedAt' => null,
                     'systemId' => $systemId,
                 ];
             }
diff --git a/resources/views/pages-legacy/userInfo.blade.php b/resources/views/pages-legacy/userInfo.blade.php
index 5b36543617..57da656885 100644
--- a/resources/views/pages-legacy/userInfo.blade.php
+++ b/resources/views/pages-legacy/userInfo.blade.php
@@ -43,15 +43,8 @@
 $userWallActive = $userMassData['UserWallActive'];
 $userIsUntracked = $userMassData['Untracked'];
 
-$recentlyPlayedSystemId = collect($userMassData['RecentlyPlayed'] ?? [])
-    ->filter(fn ($game) => System::isGameSystem($game['ConsoleID'] ?? 0) && ($game['AchievementsTotal'] ?? 0) > 0)
-    ->sortByDesc('LastPlayed')
-    ->pluck('ConsoleID')
-    ->first();
-
 $progressionCounts = (new GetUserProgressionStatusCountsAction())->execute(
-    $userPageModel,
-    $recentlyPlayedSystemId
+    $userPageModel
 );
 
 $averageCompletionPercentage = sprintf("%01.2f", $progressionCounts['avgCompletionPercentage']);