Problem Statement
Currently, the package uses only 0-year-old birth data (children born in a specific year) as the denominator for all immunity calculations. This implicitly assumes all children survive throughout the vaccination schedule, which is unrealistic and may introduce bias in estimates, particularly in settings with notable child mortality or when analyzing later vaccine doses.
Proposed Solution
Extend the package to allow more flexible denominator specifications:
- Multiple population cohorts: Accept population data for different age groups (0-year, 1-year, etc.) to serve as age-appropriate denominators
- Survival rate adjustment: Allow users to provide survival rates or life tables to adjust birth cohorts for mortality
- Flexible denominator selection: Let users specify which population data corresponds to each vaccine dose age
Example Usage (just suggestions)
# Option 1: Multiple age-specific population data
population_data <- data.frame(
dist_code = c("D01", "D01", "D02", "D02"),
age_group = c(0, 1, 0, 1),
population = c(1000, 950, 2000, 1900)
)
# Option 2: Survival rates
survival_rates <- data.frame(
dist_code = c("D01", "D01", "D02", "D02"),
age_year = c(0, 1, 0, 1),
survival_prob = c(1.00, 0.95, 1.00, 0.96)
)
# Updated function call with population adjustment
compute_immunity(
ri_data = ri_data,
birth_data = birth_data,
population_data = population_data, # new option
survival_rates = survival_rates # alternative option
)
Alternatives Considered
- Keep current approach: Simpler but less accurate for high-mortality settings
- External adjustment: Users pre-adjust birth data outside the package (adds burden)
- Sensitivity analysis: Keep current but document limitations
Benefits
- More realistic immunity estimates, especially in high-mortality contexts
- Better accuracy for later vaccine doses (IPV2, OPV3, etc.)
- Flexibility to work with available data (cohorts or survival rates)
- Aligns with standard demographic and epidemiological practice
Implementation Considerations
- Backward compatibility: Default behavior should remain unchanged
- Data validation: Need functions to validate age-specific population data
- Documentation: Clear guidance on when and how to use these options
Additional Context
This enhancement would significantly improve the package's applicability in settings with:
- High under-5 mortality
- Varying survival rates across districts
- Available demographic surveillance or census data
Checklist
Problem Statement
Currently, the package uses only 0-year-old birth data (children born in a specific year) as the denominator for all immunity calculations. This implicitly assumes all children survive throughout the vaccination schedule, which is unrealistic and may introduce bias in estimates, particularly in settings with notable child mortality or when analyzing later vaccine doses.
Proposed Solution
Extend the package to allow more flexible denominator specifications:
Example Usage (just suggestions)
Alternatives Considered
Benefits
Implementation Considerations
Additional Context
This enhancement would significantly improve the package's applicability in settings with:
Checklist