Skip to content

CHRONOS alignment follow-on: evaluate carrier passthrough on evidence/replay surface (per sociosphere#498) #329

Description

@mdheller

Context

SocioProphet/socioprophet#498 tracks the overall KAIROS↔CHRONOS alignment thread. sociosphere/docs/integration/neurosymbolic-chronos-alignment.md's authority-plane table assigns AgentPlane the "Evidence/action/replay surface" role. Its "Definition of done" requires a downstream follow-on item here. This is that item.

What already exists in this repo

AgentPlane already runs a real evidence/replay pipeline that structurally matches the shape CHRONOS carriers would need:

  • docs/receipt-lifecycle.md — MAIPJ run receipts assembled from a normalized event stream (workspace.locked, context.pack.selected, policy.evaluated, placement.selected, run.started, run.completed, evidence.sealed), joined by trace_id, fail-closed if any required event is missing.
  • docs/replay-boundary.md — defines the current ReplayArtifact contract precisely, including what it does not promise yet (no cryptographic attestation, no full authority/delegation reconstruction, no complete version-set pinning).
  • docs/sociosphere-bridge.md — a narrow, already-implemented seam where sociosphere emits normalized workspace artifacts and a Bundle, and agentplane "consumes the bundle and preserves execution-plane evidence (ValidationArtifact, PlacementDecision, RunArtifact, ReplayArtifact)" — i.e. the exact "evidence/replay surface" role named in the alignment doc, already wired for the sociosphere/workspace case.

The concrete gap

None of evidence.sealed, ReplayArtifact, or the sociosphere-bridge artifacts currently carry a method-family tag or the neuro-symbolic carrier-boundary fields (grounding status, validation status, explanation trace reference, owning authority plane, non-authority declaration) that neurosymbolic-chronos-alignment.md requires on any carrier referencing neuro-symbolic reasoning. If a candidate governed carrier produced via, say, a NeurASP-style adjudication or a dILP-style rule proposal needs to flow through AgentPlane's evidence/replay surface the way a sociosphere Bundle does today, there's currently no analogous bridge doc or artifact shape for it — sociosphere-bridge.md is scoped to workspace/task artifacts, not neuro-symbolic carriers.

Ask

Look at whether the receipt/ReplayArtifact model (or a new bridge doc analogous to sociosphere-bridge.md) should be extended so a CHRONOS neuro-symbolic carrier's explanation-trace and replay-reference fields can pass through AgentPlane's evidence/replay surface, the same way sociosphere workspace evidence does today. This is a request to look at the connection, not a mandate for a specific artifact schema.

Non-goals

  • AgentPlane does not take on carrier-schema or method-family taxonomy authority — that stays with Ontogenesis / sourceos-spec.
  • Per docs/replay-boundary.md's own stated limits, this issue does not ask AgentPlane to promise cryptographic attestation or full authority reconstruction for neuro-symbolic carriers beyond what it already promises for any other replay input.
  • No canonical-schema authority moves into sociosphere.

Refs: SocioProphet/socioprophet#498, sociosphere/docs/integration/neurosymbolic-chronos-alignment.md, docs/receipt-lifecycle.md, docs/replay-boundary.md, docs/sociosphere-bridge.md (this repo).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions