From 66db8322b1d4ad68493b2f2fc64c81a4aa987edb Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Erin Spencer Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2026 22:22:29 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 1/4] docs(language): follow UCNS lexical-floor deprecation --- docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md | 162 ++++++++++++-------------------- 1 file changed, 62 insertions(+), 100 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md b/docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md index 7557c6c..6f02b5b 100644 --- a/docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md +++ b/docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md @@ -1,142 +1,104 @@ # EDCM gonol language boundary -**Status:** active EDCM consumer boundary; UCNS construction law remains upstream. -**Authority:** Erin Spencer for the stack declaration; UCNS owns its lexical/gonol construction surfaces; EDCM owns its measurement-side use and non-use. +**Status:** active EDCM consumer boundary; UCNS lexical construction remains upstream. +**Authority:** Erin Spencer for the stack declaration; UCNS owns lexical/gonol construction surfaces; EDCM owns measurement-side use and non-use. **Recorded:** 2026-08-17. -**Selection effect:** none. -## Work graph +## Current correction -- `The-Interdependency/skill-lib@ff931cff30d04893b995f46eca177fee75c8d3ec` - supplies organization workflow, evidence, and cross-repository discipline. -- `The-Interdependency/ucns@d54c3b6b4d9867f7bc6b968e0424d702504b8497` - owns the current lexical-floor closure declaration and the upstream gonol - construction boundary. -- `The-Interdependency/edcm@330876d31065e4f9fad6e801e92e87c65bf91939` - is the EDCM base state corrected by this document. +The UCNS **lexical-floor** model is DEPRECATED. NGSL 1.2 is a word list, not the dictionary semantic source required for the active lexical construction. Its fixed-list closure rule no longer has forward authority. -No relation transfers mathematical authority, semantic validity, measurement -validity, empirical validity, proof status, or canon standing. +A Scrabble dictionary is authorized upstream as the replacement lexical source class. The exact edition/source identity and custody boundary remain to be pinned by UCNS before ingestion. -## Fixed language-object ladder - -For the current stack language path, the objects are gonols throughout: +The active language-object direction is therefore: ```text Unicode character gonols ↓ -fixed floor word gonols +dictionary lexical entries / words + ↓ +word gonols ↓ -complete lexical floor F +source-bound dictionary definitions and senses ↓ -definitions expressed only with members of F +ordered semantic relationships among word gonols ↓ -floor-definition gonols +definition gonols = first lexical deep-recursion layer ``` -Unicode character gonols are the primitive inscription objects. A floor word is -not a tokenizer token or an opaque identifier: it is a gonol constructed from -its exact ordered character-gonol inscription under UCNS-owned rules. +There is no requirement that semantic definitions close over NGSL or another artificially frozen subset. -Once the lexical floor `F` is admitted, it is closed. A semantic definition of -a floor word may not enlarge that floor. Every floor-definition gonol must -satisfy the upstream closure condition: +## No hidden token or vector layer -```text -support(definition_gonol(word, sense)) ⊆ F -``` +The correction does not introduce conventional NLP token IDs, subword IDs, opaque external embedding vectors, or whole-string cryptographic hashes as lexical primitives. -A definition requiring lexical material outside `F` is not a floor definition. -It does not admit the missing word, recursively expand the vocabulary, or create -an exception to closure. +Unicode-character gonols remain primitive inscription objects. Word spelling, constituent order, multiplicity, occurrence position, sense identity, source provenance, deterministic replay, and recursive semantic relations remain load-bearing. -## No hidden token or vector layer +Source definition prose may be retained as custody evidence; the semantic representation is the source-bound gonol relationship structure constructed from it. -The stack language path does not insert conventional NLP tokens, token IDs, -subword pieces, or an opaque embedding lookup between inscription and gonol -construction. +## First recursion -Source prose may be retained as provenance and custody evidence. Arbitrary text -is not thereby the semantic representation. +Dictionary definitions establish semantic relationships among word gonols. Those relationships are themselves the first lexical deep-recursion layer, not metadata waiting for a later embedding step. -A floor-definition gonol is intended to occupy the semantic-representation role -for which conventional systems commonly use vector embeddings: the word is -represented relationally through already-known lexical gonols rather than by an -opaque coordinate vector. This is a role analogy only. It establishes no -semantic quality, similarity behavior, benchmark advantage, or downstream -utility. +A dictionary-derived definition gonol is intended to occupy the semantic-representation role commonly served by vector embeddings. That role analogy establishes no semantic quality, equivalence, similarity behavior, benchmark advantage, or downstream utility. ## EDCM ownership and use EDCM does **not** own: -- lexical-floor membership; +- dictionary source selection or custody; - Unicode-character-gonol identity or construction; -- the UCNS word-gonol composition law; -- the UCNS definition-gonol composition law; or +- UCNS word-gonol construction; +- UCNS definition-gonol construction; - semantic validity merely because a UCNS representation exists. EDCM may: -- consume exact source-bound UCNS gonol identities and receipts; +- consume exact source-bound UCNS word/definition-gonol identities and receipts; - preserve order, multiplicity, sense identity, context, source, and provenance; -- construct measurement candidates over those represented trajectories when an - explicit EDCM mapping is declared; -- compare a definition-gonol representation against simpler baselines or - conventional embeddings under preregistered criteria; and -- record `FALSIFIED`, `SURVIVED` — not proved, `UNRESOLVED`, or `BLOCKED` - outcomes without changing the upstream construction after outcome inspection. - -UCNS representation does not activate EDCM measurement. EDCM measurement does -not validate UCNS semantics or prove the UCNS construction. - -## Existing EDCM surfaces - -Several existing EDCM surfaces predate this correction and remain useful within -their declared evidence scopes: - -- the exact UCNS **word-gonol corpus-observation profile** remains a pinned - observation/replay surface; -- the OEWN 2025 direct-atomic and molecular branches remain relational evidence - constructions; -- historical UCNS–EDCM experiment generations retain the term `token` where it - named a frozen experimental support unit. - -None of those surfaces defines the current stack lexical primitive. Historical -`token` vocabulary must not be read forward as a tokenizer layer. The OEWN -source's arbitrary definition strings must not be promoted into floor-definition -gonols merely because EDCM can ingest them. - -The old broad statement that “higher-gonol composition remains unresolved” is -too coarse for the current boundary. Gonol composition already exists at -multiple declared language grains. What remains unresolved here is narrower: -the exact UCNS composition/relation law and source-custody process for producing -a complete set of **closed floor-definition gonols**, followed by an explicit -EDCM consumer/evaluation contract if measurement is desired. +- construct measurement candidates over those represented trajectories when an explicit EDCM mapping is declared; +- compare a dictionary-definition-gonol representation against simpler baselines or conventional embeddings under preregistered criteria; and +- record `FALSIFIED`, `SURVIVED — not proved`, `UNRESOLVED`, or `BLOCKED` without changing the upstream construction after outcome inspection. + +UCNS representation does not activate EDCM measurement. EDCM measurement does not validate UCNS semantics or prove UCNS construction. + +## Historical surfaces + +Historical EDCM artifacts keep their exact identities and names. + +In particular: + +- `docs/ENGLISH_LEXICAL_FLOOR.md` and the OEWN 2025 lexical-floor-named artifacts identify a sealed historical experiment and are not renamed; +- historical `lexical-floor` package extras remain reproducibility surfaces; +- historical experiment generations may retain `token` where it names a frozen support unit; +- the NGSL lexical-floor experiment and PR #205 closed-floor producer remain historical UCNS evidence. + +None of those historical names restores the deprecated lexical-floor concept as current stack architecture. + +## PR #205 boundary + +UCNS PR #205 established reusable machinery for preserving target identity, sense, order, repeated occurrences, provenance, deterministic replay, and receipts. + +Its NGSL-specific fixed-floor rules are deprecated for forward work. EDCM must not require: + +- closure over the 2,809-word NGSL list; +- complete semantic coverage of exactly those 2,809 targets; or +- NGSL source receipts as current lexical authority. + +EDCM should consume only a future generalized dictionary-derived UCNS producer contract after the exact dictionary source is pinned. ## Usage guidance -For reproduction of historical EDCM artifacts, continue to use the exact pinned -producer and profile named by those artifacts. Do not rewrite historical reports -or identifiers to match this later language boundary. +For historical reproduction, continue using exact pinned experiment sources and artifacts. Do not rewrite sealed evidence. -For new semantic work: +For new lexical-semantic work: -1. consume the fixed lexical-floor identity from UCNS; -2. require definitions whose lexical support is entirely inside that floor; -3. require source-bound, replayable definition-gonol receipts from UCNS; -4. reject hidden tokenizer, subword, or opaque-vector substitution; -5. keep arbitrary source definition prose as provenance rather than semantic - representation; -6. declare any EDCM projection or metric separately; and -7. evaluate the representation only after the construction and criteria are - frozen. +1. wait for UCNS to pin the exact authorized Scrabble dictionary source and custody identity; +2. consume source-bound dictionary word/definition-gonol receipts; +3. reject hidden tokenizer, subword, opaque-vector, or whole-string-hash substitution; +4. keep the EDCM projection/measurement contract separate from the UCNS semantic representation; +5. freeze EDCM metrics, aggregation, baselines, partitions, stopping, and falsifiers before outcome inspection. ## hmmm -The exact UCNS relation/composition law that turns ordered floor-word gonols into -one replayable definition gonol remains unresolved upstream. The source and -custody procedure for obtaining a complete definition set expressible entirely -inside the fixed floor is also unresolved. EDCM has not yet selected a lawful -projection, metric, or benchmark for testing whether the resulting -definition-gonol representation performs useful semantic work. +The exact Scrabble dictionary edition/source, machine-readable acquisition, license/custody/redistribution boundary, and treatment of definition lexical material not separately listed as dictionary headwords remain upstream UCNS source-ingestion questions. EDCM has not yet selected the projection, information-loss accounting, metric, benchmark, or falsifier for the future dictionary-derived definition-gonol representation. From 08372f583d87aff1102217ad662bc3c144d5215c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Erin Spencer Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2026 22:22:59 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 2/4] docs(plan): follow dictionary lexical replacement --- docs/work-graphs/repository-plan-report.json | 51 +++++++++++--------- 1 file changed, 29 insertions(+), 22 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/work-graphs/repository-plan-report.json b/docs/work-graphs/repository-plan-report.json index 59905e5..f5db261 100644 --- a/docs/work-graphs/repository-plan-report.json +++ b/docs/work-graphs/repository-plan-report.json @@ -10,9 +10,9 @@ }, "source": { "branch": "main", - "commit": "330876d31065e4f9fad6e801e92e87c65bf91939", + "commit": "66db8322b1d4ad68493b2f2fc64c81a4aa987edb", "generated_at": "2026-08-17", - "note": "This report describes the cited EDCM main commit plus the current repo-owned plan. Report-only and gonol-boundary documentation commits are coordination metadata; they do not upgrade measurement, empirical, proof, semantic, or canon status." + "note": "This report describes the cited EDCM state plus the current repo-owned plan. Report-only and language-boundary documentation commits are coordination metadata; they do not upgrade measurement, empirical, proof, semantic, or canon status. The current UCNS lexical-floor premise is deprecated and replaced by a dictionary-corpus direction with Scrabble dictionary authorized as the source class." }, "authority": { "owns": [ @@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ ], "does_not_own": [ "UCNS mathematical representation canon or UCNS proof status", - "UCNS Unicode-character-gonol identity, lexical-floor membership, word-gonol construction, or definition-gonol construction law", + "UCNS Unicode-character-gonol identity, dictionary-source selection, word-gonol construction, or definition-gonol construction law", "METAPAT semantic or ontology validity", "a0 runtime, agent identity, deployment, or orchestration authority", "skill-lib organization-wide build and cross-repository workflow doctrine" @@ -35,13 +35,14 @@ "candidate registration or development-fixture success does not select canon", "integrity of the maintained baseline does not establish empirical validation", "a UCNS gonol representation does not activate EDCM measurement or establish semantic validity", - "a floor-definition-gonol role analogy does not establish vector-embedding equivalence or efficacy", + "a dictionary-definition-gonol role analogy does not establish vector-embedding equivalence or efficacy", + "historical lexical-floor-named artifacts do not restore the deprecated lexical-floor premise as current architecture", "a falsified hypothesis remains research evidence and is not repaired by relabeling status" ] }, "portfolio_role": { - "summary": "Measure and pressure responses under declared constraints, maintain falsifiable measurement candidates and evidence states, and consume exact upstream gonol representations without treating representation as measurement validity or silently inserting token, subword, or opaque-vector layers.", - "upstream_contract": "EDCM consumes exact source evidence, declared semantic constraints where used, and pinned UCNS structural candidates, profiles, or future source-bound gonol receipts without inheriting their authority. The current language path is Unicode character gonols -> fixed floor word gonols -> closed lexical floor -> floor-definition gonols; UCNS owns that construction.", + "summary": "Measure and pressure responses under declared constraints, maintain falsifiable measurement candidates and evidence states, and consume exact upstream gonol representations without treating representation as measurement validity or silently inserting token, subword, opaque-vector, or whole-string-hash layers.", + "upstream_contract": "EDCM consumes exact source evidence, declared semantic constraints where used, and pinned UCNS structural candidates, profiles, or future dictionary-derived gonol receipts without inheriting their authority. The current lexical direction is Unicode character gonols -> dictionary words/entries -> word gonols -> dictionary definitions/senses -> definition gonols as first lexical recursion; UCNS owns that construction.", "downstream_contract": "EDCM emits measurement artifacts, experiment findings, receipts, and explicit evidence statuses that downstream systems may consume without upgrading them.", "reports_to": { "repository": "The-Interdependency/skill-lib", @@ -51,10 +52,10 @@ }, "status": { "state": "active research and measurement", - "current_claim": "EDCM supports represented, candidate-measured, and experiment-supported evidence in declared scopes; canon_selection remains null and empirical validation is not established. For language, EDCM is a downstream consumer of a gonol-native UCNS path: Unicode character gonols are primitive inscription objects, floor word gonols form a closed lexical floor, and semantic floor definitions must be gonols composed only from existing floor gonols. Existing arbitrary definition text and historical token/profile surfaces are not the completed semantic representation.", + "current_claim": "EDCM supports represented, candidate-measured, and experiment-supported evidence in declared scopes; canon_selection remains null and empirical validation is not established. For language, EDCM is a downstream consumer of a gonol-native UCNS path. The NGSL lexical-floor premise and fixed-list semantic closure are DEPRECATED. A Scrabble dictionary is authorized upstream as the replacement lexical source class; dictionary definitions will establish source-bound semantic relations among word gonols as the first lexical deep-recursion layer. Historical token/profile and lexical-floor-named surfaces remain sealed evidence only.", "latest_main_milestone": { - "commit": "0b9639d69eb0a15d9b16218fc1026a5939bf435f", - "description": "merged externally labelled MultiWOZ 2.1 booking-outcome holdout with weak above-chance balanced accuracy and a falsified sensitivity hypothesis" + "commit": "66db8322b1d4ad68493b2f2fc64c81a4aa987edb", + "description": "updated the EDCM consumer boundary to follow UCNS deprecation of the lexical floor and the dictionary-derived first-recursion replacement" } }, "delivered": [ @@ -85,14 +86,19 @@ }, { "surface": "gonol-native language consumer boundary", - "status": "documented against current UCNS lexical-floor closure authority", - "boundary": "documentation does not implement the unresolved upstream floor-definition-gonol composition law or select an EDCM semantic metric" + "status": "documented against current UCNS dictionary-replacement authority", + "boundary": "documentation does not implement the upstream dictionary corpus or select an EDCM semantic metric" + }, + { + "surface": "OEWN 2025 lexical-floor-named experiment", + "status": "sealed historical evidence", + "boundary": "the historical name and artifacts remain unchanged for reproduction; they do not define current lexical-floor architecture" } ], "active_frontier": [ - "preserve the gonol-native language boundary: Unicode character gonols -> fixed floor word gonols -> closed lexical floor -> floor-definition gonols, with no hidden tokenizer, subword, or opaque-vector substitution", - "prepare a fail-closed EDCM consumer contract for exact source-bound UCNS floor-definition-gonol receipts once the upstream producer exists", - "define the smallest preregistered EDCM evaluation that can test whether floor-definition-gonol relations perform useful semantic work against simpler or conventional baselines without promoting a role analogy into an efficacy claim", + "preserve the gonol-native language boundary: Unicode character gonols -> dictionary words/entries -> word gonols -> source-bound dictionary definitions/senses -> definition gonols as first lexical recursion, with no hidden tokenizer, subword, opaque-vector, or whole-string-hash substitution", + "prepare a fail-closed EDCM consumer contract for exact source-bound UCNS dictionary-definition-gonol receipts once the generalized upstream producer exists", + "define the smallest preregistered EDCM evaluation that can test whether dictionary-definition-gonol relations perform useful semantic work against simpler or conventional baselines without promoting a role analogy into an efficacy claim", "design the next genuinely new measurement candidate under the sealed holdout boundary rather than tuning the failed candidate", "preserve development, validation, sealed-test, candidate, witness, and decision authority separation", "pressure measurement candidates against real-system outcomes while retaining falsified and weak results", @@ -101,14 +107,14 @@ ], "next_actions": [ { - "action": "consume no completed lexical semantic embedding until UCNS emits exact replayable closed floor-definition-gonol receipts; reject arbitrary definition prose, tokenizer IDs, subword units, opaque vectors, and out-of-floor lexical support as substitutes", + "action": "consume no new lexical semantic representation until UCNS pins the exact authorized Scrabble dictionary source and emits generalized replayable dictionary-definition-gonol receipts; reject historical NGSL closure, tokenizer IDs, subword units, opaque vectors, and whole-string hashes as substitutes", "owner": "The-Interdependency/edcm", - "dependency": "upstream UCNS definition-gonol construction and source/custody procedure must exist first" + "dependency": "upstream UCNS dictionary source/custody identity and generalized first-recursion producer must exist first" }, { - "action": "after the upstream representation exists, freeze one EDCM projection, information-loss declaration, baseline set, hypotheses, metric, aggregation, partitions, stopping rules, and falsifiers before semantic outcome inspection", + "action": "after the upstream dictionary-derived representation exists, freeze one EDCM projection, information-loss declaration, baseline set, hypotheses, metric, aggregation, partitions, stopping rules, and falsifiers before semantic outcome inspection", "owner": "The-Interdependency/edcm", - "dependency": "exact UCNS lexical-floor identity and source-bound definition-gonol receipts" + "dependency": "exact UCNS dictionary corpus identity and source-bound definition-gonol receipts" }, { "action": "freeze the next experiment packet around one genuinely new measurement candidate with preregistered hypotheses, partitions, custody, stopping rules, failure conditions, and provenance", @@ -127,12 +133,12 @@ } ], "blocked": [ - "EDCM semantic integration of floor-definition gonols is BLOCKED until UCNS implements the closed definition-gonol producer and emits source-bound replayable receipts; documentation of the boundary is not implementation" + "EDCM semantic integration of dictionary-definition gonols is BLOCKED until UCNS pins the exact Scrabble dictionary source/custody identity, generalizes the PR #205 producer away from NGSL closure/2,809 coverage, and emits source-bound replayable receipts" ], "cross_repository_relations": [ { "repository": "The-Interdependency/ucns", - "relation": "upstream authority for Unicode-character gonols, lexical-floor membership and construction, word gonols, closed floor-definition-gonol construction, plus structural candidate and exact observation/profile producers for declared joint experiments", + "relation": "upstream authority for Unicode-character gonols, dictionary lexical construction, word gonols, dictionary-definition-gonol construction, plus structural candidate and exact observation/profile producers for declared joint experiments", "authority_transfer": false, "proof_status_transfer": false, "measurement_status_transfer": false @@ -155,14 +161,15 @@ "system_overview": "README.md", "canon": "CANON.md", "gonol_language_boundary": "docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md", + "historical_english_lexical_floor_run": "docs/ENGLISH_LEXICAL_FLOOR.md", "mathematics_index": "docs/EDCM_MATHEMATICS.md", "joint_experiment_program": "docs/UCNS_EDCM_EXPERIMENT_PROGRAM.md", "latest_holdout_design": "docs/experiments/2026-08-02-multiwoz-booking-outcome-holdout-design.md", "latest_holdout_findings": "docs/experiments/2026-08-02-multiwoz-booking-outcome-holdout-findings.md" }, "hmmm": [ - "the exact upstream UCNS relation/composition law for closed floor-definition gonols and its complete source/custody procedure", - "the EDCM projection, information-loss accounting, metric, benchmark, and falsifier for evaluating future floor-definition-gonol representations", + "the exact upstream Scrabble dictionary edition/source, machine-readable acquisition path, immutable source identity, license/custody/redistribution boundary, and generalized UCNS dictionary-definition-gonol producer identity", + "the EDCM projection, information-loss accounting, metric, benchmark, and falsifier for evaluating future dictionary-definition-gonol representations", "empirical validity of maintained and current candidate measurement surfaces", "selection of any final EDCM or joint UCNS-EDCM canon", "external custody arrangement for the next sealed test", From f1cb175c9c3d665c6b77ecf2bf16a032d5a3436a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Erin Spencer Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2026 22:23:37 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 3/4] canon(language): deprecate lexical floor --- CANON.md | 75 ++++++++++++++++++++++---------------------------------- 1 file changed, 29 insertions(+), 46 deletions(-) diff --git a/CANON.md b/CANON.md index 9392a05..ca9d4a4 100644 --- a/CANON.md +++ b/CANON.md @@ -29,49 +29,35 @@ This reciprocal loop is the intended meaning of **UCNS–EDCM canon**. ## Gonol language boundary -The stack's current language-object construction is gonol-native: +The prior **lexical-floor** construction is DEPRECATED. NGSL 1.2 is a word list, not the dictionary semantic source required for the active language path, and its fixed-list closure rule has no forward authority. + +UCNS has authorized a Scrabble dictionary as the replacement lexical source class. Exact edition/source identity and custody must be pinned upstream before ingestion. + +The current language-object direction is gonol-native: ```text Unicode character gonols ↓ -fixed floor word gonols +dictionary lexical entries / words ↓ -complete lexical floor F +word gonols ↓ -definitions expressed only with members of F +source-bound dictionary definitions and senses ↓ -floor-definition gonols +ordered semantic relationships among word gonols + ↓ +definition gonols = first lexical deep-recursion layer ``` -UCNS owns these language-object construction rules. Unicode character gonols are -the primitive inscription objects. Once the lexical floor `F` is admitted, its -floor definitions are closed over that floor: +The semantic relationships expressed by the dictionary definitions are themselves the first lexical recursive layer. They are not metadata awaiting a later embedding step. -```text -support(definition_gonol(word, sense)) ⊆ F -``` - -A definition that needs lexical material outside `F` is not a floor definition -and does not expand the floor. The current path does not insert conventional NLP -tokens, token IDs, subword pieces, or an opaque external embedding lookup. -Arbitrary source definition text may remain provenance but is not itself a -floor-definition gonol. +The replacement path does not insert conventional NLP token IDs, subword IDs, opaque external embedding vectors, or whole-string cryptographic hashes. Source definition prose may remain custody evidence; the semantic representation is the source-bound gonol relationship structure constructed from it. -A floor-definition gonol is intended to occupy the semantic-representation role -for which conventional systems commonly use vector embeddings. That analogy -establishes no semantic quality, metric behavior, equivalence, benchmark -advantage, or downstream utility. +A dictionary-derived definition gonol is intended to occupy the semantic-representation role commonly served by vector embeddings. That analogy establishes no semantic quality, metric behavior, equivalence, benchmark advantage, or downstream utility. -EDCM may consume exact UCNS gonol identities and source-bound receipts only -under an explicit consumer contract. Any EDCM scalar projection or measurement -must separately declare its mapping and information loss. UCNS representation -does not activate or validate EDCM measurement; EDCM outcomes do not validate -UCNS semantics, proof status, or construction law. +EDCM may consume exact UCNS gonol identities and source-bound receipts only under an explicit consumer contract. Any EDCM scalar projection or measurement must separately declare its mapping and information loss. UCNS representation does not activate or validate EDCM measurement; EDCM outcomes do not validate UCNS semantics, proof status, or construction law. -Historical EDCM experiment or profile surfaces may retain `token` and -`word-gonol` terminology where those names are part of frozen evidence. Such -terms do not create a tokenizer layer or redefine the current lexical primitive. -Historical artifacts are not rewritten by this correction. +Historical EDCM experiment or profile surfaces may retain `token`, `lexical-floor`, and `word-gonol` terminology where those names are part of frozen evidence. Such terms do not create a tokenizer layer or restore the deprecated lexical-floor premise as current architecture. Historical artifacts are not rewritten by this correction. See [`docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md`](docs/GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md). @@ -196,14 +182,15 @@ Where discourse graphs are involved, the experiment must additionally retain: For new language-semantic experiments, the experiment must additionally retain: -- the exact UCNS lexical-floor identity; -- source-bound floor-definition-gonol receipt identities; -- floor-closure verification for every admitted definition; -- constituent order, multiplicity, sense, context, source, and provenance; -- explicit failure on tokenizer, subword, opaque-vector, or out-of-floor substitution; +- the exact UCNS dictionary-corpus and source identity; +- source-bound dictionary-definition-gonol receipt identities; +- constituent order, multiplicity, occurrence position, sense, context, source, and provenance; +- explicit failure on tokenizer, subword, opaque-vector, or whole-string-hash substitution; - the EDCM projection and declared information loss separately from the UCNS representation; and - preregistered comparison criteria before semantic or downstream outcome inspection. +Historical lexical-floor artifacts may be reproduced against their original exact inputs, but their fixed-list closure criteria are not forward experiment requirements. + Hypothesis failure is a valid experiment result and must not be converted into a build failure merely to preserve a preferred model. ## Non-transfer firewall @@ -217,6 +204,7 @@ candidate_registration_implies_canon = false passing_development_fixtures_implies_canon = false majority_candidate_agreement_implies_truth = false definition_gonol_role_analogy_implies_embedding_efficacy = false +historical_lexical_floor_name_implies_current_floor_architecture = false NA_equals_zero = false ``` @@ -233,7 +221,7 @@ This phase may implement: - positive unresolved-reference and alternative-bundle evidence; - reproducible reports and policy-preservation findings; - CI execution against an exact UCNS commit; -- fail-closed consumer validation for future source-bound definition-gonol receipts; and +- fail-closed consumer validation for future source-bound dictionary-definition-gonol receipts; and - preregistered EDCM evaluations of those receipts once the upstream construction exists. This phase may not promote: @@ -244,8 +232,9 @@ This phase may not promote: - canonical product character `M`; - canonical faithful breadth `B`; - canonical discourse resolver, relation vocabulary, or graph precedence; -- arbitrary dictionary prose into a floor-definition gonol; -- a tokenizer, subword vocabulary, or opaque vector lookup into the gonol-native language path; +- arbitrary dictionary prose into a completed semantic relation without source-bound gonol construction; +- the deprecated NGSL closed-floor rule into the replacement dictionary path; +- a tokenizer, subword vocabulary, opaque vector lookup, or whole-string hash into the gonol-native language path; - definition-gonol role analogy into a claim of embedding replacement efficacy; - diagnosis, intention, morality, consciousness, or external truth claims; - a complete production `UCNSObject` or EDCM deployment contract. @@ -262,14 +251,8 @@ python -m edcm.ucns_edcm_experiments_v4 \ Every report is research evidence. No report is a canon file, and no report may be renamed or imported as one. -For new semantic work, do not treat EDCM's existing arbitrary definition strings or historical word-profile outputs as completed floor-definition gonols. Consume the exact future UCNS producer receipt, freeze the EDCM mapping and falsifier, then evaluate. +For new semantic work, do not treat EDCM's existing arbitrary definition strings, historical word-profile outputs, or lexical-floor-named artifacts as the current semantic basis. Consume the exact future UCNS dictionary-derived producer receipt, freeze the EDCM mapping and falsifier, then evaluate. ## hmmm -The exact UCNS relation/composition law for closed floor-definition gonols and -the source/custody procedure for a complete closed definition set remain -upstream unresolved boundaries. EDCM has not yet selected a lawful projection, -metric, benchmark, or falsifier for evaluating that future representation. -External holdout custody, independently authored graph annotations, human -outcome labels, multilingual evidence, separate implementation replication, and -the authority procedure for the first joint canon selection also remain open. +The exact Scrabble dictionary edition/source, machine-readable acquisition, immutable source identity, and custody/redistribution boundary remain upstream UCNS source questions. UCNS must also generalize its first-recursion producer away from NGSL closure and 2,809-target coverage before EDCM consumes the replacement representation. EDCM has not yet selected a lawful projection, metric, benchmark, or falsifier for evaluating that future representation. External holdout custody, independently authored graph annotations, human outcome labels, multilingual evidence, separate implementation replication, and the authority procedure for the first joint canon selection also remain open. From 2692d91c15278a92d2cc8bff7cb5ca09a003f9a2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Erin Spencer Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2026 22:23:55 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 4/4] docs(lexical): mark OEWN lexical-floor run historical --- docs/ENGLISH_LEXICAL_FLOOR.md | 134 +++++++++------------------------- 1 file changed, 34 insertions(+), 100 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/ENGLISH_LEXICAL_FLOOR.md b/docs/ENGLISH_LEXICAL_FLOOR.md index 8af332f..4b06b54 100644 --- a/docs/ENGLISH_LEXICAL_FLOOR.md +++ b/docs/ENGLISH_LEXICAL_FLOOR.md @@ -1,47 +1,25 @@ # English lexical floor: EDCM evidence on UCNS representation -Status: `SURVIVED` only after the complete frozen run and independent replay -agree. This system represents lexical evidence; it does not prove a linguistic, -mathematical, geometric, empirical, or architectural claim. +Status: `SURVIVED` only after the complete frozen run and independent replay agree. This system represents lexical evidence; it does not prove a linguistic, mathematical, geometric, empirical, or architectural claim. -The file and artifact name are retained because they identify a completed EDCM -OEWN evidence run. They do **not** make this EDCM construction the authority for -the stack's current UCNS lexical floor. The current gonol-native language -boundary is recorded separately in -[`GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md`](GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md). +## Historical-name notice + +The file and artifact name are retained because they identify a completed EDCM OEWN evidence run. The stack-level **lexical-floor** premise is now DEPRECATED. This historical name does not define current UCNS lexical architecture and must not be read forward as a fixed-list semantic closure requirement. + +Current lexical construction is recorded separately in [`GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md`](GONOL_LANGUAGE_BOUNDARY.md): UCNS now targets a source-bound dictionary corpus, with a Scrabble dictionary authorized as the replacement source class once exact edition/source custody is pinned. ## Work graph -- `The-Interdependency/skill-lib@6ef2e4c123225f9db20e5230e5894c9c86b42ee6` - owns the build/evidence discipline used by this sealed run. -- `globalwordnet/english-wordnet@dc343f2683279ecbb13fab4e2fd778d7b162d287` - is the licensed OEWN 2025 lexical evidence source. -- `The-Interdependency/ucns@d7c6f51304ed6c32d48badf63132bea6de8af497` - owns the exact metadata-free ordered relational producer consumed by this - sealed run. -- this EDCM run owns English source ingestion, affix inventory, reversible - rendering candidates, decomposition evidence, identity bindings, freezing, - and comparison. - -For current architecture rather than reproduction of this run, -`The-Interdependency/ucns@d54c3b6b4d9867f7bc6b968e0424d702504b8497` -records the later lexical-floor closure boundary: Unicode character gonols are -the primitive inscription objects; fixed floor word gonols form the admitted -lexical floor; floor definitions may use only members of that floor; and the -resulting semantic objects are floor-definition gonols. That later declaration -does not rewrite this run or upgrade its evidence. - -No relation transfers semantic authority, proof status, certification, -measurement validity, empirical validity, or canon standing. Artifact digests -are identities, not producer signatures. +- `The-Interdependency/skill-lib@6ef2e4c123225f9db20e5230e5894c9c86b42ee6` owns the build/evidence discipline used by this sealed run. +- `globalwordnet/english-wordnet@dc343f2683279ecbb13fab4e2fd778d7b162d287` is the licensed OEWN 2025 lexical evidence source. +- `The-Interdependency/ucns@d7c6f51304ed6c32d48badf63132bea6de8af497` owns the exact metadata-free ordered relational producer consumed by this sealed run. +- this EDCM run owns English source ingestion, affix inventory, reversible rendering candidates, decomposition evidence, identity bindings, freezing, and comparison. + +No relation transfers semantic authority, proof status, certification, measurement validity, empirical validity, or canon standing. Artifact digests are identities, not producer signatures. ## Reproducible run -Install EDCM with `lexical-floor`, then clone the exact UCNS producer checkout -used by this historical EDCM construction. Do **not** substitute the later UCNS -head when reproducing the sealed artifacts. The builder reads and freshly -compiles the verified committed producer bytes; the checkout does not need to -be installed into the environment: +Install EDCM with `lexical-floor`, then clone the exact UCNS producer checkout used by this historical EDCM construction. Do **not** substitute a later UCNS head when reproducing the sealed artifacts. The historical package-extra name is retained for replay only. ```bash python -m pip install -e '.[lexical-floor]' @@ -60,94 +38,50 @@ python tools/build_oewn2025_embeddings.py \ --acquire --resume ``` -Acquisition checks the exact Git commit and release tag. Ingestion freezes the -license, source-tree digest, file and evidence counts. A valid completed branch -receipt may be reused with `--resume` only after every manifest-listed file, -branch receipt, external binding, intrinsic carrier, producer commit, and -producer-module digest is revalidated. Partial or altered state fails closed. +Acquisition checks the exact Git commit and release tag. Ingestion freezes the license, source-tree digest, file and evidence counts. A valid completed branch receipt may be reused with `--resume` only after every manifest-listed file, branch receipt, external binding, intrinsic carrier, producer commit, and producer-module digest is revalidated. Partial or altered state fails closed. -Single construction and comparison outputs remain `UNRESOLVED`. Only the -separate two-clean-run seal may record `SURVIVED` after byte identity is -observed. +Single construction and comparison outputs remain `UNRESOLVED`. Only the separate two-clean-run seal may record `SURVIVED` after byte identity is observed. -The direct-atomic branch is constructed from whole-word, sense, synset, and -OEWN relation evidence without reading molecular output. The molecular branch -is independently constructed from the materialized surface set, versioned EDCM -affix inventory, reversible transformation rules, roots, explicit compounds, -and every admitted immediate decomposition. Neither branch derives from the -other. Both intrinsic carriers and their external identity bindings are frozen -before comparison. +The direct-atomic branch is constructed from whole-word, sense, synset, and OEWN relation evidence without reading molecular output. The molecular branch is independently constructed from the materialized surface set, versioned EDCM affix inventory, reversible transformation rules, roots, explicit compounds, and every admitted immediate decomposition. Neither branch derives from the other. Both intrinsic carriers and their external identity bindings are frozen before comparison. -Intrinsic `*.ucns.json` files contain only dense integer occurrence addresses, -ordered directed typed integer relations, schema identity, and false transfer -flags. English strings and provenance live in sibling `*.binding.json` files. +Intrinsic `*.ucns.json` files contain only dense integer occurrence addresses, ordered directed typed integer relations, schema identity, and false transfer flags. English strings and provenance live in sibling `*.binding.json` files. -## Gonol interpretation boundary +## Current gonol interpretation boundary -The current stack language path is: +This sealed run does **not** define the current lexical basis. + +The current upstream direction is: ```text Unicode character gonols ↓ -fixed floor word gonols +dictionary lexical entries / words ↓ -complete lexical floor F +word gonols ↓ -definitions expressed only with members of F +source-bound dictionary definitions and senses ↓ -floor-definition gonols -``` - -This EDCM OEWN run does not implement that complete semantic construction. -In particular, OEWN definition strings loaded by EDCM are **source prose and -provenance evidence**. Arbitrary definition text is not thereby a -floor-definition gonol. - -For a future floor-definition gonol, the upstream closure condition is: - -```text -support(definition_gonol(word, sense)) ⊆ F +ordered semantic relationships among word gonols + ↓ +definition gonols = first lexical deep-recursion layer ``` -A proposed definition that requires an out-of-floor word must fail as a floor -definition rather than silently expanding `F`. No tokenizer, token ID, subword -piece, or opaque external vector lookup may be inserted to bypass that closure. +The former rule requiring definitions to close over a fixed NGSL word set is deprecated. OEWN definition strings loaded by this historical EDCM run remain source prose and provenance evidence; they are not automatically promoted into the replacement UCNS dictionary-definition-gonol representation. -The intended definition-gonol role is analogous to the semantic-representation -role of a conventional vector embedding. This run establishes no equivalence, -semantic quality, similarity behavior, benchmark advantage, or downstream -utility for that representation. +The current definition-gonol role remains analogous to the semantic-representation role of conventional vector embeddings. This historical run establishes no equivalence, semantic quality, similarity behavior, benchmark advantage, or downstream utility for that representation. ## Evidence interpretation -“Root”, “affix”, “direct-atomic”, and “molecular” name EDCM’s bounded OEWN and -inventory-relative evidence senses. They are not universal English -construction authority and are not substitutions for UCNS floor-gonol -identities. All matching affix alternatives and explicit marked compounds are -retained. Closed-compound analysis and pronunciation remain outside this run. +“Root”, “affix”, “direct-atomic”, and “molecular” name EDCM’s bounded OEWN and inventory-relative evidence senses. They are not universal English construction authority and are not substitutions for current UCNS dictionary-derived word/definition-gonol identities. All matching affix alternatives and explicit marked compounds are retained. Closed-compound analysis and pronunciation remain outside this run. -The comparison preserves agreement and disagreement between independently -frozen representations. It establishes neither equivalence nor superiority. -Repeated complete runs may claim determinism only when every manifest-listed -artifact digest and byte stream agrees. +The comparison preserves agreement and disagreement between independently frozen representations. It establishes neither equivalence nor superiority. Repeated complete runs may claim determinism only when every manifest-listed artifact digest and byte stream agrees. ## Usage guidance -Use this document and its pinned commits when reproducing or auditing the sealed -OEWN relational construction. Do not repin it to current UCNS and do not rewrite -its artifacts to use later terminology. +Use this document and its pinned commits only when reproducing or auditing the sealed OEWN relational construction. Do not repin it to current UCNS and do not rewrite its historical artifacts or filenames. -For new lexical-semantic construction, use the current UCNS lexical-floor and -definition-gonol producer contract instead. EDCM should become a consumer only -after exact source-bound definition-gonol receipts exist and an EDCM mapping is -separately declared and frozen. +For new lexical-semantic construction, follow current UCNS dictionary-corpus authority rather than this historical lexical-floor run. EDCM becomes a consumer only after UCNS pins the exact dictionary source and emits generalized source-bound definition-gonol receipts; any EDCM mapping must then be separately declared and frozen. ## hmmm -The exact UCNS relation/composition law for composing ordered floor-word gonols -into a closed definition gonol remains unresolved upstream, as does the -source/custody procedure for a complete definition set expressible entirely -inside the fixed floor. EDCM has not selected the corresponding consumer -projection, metric, benchmark, or falsifier. Canonical English morphology, -upstream signatures, and phrase/sentence/discourse semantic constructions also -remain unresolved; none are manufactured by this sealed OEWN run. +The exact Scrabble dictionary edition/source, machine-readable acquisition, immutable source identity, license/custody/redistribution boundary, and generalized UCNS dictionary-definition-gonol producer remain upstream unresolved. EDCM has not selected the corresponding consumer projection, metric, benchmark, or falsifier. Canonical English morphology, upstream signatures, and phrase/sentence/discourse semantic constructions also remain unresolved; none are manufactured by this sealed OEWN run.