diff --git a/ahbg/calibration-evidence/CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.json b/ahbg/calibration-evidence/CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..593825a --- /dev/null +++ b/ahbg/calibration-evidence/CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.json @@ -0,0 +1,131 @@ +{ + "schema": "interdependency.ahbg.calibration-evidence/1.0.0", + "standing": "experiment-receipts-not-production-workspaces", + "extracted_from": { + "closed_prs": [18, 19], + "branch_heads_at_extraction": { + "agent/ahbg-codex": "af67642f987124f91aad63e4583422602ed508eb", + "agent/ahbg-deepcode": "34648ed63e8e41c8dc775ecc59a253257c5a9de8", + "agent/ahbg-grok": "03e77a33f2a79bc586c25b17e04147a29a187218" + }, + "policy": "provider workspace trees under stack/ahbg/codex and stack/ahbg/deepseek are not merged into main; only comparison results, corpus receipts, and reproducible calibration evidence are carried here." + }, + "builders": [ + { + "builder": "Grok", + "branch": "agent/ahbg-grok", + "frozen_build_sha": "cce9cec7dae61304118efcd47bc0d7461200d335", + "successor_corpus_run": { + "scenarios": 35, + "survived": 35, + "falsified": 0, + "unresolved": 0, + "blocked": 0 + } + }, + { + "builder": "Codex", + "branch": "agent/ahbg-codex", + "frozen_build_sha": "ffb64c274583d8539f8f4fe7e0aa77366689e910", + "freeze_verification": { + "a0_tests": "7 OK", + "ahbg_tests": "12 OK", + "python_compile": "15 files OK", + "artifact_check": "SURVIVED", + "calibration_smoke_summary": { + "survived": 4, + "falsified": 0, + "unresolved": 2, + "blocked": 0 + } + }, + "successor_corpus_run": { + "scenarios": 35, + "survived": 35, + "falsified": 0, + "unresolved": 0, + "blocked": 0 + }, + "evidence_caveat": "Codex recorded that its conversation inspected sibling DeepCode/DeepSeek files before the workspace correction; the frozen implementation lives under stack/ahbg/codex and does not import sibling code." + }, + { + "builder": "DeepCode", + "branch": "agent/ahbg-deepcode", + "frozen_build_sha": "ec07f465184e7a37af856bc5b301bd8eaa4f097b", + "coordination_base_commit": "8fd2923292361b1956a003bd5c74eae50a5323b0", + "successor_corpus_run": { + "scenarios": 35, + "survived": 35, + "falsified": 0, + "unresolved": 0, + "blocked": 0 + } + } + ], + "corpus_receipt": { + "corpus_id": "calibration-family", + "proposal_version": "1.0.1-proposal-1", + "scenario_count": 35, + "canonical_scenarios_sha256": "371d2361f57b56d73544f58b247704617d550a7a0685a133c4f8b1ff3b36c835", + "corpus_json_sha256_at_successor_runs": "ea172cb68a1a31be843f45c9886590f95f60daad4f10b9e42732bfd416ef73ab", + "canonical_main_corpus_file_sha256": "bc521113ffa7bd6d5094c71f3ad66547d5f00260f380258e43c2086533a5d7ed", + "canonical_main_corpus_path": "ahbg/deepseek/corpus-proposal/corpus.json", + "note": "canonical main re-serialized the corpus file after the successor runs; the scenario digest is unchanged. Both file digests are recorded so the successor-run receipt remains reproducible.", + "predecessor": { + "proposal_version": "1.0.0-proposal-1", + "canonical_scenarios_sha256": "b05cba2cf2f15583548cc15158f09e2612545c978b6a42ddeb314f1e4ed0e5e0", + "merged_to_main_as": "3a92c7b0f8568e6fc2600b45bca760030ea2ba3f", + "merged_via_pr": 5 + } + }, + "directional_checks": [ + { + "checker": "Grok", + "subject": "Codex", + "subject_frozen_build": "ffb64c274583d8539f8f4fe7e0aa77366689e910", + "standing": "SURVIVED", + "checker_artifact": "ahbg/grok/reviews/codex-review.json" + }, + { + "checker": "Grok", + "subject": "DeepCode", + "subject_frozen_build": "ec07f465184e7a37af856bc5b301bd8eaa4f097b", + "standing": "SURVIVED", + "checker_artifact": "ahbg/grok/reviews/deepcode-review.json" + }, + { + "checker": "Codex", + "subject": "Grok", + "subject_frozen_build": "cce9cec7dae61304118efcd47bc0d7461200d335", + "standing": "SURVIVED", + "checker_artifact": "ahbg/codex/reviews/grok-review.json" + }, + { + "checker": "Codex", + "subject": "DeepCode", + "subject_frozen_build": "ec07f465184e7a37af856bc5b301bd8eaa4f097b", + "standing": "SURVIVED", + "checker_artifact": "ahbg/codex/reviews/deepcode-review.json" + }, + { + "checker": "DeepCode", + "subject": "Grok", + "subject_frozen_build": "cce9cec7dae61304118efcd47bc0d7461200d335", + "standing": "SURVIVED", + "checker_artifact": "ahbg/deepseek/reviews/grok-review.json" + }, + { + "checker": "DeepCode", + "subject": "Codex", + "subject_frozen_build": "ffb64c274583d8539f8f4fe7e0aa77366689e910", + "standing": "SURVIVED", + "checker_artifact": "ahbg/deepseek/reviews/codex-review.json" + } + ], + "hmmm": [ + "world-digest mismatches remain 35 of 35 in the burden-coupling comparison (expected while standing is binding);", + "formal sealing of the successor corpus is recorded as adopted on main, not as a three-way branch merge;", + "Codex evidence caveat about inspecting sibling files before workspace correction is preserved and not erased;", + "provider workspace trees on the closed branches are receipts only and are intentionally not merged." + ] +} diff --git a/ahbg/calibration-evidence/CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.md b/ahbg/calibration-evidence/CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..47d2022 --- /dev/null +++ b/ahbg/calibration-evidence/CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.md @@ -0,0 +1,74 @@ +# AHBG calibration evidence + +Extracted from the closed calibration PRs #18 (Codex) and #19 (DeepCode) on +2026-09-01. The provider workspace trees (`stack/ahbg/codex`, +`stack/ahbg/deepseek`) remain branch-resident experiment receipts; only the +comparison results, corpus receipts, and reproducible calibration evidence are +carried here. + +Machine-readable record: [`CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.json`](CALIBRATION_EVIDENCE.json). + +## Frozen builds + +| Builder | Branch | Frozen build SHA | +|---|---|---| +| Grok | `agent/ahbg-grok` | `cce9cec7dae61304118efcd47bc0d7461200d335` | +| Codex | `agent/ahbg-codex` | `ffb64c274583d8539f8f4fe7e0aa77366689e910` | +| DeepCode | `agent/ahbg-deepcode` | `ec07f465184e7a37af856bc5b301bd8eaa4f097b` | + +Branch heads at extraction: Codex `af67642`, DeepCode `34648ed`, Grok `03e77a3`. + +## Successor corpus receipt + +- Corpus `calibration-family`, proposal `1.0.1-proposal-1`, 35 scenarios. +- Canonical scenarios digest: + `371d2361f57b56d73544f58b247704617d550a7a0685a133c4f8b1ff3b36c835`. +- Corpus JSON file digest at the successor runs: + `ea172cb68a1a31be843f45c9886590f95f60daad4f10b9e42732bfd416ef73ab`. +- Canonical main re-serialized the corpus file; current + `ahbg/deepseek/corpus-proposal/corpus.json` file digest is + `bc521113ffa7bd6d5094c71f3ad66547d5f00260f380258e43c2086533a5d7ed` + with the same scenario digest. +- Predecessor `1.0.0-proposal-1`, digest + `b05cba2cf2f15583548cc15158f09e2612545c978b6a42ddeb314f1e4ed0e5e0`, + merged to main as `3a92c7b0` via PR #5. + +## Successor runs + +All three builders: **35 SURVIVED / 0 FALSIFIED / 0 UNRESOLVED / 0 BLOCKED**. + +Codex freeze verification: `a0` tests 7 OK, `ahbg` tests 12 OK, Python +compile 15 files OK, artifact check SURVIVED, calibration smoke summary +4 survived / 0 falsified / 2 unresolved / 0 blocked. + +## Six directional checks — all SURVIVED + +| Checker | Subject | Subject frozen build | Checker artifact | +|---|---|---|---| +| Grok | Codex | `ffb64c2` | `ahbg/grok/reviews/codex-review.json` | +| Grok | DeepCode | `ec07f46` | `ahbg/grok/reviews/deepcode-review.json` | +| Codex | Grok | `cce9cec` | `ahbg/codex/reviews/grok-review.json` | +| Codex | DeepCode | `ec07f46` | `ahbg/codex/reviews/deepcode-review.json` | +| DeepCode | Grok | `cce9cec` | `ahbg/deepseek/reviews/grok-review.json` | +| DeepCode | Codex | `ffb64c2` | `ahbg/deepseek/reviews/codex-review.json` | + +No builder was falsified. Agreement across independent builds is replication +evidence, not proof. + +## Evidence caveats (preserved, not erased) + +- Codex recorded that its conversation inspected sibling DeepCode/DeepSeek + files before the workspace correction; the frozen implementation lives under + `stack/ahbg/codex` and does not import sibling code. +- DeepCode's frozen build was reviewed by Grok and Codex; later commits on the + branch are metadata, extension evidence, and reciprocal-review records that + do not alter the frozen implementation. + +## hmmm + +- World-digest mismatches remain 35 of 35 in the burden-coupling comparison + (expected while standing is binding). +- Formal successor sealing is recorded as adopted on main, not as a three-way + branch merge. +- Provider workspace trees on the closed branches are receipts only and are + intentionally not merged into main.