Right now, speedwalk does not handle OSM access tags.
It does use them for some special foot and bicycle cases, but not in general.
My question is: Is this all we need for our routing use cases?
The access data that is straight from OSM ist included in the export, so we can filter the export or treat them as special cases during routing ("allow private from from/to parts of the route at the start and end").
But I wonder if we are missing something for Speedwalk by not handling access tags explicitly.
One case that came up is, that the routable networks UI shows an routable island because there is no direct connection (which in this case is due to the main road being a non-footway-relevant highway=tertiary)
https://a-b-street.github.io/speedwalk/#14.64/52.76118/13.16528
https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/52.76014/13.15905&layers=N
So I guess one thing we could do is to add a style that somehow shows private access differently. But the questions the are, what the conditions are (which access, foot, … tags to handle how) and why we actually do this, like what is the call to action…
Right now, speedwalk does not handle OSM
accesstags.It does use them for some special foot and bicycle cases, but not in general.
My question is: Is this all we need for our routing use cases?
The access data that is straight from OSM ist included in the export, so we can filter the export or treat them as special cases during routing ("allow private from from/to parts of the route at the start and end").
But I wonder if we are missing something for Speedwalk by not handling access tags explicitly.
One case that came up is, that the routable networks UI shows an routable island because there is no direct connection (which in this case is due to the main road being a non-footway-relevant highway=tertiary)
So I guess one thing we could do is to add a style that somehow shows private access differently. But the questions the are,
what the conditions are(whichaccess,foot, … tags to handle how) andwhy we actually do this, like what is the call to action…