diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 25cecbe..bf9aee0 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -40,10 +40,20 @@ which owns fingerprinting, comparison, baseline sealing and the report honesty r **Note on the Copilot entry.** It is a pull-request status check rather than a session hook, because Copilot's composition lives in the repository. It emits no -TRACE record and no Agent Manifest yet, so it claims neither: `integrates_with` in -the manifest schema offers only `cmcp`, `trace` and `agent-manifest`, and asserting -one of those today would be an unverifiable claim. Emitting a TRACE record per -checked pull request is the intended next step and is what would make one true. +TRACE record and no Agent Manifest, so it claims neither: `integrates_with` offers +only `cmcp`, `trace` and `agent-manifest`, and asserting one today would be an +unverifiable claim. + +That is currently blocked on a spec question rather than on implementation, tracked +in [agent-manifest#256](https://github.com/agentrust-io/agent-manifest/issues/256). +TRACE describes an execution and this check describes a composition, so a TRACE +record is the wrong artifact. Agent Manifest is the right one, but every level +requires `artifacts.model_identity`, and a repository cannot know the model: Copilot +picks it at session time from the user's plan and settings. The same repository +serves every model, with an identical contributed composition. Manufacturing a +model to satisfy the field would be exactly the kind of unverifiable claim +`CONTRIBUTING.md` rules out, so the integration ships without one until the spec +has a way to express a composition whose model is unknowable at authoring time. ## Community diff --git a/copilot/README.md b/copilot/README.md index ef7a4e7..45db20e 100644 --- a/copilot/README.md +++ b/copilot/README.md @@ -95,6 +95,23 @@ two other engines in this repo, so the shared core covers the tree. outside the repository and are invisible to a check that runs inside it. If your organisation sets Copilot instructions centrally, this check does not see them. - **It is not a sandbox.** It reports composition, it does not constrain execution. +- **It emits no signed record**, unlike the other integrations here, and that is a + spec question rather than a missing feature. See + [agent-manifest#256](https://github.com/agentrust-io/agent-manifest/issues/256). + + A TRACE record is the wrong artifact: TRACE describes an execution, and this check + describes a composition. Agent Manifest is the right one, and every level requires + `artifacts.model_identity`. A repository cannot know the model. Copilot chooses it + at session time from the user's plan and settings, so the same repository serves + every model with an identical contributed composition. + + `provider: github, model_id: copilot` would describe a product rather than a + model, and `model_id: unknown` would assert a binding to a thing called "unknown". + Either is the sort of unverifiable claim this repository's contributing rules + exclude, so the check ships without a record until the spec can express a + composition whose model is unknowable when it is authored. Notably the verifier + vocabulary already has `NOT_BOUND` for every artifact, and no conformant manifest + can currently produce it. ## Inputs