From c920d6e0b73ec36ad0328c00d9eb29f632c5af42 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:19:37 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] v0.1.1: report unlocked compute in IT power; add the sorption re-cooling limit Corrections from the cross-repository review in aska-physical/optifab. - Freed utility power is not IT power. The 3.06 MW freed carries 2.85 to 2.96 MW of new IT load. The low-end revenue falls from 76.62 to 71.35 M USD a year, and a high end (147.95) is added to the certificate. - The certificate now carries the drive, chilled-water and design re-cooling temperatures, the reversible COP limit at each, and the highest re-cooling temperature at which the 0.62 adsorption COP is possible (41.46 C). The 30 C design value is new and needs the owner's confirmation. - Two must-fail controls added (13, 14) and two SymPy identities. - The certificate names every declared input and the one control that compares only declared inputs (10). No structural, acoustic, vibration, seismic or storage result changes. Prepared by an AI agent; awaiting human sign-off. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_012tWK9W6CVMEDEnj5eQTe6K --- CHANGELOG.md | 15 ++++++++ HANDOFF.md | 15 +++++--- README.md | 9 ++--- docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md | 2 +- results/certificate.json | 58 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--- verify.py | 68 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++----- 6 files changed, 144 insertions(+), 23 deletions(-) diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 65287fa..a0fa218 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -2,6 +2,21 @@ All notable machine-verified engineering milestones for `aska-physical/funi-frame`. +## [0.1.1] — 2026-11-17 + +Corrections from the cross-repository review in [`aska-physical/optifab`](/aska-physical/optifab) (`HANDOFF.md` §3). Prepared by an AI agent; awaiting human sign-off. + +### Changed +- **Unlocked compute is reported in IT power, not utility power.** The `3.06 MW` of freed substation power carries **`2.85–2.96 MW`** of new IT load (`P_freed / PUE` if every overhead scales with load; `P_freed / (1 + 1/COP_loop)` if only the `ATES` loop does). `unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd` falls from `76.62` to **`71.35`**, and `unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd` (**`147.95`**) is now in the certificate. `README.md` §6 retitled from "Freed Compute Power" to "Freed Utility Power". This assumes the `$25–$50M/MW-yr` value is per MW of IT load. + +### Added +- **Re-cooling temperature and its second-law limit (`Theorem 5`, `Must-fail #13`).** The certificate now carries `T_drive_supply_C = 58`, `T_chilled_water_C = 18`, `T_recooling_design_C = 30`, the reversible COP limit at design re-cooling (`2.051`) and at `45 °C` dry re-cooling (`0.423`), and `T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C = 41.46`. The `30 °C` design value is a choice made in this version and needs the owner's confirmation. +- **`Must-fail #14`:** freed utility power may not be counted as IT power. +- **`declared_inputs` and `controls_on_declared_inputs_only`** in the certificate: every value that is stated from the literature or the design brief rather than computed, and the one control (`#10`) that compares only such values. + +### Not changed +- No structural, acoustic, vibration, seismic or storage result. `PUE`, `WUE` and all `12` original controls are as in `v0.1.0`. + ## [0.1.0] — 2026-11-16 ### Added diff --git a/HANDOFF.md b/HANDOFF.md index 8f1b57c..b30f71b 100644 --- a/HANDOFF.md +++ b/HANDOFF.md @@ -1,8 +1,8 @@ -# Inter-Agent Handoff — `aska-physical/funi-frame` (`v0.1.0`) +# Inter-Agent Handoff — `aska-physical/funi-frame` (`v0.1.1`) Prepared per the Aska group ethos (*maximal autonomy and agency; capture every computation, decision, and negative finding so downstream agents build forward without re-deriving*). -## 1. What Was Learned, Proved, and Verified (`v0.1.0`) +## 1. What Was Learned, Proved, and Verified (`v0.1.0`–`v0.1.1`) - **Theorem 1 — Hysteretic (`Fe-Mn-Si` / `CLD`) vs. Viscous High-Frequency Isolation Roll-Off (`SymPy + Must-fail #7`):** - Classic Kelvin-Voigt viscous dampers suffer high-frequency damper lock-up: $\lim_{r\to\infty} r\,T_{\text{visc}}(r,\zeta) = 2\zeta > 0$ (`-20 dB/decade`), leaking `29.5–120+ Hz` chiller, pump, and genset harmonics into server cabinets (`0.137 g_rms` on conventional steel frames). Rate-independent martensitic (`Fe-Mn-Si`, `4.5 Hz`, $\eta_1 = 0.16$) and viscoelastic `±45°` CFRP Constrained-Layer Damping (`CLD`, `9.2 Hz`, $\eta_2 = 0.12$) follow $\lim_{r\to\infty} r^2 T_{\text{hyst}}(r,\eta) = \sqrt{1+\eta^2}$ (`-40 dB/decade`), holding white-space rack vibration to **`0.000090 g_rms <= 0.000500 g_rms`** (`17.91%` of `STRUCTURE Magazine` optical/director-switch ceiling, `-63.69 dB` improvement). @@ -12,16 +12,21 @@ Prepared per the Aska group ethos (*maximal autonomy and agency; capture every c - Plain chilled water over a `9 K` delta-T stores only `11.5 kWh_th/m³`, exhausting an `83.33 m³` mechanical buffer in `5.75 min`. Encapsulated `savE HS24` salt hydrate (`30.0 kWh_th/m³`, Osterman et al. 2023) delivers a full **`15.0 min` (`2.5 MWh_th`)** ride-through in `-61.67%` less tank volume, while the outer `~5.2 mm` active Biot penetration skin (`eta_biot = 0.10`) of `28 °C` `mPCM`-doped Poraver wall/ceiling liners passively buffers cold-aisle air `<= 35 °C` (`ASHRAE A2`) for **`28.30 min`** vs. `1.78 min` for unbuffered room air. - **Theorem 4 — Waste-Heat Sorption Self-Cooling Threshold (`SymPy + Must-fail #11`):** - Critical liquid-cooling capture fraction $\alpha_{\text{liq}}^* = 1/(1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}}) = 61.73\%$ at silica-gel $\text{COP}_{\text{ads}} = 0.62$. Capturing `85%` of IT heat at `58 °C` (`ASHRAE W45`) self-generates `100%` of the `15–18 °C` chilled water needed for the `1.50 MW_th` air/RDHx load using `2.419 MW_th` of server reject heat with **zero mechanical chiller compressors**, dropping campus `PUE` from `1.38` to **`1.074`** at **`WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`**. +- **Theorem 5 — Sorption Re-Cooling Limit (`SymPy + Must-fail #13`, added in `v0.1.1`):** + - A heat-driven chiller between a drive at $T_h$, re-cooling at $T_a$ and chilled water at $T_c$ obeys $\text{COP}_{\text{ads}} \le \frac{T_c}{T_a - T_c}\cdot\frac{T_h - T_a}{T_h}$, so $T_a \le \frac{T_c T_h (1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}})}{\text{COP}_{\text{ads}} T_h + T_c}$. At `58 °C` drive, `18 °C` chilled water and `COP_ads = 0.62` the re-cooling temperature must stay below **`41.46 °C`**. The design value is `30 °C` (reversible limit `2.051`, so the machine runs at `30%` of the reversible limit). The certificate now carries the three temperatures. +- **Identity 6 — IT Power From Freed Utility Power (`SymPy + Must-fail #14`, added in `v0.1.1`):** + - Freed utility power $P_{\text{freed}}$ carries $P_{\text{freed}}/\text{PUE}$ of new IT load if every overhead scales with load and $P_{\text{freed}}/(1 + 1/\text{COP}_{\text{loop}})$ if only the `ATES` loop does: **`2.85–2.96 MW`** for the `3.06 MW` freed here. `v0.1.0` multiplied the full `3.06 MW` by the compute value per MW; `v0.1.1` uses the IT figure (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr`). This assumes the `$25–$50M/MW-yr` value is per MW of IT load. - **Negative Findings Captured (Do Not Re-Derive):** 1. **Shallow `L/f > 30` (`f = 0.68 m`) on `24 m` heavy-plant roof vaults over-stresses the crown:** Keeping `L/f <= 18` (`f = 1.35 m`, `L/f = 17.78`, `h_vault = 1,480 mm`) cuts horizontal arch thrust in half (`2,181.65 kN`, `f_c = 9.60 <= 24.75 MPa`) while still saving `920 mm` against `2,400 mm` deep heavy roof trusses. 2. **Stage-2 rib isolation above `15 Hz` amplifies `29.5 Hz` screw chillers past `0.0005 g_rms`:** Both isolation stages must sit below `f_min / 3` (`4.5 Hz` plinth + `9.2 Hz` `CLD` cassette seat) to prevent `29.5 Hz` chiller bleed-through. 3. **Air-cooled server exhaust (`32 °C`) and `ASHRAE W17` (`25.3 °C`) cannot drive sorption chillers without heat-pump lift (`Must-fail #11`):** Direct heat-pump-free regeneration requires `>= 55 °C` (`W45`/`W+`) for silica-gel or `>= 70–75 °C` (`HTHP`-boosted, ORNL OSTI 3740567) for single-effect `LiBr-H2O`. - 4. **Li-ion battery arbitrage (`$0.068/kWh` annualized pack capex) is `4.86x` costlier than crushed basalt (`$0.014/kWh_th`, `Must-fail #10`).** + 4. **Li-ion battery arbitrage (`$0.068/kWh` annualized pack capex) is `4.86x` costlier than crushed basalt (`$0.014/kWh_th`, `Must-fail #10`).** Both figures are declared inputs: `Must-fail #10` compares two stated constants and cannot fail (listed under `controls_on_declared_inputs_only`). A cost model that derives them is still to be written. + 5. **`45 °C` dry re-cooling cannot reach the `0.62` adsorption COP (`Must-fail #13`):** the reversible limit there is `0.423`. Zero-water operation at this COP needs the `ATES` / energy-pile / sky sinks. ## 2. Repository Artifacts (`main`) -- [`verify.py`](verify.py) (`v0.1.0`) — 4 SymPy theorems + 6 coupled thermo-structural solvers + **12/12 must-fail controls**. -- [`results/certificate.json`](results/certificate.json) (`v0.1.0`) — Canonical machine-checked outputs. +- [`verify.py`](verify.py) (`v0.1.1`) — 6 SymPy identities + 6 coupled thermo-structural solvers + **14/14 must-fail controls**. +- [`results/certificate.json`](results/certificate.json) (`v0.1.1`) — Canonical machine-checked outputs, with `declared_inputs` naming every value that is stated rather than computed. - [`docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md`](docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md) — Complete archival monograph of the Whole-Building Vibro-Thermal Shell Study and the Three-Tier Waste-Heat TES & Closed-Loop Sorption Cooling Study. - [`README.md`](README.md) & [`CHANGELOG.md`](CHANGELOG.md) — System specification and version history. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index c2cab5f..4357563 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # funi-frame -**Monolithic Vibro-Thermal Funicular Data-Center Shell, Three-Tier Waste-Heat TES & Zero-Water Sorption Cooling (`v0.1.0`).** +**Monolithic Vibro-Thermal Funicular Data-Center Shell, Three-Tier Waste-Heat TES & Zero-Water Sorption Cooling (`v0.1.1`).** `funi-frame` unifies the [`aska-physical`](/aska-physical) hardware stack—[`funi-floors`](/aska-physical/funi-floors), [`cfrp-truss`](/aska-physical/cfrp-truss), [`fibral-rigidity`](/aska-physical/fibral-rigidity), [`venturi-collars`](/aska-physical/venturi-collars), and [`impedence-analyzers`](/aska-physical/impedence-analyzers)—into a **complete, machine-verified AI data-center building exoskeleton and closed-loop thermal plant** engineered for `80–250 kW/rack` GPU halls that generate high-grade liquid heat (`50–60 °C`) under strict optical/switch vibration limits (`<= 0.0005 g_rms`). @@ -21,8 +21,9 @@ - Cuts whole-shell structural dead mass by **`64.83%`** (`1,431.4` vs. `4,069.8 tonnes`), saves **`2.02 m` of building height**, reduces seismic base shear by **`44.23%`**, holds top-down loaded story drift to **`0.563% <= 1.00%`** Immediate Occupancy limit (unbraced heavy frames hit `4.359%`), and seals overhead concrete inside stay-in-place composite pans (`0` spalling dust). 5. **Three-Tier Waste-Heat Thermal Energy Storage (`PCM` + Crushed Basalt + `ATES`/`RTES` + Energy Piles):** - Pairs **`83.33 m³` salt-hydrate `HS24` `PCM` skids** (`30.0` vs. `11.5 kWh_th/m³` water = `-61.67%` tank volume for `15-min` `2.5 MWh_th` ride-through), **`88.68 m³` (`20 MWh_th`) `500 K` crushed-basalt packed beds** (`225.5 kWh_th/m³`, `$14,046` mineral cost at **`$0.014/kWh_th`** annualized capex—`4.86x` lower than Li-ion), **`200` thermo-active foundation piles (`250 kW_th`)**, and **coastal `ATES` / deep brackish `RTES` wellfields (`COP 10–54`)**. -6. **Closed-Loop Sorption Cooling (`PUE = 1.074`, `WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`, `+3.06 MW` Freed Compute Power):** - - SymPy proves self-cooling above $\alpha_{\text{liq}}^* = 1/(1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}}) = 61.73\%$: `85%` `ASHRAE W45` (`58 °C`) cold-plate return directly regenerates **solid-sorbent silica-gel adsorption chillers (`2.419 MW_th` drive -> `1.50 MW_th` RDHx cooling, zero heat pump)**, cutting annual cooling electricity by **`85.05%`**, saving **`157.68 million L/yr` of potable water**, and freeing **`3.06 MW` of utility power (`$76.62M–$153.2M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue)**. +6. **Closed-Loop Sorption Cooling (`PUE = 1.074`, `WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`, `+3.06 MW` Freed Utility Power = `+2.85–2.96 MW` IT):** + - SymPy proves self-cooling above $\alpha_{\text{liq}}^* = 1/(1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}}) = 61.73\%$: `85%` `ASHRAE W45` (`58 °C`) cold-plate return directly regenerates **solid-sorbent silica-gel adsorption chillers (`2.419 MW_th` drive -> `1.50 MW_th` RDHx cooling, zero heat pump)**, cutting annual cooling electricity by **`85.05%`**, saving **`157.68 million L/yr` of potable water**, and freeing **`3.06 MW` of utility power, which carries `2.85–2.96 MW` of new IT load on the same substation (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue at `$25–$50M` per MW-yr of IT load)**. New racks need their own cooling and overhead, so freed utility power is not all IT power (`Must-fail #14`). + - **Re-cooling limit (`Must-fail #13`):** the `0.62` adsorption COP at a `58 °C` drive and `18 °C` chilled water is thermodynamically possible only below **`41.46 °C`** re-cooling. The design re-cools at `30 °C` into the `ATES` / energy-pile / sky sinks (reversible limit `2.051`); `45 °C` dry re-cooling cannot reach it (reversible limit `0.423`). The zero-water claim and the COP claim both depend on those sinks. ## Reproduce & Verify @@ -30,7 +31,7 @@ python3 verify.py ``` -Verifies four SymPy symbolic theorems and **12/12 must-fail controls** against [`results/certificate.json`](results/certificate.json). Full engineering monographs, inter-agent handoff, negative findings, and roadmap live in [`docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md`](docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md), [`HANDOFF.md`](HANDOFF.md), and [`CHANGELOG.md`](CHANGELOG.md). +Verifies six SymPy symbolic identities and **14/14 must-fail controls** against [`results/certificate.json`](results/certificate.json). The certificate names the inputs that are declared from the literature or the design brief rather than computed (`declared_inputs`), and the one control that rests on declared inputs only (`controls_on_declared_inputs_only`). Full engineering monographs, inter-agent handoff, negative findings, and roadmap live in [`docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md`](docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md), [`HANDOFF.md`](HANDOFF.md), and [`CHANGELOG.md`](CHANGELOG.md). ## Attribution & Ethos diff --git a/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md b/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md index 9a8b616..aa5b54b 100644 --- a/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md +++ b/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md @@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ Modern `80–250 kW/rack` AI halls (`12–15+ kN/m²` live loads, `$200,000+` pe ### II.3 Closed-Loop Sorption Cooling, Structural Conduit Coupling & `10 MW` Campus Balance - **SymPy Theorem 4 (`Must-fail #11`):** Self-cooling liquid-capture threshold $\alpha_{\text{liq}}^* = 1/(1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}}) = 61.73\%$ at silica-gel `COP_ads = 0.62` (`55–100 °C` drive). Capturing `85%` (`8.50 MW_th`) at `58 °C` (`W45`) feeds **`2.419 MW_th`** directly into silica-gel adsorption chillers to produce `1.50 MW_th` of `15–18 °C` `RDHx` chilled water with **zero compressors and zero heat-pump lift** (optional `R744/R717` `HTHP` at `COP 3.5–6.0` lifts `58 °C` -> `75–95 °C` for `20.5 MW` `LiBr-H2O` chillers or `5–8 MW_th` `4GDH` district export). - **Structural Manifold & `50 kHz` EIS Leak Twin:** Insulated `TCS/FWS` headers route inside `200 mm` `45°` Torayca T1100G rib apertures of [`funi-floors`](/aska-physical/funi-floors) with [`impedence-analyzers`](/aska-physical/impedence-analyzers) `50 kHz` Cole-Cole moisture sensing (`+46.16%` reactance shift, `0.0000%` load crosstalk). - - **Verified `10 MW` Campus Result (`Must-fail #12`):** Cuts `PUE` from `1.380` to **`1.074`** (**`-85.05%` cooling electricity**), achieves **`WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`** (**`157.68M L/yr` potable water saved**), and frees **`3.06 MW` of substation power (`$76.62M–$153.24M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue)**. + - **Verified `10 MW` Campus Result (`Must-fail #12`):** Cuts `PUE` from `1.380` to **`1.074`** (**`-85.05%` cooling electricity**), achieves **`WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`** (**`157.68M L/yr` potable water saved**), and frees **`3.06 MW` of substation power, which carries `2.85–2.96 MW` of new IT load (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue; corrected in `v0.1.1`, see [`CHANGELOG.md`](../CHANGELOG.md))**. ## Primary Engineering References 1. **Linwood, E.** (2023), *STRUCTURE Magazine* (*Design Parameters for Data Center Facilities*); **CalcSteel** (2026) (*Steel for AI Data Centers*); **S. A. Miro** (2026) & **ISTA Engineers**. diff --git a/results/certificate.json b/results/certificate.json index c51dc15..fd2c3d0 100644 --- a/results/certificate.json +++ b/results/certificate.json @@ -1,11 +1,13 @@ { "repository": "aska-physical/funi-frame", - "version": "0.1.0", + "version": "0.1.1", "symbolic_theorems": { "hysteretic_vs_viscous_rolloff": "lim_{r->oo} r*T_hyst = 0 (O(r^-2)) vs. lim_{r->oo} r*T_visc = 2*zeta (O(r^-1))", "thermal_bridge_amplification": "U_eff / U_core = 1 + rho_pin * (k_pin / k_ins - 1)", "pcm_volumetric_gain_identity": "E_tank / E_water = (1 - phi) + phi * rho_p * (cp_p*dT + L_f) / (rho_w*cp_w*dT)", - "self_cooling_liquid_capture_threshold": "alpha_liq* = 1 / (1 + COP_ads)" + "self_cooling_liquid_capture_threshold": "alpha_liq* = 1 / (1 + COP_ads)", + "sorption_recooling_limit": "COP_ads <= (T_c/(T_a - T_c))*((T_h - T_a)/T_h) <=> T_a <= T_c*T_h*(1 + COP_ads)/(COP_ads*T_h + T_c)", + "it_power_from_freed_utility_power": "dP_IT = P_freed/PUE if all overhead scales with load; P_freed/(1 + 1/COP_loop) if only the cooling loop does" }, "domain_1_funicular_radiative_roof": { "span_m": 24.0, @@ -63,6 +65,13 @@ "Q_liquid_w45_MW": 8.5, "Q_air_rdhx_MW": 1.5, "alpha_liq_critical_for_self_cooling": 0.6173, + "cop_ads_design": 0.62, + "T_drive_supply_C": 58.0, + "T_chilled_water_C": 18.0, + "T_recooling_design_C": 30.0, + "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_design_recooling": 2.051, + "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_45C_dry_recooling": 0.423, + "T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C": 41.46, "Q_drive_for_adsorption_MW": 2.419, "adsorption_self_cools_air_load": true, "cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust": 0.0, @@ -82,7 +91,10 @@ "WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh": 0.0, "potable_water_saved_million_L_yr": 157.68, "freed_substation_power_MW": 3.06, - "unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd": 76.62 + "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_low_MW": 2.85, + "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_high_MW": 2.96, + "unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd": 71.35, + "unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd": 147.95 }, "must_fail_controls": { "must_fail_01_rolled_steel_24m_rafter_fails_deflection": true, @@ -96,7 +108,43 @@ "must_fail_09_plain_water_fails_compact_15min_ridethrough": true, "must_fail_10_liion_exceeds_thermal_arbitrage_capex_ceiling": true, "must_fail_11_low_grade_air_exhaust_cannot_drive_adsorption": true, - "must_fail_12_evaporative_plant_fails_zero_water_and_pue_gate": true + "must_fail_12_evaporative_plant_fails_zero_water_and_pue_gate": true, + "must_fail_13_dry_recooling_at_45C_cannot_reach_design_adsorption_cop": true, + "must_fail_14_freed_utility_power_counted_as_it_power": true }, - "controls_passed": "12/12" + "controls_passed": "14/14", + "declared_inputs": { + "domain_1_funicular_radiative_roof": [ + "tornado_tiedown_capacity_kN", + "noon_radiative_sky_cooling_W_m2" + ], + "domain_2_vibro_thermal_sandwich_wall": [ + "nrc_poraver_helmholtz" + ], + "domain_3_broadband_vibration_cascade": [ + "oem_switch_limit_g_rms" + ], + "domain_4_top_down_seismic_cellular_frame": [ + "risk_cat_iv_drift_limit_pct" + ], + "domain_5_6_three_tier_tes_and_closed_loop_cooling": [ + "P_it_MW", + "Q_liquid_w45_MW", + "Q_air_rdhx_MW", + "cop_ads_design", + "cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust", + "T_drive_supply_C", + "T_chilled_water_C", + "T_recooling_design_C", + "basalt_battery_volume_m3", + "basalt_media_mass_tonnes", + "basalt_media_cost_usd", + "annualized_capex_basalt_usd_kWh", + "annualized_capex_liion_usd_kWh", + "WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh" + ] + }, + "controls_on_declared_inputs_only": [ + "must_fail_10_liion_exceeds_thermal_arbitrage_capex_ceiling" + ] } diff --git a/verify.py b/verify.py index 19792bc..e1efe3a 100644 --- a/verify.py +++ b/verify.py @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ #!/usr/bin/env python3 -"""Deterministic six-domain verifier for aska-physical/funi-frame (v0.1.0): +"""Deterministic six-domain verifier for aska-physical/funi-frame (v0.1.1): Monolithic Vibro-Thermal Funicular Data-Center Shell, 3-Tier Waste-Heat TES & Zero-Water Sorption Cooling. """ from __future__ import annotations @@ -29,11 +29,23 @@ def verify_symbolic_theorems() -> dict[str, str]: a_liq, cop = sp.symbols("alpha_liq cop_ads", positive=True) assert sp.simplify(sp.solve(sp.Eq(a_liq * cop, 1 - a_liq), a_liq)[0] - 1 / (1 + cop)) == 0 + + Th, Ta, Tc = sp.symbols("T_h T_a T_c", positive=True) + cop_rev = (Tc / (Ta - Tc)) * ((Th - Ta) / Th) + assert sp.simplify(cop_rev.subs(Ta, Tc * Th * (1 + cop) / (cop * Th + Tc)) - cop) == 0 + + P, pue_c, pue_f, c_loop, q0, a0, P2 = sp.symbols("P PUE_c PUE_f c_loop q0 a0 P2", positive=True) + assert sp.simplify(((P * pue_c) / pue_f - P) - P * (pue_c - pue_f) / pue_f) == 0 + used = lambda load: load + (load - q0) / c_loop + a0 + grown = sp.solve(sp.Eq(used(P2), P * pue_c), P2) + assert len(grown) == 1 and sp.simplify((grown[0] - P) - (P * pue_c - used(P)) / (1 + 1 / c_loop)) == 0 return { "hysteretic_vs_viscous_rolloff": "lim_{r->oo} r*T_hyst = 0 (O(r^-2)) vs. lim_{r->oo} r*T_visc = 2*zeta (O(r^-1))", "thermal_bridge_amplification": "U_eff / U_core = 1 + rho_pin * (k_pin / k_ins - 1)", "pcm_volumetric_gain_identity": "E_tank / E_water = (1 - phi) + phi * rho_p * (cp_p*dT + L_f) / (rho_w*cp_w*dT)", "self_cooling_liquid_capture_threshold": "alpha_liq* = 1 / (1 + COP_ads)", + "sorption_recooling_limit": "COP_ads <= (T_c/(T_a - T_c))*((T_h - T_a)/T_h) <=> T_a <= T_c*T_h*(1 + COP_ads)/(COP_ads*T_h + T_c)", + "it_power_from_freed_utility_power": "dP_IT = P_freed/PUE if all overhead scales with load; P_freed/(1 + 1/COP_loop) if only the cooling loop does", } @@ -138,16 +150,32 @@ def solve_whole_frame_seismic(roof_m: float, wall_m: float) -> dict: } +def _cop_rev(t_drive_c: float, t_recool_c: float, t_chilled_c: float) -> float: + th, ta, tc = t_drive_c + 273.15, t_recool_c + 273.15, t_chilled_c + 273.15 + return (tc / (ta - tc)) * ((th - ta) / th) + + def solve_three_tier_tes_and_cooling() -> dict: P_it, Q_liq, Q_air = 10.0, 8.5, 1.5 + cop_ads, cop_loop = 0.62, 28.0 + T_drv, T_chw, T_rec = 58.0, 18.0, 30.0 # drive supply, warmest chilled water, design recooling (deg C) v_pcm, v_wat = 2500.0 / 30.0, 2500.0 / 11.5 - Q_drv = Q_air / 0.62 + Q_drv = Q_air / cop_ads Q_pil, Q_sky = 200 * 25.0 * 50.0 * 1e-6, 2500.0 * 93.0 * 1e-6 Q_ates = (Q_liq - Q_drv) + (Q_air + Q_drv) - (Q_pil + 0.55 * Q_sky) - P_c_conv, P_c_funi = P_it / 3.0 + 0.27, Q_ates / 28.0 + 0.195 + P_c_conv, P_c_funi = P_it / 3.0 + 0.27, Q_ates / cop_loop + 0.195 + P_freed = P_c_conv - P_c_funi + pue_funi = (P_it + P_c_funi + 0.2) / P_it + # Freed utility power is not IT power: new racks need their own cooling and overhead. + P_it_low, P_it_high = P_freed / pue_funi, P_freed / (1.0 + 1.0 / cop_loop) + T_rec_max = (T_chw + 273.15) * (T_drv + 273.15) * (1.0 + cop_ads) / (cop_ads * (T_drv + 273.15) + T_chw + 273.15) - 273.15 return { "P_it_MW": P_it, "Q_liquid_w45_MW": Q_liq, "Q_air_rdhx_MW": Q_air, - "alpha_liq_critical_for_self_cooling": round(1.0 / 1.62, 4), + "alpha_liq_critical_for_self_cooling": round(1.0 / (1.0 + cop_ads), 4), + "cop_ads_design": cop_ads, "T_drive_supply_C": T_drv, "T_chilled_water_C": T_chw, "T_recooling_design_C": T_rec, + "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_design_recooling": round(_cop_rev(T_drv, T_rec, T_chw), 3), + "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_45C_dry_recooling": round(_cop_rev(T_drv, 45.0, T_chw), 3), + "T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C": round(T_rec_max, 2), "Q_drive_for_adsorption_MW": round(Q_drv, 3), "adsorption_self_cools_air_load": Q_drv <= Q_liq, "cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust": 0.0, "pcm_ride_through_volume_m3": round(v_pcm, 2), "water_equivalent_volume_m3": round(v_wat, 2), @@ -159,8 +187,11 @@ def solve_three_tier_tes_and_cooling() -> dict: "PUE_funi_frame": round((P_it + P_c_funi + 0.2) / P_it, 3), "cooling_electricity_reduction_pct": round((1.0 - P_c_funi / P_c_conv) * 100.0, 2), "WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh": 0.0, "potable_water_saved_million_L_yr": round(P_it * 8.760 * 1.80, 2), - "freed_substation_power_MW": round(P_c_conv - P_c_funi, 2), - "unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd": round((P_c_conv - P_c_funi) * 25.0, 2), + "freed_substation_power_MW": round(P_freed, 2), + "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_low_MW": round(P_it_low, 2), + "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_high_MW": round(P_it_high, 2), + "unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd": round(P_it_low * 25.0, 2), + "unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd": round(P_it_high * 50.0, 2), } @@ -182,13 +213,34 @@ def build_certificate() -> dict: "must_fail_11_low_grade_air_exhaust_cannot_drive_adsorption": ts["cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust"] == 0.0 and ts["adsorption_self_cools_air_load"] is True, "must_fail_12_evaporative_plant_fails_zero_water_and_pue_gate": ts["PUE_conventional"] > 1.35 and ts["PUE_funi_frame"] <= 1.08 and ts["WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh"] == 0.0, } + ct["must_fail_13_dry_recooling_at_45C_cannot_reach_design_adsorption_cop"] = ( + ts["cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_45C_dry_recooling"] < ts["cop_ads_design"] <= ts["cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_design_recooling"] + and ts["T_recooling_design_C"] < ts["T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C"]) + ct["must_fail_14_freed_utility_power_counted_as_it_power"] = ( + ts["extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_low_MW"] <= ts["extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_high_MW"] < ts["freed_substation_power_MW"] + and ts["unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd"] < ts["freed_substation_power_MW"] * 25.0) assert all(ct.values()), [k for k, v in ct.items() if not v] + # Values that no solver computes: they are stated from the cited literature or the design brief. + declared = { + "domain_1_funicular_radiative_roof": ["tornado_tiedown_capacity_kN", "noon_radiative_sky_cooling_W_m2"], + "domain_2_vibro_thermal_sandwich_wall": ["nrc_poraver_helmholtz"], + "domain_3_broadband_vibration_cascade": ["oem_switch_limit_g_rms"], + "domain_4_top_down_seismic_cellular_frame": ["risk_cat_iv_drift_limit_pct"], + "domain_5_6_three_tier_tes_and_closed_loop_cooling": [ + "P_it_MW", "Q_liquid_w45_MW", "Q_air_rdhx_MW", "cop_ads_design", "cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust", + "T_drive_supply_C", "T_chilled_water_C", "T_recooling_design_C", "basalt_battery_volume_m3", + "basalt_media_mass_tonnes", "basalt_media_cost_usd", "annualized_capex_basalt_usd_kWh", + "annualized_capex_liion_usd_kWh", "WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh"], + } + declared_only = ["must_fail_10_liion_exceeds_thermal_arbitrage_capex_ceiling"] return { - "repository": "aska-physical/funi-frame", "version": "0.1.0", "symbolic_theorems": th, + "repository": "aska-physical/funi-frame", "version": "0.1.1", "symbolic_theorems": th, "domain_1_funicular_radiative_roof": rf, "domain_2_vibro_thermal_sandwich_wall": wl, "domain_3_broadband_vibration_cascade": vb, "domain_4_top_down_seismic_cellular_frame": se, "domain_5_6_three_tier_tes_and_closed_loop_cooling": ts, "must_fail_controls": ct, "controls_passed": f"{sum(ct.values())}/{len(ct)}", + "declared_inputs": declared, + "controls_on_declared_inputs_only": declared_only, } @@ -204,7 +256,7 @@ def main() -> int: if saved != cert: print("ERROR: certificate drift detected against verify.py!", file=sys.stderr) return 1 - print(f"[PASS] funi-frame v0.1.0 ({cert['controls_passed']} controls, PUE={cert['domain_5_6_three_tier_tes_and_closed_loop_cooling']['PUE_funi_frame']}, WUE=0.0 L/kWh, Rack={cert['domain_3_broadband_vibration_cascade']['rack_g_rms_funi_frame']} g_rms): OK") + print(f"[PASS] funi-frame v0.1.1 ({cert['controls_passed']} controls, PUE={cert['domain_5_6_three_tier_tes_and_closed_loop_cooling']['PUE_funi_frame']}, WUE=0.0 L/kWh, Rack={cert['domain_3_broadband_vibration_cascade']['rack_g_rms_funi_frame']} g_rms): OK") return 0 From 32178c42e13617eb501e621cf83b477f872e0ca6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 17 Nov 2026 16:42:40 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] Address review of v0.1.1: state the revenue pairing, strengthen control 14, keep the monograph archival - The revenue range varies two things at once (low IT load at 25 M usd per MW-yr, high IT load at 50). README, HANDOFF and CHANGELOG now say so, and the certificate carries the pairing and the range at each rate alone. - Control 14 no longer checks an ordering only. It checks both IT figures by a power balance and both revenue figures against them, so a wrong formula that kept the ordering fails. - T_recooling_design_C = 30 is marked in the code and in the certificate as a proposal with no source, awaiting the owner's confirmation. - controls_resting_partly_on_declared_inputs lists controls 5, 11 and 12. The text now says that naming declared inputs is disclosure, not a fix: control 10 still cannot fail and its cost model is open work. - docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md is the archive of v0.1.0: its text is restored and a dated correction note is added under the header. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_012tWK9W6CVMEDEnj5eQTe6K --- CHANGELOG.md | 8 ++++---- HANDOFF.md | 5 +++-- README.md | 4 ++-- docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md | 4 +++- results/certificate.json | 21 +++++++++++++++++++-- verify.py | 34 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++---- 6 files changed, 61 insertions(+), 15 deletions(-) diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index a0fa218..52e841e 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -7,12 +7,12 @@ All notable machine-verified engineering milestones for `aska-physical/funi-fram Corrections from the cross-repository review in [`aska-physical/optifab`](/aska-physical/optifab) (`HANDOFF.md` §3). Prepared by an AI agent; awaiting human sign-off. ### Changed -- **Unlocked compute is reported in IT power, not utility power.** The `3.06 MW` of freed substation power carries **`2.85–2.96 MW`** of new IT load (`P_freed / PUE` if every overhead scales with load; `P_freed / (1 + 1/COP_loop)` if only the `ATES` loop does). `unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd` falls from `76.62` to **`71.35`**, and `unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd` (**`147.95`**) is now in the certificate. `README.md` §6 retitled from "Freed Compute Power" to "Freed Utility Power". This assumes the `$25–$50M/MW-yr` value is per MW of IT load. +- **Unlocked compute is reported in IT power, not utility power.** The `3.06 MW` of freed substation power carries **`2.85–2.96 MW`** of new IT load (`P_freed / PUE` if every overhead scales with load; `P_freed / (1 + 1/COP_loop)` if only the `ATES` loop does). `unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd` falls from `76.62` to **`71.35`**, and `unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd` (**`147.95`**) is now in the certificate. The low figure pairs the low IT load with `$25M/MW-yr` and the high figure pairs the high IT load with `$50M/MW-yr`; `unlocked_annual_revenue_pairing` says so, and two new fields give the range at each rate alone (`71.35–73.98` and `142.69–147.95`). `README.md` §6 retitled from "Freed Compute Power" to "Freed Utility Power". This assumes the `$25–$50M/MW-yr` value is per MW of IT load, which the owner has still to confirm. ### Added -- **Re-cooling temperature and its second-law limit (`Theorem 5`, `Must-fail #13`).** The certificate now carries `T_drive_supply_C = 58`, `T_chilled_water_C = 18`, `T_recooling_design_C = 30`, the reversible COP limit at design re-cooling (`2.051`) and at `45 °C` dry re-cooling (`0.423`), and `T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C = 41.46`. The `30 °C` design value is a choice made in this version and needs the owner's confirmation. -- **`Must-fail #14`:** freed utility power may not be counted as IT power. -- **`declared_inputs` and `controls_on_declared_inputs_only`** in the certificate: every value that is stated from the literature or the design brief rather than computed, and the one control (`#10`) that compares only such values. +- **Re-cooling temperature and its second-law limit (`Theorem 5`, `Must-fail #13`).** The certificate now carries `T_drive_supply_C = 58`, `T_chilled_water_C = 18`, `T_recooling_design_C = 30`, the reversible COP limit at design re-cooling (`2.051`) and at `45 °C` dry re-cooling (`0.423`), and `T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C = 41.46`. The `30 °C` design value is a proposal made in this version with no source cited. `T_recooling_design_basis` records that it awaits the owner's confirmation. +- **`Must-fail #14`:** freed utility power may not be counted as IT power. It checks both IT figures by a power balance (new IT load plus its overhead equals the freed utility power, to within rounding) and both revenue figures against them, so a wrong formula that kept the ordering fails. +- **`declared_inputs`, `controls_on_declared_inputs_only` and `controls_resting_partly_on_declared_inputs`** in the certificate: every value that is stated from the literature or the design brief rather than computed, the one control (`#10`) that compares only such values, and the three (`#5`, `#11`, `#12`) that rest on them in part. This is disclosure, not a fix: `#10` still cannot fail, and a cost model for it is open work. ### Not changed - No structural, acoustic, vibration, seismic or storage result. `PUE`, `WUE` and all `12` original controls are as in `v0.1.0`. diff --git a/HANDOFF.md b/HANDOFF.md index b30f71b..8ccbdde 100644 --- a/HANDOFF.md +++ b/HANDOFF.md @@ -15,12 +15,13 @@ Prepared per the Aska group ethos (*maximal autonomy and agency; capture every c - **Theorem 5 — Sorption Re-Cooling Limit (`SymPy + Must-fail #13`, added in `v0.1.1`):** - A heat-driven chiller between a drive at $T_h$, re-cooling at $T_a$ and chilled water at $T_c$ obeys $\text{COP}_{\text{ads}} \le \frac{T_c}{T_a - T_c}\cdot\frac{T_h - T_a}{T_h}$, so $T_a \le \frac{T_c T_h (1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}})}{\text{COP}_{\text{ads}} T_h + T_c}$. At `58 °C` drive, `18 °C` chilled water and `COP_ads = 0.62` the re-cooling temperature must stay below **`41.46 °C`**. The design value is `30 °C` (reversible limit `2.051`, so the machine runs at `30%` of the reversible limit). The certificate now carries the three temperatures. - **Identity 6 — IT Power From Freed Utility Power (`SymPy + Must-fail #14`, added in `v0.1.1`):** - - Freed utility power $P_{\text{freed}}$ carries $P_{\text{freed}}/\text{PUE}$ of new IT load if every overhead scales with load and $P_{\text{freed}}/(1 + 1/\text{COP}_{\text{loop}})$ if only the `ATES` loop does: **`2.85–2.96 MW`** for the `3.06 MW` freed here. `v0.1.0` multiplied the full `3.06 MW` by the compute value per MW; `v0.1.1` uses the IT figure (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr`). This assumes the `$25–$50M/MW-yr` value is per MW of IT load. + - Freed utility power $P_{\text{freed}}$ carries $P_{\text{freed}}/\text{PUE}$ of new IT load if every overhead scales with load and $P_{\text{freed}}/(1 + 1/\text{COP}_{\text{loop}})$ if only the `ATES` loop does: **`2.85–2.96 MW`** for the `3.06 MW` freed here. `v0.1.0` multiplied the full `3.06 MW` by the compute value per MW; `v0.1.1` uses the IT figure (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr`). The low end pairs the low IT load with `$25M/MW-yr` and the high end pairs the high IT load with `$50M/MW-yr`; at one rate the range is `$71.35M–$73.98M` (`$25M`) or `$142.69M–$147.95M` (`$50M`). This assumes the `$25–$50M/MW-yr` value is per MW of IT load, which the owner has still to confirm. + - `Must-fail #14` checks both figures by a power balance: the new IT load plus the overhead it brings must use up the freed utility power to within the certificate's rounding, and counting the freed power itself as IT load must leave the balance open. The two formulas are also proved as SymPy identities. - **Negative Findings Captured (Do Not Re-Derive):** 1. **Shallow `L/f > 30` (`f = 0.68 m`) on `24 m` heavy-plant roof vaults over-stresses the crown:** Keeping `L/f <= 18` (`f = 1.35 m`, `L/f = 17.78`, `h_vault = 1,480 mm`) cuts horizontal arch thrust in half (`2,181.65 kN`, `f_c = 9.60 <= 24.75 MPa`) while still saving `920 mm` against `2,400 mm` deep heavy roof trusses. 2. **Stage-2 rib isolation above `15 Hz` amplifies `29.5 Hz` screw chillers past `0.0005 g_rms`:** Both isolation stages must sit below `f_min / 3` (`4.5 Hz` plinth + `9.2 Hz` `CLD` cassette seat) to prevent `29.5 Hz` chiller bleed-through. 3. **Air-cooled server exhaust (`32 °C`) and `ASHRAE W17` (`25.3 °C`) cannot drive sorption chillers without heat-pump lift (`Must-fail #11`):** Direct heat-pump-free regeneration requires `>= 55 °C` (`W45`/`W+`) for silica-gel or `>= 70–75 °C` (`HTHP`-boosted, ORNL OSTI 3740567) for single-effect `LiBr-H2O`. - 4. **Li-ion battery arbitrage (`$0.068/kWh` annualized pack capex) is `4.86x` costlier than crushed basalt (`$0.014/kWh_th`, `Must-fail #10`).** Both figures are declared inputs: `Must-fail #10` compares two stated constants and cannot fail (listed under `controls_on_declared_inputs_only`). A cost model that derives them is still to be written. + 4. **Li-ion battery arbitrage (`$0.068/kWh` annualized pack capex) is `4.86x` costlier than crushed basalt (`$0.014/kWh_th`, `Must-fail #10`).** Both figures are declared inputs: `Must-fail #10` compares two stated constants and cannot fail (listed under `controls_on_declared_inputs_only`). Listing it is disclosure, not a fix. A cost model that derives the two figures is open work, and until it exists `#10` guards nothing. `Must-fail #5`, `#11` and `#12` rest partly on declared inputs (`0.72` absorption, written twice in `verify.py`; `COP = 0.0` at `32 °C` exhaust; `WUE = 0.0`) and are listed under `controls_resting_partly_on_declared_inputs`. 5. **`45 °C` dry re-cooling cannot reach the `0.62` adsorption COP (`Must-fail #13`):** the reversible limit there is `0.423`. Zero-water operation at this COP needs the `ATES` / energy-pile / sky sinks. ## 2. Repository Artifacts (`main`) diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 4357563..7ba89df 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ 5. **Three-Tier Waste-Heat Thermal Energy Storage (`PCM` + Crushed Basalt + `ATES`/`RTES` + Energy Piles):** - Pairs **`83.33 m³` salt-hydrate `HS24` `PCM` skids** (`30.0` vs. `11.5 kWh_th/m³` water = `-61.67%` tank volume for `15-min` `2.5 MWh_th` ride-through), **`88.68 m³` (`20 MWh_th`) `500 K` crushed-basalt packed beds** (`225.5 kWh_th/m³`, `$14,046` mineral cost at **`$0.014/kWh_th`** annualized capex—`4.86x` lower than Li-ion), **`200` thermo-active foundation piles (`250 kW_th`)**, and **coastal `ATES` / deep brackish `RTES` wellfields (`COP 10–54`)**. 6. **Closed-Loop Sorption Cooling (`PUE = 1.074`, `WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`, `+3.06 MW` Freed Utility Power = `+2.85–2.96 MW` IT):** - - SymPy proves self-cooling above $\alpha_{\text{liq}}^* = 1/(1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}}) = 61.73\%$: `85%` `ASHRAE W45` (`58 °C`) cold-plate return directly regenerates **solid-sorbent silica-gel adsorption chillers (`2.419 MW_th` drive -> `1.50 MW_th` RDHx cooling, zero heat pump)**, cutting annual cooling electricity by **`85.05%`**, saving **`157.68 million L/yr` of potable water**, and freeing **`3.06 MW` of utility power, which carries `2.85–2.96 MW` of new IT load on the same substation (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue at `$25–$50M` per MW-yr of IT load)**. New racks need their own cooling and overhead, so freed utility power is not all IT power (`Must-fail #14`). + - SymPy proves self-cooling above $\alpha_{\text{liq}}^* = 1/(1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}}) = 61.73\%$: `85%` `ASHRAE W45` (`58 °C`) cold-plate return directly regenerates **solid-sorbent silica-gel adsorption chillers (`2.419 MW_th` drive -> `1.50 MW_th` RDHx cooling, zero heat pump)**, cutting annual cooling electricity by **`85.05%`**, saving **`157.68 million L/yr` of potable water**, and freeing **`3.06 MW` of utility power, which carries `2.85–2.96 MW` of new IT load on the same substation (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue)**. That range varies two things at once: the low end is the low IT load (`2.85 MW`) at `$25M` per MW-yr of IT load and the high end is the high IT load (`2.96 MW`) at `$50M`. At one rate the range is narrow: `$71.35M–$73.98M` at `$25M` and `$142.69M–$147.95M` at `$50M`. New racks need their own cooling and overhead, so freed utility power is not all IT power (`Must-fail #14`). - **Re-cooling limit (`Must-fail #13`):** the `0.62` adsorption COP at a `58 °C` drive and `18 °C` chilled water is thermodynamically possible only below **`41.46 °C`** re-cooling. The design re-cools at `30 °C` into the `ATES` / energy-pile / sky sinks (reversible limit `2.051`); `45 °C` dry re-cooling cannot reach it (reversible limit `0.423`). The zero-water claim and the COP claim both depend on those sinks. ## Reproduce & Verify @@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ python3 verify.py ``` -Verifies six SymPy symbolic identities and **14/14 must-fail controls** against [`results/certificate.json`](results/certificate.json). The certificate names the inputs that are declared from the literature or the design brief rather than computed (`declared_inputs`), and the one control that rests on declared inputs only (`controls_on_declared_inputs_only`). Full engineering monographs, inter-agent handoff, negative findings, and roadmap live in [`docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md`](docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md), [`HANDOFF.md`](HANDOFF.md), and [`CHANGELOG.md`](CHANGELOG.md). +Verifies six SymPy symbolic identities and **14/14 must-fail controls** against [`results/certificate.json`](results/certificate.json). The certificate names the inputs that are declared from the literature or the design brief rather than computed (`declared_inputs`), the one control that rests on declared inputs only (`controls_on_declared_inputs_only`), and the three that rest on them in part (`controls_resting_partly_on_declared_inputs`). Naming them is disclosure, not a repair. Full engineering monographs, inter-agent handoff, negative findings, and roadmap live in [`docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md`](docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md), [`HANDOFF.md`](HANDOFF.md), and [`CHANGELOG.md`](CHANGELOG.md). ## Attribution & Ethos diff --git a/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md b/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md index aa5b54b..d5492bf 100644 --- a/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md +++ b/docs/ENGINEERING_STUDIES.md @@ -1,6 +1,8 @@ # Engineering Studies Monograph — `aska-physical/funi-frame` (`v0.1.0`) Complete archival capture of both session engineering studies for [`aska-physical/funi-frame`](/aska-physical/funi-frame), machine-verified by [`verify.py`](../verify.py) against [`results/certificate.json`](../results/certificate.json) (`12/12` must-fail controls): + +> **Correction note, `v0.1.1` (2026-11-17).** This monograph is the archive of `v0.1.0` and its text is unchanged. Two things in it were corrected later. The unlocked-compute figure in II.3 (`$76.62M–$153.24M/yr`) counted `3.06 MW` of freed utility power as IT power; the corrected figure is `2.85–2.96 MW` of new IT load. And the `0.62` adsorption COP has a re-cooling limit of `41.46 °C` that this text does not state. See [`CHANGELOG.md`](../CHANGELOG.md) and [`HANDOFF.md`](../HANDOFF.md) for `v0.1.1`. 1. **Study I:** *Whole-Building Monolithic Vibro-Thermal Data-Center Exoskeleton (Funicular Radiative Roof, Zero-Bridge Poraver-mPCM Sandwich Shear Walls, Three-Stage Hysteretic Vibration Cascade & Top-Down Seismic Cellular Box)* 2. **Study II:** *Capturing AI Data-Center Waste Heat, Three-Tier High-Density Thermal Energy Storage (PCM, Mineral Packed Beds & Subsurface ATES/RTES/Energy Piles), and Closed-Loop Sorption Cooling* @@ -50,7 +52,7 @@ Modern `80–250 kW/rack` AI halls (`12–15+ kN/m²` live loads, `$200,000+` pe ### II.3 Closed-Loop Sorption Cooling, Structural Conduit Coupling & `10 MW` Campus Balance - **SymPy Theorem 4 (`Must-fail #11`):** Self-cooling liquid-capture threshold $\alpha_{\text{liq}}^* = 1/(1 + \text{COP}_{\text{ads}}) = 61.73\%$ at silica-gel `COP_ads = 0.62` (`55–100 °C` drive). Capturing `85%` (`8.50 MW_th`) at `58 °C` (`W45`) feeds **`2.419 MW_th`** directly into silica-gel adsorption chillers to produce `1.50 MW_th` of `15–18 °C` `RDHx` chilled water with **zero compressors and zero heat-pump lift** (optional `R744/R717` `HTHP` at `COP 3.5–6.0` lifts `58 °C` -> `75–95 °C` for `20.5 MW` `LiBr-H2O` chillers or `5–8 MW_th` `4GDH` district export). - **Structural Manifold & `50 kHz` EIS Leak Twin:** Insulated `TCS/FWS` headers route inside `200 mm` `45°` Torayca T1100G rib apertures of [`funi-floors`](/aska-physical/funi-floors) with [`impedence-analyzers`](/aska-physical/impedence-analyzers) `50 kHz` Cole-Cole moisture sensing (`+46.16%` reactance shift, `0.0000%` load crosstalk). - - **Verified `10 MW` Campus Result (`Must-fail #12`):** Cuts `PUE` from `1.380` to **`1.074`** (**`-85.05%` cooling electricity**), achieves **`WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`** (**`157.68M L/yr` potable water saved**), and frees **`3.06 MW` of substation power, which carries `2.85–2.96 MW` of new IT load (`$71.35M–$147.95M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue; corrected in `v0.1.1`, see [`CHANGELOG.md`](../CHANGELOG.md))**. + - **Verified `10 MW` Campus Result (`Must-fail #12`):** Cuts `PUE` from `1.380` to **`1.074`** (**`-85.05%` cooling electricity**), achieves **`WUE = 0.000 L/kWh`** (**`157.68M L/yr` potable water saved**), and frees **`3.06 MW` of substation power (`$76.62M–$153.24M/yr` unlocked AI compute revenue)**. ## Primary Engineering References 1. **Linwood, E.** (2023), *STRUCTURE Magazine* (*Design Parameters for Data Center Facilities*); **CalcSteel** (2026) (*Steel for AI Data Centers*); **S. A. Miro** (2026) & **ISTA Engineers**. diff --git a/results/certificate.json b/results/certificate.json index fd2c3d0..87856e7 100644 --- a/results/certificate.json +++ b/results/certificate.json @@ -69,6 +69,8 @@ "T_drive_supply_C": 58.0, "T_chilled_water_C": 18.0, "T_recooling_design_C": 30.0, + "T_recooling_design_basis": "proposed in v0.1.1; no source cited; awaiting the owner's confirmation", + "cop_loop_design": 28.0, "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_design_recooling": 2.051, "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_45C_dry_recooling": 0.423, "T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C": 41.46, @@ -94,7 +96,16 @@ "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_low_MW": 2.85, "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_high_MW": 2.96, "unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd": 71.35, - "unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd": 147.95 + "unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd": 147.95, + "unlocked_annual_revenue_pairing": "low = low IT load at 25 M usd per MW-yr; high = high IT load at 50 M usd per MW-yr", + "unlocked_annual_revenue_at_25M_usd_per_MW_yr_M_usd": [ + 71.35, + 73.98 + ], + "unlocked_annual_revenue_at_50M_usd_per_MW_yr_M_usd": [ + 142.69, + 147.95 + ] }, "must_fail_controls": { "must_fail_01_rolled_steel_24m_rafter_fails_deflection": true, @@ -136,6 +147,7 @@ "T_drive_supply_C", "T_chilled_water_C", "T_recooling_design_C", + "cop_loop_design", "basalt_battery_volume_m3", "basalt_media_mass_tonnes", "basalt_media_cost_usd", @@ -146,5 +158,10 @@ }, "controls_on_declared_inputs_only": [ "must_fail_10_liion_exceeds_thermal_arbitrage_capex_ceiling" - ] + ], + "controls_resting_partly_on_declared_inputs": { + "must_fail_05_bare_concrete_fails_hall_acoustic_absorption": "nrc_poraver_helmholtz is declared as 0.72, and 0.72 is written again as a literal in the reverberation calculation", + "must_fail_11_low_grade_air_exhaust_cannot_drive_adsorption": "cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust is declared as 0.0", + "must_fail_12_evaporative_plant_fails_zero_water_and_pue_gate": "WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh is declared as 0.0" + } } diff --git a/verify.py b/verify.py index e1efe3a..9575774 100644 --- a/verify.py +++ b/verify.py @@ -158,7 +158,9 @@ def _cop_rev(t_drive_c: float, t_recool_c: float, t_chilled_c: float) -> float: def solve_three_tier_tes_and_cooling() -> dict: P_it, Q_liq, Q_air = 10.0, 8.5, 1.5 cop_ads, cop_loop = 0.62, 28.0 - T_drv, T_chw, T_rec = 58.0, 18.0, 30.0 # drive supply, warmest chilled water, design recooling (deg C) + # T_rec is a proposed design value, new in v0.1.1. No source is cited for it and the owner has not confirmed it. + # Control 13 holds for any value below T_rec_max. + T_drv, T_chw, T_rec = 58.0, 18.0, 30.0 # drive supply, warmest chilled water, proposed design recooling (deg C) v_pcm, v_wat = 2500.0 / 30.0, 2500.0 / 11.5 Q_drv = Q_air / cop_ads Q_pil, Q_sky = 200 * 25.0 * 50.0 * 1e-6, 2500.0 * 93.0 * 1e-6 @@ -173,6 +175,8 @@ def solve_three_tier_tes_and_cooling() -> dict: "P_it_MW": P_it, "Q_liquid_w45_MW": Q_liq, "Q_air_rdhx_MW": Q_air, "alpha_liq_critical_for_self_cooling": round(1.0 / (1.0 + cop_ads), 4), "cop_ads_design": cop_ads, "T_drive_supply_C": T_drv, "T_chilled_water_C": T_chw, "T_recooling_design_C": T_rec, + "T_recooling_design_basis": "proposed in v0.1.1; no source cited; awaiting the owner's confirmation", + "cop_loop_design": cop_loop, "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_design_recooling": round(_cop_rev(T_drv, T_rec, T_chw), 3), "cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_45C_dry_recooling": round(_cop_rev(T_drv, 45.0, T_chw), 3), "T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C": round(T_rec_max, 2), @@ -190,8 +194,12 @@ def solve_three_tier_tes_and_cooling() -> dict: "freed_substation_power_MW": round(P_freed, 2), "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_low_MW": round(P_it_low, 2), "extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_high_MW": round(P_it_high, 2), + # Low and high each vary two things: low is the low IT load at the low rate, high is the high IT load at the high rate. "unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd": round(P_it_low * 25.0, 2), "unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd": round(P_it_high * 50.0, 2), + "unlocked_annual_revenue_pairing": "low = low IT load at 25 M usd per MW-yr; high = high IT load at 50 M usd per MW-yr", + "unlocked_annual_revenue_at_25M_usd_per_MW_yr_M_usd": [round(P_it_low * 25.0, 2), round(P_it_high * 25.0, 2)], + "unlocked_annual_revenue_at_50M_usd_per_MW_yr_M_usd": [round(P_it_low * 50.0, 2), round(P_it_high * 50.0, 2)], } @@ -216,9 +224,19 @@ def build_certificate() -> dict: ct["must_fail_13_dry_recooling_at_45C_cannot_reach_design_adsorption_cop"] = ( ts["cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_45C_dry_recooling"] < ts["cop_ads_design"] <= ts["cop_ads_reversible_limit_at_design_recooling"] and ts["T_recooling_design_C"] < ts["T_recooling_max_for_design_cop_C"]) + # Control 14 does not trust the two formulas in the solver. It checks them by a power balance: the new IT load + # plus the overhead it brings must use up the freed utility power. Counting the freed power itself as IT load + # must leave that balance open. Tolerances follow from the certificate's rounding (0.01 MW, 0.01 M usd). + freed, it_lo, it_hi = (ts["freed_substation_power_MW"], ts["extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_low_MW"], + ts["extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_high_MW"]) + loop_factor = 1.0 + 1.0 / ts["cop_loop_design"] ct["must_fail_14_freed_utility_power_counted_as_it_power"] = ( - ts["extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_low_MW"] <= ts["extra_it_power_at_fixed_supply_high_MW"] < ts["freed_substation_power_MW"] - and ts["unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd"] < ts["freed_substation_power_MW"] * 25.0) + abs(it_lo * ts["PUE_funi_frame"] - freed) <= 0.02 and abs(it_hi * loop_factor - freed) <= 0.02 + and freed * loop_factor - freed > 0.02 + and it_lo <= it_hi < freed + and abs(ts["unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd"] - it_lo * 25.0) <= 0.13 + and abs(ts["unlocked_annual_revenue_high_M_usd"] - it_hi * 50.0) <= 0.26 + and ts["unlocked_annual_revenue_low_M_usd"] < freed * 25.0 - 0.13) assert all(ct.values()), [k for k, v in ct.items() if not v] # Values that no solver computes: they are stated from the cited literature or the design brief. declared = { @@ -228,11 +246,18 @@ def build_certificate() -> dict: "domain_4_top_down_seismic_cellular_frame": ["risk_cat_iv_drift_limit_pct"], "domain_5_6_three_tier_tes_and_closed_loop_cooling": [ "P_it_MW", "Q_liquid_w45_MW", "Q_air_rdhx_MW", "cop_ads_design", "cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust", - "T_drive_supply_C", "T_chilled_water_C", "T_recooling_design_C", "basalt_battery_volume_m3", + "T_drive_supply_C", "T_chilled_water_C", "T_recooling_design_C", "cop_loop_design", "basalt_battery_volume_m3", "basalt_media_mass_tonnes", "basalt_media_cost_usd", "annualized_capex_basalt_usd_kWh", "annualized_capex_liion_usd_kWh", "WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh"], } + # Naming these does not repair them. Control 10 compares two stated constants and still cannot fail. declared_only = ["must_fail_10_liion_exceeds_thermal_arbitrage_capex_ceiling"] + declared_partly = { + "must_fail_05_bare_concrete_fails_hall_acoustic_absorption": + "nrc_poraver_helmholtz is declared as 0.72, and 0.72 is written again as a literal in the reverberation calculation", + "must_fail_11_low_grade_air_exhaust_cannot_drive_adsorption": "cop_ads_at_32C_air_exhaust is declared as 0.0", + "must_fail_12_evaporative_plant_fails_zero_water_and_pue_gate": "WUE_funi_frame_L_per_kWh is declared as 0.0", + } return { "repository": "aska-physical/funi-frame", "version": "0.1.1", "symbolic_theorems": th, "domain_1_funicular_radiative_roof": rf, "domain_2_vibro_thermal_sandwich_wall": wl, @@ -241,6 +266,7 @@ def build_certificate() -> dict: "controls_passed": f"{sum(ct.values())}/{len(ct)}", "declared_inputs": declared, "controls_on_declared_inputs_only": declared_only, + "controls_resting_partly_on_declared_inputs": declared_partly, }