Summary
The Open Rules fixtures for CORE-000698 and CORE-000704 appear to have
paired expected-result inconsistencies. In a downstream structural comparison,
these cases are best treated as oracle/data reconciliation items rather than
native engine conformance evidence.
This is not a request to encode downstream compatibility behavior. The request
is to review whether the committed results/results.csv files match the rule
text and fixture data for the paired PDVAL minimum/maximum rules.
Observed cases
| Rule |
Case |
Official issues |
Candidate structural issues |
Missing |
Extra |
Fingerprint |
| CORE-000698 |
negative/01 |
36 |
24 |
12 |
0 |
2d5714b09294d070 |
| CORE-000698 |
negative/02 |
12 |
20 |
12 |
20 |
2c236ef4c8de4acf |
| CORE-000698 |
positive/01 |
0 |
4 |
0 |
4 |
ecb12e8d0d2f66e4 |
| CORE-000704 |
negative/01 |
36 |
24 |
12 |
0 |
4580e16d2c187249 |
| CORE-000704 |
negative/02 |
20 |
12 |
20 |
12 |
c76bfbc834a1849b |
| CORE-000704 |
positive/01 |
0 |
4 |
0 |
4 |
1b77302593f00a70 |
Review request
- Confirm whether the expected results for
CORE-000698 should reference
PDVALMIN or PDVALMAX fixture rows.
- Confirm whether the expected results for
CORE-000704 should reference
PDVALMAX or PDVALMIN fixture rows.
- Confirm whether the positive fixtures should intentionally produce issues.
Until reconciled, downstream oracle harnesses should probably keep these cases
out of supported accuracy to avoid treating a fixture/oracle discrepancy as an
engine pass or fail.
Summary
The Open Rules fixtures for
CORE-000698andCORE-000704appear to havepaired expected-result inconsistencies. In a downstream structural comparison,
these cases are best treated as oracle/data reconciliation items rather than
native engine conformance evidence.
This is not a request to encode downstream compatibility behavior. The request
is to review whether the committed
results/results.csvfiles match the ruletext and fixture data for the paired PDVAL minimum/maximum rules.
Observed cases
2d5714b09294d0702c236ef4c8de4acfecb12e8d0d2f66e44580e16d2c187249c76bfbc834a1849b1b77302593f00a70Review request
CORE-000698should referencePDVALMIN or PDVALMAX fixture rows.
CORE-000704should referencePDVALMAX or PDVALMIN fixture rows.
Until reconciled, downstream oracle harnesses should probably keep these cases
out of supported accuracy to avoid treating a fixture/oracle discrepancy as an
engine pass or fail.