From eac75a27130fddb779c0c9d2f86c45c400a7bb5f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 16:44:52 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/3] Add SIDE24 periodization first-variation candidate (author-side) MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Derives, from first principles, the leading nearest-image finite-size correction to the reference SIDE24 lifetime-density coefficient in the reconciled parent's own conventions: DPhi(J_inf)[J^(1)_L] / Phi(J_inf) = P_3(L) e^{-L^2/2}, P_3(L) = -L^2 (10 L^4 - 147 L^2 + 315) / 105, P_3(24) = -620813376/35, so the leading relative side-24 correction is -(620813376/35) e^{-288} ~ -1.4862e-118, strictly inside the coarse periodization band < 1e-106 already proved (outward-rational) in coefficients/side24_v1/PROOF.md. This sharpens the leading term of that reviewed band; it does not replace or weaken it, and asserts no numerical enclosure of the coefficient itself. Method (all finite algebra in the checker): O(3)-invariance makes DPhi a function of the isotropic spectral moments (a, m4, chi) only; exact S^2 moment weights; first-order Hermite image perturbation of the 1-D moments; the chain rule through Phi ~ Omega^(2/3) m4^(1/2) a^(-13/6) read off the parent §15 factors. first_variation_check.py: stdlib only, fail-closed, -O byte-identical, three mutants (M1 sphere weight, M2 a-exponent, M3 Hermite seed) each exit 1. Scientific effect: NONE; author-side candidate, nonauthor review open. Uses the parent (15.2) exponent structure as an input — not a re-derivation or re-acceptance of the parent. Delivered under a new explicit owner instruction (claude.ai session, 2026-09-29); OWNER_STOP left in place; no self-merge. A non-Claude lane (xAI/Grok or OpenAI/ChatGPT) should review, since Claude authored it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU --- .../side24-periodization-firstvar.yml | 59 +++++ .../side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md | 123 +++++++++ .../RESULTS.json | 52 ++++ .../SOURCE_FILES.json | 49 ++++ .../first_variation_check.py | 246 ++++++++++++++++++ 5 files changed, 529 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .github/workflows/side24-periodization-firstvar.yml create mode 100644 frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md create mode 100644 frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/RESULTS.json create mode 100644 frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json create mode 100644 frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/first_variation_check.py diff --git a/.github/workflows/side24-periodization-firstvar.yml b/.github/workflows/side24-periodization-firstvar.yml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d3e96a4ba --- /dev/null +++ b/.github/workflows/side24-periodization-firstvar.yml @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +name: SIDE24 periodization first-variation checks + +'on': + pull_request: + paths: + - 'frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/**' + - '.github/workflows/side24-periodization-firstvar.yml' + workflow_dispatch: + +permissions: + contents: read + +jobs: + exact-and-probe: + runs-on: ubuntu-latest + timeout-minutes: 10 + steps: + - uses: actions/checkout@11d5960a326750d5838078e36cf38b85af677262 + with: + persist-credentials: false + - uses: actions/setup-python@a26af69be951a213d495a4c3e4e4022e16d87065 + with: + python-version: '3.11.16' + - name: Verify sources, replay both modes, reject mutants + env: + PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE: '1' + run: | + set -euo pipefail + python -B -S - <<'PY' + import hashlib, json, pathlib, subprocess, sys + root = pathlib.Path('frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929').resolve() + manifest = json.loads((root / 'SOURCE_FILES.json').read_text())['files'] + present = sorted(p.name for p in root.iterdir()) + expected_names = sorted([e['path'] for e in manifest] + ['SOURCE_FILES.json']) + if present != expected_names: + raise ValueError('packet tree differs from manifest: ' + repr(present)) + for entry in manifest: + path = root / entry['path'] + if pathlib.PurePosixPath(entry['path']).name != entry['path'] or path.is_symlink(): + raise ValueError('flat regular source required: ' + entry['path']) + data = path.read_bytes() + if len(data) != entry['bytes'] or hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest() != entry['sha256']: + raise ValueError('source identity mismatch: ' + entry['path']) + script = str(root / 'first_variation_check.py') + expected = (root / 'RESULTS.json').read_bytes() + mutants = ['M1', 'M2', 'M3'] + for flags in (['-B', '-S'], ['-B', '-O', '-S']): + out = subprocess.run([sys.executable, *flags, script], + check=True, capture_output=True, timeout=300).stdout + if out != expected: + raise RuntimeError('output differs from RESULTS.json under ' + ' '.join(flags)) + for m in mutants: + rc = subprocess.run([sys.executable, *flags, script, '--mutant', m], + capture_output=True, timeout=300).returncode + if rc != 1: + raise RuntimeError('mutant ' + m + ' not rejected') + print(json.dumps({'scientific_effect': 'NONE', 'scientific_acceptance': False})) + PY + git diff --exit-code diff --git a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cec58f069 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md @@ -0,0 +1,123 @@ +# SIDE24 periodization first-variation: the exact nearest-image correction + +**Object:** CL-SIDE24-PFV-20260929-v1. **Author:** Anthropic Claude (session `session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU`). +**Disposition:** author-side candidate; **nonauthor review open**. No register, prize, `lemma_closed` flag or scientific +status is changed by this note. Scientific effect: NONE until a nonauthor lane reviews it. + +## Scope and exact parent + +This note evaluates the **leading finite-size correction** to the SIDE24 lifetime-density coefficient defined by the +reconciled parent chain: `imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md` eq. (15.2) +(blob `dfed3b8d…`, SHA256 `9350ad6e…`), read with the reading rule of +`reviews/d1_chain_reconciliation_20260928/RECONCILIATION.md`, and its `d=3` reference specialization in +`coefficients/side24_v1/PROOF.md` (blob `44b66f04…`). It does **not** re-derive, re-accept, or modify that parent +or that coefficient; it derives one additional scalar, the first image-shell variation, at the parent's own +existential scope. It asserts no numerical enclosure of the coefficient itself. + +Let `Φ(J)` be the isotropic coefficient functional of the even covariance jet `J` (spectral moments `a, m4, χ` +through order six) that the parent's §15 reduction produces, so that `c_{3,L}` in the reference normalization is +`Φ` evaluated at the side-`L` periodized jet `J_L`. Write `J_∞` for the nonperiodic Euclidean jet +(`a=1, m4=3, χ=15`, `Ω = aχ − m4² = 6`), which is `Φ`'s planar fixed point. Poisson summation gives +`J_L = J_∞ + J^{(1)}_L + (higher shells)`, where `J^{(1)}_L` is the contribution of the six nearest images +`±L e_i`, linear in `q = e^{−L²/2}`. + +## Theorem (candidate) + +With `P_3(L) = −L²(10L⁴ − 147L² + 315)/105` (equivalently `−(2/21)L⁶ + (7/5)L⁴ − 3L²`), + + DΦ(J_∞)[J^{(1)}_L] / Φ(J_∞) = P_3(L) · e^{−L²/2}, + +and hence the relative side-`L` correction is + + c_{3,L}/c_{3,∞} − 1 = P_3(L) e^{−L²/2} + ε_L, with |ε_L| bounded by the second-order/deep-shell + remainder of §5. + +At `L = 24`: `P_3(24) = −620813376/35`, so the leading relative correction is +`−(620813376/35) e^{−288} ≈ −1.4862 × 10^{−118}`, and it sits strictly inside the coarse periodization band +`|c_{3,24}/c_{3,∞} − 1| < 10^{−106}` proved (outward-rational) in `coefficients/side24_v1/PROOF.md` §§2–4. The +present note sharpens the *leading term* of that already-reviewed band; it does not weaken or replace the band. + +## 1. Rotational projection is exact because Φ is O(3)-invariant + +`Φ` depends on the even jet only through the three isotropic spectral moments `a, m4, χ` (parent §15: the cone +moment `D_u` and the scalar densities are computed after conditioning, and the leading coefficient integrates a +frame-invariant integrand over `S²`). Therefore `DΦ(J_∞)` annihilates the traceless part of any jet perturbation +and sees only its Haar (rotational) average. The relevant projection of an even jet onto `(a, m4, χ)` uses the +directional-derivative averages + + ⟨∂²_v⟩ = (1/3) Σ_i d_ii, + ⟨∂⁴_v⟩ = (1/5) Σ_i d_iiii + (2/5) Σ_{i exit 1. +# +# What this program proves is finite algebra: Hermite values, sphere-moment +# weights, the rotational projection of the six-image jet perturbation, the +# chain rule through the isotropic coefficient functional, the closed form +# P3(L), its value at L=24, and rigorous magnitude bounds. It does NOT prove +# the continuum Gaussian statements; those live in PROOF.md. + +import json +import math +import sys +from fractions import Fraction as F + +FAILURES = [] + + +def check(name, cond): + if not cond: + FAILURES.append(name) + print("FAIL " + name) + raise SystemExit(1) + + +# ---------- exact polynomials in L (coefficient dict: degree -> Fraction) ---- +def pzero(): + return {} + + +def padd(p, r): + out = dict(p) + for d, c in r.items(): + out[d] = out.get(d, F(0)) + c + if out[d] == 0: + del out[d] + return out + + +def pscale(p, s): + return {d: c * F(s) for d, c in p.items() if c * F(s) != 0} + + +def pmul(p, r): + out = {} + for d1, c1 in p.items(): + for d2, c2 in r.items(): + out[d1 + d2] = out.get(d1 + d2, F(0)) + c1 * c2 + return {d: c for d, c in out.items() if c != 0} + + +def peval(p, x): + return sum(c * F(x) ** d for d, c in p.items()) + + +def peq(p, r): + return padd(p, pscale(r, -1)) == {} + + +# ---------- probabilists' Hermite polynomials He_k, exact ---------- +def hermite(k): + # He_0 = 1, He_1 = x, He_{n+1} = x He_n - n He_{n-1} + hs = [{0: F(1)}, {1: F(1)}] + while len(hs) <= k: + n = len(hs) - 1 + hs.append(padd(pmul({1: F(1)}, hs[n]), pscale(hs[n - 1], -n))) + return hs[k] + + +def dfact(n): # double factorial of odd n (n!!), n >= -1 + out = 1 + while n > 1: + out *= n + n -= 2 + return out + + +def main(argv): + mutant = None + if len(argv) == 3 and argv[1] == "--mutant": + mutant = argv[2] + elif len(argv) != 1: + print("usage: first_variation_check.py [--mutant M1|M2|M3]") + raise SystemExit(2) + + results = {} + + # ---- H1: Hermite seeds and values --------------------------------------- + seed = F(2) if mutant == "M3" else F(1) # M3 corrupts He_1 + He = {k: hermite(k) for k in (0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)} + if mutant == "M3": + He[1] = {1: seed} + # rebuild upward with the corrupted seed + hs = [He[0], He[1]] + for n in range(1, 6): + hs.append(padd(pmul({1: F(1)}, hs[n]), pscale(hs[n - 1], -n))) + for k in range(7): + He[k] = hs[k] + he0 = {k: peval(He[k], 0) for k in (0, 2, 4, 6)} + check("H1_he0", [he0[0], he0[2], he0[4], he0[6]] == [F(1), F(-1), F(3), F(-15)]) + check("H1_He2", peq(He[2], {2: F(1), 0: F(-1)})) + check("H1_He4", peq(He[4], {4: F(1), 2: F(-6), 0: F(3)})) + check("H1_He6", peq(He[6], {6: F(1), 4: F(-15), 2: F(45), 0: F(-15)})) + # derivative identity spot check: (d/dz)^k e^{-z^2/2} = (-1)^k He_k(z) e^{-z^2/2} + # verified structurally by the recurrence used; record the three values used + results["H1_hermite"] = {"He2": "L^2-1", "He4": "L^4-6L^2+3", + "He6": "L^6-15L^4+45L^2-15", "at_zero": [1, -1, 3, -15]} + + # ---- H2: sphere moments on S^2 via the Gaussian factorization ----------- + # E[v1^{2a} v2^{2b} v3^{2c}] = (2a-1)!!(2b-1)!!(2c-1)!! / (2n+1)!!, n=a+b+c + # (g = R v with R^2 ~ chi^2_3 independent of v; E chi^2_3-moments = (2n+1)!!/1) + def smom(a, b, c): + n = a + b + c + return F(dfact(2 * a - 1) * dfact(2 * b - 1) * dfact(2 * c - 1), + dfact(2 * n + 1)) + + # chi^2_3 moment recursion cross-check: E R^{2n} = prod_{j 3*smom6 + 18*smom42/... keep the + # direct expansion: multinomial coefficients 1 (aaa), 3 (a^2b), 6 (abc): + # 3*E v1^6 + 3*perm... expansion above verified: 3*(1/7) + 18*(1/35) + 6*(1/105) = 15/35+18/35+2/35 = 1 + results["H2_sphere_moments"] = {"v1^2": "1/3", "v1^4": "1/5", "v1^2v2^2": "1/15", + "v1^6": "1/7", "v1^4v2^2": "1/35", + "v1^2v2^2v3^2": "1/105"} + + # ---- H3: projection weights (directional-derivative averages) ----------- + # = sum E[v_i v_j v_k v_l] d_ijkl: d_iiii weight 1/5; + # d_iijj (i weight 6/15 = 2/5. + w_iijj = F(1, 5) if mutant == "M1" else 6 * smom(1, 1, 0) + check("H3_w4_iiii", smom(2, 0, 0) == F(1, 5)) + check("H3_w4_iijj", w_iijj == F(2, 5)) + # : d_iiiiii weight 1/7; d_iiiijj (i!=j ordered) 6!/(4!2!) = 15 orderings, + # each E = 1/35 -> 15/35 = 3/7; d_iijjkk 6!/(2!2!2!) = 90 orderings, E = 1/105 -> 6/7. + check("H3_w6_i6", smom(3, 0, 0) == F(1, 7)) + check("H3_w6_i4j2", 15 * smom(2, 1, 0) == F(3, 7)) + check("H3_w6_112233", 90 * smom(1, 1, 1) == F(6, 7)) + results["H3_projection_weights"] = {"d4": ["1/5", "2/5"], "d6": ["1/7", "3/7", "6/7"]} + + # ---- H4: per-q first-order normalized 1-D moment perturbations ---------- + # dm_{2j}(L) = 2 (He_{2j}(L) - He_{2j}(0)) [coefficient of q; Z_L division included] + dm = {2 * j: pscale(padd(He[2 * j] if 2 * j else {0: F(1)}, + {0: -he0.get(2 * j, F(1))}), 2) for j in (1, 2, 3)} + # ---- H5: assemble the projected radial-moment variations (per q) -------- + # per-axis / per-pair structure (six images +/- L e_i; only the matching + # 1-D factor is perturbed at first order): + # Per-axis perturbations of the summed (unnormalized-by-count) radial moments. + # There are 3 axes i and, for the mixed terms, 3 unordered pairs {i,j}. + # = (1/3) sum_i d_ii ; only the axis-i image family perturbs d_ii. + d_ii = dm[2] # per axis i + # = (1/5) sum_i d_iiii + (2/5) sum_{i = (1/7) sum_i d_i^6 + (3/7) sum_{i 27182818284/10^10, so e^288 > (27182818284/10^10)^288; compare 10^125. + e_lo = F(27182818284, 10 ** 10) + lhs = e_lo ** 288 + check("H8_exp_bound", lhs > F(10) ** 125) + # hence e^{-288} < 10^{-125} and |P3(24)| e^{-288} < 1.8e7 * 1e-125 < 1e-117 + check("H8_linear_term_band", abs(P324) * F(10) ** -125 < F(1, 10 ** 117)) + check("H8_inside_coarse_band", F(1, 10 ** 117) < F(1, 10 ** 106)) + # informational float value of the linear term + lin = abs(float(P324)) * math.exp(-288.0) + check("H8_float_scale", 1.0e-118 < lin < 2.0e-118) + results["H8_bounds"] = {"e^-288": "<1e-125 (exact rational)", + "|P3(24)|e^-288": "<1e-117 (exact); ~%.4e (float)" % lin, + "coarse_band": "1e-106 (side24_v1 (4)); linear term inside"} + + out = { + "object": "CL-SIDE24-PFV-20260929-v1-CHECKS", + "scope": ("finite exact controls for the nearest-image first-variation " + "candidate; not the Gaussian/analytic proof"), + "results": results, + "passed": True, + } + print(json.dumps(out, indent=2, sort_keys=True)) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main(sys.argv) From 2af74799a442b94aa74477e23c99d7332664b2a9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 17:51:33 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/3] =?UTF-8?q?SIDE24=20periodization=20v1.1:=20derive=20t?= =?UTF-8?q?he=20=C2=A74=20exponents=20(answers=20xAI=20Slice=20A=20HOLD)?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit xAI/Harper ACCEPTed every Slice A identity on #144 and HOLD the §4 exponent read-off. v1.1 removes the read-off: the three exponents of Phi ~ Omega^(2/3) m4^(d/2-1) a^(-d/2-2/3) are now derived from finite Gaussian conditioning of the isotropic jet (Cov G = a I; det Cov V = m4 (m4/3)^(d-1); tau^2 = chi - m4^2/a as a Schur complement; the transverse Hessian given V=0 is the m4=3 reference law scaled by sqrt(m4/3), so D_u ~ m4^(d-1) by degree-2m homogeneity). At d=3 this is (-13/6, 1/2, 2/3); at m4=3 the conditional law is exactly (2/3)dd+dd+dd of side24_v1 §1. Checker H6 now verifies the conditional-covariance scaling at four rational m4 values, the tau^2 Schur complement, and the exponent sums for d=2..7, exactly in Fractions. Sections 1-3, 5, all closed forms, P_3(L), P_3(24) and the bounds are unchanged. -O byte-identical; mutants M1-M3 exit 1. What §4 consumes from the parent is now only the *shape* of (15.2). The values of the four factors under any isotropic jet are computed here. Scientific effect: NONE. Author-side; nonauthor review open; no self-merge. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU --- .../side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md | 56 ++++++++++++++++--- .../RESULTS.json | 2 +- .../SOURCE_FILES.json | 17 +++--- .../first_variation_check.py | 51 ++++++++++++++--- 4 files changed, 100 insertions(+), 26 deletions(-) diff --git a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md index cec58f069..56f4af15f 100644 --- a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md +++ b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md @@ -74,20 +74,58 @@ the per-axis / per-pair perturbations through the §1 projection gives, per unit (These are the exact closed forms the checker verifies as `H5_*`.) -## 4. The chain rule through Φ, and where the exponents come from - -The parent's reference specialization writes the coefficient integrand as a product whose isotropic-family -dependence is `Φ ∝ Ω^{2/3} m4^{1/2} a^{−13/6}`, `Ω = aχ − m4²`. The three exponents are read off the §15 -factors: the two gradient/`V`-densities contribute `p_G(0) ∝ a^{−3/2}` and `p_V(0) ∝ m4^{−3/2}`; the scalar -`τ_u^{4/3} = (Ω/a)^{2/3}` contributes `Ω^{2/3} a^{−2/3}`; the cone-moment scale `D_u ∝ m4²`. Summing: -`a: −3/2 − 2/3 = −13/6`, `m4: −3/2 + 2 = 1/2`, `Ω: 2/3`. Hence at the planar point `(1,3,15)`, `Ω = 6`, +## 4. The chain rule through Φ: the three exponents derived, not read off + +(v1.1, answering the xAI Slice A HOLD: every exponent below is an identity of finite Gaussian conditioning, +verifiable in any lane without the parent's prose.) + +**The isotropic family.** Let `J = (a, m4, χ)` be the even jet of a covariance that is isotropic through order six, +in the parent's sign convention `a = −⟨∂²_v K⟩(0)`, `m4 = +⟨∂⁴_v K⟩(0)`, `χ = −⟨∂⁶_v K⟩(0)`. Isotropy fixes the +derivative tensors up to these scalars: `∂_i∂_j K(0) = −a δ_ij`, `∂_i∂_j∂_k∂_l K(0) = (m4/3)(δ_ij δ_kl + δ_ik δ_jl ++ δ_il δ_jk)` (so `d_iiii = m4`, `d_iijj = m4/3`), and the axial sixth derivative `∂_x⁶ K(0) = −χ`. Using +`Cov(∂^α f, ∂^β f) = (−1)^{|β|} ∂^{α+β} K(0)`, the §15 objects at a contact point with axis `u = e_x` and +transverse coordinates `y ∈ ℝ^m`, `m = d − 1`, are: + +1. **Gradient.** `Cov(G) = a I_d`, so `p_G(0) = (2π)^{−d/2} a^{−d/2}`. +2. **The `V_u` block.** `V_u = (f_xx, f_{xy_1}, …, f_{xy_m})` has `Var f_xx = m4`, `Var f_{xy_j} = d_{xxy_jy_j} = m4/3`, + and all cross-covariances vanish (each would be a fourth derivative with an odd number of one index). Hence + `det Cov(V_u) = m4 (m4/3)^m` and `p_{V_u}(0) = (2π)^{−d/2} 3^{m/2} m4^{−d/2}`. +3. **The axial third derivative.** `Var f_xxx = χ`, `Cov(f_xxx, f_x) = −m4`, `Var f_x = a`, and `f_xxx` is + uncorrelated with the transverse gradient components. So `τ_u² = Var(f_xxx | G = 0) = χ − m4²/a = Ω/a`, + `Ω := aχ − m4²`, and `τ_u^{4/3} = Ω^{2/3} a^{−2/3}`. (Reference values: `15 − 9 = 6`.) +4. **The transverse Hessian given `V_u = 0`.** Unconditionally `Cov(A_ii, A_jj) = (m4/3)(1 + 2δ_ij)`, + `Var A_ij = m4/3` for `i ≠ j`, off-diagonal entries uncorrelated with the diagonal ones and with `V_u`; + `Cov(A_ii, f_xx) = d_{xxy_iy_i} = m4/3`; `Cov(A_ij, f_{xy_k}) = 0` (odd in `x`). Conditioning on `f_xx = 0` + (the only correlated coordinate of `V_u`) subtracts `(m4/3)²/m4 = m4/9` from every diagonal–diagonal + covariance: + + Cov(A_ii, A_jj | V_u = 0) = (m4/3)(2/3 + 2δ_ij), Var(A_ij | V_u = 0) = m4/3 (i ≠ j). + + At `m4 = 3` this is exactly `(2/3)δ_ijδ_kl + δ_ikδ_jl + δ_ilδ_jk`, i.e. `A = Q + √(2/3) Z I_m` of + `coefficients/side24_v1` §1 (and `Var A = 8/3` for `m = 1`). In general the conditional law is the fixed + `m4 = 3` law scaled by `√(m4/3)`; since `h(A) = det(A)² 1{A < 0}` is homogeneous of degree `2m` and the cone + is scale-invariant, `D_u = (m4/3)^m D_u^{(3)}`, i.e. **`D_u ∝ m4^{d−1}`**. + +**Exponents in every `d`.** Multiplying 1–4, the isotropic-family dependence of the (15.2) integrand — hence of +`Φ`, since the angular integral of a constant is a constant — is + + Φ ∝ a^{−d/2 − 2/3} · m4^{d/2 − 1} · Ω^{2/3}. + +For `d = 3`: `Φ ∝ Ω^{2/3} m4^{1/2} a^{−13/6}`. (For `d = 2` the `m4` exponent is `0`, consistent with +`coefficients/side24_v1` eq. (1) where `D_1 = 4/3` carries `m4¹` against `p_V ∝ m4^{−1}`.) The checker verifies +items 1–4 and the exponent sums exactly (group `H6`), including the conditional-covariance scaling at several +rational `m4` values. Hence at the planar point `(1,3,15)`, `Ω = 6`, d log Φ = (2/3)(dΩ/6) + (1/2)(dm4/3) − (13/6) da = dΩ/9 + dm4/6 − (13/6) da, dΩ = χ da + a dχ − 2 m4 dm4 = 15 da + dχ − 6 dm4. Substituting §3 and dividing by `q` yields exactly `P_3(L)`. The amplitude-normalization check (`c ∝ A^{−2/3}` -under `f → Af`, matching `ν_{Af}(ℓ) = A^{−1}ν_f(ℓ/A)`) is the parent's own consistency identity and is reproduced -in the D1-E full-depth review; it fixes the overall power bookkeeping the exponents above must satisfy. +under `f → Af`, matching `ν_{Af}(ℓ) = A^{−1}ν_f(ℓ/A)`) is the parent's own consistency identity — with the general +exponents above it reads `−d/2·2 + 4/3 + 2(d−1) = −2/3` and is reproduced in the D1-E full-depth review. + +**What §4 consumes from the parent.** Only the *shape* of (15.2): that the leading coefficient is the angular +integral of `p_G(0) p_{V_u}(0) τ_u^{4/3} D_u` times a jet-independent constant. The values of the four factors +under any isotropic jet are computed here from the covariance alone. ## 5. Remainder (what a reviewer must still bound analytically) diff --git a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/RESULTS.json b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/RESULTS.json index faf6adc86..b33590a1c 100644 --- a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/RESULTS.json +++ b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/RESULTS.json @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ "dchi": "-(6/7)L^6+18L^4-90L^2", "dm4": "(6/5)L^4-12L^2" }, - "H6_chain": "dlogc = dOmega/9 + dm4/6 - (13/6) da at (1,3,15)", + "H6_chain": "exponents derived: a^(-d/2-2/3) m4^(d/2-1) Omega^(2/3); d=3 -> (-13/6, 1/2, 2/3); dlogc = dOmega/9 + dm4/6 - (13/6) da at (1,3,15)", "H7_P3": { "P3(24)": "-620813376/35", "P3(L)": "-L^2(10L^4-147L^2+315)/105" diff --git a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json index b79246737..7267608cb 100644 --- a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json +++ b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json @@ -15,19 +15,19 @@ "delivered_under": "owner instruction in claude.ai session 2026-09-29; OWNER_STOP left in place; no self-merge; scientific effect NONE", "files": [ { - "bytes": 8180, + "bytes": 11111, "path": "PROOF.md", - "sha256": "619586615ca1311794d6fe171f107121f307dbdb440ecb6f9293c9967feb2877" + "sha256": "745493e5e69fa794c44f07fce18c4fc3782ab31a5843184caff860254ffe33aa" }, { - "bytes": 11333, + "bytes": 13368, "path": "first_variation_check.py", - "sha256": "6845c7eb19ede2389d1b1c19306c0e5d23a172ea5030201f662f503eadf2b85f" + "sha256": "57d0cac78975ee6c1a23321d8aa44cff92681fb2a42aff8fe820f727c975d6f3" }, { - "bytes": 1225, + "bytes": 1307, "path": "RESULTS.json", - "sha256": "fe9a48c57f69cccc1c6e956f9fe1040b372cfd90db0bf9c7889b3400f40d4293" + "sha256": "b9a28da8aa4332fcf67fc6a1a61d0c8c5caead4de6f15d653a8aafa0426c268c" } ], "mutants": [ @@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ "M2", "M3" ], - "object": "CL-SIDE24-PFV-20260929-v1", + "object": "CL-SIDE24-PFV-20260929-v1.1", "result": { "P3(24)": "-620813376/35", "P3(L)": "-L^2(10L^4-147L^2+315)/105", @@ -45,5 +45,6 @@ "reviewer_session": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU", "scientific_acceptance": false, "scientific_effect": "NONE", - "scope": "leading nearest-image first-variation of the reference SIDE24 coefficient; author-side; nonauthor review open" + "scope": "leading nearest-image first-variation of the reference SIDE24 coefficient; author-side; nonauthor review open", + "v1_1_change": "\u00a74 rewritten: the three exponents are derived from finite Gaussian conditioning of the isotropic jet (general d), not read off; checker H6 extended (conditional-covariance scaling, tau^2 Schur complement, general-d exponent sums). \u00a71-3, \u00a75 and the closed forms unchanged." } diff --git a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/first_variation_check.py b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/first_variation_check.py index fd8620421..c9ae70c5d 100644 --- a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/first_variation_check.py +++ b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/first_variation_check.py @@ -187,25 +187,60 @@ def smom(a, b, c): results["H5_moment_variations_per_q"] = { "da": "-2L^2", "dm4": "(6/5)L^4-12L^2", "dchi": "-(6/7)L^6+18L^4-90L^2"} - # ---- H6: isotropic functional exponents and the chain rule -------------- - # c proportional to Omega^{2/3} m4^{1/2} a^{-13/6}, Omega = a chi - m4^2: - # from (15.2)-specialization factors p_G ~ a^{-3/2}, p_V ~ m4^{-3/2}, - # tau^{4/3} = (Omega/a)^{2/3}, D-scale ~ m4^2 (derivation in PROOF.md §4). - ea = F(-3, 2) + F(-2, 3) # a exponent (-13/6) - em = F(-3, 2) + F(2) # m4 exponent (1/2) - eo = F(2, 3) # Omega exponent + # ---- H6: isotropic functional exponents, DERIVED from finite Gaussian + # conditioning (PROOF.md §4 items 1-4), then the chain rule ------------- + # Item 4: transverse Hessian A (m=2: A11, A22, A12) jointly with f_xx under the + # isotropic rank-4 tensor d_ijkl = (m4/3)(dd+dd+dd); condition on f_xx = 0. + def cond_cov_A(m4): + m4 = F(m4) + # unconditional: Cov(Aii,Ajj) = (m4/3)(1+2δ), Var(A12) = m4/3, + # Cov(Aii, fxx) = m4/3, Var(fxx) = m4; A12 uncorrelated with fxx. + c = {} + for i in (1, 2): + for j in (1, 2): + c[(i, j)] = (m4 / 3) * (1 + (2 if i == j else 0)) - (m4 / 3) ** 2 / m4 + return c, m4 / 3 # diagonal block after conditioning; Var(A12) + for m4 in (F(3), F(5, 2), F(7), F(1, 3)): + c, v12 = cond_cov_A(m4) + s = m4 / 3 # predicted scale factor (m4/3) times the m4=3 law + check("H6_condcov_diag_scaling_m4=%s" % m4, + c[(1, 1)] == s * F(8, 3) and c[(2, 2)] == s * F(8, 3) + and c[(1, 2)] == s * F(2, 3) and v12 == s * F(1)) + # at m4 = 3 the law is (2/3)dd+dd+dd: Var Aii = 8/3, Cov(A11,A22) = 2/3, Var A12 = 1 + c3, v3 = cond_cov_A(3) + check("H6_condcov_reference_law", c3[(1, 1)] == F(8, 3) and c3[(1, 2)] == F(2, 3) and v3 == 1) + # Item 3: tau^2 = Var(f_xxx | G=0) = chi - m4^2/a (Schur complement), reference 15-9=6 + def tau2(a, m4, chi): + return F(chi) - F(m4) ** 2 / F(a) + check("H6_tau2_reference", tau2(1, 3, 15) == 6) + check("H6_tau2_is_Omega_over_a", all(tau2(a, m4, chi) == (F(a) * chi - F(m4) ** 2) / F(a) + for (a, m4, chi) in ((1, 3, 15), (2, 5, 40), (F(1, 2), 1, 9)))) + # Items 1,2,4 + exponent sums in every d: p_G ~ a^{-d/2}; p_V ~ m4^{-d/2} + # (det Cov V = m4 (m4/3)^{d-1}); tau^{4/3} ~ Omega^{2/3} a^{-2/3}; D_u ~ m4^{d-1} + def exponents(d): + ea = F(-d, 2) + F(-2, 3) + em = F(-d, 2) + F(d - 1) + eo = F(2, 3) + return ea, em, eo + for d in range(2, 8): + ea, em, eo = exponents(d) + check("H6_exp_general_d%d" % d, ea == F(-d, 2) - F(2, 3) and em == F(d, 2) - 1 and eo == F(2, 3)) + # amplitude check: p_G ~ A^{-d}, p_V ~ A^{-d}, tau^{4/3} ~ A^{4/3}, D ~ A^{2(d-1)} + check("H6_amplitude_d%d" % d, F(-d) + F(-d) + F(4, 3) + F(2 * (d - 1)) == F(-2, 3)) + ea, em, eo = exponents(3) # M2 corrupts the target a-exponent to -11/6; the true value -13/6 then fails. target_a = F(-11, 6) if mutant == "M2" else F(-13, 6) check("H6_exp_a", ea == target_a) check("H6_exp_m4", em == F(1, 2)) check("H6_exp_Omega", eo == F(2, 3)) + check("H6_exp_d2_m4_is_zero", exponents(2)[1] == 0) # chain at planar (a, m4, chi) = (1, 3, 15), Omega = 6: # dlog c = (2/3) dOmega/6 + (1/2) dm4/3 - (13/6) da = dOmega/9 + dm4/6 - (13/6) da check("H6_planar_weights", F(2, 3) / 6 == F(1, 9) and F(1, 2) / 3 == F(1, 6)) dOmega = padd(padd(pscale(da, 15), dchi), pscale(dm4, -6)) # chi da + a dchi - 2 m4 dm4 dlogc = padd(padd(pscale(dOmega, F(1, 9)), pscale(dm4, F(1, 6))), pscale(da, F(-13, 6))) - results["H6_chain"] = "dlogc = dOmega/9 + dm4/6 - (13/6) da at (1,3,15)" + results["H6_chain"] = "exponents derived: a^(-d/2-2/3) m4^(d/2-1) Omega^(2/3); d=3 -> (-13/6, 1/2, 2/3); dlogc = dOmega/9 + dm4/6 - (13/6) da at (1,3,15)" # ---- H7: the closed form P3(L) and its value at 24 ----------------------- P3_stated = pscale(pmul({2: F(1)}, {4: F(10), 2: F(-147), 0: F(315)}), F(-1, 105)) From 56daf0bd9e75d4420262901e845fabfea32b0034 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 16:33:51 -0500 Subject: [PATCH 3/3] fix: distinguish normalized remainder and first-order Haar projection --- .../side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md | 68 ++++++++++++------- .../SOURCE_FILES.json | 4 +- 2 files changed, 46 insertions(+), 26 deletions(-) diff --git a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md index 56f4af15f..1a84f215c 100644 --- a/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md +++ b/frontiers/side24_periodization_20260929/PROOF.md @@ -14,12 +14,14 @@ reconciled parent chain: `imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AN or that coefficient; it derives one additional scalar, the first image-shell variation, at the parent's own existential scope. It asserts no numerical enclosure of the coefficient itself. -Let `Φ(J)` be the isotropic coefficient functional of the even covariance jet `J` (spectral moments `a, m4, χ` -through order six) that the parent's §15 reduction produces, so that `c_{3,L}` in the reference normalization is -`Φ` evaluated at the side-`L` periodized jet `J_L`. Write `J_∞` for the nonperiodic Euclidean jet -(`a=1, m4=3, χ=15`, `Ω = aχ − m4² = 6`), which is `Φ`'s planar fixed point. Poisson summation gives -`J_L = J_∞ + J^{(1)}_L + (higher shells)`, where `J^{(1)}_L` is the contribution of the six nearest images -`±L e_i`, linear in `q = e^{−L²/2}`. +Let `Φ(J)` be the `O(3)`-invariant coefficient functional on the full even covariance-jet tensors through order +six, defined by the parent's §15 angular integral. The moments `(a, m4, χ)` parametrize its restriction to the +isotropic jet family used in §4; the side-`L` periodized jet `J_L` need not be isotropic. In the reference +normalization, `c_{3,L} = Φ(J_L)`. Write `J_∞` for the isotropic nonperiodic Euclidean jet +(`a=1, m4=3, χ=15`, `Ω = aχ − m4² = 6`), which is fixed by rotations. Poisson summation gives +`J_L = J_∞ + J^{(1)}_L + R_L`, where `J^{(1)}_L` is the term linear in `q = e^{−L²/2}` from the six nearest +images `±L e_i` after normalization. The remaining normalized jet `R_L` includes normalization/product terms +as well as higher image shells. ## Theorem (candidate) @@ -29,8 +31,10 @@ With `P_3(L) = −L²(10L⁴ − 147L² + 315)/105` (equivalently `−(2/21)L⁶ and hence the relative side-`L` correction is - c_{3,L}/c_{3,∞} − 1 = P_3(L) e^{−L²/2} + ε_L, with |ε_L| bounded by the second-order/deep-shell - remainder of §5. + c_{3,L}/c_{3,∞} − 1 = P_3(L) e^{−L²/2} + ε_L, + +where `ε_L` consists of the nonlinear functional and remaining normalized-jet terms described in §5; no new +sharp bound on `ε_L` is asserted here. At `L = 24`: `P_3(24) = −620813376/35`, so the leading relative correction is `−(620813376/35) e^{−288} ≈ −1.4862 × 10^{−118}`, and it sits strictly inside the coarse periodization band @@ -39,11 +43,15 @@ present note sharpens the *leading term* of that already-reviewed band; it does ## 1. Rotational projection is exact because Φ is O(3)-invariant -`Φ` depends on the even jet only through the three isotropic spectral moments `a, m4, χ` (parent §15: the cone -moment `D_u` and the scalar densities are computed after conditioning, and the leading coefficient integrates a -frame-invariant integrand over `S²`). Therefore `DΦ(J_∞)` annihilates the traceless part of any jet perturbation -and sees only its Haar (rotational) average. The relevant projection of an even jet onto `(a, m4, χ)` uses the -directional-derivative averages +The full coefficient functional is `O(3)`-invariant because rotating a covariance jet rotates the angular +integration variable in the parent's §15 integral. Since `J_∞` is fixed by rotations, its derivative satisfies +`DΦ(J_∞)[U·H] = DΦ(J_∞)[H]` for every rotation `U` and jet perturbation `H`. By linearity, + + DΦ(J_∞)[H] = DΦ(J_∞)[∫_{O(3)} U·H dU], + +where Haar measure is normalized to mass one. Consequently only the Haar projection of `H` onto the isotropic +three-moment subspace contributes to this first variation; no such reduction is asserted for `Φ` at a general +anisotropic jet. The relevant projection onto `(a, m4, χ)` uses the directional-derivative averages ⟨∂²_v⟩ = (1/3) Σ_i d_ii, ⟨∂⁴_v⟩ = (1/5) Σ_i d_iiii + (2/5) Σ_{i