From 930f9737eea2b4233beab0dcff3ee435c02fbc68 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 16:58:42 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/4] Add literature reconnaissance memo for the near-diagonal H0 lifetime law MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Records a documented literature and novelty search (coverage through 2026-09-29) for the smooth-Gaussian-field H0 near-diagonal lifetime law nu(l) ~ c l^(-1/3), its corollaries, the d=3 reference constant, and the nearest-image periodization correction. Verdict under the protocol: no theorem found that proves, contradicts, or assigns a different exponent to this object. The only explicit small-bar power laws located are for rough processes (Perez 2023: semimartingales ~ eps^-2; Picard: Brownian/stable/fBm ~ eps^-1/H) — different regime, not a conflict. Closest structural neighbor: Feldbrugge et al. 2019 (Rice-formula pair densities for 2-D Gaussian fields, no small-gap asymptotic). No external benchmark exists for the periodization coefficient; the benchmark is the internal multi-path agreement (PR #144 and earlier derivations). For the other lanes: (A) attribution additions for successor packages; (B) a heuristic dimension-independence cross-check reviewers may raise, labelled heuristic; (C) the periodization benchmark situation; (D) the highest-value UNEXECUTED search — classical 1-D small crest-to-trough height distributions (Rice, Longuet-Higgins, Lindgren) as potential d=1 prior art; (E) verbatim MathSciNet/zbMATH queries still author-side. PROTOCOL.json carries every executed query verbatim, the exclusions, and the unexecuted list, so any lane can extend the search reproducibly. "None found" is a statement about the protocol, not proof of novelty. Scientific effect: NONE; no claim, PROOF_INDEX row, or status changes. Delivered under an explicit owner instruction (claude.ai session, 2026-09-29); OWNER_STOP left in place; no self-merge. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU --- .../PROTOCOL.json | 58 ++++++++ .../RECONNAISSANCE.md | 128 ++++++++++++++++++ .../SOURCE_FILES.json | 21 +++ 3 files changed, 207 insertions(+) create mode 100644 reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json create mode 100644 reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md create mode 100644 reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..48fd10335 --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +{ + "object": "CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1", + "coverage_target": "through 2026-09-29", + "exclusions": ["github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder", "mirrors of the project's own repositories"], + "executed": { + "pass_1_session_web_search_4_queries": [ + "expected persistence diagram density near diagonal Gaussian random field short bars asymptotics", + "persistent homology short lifetime power law critical points maximum saddle pairs smooth random function", + "Bargmann-Fock field persistent homology lifetime density torus", + "Kac-Rice formula pairs critical points small height gap intensity ell^(-1/3) persistence" + ], + "pass_2_extended_research_run_18_queries": [ + "expected persistence diagram density near diagonal Gaussian random field", + "arXiv 2603.29072 \"How much of persistent homology is topology\"", + "Beliaev Cammarota Wigman no repulsion between critical points planar Gaussian random fields", + "persistence diagram smooth Gaussian random field short bars power law near diagonal asymptotics", + "Azaïs Delmas mean number and correlation function of critical points isotropic Gaussian fields", + "merge tree Gaussian random field barcode random Morse function elder rule", + "Kac-Rice persistence diagram random field expected density critical pairs", + "barcode Brownian motion expected number of bars length distribution persistent homology random process", + "persistent homology Bargmann-Fock field Betti numbers excursion sets", + "expected persistence diagram smooth stationary Gaussian process density behaviour near diagonal", + "McAuley persistence barcode Gaussian field law of large numbers topological", + "\"short bars\" persistent homology random function asymptotics number of bars length epsilon smooth", + "\"persistence\" \"near the diagonal\" smooth Gaussian process fold \"2/3\" bars length", + "Buhovsky Payette Polterovich coarse nodal count topological persistence bars length delta", + "Nicolaescu random Morse functions barcode persistence expected", + "persistence diagram Gaussian random field critical values pairs Kac-Rice \"persistence\" intensity explicit formula arXiv 2025", + "Gaussian random field on torus periodization finite-size correction critical points expected number", + "persistent homology Gaussian random field Wasserstein total persistence finite p-th moment smooth field" + ], + "forward_citation_keyword_checks": ["1802.10457", "1911.03455", "1911.02300", "1706.06059", "2012.09459", "1909.09846"] + }, + "not_executed": [ + "classical 1-D small crest-to-trough height distributions for smooth stationary Gaussian processes (Rice 1945; Longuet-Higgins; Lindgren 1972; Cartwright-Longuet-Higgins) — highest priority", + "Divol-Polonik weight functions near the diagonal", + "LLN/CLT for persistent Betti numbers of smooth Gaussian fields, 2024-2026", + "Google Scholar cited-by enumeration for 1802.10457, 1911.03455, 1911.02300, 1706.06059, 1908.01619, 2012.09459, Bobrowski-Borman 2012, Adler-Taylor 2007" + ], + "author_side_paywalled": { + "mathscinet": [ + "Anywhere=(persistence diagram OR barcode) AND Anywhere=(Gaussian random field OR Gaussian field) AND Anywhere=(diagonal OR short OR small lifetime)", + "MSC=(55N31 AND 60G60)", + "MSC=(60G60 AND 58K05) AND Anywhere=(critical value* AND (gap OR pair* OR close))", + "Anywhere=\"Bargmann-Fock\" AND Anywhere=(persistence OR Betti OR barcode)", + "Anywhere=(crest trough OR wave height) AND Anywhere=(small OR asymptotic) AND MSC=60G15" + ], + "zbmath_open": [ + "ti:(persistence OR barcode) & ab:(Gaussian field) & ab:(diagonal)", + "cc:55N31 & cc:60G60", + "ab:\"critical values\" & ab:\"Kac-Rice\" & ab:(pair* | two-point)", + "ab:\"Bargmann-Fock\" & ab:(persistent | Betti | barcode)", + "ab:(torus | periodic) & ab:\"Gaussian field\" & ab:(exponentially small | finite-size correction)" + ] + }, + "verdict": "no conflicting, overlapping, or different-exponent theorem found for the smooth-field H0 near-diagonal lifetime law under this protocol; not a proof of novelty", + "scientific_effect": "NONE" +} diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9222cfa90 --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md @@ -0,0 +1,128 @@ +# Reconnaissance memo — literature and novelty check for the near-diagonal H0 lifetime law — 2026-09-29 + +**Object:** CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1. **Author:** Anthropic Claude (claude.ai session `session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU`). +**Scientific effect:** NONE. **No priority or novelty claim follows from this memo.** It records what a documented +search did and did not find, so that any lane can extend it and so that successor attribution sections have a +verified starting list. Bibliographic details below are *as indexed by the search pass*; verify against full text +before citing in a manuscript. arXiv identifiers are the stable handles. + +## 1. Object searched + +The near-diagonal law for finite ordinary superlevel H0 bars of a smooth stationary Gaussian field on a fixed torus: +`ν(ℓ) ~ c ℓ^{−1/3}` (parent Theorem C at existential scope; coefficient (15.2)); its corollaries `N(0,t] ~ (3/2) c +t^{2/3}` and the inverse-lifetime integrability threshold `p < 2/3`; the `d = 3` reference constant +`c_{3,∞} = 2^{−23/6} 3^{−8/3} (29√6 − 36) Γ(1/6) π^{−5/2} ≈ 0.0417759318…` (`coefficients/side24_v1`, main#65); and the +nearest-image periodization correction `P_3(24) e^{−288}` (PR #144). Coverage target: through 29 September 2026. + +## 2. Verdict under this protocol + +- **Same law proved elsewhere:** none found. +- **Same law contradicted:** none found. +- **Different exponent claimed for the same object** (smooth Gaussian field, finite H0 superlevel bars, `ℓ ↓ 0`): + none found. The explicit small-bar power laws that do exist are for **rough** processes and a different counting + convention (number of bars of length `≥ ε`, divergent as `ε → 0`): `N^ε ~ [X]_t/(2ε²)` for continuous + semimartingales (Perez, arXiv:2012.09459, JACT 2023), and `N^ε ~ C_H ε^{−1/H}` for Brownian, α-stable and + fractional Brownian motion (Picard, as restated by Perez). These are neighbors, not conflicts: a `C²` path has + finite variation and is outside their regime. Perez states in print that the smooth-field case is open. +- **Bargmann–Fock-specific persistence results beyond percolation:** none found (located: Rivera–Vanneuville + critical threshold, arXiv:1711.05012; Gass–Stecconi finiteness of critical-point moments, arXiv:2305.17586). +- **Periodization / nearest-image corrections to local constants on tori:** none found. There is therefore **no + external benchmark** for the `e^{−L²/2}` term or the coefficient `−620813376/35`; the benchmark is internal and + multi-path (see §4, item C). + +"None found" is a statement about this protocol (§5), not a proof of novelty. Three planned searches were not run +and the paywalled databases were not covered; §4 lists them for the next lane. + +## 3. Closest neighbors (condensed; what each does / does not cover) + +| arXiv / venue | Work | Covers | Does not cover | +|---|---|---|---| +| 1802.10457; SoCG 2018 / JoCG 2019 | Chazal–Divol, density of expected persistence diagrams | existence and smoothness of EPD densities; Brownian sublevels; notes accumulation near the diagonal | any exponent or constant for smooth fields | +| 2012.09459; JACT 2023 | Perez, PH of a.s. `C⁰` processes | sharp `ε → 0` bar-count asymptotics for semimartingales; exact Brownian expansion | smooth fields (stated open) | +| 2110.10982 | Perez, ζ-functions of superlevel barcodes of α-stable Lévy processes | meromorphic barcode ζ-functions; pole tied to `N^ε` | smooth; `d ≥ 2` | +| 1909.09846; JACT 2025 | Baryshnikov, Brownian motion / chirality | `PH_0` intensity and correlation functions for Brownian motion with drift | smooth; `d ≥ 2` | +| 1908.01619; JCAP 2019 | Feldbrugge–van Engelen–van de Weygaert–Pranav–Vegter | **Rice-formula pair densities `p_i(b,d,r)` for (saddle, extremum) pairs of 2-D Gaussian fields**, pushed to persistence diagrams by a fitting formula | small-`(d−b)` asymptotics, exponent, constant, rigorous elder pairing — **closest structural neighbor; cite and distinguish** | +| 1911.03455; ECP 2020 | Beliaev–Cammarota–Wigman, no repulsion (planar) | leading short-distance term of the critical-point two-point function; index dependence | value gaps; persistence | +| 1704.04943; IMRN 2019 | Beliaev–Cammarota–Wigman, random plane wave | two-point function of critical points | same | +| 1911.02300; SPA 2022 | Azaïs–Delmas, critical points of isotropic fields and GOE | attraction (`d > 2`) / neutrality (`d = 2`) / repulsion (`d = 1`), attributed to adjacent-index pairs | value-gap statistics; pairing | +| 2209.04150; SPA 2023 | Ladgham–Lachièze-Rey, local repulsion of planar critical points | second factorial moment of typed critical points in small balls | values; `d ≥ 3` | +| 2109.08721 | Pranav, topology and geometry of Gaussian fields II | simulated 3-D persistence diagrams / intensity maps | asymptotics | +| 1003.1001; 2010 | Adler–Bobrowski–Borman–Subag–Weinberger | framework and simulations for barcodes of excursion sets | short-bar law | +| J. Topol. Anal. 2012 | Bobrowski–Borman, Euler integration | expected Euler integrals ↔ persistence | near-diagonal density | +| 1808.05655 | Adler et al., planar point-process models of diagrams | qualitative repulsion of diagram points via Slepian models | exponent | +| 1706.06059; 2107.11212 | Curry; "trees to barcodes II" | elder-rule map merge tree → barcode; realization counts | random-field lifetime intensity | +| 2607.23903 (2026) | Kuriki–Matsubara–Iso, critical-point densities in any `d` | one-point height distributions by index | pair gaps | +| 2305.17586; PTRF 2024 | Gass–Stecconi | finite moments of critical-point counts incl. Bargmann–Fock | persistence | +| 2206.06347; JEMS 2026 | Buhovsky–Payette–Polterovich–Polterovich–Shelukhin–Stojisavljević | deterministic bounds on bars longer than `δ` | random `δ → 0` asymptotics | +| 2603.27903 (2026) | random-matrix persistence via Morse theory | bar lengths = eigenvalue spacings; Wigner-surmise bar laws | Gaussian fields | +| 2603.29072 (2026) | Loftus, "How much of persistent homology is topology?" | point-cloud PH of spin configurations (cond-mat) | **unrelated** to Gaussian-field lifetime densities (downgraded from an earlier "worth a read" flag) | + +Forward-citation trail from Chazal–Divol (keyword-level, not an exhaustive crawl): the line quantifies near-diagonal +behavior only for Brownian-type processes and treats the near-diagonal region of smooth models as an estimation +nuisance (Maroulas–Mike–Oballe JMLR 2019; Divol–Lacombe 2105.04852; persistence-intensity estimation, PMC12083882; +2407.07326 JACT 2025; 2607.20893; 2607.27126). Nothing in it states a rate for a smooth model. + +## 4. Items the other lanes can act on + +**A. Attribution additions for successor packages.** The parent's §16 attribution cites Armentano–Azaïs–León, +Curry, and Beliaev–Cammarota–Wigman. A related-work section for the lifetime law should additionally distinguish: +Feldbrugge et al. 2019 (Rice-formula pair densities — closest structural neighbor); Perez 2023 and Picard +(rough-process small-bar laws, different regime); Azaïs–Delmas 2022 and Ladgham–Lachièze-Rey 2023 (spatial +critical-point correlations, no value gaps); Chazal–Divol 2018/19 (EPD density existence). No claim of the +parent's need be changed; this is scope-setting for readers. + +**B. A heuristic dimension-independence cross-check reviewers may raise (heuristic; not sourced; not a proof).** If +the adjacent-index critical-pair correlation scales like `r^{2−d}` at small separation — the pattern consistent with +Azaïs–Delmas's `d = 1` repulsion / `d = 2` neutrality / `d > 2` attraction — and the fold gap scales as `r³`, then +`∫ r^{2−d} · r^{d−1} dr ∝ r²` in every dimension, giving `P(gap ≤ t) ∝ t^{2/3}` and density `∝ ℓ^{−1/3}` +independently of `d`. This matches the parent §10 ledger ("the dimension cancels") from the outside, and the factor +12 in the fold gap matches the `24^{1/3}` in (15.2). It rests on two unproved assumptions (short bars come from +fold-type adjacent pairs; the elder rule pairs them) — exactly what Theorem A + CAP supply rigorously. Useful as a +sanity narrative in a discussion section; not evidence. + +**C. Periodization coefficient — the benchmark is internal.** No external work computes exponentially small +nearest-image corrections to such constants. The coefficient `P_3(24) = −620813376/35` now has independent +in-project derivations: PR #144 (first principles in the parent's (15.2) conventions, stdlib checker), the July +06B suite (SymPy, Hermite + Haar), the OKComputer 2026-08 first-variation script, and a clean-context re-check on +2026-09-29 — all exact agreement. `|P_3(24)| e^{−288} < 10^{−117}` sits inside side24_v1's reviewed `< 10^{−106}` +band. The remainder enclosure remains PR #144's flagged open item. + +**D. Highest-value unexecuted search — for a lane with web access.** The classical 1-D wave literature on the +distribution of *small* crest-to-trough heights of a smooth stationary Gaussian process (Rice 1945; Longuet-Higgins; +Lindgren 1972 "Wave-length and amplitude in Gaussian noise"; Cartwright–Longuet-Higgins) is the natural `d = 1` +neighbor of the max–min small-gap law and was **not** searched. If a `t^{−1/3}` small-height density is already +explicit there, it is prior art for the `d = 1` exponent (not a conflict — the parent is `d ≥ 2` on a torus with +elder pairing) and must be cited. Also unexecuted: Divol–Polonik weight functions near the diagonal; LLN/CLT for +persistent Betti numbers of smooth Gaussian fields 2024–2026; Google-Scholar "cited by" enumeration for +1802.10457, 1911.03455, 1911.02300, 1706.06059, 1908.01619, 2012.09459, Bobrowski–Borman, Adler–Taylor. + +**E. Author-side paywalled queries (verbatim, not yet run).** +MathSciNet: `Anywhere=(persistence diagram OR barcode) AND Anywhere=(Gaussian random field OR Gaussian field) AND +Anywhere=(diagonal OR short OR small lifetime)`; `MSC=(55N31 AND 60G60)`; `MSC=(60G60 AND 58K05) AND +Anywhere=(critical value* AND (gap OR pair* OR close))`; `Anywhere="Bargmann-Fock" AND Anywhere=(persistence OR +Betti OR barcode)`; `Anywhere=(crest trough OR wave height) AND Anywhere=(small OR asymptotic) AND MSC=60G15`. +zbMATH Open: `ti:(persistence OR barcode) & ab:(Gaussian field) & ab:(diagonal)`; `cc:55N31 & cc:60G60`; +`ab:"critical values" & ab:"Kac-Rice" & ab:(pair* | two-point)`; `ab:"Bargmann-Fock" & ab:(persistent | Betti | +barcode)`; `ab:(torus | periodic) & ab:"Gaussian field" & ab:(exponentially small | finite-size correction)`. + +## 5. Protocol record + +- **Executed 2026-09-29** in two passes: (i) a four-query web pass by this session (near-diagonal EPD density + asymptotics; short-lifetime power law for max/saddle pairs; Bargmann–Fock persistent homology; Kac–Rice small- + height-gap pair intensity); (ii) an extended web-research run (18 general-search queries plus a delegated + sub-search of ~17 calls) indexing arXiv (math.PR, math.AT, math-ph, math.DG, cond-mat), Project Euclid, Springer + (JACT, PTRF), ScienceDirect, JMLR, PMC, ORA, author pages, with keyword forward-citation checks of 1802.10457, + 1911.03455, 1911.02300, 1706.06059, 2012.09459, 1909.09846. Verbatim queries are in `PROTOCOL.json`. +- **Exclusions:** `github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder` and mirrors (self-hits). The project is now search-indexed, so any + future novelty search must apply this exclusion. +- **Caveats:** keyword search is not a citation crawl; several items were characterized from snippets or + summaries and must be verified against full text; the §4-B argument is an inference made for this memo. +- **Prior in-repo reconnaissance this memo extends:** parent §16 "Primary-source attribution"; side24_v1 "External + reconnaissance, 24 September 2026" (DLMF only); OKComputer 2026-08 Part D web pass (five clusters, superseded + packet). + +## 6. Relation to open registers + +This memo discharges the *web-level* part of the standing literature item that every register since July 2026 has +carried ("paywalled MathSciNet/zbMATH pass remains author-side"). It does not close that item: §4-D and §4-E remain. +It changes no claim in `claims/LANDING_CLAIMS.json`, no `PROOF_INDEX.md` row, and no status anywhere. diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9d427ec87 --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "author": "Anthropic Claude", + "delivered_under": "explicit owner instruction, claude.ai session 2026-09-29; OWNER_STOP left in place; no self-merge", + "files": [ + { + "bytes": 12325, + "path": "RECONNAISSANCE.md", + "sha256": "e9e885a3e4a681a2c92bedec2f7fdfaba4694d12af6b441109b6f7699b8917f1" + }, + { + "bytes": 4198, + "path": "PROTOCOL.json", + "sha256": "b4a5e1fd3c515405783eaf22d125b6e68a12208480b72c4adba37c35511059de" + } + ], + "kind": "literature reconnaissance memo (prose + machine-readable protocol); no checker", + "novelty_claim": false, + "object": "CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1", + "scientific_effect": "NONE", + "session": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU" +} From 12565f7f2b088bb60619a841b0a9ae7116035901 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 20:49:06 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/4] Literature memo v1.1: record the executed 1-D neighbor pass (Lindgren 1972 full text) Records both passes on the highest-priority unexecuted search: the author's web-level location of Lindgren 1972 / Lindgren-Rychlik 1982, and the OpenAI lane's full-text read (PR #147 comment 5897859268): prior art for the d=1 amplitude object and Slepian conditional formulas, no explicit small- amplitude -1/3 density asymptotic located, absence from the 1-D literature not claimed. Adopts that as the successor attribution wording; Rice 1945, Longuet-Higgins and Cartwright-Longuet-Higgins remain unread at full-text level. PROTOCOL.json gains executed.pass_3 and a narrowed not_executed entry. Scientific effect: NONE. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU --- .../PROTOCOL.json | 125 ++++++++++-------- .../RECONNAISSANCE.md | 22 ++- .../SOURCE_FILES.json | 8 +- 3 files changed, 91 insertions(+), 64 deletions(-) diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json index 48fd10335..f4d8bd38c 100644 --- a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/PROTOCOL.json @@ -1,58 +1,73 @@ { - "object": "CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1", - "coverage_target": "through 2026-09-29", - "exclusions": ["github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder", "mirrors of the project's own repositories"], - "executed": { - "pass_1_session_web_search_4_queries": [ - "expected persistence diagram density near diagonal Gaussian random field short bars asymptotics", - "persistent homology short lifetime power law critical points maximum saddle pairs smooth random function", - "Bargmann-Fock field persistent homology lifetime density torus", - "Kac-Rice formula pairs critical points small height gap intensity ell^(-1/3) persistence" - ], - "pass_2_extended_research_run_18_queries": [ - "expected persistence diagram density near diagonal Gaussian random field", - "arXiv 2603.29072 \"How much of persistent homology is topology\"", - "Beliaev Cammarota Wigman no repulsion between critical points planar Gaussian random fields", - "persistence diagram smooth Gaussian random field short bars power law near diagonal asymptotics", - "Azaïs Delmas mean number and correlation function of critical points isotropic Gaussian fields", - "merge tree Gaussian random field barcode random Morse function elder rule", - "Kac-Rice persistence diagram random field expected density critical pairs", - "barcode Brownian motion expected number of bars length distribution persistent homology random process", - "persistent homology Bargmann-Fock field Betti numbers excursion sets", - "expected persistence diagram smooth stationary Gaussian process density behaviour near diagonal", - "McAuley persistence barcode Gaussian field law of large numbers topological", - "\"short bars\" persistent homology random function asymptotics number of bars length epsilon smooth", - "\"persistence\" \"near the diagonal\" smooth Gaussian process fold \"2/3\" bars length", - "Buhovsky Payette Polterovich coarse nodal count topological persistence bars length delta", - "Nicolaescu random Morse functions barcode persistence expected", - "persistence diagram Gaussian random field critical values pairs Kac-Rice \"persistence\" intensity explicit formula arXiv 2025", - "Gaussian random field on torus periodization finite-size correction critical points expected number", - "persistent homology Gaussian random field Wasserstein total persistence finite p-th moment smooth field" - ], - "forward_citation_keyword_checks": ["1802.10457", "1911.03455", "1911.02300", "1706.06059", "2012.09459", "1909.09846"] - }, - "not_executed": [ - "classical 1-D small crest-to-trough height distributions for smooth stationary Gaussian processes (Rice 1945; Longuet-Higgins; Lindgren 1972; Cartwright-Longuet-Higgins) — highest priority", - "Divol-Polonik weight functions near the diagonal", - "LLN/CLT for persistent Betti numbers of smooth Gaussian fields, 2024-2026", - "Google Scholar cited-by enumeration for 1802.10457, 1911.03455, 1911.02300, 1706.06059, 1908.01619, 2012.09459, Bobrowski-Borman 2012, Adler-Taylor 2007" + "object": "CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1.1", + "coverage_target": "through 2026-09-29", + "exclusions": [ + "github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder", + "mirrors of the project's own repositories" + ], + "executed": { + "pass_1_session_web_search_4_queries": [ + "expected persistence diagram density near diagonal Gaussian random field short bars asymptotics", + "persistent homology short lifetime power law critical points maximum saddle pairs smooth random function", + "Bargmann-Fock field persistent homology lifetime density torus", + "Kac-Rice formula pairs critical points small height gap intensity ell^(-1/3) persistence" ], - "author_side_paywalled": { - "mathscinet": [ - "Anywhere=(persistence diagram OR barcode) AND Anywhere=(Gaussian random field OR Gaussian field) AND Anywhere=(diagonal OR short OR small lifetime)", - "MSC=(55N31 AND 60G60)", - "MSC=(60G60 AND 58K05) AND Anywhere=(critical value* AND (gap OR pair* OR close))", - "Anywhere=\"Bargmann-Fock\" AND Anywhere=(persistence OR Betti OR barcode)", - "Anywhere=(crest trough OR wave height) AND Anywhere=(small OR asymptotic) AND MSC=60G15" - ], - "zbmath_open": [ - "ti:(persistence OR barcode) & ab:(Gaussian field) & ab:(diagonal)", - "cc:55N31 & cc:60G60", - "ab:\"critical values\" & ab:\"Kac-Rice\" & ab:(pair* | two-point)", - "ab:\"Bargmann-Fock\" & ab:(persistent | Betti | barcode)", - "ab:(torus | periodic) & ab:\"Gaussian field\" & ab:(exponentially small | finite-size correction)" - ] - }, - "verdict": "no conflicting, overlapping, or different-exponent theorem found for the smooth-field H0 near-diagonal lifetime law under this protocol; not a proof of novelty", - "scientific_effect": "NONE" + "pass_2_extended_research_run_18_queries": [ + "expected persistence diagram density near diagonal Gaussian random field", + "arXiv 2603.29072 \"How much of persistent homology is topology\"", + "Beliaev Cammarota Wigman no repulsion between critical points planar Gaussian random fields", + "persistence diagram smooth Gaussian random field short bars power law near diagonal asymptotics", + "Azaïs Delmas mean number and correlation function of critical points isotropic Gaussian fields", + "merge tree Gaussian random field barcode random Morse function elder rule", + "Kac-Rice persistence diagram random field expected density critical pairs", + "barcode Brownian motion expected number of bars length distribution persistent homology random process", + "persistent homology Bargmann-Fock field Betti numbers excursion sets", + "expected persistence diagram smooth stationary Gaussian process density behaviour near diagonal", + "McAuley persistence barcode Gaussian field law of large numbers topological", + "\"short bars\" persistent homology random function asymptotics number of bars length epsilon smooth", + "\"persistence\" \"near the diagonal\" smooth Gaussian process fold \"2/3\" bars length", + "Buhovsky Payette Polterovich coarse nodal count topological persistence bars length delta", + "Nicolaescu random Morse functions barcode persistence expected", + "persistence diagram Gaussian random field critical values pairs Kac-Rice \"persistence\" intensity explicit formula arXiv 2025", + "Gaussian random field on torus periodization finite-size correction critical points expected number", + "persistent homology Gaussian random field Wasserstein total persistence finite p-th moment smooth field" + ], + "forward_citation_keyword_checks": [ + "1802.10457", + "1911.03455", + "1911.02300", + "1706.06059", + "2012.09459", + "1909.09846" + ], + "pass_3_lindgren_1972_full_text_openai_lane": { + "comment": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/pull/147#issuecomment-5897859268", + "source": "G. Lindgren, Wave-length and amplitude in Gaussian noise, Adv. Appl. Prob. 4 (1972) 81-108, DOI 10.2307/1425807 (author-uploaded full text; Cambridge and Lund records)", + "finding": "prior art for the d=1 amplitude object and Slepian conditional formulas; no explicit small-amplitude -1/3 density asymptotic located; absence from the 1-D literature not claimed" + } + }, + "not_executed": [ + "classical 1-D small crest-to-trough height distributions: Rice 1945, Longuet-Higgins, Cartwright-Longuet-Higgins at full-text level (Lindgren 1972 read in full by the OpenAI lane, see executed.pass_3)", + "Divol-Polonik weight functions near the diagonal", + "LLN/CLT for persistent Betti numbers of smooth Gaussian fields, 2024-2026", + "Google Scholar cited-by enumeration for 1802.10457, 1911.03455, 1911.02300, 1706.06059, 1908.01619, 2012.09459, Bobrowski-Borman 2012, Adler-Taylor 2007" + ], + "author_side_paywalled": { + "mathscinet": [ + "Anywhere=(persistence diagram OR barcode) AND Anywhere=(Gaussian random field OR Gaussian field) AND Anywhere=(diagonal OR short OR small lifetime)", + "MSC=(55N31 AND 60G60)", + "MSC=(60G60 AND 58K05) AND Anywhere=(critical value* AND (gap OR pair* OR close))", + "Anywhere=\"Bargmann-Fock\" AND Anywhere=(persistence OR Betti OR barcode)", + "Anywhere=(crest trough OR wave height) AND Anywhere=(small OR asymptotic) AND MSC=60G15" + ], + "zbmath_open": [ + "ti:(persistence OR barcode) & ab:(Gaussian field) & ab:(diagonal)", + "cc:55N31 & cc:60G60", + "ab:\"critical values\" & ab:\"Kac-Rice\" & ab:(pair* | two-point)", + "ab:\"Bargmann-Fock\" & ab:(persistent | Betti | barcode)", + "ab:(torus | periodic) & ab:\"Gaussian field\" & ab:(exponentially small | finite-size correction)" + ] + }, + "verdict": "no conflicting, overlapping, or different-exponent theorem found for the smooth-field H0 near-diagonal lifetime law under this protocol; not a proof of novelty", + "scientific_effect": "NONE" } diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md index 9222cfa90..a18a729e0 100644 --- a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Reconnaissance memo — literature and novelty check for the near-diagonal H0 lifetime law — 2026-09-29 -**Object:** CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1. **Author:** Anthropic Claude (claude.ai session `session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU`). +**Object:** CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1.1 (v1 + the executed 1-D neighbor pass, §4 item D). **Author:** Anthropic Claude (claude.ai session `session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU`). **Scientific effect:** NONE. **No priority or novelty claim follows from this memo.** It records what a documented search did and did not find, so that any lane can extend it and so that successor attribution sections have a verified starting list. Bibliographic details below are *as indexed by the search pass*; verify against full text @@ -87,12 +87,24 @@ in-project derivations: PR #144 (first principles in the parent's (15.2) convent 2026-09-29 — all exact agreement. `|P_3(24)| e^{−288} < 10^{−117}` sits inside side24_v1's reviewed `< 10^{−106}` band. The remainder enclosure remains PR #144's flagged open item. -**D. Highest-value unexecuted search — for a lane with web access.** The classical 1-D wave literature on the +**D. The classical 1-D neighbor — executed in two passes (v1.1).** The classical 1-D wave literature on the distribution of *small* crest-to-trough heights of a smooth stationary Gaussian process (Rice 1945; Longuet-Higgins; Lindgren 1972 "Wave-length and amplitude in Gaussian noise"; Cartwright–Longuet-Higgins) is the natural `d = 1` -neighbor of the max–min small-gap law and was **not** searched. If a `t^{−1/3}` small-height density is already -explicit there, it is prior art for the `d = 1` exponent (not a conflict — the parent is `d ≥ 2` on a torus with -elder pairing) and must be cited. Also unexecuted: Divol–Polonik weight functions near the diagonal; LLN/CLT for +neighbor of the max–min small-gap law. *Pass 1 (author, web-level, 2026-09-29):* the neighbors were located +precisely — G. Lindgren, Adv. Appl. Prob. 4 (1972) 81–108, DOI 10.2307/1425807; Lindgren–Rychlik 1982 — but full +texts were not read. *Pass 2 (OpenAI/ChatGPT, full-text read of Lindgren 1972, +[PR #147 comment 5897859268](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/pull/147#issuecomment-5897859268)):* the paper +defines the crest-to-trough amplitude after a prescribed maximum, develops the Slepian conditional process, and in +§§2.2–2.4 constructs an *approximate* joint wavelength/amplitude density under its condition A_p; Theorem 2.4 and +Corollary 2.2 are approximation/error statements, §2.3 gives numerical amplitude-density curves, §2.4 rejects a +Rayleigh/independence hypothesis. **No theorem or displayed asymptotic of the form `f_amp(h) ~ C h^{−1/3}` (or +`F_amp(h) ~ C h^{2/3}`), and no explicit `h ↓ 0` expansion, was found in the full text or by search within it.** +Attribution consequence, adopted here as the successor wording: *Lindgren 1972 is clear `d = 1` prior art for the +object (the maximum-to-following-minimum amplitude law) and for conditional/Slepian formulas that could in +principle be expanded; it is not, on the evidence read, prior art for the `−1/3` small-amplitude density +exponent. We have not located an explicit small-amplitude `−1/3` asymptotic in that source, and absence from the +entire 1-D literature is not claimed.* Rice 1945, Longuet-Higgins and Cartwright–Longuet-Higgins remain unread at +full-text level. Still unexecuted: Divol–Polonik weight functions near the diagonal; LLN/CLT for persistent Betti numbers of smooth Gaussian fields 2024–2026; Google-Scholar "cited by" enumeration for 1802.10457, 1911.03455, 1911.02300, 1706.06059, 1908.01619, 2012.09459, Bobrowski–Borman, Adler–Taylor. diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json index 9d427ec87..c7f4193a0 100644 --- a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json @@ -3,14 +3,14 @@ "delivered_under": "explicit owner instruction, claude.ai session 2026-09-29; OWNER_STOP left in place; no self-merge", "files": [ { - "bytes": 12325, + "bytes": 13688, "path": "RECONNAISSANCE.md", - "sha256": "e9e885a3e4a681a2c92bedec2f7fdfaba4694d12af6b441109b6f7699b8917f1" + "sha256": "076430e1c19bf4a4b683d43726a967df9b8b91e7641258f19e767da4ae7f25c1" }, { - "bytes": 4198, + "bytes": 4631, "path": "PROTOCOL.json", - "sha256": "b4a5e1fd3c515405783eaf22d125b6e68a12208480b72c4adba37c35511059de" + "sha256": "aed7eebebf7840a32efbc86632825ae533d2ef242d204e7fe9ed39ece94e7461" } ], "kind": "literature reconnaissance memo (prose + machine-readable protocol); no checker", From 912c02ad1b1a2f138994d7f80fb05e42671b0b90 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 20:49:19 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 3/4] Literature memo: manifest object id v1.1 Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU --- .../literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json index c7f4193a0..c513d8b01 100644 --- a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ ], "kind": "literature reconnaissance memo (prose + machine-readable protocol); no checker", "novelty_claim": false, - "object": "CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1", + "object": "CL-LIT-RECON-LIFETIME-20260929-v1.1", "scientific_effect": "NONE", "session": "https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU" } From c3fdca11888e5fb55300372e2997679e4e38ec1d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 16:27:49 -0500 Subject: [PATCH 4/4] docs: qualify literature absence by the inspected protocol --- .../RECONNAISSANCE.md | 6 +++--- .../SOURCE_FILES.json | 4 ++-- 2 files changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md index a18a729e0..003b98794 100644 --- a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/RECONNAISSANCE.md @@ -26,8 +26,8 @@ nearest-image periodization correction `P_3(24) e^{−288}` (PR #144). Coverage finite variation and is outside their regime. Perez states in print that the smooth-field case is open. - **Bargmann–Fock-specific persistence results beyond percolation:** none found (located: Rivera–Vanneuville critical threshold, arXiv:1711.05012; Gass–Stecconi finiteness of critical-point moments, arXiv:2305.17586). -- **Periodization / nearest-image corrections to local constants on tori:** none found. There is therefore **no - external benchmark** for the `e^{−L²/2}` term or the coefficient `−620813376/35`; the benchmark is internal and +- **Periodization / nearest-image corrections to local constants on tori:** none found. **No + external benchmark was located under this protocol** for the `e^{−L²/2}` term or the coefficient `−620813376/35`; the benchmark is internal and multi-path (see §4, item C). "None found" is a statement about this protocol (§5), not a proof of novelty. Three planned searches were not run @@ -80,7 +80,7 @@ independently of `d`. This matches the parent §10 ledger ("the dimension cancel fold-type adjacent pairs; the elder rule pairs them) — exactly what Theorem A + CAP supply rigorously. Useful as a sanity narrative in a discussion section; not evidence. -**C. Periodization coefficient — the benchmark is internal.** No external work computes exponentially small +**C. Periodization coefficient — the benchmark is internal.** No external work was located under this protocol that computes exponentially small nearest-image corrections to such constants. The coefficient `P_3(24) = −620813376/35` now has independent in-project derivations: PR #144 (first principles in the parent's (15.2) conventions, stdlib checker), the July 06B suite (SymPy, Hermite + Haar), the OKComputer 2026-08 first-variation script, and a clean-context re-check on diff --git a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json index c513d8b01..816ef3d82 100644 --- a/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json +++ b/reviews/literature_lifetime_law_recon_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json @@ -3,9 +3,9 @@ "delivered_under": "explicit owner instruction, claude.ai session 2026-09-29; OWNER_STOP left in place; no self-merge", "files": [ { - "bytes": 13688, + "bytes": 13738, "path": "RECONNAISSANCE.md", - "sha256": "076430e1c19bf4a4b683d43726a967df9b8b91e7641258f19e767da4ae7f25c1" + "sha256": "16628983f7833419e33c7b04cdb2e0d49076bccfbe7a6d457bf90efba63aa4ec" }, { "bytes": 4631,