From 4ee14be8c87585d491a0663ccdf40a3896ce30c0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Claude Date: Tue, 29 Sep 2026 20:44:39 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Add second-provider nonauthor review of coefficients/side24_v1 (D3 coefficient) Object CL-SIDE24-V1-REVIEW-20260929-v1. Anthropic/Claude review of the OpenAI-authored SIDE24 coefficient package, the second nonauthor provider after xAI/Grok C1-C6 (main#65). Verdict: ACCEPT at the arithmetic-enclosure scope; no defect found; parent imports remain open. - REVIEW.md: the note's six review items rederived (reference jet covariance, cone moments D_1=4/3 and D_2=29/6-sqrt(6), the (15.2) scalar identity and formula (1), the all-direction image bound E, covariance / Schur / density comparison, and the rational interval implementation function by function), reproduction in both interpreter modes, and independent 60-decimal numerics. - coefficient_review_check.py: exact checks R1-R8 (Fractions; R7 is an independent stdlib decimal evaluation of formula (1), Stirling shift 120), mutants M1-M3 exit 1, unknown labels exit 2, -O byte-identical. - SOURCE_FILES.json binds the reviewed blobs (unchanged since e329fba1) and the packet; the workflow replays both modes, rejects mutants and replays the reviewed package against ENCLOSURE.json. - A clean-context referee pass before landing returned SOUND WITH AMENDMENTS; all amendments are applied and recorded in the revision history. Scientific effect: NONE. No register, STATUS, PROOF_INDEX, GRAPH or author source is changed. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU --- .../side24-v1-coefficient-review.yml | 69 ++++++ .../RESULTS.json | 38 +++ .../REVIEW.md | 213 +++++++++++++++++ .../SOURCE_FILES.json | 69 ++++++ .../coefficient_review_check.py | 218 ++++++++++++++++++ 5 files changed, 607 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .github/workflows/side24-v1-coefficient-review.yml create mode 100644 reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/RESULTS.json create mode 100644 reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/REVIEW.md create mode 100644 reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json create mode 100644 reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/coefficient_review_check.py diff --git a/.github/workflows/side24-v1-coefficient-review.yml b/.github/workflows/side24-v1-coefficient-review.yml new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d0f7d52ac --- /dev/null +++ b/.github/workflows/side24-v1-coefficient-review.yml @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +name: SIDE24 v1 coefficient nonauthor review checks + +'on': + pull_request: + paths: + - 'reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/**' + - '.github/workflows/side24-v1-coefficient-review.yml' + workflow_dispatch: + +permissions: + contents: read + +jobs: + exact-and-probe: + runs-on: ubuntu-latest + timeout-minutes: 10 + steps: + - uses: actions/checkout@11d5960a326750d5838078e36cf38b85af677262 + with: + persist-credentials: false + - uses: actions/setup-python@a26af69be951a213d495a4c3e4e4022e16d87065 + with: + python-version: '3.11.16' + - name: Verify sources, replay both modes, reject mutants, replay the reviewed package + env: + PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE: '1' + run: | + set -euo pipefail + python -B -S - <<'PY' + import hashlib, json, pathlib, subprocess, sys + root = pathlib.Path('reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929').resolve() + manifest = json.loads((root / 'SOURCE_FILES.json').read_text()) + present = sorted(p.name for p in root.iterdir()) + expected_names = sorted([e['path'] for e in manifest['files']] + ['SOURCE_FILES.json']) + if present != expected_names: + raise ValueError('packet tree differs from manifest: ' + repr(present)) + for entry in manifest['files']: + path = root / entry['path'] + if pathlib.PurePosixPath(entry['path']).name != entry['path'] or path.is_symlink(): + raise ValueError('flat regular source required: ' + entry['path']) + data = path.read_bytes() + if len(data) != entry['bytes'] or hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest() != entry['sha256']: + raise ValueError('source identity mismatch: ' + entry['path']) + # the reviewed package must be the bytes the verdict binds to + for entry in manifest['reviewed_object']['paths']: + data = pathlib.Path(entry['path']).read_bytes() + if len(data) != entry['bytes'] or hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest() != entry['sha256']: + raise ValueError('reviewed object drifted: ' + entry['path']) + script = str(root / 'coefficient_review_check.py') + expected = (root / 'RESULTS.json').read_bytes() + mutants = ['M1', 'M2', 'M3'] + for flags in (['-B', '-S'], ['-B', '-O', '-S']): + out = subprocess.run([sys.executable, *flags, script], + check=True, capture_output=True, timeout=300).stdout + if out != expected: + raise RuntimeError('output differs from RESULTS.json under ' + ' '.join(flags)) + for m in mutants: + rc = subprocess.run([sys.executable, *flags, script, '--mutant', m], + capture_output=True, timeout=300).returncode + if rc != 1: + raise RuntimeError('mutant ' + m + ' not rejected') + # reproduction claimed in REVIEW.md item 7: package stdout == ENCLOSURE.json + pkg = subprocess.run([sys.executable, *flags, 'coefficients/side24_v1/coefficient.py'], + check=True, capture_output=True, timeout=300).stdout + if pkg != pathlib.Path('coefficients/side24_v1/ENCLOSURE.json').read_bytes(): + raise RuntimeError('coefficient.py output differs from ENCLOSURE.json under ' + ' '.join(flags)) + print(json.dumps({'scientific_effect': 'NONE', 'mathematical_acceptance': False})) + PY + git diff --exit-code diff --git a/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/RESULTS.json b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/RESULTS.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..66e0462aa --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/RESULTS.json @@ -0,0 +1,38 @@ +{ + "object": "CL-SIDE24-V1-REVIEW-20260929-v1-CHECKS", + "passed": true, + "results": { + "R1_hermite_sums": { + "0": 1, + "1": 1, + "2": 2, + "3": 4, + "4": 10, + "5": 26, + "6": 76 + }, + "R2_lattice": "shell count 24j^2+2 <= 27j^3; |n|^6 <= 27 j^6; term ratio <= 512 e^-864 < 1/2 -> sum <= 1458 e^-288", + "R3_image_ledger": { + "32eps": "<1e-106", + "60E": "<1e-108", + "E": "21175738586478e-125" + }, + "R4_covariance_floor": "Hessian block eigen {5, 2,2,2,2,2}; odd block min eigen 8-sqrt(58)=0.384 > 1/3; gradients 1 -> C_ref >= I/3", + "R5_density_comparison": "a=m+2/3+n/2, b=d+n/2 (<=5 for d=2,3); (1+eps)^5/(1-eps)^5 <= 1+32eps exactly at eps=1e-108", + "R6_cone_moments": { + "D_1": "4/3", + "D_2": "29/6 - sqrt(6)", + "untruncated_half": "29/6 (control)" + }, + "R7_closed_form": { + "c2_decimal_60": "0.073406919306034271030135962957774050017664244684332671851381", + "c2_float": "0.073406919306034296", + "c3_decimal_60": "0.041775931840598343342936665428575556466681519661044737884976", + "c3_float": "0.041775931840598357", + "gamma_7_6_decimal_60": "0.927719333630039200708349482534621018566466519145475576936124", + "independent_45_digit": "0.0417759318405983433429366654285755564666815197 (clean-context re-derivation, 2026-09-29; matched to 1e-45)" + }, + "R8_stirling": "B_2..B_22 exact; first omitted term positive (DLMF 5.11(ii) sign)" + }, + "scope": "finite identities of the coefficient note and its program; by-hand items in REVIEW.md" +} diff --git a/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/REVIEW.md b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/REVIEW.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..665d1683f --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/REVIEW.md @@ -0,0 +1,213 @@ +# Nonauthor review: D3 SIDE24 coefficient package `coefficients/side24_v1` (second provider) + +Object: CL-SIDE24-V1-REVIEW-20260929-v1. Reviewer: Anthropic / Claude (see provenance). + +Scientific effect: **NONE**. This file records verdicts on an existing, unchanged package. It does not +change `lemma_closed`, prizes, premises, `STATUS`, `PROOF_INDEX`, `GRAPH`, `claims/LANDING_CLAIMS.json` +or any author source. The D3 disposition (REVIEWED_SCOPED, arithmetic enclosure of the stated +expression only) is not altered; this review adds a second nonauthor provider to its record. + +## Object reviewed + +All paths on Math- `main` at `3216e2e7153f9f07acedb70b97d9ab5a0d82ed47` (2026-09-29). The blobs are +byte-identical to the ones the first nonauthor review bound at `e329fba1e927a12dbb4f0d1556f85f39284d17a9`. + +| Path | Blob | Bytes | SHA256 | +|---|---|---|---| +| `coefficients/side24_v1/PROOF.md` (SIDE24-COEFFICIENT-D23-20260924-v1, OpenAI / ChatGPT) | `44b66f04f89fcd87383b3603fa69f1feb64cdddd` | 10272 | `c06daccc4ba4b9168522b9888b76a7d599934fc3b91bd753ee5d492262917769` | +| `coefficients/side24_v1/coefficient.py` | `c2d3ff339f2b9953ec08e676240cdc5edcb17a3e` | 8073 | `03ae6d0f15160cb681f9bbb19a84dc861c3a0db3e881291ea621061cc90c86ab` | +| `coefficients/side24_v1/test_coefficient.py` | `fa9beaab7d6fcb4f0a0c5a91c6d80b455c98a912` | 4762 | `81689b5394e2e949058929570ec072ccb1d4fe93cd0d36a4b258431547d02dd3` | +| `coefficients/side24_v1/ENCLOSURE.json` | `57af39a05e14ed0ba8ebc00a9b4aca4dffb067c7` | 1090 | `72b6cd92d31394cdaf5da8919a5d548e902228af1f095cc184158a71d8287811` | + +Prior review record: xAI / Grok 4.7 (Cursor cloud agent), interfaces C1–C6 all VERIFIED, +[main#65 comment 5841269490](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/65#issuecomment-5841269490); +work package closed by [comment 5841779222](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/65#issuecomment-5841779222). +Parent: UNIFORM-MATRIX-CAP-LIFETIME-20260924-v1, blob `dfed3b8d318a3ab1950957f393307733a4bef3f2`, +SHA256 `9350ad6e…c84bc7`, whose equation (15.2) defines the coefficient. The parent is imported, not re-proved here. + +## Reviewer provenance + +| Field | Value | +|---|---| +| Provider / tool | Anthropic Claude, Claude Code session `session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU` (model id `claude-fable-5-1` as configured) | +| Relation to author | Different provider from the author (OpenAI / ChatGPT) and from the first nonauthor reviewer (xAI / Grok). Same GitHub account as every lane: no organizational independence is claimed. | +| Exposure | This session consumed the published `side24_v1` endpoints as inputs in earlier work (the D1-C/D/E review, PR #143, and the periodization first-variation note, PR #144). Every derivation below was redone from the note's text and the parent's (15.2), before the C1–C6 comment was read; that comment was read afterwards only to align interface labels. No source file was edited. | +| Tooling | CPython 3.11, standard library only. Independent numerics use `decimal` (precision 90) with a Stirling shift of 120 and B₂…B₄₀ (the package uses shift 32 and B₂…B₂₀), the first omitted term < 10⁻⁷⁰, and an own Machin π; a second run with shift 300 agrees to 75 decimals. | + +## Verdicts + +The note's own list ("Nonauthor review should independently check …") is used as the interface list; the +C-labels are the first review's. + +| Item | Note locus | First review | Verdict | +|---|---|---|---| +| 1. Shared trace variance 5/3 (and the whole reference jet covariance) | §1 | C1/C2 | **VERIFIED** | +| 2. Rayleigh cone integration: D_1 = 4/3, D_2 = 29/6 − √6 with the negative-definite cone retained | §1 | C1/C2 | **VERIFIED** | +| 3. Ordered-pair / gamma normalization inherited from the parent: (15.2) scalar identity and formula (1) | §1, parent (15.2) | C3 | **VERIFIED** as algebra from the parent's displayed factors; the factors themselves stay parent-open (below) | +| 4. All-direction derivative bound and the image sum: E = 1458(76·24⁶+15)·10⁻¹²⁵ | §2 | C4 | **VERIFIED** | +| 5. Covariance and Schur-complement comparison; density comparison; (3) and (4) | §§3–4 | C5 | **VERIFIED** | +| 6. Rational interval implementation, special-function remainders, outward decimals | §5, `coefficient.py` | C6 | **VERIFIED** | +| 7. Reproduction | `coefficient.py`, tests | — | stdout byte-identical to `ENCLOSURE.json` in normal and `-O` modes; 30 tests pass in both modes | +| 8. Independent numerics | formula (1) | — | 60-decimal values (standard-library `decimal`, Stirling shift 120, remainder < 10⁻⁷⁰) lie inside the package's internal enclosures (widths ≈ 10⁻³²) and inside the published 20-digit endpoints; recomputed inside the CI checker (R7) | + +Overall: **ACCEPT at the arithmetic-enclosure scope** of the note, i.e. the two displayed intervals are +proved bounds on the expression (15.2) evaluated for the exact variance-one SIDE24 covariance in d = 2, 3. +No defect was found. Nothing here reads the coefficient as a finite-bar lifetime constant; that reading +remains conditional on the parent's separately reviewed chain, exactly as the note states. + +The exact checker `coefficient_review_check.py` (R1–R8, transcript `RESULTS.json`) verifies every +finite identity used below; three mutants (M1 wrong pairing-sum 75, M2 wrong covariance floor 1/2, +M3 untruncated 29/6 used as D_2) exit 1; an unknown mutant label exits 2. + +## Item 1 — reference jet covariance (§1) + +For K_∞(z) = e^{−|z|²/2}, Cov(∂^α f(0), ∂^β f(0)) = (−1)^{|β|} ∂^{α+β}K_∞(0), and the one-dimensional +factors give ∂^{2k}e^{−x²/2}|₀ = (−1)^k(2k−1)!!. Hence Cov(G) = I_d; Cov(H_ij,H_kl) = δ_ijδ_kl + δ_ikδ_jl + δ_ilδ_jk; +Var(t) = 15, Cov(t,G) = (−3,0,…,0) for t = ∂₁³f; odd and even orders are uncorrelated. V = He₁ has +covariance diag(3,1,…,1), so p_G(0)p_V(0) = (2π)^{−d}/√3, and τ² = Var(t | G = 0) = 15 − 9 = 6, using only +Var(t), Cov(t,G) and Cov(G); by parity t is also uncorrelated with the whole Hessian, so conditioning on +V = 0 as well changes nothing. The transverse block A = (H_ij)_{i,j≥2} correlates with V only through H₁₁ +(Cov(A_ij,H₁₁) = δ_ij, Cov(A_ij,H_k1) = 0 for k ≥ 2), so +Cov(A_ij,A_kl | V=0) = (2/3)δ_ijδ_kl + δ_ikδ_jl + δ_ilδ_jk, i.e. A = Q + √(2/3)·Z·I_m as stated. +For m = 2 with A = [[s+x, y],[y, s−x]]: Var(A₁₁) = Var(A₂₂) = 8/3, Cov(A₁₁,A₂₂) = 2/3, Var(A₁₂) = 1, giving +Var(s) = (8/3+8/3+4/3)/4 = **5/3**, Var(x) = (8/3+8/3−4/3)/4 = 1, Cov(s,x) = 0, Var(y) = 1, all independent. ✔ + +## Item 2 — cone moments (§1) + +m = 1: Var(A) = 8/3 and D_1 = E[A²1{A<0}] = (1/2)(8/3) = **4/3**. ✔ + +m = 2: eigenvalues s ± R, R = √(x²+y²); negative definite ⇔ s < −R; det A = s² − R²; R² ~ Exp(mean 2), +density e^{−z/2}/2. The kernel identity ∫₀^a (a−z)²e^{−z/2}dz/2 = a² − 4a + 8 − 8e^{−a/2} holds: both sides +vanish with their first derivatives at a = 0 and have second derivative 2 − 2e^{−a/2} (checker R6, formal +differentiation). By the symmetry of s, D_2 = (1/2)E[s⁴ − 4s² + 8 − 8e^{−s²/2}] with E s² = 5/3, E s⁴ = 25/3, +E e^{−s²/2} = (1 + 5/3)^{−1/2} = √(3/8); so D_2 = 29/6 − 4√(3/8) = **29/6 − √6** ≈ 2.383843590550155. ✔ +The untruncated half-moment is exactly 29/6 (mutant M3), confirming that the cone truncation is what +produces the −√6 term. + +## Item 3 — (15.2) scalar identity and formula (1) + +With φ_τ the centered normal density of variance τ², ∫₀^∞ k^{4/3}φ_τ(12k)dk = 12^{−7/3}·(1/2)·2^{2/3}τ^{4/3}Γ(7/6)/√π, +and 144·12^{−7/3}·2^{−1/3} = 24^{−1/3} because 144³·24 = 12⁷·2 (checker R7). This is the parent's prefactor +Γ(7/6)/(24^{1/3}√π). Substituting p_G p_V = (2π)^{−d}/√3, τ^{4/3} = 6^{2/3}, |S¹| = 2π, |S²| = 4π and +6^{2/3}/24^{1/3} = (3/2)^{1/3} gives (1): c_{d,ref} = Γ(7/6)(3/2)^{1/3}D_{d−1}/(2√3·π^{d−1}√π). ✔ +The factors 4(6κ)² = 144, |det T_r| = 12r^{−(d+3)}, the ordered maximum/saddle roles and the full pin +Jacobian are the parent's and are **not** re-proved here. + +## Item 4 — all-direction derivative bound and image sum (§2) + +For unit directions u₁…u_q (repeated or mixed), D_{u₁}…D_{u_q}φ = φ·Σ_{pairings}∏(−u_a·u_b)∏(−u_c·x), so +|D^qφ(x)| ≤ φ(x)Σ_j q!/(2^j j!(q−2j)!)|x|^{q−2j}. The pairing sums for q = 0..6 are 1,1,2,4,10,26,**76** +(76 = 1+15+45+15, checker R1); at |x| ≥ 1 every order ≤ 6 is bounded by 76|x|⁶φ(x); at x = 0 the values are +at most (q−1)!! ≤ 15 in absolute value (equality for a repeated direction). The needed covariances are unit-direction contractions of total order ≤ 6 (t with t is 6), so +the bound covers every entry in every orthonormal frame. + +Lattice: with S = Σ_n e^{−288|n|²} ≥ 1, D^qK₂₄(0) − D^qK_∞(0) = [Σ_{n≠0}D^qφ(24n) − (S−1)D^qφ(0)]/S, so +|·| ≤ (76·24⁶ + 15)Σ_{n≠0}|n|⁶e^{−288|n|²}. Points with max-coordinate j number (2j+1)³−(2j−1)³ = 24j²+2 ≤ 27j³ +(d = 3; d = 2 gives 8j), |n|⁶ ≤ 27j⁶, |n|² ≥ j², so the sum is ≤ 729Σ_j j⁹e^{−288j²}; successive terms have +ratio ≤ 2⁹e^{−864} < 1/2, so ≤ 1458e^{−288}. The positive Taylor partial sum through k = 20 proves +e^{288/125} > 10, hence e^{−288} < 10^{−125}. Therefore |D^qK₂₄(0) − D^qK_∞(0)| < E = 21175738586478·10^{−125} +(checker R2, R3, exact). ✔ The subtraction of (S−1)D^qφ(0) — the normalization term — is included. ✔ + +## Item 5 — covariance, Schur and density comparison (§§3–4) + +Joint vector (G, t, svec H), dimension d+1+d(d+1)/2 ≤ 10. The √2 off-diagonal scaling makes each entry differ +from the reference by ≤ 2E, so ‖C₂₄ − C_ref‖ ≤ 20E (row-sum bound). Reference spectrum: the svec-Hessian block +is 2I + J on the diagonal entries and 2I on the off-diagonal ones — eigenvalues d+2 (trace) and 2 (traceless) — +and is uncorrelated with the odd block; the odd block is [[1,−3],[−3,15]] ⊕ I_{d−1}, eigenvalues 8 ± √58 and 1; +8 − √58 ≈ 0.384 > 1/3 (shifted minors 2/3 and 7/9, checker R4). Hence C_ref ≥ I/3 and, with 60E < ε = 10^{−108}, +(1−ε)C_ref ≤ C₂₄ ≤ (1+ε)C_ref in every orthonormal frame. ✔ + +Transfer: a PSD sandwich is preserved by every fixed linear image (marginals), and the Schur complement's +quadratic form is v ↦ inf_w (v,w)ᵀC(v,w), an infimum of the full form, so it inherits both inequalities; +this covers τ² = Var(t | pins) and Cov(A | V = 0) with no rotational invariance of C₂₄ assumed. ✔ + +Density comparison: det C ∈ [(1−ε)^n,(1+ε)^n]det C₀ and C⁻¹ ∈ [(1+ε)⁻¹,(1−ε)⁻¹]C₀⁻¹ give +[(1−ε)/(1+ε)]^{n/2}φ_{(1−ε)C₀} ≤ φ_C ≤ [(1+ε)/(1−ε)]^{n/2}φ_{(1+ε)C₀} pointwise; h(A) = det(A)²1{A<0} is +homogeneous of degree 2m on a scale-invariant cone, so E_{aC₀}h = a^m E_{C₀}h. Combining with p_G(0), p_V(0) +(each ∈ [(1+ε)^{−d/2},(1−ε)^{−d/2}]·ref) and τ^{4/3} gives the integrand ratio in +[(1−ε)^a/(1+ε)^b, (1+ε)^a/(1−ε)^b], a = m+2/3+n/2, b = d+n/2 (d = 2: 13/6, 5/2; d = 3: 25/6, 9/2; both ≤ 5). +Exactly, (1+ε)⁵/(1−ε)⁵ ≤ 1 + 32ε at ε = 10^{−108} (checker R5), so |c_{d,24}/c_{d,ref} − 1| < 32ε < 10^{−106}. +The reference integrand is positive and constant in u, so the sphere integral keeps the bound. ✔ + +## Item 6 — implementation (`coefficient.py`, by function) + +- `I`: every constructor call floors `lo` and ceils `hi` to the 10^{−80} grid (outward, sign-correct); + `__mul__` takes min/max of the four endpoint products; `inv` refuses intervals containing 0 and maps + [lo,hi] ↦ [1/hi,1/lo]; floats and bools are rejected. ✔ +- `root`: `integer_root` returns the exact floor root — `math.isqrt` for n = 2 (every square root in the + enclosure: √3, √6, √π) and a bisection with the valid initial bracket (2^{⌈bits/n⌉})ⁿ > a for n ≥ 3 + (only the cube root (3/2)^{1/3}). The lower + endpoint ⌊N^{1/n}⌋/SCALE with N = ⌊v·SCALEⁿ⌋ is ≤ v^{1/n}; for the upper endpoint, if r = ⌊N^{1/n}⌋ has + rⁿ < v·SCALEⁿ then (r+1)ⁿ ≥ N+1 > v·SCALEⁿ, so (r+1)/SCALE > v^{1/n}. ✔ +- `atan_small`: alternating series with decreasing terms on [0,1]; the value lies between consecutive partial + sums (100 terms; the next term is the bracket). Machin: π = 16 atan(1/5) − 4 atan(1/239). ✔ +- `log_unit`: 2·atanh((x−1)/(x+1)) on [1,2], y ≤ 1/3, 120 positive terms, tail ≤ 2y²⁴¹/(241(1−y²)). ✔ + `log_point` reduces by powers of two (negative k handled by interval scaling). ✔ +- `exp_point`: reduction to [0,1/4] by halving with repeated squaring, 70 positive Taylor terms, + tail ≤ (x⁷¹/71!)/(1−x/72); negative arguments via the reciprocal interval. ✔ +- `gamma_seven_sixths`: log Γ(199/6) by DLMF 5.11.1 with B₂…B₂₀, remainder in (0, B₂₂-term) by DLMF 5.11(ii) + (real positive argument; B₂₂ = 854513/138 > 0, checker R8 recomputes B₂…B₂₂ by Akiyama–Tanigawa); + 32 recurrence logarithms removed (DLMF 5.5(i)); exponentiated. Resulting width 1.4·10^{−31}. ✔ +- `reference_coefficient`: formula (1) verbatim; `cone_moment(3)` = 29/6 − √6 by interval subtraction. ✔ +- `side24_coefficient`: the (1 ± 10^{−106}) allowance is applied to the exact rational endpoints before + the final rounding; `decimals` floors the lower and ceils the upper endpoint at 20 digits. ✔ +- Margins: 60E ≈ 1.3·10^{−110} against ε = 10^{−108}; internal enclosure widths 1.1·10^{−32} (d = 2) and + 6.5·10^{−33} (d = 3) against the 10^{−20} published grid. Nothing is marginal. + +## Items 7–8 — reproduction and independent numerics + +```sh +git -C Math- rev-parse origin/main # 3216e2e7153f9f07acedb70b97d9ab5a0d82ed47 +sha256sum coefficients/side24_v1/* # digests in the table above +python3 -B -S coefficients/side24_v1/coefficient.py | cmp - coefficients/side24_v1/ENCLOSURE.json # identical +python3 -B -O -S coefficients/side24_v1/coefficient.py | cmp - coefficients/side24_v1/ENCLOSURE.json # identical +python3 -B -S -m unittest discover -s coefficients/side24_v1 -p 'test_*.py' # Ran 30 tests, OK +python3 -B -O -S -m unittest discover -s coefficients/side24_v1 -p 'test_*.py' # Ran 30 tests, OK +``` + +Independent evaluation of (1) (checker R7; stdlib `decimal` at precision 90, Stirling shift 120 with +B₂…B₄₀, first omitted term < 10⁻⁷⁰, own Machin π; digits truncated, not rounded, at 60 decimals): + + Γ(7/6) = 0.927719333630039200708349482534621018566466519145475576936124… + c_2 = 0.073406919306034271030135962957774050017664244684332671851381… + c_3 = 0.041775931840598343342936665428575556466681519661044737884976… + +Both lie inside the package's internal enclosures ([…428569117…, …428575624…] for d = 3; +[…957762736…, …957774170…] for d = 2) and inside the published 20-digit endpoints; R7 asserts the +latter containment and that c_3 agrees to 10⁻⁴⁵ with this session's earlier clean-context 45-digit +re-derivation 0.0417759318405983433429366654285755564666815197. (A first draft of this table used a +shift-60 Stirling sum truncated after B₃₀ and printed digits past its own 6·10⁻⁴⁹ remainder; the +clean-context referee caught it, and the values above replace it.) ✔ + +## Notes (non-blocking) + +- N1. §2's "at most 27j³ possibilities" is loose for d = 2 (8j) and for d = 3 (24j²+2); the final constant + 1458 could be reduced by orders of magnitude, but E ≈ 2.1·10⁻¹¹² already leaves 60E ≈ 1.3·10⁻¹¹⁰ a factor ≈ 79 below the budget ε = 10⁻¹⁰⁸. +- N2. §4's intermediate "1 − 13ε … 1 + 28ε" is not the sharpest statement (the true ratio is within + (a+b)ε, i.e. (26/3)ε for d = 3 and (14/3)ε for d = 2); only the sufficient "1 ± 32ε" is used, and it is verified exactly. +- N3. The odd-block floor 8 − √58 ≈ 0.384 is the actual λ_min(C_ref) for both d = 2 and d = 3; the note's + 1/3 is a clean rational under-estimate, verified by the shifted minors. +- N4. `exp_lower` proves e^{288/125} > 10 by a positive partial sum through k = 20; the checker also + confirms the 125th-power step e^{−288} < 10^{−125} in exact arithmetic. +- N5. τ² = 6 needs only Var(t) = 15, Cov(t,G) = (−3,0,…,0) and Cov(G) = I. That t is independent of V + (indeed of the whole Hessian) is a parity fact — Cov(t,H_k1) is a fifth-order derivative of K at 0 — + stated in the parent's §15, not in the note; the note's covariance list is consistent with it. +- N6. The interval class re-rounds outward at every operation; the resulting widths (≈ 10^{−32}) show that + the 10^{−80} grid loses nothing at the published precision. + +## Parent-open imports (not re-proved here; identical to the first review's list) + +- Contact Jacobian |det T_r| = 12r^{−(d+3)} and the longitudinal ±6κ eigenvalues behind 4(6κ)² = 144. +- Ordered max/saddle counting as a measure, the full-pin Kac–Rice intensity, the Borel/global elder identification. +- Theorem C: reading c_{d,24} as the finite-bar lifetime asymptotic. +- Any finite-radius constant, unrestricted remainder, RN/24-jet certificate or P15 cover claim. + +## Revision history + +- v1 (2026-09-29): initial review. Exact checker R1–R8 with mutants M1–M3; reproduction in both interpreter + modes; independent numerics; verdict ACCEPT at the arithmetic-enclosure scope. Before landing, a + clean-context referee pass (Anthropic Claude subagent, no shared context) returned SOUND WITH AMENDMENTS: + the first draft's "80-digit" values were correct only to 47–49 decimals (Stirling truncation not + accounted for), N5 misattributed the source of t ⊥ V, and four wording items (isqrt for n = 2, the + |value| ≤ (q−1)!! statement at 0, the N1 and N2 constants). All are corrected above; R7 now recomputes + the values inside CI; the verdict is unchanged. diff --git a/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..de77db862 --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/SOURCE_FILES.json @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "scientific_effect": "NONE", + "review_status": "NONAUTHOR_REVIEW", + "object": "CL-SIDE24-V1-REVIEW-20260929-v1", + "verdict": "ACCEPT at the arithmetic-enclosure scope; no defect found; parent imports remain open", + "reviewer": { + "provider": "Anthropic / Claude", + "session": "session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU", + "relation": "different provider from the author (OpenAI) and from the first nonauthor reviewer (xAI); same GitHub account, no organizational independence" + }, + "reviewed_object": { + "package": "coefficients/side24_v1", + "object": "SIDE24-COEFFICIENT-D23-20260924-v1", + "author": "OpenAI / ChatGPT", + "main_head": "3216e2e7153f9f07acedb70b97d9ab5a0d82ed47", + "prior_review": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/65#issuecomment-5841269490", + "paths": [ + { + "path": "coefficients/side24_v1/PROOF.md", + "git_blob": "44b66f04f89fcd87383b3603fa69f1feb64cdddd", + "bytes": 10272, + "sha256": "c06daccc4ba4b9168522b9888b76a7d599934fc3b91bd753ee5d492262917769" + }, + { + "path": "coefficients/side24_v1/coefficient.py", + "git_blob": "c2d3ff339f2b9953ec08e676240cdc5edcb17a3e", + "bytes": 8073, + "sha256": "03ae6d0f15160cb681f9bbb19a84dc861c3a0db3e881291ea621061cc90c86ab" + }, + { + "path": "coefficients/side24_v1/test_coefficient.py", + "git_blob": "fa9beaab7d6fcb4f0a0c5a91c6d80b455c98a912", + "bytes": 4762, + "sha256": "81689b5394e2e949058929570ec072ccb1d4fe93cd0d36a4b258431547d02dd3" + }, + { + "path": "coefficients/side24_v1/ENCLOSURE.json", + "git_blob": "57af39a05e14ed0ba8ebc00a9b4aca4dffb067c7", + "bytes": 1090, + "sha256": "72b6cd92d31394cdaf5da8919a5d548e902228af1f095cc184158a71d8287811" + } + ] + }, + "files": [ + { + "path": "REVIEW.md", + "git_blob": "665d1683f33a7180957923c3cb2abce8ade235d1", + "bytes": 17903, + "sha256": "258c414c46be93142ee552cfa4c32c03dd89b6bf7b0b470334f152e1e0a57eef" + }, + { + "path": "RESULTS.json", + "git_blob": "66e0462aa1245f66053d38d8f12a07f2f4f232d7", + "bytes": 1567, + "sha256": "8af1f8f0bea0a1739bfc41dd43fcdd11c219946c16c2ad169ff0581bf6da0b03" + }, + { + "path": "coefficient_review_check.py", + "git_blob": "c47d337d6601b7fce5a2436836635837b46cfe35", + "bytes": 11978, + "sha256": "bacd5c7fee3e2024c2506cfcd6fcde12ce5d5301121eb7238e2a818f7e06176b" + } + ], + "referee": { + "kind": "clean-context Anthropic Claude subagent before landing", + "verdict": "SOUND WITH AMENDMENTS (all applied; see REVIEW.md revision history)" + } +} diff --git a/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/coefficient_review_check.py b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/coefficient_review_check.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c47d337d6 --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/side24_v1_coefficient_claude_20260929/coefficient_review_check.py @@ -0,0 +1,218 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# coefficient_review_check.py — exact finite controls for the nonauthor review +# CL-SIDE24-V1-REVIEW-20260929-v1 of coefficients/side24_v1 (OpenAI/ChatGPT). +# Python stdlib only; fail-closed via SystemExit; -O byte-identical. +# Mutants: --mutant M1|M2|M3 -> exit 1. +# M1 = image constant with coefficient sum 75 instead of 76 +# M2 = claim the reference covariance floor is 1/2 (it is 8 - sqrt(58) ~ 0.384) +# M3 = the untruncated half-moment 29/6 used as D_2 (truncation dropped) +# These verify finite identities in the note and its program (R1-R6, R8) and give an +# independent standard-library decimal evaluation of formula (1) (R7); they do not +# replace the by-hand arguments recorded in REVIEW.md. Unknown mutant labels exit 2. + +import json +import math +import sys +from decimal import Decimal, getcontext +from fractions import Fraction as F +from math import factorial + + +def check(name, cond): + if not cond: + print("FAIL " + name) + raise SystemExit(1) + + +def bernoulli_list(nmax): + """B_0..B_nmax by the Akiyama-Tanigawa algorithm (exact; B_1 = +1/2 convention).""" + A = [F(0)] * (nmax + 1) + out = [] + for mm in range(nmax + 1): + A[mm] = F(1, mm + 1) + for j in range(mm, 0, -1): + A[j - 1] = j * (A[j - 1] - A[j]) + out.append(A[0]) + return out + + +def dfact(n): + out = 1 + while n > 1: + out *= n + n -= 2 + return out + + +def main(argv): + mutant = None + if len(argv) == 3 and argv[1] == "--mutant": + mutant = argv[2] + if mutant not in ("M1", "M2", "M3"): + print("FAIL unknown mutant " + mutant) + raise SystemExit(2) + elif len(argv) != 1: + raise SystemExit(2) + res = {} + + # ---- R1: Hermite/pairing coefficient sums for q <= 6 ------------------------- + # |d^q phi| <= phi * sum_j q!/(2^j j! (q-2j)!) |x|^{q-2j}; sums and zero values + sums = {} + for q in range(7): + sums[q] = sum(factorial(q) // (2 ** j * factorial(j) * factorial(q - 2 * j)) for j in range(q // 2 + 1)) + check("R1_sum_q6_is_76", sums[6] == (75 if mutant == "M1" else 76) and sums[6] == 1 + 15 + 45 + 15) + check("R1_sums_le_76", all(sums[q] <= 76 for q in range(7))) + check("R1_zero_value_le_15", all(dfact(q - 1) <= 15 for q in range(0, 7, 2))) # (q-1)!! at x=0 + res["R1_hermite_sums"] = {str(q): sums[q] for q in range(7)} + + # ---- R2: lattice counting and the geometric ratio --------------------------- + for j in range(1, 60): + shell = (2 * j + 1) ** 3 - (2 * j - 1) ** 3 # points with max-coordinate exactly j + check("R2_shell_count", shell == 24 * j * j + 2 and shell <= 27 * j ** 3) + check("R2_norm6_bound", (3 * j * j) ** 3 == 27 * j ** 6) + # successive-term ratio of j^9 e^{-288 j^2}: ((j+1)/j)^9 e^{-288(2j+1)} <= 2^9 e^{-864} < 1/2 + # since e^{864} > 2^{864} > 2^{10} + check("R2_ratio", 2 ** 9 * 2 ** -864 < F(1, 2) and 2 ** 864 > 1024) + res["R2_lattice"] = "shell count 24j^2+2 <= 27j^3; |n|^6 <= 27 j^6; term ratio <= 512 e^-864 < 1/2 -> sum <= 1458 e^-288" + + # ---- R3: image ledger arithmetic ------------------------------------------- + exp_lower = sum((F(288, 125) ** k / factorial(k) for k in range(21)), F(0)) + check("R3_exp_288_over_125_gt_10", exp_lower > 10) + ic = 1458 * (76 * 24 ** 6 + 15) + check("R3_image_constant", ic == 21175738586478 and 24 ** 6 == 191102976) + E = F(ic, 10 ** 125) + check("R3_60E_below_eps", 60 * E < F(1, 10 ** 108)) + check("R3_32eps_below_1e-106", 32 * F(1, 10 ** 108) < F(1, 10 ** 106)) + # e^{-288} < 10^{-125} follows from e^{288/125} > 10 (125th power) + check("R3_e288_bound_logic", exp_lower ** 125 > 10 ** 125) + res["R3_image_ledger"] = {"E": "21175738586478e-125", "60E": "<1e-108", "32eps": "<1e-106"} + + # ---- R4: reference covariance eigenvalue floor ------------------------------ + # svec Hessian block at d=3: Cov = 2 I_6 + J on the 3 diagonal entries -> eigenvalues 5 (once), 2 (five) + n = 6 + C = [[F(0)] * n for _ in range(n)] + for i in range(n): + C[i][i] = F(2) + for i in range(3): + for j in range(3): + C[i][j] += 1 # Cov(H_ii, H_jj) = 1 + 2 delta_ij + def matvec(M, v): + return [sum(M[i][j] * v[j] for j in range(n)) for i in range(n)] + v_trace = [F(1), F(1), F(1), F(0), F(0), F(0)] + check("R4_trace_eigen_d+2", matvec(C, v_trace) == [5 * x for x in v_trace]) + for v in ([F(1), F(-1), F(0), F(0), F(0), F(0)], [F(1), F(1), F(-2), F(0), F(0), F(0)], + [F(0), F(0), F(0), F(1), F(0), F(0)], [F(0), F(0), F(0), F(0), F(1), F(0)], [F(0)] * 5 + [F(1)]): + check("R4_traceless_eigen_2", matvec(C, v) == [2 * x for x in v]) + # odd block [[1,-3],[-3,15]]: eigenvalues 8 +/- sqrt(58); smaller > 1/3 (shift by 1/3 -> PD) + floor = F(1, 2) if mutant == "M2" else F(1, 3) + a11, a12, a22 = F(1) - floor, F(-3), F(15) - floor + check("R4_odd_block_floor", a11 > 0 and a11 * a22 - a12 * a12 > 0) + check("R4_odd_block_exact_minors", (F(2, 3), F(7, 9)) == (F(1) - F(1, 3), (F(2, 3)) * (F(44, 3)) - 9)) + # numeric: 8 - sqrt(58) ~ 0.3844 > 1/3 + check("R4_numeric_floor", 8 - math.sqrt(58) > 1 / 3) + res["R4_covariance_floor"] = "Hessian block eigen {5, 2,2,2,2,2}; odd block min eigen 8-sqrt(58)=0.384 > 1/3; gradients 1 -> C_ref >= I/3" + + # ---- R5: density-comparison exponents and the 1 +/- 32 eps bracket --------- + eps = F(1, 10 ** 108) + for d in (2, 3): + m = d - 1 + nn = m * (m + 1) // 2 + a = F(m) + F(2, 3) + F(nn, 2) + b = F(d) + F(nn, 2) + check("R5_exponent_sums_d%d" % d, a + 2 * b < 14 and 2 * a + b < 13 and a <= 5 and b <= 5) + up = (1 + eps) ** 5 / (1 - eps) ** 5 + lo = (1 - eps) ** 5 / (1 + eps) ** 5 + check("R5_upper_bracket", up <= 1 + 32 * eps) + check("R5_lower_bracket", lo >= 1 - 32 * eps) + res["R5_density_comparison"] = "a=m+2/3+n/2, b=d+n/2 (<=5 for d=2,3); (1+eps)^5/(1-eps)^5 <= 1+32eps exactly at eps=1e-108" + + # ---- R6: cone moments -------------------------------------------------------- + # s ~ N(0,5/3): E s^2 = 5/3, E s^4 = 3 (5/3)^2 = 25/3 ; R^2 ~ Exp(1/2): E=2, E^2=8 + Es2, Es4 = F(5, 3), 3 * F(5, 3) ** 2 + check("R6_s_moments", Es2 == F(5, 3) and Es4 == F(25, 3)) + ER2, ER4 = F(2), F(8) + untrunc_half = (Es4 - 2 * Es2 * ER2 + ER4) / 2 + check("R6_untruncated_half_29_6", untrunc_half == F(29, 6)) + # kernel identity int_0^a (a-z)^2 e^{-z/2} dz/2 = a^2 - 4a + 8 - 8 X, X = e^{-a/2}, by formal + # differentiation (X' = -X/2): RHS'' = 2 - 2X = LHS'' ; RHS(0)=0, RHS'(0)=0 + # represent as (poly coeffs in a, coefficient of X): RHS = (a^2 - 4a + 8) + (-8) X + poly, cX = [F(8), F(-4), F(1)], F(-8) # poly[k] = coeff of a^k + d1_poly = [poly[1], 2 * poly[2]]; d1_X = cX * F(-1, 2) # (-4 + 2a) + 4X + d2_poly = [d1_poly[1]]; d2_X = d1_X * F(-1, 2) # 2 + (-2)X + check("R6_kernel_second_derivative", d2_poly == [F(2)] and d2_X == F(-2)) + check("R6_kernel_initial_values", poly[0] + cX == 0 and d1_poly[0] + d1_X == 0) + # E e^{-s^2/2} = (1 + 5/3)^{-1/2} = sqrt(3/8): (sqrt(3/8))^2 = 3/8 = 1/(8/3) + check("R6_gauss_expectation", F(3, 8) == 1 / (1 + F(5, 3))) + # D_2 = (1/2)[25/3 - 20/3 + 8] - 8 * (1/2) * sqrt(3/8) = 29/6 - 4 sqrt(3/8) ; (4 sqrt(3/8))^2 = 6 + D2_rational_part = (F(25, 3) - F(20, 3) + 8) / 2 + check("R6_D2_rational_part", D2_rational_part == F(29, 6)) + check("R6_D2_sqrt_part", 16 * F(3, 8) == 6) + D2_num = 29 / 6 - math.sqrt(6) + if mutant == "M3": + D2_num = 29 / 6 + check("R6_D2_numeric", abs(D2_num - 2.383843590550155) < 1e-12) + # D_1 = E[A^2 1{A<0}] for A ~ N(0, 8/3) = (1/2)(8/3) = 4/3 + check("R6_D1", F(1, 2) * F(8, 3) == F(4, 3)) + res["R6_cone_moments"] = {"D_1": "4/3", "D_2": "29/6 - sqrt(6)", "untruncated_half": "29/6 (control)"} + + # ---- R7: eq. (1) is the closed form of the parent specialization; independent numerics - + check("R7_cube_identity", F(36, 24) == F(3, 2)) # (3/2)^{1/3} = 6^{2/3}/24^{1/3} + check("R7_gamma_prefactor", F(144 ** 3, 12 ** 7 * 2) == F(1, 24)) # (144 12^{-7/3} 2^{-1/3})^3 = 1/24 + g76 = math.gamma(7 / 6) + c3 = g76 * 1.5 ** (1 / 3) * D2_num / (2 * math.sqrt(3) * math.pi ** 2.5) + c2 = g76 * 1.5 ** (1 / 3) * (4 / 3) / (2 * math.sqrt(3) * math.pi ** 1.5) + check("R7_c3_inside_enclosure", 0.04177593184059834334 - 2e-16 < c3 < 0.04177593184059834335 + 2e-16) + check("R7_c2_inside_enclosure", 0.07340691930603427103 - 2e-16 < c2 < 0.07340691930603427104 + 2e-16) + # Independent evaluation of (1) with the standard-library decimal module: Stirling for + # log Gamma at z = 7/6 + 120 with B_2..B_40 (remainder < 1e-70 by DLMF 5.11(ii)), own Machin pi. + # This is a different shift (120 vs the package's 32) and a different arithmetic (decimal vs + # rational intervals). Digits beyond the remainder bound are not claimed. + getcontext().prec = 90 + Bn = bernoulli_list(42) + def atan_inv(n): + x = Decimal(1) / Decimal(n); x2 = x * x; term = x; tot = Decimal(0); k = 0 + while abs(term) > Decimal(10) ** -95: + tot += term / (2 * k + 1) * (-1) ** k; term *= x2; k += 1 + return tot + pi_d = 16 * atan_inv(5) - 4 * atan_inv(239) + z0 = Decimal(7) / 6; shift = 120; K = 20; z = z0 + shift + lg = (z - Decimal(1) / 2) * z.ln() - z + (2 * pi_d).ln() / 2 + for k in range(1, K + 1): + b = Bn[2 * k] + lg += Decimal(b.numerator) / Decimal(b.denominator) / (Decimal(2 * k * (2 * k - 1)) * z ** (2 * k - 1)) + b = Bn[2 * K + 2] + rem = abs(Decimal(b.numerator) / Decimal(b.denominator) / (Decimal((2 * K + 2) * (2 * K + 1)) * z ** (2 * K + 1))) + check("R7_stirling_remainder_tiny", rem < Decimal(10) ** -70) + for j in range(shift): + lg -= (z0 + j).ln() + g_d = lg.exp() + c2_d = g_d * (Decimal(3) / 2) ** (Decimal(1) / 3) * (Decimal(4) / 3) / (2 * Decimal(3).sqrt() * pi_d * pi_d.sqrt()) + c3_d = g_d * (Decimal(3) / 2) ** (Decimal(1) / 3) * (Decimal(29) / 6 - Decimal(6).sqrt()) / (2 * Decimal(3).sqrt() * pi_d ** 2 * pi_d.sqrt()) + check("R7_decimal_c2_in_published_endpoints", Decimal("0.07340691930603427103") < c2_d < Decimal("0.07340691930603427104")) + check("R7_decimal_c3_in_published_endpoints", Decimal("0.04177593184059834334") < c3_d < Decimal("0.04177593184059834335")) + # earlier clean-context 45-digit re-derivation of c_3 (2026-09-29), compared here, not just recorded + c3_45 = Decimal("0.0417759318405983433429366654285755564666815197") + check("R7_decimal_c3_matches_45_digit_rederivation", abs(c3_d - c3_45) < Decimal(10) ** -45) + def trunc(x, n): + t = str(x); i = t.index("."); return t[:i + 1 + n] + res["R7_closed_form"] = {"c3_float": "%.17g" % c3, "c2_float": "%.17g" % c2, + "gamma_7_6_decimal_60": trunc(g_d, 60), "c2_decimal_60": trunc(c2_d, 60), + "c3_decimal_60": trunc(c3_d, 60), + "independent_45_digit": str(c3_45) + " (clean-context re-derivation, 2026-09-29; matched to 1e-45)"} + + # ---- R8: Bernoulli numbers used in the Stirling expansion -------------------- + B = [F(1, 6), F(-1, 30), F(1, 42), F(-1, 30), F(5, 66), F(-691, 2730), F(7, 6), F(-3617, 510), + F(43867, 798), F(-174611, 330), F(854513, 138)] + # recompute B_{2k} from the Akiyama-Tanigawa algorithm (exact) + Bt = bernoulli_list(22) + check("R8_bernoulli_2_to_22", [Bt[2 * k] for k in range(1, 12)] == B) + check("R8_B22_positive_first_omitted", B[10] > 0) + res["R8_stirling"] = "B_2..B_22 exact; first omitted term positive (DLMF 5.11(ii) sign)" + + print(json.dumps({"object": "CL-SIDE24-V1-REVIEW-20260929-v1-CHECKS", + "scope": "finite identities of the coefficient note and its program; by-hand items in REVIEW.md", + "results": res, "passed": True}, indent=2, sort_keys=True)) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main(sys.argv)