From b1aa19122a9891075b6a3ad0a6c6b6eea6597b49 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy <249851642+d6g8k5htny-coder@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Sat, 3 Oct 2026 16:10:59 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] Incorporate exact C124 endpoint-rate proof and scoped reviews Add the unchanged public C124 proof, source manifest, two nonauthor reviews and their finite controls to the existing planar soft-layer packet. Reuse the unchanged replay and workflows; preserve all prior payloads. Actual incorporator: OpenAI/Codex next_ui_triage under C126 claim52794ff2-9fd5-4514-bd44-413f20555444. Non-author of C124 mathematics; source-custody exposure disclosed. Scientific effect NONE. --- .../C124/AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md | 456 ++++++++++++++ .../C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md | 344 ++++++++++ .../C124/CHECKER_COMMENT.md | 210 +++++++ .../C124/CONTROLS.md | 172 +++++ .../C124/PROOF.md | 468 ++++++++++++++ .../C124/REVIEW.md | 169 +++++ .../C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md | 92 +++ .../C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md | 11 + .../C124/SOURCES_COMMENT.md | 583 +++++++++++++++++ .../C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json | 577 +++++++++++++++++ .../C124/author_controls.py | 271 ++++++++ .../C124/author_controls_stdout.txt | 1 + .../C124/checker.py | 179 ++++++ .../C124/checker_claude.py | 277 ++++++++ .../C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt | 9 + .../C124/checker_stdout.txt | 1 + .../README.md | 24 +- .../SOURCES.json | 591 ++++++++++++++++++ 18 files changed, 4430 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_COMMENT.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CONTROLS.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/PROOF.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCES_COMMENT.md create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls.py create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls_stdout.txt create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker.py create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude.py create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt create mode 100644 frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_stdout.txt diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..447c31746 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md @@ -0,0 +1,456 @@ +## C124 exact controls and execution record + +Dylan Roy — delegated AI work. Actual author: OpenAI/Codex next_math_triage; root publishes the exact frozen files. These are author-side arithmetic controls, not an independent analytic review. + +For the proof [5974162498](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974162498). Each file is the literal text inside its five-backtick fence, including the final LF. controls.py is 12,062 bytes SHA256 3cc864185ba8e9cee780544ea1559c5591bda45110745f73f0cd9b4277745bcb. CONTROLS.md is 10,113 bytes SHA256 400a043d664f2ad894bbc669c38203d9809a14743522c031cc86bdbef923e399. The full normal/optimized baseline and ten adverse variants are recorded below. These finite checks do not prove the analytic imports. + +### controls.py +`````python +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""C124 finite exact arithmetic controls; no analytic or formal-proof claim. + +No arguments: baseline (exit 0 on success). --mutant NAME: deliberately +incorrect candidate (exit 1 if rejected). Invalid arguments exit 2. +Only the Python standard library is used; no files or network are accessed. +""" + +from fractions import Fraction as F +from math import comb, factorial, prod +import json +import sys + + +MUTANTS = ( + "WINDOW_H_OMITTED", + "BAND_P_ONE", + "DROP_BAND_FLOOR", + "UNWEIGHTED_PROMOTION", + "INDEPENDENT_COEFFICIENTS", + "EXP_SCALE_TOO_LARGE", + "DROP_SOFT_FACTOR", + "DOUBLE_NORMALIZER", + "DROP_SCALED_FAR", + "GAUSSIAN_LAMBDA_SQUARED", +) + + +class Checks: + def __init__(self): + self.groups = {} + self.failures = [] + + def check(self, group, label, condition): + counts = self.groups.setdefault(group, {"checks": 0, "failures": 0}) + counts["checks"] += 1 + if not condition: + counts["failures"] += 1 + if len(self.failures) < 16: + self.failures.append({"group": group, "label": label}) + + def equal(self, group, label, got, want): + self.check(group, label, got == want) + + def result(self, mutant): + checks = sum(v["checks"] for v in self.groups.values()) + failures = sum(v["failures"] for v in self.groups.values()) + return { + "object": "C124-EXACT-CONTROLS-v1", + "candidate": mutant or "BASELINE", + "passed": failures == 0, + "checks": checks, + "failure_count": failures, + "failures_first_16": self.failures, + "groups": self.groups, + "scope": "finite rational controls; not analytic proof or source verification", + } + + +def ledger(c, mutant): + g = "G1_schedule_and_admissibility" + # w=(r H^4)^(-1/12), retaining both exact powers. + schedule = (F(-1, 12), F(-1, 3)) + if mutant == "WINDOW_H_OMITTED": + schedule = (F(-1, 12), F(0)) + + def substitute(r, h, w): + return (F(r) + F(w) * schedule[0], F(h) + F(w) * schedule[1]) + + # Input monomials (r,H,w) and independently hand-derived expected pairs. + cases = ( + ("radius", (0, 0, -8), (F(2, 3), F(8, 3))), + ("radius_actual", (1, 3, -4), (F(4, 3), F(13, 3))), + ("selected_edge", (1, 4, 4), (F(2, 3), F(8, 3))), + ("selected_edge_actual", (F(3, 2), 5, 2), (F(4, 3), F(13, 3))), + ("endpoint", (1, 3, 2), (F(5, 6), F(7, 3))), + ("endpoint_actual", (F(3, 2), 4, 1), (F(17, 12), F(11, 3))), + ("joint_band", (1, 0, 4), (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3))), + ("actual_band_floor", (1, 4, 0), (F(1), F(4))), + ("large_N", (2, 3, 8), (F(4, 3), F(1, 3))), + ("hessian_first", (2, 5, 4), (F(5, 3), F(11, 3))), + ("hessian_second", (2, 7, 2), (F(11, 6), F(19, 3))), + ("far_derivative", (1, 0, 0), (F(1), F(0))), + ) + target = (F(2, 3), F(8, 3)) + values = {} + for label, powers, want in cases: + got = substitute(*powers) + values[label] = got + c.equal(g, label + ":exact_pair", got, want) + c.check(g, label + ":log_dominance", + got[0] > target[0] or + (got[0] == target[0] and got[1] <= target[1])) + c.equal(g, "balanced_leading_terms", values["radius"], values["selected_edge"]) + c.equal(g, "leading_target", values["radius"], target) + for label, powers, want in ( + ("rH", (1, 1, 0), (F(1), F(1))), + ("rw", (1, 0, 1), (F(11, 12), F(-1, 3))), + ("e", (1, 0, 4), (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3))), + ("H2e", (1, 2, 4), (F(2, 3), F(2, 3))), + ("eta", (1, 0, 2), (F(5, 6), F(-2, 3))), + ): + got = substitute(*powers) + c.equal(g, label + ":exact_admissibility", got, want) + c.check(g, label + ":vanishes", got[0] > 0) + c.check(g, "window_grows", schedule[0] < 0) + # Fixed-Lambda schedule w=r^-1/12: H powers become constants. + for label, powers, _ in cases: + r, _, w = powers + c.check(g, label + ":fixed_layer_at_least_two_thirds", + F(r) - F(w, 12) >= F(2, 3)) + + +def dyadic(c, mutant): + g = "G2_joint_band_dyadic_sums" + p = 1 if mutant == "BAND_P_ONE" else 2 + for m in range(2, 33): + for scale in (F(1), F(3, 4), F(5, 7)): + a = scale / 2**m + b = F(3, 17) + endpoint = 2 * a + last = 0 + while 2 * endpoint <= F(1, 2): + last += 1 + endpoint *= 2 + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:stopping_interval", + F(1, 4) < endpoint <= F(1, 2)) + shell_a = sum((2 * a * F(2) ** ((1 - p) * j) + for j in range(last + 1)), F(0)) + shell_b = sum((b * F(2) ** (-p * j) + for j in range(last + 1)), F(0)) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:linear_geometric_sum", shell_a, + 4 * a * (1 - F(1, 2) ** (last + 1))) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:floor_geometric_sum", shell_b, + F(4, 3) * b * (1 - F(1, 4) ** (last + 1))) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:uniform_shell_bound", + shell_a + shell_b <= 4 * a + F(4, 3) * b) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:large_N_threshold", + endpoint / a > 1 / (4 * a)) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:tail_markov_coefficient", + (a / endpoint)**2 < 16 * a**2) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:combined_low_and_shells", + a + b + shell_a + shell_b <= 5 * a + F(7, 3) * b) + # Abstract continuous band fixture: measure of total mass B, N=1, + # uniform in mu on (0,delta]. It obeys mass{|mu|<=s} <= s+B for + # every s>0, with no atom at the neutral level. It is not asserted + # to be a realizable pinned Gaussian field. The bound alone cannot + # discard B; choosing delta=B/2^m defeats a delta-only unit bound. + for m in range(1, 33): + b = F(1, 64) + delta = b / 2**m + offered = delta if mutant == "DROP_BAND_FLOOR" else delta + b + c.check(g, f"continuous:m{m}:retain_band_error_floor", b <= offered) + + +def counterexample(c, mutant): + g = "G3_unweighted_band_counterexample" + # The geometric-distribution recurrence is compared with literal moments. + moments = [1] + for p in range(1, 9): + moments.append(2 + sum(comb(p, j) * moments[j] for j in range(1, p))) + c.equal(g, "geometric_moments_zero_through_eight", moments, + [1, 2, 6, 26, 150, 1082, 9366, 94586, 1091670]) + for p in range(9): + partial = sum((F(n**p, 2**n) for n in range(1, 129)), F(0)) + c.check(g, f"p{p}:partial_moment_below_exact", partial <= moments[p]) + for m in range(2, 65): + delta = F(1, 2**m) + e = delta / m + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:event_lower_bound_over_e", delta / e, F(m)) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:event_containment_at_right_endpoint", delta <= e * m) + # Exact partition into U-intervals with N=m+j, including the tail. + finite = sum((F((m + j)**2, 2**(m + j)) for j in range(1, 17)), F(0)) + tail = F((m + 16)**2 + 4 * (m + 16) + 6, 2**(m + 16)) + joint = delta * (m*m + 4*m + 6) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:joint_second_moment", finite + tail, joint) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:joint_band_ratio", joint / delta, F(m*m + 4*m + 6)) + proposed_bound = 8 * e if mutant == "UNWEIGHTED_PROMOTION" else delta + c.check(g, f"m{m}:unweighted_Oe_claim_not_inferred", delta <= proposed_bound) + + +def gaussian(c, mutant): + g = "G4_correlated_gaussian_and_exp_square" + for index, weights in enumerate(((F(1), F(1)), (F(1, 3), F(2, 3)), + (F(2), F(3), F(5)), + (F(1, 2), F(1, 3), F(1, 7)))): + s = sum(weights) + variance = sum(a*a for a in weights) if mutant == "INDEPENDENT_COEFFICIENTS" else s*s + c.equal(g, f"fixture{index}:fully_correlated_variance", variance, s*s) + c.check(g, f"fixture{index}:quadrature_is_too_small", sum(a*a for a in weights) < s*s) + for m in range(1, 17): + normal_moment = prod(range(1, 2*m, 2)) + candidate_moment = variance**m * normal_moment + c.equal(g, f"fixture{index}:m{m}:actual_even_moment", + candidate_moment, s**(2*m) * normal_moment) + c.check(g, f"fixture{index}:m{m}:Minkowski_majorant", + s**(2*m) * normal_moment <= s**(2*m) * (2*m)**m) + # Rational coefficient check: if ||J||_p <= C sqrt(p), use + # epsilon=1/(12 C^2), m! >= (m/3)^m, and sum 2^-m=2. + # The assumed moment inequality and infinite-series step are analytic. + for const in (F(1), F(3, 2), F(4), F(17, 3)): + epsilon = 1 / (const*const * (1 if mutant == "EXP_SCALE_TOO_LARGE" else 12)) + for m in range(1, 49): + c.check(g, f"C{const}:m{m}:factorial_majorant", m**m <= 3**m * factorial(m)) + coefficient = epsilon**m * const**(2*m) * (2*m)**m / factorial(m) + c.check(g, f"C{const}:m{m}:geometric_exp_coefficient", coefficient <= F(1, 2**m)) + for m in range(1, 25): + c.equal(g, f"exp_partial{m}", sum((F(1, 2**j) for j in range(m + 1)), F(0)), + 2 - F(1, 2**m)) + + +def rare_scalar(c, mutant): + g = "G5_rare_scalar_and_full_normalization" + for r in (F(1, 2), F(1, 7), F(1, 64), F(3, 100)): + for j in (F(1), F(3, 2), F(4)): + for d, s in ((F(1), F(1)), (F(2), F(3, 4)), (F(1, 3), F(5))): + top = d * r * j*j + integral = top*top / 2 if mutant == "DROP_SOFT_FACTOR" else top**3/3 + s*r*j*j*top*top/2 + numerator = r*r*j**4 * integral + coefficient = d**3/3 + s*d*d/2 + want = r**5*j**10*coefficient + label = f"r{r}:J{j}:D{d}:C{s}" + c.equal(g, label + ":scalar_integral", numerator, want) + z = F(5, 3) * r*r + normalized = numerator / (z*z if mutant == "DOUBLE_NORMALIZER" else z) + c.equal(g, label + ":probability_scaling", normalized, + r**3*j**10*coefficient/F(5, 3)) + c.equal(g, label + ":scaled_measure", normalized/r**3, + j**10*coefficient/F(5, 3)) + # The documented input is E[(W/r^2) 1_exception] <= C r^4. + c.equal(g, "near_radius_exponents", 5 - 2 - 3, 0) + c.equal(g, "far_numerator_radius_exponent", 2 + 4, 6) + far = F(0) if mutant == "DROP_SCALED_FAR" else F(1, 8) + c.check(g, "retain_permitted_far_mass", F(1, 8) <= far) + c.equal(g, "far_scaled_radius_exponent", 2 + 4 - 2 - 3, 1) + + +def exponential_tail(c, mutant): + g = "G6_exponential_tail_threshold" + for lam in (F(1), F(4), F(9), F(25), F(64), F(100)): + for const in (F(1), F(4), F(9)): + threshold_squared = lam*lam/const if mutant == "GAUSSIAN_LAMBDA_SQUARED" else lam/const + c.equal(g, f"Lambda{lam}:C{const}:threshold_square", threshold_squared, lam/const) + c.equal(g, "square_of_square_root_degree", F(1, 2)*2, 1) + for decay in (F(1, 10), F(1, 3), F(1), F(7, 2)): + D = F(2, 3)/decay + c.equal(g, f"c{decay}:minimum_log_cutoff", decay*D, F(2, 3)) + c.check(g, f"c{decay}:larger_log_cutoff", decay*(D + 1) > F(2, 3)) + + +def main(argv): + if argv == ["--list-mutants"]: + print(json.dumps(list(MUTANTS), separators=(",", ":"))) + return 0 + mutant = None + if argv: + if len(argv) != 2 or argv[0] != "--mutant" or argv[1] not in MUTANTS: + print(json.dumps({"error": "expected no arguments, --list-mutants, or --mutant NAME", + "passed": False}, sort_keys=True, separators=(",", ":"))) + return 2 + mutant = argv[1] + checks = Checks() + for group in (ledger, dyadic, counterexample, gaussian, rare_scalar, exponential_tail): + group(checks, mutant) + result = checks.result(mutant) + print(json.dumps(result, sort_keys=True, separators=(",", ":"))) + return 0 if result["passed"] else 1 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + sys.exit(main(sys.argv[1:])) +````` + +### CONTROLS.md +`````markdown +# C124 exact arithmetic controls — author-side design + +Actual author: OpenAI/Codex delegated executor `/root/next_math_triage`, under +parent C124 claim `33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4` (WE733). This executor +supplied author-side proof analysis and is not an independent reviewer. +Organizational independence credit: 0. Human review: NONE. + +The controls are finite exact arithmetic checks, not a proof of Gaussian +regression, the saddle-band integral, the actual global elder event, or the +continuum/asymptotic theorem. They import no independent reference field law. +Only `controls.py` and this document are authored by this executor. + +## Frozen test intentions before implementation + +1. Substitute `w = r^(-1/12) H^(-1/3)` into the complete new error ledger with + exact `Fraction` exponents. Check every resulting pair and dominance by + `(2/3, 8/3)` when `H = 1 + D log(1/r)`. The dominance test permits any fixed + logarithmic power if its radius exponent is strictly greater than `2/3`; + at equality its logarithmic exponent must be at most `8/3`. Check the + remaining small-radius admissibility exponents separately. A schedule + omitting the power of H must fail. +2. For `a = 2 K0 e <= 1/4` and `B = r H^4`, sum the actual mu-shell majorants + `2 a 2^(-j) + B 4^(-j)` through the last endpoint at most `1/2`. Verify + their exact geometric sums, the endpoint in `(1/4,1/2]`, and the residual + large-N cost `16 a^2 mu_r(N^2)`. The low band contributes `a+B`, so the + resulting constants are `5a + (7/3)B + 16H^3a^2`, before source constants. + Using p=1 or deleting the actual-law floor B must fail. +3. Keep a counterexample to promoting an unweighted band plus all moments: + `U ~ Uniform(0,1)`, `N = ceil(log2(1/U))`, and `e_m = 2^(-m)/m`. + On `0=1, every fixed moment is finite by the + ratio test, and `E[N^2; U<=2^(-m)] = 2^(-m)(m^2+4m+6)`. The finite + checks verify these geometric/moment identities; they do not prove an + assertion for every real p by enumeration. +4. Use perfectly correlated Gaussian coefficients `eta_i=G`, not independent + ones. The variance is `(sum a_i)^2`, and the even moments follow the exact + double-factorial identity. Check that the sum-of-standard-deviations + majorant works while the independent-coefficient variance fails. Verify + finite coefficients of a conservative exponential-square majorant; + convergence of its infinite series remains analytic reasoning. +5. Reconstruct, for rational positive parameters, the rare scalar integral + `r^2 J^4 integral_0^(D r J^2) l(l+C r J^2) dl` + `= r^5 J^10 (D^3/3+C D^2/2)`. Preserve both scalar factors. Check the + single full normalizer `r^2`, subsequent `r^-3` scaling, and the retained + scaled far/derivative contribution `O(r)`. Missing a soft factor or + normalizing twice must fail. +6. Check the threshold-degree conversion `J > sqrt(Lambda/C)` followed by + an exponential-square tail: its exponential order is Lambda, not + Lambda squared. These algebra checks do not establish a tail estimate. + +All rejection checks will use explicit conditions rather than Python +`assert`, so optimized Python cannot remove them. No network, random +sampling, third-party module, project test, or source mutation is involved. + +## Executed results + +Final script: **12062 bytes**, SHA-256 +`3cc864185ba8e9cee780544ea1559c5591bda45110745f73f0cd9b4277745bcb`. + +Executed with Python **3.11.16** at +`/Users/dylanroy/Documents/Codex/2026-09-19/connect-research-repository/work/venv/bin/python3.11`. +There were **24 final invocations**: baseline, ten named adverse candidates, +and one unknown label, each in normal and optimized mode. All had the +expected exit; all stderr streams were empty. Each corresponding pair of +stdout streams was byte-identical. + +Baseline: **1,740 checks, zero failures**, in six groups: + +| Group | Checks | +|---|---:| +| G1 — schedule and admissibility | 49 | +| G2 — joint-band dyadic sums | 683 | +| G3 — unweighted-band counterexample | 325 | +| G4 — correlated Gaussian and exponential-square arithmetic | 544 | +| G5 — rare scalar integral and normalization | 112 | +| G6 — exponential-tail threshold | 27 | + +Counts enumerate arithmetic predicates and are not theorem counts or +independent proofs. A negative candidate runs the same predicates and +must exit 1. The unknown label exits 2 before checks. Output lists at most +the first sixteen failed labels but counts every failure. + +| Candidate | Exit (both modes) | Failed predicates | Stdout bytes | Stdout SHA-256 (both modes) | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---| +| `BASELINE` | 0 | 0 | 591 | `14b587bd72fd8b16ce56791178c2fab4f57535534e5c0f4e1697daf9692cdcdd` | +| `WINDOW_H_OMITTED` | 1 | 17 | 1807 | `84cf603bbb2361ec185c3c86c177e5e1602021280b86c30c240cf7c579cf23f7` | +| `BAND_P_ONE` | 1 | 360 | 1801 | `8999f77b2e0fe300d4344505a444b0185aee2d08e4a5fac77eb8eb188d8b6830` | +| `DROP_BAND_FLOOR` | 1 | 32 | 1983 | `fff2a4497204b922b2e9d58e1a6536a67b8df9fefc4b3215fb97ffadc703abcb` | +| `UNWEIGHTED_PROMOTION` | 1 | 56 | 2092 | `7a121924fa4901d152b705a722feae2b93ae64bbaeda858a8b7ff7ee0dc4900f` | +| `INDEPENDENT_COEFFICIENTS` | 1 | 68 | 2075 | `55634f5b00ba1fcfc6d1c09639a9c1cd31e31f8ffda95be760c36b97e5ca39ad` | +| `EXP_SCALE_TOO_LARGE` | 1 | 192 | 2085 | `8c9b05ac6d858e9151fae55d0ff292972e5fc0800b1ef45f41573919f41db590` | +| `DROP_SOFT_FACTOR` | 1 | 105 | 2092 | `9ab1a8fda6ab2888d9299b48e212bee5032cc523cc2f5700163fca5ebb1f498e` | +| `DOUBLE_NORMALIZER` | 1 | 72 | 2098 | `b059ff988449f4d9f9bcd4615831ebad4628e9b166f75d4d0fb200e7f6bcaaad` | +| `DROP_SCALED_FAR` | 1 | 1 | 684 | `7f5c21d1e8719ec2564333fd6b4186cdcf02cacd742832b30e0f88401535bdd1` | +| `GAUSSIAN_LAMBDA_SQUARED` | 1 | 15 | 1820 | `8355c4cbde5561bdf2ddcebf4d1270dd79db61433a83c5947b734218fe543b91` | +| `UNKNOWN` | 2 | n/a | 83 | `5189cbc57e52c13b5608e65a6311f44598eaacec80d76a6544051e4c44d897ce` | + +Empty stderr SHA-256 is +`e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855`. + +The final baseline stdout, including its terminating newline, is: + +```json +{"candidate":"BASELINE","checks":1740,"failure_count":0,"failures_first_16":[],"groups":{"G1_schedule_and_admissibility":{"checks":49,"failures":0},"G2_joint_band_dyadic_sums":{"checks":683,"failures":0},"G3_unweighted_band_counterexample":{"checks":325,"failures":0},"G4_correlated_gaussian_and_exp_square":{"checks":544,"failures":0},"G5_rare_scalar_and_full_normalization":{"checks":112,"failures":0},"G6_exponential_tail_threshold":{"checks":27,"failures":0}},"object":"C124-EXACT-CONTROLS-v1","passed":true,"scope":"finite rational controls; not analytic proof or source verification"} +``` + +## Replaying the finite controls + +From this directory: + +```sh +python3 -B controls.py +python3 -B -O controls.py +python3 -B controls.py --list-mutants +python3 -B controls.py --mutant DROP_SOFT_FACTOR +python3 -B -O controls.py --mutant DROP_SOFT_FACTOR +python3 -B controls.py --mutant UNKNOWN +``` + +The last three commands intentionally return 1, 1 and 2. All ten labels in +the table can be substituted for `DROP_SOFT_FACTOR`. No command downloads +sources, verifies a source digest, or replays the project master suite. +The complete analytic imports and proof must be assessed independently. + +## Development and conceptual limits + +The written test intentions above preceded implementation. The first +baseline used an unfinished constant-window placeholder +`schedule = (F(0), F(0))`: it exited 1 with **18 expected ledger failures**, +while the other five groups passed. That test-first source was +11856 bytes, SHA-256 +`b37a96e544ec4f70ad6f0747c797bc457adb8ae71bb938dd755bc4c37cff9f52`; its 1792-byte stdout was +`bae8c10f566276eee0d9e348919511af574c7f27759ca68aa02dc5661f04c0fc`. Replacing the placeholder by the intended two +powers made the baseline pass. The initial red run was repeated once to +capture its identity. A later final-source tightening made the floor +fixture continuous instead of atomic; the complete final 24-invocation +matrix above was then rerun. No analytic conclusion rests on that +development history. + +The `DROP_BAND_FLOOR` fixture is an **abstract continuous measure**, with +N=1 and total mass B distributed uniformly over `00 it satisfies `mass(|mu|<=s)<=s+B`, and has no atom at mu=0. +It shows what the stated band inequality alone permits. It is not claimed +to arise from the pinned Gaussian field. In particular it does not +contradict actual neutral-level nullity. Removing B in the analytic proof +would require additional source information. + +The U,N counterexample is also abstract. Its unweighted band is exactly +`P(U<=delta)=delta` for `0<=delta<=1`; all fixed moments of N exist. +Nevertheless the ratio `P(U<=e_m N)/e_m` is at least m and unbounded. +The adverse label uses a proposed constant 8, rejected for m>8. The +divergence for arbitrary constants follows from the written argument, +not from testing only m<=64. Its joint band has an unbounded quadratic +coefficient `m^2+4m+6`, which identifies precisely the extra hypothesis +used by the C124 proof. + +The Gaussian fixtures take identical coefficients, eta_i=G. They show +that coefficient-wise variance bounds do not give independence or a +sum-of-variances bound. Minkowski uses a sum of standard deviations and +remains valid. The exponential-square coefficient check chooses the +conservative rational `epsilon=1/(12 C^2)` under the analytic premise +`||J||_p<=C sqrt(p)`, using `m!>=(m/3)^m` and the geometric sum. +Only finitely many coefficients are checked; the premise, factorial +inequality for all m, infinite series, conditional Fourier convergence +and tail transfer belong to the analytic proof. + +No finite-r saddle matching, ordinary-global-elder equivalence, retained +cap theorem, compact-family uniformity, or full normalizer lower bound +is proved by this script. It neither extends the contribution beyond +physical k=1 nor establishes once-counted replacement bars, a transported +real-valued mark, k-to-zero behavior, higher dimensions, or unrestricted +lifetime asymptotics. +````` diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..26beb44b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md @@ -0,0 +1,344 @@ +## C124 cross-provider review: reviewer controls, exact executable and stdout + +This is the standard-library script behind the [review 5974335101](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974335101). I wrote it before reading the author controls (5974185757) or the first review (5974327730), and independently of both. It checks finite algebra, exact sums and exponent bookkeeping only. It does not prove C82 LB, C101's interfaces, P4.2's residual, the Gaussian moment bounds, C95/C96/C98's identification or any measure-theoretic step. + +Dylan Roy — delegated AI review. Actual performer: Anthropic Claude (session `session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU`). Scientific effect: NONE. + +**Extraction rule.** +- The file is the exact text between the ```` ```python ```` fence under the `###` heading and the next ```` ``` ```` line, plus one final newline. +- The expected stdout is the text in the following ```` ```text ```` fence, plus one final newline. +- The byte counts below include those newlines. + +**Run.** +- `python3 -B -S c124_exact.py`: exit 0, with exactly the stdout shown. A run takes about 2 seconds. +- `-O` mode and plain `python3`: byte-identical output. +- `python3 c124_exact.py BOGUS`: exit 2. +- Each of the six mutant labels exits 1 (table below). + +The output was produced with Python 3.11.15. + +**Groups.** + +| group | what it checks | +|---|---| +| G0 | Lemma JB: `dλ = (γ²/24)dψ`, `w_λ dλ = (γ⁶/384)(ψ² − c²)dψ`, the pole cancellations, LB's multiplier in raw jets, the error term `≤ 2rH⁴` | +| G1 | Lemma DB: the integer `m`, shell widths `≤ 1/2`, the exact shell sum `≤ 4a + (4/3)b`, the shell and tail implications, the countermodel | +| G2 | Lemma ES: `(2n − 1)!! ≤ (2n)^n`, `n! ≥ (n/3)^n`, each series term `≤ 2^{−n}` at `ε₀ = 1/(12C_*²)`, the maximizer of `x¹⁰e^{−ε₀x²/2}`, the half-split | +| G3 | Lemma FT: `∫₀^{4D_cap rJ²} l(l + CrJ²) dl = O(r³J⁶)`, the weight `r⁵J¹⁰`, the scaling, the cutoff `J² > Λ/C₀` | +| G4 | §7 fixed layer: the eleven exponents at `w = r^{−1/12}`, minimum `2/3`, `O(r^{11/3})` | +| G5 | (18): every table row as an exact monomial `r^x H^y`, the domination by `r^{2/3}H^{8/3}`, the conditions (17) | +| G6 | the conditional-law normalization `≤ 4‖ν − ν₀‖/M_*`, and `Λ = D_* log(1/r)` making the tails `O(r)` | + +**Mutants.** Each was actually run; each exits 1. + +| label | change | failing groups | failed checks | +|---|---|---|---:| +| `CHART_12` | `dλ = (γ²/12)dψ` in JB | G0 | 7988 | +| `SHELL_2A` | shell sum bounded by `2a` | G1 | 1445 | +| `ES_SIX` | `ε₀ = 1/(6C_*²)` | G2 | 117 | +| `FT_R4` | near weight `r⁴J¹⁰` | G3 | 3000 | +| `W_SIXTEENTH` | fixed-layer window `w = r^{−1/16}` | G4 | 2 | +| `TABLE_H3` | `w⁻⁸` row with `H³` | G5 | 1 | + +### c124_exact.py + +- **File:** 12724 bytes, SHA-256 `92620eb802a4400f5a77784bbe0a4b3bd4a412cb0bec1e3fbc78acf0f45c46f4`. +- **Stdout:** 508 bytes, SHA-256 `fa2f4e088b61c8b4ce37647635101bb5d127be3547ada9d265a0ec0e952dee2b`. + +```python +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""C124 cross-provider review controls: exact rational checks, standard library only. + +Target: C124-PLANAR-K1-CORRELATED-BAND-ENDPOINT-LOG-RATE-20261003-v1, main issue 229, comment 5974162498 +(20,668 bytes, SHA-256 90148657...520f). +Reviewer: Anthropic Claude, session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU, for Dylan Roy (delegated AI review). +Written without the author's controls (5974185757) or any other reviewer's code. Disclosed stake: C124 +consumes the reviewer's A4. + +Usage: python3 c124_exact.py [MUTANT] (exit 0 pass, 1 fail, 2 unknown label) +Mutants (each must exit 1): + CHART_12 d lambda = (gamma^2/12) d psi in place of gamma^2/24 (Lemma JB) + SHELL_2A the dyadic shell sum bounded by 2a in place of 4a (Lemma DB) + ES_SIX epsilon_0 = 1/(6 C_*^2) in place of 1/(12 C_*^2) (Lemma ES) + FT_R4 the near-branch weight r^4 J^10 in place of r^5 J^10 (Lemma FT, (14)) + W_SIXTEENTH the fixed-layer window w = r^(-1/16) in place of r^(-1/12) (section 7) + TABLE_H3 the w^(-8) row with H^3 in place of H^(8/3) ((18) table) +These checks test finite algebra, exact sums and exponent bookkeeping only. They do not prove C82 LB, +C101's interfaces, P4.2's residual, the Gaussian moment bounds, C95/C96/C98's identification or any +measure-theoretic step. +""" +import math +import random +import sys +from fractions import Fraction as F + +MUTANTS = ("CHART_12", "SHELL_2A", "ES_SIX", "FT_R4", "W_SIXTEENTH", "TABLE_H3") +MUT = None +if len(sys.argv) > 1: + MUT = sys.argv[1] + if len(sys.argv) > 2 or MUT not in MUTANTS: + print("unknown mutant label: %s" % " ".join(sys.argv[1:])) + sys.exit(2) + +RNG = random.Random(124_5974162498) +RESULTS, FAILS = [], [] + + +class Group: + def __init__(self, name): + self.name, self.n, self.bad = name, 0, 0 + + def check(self, ok, msg=""): + self.n += 1 + if not ok: + self.bad += 1 + if len(FAILS) < 12: + FAILS.append("%s: %s" % (self.name, msg)) + + def close(self): + RESULTS.append((self.name, self.n - self.bad, self.n)) + + +def rq(lo, hi, den=97): + a, b = int(math.floor(F(lo) * den)), int(math.floor(F(hi) * den)) + return F(RNG.randint(a, b), den) + + +def rq_pos(lo, hi, den=97): + while True: + x = rq(lo, hi, den) + if x > 0: + return x + + +# ===================================================================== +# G0 Lemma JB: chart Jacobian, weight, pole cancellation; the error term over |lambda| <= Lambda +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G0 Lemma JB chart and poles") +jac = F(1, 12) if MUT == "CHART_12" else F(1, 24) +for _ in range(4000): + gam, B1, C3 = rq(-4, 4), rq(-4, 4), rq(-4, 4) + if gam == 0: + continue + D, J = gam**2 - 12 * B1, 8 * gam**3 - 144 * B1 * gam + 576 * C3 + c, R = D / gam**2, J / gam**3 + l1, l2 = rq(0, 3), rq(0, 3) + p1, p2 = 24 * l1 / gam**2, 24 * l2 / gam**2 + if p1 != p2: + g.check((l2 - l1) / (p2 - p1) == jac * gam**2, "d lambda = (gamma^2/24) d psi") + aM, aS = 24 * l1 - D, 24 * l1 + D + g.check(aM * aS / 16 * jac * gam**2 == gam**6 * (p1**2 - c**2) / 384, "w_lambda d lambda = (gamma^6/384)(psi^2 - c^2) d psi") + g.check(gam**6 * abs(c)**3 == abs(D)**3 and gam**6 * R**2 == J**2, "gamma^6 |c|^3 = |D|^3, gamma^6 R^2 = J^2") + # the multiplier of C82 LB after the Jacobian: (delta/384)[(1024/3)|D|^3 + 64 J^2] + g.check(gam**6 / 384 * ((F(1024, 3)) * abs(c)**3 + 64 * R**2) == (F(1024, 3) * abs(D)**3 + 64 * J**2) / 384, "LB multiplier in raw jets") +for Lam in [F(k, 3) for k in range(3, 60)]: + H = 1 + Lam + g.check(2 * Lam <= 2 * H and H**3 * 2 * Lam <= 2 * H**4, "error term r H^3 int_{-Lambda}^{Lambda} d lambda <= 2 r H^4") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G1 Lemma DB: dyadic shells, exact sums, the tail region, and the countermodel +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G1 Lemma DB dyadic summation") +shell_const = 2 if MUT == "SHELL_2A" else 4 +for _ in range(3000): + a = rq_pos(F(1, 10**6), F(1, 4), 10**7) + b = rq_pos(0, 1, 1000) + m = 0 + while not (F(1, 4) <= 2**m * a < F(1, 2)): + m += 1 + if m > 80: + break + g.check(F(1, 4) <= 2**m * a < F(1, 2), "the integer m with 2^m a in [1/4, 1/2) exists") + shells = sum(2 * a * F(1, 2**j) + b * F(1, 4**j) for j in range(m)) + g.check(shells <= shell_const * a + F(4, 3) * b, "sum_j [2a 2^-j + b 4^-j] <= 4a + (4/3) b") + for j in range(m): + g.check(2**(j + 1) * a <= F(1, 2), "each shell width 2^(j+1) a <= 1/2 (JB applies)") + # the implications used: |mu| <= a N with 2^j a < |mu| gives N > 2^j; |mu| > 2^m a >= 1/4 gives (4 a N)^2 > 1 + for _k in range(5): + N = rq_pos(1, 10**4) + j = RNG.randrange(m + 1) + mu = rq_pos(2**j * a, 2**(j + 1) * a, 10**7) + if 2**j * a < mu <= a * N: + g.check(N > 2**j and N**2 / 4**j > 1, "shell j: N > 2^j, so 1 < N^2 4^-j") + mu2 = rq_pos(2**m * a, 2, 10**7) + if 2**m * a < mu2 <= a * N: + g.check((4 * a * N)**2 > 1, "tail: 1 < (4 a N)^2 = 16 a^2 N^2") +# countermodel: U uniform on (0, 1), N = ceil(log2(1/U)), e_m = 2^-m/m: {U <= 2^-m} lies in {U <= e_m N} +for mm in range(1, 40): + em = F(1, 2**mm * mm) + for k in range(1, 30): + U = F(k, 2**(mm + 5)) * F(32, 30) # U in (0, 2^-m] + if U > F(1, 2**mm): + continue + N = 0 + while F(1, 2**N) > U: + N += 1 # N = ceil(log2(1/U)) + g.check(N >= mm and U <= em * N, "countermodel: U <= 2^-m implies U <= e_m N") + g.check(F(1, 2**mm) == mm * em, "P(U <= e_m N) >= 2^-m = m e_m, unbounded relative to e_m") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G2 Lemma ES: Gaussian moments, the exponential-square series and the tail bound +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G2 Lemma ES constants") +eps_den = 6 if MUT == "ES_SIX" else 12 +for n in range(1, 120): + dfact = 1 + for k in range(1, 2 * n, 2): + dfact *= k + g.check(dfact <= (2 * n)**n, "(2n - 1)!! <= (2n)^n") + g.check(math.factorial(n) * 3**n >= n**n, "n! >= (n/3)^n (from e < 3)") + # term_n = eps0^n C*^(2n) (2n)^n / n! with eps0 = 1/(12 C*^2): = (2n)^n / (12^n n!) <= (6/12)^n = 2^-n + term = F((2 * n)**n, eps_den**n * math.factorial(n)) + g.check(term <= F(1, 2**n), "series term <= 2^-n, so E exp(eps0 J^2) <= sum 2^-n = 2") +g.check(sum(F(1, 2**n) for n in range(0, 200)) < 2, "sum_{n>=0} 2^-n = 2") +for _ in range(500): + e0 = rq_pos(F(1, 100), 3) + x2 = 10 / e0 # the maximizer of x^10 exp(-e0 x^2/2) satisfies e0 x^2 = 10 + g.check(e0 * x2 == 10, "d/dx [x^10 exp(-e0 x^2/2)] = 0 at e0 x^2 = 10") + # value there: x^10 exp(-5) = (10/e0)^5 exp(-5) = (10/(e0 e))^5 + g.check(x2**5 == (10 / e0)**5, "the maximum is (10/(e0 e))^5") + A2, J2 = rq_pos(0, 9), rq_pos(0, 9) + if J2 > A2: + g.check(e0 * J2 / 2 <= e0 * J2 - e0 * A2 / 2, "on J > A: exp(e0 J^2/2) <= exp(e0 J^2) exp(-e0 A^2/2)") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G3 Lemma FT: the near-branch integral and the scaling to the failure measure +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G3 Lemma FT near branch") +rpow = 4 if MUT == "FT_R4" else 5 +for _ in range(3000): + r, Jr, Dc, Cc = rq_pos(F(1, 1000), F(1, 2), 1000), rq_pos(1, 9), rq_pos(F(1, 10), 5), rq_pos(F(1, 10), 5) + Lt, kap = 4 * Dc * r * Jr**2, Cc * r * Jr**2 + integral = Lt**3 / 3 + kap * Lt**2 / 2 # int_0^Lt l (l + kap) dl + g.check(integral == r**3 * Jr**6 * (64 * Dc**3 / 3 + 8 * Cc * Dc**2), "int_0^(4 Dcap r J^2) l (l + C r J^2) dl = O(r^3 J^6)") + weight = r**2 * Jr**4 * integral + g.check(weight == r**rpow * Jr**10 * (64 * Dc**3 / 3 + 8 * Cc * Dc**2), "r^2 J^4 * (...) = C r^5 J^10") + g.check(r**-3 * r**5 / r**2 == 1, "r^-3 (r^5 / Z_r with Z_r >= c r^2) is O(1)") +for Lam in [F(k, 2) for k in range(2, 80)]: + C0 = F(7, 3) + if Lam >= C0: + A2 = Lam / C0 + g.check(A2 * C0 == Lam, "near and |lambda| > Lambda force J^2 > Lambda/C0 = A^2") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G4 section 7, fixed layer: w = r^(-1/12), e = r^(2/3); the eleven exponents of (15) +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G4 fixed-layer exponents") +bw = F(1, 16) if MUT == "W_SIXTEENTH" else F(1, 12) # w = r^-bw +e = 1 - 4 * bw +fixed = [8 * bw, 1 + 4 * bw, e, 1 + e / 2, 1 - 2 * bw, 1 + (1 - 2 * bw) / 2, e, F(1), 2 * e, 2 - 4 * bw, 2 - 2 * bw] +g.check(fixed == [F(2, 3), F(4, 3), F(2, 3), F(4, 3), F(5, 6), F(17, 12), F(2, 3), F(1), F(4, 3), F(5, 3), F(11, 6)], "the eleven listed exponents") +g.check(min(fixed) == F(2, 3) and 3 + min(fixed) == F(11, 3), "(4): the fixed-layer mismatch is O(r^(11/3))") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G5 (18): Lambda = D log(1/r), H = 1 + Lambda, w = (r H^4)^(-1/12), e = r^(2/3) H^(-4/3); the table +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G5 (18) table") +# a monomial r^x H^y is represented by (x, y); w = r^(-1/12) H^(-1/3), e = r^(2/3) H^(-4/3) +w_ = (F(-1, 12), F(-1, 3)) +e_ = (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3)) + + +def mono(*parts): + x = sum(p[0] * k for p, k in parts) + y = sum(p[1] * k for p, k in parts) + return (x, y) + + +r_, H_ = (F(1), F(0)), (F(0), F(1)) +rows = { + "w^-8": mono((w_, -8)), + "r H^3 w^-4": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 3), (w_, -4)), + "H^4 e": mono((H_, 4), (e_, 1)), + "r H^5 sqrt(e)": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 5), (e_, F(1, 2))), + "H^3 r w^2": mono((H_, 3), (r_, 1), (w_, 2)), + "r H^4 sqrt(r w^2)": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 4), (r_, F(1, 2)), (w_, 1)), + "e": e_, + "r H^4": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 4)), + "H^3 e^2": mono((H_, 3), (e_, 2)), + "H^5 r^2 w^4": mono((H_, 5), (r_, 2), (w_, 4)), + "H^7 r^2 w^2": mono((H_, 7), (r_, 2), (w_, 2)), +} +table = { + "w^-8": (F(2, 3), F(3) if MUT == "TABLE_H3" else F(8, 3)), + "r H^3 w^-4": (F(4, 3), F(13, 3)), + "H^4 e": (F(2, 3), F(8, 3)), + "r H^5 sqrt(e)": (F(4, 3), F(13, 3)), + "H^3 r w^2": (F(5, 6), F(7, 3)), + "r H^4 sqrt(r w^2)": (F(17, 12), F(11, 3)), + "e": (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3)), + "r H^4": (F(1), F(4)), + "H^3 e^2": (F(4, 3), F(1, 3)), + "H^5 r^2 w^4": (F(5, 3), F(11, 3)), + "H^7 r^2 w^2": (F(11, 6), F(19, 3)), +} +for name, mon in rows.items(): + g.check(mon == table[name], "(18) row %s" % name) + x, y = mon + g.check(x > F(2, 3) or (x == F(2, 3) and y <= F(8, 3)), "row %s is O(r^(2/3) H^(8/3))" % name) +# the conditions (17) as r -> 0 with H ~ log(1/r): positive r-powers beat polylog factors +conds = {"r H": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 1)), "r w": mono((r_, 1), (w_, 1)), "e": e_, "H^2 e": mono((H_, 2), (e_, 1)), + "r w^2": mono((r_, 1), (w_, 2))} +for name, (x, y) in conds.items(): + g.check(x > 0, "(17): %s -> 0" % name) +g.check(w_[0] < 0, "(17): w = r^(-1/12) H^(-1/3) -> infinity, so w >= 5 eventually") +g.check(e_[0] > 0, "2 K0 e <= 1/4 eventually") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G6 normalization of the conditional laws, and the tail choice Lambda = D log(1/r) +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G6 normalization and tails") +for _ in range(3000): + M0 = rq_pos(F(1, 10), 5) + Mstar = M0 * rq_pos(F(1, 10), 1, 1000) + m0 = M0 + m = m0 + rq(-Mstar / 4, Mstar / 4, 1000) + n0 = rq(-m0, m0, 1000) # nu_0(phi), |phi| <= 1 + tv = rq_pos(0, Mstar / 4, 1000) # ||nu - nu_0|| >= |m - m0| and >= |nu(phi) - nu_0(phi)| + if abs(m - m0) > tv: + continue + n = n0 + rq(-tv, tv, 1000) + if m < Mstar / 2: + continue + lhs = abs(n / m - n0 / m0) + g.check(lhs <= tv / m + abs(m - m0) / m <= 2 * tv / m <= 4 * tv / Mstar, "||nu/m - nu0/m0|| <= 4 ||nu - nu0||/M_*") +for cexp in [F(k, 10) for k in range(1, 30)]: + Dst = max(F(1), 1 / cexp) + g.check(cexp * Dst >= 1, "exp(-c D_* log(1/r)) = r^(c D_*) <= r") +g.close() + +# --------------------------------------------------------------------- +total = sum(t for _, _, t in RESULTS) +passed = sum(p for _, p, _ in RESULTS) +for name, p, t in RESULTS: + print("%-46s %6d/%-6d %s" % (name, p, t, "PASS" if p == t else "FAIL")) +print("mutant: %s" % (MUT if MUT else "none")) +print("total checks: %d; failures: %d" % (total, total - passed)) +for f_ in FAILS: + print(" FAIL " + f_) +sys.exit(0 if passed == total else 1) +``` + +```text +G0 Lemma JB chart and poles 16037/16037 PASS +G1 Lemma DB dyadic summation 42972/42972 PASS +G2 Lemma ES constants 1582/1582 PASS +G3 Lemma FT near branch 9075/9075 PASS +G4 fixed-layer exponents 2/2 PASS +G5 (18) table 29/29 PASS +G6 normalization and tails 1536/1536 PASS +mutant: none +total checks: 71233; failures: 0 +``` + +🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) + + +--- +_Generated by [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)_ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_COMMENT.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_COMMENT.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3762d2ebb --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CHECKER_COMMENT.md @@ -0,0 +1,210 @@ +## C124 nonauthor review: independently designed executable controls + +Dylan Roy — delegated AI review. Actual reviewer/control author: OpenAI/Codex c99_custody_audit; root publishes the frozen bytes. Full analytic review: [5974327730](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974327730). These controls were frozen before execution and the C124 author checker/output remained unopened. Prior source exposure and organizational independence 0 are disclosed in that review. The finite controls do not prove the analytic source theorems. + +Extraction: each file is the exact text within its five-backtick fence, including its final LF. independent_controls.py: 8,759B SHA256 1d77a571133c7803704ee5e0c0dfd5f13bb0d33249748b09291205646d2c2cdc; DESIGN.md: 3,213B SHA256 457b7a19db5ae1a9ee7dc24e08f4b277d4493d36787c9bb7d84747a3e49c0bdb; baseline stdout: 255B SHA256 988e0f97d1a4cda0cd92c01800991d5cbd89b84e6eaa6349e477ee75b7faf25e. + +Python3.11.16, both `-B -S` and `-O -B -S`: baseline601checks/0failures. Each positional mutation GAMMA_POWER, UNWEIGHTED_BAND, DIAGONAL_RESIDUAL, UNCENTERED_RESIDUAL, UNSAFE_EPSILON, FACTOR_TAIL, NORMALIZER_POWER, H_SCHEDULE exited1 in both modes; UNKNOWN exited2. Twenty invocations and forty transcripts are bound by the immutable review evidence seal. + +### independent_controls.py +`````python +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""C124 nonauthor finite falsification controls; no author checker imported.""" +from fractions import Fraction as F +from math import factorial +import json +import sys + +MODES = ('GAMMA_POWER', 'UNWEIGHTED_BAND', 'DIAGONAL_RESIDUAL', + 'UNCENTERED_RESIDUAL', 'UNSAFE_EPSILON', 'FACTOR_TAIL', + 'NORMALIZER_POWER', 'H_SCHEDULE') +if len(sys.argv) > 2 or (len(sys.argv) == 2 and sys.argv[1] not in MODES): + print('UNKNOWN_CONTROL_MODE') + sys.exit(2) +mode = sys.argv[1] if len(sys.argv) == 2 else 'BASELINE' +counts = {} +failures = [] + + +def check(group, truth, label): + counts[group] = counts.get(group, 0) + 1 + if not truth: + failures.append(group + ': ' + label) + + +# The chart Jacobian and pole cancellations are checked on signed gamma, +# including arbitrarily small rational values; no numeric tolerance is used. +for gamma in (F(-7), F(-1, 1000), F(-1), F(1, 1000), F(2, 3), F(5)): + for b in (F(-2), F(0), F(1, 7)): + for c3 in (F(-1, 5), F(0), F(3)): + d = gamma**2 - 12*b + j = 8*gamma**3 - 144*b*gamma + 576*c3 + c, rr = d/gamma**2, j/gamma**3 + psi = abs(c) + F(7, 3) + lam = gamma**2 * psi / 24 + wl = (24*lam-d)*(24*lam+d)/16 + power = 4 if mode == 'GAMMA_POWER' else 6 + check('chart', wl*gamma**2/24 == gamma**power*(psi**2-c**2)/384, + 'w d-lambda = gamma^6 polynomial d-psi') + check('chart', gamma**6*abs(c)**3 == abs(d)**3, 'absolute c pole') + check('chart', gamma**6*rr**2 == j**2, 'signed R pole') + +# Correlated atomic measures, not products of marginal laws. The finite model +# uses exact band constants extracted from the actual weighted atomic bands. +for depth in (2, 3, 8, 20, 50): + a = F(1, 2**depth) + m = 0 + while 2**m*a < F(1, 4): + m += 1 + check('dyadic', F(1, 4) <= 2**m*a < F(1, 2), 'terminal band') + shells = [F(2)*a*F(1, 2**j) for j in range(m)] + floors = [F(1, 4**j) for j in range(m)] + check('dyadic', sum(shells) <= 4*a, 'width sum') + check('dyadic', sum(floors) <= F(4, 3), 'finite-r floor sum') + # A boundary-focused, strongly correlated finite population. + atoms = [(a/2, F(1), F(1, 7)), + (a, F(1), F(1, 13)), + (2*a, F(2), F(1, 17)), + (3*a, F(4), F(1, 19)), + (F(1, 3), F(2**depth), F(1, 23)), + (-F(3), F(4*2**depth), F(1, 29)), + (F(10), F(1), F(1, 31))] + band = lambda delta, p: sum(mass*n**p for u,n,mass in atoms if abs(u)<=delta) + floor = F(1, 100) + h3 = F(8) + deltas = [2**j*a for j in range(m+1)] + moment2 = sum(mass*n*n for u,n,mass in atoms) + cc = max([band(delta,p)/(delta+floor) for delta in deltas for p in (0,2)] + + [moment2/h3]) + actual = sum(mass for u,n,mass in atoms if abs(u)<=a*n) + bound = cc*(5*a + F(7,3)*floor + 16*h3*a*a) + check('dyadic', actual <= bound, 'correlated decomposition bound') + part = band(a,0) + for j in range(m): + selected = [(u,n,mass) for u,n,mass in atoms + if 2**j*a < abs(u) <= 2**(j+1)*a and abs(u)<=a*n] + check('dyadic', all(n>2**j for u,n,mass in selected), 'shell norm implication') + part += sum(mass for u,n,mass in selected) + outer = [(u,n,mass) for u,n,mass in atoms if abs(u)>2**m*a and abs(u)<=a*n] + check('dyadic', all(n>1/(4*a) for u,n,mass in outer), 'outer norm implication') + # Inner band can include points not in the moving band, so it is a cover. + part += sum(mass for u,n,mass in outer) + check('dyadic', actual <= part, 'all moving-band atoms covered') + +# The unweighted small-ball condition cannot be multiplied by an independent +# moment. U uniform and N=ceil(log2(1/U)) gives a factor m on the stated event. +for m in (2,4,8,16,32): + em = F(1,2**m*m) + lower_mass = F(1,2**m) + inferred = em if mode == 'UNWEIGHTED_BAND' else m*em + check('correlation', lower_mass <= inferred, 'unweighted O(e) shortcut fails') + +# Orthogonal projection onto the complement of (3/5,4/5). Its negative +# off-diagonal entries increase variance along (1,-1); they are not zero. +a0,a1 = F(3,5),F(4,5) +cov = ((1-a0*a0,-a0*a1),(-a0*a1,1-a1*a1)) +check('projection', cov[0][0]+cov[1][1] == 1, 'rank-one trace') +check('projection', cov[0][0]*cov[1][1]-cov[0][1]**2 == 0, 'PSD rank-one') +actual_var = cov[0][0] + cov[1][1] - 2*cov[0][1] +used_var = cov[0][0]+cov[1][1] if mode == 'DIAGONAL_RESIDUAL' else actual_var +check('projection', used_var == F(49,25), 'correlation retained in linear-form variance') +for value in (F(-4),F(0),F(7)): + mean, coeff, obs, obsmean = F(100),F(3,7),F(19),F(11) + field = mean+coeff*(obs-obsmean)+value + residual = field-coeff*(obs-obsmean) + if mode != 'UNCENTERED_RESIDUAL': + residual -= mean + check('projection', residual == value, 'centered endpoint residual') + +# Explicit Gaussian even moments and the exponential-series coefficient +# bound implied by Minkowski; no independence of Fourier residuals is used. +moment = 1 +for n in range(1,81): + moment *= 2*n-1 + check('exponential', moment <= (2*n)**n, 'Gaussian moment upper bound') + divisor = 2 if mode == 'UNSAFE_EPSILON' else 12 + coefficient = F((2*n)**n, divisor**n*factorial(n)) + check('exponential', coefficient <= F(1,2**n), 'exponential series majorant') +check('exponential', sum(F(1,2**n) for n in range(81)) < 2, 'geometric series partial sum') + +# Exact independent endpoint-scalar integration. r^2 J^4 times the cubic +# endpoint integral is r^5 J^10, and r^-3/Z_r has Z_r proportional to r^2. +for radius in (F(1,2),F(1,7),F(1,100)): + for jr in (F(1),F(2),F(17,3)): + for depth_const in (F(1),F(4),F(7,2)): + for cross_const in (F(1),F(5,2)): + upper = depth_const*radius*jr**2 + integral = upper**3/3 + cross_const*radius*jr**2*upper**2/2 + numerator = radius**2*jr**4*integral + expected = radius**5*jr**10*(depth_const**3/3+cross_const*depth_const**2/2) + check('scalar_tail', numerator == expected, 'r^5 J^10 numerator') + zpower = 4 if mode == 'NORMALIZER_POWER' else 2 + scaled = numerator/radius**zpower/radius**3 + check('scalar_tail', scaled == jr**10*(depth_const**3/3+cross_const*depth_const**2/2), + 'one full r^2 normalizer and r^-3 scaling') +weights = ((F(1),F(99,100)),(F(10),F(1,100))) +weighted_tail = sum(prob*j**10 for j,prob in weights if j>5) +tailprob = sum(prob for j,prob in weights if j>5) +moment10 = sum(prob*j**10 for j,prob in weights) +used_tail = moment10*tailprob if mode == 'FACTOR_TAIL' else weighted_tail +check('scalar_tail', weighted_tail <= used_tail, 'same residual tail indicator retained') + +# Independently encode each term as powers (r,H,w), then substitute w. +rows = { + 'radius':(0,0,-8),'radius_error':(1,3,-4), + 'elder':(1,4,4),'elder_error':(F(3,2),5,2), + 'endpoint':(1,3,2),'endpoint_error':(F(3,2),4,1), + 'band':(1,0,4),'leak':(1,4,0),'outer_band':(2,3,8), + 'hessian1':(2,5,4),'hessian2':(2,7,2)} +expected = [(F(2,3),F(8,3)),(F(4,3),F(13,3)), + (F(2,3),F(8,3)),(F(4,3),F(13,3)),(F(5,6),F(7,3)), + (F(17,12),F(11,3)),(F(2,3),F(-4,3)),(F(1),F(4)), + (F(4,3),F(1,3)),(F(5,3),F(11,3)),(F(11,6),F(19,3))] +wh = F(-1,4) if mode == 'H_SCHEDULE' else F(-1,3) +for (label,(pr,ph,pw)),want in zip(rows.items(),expected): + got = (F(pr)-F(pw,12),F(ph)+pw*wh) + check('ledger', got == want, label+' substituted powers') + check('ledger', got[0]>F(2,3) or (got[0]==F(2,3) and got[1]<=F(8,3)), + label+' target domination') + check('ledger', F(pr)-F(pw,12)>=F(2,3),label+' fixed-layer endpoint') +for label,(pr,ph,pw) in {'rH':(1,1,0),'embedding':(1,0,1), + 'e':(1,0,4),'H2e':(1,2,4),'rw2':(1,0,2)}.items(): + check('ledger', F(pr)-F(pw,12)>0,label+' cutoff decays') +check('ledger', F(3)+F(2,3)==F(11,3),'physical fixed-layer power') + +# Variation norm on atomic signed measures is sum of absolute masses. +for nu0 in ((F(1),F(2)),(F(1,5),F(4,5)),(F(2),F(0))): + for changes in ((F(1,10),F(-1,20)),(F(0),F(0)),(F(-1,10),F(1,10))): + nu=tuple(a+b for a,b in zip(nu0,changes)) + if min(nu)<0:continue + m,m0=sum(nu),sum(nu0) + err=sum(abs(a-b) for a,b in zip(nu,nu0)) + normalized=sum(abs(a/m-b/m0) for a,b in zip(nu,nu0)) + check('normalization', normalized<=err/m+abs(m-m0)/m,'probability normalization') + if m>=m0/2: + check('normalization', normalized<=4*err/m0,'positive mass floor') + +print(json.dumps({'mode':mode,'checks':sum(counts.values()),'groups':counts, + 'failures':failures,'scope':'finite controls only; no analytic proof'},sort_keys=True)) +sys.exit(1 if failures else 0) +````` + +### DESIGN.md +`````markdown +# C124 independent review design and exposure record + +Reviewer: OpenAI/Codex /root/c99_custody_audit, delegated child of root01a0bbb5 under existing C124 claim33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4. No C124 proof, control or design contribution. Prior exposure includes C99/C103 source/author-side project work, C101 author-control custody, C102/C104 analytic reviews, C107 authorship and subsequent engineering/analytic review/custody roles. The immediately preceding source-only frontier audit identified the published beta<2/3 boundary and need for quantitative tails, but did not inspect or contribute to this new JB/DB/ES derivation. No fresh-context, blind-source, provider-independent or human-review claim. Organizational independence0. Dylan's owner-reported ongoing review is acknowledged under5973603003; this review itself is AI work, not his human verdict. + +Target PROOF.md20668B SHA90148657397dcce31e8039afa9015c022f74b2ed0d41e75f2f2339074a8a520f; source manifest SHAa0371bd1985358820250e0d75936d6ec5112f165824df7a9f6e29e25e3f46f6d. I read the entire proof and exact C82/C101/A4/P interfaces before this design. I have not opened C124 controls.py, CONTROLS.md, author outputs, or author development notes. Existing sources' own equations are inputs, not independently rediscovered theorems. + +Analytic obligations: reconstruct JB from weighted-before-conditioning Q10 and fixed-width LB, verify gamma-six cancellation and actual finite-r error; reconstruct DB as a partition including m=0 and the outer band, with fixed moment order2; identify centered endpoint residual as joint Gaussian projection after U_r,A_M and verify summable Fourier/Lp and exponential-series constants without coefficient independence; retain the residual indicator in Q30's scalar integral and one full normalization; verify failure-marked model tail separately; map every ledger/cutoff to the imported geometry and distinguish fixed11/3 from global2/3 log8/3 and conditional normalization. + +Independent finite controls will use Fraction, not author code: signed/small-gamma chart cancellation; finite atomic correlated band decompositions and geometric sums; explicit correlated Gaussian projection and noncentered-regression falsifiers; exact Gaussian even moments/exponential-series coefficient majorant; endpoint-scalar integral powers and a two-atom residual-weight correlation countermodel; independently composed rational r/H exponent ledger and cutoff powers; signed finite-measure normalization. Negative modes will delete a gamma power, discard weighted correlation, assume diagonal residual covariance, omit centering, enlarge epsilon beyond the stated safe coefficient, omit the residual tail indicator, drop one normalizer power, or change the H schedule. Unknown modes must be rejected. These controls can refute algebra/finite implications but do not prove LB, Gaussian series convergence, topology or infinite-dimensional analytic estimates. + +Freeze this design and independent_controls.py before execution or any author-checker exposure. Run only these new bounded controls in normal and optimized Python modes. Do not rerun parent/master suites. Preserve any actual failures rather than edit the candidate. +````` + +### normal-baseline.stdout +`````text +{"checks": 601, "failures": [], "groups": {"chart": 162, "correlation": 5, "dyadic": 103, "exponential": 161, "ledger": 39, "normalization": 16, "projection": 6, "scalar_tail": 109}, "mode": "BASELINE", "scope": "finite controls only; no analytic proof"} +````` diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CONTROLS.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CONTROLS.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7b5c77b4d --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/CONTROLS.md @@ -0,0 +1,172 @@ +# C124 exact arithmetic controls — author-side design + +Actual author: OpenAI/Codex delegated executor `/root/next_math_triage`, under +parent C124 claim `33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4` (WE733). This executor +supplied author-side proof analysis and is not an independent reviewer. +Organizational independence credit: 0. Human review: NONE. + +The controls are finite exact arithmetic checks, not a proof of Gaussian +regression, the saddle-band integral, the actual global elder event, or the +continuum/asymptotic theorem. They import no independent reference field law. +Only `controls.py` and this document are authored by this executor. + +## Frozen test intentions before implementation + +1. Substitute `w = r^(-1/12) H^(-1/3)` into the complete new error ledger with + exact `Fraction` exponents. Check every resulting pair and dominance by + `(2/3, 8/3)` when `H = 1 + D log(1/r)`. The dominance test permits any fixed + logarithmic power if its radius exponent is strictly greater than `2/3`; + at equality its logarithmic exponent must be at most `8/3`. Check the + remaining small-radius admissibility exponents separately. A schedule + omitting the power of H must fail. +2. For `a = 2 K0 e <= 1/4` and `B = r H^4`, sum the actual mu-shell majorants + `2 a 2^(-j) + B 4^(-j)` through the last endpoint at most `1/2`. Verify + their exact geometric sums, the endpoint in `(1/4,1/2]`, and the residual + large-N cost `16 a^2 mu_r(N^2)`. The low band contributes `a+B`, so the + resulting constants are `5a + (7/3)B + 16H^3a^2`, before source constants. + Using p=1 or deleting the actual-law floor B must fail. +3. Keep a counterexample to promoting an unweighted band plus all moments: + `U ~ Uniform(0,1)`, `N = ceil(log2(1/U))`, and `e_m = 2^(-m)/m`. + On `0=1, every fixed moment is finite by the + ratio test, and `E[N^2; U<=2^(-m)] = 2^(-m)(m^2+4m+6)`. The finite + checks verify these geometric/moment identities; they do not prove an + assertion for every real p by enumeration. +4. Use perfectly correlated Gaussian coefficients `eta_i=G`, not independent + ones. The variance is `(sum a_i)^2`, and the even moments follow the exact + double-factorial identity. Check that the sum-of-standard-deviations + majorant works while the independent-coefficient variance fails. Verify + finite coefficients of a conservative exponential-square majorant; + convergence of its infinite series remains analytic reasoning. +5. Reconstruct, for rational positive parameters, the rare scalar integral + `r^2 J^4 integral_0^(D r J^2) l(l+C r J^2) dl` + `= r^5 J^10 (D^3/3+C D^2/2)`. Preserve both scalar factors. Check the + single full normalizer `r^2`, subsequent `r^-3` scaling, and the retained + scaled far/derivative contribution `O(r)`. Missing a soft factor or + normalizing twice must fail. +6. Check the threshold-degree conversion `J > sqrt(Lambda/C)` followed by + an exponential-square tail: its exponential order is Lambda, not + Lambda squared. These algebra checks do not establish a tail estimate. + +All rejection checks will use explicit conditions rather than Python +`assert`, so optimized Python cannot remove them. No network, random +sampling, third-party module, project test, or source mutation is involved. + +## Executed results + +Final script: **12062 bytes**, SHA-256 +`3cc864185ba8e9cee780544ea1559c5591bda45110745f73f0cd9b4277745bcb`. + +Executed with Python **3.11.16** at +`/Users/dylanroy/Documents/Codex/2026-09-19/connect-research-repository/work/venv/bin/python3.11`. +There were **24 final invocations**: baseline, ten named adverse candidates, +and one unknown label, each in normal and optimized mode. All had the +expected exit; all stderr streams were empty. Each corresponding pair of +stdout streams was byte-identical. + +Baseline: **1,740 checks, zero failures**, in six groups: + +| Group | Checks | +|---|---:| +| G1 — schedule and admissibility | 49 | +| G2 — joint-band dyadic sums | 683 | +| G3 — unweighted-band counterexample | 325 | +| G4 — correlated Gaussian and exponential-square arithmetic | 544 | +| G5 — rare scalar integral and normalization | 112 | +| G6 — exponential-tail threshold | 27 | + +Counts enumerate arithmetic predicates and are not theorem counts or +independent proofs. A negative candidate runs the same predicates and +must exit 1. The unknown label exits 2 before checks. Output lists at most +the first sixteen failed labels but counts every failure. + +| Candidate | Exit (both modes) | Failed predicates | Stdout bytes | Stdout SHA-256 (both modes) | +|---|---:|---:|---:|---| +| `BASELINE` | 0 | 0 | 591 | `14b587bd72fd8b16ce56791178c2fab4f57535534e5c0f4e1697daf9692cdcdd` | +| `WINDOW_H_OMITTED` | 1 | 17 | 1807 | `84cf603bbb2361ec185c3c86c177e5e1602021280b86c30c240cf7c579cf23f7` | +| `BAND_P_ONE` | 1 | 360 | 1801 | `8999f77b2e0fe300d4344505a444b0185aee2d08e4a5fac77eb8eb188d8b6830` | +| `DROP_BAND_FLOOR` | 1 | 32 | 1983 | `fff2a4497204b922b2e9d58e1a6536a67b8df9fefc4b3215fb97ffadc703abcb` | +| `UNWEIGHTED_PROMOTION` | 1 | 56 | 2092 | `7a121924fa4901d152b705a722feae2b93ae64bbaeda858a8b7ff7ee0dc4900f` | +| `INDEPENDENT_COEFFICIENTS` | 1 | 68 | 2075 | `55634f5b00ba1fcfc6d1c09639a9c1cd31e31f8ffda95be760c36b97e5ca39ad` | +| `EXP_SCALE_TOO_LARGE` | 1 | 192 | 2085 | `8c9b05ac6d858e9151fae55d0ff292972e5fc0800b1ef45f41573919f41db590` | +| `DROP_SOFT_FACTOR` | 1 | 105 | 2092 | `9ab1a8fda6ab2888d9299b48e212bee5032cc523cc2f5700163fca5ebb1f498e` | +| `DOUBLE_NORMALIZER` | 1 | 72 | 2098 | `b059ff988449f4d9f9bcd4615831ebad4628e9b166f75d4d0fb200e7f6bcaaad` | +| `DROP_SCALED_FAR` | 1 | 1 | 684 | `7f5c21d1e8719ec2564333fd6b4186cdcf02cacd742832b30e0f88401535bdd1` | +| `GAUSSIAN_LAMBDA_SQUARED` | 1 | 15 | 1820 | `8355c4cbde5561bdf2ddcebf4d1270dd79db61433a83c5947b734218fe543b91` | +| `UNKNOWN` | 2 | n/a | 83 | `5189cbc57e52c13b5608e65a6311f44598eaacec80d76a6544051e4c44d897ce` | + +Empty stderr SHA-256 is +`e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855`. + +The final baseline stdout, including its terminating newline, is: + +```json +{"candidate":"BASELINE","checks":1740,"failure_count":0,"failures_first_16":[],"groups":{"G1_schedule_and_admissibility":{"checks":49,"failures":0},"G2_joint_band_dyadic_sums":{"checks":683,"failures":0},"G3_unweighted_band_counterexample":{"checks":325,"failures":0},"G4_correlated_gaussian_and_exp_square":{"checks":544,"failures":0},"G5_rare_scalar_and_full_normalization":{"checks":112,"failures":0},"G6_exponential_tail_threshold":{"checks":27,"failures":0}},"object":"C124-EXACT-CONTROLS-v1","passed":true,"scope":"finite rational controls; not analytic proof or source verification"} +``` + +## Replaying the finite controls + +From this directory: + +```sh +python3 -B controls.py +python3 -B -O controls.py +python3 -B controls.py --list-mutants +python3 -B controls.py --mutant DROP_SOFT_FACTOR +python3 -B -O controls.py --mutant DROP_SOFT_FACTOR +python3 -B controls.py --mutant UNKNOWN +``` + +The last three commands intentionally return 1, 1 and 2. All ten labels in +the table can be substituted for `DROP_SOFT_FACTOR`. No command downloads +sources, verifies a source digest, or replays the project master suite. +The complete analytic imports and proof must be assessed independently. + +## Development and conceptual limits + +The written test intentions above preceded implementation. The first +baseline used an unfinished constant-window placeholder +`schedule = (F(0), F(0))`: it exited 1 with **18 expected ledger failures**, +while the other five groups passed. That test-first source was +11856 bytes, SHA-256 +`b37a96e544ec4f70ad6f0747c797bc457adb8ae71bb938dd755bc4c37cff9f52`; its 1792-byte stdout was +`bae8c10f566276eee0d9e348919511af574c7f27759ca68aa02dc5661f04c0fc`. Replacing the placeholder by the intended two +powers made the baseline pass. The initial red run was repeated once to +capture its identity. A later final-source tightening made the floor +fixture continuous instead of atomic; the complete final 24-invocation +matrix above was then rerun. No analytic conclusion rests on that +development history. + +The `DROP_BAND_FLOOR` fixture is an **abstract continuous measure**, with +N=1 and total mass B distributed uniformly over `00 it satisfies `mass(|mu|<=s)<=s+B`, and has no atom at mu=0. +It shows what the stated band inequality alone permits. It is not claimed +to arise from the pinned Gaussian field. In particular it does not +contradict actual neutral-level nullity. Removing B in the analytic proof +would require additional source information. + +The U,N counterexample is also abstract. Its unweighted band is exactly +`P(U<=delta)=delta` for `0<=delta<=1`; all fixed moments of N exist. +Nevertheless the ratio `P(U<=e_m N)/e_m` is at least m and unbounded. +The adverse label uses a proposed constant 8, rejected for m>8. The +divergence for arbitrary constants follows from the written argument, +not from testing only m<=64. Its joint band has an unbounded quadratic +coefficient `m^2+4m+6`, which identifies precisely the extra hypothesis +used by the C124 proof. + +The Gaussian fixtures take identical coefficients, eta_i=G. They show +that coefficient-wise variance bounds do not give independence or a +sum-of-variances bound. Minkowski uses a sum of standard deviations and +remains valid. The exponential-square coefficient check chooses the +conservative rational `epsilon=1/(12 C^2)` under the analytic premise +`||J||_p<=C sqrt(p)`, using `m!>=(m/3)^m` and the geometric sum. +Only finitely many coefficients are checked; the premise, factorial +inequality for all m, infinite series, conditional Fourier convergence +and tail transfer belong to the analytic proof. + +No finite-r saddle matching, ordinary-global-elder equivalence, retained +cap theorem, compact-family uniformity, or full normalizer lower bound +is proved by this script. It neither extends the contribution beyond +physical k=1 nor establishes once-counted replacement bars, a transported +real-valued mark, k-to-zero behavior, higher dimensions, or unrestricted +lifetime asymptotics. diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/PROOF.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/PROOF.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d99cec53e --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/PROOF.md @@ -0,0 +1,468 @@ +# A correlated saddle-level estimate and the planar endpoint rate + +Object: C124-PLANAR-K1-CORRELATED-BAND-ENDPOINT-LOG-RATE-20261003-v1. +Author: OpenAI/Codex root01a0bbb5, delegated by Dylan Roy. +Author-side analytic/control contributor: OpenAI/Codex next_math_triage. +Source-custody executor: OpenAI/Codex next_ui_triage. +Exact model variant/build UNKNOWN; organizational independence 0. +This is AI-authored mathematics. A subsequent AI review is not human review. +Scientific effect of the author-side packet: NONE; source-bound review follows. +Claim33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4, Work Events733, pickup5974059664. + +This additive argument improves the quantitative rate in C101/A4 at physical +gap k=1. It does not replace their field model, event identification, determinant +weight, full normalizer, or geometric hypotheses. The two new ingredients are +a saddle-level band estimate with the correlated field norm still inside the +weight, and an exponential-square bound for the precise endpoint residual. + +## 1. Exact population, sources, and conclusion + +Fix L>0 and a nonempty compact birth set B0. Work uniformly in b in B0 and +orthonormal planar frames. The centered variance-one Gaussian field on the +flat torus X=R^2/(L Z^2) has covariance + + K_L(z) = sum_(n in Z^2) exp(-|z+Ln|^2/2) + / sum_(n in Z^2) exp(-|Ln|^2/2). + +The continuous Gaussian regression Q_r has exact pins +M_r=(-r/2,0), S_r=(r/2,0), f(M_r)=b, f(S_r)=b-r^3, and zero gradients. +Thus physical k=1, not a variable cubic mark. Define + + W_r=|det H_M det H_S| 1{H_M<0, index H_S=1}, + Z_r=E_Qr W_r=r^2 z_r, Q_r^W=(W_r/Z_r)Q_r. + +The index counts negative eigenvalues. Singular endpoints have weight zero. +H_r is the event that the finite ordinary-superlevel H0 bar born at M_r dies +at S_r, with the global older-point maximin convention of C96. The essential +class is not such a finite bar. Define H_r false off the Morse/distinct-value +locus, F_r=H_r^c and p_r=Q_r^W(H_r). P8/C96 give the actual persistence +interpretation almost surely for each fixed parameter and r; no common +probability-one set over uncountably many laws is asserted here. + +Write + + A=f_zz(0), lambda=-A/r, + t=(gamma,B1,C3)=(f_xxz(0),f_xzz(0),f_zzz(0)), theta=(lambda,t), + Pjet=1+|gamma|+|B1|+|C3|, + N=1+max_(|alpha|<=4) sup_X |D^alpha f|, + a_M=24lambda-gamma^2+12B1, a_S=24lambda+gamma^2-12B1, + T={a_M>0,a_S>0}, w_lambda=(a_M a_S/16)1_T, + D=gamma^2-12B1, J=8gamma^3-144B1 gamma+576C3. + +On T and gamma!=0 put psi=24lambda/gamma^2, c=D/gamma^2, R=J/gamma^3. +The raw-to-sheared chart is u=X+gamma zeta/12, Z=gamma zeta and the cubic is + + P_QS(u,Z)=2u^3-3u/2-1/2-(psi+2cu)Z^2/48+RZ^3/3456. + +Let mu be the highest P_QS(Y)+1 among its extra nondegenerate saddles, or +-infinity if none exists. Set E={T,gamma!=0,mu<0}, Rsec={T,gamma!=0,mu>0}. +All such definitions include C82/C98's absent, degree-drop and tangency cases. +The gamma=0 chart and neutral mu=0 locus are null under the nonsingular raw +jet laws. A neighborhood of the neutral locus is not treated as null. + +Let rho_0(a,t) be the JOINT contact-conditioned density of (A,t), with +U_0=(f,f_x,f_xx,f_xxx,f_z,f_xz)(0)=(b,0,0,12,0,0), and let +z_0=36 E[A^2 1{A<0}|U_0]. Define finite failure measures on raw theta-space by + + nu_r^F(B)=r^(-3) Q_r^W(theta in B,F_r), + dnu_0^F=z_0^(-1) rho_0(0,t) w_lambda 1_Rsec dtheta. (1) + +The variation norm is sup_(|phi|<=1)|integral phi d(nu-nu')|, without 1/2. +The source CUB/C101 identifies its mass as + + M_F=nu_0^F(R^4)=alpha_1+alpha_2, 00, depending on the fixed +L and compact birth set, uniformly in births and frames, such that for +0=1, a sharper local statement is + + Q_r^W(D_Lambda intersect (H_r symmetric_difference E)) + <= C_Lambda r^(11/3), + D_Lambda={|lambda|<=Lambda}. (4) + +The constants and cutoff are analytically finite, not optimized numerical +error bars. No uniformity in L, a growing birth set, or physical k is asserted. +The result is not a once-counted replacement-bar measure, transported +real-height/location total variation, lifetime density theorem, or closure +of shrinking witness collision, small gaps, intermediate regions, higher +dimensions, or the complete persistence-asymptotic dependency graph. + +### Source identities and the exact conclusions consumed + +All source texts and full hashes are in SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json. These are +frozen inputs, not mutable names used as evidence: + +- C82 LB, native5959920397 (proof prefix SHA256 + f390ad99b07ec4eda9160191d776cfc3a53ca628976165987d9a61ab79816827): + the explicit polynomial saddle-level integral, including exceptional branches. +- C101, native5967063473, SHA256 + 300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4: + Q5–Q19, Q24–Q35, together with its exact P/E1/E2/REC, C91–C98, + ELDER and CUB interfaces. Its Q23 and polynomial tails are strengthened + below; its original rejected endpoint estimate is replaced by A4. +- A4, native5972396791, SHA256 + acd172c5f8626aa3b7be5ac691786eefa6d6f243a32909502dfdbd79c8066a7c: + Lemma LE, Corollary LE, Lemma B-prime and section3's error ledger. + Full source-bound review5972610615 is a separate record. +- P4.2 is the CENTERED endpoint-matrix residual, with E1 congruence correction, + E2 section9 replacement and REC. Its P7.5–7.7 and P8 remain hypotheses of + the imported actual failure-tail and global event interfaces. + +In particular, this packet does not independently reprove C95's geometric +theorem or C96's persistence identification. It proves the new analytic +estimates from the identified, scoped input theorems. The present result has +exactly their retained hypotheses; a defect in an input would propagate. + +## 2. Retained cutoff-uniform estimates + +Let Lambda>=1, H=1+Lambda. C101 constructs constants from the fixed covariance +and compact family, independently of Lambda, such that when r<=r_0 and rH<=1, +the actual conditional joint density satisfies + + rho_r(-r lambda,t)<=C exp(-c|t|^2) on D_Lambda. (5) + +Put D_r=W_r/r^4 and, for field-dependent Phi, + + mu_r(Phi)=r^(-5) E_Qr[W_r Phi 1_DLambda]. + +The dA=r d lambda change of variables gives + + mu_r(N^p 1_B)=integral_B rho_r(-r lambda,t) + E[D_r N^p|lambda,t] d lambda dt, + Q_r^W(Phi 1_DLambda)=r^3 mu_r(Phi)/z_r. (6) + +C101 Q7–Q12 prove, for every FIXED p,q>=0, + + E[D_r N^p|lambda,t] + <=C_p w_lambda Pjet^p+C_p rH^3 Pjet^(p+4), + mu_r(N^p Pjet^q)<=C_(p,q) H^3, + mu_r(T^c)<=CrH^4, + integral_DLambda |g_r/z_r-g_0/z_0|<=CrH^4, + |z_r-z_0|<=Cr, z_*/2<=z_r<=2z^*, 0=0, uniformly under the conditions of section2 +and for 0|c|. + +Extend the nonnegative lambda integral from D_Lambda to the whole typed +half-line. C82 LB gives the actual highest-saddle band bound + + integral_(psi>|c|) (psi^2-c^2)1{|mu|<=delta}d psi + <=delta[(1024/3)|c|^3+64R^2]. + +There is no substitution of a psi-dependent width. Multiplying by gamma^6 +cancels the chart poles exactly: + + gamma^6 |c|^3=|D|^3, gamma^6 R^2=J^2. + +Thus the principal term is at most a fixed multiple of + + delta integral exp(-c|t|^2)Pjet^p (|D|^3+J^2) dt. + +This is finite independently of Lambda, since D,J are polynomials in t. +Tonelli applies to these nonnegative integrands. Gamma=0 has measure zero +under the joint Gaussian density. The absent-saddle value -infinity never +belongs to this band. C82 already includes degree drops and tangencies. +Combining the two terms proves (8). No independent-reference Gaussian has +been substituted for rho_r. QED. + +## 4. Fixed-order dyadic summation removes the epsilon loss + +For the raw window W_w={|X|,|zeta|<=w}, let E0 be the sup norm of the +difference of the raw pinned field and its cubic. C91/C101 Q16 give + + E0<=K0 N e, e=rw^4, K0=167/192. (9) + +**Lemma DB.** For w>=1 in the embedded-window range, rH<=1, and sufficiently +small e, the actual weighted decision error satisfies + + mu_r(E union Rsec, E0>=|mu|/2) + <=C[e+rH^4+H^3e^2]. (10) + +**Proof.** Put a=2K0e, b_r=rH^4 and assume 02^j. Apply JB with the SINGLE fixed p=2 and fixed band width +delta=2^(j+1)a, which is <=1/2. Its contribution is at most + + 2^(-2j) mu_r(N^2;|mu|<=2^(j+1)a) + <=C[2a 2^(-j)+b_r 4^(-j)]. + +The finite sums are bounded by 4a+(4/3)b_r. The remaining region +|mu|>2^m a>=1/4 forces N>1/(4a). Its mass is at most + + 16a^2 mu_r(N^2)<=C H^3 a^2 + +by (7). This also covers large negative values of mu. Combining all regions +proves (10). The moment order and constants do not grow with r or m. QED. + +An unweighted band bound plus arbitrary fixed moments of N would not prove +this: on U uniform in (0,1), let N=ceil(log_2(1/U)). All moments are finite +and P(U<=delta)=delta, but for e_m=2^(-m)/m, +P(U<=e_m N)>=2^(-m)=m e_m. JB's correlated weighted assertion is essential. +Similarly the finite-r floor rH^4 survives the entire dyadic summation. + +## 5. Exponential-square control of the precise endpoint residual + +This section strengthens the tail decay in C101 Q32; it does not change its +rare endpoint-scalar integration. Distinguish the raw cubic variable J in +section1 from the random field norm J_r below. + +Let A_M=f_zz(M_r), the entire transverse Hessian block in dimension2. +The centered residual from P4.2 is + + g_r=f-E_Qr f-B_r(A_M-E_Qr A_M), J_r=1+||g_r||_C4. (11) + +It is jointly independent of A_M; its internal Fourier coefficients are +not asserted independent. The regression coefficient and mean have uniformly +bounded C4 norm as stated in P4.2. C101 Q30 uses exactly this residual. + +**Lemma ES.** There are epsilon_0>0 and CA]<=C exp(-epsilon_0 A^2/2), A>=1. (12) + +**Proof.** Express the original centered field in a standardized real Fourier +Gaussian basis as sum_n xi_n phi_n. Gaussian spectral decay gives + + S=sum_n ||phi_n||_C4 < infinity, + +uniformly in rotated coordinate norms: derivatives of order at most4 in a +unit direction are bounded by a fixed multiple of (1+|2pi n/L|)^4. The real +sine/cosine multiplicities are included in S. After joint conditioning on +U_r and A_M, set eta_n=xi_n-E[xi_n|U_r,A_M]. Each eta_n is centered Gaussian +of variance at most1. This is the orthogonal Gaussian projection defining +(11). Covariance between distinct eta_n is retained. + +For every integer n>=1, Minkowski applied to finite Fourier partial sums, +followed by their L^(2n)(C4) limit, gives + + ||J_r||_(2n)<=1+S sqrt(2n)<=C_* sqrt(2n), C_*=1+S. + +Indeed a centered Gaussian of variance <=1 has even moment at most +(2n-1)!!<=(2n)^n. The same summable Fourier majorant makes the residual +partial sums C4-convergent in each of these spaces, so this limit is the +actual Gaussian regression residual. None of these estimates uses independence +between its Fourier coefficients or moments with uncontrolled order constants. + +Using n!>=(n/e)^n and monotone convergence for the exponential series, choose +epsilon_0=1/(12 C_*^2). Since the numerical exponential base e<3, we have + + E exp(epsilon_0 J_r^2) + <=1+sum_(n>=1) epsilon_0^n C_*^(2n)(2n)^n/n! + <=sum_(n>=0) (1/2)^n=2. + +Finally x^10 exp(-epsilon_0 x^2/2)<=(10/(epsilon_0 e))^5 for x>=0. +On J_r>A split the exponential into two halves to obtain + + J_r^10 1{J_r>A} + <=(10/(epsilon_0 e))^5 exp(epsilon_0 J_r^2) + exp(-epsilon_0 A^2/2). + +Taking expectation proves (12). QED. + +**Lemma FT.** For Lambda>=1 and all sufficiently small r, + + nu_r^F(D_Lambda^c)<=C exp(-c Lambda)+Cr, + nu_0^F(D_Lambda^c)<=C exp(-c Lambda). (13) + +**Proof for the actual measure.** C101 Q30–Q31 are the retained analytic +interfaces. Let l_end=-f_zz(M_r)>0 on the typed support. The cap-failure +decomposition from P7.5 has a near branch +01/(4Dcap r), and the fourth- +derivative exception. On near, |lambda|<=C_0 J_r^2, and + + W_r<=C r^2 J_r^4 l_end(l_end+C rJ_r^2). + +Independence of the endpoint residual from this scalar and its bounded scalar +density give, keeping the SAME residual tail indicator within the integral, + + E_Qr[W_r;near,J_r>A] + <=C r^2 E[J_r^4 1{J_r>A} + integral_0^(4Dcap rJ_r^2) l(l+C rJ_r^2)dl] + <=C r^5 E[J_r^10;J_r>A]. (14) + +F_r is bounded by cap failure, not declared independent of these variables. +If Lambda>=C_0, set A=(Lambda/C_0)^(1/2). On near and D_Lambda^c this +residual event holds. Lemma ES followed by the single full floor Z_r>=c r^2 +and the r^(-3) scaling in (1) yields C exp(-c Lambda). If 1<=LambdaLambda/C}dt + <=C' exp(-c' Lambda). + +For large Lambda the indicated event implies |t|^2>=c_1 Lambda; absorb the +polynomial with half the Gaussian exponential. For bounded Lambda enlarge +C'. The full z_0 floor is retained. This exhausts only the failure-marked +measure; the unmarked soft measure has mass of order Lambda^3. QED. + +## 6. The unchanged geometry and the new error ledger + +Use C101's radius, elder value-margin, typing and Hessian estimates, and A4's +local endpoint certificate for the rejected chord. A4 LE retains both the +strict saddle clearance and the endpoint above the birth level. Its condition +eta_LE=2(115/48)rw^2 and B-prime give endpoint loss +C[H^3 rw^2+rH^4 sqrt(rw^2)]. These are actual weighted sufficient events. + +C95/C96 identify the elder good event with actual H_r. C98's coverage puts +every typed nonneutral jet in E or Rsec. Finite-r T^c is not null and is +included with its entire CrH^4 loss. With the new decision Lemma DB replacing +C101 Q23/A4's unweighted-band split, the full scaled layer error is + + R_*(r,H,w) = w^(-8)+rH^3w^(-4) + +H^4e+rH^5 sqrt(e) + +H^3rw^2+rH^4 sqrt(rw^2) + +e+rH^4+H^3e^2 + +H^5r^2w^4+H^7r^2w^2, e=rw^4. (15) + +Specifically, these terms come respectively from C101 Q17 (radius), Q19 +(elder value margin), A4 B-prime (rejected endpoint), JB/DB plus Q12 +(decision level and typing), and Q25 (rescaled Hessian errors). + +The event union and the normalized raw-jet density comparison in C101 +Q28–Q29 now give + + r^(-3) Q_r^W(D_Lambda,H_r symmetric_difference E)<=C R_*, + ||nu_r^F|D_Lambda-nu_0^F|D_Lambda||_var<=C R_*. (16) + +For the second inequality take any measurable |phi(theta)|<=1, replace the +actual failure indicator by 1_Rsec and pay the first bound, plus off-type +CrH^4. Then use (7) on that same fixed jet event. This also explains why +(16) applies to raw-jet/Boolean measures and does not assert anything about +moving real-valued marks. + +The uniform constants hold when + + r<=r_0, Lambda>=1, rH<=1, w>=5, 2rw<=L/4, + e<=1, 2K0e<=1/4, C_V H^2e<=1, + C_eta rw^2<=1, eta_LE<=1. (17) + +C_V and C_eta are the fixed constants of C101. The obsolete C_H H^3e +condition is not needed after A4, but would also hold for our choices below. +No growing-Lambda substitution into an unspecified fixed-cutoff constant +has been used. + +## 7. Fixed-layer and full-measure rates + +For fixed Lambda, take w=r^(-1/12). Then e=r^(2/3). Every term of (15) +is O_Lambda(r^(2/3)): their r-exponents in displayed order are + + 2/3, 4/3, 2/3, 4/3, 5/6, 17/12, + 2/3, 1, 4/3, 5/3, 11/6. + +All cutoffs (17) hold for sufficiently small r. Multiply the first bound +of (16) by r^3 to obtain (4). In particular both sector mismatches have +the exact endpoint exponent 11/3, with no epsilon loss on a fixed layer. + +For full exhaustion choose D_*>0 large enough that both exponential tails +in (13), at Lambda=D_* log(1/r), are O(r). Increase D_* to at least1. +Set + + Lambda=D_* log(1/r), H=1+Lambda, + w=(rH^4)^(-1/12)=r^(-1/12)H^(-1/3), + e=r^(2/3)H^(-4/3). (18) + +For r small enough w>=5 and every condition (17) holds. In particular +rH->0, rw->0, e->0, H^2e->0 and rw^2->0. Powers of log do not defeat any +of these positive powers of r. Each term in (15) is as follows: + +| term | after (18) | +|---|---| +| w^(-8) | r^(2/3)H^(8/3) | +| rH^3w^(-4) | r^(4/3)H^(13/3) | +| H^4e | r^(2/3)H^(8/3) | +| rH^5 sqrt(e) | r^(4/3)H^(13/3) | +| H^3rw^2 | r^(5/6)H^(7/3) | +| rH^4 sqrt(rw^2) | r^(17/12)H^(11/3) | +| e | r^(2/3)H^(-4/3) | +| rH^4 | rH^4 | +| H^3e^2 | r^(4/3)H^(1/3) | +| H^5r^2w^4 | r^(5/3)H^(11/3) | +| H^7r^2w^2 | r^(11/6)H^(19/3) | + +All rows are O(r^(2/3)H^(8/3)); rows with a strictly larger r power have +ratio tending to zero, even when their H power is larger. For r<=exp(-1), +H<=(1+D_*)log(1/r). Splitting each finite measure into D_Lambda and its +complement, using (13),(16), proves the first assertion of (3). + +Taking total masses gives |r^(-3)(1-p_r)-M_F| bounded by that variation +norm. Multiplication by r^3 gives the second assertion. Since M_F>=M_*>0, +the actual total mass is >=M_*/2 for small r. The elementary inequality + + ||nu/m-nu0/m0||_var + <= ||nu-nu0||_var/m + |m-m0|/m + <= 4 ||nu-nu0||_var/M_* + +gives the stated rate for the conditional raw-jet laws. QED. + +This argument supplies an endpoint power with an explicit logarithmic loss; +it does not prove an O(r^(2/3)) global rate or an optimality statement. +The logarithm comes from exhausting the failure measure while balancing +the radius tail w^(-8) against the elder value-margin term H^4rw^4. + +## 8. Evidence boundaries and completion effect + +The proof's new analytic obligations are JB, DB, ES and FT. Equations (15)–(18) +then compose them with the stated geometric and regression sources. The +separate controls.py checks exact exponent algebra, fixed-order summation, +normalization powers and countermodels. Passing those checks is not a proof +of Gaussian conditioning, global path topology or an unproved source lemma. + +The change removes A4's arbitrarily small exponent loss for fixed-layer +sector errors, and replaces its family of beta<2/3 full-measure bounds by +the explicit endpoint logarithmic rate (3). It preserves the failure measure, +its alpha_1+alpha_2 coefficient, the full pair-Palm normalizer and the actual +finite-H0 selection event. It closes no other dependency merely by proximity. + +In particular no mathematical-completion certificate with zero open nodes +is warranted by this packet. The distinction between a selected pair's +failure law and a once-counted small-persistence-bar intensity remains. diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5cd4095e1 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW.md @@ -0,0 +1,169 @@ +# C124 nonauthor review: correlated band and planar endpoint logarithmic rate + +**Verdict: PASS_SCOPED. No required amendment was found in the frozen C124 argument.** This is a substantive analytic review of its new JB, DB, ES and FT estimates and their composition with the identified source interfaces. It is not a new acceptance of every imported theorem, a provider-independent vote, human review, a register promotion, or a mathematical-completion certificate. + +The reviewed target is *A correlated saddle-level estimate and the planar endpoint rate*, object `C124-PLANAR-K1-CORRELATED-BAND-ENDPOINT-LOG-RATE-20261003-v1`: `PROOF.md`, **20,668 UTF-8 bytes**, SHA256 **`90148657397dcce31e8039afa9015c022f74b2ed0d41e75f2f2339074a8a520f`**. Its exact full native body is [main229 comment5974162498](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974162498). I compared the supplied saved native response with the complete local proof; this review makes no claim of a separate new network read. The source manifest is `SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json`, **26,552 bytes**, SHA256 **`a0371bd1985358820250e0d75936d6ec5112f165824df7a9f6e29e25e3f46f6d`**. All 21 listed snapshots, totaling 353,932 bytes, match that manifest. + +## 1. Actual reviewer, exposure and review order + +Reviewer/executor: **OpenAI/Codex `/root/c99_custody_audit`**, delegated child of parent session `01a0bbb5-2fcb-77f0-b78b-4d220ddd7ab2`, under C124 claim `33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4`, Work Events733. Exact model variant/build UNKNOWN. Organizational independence **0**. This agent did not author the new C124 proof, checker, or design. Root and next_math_triage are author-side; next_ui_triage prepared source custody. Their work is not counted as this nonauthor assessment. + +I have substantial prior project exposure: C99/C103 source/author-side work, C101 author-control custody, C102/C104 analytic reviews, C107 authorship, and later analytic/engineering review and custody roles. Before seeing C124 I performed a source-only frontier audit of the published beta<2/3 boundary and the need for quantitative tails. I did not inspect or contribute to root/next_math_triage's new JB/DB/ES derivation before its proof freeze. This is neither a fresh-context review nor a blind-source review. Its independence is the absence of C124 authorship and the separate reconstruction/control design, with those limitations disclosed. + +I read the complete frozen proof and the exact source interfaces used below, then froze `DESIGN.md` and `independent_controls.py` at **2026-10-03T22:34:20.521783Z**, before executing the controls. I have **not opened C124 `controls.py`, `CONTROLS.md`, author outputs, or author development notes**, including at this report's freeze. A root coordination message repeated the proof's displayed epsilon constant and said it matched the author design; no implementation or additional control content was read. Source texts' own equations and retained antecedent material were available inputs, not independently rediscovered theorems. + +This review is AI work, **human review NONE for this artifact**. Dylan's owner-reported ongoing review, recorded in5973603003, is acknowledged; I neither reinterpret that as his mathematical verdict on C124 nor impose a new personal-reading or external-human gate. + +## 2. What is established, and what remains imported + +The population is the fixed planar periodized Gaussian field at fixed L, compact birth set, all orthonormal frames and **physical cubic gap k=1**. The original continuously conditioned law, full determinant weight, full `Z_r=r^2 z_r`, and actual finite ordinary-superlevel H0 selection event remain in use. An essential class is not a finite bar; failure is the complement of this specified event. The null-set statement is for each fixed parameter/r, not a single probability-one set over an uncountable family. + +Under the retained source hypotheses, the new conclusion is + + ||nu_r^F - nu_0^F||_var <= C r^(2/3) log(1/r)^(8/3), + 1-p_r = r^3(alpha_1+alpha_2) + + O(r^(11/3) log(1/r)^(8/3)). + +The same rate holds after normalizing the finite failure measures to conditional raw-jet probability laws. For every fixed Lambda, the actual sector mismatch inside `D_Lambda` is `O_Lambda(r^(11/3))`. These distinctions are necessary: the proof does not establish global `O(r^(2/3))` without the logarithm, a physical-k-uniform theorem, transport in total variation of moving real-valued height/location marks, a lifetime density rate, once-counted replacement-bar intensity, collision exhaustion, or global theorem closure. + +The new analytic obligations are JB (a weighted correlated band), DB (fixed-order dyadic summation), ES (uniform exponential-square control of the exact endpoint residual), and FT (exponential failure tails using the original rare scalar integral). The remaining work is cutoff-uniform composition and normalization. The following are imported with their scope intact: + +| Input | Exact source and relevant interface | +|---|---| +| C82 | [5959920397](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959920397), proof prefix 11,253B, SHA `f390ad99b07ec4eda9160191d776cfc3a53ca628976165987d9a61ab79816827`; the deterministic highest-saddle level-band integral LB, including absent/degree-drop/tangency cases | +| C101 | [5967063473](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5967063473), 36,333B, SHA `300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4`; Q6–Q12, Q17/Q19/Q25, event comparison, Q30/Q31/Q33/Q35 | +| A4 | [5972396791](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5972396791), 16,544B, SHA `acd172c5f8626aa3b7be5ac691786eefa6d6f243a32909502dfdbd79c8066a7c`; LE, Corollary LE, B-prime and the explicit growing-layer ledger | +| P | [immutable parent](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md), 40,261B, SHA `9350ad6eaba6626b93c3dedeef9e2ff816e5cdf1c8318e85fb27499141c84bc7`; exact Fourier law, centered P4.2 regression, full normalization, P7.5–7.7 cap-tail decomposition, P8 genericity/global event | +| E1/E2/REC | Exact manifest-bound parent corrections/reconciliation at044d42d5; E1's congruence correction and E2's replacement of P section9 remain necessary. No literal obsolete parent formula is silently restored. | +| C91–C98, ELDER, CUB | Exact manifest-bound deterministic approximation/geometry, actual persistence identification, coverage and contact coefficient interfaces already consumed by C101. Their conclusions are used as hypotheses, not reaccepted by this packet. | + +I inspected the primary analytic interfaces rather than using the prior review comments as mathematical proofs. C82_REVIEW and A4_REVIEW are retained provenance/disposition records. In particular, C95's global geometric assertion and C96's persistence identification are not independently reproved here; a defect in an imported assertion would propagate. `rho_0(0,t)` is the joint contact-density slice, not its separately normalized conditional density. `z_0` is the full contact normalizer. C101 Q35/CUB supplies the positive compact-family mass floor and **alpha_1+alpha_2**, with no extra factor2. + +## 3. JB: conditional correlation and the chart singularity + +I checked C124 lines127–199 against C101 Q6–Q12 and C82 LB. The change `dA=r d lambda`, `W_r=r^4 D_r` gives exactly + + mu_r(Phi) = r^-5 E_Q[W_r Phi 1_DLambda], + Q_r^W(Phi 1_DLambda) = r^3 mu_r(Phi)/z_r. + +C101 Q10 is strong enough for the new purpose: it bounds `E[D_r N^p | theta]` after multiplying the pointwise filtered-determinant error by `N^p`. It does not assert independence of the field norm and jet event. The Gaussian envelope holds uniformly on the growing layer when `rH<=1`; its determinant-error contribution integrates over length2Lambda to `C_p rH^4`. + +For fixed `t=(gamma,B1,C3)` with gamma nonzero, the principal multiplier `exp(-c|t|^2)Pjet^p` is independent of lambda. Direct calculation from `a_M=gamma^2(psi-c)`, `a_S=gamma^2(psi+c)` gives + + w_lambda d lambda = gamma^6(psi^2-c^2)d psi/384. + +The proof extends only this nonnegative upper-bound integral, not the actual Gaussian envelope outside its stated layer. LB applies with a fixed delta and the actual highest saddle. Its polynomial prefactor cancels the chart poles: + + gamma^6 |c|^3 = |gamma^2-12B1|^3, + gamma^6 R^2 = (8gamma^3-144B1 gamma+576C3)^2. + +The remaining integral is Gaussian times a fixed polynomial and `Pjet^p`; it is finite uniformly in Lambda. No independent-reference Gaussian replaces the actual law. No psi-dependent random width is inserted into LB. The argument remains valid as nonzero gamma approaches zero, through the polynomial cancellation; the gamma=0 set itself is null. An absent saddle has mu=-infinity and is never in a finite level band. C82's exceptional branches are included in its imported deterministic estimate. This proves the stated `C_p(delta+rH^4)` with the finite-r floor retained. + +## 4. DB: a fixed second moment is sufficient + +For C124 lines201–241, I reconstructed the partition instead of choosing a moment order depending on r. With `a=2K0 e`, the decision error implies `|mu|<=aN`. The inner band `|mu|<=a` uses JB at p=0. Choose m with `2^m a` in `[1/4,1/2)`; m=0 is allowed. In each intermediate shell, + + 2^j a < |mu| <= 2^(j+1)a, + +the same decision error forces `N>2^j`. Applying JB at the single fixed p=2 bounds that shell by + + C(2a 2^-j + rH^4 4^-j). + +The sums are bounded by `4a+(4/3)rH^4`, independently of the number of shells. The outer region has `|mu|>=1/4` up to an immaterial endpoint convention and forces `N>1/(4a)`; Q12 gives `C H^3 a^2`. The partition also covers negative finite mu. The absent-saddle event contributes nothing to this decision error. Thus the new bound `C(e+rH^4+H^3e^2)` follows without hidden growth of moment constants. + +The correlation issue is substantive. The proof's countermodel `U` uniform, `N=ceil(log_2(1/U))`, has every fixed moment and an unweighted linear small-ball bound, but at `e_m=2^-m/m` its moving-band mass is at least `m e_m`. That refutes the proposed shortcut from marginal small-ball control and moments alone. JB supplies the stronger weighted assertion needed for this summation. + +## 5. ES: exact centering, contraction and infinite-series control + +C124 lines243–301 use the endpoint variable `A_M=f_zz(M_r)`, not the midpoint A and not its scaled lambda. P4.2 says + + g_r = f-E_Q f-B_r(A_M-E_Q A_M). + +This is the jointly Gaussian residual after conditioning on the full pins and A_M. It is centered and independent of A_M. Its internal correlations are retained. P section2 gives the summability of square-root spectral amplitudes with every fixed derivative power for this exact periodized covariance. + +For each original standardized real Fourier coefficient, subtracting its orthogonal projection on the finite observation vector yields a centered residual coefficient of variance at most1. Its covariance with other residual coefficients generally is nonzero. This variance contraction is enough: the C4 norm of each term is bounded by its absolute coefficient times the deterministic basis C4 norm, so Minkowski uses a sum of individual L^(2n) norms and requires no coefficient independence. + +The sum `S=sum ||phi_n||_C4` is finite for fixed L, uniformly over frames, because directional derivatives up to order4 are bounded by a fixed polynomial in the Fourier frequency. The same summable bound makes residual partial sums converge in L^(2n)(C4); the limit is the actual orthogonal-regression residual, rather than a separately coupled reference field. The proof obtains the explicit order dependence + + ||1+||g_r||_C4||_(2n) <= (1+S)sqrt(2n). + +Consequently the exponential series can be summed with a numerical choice independent of r, b and frame. With `C_*=1+S`, `epsilon_0=1/(12 C_*^2)`, `n! >= (n/e)^n`, and numerical e<3, each positive term is at most `2^-n`; monotone convergence gives expectation at most2. This is stronger than merely knowing all fixed moments. The subsequent inequality using `sup x^10 exp(-epsilon_0 x^2/2)=(10/(epsilon_0 e))^5` correctly bounds the tenth-moment tail by `C exp(-epsilon_0 A^2/2)`. + +The repeated symbol `g_r` in the earlier density paragraph and the field-residual paragraph has locally explicit definitions; the proof does not use the density as a random residual. I found no resulting mathematical ambiguity requiring revision. + +## 6. FT: the rare scalar integration survives normalization + +I checked lines303–346 against C101 Q30/Q31/Q33 and P7.5–7.7. On the typed support the endpoint depth is `l_end=-f_zz(M_r)>0`. It is distinct from midpoint lambda. The original cap-failure split retains the near branch, far branch, and fourth-derivative exception. The actual failure event is bounded by cap failure via the imported global event interface; it is not asserted independent of the scalar or residual. + +On the near branch the proof keeps `1{J_r>A}` inside the same scalar integral. Independence of the centered residual and endpoint scalar, with the scalar's bounded density, gives + + C r^2 E[J_r^4 1{J_r>A} + integral_0^(4Dcap rJ_r^2) l(l+C rJ_r^2) dl] + <= C r^5 E[J_r^10; J_r>A]. + +The power r^5 is obtained before normalization. Dividing once by the full `Z_r >= c r^2` and once by r^3 for the definition of nu yields the desired exponential bound. Factoring the tail indicator off the weighted residual expectation would be invalid and is not done. Q31 gives `|lambda|<=C J_r^2` on near, so the cutoff in lambda is a square-root cutoff in J_r. Bounded Lambda is handled separately by enlarging constants; no unavailable `A>=1` assumption is used there. + +P7.6–7.7 contribute actual tilted mass `O(r^4)` and hence scaled `Cr`. They are retained, not absorbed as a zero event or claimed exponentially small. This actual tail bound does not rely on `rH<=1`, which is only needed for local-layer estimates. + +For the model failure measure, Q33 bounds lambda by `C Pjet^2` on Rsec and its integrated determinant factor by `C Pjet^6`. Gaussian decay in t then gives an exponential Lambda tail after absorbing the polynomial. This is the failure-marked measure; the proof correctly avoids claiming an integrable tail for the unmarked soft measure, whose mass grows like Lambda^3. Both tails preserve the full normalizers. + +## 7. Geometry, all ledger terms and both rate conclusions + +I matched the eleven terms in equation15 to C101/A4. The radius terms are `w^-8+rH^3w^-4`; the selected elder value margin is `H^4e+rH^5 sqrt(e)`; A4's rejected endpoint terms are `H^3rw^2+rH^4 sqrt(rw^2)`; the new decision/typing terms are `e+rH^4+H^3e^2`; and the Hessian losses are `H^5r^2w^4+H^7r^2w^2`. + +A4's sufficient rejected event retains both strict clearance along the chord and an endpoint strictly above the birth. Only the old endpoint-margin estimate is replaced, not the need for an older endpoint. Its B-prime proof uses Q14/Q12 with constants independent of Lambda and gives the displayed growing-layer powers. The new DB changes the saddle-level error, leaving these endpoint and Hessian requirements intact. + +C98's typed nonneutral coverage and C95/C96's event interface are the exact imported bridge to actual H_r. The proof pays the entire finite-r off-T leakage `CrH^4`, rather than using contact typing as an almost-sure finite-r statement. For raw-jet variation, replacing the actual failure indicator by `1_Rsec` costs the actual event mismatch and off-type leakage; applying the normalized density comparison to that same fixed jet event gives equation16. This does not establish variation convergence of a moving continuous mark. + +I independently substituted the cutoffs in every term. For fixed Lambda, `w=r^-1/12` gives the r powers + + 2/3, 4/3, 2/3, 4/3, 5/6, 17/12, + 2/3, 1, 4/3, 5/3, 11/6. + +All are at least2/3. Multiplication by r^3 gives exact fixed-layer 11/3. There is no epsilon-loss moment choice left in that local conclusion. + +For exhaustion choose `Lambda=D_* log(1/r)`, with D_* fixed large enough for both exponential tails, and `w=r^-1/12 H^-1/3`. The r/H powers of all eleven terms are, in order, + + (2/3,8/3), (4/3,13/3), (2/3,8/3), (4/3,13/3), + (5/6,7/3), (17/12,11/3), (2/3,-4/3), (1,4), + (4/3,1/3), (5/3,11/3), (11/6,19/3). + +Every term is bounded by `C r^(2/3) H^(8/3)` for sufficiently small r. Terms with larger H powers also have strictly larger positive r powers. The logarithmic schedule simultaneously ensures `rH`, `rw`, `e`, `H^2e`, and `rw^2` tend to zero, while w tends to infinity. Thus one sufficiently small fixed r_* satisfies all embedded-window, strip, Taylor and dyadic cutoffs. No unspecified fixed-Lambda constant is substituted at growing Lambda. The obsolete `C_H H^3e` condition is unnecessary after A4 and would also decay under this schedule. + +The actual tail's retained Cr is smaller than the target rate. The contact mass floor from C101 Q35 gives actual mass at least M_*/2 for small r. The stated finite-measure normalization inequality then gives at most `4||nu-nu0||_var/M_*`. The norm convention is the supremum over absolute-test functions bounded by1, without an extra1/2. Taking total masses gives alpha_1+alpha_2 and the claimed failure-probability error. + +## 8. Independent finite controls and observed executions + +The review's own control design is `DESIGN.md`, **3,213B**, SHA **`457b7a19db5ae1a9ee7dc24e08f4b277d4493d36787c9bb7d84747a3e49c0bdb`**. Its independently written `independent_controls.py` is **8,759B**, SHA **`1d77a571133c7803704ee5e0c0dfd5f13bb0d33249748b09291205646d2c2cdc`**. Both identities were frozen in `CONTROLS_FREEZE.json` before execution, with author-checker/output exposure false. The code imports only Python standard-library arithmetic/serialization modules and no author checker. + +The actual runtime was **Python3.11.16**, executable `/Users/dylanroy/Documents/Codex/2026-09-19/connect-research-repository/work/runtime/python/bin/python3.11`. The commands were the following, with M omitted for the baseline and then each of the eight named mutations plus UNKNOWN: + + python3.11 -B -S work/continuation124/review/independent_controls.py [M] + python3.11 -O -B -S work/continuation124/review/independent_controls.py [M] + +The saved argv use absolute paths. `CONTROL_RUNS.json` binds all20 invocations, exit codes, timings and40 stdout/stderr transcripts. Both baselines passed **601/601** checks and have identical255B stdout, SHA **`988e0f97d1a4cda0cd92c01800991d5cbd89b84e6eaa6349e477ee75b7faf25e`**. Every substantive mutant exited1 with a nonempty reported failure list in both modes; unknown mode exited2 in both modes. No control implementation change or test rerun followed that freeze. + +| Independent group | Checks per mode | What was challenged | +|---|---:|---| +| Chart | 162 | Signed/small rational gamma, determinant Jacobian and both pole cancellations | +| Dyadic | 103 | m=0 through depth50, exact correlated atomic populations, shell coverage, fixed geometric sums and retained floor | +| Correlation | 5 | Exact moving-band countermodel showing the marginal shortcut's factor m loss | +| Projection | 6 | Nonzero residual off-diagonal covariance and subtraction of the conditional mean | +| Exponential | 161 | Gaussian even moments, explicit factorial coefficient bounds through order80 and geometric majorant | +| Scalar tail | 109 | Exact polynomial scalar integrals, r^5 J^10, one full normalizer, and a correlated two-atom tail countermodel | +| Ledger | 39 | Independent monomial substitution for eleven errors and all cutoff powers | +| Normalization | 16 | Exact atomic signed-measure variation and positive mass-floor normalization | + +The substantive negative modes are GAMMA_POWER, UNWEIGHTED_BAND, DIAGONAL_RESIDUAL, UNCENTERED_RESIDUAL, UNSAFE_EPSILON, FACTOR_TAIL, NORMALIZER_POWER and H_SCHEDULE. These controls falsify finite algebraic/probabilistic shortcuts. They do **not** prove the infinite Fourier limit, LB, Gaussian conditioning, topology, imported theorems, or optimality. Those steps were assessed analytically above. + +The final read-only input/transcript audit passed **248 custody checks**, including all21 source identities, 15 source-to-saved-native extraction bindings, six computed Git blob identities, exact stored native proof equality, frozen review design/control identities, and all existing control transcripts. This verifies the supplied cut and saved responses; it does not independently repeat every remote commit:path association. The C96 snapshot is explicitly the7,657B mathematical suffix after a256B native preface. C82 is explicitly the11,253B proof prefix before a392B native footer. Neither is mislabeled a whole native comment. + +One reviewer-side custody diagnostic is preserved: the first `verify_review_inputs.py` invocation exited1 because its generic JSON reader tried to parse the correct plain-text UNKNOWN_CONTROL_MODE output. The initial script and `INPUT_CUSTODY_INITIAL_DIAGNOSTIC.json` retain that failure. The bounded correction branches on UNKNOWN before JSON parsing and checks its exact diagnostic plus exit2; the corrected read-only audit exited0. No candidate or frozen control bytes changed, and no mathematical control was rerun to conceal that reader error. The final audit output is `INPUT_AND_CONTROL_CUSTODY.json`. No project master, hosted job, Lean proof or author checker was run for this review. + +## 9. Findings and final boundary + +**Required findings: none. Optional requested revisions: none.** The correlated weighted assertion, fixed-p dyadic partition, exact centered residual, tail indicator, full normalizer, nonzero far remainder, cutoff powers and event scope are all explicit and sufficient at this source-bound cut. + +The result supplies an exact fixed-layer11/3 error and an endpoint full-measure2/3 power with log^(8/3) loss, under the inherited analytic and geometric hypotheses. It leaves the global no-log endpoint, optimality, uniform variable-k extension, once-counted/bar-density conversion, moving-mark total variation and remaining global persistence obligations open. It creates no organizational-independent or human acceptance count and changes no scientific dependency status by itself. + +This report and its review artifacts are ready for root disposition. This agent has made no C124 external publication, register write, source edit or theorem-completion claim. diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c7f604be7 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md @@ -0,0 +1,92 @@ +## Cross-provider nonauthor review of C124 (a correlated saddle-level estimate and the planar endpoint rate): ACCEPT (PASS_TECHNICAL_SCOPED), no amendment + +**Who.** Dylan Roy — delegated AI review. Actual performer: Anthropic Claude (session `session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU`). +- Claim: [5974309014](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974309014), released by this post. +- Independence: provider-distinct (Anthropic, against OpenAI/Codex authors). It runs through the same GitHub account, so organizational-independence credit is 0. +- **Disclosed stake.** C124 consumes my A4 (Lemma LE, Corollary LE, Lemma B′ and §3's ledger), and it supersedes A4's and A4.1's `ε` loss. +- This is a second review. The first, reserved for `/root/c99_custody_audit`, is 5974327730. +- Owner review is as recorded in 5973603003. Scientific effect: NONE. + +**Target.** [C124, 5974162498](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974162498): 20,668 bytes, SHA-256 `90148657397dcce31e8039afa9015c022f74b2ed0d41e75f2f2339074a8a520f`. I read it back live before posting; created = updated (22:30:33Z). + +**Verdict.** **ACCEPT / PASS_TECHNICAL_SCOPED** for Theorem ER, (1)–(18), and Lemmas JB, DB, ES and FT. The retained inputs are C82 LB, C101 (Q5–Q19, Q24–Q35), A4, P4.2 with E1/E2/REC, P7.5–7.7 and P8, and C95/C96/C98, exactly as C124 states them. I found no mathematical error. I did not read or run the author controls (5974185757). + +### What I checked +- **Lemma JB.** + - The chart is exact: `dλ = (γ²/24)dψ`, `w_λ dλ = (γ⁶/384)(ψ² − c²)dψ`, `γ⁶|c|³ = |D|³` and `γ⁶R² = J²`. So C82 LB's fixed-`(c, R)` bound becomes `(δ/384)[(1024/3)|D|³ + 64J²]` in raw jets, integrable against `e^{−c|t|²}Pjet^p` with no pole. + - The determinant-error part is `rH³·2Λ ≤ 2rH⁴`. + - The weight `N^p` stays inside `E[D_r N^p | λ, t]`, as (7) provides. No independence or unweighted band is used. +- **Lemma DB.** + - With `a = 2K₀e ≤ 1/4`, the integer `m` with `2^m a ∈ [1/4, 1/2)` exists, and every shell width `2^{j+1}a` is at most `1/2`, so JB applies. + - On shell `j`, `|μ| ≤ aN` forces `N > 2^j`. + - The shell sum is `Σ_{j 2^m a ≥ 1/4` forces `(4aN)² > 1`. + - So the bound is `C[e + rH⁴ + H³e²]` with the single moment order `p = 2`. + - The countermodel is right: `U ≤ 2^{−m}` implies `U ≤ e_m N`, so `P ≥ 2^{−m} = m·e_m`. An unweighted band with moments cannot give DB. +- **Lemma ES.** + - `(2n − 1)!! ≤ (2n)^n` and `n! ≥ (n/3)^n`. With `ε₀ = 1/(12C_*²)` each series term is `(2n)^n/(12^n n!) ≤ 2^{−n}` exactly, so `E exp(ε₀J_r²) ≤ 2`. + - `x¹⁰e^{−ε₀x²/2}` is maximal at `ε₀x² = 10`, with value `(10/(ε₀e))⁵`. On `J > A` the half-split gives `e^{−ε₀A²/2}`. + - The residual's Fourier coefficients have conditional variance at most 1, and no independence among them is used. +- **Lemma FT.** + - `∫₀^{4D_cap rJ²} l(l + CrJ²) dl = r³J⁶(64D_cap³/3 + 8CD_cap²)`, so the near weight is `r⁵J¹⁰`. After the full floor `Z_r ≥ cr²` and the `r⁻³` scaling it is `O(1)·E[J¹⁰; J > A]`. + - Near and `|λ| > Λ` force `J > (Λ/C₀)^{1/2}`. + - The model tail uses C101 Q33's `λ ≤ CPjet²` on `Rsec`. +- **Fixed layer (4).** At `w = r^{−1/12}` and `e = r^{2/3}` the eleven exponents of (15) are exactly `2/3, 4/3, 2/3, 4/3, 5/6, 17/12, 2/3, 1, 4/3, 5/3, 11/6`. The minimum `2/3` gives `O_Λ(r^{11/3})`, with no `ε`. +- **Exhaustion (18).** + - With `w = (rH⁴)^{−1/12}` and `e = r^{2/3}H^{−4/3}`, I recomputed every row of the table as a monomial `r^x H^y`. All eleven match. + - Each row has `x > 2/3`, or `x = 2/3` with `y ≤ 8/3`, so the sum is `O(r^{2/3}H^{8/3})`. + - Every condition in (17) has a positive `r`-power or `w → ∞`, so the polylog factors are harmless. + - `Λ = D_* log(1/r)` makes the exponential tails `r^{cD_*} ≤ r`. +- **Normalization.** `‖ν/m − ν₀/m₀‖ ≤ ‖ν − ν₀‖/m + |m − m₀|/m ≤ 4‖ν − ν₀‖/M_*` once `m ≥ M_*/2`. +- **Composition.** In (15) the decision term DB replaces the band split of A4.1 and C101 Q23, and every other term is C101's or A4's. + - `Tᶜ` is charged as `CrH⁴`, not treated as null. + - C98's coverage and C96's identification are deterministic, so they hold for growing `Λ`. + - (16)'s variation bound pays the event bound plus C101's density comparison on the same jet event. + +### Observations (not findings) +- **O1. C98's rates improve.** C98's (B19) bounds `Q_r^W(D_Λ ∩ (H_r Δ E))` by `Cr^{7/2}`, and C124's (4) bounds the same quantity by `C_Λ r^{11/3}`. Substituted into C98's §§3–4 unchanged: + - (B5) becomes `O(r^{11/3})`; + - (B6) has error `O(r^{11/3})`; + - (B7) becomes `Q_r^W(H_r | D_Λ) = m_E/m_Λ + O(r^{2/3})`; + - the joint jet/Boolean bound (B8) becomes `O(‖φ‖ r^{2/3})`. + + This is a composition of two objects, C98 (two providers) and C124. It is not claimed by either, and it is stated here only as an observation. +- **O2. The compact-`K` extension is in reach.** + - JB and DB use only the joint-density envelope and the moment bound (7). C103 supplies these on compact `K` with `k`-uniform constants (its (S4)–(S8)). + - ES concerns the centered endpoint residual, whose Fourier argument is the same at gap `k`. + - FT's P7.5–7.7 are proved on compact `K` (C103 §5). + + So C124's rate should hold uniformly on compact `K`, as A4.1 did for A4. That would give `1 − p_r = r³(α₁ + α₂) + O_K(r^{11/3} log(1/r)^{8/3})`. Corollary PD's error would then become `O(ℓ^{8/9} log(1/ℓ)^{8/3})`. C124 does not claim this; I would write it as a separate author-side note. + +### Comparison with the first review (read after my verdict) +- The reserved first review 5974327730 (OpenAI/Codex `/root/c99_custody_audit`, PASS_SCOPED, no amendment) was posted at 22:51Z, after I had reached this verdict. I read it afterwards. +- It agrees on every step: + - JB's pole cancellation and fixed `δ`; + - DB's partition, the sums `4a + (4/3)rH⁴`, and the countermodel; + - ES's variance contraction, `ε₀ = 1/(12C_*²)`, and the series bound 2; + - FT's near integral `r⁵` with the tail indicator kept inside; + - the eleven ledger terms and both rates; + - the `Tᶜ` charge. +- This review adds O1 (C98's rates) and O2 (the compact-`K` extension). + +### Reviewer controls +These are posted separately for replay. +- **`c124_exact.py`** (standard library): 71,233 exact rational checks in seven groups (G0–G6). + - Six mutants each exit 1, and an unknown label exits 2. + - The output is byte-identical under `-O` and `-B -S` (Python 3.11.15). + +### Exposure and boundary +- I did not draft or contribute to C124. +- I authored A4, which it consumes, and A4.1 and Corollary PD, which it affects. This is a disclosed stake. +- I reviewed C91–C94, C96–C98 and C101–C103 cross-provider. +- This review accepts Theorem ER at its stated scope: physical `k = 1`, fixed `L`, compact births, all frames, and the raw-jet failure measure. It accepts nothing about: + - compact or small `k` (O2 is prospective); + - once-counted replacement bars, or real-mark total variation; + - the lifetime density; + - collisions, or intermediate or global closure. +- It authorizes no merge or status change. + +🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) + + +--- +_Generated by [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)_ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..75bd5e4f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +# C124 independent review design and exposure record + +Reviewer: OpenAI/Codex /root/c99_custody_audit, delegated child of root01a0bbb5 under existing C124 claim33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4. No C124 proof, control or design contribution. Prior exposure includes C99/C103 source/author-side project work, C101 author-control custody, C102/C104 analytic reviews, C107 authorship and subsequent engineering/analytic review/custody roles. The immediately preceding source-only frontier audit identified the published beta<2/3 boundary and need for quantitative tails, but did not inspect or contribute to this new JB/DB/ES derivation. No fresh-context, blind-source, provider-independent or human-review claim. Organizational independence0. Dylan's owner-reported ongoing review is acknowledged under5973603003; this review itself is AI work, not his human verdict. + +Target PROOF.md20668B SHA90148657397dcce31e8039afa9015c022f74b2ed0d41e75f2f2339074a8a520f; source manifest SHAa0371bd1985358820250e0d75936d6ec5112f165824df7a9f6e29e25e3f46f6d. I read the entire proof and exact C82/C101/A4/P interfaces before this design. I have not opened C124 controls.py, CONTROLS.md, author outputs, or author development notes. Existing sources' own equations are inputs, not independently rediscovered theorems. + +Analytic obligations: reconstruct JB from weighted-before-conditioning Q10 and fixed-width LB, verify gamma-six cancellation and actual finite-r error; reconstruct DB as a partition including m=0 and the outer band, with fixed moment order2; identify centered endpoint residual as joint Gaussian projection after U_r,A_M and verify summable Fourier/Lp and exponential-series constants without coefficient independence; retain the residual indicator in Q30's scalar integral and one full normalization; verify failure-marked model tail separately; map every ledger/cutoff to the imported geometry and distinguish fixed11/3 from global2/3 log8/3 and conditional normalization. + +Independent finite controls will use Fraction, not author code: signed/small-gamma chart cancellation; finite atomic correlated band decompositions and geometric sums; explicit correlated Gaussian projection and noncentered-regression falsifiers; exact Gaussian even moments/exponential-series coefficient majorant; endpoint-scalar integral powers and a two-atom residual-weight correlation countermodel; independently composed rational r/H exponent ledger and cutoff powers; signed finite-measure normalization. Negative modes will delete a gamma power, discard weighted correlation, assume diagonal residual covariance, omit centering, enlarge epsilon beyond the stated safe coefficient, omit the residual tail indicator, drop one normalizer power, or change the H schedule. Unknown modes must be rejected. These controls can refute algebra/finite implications but do not prove LB, Gaussian series convergence, topology or infinite-dimensional analytic estimates. + +Freeze this design and independent_controls.py before execution or any author-checker exposure. Run only these new bounded controls in normal and optimized Python modes. Do not rerun parent/master suites. Preserve any actual failures rather than edit the candidate. diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCES_COMMENT.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCES_COMMENT.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..35f0effa6 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCES_COMMENT.md @@ -0,0 +1,583 @@ +# C124 source-identity manifest — exact frozen bytes + +This is the unchanged author snapshot manifest referenced by C124 and its nonauthor review: 26,552 bytes; SHA-256 `a0371bd1985358820250e0d75936d6ec5112f165824df7a9f6e29e25e3f46f6d`. Paths name the original delivery snapshot; incorporation may supply an additive path-resolution map without altering this manifest. Full proof5974162498; review5974327730. The file is the UTF-8 content inside the following five-backtick fence, including its final LF. + +`````json +{ + "schema": 1, + "kind": "C124 source inventory and custody only; no mathematical vote", + "created_utc": "2026-10-03T22:23:26.437721+00:00", + "claim_id": "33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4", + "claim_row": 733, + "native_pickup": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974059664", + "main_head_readback": "4aadc771e8ffc08ee56bac63991a6ceb282a4292", + "math_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "source_count": 21, + "source_bytes": 353932, + "sources": [ + { + "key": "C91", + "path": "sources/C91.md", + "bytes": 12433, + "sha256": "74a9ee276c3647276deb544c6d83e3cf21f708f55f9009fa4db5cc49c9d0e9aa", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5963566666", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C91.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5963566666, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T00:22:20Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T00:22:20Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 12433, + "sha256": "74a9ee276c3647276deb544c6d83e3cf21f708f55f9009fa4db5cc49c9d0e9aa" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5963566666.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C91/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 12433, + "sha256": "74a9ee276c3647276deb544c6d83e3cf21f708f55f9009fa4db5cc49c9d0e9aa" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C92", + "path": "sources/C92.md", + "bytes": 19567, + "sha256": "6fa4c3d6d1e8c3d8590c865802d5df061ad5b17652ddc7fd7bf5c5e8b8de084a", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5963825788", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C92.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5963825788, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T00:52:49Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T00:52:49Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 19567, + "sha256": "6fa4c3d6d1e8c3d8590c865802d5df061ad5b17652ddc7fd7bf5c5e8b8de084a" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5963825788.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C92/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 19567, + "sha256": "6fa4c3d6d1e8c3d8590c865802d5df061ad5b17652ddc7fd7bf5c5e8b8de084a" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C93", + "path": "sources/C93.md", + "bytes": 15545, + "sha256": "f25f86cc66ae335b4832ea53670646815567ec7854fa0386f8c57f6939e0af1c", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964167051", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C93.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5964167051, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T01:36:14Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T01:36:14Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 15545, + "sha256": "f25f86cc66ae335b4832ea53670646815567ec7854fa0386f8c57f6939e0af1c" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5964167051.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C93/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 15545, + "sha256": "f25f86cc66ae335b4832ea53670646815567ec7854fa0386f8c57f6939e0af1c" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C94", + "path": "sources/C94.md", + "bytes": 15407, + "sha256": "0fe4fa2028f8ddbbf5a79df3879bcbd3789f19409fb44ad739caeabedff1af3c", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964517708", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C94.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5964517708, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T02:18:00Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T02:18:00Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 15407, + "sha256": "0fe4fa2028f8ddbbf5a79df3879bcbd3789f19409fb44ad739caeabedff1af3c" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5964517708.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C94/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 15407, + "sha256": "0fe4fa2028f8ddbbf5a79df3879bcbd3789f19409fb44ad739caeabedff1af3c" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C95", + "path": "sources/C95.md", + "bytes": 16185, + "sha256": "c0d9ee72352fafe91f96a8b6187c978f09ee3c187d5f4c7c2462c0187750d2e1", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964938563", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C95.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5964938563, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T03:09:41Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T03:09:41Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 16185, + "sha256": "c0d9ee72352fafe91f96a8b6187c978f09ee3c187d5f4c7c2462c0187750d2e1" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5964938563.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C95/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 16185, + "sha256": "c0d9ee72352fafe91f96a8b6187c978f09ee3c187d5f4c7c2462c0187750d2e1" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C96", + "path": "sources/C96.md", + "bytes": 7657, + "sha256": "7198ff636e330749428ded6938776dad612f6bdb51ad62359b445f016df13a7a", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965141133", + "extraction": "explicitly published mathematical suffix; 256-byte native preface excluded", + "full_native_identity_recorded_but_not_claimed_as_local": { + "bytes": 7913, + "sha256": "0758b5de8f4d9e4658ca3c6cf3e52c23d8e12f77999e9c3668ef0bedb15a05f5" + }, + "suffix_extraction": "Suffix beginning '# Designated maximin level equals the ordinary-superlevel H0 death', final LF retained; full native preface is 256 bytes.", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C96.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965141133, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T03:38:26Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T03:38:26Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 7913, + "sha256": "0758b5de8f4d9e4658ca3c6cf3e52c23d8e12f77999e9c3668ef0bedb15a05f5" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965141133.json", + "extraction_checked": "Exact 7657-byte suffix after the native 256-byte preface", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C96/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 7913, + "sha256": "0758b5de8f4d9e4658ca3c6cf3e52c23d8e12f77999e9c3668ef0bedb15a05f5" + }, + "extraction": "256-byte preface excluded", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C97", + "path": "sources/C97.md", + "bytes": 16098, + "sha256": "acf83958e6ea650d83bf811b2beacc03b553637dc4a3160012567c7f0a300a57", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965421543", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C97.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965421543, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T04:14:09Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T04:14:09Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 16098, + "sha256": "acf83958e6ea650d83bf811b2beacc03b553637dc4a3160012567c7f0a300a57" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965421543.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C97/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 16098, + "sha256": "acf83958e6ea650d83bf811b2beacc03b553637dc4a3160012567c7f0a300a57" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C98", + "path": "sources/C98.md", + "bytes": 15050, + "sha256": "3ca1622197bf22cf71ab64f2938ecc0b022ed09487b691d50ae8d2ad1f46d198", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965738339", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C98.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965738339, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T04:56:45Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T04:56:45Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 15050, + "sha256": "3ca1622197bf22cf71ab64f2938ecc0b022ed09487b691d50ae8d2ad1f46d198" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965738339.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C98/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 15050, + "sha256": "3ca1622197bf22cf71ab64f2938ecc0b022ed09487b691d50ae8d2ad1f46d198" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "P", + "path": "sources/P.md", + "bytes": 40261, + "sha256": "9350ad6eaba6626b93c3dedeef9e2ff816e5cdf1c8318e85fb27499141c84bc7", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "dfed3b8d318a3ab1950957f393307733a4bef3f2", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/P.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "dfed3b8d318a3ab1950957f393307733a4bef3f2", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "E1", + "path": "sources/E1.md", + "bytes": 1782, + "sha256": "bad7ef609c4ad8c41ad6af562c1b6807921e19a9d556ed793ad1a0db6e202028", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/ERRATUM_CONGRUENCE.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "213594d6ca6a86fb938110f4d166d9ce275a02d0", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/ERRATUM_CONGRUENCE.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/E1.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "213594d6ca6a86fb938110f4d166d9ce275a02d0", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "E2", + "path": "sources/E2.md", + "bytes": 9062, + "sha256": "845abf9f9c99d672c2a10a887b5a2e7206a3d2de3d876f35f75ff6e2dc13e62f", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/reviews/d1_section9_borel_repair_20260925/REPAIR.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "fe9b9ce4999908bb3814b500ee2d0ceb0c6f704a", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "reviews/d1_section9_borel_repair_20260925/REPAIR.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/E2.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "fe9b9ce4999908bb3814b500ee2d0ceb0c6f704a", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "REC", + "path": "sources/REC.md", + "bytes": 23312, + "sha256": "451b9d7ffee072a73fc904cab891b6693e3f233808b89df10cce1b57036b65da", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/reviews/d1_chain_reconciliation_20260928/RECONCILIATION.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "75da2597971510f843f8d90c743950cb8c177342", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "reviews/d1_chain_reconciliation_20260928/RECONCILIATION.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/REC.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "75da2597971510f843f8d90c743950cb8c177342", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "CUB", + "path": "sources/CUB.md", + "bytes": 19889, + "sha256": "117e9299a71e6139270266889eb772ed97518e402d9af029bbdb67caf9d4a0f0", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/frontiers/planar_cubic_cluster_20260929/PROOF.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "bb446d08db8a944537a743ad550b88c1c2ad5758", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "frontiers/planar_cubic_cluster_20260929/PROOF.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/CUB.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "bb446d08db8a944537a743ad550b88c1c2ad5758", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "ELDER", + "path": "sources/ELDER.md", + "bytes": 39722, + "sha256": "f68038be79b46124b0f9b31205aa6e3682b34b6f5ef81f4a5697ae81f07cc46b", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/frontiers/local_elder_geometry_20260930/PROOF.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "ef2aa57959ea9f721bbf2316ce94cf616c1c9113", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "frontiers/local_elder_geometry_20260930/PROOF.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/ELDER.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "ef2aa57959ea9f721bbf2316ce94cf616c1c9113", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C96_COMPLETION", + "path": "sources/C96_COMPLETION.md", + "bytes": 3466, + "sha256": "634fdab86ef2d568fecba9da80ccd067e3dc12849d88731648f1b09e46861603", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965212531", + "extraction": "Exact UTF-8 native body", + "role": "Closed-manifold and measurable-event conventions", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/custody/antecedents/C96_COMPLETION.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965212531, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T03:47:53Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T03:47:53Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 3466, + "sha256": "634fdab86ef2d568fecba9da80ccd067e3dc12849d88731648f1b09e46861603" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965212531.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C82_NATIVE", + "path": "sources/C82_NATIVE.md", + "bytes": 11645, + "sha256": "1b7523bf145f03dbaf73ceae2aa256e17505bbb1c2693e339bc399c64e1654c9", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959920397", + "extraction": "Exact UTF-8 body", + "role": "scoped analytic source or its disposition", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/custody/antecedents/C82_NATIVE.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5959920397, + "created_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 11645, + "sha256": "1b7523bf145f03dbaf73ceae2aa256e17505bbb1c2693e339bc399c64e1654c9" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5959920397.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C82", + "path": "sources/C82.md", + "bytes": 11253, + "sha256": "f390ad99b07ec4eda9160191d776cfc3a53ca628976165987d9a61ab79816827", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959920397", + "extraction": "11253-byte proof prefix before native footer", + "role": "scoped analytic source or its disposition", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/custody/antecedents/C82_PROOF.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5959920397, + "created_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 11645, + "sha256": "1b7523bf145f03dbaf73ceae2aa256e17505bbb1c2693e339bc399c64e1654c9" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5959920397.json", + "extraction_checked": "Exact 11253-byte prefix; 392-byte native footer excluded", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C101", + "path": "sources/C101.md", + "bytes": 36333, + "sha256": "300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5967063473", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/PROOF.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5967063473, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T08:11:34Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T08:11:34Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 36333, + "sha256": "300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5967063473.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C101/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 36333, + "sha256": "300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C82_REVIEW", + "path": "sources/C82_REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 4301, + "sha256": "bf6425b5fa878aafcf60b618ba85c16c22f9b2548615f790c1a1f43d138e1e72", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959988102", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation82/review/NONAUTHOR_REVIEW.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5959988102, + "created_at": "2026-10-02T19:35:11Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-02T19:35:11Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 4301, + "sha256": "bf6425b5fa878aafcf60b618ba85c16c22f9b2548615f790c1a1f43d138e1e72" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5959988102.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "A4", + "path": "sources/A4.md", + "bytes": 16544, + "sha256": "acd172c5f8626aa3b7be5ac691786eefa6d6f243a32909502dfdbd79c8066a7c", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5972396791", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation123/checkout/frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/PROOF.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5972396791, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T18:53:16Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T18:53:16Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 16544, + "sha256": "acd172c5f8626aa3b7be5ac691786eefa6d6f243a32909502dfdbd79c8066a7c" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5972396791.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "historical_incorporation_binding": { + "commit": "5217c22a9e2921a5d46192654cc5ce890fddd7e1", + "path": "frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/PROOF.md", + "matches": true, + "boundary": "Historical author PR256 snapshot; no current branch or integration claim" + } + }, + { + "key": "A4_REVIEW", + "path": "sources/A4_REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 18420, + "sha256": "b27f530d243d92a15302026eb66731de8f50464e71941bf1a03b983713b012f8", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5972610615", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation123/checkout/frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/REVIEW.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5972610615, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T19:15:10Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T19:15:10Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 18420, + "sha256": "b27f530d243d92a15302026eb66731de8f50464e71941bf1a03b983713b012f8" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5972610615.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "historical_incorporation_binding": { + "commit": "5217c22a9e2921a5d46192654cc5ce890fddd7e1", + "path": "frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/REVIEW.md", + "matches": true, + "boundary": "Historical author PR256 snapshot; no current branch or integration claim" + } + } + ], + "prior_manifest": { + "path": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "bytes": 7191, + "sha256": "f9f14a3ff629344a4bf7650587c40725bd3fb8c4b7c7c2b1704add677d589de9" + }, + "scope": "Planar k=1 correlated saddle-band and endpoint Gaussian-tail rate candidate only", + "boundary": "Exact cached bytes copied; 14 fresh native comment readbacks, 6 immutable Git/current-source bindings, 9 current landed native-proof bindings, 2 historical A4 incorporation bindings. No source payload execution, project test, master, proof edit, source-status promotion or review vote. Historical owner-reading labels are preserved bytes; current5973603003 clarification applies." +} +````` diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1a9446c00 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json @@ -0,0 +1,577 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "kind": "C124 source inventory and custody only; no mathematical vote", + "created_utc": "2026-10-03T22:23:26.437721+00:00", + "claim_id": "33e06044-3ffa-4d61-81d8-937ad54e3fb4", + "claim_row": 733, + "native_pickup": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974059664", + "main_head_readback": "4aadc771e8ffc08ee56bac63991a6ceb282a4292", + "math_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "source_count": 21, + "source_bytes": 353932, + "sources": [ + { + "key": "C91", + "path": "sources/C91.md", + "bytes": 12433, + "sha256": "74a9ee276c3647276deb544c6d83e3cf21f708f55f9009fa4db5cc49c9d0e9aa", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5963566666", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C91.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5963566666, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T00:22:20Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T00:22:20Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 12433, + "sha256": "74a9ee276c3647276deb544c6d83e3cf21f708f55f9009fa4db5cc49c9d0e9aa" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5963566666.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C91/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 12433, + "sha256": "74a9ee276c3647276deb544c6d83e3cf21f708f55f9009fa4db5cc49c9d0e9aa" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C92", + "path": "sources/C92.md", + "bytes": 19567, + "sha256": "6fa4c3d6d1e8c3d8590c865802d5df061ad5b17652ddc7fd7bf5c5e8b8de084a", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5963825788", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C92.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5963825788, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T00:52:49Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T00:52:49Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 19567, + "sha256": "6fa4c3d6d1e8c3d8590c865802d5df061ad5b17652ddc7fd7bf5c5e8b8de084a" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5963825788.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C92/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 19567, + "sha256": "6fa4c3d6d1e8c3d8590c865802d5df061ad5b17652ddc7fd7bf5c5e8b8de084a" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C93", + "path": "sources/C93.md", + "bytes": 15545, + "sha256": "f25f86cc66ae335b4832ea53670646815567ec7854fa0386f8c57f6939e0af1c", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964167051", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C93.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5964167051, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T01:36:14Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T01:36:14Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 15545, + "sha256": "f25f86cc66ae335b4832ea53670646815567ec7854fa0386f8c57f6939e0af1c" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5964167051.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C93/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 15545, + "sha256": "f25f86cc66ae335b4832ea53670646815567ec7854fa0386f8c57f6939e0af1c" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C94", + "path": "sources/C94.md", + "bytes": 15407, + "sha256": "0fe4fa2028f8ddbbf5a79df3879bcbd3789f19409fb44ad739caeabedff1af3c", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964517708", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C94.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5964517708, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T02:18:00Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T02:18:00Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 15407, + "sha256": "0fe4fa2028f8ddbbf5a79df3879bcbd3789f19409fb44ad739caeabedff1af3c" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5964517708.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C94/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 15407, + "sha256": "0fe4fa2028f8ddbbf5a79df3879bcbd3789f19409fb44ad739caeabedff1af3c" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C95", + "path": "sources/C95.md", + "bytes": 16185, + "sha256": "c0d9ee72352fafe91f96a8b6187c978f09ee3c187d5f4c7c2462c0187750d2e1", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964938563", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C95.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5964938563, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T03:09:41Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T03:09:41Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 16185, + "sha256": "c0d9ee72352fafe91f96a8b6187c978f09ee3c187d5f4c7c2462c0187750d2e1" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5964938563.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C95/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 16185, + "sha256": "c0d9ee72352fafe91f96a8b6187c978f09ee3c187d5f4c7c2462c0187750d2e1" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C96", + "path": "sources/C96.md", + "bytes": 7657, + "sha256": "7198ff636e330749428ded6938776dad612f6bdb51ad62359b445f016df13a7a", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965141133", + "extraction": "explicitly published mathematical suffix; 256-byte native preface excluded", + "full_native_identity_recorded_but_not_claimed_as_local": { + "bytes": 7913, + "sha256": "0758b5de8f4d9e4658ca3c6cf3e52c23d8e12f77999e9c3668ef0bedb15a05f5" + }, + "suffix_extraction": "Suffix beginning '# Designated maximin level equals the ordinary-superlevel H0 death', final LF retained; full native preface is 256 bytes.", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C96.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965141133, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T03:38:26Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T03:38:26Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 7913, + "sha256": "0758b5de8f4d9e4658ca3c6cf3e52c23d8e12f77999e9c3668ef0bedb15a05f5" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965141133.json", + "extraction_checked": "Exact 7657-byte suffix after the native 256-byte preface", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C96/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 7913, + "sha256": "0758b5de8f4d9e4658ca3c6cf3e52c23d8e12f77999e9c3668ef0bedb15a05f5" + }, + "extraction": "256-byte preface excluded", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C97", + "path": "sources/C97.md", + "bytes": 16098, + "sha256": "acf83958e6ea650d83bf811b2beacc03b553637dc4a3160012567c7f0a300a57", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965421543", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C97.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965421543, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T04:14:09Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T04:14:09Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 16098, + "sha256": "acf83958e6ea650d83bf811b2beacc03b553637dc4a3160012567c7f0a300a57" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965421543.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C97/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 16098, + "sha256": "acf83958e6ea650d83bf811b2beacc03b553637dc4a3160012567c7f0a300a57" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C98", + "path": "sources/C98.md", + "bytes": 15050, + "sha256": "3ca1622197bf22cf71ab64f2938ecc0b022ed09487b691d50ae8d2ad1f46d198", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965738339", + "extraction": "full native body", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/C98.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965738339, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T04:56:45Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T04:56:45Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 15050, + "sha256": "3ca1622197bf22cf71ab64f2938ecc0b022ed09487b691d50ae8d2ad1f46d198" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965738339.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C98/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 15050, + "sha256": "3ca1622197bf22cf71ab64f2938ecc0b022ed09487b691d50ae8d2ad1f46d198" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "P", + "path": "sources/P.md", + "bytes": 40261, + "sha256": "9350ad6eaba6626b93c3dedeef9e2ff816e5cdf1c8318e85fb27499141c84bc7", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "dfed3b8d318a3ab1950957f393307733a4bef3f2", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/P.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "dfed3b8d318a3ab1950957f393307733a4bef3f2", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "E1", + "path": "sources/E1.md", + "bytes": 1782, + "sha256": "bad7ef609c4ad8c41ad6af562c1b6807921e19a9d556ed793ad1a0db6e202028", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/ERRATUM_CONGRUENCE.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "213594d6ca6a86fb938110f4d166d9ce275a02d0", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/ERRATUM_CONGRUENCE.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/E1.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "213594d6ca6a86fb938110f4d166d9ce275a02d0", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "E2", + "path": "sources/E2.md", + "bytes": 9062, + "sha256": "845abf9f9c99d672c2a10a887b5a2e7206a3d2de3d876f35f75ff6e2dc13e62f", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/reviews/d1_section9_borel_repair_20260925/REPAIR.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "fe9b9ce4999908bb3814b500ee2d0ceb0c6f704a", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "reviews/d1_section9_borel_repair_20260925/REPAIR.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/E2.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "fe9b9ce4999908bb3814b500ee2d0ceb0c6f704a", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "REC", + "path": "sources/REC.md", + "bytes": 23312, + "sha256": "451b9d7ffee072a73fc904cab891b6693e3f233808b89df10cce1b57036b65da", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/reviews/d1_chain_reconciliation_20260928/RECONCILIATION.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "75da2597971510f843f8d90c743950cb8c177342", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "reviews/d1_chain_reconciliation_20260928/RECONCILIATION.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/REC.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "75da2597971510f843f8d90c743950cb8c177342", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "CUB", + "path": "sources/CUB.md", + "bytes": 19889, + "sha256": "117e9299a71e6139270266889eb772ed97518e402d9af029bbdb67caf9d4a0f0", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/frontiers/planar_cubic_cluster_20260929/PROOF.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "bb446d08db8a944537a743ad550b88c1c2ad5758", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "frontiers/planar_cubic_cluster_20260929/PROOF.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/CUB.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "bb446d08db8a944537a743ad550b88c1c2ad5758", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "ELDER", + "path": "sources/ELDER.md", + "bytes": 39722, + "sha256": "f68038be79b46124b0f9b31205aa6e3682b34b6f5ef81f4a5697ae81f07cc46b", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/frontiers/local_elder_geometry_20260930/PROOF.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "git_blob": "ef2aa57959ea9f721bbf2316ce94cf616c1c9113", + "commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_path": "frontiers/local_elder_geometry_20260930/PROOF.md", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/sources/ELDER.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "immutable_git_binding": { + "original_commit": "044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43", + "git_blob": "ef2aa57959ea9f721bbf2316ce94cf616c1c9113", + "exact_original_blob": true, + "live_head_readback": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "same_current_bytes": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C96_COMPLETION", + "path": "sources/C96_COMPLETION.md", + "bytes": 3466, + "sha256": "634fdab86ef2d568fecba9da80ccd067e3dc12849d88731648f1b09e46861603", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965212531", + "extraction": "Exact UTF-8 native body", + "role": "Closed-manifold and measurable-event conventions", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/custody/antecedents/C96_COMPLETION.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5965212531, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T03:47:53Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T03:47:53Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 3466, + "sha256": "634fdab86ef2d568fecba9da80ccd067e3dc12849d88731648f1b09e46861603" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5965212531.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C82_NATIVE", + "path": "sources/C82_NATIVE.md", + "bytes": 11645, + "sha256": "1b7523bf145f03dbaf73ceae2aa256e17505bbb1c2693e339bc399c64e1654c9", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959920397", + "extraction": "Exact UTF-8 body", + "role": "scoped analytic source or its disposition", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/custody/antecedents/C82_NATIVE.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5959920397, + "created_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 11645, + "sha256": "1b7523bf145f03dbaf73ceae2aa256e17505bbb1c2693e339bc399c64e1654c9" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5959920397.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C82", + "path": "sources/C82.md", + "bytes": 11253, + "sha256": "f390ad99b07ec4eda9160191d776cfc3a53ca628976165987d9a61ab79816827", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959920397", + "extraction": "11253-byte proof prefix before native footer", + "role": "scoped analytic source or its disposition", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/custody/antecedents/C82_PROOF.md", + "original_manifest": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5959920397, + "created_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-02T19:30:38Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 11645, + "sha256": "1b7523bf145f03dbaf73ceae2aa256e17505bbb1c2693e339bc399c64e1654c9" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5959920397.json", + "extraction_checked": "Exact 11253-byte prefix; 392-byte native footer excluded", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C101", + "path": "sources/C101.md", + "bytes": 36333, + "sha256": "300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5967063473", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation101/PROOF.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5967063473, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T08:11:34Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T08:11:34Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 36333, + "sha256": "300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5967063473.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "landed_native_incorporation": { + "commit": "b55b8f34d09084300088105b90fe60759fd7e144", + "path": "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C101/PROOF.md", + "full_git_blob": { + "bytes": 36333, + "sha256": "300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4" + }, + "extraction": "full blob", + "matches": true + } + }, + { + "key": "C82_REVIEW", + "path": "sources/C82_REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 4301, + "sha256": "bf6425b5fa878aafcf60b618ba85c16c22f9b2548615f790c1a1f43d138e1e72", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959988102", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation82/review/NONAUTHOR_REVIEW.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5959988102, + "created_at": "2026-10-02T19:35:11Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-02T19:35:11Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 4301, + "sha256": "bf6425b5fa878aafcf60b618ba85c16c22f9b2548615f790c1a1f43d138e1e72" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5959988102.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + } + }, + { + "key": "A4", + "path": "sources/A4.md", + "bytes": 16544, + "sha256": "acd172c5f8626aa3b7be5ac691786eefa6d6f243a32909502dfdbd79c8066a7c", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5972396791", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation123/checkout/frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/PROOF.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5972396791, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T18:53:16Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T18:53:16Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 16544, + "sha256": "acd172c5f8626aa3b7be5ac691786eefa6d6f243a32909502dfdbd79c8066a7c" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5972396791.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "historical_incorporation_binding": { + "commit": "5217c22a9e2921a5d46192654cc5ce890fddd7e1", + "path": "frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/PROOF.md", + "matches": true, + "boundary": "Historical author PR256 snapshot; no current branch or integration claim" + } + }, + { + "key": "A4_REVIEW", + "path": "sources/A4_REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 18420, + "sha256": "b27f530d243d92a15302026eb66731de8f50464e71941bf1a03b983713b012f8", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5972610615", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "copied_from": "work/continuation123/checkout/frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/REVIEW.md", + "fresh_native_binding": { + "comment_id": 5972610615, + "created_at": "2026-10-03T19:15:10Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T19:15:10Z", + "full_native_body": { + "bytes": 18420, + "sha256": "b27f530d243d92a15302026eb66731de8f50464e71941bf1a03b983713b012f8" + }, + "readback_path": "entry/native-sources/5972610615.json", + "extraction_checked": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added LF", + "matches_cached_source": true + }, + "historical_incorporation_binding": { + "commit": "5217c22a9e2921a5d46192654cc5ce890fddd7e1", + "path": "frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/REVIEW.md", + "matches": true, + "boundary": "Historical author PR256 snapshot; no current branch or integration claim" + } + } + ], + "prior_manifest": { + "path": "work/continuation101/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "bytes": 7191, + "sha256": "f9f14a3ff629344a4bf7650587c40725bd3fb8c4b7c7c2b1704add677d589de9" + }, + "scope": "Planar k=1 correlated saddle-band and endpoint Gaussian-tail rate candidate only", + "boundary": "Exact cached bytes copied; 14 fresh native comment readbacks, 6 immutable Git/current-source bindings, 9 current landed native-proof bindings, 2 historical A4 incorporation bindings. No source payload execution, project test, master, proof edit, source-status promotion or review vote. Historical owner-reading labels are preserved bytes; current5973603003 clarification applies." +} diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls.py b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..833872fe1 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls.py @@ -0,0 +1,271 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""C124 finite exact arithmetic controls; no analytic or formal-proof claim. + +No arguments: baseline (exit 0 on success). --mutant NAME: deliberately +incorrect candidate (exit 1 if rejected). Invalid arguments exit 2. +Only the Python standard library is used; no files or network are accessed. +""" + +from fractions import Fraction as F +from math import comb, factorial, prod +import json +import sys + + +MUTANTS = ( + "WINDOW_H_OMITTED", + "BAND_P_ONE", + "DROP_BAND_FLOOR", + "UNWEIGHTED_PROMOTION", + "INDEPENDENT_COEFFICIENTS", + "EXP_SCALE_TOO_LARGE", + "DROP_SOFT_FACTOR", + "DOUBLE_NORMALIZER", + "DROP_SCALED_FAR", + "GAUSSIAN_LAMBDA_SQUARED", +) + + +class Checks: + def __init__(self): + self.groups = {} + self.failures = [] + + def check(self, group, label, condition): + counts = self.groups.setdefault(group, {"checks": 0, "failures": 0}) + counts["checks"] += 1 + if not condition: + counts["failures"] += 1 + if len(self.failures) < 16: + self.failures.append({"group": group, "label": label}) + + def equal(self, group, label, got, want): + self.check(group, label, got == want) + + def result(self, mutant): + checks = sum(v["checks"] for v in self.groups.values()) + failures = sum(v["failures"] for v in self.groups.values()) + return { + "object": "C124-EXACT-CONTROLS-v1", + "candidate": mutant or "BASELINE", + "passed": failures == 0, + "checks": checks, + "failure_count": failures, + "failures_first_16": self.failures, + "groups": self.groups, + "scope": "finite rational controls; not analytic proof or source verification", + } + + +def ledger(c, mutant): + g = "G1_schedule_and_admissibility" + # w=(r H^4)^(-1/12), retaining both exact powers. + schedule = (F(-1, 12), F(-1, 3)) + if mutant == "WINDOW_H_OMITTED": + schedule = (F(-1, 12), F(0)) + + def substitute(r, h, w): + return (F(r) + F(w) * schedule[0], F(h) + F(w) * schedule[1]) + + # Input monomials (r,H,w) and independently hand-derived expected pairs. + cases = ( + ("radius", (0, 0, -8), (F(2, 3), F(8, 3))), + ("radius_actual", (1, 3, -4), (F(4, 3), F(13, 3))), + ("selected_edge", (1, 4, 4), (F(2, 3), F(8, 3))), + ("selected_edge_actual", (F(3, 2), 5, 2), (F(4, 3), F(13, 3))), + ("endpoint", (1, 3, 2), (F(5, 6), F(7, 3))), + ("endpoint_actual", (F(3, 2), 4, 1), (F(17, 12), F(11, 3))), + ("joint_band", (1, 0, 4), (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3))), + ("actual_band_floor", (1, 4, 0), (F(1), F(4))), + ("large_N", (2, 3, 8), (F(4, 3), F(1, 3))), + ("hessian_first", (2, 5, 4), (F(5, 3), F(11, 3))), + ("hessian_second", (2, 7, 2), (F(11, 6), F(19, 3))), + ("far_derivative", (1, 0, 0), (F(1), F(0))), + ) + target = (F(2, 3), F(8, 3)) + values = {} + for label, powers, want in cases: + got = substitute(*powers) + values[label] = got + c.equal(g, label + ":exact_pair", got, want) + c.check(g, label + ":log_dominance", + got[0] > target[0] or + (got[0] == target[0] and got[1] <= target[1])) + c.equal(g, "balanced_leading_terms", values["radius"], values["selected_edge"]) + c.equal(g, "leading_target", values["radius"], target) + for label, powers, want in ( + ("rH", (1, 1, 0), (F(1), F(1))), + ("rw", (1, 0, 1), (F(11, 12), F(-1, 3))), + ("e", (1, 0, 4), (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3))), + ("H2e", (1, 2, 4), (F(2, 3), F(2, 3))), + ("eta", (1, 0, 2), (F(5, 6), F(-2, 3))), + ): + got = substitute(*powers) + c.equal(g, label + ":exact_admissibility", got, want) + c.check(g, label + ":vanishes", got[0] > 0) + c.check(g, "window_grows", schedule[0] < 0) + # Fixed-Lambda schedule w=r^-1/12: H powers become constants. + for label, powers, _ in cases: + r, _, w = powers + c.check(g, label + ":fixed_layer_at_least_two_thirds", + F(r) - F(w, 12) >= F(2, 3)) + + +def dyadic(c, mutant): + g = "G2_joint_band_dyadic_sums" + p = 1 if mutant == "BAND_P_ONE" else 2 + for m in range(2, 33): + for scale in (F(1), F(3, 4), F(5, 7)): + a = scale / 2**m + b = F(3, 17) + endpoint = 2 * a + last = 0 + while 2 * endpoint <= F(1, 2): + last += 1 + endpoint *= 2 + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:stopping_interval", + F(1, 4) < endpoint <= F(1, 2)) + shell_a = sum((2 * a * F(2) ** ((1 - p) * j) + for j in range(last + 1)), F(0)) + shell_b = sum((b * F(2) ** (-p * j) + for j in range(last + 1)), F(0)) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:linear_geometric_sum", shell_a, + 4 * a * (1 - F(1, 2) ** (last + 1))) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:floor_geometric_sum", shell_b, + F(4, 3) * b * (1 - F(1, 4) ** (last + 1))) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:uniform_shell_bound", + shell_a + shell_b <= 4 * a + F(4, 3) * b) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:large_N_threshold", + endpoint / a > 1 / (4 * a)) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:tail_markov_coefficient", + (a / endpoint)**2 < 16 * a**2) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:{scale}:combined_low_and_shells", + a + b + shell_a + shell_b <= 5 * a + F(7, 3) * b) + # Abstract continuous band fixture: measure of total mass B, N=1, + # uniform in mu on (0,delta]. It obeys mass{|mu|<=s} <= s+B for + # every s>0, with no atom at the neutral level. It is not asserted + # to be a realizable pinned Gaussian field. The bound alone cannot + # discard B; choosing delta=B/2^m defeats a delta-only unit bound. + for m in range(1, 33): + b = F(1, 64) + delta = b / 2**m + offered = delta if mutant == "DROP_BAND_FLOOR" else delta + b + c.check(g, f"continuous:m{m}:retain_band_error_floor", b <= offered) + + +def counterexample(c, mutant): + g = "G3_unweighted_band_counterexample" + # The geometric-distribution recurrence is compared with literal moments. + moments = [1] + for p in range(1, 9): + moments.append(2 + sum(comb(p, j) * moments[j] for j in range(1, p))) + c.equal(g, "geometric_moments_zero_through_eight", moments, + [1, 2, 6, 26, 150, 1082, 9366, 94586, 1091670]) + for p in range(9): + partial = sum((F(n**p, 2**n) for n in range(1, 129)), F(0)) + c.check(g, f"p{p}:partial_moment_below_exact", partial <= moments[p]) + for m in range(2, 65): + delta = F(1, 2**m) + e = delta / m + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:event_lower_bound_over_e", delta / e, F(m)) + c.check(g, f"m{m}:event_containment_at_right_endpoint", delta <= e * m) + # Exact partition into U-intervals with N=m+j, including the tail. + finite = sum((F((m + j)**2, 2**(m + j)) for j in range(1, 17)), F(0)) + tail = F((m + 16)**2 + 4 * (m + 16) + 6, 2**(m + 16)) + joint = delta * (m*m + 4*m + 6) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:joint_second_moment", finite + tail, joint) + c.equal(g, f"m{m}:joint_band_ratio", joint / delta, F(m*m + 4*m + 6)) + proposed_bound = 8 * e if mutant == "UNWEIGHTED_PROMOTION" else delta + c.check(g, f"m{m}:unweighted_Oe_claim_not_inferred", delta <= proposed_bound) + + +def gaussian(c, mutant): + g = "G4_correlated_gaussian_and_exp_square" + for index, weights in enumerate(((F(1), F(1)), (F(1, 3), F(2, 3)), + (F(2), F(3), F(5)), + (F(1, 2), F(1, 3), F(1, 7)))): + s = sum(weights) + variance = sum(a*a for a in weights) if mutant == "INDEPENDENT_COEFFICIENTS" else s*s + c.equal(g, f"fixture{index}:fully_correlated_variance", variance, s*s) + c.check(g, f"fixture{index}:quadrature_is_too_small", sum(a*a for a in weights) < s*s) + for m in range(1, 17): + normal_moment = prod(range(1, 2*m, 2)) + candidate_moment = variance**m * normal_moment + c.equal(g, f"fixture{index}:m{m}:actual_even_moment", + candidate_moment, s**(2*m) * normal_moment) + c.check(g, f"fixture{index}:m{m}:Minkowski_majorant", + s**(2*m) * normal_moment <= s**(2*m) * (2*m)**m) + # Rational coefficient check: if ||J||_p <= C sqrt(p), use + # epsilon=1/(12 C^2), m! >= (m/3)^m, and sum 2^-m=2. + # The assumed moment inequality and infinite-series step are analytic. + for const in (F(1), F(3, 2), F(4), F(17, 3)): + epsilon = 1 / (const*const * (1 if mutant == "EXP_SCALE_TOO_LARGE" else 12)) + for m in range(1, 49): + c.check(g, f"C{const}:m{m}:factorial_majorant", m**m <= 3**m * factorial(m)) + coefficient = epsilon**m * const**(2*m) * (2*m)**m / factorial(m) + c.check(g, f"C{const}:m{m}:geometric_exp_coefficient", coefficient <= F(1, 2**m)) + for m in range(1, 25): + c.equal(g, f"exp_partial{m}", sum((F(1, 2**j) for j in range(m + 1)), F(0)), + 2 - F(1, 2**m)) + + +def rare_scalar(c, mutant): + g = "G5_rare_scalar_and_full_normalization" + for r in (F(1, 2), F(1, 7), F(1, 64), F(3, 100)): + for j in (F(1), F(3, 2), F(4)): + for d, s in ((F(1), F(1)), (F(2), F(3, 4)), (F(1, 3), F(5))): + top = d * r * j*j + integral = top*top / 2 if mutant == "DROP_SOFT_FACTOR" else top**3/3 + s*r*j*j*top*top/2 + numerator = r*r*j**4 * integral + coefficient = d**3/3 + s*d*d/2 + want = r**5*j**10*coefficient + label = f"r{r}:J{j}:D{d}:C{s}" + c.equal(g, label + ":scalar_integral", numerator, want) + z = F(5, 3) * r*r + normalized = numerator / (z*z if mutant == "DOUBLE_NORMALIZER" else z) + c.equal(g, label + ":probability_scaling", normalized, + r**3*j**10*coefficient/F(5, 3)) + c.equal(g, label + ":scaled_measure", normalized/r**3, + j**10*coefficient/F(5, 3)) + # The documented input is E[(W/r^2) 1_exception] <= C r^4. + c.equal(g, "near_radius_exponents", 5 - 2 - 3, 0) + c.equal(g, "far_numerator_radius_exponent", 2 + 4, 6) + far = F(0) if mutant == "DROP_SCALED_FAR" else F(1, 8) + c.check(g, "retain_permitted_far_mass", F(1, 8) <= far) + c.equal(g, "far_scaled_radius_exponent", 2 + 4 - 2 - 3, 1) + + +def exponential_tail(c, mutant): + g = "G6_exponential_tail_threshold" + for lam in (F(1), F(4), F(9), F(25), F(64), F(100)): + for const in (F(1), F(4), F(9)): + threshold_squared = lam*lam/const if mutant == "GAUSSIAN_LAMBDA_SQUARED" else lam/const + c.equal(g, f"Lambda{lam}:C{const}:threshold_square", threshold_squared, lam/const) + c.equal(g, "square_of_square_root_degree", F(1, 2)*2, 1) + for decay in (F(1, 10), F(1, 3), F(1), F(7, 2)): + D = F(2, 3)/decay + c.equal(g, f"c{decay}:minimum_log_cutoff", decay*D, F(2, 3)) + c.check(g, f"c{decay}:larger_log_cutoff", decay*(D + 1) > F(2, 3)) + + +def main(argv): + if argv == ["--list-mutants"]: + print(json.dumps(list(MUTANTS), separators=(",", ":"))) + return 0 + mutant = None + if argv: + if len(argv) != 2 or argv[0] != "--mutant" or argv[1] not in MUTANTS: + print(json.dumps({"error": "expected no arguments, --list-mutants, or --mutant NAME", + "passed": False}, sort_keys=True, separators=(",", ":"))) + return 2 + mutant = argv[1] + checks = Checks() + for group in (ledger, dyadic, counterexample, gaussian, rare_scalar, exponential_tail): + group(checks, mutant) + result = checks.result(mutant) + print(json.dumps(result, sort_keys=True, separators=(",", ":"))) + return 0 if result["passed"] else 1 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + sys.exit(main(sys.argv[1:])) diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls_stdout.txt b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls_stdout.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..398f02fd2 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/author_controls_stdout.txt @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +{"candidate":"BASELINE","checks":1740,"failure_count":0,"failures_first_16":[],"groups":{"G1_schedule_and_admissibility":{"checks":49,"failures":0},"G2_joint_band_dyadic_sums":{"checks":683,"failures":0},"G3_unweighted_band_counterexample":{"checks":325,"failures":0},"G4_correlated_gaussian_and_exp_square":{"checks":544,"failures":0},"G5_rare_scalar_and_full_normalization":{"checks":112,"failures":0},"G6_exponential_tail_threshold":{"checks":27,"failures":0}},"object":"C124-EXACT-CONTROLS-v1","passed":true,"scope":"finite rational controls; not analytic proof or source verification"} diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker.py b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..05311c3eb --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker.py @@ -0,0 +1,179 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""C124 nonauthor finite falsification controls; no author checker imported.""" +from fractions import Fraction as F +from math import factorial +import json +import sys + +MODES = ('GAMMA_POWER', 'UNWEIGHTED_BAND', 'DIAGONAL_RESIDUAL', + 'UNCENTERED_RESIDUAL', 'UNSAFE_EPSILON', 'FACTOR_TAIL', + 'NORMALIZER_POWER', 'H_SCHEDULE') +if len(sys.argv) > 2 or (len(sys.argv) == 2 and sys.argv[1] not in MODES): + print('UNKNOWN_CONTROL_MODE') + sys.exit(2) +mode = sys.argv[1] if len(sys.argv) == 2 else 'BASELINE' +counts = {} +failures = [] + + +def check(group, truth, label): + counts[group] = counts.get(group, 0) + 1 + if not truth: + failures.append(group + ': ' + label) + + +# The chart Jacobian and pole cancellations are checked on signed gamma, +# including arbitrarily small rational values; no numeric tolerance is used. +for gamma in (F(-7), F(-1, 1000), F(-1), F(1, 1000), F(2, 3), F(5)): + for b in (F(-2), F(0), F(1, 7)): + for c3 in (F(-1, 5), F(0), F(3)): + d = gamma**2 - 12*b + j = 8*gamma**3 - 144*b*gamma + 576*c3 + c, rr = d/gamma**2, j/gamma**3 + psi = abs(c) + F(7, 3) + lam = gamma**2 * psi / 24 + wl = (24*lam-d)*(24*lam+d)/16 + power = 4 if mode == 'GAMMA_POWER' else 6 + check('chart', wl*gamma**2/24 == gamma**power*(psi**2-c**2)/384, + 'w d-lambda = gamma^6 polynomial d-psi') + check('chart', gamma**6*abs(c)**3 == abs(d)**3, 'absolute c pole') + check('chart', gamma**6*rr**2 == j**2, 'signed R pole') + +# Correlated atomic measures, not products of marginal laws. The finite model +# uses exact band constants extracted from the actual weighted atomic bands. +for depth in (2, 3, 8, 20, 50): + a = F(1, 2**depth) + m = 0 + while 2**m*a < F(1, 4): + m += 1 + check('dyadic', F(1, 4) <= 2**m*a < F(1, 2), 'terminal band') + shells = [F(2)*a*F(1, 2**j) for j in range(m)] + floors = [F(1, 4**j) for j in range(m)] + check('dyadic', sum(shells) <= 4*a, 'width sum') + check('dyadic', sum(floors) <= F(4, 3), 'finite-r floor sum') + # A boundary-focused, strongly correlated finite population. + atoms = [(a/2, F(1), F(1, 7)), + (a, F(1), F(1, 13)), + (2*a, F(2), F(1, 17)), + (3*a, F(4), F(1, 19)), + (F(1, 3), F(2**depth), F(1, 23)), + (-F(3), F(4*2**depth), F(1, 29)), + (F(10), F(1), F(1, 31))] + band = lambda delta, p: sum(mass*n**p for u,n,mass in atoms if abs(u)<=delta) + floor = F(1, 100) + h3 = F(8) + deltas = [2**j*a for j in range(m+1)] + moment2 = sum(mass*n*n for u,n,mass in atoms) + cc = max([band(delta,p)/(delta+floor) for delta in deltas for p in (0,2)] + + [moment2/h3]) + actual = sum(mass for u,n,mass in atoms if abs(u)<=a*n) + bound = cc*(5*a + F(7,3)*floor + 16*h3*a*a) + check('dyadic', actual <= bound, 'correlated decomposition bound') + part = band(a,0) + for j in range(m): + selected = [(u,n,mass) for u,n,mass in atoms + if 2**j*a < abs(u) <= 2**(j+1)*a and abs(u)<=a*n] + check('dyadic', all(n>2**j for u,n,mass in selected), 'shell norm implication') + part += sum(mass for u,n,mass in selected) + outer = [(u,n,mass) for u,n,mass in atoms if abs(u)>2**m*a and abs(u)<=a*n] + check('dyadic', all(n>1/(4*a) for u,n,mass in outer), 'outer norm implication') + # Inner band can include points not in the moving band, so it is a cover. + part += sum(mass for u,n,mass in outer) + check('dyadic', actual <= part, 'all moving-band atoms covered') + +# The unweighted small-ball condition cannot be multiplied by an independent +# moment. U uniform and N=ceil(log2(1/U)) gives a factor m on the stated event. +for m in (2,4,8,16,32): + em = F(1,2**m*m) + lower_mass = F(1,2**m) + inferred = em if mode == 'UNWEIGHTED_BAND' else m*em + check('correlation', lower_mass <= inferred, 'unweighted O(e) shortcut fails') + +# Orthogonal projection onto the complement of (3/5,4/5). Its negative +# off-diagonal entries increase variance along (1,-1); they are not zero. +a0,a1 = F(3,5),F(4,5) +cov = ((1-a0*a0,-a0*a1),(-a0*a1,1-a1*a1)) +check('projection', cov[0][0]+cov[1][1] == 1, 'rank-one trace') +check('projection', cov[0][0]*cov[1][1]-cov[0][1]**2 == 0, 'PSD rank-one') +actual_var = cov[0][0] + cov[1][1] - 2*cov[0][1] +used_var = cov[0][0]+cov[1][1] if mode == 'DIAGONAL_RESIDUAL' else actual_var +check('projection', used_var == F(49,25), 'correlation retained in linear-form variance') +for value in (F(-4),F(0),F(7)): + mean, coeff, obs, obsmean = F(100),F(3,7),F(19),F(11) + field = mean+coeff*(obs-obsmean)+value + residual = field-coeff*(obs-obsmean) + if mode != 'UNCENTERED_RESIDUAL': + residual -= mean + check('projection', residual == value, 'centered endpoint residual') + +# Explicit Gaussian even moments and the exponential-series coefficient +# bound implied by Minkowski; no independence of Fourier residuals is used. +moment = 1 +for n in range(1,81): + moment *= 2*n-1 + check('exponential', moment <= (2*n)**n, 'Gaussian moment upper bound') + divisor = 2 if mode == 'UNSAFE_EPSILON' else 12 + coefficient = F((2*n)**n, divisor**n*factorial(n)) + check('exponential', coefficient <= F(1,2**n), 'exponential series majorant') +check('exponential', sum(F(1,2**n) for n in range(81)) < 2, 'geometric series partial sum') + +# Exact independent endpoint-scalar integration. r^2 J^4 times the cubic +# endpoint integral is r^5 J^10, and r^-3/Z_r has Z_r proportional to r^2. +for radius in (F(1,2),F(1,7),F(1,100)): + for jr in (F(1),F(2),F(17,3)): + for depth_const in (F(1),F(4),F(7,2)): + for cross_const in (F(1),F(5,2)): + upper = depth_const*radius*jr**2 + integral = upper**3/3 + cross_const*radius*jr**2*upper**2/2 + numerator = radius**2*jr**4*integral + expected = radius**5*jr**10*(depth_const**3/3+cross_const*depth_const**2/2) + check('scalar_tail', numerator == expected, 'r^5 J^10 numerator') + zpower = 4 if mode == 'NORMALIZER_POWER' else 2 + scaled = numerator/radius**zpower/radius**3 + check('scalar_tail', scaled == jr**10*(depth_const**3/3+cross_const*depth_const**2/2), + 'one full r^2 normalizer and r^-3 scaling') +weights = ((F(1),F(99,100)),(F(10),F(1,100))) +weighted_tail = sum(prob*j**10 for j,prob in weights if j>5) +tailprob = sum(prob for j,prob in weights if j>5) +moment10 = sum(prob*j**10 for j,prob in weights) +used_tail = moment10*tailprob if mode == 'FACTOR_TAIL' else weighted_tail +check('scalar_tail', weighted_tail <= used_tail, 'same residual tail indicator retained') + +# Independently encode each term as powers (r,H,w), then substitute w. +rows = { + 'radius':(0,0,-8),'radius_error':(1,3,-4), + 'elder':(1,4,4),'elder_error':(F(3,2),5,2), + 'endpoint':(1,3,2),'endpoint_error':(F(3,2),4,1), + 'band':(1,0,4),'leak':(1,4,0),'outer_band':(2,3,8), + 'hessian1':(2,5,4),'hessian2':(2,7,2)} +expected = [(F(2,3),F(8,3)),(F(4,3),F(13,3)), + (F(2,3),F(8,3)),(F(4,3),F(13,3)),(F(5,6),F(7,3)), + (F(17,12),F(11,3)),(F(2,3),F(-4,3)),(F(1),F(4)), + (F(4,3),F(1,3)),(F(5,3),F(11,3)),(F(11,6),F(19,3))] +wh = F(-1,4) if mode == 'H_SCHEDULE' else F(-1,3) +for (label,(pr,ph,pw)),want in zip(rows.items(),expected): + got = (F(pr)-F(pw,12),F(ph)+pw*wh) + check('ledger', got == want, label+' substituted powers') + check('ledger', got[0]>F(2,3) or (got[0]==F(2,3) and got[1]<=F(8,3)), + label+' target domination') + check('ledger', F(pr)-F(pw,12)>=F(2,3),label+' fixed-layer endpoint') +for label,(pr,ph,pw) in {'rH':(1,1,0),'embedding':(1,0,1), + 'e':(1,0,4),'H2e':(1,2,4),'rw2':(1,0,2)}.items(): + check('ledger', F(pr)-F(pw,12)>0,label+' cutoff decays') +check('ledger', F(3)+F(2,3)==F(11,3),'physical fixed-layer power') + +# Variation norm on atomic signed measures is sum of absolute masses. +for nu0 in ((F(1),F(2)),(F(1,5),F(4,5)),(F(2),F(0))): + for changes in ((F(1,10),F(-1,20)),(F(0),F(0)),(F(-1,10),F(1,10))): + nu=tuple(a+b for a,b in zip(nu0,changes)) + if min(nu)<0:continue + m,m0=sum(nu),sum(nu0) + err=sum(abs(a-b) for a,b in zip(nu,nu0)) + normalized=sum(abs(a/m-b/m0) for a,b in zip(nu,nu0)) + check('normalization', normalized<=err/m+abs(m-m0)/m,'probability normalization') + if m>=m0/2: + check('normalization', normalized<=4*err/m0,'positive mass floor') + +print(json.dumps({'mode':mode,'checks':sum(counts.values()),'groups':counts, + 'failures':failures,'scope':'finite controls only; no analytic proof'},sort_keys=True)) +sys.exit(1 if failures else 0) diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude.py b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude.py new file mode 100644 index 000000000..356b3e6d6 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude.py @@ -0,0 +1,277 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""C124 cross-provider review controls: exact rational checks, standard library only. + +Target: C124-PLANAR-K1-CORRELATED-BAND-ENDPOINT-LOG-RATE-20261003-v1, main issue 229, comment 5974162498 +(20,668 bytes, SHA-256 90148657...520f). +Reviewer: Anthropic Claude, session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU, for Dylan Roy (delegated AI review). +Written without the author's controls (5974185757) or any other reviewer's code. Disclosed stake: C124 +consumes the reviewer's A4. + +Usage: python3 c124_exact.py [MUTANT] (exit 0 pass, 1 fail, 2 unknown label) +Mutants (each must exit 1): + CHART_12 d lambda = (gamma^2/12) d psi in place of gamma^2/24 (Lemma JB) + SHELL_2A the dyadic shell sum bounded by 2a in place of 4a (Lemma DB) + ES_SIX epsilon_0 = 1/(6 C_*^2) in place of 1/(12 C_*^2) (Lemma ES) + FT_R4 the near-branch weight r^4 J^10 in place of r^5 J^10 (Lemma FT, (14)) + W_SIXTEENTH the fixed-layer window w = r^(-1/16) in place of r^(-1/12) (section 7) + TABLE_H3 the w^(-8) row with H^3 in place of H^(8/3) ((18) table) +These checks test finite algebra, exact sums and exponent bookkeeping only. They do not prove C82 LB, +C101's interfaces, P4.2's residual, the Gaussian moment bounds, C95/C96/C98's identification or any +measure-theoretic step. +""" +import math +import random +import sys +from fractions import Fraction as F + +MUTANTS = ("CHART_12", "SHELL_2A", "ES_SIX", "FT_R4", "W_SIXTEENTH", "TABLE_H3") +MUT = None +if len(sys.argv) > 1: + MUT = sys.argv[1] + if len(sys.argv) > 2 or MUT not in MUTANTS: + print("unknown mutant label: %s" % " ".join(sys.argv[1:])) + sys.exit(2) + +RNG = random.Random(124_5974162498) +RESULTS, FAILS = [], [] + + +class Group: + def __init__(self, name): + self.name, self.n, self.bad = name, 0, 0 + + def check(self, ok, msg=""): + self.n += 1 + if not ok: + self.bad += 1 + if len(FAILS) < 12: + FAILS.append("%s: %s" % (self.name, msg)) + + def close(self): + RESULTS.append((self.name, self.n - self.bad, self.n)) + + +def rq(lo, hi, den=97): + a, b = int(math.floor(F(lo) * den)), int(math.floor(F(hi) * den)) + return F(RNG.randint(a, b), den) + + +def rq_pos(lo, hi, den=97): + while True: + x = rq(lo, hi, den) + if x > 0: + return x + + +# ===================================================================== +# G0 Lemma JB: chart Jacobian, weight, pole cancellation; the error term over |lambda| <= Lambda +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G0 Lemma JB chart and poles") +jac = F(1, 12) if MUT == "CHART_12" else F(1, 24) +for _ in range(4000): + gam, B1, C3 = rq(-4, 4), rq(-4, 4), rq(-4, 4) + if gam == 0: + continue + D, J = gam**2 - 12 * B1, 8 * gam**3 - 144 * B1 * gam + 576 * C3 + c, R = D / gam**2, J / gam**3 + l1, l2 = rq(0, 3), rq(0, 3) + p1, p2 = 24 * l1 / gam**2, 24 * l2 / gam**2 + if p1 != p2: + g.check((l2 - l1) / (p2 - p1) == jac * gam**2, "d lambda = (gamma^2/24) d psi") + aM, aS = 24 * l1 - D, 24 * l1 + D + g.check(aM * aS / 16 * jac * gam**2 == gam**6 * (p1**2 - c**2) / 384, "w_lambda d lambda = (gamma^6/384)(psi^2 - c^2) d psi") + g.check(gam**6 * abs(c)**3 == abs(D)**3 and gam**6 * R**2 == J**2, "gamma^6 |c|^3 = |D|^3, gamma^6 R^2 = J^2") + # the multiplier of C82 LB after the Jacobian: (delta/384)[(1024/3)|D|^3 + 64 J^2] + g.check(gam**6 / 384 * ((F(1024, 3)) * abs(c)**3 + 64 * R**2) == (F(1024, 3) * abs(D)**3 + 64 * J**2) / 384, "LB multiplier in raw jets") +for Lam in [F(k, 3) for k in range(3, 60)]: + H = 1 + Lam + g.check(2 * Lam <= 2 * H and H**3 * 2 * Lam <= 2 * H**4, "error term r H^3 int_{-Lambda}^{Lambda} d lambda <= 2 r H^4") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G1 Lemma DB: dyadic shells, exact sums, the tail region, and the countermodel +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G1 Lemma DB dyadic summation") +shell_const = 2 if MUT == "SHELL_2A" else 4 +for _ in range(3000): + a = rq_pos(F(1, 10**6), F(1, 4), 10**7) + b = rq_pos(0, 1, 1000) + m = 0 + while not (F(1, 4) <= 2**m * a < F(1, 2)): + m += 1 + if m > 80: + break + g.check(F(1, 4) <= 2**m * a < F(1, 2), "the integer m with 2^m a in [1/4, 1/2) exists") + shells = sum(2 * a * F(1, 2**j) + b * F(1, 4**j) for j in range(m)) + g.check(shells <= shell_const * a + F(4, 3) * b, "sum_j [2a 2^-j + b 4^-j] <= 4a + (4/3) b") + for j in range(m): + g.check(2**(j + 1) * a <= F(1, 2), "each shell width 2^(j+1) a <= 1/2 (JB applies)") + # the implications used: |mu| <= a N with 2^j a < |mu| gives N > 2^j; |mu| > 2^m a >= 1/4 gives (4 a N)^2 > 1 + for _k in range(5): + N = rq_pos(1, 10**4) + j = RNG.randrange(m + 1) + mu = rq_pos(2**j * a, 2**(j + 1) * a, 10**7) + if 2**j * a < mu <= a * N: + g.check(N > 2**j and N**2 / 4**j > 1, "shell j: N > 2^j, so 1 < N^2 4^-j") + mu2 = rq_pos(2**m * a, 2, 10**7) + if 2**m * a < mu2 <= a * N: + g.check((4 * a * N)**2 > 1, "tail: 1 < (4 a N)^2 = 16 a^2 N^2") +# countermodel: U uniform on (0, 1), N = ceil(log2(1/U)), e_m = 2^-m/m: {U <= 2^-m} lies in {U <= e_m N} +for mm in range(1, 40): + em = F(1, 2**mm * mm) + for k in range(1, 30): + U = F(k, 2**(mm + 5)) * F(32, 30) # U in (0, 2^-m] + if U > F(1, 2**mm): + continue + N = 0 + while F(1, 2**N) > U: + N += 1 # N = ceil(log2(1/U)) + g.check(N >= mm and U <= em * N, "countermodel: U <= 2^-m implies U <= e_m N") + g.check(F(1, 2**mm) == mm * em, "P(U <= e_m N) >= 2^-m = m e_m, unbounded relative to e_m") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G2 Lemma ES: Gaussian moments, the exponential-square series and the tail bound +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G2 Lemma ES constants") +eps_den = 6 if MUT == "ES_SIX" else 12 +for n in range(1, 120): + dfact = 1 + for k in range(1, 2 * n, 2): + dfact *= k + g.check(dfact <= (2 * n)**n, "(2n - 1)!! <= (2n)^n") + g.check(math.factorial(n) * 3**n >= n**n, "n! >= (n/3)^n (from e < 3)") + # term_n = eps0^n C*^(2n) (2n)^n / n! with eps0 = 1/(12 C*^2): = (2n)^n / (12^n n!) <= (6/12)^n = 2^-n + term = F((2 * n)**n, eps_den**n * math.factorial(n)) + g.check(term <= F(1, 2**n), "series term <= 2^-n, so E exp(eps0 J^2) <= sum 2^-n = 2") +g.check(sum(F(1, 2**n) for n in range(0, 200)) < 2, "sum_{n>=0} 2^-n = 2") +for _ in range(500): + e0 = rq_pos(F(1, 100), 3) + x2 = 10 / e0 # the maximizer of x^10 exp(-e0 x^2/2) satisfies e0 x^2 = 10 + g.check(e0 * x2 == 10, "d/dx [x^10 exp(-e0 x^2/2)] = 0 at e0 x^2 = 10") + # value there: x^10 exp(-5) = (10/e0)^5 exp(-5) = (10/(e0 e))^5 + g.check(x2**5 == (10 / e0)**5, "the maximum is (10/(e0 e))^5") + A2, J2 = rq_pos(0, 9), rq_pos(0, 9) + if J2 > A2: + g.check(e0 * J2 / 2 <= e0 * J2 - e0 * A2 / 2, "on J > A: exp(e0 J^2/2) <= exp(e0 J^2) exp(-e0 A^2/2)") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G3 Lemma FT: the near-branch integral and the scaling to the failure measure +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G3 Lemma FT near branch") +rpow = 4 if MUT == "FT_R4" else 5 +for _ in range(3000): + r, Jr, Dc, Cc = rq_pos(F(1, 1000), F(1, 2), 1000), rq_pos(1, 9), rq_pos(F(1, 10), 5), rq_pos(F(1, 10), 5) + Lt, kap = 4 * Dc * r * Jr**2, Cc * r * Jr**2 + integral = Lt**3 / 3 + kap * Lt**2 / 2 # int_0^Lt l (l + kap) dl + g.check(integral == r**3 * Jr**6 * (64 * Dc**3 / 3 + 8 * Cc * Dc**2), "int_0^(4 Dcap r J^2) l (l + C r J^2) dl = O(r^3 J^6)") + weight = r**2 * Jr**4 * integral + g.check(weight == r**rpow * Jr**10 * (64 * Dc**3 / 3 + 8 * Cc * Dc**2), "r^2 J^4 * (...) = C r^5 J^10") + g.check(r**-3 * r**5 / r**2 == 1, "r^-3 (r^5 / Z_r with Z_r >= c r^2) is O(1)") +for Lam in [F(k, 2) for k in range(2, 80)]: + C0 = F(7, 3) + if Lam >= C0: + A2 = Lam / C0 + g.check(A2 * C0 == Lam, "near and |lambda| > Lambda force J^2 > Lambda/C0 = A^2") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G4 section 7, fixed layer: w = r^(-1/12), e = r^(2/3); the eleven exponents of (15) +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G4 fixed-layer exponents") +bw = F(1, 16) if MUT == "W_SIXTEENTH" else F(1, 12) # w = r^-bw +e = 1 - 4 * bw +fixed = [8 * bw, 1 + 4 * bw, e, 1 + e / 2, 1 - 2 * bw, 1 + (1 - 2 * bw) / 2, e, F(1), 2 * e, 2 - 4 * bw, 2 - 2 * bw] +g.check(fixed == [F(2, 3), F(4, 3), F(2, 3), F(4, 3), F(5, 6), F(17, 12), F(2, 3), F(1), F(4, 3), F(5, 3), F(11, 6)], "the eleven listed exponents") +g.check(min(fixed) == F(2, 3) and 3 + min(fixed) == F(11, 3), "(4): the fixed-layer mismatch is O(r^(11/3))") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G5 (18): Lambda = D log(1/r), H = 1 + Lambda, w = (r H^4)^(-1/12), e = r^(2/3) H^(-4/3); the table +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G5 (18) table") +# a monomial r^x H^y is represented by (x, y); w = r^(-1/12) H^(-1/3), e = r^(2/3) H^(-4/3) +w_ = (F(-1, 12), F(-1, 3)) +e_ = (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3)) + + +def mono(*parts): + x = sum(p[0] * k for p, k in parts) + y = sum(p[1] * k for p, k in parts) + return (x, y) + + +r_, H_ = (F(1), F(0)), (F(0), F(1)) +rows = { + "w^-8": mono((w_, -8)), + "r H^3 w^-4": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 3), (w_, -4)), + "H^4 e": mono((H_, 4), (e_, 1)), + "r H^5 sqrt(e)": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 5), (e_, F(1, 2))), + "H^3 r w^2": mono((H_, 3), (r_, 1), (w_, 2)), + "r H^4 sqrt(r w^2)": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 4), (r_, F(1, 2)), (w_, 1)), + "e": e_, + "r H^4": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 4)), + "H^3 e^2": mono((H_, 3), (e_, 2)), + "H^5 r^2 w^4": mono((H_, 5), (r_, 2), (w_, 4)), + "H^7 r^2 w^2": mono((H_, 7), (r_, 2), (w_, 2)), +} +table = { + "w^-8": (F(2, 3), F(3) if MUT == "TABLE_H3" else F(8, 3)), + "r H^3 w^-4": (F(4, 3), F(13, 3)), + "H^4 e": (F(2, 3), F(8, 3)), + "r H^5 sqrt(e)": (F(4, 3), F(13, 3)), + "H^3 r w^2": (F(5, 6), F(7, 3)), + "r H^4 sqrt(r w^2)": (F(17, 12), F(11, 3)), + "e": (F(2, 3), F(-4, 3)), + "r H^4": (F(1), F(4)), + "H^3 e^2": (F(4, 3), F(1, 3)), + "H^5 r^2 w^4": (F(5, 3), F(11, 3)), + "H^7 r^2 w^2": (F(11, 6), F(19, 3)), +} +for name, mon in rows.items(): + g.check(mon == table[name], "(18) row %s" % name) + x, y = mon + g.check(x > F(2, 3) or (x == F(2, 3) and y <= F(8, 3)), "row %s is O(r^(2/3) H^(8/3))" % name) +# the conditions (17) as r -> 0 with H ~ log(1/r): positive r-powers beat polylog factors +conds = {"r H": mono((r_, 1), (H_, 1)), "r w": mono((r_, 1), (w_, 1)), "e": e_, "H^2 e": mono((H_, 2), (e_, 1)), + "r w^2": mono((r_, 1), (w_, 2))} +for name, (x, y) in conds.items(): + g.check(x > 0, "(17): %s -> 0" % name) +g.check(w_[0] < 0, "(17): w = r^(-1/12) H^(-1/3) -> infinity, so w >= 5 eventually") +g.check(e_[0] > 0, "2 K0 e <= 1/4 eventually") +g.close() + +# ===================================================================== +# G6 normalization of the conditional laws, and the tail choice Lambda = D log(1/r) +# ===================================================================== +g = Group("G6 normalization and tails") +for _ in range(3000): + M0 = rq_pos(F(1, 10), 5) + Mstar = M0 * rq_pos(F(1, 10), 1, 1000) + m0 = M0 + m = m0 + rq(-Mstar / 4, Mstar / 4, 1000) + n0 = rq(-m0, m0, 1000) # nu_0(phi), |phi| <= 1 + tv = rq_pos(0, Mstar / 4, 1000) # ||nu - nu_0|| >= |m - m0| and >= |nu(phi) - nu_0(phi)| + if abs(m - m0) > tv: + continue + n = n0 + rq(-tv, tv, 1000) + if m < Mstar / 2: + continue + lhs = abs(n / m - n0 / m0) + g.check(lhs <= tv / m + abs(m - m0) / m <= 2 * tv / m <= 4 * tv / Mstar, "||nu/m - nu0/m0|| <= 4 ||nu - nu0||/M_*") +for cexp in [F(k, 10) for k in range(1, 30)]: + Dst = max(F(1), 1 / cexp) + g.check(cexp * Dst >= 1, "exp(-c D_* log(1/r)) = r^(c D_*) <= r") +g.close() + +# --------------------------------------------------------------------- +total = sum(t for _, _, t in RESULTS) +passed = sum(p for _, p, _ in RESULTS) +for name, p, t in RESULTS: + print("%-46s %6d/%-6d %s" % (name, p, t, "PASS" if p == t else "FAIL")) +print("mutant: %s" % (MUT if MUT else "none")) +print("total checks: %d; failures: %d" % (total, total - passed)) +for f_ in FAILS: + print(" FAIL " + f_) +sys.exit(0 if passed == total else 1) diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..60abc044c --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt @@ -0,0 +1,9 @@ +G0 Lemma JB chart and poles 16037/16037 PASS +G1 Lemma DB dyadic summation 42972/42972 PASS +G2 Lemma ES constants 1582/1582 PASS +G3 Lemma FT near branch 9075/9075 PASS +G4 fixed-layer exponents 2/2 PASS +G5 (18) table 29/29 PASS +G6 normalization and tails 1536/1536 PASS +mutant: none +total checks: 71233; failures: 0 diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_stdout.txt b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_stdout.txt new file mode 100644 index 000000000..283717623 --- /dev/null +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C124/checker_stdout.txt @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +{"checks": 601, "failures": [], "groups": {"chart": 162, "correlation": 5, "dyadic": 103, "exponential": 161, "ledger": 39, "normalization": 16, "projection": 6, "scalar_tail": 109}, "mode": "BASELINE", "scope": "finite controls only; no analytic proof"} diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/README.md b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/README.md index 2d5c828a5..6dcac48c2 100644 --- a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/README.md +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/README.md @@ -1,8 +1,8 @@ -# Planar soft-layer chain C91–C103: exact records and replayable checkers +# Planar soft-layer chain C91–C103 and C124: exact records and replayable checkers Incorporated on 3 October 2026. **Scientific effect: NONE. No new mathematics and no status change.** -This packet stores twelve reviewed objects in the repository, byte for byte: C91–C99 and C101–C103. OpenAI/Codex lanes posted them as native comments on [main#229](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229) between 00:22Z and 10:40Z on 3 October 2026. For each object the packet holds: +The original incorporation stores twelve reviewed objects in the repository, byte for byte: C91–C99 and C101–C103. OpenAI/Codex lanes posted them as native comments on [main#229](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229) between 00:22Z and 10:40Z on 3 October 2026. For each original object the packet holds: - the frozen proof; - the full nonauthor review; - the delivery note; @@ -10,6 +10,18 @@ This packet stores twelve reviewed objects in the repository, byte for byte: C91 Anthropic Claude incorporated them at the authors' request (pickups [5969536391](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5969536391) and [5969615506](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5969615506); requests listed in `SOURCES.json`). +## C124 addition: the endpoint rate at physical gap 1 + +[C124's proof](C124/PROOF.md) and [full nonauthor review](C124/REVIEW.md) add a rate for the **designated candidate's failure**, on the same fixed planar torus, compact birth set and all frames, at physical gap `k = 1`. The scaled failure raw-jet measure has variation error `O(r^(2/3) log(1/r)^(8/3))`; the failure probability is `r³(α₁ + α₂) + O(r^(11/3) log(1/r)^(8/3))`. For each fixed soft layer, the actual sector mismatch is `O(r^(11/3))`. The full determinant weight, normalizer and imported geometric/event hypotheses remain in force. + +This addition does not provide a global rate without the logarithm, a variable-gap or small-gap theorem, replacement-bar counting, a lifetime-density rate, or total variation for transported real-valued marks. It does not change the earlier objects or their reviews. See the [author control record](C124/CONTROLS.md), [independent review design](C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md), and exact identities and extraction rules in `SOURCES.json`. + +The analytic authors are OpenAI/Codex root and next_math_triage. The actual nonauthor analytic reviewer is OpenAI/Codex c99_custody_audit, with prior source exposure disclosed in the full review. OpenAI/Codex next_ui_triage incorporates these published bytes under [C126](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974325580); prior C124 source custody is disclosed. This incorporation is engineering custody, not an additional mathematical vote. + +A [second, provider-distinct review](C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md) by Anthropic Claude also records scoped acceptance without amendment. It discloses authorship of the consumed A4 input and a stake in A4.1/PD; organizational independence remains zero. Its prospective compact-gap and C98-composition observations do not expand C124's theorem. Its [independent controls](C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md) are retained separately. + +[SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json](C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json) is the unchanged manifest named by the proof and first review. Its paths describe the original delivery snapshot. The additive `source_resolution` map in this packet's `SOURCES.json` points to byte-identical files already in the repository or to the original native comment with its exact extraction rule. Parent source files are not duplicated here. + Two objects from the same run are left out: - **C100**, a reader-interface object; - **C104**, the d = 3 contact transfer, which bears on the separate C6/C8 lane (#184, #217). @@ -17,7 +29,7 @@ Two objects from the same run are left out: ## Status and attribution - **Authorship and custody stay with the authors.** The authors are OpenAI/Codex lanes, named per object in `SOURCES.json` together with the reviewer and the verdict quoted from the delivery note. Their R17 claims and Drive deliveries also stay with them. -- **Independence.** Every review is a same-account, delegated AI review. Organizational independence is **0**, and Dylan Roy's personal reading is **PENDING**. +- **Independence and current owner review.** The incorporated reviews are same-account, delegated AI work; organizational independence is **0**. Older stored records retain their historical personal-reading labels. Under the [owner clarification](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5973603003), Dylan reports reviewing work as it is done; those labels do not impose a new personal-reading or external-human wait. That owner report is distinct from AI execution and from an exact mathematical acceptance verdict. - **What governs.** Each proof's own statement, hypotheses and limits govern. The summaries below paraphrase the delivery notes and are not a substitute for them. - **Not edited here.** No other packet, `PROOF_INDEX.md`, STATUS, register or graph. @@ -37,9 +49,10 @@ Two objects from the same run are left out: | C101 | At `k = 1`, `1 − p_r = r³(α₁ + α₂) + O(r^{13/4})`, and more generally `O_β(r^{3+β})` for `0 < β < 1/2`. The failure raw-jet measure divided by `r³` converges in variation at rate `O_β(r^β)`. | `C101/` | | C102 | Original-law Gaussian transfer on a fixed compact gap interval `K ⊂ (0, ∞)`. It gives the physical-jet volume factor `r/k⁴`, correlated moment bounds, typing strips, `Z_r = r²z_r` with `z_r = z₀ + O(r)`, and `A_r = A₀ + O(r)`. | `C102/` | | C103 | Uniform on compact `K`, the designated-pair failure raw-jet measure has variation error `O_K(r^{1/4})`, and `1 − p_r = r³(α₁ + α₂) + O_K(r^{13/4})`. | `C103/` | +| C124 | At physical `k = 1`, the failure raw-jet variation error is `O(r^(2/3) log(1/r)^(8/3))`, the failure-probability remainder is `O(r^(11/3) log(1/r)^(8/3))`, and each fixed-layer sector mismatch is `O(r^(11/3))`. Retains the exact C101/A4 source hypotheses. | [Proof and review](C124/) | **Common setting.** A normalized periodized Gaussian field on a fixed planar torus. Birth heights lie in a fixed compact set, all orthonormal frames are allowed, and the full weighted normalizer is used. -- **Gap mark.** C91–C101 use gap mark `k = 1`. C102 and C103 cover a fixed compact `K` of positive gaps. +- **Gap mark.** C91–C101 and C124 use physical gap mark `k = 1`. C102 and C103 cover a fixed compact `K` of positive gaps; C124 does not upgrade their variable-gap rate. - **Soft layer.** C91–C98 work on a fixed bounded soft layer `Λ`. - **Rarity.** `E` is a rare sector of mass order `r³`, so the conditional statements are not unconditional probabilities tending to one. @@ -76,7 +89,7 @@ C99 claims no quantitative rate. C101 and C103 count each designated candidate's `replay.py` uses the standard library only. It runs four checks: 1. **Identities.** Every stored file has the identity pinned in `SOURCES.json`, and the tree holds nothing else. C96's frozen proof (7657 bytes, SHA256 `7198ff63…`) is the tail of its native comment. -2. **Fourteen checkers.** Each reproduces its published stdout. These are the independent checkers of C91–C95, C97–C99 and C101–C103, plus the author controls of C99, C101 and C103. +2. **Seventeen checkers.** Each reproduces its published stdout. These are the original fourteen independent checkers and author controls, plus C124's author controls and two independently written nonauthor checkers. C124's published baselines contain 1,740, 601 and 71,233 finite checks respectively; those counts are not theorem counts. - Five of them print the interpreter version (`SOURCES.json` records the line). On that line only, the published version is replaced by the running one, and every other byte must be identical. - The rest must match byte for byte. 3. **C102's source tree.** It is assembled in a temporary directory from the stored copies and the repository paths in `C102/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json`, each checked by size and hash first. @@ -94,6 +107,7 @@ C99 claims no quantitative rate. C101 and C103 count each designated candidate's - where published: `CHECKER_COMMENT.md`, `AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md`, `HANDOFF.md`, `COMPLETION.md` (C96) and `SOURCES_COMMENT.md` (C103). - **Checker payloads.** `checker.py` with `checker_stdout.txt`, and `author_controls.py` with `author_controls_stdout.txt`, are extracted verbatim from those comments. Each fence is saved with its final newline. - **`C102/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json`** is C102's published source manifest. +- **`C124/`** holds the exact new proof, full review, author/reviewer control comments, literal control/design extracts and their published baseline stdout. Existing C91–C103 payloads are retained byte for byte. - **`SOURCES.json`** gives the exact identities of every stored file. For each object it also records: - author, reviewer and the verdict as recorded; - the unstored pickup and ownership comments (with hashes); diff --git a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/SOURCES.json b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/SOURCES.json index bdf0406ee..78f3459e5 100644 --- a/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/SOURCES.json +++ b/frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/SOURCES.json @@ -1203,6 +1203,517 @@ "5967654152", "5967657529" ] + }, + { + "tag": "C124", + "object": "C124-PLANAR-K1-CORRELATED-BAND-ENDPOINT-LOG-RATE-20261003-v1", + "title": "A correlated saddle-level estimate and the planar endpoint rate", + "author": "OpenAI/Codex root01a0bbb5; next_math_triage author-side analytic/control contributor", + "reviewer": "OpenAI/Codex /root/c99_custody_audit; substantial prior source exposure disclosed; nonauthor of this exact proof/controls", + "verdict_as_recorded": "PASS_SCOPED; no required amendment (full native review5974327730)", + "organizational_independence": 0, + "scientific_effect": "NONE", + "incorporated_by": { + "performer": "OpenAI/Codex /root/next_ui_triage", + "role": "nonauthor scientific-payload incorporator; prior C124 source-custody exposure", + "claim": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974325580", + "R17_claim": "52794ff2-9fd5-4514-bd44-413f20555444", + "base_commit": "efc88c3fcdbd1d1384d57e2191cbcbadd557c6c6" + }, + "owner_review_context": "Owner reports ongoing review under5973603003; AI execution is separately attributed. Historical labels in frozen source records are retained, with no new external-human or repeated personal-reading gate.", + "scope": "Fixed planar torus, compact birth set, all frames and physical k=1. Failure raw-jet variation O(r^(2/3)log(1/r)^(8/3)); failure probability remainder O(r^(11/3)log(1/r)^(8/3)); fixed soft-layer sector mismatch O(r^(11/3)). Retain full weighted normalizer and imported analytic/geometric interfaces. No global no-log rate, variable-k uniformity, replacement-bar counting, lifetime-density rate, moving-mark total variation or global closure.", + "stored": [ + { + "path": "C124/PROOF.md", + "role": "exact frozen C124 mathematical proof", + "comment": "5974162498", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974162498", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:30:33Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:30:33Z", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added newline", + "bytes": 20668, + "sha256": "90148657397dcce31e8039afa9015c022f74b2ed0d41e75f2f2339074a8a520f" + }, + { + "path": "C124/REVIEW.md", + "role": "exact full nonauthor analytic review; original scope and exposure retained", + "comment": "5974327730", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974327730", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:51:24Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:51:24Z", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added newline", + "bytes": 22542, + "sha256": "19c405c68a93c3f5506629f0ebf1ffa78d5c25ad92f17fc4fd04ef0066deb6cf" + }, + { + "path": "C124/AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md", + "role": "full published author finite-controls record", + "comment": "5974185757", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974185757", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added newline", + "bytes": 23018, + "sha256": "c8387191a6b11b2e9a1f67e7f22a5ad58b667cc11d29b90fded1c0b33e459dc4" + }, + { + "path": "C124/CHECKER_COMMENT.md", + "role": "full published independent reviewer finite-controls record", + "comment": "5974332463", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974332463", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization or added newline", + "bytes": 13660, + "sha256": "78bd11456ef50d4e7652856fe31b055b544b078871419276a7fea7f6c8941c83" + }, + { + "path": "C124/author_controls.py", + "role": "author finite arithmetic controls", + "comment": "5974185757", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974185757", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick fence labelled controls.py; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 12062, + "sha256": "3cc864185ba8e9cee780544ea1559c5591bda45110745f73f0cd9b4277745bcb" + }, + { + "path": "C124/CONTROLS.md", + "role": "author design, exact execution summary and limitations", + "comment": "5974185757", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974185757", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick fence labelled CONTROLS.md; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 10113, + "sha256": "400a043d664f2ad894bbc669c38203d9809a14743522c031cc86bdbef923e399" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker.py", + "role": "independent nonauthor reviewer finite controls", + "comment": "5974332463", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974332463", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick fence labelled independent_controls.py; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 8759, + "sha256": "1d77a571133c7803704ee5e0c0dfd5f13bb0d33249748b09291205646d2c2cdc" + }, + { + "path": "C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md", + "role": "independent nonauthor reviewer design and exposure", + "comment": "5974332463", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974332463", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick fence labelled DESIGN.md; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 3213, + "sha256": "457b7a19db5ae1a9ee7dc24e08f4b277d4493d36787c9bb7d84747a3e49c0bdb" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker_stdout.txt", + "role": "published independent baseline stdout", + "comment": "5974332463", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974332463", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:06Z", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick fence labelled normal-baseline.stdout; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 255, + "sha256": "988e0f97d1a4cda0cd92c01800991d5cbd89b84e6eaa6349e477ee75b7faf25e" + }, + { + "path": "C124/author_controls_stdout.txt", + "role": "published author baseline stdout", + "comment": "5974185757", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974185757", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:33:08Z", + "extraction": "Exact JSON fence inside published CONTROLS.md fence; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 591, + "sha256": "14b587bd72fd8b16ce56791178c2fab4f57535534e5c0f4e1697daf9692cdcdd" + }, + { + "path": "C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "role": "frozen original author snapshot source identities", + "comment": "5974391189", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974391189", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T23:00:31Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T23:00:31Z", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick JSON fence; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 26552, + "sha256": "a0371bd1985358820250e0d75936d6ec5112f165824df7a9f6e29e25e3f46f6d" + }, + { + "path": "C124/SOURCES_COMMENT.md", + "role": "public manifest publication and extraction rule", + "comment": "5974391189", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974391189", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T23:00:31Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T23:00:31Z", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 body; no normalization", + "bytes": 27075, + "sha256": "0e9d94a6dcec40608faedf1e730e9913223f859457df0f5cfd7dc85eff387cf1" + }, + { + "path": "C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md", + "role": "full second provider-distinct nonauthor review; A4 authorship/stake disclosed; no organizational independence", + "comment": "5974335101", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974335101", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:29Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:29Z", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 body, including provider footer", + "bytes": 7490, + "sha256": "1ebe3e0faa30d1e2f81a4a6f292bf953811ca9ea8efa4b12f2a9ac6f4a2d5f2b" + }, + { + "path": "C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md", + "role": "full public second-review checker and execution record", + "comment": "5974337824", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974337824", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:53Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:53Z", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 body, including provider footer", + "bytes": 16409, + "sha256": "c82edca3b2305b130e25a2dff433e0a71d2f96547d5ded1e1f9bb00abf7a1e68" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker_claude.py", + "role": "second nonauthor reviewer finite exact controls", + "comment": "5974337824", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974337824", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:53Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:53Z", + "extraction": "Exact python fence under c124_exact.py; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 12724, + "sha256": "92620eb802a4400f5a77784bbe0a4b3bd4a412cb0bec1e3fbc78acf0f45c46f4" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt", + "role": "published second-review baseline stdout", + "comment": "5974337824", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974337824", + "created_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:53Z", + "updated_at": "2026-10-03T22:52:53Z", + "extraction": "Exact following text fence; terminating LF retained", + "bytes": 508, + "sha256": "fa2f4e088b61c8b4ce37647635101bb5d127be3547ada9d265a0ec0e952dee2b" + } + ], + "replays": [ + { + "name": "author_controls", + "role": "author (not independent)", + "script": "C124/author_controls.py", + "script_bytes": 12062, + "script_sha256": "3cc864185ba8e9cee780544ea1559c5591bda45110745f73f0cd9b4277745bcb", + "stdout": "C124/author_controls_stdout.txt", + "stdout_bytes": 591, + "stdout_sha256": "14b587bd72fd8b16ce56791178c2fab4f57535534e5c0f4e1697daf9692cdcdd", + "extracted_from": "5974185757", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick fence labelled controls.py; terminating LF retained; stdout: Exact JSON fence inside published CONTROLS.md fence; terminating LF retained" + }, + { + "name": "checker", + "role": "independent nonauthor reviewer; original exposure retained", + "script": "C124/checker.py", + "script_bytes": 8759, + "script_sha256": "1d77a571133c7803704ee5e0c0dfd5f13bb0d33249748b09291205646d2c2cdc", + "stdout": "C124/checker_stdout.txt", + "stdout_bytes": 255, + "stdout_sha256": "988e0f97d1a4cda0cd92c01800991d5cbd89b84e6eaa6349e477ee75b7faf25e", + "extracted_from": "5974332463", + "extraction": "Exact five-backtick fence labelled independent_controls.py; terminating LF retained; stdout: Exact five-backtick fence labelled normal-baseline.stdout; terminating LF retained" + }, + { + "name": "checker_claude", + "role": "provider-distinct nonauthor reviewer; A4 authorship disclosed", + "script": "C124/checker_claude.py", + "script_bytes": 12724, + "script_sha256": "92620eb802a4400f5a77784bbe0a4b3bd4a412cb0bec1e3fbc78acf0f45c46f4", + "stdout": "C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt", + "stdout_bytes": 508, + "stdout_sha256": "fa2f4e088b61c8b4ce37647635101bb5d127be3547ada9d265a0ec0e952dee2b", + "extracted_from": "5974337824", + "extraction": "Exact python fence and following text fence, each including its terminating LF; stdout must match byte for byte." + } + ], + "source_resolution": { + "kind": "additive incorporation metadata; original SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json bytes are unchanged", + "original_manifest_bytes": 26552, + "original_manifest_sha256": "a0371bd1985358820250e0d75936d6ec5112f165824df7a9f6e29e25e3f46f6d", + "repository_base": "efc88c3fcdbd1d1384d57e2191cbcbadd557c6c6", + "rule": "Original snapshot paths identify the reviewed delivery layout. The following map resolves equal bytes already in this repository, or the original public native source, without duplicating the parent source tree. A native proof prefix/suffix is not mislabeled as a whole comment.", + "sources": [ + { + "key": "C91", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C91.md", + "bytes": 12433, + "sha256": "74a9ee276c3647276deb544c6d83e3cf21f708f55f9009fa4db5cc49c9d0e9aa", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5963566666", + "extraction": "full native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C91/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C92", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C92.md", + "bytes": 19567, + "sha256": "6fa4c3d6d1e8c3d8590c865802d5df061ad5b17652ddc7fd7bf5c5e8b8de084a", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5963825788", + "extraction": "full native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C92/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C93", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C93.md", + "bytes": 15545, + "sha256": "f25f86cc66ae335b4832ea53670646815567ec7854fa0386f8c57f6939e0af1c", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964167051", + "extraction": "full native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C93/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C94", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C94.md", + "bytes": 15407, + "sha256": "0fe4fa2028f8ddbbf5a79df3879bcbd3789f19409fb44ad739caeabedff1af3c", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964517708", + "extraction": "full native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C94/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C95", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C95.md", + "bytes": 16185, + "sha256": "c0d9ee72352fafe91f96a8b6187c978f09ee3c187d5f4c7c2462c0187750d2e1", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5964938563", + "extraction": "full native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C95/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C96", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C96.md", + "bytes": 7657, + "sha256": "7198ff636e330749428ded6938776dad612f6bdb51ad62359b445f016df13a7a", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965141133", + "extraction": "explicitly published mathematical suffix; 256-byte native preface excluded", + "repository_paths_at_base": [], + "resolution": "original native source with the recorded extraction rule" + }, + { + "key": "C97", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C97.md", + "bytes": 16098, + "sha256": "acf83958e6ea650d83bf811b2beacc03b553637dc4a3160012567c7f0a300a57", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965421543", + "extraction": "full native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C97/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C98", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C98.md", + "bytes": 15050, + "sha256": "3ca1622197bf22cf71ab64f2938ecc0b022ed09487b691d50ae8d2ad1f46d198", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965738339", + "extraction": "full native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C98/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "P", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/P.md", + "bytes": 40261, + "sha256": "9350ad6eaba6626b93c3dedeef9e2ff816e5cdf1c8318e85fb27499141c84bc7", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md", + "frontiers/lifetime_moment_boundary_20260930/sources/P.md", + "frontiers/moving_remote_collision_20261003/sources/P.md", + "reviews/radial_moment_corollaries_20260930/P.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "E1", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/E1.md", + "bytes": 1782, + "sha256": "bad7ef609c4ad8c41ad6af562c1b6807921e19a9d556ed793ad1a0db6e202028", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/ERRATUM_CONGRUENCE.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/ERRATUM_CONGRUENCE.md", + "frontiers/lifetime_moment_boundary_20260930/sources/ERR.md", + "frontiers/moving_remote_collision_20261003/sources/E1.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "E2", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/E2.md", + "bytes": 9062, + "sha256": "845abf9f9c99d672c2a10a887b5a2e7206a3d2de3d876f35f75ff6e2dc13e62f", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/reviews/d1_section9_borel_repair_20260925/REPAIR.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "reviews/d1_section9_borel_repair_20260925/REPAIR.md", + "frontiers/lifetime_moment_boundary_20260930/sources/BOREL.md", + "frontiers/moving_remote_collision_20261003/sources/E2.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "REC", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/REC.md", + "bytes": 23312, + "sha256": "451b9d7ffee072a73fc904cab891b6693e3f233808b89df10cce1b57036b65da", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/reviews/d1_chain_reconciliation_20260928/RECONCILIATION.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "reviews/d1_chain_reconciliation_20260928/RECONCILIATION.md", + "frontiers/lifetime_moment_boundary_20260930/sources/REC.md", + "frontiers/moving_remote_collision_20261003/sources/REC.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "CUB", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/CUB.md", + "bytes": 19889, + "sha256": "117e9299a71e6139270266889eb772ed97518e402d9af029bbdb67caf9d4a0f0", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/frontiers/planar_cubic_cluster_20260929/PROOF.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_cubic_cluster_20260929/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "ELDER", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/ELDER.md", + "bytes": 39722, + "sha256": "f68038be79b46124b0f9b31205aa6e3682b34b6f5ef81f4a5697ae81f07cc46b", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/Math-/blob/044d42d5bd7f31df6f7e6b9034d6711e8fb7ee43/frontiers/local_elder_geometry_20260930/PROOF.md", + "extraction": "complete immutable Git object", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/local_elder_geometry_20260930/PROOF.md", + "frontiers/lifetime_moment_boundary_20260930/sources/MARK_2.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C96_COMPLETION", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C96_COMPLETION.md", + "bytes": 3466, + "sha256": "634fdab86ef2d568fecba9da80ccd067e3dc12849d88731648f1b09e46861603", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5965212531", + "extraction": "Exact UTF-8 native body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C96/COMPLETION.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C82_NATIVE", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C82_NATIVE.md", + "bytes": 11645, + "sha256": "1b7523bf145f03dbaf73ceae2aa256e17505bbb1c2693e339bc399c64e1654c9", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959920397", + "extraction": "Exact UTF-8 body", + "repository_paths_at_base": [], + "resolution": "original native source with the recorded extraction rule" + }, + { + "key": "C82", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C82.md", + "bytes": 11253, + "sha256": "f390ad99b07ec4eda9160191d776cfc3a53ca628976165987d9a61ab79816827", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959920397", + "extraction": "11253-byte proof prefix before native footer", + "repository_paths_at_base": [], + "resolution": "original native source with the recorded extraction rule" + }, + { + "key": "C101", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C101.md", + "bytes": 36333, + "sha256": "300d0d18abb74332e593e389485c817a3c0ea7c31345194e3cfdd4039ac3b5c4", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5967063473", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_soft_layer_chain_20261003/C101/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "C82_REVIEW", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/C82_REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 4301, + "sha256": "bf6425b5fa878aafcf60b618ba85c16c22f9b2548615f790c1a1f43d138e1e72", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5959988102", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "repository_paths_at_base": [], + "resolution": "original native source with the recorded extraction rule" + }, + { + "key": "A4", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/A4.md", + "bytes": 16544, + "sha256": "acd172c5f8626aa3b7be5ac691786eefa6d6f243a32909502dfdbd79c8066a7c", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5972396791", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/PROOF.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + }, + { + "key": "A4_REVIEW", + "original_snapshot_path": "sources/A4_REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 18420, + "sha256": "b27f530d243d92a15302026eb66731de8f50464e71941bf1a03b983713b012f8", + "original_source_url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5972610615", + "extraction": "Entire native UTF-8 comment body; no newline added", + "repository_paths_at_base": [ + "frontiers/planar_rejected_endpoint_margin_20261003/A4/REVIEW.md" + ], + "resolution": "existing byte-identical repository source" + } + ] + }, + "additional_reviews": [ + { + "reviewer": "Anthropic Claude session_01NMeKEismAyeqgdB4sy2NJU", + "verdict_as_recorded": "ACCEPT / PASS_TECHNICAL_SCOPED, no amendment for Theorem ER (1)-(18) and JB/DB/ES/FT", + "comment": "5974335101", + "url": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/229#issuecomment-5974335101", + "stored": "C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md", + "provider_distinct": true, + "organizational_independence": 0, + "exposure": "Authored consumed A4 and affected A4.1/PD; prior C91-C103 reviews; first C124 review read after own verdict; author controls unopened as recorded.", + "boundary": "O1 C98 composition and O2 compact-K/PD extension are observations, not additional claims of the frozen C124 theorem. Separate author work5974351360 remains excluded." + } + ] } ], "files": [ @@ -1605,6 +2116,86 @@ "path": "C103/author_controls_stdout.txt", "bytes": 290, "sha256": "edf94d5a85b967b80d55b6c0eab5f275b5f76a8cfaee137fccacfc9bae020ed9" + }, + { + "path": "C124/PROOF.md", + "bytes": 20668, + "sha256": "90148657397dcce31e8039afa9015c022f74b2ed0d41e75f2f2339074a8a520f" + }, + { + "path": "C124/REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 22542, + "sha256": "19c405c68a93c3f5506629f0ebf1ffa78d5c25ad92f17fc4fd04ef0066deb6cf" + }, + { + "path": "C124/AUTHOR_CONTROLS_COMMENT.md", + "bytes": 23018, + "sha256": "c8387191a6b11b2e9a1f67e7f22a5ad58b667cc11d29b90fded1c0b33e459dc4" + }, + { + "path": "C124/CHECKER_COMMENT.md", + "bytes": 13660, + "sha256": "78bd11456ef50d4e7652856fe31b055b544b078871419276a7fea7f6c8941c83" + }, + { + "path": "C124/author_controls.py", + "bytes": 12062, + "sha256": "3cc864185ba8e9cee780544ea1559c5591bda45110745f73f0cd9b4277745bcb" + }, + { + "path": "C124/CONTROLS.md", + "bytes": 10113, + "sha256": "400a043d664f2ad894bbc669c38203d9809a14743522c031cc86bdbef923e399" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker.py", + "bytes": 8759, + "sha256": "1d77a571133c7803704ee5e0c0dfd5f13bb0d33249748b09291205646d2c2cdc" + }, + { + "path": "C124/REVIEW_DESIGN.md", + "bytes": 3213, + "sha256": "457b7a19db5ae1a9ee7dc24e08f4b277d4493d36787c9bb7d84747a3e49c0bdb" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker_stdout.txt", + "bytes": 255, + "sha256": "988e0f97d1a4cda0cd92c01800991d5cbd89b84e6eaa6349e477ee75b7faf25e" + }, + { + "path": "C124/author_controls_stdout.txt", + "bytes": 591, + "sha256": "14b587bd72fd8b16ce56791178c2fab4f57535534e5c0f4e1697daf9692cdcdd" + }, + { + "path": "C124/SOURCE_IDENTITIES.json", + "bytes": 26552, + "sha256": "a0371bd1985358820250e0d75936d6ec5112f165824df7a9f6e29e25e3f46f6d" + }, + { + "path": "C124/SOURCES_COMMENT.md", + "bytes": 27075, + "sha256": "0e9d94a6dcec40608faedf1e730e9913223f859457df0f5cfd7dc85eff387cf1" + }, + { + "path": "C124/REVIEW_CLAUDE.md", + "bytes": 7490, + "sha256": "1ebe3e0faa30d1e2f81a4a6f292bf953811ca9ea8efa4b12f2a9ac6f4a2d5f2b" + }, + { + "path": "C124/CHECKER_CLAUDE_COMMENT.md", + "bytes": 16409, + "sha256": "c82edca3b2305b130e25a2dff433e0a71d2f96547d5ded1e1f9bb00abf7a1e68" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker_claude.py", + "bytes": 12724, + "sha256": "92620eb802a4400f5a77784bbe0a4b3bd4a412cb0bec1e3fbc78acf0f45c46f4" + }, + { + "path": "C124/checker_claude_stdout.txt", + "bytes": 508, + "sha256": "fa2f4e088b61c8b4ce37647635101bb5d127be3547ada9d265a0ec0e952dee2b" } ] }