diff --git a/reviews/iba2_012_log_cap_concentration_20261006/NOTE.md b/reviews/iba2_012_log_cap_concentration_20261006/NOTE.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e37ea10e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/reviews/iba2_012_log_cap_concentration_20261006/NOTE.md @@ -0,0 +1,284 @@ +# IBA2-012: a shifted count tail and growing factorial orders + +Object: IBA2-012-LOG-CAP-CONCENTRATION-20261006-v1. +Dylan Roy — delegated AI mathematical work. Actual author OpenAI / GPT-6 Astra Pro, +`iba2-concentration-continuation-20261006-r8`, pickup main#259/6008758240. +Author-exposed continuation of the FR/CT/LT lineage; organizational credit 0; +scientific effect NONE. **Conditional author-side candidate; nonauthor review required.** +No existing source, scientific status, formal target or workflow is changed. + +## 1. New scope, exact inputs, and inherited limits + +The fixed-power logarithmic bound is already LT, Math-#327. The fixed-moment +transfer and its all-order no-loss obstruction are CT, Math-#319. Neither is +claimed again. This note retains the cap-tail's dependence on log(1/r), proving +an exponential bound for a shifted, budget-scaled finite measure. It then permits +explicitly GROWING count orders without pretending fixed-order constants are +uniform. Its threshold is an inference result, not actual-field optimality. + +At source cut `07ff1191f3f99987060517b6413417287b5adf21`, the quantitative inputs are: + +| Tag | Path | Full Git blob | Consumed scope | +|---|---|---|---| +| FR | `reviews/iba2_012_finite_radius_20261005/PROOF.md` | `5ed684c9bb446efc9bef5f3980717c6dc039abfd` | Sections3–5/8: exact law, full Z, derivative-weighted event bound | +| SH | `frontiers/c6_sharpened_20260929/PROOF.md` | `70ba19726a9114bfceae04d021095e6c8eed5026` | Sections3–4 and (5.1): original-law cap tail, BEFORE first-moment assembly | +| P | `imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md` | `dfed3b8d318a3ab1950957f393307733a4bef3f2` | (4.1), moment sentence after (5.3), (5.5) | + +Provenance-only LT is `reviews/iba2_012_log_cap_transfer_20261006/NOTE.md`, blob +`b158965faf0f4113309d825ce1892743910fc028`, at its reviewed head +`e71fd6ecd59071181d4e476d0e4e87287d4488b1`. Its (dyadic) abstract family is reused +and credited in section6. LT review6008413541 does NOT review this note. CT is +blob `752bc9da5e49af3d0724d80c91cffc0dde35a2d8` at the source cut above. Neither +LT integration nor a new verdict on its ancestors is an assumption here. + +Keep FR's fixed d>=3, torus side L, physical observation radius R>=1, compact +birth interval, compact gap marks with k_->0, and compact frame space. Use its +original Gaussian pin law Q_r and its FULL tilted law P_r=Q_r^W with density +D_r=W_r/Z_r. N is the torus-wide between-pin count, N_R its local subcount, and +K>=1 is FR's fixed multiple of 1+||f||_C4. No source's other use of K is identified +with this variable. Let 1<=q<=d-2 and choose deterministic ordered thresholds +0<=eta_2<=...<=eta_(q+1)<=1/2. Set + + S_r = {h_j<=eta_j, j=2,...,q+1}, + E_r = {N_R>0} intersect S_r, + beta = q(q+7)/2, + Xi_r = product_(j=2..q+1)(eta_j+r)^(j+2), + rho_r = r^3 Xi_r. + +At r<=1/2, r^beta<=Xi_r<=1. The remaining eigenvalues have no unmentioned hard +lower bound; zero thresholds and the all-soft transverse case remain included. +FR supplies for the one fixed derivative power a>=0 + + E_(P_r)[K^a 1_Er] <= A_a rho_r. (F) + +SH supplies a measurable cap Psi>=N and fixed C_t,c,x0>0 such that + + Q_r(Psi>x) <= C_t exp[-c x^(1/d) log x], x>=x0. (T) + +Its moment/cover/Gram qualifications remain inherited. In particular this note +does not repair an invalid tail or re-audit the complex-gradient argument. The +later G_d/I5 first-moment assembly of SH is NOT consumed. All constants below +are conditional on the stated inputs at their existing scope. + +## 2. A finite measure, not a conditional probability + +Put u=log(1/r), Lambda=u/log u and X=N^(1/d)/Lambda. Reduce the common radius +cutoff so u>=u0>=8 and Lambda^d>=max(1,x0). This is possible since Lambda grows +and is increasing for u>e. No numerical field radius is supplied. + +Define a finite measure on [0,infinity) by + + mu_r(B) = rho_r^(-1) E_(P_r)[K^a 1_Er 1_{X in B}]. (M) + +Its total mass is at most A_a. rho_r is an upper-bound SCALE, not the measured +mass of E_r, and mu_r is not in general a probability measure. No lower local, +Palm, factorial or derivative-weighted event denominator is assumed. + +P supplies uniform ||D_r||_(L4(Q_r)) and ||K^a||_(L4(Q_r)). Write + + H_a = sup_r ||D_r||_4 ||K^a||_4 sqrt(C_t) < infinity. + +This follows from ||D_r||_4=||W_r/r^2||_4/(Z_r/r^2), the full floor in P(5.5), +and the fixed moment order4a in P(4.1). The density is inserted once. Correlation +among D_r,K,Psi, and E_r is unrestricted. + +**Tail lemma.** For every y>=1, + + mu_r((y,infinity)) + <= H_a exp[(beta+3-c y/2)u]. (1) + +**Proof.** Cauchy–Schwarz under ORIGINAL Q_r, then Holder on D_r K^a, gives + + E_(P_r)[K^a; E_r, X>y] + <= ||D_r K^a||_2 Q_r(Psi>(y Lambda)^d)^(1/2) + <= H_a exp[-(c/2) y Lambda log((y Lambda)^d)]. + +Only the cap EVENT is in this tail inequality, not a Psi^s factor; the exponent +is therefore one half rather than LT's four-factor one quarter. For u>=8 we +have log u>2. At t=log u>=2, t/2-log t is positive and nondecreasing. Hence +log((y Lambda)^d)>=d(log u-loglog u)>=(d/2)log u>=log u. +The exponent is at most -(c/2)y u. Finally rho_r^(-1)<=r^(-3-beta), proving (1). +Neither independence nor a global count first moment was used. + +## 3. Shifted exponential control with its actual u dependence + +Let + + y0 = max(1,4(beta+3)/c), + Y = (X-y0)_+, + kappa_r = c u/8. + +For z>=0, (1) and beta+3<=c y0/4 imply + + mu_r(Y>z) <= H_a exp[-c u(y0+z)/4]. (2) + +The original unshifted bound with y=y0+z is valid even at z=0 because Y>0 is +X>y0. The stronger inequality from (1) has a z coefficient c/2; (2) only weakens +it to c/4. + +**Exponential theorem EC.** Uniformly in r and every allowed threshold, + + integral exp[kappa_r (x-y0)_+] dmu_r(x) + <= A_a + H_a exp[-c u y0/4] <= A_a+H_a=:M_a. (EC) + +**Proof.** For a finite measure, Tonelli and exp(kY)=1+integral_0^Y k exp(kz)dz +show that the left side equals mu_r(total)+kappa_r integral_0^infinity +exp(kappa_r z) mu_r(Y>z) dz. Insert (2). Since c u/4=2 kappa_r, the exponential +integral contributes H_a exp[-c u y0/4]. This proves finiteness as well as the +bound. It is not a probability-only layer-cake identity. + +As a quantitative tail-budget consequence, for 0[Lambda(y0+z_delta)]^d on E_r by delta*rho_r. Constants are existential source +constants; this is not an evaluated numerical sampler budget. It does not +normalize by an unknown conditional-event probability. + +## 4. Uniform count-order envelope and its growing-order consequence + +For every real s>0 satisfying + + d s <= kappa_r y0 = c u y0/8, (O) + +EC implies the SAME-constant bound + + E_(P_r)[K^a N^s;E_r] + <= M_a rho_r (y0 Lambda)^(d s). (G) + +M_a,y0,c are independent of s in (O). Indeed let v=d s. The scalar inequality + + x^v <= y0^v exp[kappa_r(x-y0)_+], x>=0, (3) + +holds because it is immediate for x<=y0 and, for x>=y0, the derivative of +v log(x/y0)-kappa_r(x-y0) is v/x-kappa_r<=0 under (O). Integrate (3) in (M). +Since s>0 and 0<=N_R<=N, the same bound holds for E[K^a N_R^s;S_r]. The s=0 +case keeps E_r and uses (F); N_R^0 1_Sr is not identified with that event. + +**Growing-degree corollary.** Suppose Xi_r<=C_X r^B for some fixed B>0. For a +fixed theta with 0 0. (4) + +This also holds with the falling factorial replaced by N_R^(s(r)). To prove it, +note s(r)/u<=theta/log u->0, so (O) holds eventually with the SAME constants. +Use (N_R)_s<=N_R^s and (G). The logarithm of its upper bound, apart from a fixed +constant, is at most + + -B u + d theta (u/log u) [log u - loglog u + log y0]. (5) + +For theta -infinity. (6) + +We do not infer (4) by choosing an r-dependent p in CT or s in LT with unknown +constant dependence. It follows from EC and its explicit simultaneous envelope. +The endpoint statement is for this precise floor(theta Lambda) convention; +arbitrary sequences asymptotic to (B/d)Lambda can have consequential second-order +changes. No claim at every such critical sequence is made. + +For eta_j=r^alpha_j with fixed consistently ordered positive alpha_j, +B=sum_(j=2..q+1)(j+2)min(alpha_j,1)>0 and C_X can be 2^beta. In d3,q1,eta=r, +B=4, so (4) holds for s(r)=floor(theta Lambda) with 0