diff --git a/docs/DISCOVERY_PRIORITY_LEDGER_20260925.md b/docs/DISCOVERY_PRIORITY_LEDGER_20260925.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2144ef9d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/DISCOVERY_PRIORITY_LEDGER_20260925.md @@ -0,0 +1,143 @@ +# Discovery / priority ledger — 2026-09-25 + +**Object:** DISCOVERY-PRIORITY-LEDGER-20260925-v1 +**Purpose:** preserve candidate discoveries, nearest prior art, novelty delta and proof/review state without turning a novelty search into theorem acceptance. +**Scientific effect:** NONE. "Apparently novel" means no matching result was found in the scoped search; it is not a worldwide-first certificate. + +**Amended 2026-09-27** at queue reconciliation, answering the nonauthor review in [PR #114 comment 5848575436](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/pull/114#issuecomment-5848575436): source bindings added per row, "current state" cells aligned with `STATUS.md` (2026-09-26), and the prior art that the scoped search missed recorded under each entry. The novelty deltas below are narrowed accordingly; none is widened. + +## Candidate contributions + +| ID | Candidate contribution | Novelty assessment | Current state | +|---|---|---|---| +| DP-01 | Near-diagonal H0 lifetime law for the 3D SIDE24 periodized Gaussian field: nu(ell) ~ c ell^(-1/3) | **Strongest apparent novelty** (delta narrowed; see prior art) | Coefficient D3 is ACCEPT-scoped (#65 closed); remainder D2 is ACCEPT-scoped at its O(1) scope (#67). The leading law **rests on DP-02, whose parent §§2–7 selection chain is AMEND** (#63 reopened). Not a landed theorem. | +| DP-02 | Quantitative cubic elder-selection defect / close-pair persistence-selection control: 1-p_r=O(r^3) | **Apparently distinctive quantitative theorem** | **AMEND.** `STATUS.md` D1: the quantitative §§2–7 selection chain is reopened for independent review with an additive §5 congruence erratum; the §8–§15 interfaces were accepted. | +| DP-03 | Finite-r Hermite-before-blow-up correction for coalescing maximum–saddle pins | **New technical discovery in this project** | Exact algebraic falsifier of old rows (bound below); the replacement continuum theorem is not thereby accepted. Math- PR9 AMEND; PR16 closed SUPERSEDED/CONSUMED (candidate imported at Math- `6e4085a`); PR19 merged 2026-09-25. | +| DP-04 | Three-critical-gradient ⇒ three-small-Hessian mechanism and fixed transverse O(k r^3) witness count | **High-potential original lemma/mechanism** | OpenAI author-side candidate; independent continuum review required. Source bound below. | +| DP-05 | Collision-order / pair-intensity universality: nu(ell) ~ ell^((alpha+1)/m - 1) | **Conjectural synthesis** (m=3 is the classical fold normal form; see prior art) | Not a theorem | +| DP-06 | P15 realized-family full-probability transformed-price budget with sharp factor 1/[3-log(3e-2)] | **Likely project-specific theorem** | **ACCEPT — scoped** (`STATUS.md` D6; #74 closed 2026-09-26; Math- `reviews/p15_full_price_nonauthor_20260926/REVIEW.md` records ACCEPT on all five steps at the realized-family, demand ≥ 2 scope). Demand one remains an obstruction. | + +### Source bindings (step 2 of the protocol) + +Each row binds the earliest recoverable exact source in the public Math- repository at commit `d6628da09384728992dcbe6e921cc28ba85aebb0` (an ancestor of Math- `main`; the pinned public reading checkout in `README.md`). Bytes and SHA-256 were read back through the GitHub API on 2026-09-27. + +| ID | Math- path | Bytes | SHA-256 | +|---|---|---:|---| +| DP-01, DP-02 | `imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/UNIFORM_MATRIX_CAP_AND_LIFETIME.md` | 40261 | `9350ad6eaba6626b93c3dedeef9e2ff816e5cdf1c8318e85fb27499141c84bc7` | +| DP-02 (erratum) | `imports/lifetime_parent_20260925/ERRATUM_CONGRUENCE.md` at `5ed3b455b9a192487cedb32ad5dd8f2b90fbc1c1` | 1782 | `bad7ef609c4ad8c41ad6af562c1b6807921e19a9d556ed793ad1a0db6e202028` | +| DP-03 | `reviews/d5_finite_r_hermite_repair_20260925/C6_REMAINDERS.md` | 8054 | `8260e567e46cad8892442a5baf59cc0cbcbbeaf860edb1e234379e666e035bad` | +| DP-04 | `reviews/downstream_boundary_20260925/TRANSVERSE_BOUND_CANDIDATE.md` | 9902 | `f64c954245f17bcbc64a5ccf58a60689cf2a2fd85362f8321c0f64ff66584e36` | +| DP-05 | no source body; conjecture stated only in this ledger | — | — | +| DP-06 | `frontiers/full_price_20260924/PROOF.md` | 11352 | `87521901ca8e5405b4d1e47f1deb1cd0326affbd6f5967b53c4178590da993f9` | + +A binding records where the statement lives; it is custody, not correctness. + +## DP-01 — near-diagonal lifetime singularity + +**Candidate claim.** For the exact 3D SIDE24 periodized Gaussian model and declared H0 maximum–saddle pairing convention, + + nu_{3,24}(ell) = c_{3,24} ell^(-1/3)(1+o(1)), ell -> 0+. + +Structural mechanism: cubic persistence splitting `ell ~ kappa r^3` combined with the close-pair Kac–Rice/contact radial law. + +**Internal route.** `docs/RESEARCH_INDEX.md` routes the parent matrix-cap/lifetime proof, coefficient proof and quantitative remainder to review issues #63, #65, #67. Historical SIDE24 evidence remains provenance; use current source-bound review before citing the theorem. + +**Nearest prior art found.** +- Bobrowski & Borman (2012), *Euler Integration of Gaussian Random Fields and Persistent Homology*: expected Euler-integral descriptor, not a near-diagonal lifetime density. +- Feldbrugge et al. (JCAP 2019, DOI 10.1088/1475-7516/2019/09/052): Betti numbers/persistence diagrams of 2D Gaussian fields and critical-point formalism; no located ell^(-1/3) near-diagonal lifetime law. +- Pranav, arXiv:2109.08721: statistical persistence-diagram/intensity analysis in 3D Gaussian fields; no located analytic near-diagonal power law. +- Cadiou et al., arXiv:2003.04413: coalescing critical events under changing smoothing scale; a different parameterized critical-event problem. +- Cammarota/Marinucci/Wigman critical-value/Kac–Rice work: critical point/extrema/saddle densities and covariance degeneracies, not a persistence-pair lifetime law. + +**Prior art the scoped search missed (added 2026-09-27).** +- The close-pair radial law `r^alpha dr` is the short-range two-point function of critical points: Beliaev–Cammarota–Wigman, *Two point function for critical points of a random plane wave*, IMRN 2019(9) 2661, arXiv:1704.04943 (second factorial moment in a radius-r disc ∝ r^4, no repulsion, so unrestricted pair intensity ∝ r dr in d=2), and Azaïs–Delmas, arXiv:1911.02300, for isotropic fields in any d. DP-01 must state its α against these and explain why the #63 accounting (d−1)+3−(d+3)+2 = 1 gives α = 1 in every d. +- Chazal–Divol, *The density of expected persistence diagrams and its kernel based estimation*, JoCG 10(2) 2019, arXiv:1802.10457: density and near-diagonal behaviour of expected persistence diagrams in general. DP-01's delta is therefore "Gaussian sublevel-set law with explicit exponent and coefficient", not "near-diagonal intensity" as such. + +**Novelty delta (narrowed).** Not "persistent homology of Gaussian fields", "Kac–Rice for critical points", "close-pair critical-point intensity" or "near-diagonal density of expected diagrams". The apparent novelty is the explicit analytic exponent −1/3 and coefficient for the H0 maximum–saddle lifetime law of the declared Gaussian model, together with the collision-to-persistence selection control (DP-02) that licenses it. That control is currently AMEND. + +**Publication blockers.** Independent review of parent marked Kac–Rice/regression/normalizer/elder/domination (#63), coefficient (#65), remainder (#67); no reliance on falsified old D5 rows. + +## DP-02 — cubic elder-selection defect + +Candidate scoped statement: `1-p_r=O(r^3)` for the declared close maximum–saddle regime. The elder rule itself is classical and not ours. The scoped search did not locate a quantitative small-separation cubic failure probability connecting a local Gaussian critical pair to the actual elder-selected persistence pair. + +**Novelty delta:** quantitative local-to-global persistence-selection control, not the elder rule. + +## DP-03 — finite-r Hermite pins before singular blow-up + +The 2026-09-25 exact six-pin cubic family shows + + f_x(ru,rv)/r^2 + = 6 kappa (u^2-1/4) + q u v + (c/2) v^2, + +not the old `6 kappa u^2 + ...`. Corresponding midpoint corrections survive in the transverse derivative and cubic height coefficient. + +**Internal evidence:** Math- PR16 source-bound oracle (closed SUPERSEDED/CONSUMED 2026-09-26; candidate imported at Math- `6e4085a`); PR9 returned AMEND REQUIRED; PR19 (OpenAI-authored finite-r Hermite repair candidate) merged 2026-09-25T21:27Z. The bound source is `reviews/d5_finite_r_hermite_repair_20260925/C6_REMAINDERS.md` (table above). + +**Novelty delta:** finite-radius Hermite constraints and singular blow-up do not commute when a discarded pin residual has the same order as the blow-up denominator. Exact falsification is algebraic; replacement continuum theorem is not thereby accepted. + +## DP-04 — three critical points force three small Hessians + +On a fixed 2D scaled transverse chart away from axis/pins, the candidate mechanism is + + ||H_M|| + ||H_S|| + ||H_X|| <= C r M_3, + +hence + + |det H_M det H_S det H_X| <= C r^6 M_3^6. + +Combined with joint gradient-height density r^-6, spatial r^2, height kappa r^3 and full endpoint normalizer Z_r~r^2, this gives candidate count + + E N_j(rE) <= C kappa r^3 area(E). + +**Internal source:** Math- `reviews/downstream_boundary_20260925/TRANSVERSE_BOUND_CANDIDATE.md` (bound in the table above; originally delivered via PR16), OpenAI-authored. Independent review interfaces: endpoint regression/normalizer; corrected joint density; deterministic Hessian suppression; conditional C3 moments; weighted marked Kac–Rice. + +**Novelty delta:** scoped search did not locate this triple-Hessian suppression mechanism used to cancel the singular witness density in a persistence-pair problem. **Status: candidate, not accepted.** + +## DP-05 — persistence-collision universality conjecture + +If `ell ~ kappa r^m` and close-pair intensity is `r^alpha dr`, change of variables predicts + + nu(ell) ~ C ell^((alpha+1)/m - 1). + +SIDE24 corresponds to m=3, alpha=1, giving -1/3. Treat as a conjectural synthesis until precise hypotheses are formulated and at least one non-SIDE24 model is proved. + +**Prior art (added 2026-09-27).** The splitting `ell ~ kappa r^3` is the fold normal form: `x^3 − 3εx` has critical points at ±√ε, separation r = 2√ε and gap 4ε^{3/2} = r^3/2, so m = 3 is classical for any C^3 field and carries no novelty; the delta of DP-05 is the exponent α and the selection control only. A universality programme for random persistence already exists — Bobrowski–Skraba, arXiv:2207.03926 (experiments include Gaussian fields), Sci. Rep. 2023, and arXiv:2406.05553 — for a different statistic (the death/birth ratio); DP-05 must be stated against it. + +## DP-06 — P15 full-price realized-family theorem + +Within exact realized-family/palette hypotheses and demands >=2, the project derives a full independent-probability-range transformed-price budget with sharp factor + + rho_* = 1/[3-log(3e-2)] < 6/7. + +The earlier 16/27 factor is stronger on its smaller domain; demand-one counterexamples remain. + +Exact-expression and terminology searches found no matching theorem. This is lower-confidence novelty evidence because P15 terminology is project-specific. Review #74 closed 2026-09-26 with ACCEPT at the realized-family scope (`STATUS.md` D6); acceptance at scope is separate from novelty. + +**Prior art (added 2026-09-27).** `frontiers/full_price_20260924/PROOF.md` §7 already records Gunby–He–Narayanan, arXiv:2112.08525, and Warnke, arXiv:2310.11662; carry them here. Any priority statement must also say why the cover-cost / −log μ_p shape is not a case of Talagrand's selector-process bounds (STOC 2010) or of Frankston–Kahn–Narayanan–Park, *Thresholds versus fractional expectation-thresholds*, Ann. Math. 194 (2021). + +## Scoped literature reconnaissance + +Search date: 2026-09-25, with the additions of 2026-09-27 noted per entry. Sources/records inspected include Bobrowski–Borman; Feldbrugge et al.; Pranav/Pranav et al.; Cadiou et al.; Cammarota/Marinucci/Wigman; general elder/persistence-pair literature; exact P15 constants. Queries targeted Gaussian random fields + persistence diagrams, small persistence/lifetime/near diagonal, maximum–saddle + Kac–Rice, ell^-1/3, critical-pair coalescence, and P15 constants. + +**This does not prove worldwide priority.** It is not an exhaustive MathSciNet/Zentralblatt/dissertation/non-English/patent/unpublished-manuscript search. Require a second independent novelty audit before public "first" language. + +## Priority-preservation protocol + +1. Freeze exact statement/scope. +2. Bind earliest recoverable internal source/commit/Drive carrier and timestamp. +3. Preserve falsifiers and superseded versions. +4. Record nearest prior art and exact novelty delta. +5. Require distinct-lineage review of the current semantic digest. +6. Keep theorem status separate from novelty status. +7. For public release, use a timestamped preprint/repository release with reproducible source package once the chosen proof/review threshold is met. +8. Avoid public worldwide-first language until independent novelty review. + +## Recommended paper decomposition + +- **Paper A — Local collision theory / near-diagonal law:** DP-01 + DP-02 + corrected DP-03; DP-05 as outlook unless generalized. +- **Paper B — SIDE24 coefficient / finite-volume implementation:** coefficient, periodization/image correction, reproducibility, remainder. +- **Paper C / technical note — shrinking witness regions:** DP-04 plus axis/thin-belt/pin/intermediate/collision regions once independently closed. +- **P15 separate paper/note:** DP-06 belongs to a different combinatorial line. + +Novelty and correctness are orthogonal. diff --git a/docs/RECON_NOVELTY_20260925.md b/docs/RECON_NOVELTY_20260925.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..569fb1e36 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/RECON_NOVELTY_20260925.md @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +# Reconnaissance memo — novelty audit 2026-09-25 + +**Scope:** candidate contributions in Gaussian persistence/RN collision analysis and P15 combinatorics. **Scientific effect:** NONE. + +The literature predates this project on persistent homology of Gaussian random fields, persistence diagrams, elder pairing, Kac–Rice critical-point statistics and peak–saddle critical events. Those broad concepts are excluded from project novelty claims. + +No matching source was located for the strongest specific candidate: an analytic near-diagonal H0 persistence-lifetime law with exponent -1/3 for the declared SIDE24 Gaussian model, derived from a cubic maximum–saddle collision law plus persistence-selection control. The nearest sources found analyze GRF persistence diagrams statistically/numerically, expected Euler-persistence descriptors, critical-point/Betti statistics, or coalescence under an external smoothing parameter. + +No matching source was located for the scoped cubic elder-selection failure bound, the exact finite-r Hermite-before-blow-up correction found on 2026-09-25, or the proposed triple-Hessian suppression mechanism. The last is still an author-side candidate, so novelty does not imply correctness. + +Exact searches did not locate the P15 sharp factor 1/[3-log(3e-2)] in a matching combinatorial setting. Because P15 terminology is project-specific, this is lower-confidence novelty evidence. + +This is a bounded web/arXiv/publisher reconnaissance, not a worldwide novelty certificate. Require a second independent literature audit before public "first" language. + +**Addendum 2026-09-27.** The nonauthor challenge requested in PR #114 located prior art the scoped search missed: Beliaev–Cammarota–Wigman (arXiv:1704.04943) and Azaïs–Delmas (arXiv:1911.02300) for the close-pair critical-point intensity; the fold normal form for the cubic gap; Chazal–Divol (arXiv:1802.10457) for near-diagonal density of expected diagrams; Bobrowski–Skraba (arXiv:2207.03926, arXiv:2406.05553) for random-persistence universality; and, for P15, Talagrand (STOC 2010) and Frankston–Kahn–Narayanan–Park (Ann. Math. 2021) alongside the two references already in the proof. The ledger records the narrowed deltas. Safe public wording, if DP-01's premise is later accepted, is "we derive …; to our knowledge …", never "first". diff --git a/docs/RESEARCH_INDEX.md b/docs/RESEARCH_INDEX.md index e48d17846..d486ff868 100644 --- a/docs/RESEARCH_INDEX.md +++ b/docs/RESEARCH_INDEX.md @@ -63,6 +63,8 @@ The full-range successor removes the probability ceiling, not the demand or real Check current claims before writing and release completed work. Offered reviews are not accepted tasks or evidence of active agents. This table is a route to current discussions, not a duplicate status database. +The [discovery / priority ledger](DISCOVERY_PRIORITY_LEDGER_20260925.md) and its [reconnaissance memo](RECON_NOVELTY_20260925.md) record candidate contributions, nearest prior art and source bindings. They are novelty bookkeeping, not status; "apparently novel" is not "accepted". + ## Repository map | Repository | Responsibility |