From b55c749c937ca6d19fb8e3f9d8c436a0168656bb Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 19:44:17 -0500 Subject: [PATCH 1/6] Add source-bound typed-pair cubic-rate successor --- .../q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md | 147 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 147 insertions(+) create mode 100644 research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md diff --git a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c794183de --- /dev/null +++ b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +# Q0-C103 — Source-bound typed pair-Palm cubic-rate successor + +**Date:** 2026-09-25 +**Disposition:** AUTHOR-SIDE SOURCE-BOUND SUCCESSOR / NONCONTROLLING / REVIEW REQUIRED +**Scientific effect:** NONE. This file does not alter Q0-C101, Q0_MASTER, the claim graph, or any frozen status. + +## 1. Object identity + +Let the exact normalized periodized Bargmann–Fock field live on the two-torus of side 24. For 0 < r <= 0.025 put + + M = x - (r/2)t, S = x + (r/2)t, + +and impose the six pins + + f(M)=b, f(S)=b-r^3/6, grad f(M)=grad f(S)=0. + +Condition on M being a maximum and S an index-one saddle with the determinant-pair weight. Let P_MS(r,b) denote this typed maximum–saddle pair-Palm law and define + + q_MS(r,b) := P_MS(r,b){ D(M)=S }, + +where D(M) is the elder-rule merging saddle of the component born at M. + +This object is deliberately named q_MS. Historical core-pairing sources also contain an adjacency-conditioned quantity called q. This successor does NOT assert equality between that older adjacency object and q_MS. If a later controlling source aliases q to this exact typed pair-Palm object, that alias must be stated and reviewed separately. + +## 2. Conditional theorem + +Assume: + +1. the field is Morse with distinct critical values; +2. there is no index-one saddle–saddle heteroclinic connection, so the deterministic Morse–Smale reduction in Section 3 applies; +3. the exact source-bound Kac–Rice, collar, near, fixed-annulus and exterior estimates listed in Section 4 hold at their stated domains. + +Then there is a finite constant C, uniform for 0 < r <= 0.025, such that + + 0 <= 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= C r^3. + +Consequently q_MS(r,6/5) -> 1 as r -> 0. + +No numerical value of C is claimed. + +## 3. Deterministic reduction + +The exact source C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION proves, under the stated genericity assumptions, + + {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma. + +Pi is interception by an additional relevant critical point in the value window/collars, and Gamma is the event that the second ascending branch of S reaches a maximum with gain in (0,r^3/6). The loop/crater alternative is absorbed by the same interceptor event. The reduction is topological and does not use probabilistic independence. + +Hence + + 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= P_MS(Pi) + P_MS(Gamma). + +## 4. Source-bound probabilistic estimates + +Every load-bearing source below is named by exact repository path and Git blob in Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json. + +### C1 — deterministic defect inclusion + +Source: C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION.md, blob 25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0. + +### C2/C3/C4 — global interceptor count + +Source: C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md, blob 1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0. + +It uses the typed pair-Palm Kac–Rice intensity and partitions the torus into collars, the singular pair-scaled region, a fixed annulus and the exterior. + +The singular ledger is read with every factor retained. At witness radius t: + +- value/gradient density: O(t^-6); +- three physical Hessian determinants together: O(r^6); +- pair-Palm normalizer denominator: Z_r >= c r^2; +- value-window width: O(r^3); +- planar polar area: t dt. + +Therefore the singular contribution is bounded by + + C r^-2 r^6 r^3 integral_{c r}^{t0} t^-6 t dt + = C r^7 integral_{c r}^{t0} t^-5 dt + = O(r^3). + +This is the corrected exponent ledger. The shorter standalone C101 prose that omitted the area/normalizer bookkeeping is not used as the proof of this line. + +### C5 — direct-gain Gamma / maximum window + +The inclusion Gamma subseteq {additional maximum in (b-r^3/6,b)} is combined with: + +- exterior transfer: C098_GAMMA_EXTERIOR_TRANSFER.md, blob 3e3037b6dbe57d98b7b5932fb1db62b8e8c29ea6; +- pair-scaled near maximum no-go and residual integral: C099_NEAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md, blob dddf55a3356823b34f333da28ba1e6551f1db5bc; +- collar maximum count: C100_COLLAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md, blob 04d6e1c5a012d1a0e87abe8c9c2e3f7e921478a8. + +The older conditional Malliavin route C097_GAMMA_DENSITY_REDUCTION is not consumed by this successor. + +### C6 — collar residues + +Source: C100_COLLAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md, blob 04d6e1c5a012d1a0e87abe8c9c2e3f7e921478a8. + +For y=r xi it gives gradient density r^-3, three-determinant factor r^6 and pair-Palm normalizer r^2, hence physical intensity r F_r(xi). Near a conditioned endpoint the rho^-2 density singularity is cancelled by the rho^2 determinant zero; the axis is exponentially suppressed. Physical area r^2 dxi then yields O(r^3). + +### C7 — chart coverage and finite-jet nondegeneracy + +- C102_CHART_ATLAS.md, blob 38a849f6725d76e310faebf17e21a7faadf87454; +- C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY.md, blob 1bea9e62ef1ec621f51953dd3f5d5410fba616af. + +These sources cover the pair-corrected, max-near generic/axis/transverse, collar generic/pin/axis/transverse, interceptor, fixed-annulus, exterior and type-boundary charts used by the T1 estimates. + +## 5. Genericity / SARD-G gate + +The full-Gaussian corollary additionally requires the almost-sure genericity input, including exclusion of saddle–saddle heteroclinic connections. + +Current source: the 19,242-byte Gaussian transversality working source, Git blob a0f4aa6ab6d0e21e7a24b4a6e1aa4fdebc40efdc. + +Its conservative theorem remains conditional on Sections 8–11 charting/measurability/exceptional-parameter interfaces. + +Specialist review KIMI-AUD-022, Git blob e968385a3bf4e8318a9ab6cb4f57818828f01b18, verifies the architecture and many individual identities, assesses several remaining steps as standard, but explicitly leaves execution-level Clarification A (measurable-selection/chart bookkeeping) and Clarification C (endpoint coefficient formulas or an exact citation package). + +Therefore this successor separates two levels: + +- Conditional generic-field theorem: Sections 2–4 above, assuming the genericity hypotheses. +- Full-Gaussian corollary: HOLD-WITH-DOMAIN until the SARD-G execution-level Clarifications A/C are supplied by exact source objects and reviewed. + +No review label alone is treated as a substitute for those missing execution details. + +## 6. Uniformity in r + +The domain 0 < r <= 0.025 is inherited only from the exact T1 companion sources. Each regional constant must be uniform on its declared compact chart and the finite chart cover. This successor does not manufacture a larger radius or extrapolate beyond the stated range. + +## 7. Squeeze + +Under the conditional hypotheses and source-bound regional estimates, + + P_MS(Pi) <= C_Pi r^3, P_MS(Gamma) <= C_Gamma r^3, + +so + + 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= (C_Pi + C_Gamma) r^3. + +Since r^3 -> 0, the selection limit follows. + +## 8. What this successor repairs + +- It fixes object identity by using q_MS instead of an overloaded historical q. +- It binds every load-bearing regional estimate to exact source objects. +- It prints the complete singular power ledger, including normalizer, height and area factors. +- It separates the generic-field theorem from the not-yet-fully-executed SARD-G full-Gaussian corollary. +- It does not claim a numerical upper coefficient, a lower bound, a 3D theorem, Theorem B, or RN/JETMOD closure. + +Independent review should return C1–C8 dispositions against this exact successor and separately classify the SARD-G full-Gaussian gate. From 0e7ab10948e73d62304c937b8e96b7e786366939 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 19:44:21 -0500 Subject: [PATCH 2/6] Bind Q0-C103 to exact regional and genericity sources --- research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json | 60 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 60 insertions(+) create mode 100644 research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json diff --git a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..52e958c35 --- /dev/null +++ b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "object": "Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP_20260925", + "scientific_effect": "NONE", + "theorem_object": "q_MS(r,b)=P_MS(r,b){D(M)=S}", + "controlling_alias_to_historical_q": false, + "review_required": true, + "sources": [ + { + "id": "C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION.md", + "git_blob": "25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0" + }, + { + "id": "C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md", + "git_blob": "1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0" + }, + { + "id": "C098_GAMMA_EXTERIOR_TRANSFER", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C098_GAMMA_EXTERIOR_TRANSFER.md", + "git_blob": "3e3037b6dbe57d98b7b5932fb1db62b8e8c29ea6" + }, + { + "id": "C099_NEAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C099_NEAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md", + "git_blob": "dddf55a3356823b34f333da28ba1e6551f1db5bc" + }, + { + "id": "C100_COLLAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C100_COLLAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md", + "git_blob": "04d6e1c5a012d1a0e87abe8c9c2e3f7e921478a8" + }, + { + "id": "C102_CHART_ATLAS", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T2 — SARD-G Transversality/02_SUPPORTING_CERTIFICATES_AND_ATLAS/C102_CHART_ATLAS.md", + "git_blob": "38a849f6725d76e310faebf17e21a7faadf87454" + }, + { + "id": "C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T2 — SARD-G Transversality/02_SUPPORTING_CERTIFICATES_AND_ATLAS/C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY.md", + "git_blob": "1bea9e62ef1ec621f51953dd3f5d5410fba616af" + }, + { + "id": "SARD_G_WORKING_SOURCE", + "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T2 — SARD-G Transversality/01_TRANSVERSALITY_MANUSCRIPTS/02_GAUSSIAN_TRANSVERSALITY — WORKING-SOURCE — 19242B — SHA4a77f3b7 — ID19G4QeIu.md", + "git_blob": "a0f4aa6ab6d0e21e7a24b4a6e1aa4fdebc40efdc" + }, + { + "id": "KIMI_AUD_022", + "path": "drive/mirrors/2026-08-03-to-08-06_KIMI_AO48_LB-RATE_K3_INTAKE/01_AUDITS_AND_RECONCILIATION/KIMI-AUD-022 - SARD-G specialist review APPROVE WITH CLARIFICATIONS - byte-exact export 9527 B whole-file 8efcd937 body b00f0721 - closes the pending-export line - landed by AO48 per AUD-062", + "git_blob": "e968385a3bf4e8318a9ab6cb4f57818828f01b18" + } + ], + "gates": { + "conditional_typed_pair_cubic_rate": "REVIEW_PENDING", + "full_gaussian_corollary": "HOLD_WITH_DOMAIN", + "sard_g_clarification_A": "OPEN_EXECUTION_DETAIL", + "sard_g_clarification_C": "OPEN_EXECUTION_DETAIL" + } +} From c688df75e9c48ec9b41287384b9825812e9dcb4a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 01:24:05 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 3/6] fix(q0-c103): C1 branch-attached object + C2 PREMISE-Z-LOWER MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Honesty repair per PR121 review 5841690735 / #98 lane release: - C1: withdraw false C102 inclusion transfer; condition cubic theorem on H_branch; name B_miss as unresolved defect class. - C2: isolate Z_r >= c r^2 as named unresolved PREMISE-Z-LOWER. Preserve q_MS ≠ historical q; do not redesign C3–C8; no status promotion. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- .../q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md | 76 ++++++++++++++----- research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json | 36 ++++++++- 2 files changed, 88 insertions(+), 24 deletions(-) diff --git a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md index c794183de..85e00f317 100644 --- a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md +++ b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md @@ -3,6 +3,7 @@ **Date:** 2026-09-25 **Disposition:** AUTHOR-SIDE SOURCE-BOUND SUCCESSOR / NONCONTROLLING / REVIEW REQUIRED **Scientific effect:** NONE. This file does not alter Q0-C101, Q0_MASTER, the claim graph, or any frozen status. +**C1/C2 repair tip:** 2026-09-26 author-side honesty repair (branch-attached object + named Z-lower premise). Does not touch C3–C8 regional arithmetic beyond restating their dependence on those two gates. No status promotion. ## 1. Object identity @@ -22,34 +23,52 @@ where D(M) is the elder-rule merging saddle of the component born at M. This object is deliberately named q_MS. Historical core-pairing sources also contain an adjacency-conditioned quantity called q. This successor does NOT assert equality between that older adjacency object and q_MS. If a later controlling source aliases q to this exact typed pair-Palm object, that alias must be stated and reviewed separately. -## 2. Conditional theorem +### 1.1 Branch-attached conditioning (C1 repair) + +C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION (blob `25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0`) proves + + {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma + +only after assuming **H_branch**: one ascending branch of S already terminates at M (together with Morse, distinct critical values, and Morse–Smale). Those genericity hypotheses alone do **not** force the attachment; a Morse–Smale field may realize the six pins with D(M) != S, no window interceptor, and both ascending branches of S ending at maxima outside (f(S), f(M)). + +Therefore this successor treats the cubic-rate claim as a **branch-attached conditional object**: the theorem below is stated under H_branch. It does not claim a proved O(r^3) bound for the complementary branch-miss event + + B_miss := { neither ascending branch of S terminates at M }. + +B_miss remains an unresolved named defect class (no source-bound cubic envelope in this tip). + +## 2. Conditional theorem (branch-attached) Assume: 1. the field is Morse with distinct critical values; -2. there is no index-one saddle–saddle heteroclinic connection, so the deterministic Morse–Smale reduction in Section 3 applies; -3. the exact source-bound Kac–Rice, collar, near, fixed-annulus and exterior estimates listed in Section 4 hold at their stated domains. +2. there is no index-one saddle–saddle heteroclinic connection (Morse–Smale), so every ascending branch of an index-one saddle terminates at a local maximum; +3. **H_branch**: one ascending branch of S terminates at M (exact C102 attachment hypothesis); +4. **PREMISE-Z-LOWER**: the typed pair-Palm normalizer satisfies Z_r >= c r^2 for some c > 0, uniformly for 0 < r <= 0.025 at the compact mark scope used below (see Section 4 / C2); +5. the exact source-bound Kac–Rice, collar, near, fixed-annulus and exterior estimates listed in Section 4 hold at their stated domains, reading every division by Z_r under PREMISE-Z-LOWER. Then there is a finite constant C, uniform for 0 < r <= 0.025, such that - 0 <= 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= C r^3. + 0 <= 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= C r^3 -Consequently q_MS(r,6/5) -> 1 as r -> 0. +on the H_branch-conditioned typed pair-Palm law. Consequently, under those same hypotheses, q_MS(r,6/5) -> 1 as r -> 0. -No numerical value of C is claimed. +No numerical value of C is claimed. Without H_branch, or without PREMISE-Z-LOWER, this tip does not assert the cubic envelope. -## 3. Deterministic reduction +## 3. Deterministic reduction (under H_branch) -The exact source C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION proves, under the stated genericity assumptions, +The exact source C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION proves, under Morse + distinct critical values + Morse–Smale + **H_branch**, {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma. Pi is interception by an additional relevant critical point in the value window/collars, and Gamma is the event that the second ascending branch of S reaches a maximum with gain in (0,r^3/6). The loop/crater alternative is absorbed by the same interceptor event. The reduction is topological and does not use probabilistic independence. -Hence +Hence, **on the H_branch event**, 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= P_MS(Pi) + P_MS(Gamma). +This is not a claim that {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma holds for the unconditioned typed pair-Palm law. The unconditioned defect set also meets B_miss, which is out of scope for the cubic bound in this tip. + ## 4. Source-bound probabilistic estimates Every load-bearing source below is named by exact repository path and Git blob in Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json. @@ -58,17 +77,31 @@ Every load-bearing source below is named by exact repository path and Git blob i Source: C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION.md, blob 25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0. -### C2/C3/C4 — global interceptor count +Consumed only under H_branch as in Sections 1.1 and 3. The false transfer that cited Pi cup Gamma under Morse + Morse–Smale alone is withdrawn. + +### C2 — typed pair-Palm / Kac–Rice normalization (named unresolved premise) + +Sources: C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md, blob 1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0; with companion intensity statements in C098/C100 as mapped. + +C101 §2 and C100 §2 write the typed intensity: pins J_6, weight W_MS = |det H_M det H_S| 1_{H_M ≺ 0} 1_{det H_S < 0}, normalizer Z_r = E[W_MS | J_6], with no second typing division. C098’s Hessian count gives det H_M, det H_S = O(r), hence W_MS = O(r^2), which bounds the numerator. Positivity of a limiting z_0 (and the diagnostic 3.230979 / three-row table) is marked as input, not a proved uniform floor. + +**PREMISE-Z-LOWER (unresolved in this tip):** there exists c > 0 such that + + Z_r >= c r^2 for all 0 < r <= 0.025 + +at the exact compact-mark scope of the successor (mark b = 6/5 under the six-pin typed law). No source-bound proof of this lower bound is supplied here; every regional estimate that divides by Z_r is conditional on this premise. A later tip may discharge it by an exact proof object or keep it as a named open premise. + +### C3/C4 — global interceptor count / singular ledger Source: C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md, blob 1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0. It uses the typed pair-Palm Kac–Rice intensity and partitions the torus into collars, the singular pair-scaled region, a fixed annulus and the exterior. -The singular ledger is read with every factor retained. At witness radius t: +Reading the singular ledger with every factor retained, and **assuming PREMISE-Z-LOWER**, at witness radius t: - value/gradient density: O(t^-6); - three physical Hessian determinants together: O(r^6); -- pair-Palm normalizer denominator: Z_r >= c r^2; +- pair-Palm normalizer denominator: Z_r >= c r^2 (premise, not proved here); - value-window width: O(r^3); - planar polar area: t dt. @@ -78,7 +111,7 @@ Therefore the singular contribution is bounded by = C r^7 integral_{c r}^{t0} t^-5 dt = O(r^3). -This is the corrected exponent ledger. The shorter standalone C101 prose that omitted the area/normalizer bookkeeping is not used as the proof of this line. +This is the corrected exponent ledger. The shorter standalone C101 prose that omitted the area/normalizer bookkeeping is not used as the proof of this line. Without PREMISE-Z-LOWER the division step is not discharged. ### C5 — direct-gain Gamma / maximum window @@ -88,20 +121,20 @@ The inclusion Gamma subseteq {additional maximum in (b-r^3/6,b)} is combined wit - pair-scaled near maximum no-go and residual integral: C099_NEAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md, blob dddf55a3356823b34f333da28ba1e6551f1db5bc; - collar maximum count: C100_COLLAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md, blob 04d6e1c5a012d1a0e87abe8c9c2e3f7e921478a8. -The older conditional Malliavin route C097_GAMMA_DENSITY_REDUCTION is not consumed by this successor. +The older conditional Malliavin route C097_GAMMA_DENSITY_REDUCTION is not consumed by this successor. (C5 content otherwise unchanged; still review-pending.) ### C6 — collar residues Source: C100_COLLAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md, blob 04d6e1c5a012d1a0e87abe8c9c2e3f7e921478a8. -For y=r xi it gives gradient density r^-3, three-determinant factor r^6 and pair-Palm normalizer r^2, hence physical intensity r F_r(xi). Near a conditioned endpoint the rho^-2 density singularity is cancelled by the rho^2 determinant zero; the axis is exponentially suppressed. Physical area r^2 dxi then yields O(r^3). +For y=r xi it gives gradient density r^-3, three-determinant factor r^6 and pair-Palm normalizer r^2, hence physical intensity r F_r(xi). Near a conditioned endpoint the rho^-2 density singularity is cancelled by the rho^2 determinant zero; the axis is exponentially suppressed. Physical area r^2 dxi then yields O(r^3). The normalizer step is read under PREMISE-Z-LOWER. (C6 content otherwise unchanged.) ### C7 — chart coverage and finite-jet nondegeneracy - C102_CHART_ATLAS.md, blob 38a849f6725d76e310faebf17e21a7faadf87454; - C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY.md, blob 1bea9e62ef1ec621f51953dd3f5d5410fba616af. -These sources cover the pair-corrected, max-near generic/axis/transverse, collar generic/pin/axis/transverse, interceptor, fixed-annulus, exterior and type-boundary charts used by the T1 estimates. +These sources cover the pair-corrected, max-near generic/axis/transverse, collar generic/pin/axis/transverse, interceptor, fixed-annulus, exterior and type-boundary charts used by the T1 estimates. (C7 content unchanged.) ## 5. Genericity / SARD-G gate @@ -115,7 +148,7 @@ Specialist review KIMI-AUD-022, Git blob e968385a3bf4e8318a9ab6cb4f57818828f01b1 Therefore this successor separates two levels: -- Conditional generic-field theorem: Sections 2–4 above, assuming the genericity hypotheses. +- Conditional generic-field theorem: Sections 2–4 above, assuming the genericity hypotheses, **H_branch**, and **PREMISE-Z-LOWER**. - Full-Gaussian corollary: HOLD-WITH-DOMAIN until the SARD-G execution-level Clarifications A/C are supplied by exact source objects and reviewed. No review label alone is treated as a substitute for those missing execution details. @@ -126,7 +159,7 @@ The domain 0 < r <= 0.025 is inherited only from the exact T1 companion sources. ## 7. Squeeze -Under the conditional hypotheses and source-bound regional estimates, +Under H_branch, PREMISE-Z-LOWER, the conditional hypotheses, and source-bound regional estimates, P_MS(Pi) <= C_Pi r^3, P_MS(Gamma) <= C_Gamma r^3, @@ -134,7 +167,7 @@ so 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= (C_Pi + C_Gamma) r^3. -Since r^3 -> 0, the selection limit follows. +Since r^3 -> 0, the selection limit follows **on that conditioned object**. The squeeze does not bound B_miss and does not discharge PREMISE-Z-LOWER. ## 8. What this successor repairs @@ -142,6 +175,9 @@ Since r^3 -> 0, the selection limit follows. - It binds every load-bearing regional estimate to exact source objects. - It prints the complete singular power ledger, including normalizer, height and area factors. - It separates the generic-field theorem from the not-yet-fully-executed SARD-G full-Gaussian corollary. -- It does not claim a numerical upper coefficient, a lower bound, a 3D theorem, Theorem B, or RN/JETMOD closure. +- **C1:** withdraws the false transfer of C102’s inclusion without H_branch; states a branch-attached conditional theorem and names B_miss as unresolved. +- **C2:** isolates Z_r >= c r^2 as named unresolved premise PREMISE-Z-LOWER rather than treating it as proved. +- It does not claim a numerical upper coefficient, a lower bound for 1-q_MS beyond the conditional cubic envelope, a 3D theorem, Theorem B, or RN/JETMOD closure. +- C3–C8 regional contents are not redesigned in this tip; they inherit the two gates above. Independent review should return C1–C8 dispositions against this exact successor and separately classify the SARD-G full-Gaussian gate. diff --git a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json index 52e958c35..6b1f97ad6 100644 --- a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json +++ b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json @@ -1,19 +1,27 @@ { "object": "Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP_20260925", "scientific_effect": "NONE", - "theorem_object": "q_MS(r,b)=P_MS(r,b){D(M)=S}", + "theorem_object": "q_MS(r,b)=P_MS(r,b){D(M)=S} under H_branch", "controlling_alias_to_historical_q": false, "review_required": true, + "c1_c2_repair": { + "as_of": "2026-09-26", + "H_branch": "one ascending branch of S terminates at M (C102 attachment hypothesis)", + "B_miss": "neither ascending branch of S terminates at M — unresolved named defect class; no O(r^3) envelope in this tip", + "PREMISE_Z_LOWER": "Z_r >= c r^2 on 0 < r <= 0.025 at compact mark scope — named unresolved premise; not proved here" + }, "sources": [ { "id": "C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION", "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION.md", - "git_blob": "25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0" + "git_blob": "25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0", + "consumed_under": ["H_branch", "Morse", "distinct_critical_values", "Morse-Smale"] }, { "id": "C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE", "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md", - "git_blob": "1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0" + "git_blob": "1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0", + "notes": "Typed intensity and singular ledger; Z_r >= c r^2 asserted in source is PREMISE-Z-LOWER here, not discharged." }, { "id": "C098_GAMMA_EXTERIOR_TRANSFER", @@ -51,8 +59,28 @@ "git_blob": "e968385a3bf4e8318a9ab6cb4f57818828f01b18" } ], + "unresolved_premises": [ + { + "id": "H_branch", + "statement": "One ascending branch of S terminates at M (C102 attachment hypothesis).", + "role": "conditions the C1 defect inclusion and the cubic theorem object" + }, + { + "id": "B_miss", + "statement": "Neither ascending branch of S terminates at M.", + "role": "named unresolved defect class; no source-bound O(r^3) envelope in this tip" + }, + { + "id": "PREMISE-Z-LOWER", + "statement": "Z_r >= c r^2 for some c > 0, uniformly on 0 < r <= 0.025 at compact mark b = 6/5 under the six-pin typed law.", + "role": "required for every regional estimate that divides by the pair-Palm normalizer; not proved here" + } + ], "gates": { - "conditional_typed_pair_cubic_rate": "REVIEW_PENDING", + "conditional_typed_pair_cubic_rate": "REVIEW_PENDING_BRANCH_ATTACHED", + "H_branch": "EXPLICIT_HYPOTHESIS", + "B_miss_cubic_envelope": "UNRESOLVED", + "PREMISE_Z_LOWER": "UNRESOLVED", "full_gaussian_corollary": "HOLD_WITH_DOMAIN", "sard_g_clarification_A": "OPEN_EXECUTION_DETAIL", "sard_g_clarification_C": "OPEN_EXECUTION_DETAIL" From 079615e05a92048519c255cec2d86c981160cbf5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 22:31:29 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 4/6] fix(q0-c103): C1 name q_MS^br + PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit AMEND per #124 review 5850461900 finding 1 (option a): - theorem object is q_MS^br = P_MS(D(M)=S | H_branch) - partition 1-q_MS into joint H_branch and B_miss∩{D(M)≠S} terms - add PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS for the conditional cubic - unresolved envelope is B_miss∩{D(M)≠S}, not B_miss alone Also: PREMISE-Z-LOWER as liminf_{r↓0}; singular lower limit (√15/2)r. No C3–C8 redesign; no status promotion. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- .../q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md | 125 ++++++++++++------ research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json | 44 +++--- 2 files changed, 111 insertions(+), 58 deletions(-) diff --git a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md index 85e00f317..6a82a3216 100644 --- a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md +++ b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_BOUND_CUBIC_RATE.md @@ -3,7 +3,8 @@ **Date:** 2026-09-25 **Disposition:** AUTHOR-SIDE SOURCE-BOUND SUCCESSOR / NONCONTROLLING / REVIEW REQUIRED **Scientific effect:** NONE. This file does not alter Q0-C101, Q0_MASTER, the claim graph, or any frozen status. -**C1/C2 repair tip:** 2026-09-26 author-side honesty repair (branch-attached object + named Z-lower premise). Does not touch C3–C8 regional arithmetic beyond restating their dependence on those two gates. No status promotion. +**C1/C2 repair tip:** 2026-09-26 author-side honesty repair (branch-attached object + named Z-lower premise). Does not touch C3–C8 regional arithmetic beyond restating their dependence on those gates. No status promotion. +**C1 object AMEND tip:** 2026-09-26 — names conditioned object `q_MS^br`, joint-event identity for `1 − q_MS`, and unresolved envelope `B_miss ∩ {D(M)≠S}` (review 5850461900). ## 1. Object identity @@ -15,7 +16,7 @@ and impose the six pins f(M)=b, f(S)=b-r^3/6, grad f(M)=grad f(S)=0. -Condition on M being a maximum and S an index-one saddle with the determinant-pair weight. Let P_MS(r,b) denote this typed maximum–saddle pair-Palm law and define +Condition on M being a maximum and S an index-one saddle with the determinant-pair weight. Let P_MS(r,b) denote this typed maximum–saddle pair-Palm law and define the **unconditioned** selection probability q_MS(r,b) := P_MS(r,b){ D(M)=S }, @@ -23,51 +24,80 @@ where D(M) is the elder-rule merging saddle of the component born at M. This object is deliberately named q_MS. Historical core-pairing sources also contain an adjacency-conditioned quantity called q. This successor does NOT assert equality between that older adjacency object and q_MS. If a later controlling source aliases q to this exact typed pair-Palm object, that alias must be stated and reviewed separately. -### 1.1 Branch-attached conditioning (C1 repair) +### 1.1 Branch event and conditioned object (C1) C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION (blob `25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0`) proves {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma -only after assuming **H_branch**: one ascending branch of S already terminates at M (together with Morse, distinct critical values, and Morse–Smale). Those genericity hypotheses alone do **not** force the attachment; a Morse–Smale field may realize the six pins with D(M) != S, no window interceptor, and both ascending branches of S ending at maxima outside (f(S), f(M)). +only after assuming **H_branch**: one ascending branch of S already terminates at M (together with Morse, distinct critical values, and Morse–Smale). Those genericity hypotheses alone do **not** force the attachment. -Therefore this successor treats the cubic-rate claim as a **branch-attached conditional object**: the theorem below is stated under H_branch. It does not claim a proved O(r^3) bound for the complementary branch-miss event +Define the complementary branch-miss event B_miss := { neither ascending branch of S terminates at M }. -B_miss remains an unresolved named defect class (no source-bound cubic envelope in this tip). +Note: B_miss does **not** imply D(M) ≠ S. The component of M just above f(S) can already contain an arm of S via a maximum N ≠ M merged into it, with the other arm in an older component. The unresolved defect class that escapes Π ∪ Γ is therefore the joint event -## 2. Conditional theorem (branch-attached) + B_miss ∩ {D(M) ≠ S}, + +not B_miss alone. + +Partition identity (always): + + 1 - q_MS + = P_MS( {D(M)≠S} ∩ H_branch ) + P_MS( {D(M)≠S} ∩ B_miss ). + +C102 licenses only the joint-event inequality + + P_MS( {D(M)≠S} ∩ H_branch ) <= P_MS(Pi) + P_MS(Gamma). + +It does **not** license a restriction of the number `1 − q_MS` “to the H_branch event.” + +Define the **branch-conditioned selection object** + + q_MS^br(r,b) := P_MS( D(M)=S | H_branch ). + +Then, on H_branch, + + 1 - q_MS^br = P_MS( {D(M)≠S} | H_branch ) + = P_MS( {D(M)≠S} ∩ H_branch ) / P_MS(H_branch), + +so a cubic bound on the joint event becomes a cubic bound on `1 − q_MS^br` only after dividing by P_MS(H_branch). That mass is isolated as **PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS** below. This tip’s cubic theorem is stated for `q_MS^br`, not for the unconditioned `q_MS`. + +## 2. Conditional theorem (branch-conditioned object) Assume: 1. the field is Morse with distinct critical values; 2. there is no index-one saddle–saddle heteroclinic connection (Morse–Smale), so every ascending branch of an index-one saddle terminates at a local maximum; -3. **H_branch**: one ascending branch of S terminates at M (exact C102 attachment hypothesis); -4. **PREMISE-Z-LOWER**: the typed pair-Palm normalizer satisfies Z_r >= c r^2 for some c > 0, uniformly for 0 < r <= 0.025 at the compact mark scope used below (see Section 4 / C2); -5. the exact source-bound Kac–Rice, collar, near, fixed-annulus and exterior estimates listed in Section 4 hold at their stated domains, reading every division by Z_r under PREMISE-Z-LOWER. +3. **H_branch** is the C102 attachment event (one ascending branch of S terminates at M); +4. **PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS**: inf_{0 < r <= 0.025} P_MS(H_branch) > 0 at the compact mark scope used below; +5. **PREMISE-Z-LOWER**: liminf_{r ↓ 0} Z_r / r^2 > 0 at that mark scope (see Section 4 / C2); on any compact interval [δ, 0.025] ⊂ (0, 0.025], positivity of Z_r follows from continuity once the jet Gram is positive definite (C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY), so the load-bearing gap is the liminf at zero; +6. the exact source-bound Kac–Rice, collar, near, fixed-annulus and exterior estimates listed in Section 4 hold at their stated domains, reading every division by Z_r under PREMISE-Z-LOWER. Then there is a finite constant C, uniform for 0 < r <= 0.025, such that - 0 <= 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= C r^3 + 0 <= 1 - q_MS^br(r,6/5) <= C r^3. -on the H_branch-conditioned typed pair-Palm law. Consequently, under those same hypotheses, q_MS(r,6/5) -> 1 as r -> 0. +Consequently, under those same hypotheses, q_MS^br(r,6/5) -> 1 as r -> 0. -No numerical value of C is claimed. Without H_branch, or without PREMISE-Z-LOWER, this tip does not assert the cubic envelope. +No numerical value of C is claimed. This tip does **not** assert a cubic envelope for the unconditioned `1 − q_MS`, nor for P_MS(B_miss ∩ {D(M)≠S}). -## 3. Deterministic reduction (under H_branch) +## 3. Deterministic reduction (joint event under H_branch) The exact source C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION proves, under Morse + distinct critical values + Morse–Smale + **H_branch**, - {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma. + {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma -Pi is interception by an additional relevant critical point in the value window/collars, and Gamma is the event that the second ascending branch of S reaches a maximum with gain in (0,r^3/6). The loop/crater alternative is absorbed by the same interceptor event. The reduction is topological and does not use probabilistic independence. +on the H_branch locus. Pi is interception by an additional relevant critical point in the value window/collars, and Gamma is the event that the second ascending branch of S reaches a maximum with gain in (0,r^3/6). The loop/crater alternative is absorbed by the same interceptor event. The reduction is topological and does not use probabilistic independence. -Hence, **on the H_branch event**, +Hence the joint-event inequality - 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= P_MS(Pi) + P_MS(Gamma). + P_MS( {D(M)≠S} ∩ H_branch ) <= P_MS(Pi) + P_MS(Gamma). -This is not a claim that {D(M) != S} subseteq Pi union Gamma holds for the unconditioned typed pair-Palm law. The unconditioned defect set also meets B_miss, which is out of scope for the cubic bound in this tip. +Combined with PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS, + + 1 - q_MS^br <= ( P_MS(Pi) + P_MS(Gamma) ) / P_MS(H_branch). ## 4. Source-bound probabilistic estimates @@ -77,19 +107,19 @@ Every load-bearing source below is named by exact repository path and Git blob i Source: C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION.md, blob 25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0. -Consumed only under H_branch as in Sections 1.1 and 3. The false transfer that cited Pi cup Gamma under Morse + Morse–Smale alone is withdrawn. +Consumed only as a joint-event inclusion under H_branch (Sections 1.1 and 3). The false transfer that cited Π ∪ Γ under Morse + Morse–Smale alone is withdrawn. The false reading that “restricts `1 − q_MS` to H_branch” is also withdrawn; the theorem object is `q_MS^br`. ### C2 — typed pair-Palm / Kac–Rice normalization (named unresolved premise) Sources: C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md, blob 1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0; with companion intensity statements in C098/C100 as mapped. -C101 §2 and C100 §2 write the typed intensity: pins J_6, weight W_MS = |det H_M det H_S| 1_{H_M ≺ 0} 1_{det H_S < 0}, normalizer Z_r = E[W_MS | J_6], with no second typing division. C098’s Hessian count gives det H_M, det H_S = O(r), hence W_MS = O(r^2), which bounds the numerator. Positivity of a limiting z_0 (and the diagnostic 3.230979 / three-row table) is marked as input, not a proved uniform floor. +C101 §2 and C100 §2 write the typed intensity: pins J_6, weight W_MS = |det H_M det H_S| 1_{H_M ≺ 0} 1_{det H_S < 0}, normalizer Z_r = E[W_MS | J_6], with no second typing division. C098’s Hessian count gives det H_M, det H_S = O(r), hence W_MS = O(r^2), which bounds the numerator. C098’s three-row table (r = 0.05, 0.025, 0.0125; Z_r/r^2 ≈ 3.2337, 3.2245, 3.2232) is diagnostic; positivity of a limiting z_0 is marked as input. C099/C100 likewise assert inf z_r > 0 without proof. -**PREMISE-Z-LOWER (unresolved in this tip):** there exists c > 0 such that +**PREMISE-Z-LOWER (unresolved at zero):** - Z_r >= c r^2 for all 0 < r <= 0.025 + liminf_{r ↓ 0} Z_r / r^2 > 0 -at the exact compact-mark scope of the successor (mark b = 6/5 under the six-pin typed law). No source-bound proof of this lower bound is supplied here; every regional estimate that divides by Z_r is conditional on this premise. A later tip may discharge it by an exact proof object or keep it as a named open premise. +at the exact compact-mark scope of the successor (mark b = 6/5 under the six-pin typed law). On any compact [δ, 0.025] ⊂ (0, 0.025], C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY (blob `1bea9e62ef1ec621f51953dd3f5d5410fba616af`) supplies a positive-definite distinct-point jet Gram, hence Z_r is continuous and positive there; that compact piece is not the open gap. Every regional estimate that divides by Z_r near r ↓ 0 is conditional on this liminf premise. A later tip may discharge it by an exact proof object or keep it named. ### C3/C4 — global interceptor count / singular ledger @@ -97,21 +127,28 @@ Source: C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md, blob 1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beea It uses the typed pair-Palm Kac–Rice intensity and partitions the torus into collars, the singular pair-scaled region, a fixed annulus and the exterior. -Reading the singular ledger with every factor retained, and **assuming PREMISE-Z-LOWER**, at witness radius t: +Collars of radius 2r about (±r/2, 0) exclude the singular witness radius below + + t_* = (√15 / 2) r + +(equivalently η^2 ≤ 4/15 at the collar boundary; C101 §4). Reading the singular ledger with every factor retained, and **assuming PREMISE-Z-LOWER**, at witness radius t: - value/gradient density: O(t^-6); - three physical Hessian determinants together: O(r^6); -- pair-Palm normalizer denominator: Z_r >= c r^2 (premise, not proved here); +- pair-Palm normalizer denominator: under PREMISE-Z-LOWER, Z_r / r^2 stays bounded away from 0 along the liminf; - value-window width: O(r^3); - planar polar area: t dt. Therefore the singular contribution is bounded by - C r^-2 r^6 r^3 integral_{c r}^{t0} t^-6 t dt - = C r^7 integral_{c r}^{t0} t^-5 dt - = O(r^3). + C r^-2 r^6 r^3 integral_{t_*}^{t0} t^-6 t dt + = C r^7 integral_{(√15/2) r}^{t0} t^-5 dt + = C r^7 [ -1/(4 t^4) ]_{(√15/2) r}^{t0} + = O(r^3), + +with lower-limit constant 1/(4 t_*^4 / r^4) = 4/225. The integration lower limit is written `(√15/2) r`, not a bare `c r`, so it does not collide with the constant `c` in informal Z_r ≥ c r^2 shorthand. -This is the corrected exponent ledger. The shorter standalone C101 prose that omitted the area/normalizer bookkeeping is not used as the proof of this line. Without PREMISE-Z-LOWER the division step is not discharged. +This is the corrected exponent ledger. The shorter standalone C101 prose that omitted the area/normalizer bookkeeping is not used as the proof of this line. Without PREMISE-Z-LOWER the division step near r ↓ 0 is not discharged. ### C5 — direct-gain Gamma / maximum window @@ -127,14 +164,14 @@ The older conditional Malliavin route C097_GAMMA_DENSITY_REDUCTION is not consum Source: C100_COLLAR_CUBIC_CLOSURE.md, blob 04d6e1c5a012d1a0e87abe8c9c2e3f7e921478a8. -For y=r xi it gives gradient density r^-3, three-determinant factor r^6 and pair-Palm normalizer r^2, hence physical intensity r F_r(xi). Near a conditioned endpoint the rho^-2 density singularity is cancelled by the rho^2 determinant zero; the axis is exponentially suppressed. Physical area r^2 dxi then yields O(r^3). The normalizer step is read under PREMISE-Z-LOWER. (C6 content otherwise unchanged.) +For y=r xi it gives gradient density r^-3, three-determinant factor r^6 and pair-Palm normalizer r^2, hence physical intensity r F_r(xi). Near a conditioned endpoint the rho^-2 density singularity is cancelled by the rho^2 determinant zero; the axis is exponentially suppressed. Physical area r^2 dxi then yields O(r^3). The normalizer step near r ↓ 0 is read under PREMISE-Z-LOWER. (C6 content otherwise unchanged.) ### C7 — chart coverage and finite-jet nondegeneracy - C102_CHART_ATLAS.md, blob 38a849f6725d76e310faebf17e21a7faadf87454; - C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY.md, blob 1bea9e62ef1ec621f51953dd3f5d5410fba616af. -These sources cover the pair-corrected, max-near generic/axis/transverse, collar generic/pin/axis/transverse, interceptor, fixed-annulus, exterior and type-boundary charts used by the T1 estimates. (C7 content unchanged.) +These sources cover the pair-corrected, max-near generic/axis/transverse, collar generic/pin/axis/transverse, interceptor, fixed-annulus, exterior and type-boundary charts used by the T1 estimates. Finite-jet also underwrites the compact-[δ, 0.025] positivity half of the Z_r story (Section 4 / C2). (C7 content otherwise unchanged.) ## 5. Genericity / SARD-G gate @@ -148,7 +185,7 @@ Specialist review KIMI-AUD-022, Git blob e968385a3bf4e8318a9ab6cb4f57818828f01b1 Therefore this successor separates two levels: -- Conditional generic-field theorem: Sections 2–4 above, assuming the genericity hypotheses, **H_branch**, and **PREMISE-Z-LOWER**. +- Conditional generic-field theorem: Sections 2–4 above, for `q_MS^br`, assuming the genericity hypotheses, **H_branch**, **PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS**, and **PREMISE-Z-LOWER**. - Full-Gaussian corollary: HOLD-WITH-DOMAIN until the SARD-G execution-level Clarifications A/C are supplied by exact source objects and reviewed. No review label alone is treated as a substitute for those missing execution details. @@ -159,25 +196,29 @@ The domain 0 < r <= 0.025 is inherited only from the exact T1 companion sources. ## 7. Squeeze -Under H_branch, PREMISE-Z-LOWER, the conditional hypotheses, and source-bound regional estimates, +Under H_branch, PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS, PREMISE-Z-LOWER, the conditional hypotheses, and source-bound regional estimates, P_MS(Pi) <= C_Pi r^3, P_MS(Gamma) <= C_Gamma r^3, so - 1 - q_MS(r,6/5) <= (C_Pi + C_Gamma) r^3. + P_MS( {D(M)≠S} ∩ H_branch ) <= (C_Pi + C_Gamma) r^3 + +and therefore + + 1 - q_MS^br(r,6/5) <= (C_Pi + C_Gamma) r^3 / P_MS(H_branch). -Since r^3 -> 0, the selection limit follows **on that conditioned object**. The squeeze does not bound B_miss and does not discharge PREMISE-Z-LOWER. +Since r^3 -> 0 and PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS keeps the denominator bounded away from 0, the selection limit for `q_MS^br` follows. The squeeze does **not** bound P_MS(B_miss ∩ {D(M)≠S}) and does not bound the unconditioned `1 − q_MS`. ## 8. What this successor repairs -- It fixes object identity by using q_MS instead of an overloaded historical q. +- It fixes object identity by using q_MS instead of an overloaded historical q, and by naming the theorem object `q_MS^br`. - It binds every load-bearing regional estimate to exact source objects. -- It prints the complete singular power ledger, including normalizer, height and area factors. +- It prints the complete singular power ledger, including normalizer, height and area factors, with lower limit `(√15/2) r`. - It separates the generic-field theorem from the not-yet-fully-executed SARD-G full-Gaussian corollary. -- **C1:** withdraws the false transfer of C102’s inclusion without H_branch; states a branch-attached conditional theorem and names B_miss as unresolved. -- **C2:** isolates Z_r >= c r^2 as named unresolved premise PREMISE-Z-LOWER rather than treating it as proved. -- It does not claim a numerical upper coefficient, a lower bound for 1-q_MS beyond the conditional cubic envelope, a 3D theorem, Theorem B, or RN/JETMOD closure. -- C3–C8 regional contents are not redesigned in this tip; they inherit the two gates above. +- **C1:** withdraws the false transfer of C102’s inclusion without H_branch; withdraws the false “`1 − q_MS` restricted to H_branch” reading; states the cubic theorem for `q_MS^br`; names PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS; names unresolved envelope `B_miss ∩ {D(M)≠S}`. +- **C2:** isolates liminf_{r↓0} Z_r/r^2 > 0 as PREMISE-Z-LOWER; records that compact-[δ,0.025] positivity is already underwritten by finite-jet continuity. +- It does not claim a numerical upper coefficient, a cubic bound for unconditioned `1 − q_MS`, a 3D theorem, Theorem B, or RN/JETMOD closure. +- C3–C8 regional contents are not redesigned in this tip; they inherit the named gates above. Independent review should return C1–C8 dispositions against this exact successor and separately classify the SARD-G full-Gaussian gate. diff --git a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json index 6b1f97ad6..30409d6f3 100644 --- a/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json +++ b/research/q0/Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP.json @@ -1,27 +1,31 @@ { "object": "Q0_C103_SOURCE_MAP_20260925", "scientific_effect": "NONE", - "theorem_object": "q_MS(r,b)=P_MS(r,b){D(M)=S} under H_branch", + "theorem_object": "q_MS^br(r,b)=P_MS(D(M)=S | H_branch)", + "unconditioned_object": "q_MS(r,b)=P_MS(r,b){D(M)=S}", "controlling_alias_to_historical_q": false, "review_required": true, "c1_c2_repair": { "as_of": "2026-09-26", "H_branch": "one ascending branch of S terminates at M (C102 attachment hypothesis)", - "B_miss": "neither ascending branch of S terminates at M — unresolved named defect class; no O(r^3) envelope in this tip", - "PREMISE_Z_LOWER": "Z_r >= c r^2 on 0 < r <= 0.025 at compact mark scope — named unresolved premise; not proved here" + "B_miss": "neither ascending branch of S terminates at M", + "unresolved_defect_envelope": "B_miss ∩ {D(M)≠S} — not B_miss alone (B_miss does not imply D(M)≠S)", + "PREMISE_BRANCH_MASS": "inf_{0 0 — required to pass from joint-event cubic to 1−q_MS^br", + "PREMISE_Z_LOWER": "liminf_{r↓0} Z_r/r^2 > 0 at compact mark scope — named unresolved premise; compact [δ,0.025] positivity via finite-jet continuity" }, "sources": [ { "id": "C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION", "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C102_DETERMINISTIC_REDUCTION.md", "git_blob": "25917befb388211e3848b00c5ba90670e9b716b0", - "consumed_under": ["H_branch", "Morse", "distinct_critical_values", "Morse-Smale"] + "consumed_under": ["H_branch", "Morse", "distinct_critical_values", "Morse-Smale"], + "licenses": "P_MS({D(M)≠S} ∩ H_branch) ≤ P_MS(Π)+P_MS(Γ); not a bound on unconditioned 1−q_MS" }, { "id": "C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE", "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T1 — Upper Rate (finite C_Q0)/02_CLOSURE_AND_REDUCTION_PACKAGES/C101_GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CLOSURE.md", "git_blob": "1daec2574e2505ab8162c9a36d8beead34360dd0", - "notes": "Typed intensity and singular ledger; Z_r >= c r^2 asserted in source is PREMISE-Z-LOWER here, not discharged." + "notes": "Typed intensity and singular ledger; Z_r ≥ c r^2 asserted in source is PREMISE-Z-LOWER (liminf form) here, not discharged. Singular lower limit t_*=(√15/2)r." }, { "id": "C098_GAMMA_EXTERIOR_TRANSFER", @@ -46,7 +50,8 @@ { "id": "C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY", "path": "drive/mirrors/16_THEMATIC_RESEARCH_TRACKS/T2 — SARD-G Transversality/02_SUPPORTING_CERTIFICATES_AND_ATLAS/C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY.md", - "git_blob": "1bea9e62ef1ec621f51953dd3f5d5410fba616af" + "git_blob": "1bea9e62ef1ec621f51953dd3f5d5410fba616af", + "notes": "Underwrites Z_r continuous/positive on compact [δ,0.025]; does not discharge liminf_{r↓0} Z_r/r^2 > 0." }, { "id": "SARD_G_WORKING_SOURCE", @@ -63,24 +68,31 @@ { "id": "H_branch", "statement": "One ascending branch of S terminates at M (C102 attachment hypothesis).", - "role": "conditions the C1 defect inclusion and the cubic theorem object" + "role": "conditions the C1 defect inclusion; defines the conditioning event for q_MS^br" }, { - "id": "B_miss", - "statement": "Neither ascending branch of S terminates at M.", - "role": "named unresolved defect class; no source-bound O(r^3) envelope in this tip" + "id": "PREMISE-BRANCH-MASS", + "statement": "inf_{0 < r <= 0.025} P_MS(H_branch) > 0 at compact mark b = 6/5 under the six-pin typed law.", + "role": "required to convert the joint-event cubic into a bound on 1 − q_MS^br" + }, + { + "id": "B_miss_cap_defect", + "statement": "B_miss ∩ {D(M)≠S}: neither ascending branch of S terminates at M, and D(M)≠S.", + "role": "named unresolved defect envelope; no source-bound O(r^3) bound in this tip; not implied by B_miss alone" }, { "id": "PREMISE-Z-LOWER", - "statement": "Z_r >= c r^2 for some c > 0, uniformly on 0 < r <= 0.025 at compact mark b = 6/5 under the six-pin typed law.", - "role": "required for every regional estimate that divides by the pair-Palm normalizer; not proved here" + "statement": "liminf_{r ↓ 0} Z_r / r^2 > 0 at compact mark b = 6/5 under the six-pin typed law.", + "role": "required for regional estimates that divide by the pair-Palm normalizer as r↓0; compact [δ,0.025] positivity already underwritten by C102_FINITE_JET_NONDEGENERACY" } ], "gates": { - "conditional_typed_pair_cubic_rate": "REVIEW_PENDING_BRANCH_ATTACHED", - "H_branch": "EXPLICIT_HYPOTHESIS", - "B_miss_cubic_envelope": "UNRESOLVED", - "PREMISE_Z_LOWER": "UNRESOLVED", + "conditional_typed_pair_cubic_rate": "REVIEW_PENDING_q_MS_br", + "H_branch": "EXPLICIT_CONDITIONING_EVENT", + "PREMISE_BRANCH_MASS": "UNRESOLVED", + "B_miss_cap_defect_cubic_envelope": "UNRESOLVED", + "PREMISE_Z_LOWER": "UNRESOLVED_AT_ZERO", + "Z_r_compact_away_from_zero": "UNDERWRITTEN_BY_FINITE_JET", "full_gaussian_corollary": "HOLD_WITH_DOMAIN", "sard_g_clarification_A": "OPEN_EXECUTION_DETAIL", "sard_g_clarification_C": "OPEN_EXECUTION_DETAIL" From 4b628f0a4424c43a35812164ac599ef39e2c10d5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sun, 27 Sep 2026 17:11:42 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 5/6] fix(ci): fetch push before/after for claims-gate after force-push Force-rebase leaves github.event.before as an orphaned SHA outside the tip ancestry even with fetch-depth:0, so event-compare fail-closed with "before ref is not a resolvable commit". Fetch missing before/after explicitly (token one-shot) while keeping all-zero before fail-closed. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- .github/workflows/ci.yml | 28 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 28 insertions(+) diff --git a/.github/workflows/ci.yml b/.github/workflows/ci.yml index 9bad97df7..f4f25f4c9 100644 --- a/.github/workflows/ci.yml +++ b/.github/workflows/ci.yml @@ -123,6 +123,34 @@ jobs: run: python tools/scientific_state_check.py - name: Claims→gate #90 tip-health (identity only; not base→head evidence) run: python tools/claims_gate_adapter.py tip-health + # checkout fetch-depth:0 only walks the tip ancestry. Force-push rewrites leave + # github.event.before as an orphaned-but-still-hosted SHA that is not in that + # ancestry; fetch it explicitly so event-compare can resolve immutable refs. + # All-zero before (first push of a new branch) is left for the adapter fail-closed path. + - name: Fetch push before/after refs for claims-gate (force-push safe) + if: github.event_name == 'push' + env: + BEFORE: ${{ github.event.before }} + AFTER: ${{ github.event.after }} + GH_TOKEN: ${{ github.token }} + run: | + set -euo pipefail + zero=0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 + auth_header="$(printf 'AUTHORIZATION: basic %s' "$(printf 'x-access-token:%s' "$GH_TOKEN" | base64 -w0)")" + fetch_sha() { + local sha="$1" + if [[ -z "$sha" || "$sha" == "$zero" ]]; then + return 0 + fi + if git rev-parse --verify "${sha}^{commit}" >/dev/null 2>&1; then + return 0 + fi + echo "Fetching missing event ref ${sha}" + git -c "http.extraheader=${auth_header}" fetch --no-tags --depth=1 origin "$sha" + git rev-parse --verify "${sha}^{commit}" >/dev/null + } + fetch_sha "$BEFORE" + fetch_sha "$AFTER" - name: Claims→gate #90 event base→head compare (immutable refs; impact≠illegal) run: python tools/claims_gate_adapter.py event-compare --write-report /tmp/claims-gate-impact.json - name: Declared navigation links and anchors From 6ad685c5c68bd34b6a5c3833e7cdd990cb9f9b3d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sun, 27 Sep 2026 17:24:11 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 6/6] fix(#90): fetch orphaned push before SHA for event-compare Force-rebase leaves github.event.before hosted on origin but outside tip ancestry; checkout fetch-depth:0 does not materialize it, so push verify fail-closed. Retry once via git fetch origin (GITHUB_TOKEN header when persist-credentials is false). All-zero before still fail-closed. Revert the CI multi-step form that broke closure_pipeline check-plan. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- .github/workflows/ci.yml | 28 ----------- tests/test_claims_gate_adapter.py | 81 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ tools/claims_gate_adapter.py | 43 +++++++++++++++- 3 files changed, 123 insertions(+), 29 deletions(-) diff --git a/.github/workflows/ci.yml b/.github/workflows/ci.yml index f4f25f4c9..9bad97df7 100644 --- a/.github/workflows/ci.yml +++ b/.github/workflows/ci.yml @@ -123,34 +123,6 @@ jobs: run: python tools/scientific_state_check.py - name: Claims→gate #90 tip-health (identity only; not base→head evidence) run: python tools/claims_gate_adapter.py tip-health - # checkout fetch-depth:0 only walks the tip ancestry. Force-push rewrites leave - # github.event.before as an orphaned-but-still-hosted SHA that is not in that - # ancestry; fetch it explicitly so event-compare can resolve immutable refs. - # All-zero before (first push of a new branch) is left for the adapter fail-closed path. - - name: Fetch push before/after refs for claims-gate (force-push safe) - if: github.event_name == 'push' - env: - BEFORE: ${{ github.event.before }} - AFTER: ${{ github.event.after }} - GH_TOKEN: ${{ github.token }} - run: | - set -euo pipefail - zero=0000000000000000000000000000000000000000 - auth_header="$(printf 'AUTHORIZATION: basic %s' "$(printf 'x-access-token:%s' "$GH_TOKEN" | base64 -w0)")" - fetch_sha() { - local sha="$1" - if [[ -z "$sha" || "$sha" == "$zero" ]]; then - return 0 - fi - if git rev-parse --verify "${sha}^{commit}" >/dev/null 2>&1; then - return 0 - fi - echo "Fetching missing event ref ${sha}" - git -c "http.extraheader=${auth_header}" fetch --no-tags --depth=1 origin "$sha" - git rev-parse --verify "${sha}^{commit}" >/dev/null - } - fetch_sha "$BEFORE" - fetch_sha "$AFTER" - name: Claims→gate #90 event base→head compare (immutable refs; impact≠illegal) run: python tools/claims_gate_adapter.py event-compare --write-report /tmp/claims-gate-impact.json - name: Declared navigation links and anchors diff --git a/tests/test_claims_gate_adapter.py b/tests/test_claims_gate_adapter.py index f9695faf3..33c778a71 100644 --- a/tests/test_claims_gate_adapter.py +++ b/tests/test_claims_gate_adapter.py @@ -576,6 +576,87 @@ def test_event_compare_fails_closed_on_missing_base(self): ) self.assertIn("all-zero", str(ctx.exception)) + def test_require_usable_ref_fetches_orphaned_before_from_origin(self): + """Force-push leaves before outside tip ancestry; fetch from origin once.""" + import subprocess + import tempfile + + with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as raw: + upstream = Path(raw) / "upstream" + shallow = Path(raw) / "shallow" + upstream.mkdir() + subprocess.run(["git", "init"], cwd=upstream, check=True, capture_output=True) + subprocess.run( + ["git", "config", "user.email", "test@example.com"], + cwd=upstream, + check=True, + capture_output=True, + ) + subprocess.run( + ["git", "config", "user.name", "test"], + cwd=upstream, + check=True, + capture_output=True, + ) + (upstream / "a.txt").write_text("before\n", encoding="utf-8") + subprocess.run(["git", "add", "a.txt"], cwd=upstream, check=True, capture_output=True) + subprocess.run( + ["git", "commit", "-m", "before"], + cwd=upstream, + check=True, + capture_output=True, + ) + before = subprocess.run( + ["git", "rev-parse", "HEAD"], + cwd=upstream, + check=True, + capture_output=True, + text=True, + ).stdout.strip() + (upstream / "a.txt").write_text("after\n", encoding="utf-8") + subprocess.run(["git", "add", "a.txt"], cwd=upstream, check=True, capture_output=True) + subprocess.run( + ["git", "commit", "-m", "after"], + cwd=upstream, + check=True, + capture_output=True, + ) + after = subprocess.run( + ["git", "rev-parse", "HEAD"], + cwd=upstream, + check=True, + capture_output=True, + text=True, + ).stdout.strip() + # --no-local avoids object alternates; --depth=1 keeps only tip ancestry. + subprocess.run( + [ + "git", + "clone", + "--no-local", + "--depth", + "1", + str(upstream), + str(shallow), + ], + check=True, + capture_output=True, + ) + missing = subprocess.run( + ["git", "rev-parse", "--verify", f"{before}^{{commit}}"], + cwd=shallow, + capture_output=True, + ) + self.assertNotEqual(missing.returncode, 0, "before must be absent pre-fetch") + resolved = CGA._require_usable_ref( + before, role="before", root=shallow, resolve=True + ) + self.assertEqual(resolved, before) + self.assertEqual( + CGA._require_usable_ref(after, role="after", root=shallow, resolve=True), + after, + ) + def test_event_compare_uses_pull_request_base_head(self): before = "a" * 40 after = "b" * 40 diff --git a/tools/claims_gate_adapter.py b/tools/claims_gate_adapter.py index 8a30241ca..a67edb72a 100644 --- a/tools/claims_gate_adapter.py +++ b/tools/claims_gate_adapter.py @@ -1592,6 +1592,40 @@ def _git_bytes( return result.stdout +def _try_fetch_commit(root: Path, sha: str) -> bool: + """Best-effort fetch of a missing commit from origin (force-push before SHA). + + Returns True if the commit is locally resolvable after the attempt. Never + treats all-zero / empty refs. Uses GITHUB_TOKEN when present because CI + checkout sets ``persist-credentials: false``. + """ + import base64 + import os + + if not re.fullmatch(r"[0-9a-f]{7,40}", sha): + return False + if ( + _git_bytes(root, "rev-parse", "--verify", f"{sha}^{{commit}}", missing_ok=True) + is not None + ): + return True + token = (os.environ.get("GITHUB_TOKEN") or os.environ.get("GH_TOKEN") or "").strip() + fetch_cmd = ["git", "-C", str(root)] + if token: + auth = base64.b64encode(f"x-access-token:{token}".encode("ascii")).decode( + "ascii" + ) + fetch_cmd.extend(["-c", f"http.extraheader=AUTHORIZATION: basic {auth}"]) + fetch_cmd.extend(["fetch", "--no-tags", "--depth=1", "origin", sha]) + result = subprocess.run(fetch_cmd, capture_output=True, timeout=120) + if result.returncode != 0: + return False + return ( + _git_bytes(root, "rev-parse", "--verify", f"{sha}^{{commit}}", missing_ok=True) + is not None + ) + + def _require_usable_ref( ref: str, *, @@ -1615,7 +1649,14 @@ def _require_usable_ref( root, "rev-parse", "--verify", f"{cleaned}^{{commit}}", missing_ok=True ) if resolved is None: - raise AdapterError(f"{role} ref is not a resolvable commit: {cleaned!r}") + # Force-push: github.event.before may be hosted on origin but outside tip ancestry. + if not _try_fetch_commit(root, cleaned): + raise AdapterError(f"{role} ref is not a resolvable commit: {cleaned!r}") + resolved = _git_bytes( + root, "rev-parse", "--verify", f"{cleaned}^{{commit}}", missing_ok=True + ) + if resolved is None: + raise AdapterError(f"{role} ref is not a resolvable commit: {cleaned!r}") full = resolved.decode().strip() if not re.fullmatch(r"[0-9a-f]{40}", full): raise AdapterError(f"{role} ref did not resolve to a 40-hex commit id: {full!r}")