From 6a72aefdbd56556bb51cec1371f1041836c63a31 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy Date: Mon, 28 Sep 2026 04:53:24 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] docs: publish exact q0 recovery crosswalk and bounded scan replay Record ten literal source matches and replay of the existing 387-occurrence extraction. Four add-only review files; no source-body or scientific-status changes. --- .../IDENTITY.json | 36 +++++++ .../REPLAY_RECEIPT.json | 92 ++++++++++++++++++ .../RESULT.md | 97 +++++++++++++++++++ .../SOURCE_CROSSWALK.csv | 11 +++ 4 files changed, 236 insertions(+) create mode 100644 incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/IDENTITY.json create mode 100644 incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/REPLAY_RECEIPT.json create mode 100644 incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/RESULT.md create mode 100644 incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/SOURCE_CROSSWALK.csv diff --git a/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/IDENTITY.json b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/IDENTITY.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c3254292b --- /dev/null +++ b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/IDENTITY.json @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "scientific_effect": "NONE", + "review_status": "REVIEW_REQUIRED", + "sources": [ + { + "repository": "d6g8k5htny-coder/main", + "commit": "7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93", + "path": "drive/mirrors/10_AXIOMATIC_CORE_SPINE/00.2_CANONICAL_MASTER/00_CANONICAL_MASTERS_AND_SOURCE/Q0_MASTER.md", + "sha256": "3112fb610f27feea8ff84b8bdf9b475fc17c2e9cf12b4173866cb6ae2d9e22cc" + }, + { + "repository": "d6g8k5htny-coder/main", + "commit": "f160a54bef29bd16416f4d0357bee21c8f9c8e53", + "path": "incoming/chatgpt-c022-q0-recovery-20260928/context/Q0_LEDGER.md", + "sha256": "d1fea170ee04c93b075786ed636c3d9088fd80f2c0def51a6a2dbc0812e3e80a" + } + ], + "artifacts": [ + { + "path": "REPLAY_RECEIPT.json", + "bytes": 3223, + "sha256": "75e8b305d8bdc56b1e1719f16b774a57ec087b6ccf1d75f3e0b52897f1d95a07" + }, + { + "path": "RESULT.md", + "bytes": 5987, + "sha256": "3f7e78af61a0f2f8ad8608195013bf13eb70e8d77f696cdc4df9fe2ac6bc0d80" + }, + { + "path": "SOURCE_CROSSWALK.csv", + "bytes": 1644, + "sha256": "580a24070fea51a7760815d1ad92e04affb68124f089ce18b1b902e1529199a7" + } + ] +} diff --git a/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/REPLAY_RECEIPT.json b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/REPLAY_RECEIPT.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..60cd4659a --- /dev/null +++ b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/REPLAY_RECEIPT.json @@ -0,0 +1,92 @@ +{ + "scientific_effect": "NONE", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-28T09:49:35.301228+00:00", + "historical_run": { + "report_identity": { + "bytes": 2962992, + "sha256": "a70263a2e574b5eca507b245ca96b3540db9cf03bb568b05f8b892d01dedabe9" + }, + "steps_with_matching_log_identity": 41, + "matching_artifact_identities": 42, + "before_after_input_maps_equal": true, + "source_commit_reported": "d107ab121d230de33c09e727c7804098ec4e8249", + "dirty_worktree_reported": true, + "source_run_start": "2026-09-22T02:34:36.611745+00:00", + "source_run_end": "2026-09-22T02:45:05.594132+00:00", + "reported_status": "PASS", + "pytest_xml_counts": { + "testcases": 2892, + "failures": 0, + "errors": 0, + "skipped": 2 + }, + "historical_tests_rerun": false, + "underlying_source_inputs_not_reverified": 4177 + }, + "extraction": { + "occurrences_rehashed": 387, + "distinct_hashes_rehashed": 386, + "identical_repeat_payloads": 387, + "identical_repeat_receipts": 3, + "unresolved_occurrences": 81, + "unresolved_by_reason": { + "derived_text_not_original_file_bytes": 20, + "no_full_hash_and_size_match; semantic content not promoted": 60, + "missing or malformed script hash declaration": 1 + } + }, + "controls": { + "single_byte_log_mutation_rejected": true, + "wrong_recorded_size_rejected": true + }, + "recovered_programs_executed": false, + "private_log_bodies_published": false, + "schema": "q0-recovery-replay-v1", + "review_status": "REVIEW_REQUIRED", + "author": "OpenAI ChatGPT", + "same_owner_account": true, + "independent_review_observed": false, + "public_parent_sources": { + "MASTER": { + "repository": "d6g8k5htny-coder/main", + "commit": "7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93", + "path": "drive/mirrors/10_AXIOMATIC_CORE_SPINE/00.2_CANONICAL_MASTER/00_CANONICAL_MASTERS_AND_SOURCE/Q0_MASTER.md", + "sha256": "3112fb610f27feea8ff84b8bdf9b475fc17c2e9cf12b4173866cb6ae2d9e22cc" + }, + "LEDGER": { + "repository": "d6g8k5htny-coder/main", + "commit": "f160a54bef29bd16416f4d0357bee21c8f9c8e53", + "path": "incoming/chatgpt-c022-q0-recovery-20260928/context/Q0_LEDGER.md", + "sha256": "d1fea170ee04c93b075786ed636c3d9088fd80f2c0def51a6a2dbc0812e3e80a" + } + }, + "scan": { + "files": 63, + "bytes": 13030109, + "distinct_hashes": 63, + "text_searched": 63, + "read_errors": 0, + "master_final_files": 43, + "master_final_bytes": 3994290, + "master_final_all_previously_scanned": true, + "new_hashes_vs_two_previous_scan_ledgers": 17, + "is_exhaustive_dropbox_scan": false + }, + "tool_tests": { + "scanner_normal": 10, + "scanner_optimized": 10, + "unpacker_normal": 20, + "unpacker_optimized": 20, + "failures": 0 + }, + "unpacker_sha256": "60bddb2540a436d2467377b8dc2bf924ecfe1aeab098a81723cc3e8bcbc07b9f", + "standalone_literal_slice_matches": 10, + "previous_public_extraction": { + "repository": "d6g8k5htny-coder/main", + "commit": "5f22638a8fad05afd3370213943907dc4c050518", + "path": "tools/source_census_20260927/EMBEDDED_RECOVERY.md", + "reported_occurrences": 387, + "reported_distinct_hashes": 386 + }, + "r2_target_queue_reclassified": false +} diff --git a/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/RESULT.md b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/RESULT.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c25367a63 --- /dev/null +++ b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/RESULT.md @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +# q0 recovery crosswalk and bounded Dropbox continuation + +Scientific effect: NONE. Review status: REVIEW_REQUIRED. +Author: OpenAI ChatGPT, 28 September 2026. Same-owner-account work; no independent +review is claimed. This packet adds evidence and navigation, not source bodies, +mathematical verdicts, workflow changes or another status registry. + +## What was completed + +The 43 files in the `master-final-v1/master-final-v1` Dropbox folder were acquired +individually and their complete available text searched, alongside the interrupted +20-file batch. Total: 63 files, 13,030,109 bytes, 63 distinct hashes, no read errors. +The complete 43-file folder is 3,994,290 bytes. Every one of those 43 hashes already +occurred in the previous archive scan. Seventeen of the combined 63 hashes are new +relative to the two earlier scan ledgers only, not necessarily new to the project. +Dropbox-wide coverage is still incomplete; this is a finished bounded batch. + +The existing, unchanged source-census unpacker was inspected and replayed as data +extraction: 387 full-hash/size-matching occurrences, 386 distinct payloads. All +387 outputs were freshly rehashed. A second extraction reproduced all payloads +and all three receipts byte-for-byte. This is the same 387/386 count documented +in the existing September-27 EMBEDDED_RECOVERY.md, not 387 newly discovered proofs. + +The 81 unresolved embedded occurrences remain explicitly excluded: 20 PDF-derived +text readings are not original PDF bytes; 60 JSON formatting candidates did not +match full hashes and sizes; one script lacked a usable full-hash declaration. +These are extraction outcomes, not 81 open mathematical obligations. Loose-source +recoveries and the separate R2 target queue are not reclassified by these counts. + +## Ten exact connections + +`SOURCE_CROSSWALK.csv` joins ten independently acquired loose documents to exact +literal slices of Q0_MASTER or Q0_LEDGER. Every row matches full SHA-256, length +and the complete sliced bytes. Offsets are zero-based and half-open. Container +keys resolve to the full repository/path/commit/SHA-256 records in +`REPLAY_RECEIPT.json`. No source text was reconstructed or rewritten. + +MASTER is the 1,831,987-byte public historical Q0_MASTER at commit +`7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93`. Its locally computed Git blob matches +freshly returned public blob metadata; the large public file was not downloaded +a second time. LEDGER is the 253,067-byte exact Q0_LEDGER in PR #202 at +`f160a54bef29bd16416f4d0357bee21c8f9c8e53`. PR #202 remains unmerged and review-only. +Its branch must remain reachable until its source ancestry is retained by a merge +commit; this packet does not pretend that branch source is already on main. + +The ten connections cover the prior-art/conditions section, B2 positivity +composition, terminal-height package, C094 lower-coefficient adjudication, C102 +qualitative-rate package, LB-ARCH, Lemma P, MS-Shift/R0, the C096 conditional +contract, and the July-9 verification review. The contribution is their exact +crosswalk and repeatable source extraction, not a claim that these texts were +never public. Existing source copies are linked rather than duplicated. + +## Scope cautions for the next reviewer + +Read the corrections with the claims. C094 withdraws the bare 0.8411 probability +lower coefficient and distinguishes a qualifying first moment from the final +probability. Its historical upper wording must also be read with later changes. +C096 explicitly retains GLOBAL_INTERCEPTOR_CUBIC_UNIFORM, +GAMMA_GAIN_DENSITY_UNIFORM and COLLAR_CUBIC_EXPLICIT as conditions, not proved +premises. LB-ARCH separates fixed-radius positivity from its rate architecture +note. MS-Shift/R0 names residual uniformity work. The crosswalk is not a source- +bound mathematical review of any of these arguments and transfers none of their +historical PROVEN, CLOSED, PASS or APPROVE wording into current acceptance. + +Four loosely named text files in the batch belong to the older RUFT physics +corpus. Keyword similarity alone does not make them persistence proof carriers. +They are not added to this packet or composed into the current q0 dependency graph. + +## Historical execution record: checked as an artifact, not rerun + +The acquired master-final report describes a September-22 run with 41 steps. +All 41 step-log identities and all 42 artifact identities (logs plus pytest.xml) +match the acquired bytes. Its XML lists 2,892 tests, including two skips and no +reported failures/errors. The report explicitly says the source worktree was +DIRTY. The before/after 4,177-entry input maps are identical to each other; those +4,177 underlying source files were not freshly reverified. No historical test +was rerun and this receipt does not bind that run to today's clean GitHub head. +Private paths and host information in the raw logs remain out of the public packet. + +Fresh execution was limited to custody tools: scanner tests 10 normal + 10 +optimized; unpacker tests 20 normal + 20 optimized, all passing. Byte-change and +wrong-size controls reject altered log evidence. No recovered research program, +notebook, pickle, macro or archived verifier was executed; no OCR was used. + +## Coordination and remaining work + +The existing public evidence lane is unchanged: #199/#200 carry recovered +Claude/Kimi sources, #201 carries T9, #202 carries C022/Q0, and #203 carries the +CL-MIRROR cross-check. #201-#203 were still open when checked. Current-head review +and the separately offered Claude August-3 upload lane remain outstanding; no +recipient pickup is inferred from silence. Coordination is in main #95 and #201. + +Continue the saved Dropbox pagination and unopened subfolders, then review the +recovered source-to-obligation scope mappings. Do not count a file as absent +merely because one search missed it, and do not count a found file as a proof of +a stronger or differently conditioned theorem. This packet closes a bounded +custody/reconciliation task, not a theorem or the full Dropbox search. diff --git a/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/SOURCE_CROSSWALK.csv b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/SOURCE_CROSSWALK.csv new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f7aa10daa --- /dev/null +++ b/incoming/chatgpt-q0-recovery-crosswalk-20260928/SOURCE_CROSSWALK.csv @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +original_name,loose_filename,bytes,sha256,container,byte_start,byte_end_exclusive +05_PART_V_PRIOR_ART_AND_CONDITIONS.md,05 PART V PRIOR ART AND CONDITIONS (1).md,27462,555d4ebbd45e745b4fd76218640923de40da852128929fefdd0419cd617b65f0,MASTER,424084,451546 +B2_Positivity_Compositionv2_07-09-26.md,B2 Positivity Compositionv2 07-09-26.md,5183,653036a238e675876da931ed953def29716364521d104488e4cbffdf260f24c3,MASTER,657410,662593 +C025_TerminalHeight_Package.md,C025 TerminalHeight Package.md,7195,d1afd84b3143ed512b0fb1cafba5c2eb6eb190b28ec7f8e789cc817c08bf792a,MASTER,672769,679964 +C094_LOWER_COEFFICIENT_ADJUDICATION.md,C094_LOWER_COEFFICIENT_ADJUDICATION (2).md,1918,03c98a500ce80c5c1b93b47cdbf9352319dd7def3b8c32b82464bf25d5b088e0,LEDGER,83506,85424 +C102_QUALITATIVE_RATE_PACKAGE.md,C102_QUALITATIVE_RATE_PACKAGE (2).md,5520,ffadddcd1a9246ca87263fdb44cfc127ad4e3dc5f365b72fce0144906a2edc0e,MASTER,15646,21166 +Lemma_LB_ARCH_Package.md,Lemma LB ARCH Package.md,14692,39c8ee1813f8b0afdaa9e7bdb068db3a9b4266ceeb8c111637be4c3a02cb1381,MASTER,882995,897687 +LemmaP_Discharge.md,LemmaP Discharge.md,4262,08294007291201b793011283a8c14615ad99dfb4bf9a4b6a0d60161224e36521,LEDGER,37387,41649 +MS_Shift_R0_Closure.md,MS Shift R0 Closure.md,12350,6575e2bb5178e1229794360d44bdcd5a733952033899b92d89868cf15c3d6c32,MASTER,939346,951696 +Q0_C096_CONDITIONAL_RESIDUAL_CONTRACT.md,Q0_C096_CONDITIONAL_RESIDUAL_CONTRACT.md,1359,02658f4f473be6d9132cb2487c92cf87eed6f83702b698515ac8cdb6534e7401,MASTER,72403,73762 +Verification_Review_07-09-26.md,Verification Review 07-09-26.md,11308,7c26be5b896409a6f957289c22effc72b1643ecddb282568314d2edcfd1b90d7,MASTER,968266,979574