From d46ace58aacc27d578402a3b47df38d9ff9c8266 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Wed, 23 Sep 2026 23:31:57 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] docs: deepen inventable REFUSED/EMPTY/ABSENT honesty walls Record generation-time tip pins as provenance, not a re-run on LOCK b3da668. Honesty labels stay non-discharge, non-SoT, and non-FREEZE. OBL-H5-JETMOD stays OPEN. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- docs/math_status/PACKET.json | 4 ++-- docs/math_status/README.md | 9 +++++++++ docs/math_status/STATUS_JETMOD.md | 10 ++++++++++ .../INVENTABLE_INSTRUMENTATION_STATUS_INDEX.json | 6 ++++-- docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json | 8 ++++---- docs/math_status_probes/README.md | 12 ++++++++++++ .../inventable_jetmod_instrumentation_status.py | 3 +++ docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_probes.py | 10 +++++++++- 8 files changed, 53 insertions(+), 9 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/math_status/PACKET.json b/docs/math_status/PACKET.json index 78bf4c455..97a9a5ff6 100644 --- a/docs/math_status/PACKET.json +++ b/docs/math_status/PACKET.json @@ -38,8 +38,8 @@ "bytes": 6270 }, "STATUS_JETMOD.md": { - "sha256": "7d895a83beab36a35939ba0c7873b075f4346ba7e800fcf46c1afd4726f09a23", - "bytes": 12955 + "sha256": "a818d18b0bbc10e85600e4ad412ef1354746404881df5b04bb50c68b955f713c", + "bytes": 15434 }, "STATUS_RN_UNIF.md": { "sha256": "0d15e62e468192ca9a85165b6ab33de03fc097c2fb9d66602bc7a772eef4aa1d", diff --git a/docs/math_status/README.md b/docs/math_status/README.md index cd2803e70..640a429f5 100644 --- a/docs/math_status/README.md +++ b/docs/math_status/README.md @@ -97,6 +97,15 @@ does not merge draft PR #12. `PARTIAL`, and similar receipt tokens are honesty labels. They are not discharge. They do not imply `lemma_closed`, `discharges_OBL_H5_JETMOD`, `certified_C_H`, `prizes_solved`, `freeze`, or an RN-UNIF discharge. +They are not a source of truth and not FREEZE. + +Where `aligned_to_base_tip` is already present, it is generation provenance +(`1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba` on the inventable probe index), +not a re-run on hardening LOCK `b3da6688a55d34681bb27f17ba6c6c5e16ad534c` +(short `b3da668`). Advancing the tip does not upgrade those labels into +`PRESENT` or `SUCCESS`. The source-named jet subset stays 8. Inventing +toward 24 without a Drive/PROMOTE enumeration stays `REFUSED_NOT_24JET`. +`scientific_status_changed` stays false. A green checker, a green dashboard, and green CI are not obligation discharge. `OBL-H5-JETMOD` stays OPEN. `D3-LEMMA-RN-UNIF` stays OPEN. Disposition stays diff --git a/docs/math_status/STATUS_JETMOD.md b/docs/math_status/STATUS_JETMOD.md index 163e75d98..4597fc8a6 100644 --- a/docs/math_status/STATUS_JETMOD.md +++ b/docs/math_status/STATUS_JETMOD.md @@ -211,3 +211,13 @@ Local `code_prototypes` inventory rows previously marked `?` only (no new walls; All five keep `discharges_OBL_H5_JETMOD: false`, `lemma_closed: false`, `inventable_attempt_accepted: false`, `certified_C_H: false`, `prizes_solved: 0`. **OBL-H5-JETMOD remains OPEN.** These instrumentation STATUS receipts do not discharge OBL-H5-JETMOD. Green ≠ discharge. PR #12 left unmerged. Certificate skim-trap PRs not reopened. + +## Inventable REFUSED / EMPTY / ABSENT honesty (tip provenance) + +Named inventable receipts under `docs/math_status_probes/` are instrumentation only. `REFUSED`, `REFUSED_IA_STRADDLES`, `EMPTY`, `ABSENT`, `PARTIAL`, and `REFUSED_NOT_24JET` are honesty labels. They are not discharge. They are not a source of truth. They are not FREEZE. They do not close OBL-H5-JETMOD. RN Absent-historical-objects stay as recorded in `STATUS_RN_UNIF.md`. This note does not reopen that lane and does not invent substitutes. + +`aligned_to_base_tip`, where a receipt or `INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json` already carries it, is generation provenance: `1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba`. The index marks that pin `HISTORICAL_NONCURRENT`. The three shortcut receipts that carry the field are `inventable_24jet_roster_without_Drive_list_REFUSED_NOT_24JET_receipt.json`, `inventable_promote_display_residual_struct_kappa_REFUSED_receipt.json`, and `inventable_merge_PR12_or_rung_discharge_REFUSED_receipt.json`. The four sibling receipts (`inventable_interval_schur_ainv_REFUSED_receipt.json`, `inventable_eval_F_G12box_REFUSED_receipt.json`, `inventable_joint_ry_cancel_EMPTY_receipt.json`, `inventable_phi_bridge_ABSENT_receipt.json`) and the five instrumentation receipts (`inventable_first_band_proto_PARTIAL_receipt.json`, `inventable_first_band_smoke_PARTIAL_receipt.json`, `inventable_first_band_multi_gram_PARTIAL_receipt.json`, `inventable_multi_jet_band_REFUSED_NOT_24JET_receipt.json`, `inventable_g12_ext_named_REFUSED_NOT_24JET_receipt.json`) do not carry `aligned_to_base_tip`. This note does not add the field and does not re-hash receipt bytes. It is written against hardening LOCK `b3da6688a55d34681bb27f17ba6c6c5e16ad534c` (short `b3da668`). The probe runners were not re-executed on that LOCK. Advancing the tip does not re-execute them and does not upgrade any of those labels into `PRESENT` or `SUCCESS`. + +The 24-jet STOP above still holds. The source-named subset stays 8 (6 MS-diag + `kappa_c2` + `s_f_fx`). Inventing named jets toward 24 without a Drive H5_ANALYTIC_ADVANCE / PROMOTE enumeration stays **REFUSED_NOT_24JET**. `PARTIAL` is not that roster. + +`lemma_closed` stays false. `prizes_solved` stays false. `discharges_OBL_H5_JETMOD` stays false. `certified_C_H` stays false. `freeze` stays false. `inventable_attempt_accepted` stays false. `scientific_status_changed` stays false. **OBL-H5-JETMOD remains OPEN.** Green CI ≠ discharge. Draft PR #12 stays unmerged. diff --git a/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_INSTRUMENTATION_STATUS_INDEX.json b/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_INSTRUMENTATION_STATUS_INDEX.json index c6dcf41d0..7d40efa63 100644 --- a/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_INSTRUMENTATION_STATUS_INDEX.json +++ b/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_INSTRUMENTATION_STATUS_INDEX.json @@ -1,6 +1,8 @@ { "schema": "q0.inventable-jetmod-instrumentation-status/v1", - "as_of_note": "48h coding lane under Dylan autonomy; instrumentation STATUS vocabulary only for inventory ? rows", + "as_of_note": "48h coding lane under Dylan autonomy; instrumentation STATUS vocabulary only for inventory ? rows. PARTIAL and REFUSED_NOT_24JET are honesty labels, not discharge, not a source of truth, and not FREEZE.", + "tip_provenance_note": "These instrumentation receipts carry no aligned_to_base_tip pin. This index does not add one and does not re-hash receipt sha256/bytes. They were not re-executed on hardening LOCK b3da6688a55d34681bb27f17ba6c6c5e16ad534c (short b3da668). Advancing the tip does not upgrade PARTIAL or REFUSED_NOT_24JET into PRESENT or SUCCESS.", + "honesty_labels_note": "Source-named subset stays 8 (6 MS-diag + kappa_c2 + s_f_fx). Inventing named jets toward 24 without a Drive/PROMOTE enumeration stays REFUSED_NOT_24JET. scientific_status_changed stays false.", "discharges_OBL_H5_JETMOD": false, "lemma_closed": false, "freeze": false, @@ -51,5 +53,5 @@ "bytes": 1558 } ], - "does_not_establish": "These instrumentation STATUS receipts do not discharge OBL-H5-JETMOD, do not FREEZE, do not invent a 24-jet roster, do not promote display/\u03ba, do not merge PR #12, and do not reopen certificate skim-trap PRs. Green \u2260 discharge." + "does_not_establish": "These instrumentation STATUS receipts do not discharge OBL-H5-JETMOD, do not FREEZE, do not invent a 24-jet roster, do not promote display/\u03ba, do not merge PR #12, and do not reopen certificate skim-trap PRs. PARTIAL and REFUSED_NOT_24JET are honesty labels, not a source of truth, and not PRESENT or SUCCESS. Green \u2260 discharge. scientific_status_changed stays false." } diff --git a/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json b/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json index 19a844881..5fe375eaf 100644 --- a/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json +++ b/docs/math_status_probes/INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json @@ -1,13 +1,13 @@ { "schema": "q0.inventable-jetmod-probes/v1", - "as_of_note": "Sibling-sweep named walls plus three shortcut refusals produced on chatgpt/drive-github-hardening-20260919 at historical SHA 1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba. aligned_to_base_tip is HISTORICAL / NONCURRENT: it records where those receipts were produced and is not alignment to the current hardening tip. Receipts were NOT re-executed on later hardening tips. No new lemmas. PR #12 left unmerged.", + "as_of_note": "Sibling-sweep named walls plus three shortcut refusals produced on chatgpt/drive-github-hardening-20260919 at historical SHA 1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba. aligned_to_base_tip is HISTORICAL / NONCURRENT generation provenance: it records where those receipts were produced and is not alignment to the current hardening tip. Receipts were NOT re-executed on later hardening tips, including LOCK b3da6688a55d34681bb27f17ba6c6c5e16ad534c (short b3da668). Advancing the tip does not upgrade REFUSED, REFUSED_IA_STRADDLES, EMPTY, ABSENT, or REFUSED_NOT_24JET into PRESENT or SUCCESS. Those tokens are honesty labels, not discharge, not a source of truth, and not FREEZE. Source-named subset stays 8; inventing toward 24 without Drive/PROMOTE enumeration stays REFUSED_NOT_24JET. No new lemmas. PR #12 left unmerged. scientific_status_changed stays false.", "aligned_to_base_branch": "chatgpt/drive-github-hardening-20260919", "aligned_to_base_tip": "1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba", "aligned_to_base_tip_status": "HISTORICAL_NONCURRENT", "aligned_to_base_tip_is_current": false, - "hardening_tip_observed_at_edit": "580864c7713f2a1ea831fadb3680166e36e4d449", + "hardening_tip_observed_at_edit": "b3da6688a55d34681bb27f17ba6c6c5e16ad534c", "receipts_reexecuted_on_hardening_tip_observed_at_edit": false, - "hardening_tip_observed_at_edit_note": "Observation only. Receipts were NOT re-executed on hardening_tip_observed_at_edit. This field does not re-verify the probes and does not make aligned_to_base_tip current.", + "hardening_tip_observed_at_edit_note": "Observation only at this docs edit. Receipts were NOT re-executed on hardening_tip_observed_at_edit. This field does not re-verify the probes, does not make aligned_to_base_tip current, and does not upgrade a refusal into PRESENT or SUCCESS. aligned_to_base_tip stays 1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba.", "discharges_OBL_H5_JETMOD": false, "discharges_lemma": false, "lemma_closed": false, @@ -77,5 +77,5 @@ "bytes": 2653 } ], - "does_not_establish": "These inventable probes do not discharge OBL-H5-JETMOD, do not FREEZE, do not certify an enclosure, do not invent lemmas, and do not merge or rebase draft PR #12. Green \u2260 discharge. OBL-H5-JETMOD stays OPEN." + "does_not_establish": "These inventable probes do not discharge OBL-H5-JETMOD, do not FREEZE, do not certify an enclosure, do not invent lemmas, and do not merge or rebase draft PR #12. REFUSED / REFUSED_IA_STRADDLES / EMPTY / ABSENT / REFUSED_NOT_24JET are honesty labels, not a source of truth, and not PRESENT or SUCCESS. Green \u2260 discharge. OBL-H5-JETMOD stays OPEN. scientific_status_changed stays false." } diff --git a/docs/math_status_probes/README.md b/docs/math_status_probes/README.md index 44cb424c8..055c3e50f 100644 --- a/docs/math_status_probes/README.md +++ b/docs/math_status_probes/README.md @@ -43,3 +43,15 @@ python3 tools/math_status_check.py Does not invent a 24-jet roster. Does not promote display/κ. Does not merge PR #12. `discharges_OBL_H5_JETMOD` stays false. `lemma_closed` stays false. `certified_C_H` stays false. `prizes_solved` stays 0. OBL-H5-JETMOD stays OPEN. Green ≠ discharge. + +## Honesty labels and tip provenance + +`REFUSED`, `REFUSED_IA_STRADDLES`, `EMPTY`, `ABSENT`, `PARTIAL`, and `REFUSED_NOT_24JET` are honesty labels. They are not discharge, not a source of truth, and not FREEZE. They are not an RN source of truth. `STATUS_RN_UNIF.md` keeps that lane. + +`aligned_to_base_tip` on `INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json`, and on the three shortcut receipts that already carry it (`inventable_24jet_roster_without_Drive_list_REFUSED_NOT_24JET_receipt.json`, `inventable_promote_display_residual_struct_kappa_REFUSED_receipt.json`, `inventable_merge_PR12_or_rung_discharge_REFUSED_receipt.json`), is `1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba`. That SHA is generation provenance (`HISTORICAL_NONCURRENT`). It is not a re-run on hardening LOCK `b3da6688a55d34681bb27f17ba6c6c5e16ad534c` (short `b3da668`). Sibling receipts and instrumentation receipts that omit the field stay without it. Receipt bytes are not re-hashed here. + +Advancing the tip does not re-execute `inventable_jetmod_probes.py` or `inventable_jetmod_instrumentation_status.py`. It does not upgrade a refusal, `EMPTY`, `ABSENT`, or `PARTIAL` into `PRESENT` or `SUCCESS`. + +24-jet STOP in `docs/math_status/STATUS_JETMOD.md`: the source-named subset stays 8 (6 MS-diag + `kappa_c2` + `s_f_fx`). Inventing toward 24 without a Drive/PROMOTE enumeration stays **REFUSED_NOT_24JET**. + +`scientific_status_changed` stays false. OBL-H5-JETMOD stays OPEN. Green ≠ discharge. diff --git a/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_instrumentation_status.py b/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_instrumentation_status.py index 30f6237d0..cef2c5cd8 100644 --- a/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_instrumentation_status.py +++ b/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_instrumentation_status.py @@ -5,6 +5,9 @@ first_band_proto / first_band_smoke / first_band_multi_gram → PARTIAL multi_jet_band / g12_ext_named → REFUSED_NOT_24JET +PARTIAL and REFUSED_NOT_24JET are honesty labels, not discharge, not a source +of truth, and not FREEZE. Source-named subset stays 8. A later hardening tip +does not upgrade these tokens to PRESENT or SUCCESS and is not a re-run. Does not invent a 24-jet roster, does not promote display/κ, does not claim OBL discharge, does not merge PR #12, does not reopen skim-trap PRs #7/#8. Green ≠ discharge. diff --git a/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_probes.py b/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_probes.py index 04681c246..ed7b25bf5 100644 --- a/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_probes.py +++ b/docs/math_status_probes/inventable_jetmod_probes.py @@ -27,7 +27,11 @@ HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent CT = "America/Chicago" -# Base this probe set is aligned to. Not a discharge and not a moving claim. +# Generation-time pin only (historical). Not the current hardening LOCK. +# Do not rewrite BASE_TIP to a later SHA unless these probes are actually +# re-run and that re-run is stated. Advancing the tip does not upgrade +# REFUSED / EMPTY / ABSENT / REFUSED_NOT_24JET into PRESENT or SUCCESS. +# Honesty note LOCK (not a re-run): b3da6688a55d34681bb27f17ba6c6c5e16ad534c. BASE_TIP = "1ea0ae8183fb0459c6678243946295518fded1ba" BASE_BRANCH = "chatgpt/drive-github-hardening-20260919" @@ -442,6 +446,10 @@ def main() -> int: probe_merge_pr12_or_rung_discharge, ), ] + # Checked-in INVENTABLE_PROBES_INDEX.json carries extra honesty fields + # (HISTORICAL_NONCURRENT, hardening_tip_observed_at_edit) that this + # generator does not emit. Running main() rewrites receipts; a later tip + # is not a reason to bump BASE_TIP without an honest re-run. index = { "schema": "q0.inventable-jetmod-probes/v1", "as_of_note": (