diff --git a/docs/retro/GP-DER-118-v1_10-legacy-source-crosswalk-20261023.md b/docs/retro/GP-DER-118-v1_10-legacy-source-crosswalk-20261023.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7cc6d2192 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/retro/GP-DER-118-v1_10-legacy-source-crosswalk-20261023.md @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +# GP-DER-118 v1.10 — legacy whole-carrier and body identity crosswalk (2026-10-23) + +**Disposition:** historical source-custody/navigation evidence only. **Scientific effect: NONE.** The cited GP-DER-118 v1.10 carrier remains **HOLD / NOT PROMOTED** at the evidence tier specified by its public cross-reference; this crosswalk neither changes that verdict nor grades the underlying proof. It establishes no new theorem, runtime execution, formal alignment, independence credit, graph node or current mathematical acceptance. + +## Reason for the crosswalk + +The public repository's latest default source cut examined for this work, main `897b6fb1a4a09bce87f98f172574af6b9c5cebc5`, has named v1.9 lineage carriers and references to v1.10, but no tracked file **named** `GP-DER-118-v1.10.md`. That absence in the *current filename tree* is **not** an absence of preserved original bytes: complete, nontruncated Git tree inspection of historical main `7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93` recovered full source replicas and the separate frozen theorem body. A connected owner-controlled historical source, checked privately and not uploaded here, matched those immutable public Git objects byte-for-byte. + +| Source object | Exact bytes | SHA-256 | Public Git blob | Status in this crosswalk | +|---|---:|---|---|---| +| GP-DER-118-v1.10 **whole carrier** | 30,933 | `c1d6e559274d7e87a3fa92f44cb2534a5e277a3b5941fd40db380599ddba0564` | `ade0b6984c7b94dc4880018fb6a7e10328bb858c` | Historical source bytes verified | +| GP-DER-118-v1.10 **frozen theorem body**, a different byte object | 29,293 | `9b7901e112a4857e3ea59942858684f72fc09a2825b1efa859360dd8fa55f014` | `d4711ab4daa3decba35cd9f9fcb833178684d0ea` | Historical body bytes verified | + +The body is not interchangeable with the whole carrier. In the checked owner-controlled original, the body occupies the exact contiguous byte interval `[1616,30909)` of the 30,933-byte file. The Git blob and SHA-256 of that slice match the separate historical body. These two sizes, hashes and their distinct roles independently match the publicly recorded [KIMI-AUD-024 two-sided dependency identity](../../history/carrier20_recovery_20260928/public_carriers/KIMI-AUD-024_lb6_two_sided.txt). Exact byte identity is **source-custody evidence**, not mathematical validation. + +## Immutable publicly inspectable source locations + +Historical commit: `7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93`, tree `6b3a408d4ee57f585ed35809f9330bcd45de0a27`; GitHub recursive tree was not truncated. + +1. [Whole carrier — controlling freeze and record](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/blob/7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93/drive/mirrors/15_REVIEWS_RESPONSES_AND_CLOSURES/00_REVIEW_PACKAGES_AND_GATE_CLARIFICATIONS/P0.1%20%E2%80%94%20FROZEN%20HASH%20666f582c%20%E2%80%94%20SAME-LINE%20AUDITS%20AND%20REPAIRS/P0.1%20POST-RATIFICATION%20RAW%20%E2%80%94%202026-08-02/01%20%E2%80%94%20CONTROLLING%20FREEZE%20AND%20RECORD/GP-DER-118-v1.10.md). At `7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93`, pathname `drive/mirrors/15_REVIEWS_RESPONSES_AND_CLOSURES/00_REVIEW_PACKAGES_AND_GATE_CLARIFICATIONS/P0.1 — FROZEN HASH 666f582c — SAME-LINE AUDITS AND REPAIRS/P0.1 POST-RATIFICATION RAW — 2026-08-02/01 — CONTROLLING FREEZE AND RECORD/GP-DER-118-v1.10.md`, 30,933 bytes, Git blob `ade0b6984c7b94dc4880018fb6a7e10328bb858c`. +2. [Whole carrier — separately filed later reading copy](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/blob/7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93/drive/mirrors/02_RESEARCH_CARRY_FORWARD_CANON/2026-09-12%20%E2%80%94%20NEXT%20PHASE%20%E2%80%94%20LOCAL%20PATH%20LOWER-BOUND%20CANDIDATE/REVIEW_INTAKE%20%E2%80%94%202026-09-12%20%E2%80%94%20KIMI%20LPW/GP-DER-118-v1.10_RAW.md). At the same commit, pathname `drive/mirrors/02_RESEARCH_CARRY_FORWARD_CANON/2026-09-12 — NEXT PHASE — LOCAL PATH LOWER-BOUND CANDIDATE/REVIEW_INTAKE — 2026-09-12 — KIMI LPW/GP-DER-118-v1.10_RAW.md`, same 30,933 bytes and Git blob. It is a **replica of the same evidence object**, not independent corroboration. +3. [Frozen body — separate byte annex](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/blob/7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93/drive/mirrors/15_REVIEWS_RESPONSES_AND_CLOSURES/00_REVIEW_PACKAGES_AND_GATE_CLARIFICATIONS/P0.1%20%E2%80%94%20FROZEN%20HASH%20666f582c%20%E2%80%94%20SAME-LINE%20AUDITS%20AND%20REPAIRS/P0.1%20POST-RATIFICATION%20RAW%20%E2%80%94%202026-08-02/06%20%E2%80%94%20ROUND%206%2B7%20CONTROL%20FOLD%20AND%20BYTE%20ANNEX%20%E2%80%94%202026-08-02/BYTE%20ANNEX%20AND%20ARCHIVE-INDEPENDENT%20REPLAY%20%E2%80%94%202026-08-02/GP-DER-118-v1.10_frozen_theorem_body.md). At the same commit, pathname `drive/mirrors/15_REVIEWS_RESPONSES_AND_CLOSURES/00_REVIEW_PACKAGES_AND_GATE_CLARIFICATIONS/P0.1 — FROZEN HASH 666f582c — SAME-LINE AUDITS AND REPAIRS/P0.1 POST-RATIFICATION RAW — 2026-08-02/06 — ROUND 6+7 CONTROL FOLD AND BYTE ANNEX — 2026-08-02/BYTE ANNEX AND ARCHIVE-INDEPENDENT REPLAY — 2026-08-02/GP-DER-118-v1.10_frozen_theorem_body.md`, 29,293 bytes, Git blob `d4711ab4daa3decba35cd9f9fcb833178684d0ea`. + +Reproduction using only the **already-public** immutable Git history (no private cloud access needed): + +```sh +git show '7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93:drive/mirrors/15_REVIEWS_RESPONSES_AND_CLOSURES/00_REVIEW_PACKAGES_AND_GATE_CLARIFICATIONS/P0.1 — FROZEN HASH 666f582c — SAME-LINE AUDITS AND REPAIRS/P0.1 POST-RATIFICATION RAW — 2026-08-02/01 — CONTROLLING FREEZE AND RECORD/GP-DER-118-v1.10.md' | sha256sum +git show '7caac254cbba5f513b2dc0afb56b78a598bc0c93:drive/mirrors/15_REVIEWS_RESPONSES_AND_CLOSURES/00_REVIEW_PACKAGES_AND_GATE_CLARIFICATIONS/P0.1 — FROZEN HASH 666f582c — SAME-LINE AUDITS AND REPAIRS/P0.1 POST-RATIFICATION RAW — 2026-08-02/06 — ROUND 6+7 CONTROL FOLD AND BYTE ANNEX — 2026-08-02/BYTE ANNEX AND ARCHIVE-INDEPENDENT REPLAY — 2026-08-02/GP-DER-118-v1.10_frozen_theorem_body.md' | sha256sum +``` + +The expected output hashes are the two SHA-256 values in the table above. The public history may contain further replicas; this document cites three personally inspected GitHub file objects rather than claiming a complete historical replica census. + +## The mathematical/source boundaries remain separate + +- **Version:** `GP-DER-118-v1.9` and v1.10 are distinct historical source versions. Matching a v1.10 body or carrier does not imply that earlier v1.9 review applies to new v1.10 bytes. +- **Upper versus lower:** This upper theorem carrier must not be collapsed with `KIMI-THM-023` (the **lower-bound assembly**). The [KIMI lower-bound landing review](../../reviews/lb_rate_thm023_landing_20260926/REVIEW.md) expressly retains its conditional/HOLD status and rejects promotion of the printed 0.9144 constant as a proved all-small-radius uniform lower bound. +- **Scope:** The cited KIMI-AUD-024 record explicitly carries the GP-DER-118-v1.10 **HOLD / NOT PROMOTED** evidence-tier label, independent of distinct ratification of some component arguments. Neither ratified component scope nor archived bytes retroactively ratify this whole successor carrier. +- **Implementation:** `code_implementation = NOT_VERIFIED`. This metadata-only cut did not authenticate a matching executable program, CI or Lean theorem expressing the v1.10 mathematical statement. Do not infer a program from a related SIDE24 or later graph component. +- **Current graph / authoritative register:** `admitted_graph_node = NOT_ESTABLISHED`; `scientific_acceptance = NOT_INFERRED`; `formal_statement_alignment = NOT_RUN`. No existing graph node ID, Artifact Index row or research-status value is changed by this document. A later reviewed mapping must preserve statement/hypothesis scope, not use a title-only join. +- **Storage/publication:** This change contains public Git metadata and paths **already visible at the historical public commit**, not a private Dropbox path, namespace, file ID, bearer link, personal locator, unpublished content or raw source. The user-controlled private original was only used for read-only byte authentication and was not mirrored/uploaded to this PR. + +## Dependency use and remaining work + +This is a **historical source locator** for the existing RETRO-MATH-BIND work; it does not create a new registry. Consumers may use the exact Git commit/paths/blob/sha256 as source-custody inputs. To map this carrier to an implementation or graph node, a separate task must identify a specific accepted mathematical statement scope, exact code/formal source, applicable reviews, and any needed historical/successor dependencies, and independently verify the association. Unknown relationships stay `UNVERIFIED`. + +Companion public evidence: [historical KIMI-AUD-024](../../history/carrier20_recovery_20260928/public_carriers/KIMI-AUD-024_lb6_two_sided.txt), [KIMI-THM-023 source-review HOLD](../../reviews/lb_rate_thm023_landing_20260926/REVIEW.md), and the [RETRO-MATH-BIND inventory discussion](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/539) (active coordination successor to #475). No direct mutation of `Math-`, proof bodies, `LANDING_CLAIMS`, `lemma_closed`, CI/workflows, permissions, or hosted files was performed. + +*Author: OpenAI/GPT-6 foreground archival metadata stage; source exposed and organizational independence 0. Distinct nonauthor review and nonauthor integration are required before this Draft becomes an effective current-tree source locator. Owner mandate: [2026-10-15](../../governance/OWNER_MANDATE_20261015.md); standing delegation: [v2.1](../../governance/OP-AUTONOMY-20260923-v2.1.md).*