From 20caa0e20a47a826f017abb26f35830e17464204 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy <249851642+d6g8k5htny-coder@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 13:03:55 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 1/4] Record freshness integration and source accounting boundaries --- BASELINE.md | 21 +++++++++- DECISIONS.md | 3 ++ GOVERNANCE.md | 16 +++++++- PROOF_INDEX.md | 21 ++++++++-- STATUS.md | 103 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-- TOOLING.md | 19 +++++++-- 6 files changed, 169 insertions(+), 14 deletions(-) diff --git a/BASELINE.md b/BASELINE.md index 81c3862b9..fd317f564 100644 --- a/BASELINE.md +++ b/BASELINE.md @@ -1,11 +1,30 @@ # CBZ baseline ledger -**State: Partial Baseline; CBZ-0 is not established.** +**State: active intermediate baseline; CBZ-0 is not established. No terminal Partial Baseline is declared.** This ledger binds the currently observed repository snapshot to the twelve owner criteria and final gate matrix. It records evidence and gaps; it is not a completion certificate. +## Observed integration boundary — 9 November 2026 + +Before this documentation change, the sequentially observed defaults were +Main `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`, Math- +`f532c3e2d91a0c7679a37c733741660917a9b21b`, and Workspace +`1c552538e6a8952548e2bd5297a0031dda1f94e7`, whose gitlink pins that Main. +The source-bound observations, skips, failures and completed post-merge +checks are in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november-2026). +A later Main merge requires another guarded Workspace pin refresh. + +All twelve CBZ-0 criteria remain unawarded: complete Git/ref/admin cleanup, +proof dispositions, full Layer A audit, no-skip regression, whole-federation +Lean/kernel/axiom pass, declared mutation threshold, final current pins, +complete self-verified tools, consistent surfaces, STATUS-only cold start and +decisions must be observed together. The known 25 skips, unadopted T10 +proposals and missing final orchestrator remain explicit. This is an active +intermediate ledger, not a terminal Partial or CBZ-0 declaration. Earlier +dated tip descriptions below are historical. + ## Freshness provenance candidate — 9 November 2026 The sequential observed boundary is Main signed merge diff --git a/DECISIONS.md b/DECISIONS.md index 909ff6434..df1145ba6 100644 --- a/DECISIONS.md +++ b/DECISIONS.md @@ -113,3 +113,6 @@ Append-only. Historical source outcomes remain in their original records. | 2026-11-09 18:16 | 2 | B/tooling, conflict | Preserve the real subject-origin false kill in the older node-status freshness mutation grader and require actual pre-cleanup selected-body/assertion provenance for future kills. Add adverse and workflow controls, retain all eleven original mutations, and keep the strict stale outcome visible. Correct the `eng.hard-gate` status and published projection after the read-only directory observation while preserving its original source pin. Local tests and exact limits are in STATUS and TOOLING; hosted integration remains unobserved. This changes no mathematical or scientific disposition. | Yes | Native source `9486c850d0c22fd1438e18fb392dbe02d7bd214f`, tree `d9a794488b34168cad49580a40460b44a5b33dfd`; local qualification archive SHA-256 `9e980d03e16d94716d62df10c00a39c88f0c0717b9de414d60a13ebc5b3d7411`; [A8 finding](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/738#issuecomment-6747450269); [source observation](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/738#issuecomment-6747623136); [Workspace checks](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/738#issuecomment-6747829645). | | 2026-11-09 18:28 | 2 | B/integration, conflict | Integrated Workspace #53 through fresh exact-head checks and normal expected-head merge. The tested tree became signed Workspace `2441baf051312878ca28e462d455cfbcd8e91b20`, pinning then-current Main `6ab126be…`. Preserve the four earlier zero-job internal-server failures and refused retries. Main #782's actual provenance artifact qualifies the bounded hosted component, while navigation failed before jobs and two other workflow runs reported internal errors despite successful individual jobs. Preserve each outcome and require fresh current-head checks; no bypass or final-gate claim. | Yes | Workspace tested tree `13dd6b73201627177c568cb4233a33fb60acbbab`; hosted artifact SHA-256 `478e130f46398aa00756f4b78692a8a34e6897eda4d2ceb63bba43b74e71c303`; read-back supplement SHA-256 `528f5686c2ef37c214142d5d2ab00a2a4b8a5642aae320a5304002abbde464ce`; [board result](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/738#issuecomment-6748069485). | | 2026-11-09 18:30 | 2 | B/CI | The post-merge Workspace pins job passed eight network and strict-current pins, four canonical inputs and 187 tests. The post-merge federation workflow failed before any job with GitHub internal-server correlation `63dc5ffa-474e-4405-925b-574e391c43c6`; GitHub refused its failed-job retry with HTTP 403. Preserve both outcomes, do not infer a passing post-merge federation run, and continue other authorized checks. | Yes | Workspace pins run `42674111147`, job `129351557433`; federation run `42674110867`. | +| 2026-11-09 19:00 | 2 | B/integration, status | Record Main #782 and Workspace #54 normal expected-head integration, exact hosted and local execution, 25 preserved Main regression skips, and actual post-merge outcomes. Bound all five canonical surfaces to the sequential pre-documentation observation without claiming final gates; any subsequent Main merge requires another Workspace pin refresh. Historical failed or abandoned workflows, original false kill, proof and scientific boundaries remain unchanged. | Yes | Main `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`, tree `5b771047cb384a9bb167ed2df505489cee1cbf7d`; Workspace `1c552538e6a8952548e2bd5297a0031dda1f94e7`, tree `e069b39ba25ffc2e3c6e2838a9b53c1e4e8484a6`; checkpoint v152 SHA-256 `0158242067489b021eb889714684e4cbb6f8334871aeb10b0332b52bc0ffd839`; board #738 comment 6748667855. | +| 2026-11-09 19:00 | 2 | B/accounting | Independently reproduced the T10 normalization and proposal records byte for byte; independently checked 46 quotations across five selected records, and restored all 1,872 bound source blobs through a selective native-object pack without network. The pack is not a full ref/history backup; no branch deletion, adoption, logical isolation or scientific review is implied. Preserve the initial ad hoc pack-script SyntaxError and its corrected result. | Yes; retained source and selective pack | Source Main `fd77339a5e4f6f27704f69b3082e31da90fb1dcd`; records SHA-256 `2ee2f0e5d9784cfee824450efb7f8c35f9f89f2dc1199451b913122613b28722`; read-back supplement SHA-256 `2bebe703fba2b7538e127182fb91dbd4c32d2a53ecf0d768982cb94c62a0a10a`; [readback](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/684#issuecomment-6748666194). | +| 2026-11-09 19:01 | 2 | B/publication | The ordinary Main #782 workflow deployed the qualified site artifact and observed the public publication receipt for 32 snapshots. The separately retained rendered Chromium report recorded 39/39 cases and zero page errors, within its physical-device and screen-reader limits. This publication does not establish scientific acceptance, proof closure or the STATUS-only cold start. A first receipt-bundle restore attempt failed because the prerequisite was not connected to a ref; after connecting the exact prerequisite, a fresh unbundle retained the two receipt commits and blobs even with alternates removed. Preserve both outcomes. | Published; receipt history retained | Run `42677287313`, deploy job `129367351564`; source `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`; prepared receipt `29a8b2be282ebfe02c2bc71743ac477a63f74842`, observed receipt `4a92fb8a90fa2f0a54ffdd1b009e0771201c0fe9`; metadata artifact SHA-256 `5088130f7dd1d6b0c716651905b09bfa7bd73628e6d46a0a010381c978be9fb4`; state artifact SHA-256 `7ef72f47e85b03ba10f807b307bfad0e7a33ca059d762706e4d6df89e9c18a98`. | diff --git a/GOVERNANCE.md b/GOVERNANCE.md index 0393c631d..20f9a407f 100644 --- a/GOVERNANCE.md +++ b/GOVERNANCE.md @@ -18,6 +18,18 @@ Its team-model sections 1.5, 7.4 and 8 supersede older exclusive-owner and monitor-specific integration restrictions. Historical decisions retain their original timestamps and outcomes; the latest directive controls future action. +## Observed freshness integration — 9 November 2026 + +Main #782 and Workspace #54 integrated through normal expected-head checks. +The sequential source boundary, executed checks, retained failures and +post-merge limits are in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november-2026). +The selected-body provenance rule below is now used by the landed freshness +mutation component; its old false kill stays historical. No scientific review, +whole Layer A clearance or final G0–G11 pass is implied. A subsequent Main +merge requires a guarded Workspace pin refresh, and actual platform +protections remain binding. This section supersedes older dated statements +about current tips below. + ## Freshness mutation provenance candidate — 9 November 2026 An assertion is an admissible kill for the node-status freshness mutation @@ -30,8 +42,8 @@ historical results are not rebound. The new bounded control's purpose, commands, verification and limits are registered in [TOOLING.md](TOOLING.md) and its current observation in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md). These controls are not an adversarial process sandbox or mathematical/scientific review. -Workspace #53's guarded merge pins the then-current Main `6ab126be…`; -the newer Main freshness repair remains a draft. Later integration must use +Workspace #53's guarded merge pinned then-current Main `6ab126be…`; +the freshness repair was a draft at that earlier observation. Later integration must use fresh heads and normal required checks, preserving the recorded platform failures. Older dated descriptions of current tips below are historical. diff --git a/PROOF_INDEX.md b/PROOF_INDEX.md index 8c5538918..21a71fb6f 100644 --- a/PROOF_INDEX.md +++ b/PROOF_INDEX.md @@ -8,6 +8,21 @@ into a kernel proof. A theorem is CLOSED only for the literal statement and allowed-axiom boundary actually checked. Anything else must remain OPEN or be placed in a complete dormant quarantine. +## Observed integration proof boundary — 9 November 2026 + +The landed Main #782 freshness repair and Workspace #54 pin update are +engineering and custody changes. They do not change, close, refute or rebind +any mathematical statement, bound, axiom, hypothesis, proof, quarantine, +kernel result or scientific disposition. The current observed source boundary +is described in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november-2026). + +The independent T10 readback checked byte reproduction and selected source +quotations for 65 proposed records; it did not prove the proposals complete, +logically isolated or scientifically accepted, and did not adopt them. The +selective source-object pack is not a full history backup. Whole-federation +proof inventory and final kernel/axiom checks remain unawarded. This section +supersedes older dated descriptions of current tips below. + ## Freshness repair proof boundary — 9 November 2026 The candidate described in @@ -18,9 +33,9 @@ quarantine, kernel result, historical mathematical statement or scientific disposition. The retained original false kill concerns mutation evidence, not the mathematical statements. -The current sequential Workspace merge `2441baf0…` pins Main `6ab126be…`; -the freshness repair remains a separate Main draft. This observation -supersedes older dated descriptions of current tips below. +At that earlier observation, Workspace `2441baf0…` pinned Main `6ab126be…`, +and the freshness repair was a separate Main draft. The later integration is +recorded above. ## Navigation history candidate boundary — 9 November 2026 diff --git a/STATUS.md b/STATUS.md index b218341e4..c2b552e38 100644 --- a/STATUS.md +++ b/STATUS.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # CBZ-0 execution status -**State: Partial Baseline; CBZ-0 is not established.** +**State: active intermediate baseline; CBZ-0 is not established. No terminal Partial Baseline is declared.** This entry adopts the owner's expanded [Master Directive](governance/MASTER_DIRECTIVE_20261029_SWARM.txt) and [team protocol](GOVERNANCE.md#team-structure-and-coordination). @@ -8,6 +8,102 @@ The inherited scientific material below is explicitly the 29 September snapshot, not a fresh CLOSED decision or an empirical-validation receipt. Its mathematical statements, source cuts and review limits are preserved. +## Observed integration boundary — 9 November 2026 + +This section records sequential observations through 19:02 UTC, before this +documentation change. Main #782 merged as +`f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`, tree +`5b771047cb384a9bb167ed2df505489cee1cbf7d`, with parents `6ab126be…` and +`9bf048e9aeee3b846da92fba6e4d0708dee310e7`. Workspace #54 merged as +`1c552538e6a8952548e2bd5297a0031dda1f94e7`, tree +`e069b39ba25ffc2e3c6e2838a9b53c1e4e8484a6`, pinning that Main commit. +Math- was `f532c3e2d91a0c7679a37c733741660917a9b21b`. These observations +were not simultaneous. A later Main merge, including this documentation +change, requires another guarded Workspace pin refresh before current-tip +agreement may be claimed. The older dated sections below remain historical. + +The repaired freshness mutation grader rejects the real subject-origin false +kill; the original failure and all eleven original mutations remain. Current +Main #782 hosted controls job `129353108258` passed 20 focused controls, +eight designated guard detections and 22/22 authorized original-mutation +kills in each parent mode, with real subject-origin refusal in both child +modes. This is selected synchronous unittest and named-pattern evidence, not +a hostile-child sandbox, full Layer A audit or final G0/G6. Its bounded +commands and limits are in [TOOLING.md](TOOLING.md). The old false-kill +result is not retroactively rebound. The `eng.hard-gate` engineering record +remains explicitly stale under the cited-content check; its historical source +pin is preserved. A strict freshness check is expected to return nonzero +while that observed drift remains. + +At earlier native tree `1c765f1aae84cd91c2d26706b967690b73823e2c`, full +local discovery completed 2,489 tests in each Python mode with 25 explicit +skips each. At the current tested Main #782 merge, hosted navigation ran +2,489 tests with 25 skips and a separate 20 history tests without skips. The +25 local skips comprised five restricted-container checks, two browser +checks, two Lean-dependent checks, one historical composition check, four +real-record checks with no applicable fields, one real-record live-source +comparison not performed, and ten pytest-dependent checks. Other separately executed controls do not turn these into one +no-skip run. Criterion 5 remains unawarded. Exact logs and limits are in +checkpoint v152 and the independently read-back supplement +`libfile_fde3_f-9cfc31236cd88191b63533d7eb3b0729_59a0f9f234e48191bc19fddcc0f80648`. + +Workspace #54's exact-head hosted federation job ran 187 tests in both modes +without skips; its pins job passed eight network and strict-current pins, +four canonical inputs and 187 tests. Local exact-tree tests also ran 187 per +mode without skips. Its post-merge pins job `129366156775` passed the same +eight current pins, four canonical inputs and 187 tests; the separate +post-merge federation job `129366157128` subsequently ran 187 tests in +each mode without skips. Main's post-merge required aggregate job +`129366584981` reported success at `f1ef3a2b…`. Its current-site deployment +job `129367351564` completed: the published-source receipt was prepared at +`29a8b2be282ebfe02c2bc71743ac477a63f74842` and observed at +`4a92fb8a90fa2f0a54ffdd1b009e0771201c0fe9` for 32 snapshots. The hosted +rendered Chromium report recorded 39/39 passing cases and no page errors; +this is bounded emulation, not physical-device, complete screen-reader or +scientific certification, nor the STATUS-only cold-start test. Previously +failed GitHub startup, abandoned-job and retry outcomes remain recorded +below and are not replaced by later successes. + +Independent mechanical T10 readback reproduced 65 **proposed** obligation +records and 559 other items byte for byte from retained source. It matched +all 46 source statements in five selected records. A restored selective +Git-object pack resolved all 1,872 recorded source bindings; it is not full +ref/history retention and authorizes no branch deletion. Those proposals +have not thereby been adopted or shown mathematically isolated, closed or +scientifically accepted. The exact source, logs and selective pack were +independently read back from +`libfile_fde3_f-5a2970c2901881918ed36aad44f1610a_59a0f9f234e48191bc19fddcc0f80648`, +SHA-256 `2bebe703fba2b7538e127182fb91dbd4c32d2a53ecf0d768982cb94c62a0a10a`. + +For available bounded checks, from a Main checkout run: + +```sh +python3 -B -S -m unittest tests.test_node_status_mutation_grader -v +python3 -B -O -S -m unittest tests.test_node_status_mutation_grader -v +python3 -B -S cbz/evidence/node-status-freshness/run_mutations.py +python3 -B -O -S cbz/evidence/node-status-freshness/run_mutations.py +python3 -B -S tools/cbz/g11_census.py --rev HEAD --json /tmp/cbz-g11.json +python3 -B -O -S tools/cbz/g11_census.py --rev HEAD --json /tmp/cbz-g11-opt.json +python3 -B -S tools/node_status_refresh.py records/node_status --check +python3 -B -S -m unittest discover -s tests -p 'test_*.py' -v +``` + +From the Workspace checkout, run `python3 tools/verify_pins.py +--require-current` and `python3 tools/verify_canonical_inputs.py`. These +commands need the documented dependencies and network where applicable. +They do not implement the complete G0–G11 matrix; no single documented +command currently runs that final pass. Retain actual skips, errors, sources +and exits. The proof index, quarantine inventory, whole Layer A audit, +full regression, final kernel/axiom pass, mutation threshold, final pin and +Git/admin inventory, tooling admission, consistent surfaces and STATUS-only +cold start have not been observed together. No CBZ-0 or terminal Partial is +claimed. + +The durable contribution checkpoint is version 152, independently read back +with SHA-256 `0158242067489b021eb889714684e4cbb6f8334871aeb10b0332b52bc0ffd839`. +The original large evidence ZIP remains at its v139 identity and SHA; newer +supplements are separate, not a matched replacement. + ## Freshness provenance repair candidate — 9 November 2026 Main #779 merged as signed `6ab126beda65e19865b8468b52f8757ac2324e1f`, @@ -17,7 +113,7 @@ native source commit `9486c850d0c22fd1438e18fb392dbe02d7bd214f` has tree `d9a794488b34168cad49580a40460b44a5b33dfd`. Draft Main #782 hosted head `c65dc2d3ee52038a0804f6c7455ff8b5844d17ab` tested synthetic merge `0f76c40fac38af52aed6b32693bb3e1c6ea902d3`, tree -`cfc7bca8d65eec3592e22be0530ddbdcc406f134`; it is not yet integrated. +`cfc7bca8d65eec3592e22be0530ddbdcc406f134`; at that earlier observation it was not yet integrated. The later integration is recorded above. Workspace #53 merged as signed `2441baf051312878ca28e462d455cfbcd8e91b20`, tree `13dd6b73201627177c568cb4233a33fb60acbbab`, pinning Main `6ab126be…`. @@ -61,8 +157,7 @@ contains the eight expected files: 20 controls, eight guard detections and refusals in both child modes. This observed component is not final G0 or G6. The exact native composed-tree G11 censuses passed in both modes with 69 tools, zero failing tools and zero skips; that is not the final federation G11 gate. -The full local regressions were still running. Inspect all checks at any later -candidate head. +At that earlier observation the full local regressions were still running. Their later outcomes are recorded above. The hosted navigation workflow `42673203393` failed before jobs with a GitHub internal-server annotation; its failed-job retry was refused with diff --git a/TOOLING.md b/TOOLING.md index 129b05a85..aa836ca6f 100644 --- a/TOOLING.md +++ b/TOOLING.md @@ -2,13 +2,24 @@ **State: component registry; the final federation toolchain is incomplete.** -This file lists runnable mission-relevant tools present in Main. The current -documentation candidate is based on signed Main -`6ab126beda65e19865b8468b52f8757ac2324e1f`; older source-parent bindings are -preserved in their dated sections as history. Each entry states purpose, +This file lists runnable mission-relevant tools present in Main. The latest +observed integration boundary is recorded below; older source-parent bindings +are preserved in their dated sections as history. Each entry states purpose, command, verification and scope. A component passing in isolation does not complete a CBZ gate or the final G0–G11 matrix. +## Observed freshness tool integration — 9 November 2026 + +The node-status provenance guard below landed through Main #782. Current-head +hosted controls job `129353108258` exercised 20 focused controls, eight +designated guard detections and 22/22 authorized original-mutation kills per +parent mode, including real subject-origin refusals in both child modes. Its +commands, original false kill and bounded synchronous-unittest scope remain +documented below; historical outcomes are not rebound. See +[STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november-2026) for +the source boundary, current stale record, retained failures and final-gate +limits. This section supersedes earlier dated current-tip descriptions. + ## Node-status freshness origin guard candidate — 9 November 2026 **Purpose:** reject false mutation kills caused by failures in the subject, From 681c16025d97e29f95070d533eb35df041f5991d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy <249851642+d6g8k5htny-coder@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 13:08:50 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 2/4] Record T10 field and procedural-boundary checks --- DECISIONS.md | 1 + GOVERNANCE.md | 7 +++++-- PROOF_INDEX.md | 6 +++++- STATUS.md | 14 ++++++++++++-- TOOLING.md | 29 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 5 files changed, 52 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/DECISIONS.md b/DECISIONS.md index df1145ba6..24f587a6d 100644 --- a/DECISIONS.md +++ b/DECISIONS.md @@ -116,3 +116,4 @@ Append-only. Historical source outcomes remain in their original records. | 2026-11-09 19:00 | 2 | B/integration, status | Record Main #782 and Workspace #54 normal expected-head integration, exact hosted and local execution, 25 preserved Main regression skips, and actual post-merge outcomes. Bound all five canonical surfaces to the sequential pre-documentation observation without claiming final gates; any subsequent Main merge requires another Workspace pin refresh. Historical failed or abandoned workflows, original false kill, proof and scientific boundaries remain unchanged. | Yes | Main `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`, tree `5b771047cb384a9bb167ed2df505489cee1cbf7d`; Workspace `1c552538e6a8952548e2bd5297a0031dda1f94e7`, tree `e069b39ba25ffc2e3c6e2838a9b53c1e4e8484a6`; checkpoint v152 SHA-256 `0158242067489b021eb889714684e4cbb6f8334871aeb10b0332b52bc0ffd839`; board #738 comment 6748667855. | | 2026-11-09 19:00 | 2 | B/accounting | Independently reproduced the T10 normalization and proposal records byte for byte; independently checked 46 quotations across five selected records, and restored all 1,872 bound source blobs through a selective native-object pack without network. The pack is not a full ref/history backup; no branch deletion, adoption, logical isolation or scientific review is implied. Preserve the initial ad hoc pack-script SyntaxError and its corrected result. | Yes; retained source and selective pack | Source Main `fd77339a5e4f6f27704f69b3082e31da90fb1dcd`; records SHA-256 `2ee2f0e5d9784cfee824450efb7f8c35f9f89f2dc1199451b913122613b28722`; read-back supplement SHA-256 `2bebe703fba2b7538e127182fb91dbd4c32d2a53ecf0d768982cb94c62a0a10a`; [readback](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/684#issuecomment-6748666194). | | 2026-11-09 19:01 | 2 | B/publication | The ordinary Main #782 workflow deployed the qualified site artifact and observed the public publication receipt for 32 snapshots. The separately retained rendered Chromium report recorded 39/39 cases and zero page errors, within its physical-device and screen-reader limits. This publication does not establish scientific acceptance, proof closure or the STATUS-only cold start. A first receipt-bundle restore attempt failed because the prerequisite was not connected to a ref; after connecting the exact prerequisite, a fresh unbundle retained the two receipt commits and blobs even with alternates removed. Preserve both outcomes. | Published; receipt history retained | Run `42677287313`, deploy job `129367351564`; source `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`; prepared receipt `29a8b2be282ebfe02c2bc71743ac477a63f74842`, observed receipt `4a92fb8a90fa2f0a54ffdd1b009e0771201c0fe9`; metadata artifact SHA-256 `5088130f7dd1d6b0c716651905b09bfa7bd73628e6d46a0a010381c978be9fb4`; state artifact SHA-256 `7ef72f47e85b03ba10f807b307bfad0e7a33ca059d762706e4d6df89e9c18a98`. | +| 2026-11-09 19:08 | 2 | B/conflict, accounting | A non-admitted T10 structural probe found all eleven named fields nonempty and refused 26 adverse malformed-input controls in each mode. It did not verify semantic accuracy, mathematical blocking reasons, logical isolation or adoption. Proposals 019, 020 and 049 mention absent or unresolved review/novelty alongside source or proof limitations; preserve that history while treating missing procedural review alone as no mathematical blocker under the owner directive. No record was modified or promoted. | Yes; evidence-only probe | Input SHA-256 `2ee2f0e5d9784cfee824450efb7f8c35f9f89f2dc1199451b913122613b28722`; probe supplement SHA-256 `fb4d20e9a6e653e589e3e93cf053026ba73aa290367aba9309cecb5958ed6bcb`; main#684 comment 6748878712. | diff --git a/GOVERNANCE.md b/GOVERNANCE.md index 20f9a407f..6dfbe24fd 100644 --- a/GOVERNANCE.md +++ b/GOVERNANCE.md @@ -27,8 +27,11 @@ The selected-body provenance rule below is now used by the landed freshness mutation component; its old false kill stays historical. No scientific review, whole Layer A clearance or final G0–G11 pass is implied. A subsequent Main merge requires a guarded Workspace pin refresh, and actual platform -protections remain binding. This section supersedes older dated statements -about current tips below. +protections remain binding. The retained T10 field-shape probe is evidence +only: nonempty fields cannot establish a mathematical obstruction or logical +isolation, and missing procedural review alone is not a mathematical blocker. +Its exact commands and limits are in [TOOLING.md](TOOLING.md#t10-structural-readback-probe--9-november-2026). +This section supersedes older dated statements about current tips below. ## Freshness mutation provenance candidate — 9 November 2026 diff --git a/PROOF_INDEX.md b/PROOF_INDEX.md index 21a71fb6f..d0a1cf9bf 100644 --- a/PROOF_INDEX.md +++ b/PROOF_INDEX.md @@ -18,7 +18,11 @@ is described in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november- The independent T10 readback checked byte reproduction and selected source quotations for 65 proposed records; it did not prove the proposals complete, -logically isolated or scientifically accepted, and did not adopt them. The +logically isolated or scientifically accepted, and did not adopt them. A +separate structural-only check found all eleven fields present; it did not +validate their mathematical meaning. Proposals 019, 020 and 049 mention +review or novelty in blocking-reason text alongside source/proof limits; +missing procedural review itself is not a mathematical blocker. The selective source-object pack is not a full history backup. Whole-federation proof inventory and final kernel/axiom checks remain unawarded. This section supersedes older dated descriptions of current tips below. diff --git a/STATUS.md b/STATUS.md index c2b552e38..88236b96b 100644 --- a/STATUS.md +++ b/STATUS.md @@ -74,6 +74,15 @@ scientifically accepted. The exact source, logs and selective pack were independently read back from `libfile_fde3_f-5a2970c2901881918ed36aad44f1610a_59a0f9f234e48191bc19fddcc0f80648`, SHA-256 `2bebe703fba2b7538e127182fb91dbd4c32d2a53ecf0d768982cb94c62a0a10a`. +A later structural-only readback found nonempty, basic-type values for all +eleven required fields in the 65 proposals, with 26 adverse malformed-input +controls refused in each mode. This does not establish the truth of any +field, an exact mathematical boundary, a blocking reason or isolation. +Proposals 019, 020 and 049 mention absent or unresolved review/novelty in +their blocking-reason text alongside source or proof limits. Those historical +notes remain, but missing procedural review alone is not a mathematical +blocker. The scope, commands and retained probe are in +[TOOLING.md](TOOLING.md#t10-structural-readback-probe--9-november-2026). For available bounded checks, from a Main checkout run: @@ -99,8 +108,9 @@ Git/admin inventory, tooling admission, consistent surfaces and STATUS-only cold start have not been observed together. No CBZ-0 or terminal Partial is claimed. -The durable contribution checkpoint is version 152, independently read back -with SHA-256 `0158242067489b021eb889714684e4cbb6f8334871aeb10b0332b52bc0ffd839`. +At 19:06 UTC the independently read-back contribution checkpoint was version +153, SHA-256 `ed780a4dd034b648f96d8e959587ef17f0270d5a85e65b52fdbfb82f1df5c7e4`; +later versions may exist. The original large evidence ZIP remains at its v139 identity and SHA; newer supplements are separate, not a matched replacement. diff --git a/TOOLING.md b/TOOLING.md index aa836ca6f..fd7ff6d30 100644 --- a/TOOLING.md +++ b/TOOLING.md @@ -20,6 +20,35 @@ documented below; historical outcomes are not rebound. See the source boundary, current stale record, retained failures and final-gate limits. This section supersedes earlier dated current-tip descriptions. +## T10 structural readback probe — 9 November 2026 + +**Purpose and scope:** a one-off, non-admitted evidence probe checks that +the eleven named fields exist with basic nonempty types in the retained T10 +proposals, that owner is `none`, maintenance is `zero`, and ids are unique. +It does not evaluate truth, mathematical blocking reasons, exact boundaries, +logical isolation, scientific review or adoption. The source and reports are +in separately read-back Library file +`libfile_fde3_f-765237bb3abc8191a41b33747a6fc852_59a0f9f234e48191bc19fddcc0f80648`, +SHA-256 `fb4d20e9a6e653e589e3e93cf053026ba73aa290367aba9309cecb5958ed6bcb`. +Its input `records_verified_t10.json`, SHA-256 +`2ee2f0e5d9784cfee824450efb7f8c35f9f89f2dc1199451b913122613b28722`, is in +the retained T10 readback supplement named in STATUS. + +**Commands:** after extracting those two retained artifacts into the same +working directory and supplying a new output path: + +```sh +python3 -I -B check_fields.py records_verified_t10.json t10-fields-normal.json +python3 -I -B -O check_fields.py records_verified_t10.json t10-fields-optimized.json +cmp t10-fields-normal.json t10-fields-optimized.json +``` + +**Observed verification:** 65 records had no structural errors; the probe +refused 26 missing, null, invalid-value or duplicate-id controls in each mode, +and both reports were byte-identical. Its literal review-word matches are +flags for interpretation, not semantic judgments. This is not a federation +auditor, a source-mutation qualification or a final gate. + ## Node-status freshness origin guard candidate — 9 November 2026 **Purpose:** reject false mutation kills caused by failures in the subject, From f1f4b4fa60c65159f12edba1f826f8762f415c63 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy <249851642+d6g8k5htny-coder@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 13:16:58 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 3/4] Record inventory mutation-origin adverse finding --- DECISIONS.md | 1 + STATUS.md | 15 +++++++++++++++ TOOLING.md | 12 ++++++++++++ 3 files changed, 28 insertions(+) diff --git a/DECISIONS.md b/DECISIONS.md index 24f587a6d..3ae4464c8 100644 --- a/DECISIONS.md +++ b/DECISIONS.md @@ -117,3 +117,4 @@ Append-only. Historical source outcomes remain in their original records. | 2026-11-09 19:00 | 2 | B/accounting | Independently reproduced the T10 normalization and proposal records byte for byte; independently checked 46 quotations across five selected records, and restored all 1,872 bound source blobs through a selective native-object pack without network. The pack is not a full ref/history backup; no branch deletion, adoption, logical isolation or scientific review is implied. Preserve the initial ad hoc pack-script SyntaxError and its corrected result. | Yes; retained source and selective pack | Source Main `fd77339a5e4f6f27704f69b3082e31da90fb1dcd`; records SHA-256 `2ee2f0e5d9784cfee824450efb7f8c35f9f89f2dc1199451b913122613b28722`; read-back supplement SHA-256 `2bebe703fba2b7538e127182fb91dbd4c32d2a53ecf0d768982cb94c62a0a10a`; [readback](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/issues/684#issuecomment-6748666194). | | 2026-11-09 19:01 | 2 | B/publication | The ordinary Main #782 workflow deployed the qualified site artifact and observed the public publication receipt for 32 snapshots. The separately retained rendered Chromium report recorded 39/39 cases and zero page errors, within its physical-device and screen-reader limits. This publication does not establish scientific acceptance, proof closure or the STATUS-only cold start. A first receipt-bundle restore attempt failed because the prerequisite was not connected to a ref; after connecting the exact prerequisite, a fresh unbundle retained the two receipt commits and blobs even with alternates removed. Preserve both outcomes. | Published; receipt history retained | Run `42677287313`, deploy job `129367351564`; source `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`; prepared receipt `29a8b2be282ebfe02c2bc71743ac477a63f74842`, observed receipt `4a92fb8a90fa2f0a54ffdd1b009e0771201c0fe9`; metadata artifact SHA-256 `5088130f7dd1d6b0c716651905b09bfa7bd73628e6d46a0a010381c978be9fb4`; state artifact SHA-256 `7ef72f47e85b03ba10f807b307bfad0e7a33ca059d762706e4d6df89e9c18a98`. | | 2026-11-09 19:08 | 2 | B/conflict, accounting | A non-admitted T10 structural probe found all eleven named fields nonempty and refused 26 adverse malformed-input controls in each mode. It did not verify semantic accuracy, mathematical blocking reasons, logical isolation or adoption. Proposals 019, 020 and 049 mention absent or unresolved review/novelty alongside source or proof limitations; preserve that history while treating missing procedural review alone as no mathematical blocker under the owner directive. No record was modified or promoted. | Yes; evidence-only probe | Input SHA-256 `2ee2f0e5d9784cfee824450efb7f8c35f9f89f2dc1199451b913122613b28722`; probe supplement SHA-256 `fb4d20e9a6e653e589e3e93cf053026ba73aa290367aba9309cecb5958ed6bcb`; main#684 comment 6748878712. | +| 2026-11-09 19:16 | 2 | B/tooling, conflict | Preserve an independent adverse assertion-origin finding on unmerged Main #780. At its exact observed head, 20 selected original-source baselines passed; 16 combined nominal-mutation and subject-assertion selected children satisfied RF312/replay/status classifier conditions in both modes. Two inventory mutations on their actual full-suite path also yielded four accepted adverse children, each reporting 81 tests, 95 failures and four controller skips. The historical mutant runs are not reclassified. The candidate remains unadmitted; future classifier evidence requires actual pre-cleanup selected-test/oracle code provenance and fresh adverse qualification. No peer source or mathematical disposition changed. | Yes; source and failure logs retained | Head `24ad8a143862fb9255fc6e2e7bf08c12f989f71d`; selected evidence SHA-256 `b66a035e7ffa6fb59aef3ea2b0af98bc35b1d6fede527b581a1d00b53df00a0f`; full-suite evidence SHA-256 `29c6295898ab74f1a3e657a60cbc38297bd9411e65e0df07713dd1539fbc2733`; [peer report](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/pull/780#issuecomment-6749064045). | diff --git a/STATUS.md b/STATUS.md index 88236b96b..07664fa2f 100644 --- a/STATUS.md +++ b/STATUS.md @@ -84,6 +84,21 @@ notes remain, but missing procedural review alone is not a mathematical blocker. The scope, commands and retained probe are in [TOOLING.md](TOOLING.md#t10-structural-readback-probe--9-november-2026). +At the later read-only #780 A8 probe, the unmerged inventory candidate at +head `24ad8a143862fb9255fc6e2e7bf08c12f989f71d` accepted subject-origin +`AssertionError` failures under its mutation classifiers. Twenty selected +original-source baselines passed; sixteen combined nominal-mutation and +subject-assertion selected children met the RF312/replay/status classifier +conditions in both modes. The two older inventory conditions also accepted +all four full-suite adverse children, each reporting 81 tests, 95 failures and +four controller skips. These are adverse probes, not the historical mutant +results; those outcomes remain unchanged. The test-name and message checks do +not establish selected-oracle origin. The active inventory candidate must +qualify any later provenance repair and its own tests before future mutation +counts are treated as sound. Source, baselines and raw adverse logs are +retained in separately read-back evidence files identified in DECISIONS. +No peer branch or mathematical disposition was changed by the probe. + For available bounded checks, from a Main checkout run: ```sh diff --git a/TOOLING.md b/TOOLING.md index fd7ff6d30..84a6ba478 100644 --- a/TOOLING.md +++ b/TOOLING.md @@ -49,6 +49,18 @@ and both reports were byte-identical. Its literal review-word matches are flags for interpretation, not semantic judgments. This is not a federation auditor, a source-mutation qualification or a final gate. +## Unmerged inventory classifier boundary — 9 November 2026 + +Main #780 is a separate, unadmitted inventory candidate. At its observed +head `24ad8a143862fb9255fc6e2e7bf08c12f989f71d`, an isolated A8 probe +showed that subject-origin assertions could satisfy its mutation-result +conditions, including the full-suite inventory conditions. This does not +change or refute the earlier historical mutant runs. Future mutation counts +need actual pre-cleanup traceback/code provenance and explicitly authorized +test or oracle origins, plus fresh adverse checks. Exact observations and +source-bound evidence are in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november-2026) +and DECISIONS. This candidate is not part of the admitted Main toolchain. + ## Node-status freshness origin guard candidate — 9 November 2026 **Purpose:** reject false mutation kills caused by failures in the subject, From 67f80ee916dee189d5d96419544c8fd0c39afa24 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Dylan Roy <249851642+d6g8k5htny-coder@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 13:46:07 -0600 Subject: [PATCH 4/4] Record Workspace pin integration --- BASELINE.md | 8 ++++---- DECISIONS.md | 1 + GOVERNANCE.md | 2 ++ PROOF_INDEX.md | 2 +- STATUS.md | 18 +++++++++++++----- TOOLING.md | 4 +++- 6 files changed, 24 insertions(+), 11 deletions(-) diff --git a/BASELINE.md b/BASELINE.md index aed08f513..914a504fc 100644 --- a/BASELINE.md +++ b/BASELINE.md @@ -8,11 +8,11 @@ completion certificate. ## Observed integration boundary — 9 November 2026 -After Main #780 landed, the sequentially observed defaults were Main -`b1d36c80403acc96d257b9e71140a6cb83a595af`, Math- +After Main #780 and Workspace #55 landed, the sequentially observed defaults +were Main `b1d36c80403acc96d257b9e71140a6cb83a595af`, Math- `f532c3e2d91a0c7679a37c733741660917a9b21b`, and Workspace -`1c552538e6a8952548e2bd5297a0031dda1f94e7`, whose gitlink still pins -the previous Main `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c`. +`8a7aac8626438967830ea5a516a944ce48759018`, whose gitlink pins that Main. +A subsequent Main merge requires another fresh pin comparison. The source-bound observations, skips, failures and completed post-merge checks are in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november-2026). A later Main merge requires another guarded Workspace pin refresh. diff --git a/DECISIONS.md b/DECISIONS.md index 6c951cad7..1f23669f3 100644 --- a/DECISIONS.md +++ b/DECISIONS.md @@ -121,3 +121,4 @@ Append-only. Historical source outcomes remain in their original records. | 2026-11-09 19:08 | 2 | B/conflict, accounting | A non-admitted T10 structural probe found all eleven named fields nonempty and refused 26 adverse malformed-input controls in each mode. It did not verify semantic accuracy, mathematical blocking reasons, logical isolation or adoption. Proposals 019, 020 and 049 mention absent or unresolved review/novelty alongside source or proof limitations; preserve that history while treating missing procedural review alone as no mathematical blocker under the owner directive. No record was modified or promoted. | Yes; evidence-only probe | Input SHA-256 `2ee2f0e5d9784cfee824450efb7f8c35f9f89f2dc1199451b913122613b28722`; probe supplement SHA-256 `fb4d20e9a6e653e589e3e93cf053026ba73aa290367aba9309cecb5958ed6bcb`; main#684 comment 6748878712. | | 2026-11-09 19:16 | 2 | B/tooling, conflict | Preserve an independent adverse assertion-origin finding on unmerged Main #780. At its exact observed head, 20 selected original-source baselines passed; 16 combined nominal-mutation and subject-assertion selected children satisfied RF312/replay/status classifier conditions in both modes. Two inventory mutations on their actual full-suite path also yielded four accepted adverse children, each reporting 81 tests, 95 failures and four controller skips. The historical mutant runs are not reclassified. The candidate remains unadmitted; future classifier evidence requires actual pre-cleanup selected-test/oracle code provenance and fresh adverse qualification. No peer source or mathematical disposition changed. | Yes; source and failure logs retained | Head `24ad8a143862fb9255fc6e2e7bf08c12f989f71d`; selected evidence SHA-256 `b66a035e7ffa6fb59aef3ea2b0af98bc35b1d6fede527b581a1d00b53df00a0f`; full-suite evidence SHA-256 `29c6295898ab74f1a3e657a60cbc38297bd9411e65e0df07713dd1539fbc2733`; [peer report](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/pull/780#issuecomment-6749064045). | | 2026-11-09 19:30 | 2 | B/integration, conflict | Main #780 landed as an ordinary merge after the assertion-origin adverse finding; the recovered inventory source and its documented bounded source/state use are retained. Its mutation classifiers are not admitted as sound by that merge or by historical counts. Preserve both branches' appended decision records, the false-kill evidence, the separately reported Node regression and all prior outcomes. Workspace still pins the earlier Main and requires a guarded refresh. Subsequent integration requires fresh source and checks. | Yes; normal Git composition | Main `b1d36c80403acc96d257b9e71140a6cb83a595af`, tree `10bc30f82661ebdd763384496afffbe7f575459a`, parents `f1ef3a2babecca0f0d4eb35b018dc81d30e9d62c` and `24ad8a143862fb9255fc6e2e7bf08c12f989f71d`; [Main #780](https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/main/pull/780); Workspace `1c552538e6a8952548e2bd5297a0031dda1f94e7`. | +| 2026-11-09 19:44 | 2 | B/integration, pins | Workspace #55 integrated through hosted required checks and a fresh expected-head merge, updating only the Main gitlink, pin, README and appended decision. The tested merge tree equals the published tree; prior source and seven other pins remain. Both hosted modes ran 187 tests without skips; strict-current pins and canonical inputs passed at the observed pre-merge interval. This does not establish final G7 or a full federation matrix. A later Main merge requires a fresh pin comparison. | Yes; ordinary Git history | Workspace `8a7aac8626438967830ea5a516a944ce48759018`, tree `d8db9ab8dd764d6f564b1d46fee03990be7b770a`, tested merge `238b379f671b0d0f0d4c471befdfa7dc1ebf4c35`; Main `b1d36c80403acc96d257b9e71140a6cb83a595af`; premerge evidence SHA-256 `4d2b668a2e62a8ea1beeb627e89229cd512b7a4fe79fdd937257d84cb12659fc`. | diff --git a/GOVERNANCE.md b/GOVERNANCE.md index 4b96980d2..8b4b0478f 100644 --- a/GOVERNANCE.md +++ b/GOVERNANCE.md @@ -21,6 +21,8 @@ original timestamps and outcomes; the latest directive controls future action. ## Observed freshness integration — 9 November 2026 Main #782 and Workspace #54 integrated through normal expected-head checks. +Workspace #55 subsequently refreshed the Main pin through the same guarded +process; the sequential observation and limits are in STATUS. Main #780 later landed its bounded source inventory; its mutation classifiers remain unqualified under the adverse assertion-origin evidence. The inventory purpose, exact commands, verification and limits are registered in diff --git a/PROOF_INDEX.md b/PROOF_INDEX.md index 272d5a716..418b91862 100644 --- a/PROOF_INDEX.md +++ b/PROOF_INDEX.md @@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ placed in a complete dormant quarantine. ## Observed integration proof boundary — 9 November 2026 The landed Main #782 freshness repair, Main #780 source inventory and -Workspace #54 pin update are engineering and custody changes. They do not change, close, refute or rebind +Workspace #54 and #55 pin updates are engineering and custody changes. They do not change, close, refute or rebind any mathematical statement, bound, axiom, hypothesis, proof, quarantine, kernel result or scientific disposition. The current observed source boundary is described in [STATUS.md](STATUS.md#observed-integration-boundary--9-november-2026). diff --git a/STATUS.md b/STATUS.md index 83494fd02..0cf8c2bbf 100644 --- a/STATUS.md +++ b/STATUS.md @@ -12,11 +12,19 @@ Its mathematical statements, source cuts and review limits are preserved. Main #780 merged at 19:26 UTC as `b1d36c80403acc96d257b9e71140a6cb83a595af`, tree `10bc30f82661ebdd763384496afffbe7f575459a`, with parents `f1ef3a2b…` -and `24ad8a143862fb9255fc6e2e7bf08c12f989f71d`. Workspace default was -subsequently observed at `1c552538e6a8952548e2bd5297a0031dda1f94e7`, still -pinning the earlier Main `f1ef3a2b…`; it is not current with that Main merge. -The observations are sequential and another Main merge requires another fresh -comparison. A guarded Workspace pin update remains necessary. +and `24ad8a143862fb9255fc6e2e7bf08c12f989f71d`. Workspace #55 subsequently merged at 19:43 UTC as +`8a7aac8626438967830ea5a516a944ce48759018`, tree +`d8db9ab8dd764d6f564b1d46fee03990be7b770a`, with parents `1c552538…` and +`9f0fbbbb615c7d39207f7bfaef3fd53a7e561fc3`; its Main gitlink now pins +`b1d36c80403acc96d257b9e71140a6cb83a595af`. The tested merge +`238b379f671b0d0f0d4c471befdfa7dc1ebf4c35` had that exact tree. Hosted +job `129389209449` passed eight strict-current pins, four canonical inputs +and 187 tests; job `129389215646` ran 187 tests in each Python mode without +skips. Local strict pins and canonical inputs also passed; local normal +regression ran 187 tests without skips, while its optimized run was still in +progress at this observation. These are sequential observations, not final +G7. Post-merge jobs require their own observed outcomes. A later Main merge, +including this documentation change, requires another guarded pin comparison. The recovered inventory CLI is present in the merged source, with commands and scope in [TOOLING.md](TOOLING.md#recovered-tracked-source-inventory--9-november-2026). diff --git a/TOOLING.md b/TOOLING.md index 6de923c4b..484dda5d6 100644 --- a/TOOLING.md +++ b/TOOLING.md @@ -10,7 +10,9 @@ complete a CBZ gate or the final G0–G11 matrix. ## Observed freshness tool integration — 9 November 2026 -The node-status provenance guard below landed through Main #782. Current-head +The node-status provenance guard below landed through Main #782. Workspace +#55 later refreshed the Main pin; its sequential observation is in STATUS. +Current-head hosted controls job `129353108258` exercised 20 focused controls, eight designated guard detections and 22/22 authorized original-mutation kills per parent mode, including real subject-origin refusals in both child modes. Its