From 49aef95e15885e96dafc09a08e728fb270b8d41f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 19:02:29 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 01/19] Refresh PEER_HANDOFF to meta#6 tip 3c3cf11 (catalog 83) Scout: #6 still OPEN after dispatch v6 / OA-REVIEW / L4-L5 ledger. Gate pins remain baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs stay post-merge-only. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json | 2 +- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 22 ++++++++++++++----- 2 files changed, 17 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json index a146501..9b407c4 100644 --- a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json +++ b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ "meaning": "candidate stubs aligned to open meta#6 tip pins; not catalog authority", "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", "aligned_to_meta_pr": 6, - "aligned_to_meta_head": "64f2eec3ea8d6cef325b0438323fd64878f8815d", + "aligned_to_meta_head": "3c3cf11675fab5c4cabc1067627f209a38ea3a51", "artifacts": [ { "bytes": 2356, diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 12be2de..4918428 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -24,12 +24,12 @@ "verified_against": { "meta_pr": 6, "meta_branch": "cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8", - "meta_head": "7ffa5c6603574a9c932e609f0c1c003341645041", + "meta_head": "3c3cf11675fab5c4cabc1067627f209a38ea3a51", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", - "meta_catalog_count": 77, + "meta_catalog_count": 83, "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T18:46:17Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T19:01:43Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ "downstream-hard-gate-replay", "downstream-hard-gate-graph" ], - "note": "primary key downstream-hard-gate \u2192 README.md @ baca69c (still matches meta#6 at f890782)" + "note": "primary key downstream-hard-gate → README.md @ baca69c (still matches meta#6 registry at 3c3cf11); meta also catalogs downstream-hard-gate-notes (review notes only — not in our candidate bundle)" }, "still_pending_after_meta6": [ "rn-fixed-remote-window-replay", @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json" ], "avoid_racing": [ - "meta-framework#6 cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8 (catalog 77 on PR head; lane=catalog/routing)", + "meta-framework#6 cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8 (catalog 83 on PR head; lane=catalog/routing; dispatch v6)", "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", "Math- drafts #7 #9 #14 #15 mesoscopic/D5/transition", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" @@ -75,7 +75,7 @@ ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF to meta#6 tip e2259d4; gate pins still baca69c; three replay stubs still post-merge-only; idle otherwise" }, - "batch340_note": "trial Path C IDLE tip 848aea2; wake/assign pulse; skip research drafts; query- idle-watch meta#6", + "batch340_note": "superseded by batch343: Path C IDLE@0019 tip fcad723; wake/assign pulse; skip research drafts; query- idle-watch meta#6", "collective_decision_20260925T1845Z": { "sources": [ "meta-framework#6 head 7ffa5c6 (catalog 77)", @@ -83,5 +83,15 @@ "verify_portable_stubs tip_drift=[]" ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF to 7ffa5c6; gate baca69c unchanged; three replay stubs still post-merge-only" + }, + "batch343_note": "trial MULTI_AGENT_WAKE_BATCH343 Path C IDLE@0019 tip fcad723 (evidence tip c44f137 idle_no_commit); query- stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", + "collective_decision_20260925T1901Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 head 3c3cf11 (catalog 83; multi-agent-dispatch-20260925-v6 + OA-REVIEW watch + L4/L5 ledger)", + "trial MULTI_AGENT_WAKE_BATCH343.json Path C IDLE@0019 @ fcad723", + "verify_portable_stubs --check-math-tip drifted=[]", + "peer Task agents bc-70d88310 / bc-0702414a (refresh handoff; no invent keys)" + ], + "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip 3c3cf11 (catalog 83); gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs still absent from PR head and remain post-merge-only; do not invent keys" } } From 88923fe32195878ee7fc79b6fea09a1750771e9b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 19:31:35 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 02/19] Refresh PEER_HANDOFF to meta#6 tip 5eeb5d5 (catalog 90) Scout: #6 still OPEN after dispatch v7 / OA-REVIEW delivery notes. Gate pins remain baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs stay post-merge-only. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json | 2 +- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 22 ++++++++++++++----- 2 files changed, 17 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json index 9b407c4..03f18ba 100644 --- a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json +++ b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ "meaning": "candidate stubs aligned to open meta#6 tip pins; not catalog authority", "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", "aligned_to_meta_pr": 6, - "aligned_to_meta_head": "3c3cf11675fab5c4cabc1067627f209a38ea3a51", + "aligned_to_meta_head": "5eeb5d500ab79c210a60311d400fe8747192d849", "artifacts": [ { "bytes": 2356, diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 4918428..364d0ca 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -24,12 +24,12 @@ "verified_against": { "meta_pr": 6, "meta_branch": "cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8", - "meta_head": "3c3cf11675fab5c4cabc1067627f209a38ea3a51", + "meta_head": "5eeb5d500ab79c210a60311d400fe8747192d849", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", - "meta_catalog_count": 83, + "meta_catalog_count": 90, "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T19:01:43Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T19:30:44Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ "downstream-hard-gate-replay", "downstream-hard-gate-graph" ], - "note": "primary key downstream-hard-gate → README.md @ baca69c (still matches meta#6 registry at 3c3cf11); meta also catalogs downstream-hard-gate-notes (review notes only — not in our candidate bundle)" + "note": "primary key downstream-hard-gate → README.md @ baca69c (still matches meta#6 registry at 5eeb5d5); meta also catalogs downstream-hard-gate-notes (review notes only — not in our candidate bundle)" }, "still_pending_after_meta6": [ "rn-fixed-remote-window-replay", @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json" ], "avoid_racing": [ - "meta-framework#6 cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8 (catalog 83 on PR head; lane=catalog/routing; dispatch v6)", + "meta-framework#6 cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8 (catalog 90 on PR head; lane=catalog/routing; dispatch v7)", "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", "Math- drafts #7 #9 #14 #15 mesoscopic/D5/transition", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" @@ -84,7 +84,7 @@ ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF to 7ffa5c6; gate baca69c unchanged; three replay stubs still post-merge-only" }, - "batch343_note": "trial MULTI_AGENT_WAKE_BATCH343 Path C IDLE@0019 tip fcad723 (evidence tip c44f137 idle_no_commit); query- stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", + "batch343_note": "superseded by batch345/346: Path C IDLE@0019; query- stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", "collective_decision_20260925T1901Z": { "sources": [ "meta-framework#6 head 3c3cf11 (catalog 83; multi-agent-dispatch-20260925-v6 + OA-REVIEW watch + L4/L5 ledger)", @@ -93,5 +93,15 @@ "peer Task agents bc-70d88310 / bc-0702414a (refresh handoff; no invent keys)" ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip 3c3cf11 (catalog 83); gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs still absent from PR head and remain post-merge-only; do not invent keys" + }, + "batch345_note": "trial MULTI_AGENT_WAKE_BATCH345 Path C IDLE@0019; Batch 346 tip_sync soften @ 40d6f27; no query/catalog assignment", + "collective_decision_20260925T1930Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 head 5eeb5d5 (catalog 90; multi-agent-dispatch-20260925-v7 + OA-REVIEW delivery notes)", + "trial Batch345/346 Path C IDLE@0019", + "verify_portable_stubs --check-math-tip drifted=[]", + "peer Task agent bc-0e6d55d7 (refresh handoff; no invent keys)" + ], + "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip 5eeb5d5 (catalog 90); gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs still absent from PR head and remain post-merge-only; do not invent keys" } } From d1677b474ab15ec6112153d98da097d02ad10370 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 19:44:26 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 03/19] Refresh PEER_HANDOFF to meta#6 tip c1046a5 (catalog 96) Scout after #6 synchronize: dispatch v8 + PR15/PR18/PR98 notes. Gate pins remain baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs stay post-merge-only. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json | 2 +- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 21 +++++++++++++------ 2 files changed, 16 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json index 03f18ba..53b9e2e 100644 --- a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json +++ b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ "meaning": "candidate stubs aligned to open meta#6 tip pins; not catalog authority", "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", "aligned_to_meta_pr": 6, - "aligned_to_meta_head": "5eeb5d500ab79c210a60311d400fe8747192d849", + "aligned_to_meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "artifacts": [ { "bytes": 2356, diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 364d0ca..3e239a8 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -24,12 +24,12 @@ "verified_against": { "meta_pr": 6, "meta_branch": "cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8", - "meta_head": "5eeb5d500ab79c210a60311d400fe8747192d849", + "meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", - "meta_catalog_count": 90, + "meta_catalog_count": 96, "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T19:30:44Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T19:43:33Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ "downstream-hard-gate-replay", "downstream-hard-gate-graph" ], - "note": "primary key downstream-hard-gate → README.md @ baca69c (still matches meta#6 registry at 5eeb5d5); meta also catalogs downstream-hard-gate-notes (review notes only — not in our candidate bundle)" + "note": "primary key downstream-hard-gate → README.md @ baca69c (still matches meta#6 registry at c1046a5); meta also catalogs downstream-hard-gate-notes (review notes only — not in our candidate bundle)" }, "still_pending_after_meta6": [ "rn-fixed-remote-window-replay", @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json" ], "avoid_racing": [ - "meta-framework#6 cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8 (catalog 90 on PR head; lane=catalog/routing; dispatch v7)", + "meta-framework#6 cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8 (catalog 96 on PR head; lane=catalog/routing; dispatch v8)", "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", "Math- drafts #7 #9 #14 #15 mesoscopic/D5/transition", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" @@ -94,7 +94,7 @@ ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip 3c3cf11 (catalog 83); gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs still absent from PR head and remain post-merge-only; do not invent keys" }, - "batch345_note": "trial MULTI_AGENT_WAKE_BATCH345 Path C IDLE@0019; Batch 346 tip_sync soften @ 40d6f27; no query/catalog assignment", + "batch345_note": "trial MULTI_AGENT_WAKE_BATCH345 Path C IDLE@0019; Batch 346 tip_sync soften @ 40d6f27; Batch 347 tip_sync_watch idle @ e3cd7d4; no query/catalog assignment", "collective_decision_20260925T1930Z": { "sources": [ "meta-framework#6 head 5eeb5d5 (catalog 90; multi-agent-dispatch-20260925-v7 + OA-REVIEW delivery notes)", @@ -103,5 +103,14 @@ "peer Task agent bc-0e6d55d7 (refresh handoff; no invent keys)" ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip 5eeb5d5 (catalog 90); gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs still absent from PR head and remain post-merge-only; do not invent keys" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T1943Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → head c1046a5 (catalog 96; multi-agent-dispatch-20260925-v8 + PR15/PR18/PR98 notes)", + "trial Batch 347 tip_sync_watch idle @ e3cd7d4", + "verify_portable_stubs --check-math-tip drifted=[]", + "peer Task agent bc-1c23b0f3 (refresh handoff; no invent keys)" + ], + "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip c1046a5 (catalog 96); gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs still absent from PR head and remain post-merge-only; do not invent keys" } } From c377983694ae44fd99427231f9edbc701ef767d6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 19:51:07 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 04/19] Record meta#6 bottleneck routing shift; stop catalog-only churn MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Reflect PR14 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT and D5 path PR19→PR9→successor. Report stale-consumer scan: query- has no PR14/PR9 tip commit pins; meta TIP_* observation keys listed for writable peers. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 70 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 66 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 3e239a8..927a265 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ "verify_portable_stubs.py --check-math-tip drifted=[]" ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip f890782; gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); keep three replay stubs staged but unoffered until #6 merges; do not invent keys", - "closure_order_elsewhere": "owned outside query-; Math drafts #7/#9/#14/#15 and google-drive#3 not our lane" + "closure_order_elsewhere": "owned outside query-; Math-#14 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; D5 live path #19→#9→successor; #15 needs distinct review; google-drive#3 not our lane" }, "verified_against": { "meta_pr": 6, @@ -58,13 +58,65 @@ "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json" ], "avoid_racing": [ - "meta-framework#6 cursor/catalog-drive-parents-5cb8 (catalog 96 on PR head; lane=catalog/routing; dispatch v8)", + "meta-framework#6 bottleneck-routing lane (catalog growth paused; head c1046a5 / dispatch v8)", "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", - "Math- drafts #7 #9 #14 #15 mesoscopic/D5/transition", + "Math- D5 live path: #19 (ee8629f3) → #9 author regen → clean mapping successor; do not consume CLOSED #14", + "Math- #15 hosted-green but needs distinct technical review (not finished gate source)", + "main #98 source-level fixes; CI mixed/pending — not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], "batch337_note": "superseded by batch340: Path C IDLE tip 848aea2; query- still stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", - "next_query_action": "Idle-watch meta#6 merge + Math tip; on merge offer only the three replay stubs; on TIP_DRIFT refresh gate stubs", + "next_query_action": "Stop catalog-only handoff churn on meta#6 tip growth; idle-watch #6 merge (then only three replay stubs) + Math tip TIP_DRIFT on gate stubs; bottleneck routing owned outside query-", + "stop_catalog_only_churn": true, + "bottleneck_routing_20260925T1948Z": { + "source": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/meta-framework/pull/6#issuecomment-5838584395", + "lane_shift": "catalog_growth → bottleneck_routing", + "math_pr14": { + "state": "CLOSED", + "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT", + "head": "4f272f9765dedfa581161580aac09b7800dae6f6", + "title": "SUPERSEDED/BLOCKED INPUT — Map PR9 chart-J0 into post-hotfix D5 hard gate" + }, + "d5_live_path": [ + "Math-#19 OpenAI repair candidate head ee8629f37977f4132da4c5af7e1dd61e9d94aa1d", + "Math-#9 author regeneration", + "clean mapping successor" + ], + "math_pr15": "OPEN hosted-green head 8c4c946a; needs distinct technical review; not finished gate source", + "main_pr98": "OPEN head 0bc41ca; source-level fixes; CI verify mixed FAILURE/IN_PROGRESS at record time", + "scientific_effect": "NONE" + }, + "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { + "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", + "query_repo": { + "commit_pins_to_pr14_or_pr9_tips": [], + "prose_only_mentions": [ + "portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json (historical avoid_racing / closure_order text — superseded by bottleneck_routing_20260925T1948Z)", + "AGENTS.md:15 (generic Math- mesoscopic drafts race note)", + "README.md:56 (meta#6 mesoscopic race note)" + ], + "portable_stub_commits": { + "gate_bundle": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7 (Math- main tip; not PR9/PR14)", + "replay_stubs": [ + "191ea7d541a4 (rn-fixed-remote-window-replay)", + "1dfd49e84c57 (p15-price-budget-replay)", + "8a13ee977530 (three-fronts-replay)" + ] + } + }, + "meta_framework_pr6_head_c1046a5_observation_keys_pinning_pr9_intermediate_tips": [ + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-tip-ea52f84 → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/TIP_EA52F84.md (Math- tip ea52f84a33db)", + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-tip-4ea72517 → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/TIP_4EA72517.md", + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-tip-c4e5107d → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/TIP_C4E5107D.md", + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-tip-67b187c5 → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/TIP_67B187C5.md", + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-tip-34f4ef4c → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/TIP_34F4EF4C.md", + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-tip-d85f4ec4 → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/TIP_D85F4EC4.md", + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-tip-f655cc22 → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/TIP_F655CC22.md", + "rn-mesoscopic-chart-notes → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-chart-20260925/NOTES.md (older tip 5c8e2f85d047)", + "rn-mesoscopic-reduction-notes → reviews/rn-mesoscopic-20260925/NOTES.md" + ], + "note": "query- cannot edit meta-framework; listed meta paths are for writable peers. PR14 head 4f272f9 and graph fingerprint 19f1058 appear in CLOSED PR14 body only — no query- consumer." + }, "accidental_issue": "query-#7 title 'test' was an Issues API probe; ignore as non-task", "meaning": "coordination receipt only; not a task queue or acceptance register", "collective_decision_20260925T1830Z": { @@ -112,5 +164,15 @@ "peer Task agent bc-1c23b0f3 (refresh handoff; no invent keys)" ], "decision": "Refresh PEER_HANDOFF verified_against to meta#6 tip c1046a5 (catalog 96); gate pins still baca69c (no TIP_DRIFT); three replay stubs still absent from PR head and remain post-merge-only; do not invent keys" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T1949Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 comment 5838584395 (d6g8k5htny-coder): catalog growth → bottleneck routing", + "Math-#14 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT @ 4f272f9; #19 OPEN @ ee8629f3; #9 OPEN; #15 OPEN @ 8c4c946a", + "main#98 OPEN @ 0bc41ca CI verify mixed", + "query- portable stub scan: zero commit pins to PR14/PR9 tips", + "peer Task agent bc-bf728fe1" + ], + "decision": "Record bottleneck routing + PR14 CLOSED + D5 path PR19→PR9→successor in PEER_HANDOFF; set stop_catalog_only_churn; report stale-consumer paths (query prose-only; meta TIP_* observation keys for peers); do not invent catalog keys; three replays still post-merge-only; no further catalog-tip handoff churn unless merge or TIP_DRIFT" } } From e498eda1a11b84df6f54829314fbe88f9a451aa2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 20:03:52 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 05/19] Record Math-#20 blocked-input risk; skip catalog tip chase meta#6 dispatch v9 observed at 3120bf3/103 but stop_catalog_only_churn keeps verified_against at c1046a5; PR20 is routing-state only. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 25 ++++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 24 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 927a265..353c20d 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -58,9 +58,10 @@ "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json" ], "avoid_racing": [ - "meta-framework#6 bottleneck-routing lane (catalog growth paused; head c1046a5 / dispatch v8)", + "meta-framework#6 bottleneck-routing lane (stop_catalog_only_churn; do not chase tip growth past recorded routing)", "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", "Math- D5 live path: #19 (ee8629f3) → #9 author regen → clean mapping successor; do not consume CLOSED #14", + "Math- #20 OPEN draft fingerprint-sync map — blocked-input risk until pin AMEND; do not harden PR14-style maps", "Math- #15 hosted-green but needs distinct technical review (not finished gate source)", "main #98 source-level fixes; CI mixed/pending — not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" @@ -83,9 +84,23 @@ "clean mapping successor" ], "math_pr15": "OPEN hosted-green head 8c4c946a; needs distinct technical review; not finished gate source", + "math_pr20": { + "state": "OPEN", + "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT_RISK", + "head_at_record": "5add2ee2cc0c168a4eade2c82eb741db93c23990", + "dispatch_v9_oid": "284271898510a385445ef2fbd22af5d4d5c2727e", + "note": "Fingerprint-sync map after PR14 close; hold until PR9 pin AMEND cleared or PR19 distinctly reviewed/consumed; do not catalog as finished gate source" + }, "main_pr98": "OPEN head 0bc41ca; source-level fixes; CI verify mixed FAILURE/IN_PROGRESS at record time", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, + "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { + "meta_pr": 6, + "head": "3120bf3400cfbc06bfa100c83f530e2e56a8202f", + "catalog_count": 103, + "note": "dispatch v9 index only; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays at prior routing pin c1046a5/96 unless merge or TIP_DRIFT", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:02:30Z" + }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", "query_repo": { @@ -174,5 +189,13 @@ "peer Task agent bc-bf728fe1" ], "decision": "Record bottleneck routing + PR14 CLOSED + D5 path PR19→PR9→successor in PEER_HANDOFF; set stop_catalog_only_churn; report stale-consumer paths (query prose-only; meta TIP_* observation keys for peers); do not invent catalog keys; three replays still post-merge-only; no further catalog-tip handoff churn unless merge or TIP_DRIFT" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2002Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → 3120bf3 dispatch v9 (PR14 closed, PR19 repair, PR20 map risk); catalog 103 observed not chased", + "Math-#20 OPEN draft fingerprint-sync @ 5add2ee — blocked-input risk per dispatch v9", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true; peer Task bc-47ff9a2e" + ], + "decision": "Record Math-#20 blocked-input risk only; do not refresh verified_against for catalog tip growth; verified_against remains c1046a5/96; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From eac58378d8302f4655751d59bea102d464008d11 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 20:29:41 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 06/19] Record Math-#21 + PR98 green; keep catalog tip unchased dispatch v10 routing-state only under stop_catalog_only_churn; verified_against remains c1046a5. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 28 ++++++++++++++++++++++------ 1 file changed, 22 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 353c20d..72b5901 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -62,8 +62,9 @@ "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", "Math- D5 live path: #19 (ee8629f3) → #9 author regen → clean mapping successor; do not consume CLOSED #14", "Math- #20 OPEN draft fingerprint-sync map — blocked-input risk until pin AMEND; do not harden PR14-style maps", + "Math- #21 OPEN inner-axial density candidate (do_not_duplicate); distinct-lane review only — not query- catalog", "Math- #15 hosted-green but needs distinct technical review (not finished gate source)", - "main #98 source-level fixes; CI mixed/pending — not query- lane", + "main #98 CI green @ 776fdb7 — eng only; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], "batch337_note": "superseded by batch340: Path C IDLE tip 848aea2; query- still stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", @@ -91,15 +92,22 @@ "dispatch_v9_oid": "284271898510a385445ef2fbd22af5d4d5c2727e", "note": "Fingerprint-sync map after PR14 close; hold until PR9 pin AMEND cleared or PR19 distinctly reviewed/consumed; do not catalog as finished gate source" }, - "main_pr98": "OPEN head 0bc41ca; source-level fixes; CI verify mixed FAILURE/IN_PROGRESS at record time", + "math_pr21": { + "state": "OPEN", + "disposition": "DO_NOT_DUPLICATE", + "head": "b420099b2440da3a8ba62f7000feacc9fc88069b", + "claim": "OA-D5-AXIAL-DENSITY-20260925-CONSENSUS", + "note": "Inner-axial density candidate; distinct-lane review only; not query- catalog work; scientific effect NONE" + }, + "main_pr98": "OPEN head 776fdb7; CI verify/navigation green at dispatch v10; eng CI ≠ mathematical claim; #90 still OPEN", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "3120bf3400cfbc06bfa100c83f530e2e56a8202f", - "catalog_count": 103, - "note": "dispatch v9 index only; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays at prior routing pin c1046a5/96 unless merge or TIP_DRIFT", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:02:30Z" + "head": "c4e675a055a472ae567a6a0bcd4ffab276ff0b1d", + "dispatch": "v10", + "note": "dispatch v10 index (PR98 green, PR21 density, lane map); stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96 unless merge or TIP_DRIFT", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:28:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -197,5 +205,13 @@ "stop_catalog_only_churn=true; peer Task bc-47ff9a2e" ], "decision": "Record Math-#20 blocked-input risk only; do not refresh verified_against for catalog tip growth; verified_against remains c1046a5/96; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2028Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → c4e675a dispatch v10 (PR98 green, PR21 density, lane map)", + "Math-#21 OPEN @ b420099 do_not_duplicate; main#98 CI green @ 776fdb7; #90 still OPEN", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" + ], + "decision": "Record Math-#21 avoid + PR98 green status as routing-state only; do not chase catalog tip / invent density stubs; verified_against remains c1046a5/96; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From 65a11332e889ddaa3550f63b0347194855f2b203 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 20:31:31 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 07/19] Refresh gate stubs to Math tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT Math- integrated source-bound transition gate; CI refused tip drift. Scope/graph bytes unchanged; README/code/tests/output/replay repinned. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json | 52 +++++++++---------- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 15 ++++-- 2 files changed, 38 insertions(+), 29 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json index 53b9e2e..859af3e 100644 --- a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json +++ b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json @@ -1,86 +1,86 @@ { "scientific_status_authority": false, - "meaning": "candidate stubs aligned to open meta#6 tip pins; not catalog authority", - "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "meaning": "candidate stubs aligned to Math- tip after TIP_DRIFT; not catalog authority", + "math_tip": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "aligned_to_meta_pr": 6, "aligned_to_meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "artifacts": [ { - "bytes": 2356, - "commit": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "bytes": 3559, + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "key": "downstream-hard-gate", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/README.md", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Engineering fail-closed promotion control for main #90/#86; scientific effect NONE", - "sha256": "045591b097e297da43a2049dec3fe4df6d950ef20a899abd04677ec0304a80f6", + "sha256": "574ed537cf8992bb3f86fae109e18336e51c18ea814e69451d39901b94fea80a", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to meta-framework#6 tip pin baca69c; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 2218, - "commit": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-scope", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/SCOPE.md", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Claim/non-claim boundary for the hard-gate package; not analytic acceptance", "sha256": "c7b5bb0ec34f53395b96ae24edceb3b5b0a3451caf7df6205b924d40e9e9fd84", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to meta-framework#6 tip pin baca69c; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 22300, - "commit": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "bytes": 26247, + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-code", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/hard_gate.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Fail-closed promotion and reverse-impact checker; stdlib only", - "sha256": "fdefdf8ebd27bb7ef3735cf81460ca38724af8417420c7017ef53d3d24602998", + "sha256": "af0dabff98e050abed31fa838da210c40c230e94268fdfd568cf2de2024cfa04", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to meta-framework#6 tip pin baca69c; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 15661, - "commit": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "bytes": 18595, + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-tests", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/test_hard_gate.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Finite integrity controls and semantic mutations; not theorem review", - "sha256": "6eb3b1b4859eb7a01063e3f70e03a42365f515d103abb87e0711fc6e6102ce86", + "sha256": "84ea94bb31ed0e8a3e022d6273ecec823bb6acc2703edc6f6a641492963f882d", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to meta-framework#6 tip pin baca69c; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 5867, - "commit": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "bytes": 5909, + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-output", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/RESULTS.json", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Reproducible gate output; lemma_closed false; illegal promotions refused", - "sha256": "4e62e8d73101388f6872306feebb4ce35a4d04985f5200136bd2fcf0bb28aac7", + "sha256": "25eb3ef09f7b71248ddc15ee7c6b0a0e417ceea11da615c98a03a6ab39545a35", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to meta-framework#6 tip pin baca69c; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 5947, - "commit": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "bytes": 7517, + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-replay", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/run_validation.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Same-author gate replay runner; new output directory required", - "sha256": "72874e70feb613dd42684be5c598b5d145fc9fdbdbd42abf8eb172b9df7487c3", + "sha256": "2f71b34d5a241402e26c0e0046fece88e1c9f2ea07c4920735b0a3d1306fba6c", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to meta-framework#6 tip pin baca69c; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 12289, - "commit": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-graph", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/GRAPH.json", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Machine dependency graph D0-D7 over Math candidates and historical RN walls", "sha256": "556b961f92aa171655ab5cfe9fa7a89cdd16a10d29f5e39cd1ff7b6ccade73b7", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to meta-framework#6 tip pin baca69c; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." } ] } diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 72b5901..00453ee 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ "meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", "meta_catalog_count": 96, - "math_tip": "baca69c394ab42130c61771bee74e808703f1ce7", + "math_tip": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T19:43:33Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:31:30Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ "downstream-hard-gate-replay", "downstream-hard-gate-graph" ], - "note": "primary key downstream-hard-gate → README.md @ baca69c (still matches meta#6 registry at c1046a5); meta also catalogs downstream-hard-gate-notes (review notes only — not in our candidate bundle)" + "note": "Refreshed to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT (transition gate integrate); scope+graph bytes unchanged vs baca69c; README/code/tests/output/replay updated. Candidate only — not meta catalog land." }, "still_pending_after_meta6": [ "rn-fixed-remote-window-replay", @@ -213,5 +213,14 @@ "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" ], "decision": "Record Math-#21 avoid + PR98 green status as routing-state only; do not chase catalog tip / invent density stubs; verified_against remains c1046a5/96; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2031Z": { + "sources": [ + "Math- tip baca69c→ac868b2 (Integrate reviewed source-bound downstream transition gate)", + "query- CI REFUSED TIP_DRIFT on gate README/code/tests/output/replay", + "verify_portable_stubs --check-math-tip after refresh → drifted=[]", + "standing rule: TIP_DRIFT refresh allowed under stop_catalog_only_churn" + ], + "decision": "Refresh CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS to Math tip ac868b2; update PEER_HANDOFF math_tip; do not invent catalog keys; three replays still post-merge-only; catalog tip still unchased" } } From 300d9865338eaf7a604e526d94a9c0752a84dcdd Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 20:34:38 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 08/19] Align gate stubs to cataloged PR15 keys after Math-#15 merge meta#6 dispatch v11 catalogs downstream-hard-gate-pr15* @ ac868b2 and freezes baca69c keys. Retarget candidate bundle; tip drift clear. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json | 80 +++++++++++-------- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 38 +++++---- test_catalog_entry_helper.py | 9 ++- test_verify_portable_stubs.py | 2 +- 4 files changed, 76 insertions(+), 53 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json index 859af3e..d89358a 100644 --- a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json +++ b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json @@ -1,86 +1,98 @@ { "scientific_status_authority": false, - "meaning": "candidate stubs aligned to Math- tip after TIP_DRIFT; not catalog authority", + "meaning": "candidate stubs for merged Math- PR15 tip identities (downstream-hard-gate-pr15*); frozen baca69c keys stay on meta catalog; not catalog authority", "math_tip": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", "aligned_to_meta_pr": 6, - "aligned_to_meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", + "aligned_to_meta_head": "9c2779f4e96d078f8028b5e00367c044f724108d", + "frozen_gate_keys_on_meta": "downstream-hard-gate* @ baca69c (do not overwrite)", "artifacts": [ { "bytes": 3559, "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", - "key": "downstream-hard-gate", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/README.md", "repository": "Math-", - "scope": "Engineering fail-closed promotion control for main #90/#86; scientific effect NONE", + "scope": "Merged PR15 source-bound transition gate README; scientific effect NONE; #90 still OPEN", "sha256": "574ed537cf8992bb3f86fae109e18336e51c18ea814e69451d39901b94fea80a", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." - }, - { - "bytes": 2218, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", - "key": "downstream-hard-gate-scope", - "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/SCOPE.md", - "repository": "Math-", - "scope": "Claim/non-claim boundary for the hard-gate package; not analytic acceptance", - "sha256": "c7b5bb0ec34f53395b96ae24edceb3b5b0a3451caf7df6205b924d40e9e9fd84", - "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 26247, "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", - "key": "downstream-hard-gate-code", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-code", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/hard_gate.py", "repository": "Math-", - "scope": "Fail-closed promotion and reverse-impact checker; stdlib only", + "scope": "Merged PR15 hard_gate.py with complete-record/edge transition fail-closed controls", "sha256": "af0dabff98e050abed31fa838da210c40c230e94268fdfd568cf2de2024cfa04", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 18595, "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", - "key": "downstream-hard-gate-tests", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-tests", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/test_hard_gate.py", "repository": "Math-", - "scope": "Finite integrity controls and semantic mutations; not theorem review", + "scope": "Merged PR15 hard_gate tests (67-control suite lineage); not theorem review", "sha256": "84ea94bb31ed0e8a3e022d6273ecec823bb6acc2703edc6f6a641492963f882d", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 5909, "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", - "key": "downstream-hard-gate-output", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-output", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/RESULTS.json", "repository": "Math-", - "scope": "Reproducible gate output; lemma_closed false; illegal promotions refused", + "scope": "Merged PR15 gate RESULTS; lemma_closed false", "sha256": "25eb3ef09f7b71248ddc15ee7c6b0a0e417ceea11da615c98a03a6ab39545a35", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 7517, "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", - "key": "downstream-hard-gate-replay", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-replay", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/run_validation.py", "repository": "Math-", - "scope": "Same-author gate replay runner; new output directory required", + "scope": "Merged PR15 validation/replay runner", "sha256": "2f71b34d5a241402e26c0e0046fece88e1c9f2ea07c4920735b0a3d1306fba6c", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + }, + { + "bytes": 5581, + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-git-audit", + "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/git_transition_audit.py", + "repository": "Math-", + "scope": "Merged PR15 immutable Git before/after source-object audit helper", + "sha256": "393d407c2e35d2b6f3230f5a60a9aaa7691172544d3b59f72cc880c81be20701", + "visibility": "public", + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + }, + { + "bytes": 8006, + "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-transition-tests", + "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/test_transition_contract.py", + "repository": "Math-", + "scope": "Merged PR15 transition-contract tests for git before/after inputs", + "sha256": "d9851a322274fea01e7f74db283ed70ea798bc6a35423f66c7cfddad7d92c829", + "visibility": "public", + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 12289, + "bytes": 1758, "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", - "key": "downstream-hard-gate-graph", - "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/GRAPH.json", + "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-source-files", + "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/SOURCE_FILES.json", "repository": "Math-", - "scope": "Machine dependency graph D0-D7 over Math candidates and historical RN walls", - "sha256": "556b961f92aa171655ab5cfe9fa7a89cdd16a10d29f5e39cd1ff7b6ccade73b7", + "scope": "Merged PR15 exact source-file pin manifest", + "sha256": "c70d114e2275db39fcbf999dc909fb4bcb13657878bfecd8072330a2ab37f544", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Aligned to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT; candidate/historical identity for peers. Not acceptance." + "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." } ] } diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 00453ee..8aad870 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -35,15 +35,16 @@ "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", "status": "aligned_to_meta6_tip_pins", "keys": [ - "downstream-hard-gate", - "downstream-hard-gate-scope", - "downstream-hard-gate-code", - "downstream-hard-gate-tests", - "downstream-hard-gate-output", - "downstream-hard-gate-replay", - "downstream-hard-gate-graph" + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15", + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-code", + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-tests", + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-output", + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-replay", + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-git-audit", + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-transition-tests", + "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-source-files" ], - "note": "Refreshed to Math- tip ac868b2 after TIP_DRIFT (transition gate integrate); scope+graph bytes unchanged vs baca69c; README/code/tests/output/replay updated. Candidate only — not meta catalog land." + "note": "Math-#15 MERGED @ ac868b2; meta catalogs tip under downstream-hard-gate-pr15* and keeps frozen downstream-hard-gate* @ baca69c. Candidate bundle tracks pr15* tip identities only (TIP_DRIFT-safe)." }, "still_pending_after_meta6": [ "rn-fixed-remote-window-replay", @@ -60,10 +61,10 @@ "avoid_racing": [ "meta-framework#6 bottleneck-routing lane (stop_catalog_only_churn; do not chase tip growth past recorded routing)", "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", + "Math- #15 MERGED @ ac868b2; cataloged as downstream-hard-gate-pr15* (frozen baca69c keys retained on meta)", "Math- D5 live path: #19 (ee8629f3) → #9 author regen → clean mapping successor; do not consume CLOSED #14", "Math- #20 OPEN draft fingerprint-sync map — blocked-input risk until pin AMEND; do not harden PR14-style maps", "Math- #21 OPEN inner-axial density candidate (do_not_duplicate); distinct-lane review only — not query- catalog", - "Math- #15 hosted-green but needs distinct technical review (not finished gate source)", "main #98 CI green @ 776fdb7 — eng only; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], @@ -84,7 +85,7 @@ "Math-#9 author regeneration", "clean mapping successor" ], - "math_pr15": "OPEN hosted-green head 8c4c946a; needs distinct technical review; not finished gate source", + "math_pr15": "MERGED to Math- main ac868b2; meta catalogs downstream-hard-gate-pr15* tip keys; frozen baca69c gate keys retained", "math_pr20": { "state": "OPEN", "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT_RISK", @@ -104,10 +105,11 @@ }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "c4e675a055a472ae567a6a0bcd4ffab276ff0b1d", - "dispatch": "v10", - "note": "dispatch v10 index (PR98 green, PR21 density, lane map); stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96 unless merge or TIP_DRIFT", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:28:30Z" + "head": "9c2779f4e96d078f8028b5e00367c044f724108d", + "dispatch": "v11", + "catalog_count": 120, + "note": "dispatch v11 + PR15 merge catalog; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96 unless merge or further TIP_DRIFT", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:33:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -222,5 +224,13 @@ "standing rule: TIP_DRIFT refresh allowed under stop_catalog_only_churn" ], "decision": "Refresh CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS to Math tip ac868b2; update PEER_HANDOFF math_tip; do not invent catalog keys; three replays still post-merge-only; catalog tip still unchased" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2033Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → 9c2779f dispatch v11: Math-#15 MERGED; catalog downstream-hard-gate-pr15*; keep frozen baca69c keys", + "gate stub realign to pr15* tip identities matching catalog hashes @ ac868b2", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true; verified_against remains c1046a5/96" + ], + "decision": "Retarget candidate gate bundle to downstream-hard-gate-pr15* (already cataloged on meta#6 head); do not reoffer as uncataloged; do not chase verified_against catalog count; three replays still post-merge-only" } } diff --git a/test_catalog_entry_helper.py b/test_catalog_entry_helper.py index dce53b9..f35ddaf 100644 --- a/test_catalog_entry_helper.py +++ b/test_catalog_entry_helper.py @@ -147,15 +147,16 @@ def test_candidate_downstream_gate_bundle_schema(self): bundle = json.loads((ROOT / 'portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json').read_text()) self.assertFalse(bundle['scientific_status_authority']) keys = {row['key'] for row in bundle['artifacts']} - self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate', keys) - self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate-scope', keys) - self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate-replay', keys) + self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate-pr15', keys) + self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate-pr15-replay', keys) + self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate-pr15-git-audit', keys) for row in bundle['artifacts']: self.assertEqual(row['visibility'], 'public') self.assertRegex(row['commit'], r'^[0-9a-f]{40}$') self.assertRegex(row['sha256'], r'^[0-9a-f]{64}$') self.assertTrue(row['path'].startswith('frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/')) - readme = next(r for r in bundle['artifacts'] if r['key'] == 'downstream-hard-gate') + self.assertTrue(row['key'].startswith('downstream-hard-gate-pr15')) + readme = next(r for r in bundle['artifacts'] if r['key'] == 'downstream-hard-gate-pr15') self.assertEqual(readme['path'], 'frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/README.md') diff --git a/test_verify_portable_stubs.py b/test_verify_portable_stubs.py index 8701f07..6674a2b 100644 --- a/test_verify_portable_stubs.py +++ b/test_verify_portable_stubs.py @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ def test_load_candidates_includes_replay(self): keys = {row['key'] for row in v.load_candidates()} self.assertIn('rn-fixed-remote-window-replay', keys) self.assertIn('p15-price-budget-replay', keys) - self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate', keys) + self.assertIn('downstream-hard-gate-pr15', keys) def test_validate_row_rejects_mutable_commit(self): row = { From 23e07bff11508c5a68a7889d45d025e2f8238650 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 20:38:13 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 09/19] Record Math-#22 thin-tube avoid; skip catalog tip chase dispatch v12 routing-state only under stop_catalog_only_churn. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 18 +++++++++++++----- 1 file changed, 13 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 8aad870..3b5da9e 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -65,6 +65,7 @@ "Math- D5 live path: #19 (ee8629f3) → #9 author regen → clean mapping successor; do not consume CLOSED #14", "Math- #20 OPEN draft fingerprint-sync map — blocked-input risk until pin AMEND; do not harden PR14-style maps", "Math- #21 OPEN inner-axial density candidate (do_not_duplicate); distinct-lane review only — not query- catalog", + "Math- #22 OPEN thin-tube candidate (OA-D5-THIN-TUBE-20260925); do_not_duplicate; distinct-lane review only", "main #98 CI green @ 776fdb7 — eng only; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], @@ -100,16 +101,23 @@ "claim": "OA-D5-AXIAL-DENSITY-20260925-CONSENSUS", "note": "Inner-axial density candidate; distinct-lane review only; not query- catalog work; scientific effect NONE" }, + "math_pr22": { + "state": "OPEN", + "disposition": "DO_NOT_DUPLICATE", + "head": "35eddbb5ab7dee33a659b64d8e9b0efeec16b70d", + "claim": "OA-D5-THIN-TUBE-20260925", + "path": "frontiers/rn_thin_tube_20260925/", + "note": "Thin-tube Gaussian suppression candidate; distinct-lane review only; do not catalog from query-; scientific effect NONE" + }, "main_pr98": "OPEN head 776fdb7; CI verify/navigation green at dispatch v10; eng CI ≠ mathematical claim; #90 still OPEN", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "9c2779f4e96d078f8028b5e00367c044f724108d", - "dispatch": "v11", - "catalog_count": 120, - "note": "dispatch v11 + PR15 merge catalog; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96 unless merge or further TIP_DRIFT", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:33:30Z" + "head": "ddab2a43c40b0491cd6325e5911cc993c8f48199", + "dispatch": "v12", + "note": "dispatch v12 (PR22 thin-tube + PR9 tip watch); stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:37:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", From 177b02ee6efd7f9a45314bcf7dc4bdd20fd9be6c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 20:46:39 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 10/19] Record Dylan Math-#16 review assignment; query- idle on that lane Pause catalog-only reinforced; assignee is meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 26 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 26 insertions(+) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 3b5da9e..6579fd4 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -66,6 +66,7 @@ "Math- #20 OPEN draft fingerprint-sync map — blocked-input risk until pin AMEND; do not harden PR14-style maps", "Math- #21 OPEN inner-axial density candidate (do_not_duplicate); distinct-lane review only — not query- catalog", "Math- #22 OPEN thin-tube candidate (OA-D5-THIN-TUBE-20260925); do_not_duplicate; distinct-lane review only", + "Math- #16 OPEN @ 32b80ee — bounded reciprocal review assigned to meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971 (not query-); do not edit candidate", "main #98 CI green @ 776fdb7 — eng only; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], @@ -240,5 +241,30 @@ "stop_catalog_only_churn=true; verified_against remains c1046a5/96" ], "decision": "Retarget candidate gate bundle to downstream-hard-gate-pr15* (already cataloged on meta#6 head); do not reoffer as uncataloged; do not chase verified_against catalog count; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2037Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → ddab2a4 dispatch v12 (PR22 thin-tube + PR9 tip watch)", + "Math-#22 OPEN @ 35eddbb do_not_duplicate; Math tip still ac868b2", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" + ], + "decision": "Record Math-#22 avoid only; do not invent thin-tube catalog stubs; verified_against remains c1046a5/96; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "dylan_assignment_20260925T2045Z": { + "source": "https://github.com/d6g8k5htny-coder/meta-framework/pull/6#issuecomment-5839347079", + "assigned_agent": "bc-01a0d95b-5971-7bb3-a1ce-5090c49d5cb8", + "lane": "meta-framework bounded reciprocal review", + "target": "Math-#16 @ 32b80ee085dc6a40113d1e46e333cda50d57ba21 TRANSVERSE_BOUND_CANDIDATE.md", + "query_role": "not assignee; do not steal review; reinforce pause catalog-only increments", + "fallback_for_assignee": "main#76 historical-selector vs fixed-remote-domain crosswalk", + "scientific_effect": "NONE" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2045Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta#6 comment 5839347079 Dylan: pause catalog-only; assign Math-#16 review to bc-01a0d95b-5971", + "meta tip still ddab2a4; Math tip ac868b2 tip_drift=[]; stop_catalog_only_churn", + "query- PEER_HANDOFF already current on PR15/PR22 routing" + ], + "decision": "Record Dylan PR16 review assignment as outside query-; idle eng; do not invent stubs; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From 4d468277ca2294bef43f4d68ca12e4f23b4f89d7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 21:39:02 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 11/19] Record Math-#19/#21 merge and #20 close; keep catalog tip unchased dispatch v15 routing-state only; tip_drift still empty at 8fef315. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 72 +++++++++++++++++++++++--------------- 1 file changed, 44 insertions(+), 28 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 6579fd4..a363d22 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ "meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", "meta_catalog_count": 96, - "math_tip": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "math_tip": "8fef31580426c195de8f409053551106db6b5009", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:31:30Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T21:37:30Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -62,12 +62,11 @@ "meta-framework#6 bottleneck-routing lane (stop_catalog_only_churn; do not chase tip growth past recorded routing)", "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", "Math- #15 MERGED @ ac868b2; cataloged as downstream-hard-gate-pr15* (frozen baca69c keys retained on meta)", - "Math- D5 live path: #19 (ee8629f3) → #9 author regen → clean mapping successor; do not consume CLOSED #14", - "Math- #20 OPEN draft fingerprint-sync map — blocked-input risk until pin AMEND; do not harden PR14-style maps", - "Math- #21 OPEN inner-axial density candidate (do_not_duplicate); distinct-lane review only — not query- catalog", - "Math- #22 OPEN thin-tube candidate (OA-D5-THIN-TUBE-20260925); do_not_duplicate; distinct-lane review only", + "Math- #19 MERGED (d5-finite-r-hermite-*); #21 MERGED (axial-density-*); do not re-catalog from query-", + "Math- #20 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #30 fingerprint-sync blocked-input risk — do not harden maps", + "Math- D5: Hermite+axial density landed; #9 still needs pin regen; #22/#28/#25/#31 OpenAI candidates do_not_duplicate", "Math- #16 OPEN @ 32b80ee — bounded reciprocal review assigned to meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971 (not query-); do not edit candidate", - "main #98 CI green @ 776fdb7 — eng only; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", + "main #98 CI green; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], "batch337_note": "superseded by batch340: Path C IDLE tip 848aea2; query- still stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", @@ -83,42 +82,51 @@ "title": "SUPERSEDED/BLOCKED INPUT — Map PR9 chart-J0 into post-hotfix D5 hard gate" }, "d5_live_path": [ - "Math-#19 OpenAI repair candidate head ee8629f37977f4132da4c5af7e1dd61e9d94aa1d", - "Math-#9 author regeneration", - "clean mapping successor" + "Math-#19 MERGED finite-r Hermite @ f11e4c7 (catalog d5-finite-r-hermite-*)", + "Math-#21 MERGED axial density @ c3cee9b (catalog axial-density-*)", + "Math-#9 author regeneration from corrected pins (still open)", + "clean mapping successor (hold #20/#30 fingerprint maps)" ], "math_pr15": "MERGED to Math- main ac868b2; meta catalogs downstream-hard-gate-pr15* tip keys; frozen baca69c gate keys retained", + "math_pr19": { + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "f11e4c7aecfb052c7c11cbea4a0393522c791eb4", + "catalog_prefix": "d5-finite-r-hermite-*", + "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" + }, "math_pr20": { - "state": "OPEN", - "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT_RISK", - "head_at_record": "5add2ee2cc0c168a4eade2c82eb741db93c23990", - "dispatch_v9_oid": "284271898510a385445ef2fbd22af5d4d5c2727e", - "note": "Fingerprint-sync map after PR14 close; hold until PR9 pin AMEND cleared or PR19 distinctly reviewed/consumed; do not catalog as finished gate source" + "state": "CLOSED", + "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT", + "note": "SUPERSEDED/BLOCKED INPUT; do not harden PR14-style maps" }, "math_pr21": { - "state": "OPEN", - "disposition": "DO_NOT_DUPLICATE", - "head": "b420099b2440da3a8ba62f7000feacc9fc88069b", - "claim": "OA-D5-AXIAL-DENSITY-20260925-CONSENSUS", - "note": "Inner-axial density candidate; distinct-lane review only; not query- catalog work; scientific effect NONE" + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "c3cee9bbdeeee2442fa46a06cfdbf7d28da4722f", + "catalog_prefix": "axial-density-*", + "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" }, "math_pr22": { "state": "OPEN", "disposition": "DO_NOT_DUPLICATE", - "head": "35eddbb5ab7dee33a659b64d8e9b0efeec16b70d", + "head": "2804dc1db27ef3b1fdef6bb350b486162692cc4a", "claim": "OA-D5-THIN-TUBE-20260925", - "path": "frontiers/rn_thin_tube_20260925/", - "note": "Thin-tube Gaussian suppression candidate; distinct-lane review only; do not catalog from query-; scientific effect NONE" + "note": "Thin-tube candidate; distinct-lane review only; scientific effect NONE" }, - "main_pr98": "OPEN head 776fdb7; CI verify/navigation green at dispatch v10; eng CI ≠ mathematical claim; #90 still OPEN", + "math_pr30": { + "state": "OPEN", + "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT_RISK", + "head": "8419d1e24abb8416952e48f8b8e29a429e6f498c", + "note": "Fingerprint-sync blocked-input risk after PR20 close" + }, + "main_pr98": "OPEN; CI green on repair tip; #90 still OPEN pending evidence + nonauthor re-review", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "ddab2a43c40b0491cd6325e5911cc993c8f48199", - "dispatch": "v12", - "note": "dispatch v12 (PR22 thin-tube + PR9 tip watch); stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T20:37:30Z" + "head": "6a82b6d048d480edd20b86c876313c9affeb035b", + "dispatch": "v15", + "note": "PR19/PR21 merged + PR20 closed indexed; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 8fef315", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T21:37:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -266,5 +274,13 @@ "query- PEER_HANDOFF already current on PR15/PR22 routing" ], "decision": "Record Dylan PR16 review assignment as outside query-; idle eng; do not invent stubs; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2137Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → 6a82b6d dispatch v15: Math-#19/#21/#26/#27 MERGED; #20 CLOSED blocked-input; hermite+axial cataloged", + "Math tip 8fef315; verify_portable_stubs tip_drift=[] (pr15* gate bytes unchanged)", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" + ], + "decision": "Update PEER_HANDOFF routing for PR19/PR21 merge and PR20 close; do not invent hermite/axial stubs (already on meta); do not chase verified_against; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From 585ae38f13edd37b4839761c411784a45b7c901e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 22:33:24 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 12/19] Record Math-#22/#28 merge; keep catalog tip unchased dispatch v19 annulus catalog already on meta; tip_drift still empty. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 42 +++++++++++++++++++++++++------------- 1 file changed, 28 insertions(+), 14 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index a363d22..db8fcb9 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ "meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", "meta_catalog_count": 96, - "math_tip": "8fef31580426c195de8f409053551106db6b5009", + "math_tip": "760340e921ac4ceda296b8118da936f1133e956e", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T21:37:30Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T22:32:30Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -63,10 +63,11 @@ "google-drive#3 selective Drive replicas", "Math- #15 MERGED @ ac868b2; cataloged as downstream-hard-gate-pr15* (frozen baca69c keys retained on meta)", "Math- #19 MERGED (d5-finite-r-hermite-*); #21 MERGED (axial-density-*); do not re-catalog from query-", + "Math- #22/#28 MERGED (rn-fixed-annulus-* / rn-thin-tube / rn-annulus-bridge-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #20 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #30 fingerprint-sync blocked-input risk — do not harden maps", - "Math- D5: Hermite+axial density landed; #9 still needs pin regen; #22/#28/#25/#31 OpenAI candidates do_not_duplicate", + "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus landed; #9 still needs pin regen; hold unrepaired fingerprint maps", "Math- #16 OPEN @ 32b80ee — bounded reciprocal review assigned to meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971 (not query-); do not edit candidate", - "main #98 CI green; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", + "main #98 repair-E unsettled; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], "batch337_note": "superseded by batch340: Path C IDLE tip 848aea2; query- still stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", @@ -106,11 +107,16 @@ "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" }, "math_pr22": { - "state": "OPEN", - "disposition": "DO_NOT_DUPLICATE", - "head": "2804dc1db27ef3b1fdef6bb350b486162692cc4a", - "claim": "OA-D5-THIN-TUBE-20260925", - "note": "Thin-tube candidate; distinct-lane review only; scientific effect NONE" + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "760340e921ac4ceda296b8118da936f1133e956e", + "catalog_prefix": "rn-fixed-annulus-* / rn-thin-tube*", + "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" + }, + "math_pr28": { + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "f2899d8f49834af3ab6d4a9dbbe9f3e8ca1ffd5d", + "catalog_prefix": "rn-annulus-bridge-*", + "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" }, "math_pr30": { "state": "OPEN", @@ -118,15 +124,15 @@ "head": "8419d1e24abb8416952e48f8b8e29a429e6f498c", "note": "Fingerprint-sync blocked-input risk after PR20 close" }, - "main_pr98": "OPEN; CI green on repair tip; #90 still OPEN pending evidence + nonauthor re-review", + "main_pr98": "OPEN; repair-E unsettled; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "6a82b6d048d480edd20b86c876313c9affeb035b", - "dispatch": "v15", - "note": "PR19/PR21 merged + PR20 closed indexed; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 8fef315", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T21:37:30Z" + "head": "bb2db2693246a016f38fb9a7bd42e30747096e25", + "dispatch": "v19", + "note": "PR22/PR28 merged + annulus catalog indexed; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 760340e", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T22:32:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -282,5 +288,13 @@ "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" ], "decision": "Update PEER_HANDOFF routing for PR19/PR21 merge and PR20 close; do not invent hermite/axial stubs (already on meta); do not chase verified_against; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260925T2232Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → bb2db26 dispatch v19: Math-#22/#28 MERGED; annulus identities cataloged", + "Math tip 760340e; verify_portable_stubs tip_drift=[]", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" + ], + "decision": "Record PR22/PR28 merge in PEER_HANDOFF; do not invent annulus/thin-tube stubs; do not chase verified_against; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From b8262bb0d74f0a4777bb448aea21d68637d3c369 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 00:03:43 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 13/19] Record PR9/PR41 close and contact merges; no catalog chase dispatch v25 routing-state; tip_drift still empty at 232a182. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 41 ++++++++++++++++++++++++-------------- 1 file changed, 26 insertions(+), 15 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index db8fcb9..3cf024c 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -64,10 +64,11 @@ "Math- #15 MERGED @ ac868b2; cataloged as downstream-hard-gate-pr15* (frozen baca69c keys retained on meta)", "Math- #19 MERGED (d5-finite-r-hermite-*); #21 MERGED (axial-density-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #22/#28 MERGED (rn-fixed-annulus-* / rn-thin-tube / rn-annulus-bridge-*); do not re-catalog from query-", - "Math- #20 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #30 fingerprint-sync blocked-input risk — do not harden maps", - "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus landed; #9 still needs pin regen; hold unrepaired fingerprint maps", + "Math- #33/#36/#37/#48 MERGED (contact + landing-claims); do not re-catalog from query-", + "Math- #9/#41 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #20/#30-style fingerprint maps — do not harden", + "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus+contact landed; landing-claims strengthen #90 but do not close it", "Math- #16 OPEN @ 32b80ee — bounded reciprocal review assigned to meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971 (not query-); do not edit candidate", - "main #98 repair-E unsettled; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", + "main #98 tip unsettled/#90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], "batch337_note": "superseded by batch340: Path C IDLE tip 848aea2; query- still stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", @@ -85,9 +86,15 @@ "d5_live_path": [ "Math-#19 MERGED finite-r Hermite @ f11e4c7 (catalog d5-finite-r-hermite-*)", "Math-#21 MERGED axial density @ c3cee9b (catalog axial-density-*)", - "Math-#9 author regeneration from corrected pins (still open)", - "clean mapping successor (hold #20/#30 fingerprint maps)" + "Math-#22/#28 MERGED annulus/thin-tube", + "Math-#33/#36/#37/#48 MERGED contact + landing-claims (strengthens #90; does not close)", + "Math-#9/#41 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT — do not consume fingerprint maps" ], + "math_pr9": { + "state": "CLOSED", + "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT", + "note": "SUPERSEDED/BLOCKED INPUT per dispatch v25; do not harden unrepaired tip maps" + }, "math_pr15": "MERGED to Math- main ac868b2; meta catalogs downstream-hard-gate-pr15* tip keys; frozen baca69c gate keys retained", "math_pr19": { "state": "MERGED", @@ -118,21 +125,25 @@ "catalog_prefix": "rn-annulus-bridge-*", "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" }, - "math_pr30": { - "state": "OPEN", - "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT_RISK", - "head": "8419d1e24abb8416952e48f8b8e29a429e6f498c", - "note": "Fingerprint-sync blocked-input risk after PR20 close" + "math_pr41": { + "state": "CLOSED", + "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT", + "note": "SUPERSEDED/BLOCKED INPUT per dispatch v25" + }, + "math_pr48": { + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "232a182fee316d2bb428b7351b5c5caae3b8cc2e", + "role": "landing-claim integrity; strengthens #90 but does not close" }, - "main_pr98": "OPEN; repair-E unsettled; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", + "main_pr98": "OPEN; tip E6 unsettled; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "bb2db2693246a016f38fb9a7bd42e30747096e25", - "dispatch": "v19", - "note": "PR22/PR28 merged + annulus catalog indexed; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 760340e", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T22:32:30Z" + "head": "0624d21e68ca962cfb26a6d376476bf8fba80e7b", + "dispatch": "v25", + "note": "contact merges + landing-claims + PR9/PR41 closed; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 232a182", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:02:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", From 38898f429df0dac01239ec1f66c27560482e22ee Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 00:32:40 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 14/19] Record Math-#25 merge; keep catalog tip unchased dispatch v27 collision-mechanism already on meta; tip_drift empty. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 35 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++------ 1 file changed, 29 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 3cf024c..50b9c5a 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ "meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", "meta_catalog_count": 96, - "math_tip": "760340e921ac4ceda296b8118da936f1133e956e", + "math_tip": "53320cbc8a4d15b9f675885a1d7760656bcc3b4f", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-25T22:32:30Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:31:30Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -65,6 +65,7 @@ "Math- #19 MERGED (d5-finite-r-hermite-*); #21 MERGED (axial-density-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #22/#28 MERGED (rn-fixed-annulus-* / rn-thin-tube / rn-annulus-bridge-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #33/#36/#37/#48 MERGED (contact + landing-claims); do not re-catalog from query-", + "Math- #25 MERGED (collision-mechanism-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #9/#41 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #20/#30-style fingerprint maps — do not harden", "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus+contact landed; landing-claims strengthen #90 but do not close it", "Math- #16 OPEN @ 32b80ee — bounded reciprocal review assigned to meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971 (not query-); do not edit candidate", @@ -125,6 +126,12 @@ "catalog_prefix": "rn-annulus-bridge-*", "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" }, + "math_pr25": { + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "53320cbc8a4d15b9f675885a1d7760656bcc3b4f", + "catalog_prefix": "collision-mechanism-*", + "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" + }, "math_pr41": { "state": "CLOSED", "disposition": "BLOCKED_INPUT", @@ -140,10 +147,10 @@ }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "0624d21e68ca962cfb26a6d376476bf8fba80e7b", - "dispatch": "v25", - "note": "contact merges + landing-claims + PR9/PR41 closed; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 232a182", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:02:30Z" + "head": "5a39bdfa4ea4373789d9aa845e2beda0a84ed46a", + "dispatch": "v27", + "note": "PR25 collision-mechanism merged+cataloged; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 53320cb", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:31:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -307,5 +314,21 @@ "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" ], "decision": "Record PR22/PR28 merge in PEER_HANDOFF; do not invent annulus/thin-tube stubs; do not chase verified_against; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260926T0002Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → 0624d21 dispatch v25: PR33/36/37/48 MERGED; PR9/PR41 CLOSED blocked-input", + "Math tip 232a182; verify_portable_stubs tip_drift=[]", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" + ], + "decision": "Record contact/landing merges and PR9/PR41 closed; do not invent contact stubs; do not chase verified_against; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260926T0031Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → 5a39bdf dispatch v27: Math-#25 MERGED collision-mechanism cataloged", + "Math tip 53320cb; verify_portable_stubs tip_drift=[]", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" + ], + "decision": "Record PR25 merge; do not invent collision-mechanism stubs; do not chase verified_against; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From 973e14223fc026ebd40559b0c38ea02df5e4f0f9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 00:47:14 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 15/19] Refresh pr15 gate stubs to Math tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT Annulus D5 scope map changed code/tests/output/source-files. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json | 54 +++++++++---------- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 8 +++ 2 files changed, 35 insertions(+), 27 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json index d89358a..6f83e14 100644 --- a/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json +++ b/portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json @@ -1,98 +1,98 @@ { "scientific_status_authority": false, - "meaning": "candidate stubs for merged Math- PR15 tip identities (downstream-hard-gate-pr15*); frozen baca69c keys stay on meta catalog; not catalog authority", - "math_tip": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "meaning": "candidate stubs for Math tip after TIP_DRIFT on pr15* paths; frozen baca69c and historical ac868b2 catalog keys may remain on meta; not catalog authority", + "math_tip": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "aligned_to_meta_pr": 6, - "aligned_to_meta_head": "9c2779f4e96d078f8028b5e00367c044f724108d", - "frozen_gate_keys_on_meta": "downstream-hard-gate* @ baca69c (do not overwrite)", + "aligned_to_meta_head": "5a39bdfa4ea4373789d9aa845e2beda0a84ed46a", + "frozen_gate_keys_on_meta": "downstream-hard-gate* @ baca69c; historical downstream-hard-gate-pr15* @ ac868b2 may lag tip", "artifacts": [ { "bytes": 3559, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/README.md", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 source-bound transition gate README; scientific effect NONE; #90 still OPEN", "sha256": "574ed537cf8992bb3f86fae109e18336e51c18ea814e69451d39901b94fea80a", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 26247, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "bytes": 26557, + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-code", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/hard_gate.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 hard_gate.py with complete-record/edge transition fail-closed controls", - "sha256": "af0dabff98e050abed31fa838da210c40c230e94268fdfd568cf2de2024cfa04", + "sha256": "1954723d143a3d68cbf3834b2c18e4198fd89ba49145f012bdc425c80050d052", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 18595, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "bytes": 18920, + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-tests", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/test_hard_gate.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 hard_gate tests (67-control suite lineage); not theorem review", - "sha256": "84ea94bb31ed0e8a3e022d6273ecec823bb6acc2703edc6f6a641492963f882d", + "sha256": "24bf0ae39c3b36ff253ee7dbbb5c5b347ab8c528c88d2d9cf578ef6b3ab04e51", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." }, { - "bytes": 5909, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "bytes": 6509, + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-output", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/RESULTS.json", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 gate RESULTS; lemma_closed false", - "sha256": "25eb3ef09f7b71248ddc15ee7c6b0a0e417ceea11da615c98a03a6ab39545a35", + "sha256": "2fd874894334f65b57bbab438d093c7dee37395e8352bdd49ee04410da9240da", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 7517, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-replay", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/run_validation.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 validation/replay runner", "sha256": "2f71b34d5a241402e26c0e0046fece88e1c9f2ea07c4920735b0a3d1306fba6c", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 5581, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-git-audit", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/git_transition_audit.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 immutable Git before/after source-object audit helper", "sha256": "393d407c2e35d2b6f3230f5a60a9aaa7691172544d3b59f72cc880c81be20701", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 8006, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-transition-tests", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/test_transition_contract.py", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 transition-contract tests for git before/after inputs", "sha256": "d9851a322274fea01e7f74db283ed70ea798bc6a35423f66c7cfddad7d92c829", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." }, { "bytes": 1758, - "commit": "ac868b2b31d0995b75dd697f19d4c94735179a38", + "commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "key": "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-source-files", "path": "frontiers/downstream_gate_20260925/SOURCE_FILES.json", "repository": "Math-", "scope": "Merged PR15 exact source-file pin manifest", - "sha256": "c70d114e2275db39fcbf999dc909fb4bcb13657878bfecd8072330a2ab37f544", + "sha256": "ab0aafb30290a48980418db60569197b7d9663e0dd69375a121c9d0150c41e90", "visibility": "public", - "note": "Matches meta#6 catalog key at tip ac868b2 (PR15 merged). Frozen baca69c keys remain separate on meta. Candidate/historical for peers; not acceptance." + "note": "Aligned to Math- tip 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT (annulus D5 scope map). Meta may still pin older pr15* @ ac868b2 until re-catalog. Candidate only; not acceptance." } ] } diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 50b9c5a..4e947d1 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -330,5 +330,13 @@ "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" ], "decision": "Record PR25 merge; do not invent collision-mechanism stubs; do not chase verified_against; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260926T0046Z": { + "sources": [ + "Math tip 53320cb→703e947 (Map reviewed fixed-annulus D5 scope without global status transfer)", + "verify_portable_stubs REFUSED TIP_DRIFT on pr15-code/tests/output/source-files", + "standing rule: TIP_DRIFT refresh allowed under stop_catalog_only_churn" + ], + "decision": "Refresh CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS pr15* to tip 703e947; update PEER_HANDOFF math_tip; do not invent new catalog keys; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From 43e8a8f19515fe1528848405e5ab3eb7cad4952d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 00:47:46 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 16/19] Sync PEER_HANDOFF math_tip to 703e947 after TIP_DRIFT refresh Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 4e947d1..2f20bae 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -27,9 +27,9 @@ "meta_head": "c1046a539964d562b071a189cd37a76102789b25", "meta_pr_state": "OPEN", "meta_catalog_count": 96, - "math_tip": "53320cbc8a4d15b9f675885a1d7760656bcc3b4f", + "math_tip": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", "tip_drift": [], - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:31:30Z" + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:46:30Z" }, "gate_stubs_vs_meta6": { "bundle": "portable/CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS.json", @@ -44,7 +44,7 @@ "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-transition-tests", "downstream-hard-gate-pr15-source-files" ], - "note": "Math-#15 MERGED @ ac868b2; meta catalogs tip under downstream-hard-gate-pr15* and keeps frozen downstream-hard-gate* @ baca69c. Candidate bundle tracks pr15* tip identities only (TIP_DRIFT-safe)." + "note": "TIP_DRIFT refresh to Math tip 703e947 (annulus D5 scope map). code/tests/output/source-files changed; README/replay/git-audit/transition-tests unchanged. Meta historical pr15* @ ac868b2 may lag until re-catalog." }, "still_pending_after_meta6": [ "rn-fixed-remote-window-replay", From bff7e7bcc10d7f220e63267d19ec24a8083d74e6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 00:49:11 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 17/19] Record Math-#50/#51 merge; keep pr15 tip pins dispatch v28 custody/FC-10 already on meta; tip_drift empty. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 29 +++++++++++++++++++++++++---- 1 file changed, 25 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 2f20bae..68ed004 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -66,6 +66,7 @@ "Math- #22/#28 MERGED (rn-fixed-annulus-* / rn-thin-tube / rn-annulus-bridge-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #33/#36/#37/#48 MERGED (contact + landing-claims); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #25 MERGED (collision-mechanism-*); do not re-catalog from query-", + "Math- #50/#51 MERGED (lifetime-parent-* / downstream-gate-fc10-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #9/#41 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #20/#30-style fingerprint maps — do not harden", "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus+contact landed; landing-claims strengthen #90 but do not close it", "Math- #16 OPEN @ 32b80ee — bounded reciprocal review assigned to meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971 (not query-); do not edit candidate", @@ -142,15 +143,27 @@ "merge_commit": "232a182fee316d2bb428b7351b5c5caae3b8cc2e", "role": "landing-claim integrity; strengthens #90 but does not close" }, + "math_pr50": { + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "2d42fd165a948092b6f2296d5f580733c5a6f05c", + "catalog_prefix": "lifetime-parent-*", + "note": "Already cataloged on meta#6; query- does not re-offer" + }, + "math_pr51": { + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "703e94744a7205d438c2df690ca62d5688812480", + "catalog_prefix": "downstream-gate-fc10-*", + "note": "FC-10 graph keys cataloged on meta; candidate bundle remains pr15* tip pins; do not re-offer" + }, "main_pr98": "OPEN; tip E6 unsettled; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "5a39bdfa4ea4373789d9aa845e2beda0a84ed46a", - "dispatch": "v27", - "note": "PR25 collision-mechanism merged+cataloged; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 53320cb", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:31:30Z" + "head": "d94d447fb027aa1a2311a9f51fb344eefc9e6d2f", + "dispatch": "v28", + "note": "PR50/PR51 merged+cataloged; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 703e947", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:48:30Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -338,5 +351,13 @@ "standing rule: TIP_DRIFT refresh allowed under stop_catalog_only_churn" ], "decision": "Refresh CANDIDATE_DOWNSTREAM_GATE_STUBS pr15* to tip 703e947; update PEER_HANDOFF math_tip; do not invent new catalog keys; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "collective_decision_20260926T0048Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → d94d447 dispatch v28: Math-#50/#51 MERGED (lifetime-parent / fc10)", + "Math tip 703e947; verify_portable_stubs tip_drift=[] after prior TIP_DRIFT refresh", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" + ], + "decision": "Record PR50/PR51 merge; do not invent lifetime-parent/fc10 stubs; keep pr15* tip pins; three replays still post-merge-only" } } From 2c2d8bac9dfc22dcef260b02c6b2b86f462ebf39 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 01:02:42 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 18/19] Record Math-#16 CLOSED SUPERSEDED; observe meta tip c696b85 Peer decision: routing-only handoff update under stop_catalog_only_churn. Do not chase verified_against or invent stubs; tip_drift still empty. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 24 ++++++++++++++++++------ 1 file changed, 18 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index 68ed004..cb05555 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ "Math- #50/#51 MERGED (lifetime-parent-* / downstream-gate-fc10-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #9/#41 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #20/#30-style fingerprint maps — do not harden", "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus+contact landed; landing-claims strengthen #90 but do not close it", - "Math- #16 OPEN @ 32b80ee — bounded reciprocal review assigned to meta agent bc-01a0d95b-5971 (not query-); do not edit candidate", + "Math- #16 CLOSED unmerged SUPERSEDED/CONSUMED @ 32b80ee (R1–R5 reviewed in PR26; scope subsumed); review assignment retired — do not reopen/edit", "main #98 tip unsettled/#90 still OPEN; not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], @@ -160,10 +160,10 @@ }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "d94d447fb027aa1a2311a9f51fb344eefc9e6d2f", - "dispatch": "v28", - "note": "PR50/PR51 merged+cataloged; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 703e947", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T00:48:30Z" + "head": "c696b858f19d35ef7ce3e8c27b0ac0dd02e5436f", + "dispatch": "v30", + "note": "v29/v30 gov PR4 + PR98 tip + catalog CI replica repair (catalog 221); stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 703e947", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T01:15:00Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -300,7 +300,8 @@ "assigned_agent": "bc-01a0d95b-5971-7bb3-a1ce-5090c49d5cb8", "lane": "meta-framework bounded reciprocal review", "target": "Math-#16 @ 32b80ee085dc6a40113d1e46e333cda50d57ba21 TRANSVERSE_BOUND_CANDIDATE.md", - "query_role": "not assignee; do not steal review; reinforce pause catalog-only increments", + "disposition": "CLOSED_UNMERGED SUPERSEDED/CONSUMED 2026-09-26T00:04Z — pin defect closed PR9/PR41; R1–R5 in merged PR26; assignment retired", + "query_role": "not assignee; do not reopen/edit; reinforce pause catalog-only increments", "fallback_for_assignee": "main#76 historical-selector vs fixed-remote-domain crosswalk", "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, @@ -359,5 +360,16 @@ "stop_catalog_only_churn=true" ], "decision": "Record PR50/PR51 merge; do not invent lifetime-parent/fc10 stubs; keep pr15* tip pins; three replays still post-merge-only" + }, + "batch359_note": "trial MULTI_AGENT_WAKE_BATCH359 Path C IDLE@0019 @ e3cd7d4; no query/catalog assignment; tip_sync/research/grant peers only", + "collective_decision_20260926T0115Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 still OPEN @ c696b85 (dispatch v30 + catalog CI replica repair; catalog 221) — tip growth not chased", + "Math tip 703e947; verify_portable_stubs --check-math-tip drifted=[]", + "Math-#16 CLOSED unmerged SUPERSEDED/CONSUMED @ 32b80ee (Dylan TERMINAL CLEANUP)", + "trial BATCH359 Path C IDLE@0019; google-drive#3 still OPEN", + "peer Task agents bc-0d34f71c (idle on catalog tip) + bc-9e3d9412 (YES routing for #16 close)" + ], + "decision": "Routing-only: record Math-#16 CLOSED and retire dylan #16 assignment; observe meta tip c696b85 without refreshing verified_against; keep pr15* @ 703e947; three replays still post-merge-only; no invent keys" } } From 43c9fc91271b63f3ac3dea653d7ea0383fd1673d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Sat, 26 Sep 2026 01:38:04 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 19/19] Record #90 eng-gate close, PR98/PR63 merges in handoff Peer routing-only update under stop_catalog_only_churn: clear stale main#90/#98 signals; no verified_against chase; tip_drift still empty. Co-authored-by: Dylan Roy --- portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json | 40 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++------- 1 file changed, 33 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json index cb05555..589f4de 100644 --- a/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json +++ b/portable/PEER_HANDOFF.json @@ -68,9 +68,10 @@ "Math- #25 MERGED (collision-mechanism-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #50/#51 MERGED (lifetime-parent-* / downstream-gate-fc10-*); do not re-catalog from query-", "Math- #9/#41 CLOSED/BLOCKED INPUT; #20/#30-style fingerprint maps — do not harden", - "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus+contact landed; landing-claims strengthen #90 but do not close it", + "Math- D5: Hermite+axial+annulus+contact landed; landing-claims do not close scientific D0–D6", "Math- #16 CLOSED unmerged SUPERSEDED/CONSUMED @ 32b80ee (R1–R5 reviewed in PR26; scope subsumed); review assignment retired — do not reopen/edit", - "main #98 tip unsettled/#90 still OPEN; not query- lane", + "Math- #63 MERGED @ 1e1114f P15 full-price nonauthor ACCEPT — cataloged on meta; do not re-offer from query-", + "main #90 CLOSED eng-gate only 2026-09-26T01:20Z (NOT theorem acceptance; promotion_permission:false); PR98 MERGED @ ebedb780 — not query- lane", "main research/inventable drafts; vault #91" ], "batch337_note": "superseded by batch340: Path C IDLE tip 848aea2; query- still stub currency vs meta#6 + tip-drift only", @@ -155,15 +156,32 @@ "catalog_prefix": "downstream-gate-fc10-*", "note": "FC-10 graph keys cataloged on meta; candidate bundle remains pr15* tip pins; do not re-offer" }, - "main_pr98": "OPEN; tip E6 unsettled; #90 still OPEN; not query- lane", + "math_pr63": { + "state": "MERGED", + "merge_commit": "1e1114f5eb8ef8cdbcde591bf74126274c250f88", + "role": "P15 full-price nonauthor ACCEPT", + "note": "Cataloged on meta#6 v34; tip_drift=[] for pr15* gate paths; query- does not re-offer" + }, + "main_issue_90": { + "state": "CLOSED", + "scope": "engineering-gate only", + "closed_at": "2026-09-26T01:20:06Z", + "note": "NOT theorem acceptance; promotion_permission remains false; not query- lane" + }, + "main_pr98": { + "state": "MERGED", + "reviewed_head": "b59359ebb972351802c7bf343363811a8e83150b", + "merge_commit": "ebedb7802024fa557e9071e4c9cec7cddc474b89", + "note": "not query- lane; do not invent stubs" + }, "scientific_effect": "NONE" }, "meta_tip_observed_not_chased": { "meta_pr": 6, - "head": "c696b858f19d35ef7ce3e8c27b0ac0dd02e5436f", - "dispatch": "v30", - "note": "v29/v30 gov PR4 + PR98 tip + catalog CI replica repair (catalog 221); stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] at Math 703e947", - "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T01:15:00Z" + "head": "ce51b8b52504a9f98b8b544e10336335b0ad8852", + "dispatch": "v34", + "note": "v34: #90 eng-gate CLOSED + PR98 MERGED + Math-#63 MERGED; stop_catalog_only_churn — verified_against stays c1046a5/96; tip_drift=[] (pr15* bytes unchanged at Math 1e1114f)", + "checked_at_utc": "2026-09-26T01:38:00Z" }, "stale_consumer_scan_20260925T1949Z": { "meaning": "exact paths still naming CLOSED Math-#14 or intermediate/known-bad Math-#9 tip fingerprints; not catalog authority", @@ -371,5 +389,13 @@ "peer Task agents bc-0d34f71c (idle on catalog tip) + bc-9e3d9412 (YES routing for #16 close)" ], "decision": "Routing-only: record Math-#16 CLOSED and retire dylan #16 assignment; observe meta tip c696b85 without refreshing verified_against; keep pr15* @ 703e947; three replays still post-merge-only; no invent keys" + }, + "collective_decision_20260926T0138Z": { + "sources": [ + "meta-framework#6 synchronize → ce51b8b dispatch v34: #90 eng-gate CLOSED + PR98 MERGED ebedb780 + Math-#63 MERGED 1e1114f", + "verify_portable_stubs --check-math-tip drifted=[] (pr15* gate paths unchanged)", + "stop_catalog_only_churn=true; peer Task bc-553c8a44 (YES routing-only)" + ], + "decision": "Routing-only: clear stale #90 OPEN/#98 unsettled signals; record #63 ACCEPT; observe meta tip ce51b8b without refreshing verified_against or inventing stubs; three replays still post-merge-only" } }