img:first-child]:pt-0 data-[size=sm]:gap-3 data-[size=sm]:py-3 data-[size=sm]:has-data-[slot=card-footer]:pb-0 *:[img:first-child]:rounded-t-xl *:[img:last-child]:rounded-b-xl",
+ className
+ )}
+ {...props}
+ />
+ )
+}
+
+function CardHeader({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"div">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function CardTitle({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"div">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function CardDescription({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"div">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function CardAction({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"div">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function CardContent({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"div">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function CardFooter({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"div">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export {
+ Card,
+ CardHeader,
+ CardFooter,
+ CardTitle,
+ CardAction,
+ CardDescription,
+ CardContent,
+}
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/dialog.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/dialog.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..014f5aa
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/dialog.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,160 @@
+"use client"
+
+import * as React from "react"
+import { Dialog as DialogPrimitive } from "@base-ui/react/dialog"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+import { Button } from "@/components/ui/button"
+import { XIcon } from "lucide-react"
+
+function Dialog({ ...props }: DialogPrimitive.Root.Props) {
+ return
+}
+
+function DialogTrigger({ ...props }: DialogPrimitive.Trigger.Props) {
+ return
+}
+
+function DialogPortal({ ...props }: DialogPrimitive.Portal.Props) {
+ return
+}
+
+function DialogClose({ ...props }: DialogPrimitive.Close.Props) {
+ return
+}
+
+function DialogOverlay({
+ className,
+ ...props
+}: DialogPrimitive.Backdrop.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function DialogContent({
+ className,
+ children,
+ showCloseButton = true,
+ ...props
+}: DialogPrimitive.Popup.Props & {
+ showCloseButton?: boolean
+}) {
+ return (
+
+
+
+ {children}
+ {showCloseButton && (
+
+ }
+ >
+
+ Close
+
+ )}
+
+
+ )
+}
+
+function DialogHeader({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"div">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function DialogFooter({
+ className,
+ showCloseButton = false,
+ children,
+ ...props
+}: React.ComponentProps<"div"> & {
+ showCloseButton?: boolean
+}) {
+ return (
+
+ {children}
+ {showCloseButton && (
+ }>
+ Close
+
+ )}
+
+ )
+}
+
+function DialogTitle({ className, ...props }: DialogPrimitive.Title.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function DialogDescription({
+ className,
+ ...props
+}: DialogPrimitive.Description.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export {
+ Dialog,
+ DialogClose,
+ DialogContent,
+ DialogDescription,
+ DialogFooter,
+ DialogHeader,
+ DialogOverlay,
+ DialogPortal,
+ DialogTitle,
+ DialogTrigger,
+}
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/input.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/input.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..7d21bab
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/input.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+import * as React from "react"
+import { Input as InputPrimitive } from "@base-ui/react/input"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function Input({ className, type, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"input">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export { Input }
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/label.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/label.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..74da65c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/label.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+"use client"
+
+import * as React from "react"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function Label({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"label">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export { Label }
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/progress.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/progress.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..986f346
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/progress.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,83 @@
+"use client"
+
+import { Progress as ProgressPrimitive } from "@base-ui/react/progress"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function Progress({
+ className,
+ children,
+ value,
+ ...props
+}: ProgressPrimitive.Root.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ {children}
+
+
+
+
+ )
+}
+
+function ProgressTrack({ className, ...props }: ProgressPrimitive.Track.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function ProgressIndicator({
+ className,
+ ...props
+}: ProgressPrimitive.Indicator.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function ProgressLabel({ className, ...props }: ProgressPrimitive.Label.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function ProgressValue({ className, ...props }: ProgressPrimitive.Value.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export {
+ Progress,
+ ProgressTrack,
+ ProgressIndicator,
+ ProgressLabel,
+ ProgressValue,
+}
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/scroll-area.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/scroll-area.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..84c1e9f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/scroll-area.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,55 @@
+"use client"
+
+import * as React from "react"
+import { ScrollArea as ScrollAreaPrimitive } from "@base-ui/react/scroll-area"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function ScrollArea({
+ className,
+ children,
+ ...props
+}: ScrollAreaPrimitive.Root.Props) {
+ return (
+
+
+ {children}
+
+
+
+
+ )
+}
+
+function ScrollBar({
+ className,
+ orientation = "vertical",
+ ...props
+}: ScrollAreaPrimitive.Scrollbar.Props) {
+ return (
+
+
+
+ )
+}
+
+export { ScrollArea, ScrollBar }
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/separator.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/separator.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..6e1369e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/separator.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+"use client"
+
+import { Separator as SeparatorPrimitive } from "@base-ui/react/separator"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function Separator({
+ className,
+ orientation = "horizontal",
+ ...props
+}: SeparatorPrimitive.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export { Separator }
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/table.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/table.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..abeaced
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/table.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,116 @@
+"use client"
+
+import * as React from "react"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function Table({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"table">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TableHeader({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"thead">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TableBody({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"tbody">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TableFooter({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"tfoot">) {
+ return (
+
tr]:last:border-b-0",
+ className
+ )}
+ {...props}
+ />
+ )
+}
+
+function TableRow({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"tr">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TableHead({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"th">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TableCell({ className, ...props }: React.ComponentProps<"td">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TableCaption({
+ className,
+ ...props
+}: React.ComponentProps<"caption">) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export {
+ Table,
+ TableHeader,
+ TableBody,
+ TableFooter,
+ TableHead,
+ TableRow,
+ TableCell,
+ TableCaption,
+}
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/tabs.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/tabs.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..8ee8054
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/tabs.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,82 @@
+"use client"
+
+import { Tabs as TabsPrimitive } from "@base-ui/react/tabs"
+import { cva, type VariantProps } from "class-variance-authority"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function Tabs({
+ className,
+ orientation = "horizontal",
+ ...props
+}: TabsPrimitive.Root.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+const tabsListVariants = cva(
+ "group/tabs-list inline-flex w-fit items-center justify-center rounded-lg p-[3px] text-muted-foreground group-data-horizontal/tabs:h-8 group-data-vertical/tabs:h-fit group-data-vertical/tabs:flex-col data-[variant=line]:rounded-none",
+ {
+ variants: {
+ variant: {
+ default: "bg-muted",
+ line: "gap-1 bg-transparent",
+ },
+ },
+ defaultVariants: {
+ variant: "default",
+ },
+ }
+)
+
+function TabsList({
+ className,
+ variant = "default",
+ ...props
+}: TabsPrimitive.List.Props & VariantProps) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TabsTrigger({ className, ...props }: TabsPrimitive.Tab.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function TabsContent({ className, ...props }: TabsPrimitive.Panel.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+export { Tabs, TabsList, TabsTrigger, TabsContent, tabsListVariants }
diff --git a/web/src/components/ui/tooltip.tsx b/web/src/components/ui/tooltip.tsx
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..69e8a82
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/components/ui/tooltip.tsx
@@ -0,0 +1,66 @@
+"use client"
+
+import { Tooltip as TooltipPrimitive } from "@base-ui/react/tooltip"
+
+import { cn } from "@/lib/utils"
+
+function TooltipProvider({
+ delay = 0,
+ ...props
+}: TooltipPrimitive.Provider.Props) {
+ return (
+
+ )
+}
+
+function Tooltip({ ...props }: TooltipPrimitive.Root.Props) {
+ return
+}
+
+function TooltipTrigger({ ...props }: TooltipPrimitive.Trigger.Props) {
+ return
+}
+
+function TooltipContent({
+ className,
+ side = "top",
+ sideOffset = 4,
+ align = "center",
+ alignOffset = 0,
+ children,
+ ...props
+}: TooltipPrimitive.Popup.Props &
+ Pick<
+ TooltipPrimitive.Positioner.Props,
+ "align" | "alignOffset" | "side" | "sideOffset"
+ >) {
+ return (
+
+
+
+ {children}
+
+
+
+
+ )
+}
+
+export { Tooltip, TooltipTrigger, TooltipContent, TooltipProvider }
diff --git a/web/src/data/benchmark-results.json b/web/src/data/benchmark-results.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..43cdd61
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/data/benchmark-results.json
@@ -0,0 +1,9515 @@
+{
+ "leaderboard": [
+ {
+ "model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)",
+ "provider": "Anthropic",
+ "elo": 1590.0,
+ "arena_score": 1503,
+ "rank": 1
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)",
+ "provider": "xAI",
+ "elo": 1577.3,
+ "arena_score": 1480,
+ "rank": 2
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent",
+ "provider": "xAI",
+ "elo": 1559.5,
+ "arena_score": 1475,
+ "rank": 3
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20",
+ "provider": "xAI",
+ "elo": 1546.3,
+ "arena_score": 1490,
+ "rank": 4
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat",
+ "provider": "OpenAI",
+ "elo": 1545.6,
+ "arena_score": 1477,
+ "rank": 5
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6",
+ "provider": "Anthropic",
+ "elo": 1508.1,
+ "arena_score": 1497,
+ "rank": 6
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash",
+ "provider": "Google",
+ "elo": 1458.6,
+ "arena_score": 1474,
+ "rank": 7
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro",
+ "provider": "Google",
+ "elo": 1430.5,
+ "arena_score": 1486,
+ "rank": 8
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)",
+ "provider": "OpenAI",
+ "elo": 1407.1,
+ "arena_score": 1484,
+ "rank": 9
+ },
+ {
+ "model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview",
+ "provider": "Google",
+ "elo": 1377.0,
+ "arena_score": 1493,
+ "rank": 10
+ }
+ ],
+ "elo_history": [
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-001-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1500.0,
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1516.0,
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1484.0
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-002-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1516.0,
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1531.3,
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1484.7
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-003-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-grok-4.20",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1531.3,
+ "grok-4.20": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1545.9,
+ "grok-4.20": 1485.4
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-004-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1545.9,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1559.8,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1486.1
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-005-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1559.8,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1573.1,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1486.7
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-006-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1573.1,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1585.8,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1487.3
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-007-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1585.8,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1597.9,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1487.9
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-008-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1597.9,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1577.5,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1520.4
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-009-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1577.5,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1500.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": 1590.0,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1487.5
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-010-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1484.0,
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1484.7
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1500.0,
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1468.7
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-011-claude-opus-4.6-vs-grok-4.20",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1500.0,
+ "grok-4.20": 1485.4
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1515.3,
+ "grok-4.20": 1470.1
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-012-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1515.3,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1486.1
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1530.0,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1471.4
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-013-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1530.0,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1486.7
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1544.0,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1472.7
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-014-claude-opus-4.6-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1544.0,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1487.3
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1525.4,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1505.9
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-015-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "winner": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1525.4,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1487.9
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1507.7,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1505.6
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-016-claude-opus-4.6-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1507.7,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1520.4
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1492.3,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1535.8
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-017-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1492.3,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1487.5
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": 1508.1,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1471.7
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-018-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-grok-4.20",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1468.7,
+ "grok-4.20": 1470.1
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1452.8,
+ "grok-4.20": 1486.0
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-019-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "winner": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1452.8,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1471.4
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1437.7,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1486.5
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-020-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "winner": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1437.7,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1472.7
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1423.3,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1487.1
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-021-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1423.3,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1505.9
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1411.0,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1518.2
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-022-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "winner": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1411.0,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1505.6
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1399.3,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1517.3
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-023-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1399.3,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1535.8
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1389.3,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1545.8
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-024-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1389.3,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1471.7
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": 1377.0,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1484.0
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-025-grok-4.20-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1486.0,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1486.5
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1502.0,
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1470.5
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-026-grok-4.20-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1502.0,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1487.1
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1517.3,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1471.8
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-027-grok-4.20-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1517.3,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1518.2
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1533.3,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1502.2
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-028-grok-4.20-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1533.3,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1517.3
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1548.6,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1502.0
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-029-grok-4.20-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1548.6,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1545.8
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1532.5,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1561.9
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-030-grok-4.20-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1532.5,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1484.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20": 1546.3,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1470.2
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-031-gemini-3-pro-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "winner": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1470.5,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1471.8
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1486.6,
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1455.7
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-032-gemini-3-pro-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1486.6,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1502.2
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1471.3,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1517.5
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-033-gemini-3-pro-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "winner": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1471.3,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1502.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1456.7,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1516.6
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-034-gemini-3-pro-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1456.7,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1561.9
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1445.4,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1573.2
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-035-gemini-3-pro-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1445.4,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1470.2
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gemini-3-pro": 1430.5,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1485.1
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-036-gpt-5.4-high-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_a": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1455.7,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1517.5
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1442.5,
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1530.7
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-037-gpt-5.4-high-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_a": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "winner": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1442.5,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1516.6
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1429.9,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1529.2
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-038-gpt-5.4-high-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1429.9,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1573.2
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1420.1,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1583.0
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-039-gpt-5.4-high-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1420.1,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1485.1
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gpt-5.4-high": 1407.1,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1498.1
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-040-grok-4.20-reasoning-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_b": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1530.7,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1529.2
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1546.6,
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1513.3
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-041-grok-4.20-reasoning-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1546.6,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1583.0
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1564.3,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1565.3
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-042-grok-4.20-reasoning-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1564.3,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1498.1
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": 1577.3,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1485.1
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-043-gpt-5.2-chat-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_a": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_b": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "winner": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1513.3,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1565.3
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1531.7,
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1546.9
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-044-gpt-5.2-chat-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1531.7,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1485.1
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": 1545.6,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1471.2
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-045-grok-4.20-multi-agent-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "model_a": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "model_b": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "winner": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "elo_before": {
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1546.9,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1471.2
+ },
+ "elo_after": {
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": 1559.5,
+ "gemini-3-flash": 1458.6
+ }
+ }
+ ],
+ "judge_tendencies": {
+ "per_judge": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 37.8,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 50.0,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 52.1,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 2.1,
+ "for_vote_pct": 2.2,
+ "against_vote_pct": 11.1,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 86.7,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 0,
+ "self_bias_rate": 0.0,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 60.0,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 52.8,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 78.0,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 25.2,
+ "for_vote_pct": 55.6,
+ "against_vote_pct": 44.4,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 0.0,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 7,
+ "self_bias_rate": 77.8,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 6.7,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 50.0,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 51.1,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 1.1,
+ "for_vote_pct": 4.4,
+ "against_vote_pct": 2.2,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 93.3,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 0,
+ "self_bias_rate": 0.0,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 35.6,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 65.0,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 69.4,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 4.4,
+ "for_vote_pct": 48.9,
+ "against_vote_pct": 51.1,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 0.0,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 7,
+ "self_bias_rate": 77.8,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 53.3,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 63.2,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 62.2,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": -1.0,
+ "for_vote_pct": 20.0,
+ "against_vote_pct": 11.1,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 68.9,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 3,
+ "self_bias_rate": 33.3,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "UNDECIDED",
+ "favored_self": false
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 60.0,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 58.5,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 67.2,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 8.7,
+ "for_vote_pct": 17.8,
+ "against_vote_pct": 28.9,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 53.3,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 0,
+ "self_bias_rate": 0.0,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 40.0,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 64.3,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 69.8,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 5.5,
+ "for_vote_pct": 48.9,
+ "against_vote_pct": 51.1,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 0.0,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 7,
+ "self_bias_rate": 77.8,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 57.8,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 74.8,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 82.0,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 7.2,
+ "for_vote_pct": 51.1,
+ "against_vote_pct": 48.9,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 0.0,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 6,
+ "self_bias_rate": 66.7,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "debate_against": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 37.8,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 69.8,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 72.6,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 2.8,
+ "for_vote_pct": 57.8,
+ "against_vote_pct": 42.2,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 0.0,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 7,
+ "self_bias_rate": 77.8,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "debate_against": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "FOR",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": true
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "total_judgments": 45,
+ "stance_flip_rate": 53.3,
+ "avg_confidence_initial": 78.0,
+ "avg_confidence_final": 87.6,
+ "avg_confidence_delta": 9.6,
+ "for_vote_pct": 53.3,
+ "against_vote_pct": 44.4,
+ "undecided_vote_pct": 2.2,
+ "self_judging": {
+ "total": 9,
+ "favored_self": 3,
+ "self_bias_rate": 33.3,
+ "votes": [
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "AGAINST",
+ "favored_self": true
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_for": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "debate_against": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "self_side": "AGAINST",
+ "voted": "FOR",
+ "favored_self": false
+ }
+ ]
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "cross_model_matrix": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ }
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 5,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 55.6
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 8,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 88.9
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ }
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ }
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 5,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 55.6
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 8,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 88.9
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ }
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 4,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 44.4
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ }
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 5,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 55.6
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ }
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 5,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 55.6
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 8,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 88.9
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ }
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 5,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 55.6
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 8,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 88.9
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ }
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 1,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 11.1
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 5,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 55.6
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ }
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "claude-opus-4.6": {
+ "favored": 6,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 66.7
+ },
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gemini-3-pro": {
+ "favored": 2,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 22.2
+ },
+ "gpt-5.4-high": {
+ "favored": 0,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 0.0
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": {
+ "favored": 5,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 55.6
+ },
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": {
+ "favored": 7,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 77.8
+ },
+ "gemini-3-flash": {
+ "favored": 3,
+ "total": 9,
+ "favor_rate": 33.3
+ }
+ }
+ }
+ },
+ "total_debates": 45,
+ "debates": [
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-001-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-claude-opus-4.6",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 20.0,
+ "delta_against": -30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 185,
+ "for_final": 322,
+ "against_initial": 281,
+ "against_final": 65
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 137,
+ "persuasion_against": -216,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 63,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -13,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 60,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 60,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -18,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 449.4,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-08T23:23:01Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-002-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 2,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 20.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 8,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 80.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 30.0,
+ "delta_against": -20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 327,
+ "for_final": 740,
+ "against_initial": 115,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 413,
+ "persuasion_against": -115,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 35,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 50,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 48,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 345.1,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-08T23:28:48Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-003-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-grok-4.20",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 5,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 50.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -10.0,
+ "delta_against": -20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 135,
+ "for_final": 65,
+ "against_initial": 533,
+ "against_final": 347
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -70,
+ "persuasion_against": -186,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 95,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -45,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 81,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -31,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 60,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 455.2,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T00:29:36Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-004-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 5,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 2,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 20.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 30.0,
+ "delta_against": -10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 143,
+ "for_final": 367,
+ "against_initial": 180,
+ "against_final": 115
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 224,
+ "persuasion_against": -65,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 47,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -8,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 789.4,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T00:42:47Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-005-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 8,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 80.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 30.0,
+ "delta_against": 0.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 357,
+ "for_final": 764,
+ "against_initial": 60,
+ "against_final": 50
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 407,
+ "persuasion_against": -10,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 55,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 35,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 49,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 35,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 16,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 342.9,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T00:48:32Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-006-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 5,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 7,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 70.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 50.0,
+ "delta_against": -30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 135,
+ "for_final": 466,
+ "against_initial": 215,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 331,
+ "persuasion_against": -215,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 7,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -13,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 80,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 356.0,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T00:54:30Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-007-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 7,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 70.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 20.0,
+ "delta_against": -30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 317,
+ "for_final": 497,
+ "against_initial": 197,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 180,
+ "persuasion_against": -197,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 78,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 16,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 55,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -12,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 7,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 12,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 286.6,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T00:59:19Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-008-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 8,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 80.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -10.0,
+ "delta_against": 10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 75,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 482,
+ "against_final": 582
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -75,
+ "persuasion_against": 100,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 40,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 80,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 80,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 466.2,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:07:07Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-009-claude-opus-4.6-thinking-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 30.0,
+ "delta_against": -40.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 220,
+ "for_final": 409,
+ "against_initial": 248,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 189,
+ "persuasion_against": -248,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 37,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 68,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -18,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 60,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -13,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 242.5,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:11:12Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-010-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 4,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 5,
+ "pct_for": 40.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 7,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 70.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 30.0,
+ "delta_against": -10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 278,
+ "for_final": 655,
+ "against_initial": 60,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 377,
+ "persuasion_against": -60,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 53,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 58,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 39,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 245.8,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:15:20Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-011-claude-opus-4.6-vs-grok-4.20",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 5,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 4,
+ "against": 2,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 40.0,
+ "pct_against": 20.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 30.0,
+ "delta_against": -20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 75,
+ "for_final": 284,
+ "against_initial": 245,
+ "against_final": 140
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 209,
+ "persuasion_against": -105,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 7,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 433.9,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:22:35Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-012-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 7,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 70.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 40.0,
+ "delta_against": -40.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 187,
+ "for_final": 634,
+ "against_initial": 255,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 447,
+ "persuasion_against": -255,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 33,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 47,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 92,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 17,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 80,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 368.9,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:28:46Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-013-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 8,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 80.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 8,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 80.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 70.0,
+ "delta_against": -80.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 75,
+ "for_final": 745,
+ "against_initial": 606,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 670,
+ "persuasion_against": -606,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 92,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 95,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 84,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 14,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 80,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 285.0,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:33:33Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-014-claude-opus-4.6-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -10.0,
+ "delta_against": 0.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 212,
+ "for_final": 134,
+ "against_initial": 230,
+ "against_final": 270
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -78,
+ "persuasion_against": 40,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 27,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 318.2,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:38:54Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-015-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 2,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 20.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 0.0,
+ "delta_against": 10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 368,
+ "for_final": 352,
+ "against_initial": 55,
+ "against_final": 132
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -16,
+ "persuasion_against": 77,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 60,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -6,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 363.6,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:44:59Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-016-claude-opus-4.6-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 5,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 6,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 60.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 135,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 200,
+ "against_final": 417
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -135,
+ "persuasion_against": 217,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -3,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 78,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 3,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 367.5,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:51:09Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-017-claude-opus-4.6-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "display_name": "Claude Opus 4.6"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 4,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 40.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 20.0,
+ "delta_against": -30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 262,
+ "for_final": 459,
+ "against_initial": 185,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 197,
+ "persuasion_against": -185,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 7,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 80,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 234.1,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T01:55:05Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-018-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-grok-4.20",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 8,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 80.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 135,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 545,
+ "against_final": 714
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -135,
+ "persuasion_against": 169,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 23,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 95,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 80,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 96,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 26,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 80,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 304.8,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T02:00:11Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-019-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 8,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 80.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -30.0,
+ "delta_against": 50.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 223,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 180,
+ "against_final": 534
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -223,
+ "persuasion_against": 354,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 27,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 45,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -6,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 60,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 793.4,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T02:13:27Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-020-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 4,
+ "against": 2,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 40.0,
+ "pct_against": 20.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 430,
+ "for_final": 216,
+ "against_initial": 60,
+ "against_final": 120
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -214,
+ "persuasion_against": 60,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 42,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 74,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 24,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 55,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 55,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -23,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 45,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 365.5,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T02:19:34Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-021-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 6,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 60.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -30.0,
+ "delta_against": 20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 205,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 274,
+ "against_final": 506
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -205,
+ "persuasion_against": 232,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 88,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 46,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 64,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -14,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 28,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 335.5,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T02:25:12Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-022-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 4,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 40.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 6,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 60.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -40.0,
+ "delta_against": 30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 267,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 202,
+ "against_final": 456
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -267,
+ "persuasion_against": 254,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 78,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 16,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -12,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 88,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 13,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 528.2,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T02:34:02Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-023-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 8,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 80.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 135,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 539,
+ "against_final": 726
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -135,
+ "persuasion_against": 187,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 95,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 16,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 80,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 96,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 26,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 80,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 659.7,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T02:45:04Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-024-gemini-3.1-pro-preview-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 5,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 8,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 80.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 50.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 152,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 180,
+ "against_final": 675
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -152,
+ "persuasion_against": 495,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 47,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 50,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 96,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 46,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 92,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 250.6,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T02:49:16Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-025-grok-4.20-vs-gemini-3-pro",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 0.0,
+ "delta_against": -10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 405,
+ "for_final": 451,
+ "against_initial": 60,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 46,
+ "persuasion_against": -60,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 2,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 78,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -6,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 642.3,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:03:22Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-026-grok-4.20-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 8,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 80.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 50.0,
+ "delta_against": -20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 190,
+ "for_final": 697,
+ "against_initial": 200,
+ "against_final": 50
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 507,
+ "persuasion_against": -150,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 55,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 49,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 96,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 21,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 579.2,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:12:22Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-027-grok-4.20-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 10.0,
+ "delta_against": -10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 322,
+ "for_final": 422,
+ "against_initial": 65,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 100,
+ "persuasion_against": -65,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -3,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 78,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 13,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 445.4,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:19:49Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-028-grok-4.20-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 0.0,
+ "delta_against": -30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 135,
+ "for_final": 130,
+ "against_initial": 541,
+ "against_final": 292
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -5,
+ "persuasion_against": -249,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 95,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -45,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 79,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -29,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 397.3,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:26:28Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-029-grok-4.20-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 5,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 50.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 212,
+ "for_final": 75,
+ "against_initial": 180,
+ "against_final": 335
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -137,
+ "persuasion_against": 155,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 27,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 78,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -4,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 443.6,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:33:54Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-030-grok-4.20-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 10.0,
+ "delta_against": -10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 372,
+ "for_final": 416,
+ "against_initial": 60,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 44,
+ "persuasion_against": -60,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 2,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 178.0,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:36:54Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-031-gemini-3-pro-vs-gpt-5.4-high",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 5,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 50.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 10,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 0,
+ "pct_for": 100.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 80.0,
+ "delta_against": -50.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 135,
+ "for_final": 937,
+ "against_initial": 320,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 802,
+ "persuasion_against": -320,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 45,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 53,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 50,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 40,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 47,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 35,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 90,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 547.7,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:46:04Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-032-gemini-3-pro-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -30.0,
+ "delta_against": 40.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 192,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 197,
+ "against_final": 500
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -192,
+ "persuasion_against": 303,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 78,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 16,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -12,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 7,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 558.4,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:55:24Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-033-gemini-3-pro-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 0.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 130,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 549,
+ "against_final": 554
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -130,
+ "persuasion_against": 5,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 95,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -45,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 94,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 12,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 80,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 88,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 23,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 826.3,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:09:12Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-034-gemini-3-pro-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 2,
+ "undecided": 6,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 20.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -10.0,
+ "delta_against": 50.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 147,
+ "for_final": 75,
+ "against_initial": 135,
+ "against_final": 500
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -72,
+ "persuasion_against": 365,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 37,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 88,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 6,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 936.6,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:24:51Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-035-gemini-3-pro-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 6,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 60.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -60.0,
+ "delta_against": 50.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 402,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 65,
+ "against_final": 454
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -402,
+ "persuasion_against": 389,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 92,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 17,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 687.1,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:53:45Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-036-gpt-5.4-high-vs-grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -30.0,
+ "delta_against": 30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 195,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 260,
+ "against_final": 639
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -195,
+ "persuasion_against": 379,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 97,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 55,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 49,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 30,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 28,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 407.0,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T03:49:05Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-037-gpt-5.4-high-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 4,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 40.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -40.0,
+ "delta_against": 40.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 257,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 185,
+ "against_final": 569
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -257,
+ "persuasion_against": 384,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 49,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 98,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 28,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 351.4,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:03:29Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-038-gpt-5.4-high-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 9,
+ "undecided": 1,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 90.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -10.0,
+ "delta_against": 20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 70,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 504,
+ "against_final": 821
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -70,
+ "persuasion_against": 317,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 49,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 27,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 17,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 29,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 350.8,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:03:28Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-039-gpt-5.4-high-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.4 (High)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "AGAINST",
+ "winner_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 0,
+ "against": 8,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 0.0,
+ "pct_against": 80.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": -20.0,
+ "delta_against": 40.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 150,
+ "for_final": 0,
+ "against_initial": 248,
+ "against_final": 678
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": -150,
+ "persuasion_against": 430,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 95,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 60,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 68,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 31,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 99,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 14,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 100,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 25,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 262.4,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:02:00Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-040-grok-4.20-reasoning-vs-gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 0.0,
+ "delta_against": -10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 409,
+ "for_final": 412,
+ "against_initial": 65,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 3,
+ "persuasion_against": -65,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -3,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 68,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -14,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 226.9,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:07:16Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-041-grok-4.20-reasoning-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 4,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 40.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 20.0,
+ "delta_against": -30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 195,
+ "for_final": 341,
+ "against_initial": 271,
+ "against_final": 65
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 146,
+ "persuasion_against": -206,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 42,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -15,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 61,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -11,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 55,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 7,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 70,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 2,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -5,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 642.2,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:14:11Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-042-grok-4.20-reasoning-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 4,
+ "against": 2,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 40.0,
+ "pct_against": 20.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 20.0,
+ "delta_against": -20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 237,
+ "for_final": 447,
+ "against_initial": 130,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 210,
+ "persuasion_against": -130,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 20,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 10,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 571.6,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:13:00Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-043-gpt-5.2-chat-vs-grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "motion": "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 1,
+ "against": 7,
+ "undecided": 2,
+ "pct_for": 10.0,
+ "pct_against": 70.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 2,
+ "against": 5,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 20.0,
+ "pct_against": 50.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 10.0,
+ "delta_against": -20.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 75,
+ "for_final": 120,
+ "against_initial": 516,
+ "against_final": 389
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 45,
+ "persuasion_against": -127,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 72,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 84,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 1,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 82,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 7,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 55,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -30,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 360.1,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:20:11Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-044-gpt-5.2-chat-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "display_name": "GPT-5.2 Chat"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 3,
+ "against": 3,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 30.0,
+ "pct_against": 30.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 6,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 60.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 30.0,
+ "delta_against": -30.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 215,
+ "for_final": 413,
+ "against_initial": 180,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 198,
+ "persuasion_against": -180,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 35,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 37,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -25,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 64,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -14,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": -3,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 74,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -1,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 75,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 75,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 295.0,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:19:06Z"
+ }
+ },
+ {
+ "debate_id": "debate-045-grok-4.20-multi-agent-vs-gemini-3-flash",
+ "motion": "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+ "model_for": {
+ "id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "display_name": "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent"
+ },
+ "model_against": {
+ "id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "display_name": "Gemini 3 Flash"
+ },
+ "score": {
+ "winner_side": "FOR",
+ "winner_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "initial": {
+ "for": 5,
+ "against": 1,
+ "undecided": 4,
+ "pct_for": 50.0,
+ "pct_against": 10.0
+ },
+ "final": {
+ "for": 7,
+ "against": 0,
+ "undecided": 3,
+ "pct_for": 70.0,
+ "pct_against": 0.0
+ },
+ "delta_for": 20.0,
+ "delta_against": -10.0,
+ "confidence": {
+ "for_initial": 359,
+ "for_final": 504,
+ "against_initial": 60,
+ "against_final": 0
+ },
+ "persuasion_for": 145,
+ "persuasion_against": -60,
+ "vote_details": [
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ "persona": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "claude-opus-4.6",
+ "persona": "Philosophy professor",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 62,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 62,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ "persona": "Neutral academic",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20",
+ "persona": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-pro",
+ "persona": "Environmental activist",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 35,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.4-high",
+ "persona": "Corporate executive",
+ "initial_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "initial_confidence": 50,
+ "final_stance": "UNDECIDED",
+ "final_confidence": 50,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ "persona": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "initial_stance": "AGAINST",
+ "initial_confidence": 60,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 65,
+ "stance_changed": true,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ "persona": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 82,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 72,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": -10,
+ "is_self_judging": false,
+ "self_judging_side": null
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ "persona": "Union labor representative",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 65,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 70,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 5,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "FOR"
+ },
+ {
+ "judge_model_id": "gemini-3-flash",
+ "persona": "Data scientist and AI researcher",
+ "initial_stance": "FOR",
+ "initial_confidence": 85,
+ "final_stance": "FOR",
+ "final_confidence": 85,
+ "stance_changed": false,
+ "confidence_delta": 0,
+ "is_self_judging": true,
+ "self_judging_side": "AGAINST"
+ }
+ ]
+ },
+ "metadata": {
+ "elapsed_seconds": 470.6,
+ "timestamp": "2026-04-09T04:22:02Z"
+ }
+ }
+ ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/web/src/lib/benchmark-data.ts b/web/src/lib/benchmark-data.ts
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..a85780e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/lib/benchmark-data.ts
@@ -0,0 +1,99 @@
+// AIΒ² Benchmark β Data Loading Layer
+// Loads pre-computed benchmark results from JSON files
+
+import { BenchmarkData, LeaderboardEntry, JudgeTendencies, DebateSummary } from "./types";
+import { MODELS } from "./models";
+
+// This will be populated from the benchmark results
+// For now, we use placeholder data that gets overwritten when results are available
+let _benchmarkData: BenchmarkData | null = null;
+
+export function getBenchmarkData(): BenchmarkData {
+ if (_benchmarkData) return _benchmarkData;
+
+ try {
+ // Load from the pre-built JSON file
+ // eslint-disable-next-line @typescript-eslint/no-require-imports
+ const raw = require("@/data/benchmark-results.json");
+ // If the file has data, use it; otherwise fall back to placeholder
+ if (raw && raw.leaderboard && raw.leaderboard.length > 0) {
+ _benchmarkData = raw as BenchmarkData;
+ return _benchmarkData;
+ }
+ return getPlaceholderData();
+ } catch {
+ // Return placeholder data
+ return getPlaceholderData();
+ }
+}
+
+function getPlaceholderData(): BenchmarkData {
+ // Generate placeholder leaderboard based on arena scores
+ const leaderboard: LeaderboardEntry[] = MODELS.map((m, i) => ({
+ rank: i + 1,
+ model_id: m.id,
+ display_name: m.display_name,
+ provider: m.provider,
+ elo: 1500 + (MODELS.length - i) * 8, // Spread around 1500
+ arena_score: m.arena_score,
+ })).sort((a, b) => b.elo - a.elo);
+
+ leaderboard.forEach((e, i) => (e.rank = i + 1));
+
+ return {
+ leaderboard,
+ elo_history: [],
+ judge_tendencies: {
+ per_judge: {},
+ cross_model_matrix: {},
+ },
+ total_debates: 0,
+ debates: [],
+ };
+}
+
+export function getLeaderboard(): LeaderboardEntry[] {
+ return getBenchmarkData().leaderboard;
+}
+
+export function getJudgeTendencies(): JudgeTendencies {
+ return getBenchmarkData().judge_tendencies;
+}
+
+export function getDebates(): DebateSummary[] {
+ return getBenchmarkData().debates;
+}
+
+export function getModelStats(modelId: string) {
+ const data = getBenchmarkData();
+ const debates = data.debates.filter(
+ (d) => d.model_for.id === modelId || d.model_against.id === modelId
+ );
+
+ const wins = debates.filter((d) => d.score.winner_model_id === modelId).length;
+ const losses = debates.filter(
+ (d) => d.score.winner_model_id !== null && d.score.winner_model_id !== modelId
+ ).length;
+ const ties = debates.filter((d) => d.score.winner_side === "TIE").length;
+
+ // Average persuasion when this model debates
+ let totalPersuasion = 0;
+ let count = 0;
+ for (const d of debates) {
+ if (d.model_for.id === modelId) {
+ totalPersuasion += d.score.persuasion_for;
+ } else {
+ totalPersuasion += d.score.persuasion_against;
+ }
+ count++;
+ }
+
+ return {
+ wins,
+ losses,
+ ties,
+ total_debates: debates.length,
+ win_rate: debates.length > 0 ? Math.round((wins / debates.length) * 100) : 0,
+ avg_persuasion: count > 0 ? Math.round(totalPersuasion / count) : 0,
+ };
+}
diff --git a/web/src/lib/debate-engine.ts b/web/src/lib/debate-engine.ts
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..01aa868
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/lib/debate-engine.ts
@@ -0,0 +1,320 @@
+import { Model } from "./types";
+import { MODELS, PERSONA_MAP } from "./models";
+
+const OPENROUTER_API = "https://openrouter.ai/api/v1/chat/completions";
+
+interface ChatMessage {
+ role: string;
+ content: string;
+}
+
+export interface Vote {
+ stance: string;
+ confidence: number;
+ reasoning: string;
+ judge_model_id: string;
+ persona: string;
+}
+
+export interface TranscriptEntry {
+ phase: string;
+ speaker: string;
+ side: string;
+ content: string;
+ type?: string;
+}
+
+export interface DebateScore {
+ winner_side: string;
+ winner_model_id: string | null;
+ delta_for: number;
+ delta_against: number;
+ initial: { for: number; against: number; undecided: number };
+ final: { for: number; against: number; undecided: number };
+}
+
+export type DebateEvent =
+ | { type: "phase"; phase: string }
+ | { type: "transcript"; entry: TranscriptEntry }
+ | { type: "initial_votes"; votes: Vote[] }
+ | { type: "final_votes"; votes: Vote[] }
+ | { type: "score"; score: DebateScore }
+ | { type: "done" }
+ | { type: "error"; message: string };
+
+const PERSONA_DESCRIPTIONS: Record = {
+ "Risk-averse economist":
+ "You are a risk-averse economist who prioritizes economic stability and empirical evidence.",
+ "Philosophy professor":
+ "You are a philosophy professor valuing logical consistency, moral frameworks, and intellectual rigor.",
+ "Neutral academic":
+ "You are a neutral academic researcher who prizes objectivity and peer-reviewed evidence.",
+ "Contrarian thinker":
+ "You are a contrarian thinker who questions conventional wisdom and values original thinking.",
+ "Environmental activist":
+ "You are an environmental activist who prioritizes ecological sustainability and social justice.",
+ "Corporate executive":
+ "You are a corporate executive who values practical outcomes, scalability, and innovation.",
+ "Skeptical policymaker":
+ "You are a skeptical policymaker who demands concrete, evidence-backed policy proposals.",
+ "Optimistic technologist":
+ "You are an optimistic technologist who believes in technology's transformative power.",
+ "Union labor representative":
+ "You are a union labor representative who prioritizes workers' rights and fair wages.",
+ "Data scientist & AI researcher":
+ "You are a data scientist who values quantitative evidence and technical precision.",
+};
+
+async function chatCompletion(
+ apiKey: string,
+ modelId: string,
+ messages: ChatMessage[],
+ maxTokens: number,
+ config: Record = {},
+ responseFormat?: { type: string },
+ signal?: AbortSignal
+): Promise {
+ const payload: Record = {
+ model: modelId,
+ messages,
+ max_tokens: maxTokens,
+ temperature: 0.7,
+ ...config,
+ };
+
+ if (responseFormat) {
+ payload.response_format = responseFormat;
+ }
+
+ const resp = await fetch(OPENROUTER_API, {
+ method: "POST",
+ headers: {
+ "Content-Type": "application/json",
+ Authorization: `Bearer ${apiKey}`,
+ "HTTP-Referer": typeof window !== "undefined" ? window.location.origin : "",
+ },
+ body: JSON.stringify(payload),
+ signal,
+ });
+
+ if (!resp.ok) {
+ const err = await resp.json().catch(() => ({}));
+ throw new Error(
+ `API error ${resp.status}: ${err?.error?.message || JSON.stringify(err)}`
+ );
+ }
+
+ const data = await resp.json();
+ return data?.choices?.[0]?.message?.content || "";
+}
+
+export async function runDebate(
+ apiKey: string,
+ modelFor: Model,
+ modelAgainst: Model,
+ motion: string,
+ onEvent: (event: DebateEvent) => void,
+ signal?: AbortSignal
+): Promise {
+ const debaterSystemFor = `You are a world-class debater arguing FOR the motion: "${motion}". Be logical, precise, and persuasive. Do not reveal you are an AI.`;
+ const debaterSystemAgainst = `You are a world-class debater arguing AGAINST the motion: "${motion}". Be logical, precise, and persuasive. Do not reveal you are an AI.`;
+
+ const transcript: TranscriptEntry[] = [];
+
+ function formatTranscript() {
+ return transcript
+ .map((e) => `[${e.phase.toUpperCase()}] ${e.speaker} (${e.side}):\n${e.content}`)
+ .join("\n\n---\n\n");
+ }
+
+ function call(
+ modelOpenrouterId: string,
+ messages: ChatMessage[],
+ maxTokens: number,
+ modelConfig: Record = {},
+ responseFormat?: { type: string }
+ ) {
+ return chatCompletion(apiKey, modelOpenrouterId, messages, maxTokens, modelConfig, responseFormat, signal);
+ }
+
+ // PHASE 1: Initial votes (all 10 judges in parallel)
+ onEvent({ type: "phase", phase: "Collecting initial jury votes..." });
+
+ const initialVotes = await Promise.all(
+ MODELS.map(async (jm): Promise => {
+ const persona = PERSONA_MAP[jm.id] || "Neutral judge";
+ const desc = PERSONA_DESCRIPTIONS[persona] || persona;
+ try {
+ const resp = await call(
+ jm.openrouter_id,
+ [
+ {
+ role: "system",
+ content: `You are an independent judge. ${desc}\nMOTION: "${motion}"\nRespond with ONLY JSON: {"stance": "FOR" or "AGAINST" or "UNDECIDED", "confidence": 0-100, "reasoning": "brief"}`,
+ },
+ { role: "user", content: "Provide your initial stance on this motion." },
+ ],
+ 200,
+ jm.config,
+ { type: "json_object" }
+ );
+ const parsed = JSON.parse(resp || "{}");
+ return { stance: parsed.stance || "UNDECIDED", confidence: parsed.confidence || 50, reasoning: parsed.reasoning || "", judge_model_id: jm.id, persona };
+ } catch {
+ return { stance: "UNDECIDED", confidence: 50, reasoning: "Error", judge_model_id: jm.id, persona };
+ }
+ })
+ );
+ onEvent({ type: "initial_votes", votes: initialVotes });
+
+ // PHASE 2: Opening statements (parallel)
+ onEvent({ type: "phase", phase: "Opening Statements" });
+
+ const [openingFor, openingAgainst] = await Promise.all([
+ call(modelFor.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemFor },
+ { role: "user", content: "Deliver your opening statement. Define your framing, establish key claims, and preempt opposing arguments. Do not reference your opponent." },
+ ], 600, modelFor.config || {}),
+ call(modelAgainst.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemAgainst },
+ { role: "user", content: "Deliver your opening statement. Define your framing, establish key claims, and preempt opposing arguments. Do not reference your opponent." },
+ ], 600, modelAgainst.config || {}),
+ ]);
+
+ transcript.push({ phase: "opening", speaker: modelFor.display_name, side: "FOR", content: openingFor });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+ transcript.push({ phase: "opening", speaker: modelAgainst.display_name, side: "AGAINST", content: openingAgainst });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+
+ // PHASE 3: Rebuttals (sequential β each needs the other's opening)
+ onEvent({ type: "phase", phase: "Rebuttals" });
+
+ const rebuttalFor = await call(modelFor.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemFor },
+ { role: "user", content: `Your opponent's opening:\n\n${openingAgainst}\n\nDeliver your rebuttal. Reference their specific claims. Attack assumptions. Reframe the stakes.` },
+ ], 500, modelFor.config || {});
+ transcript.push({ phase: "rebuttal", speaker: modelFor.display_name, side: "FOR", content: rebuttalFor });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+
+ const rebuttalAgainst = await call(modelAgainst.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemAgainst },
+ { role: "user", content: `Your opponent's opening:\n\n${openingFor}\n\nDeliver your rebuttal. Reference their specific claims. Attack assumptions. Reframe the stakes.` },
+ ], 500, modelAgainst.config || {});
+ transcript.push({ phase: "rebuttal", speaker: modelAgainst.display_name, side: "AGAINST", content: rebuttalAgainst });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+
+ // PHASE 4: Cross-Examination (3 rounds, sequential Q&A)
+ for (let round = 1; round <= 3; round++) {
+ onEvent({ type: "phase", phase: `Cross-Examination (Round ${round}/3)` });
+ const tx = formatTranscript();
+
+ const qFor = await call(modelFor.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemFor },
+ { role: "user", content: `Transcript:\n${tx}\n\nAsk your opponent ONE pointed question targeting a weakness in their arguments.` },
+ ], 150, modelFor.config || {});
+ transcript.push({ phase: `cross_exam_r${round}`, speaker: modelFor.display_name, side: "FOR", content: qFor, type: "question" });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+
+ const aAgainst = await call(modelAgainst.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemAgainst },
+ { role: "user", content: `Question from opponent: ${qFor}\n\nAnswer directly. No dodging.` },
+ ], 300, modelAgainst.config || {});
+ transcript.push({ phase: `cross_exam_r${round}`, speaker: modelAgainst.display_name, side: "AGAINST", content: aAgainst, type: "answer" });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+
+ const qAgainst = await call(modelAgainst.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemAgainst },
+ { role: "user", content: `Transcript:\n${tx}\n\nAsk your opponent ONE pointed question targeting a weakness in their arguments.` },
+ ], 150, modelAgainst.config || {});
+ transcript.push({ phase: `cross_exam_r${round}`, speaker: modelAgainst.display_name, side: "AGAINST", content: qAgainst, type: "question" });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+
+ const aFor = await call(modelFor.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemFor },
+ { role: "user", content: `Question from opponent: ${qAgainst}\n\nAnswer directly. No dodging.` },
+ ], 300, modelFor.config || {});
+ transcript.push({ phase: `cross_exam_r${round}`, speaker: modelFor.display_name, side: "FOR", content: aFor, type: "answer" });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+ }
+
+ // PHASE 5: Closing statements (parallel)
+ onEvent({ type: "phase", phase: "Closing Statements" });
+ const tx = formatTranscript();
+
+ const [closingFor, closingAgainst] = await Promise.all([
+ call(modelFor.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemFor },
+ { role: "user", content: `Transcript:\n${tx}\n\nClosing statement. No new arguments. Compress strongest points. Address biggest objection. Target undecided judges.` },
+ ], 300, modelFor.config || {}),
+ call(modelAgainst.openrouter_id, [
+ { role: "system", content: debaterSystemAgainst },
+ { role: "user", content: `Transcript:\n${tx}\n\nClosing statement. No new arguments. Compress strongest points. Address biggest objection. Target undecided judges.` },
+ ], 300, modelAgainst.config || {}),
+ ]);
+
+ transcript.push({ phase: "closing", speaker: modelFor.display_name, side: "FOR", content: closingFor });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+ transcript.push({ phase: "closing", speaker: modelAgainst.display_name, side: "AGAINST", content: closingAgainst });
+ onEvent({ type: "transcript", entry: transcript[transcript.length - 1] });
+
+ // PHASE 6: Final votes (all 10 judges in parallel)
+ onEvent({ type: "phase", phase: "Collecting final jury votes..." });
+ const fullTx = formatTranscript();
+
+ const finalVotes = await Promise.all(
+ MODELS.map(async (jm): Promise => {
+ const persona = PERSONA_MAP[jm.id] || "Neutral judge";
+ const desc = PERSONA_DESCRIPTIONS[persona] || persona;
+ try {
+ const resp = await call(
+ jm.openrouter_id,
+ [
+ {
+ role: "system",
+ content: `You are an independent judge. ${desc}\nMOTION: "${motion}"\nEvaluate fairly based on argument quality. Respond with ONLY JSON.`,
+ },
+ {
+ role: "user",
+ content: `DEBATE TRANSCRIPT:\n${fullTx}\n\nProvide your final vote: {"stance": "FOR" or "AGAINST" or "UNDECIDED", "confidence": 0-100, "reasoning": "brief"}`,
+ },
+ ],
+ 300,
+ jm.config,
+ { type: "json_object" }
+ );
+ const parsed = JSON.parse(resp || "{}");
+ return { stance: parsed.stance || "UNDECIDED", confidence: parsed.confidence || 50, reasoning: parsed.reasoning || "", judge_model_id: jm.id, persona };
+ } catch {
+ return { stance: "UNDECIDED", confidence: 50, reasoning: "Error", judge_model_id: jm.id, persona };
+ }
+ })
+ );
+ onEvent({ type: "final_votes", votes: finalVotes });
+
+ // Compute score
+ const n = 10;
+ const initFor = initialVotes.filter((v) => v.stance === "FOR").length;
+ const initAgainst = initialVotes.filter((v) => v.stance === "AGAINST").length;
+ const finFor = finalVotes.filter((v) => v.stance === "FOR").length;
+ const finAgainst = finalVotes.filter((v) => v.stance === "AGAINST").length;
+
+ const deltaFor = ((finFor - initFor) / n) * 100;
+ const deltaAgainst = ((finAgainst - initAgainst) / n) * 100;
+
+ const winnerSide = deltaFor > deltaAgainst ? "FOR" : deltaAgainst > deltaFor ? "AGAINST" : "TIE";
+ const winnerModelId = winnerSide === "FOR" ? modelFor.id : winnerSide === "AGAINST" ? modelAgainst.id : null;
+
+ onEvent({
+ type: "score",
+ score: {
+ winner_side: winnerSide,
+ winner_model_id: winnerModelId,
+ delta_for: Math.round(deltaFor * 10) / 10,
+ delta_against: Math.round(deltaAgainst * 10) / 10,
+ initial: { for: initFor, against: initAgainst, undecided: n - initFor - initAgainst },
+ final: { for: finFor, against: finAgainst, undecided: n - finFor - finAgainst },
+ },
+ });
+
+ onEvent({ type: "done" });
+}
diff --git a/web/src/lib/models.ts b/web/src/lib/models.ts
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..3404c94
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/lib/models.ts
@@ -0,0 +1,145 @@
+// AIΒ² Benchmark β Model Definitions (mirrors benchmark/models.py)
+
+import { Model } from "./types";
+
+export const MODELS: Model[] = [
+ {
+ id: "claude-opus-4.6-thinking",
+ display_name: "Claude Opus 4.6 (Thinking)",
+ provider: "Anthropic",
+ openrouter_id: "anthropic/claude-opus-4.6",
+ config: { reasoning: { effort: "high" } },
+ arena_score: 1503,
+ pricing: { input: 5.0, output: 25.0 },
+ context_window: 1_000_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "claude-opus-4.6",
+ display_name: "Claude Opus 4.6",
+ provider: "Anthropic",
+ openrouter_id: "anthropic/claude-opus-4.6",
+ config: {},
+ arena_score: 1497,
+ pricing: { input: 5.0, output: 25.0 },
+ context_window: 1_000_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ display_name: "Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview",
+ provider: "Google",
+ openrouter_id: "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
+ config: {},
+ arena_score: 1493,
+ pricing: { input: 2.0, output: 12.0 },
+ context_window: 1_000_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "grok-4.20",
+ display_name: "Grok 4.20",
+ provider: "xAI",
+ openrouter_id: "x-ai/grok-4.20",
+ config: {},
+ arena_score: 1490,
+ pricing: { input: 2.0, output: 6.0 },
+ context_window: 2_000_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "gemini-3-pro",
+ display_name: "Gemini 3 Pro",
+ provider: "Google",
+ openrouter_id: "google/gemini-3-pro-image-preview",
+ config: {},
+ arena_score: 1486,
+ pricing: { input: 2.0, output: 12.0 },
+ context_window: 1_000_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "gpt-5.4-high",
+ display_name: "GPT-5.4 (High)",
+ provider: "OpenAI",
+ openrouter_id: "openai/gpt-5.4",
+ config: { reasoning: { effort: "high" } },
+ arena_score: 1484,
+ pricing: { input: 2.5, output: 15.0 },
+ context_window: 1_100_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "grok-4.20-reasoning",
+ display_name: "Grok 4.20 (Reasoning)",
+ provider: "xAI",
+ openrouter_id: "x-ai/grok-4.20",
+ config: { reasoning: { effort: "high" } },
+ arena_score: 1480,
+ pricing: { input: 2.0, output: 6.0 },
+ context_window: 2_000_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "gpt-5.2-chat",
+ display_name: "GPT-5.2 Chat",
+ provider: "OpenAI",
+ openrouter_id: "openai/gpt-5.2-chat",
+ config: {},
+ arena_score: 1477,
+ pricing: { input: 1.75, output: 14.0 },
+ context_window: 128_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ display_name: "Grok 4.20 Multi-Agent",
+ provider: "xAI",
+ openrouter_id: "x-ai/grok-4.20-multi-agent",
+ config: {},
+ arena_score: 1475,
+ pricing: { input: 2.0, output: 6.0 },
+ context_window: 2_000_000,
+ },
+ {
+ id: "gemini-3-flash",
+ display_name: "Gemini 3 Flash",
+ provider: "Google",
+ openrouter_id: "google/gemini-3-flash-preview",
+ config: {},
+ arena_score: 1474,
+ pricing: { input: 0.5, output: 3.0 },
+ context_window: 1_000_000,
+ },
+];
+
+export const PERSONA_MAP: Record = {
+ "claude-opus-4.6-thinking": "Risk-averse economist",
+ "claude-opus-4.6": "Philosophy professor",
+ "gemini-3.1-pro-preview": "Neutral academic",
+ "grok-4.20": "Contrarian thinker",
+ "gemini-3-pro": "Environmental activist",
+ "gpt-5.4-high": "Corporate executive",
+ "grok-4.20-reasoning": "Skeptical policymaker",
+ "gpt-5.2-chat": "Optimistic technologist",
+ "grok-4.20-multi-agent": "Union labor representative",
+ "gemini-3-flash": "Data scientist & AI researcher",
+};
+
+export const PROVIDER_COLORS: Record = {
+ Anthropic: "#D97706", // amber
+ Google: "#2563EB", // blue
+ xAI: "#A855F7", // purple
+ OpenAI: "#10B981", // green
+};
+
+export const PROVIDER_ICONS: Record = {
+ Anthropic: "/images/icon-anthropic.png",
+ Google: "/images/icon-google.png",
+ xAI: "/images/icon-xai.png",
+ OpenAI: "/images/icon-openai.png",
+};
+
+export function getModelById(id: string): Model | undefined {
+ return MODELS.find((m) => m.id === id);
+}
+
+export const DEBATE_TOPICS = [
+ "This house believes AI will eliminate more jobs than it creates within the next decade.",
+ "This house believes social media does more harm than good to democratic societies.",
+ "This house believes space colonization should be humanity's top funding priority over climate change.",
+ "This house believes universal basic income is both inevitable and desirable.",
+ "This house believes open-source AI models are more beneficial to humanity than proprietary ones.",
+];
diff --git a/web/src/lib/types.ts b/web/src/lib/types.ts
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..1f41164
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/lib/types.ts
@@ -0,0 +1,171 @@
+// AIΒ² Benchmark β TypeScript Types
+
+export interface Model {
+ id: string;
+ display_name: string;
+ provider: string;
+ openrouter_id: string;
+ config: Record;
+ arena_score: number;
+ pricing: { input: number; output: number };
+ context_window: number;
+}
+
+export interface Vote {
+ stance: "FOR" | "AGAINST" | "UNDECIDED";
+ confidence: number;
+ reasoning: string;
+ judge_model_id: string;
+ persona: string;
+ error?: boolean;
+ parse_fallback?: boolean;
+}
+
+export interface VoteDetail {
+ judge_model_id: string;
+ persona: string;
+ initial_stance: string;
+ initial_confidence: number;
+ final_stance: string;
+ final_confidence: number;
+ stance_changed: boolean;
+ confidence_delta: number;
+ is_self_judging: boolean;
+ self_judging_side: string | null;
+}
+
+export interface DebateScore {
+ winner_side: "FOR" | "AGAINST" | "TIE";
+ winner_model_id: string | null;
+ initial: {
+ for: number;
+ against: number;
+ undecided: number;
+ pct_for: number;
+ pct_against: number;
+ };
+ final: {
+ for: number;
+ against: number;
+ undecided: number;
+ pct_for: number;
+ pct_against: number;
+ };
+ delta_for: number;
+ delta_against: number;
+ confidence: {
+ for_initial: number;
+ for_final: number;
+ against_initial: number;
+ against_final: number;
+ };
+ persuasion_for: number;
+ persuasion_against: number;
+ vote_details: VoteDetail[];
+}
+
+export interface TranscriptEntry {
+ phase: string;
+ speaker: string;
+ side: "FOR" | "AGAINST";
+ content: string;
+ type?: "question" | "answer" | "answers";
+}
+
+export interface DebateResult {
+ debate_id: string;
+ motion: string;
+ model_for: { id: string; display_name: string };
+ model_against: { id: string; display_name: string };
+ transcript: TranscriptEntry[];
+ initial_votes: Vote[];
+ final_votes: Vote[];
+ audience_questions: Array<{ question: string; judge_model_id: string; persona: string }>;
+ score: DebateScore;
+ metadata: {
+ elapsed_seconds: number;
+ timestamp: string;
+ };
+}
+
+export interface LeaderboardEntry {
+ rank: number;
+ model_id: string;
+ display_name: string;
+ provider: string;
+ elo: number;
+ arena_score: number;
+}
+
+export interface EloHistoryEntry {
+ debate_id: string;
+ model_a: string;
+ model_b: string;
+ winner: string | null;
+ elo_before: Record;
+ elo_after: Record;
+}
+
+export interface JudgeSelfJudging {
+ total: number;
+ favored_self: number;
+ self_bias_rate: number;
+ votes: Array<{
+ debate_for: string;
+ debate_against: string;
+ self_side: string;
+ voted: string;
+ favored_self: boolean;
+ }>;
+}
+
+export interface JudgeStats {
+ total_judgments: number;
+ stance_flip_rate: number;
+ avg_confidence_initial: number;
+ avg_confidence_final: number;
+ avg_confidence_delta: number;
+ for_vote_pct: number;
+ against_vote_pct: number;
+ undecided_vote_pct: number;
+ self_judging: JudgeSelfJudging;
+}
+
+export interface CrossModelEntry {
+ favored: number;
+ total: number;
+ favor_rate: number;
+}
+
+export interface JudgeTendencies {
+ per_judge: Record;
+ cross_model_matrix: Record>;
+}
+
+export interface DebateSummary {
+ debate_id: string;
+ motion: string;
+ model_for: { id: string; display_name: string };
+ model_against: { id: string; display_name: string };
+ score: DebateScore;
+ metadata: { elapsed_seconds: number; timestamp: string };
+}
+
+export interface BenchmarkData {
+ leaderboard: LeaderboardEntry[];
+ elo_history: EloHistoryEntry[];
+ judge_tendencies: JudgeTendencies;
+ total_debates: number;
+ debates: DebateSummary[];
+}
+
+// Live debate arena types
+export interface DebatePhaseEvent {
+ phase: string;
+ speaker?: string;
+ side?: "FOR" | "AGAINST";
+ content?: string;
+ votes?: Vote[];
+ score?: DebateScore;
+ type?: string;
+}
diff --git a/web/src/lib/utils.ts b/web/src/lib/utils.ts
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..bd0c391
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/src/lib/utils.ts
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+import { clsx, type ClassValue } from "clsx"
+import { twMerge } from "tailwind-merge"
+
+export function cn(...inputs: ClassValue[]) {
+ return twMerge(clsx(inputs))
+}
diff --git a/web/tsconfig.json b/web/tsconfig.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..cf9c65d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/web/tsconfig.json
@@ -0,0 +1,34 @@
+{
+ "compilerOptions": {
+ "target": "ES2017",
+ "lib": ["dom", "dom.iterable", "esnext"],
+ "allowJs": true,
+ "skipLibCheck": true,
+ "strict": true,
+ "noEmit": true,
+ "esModuleInterop": true,
+ "module": "esnext",
+ "moduleResolution": "bundler",
+ "resolveJsonModule": true,
+ "isolatedModules": true,
+ "jsx": "react-jsx",
+ "incremental": true,
+ "plugins": [
+ {
+ "name": "next"
+ }
+ ],
+ "paths": {
+ "@/*": ["./src/*"]
+ }
+ },
+ "include": [
+ "next-env.d.ts",
+ "**/*.ts",
+ "**/*.tsx",
+ ".next/types/**/*.ts",
+ ".next/dev/types/**/*.ts",
+ "**/*.mts"
+ ],
+ "exclude": ["node_modules"]
+}