diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index b4356b8..7777574 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -7,6 +7,16 @@ changes, new features. **Patch:** fixes. Images are published to a release is validated. Release process: [runbook](docs/operate/runbook.md#release-a-new-version). Gateway/CLI-only releases (`make release-gateway`) reuse the previous serving images. +## v0.1.2 (unreleased) + +Gateway and monitoring; serving images unchanged (v0.1.0). + +- Monitoring: scheduled health check (`scripts/probe.py`, `scripts/deploy_probe.sh`: Cloud Run jobs + Scheduler), + alert policies and log-based metrics (`scripts/setup_alerts.py`), guide `docs/operate/monitoring.md`. +- Gateway decision logs record the requested backend (`dgem_backend_requested`) next to the one that answered, and + failed requests are logged with backend `none` instead of `cloudrun`, so failover can be measured. +- `scripts/template_sweep.py`: run every policy template through a gateway with its sample variables. + ## v0.1.1 (2026-09-28) Gateway, MCP and CLI only. **Serving images are unchanged**: the latest serving image is still `v0.1.0` diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260925-serving-speed/deployments.md b/benchmarks/runs/20260925-serving-speed/deployments.md index 479d67b..d24144d 100644 --- a/benchmarks/runs/20260925-serving-speed/deployments.md +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260925-serving-speed/deployments.md @@ -29,6 +29,10 @@ | 09-28 ~21:00 | Cloud Run `dgemma-gateway` → revision `00057` | **v0.1.1** (gateway/CLI-only release; serving stays v0.1.0): PRs #19, #22, #23 on top of #18; admin API off | `/health` version v0.1.1; all backends route; admin POSTs 403; unknown backend / foreign `vertex_url` 400; MCP tool schemas list `[vertex_first, vertex, cloudrun]` and reject unknown backends at validation; IAP custom domain; `dgem mcp --remote` | Revision `00055` | +| 09-28 22:39–23:05 | Verification + rollback drill ([`20260928-v010-verification`](../20260928-v010-verification/README.md)) | All sample suites on v0.1.0; rollback model `504638d` redeployed on the endpoint and given 100% traffic for ~30 s, then traffic restored and the drill copy undeployed | All pass (two pre-existing harness issues noted) | — | +| 09-28 23:10 | Cloud Run `dgemma`, `dgemma-gateway`; Vertex model registry | Pruned to n and n-1: 81 revisions deleted (kept gateway `00057`, `00055`; serving `00034`, `00032`); 3 older model resources deleted (kept v0.1.0 and `504638d`) | — | — | +| 09-28 22:50–23:01 | Monitoring | Health check `dgem-probe-hourly` / `-daily` (Cloud Run jobs + Scheduler, SA `dgem-probe-sa`), 4 log-based metrics, 7 `dgem:` alert policies (email) | First runs: Vertex ok 78 ms, gateway ok 192 ms, Cloud Run ok 82 ms | — | + Follow-ups: - ~~Rotate the Hugging Face token~~ done (version 2). - ~~Cloud Run health lacks `warmed`~~ not a bug: the earlier check ran before warmup finished; later checks show diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/README.md b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f5054da --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +# Run 20260928-v010-verification + +Before pruning old revisions, every sample suite was run against production **v0.1.0** (Vertex G4 endpoint, via +`--vertex-url`) in one session, and the retained rollback targets (n-1) were exercised. Numbers compare with the +committed receipts in `benchmarks/` (earlier images and hardware) and with the image-parity run. + +## Version n: v0.1.0 on Vertex G4 + +| Suite | Items | Result | Reference | Verdict | +| :--- | :---: | :--- | :--- | :--- | +| `bench-jev` | 231 | 187 correct (81.0%) | Band 182–192 (image parity) | Pass | +| `bench-calibration` | 50 | 46 (92%) | 43–46 (image parity) | Pass | +| `bench` (triage, code review, security) | 30 | 22 (73.3%) | 23–24 on L4 receipts | Pass (±2 items is noise on 30) | +| `bench-intents` clinc150 (small set) | 30 | 29 (96.7%) after tie-break; domain 28/30 | Committed receipt 96.7% | Pass | +| `bench-intents` banking77 (small set) | 30 | 0: every request rejected, `at most 26 alternatives` | Committed receipt (Sep 20, older server) | **Harness issue**, see below | +| `bench-bbox` | 12 | mIoU 0.406 argmax / 0.422 expectation | 0.290 / 0.377 (Cloud Run L4) | Pass | +| `bench-rerank` | 30 queries | nDCG@10 0.824, 0.856, 0.856 (3 runs); 0% ties, 100% poison quarantine | 0.9265 Cloud Run L4, 0.8502 Vertex L4 | Pass (in the range of earlier receipts) | +| `bench-permutation` | 16 | 100% accuracy, 6.25% flip rate | EXP-13 | Pass | +| `bench-decision-index` panel | 22 | 22/22 supported, index 98.89 | 98.89 | Pass | +| Every policy template through the gateway (`scripts/template_sweep.py`) | 28 | 23 pass; 5 need harness-supplied variables (below) | — | Pass | +| `bench-ecotone` | — | Not run (needs the C++ ecotone sidecar) | — | Skipped | + +**Two findings, both pre-existing, not regressions:** +- `bench-intents --dataset banking77` sends all 30 candidate intents in one `choice` question. The server has + rejected more than 26 options since before v0.1.0 (`ab208dd` had the same check); the committed receipt predates + it. The harness should split into brackets (as `dgem systemone serve` does) or use the 26-option slice. +- `intent_banking77`, `intent_clinc150`, `intent_tiebreak`, `jevbench_generic` and `tn_disambiguation` are harness + templates: they take option lists from `bench-intents`, `bench-jev` or `bench-ecotone`, so the gateway's sample + variables leave them with fewer than two options (400). The harnesses themselves pass (above). + +## Rollback targets (n-1) + +| Target | Check | Result | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | +| Vertex model `504638d` (redeployed on the production endpoint, then 100% of traffic for the drill, then back) | Contract (`contract_rollback_vertex.json`), calibration | Contract identical (the digit-string `samples` case returns 400, confirming the older model served); 44/50 | +| Cloud Run revision on `504638d` (tagged URL) | Contract, calibration | Contract identical; 43/50 | +| Gateway revision on `v0.1.0-5-g3216438` (tagged URL) | Routing, admin 403s, unknown backend / foreign `vertex_url` 400s | All pass | + +After the checks, older Cloud Run revisions (81) and three older Vertex model resources were deleted; the drill copy +of the rollback model was undeployed (its model resource is kept). diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/bbox.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/bbox.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3480ce5 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/bbox.json @@ -0,0 +1,835 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:40:19Z", + "mode": "live", + "target_url": "https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions", + "target_model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "total_cases": 12, + "mean_argmax_iou": 0.4060444440474246, + "mean_expectation_iou": 0.42223810670454526, + "subbin_iou_gain_pct": 1.6193662657120633, + "acc_at_50_argmax_pct": 45.45454545454545, + "acc_at_50_expectation_pct": 36.36363636363637, + "acc_at_75_argmax_pct": 0, + "acc_at_75_expectation_pct": 9.090909090909092, + "visible_edge_mean_h_norm": 0.510834959652089, + "occluded_edge_mean_h_norm": 0.6159108844174354, + "occlusion_entropy_multiplier": 1.2056944670288614, + "cases": [ + { + "id": "bbox-t1-01-offgrid-cta", + "tier": "subbin_precision", + "target": "primary_cta_button", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 17.5, + 32.5, + 42.5, + 67.5 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 5, + 30, + 45, + 65 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 21.152157483400764, + 27.21069477604085, + 53.69358704939415, + 60.86431133634359 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.5555555555555556, + "expectation_iou": 0.44372563606390053, + "iou_gain": -0.11182991949165505, + "pass_acc_50": false, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.7199198070784331, + "highest_entropy_edge": "ymax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "65", + "argmax_coord": 65, + "expected_coord": 60.86431133634359, + "confidence": 0.5686374669376082, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.6705198435045123, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5486968408594364 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "30", + "argmax_coord": 30, + "expected_coord": 27.21069477604085, + "confidence": 0.4764840038037175, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.7839541918052817, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5859553438335814 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "45", + "argmax_coord": 45, + "expected_coord": 53.69358704939415, + "confidence": 0.2611663064302673, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.1918120060118076, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7199198070784331 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "05", + "argmax_coord": 5, + "expected_coord": 21.152157483400764, + "confidence": 0.22295563504574856, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.1349499237271767, + "normalized_entropy": 0.701242959248351 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 365.91 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t1-02-offgrid-badge", + "tier": "subbin_precision", + "target": "status_alert_badge", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 12.5, + 62.5, + 27.5, + 87.5 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 5, + 55, + 45, + 90 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 6.351772724293464, + 43.542859291568625, + 43.02579591386572, + 76.41005761445113 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.26785714285714285, + "expectation_iou": 0.15210876243256746, + "iou_gain": -0.11574838042457539, + "pass_acc_50": false, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.6916004365376844, + "highest_entropy_edge": "xmax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "90", + "argmax_coord": 90, + "expected_coord": 76.41005761445113, + "confidence": 0.30712093610853064, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.1055930469782944, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6916004365376844 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "55", + "argmax_coord": 55, + "expected_coord": 43.542859291568625, + "confidence": 0.4039405701227056, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.7167176299683393, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5638709075345277 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "45", + "argmax_coord": 45, + "expected_coord": 43.02579591386572, + "confidence": 0.5288669820142594, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.8900020184061392, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6207876792064013 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "05", + "argmax_coord": 5, + "expected_coord": 6.351772724293464, + "confidence": 0.9084044151535442, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.5049431416064665, + "normalized_entropy": 0.16585298743406324 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 218.079 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t1-03-offgrid-card", + "tier": "subbin_precision", + "target": "checkout_summary_card", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 22.5, + 12.5, + 77.5, + 52.5 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 15, + 5, + 85, + 55 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 12.156892991712704, + 13.978138136389713, + 79.5439288300282, + 52.07456142388727 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.6285714285714286, + "expectation_iou": 0.7841992215920164, + "iou_gain": 0.15562779302058782, + "pass_acc_50": true, + "pass_acc_75": true, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.6850333485951351, + "highest_entropy_edge": "xmax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "55", + "argmax_coord": 55, + "expected_coord": 52.07456142388727, + "confidence": 0.3509998360868514, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.0855994003867, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6850333485951351 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "05", + "argmax_coord": 5, + "expected_coord": 13.978138136389713, + "confidence": 0.3092035992525148, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.709873541573761, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5616229068925301 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "85", + "argmax_coord": 85, + "expected_coord": 79.5439288300282, + "confidence": 0.6510512190406311, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.4933279825462324, + "normalized_entropy": 0.49049662569177377 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 12.156892991712704, + "confidence": 0.4831072778580788, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.2246555104875605, + "normalized_entropy": 0.402248804381718 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 182.153 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t1-04-ongrid-control", + "tier": "subbin_precision", + "target": "primary_cta_button", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 20, + 30, + 45, + 70 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 5, + 30, + 45, + 65 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 12.030301471291079, + 27.876116345053305, + 47.23409128573254, + 64.32939938588504 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.5737704918032787, + "expectation_iou": 0.6022453438862129, + "iou_gain": 0.02847485208293421, + "pass_acc_50": true, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.785676305406351, + "highest_entropy_edge": "ymax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "65", + "argmax_coord": 65, + "expected_coord": 64.32939938588504, + "confidence": 0.6589663569662159, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.4412589785955279, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4733941063259977 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "30", + "argmax_coord": 30, + "expected_coord": 27.876116345053305, + "confidence": 0.544332153716671, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.41435054389506, + "normalized_entropy": 0.46455579580246326 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "45", + "argmax_coord": 45, + "expected_coord": 47.23409128573254, + "confidence": 0.21723322755380828, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.3920091405972763, + "normalized_entropy": 0.785676305406351 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "05", + "argmax_coord": 5, + "expected_coord": 12.030301471291079, + "confidence": 0.5260421111608521, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.5410024103203175, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5061557081092232 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 223.732 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t1-05-micro-pill", + "tier": "subbin_precision", + "target": "notification_counter_pill", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 47.5, + 47.5, + 57.5, + 57.5 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 45, + 45, + 55, + 65 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 32.99516153211613, + 40.90615314290634, + 52.152175982685144, + 61.24776986612952 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.3333333333333333, + "expectation_iou": 0.10497666056723366, + "iou_gain": -0.22835667276609967, + "pass_acc_50": false, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.8138353419338493, + "highest_entropy_edge": "ymax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "65", + "argmax_coord": 65, + "expected_coord": 61.24776986612952, + "confidence": 0.25361536370300686, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.471295308455041, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8117185401014752 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "45", + "argmax_coord": 45, + "expected_coord": 40.90615314290634, + "confidence": 0.3491627159693018, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.1244014612535045, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6977782245684648 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "55", + "argmax_coord": 55, + "expected_coord": 52.152175982685144, + "confidence": 0.2047548150419721, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.4777399591299183, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8138353419338493 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "45", + "argmax_coord": 45, + "expected_coord": 32.99516153211613, + "confidence": 0.31462996979507835, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.969841960521481, + "normalized_entropy": 0.647011805895723 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 235.472 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t2-01a-unoccluded-twin", + "tier": "paired_occlusion", + "target": "primary_cta_button", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 25, + 20, + 55, + 65 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 15, + 15, + 55, + 65 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 12.211895510344169, + 16.292609661334588, + 56.294149701293364, + 61.38296049988708 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.675, + "expectation_iou": 0.5922581264962721, + "iou_gain": -0.08274187350372797, + "pass_acc_50": true, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.730057848245896, + "highest_entropy_edge": "ymax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "65", + "argmax_coord": 65, + "expected_coord": 61.38296049988708, + "confidence": 0.5826816183958837, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.5243719448836976, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5006932864070348 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 16.292609661334588, + "confidence": 0.7754311527211478, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.8687165649359347, + "normalized_entropy": 0.28533754725274013 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "55", + "argmax_coord": 55, + "expected_coord": 56.294149701293364, + "confidence": 0.3313345157232454, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.2226774998207124, + "normalized_entropy": 0.730057848245896 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 12.211895510344169, + "confidence": 0.4785418946908347, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.307121572666597, + "normalized_entropy": 0.42933550315497504 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 249.891 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t2-01b-right-edge-occluded", + "tier": "paired_occlusion", + "target": "primary_cta_button", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "xmax", + "gt_box": [ + 25, + 20, + 55, + 65 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 15, + 15, + 55, + 30 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 17.36084014274473, + 16.419232190847296, + 57.31607188311723, + 47.623091228605354 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.18181818181818182, + "expectation_iou": 0.4687004639626631, + "iou_gain": 0.2868822821444813, + "pass_acc_50": false, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.769172438948636, + "highest_entropy_edge": "ymax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "30", + "argmax_coord": 30, + "expected_coord": 47.623091228605354, + "confidence": 0.32154140214803, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.1645269911834184, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7109578055210422 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 16.419232190847296, + "confidence": 0.762752388502344, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.9557157870103731, + "normalized_entropy": 0.31391320200780676 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "55", + "argmax_coord": 55, + "expected_coord": 57.31607188311723, + "confidence": 0.24451519467865715, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.341762748857572, + "normalized_entropy": 0.769172438948636 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 17.36084014274473, + "confidence": 0.4062646485269269, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.763975731437384, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5793932439389139 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 207.698 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t2-02a-unoccluded-twin", + "tier": "paired_occlusion", + "target": "warning_modal_banner", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 30, + 25, + 70, + 75 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 15, + 30, + 65, + 80 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 15.121390066591166, + 25.410069942366256, + 65.12557262255753, + 73.26880118817054 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.5384615384615384, + "expectation_iou": 0.6198455334348014, + "iou_gain": 0.08138399497326299, + "pass_acc_50": true, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.7713338583826017, + "highest_entropy_edge": "ymax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "80", + "argmax_coord": 80, + "expected_coord": 73.26880118817054, + "confidence": 0.38213250983420644, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.8222524419587, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5985347387754221 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "30", + "argmax_coord": 30, + "expected_coord": 25.410069942366256, + "confidence": 0.43158330206054835, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.3600297982272256, + "normalized_entropy": 0.44671367219228103 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "65", + "argmax_coord": 65, + "expected_coord": 65.12557262255753, + "confidence": 0.27623853817833305, + "raw_entropy_nats": 2.348343238821612, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7713338583826017 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 15.121390066591166, + "confidence": 0.8247506930617594, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.689422775282416, + "normalized_entropy": 0.22644693523689052 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 244.295 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t2-02b-bottom-edge-occluded", + "tier": "paired_occlusion", + "target": "warning_modal_banner", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "ymax", + "gt_box": [ + 30, + 25, + 70, + 75 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 15, + 15, + 55, + 65 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 15.626596645135345, + 19.617296007412545, + 55.905529674558295, + 71.72675122927838 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.3333333333333333, + "expectation_iou": 0.41907901368094724, + "iou_gain": 0.08574568034761393, + "pass_acc_50": false, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.6091443256495772, + "highest_entropy_edge": "xmax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "65", + "argmax_coord": 65, + "expected_coord": 71.72675122927838, + "confidence": 0.27749745513153784, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.8545535672520415, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6091443256495772 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 19.617296007412545, + "confidence": 0.5214870721114357, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.3385451532723465, + "normalized_entropy": 0.43965685280784433 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "55", + "argmax_coord": 55, + "expected_coord": 55.905529674558295, + "confidence": 0.5920855050995082, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.5857820233105009, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5208639633138286 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "15", + "argmax_coord": 15, + "expected_coord": 15.626596645135345, + "confidence": 0.7845977796595538, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.9070630973437438, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2979328009229621 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 232.768 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t3-01-detr-dual-buttons", + "tier": "detr_and_negative", + "target": "dual_dialog_controls", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 60, + 15, + 78, + 45 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 50, + 0, + 70, + 30 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 47.59684262708259, + 7.438262149505142, + 69.62220401394319, + 30.718752338783187 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.15151515151515152, + "expectation_iou": 0.16777260168530547, + "iou_gain": 0.016257450170153953, + "pass_acc_50": false, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.49703925195318266, + "highest_entropy_edge": "xmin", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "30", + "argmax_coord": 30, + "expected_coord": 30.718752338783187, + "confidence": 0.8452378463020024, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.6994278423618554, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3037576524272513 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "00", + "argmax_coord": 0, + "expected_coord": 7.438262149505142, + "confidence": 0.4923523931705466, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.1444751721803101, + "normalized_entropy": 0.49703925195318266 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "70", + "argmax_coord": 70, + "expected_coord": 69.62220401394319, + "confidence": 0.7981758774672804, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.7586371017663648, + "normalized_entropy": 0.32947190706420787 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "50", + "argmax_coord": 50, + "expected_coord": 47.59684262708259, + "confidence": 0.8444984747513771, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.6433705641218901, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2794122858171191 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 299.488 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t3-02-detr-stacked-banner-cta", + "tier": "detr_and_negative", + "target": "banner_and_cta", + "object_present_gt": true, + "object_present_pred": true, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 12, + 20, + 28, + 80 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 0, + 10, + 20, + 70 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 0.939351498627836, + 10.430615456837323, + 22.877168007248834, + 64.17393195877757 + ], + "argmax_iou": 0.22727272727272727, + "expectation_iou": 0.2897078099480777, + "iou_gain": 0.062435082675350445, + "pass_acc_50": false, + "pass_acc_75": false, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0.4435819206621941, + "highest_entropy_edge": "ymax", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "70", + "argmax_coord": 70, + "expected_coord": 64.17393195877757, + "confidence": 0.7670497660301617, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.9565610499259448, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4154291855864188 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "10", + "argmax_coord": 10, + "expected_coord": 10.430615456837323, + "confidence": 0.9425317746810916, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.292550407248538, + "normalized_entropy": 0.12705302754658912 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "20", + "argmax_coord": 20, + "expected_coord": 22.877168007248834, + "confidence": 0.6852267124966106, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.0213851180384357, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4435819206621941 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "00", + "argmax_coord": 0, + "expected_coord": 0.939351498627836, + "confidence": 0.9317602219647692, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.28598646804285066, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1242023449700107 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 273.129 + }, + { + "id": "bbox-t3-03-absent-target-gate", + "tier": "detr_and_negative", + "target": "primary_cta_button", + "object_present_gt": false, + "object_present_pred": false, + "occluded_edge": "none", + "gt_box": [ + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0 + ], + "argmax_box": [ + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0 + ], + "expectation_box": [ + 0, + 0, + 0, + 0 + ], + "argmax_iou": 1, + "expectation_iou": 1, + "iou_gain": 0, + "pass_acc_50": true, + "pass_acc_75": true, + "max_edge_normalized_entropy": 0, + "highest_entropy_edge": "none", + "edges": { + "xmax": { + "argmax_bin": "00", + "argmax_coord": 0, + "expected_coord": 30.16774161359408, + "confidence": 0.6399789926161097, + "raw_entropy_nats": 1.2310229079739865, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4043402317292489 + }, + "xmin": { + "argmax_bin": "00", + "argmax_coord": 0, + "expected_coord": 6.235515423630125, + "confidence": 0.8843760791862776, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.6125974212171433, + "normalized_entropy": 0.20121297633635446 + }, + "ymax": { + "argmax_bin": "00", + "argmax_coord": 0, + "expected_coord": 18.120432351254692, + "confidence": 0.7739090215790301, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.9117672319807281, + "normalized_entropy": 0.29947791505275045 + }, + "ymin": { + "argmax_bin": "00", + "argmax_coord": 0, + "expected_coord": 5.953675971612923, + "confidence": 0.8810481689814413, + "raw_entropy_nats": 0.6414151780381093, + "normalized_entropy": 0.21067842039546109 + } + }, + "wall_time_ms": 209.249 + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/bench.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/bench.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6bbe33a --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/bench.json @@ -0,0 +1,467 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:41:19Z", + "target_url": "https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions", + "target_model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "total_cases": 30, + "failed_cases": 0, + "total_retries": 0, + "workers": 4, + "total_elapsed_sec": 1.397251334, + "mode": "slot", + "slot_avg_denoise_ms": 128.5627285639445, + "slot_avg_wall_ms": 174.16666666666666, + "slot_accuracy_pct": 73.33333333333333, + "slot_multi_reads_triggered": 0, + "cases": [ + { + "id": "sup-01", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 129.0457248687744, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 176, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "engineering", + "urgent": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-02", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 126.3132095336914, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 169, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "billing", + "urgent": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-03", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 127.51555442810059, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 182, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "support", + "urgent": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-04", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 130.5530071258545, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 176, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "engineering", + "urgent": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-05", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "negation", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 125.60033798217773, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 174, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "support", + "urgent": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-06", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 114.17627334594727, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 161, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "engineering", + "urgent": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-07", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 120.44477462768555, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 166, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "billing", + "urgent": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-08", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "negation", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 107.90753364562988, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 154, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "engineering", + "urgent": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-09", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 146.63958549499512, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 188, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "engineering", + "urgent": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sup-10", + "domain": "support", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 147.50981330871582, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 198, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "team": "support", + "urgent": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-01", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 144.8037624359131, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 194, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "yes", + "category": "security" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-02", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 142.61794090270996, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 193, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "yes", + "category": "bugfix" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-03", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 129.0433406829834, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 173, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "yes", + "category": "refactor" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-04", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 122.89690971374512, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 166, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "yes", + "category": "feature" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-05", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 117.36321449279785, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 160, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "no", + "category": "security" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-06", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 120.90015411376953, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 168, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "yes", + "category": "refactor" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-07", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "negation", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 130.95498085021973, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 178, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "yes", + "category": "refactor" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-08", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "complex", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 122.30110168457031, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 167, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "no", + "category": "refactor" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-09", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 126.31702423095703, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 171, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "no", + "category": "security" + } + }, + { + "id": "code-10", + "domain": "code_review", + "tier": "negation", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 120.41521072387695, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 164, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "approved": "yes", + "category": "feature" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-01", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 138.76867294311523, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 186, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "revoke_key", + "data_compromise": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-02", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 136.15775108337402, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 183, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "isolate_host", + "data_compromise": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-03", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 133.9273452758789, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 181, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "monitor", + "data_compromise": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-04", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 132.19475746154785, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 180, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "isolate_host", + "data_compromise": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-05", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "negation", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 133.91566276550293, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 176, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "monitor", + "data_compromise": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-06", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 137.54940032958984, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 181, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "isolate_host", + "data_compromise": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-07", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 134.12189483642578, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 177, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "revoke_key", + "data_compromise": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-08", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 134.4926357269287, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 183, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "monitor", + "data_compromise": "no" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-09", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "slot_accurate": false, + "slot_denoise_ms": 111.70411109924316, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 150, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "revoke_key", + "data_compromise": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "sec-10", + "domain": "security", + "tier": "unambiguous", + "slot_accurate": true, + "slot_denoise_ms": 110.73017120361328, + "slot_prefill_ms": 0, + "slot_wall_time_ms": 150, + "slot_samples": 4, + "slot_extended": false, + "slot_answers": { + "action": "monitor", + "data_compromise": "no" + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..62d101a --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration.json @@ -0,0 +1,1724 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:40:03Z", + "idc_config": "none", + "target_url": "https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions", + "target_model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "workers": 4, + "total_cases": 50, + "total_correct": 46, + "overall_accuracy_pct": 92, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.205128205128204, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 88.69974646867078, + "avg_confidence": 0.8994134443640456, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.26222162823775724, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.19563988053335377, + "avg_brier_score": 0.17054863235383164, + "ece_10bin": 0.09073642238505861, + "p50_latency_ms": 232.99999999999997, + "p95_latency_ms": 682.2, + "avg_wall_time_ms": 238.04, + "total_elapsed_sec": 3.05781496, + "temperature_scale": 1, + "jev_parity": { + "protocol_version": "jevbench::v1.4", + "temperature_applied": 1, + "optimal_temperature": 1.5, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.205128205128204, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 88.69974646867078, + "intelligence_score": 88.60248324590074, + "calibration_score": 83.15792876871623, + "speed_score": 80.30178686879835, + "cost_score": 57.55079956087546, + "composite_jevbench_score": 76.38912442713793, + "ece_10bin": 0.09073642238505861, + "brier_mean": 0.17054863235383164, + "soft_tvd_mean": 0.1553685798555579, + "probability_fidelity": 84.4631420144442, + "p50_latency_sec": 0.23299999999999998, + "p95_latency_sec": 0.6822, + "usd_per_1k_decisions": 0.026, + "presets": { + "Balanced 33:33:33 (no calibration)": 74.25758510636571, + "Emphasis on Accuracy 60:20:20": 79.69349080032276, + "Emphasis on Speed 20:60:20": 76.61866431379038, + "JevBench Score (25:25:25:25)": 76.38912442713793 + }, + "raw_t1_ece_10bin": 0.09073642238505861, + "raw_t1_brier_mean": 0.17054863235383164, + "raw_t1_calibration_score": 83.15792876871623, + "raw_t1_composite_score": 76.38912442713793, + "reliability_bins": [ + { + "bin_index": 0, + "range_label": "[0.0, 0.1)", + "lower": 0, + "upper": 0.1, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 1, + "range_label": "[0.1, 0.2)", + "lower": 0.1, + "upper": 0.2, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 2, + "range_label": "[0.2, 0.3)", + "lower": 0.2, + "upper": 0.30000000000000004, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 3, + "range_label": "[0.3, 0.4)", + "lower": 0.30000000000000004, + "upper": 0.4, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 4, + "range_label": "[0.4, 0.5)", + "lower": 0.4, + "upper": 0.5, + "count": 3, + "avg_confidence": 0.49359589625456807, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.6666666666666666, + "abs_gap": 0.17307077041209856 + }, + { + "bin_index": 5, + "range_label": "[0.5, 0.6)", + "lower": 0.5, + "upper": 0.6000000000000001, + "count": 3, + "avg_confidence": 0.5593963107886296, + "empirical_accuracy": 1, + "abs_gap": 0.4406036892113704 + }, + { + "bin_index": 6, + "range_label": "[0.6, 0.7)", + "lower": 0.6000000000000001, + "upper": 0.7000000000000001, + "count": 2, + "avg_confidence": 0.6505973899600804, + "empirical_accuracy": 1, + "abs_gap": 0.34940261003991957 + }, + { + "bin_index": 7, + "range_label": "[0.7, 0.8)", + "lower": 0.7000000000000001, + "upper": 0.8, + "count": 1, + "avg_confidence": 0.7567541484249153, + "empirical_accuracy": 1, + "abs_gap": 0.24324585157508472 + }, + { + "bin_index": 8, + "range_label": "[0.8, 0.9)", + "lower": 0.8, + "upper": 0.9, + "count": 5, + "avg_confidence": 0.8620012354817673, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.6, + "abs_gap": 0.26200123548176735 + }, + { + "bin_index": 9, + "range_label": "[0.9, 1.0]", + "lower": 0.9, + "upper": 1, + "count": 36, + "avg_confidence": 0.9845483469810767, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.9722222222222222, + "abs_gap": 0.012326124758854529 + } + ], + "endpoint_kind": "gpu", + "raw_speed_score": 87.98732363902603, + "adjusted_speed_score": 80.30178686879835, + "v14_intelligence_score": 88.60248324590074, + "v14_calibration_score": 83.15792876871623, + "v14_composite_score": 75.27193897249262, + "v14_public_only_estimate": true + }, + "categories": [ + { + "name": "agent-trajectory", + "total": 7, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 35.714285714285715, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9991223320313772, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.0070585108427689966, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.0057450885223036974, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0000027852315522696895, + "ece_10bin": 0.000877667968622764, + "avg_latency_ms": 128.57142857142858 + }, + { + "name": "emotion", + "total": 4, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 3.8461538461538463, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.8696355688675891, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.3905797410864087, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.11987973239233507, + "avg_brier_score": 0.07025965587432705, + "ece_10bin": 0.1303644311324109, + "avg_latency_ms": 189.5 + }, + { + "name": "grounding", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9934005844859043, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.038457489889493046, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.055482429948609066, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00011787924463482194, + "ece_10bin": 0.006599415514095708, + "avg_latency_ms": 103 + }, + { + "name": "guardrail", + "total": 4, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.997356869683358, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.017468667803529264, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.025201960411088367, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00002331808755940371, + "ece_10bin": 0.002643130316641984, + "avg_latency_ms": 408.25 + }, + { + "name": "intent", + "total": 7, + "correct": 6, + "accuracy_pct": 85.71428571428571, + "chance_baseline_pct": 6.41025641025641, + "chance_corrected_pct": 84.7358121330724, + "avg_confidence": 0.9592409391435439, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.16979941658450848, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.053921330160339995, + "avg_brier_score": 0.21896650197484907, + "ece_10bin": 0.10750616353734944, + "avg_latency_ms": 165.57142857142858 + }, + { + "name": "nli", + "total": 3, + "correct": 1, + "accuracy_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "avg_confidence": 0.665383542660572, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.6608306760652969, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.6015140035129659, + "avg_brier_score": 1.1668859011384538, + "ece_10bin": 0.6248783486062012, + "avg_latency_ms": 292.6666666666667 + }, + { + "name": "nli-soft", + "total": 6, + "correct": 5, + "accuracy_pct": 83.33333333333334, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 74.99999999999999, + "avg_confidence": 0.7880767333894773, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.45602128067304504, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.41508845784521253, + "avg_brier_score": 0.36901655876457456, + "ece_10bin": 0.3154141033926428, + "avg_latency_ms": 218.33333333333334 + }, + { + "name": "ordinal", + "total": 7, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 20, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.8720877132679477, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.4134813123557858, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.2569103841542046, + "avg_brier_score": 0.05336304949111308, + "ece_10bin": 0.1279122867320524, + "avg_latency_ms": 218.14285714285714 + }, + { + "name": "reading-comprehension", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9428343560633439, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.2155542343870916, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.31097902499287433, + "avg_brier_score": 0.007285310611920256, + "ece_10bin": 0.05716564393665613, + "avg_latency_ms": 247.5 + }, + { + "name": "retrieval", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9909316363069836, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.05123900573805215, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.07392225947836897, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00017990431924373555, + "ece_10bin": 0.009068363693016446, + "avg_latency_ms": 476.5 + }, + { + "name": "toxicity", + "total": 6, + "correct": 6, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 35, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.851766898477893, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.3362319875972049, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.30163157485769637, + "avg_brier_score": 0.10167502010117106, + "ece_10bin": 0.148233101522107, + "avg_latency_ms": 347.1666666666667 + } + ], + "tiers": [ + { + "name": "adversarial", + "total": 5, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 80, + "chance_baseline_pct": 43.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 64.70588235294119, + "avg_confidence": 0.8994641070181622, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.23483353778814414, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.2180723049611834, + "avg_brier_score": 0.4273891690952767, + "ece_10bin": 0.27516099058553967, + "avg_latency_ms": 191 + }, + { + "name": "ambiguous", + "total": 9, + "correct": 8, + "accuracy_pct": 88.88888888888889, + "chance_baseline_pct": 27.891737891737893, + "chance_corrected_pct": 84.59107072303436, + "avg_confidence": 0.8767805178574573, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.3110871949011742, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.26740599051973585, + "avg_brier_score": 0.17700279800216384, + "ece_10bin": 0.12168704958302232, + "avg_latency_ms": 345.3333333333333 + }, + { + "name": "easy", + "total": 17, + "correct": 17, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 31.138763197586727, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9411757578741802, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.15729418321979322, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.08593797982121348, + "avg_brier_score": 0.03960423854082793, + "ece_10bin": 0.05882424212581975, + "avg_latency_ms": 237.41176470588235 + }, + { + "name": "held-out", + "total": 8, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 87.5, + "chance_baseline_pct": 21.442307692307693, + "chance_corrected_pct": 84.08812729498165, + "avg_confidence": 0.857832966334099, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.45694897833593734, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.2866674736479639, + "avg_brier_score": 0.23875662316043877, + "ece_10bin": 0.1697287073567741, + "avg_latency_ms": 226.875 + }, + { + "name": "high-entropy", + "total": 3, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 66.66666666666666, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 49.99999999999999, + "avg_confidence": 0.6079627293236245, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.7707160610519835, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.70153599136084, + "avg_brier_score": 0.7348664434710118, + "ece_10bin": 0.5990189442406156, + "avg_latency_ms": 239.66666666666666 + }, + { + "name": "localization", + "total": 3, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 25, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9984554003557768, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.011942009755889197, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.008614339126534481, + "avg_brier_score": 0.000005989384545296953, + "ece_10bin": 0.0015445996442231547, + "avg_latency_ms": 131 + }, + { + "name": "low-entropy", + "total": 3, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.96819073745533, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.14132650029410657, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.12864092432958507, + "avg_brier_score": 0.003166674058137151, + "ece_10bin": 0.03180926254466998, + "avg_latency_ms": 197 + }, + { + "name": "out-of-scope", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 8.333333333333332, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9979244032281467, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.01779115705332429, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.00715968829446456, + "avg_brier_score": 0.000009114488526636751, + "ece_10bin": 0.0020755967718533164, + "avg_latency_ms": 142.5 + } + ], + "cases": [ + { + "id": "tox-01", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9997380056594533, + "entropy_nats": 0.0024226765081747153, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0034951833840218523, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 1.3728206895704768e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 274, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9997380056594533, + "yes": 0.00026199434054678233 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-02", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9901378161024849, + "entropy_nats": 0.0553672891976805, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07987811355295873, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0001945253424568139, + "wall_time_ms": 274, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.009862183897515104, + "yes": 0.9901378161024849 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-03", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.689478181610305, + "entropy_nats": 0.6195175450874202, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8937748900413259, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.19284759939208537, + "tvd_gold": 0.06052181838969495, + "stderr": 0.04688206430349549, + "wall_time_ms": 897, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.689478181610305, + "yes": 0.310521818389695 + } + }, + { + "id": "marco-01", + "metric": "calibration/ms-marco-passage-relevance-check", + "category": "retrieval", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9937095743108, + "entropy_nats": 0.03815504694312889, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05504609700973766, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00007913891070269506, + "wall_time_ms": 273, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9937095743108, + "yes": 0.006290425689199977 + } + }, + { + "id": "marco-02", + "metric": "calibration/ms-marco-passage-relevance-check", + "category": "retrieval", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.988153698303167, + "entropy_nats": 0.06432296453297541, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0927984219470003, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00028066972778477607, + "tvd_gold": 0.23815369830316702, + "wall_time_ms": 680, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.011846301696832994, + "yes": 0.988153698303167 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-01", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9986313536296104, + "entropy_nats": 0.010392471920703066, + "normalized_entropy": 0.014993167702576115, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0000037463857743611495, + "wall_time_ms": 684, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9986313536296104, + "yes": 0.0013686463703896164 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-02", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9938454186493256, + "entropy_nats": 0.03746585959133382, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05405180983505951, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00007575774320413753, + "wall_time_ms": 685, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.00615458135067437, + "yes": 0.9938454186493256 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-03", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9974182309386191, + "entropy_nats": 0.017963919272030893, + "normalized_entropy": 0.025916457248688646, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.000013331062972606776, + "wall_time_ms": 138, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0025817690613808256, + "yes": 0.9974182309386191 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-04", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9995324755158768, + "entropy_nats": 0.004052420430049268, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0058464068580292, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 4.3715828650940043e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9995324755158768, + "yes": 0.00046752448412329834 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-01", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9999104310088098, + "entropy_nats": 0.0009243928856136462, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0013336170319078462, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 1.6045208365649435e-8, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9999104310088098, + "yes": 0.00008956899119016347 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-02", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9998584057531458, + "entropy_nats": 0.0013964696074067237, + "normalized_entropy": 0.002014679777357838, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 4.0097861484431204e-8, + "wall_time_ms": 121, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.000141594246854272, + "yes": 0.9998584057531458 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-03", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9995366689049231, + "entropy_nats": 0.0040202483658262015, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00579999238051942, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 4.293514073303225e-7, + "tvd_gold": 0.2495366689049231, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9995366689049231, + "yes": 0.0004633310950769815 + } + }, + { + "id": "ground-01", + "metric": "calibration/grounding-claim-support-check", + "category": "grounding", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9894779148350512, + "entropy_nats": 0.0583870430997275, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08423469753214703, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00022142855243687087, + "wall_time_ms": 105, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.010522085164948802, + "yes": 0.9894779148350512 + } + }, + { + "id": "ground-02", + "metric": "calibration/grounding-claim-support-check", + "category": "grounding", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9973232541367574, + "entropy_nats": 0.018527936679258592, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0267301623650711, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.000014329936832773005, + "wall_time_ms": 101, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9973232541367574, + "yes": 0.002676745863242619 + } + }, + { + "id": "boolq-01", + "metric": "calibration/boolq-passage-answer-check", + "category": "reading-comprehension", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.962192673636614, + "entropy_nats": 0.16091198374847496, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2321469209735303, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0028587878534951667, + "stderr": 0.011284180834627466, + "wall_time_ms": 222, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.03780732636338604, + "yes": 0.962192673636614 + } + }, + { + "id": "boolq-02", + "metric": "calibration/boolq-passage-answer-check", + "category": "reading-comprehension", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9234760384900738, + "entropy_nats": 0.27019648502570826, + "normalized_entropy": 0.38981112901221837, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.011711833370345346, + "stderr": 0.00825910432575482, + "wall_time_ms": 273, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9234760384900738, + "yes": 0.0765239615099262 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-01", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "sadness", + "actual": "sadness", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5960139103256583, + "entropy_nats": 1.0745576026503056, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3298114681717944, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.2599412000743276, + "stderr": 0.01576077588547065, + "wall_time_ms": 254, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.0028378347944344176, + "amusement": 0.0003618459180451318, + "anger": 0.0016956552609511885, + "annoyance": 0.01822206367312231, + "approval": 0.0006504227716337304, + "caring": 0.0001522300391610143, + "confusion": 0.00027211344886274573, + "curiosity": 0.00012826704395155311, + "desire": 0.00021678206357178908, + "disappointment": 0.3071289495780529, + "disapproval": 0.0033897111285123424, + "disgust": 0.00030648474351209536, + "embarrassment": 0.0006104633971505301, + "excitement": 0.00017269182226494842, + "fear": 0.00006665892174075411, + "gratitude": 0.00028350425987652895, + "joy": 0.00087237850908879, + "love": 0.00012783936725380607, + "neutral": 0.04278178328357303, + "optimism": 0.00023141752927512428, + "pride": 0.00014104034433237166, + "realization": 0.006547964487583826, + "relief": 0.002173512334356351, + "remorse": 0.0015207739791020364, + "sadness": 0.5960139103256583, + "surprise": 0.01309370097493241 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-02", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "gratitude", + "actual": "gratitude", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9962320685855028, + "entropy_nats": 0.03238595169888197, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00994014490391642, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.000018442827507643172, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.00014221122256854803, + "amusement": 0.00013091794386498637, + "anger": 0.00003298879750441875, + "annoyance": 0.00005598391212939385, + "approval": 0.000030163261936364802, + "caring": 0.00006656450738025829, + "confusion": 0.00005598391212939385, + "curiosity": 0.000027568745267949683, + "desire": 0.00005598391212939385, + "disappointment": 0.00023168422379227907, + "disapproval": 0.00015441741115732136, + "disgust": 0.00014221122256854803, + "embarrassment": 0.000030163261936364802, + "excitement": 0.00010189328706593375, + "fear": 0.000005360641881004924, + "gratitude": 0.9962320685855028, + "joy": 0.0020038766145960177, + "love": 0.00005131144323582339, + "neutral": 0.00008604120011621586, + "optimism": 0.000027568745267949683, + "pride": 0.000020999093450988857, + "realization": 0.000036064600451303214, + "relief": 0.000013235729751135725, + "remorse": 0.000020999093450988857, + "sadness": 0.000012054407072434055, + "surprise": 0.00023168422379227907 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-03", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "confusion", + "actual": "confusion", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8892869722989839, + "entropy_nats": 0.4291681099559232, + "normalized_entropy": 0.13172357078668412, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.021067937593140056, + "tvd_gold": 0.1392869722989839, + "stderr": 0.03435112567276805, + "wall_time_ms": 253, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.0008639488530907038, + "amusement": 0.00022523829816866966, + "anger": 0.0003033518615356719, + "annoyance": 0.0006535132700854957, + "approval": 0.00009104384277522901, + "caring": 0.000026803416725892184, + "confusion": 0.8892869722989839, + "curiosity": 0.0934465141809194, + "desire": 0.00007485679437560771, + "disappointment": 0.00020660608591554353, + "disapproval": 0.0004210685398043206, + "disgust": 0.00010515074049614515, + "embarrassment": 0.00014545234284490645, + "excitement": 0.0003261077714554938, + "fear": 0.00004147017563840904, + "gratitude": 0.00012825557419773507, + "joy": 0.0009256653177737719, + "love": 0.00004347550693630596, + "neutral": 0.0016164039333243228, + "optimism": 0.00001610762525611453, + "pride": 0.000041329875411768605, + "realization": 0.002682405288254463, + "relief": 0.00001610539829585939, + "remorse": 0.000043322835504477875, + "sadness": 0.00015026992261123824, + "surprise": 0.008118560249619001 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-04", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "neutral", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9970093242602114, + "entropy_nats": 0.026207300040523768, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008043745706945339, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.000011043002332911488, + "tvd_gold": 0.24700932426021138, + "wall_time_ms": 131, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.00030396978557262227, + "amusement": 0.00007607518171188136, + "anger": 0.00000896236369019224, + "annoyance": 0.00015453525599108542, + "approval": 0.000050602623659201384, + "caring": 0.000014023727407477503, + "confusion": 0.000010732909573040638, + "curiosity": 0.000004709632892219741, + "desire": 0.000014023727407477503, + "disappointment": 0.000039431393133094644, + "disapproval": 0.000039431393133094644, + "disgust": 0.000011738312032871143, + "embarrassment": 0.00003625640484393636, + "excitement": 0.00002172596745254236, + "fear": 0.000003232681608174195, + "gratitude": 0.00004286740635655554, + "joy": 0.0006655479279823336, + "love": 0.000012832766437804158, + "neutral": 0.9970093242602114, + "optimism": 0.00000164853231157561, + "pride": 0.0000014235259270220791, + "realization": 0.00007607518171188136, + "relief": 0.000008184977556311786, + "remorse": 0.000005169146818951976, + "sadness": 0.00016686314299337873, + "surprise": 0.0012206117715838202 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-01", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "bill_balance", + "actual": "bill_balance", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9902509018744544, + "entropy_nats": 0.07035048634387354, + "normalized_entropy": 0.028311118387435396, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.0001199146467711555, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.00047919223423824423, + "balance": 0.0015423086703241146, + "bill_balance": 0.9902509018744544, + "bill_due": 0.0015423086703241146, + "freeze_account": 0.00029420321182839363, + "interest_rate": 0.000008800347440347128, + "min_payment": 0.000040604397025496964, + "out_of_scope": 0.004172430448509115, + "pay_bill": 0.0015423086703241146, + "pin_change": 0.000014863402695596138, + "routing": 0.00005603903641798807, + "transfer": 0.00005603903641798807 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-02", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "freeze_account", + "actual": "freeze_account", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9966944292430922, + "entropy_nats": 0.026382103060531834, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01061693929741088, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000014747681280887302, + "wall_time_ms": 112, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.0013624713173290375, + "balance": 0.00016834690893196912, + "bill_balance": 0.00000837747144945541, + "bill_due": 0.00011720988746274387, + "freeze_account": 0.9966944292430922, + "interest_rate": 0.000001993208357160913, + "min_payment": 0.000005907005010618217, + "out_of_scope": 0.0013624713173290375, + "pay_bill": 0.0002566332716109701, + "pin_change": 0.00000452625983790975, + "routing": 0.000009952782829379132, + "transfer": 0.000007681326759679617 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-03", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "out-of-scope", + "expected": "out_of_scope", + "actual": "out_of_scope", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9997565929831389, + "entropy_nats": 0.002738953979592599, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0011022361664275286, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 7.003346036760498e-8, + "wall_time_ms": 117, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.0000643347817489966, + "balance": 0.000027174894335716328, + "bill_balance": 0.000004193054580941234, + "bill_due": 0.000034540123713254665, + "freeze_account": 0.000016640378727868412, + "interest_rate": 0.0000013948864724191134, + "min_payment": 0.000008460708898573911, + "out_of_scope": 0.9997565929831389, + "pay_bill": 0.0000643347817489966, + "pin_change": 0.0000026690983500834736, + "routing": 0.000007760755302564626, + "transfer": 0.000011903552981721317 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-04", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "out-of-scope", + "expected": "out_of_scope", + "actual": "out_of_scope", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9960922134731545, + "entropy_nats": 0.032843360127055986, + "normalized_entropy": 0.013217140422501591, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000018158943592905896, + "wall_time_ms": 168, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.0009658789526271179, + "balance": 0.0005033664690503423, + "bill_balance": 0.00007568043827436337, + "bill_due": 0.00017139408075518458, + "freeze_account": 0.00015822574318062003, + "interest_rate": 0.0008998140638038455, + "min_payment": 0.00003504248630643669, + "out_of_scope": 0.9960922134731545, + "pay_bill": 0.0008998140638038455, + "pin_change": 0.000009921112739850957, + "routing": 0.000053964261735323905, + "transfer": 0.000134684854568743 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-01", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9422887834180014, + "entropy_nats": 0.25312009893543086, + "normalized_entropy": 0.23039984309869518, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.803501228094789, + "stderr": 0.015918437774794354, + "wall_time_ms": 294, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.04324310790528882, + "entailment": 0.9422887834180014, + "neutral": 0.014468108676709779 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-02", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5607577910815562, + "entropy_nats": 0.880503313623951, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8014686552354329, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.3334165192235027, + "stderr": 0.10983251153335577, + "wall_time_ms": 296, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.5607577910815562, + "entailment": 0.36797194213830603, + "neutral": 0.07127026678013773 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-03", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4931040534821584, + "entropy_nats": 0.8488686156365087, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7726735122047699, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.3637399560970698, + "tvd_gold": 0.24310405348215847, + "stderr": 0.12680233232887542, + "wall_time_ms": 288, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.46020555006877245, + "entailment": 0.4931040534821584, + "neutral": 0.0466903964490691 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-01", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "entailment", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9285277975297197, + "entropy_nats": 0.2900982731965097, + "normalized_entropy": 0.26405882784017204, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.008769963062816181, + "tvd_gold": 0.00852779752971966, + "stderr": 0.02699124458946807, + "wall_time_ms": 237, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.01220368238489159, + "entailment": 0.9285277975297197, + "neutral": 0.05926852008538872 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-02", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8104725103463601, + "entropy_nats": 0.5631900896073412, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5126377116080856, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.3590125402087354, + "tvd_gold": 0.21047251034636016, + "stderr": 0.03045054672687464, + "wall_time_ms": 235, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.8104725103463601, + "entailment": 0.027033339621572543, + "neutral": 0.16249415003206732 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-03", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9802666901148194, + "entropy_nats": 0.10383696804219612, + "normalized_entropy": 0.09451648148600424, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.0007025663555332981, + "tvd_gold": 0.06026669011481933, + "stderr": 0.007655564600635086, + "wall_time_ms": 231, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.9802666901148194, + "entailment": 0.0021705170476313245, + "neutral": 0.017562792837549284 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-04", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5214172309586742, + "entropy_nats": 0.71015903238838, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6464146084232623, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.45528116009355657, + "tvd_gold": 0.12141723095867418, + "stderr": 0.04225973044781855, + "wall_time_ms": 224, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.5214172309586742, + "entailment": 0.0029452825233355824, + "neutral": 0.4756374865179902 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-05", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "entailment", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9957777247214509, + "entropy_nats": 0.030044259643613843, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02734746366257897, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000027492756061972568, + "tvd_gold": 0.07577772472145083, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.0014982170611399536, + "entailment": 0.9957777247214509, + "neutral": 0.002724058217409208 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-06", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "neutral", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.4919984466658392, + "entropy_nats": 1.0387990611602294, + "normalized_entropy": 0.945555654051172, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.3903056301107437, + "tvd_gold": 0.09199844666583917, + "stderr": 0.07733883677937524, + "wall_time_ms": 260, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.29404614360174175, + "entailment": 0.21395540973241903, + "neutral": 0.4919984466658392 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-01", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "benign", + "actual": "benign", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9991846174854317, + "entropy_nats": 0.007242435772868818, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005224313086737336, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.0000010429727528165665, + "wall_time_ms": 138, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.9991846174854317, + "failed_injection": 0.0001186149565662165, + "hijacked": 0.00010209930436891081, + "injection_point": 0.0005946682536331489 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-02", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "injection_point", + "actual": "injection_point", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9997377057061719, + "entropy_nats": 0.002549901408679189, + "normalized_entropy": 0.001839365058528624, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 1.2138348095555189e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 134, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.00022796397209085874, + "failed_injection": 0.000020928557875064575, + "hijacked": 0.000013401763862067968, + "injection_point": 0.9997377057061719 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-03", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "hijacked", + "actual": "hijacked", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9983417729357298, + "entropy_nats": 0.013684117974035253, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009871004570040094, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.000004148263148471669, + "wall_time_ms": 136, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.0011152448548011336, + "failed_injection": 0.00021082717091456868, + "hijacked": 0.9983417729357298, + "injection_point": 0.000332155038554618 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-04", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "benign", + "actual": "benign", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9972867224254285, + "entropy_nats": 0.019592009884953146, + "normalized_entropy": 0.014132647751034727, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.000013698507006463637, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.9972867224254285, + "failed_injection": 0.00007739340812919457, + "hijacked": 0.00012280623305212533, + "injection_point": 0.002513077933390178 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-01", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "card_arrival", + "actual": "card_arrival", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8736953221097539, + "entropy_nats": 0.5518035104134884, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1693637692972037, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.023350707918393762, + "stderr": 0.030639699953488714, + "wall_time_ms": 257, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.00032295898607307604, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.0037543511172345324, + "atm_support": 0.0011428121145570683, + "automatic_top_up": 0.0004944711194385835, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.0003276482062639332, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 0.00011472517367747631, + "cancel_transfer": 0.0000963937435687235, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.0004242478896395012, + "card_acceptance": 0.002386413331705436, + "card_arrival": 0.8736953221097539, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.08439755962208637, + "card_linking": 0.0025035521356647304, + "card_not_working": 0.00011578786822848621, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.00017415064716260056, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 0.00004004384916769633, + "card_swallowed": 0.0003107111379212576, + "change_pin": 0.012414074752075347, + "compromised_card": 0.00025607849209894603, + "contactless_not_working": 0.00004215694986507805, + "declined_card_payment": 0.00007000775136120715, + "declined_transfer": 0.00017050210672329297, + "failed_transfer": 0.00006332308211416936, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.005880600963091758, + "pending_top_up": 0.0003485436677039346, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.003968256520233136, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.006485306662589762 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-02", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "pending_top_up", + "actual": "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8599195372733732, + "entropy_nats": 0.4886186877528481, + "normalized_entropy": 0.14997059849232325, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 1.5092580707087384, + "stderr": 0.024376508845475132, + "wall_time_ms": 252, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.0018922493222307166, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.0037512125783997173, + "atm_support": 0.000036693663507637324, + "automatic_top_up": 0.006858948806642546, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.8599195372733732, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 0.000040537536208380474, + "cancel_transfer": 0.000027367689985167848, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.0001654702233806942, + "card_acceptance": 0.00004706005756655239, + "card_arrival": 0.00005130497013326386, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.000004691910322390233, + "card_linking": 0.00004959171290936638, + "card_not_working": 0.000020761534843735262, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.00007049221042057134, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 0.00000604555713398153, + "card_swallowed": 0.00003329635723311442, + "change_pin": 0.0005094667786354135, + "compromised_card": 0.00023457451838838426, + "contactless_not_working": 0.000010504516362187708, + "declined_card_payment": 0.0000016269648565097472, + "declined_transfer": 0.00010845110349515247, + "failed_transfer": 0.000019638767285914506, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.000015277155680929743, + "pending_top_up": 0.12266052901930716, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.0010837343729311452, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.002380935398765968 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-03", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "transaction_charged_twice", + "actual": "transaction_charged_twice", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9982775770478407, + "entropy_nats": 0.01585881441416879, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004867509059077556, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.000003843891706091908, + "wall_time_ms": 133, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.00015919230098774962, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.00006963463135278581, + "atm_support": 0.0000027604716967697453, + "automatic_top_up": 0.000026744733675634982, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.000029028586736362675, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 3.284658090702455e-7, + "cancel_transfer": 0.000012563583819524437, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.000022674681020675698, + "card_acceptance": 0.000003027430931745911, + "card_arrival": 0.000005713582405783651, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.00003702932913425739, + "card_linking": 0.000014902134189361473, + "card_not_working": 0.000017647678493567437, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.000024630650421974373, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 0.000001300591316249895, + "card_swallowed": 0.000005713582405783651, + "change_pin": 0.000262836450886059, + "compromised_card": 0.000043466747811478574, + "contactless_not_working": 0.000004362399240292775, + "declined_card_payment": 0.000011528816658641674, + "declined_transfer": 0.000009696282360901369, + "failed_transfer": 0.000001300591316249895, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.000011528816658641674, + "pending_top_up": 0.00006963463135278581, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.9982775770478407, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.0008751757814770506 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-01", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "0.0", + "actual": "0.00", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9985959894313647, + "entropy_nats": 0.011928395176139247, + "normalized_entropy": 0.007411528636167669, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0000029459468027323898, + "wall_time_ms": 137, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.9985959894313647, + "0.2": 0.0009300614250906563, + "0.5": 0.00004067671556487727, + "0.7": 0.00013246443178724352, + "0.9": 0.00030080799619251264 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-02", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "0.2", + "actual": "0.20", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9369662094480434, + "entropy_nats": 0.30302707598046325, + "normalized_entropy": 0.18828130842411167, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0056447633945082, + "tvd_gold": 0.18696620944804343, + "stderr": 0.014364952187141367, + "wall_time_ms": 251, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.0374997435501812, + "0.2": 0.9369662094480434, + "0.5": 0.013825830657050085, + "0.7": 0.0075243055388499215, + "0.9": 0.004183910805875336 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-03", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "0.9", + "actual": "0.70", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.49568518861570665, + "entropy_nats": 1.0251289436333515, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6369484251075924, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.41136014924910425, + "stderr": 0.06949748231606431, + "wall_time_ms": 250, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.0103455492775123, + "0.2": 0.003437779144088106, + "0.5": 0.1099932319617797, + "0.7": 0.49568518861570665, + "0.9": 0.38053825100091326 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-01", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "1", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9871827314836613, + "entropy_nats": 0.08438874219230262, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05243367360762231, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.00021752747126404368, + "wall_time_ms": 122, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.9871827314836613, + "2": 0.0037318050596264647, + "3": 0.0022368878759789212, + "4": 0.0010936688887814715, + "5": 0.0057549066919519295 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-02", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9756716556049359, + "entropy_nats": 0.14657005104213977, + "normalized_entropy": 0.09106909307266688, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.000758715222463328, + "tvd_gold": 0.22567165560493585, + "stderr": 0.004906733220681784, + "wall_time_ms": 245, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.008833460941675482, + "2": 0.007483850095982176, + "3": 0.9756716556049359, + "4": 0.0034053045226700813, + "5": 0.004605728834736438 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-03", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "5", + "actual": "5", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.974839126867512, + "entropy_nats": 0.13712520445446091, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08520067993618587, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0010212939645501328, + "stderr": 0.004502099826746304, + "wall_time_ms": 242, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.01939385912499479, + "2": 0.0014924241936632163, + "3": 0.0027452698195343703, + "4": 0.0015293199942957264, + "5": 0.974839126867512 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-04", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9218178968043876, + "entropy_nats": 0.3580828434687871, + "normalized_entropy": 0.22248938011359856, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.008674068238682693, + "tvd_gold": 0.17181789680438764, + "stderr": 0.016065650714407707, + "wall_time_ms": 240, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.018459749634411465, + "2": 0.004849266194313592, + "3": 0.9218178968043876, + "4": 0.04603521810956634, + "5": 0.008837869257321081 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-01", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "1", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8766318353803655, + "entropy_nats": 0.45489724729587305, + "normalized_entropy": 0.28264355137992886, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.02499565885824131, + "stderr": 0.029633292786368275, + "wall_time_ms": 238, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.8766318353803655, + "1": 0.09643490062885539, + "2": 0.02132770444354119, + "3": 0.004488400071460817, + "4": 0.0011171594757771468 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-02", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "2", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6117165983098558, + "entropy_nats": 0.9107037613444349, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5658520619581368, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.2531306898346025, + "stderr": 0.034955061710961625, + "wall_time_ms": 237, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.02858716593597386, + "1": 0.6117165983098558, + "2": 0.31587416571568605, + "3": 0.042070254652850844, + "4": 0.0017518153856333296 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-03", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "0", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7567541484249153, + "entropy_nats": 0.8026013366925023, + "normalized_entropy": 0.49868424901129293, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.08474339284798754, + "stderr": 0.02916462730755183, + "wall_time_ms": 203, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.7567541484249153, + "1": 0.144005798707834, + "2": 0.062475782529443365, + "3": 0.029743237417721717, + "4": 0.007021032920085615 + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration_rollback_cloudrun.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration_rollback_cloudrun.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d2b61b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration_rollback_cloudrun.json @@ -0,0 +1,1722 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:44:31Z", + "idc_config": "none", + "target_url": "https://rb00032---dgemma--uc.a.run.app/v1", + "target_model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "workers": 4, + "total_cases": 50, + "total_correct": 43, + "overall_accuracy_pct": 86, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.205128205128204, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 80.22455632017385, + "avg_confidence": 0.8996163430147146, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.25578431918403216, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.1879061504699149, + "avg_brier_score": 0.18423647760231088, + "ece_10bin": 0.06240700112182909, + "p50_latency_ms": 256.5, + "p95_latency_ms": 1583.5999999999997, + "avg_wall_time_ms": 350.5, + "total_elapsed_sec": 4.400891627, + "temperature_scale": 1, + "jev_parity": { + "protocol_version": "jevbench::v1.4", + "temperature_applied": 1, + "optimal_temperature": 1.4, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.205128205128204, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 80.22455632017385, + "intelligence_score": 80.65411368068337, + "calibration_score": 86.18694383923875, + "speed_score": 76.57714814884943, + "cost_score": 57.55079956087546, + "composite_jevbench_score": 74.39686556997238, + "ece_10bin": 0.06240700112182909, + "brier_mean": 0.18423647760231088, + "soft_tvd_mean": 0.1514471209715668, + "probability_fidelity": 84.85528790284333, + "p50_latency_sec": 0.2565, + "p95_latency_sec": 1.5835999999999997, + "usd_per_1k_decisions": 0.026, + "presets": { + "Balanced 33:33:33 (no calibration)": 70.8368147440007, + "Emphasis on Accuracy 60:20:20": 74.61154340932886, + "Emphasis on Speed 20:60:20": 73.07941969298423, + "JevBench Score (25:25:25:25)": 74.39686556997238 + }, + "raw_t1_ece_10bin": 0.06240700112182909, + "raw_t1_brier_mean": 0.1842364776023109, + "raw_t1_calibration_score": 86.18694383923875, + "raw_t1_composite_score": 74.39686556997238, + "reliability_bins": [ + { + "bin_index": 0, + "range_label": "[0.0, 0.1)", + "lower": 0, + "upper": 0.1, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 1, + "range_label": "[0.1, 0.2)", + "lower": 0.1, + "upper": 0.2, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 2, + "range_label": "[0.2, 0.3)", + "lower": 0.2, + "upper": 0.30000000000000004, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 3, + "range_label": "[0.3, 0.4)", + "lower": 0.30000000000000004, + "upper": 0.4, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 4, + "range_label": "[0.4, 0.5)", + "lower": 0.4, + "upper": 0.5, + "count": 3, + "avg_confidence": 0.4839098572054685, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, + "abs_gap": 0.15057652387213516 + }, + { + "bin_index": 5, + "range_label": "[0.5, 0.6)", + "lower": 0.5, + "upper": 0.6000000000000001, + "count": 3, + "avg_confidence": 0.5494605973297064, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.6666666666666666, + "abs_gap": 0.1172060693369602 + }, + { + "bin_index": 6, + "range_label": "[0.6, 0.7)", + "lower": 0.6000000000000001, + "upper": 0.7000000000000001, + "count": 2, + "avg_confidence": 0.6462708297789808, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0.6462708297789808 + }, + { + "bin_index": 7, + "range_label": "[0.7, 0.8)", + "lower": 0.7000000000000001, + "upper": 0.8, + "count": 1, + "avg_confidence": 0.7818517553330173, + "empirical_accuracy": 1, + "abs_gap": 0.21814824466698268 + }, + { + "bin_index": 8, + "range_label": "[0.8, 0.9)", + "lower": 0.8, + "upper": 0.9, + "count": 3, + "avg_confidence": 0.819945283840691, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.6666666666666666, + "abs_gap": 0.15327861717402436 + }, + { + "bin_index": 9, + "range_label": "[0.9, 1.0]", + "lower": 0.9, + "upper": 1, + "count": 38, + "avg_confidence": 0.982802013703083, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.9736842105263158, + "abs_gap": 0.009117803176767136 + } + ], + "endpoint_kind": "gpu", + "raw_speed_score": 83.91267137471998, + "adjusted_speed_score": 76.57714814884943, + "v14_intelligence_score": 80.65411368068337, + "v14_calibration_score": 86.18694383923875, + "v14_composite_score": 73.48080049564528, + "v14_public_only_estimate": true + }, + "categories": [ + { + "name": "agent-trajectory", + "total": 7, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 35.714285714285715, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9983821049462025, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.011947456412756666, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.009955031855163837, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0000084492638230801, + "ece_10bin": 0.0016178950537975023, + "avg_latency_ms": 139.71428571428572 + }, + { + "name": "emotion", + "total": 4, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 3.8461538461538463, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.8412931074806923, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.4925468066108808, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.15117624688616063, + "avg_brier_score": 0.08222979279604789, + "ece_10bin": 0.15870689251930772, + "avg_latency_ms": 225.25 + }, + { + "name": "grounding", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.992956632149754, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.04115855590086716, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.059379244488332227, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00011983114629954005, + "ece_10bin": 0.007043367850245952, + "avg_latency_ms": 144.5 + }, + { + "name": "guardrail", + "total": 4, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9880539760977142, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.05874075562173359, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.08474499683354554, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0005665199508879864, + "ece_10bin": 0.01194602390228583, + "avg_latency_ms": 164.75 + }, + { + "name": "intent", + "total": 7, + "correct": 6, + "accuracy_pct": 85.71428571428571, + "chance_baseline_pct": 6.41025641025641, + "chance_corrected_pct": 84.7358121330724, + "avg_confidence": 0.9579373108216476, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.16162972183388527, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.05104685063712149, + "avg_brier_score": 0.1869081339010492, + "ece_10bin": 0.12847350248772538, + "avg_latency_ms": 588 + }, + { + "name": "nli", + "total": 3, + "correct": 0, + "accuracy_pct": 0, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "avg_confidence": 0.6941222404294631, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.5863576800349173, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.5337257612016898, + "avg_brier_score": 1.3800935562180168, + "ece_10bin": 0.6941222404294631, + "avg_latency_ms": 258 + }, + { + "name": "nli-soft", + "total": 6, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 50, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 25, + "avg_confidence": 0.7742619437957153, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.466066443802557, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.4242319593635599, + "avg_brier_score": 0.39699064895992225, + "ece_10bin": 0.2984824701885328, + "avg_latency_ms": 222.5 + }, + { + "name": "ordinal", + "total": 7, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 20, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.857839422689125, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.408018030538385, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.25351585630370915, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0827327749362394, + "ece_10bin": 0.14216057731087492, + "avg_latency_ms": 250 + }, + { + "name": "reading-comprehension", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.976809581564192, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.1082265541852433, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.1561379130155512, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0012502330270751703, + "ece_10bin": 0.023190418435808047, + "avg_latency_ms": 233.5 + }, + { + "name": "retrieval", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9974346115174637, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.017591043945036453, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.025378511863563918, + "avg_brier_score": 0.000015877883382358973, + "ece_10bin": 0.0025653884825362905, + "avg_latency_ms": 386 + }, + { + "name": "toxicity", + "total": 6, + "correct": 6, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 35, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.8836628187829637, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.2705792062989288, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.2702729997539394, + "avg_brier_score": 0.07801611264882063, + "ece_10bin": 0.1163371812170363, + "avg_latency_ms": 914 + } + ], + "tiers": [ + { + "name": "adversarial", + "total": 5, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 60, + "chance_baseline_pct": 43.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 29.41176470588236, + "avg_confidence": 0.9120929116345009, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.2143044308732991, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.20813623529171502, + "avg_brier_score": 0.5465555359776595, + "ece_10bin": 0.3120929116345008, + "avg_latency_ms": 183.6 + }, + { + "name": "ambiguous", + "total": 9, + "correct": 8, + "accuracy_pct": 88.88888888888889, + "chance_baseline_pct": 27.891737891737893, + "chance_corrected_pct": 84.59107072303436, + "avg_confidence": 0.853515393527588, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.32771626059979275, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.272530541605062, + "avg_brier_score": 0.2112829229289998, + "ece_10bin": 0.14647160310069363, + "avg_latency_ms": 436.1111111111111 + }, + { + "name": "easy", + "total": 17, + "correct": 17, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 31.138763197586727, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9574448568893885, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.14933878175897672, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.08042977173212734, + "avg_brier_score": 0.018764259225777357, + "ece_10bin": 0.04255514311061137, + "avg_latency_ms": 345.47058823529414 + }, + { + "name": "held-out", + "total": 8, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 87.5, + "chance_baseline_pct": 21.442307692307693, + "chance_corrected_pct": 84.08812729498165, + "avg_confidence": 0.8534413688476314, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.41882841759900685, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.24213358472194257, + "avg_brier_score": 0.23456280668092314, + "ece_10bin": 0.22216809279806976, + "avg_latency_ms": 594.25 + }, + { + "name": "high-entropy", + "total": 3, + "correct": 0, + "accuracy_pct": 0, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "avg_confidence": 0.5727444139842481, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.8185706725987929, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.7450951359657355, + "avg_brier_score": 0.7919485248832993, + "ece_10bin": 0.572744413984248, + "avg_latency_ms": 264.6666666666667 + }, + { + "name": "localization", + "total": 3, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 25, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9972236214047028, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.019753988331774473, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.01424949050201474, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00001774694725933654, + "ece_10bin": 0.002776378595297224, + "avg_latency_ms": 142.33333333333334 + }, + { + "name": "low-entropy", + "total": 3, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9757794736071824, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.11356221500632102, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.10336878276138432, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0020327730365452133, + "ece_10bin": 0.024220526392817576, + "avg_latency_ms": 180.33333333333334 + }, + { + "name": "out-of-scope", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 8.333333333333332, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9986890029629409, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.0116001004658256, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.0046682238412518486, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0000039494896696894295, + "ece_10bin": 0.0013109970370590585, + "avg_latency_ms": 146.5 + } + ], + "cases": [ + { + "id": "tox-01", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.999603530904076, + "entropy_nats": 0.003501898213968182, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0050521711869898145, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 3.1437548804550195e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 637, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.999603530904076, + "yes": 0.00039646909592399324 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-02", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9905867683480455, + "entropy_nats": 0.05328752781877272, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07687765212537609, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00017721786026671655, + "wall_time_ms": 641, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.009413231651954544, + "yes": 0.9905867683480455 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-03", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5430758251422115, + "entropy_nats": 0.6894315228140827, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9946394389964034, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.4175594031389417, + "tvd_gold": 0.20692417485778847, + "stderr": 0.05686187625344647, + "wall_time_ms": 773, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.5430758251422115, + "yes": 0.45692417485778847 + } + }, + { + "id": "marco-01", + "metric": "calibration/ms-marco-passage-relevance-check", + "category": "retrieval", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.996269397535034, + "entropy_nats": 0.024582125654191964, + "normalized_entropy": 0.035464510775812114, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00002783478950322135, + "wall_time_ms": 638, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.996269397535034, + "yes": 0.0037306024649659936 + } + }, + { + "id": "marco-02", + "metric": "calibration/ms-marco-passage-relevance-check", + "category": "retrieval", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9985998254998936, + "entropy_nats": 0.01059996223588094, + "normalized_entropy": 0.015292512951315722, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.000003920977261496597, + "tvd_gold": 0.24859982549989357, + "wall_time_ms": 134, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.001400174500106488, + "yes": 0.9985998254998936 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-01", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9952820796705182, + "entropy_nats": 0.029977781390436845, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04324879654883669, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00004451754447067564, + "wall_time_ms": 135, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9952820796705182, + "yes": 0.004717920329481862 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-02", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9686407547332957, + "entropy_nats": 0.13943574841243897, + "normalized_entropy": 0.20116326275726687, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0019668045273946327, + "stderr": 0.006317284294785691, + "wall_time_ms": 266, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.031359245266704326, + "yes": 0.9686407547332957 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-03", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9887219262205692, + "entropy_nats": 0.06179521044193594, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08915164365527088, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00025438989634856893, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.011278073779430872, + "yes": 0.9887219262205692 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-04", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9995711437664737, + "entropy_nats": 0.0037542822421225744, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005416284372807737, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 3.678353380687062e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9995711437664737, + "yes": 0.00042885623352627663 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-01", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9997502379630008, + "entropy_nats": 0.00232150742666158, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0033492272518315606, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 1.247621502520032e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9997502379630008, + "yes": 0.000249762036999275 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-02", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9994521372509538, + "entropy_nats": 0.004661880157412946, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0067256713843183175, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 6.0030718358485e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 143, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0005478627490460652, + "yes": 0.9994521372509538 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-03", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9992718668761021, + "entropy_nats": 0.005988649205706392, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008639794510696241, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0000010603556922345013, + "tvd_gold": 0.24927186687610214, + "wall_time_ms": 144, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9992718668761021, + "yes": 0.0007281331238978986 + } + }, + { + "id": "ground-01", + "metric": "calibration/grounding-claim-support-check", + "category": "grounding", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9961670125751695, + "entropy_nats": 0.02515279874955398, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03628781802045965, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00002938358519781771, + "wall_time_ms": 146, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.003832987424830589, + "yes": 0.9961670125751695 + } + }, + { + "id": "ground-02", + "metric": "calibration/grounding-claim-support-check", + "category": "grounding", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9897462517243385, + "entropy_nats": 0.05716431305218033, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0824706709562048, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0002102787074012624, + "wall_time_ms": 143, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9897462517243385, + "yes": 0.010253748275661544 + } + }, + { + "id": "boolq-01", + "metric": "calibration/boolq-passage-answer-check", + "category": "reading-comprehension", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9674650106104392, + "entropy_nats": 0.14344651865397712, + "normalized_entropy": 0.206949581094879, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.002117051069157666, + "stderr": 0.00881078874493946, + "wall_time_ms": 306, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.03253498938956083, + "yes": 0.9674650106104392 + } + }, + { + "id": "boolq-02", + "metric": "calibration/boolq-passage-answer-check", + "category": "reading-comprehension", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9861541525179447, + "entropy_nats": 0.07300658971650946, + "normalized_entropy": 0.10532624493622339, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00038341498499267455, + "wall_time_ms": 161, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9861541525179447, + "yes": 0.013845847482055326 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-01", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "sadness", + "actual": "sadness", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5567140154591986, + "entropy_nats": 1.2997987695393374, + "normalized_entropy": 0.39894421616145714, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.2712318874218151, + "stderr": 0.04829114340483047, + "wall_time_ms": 312, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.003863648547346874, + "amusement": 0.0009298680994586277, + "anger": 0.004757255338525102, + "annoyance": 0.02455389264537816, + "approval": 0.0005034308410147159, + "caring": 0.00012083933819327354, + "confusion": 0.0005403647346845219, + "curiosity": 0.0002422603881778873, + "desire": 0.00226518126472781, + "disappointment": 0.24464226257031496, + "disapproval": 0.005102268138510665, + "disgust": 0.0005746069584692752, + "embarrassment": 0.002629733847789108, + "excitement": 0.0003079981571561152, + "fear": 0.00005894765354049132, + "gratitude": 0.0002889022584828125, + "joy": 0.0016203546103288088, + "love": 0.0002434959100901411, + "neutral": 0.11681029880442587, + "optimism": 0.0002744200760443097, + "pride": 0.00012000876278848971, + "realization": 0.02204640613907582, + "relief": 0.0009305327713848863, + "remorse": 0.0020897522758352768, + "sadness": 0.5567140154591986, + "surprise": 0.007769254409057319 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-02", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "gratitude", + "actual": "gratitude", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9935808468349622, + "entropy_nats": 0.0539748972017073, + "normalized_entropy": 0.016566389783675407, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.00004902327696199549, + "wall_time_ms": 158, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.0003259291260444824, + "amusement": 0.00014256942325992084, + "anger": 0.00005475696763666317, + "annoyance": 0.00010429746385619359, + "approval": 0.000059432911306541246, + "caring": 0.0005381296397323062, + "confusion": 0.000059432911306541246, + "curiosity": 0.000039295794933173, + "desire": 0.00017948366280982696, + "disappointment": 0.0003505431914940118, + "disapproval": 0.0003505431914940118, + "disgust": 0.00024263072570846083, + "embarrassment": 0.00008899349427257374, + "excitement": 0.00026136444982524524, + "fear": 0.000008931543567268075, + "gratitude": 0.9935808468349622, + "joy": 0.002604406051781115, + "love": 0.00016628932756294754, + "neutral": 0.00012203846467382124, + "optimism": 0.00002802003544408255, + "pride": 0.000039295794933173, + "realization": 0.00016628932756294754, + "relief": 0.00002802003544408255, + "remorse": 0.00013193113489807219, + "sadness": 0.000023604012974015047, + "surprise": 0.00030292448251637244 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-03", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "confusion", + "actual": "confusion", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8183265308443377, + "entropy_nats": 0.587367423189482, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1802793184103034, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.05762296227249292, + "tvd_gold": 0.06832653084433771, + "stderr": 0.0226065558375463, + "wall_time_ms": 280, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.00031201336645658256, + "amusement": 0.00016819427793963058, + "anger": 0.00016612994737731337, + "annoyance": 0.0008506233036001925, + "approval": 0.0000636436397053849, + "caring": 0.000017860983748246846, + "confusion": 0.8183265308443377, + "curiosity": 0.15624983036286413, + "desire": 0.0000628822755671801, + "disappointment": 0.00021259422077172485, + "disapproval": 0.00029720037515610915, + "disgust": 0.00013447596155840032, + "embarrassment": 0.000122507347924854, + "excitement": 0.0002909703835432198, + "fear": 0.00001655731680226958, + "gratitude": 0.00004587489752681778, + "joy": 0.000872607965821522, + "love": 0.00004423037358397411, + "neutral": 0.0014902140769218859, + "optimism": 0.000006097212649010586, + "pride": 0.000023836102749464502, + "realization": 0.009711718862712666, + "relief": 0.000011226420161284383, + "remorse": 0.000038390434167253185, + "sadness": 0.00020619368529415543, + "surprise": 0.010257595361059182 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-04", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "neutral", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9965510367842706, + "entropy_nats": 0.029046136512996496, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008915063189206514, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.000015298212921548033, + "tvd_gold": 0.2465510367842706, + "wall_time_ms": 151, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.00016233877433478804, + "amusement": 0.0000604728040204754, + "anger": 0.000017796868405033847, + "annoyance": 0.00015082192572535982, + "approval": 0.000022893861617611083, + "caring": 0.000011603018111945162, + "confusion": 0.000003990538973487187, + "curiosity": 0.0000025152369333336036, + "desire": 0.000008933495959438576, + "disappointment": 0.0001300270427146568, + "disapproval": 0.00005164055113311996, + "disgust": 0.000008933495959438576, + "embarrassment": 0.000017796868405033847, + "excitement": 0.000037477368587355875, + "fear": 0.0000013603266625392822, + "gratitude": 0.000012649510873974782, + "joy": 0.0009010597875624436, + "love": 0.000010638839422380298, + "neutral": 0.9965510367842706, + "optimism": 0.0000010187035168439836, + "pride": 0.0000027606459548748397, + "realization": 0.00010377698796430396, + "relief": 0.000006268988822641805, + "remorse": 0.000005732041366714246, + "sadness": 0.00014006654096379706, + "surprise": 0.0015763889917379148 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-01", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "bill_balance", + "actual": "bill_balance", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9921758063597531, + "entropy_nats": 0.05747690049061435, + "normalized_entropy": 0.023130406325532586, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.0000793056451751561, + "wall_time_ms": 166, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.00025598775792707017, + "balance": 0.002934413228139043, + "bill_balance": 0.9921758063597531, + "bill_due": 0.00042265200910695687, + "freeze_account": 0.00036695367506345516, + "interest_rate": 0.0000506450134068994, + "min_payment": 0.00003086328172932912, + "out_of_scope": 0.0006847024699036769, + "pay_bill": 0.002934413228139043, + "pin_change": 0.0000070149171396877865, + "routing": 0.000015592020257223046, + "transfer": 0.000120956039434576 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-02", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "freeze_account", + "actual": "freeze_account", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9970411625224643, + "entropy_nats": 0.024739720249407935, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009955995832486747, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000011785829319950281, + "wall_time_ms": 157, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.0016559373671697361, + "balance": 0.0001248774974476478, + "bill_balance": 0.00003739104124191147, + "bill_due": 0.00035318391318167, + "freeze_account": 0.9970411625224643, + "interest_rate": 0.0001912558966412881, + "min_payment": 0.000015382879533291836, + "out_of_scope": 0.0002197750699270813, + "pay_bill": 0.0002354557133513482, + "pin_change": 0.00005947305729214067, + "routing": 0.000011004011659260586, + "transfer": 0.00005510103009041807 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-03", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "out-of-scope", + "expected": "out_of_scope", + "actual": "out_of_scope", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.99988153312181, + "entropy_nats": 0.0014002857703297616, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0005635164485753326, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.7510553610582403e-8, + "wall_time_ms": 152, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.000010876403938896142, + "balance": 0.000009162257492381226, + "bill_balance": 0.0000018218292127771747, + "bill_due": 0.0000041518157881399695, + "freeze_account": 0.000023069790611954582, + "interest_rate": 7.744863741019137e-7, + "min_payment": 0.0000034669148020643304, + "out_of_scope": 0.99988153312181, + "pay_bill": 0.00005121108137539739, + "pin_change": 0.000002637617980714948, + "routing": 0.0000028904157617426906, + "transfer": 0.000008404264851783911 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-04", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "out-of-scope", + "expected": "out_of_scope", + "actual": "out_of_scope", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9974964728040717, + "entropy_nats": 0.02179991516132144, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008772931233928364, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000007881468785768277, + "wall_time_ms": 141, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.000341318301373438, + "balance": 0.0002947224401148965, + "bill_balance": 0.00006752697211655357, + "bill_due": 0.00004861596479553374, + "freeze_account": 0.000034777015725727086, + "interest_rate": 0.0011161998938467208, + "min_payment": 0.00003783775020181543, + "out_of_scope": 0.9974964728040717, + "pay_bill": 0.00036709437747641183, + "pin_change": 0.000005394602331199548, + "routing": 0.00006223914460151692, + "transfer": 0.00012780073334460896 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-01", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9784409490235777, + "entropy_nats": 0.11828351190703601, + "normalized_entropy": 0.10766629240096678, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.9305470700640996, + "stderr": 0.011241960853727778, + "wall_time_ms": 261, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.013523538106027588, + "entailment": 0.9784409490235777, + "neutral": 0.00803551287039472 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-02", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6039842874375452, + "entropy_nats": 0.8305248367232205, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7559762850733247, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.8017655733851096, + "stderr": 0.07467930355369624, + "wall_time_ms": 256, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.34123759113995283, + "entailment": 0.6039842874375452, + "neutral": 0.05477812142250202 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-03", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4999414848272666, + "entropy_nats": 0.8102646914744953, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7375347061307778, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.4079680252048405, + "tvd_gold": 0.24994148482726652, + "stderr": 0.07575376379514209, + "wall_time_ms": 257, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.4687280097864463, + "entailment": 0.4999414848272666, + "neutral": 0.031330505386287184 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-01", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "entailment", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9404383791903109, + "entropy_nats": 0.2558656682329654, + "normalized_entropy": 0.23289896797273343, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.005944378581700041, + "tvd_gold": 0.020438379190310885, + "stderr": 0.020649209708185477, + "wall_time_ms": 279, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.012131468044797995, + "entailment": 0.9404383791903109, + "neutral": 0.04743015276489102 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-02", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6885573721204162, + "entropy_nats": 0.6932911268385317, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6310607791207538, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.9759088711227821, + "tvd_gold": 0.08855737212041626, + "stderr": 0.0673335605650376, + "wall_time_ms": 264, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.6885573721204162, + "entailment": 0.019549562616775557, + "neutral": 0.2918930652628082 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-03", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9920306453592204, + "entropy_nats": 0.04974942284378782, + "normalized_entropy": 0.045283876174460946, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.00011124847412144016, + "tvd_gold": 0.07203064535922032, + "wall_time_ms": 134, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.9920306453592204, + "entailment": 0.001157792636177653, + "neutral": 0.006811562004601959 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-04", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "neutral", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.548591951387709, + "entropy_nats": 0.7132854782429909, + "normalized_entropy": 0.649260422080054, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.6068001685851863, + "tvd_gold": 0.05140804861229098, + "stderr": 0.1338217797948031, + "wall_time_ms": 264, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.446983308450538, + "entailment": 0.0044247401617530345, + "neutral": 0.548591951387709 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-05", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "entailment", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9948693962720156, + "entropy_nats": 0.035071553942209864, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03192350413695852, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000042692053814158896, + "tvd_gold": 0.07486939627201561, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.0012989267430764811, + "entailment": 0.9948693962720156, + "neutral": 0.0038316769849078753 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-06", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4810839184446191, + "entropy_nats": 1.0491354127148562, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9549642066963987, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.7931365349419296, + "tvd_gold": 0.1189160815553808, + "stderr": 0.07657021269851898, + "wall_time_ms": 266, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.4810839184446191, + "entailment": 0.23167299716031398, + "neutral": 0.2872430843950669 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-01", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "benign", + "actual": "benign", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9985296283192525, + "entropy_nats": 0.011398193104192319, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008222058333256519, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.0000041185799574797254, + "wall_time_ms": 136, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.9985296283192525, + "failed_injection": 0.000040601604086735745, + "hijacked": 0.000031943843342235255, + "injection_point": 0.001397826233318596 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-02", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "injection_point", + "actual": "injection_point", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9958349765453671, + "entropy_nats": 0.0296533160886261, + "normalized_entropy": 0.021390346033486895, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.00002814782032877084, + "wall_time_ms": 136, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.0008777645413739519, + "failed_injection": 0.00012262752046442288, + "hijacked": 0.0031646313927944565, + "injection_point": 0.9958349765453671 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-03", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "hijacked", + "actual": "hijacked", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9993610531097705, + "entropy_nats": 0.005853979004551287, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0042227532396671265, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 6.296110711873936e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 136, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.00045079909190560096, + "failed_injection": 0.0000792697716373108, + "hijacked": 0.9993610531097705, + "injection_point": 0.00010887802668643065 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-04", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "benign", + "actual": "benign", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9964748345589709, + "entropy_nats": 0.023754669902146038, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017135372232890203, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.000024463410378051388, + "wall_time_ms": 155, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.9964748345589709, + "failed_injection": 0.000025698560844473802, + "hijacked": 0.000030311392914671825, + "injection_point": 0.003469155487270007 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-01", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "card_arrival", + "actual": "card_arrival", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9170519038125, + "entropy_nats": 0.4738202047475712, + "normalized_entropy": 0.14542853448882279, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.007811978600389612, + "stderr": 0.0202244392554557, + "wall_time_ms": 1674, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.006910802776928644, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.013468252598225415, + "atm_support": 0.0010498578522876408, + "automatic_top_up": 0.0004857381116680427, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.0003693529440327282, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 0.00009892338316612952, + "cancel_transfer": 0.00004839238196187783, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.0019020314635402268, + "card_acceptance": 0.002338938382223116, + "card_arrival": 0.9170519038125, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.011989378939814228, + "card_linking": 0.003284284357996513, + "card_not_working": 0.00012007678271782777, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.00010626702964442937, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 0.000008473523352016031, + "card_swallowed": 0.0005478520507732529, + "change_pin": 0.010008709981012902, + "compromised_card": 0.0003682137225494589, + "contactless_not_working": 0.0000262675105968246, + "declined_card_payment": 0.00004958603474700358, + "declined_transfer": 0.00008156386031669231, + "failed_transfer": 0.000035348377012165364, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.019835193423351744, + "pending_top_up": 0.0005942591310049187, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.005051756455220969, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.004168575113355222 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-02", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "pending_top_up", + "actual": "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8024378465828051, + "entropy_nats": 0.5465331761281561, + "normalized_entropy": 0.16774615784099658, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 1.3004456449002857, + "stderr": 0.05813215198824891, + "wall_time_ms": 1674, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.0017943892439284176, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.0012295785203637044, + "atm_support": 0.00003766146379385546, + "automatic_top_up": 0.0014447986329640863, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.8024378465828051, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 0.00006938867637680768, + "cancel_transfer": 0.0000034122272092098287, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.00012387691628991016, + "card_acceptance": 0.00020052581335962537, + "card_arrival": 0.00006145754038809266, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.0000017181622988174517, + "card_linking": 0.0000607724476192111, + "card_not_working": 0.00000967565395630653, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.00004671531385644435, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 0.000004319836562274193, + "card_swallowed": 0.00004254492099127072, + "change_pin": 0.0005260000994745347, + "compromised_card": 0.00002474540944372492, + "contactless_not_working": 0.000008149349386068, + "declined_card_payment": 0.000001215203937770363, + "declined_transfer": 0.00007265304637905222, + "failed_transfer": 0.000022604819389715017, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.000003733126843527091, + "pending_top_up": 0.18973470829454628, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.0011814361236635656, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.0008560725741725752 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-03", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "transaction_charged_twice", + "actual": "transaction_charged_twice", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9994764505481281, + "entropy_nats": 0.005637850289795937, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0017304122895080293, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 3.2335283471540864e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 152, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.00005916282836697445, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.00008753310619198938, + "atm_support": 0.000017203413480593647, + "automatic_top_up": 0.000020389268662188153, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.000006002139297350655, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 2.0159326778744708e-8, + "cancel_transfer": 0.0000014158046146499655, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.000010234803397099067, + "card_acceptance": 0.0000017148727088672099, + "card_arrival": 0.0000023892626918263637, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.000018732490847493638, + "card_linking": 0.000020389268662188153, + "card_not_working": 0.0000017148727088672099, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.000012188557576536062, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 1.4778439379678795e-7, + "card_swallowed": 0.000006002139297350655, + "change_pin": 0.000036489923419344065, + "compromised_card": 0.000013293184407081935, + "contactless_not_working": 0.0000011670940762911372, + "declined_card_payment": 0.0000093731034923204, + "declined_transfer": 6.807281354988156e-7, + "failed_transfer": 1.1367226658201004e-7, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.0000026244295738708103, + "pending_top_up": 0.000008580515224901193, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.9994764505481281, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.00018598602905138653 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-01", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "0.0", + "actual": "0.00", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9999343391586882, + "entropy_nats": 0.0007670834206563609, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0004766157269752832, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 6.194895110387991e-9, + "wall_time_ms": 1511, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.9999343391586882, + "0.2": 0.000014229279179689865, + "0.5": 0.000005601602326963978, + "0.7": 0.000005601602326963978, + "0.9": 0.000040228357478111133 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-02", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "0.2", + "actual": "0.20", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.929704975049831, + "entropy_nats": 0.33523935537596655, + "normalized_entropy": 0.20829592293433263, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0066702150375897015, + "tvd_gold": 0.17970497504983096, + "stderr": 0.01329563163842451, + "wall_time_ms": 1643, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.01088323711688546, + "0.2": 0.929704975049831, + "0.5": 0.02771034297280521, + "0.7": 0.028889620848261133, + "0.9": 0.0028118240122172724 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-03", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "0.9", + "actual": "0.90", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8390714740949301, + "entropy_nats": 0.5412478501501264, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3362961975535594, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.043689519285742565, + "stderr": 0.03383439382065462, + "wall_time_ms": 279, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.004384514765753097, + "0.2": 0.004203644595310875, + "0.5": 0.020713711157523986, + "0.7": 0.13162665538648197, + "0.9": 0.8390714740949301 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-01", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "1", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9681749382627072, + "entropy_nats": 0.17999781673029747, + "normalized_entropy": 0.11183893167899238, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0013440096519159474, + "stderr": 0.0032925313369453557, + "wall_time_ms": 269, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.9681749382627072, + "2": 0.00950404208945825, + "3": 0.005569543515736342, + "4": 0.0024798712926457516, + "5": 0.014271604839452515 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-02", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9810789285238869, + "entropy_nats": 0.11673278996411096, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0725301604133118, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.00047619257684378255, + "tvd_gold": 0.2310789285238869, + "stderr": 0.0038191514526292308, + "wall_time_ms": 275, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.004749957820679615, + "2": 0.008685513537670074, + "3": 0.9810789285238869, + "4": 0.004345841231514676, + "5": 0.0011397588862487684 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-03", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "5", + "actual": "5", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9855884371275552, + "entropy_nats": 0.08643679119282786, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05370619799933853, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.00033595320077688297, + "wall_time_ms": 151, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.011134987494039517, + "2": 0.0007522258334161645, + "3": 0.00177212371157294, + "4": 0.0007522258334161645, + "5": 0.9855884371275552 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-04", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9150880682004906, + "entropy_nats": 0.3647758146254135, + "normalized_entropy": 0.22664795690921039, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.011229228584414518, + "tvd_gold": 0.1650880682004906, + "stderr": 0.022946644733461342, + "wall_time_ms": 268, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.010187979433042501, + "2": 0.005499886442643184, + "3": 0.9150880682004906, + "4": 0.06189905455796525, + "5": 0.007325011365858444 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-01", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "1", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7818517553330173, + "entropy_nats": 0.7152676315197738, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4444207670229472, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.06925888884564488, + "stderr": 0.03821193547244103, + "wall_time_ms": 269, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.7818517553330173, + "1": 0.11040516107676127, + "2": 0.09691071580593012, + "3": 0.009326149879766859, + "4": 0.0015062179045242392 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-02", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "2", + "actual": "2", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.47070416834451967, + "entropy_nats": 0.970219003636212, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6028309611327977, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.48329468957245697, + "stderr": 0.05639679843327608, + "wall_time_ms": 259, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.01734400728346235, + "1": 0.44560483704100856, + "2": 0.47070416834451967, + "3": 0.06538502434666987, + "4": 0.0009619629843396245 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-03", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "0", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9023896630316983, + "entropy_nats": 0.42269636610005945, + "normalized_entropy": 0.26263601896936617, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.013190462121622809, + "stderr": 0.019384184289031495, + "wall_time_ms": 259, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.9023896630316983, + "1": 0.04300232324471003, + "2": 0.040761509492907425, + "3": 0.012220465452055974, + "4": 0.0016260387786282754 + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration_rollback_vertex.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration_rollback_vertex.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cc0e3a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/calibration_rollback_vertex.json @@ -0,0 +1,1722 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T23:02:24Z", + "idc_config": "none", + "target_url": "https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions", + "target_model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "workers": 4, + "total_cases": 50, + "total_correct": 44, + "overall_accuracy_pct": 88, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.205128205128204, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 83.04961970300616, + "avg_confidence": 0.9012386289534349, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.2610803713068672, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.19780956946065176, + "avg_brier_score": 0.16646681142921985, + "ece_10bin": 0.042632924441280036, + "p50_latency_ms": 217.5, + "p95_latency_ms": 1272.2999999999997, + "avg_wall_time_ms": 281.74, + "total_elapsed_sec": 3.541350543, + "temperature_scale": 1, + "jev_parity": { + "protocol_version": "jevbench::v1.4", + "temperature_applied": 1, + "optimal_temperature": 1.05, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.205128205128204, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 83.04961970300616, + "intelligence_score": 84.10326086956523, + "calibration_score": 88.06244546559911, + "speed_score": 78.02349828471462, + "cost_score": 57.55079956087546, + "composite_jevbench_score": 75.93991192665607, + "ece_10bin": 0.042632924441280036, + "brier_mean": 0.16646681142921985, + "soft_tvd_mean": 0.1534852418054576, + "probability_fidelity": 84.65147581945423, + "p50_latency_sec": 0.2175, + "p95_latency_sec": 1.2722999999999998, + "usd_per_1k_decisions": 0.026, + "presets": { + "Balanced 33:33:33 (no calibration)": 72.28195188869739, + "Emphasis on Accuracy 60:20:20": 76.79678811975292, + "Emphasis on Speed 20:60:20": 74.52604774928582, + "JevBench Score (25:25:25:25)": 75.93991192665607 + }, + "raw_t1_ece_10bin": 0.042632924441279856, + "raw_t1_brier_mean": 0.16646681142921987, + "raw_t1_calibration_score": 88.06244546559913, + "raw_t1_composite_score": 75.93991192665607, + "reliability_bins": [ + { + "bin_index": 0, + "range_label": "[0.0, 0.1)", + "lower": 0, + "upper": 0.1, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 1, + "range_label": "[0.1, 0.2)", + "lower": 0.1, + "upper": 0.2, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 2, + "range_label": "[0.2, 0.3)", + "lower": 0.2, + "upper": 0.30000000000000004, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 3, + "range_label": "[0.3, 0.4)", + "lower": 0.30000000000000004, + "upper": 0.4, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 4, + "range_label": "[0.4, 0.5)", + "lower": 0.4, + "upper": 0.5, + "count": 2, + "avg_confidence": 0.4546656732409018, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.5, + "abs_gap": 0.04533432675909821 + }, + { + "bin_index": 5, + "range_label": "[0.5, 0.6)", + "lower": 0.5, + "upper": 0.6000000000000001, + "count": 2, + "avg_confidence": 0.5250592571743169, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0.5250592571743169 + }, + { + "bin_index": 6, + "range_label": "[0.6, 0.7)", + "lower": 0.6000000000000001, + "upper": 0.7000000000000001, + "count": 4, + "avg_confidence": 0.6389528165805164, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.75, + "abs_gap": 0.11104718341948361 + }, + { + "bin_index": 7, + "range_label": "[0.7, 0.8)", + "lower": 0.7000000000000001, + "upper": 0.8, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 8, + "range_label": "[0.8, 0.9)", + "lower": 0.8, + "upper": 0.9, + "count": 7, + "avg_confidence": 0.8635524170401269, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.8571428571428571, + "abs_gap": 0.006409559897269768 + }, + { + "bin_index": 9, + "range_label": "[0.9, 1.0]", + "lower": 0.9, + "upper": 1, + "count": 35, + "avg_confidence": 0.9857658114639528, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.9714285714285714, + "abs_gap": 0.014337240035381393 + } + ], + "endpoint_kind": "gpu", + "raw_speed_score": 85.57951211529972, + "adjusted_speed_score": 78.02349828471462, + "v14_intelligence_score": 84.10326086956523, + "v14_calibration_score": 88.06244546559911, + "v14_composite_score": 74.85264045954096, + "v14_public_only_estimate": true + }, + "categories": [ + { + "name": "agent-trajectory", + "total": 7, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 35.714285714285715, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9983233010994851, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.011631151279087525, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.00977585141156707, + "avg_brier_score": 0.000016479841831062998, + "ece_10bin": 0.0016766989005149169, + "avg_latency_ms": 132.85714285714286 + }, + { + "name": "emotion", + "total": 4, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 3.8461538461538463, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.8755425792166093, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.39911207503507323, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.12249854182572467, + "avg_brier_score": 0.06196654901893351, + "ece_10bin": 0.12445742078339067, + "avg_latency_ms": 188 + }, + { + "name": "grounding", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9957368771082851, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.027398915533923474, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.039528279566526985, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00003840330340598425, + "ece_10bin": 0.004263122891714932, + "avg_latency_ms": 118 + }, + { + "name": "guardrail", + "total": 4, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9915797593126893, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.04759192752610088, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.0686606378282527, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00017896404164000328, + "ece_10bin": 0.008420240687310732, + "avg_latency_ms": 131.75 + }, + { + "name": "intent", + "total": 7, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 6.41025641025641, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9340748364621153, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.1827513732235672, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.058208235750029404, + "avg_brier_score": 0.03761355299746211, + "ece_10bin": 0.06592516353788481, + "avg_latency_ms": 496.42857142857144 + }, + { + "name": "nli", + "total": 3, + "correct": 0, + "accuracy_pct": 0, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "avg_confidence": 0.7619640439216643, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.5432337130736384, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.49447263486577403, + "avg_brier_score": 1.5477611471757635, + "ece_10bin": 0.7619640439216642, + "avg_latency_ms": 373.3333333333333 + }, + { + "name": "nli-soft", + "total": 6, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 66.66666666666666, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 49.99999999999999, + "avg_confidence": 0.7659075478126708, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.4859144345782284, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.4422983791373037, + "avg_brier_score": 0.36251976174148454, + "ece_10bin": 0.30395523686661624, + "avg_latency_ms": 196.5 + }, + { + "name": "ordinal", + "total": 7, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 20, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.867590944862126, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.42816384851212214, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.266033156796071, + "avg_brier_score": 0.053417108825566835, + "ece_10bin": 0.13240905513787407, + "avg_latency_ms": 215.42857142857142 + }, + { + "name": "reading-comprehension", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9170355522039488, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.2807972032803834, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.4051047326680993, + "avg_brier_score": 0.01530686239809184, + "ece_10bin": 0.08296444779605117, + "avg_latency_ms": 243.5 + }, + { + "name": "retrieval", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9923122196138539, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.0448630268637043, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.06472366637553455, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00012485950235544463, + "ece_10bin": 0.007687780386146148, + "avg_latency_ms": 176.5 + }, + { + "name": "toxicity", + "total": 6, + "correct": 5, + "accuracy_pct": 83.33333333333334, + "chance_baseline_pct": 35, + "chance_corrected_pct": 74.35897435897438, + "avg_confidence": 0.8836686333492109, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.2763453176581527, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.2719665850119228, + "avg_brier_score": 0.09801437753012927, + "ece_10bin": 0.1250777323817323, + "avg_latency_ms": 586.6666666666666 + } + ], + "tiers": [ + { + "name": "adversarial", + "total": 5, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 60, + "chance_baseline_pct": 43.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 29.41176470588236, + "avg_confidence": 0.9551692336288375, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.17571077683559025, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.17378619185286923, + "avg_brier_score": 0.6644765302926308, + "ece_10bin": 0.3551692336288375, + "avg_latency_ms": 226.8 + }, + { + "name": "ambiguous", + "total": 9, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 77.77777777777779, + "chance_baseline_pct": 27.891737891737893, + "chance_corrected_pct": 69.18214144606874, + "avg_confidence": 0.8516213527241607, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.3434531006242799, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.2943661765893796, + "avg_brier_score": 0.21428550206363783, + "ece_10bin": 0.15129268942472834, + "avg_latency_ms": 347.44444444444446 + }, + { + "name": "easy", + "total": 17, + "correct": 17, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 31.138763197586727, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9641309575066733, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.1309783630245505, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.06869786772153201, + "avg_brier_score": 0.015061467445066992, + "ece_10bin": 0.03586904249332657, + "avg_latency_ms": 225.94117647058823 + }, + { + "name": "held-out", + "total": 8, + "correct": 8, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 21.442307692307693, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.8316051396060368, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.4778898422487655, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.3104101736651608, + "avg_brier_score": 0.08013000800605301, + "ece_10bin": 0.16839486039396317, + "avg_latency_ms": 501.875 + }, + { + "name": "high-entropy", + "total": 3, + "correct": 1, + "accuracy_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "avg_confidence": 0.544015202680831, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.9056731375852346, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.8243792163322855, + "avg_brier_score": 0.724585105234821, + "ece_10bin": 0.5957103666777432, + "avg_latency_ms": 237.33333333333334 + }, + { + "name": "localization", + "total": 3, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 25, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9968871493047816, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.0202427427751157, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.014602052307825157, + "avg_brier_score": 0.000037488115975763685, + "ece_10bin": 0.003112850695218383, + "avg_latency_ms": 132.66666666666666 + }, + { + "name": "low-entropy", + "total": 3, + "correct": 3, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9877998929445108, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.06615573157122205, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.060217541942321824, + "avg_brier_score": 0.0004544182481480536, + "ece_10bin": 0.01220010705548924, + "avg_latency_ms": 155.66666666666666 + }, + { + "name": "out-of-scope", + "total": 2, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 8.333333333333332, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9961594878789946, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.02921051517234423, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.011755176064596359, + "avg_brier_score": 0.00003617800685114195, + "ece_10bin": 0.003840512121005446, + "avg_latency_ms": 196.5 + } + ], + "cases": [ + { + "id": "tox-01", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9995253818210019, + "entropy_nats": 0.004106758411534803, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005924799994450297, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 4.5052483167090006e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 208, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9995253818210019, + "yes": 0.00047461817899813993 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-02", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9940260394431708, + "entropy_nats": 0.03654482084786397, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05272303180738896, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00007137640946910195, + "wall_time_ms": 218, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.005973960556829179, + "yes": 0.9940260394431708 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-03", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-check", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5262390971928295, + "entropy_nats": 0.6917695673946511, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9980125243181668, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.5538551748286484, + "tvd_gold": 0.27623909719282946, + "stderr": 0.04141516426599375, + "wall_time_ms": 315, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.47376090280717054, + "yes": 0.5262390971928295 + } + }, + { + "id": "marco-01", + "metric": "calibration/ms-marco-passage-relevance-check", + "category": "retrieval", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9941364410675455, + "entropy_nats": 0.03597915532673065, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05190694896524804, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00006876264670873376, + "wall_time_ms": 217, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9941364410675455, + "yes": 0.005863558932454567 + } + }, + { + "id": "marco-02", + "metric": "calibration/ms-marco-passage-relevance-check", + "category": "retrieval", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9904879981601622, + "entropy_nats": 0.05374689840067796, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07754038378582105, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00018095635800215547, + "tvd_gold": 0.2404879981601622, + "wall_time_ms": 136, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.009512001839837712, + "yes": 0.9904879981601622 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-01", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.993510021320329, + "entropy_nats": 0.0391621149157013, + "normalized_entropy": 0.056498988979605966, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00008423964652516955, + "wall_time_ms": 127, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.993510021320329, + "yes": 0.00648997867967109 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-02", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9927313888234878, + "entropy_nats": 0.04303415334930483, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06208515962589725, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.000105665416870637, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0072686111765122895, + "yes": 0.9927313888234878 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-03", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9843588011970996, + "entropy_nats": 0.08055194236360685, + "normalized_entropy": 0.11621188778194921, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0004892941999837045, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.01564119880290038, + "yes": 0.9843588011970996 + } + }, + { + "id": "pi-04", + "metric": "calibration/prompt-injection-check", + "category": "guardrail", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9957188259098407, + "entropy_nats": 0.027619499475790548, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03984651492555835, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00003665690318050206, + "wall_time_ms": 150, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9957188259098407, + "yes": 0.004281174090159298 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-01", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9996260776152701, + "entropy_nats": 0.003324646872831339, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004796451556140773, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 2.7963589960416915e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9996260776152701, + "yes": 0.00037392238472985144 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-02", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9992295231318423, + "entropy_nats": 0.006293344117071385, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00907937634830662, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.0000011872692087321242, + "wall_time_ms": 149, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0007704768681577319, + "yes": 0.9992295231318423 + } + }, + { + "id": "ad-03", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-drift-check", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9995614415495073, + "entropy_nats": 0.0038294038654940444, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005524661966309285, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 3.8466702899707476e-7, + "tvd_gold": 0.24956144154950732, + "wall_time_ms": 139, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9995614415495073, + "yes": 0.00043855845049265335 + } + }, + { + "id": "ground-01", + "metric": "calibration/grounding-claim-support-check", + "category": "grounding", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9947232524671439, + "entropy_nats": 0.032936415108233204, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04751720274130838, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.00005568812905100627, + "wall_time_ms": 131, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0052767475328561525, + "yes": 0.9947232524671439 + } + }, + { + "id": "ground-02", + "metric": "calibration/grounding-claim-support-check", + "category": "grounding", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9967505017494264, + "entropy_nats": 0.021861415959613745, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03153935639174559, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.000021118477760962224, + "wall_time_ms": 105, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9967505017494264, + "yes": 0.0032494982505736902 + } + }, + { + "id": "boolq-01", + "metric": "calibration/boolq-passage-answer-check", + "category": "reading-comprehension", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "true", + "actual": "true", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9447904004460528, + "entropy_nats": 0.21357784524808265, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3081276981831593, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.006096199765814418, + "stderr": 0.023746262243989253, + "wall_time_ms": 218, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.05520959955394728, + "yes": 0.9447904004460528 + } + }, + { + "id": "boolq-02", + "metric": "calibration/boolq-passage-answer-check", + "category": "reading-comprehension", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "false", + "actual": "false", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8892807039618449, + "entropy_nats": 0.34801656131268416, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5020817671530393, + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "brier_score": 0.02451752503036926, + "stderr": 0.019378595564169755, + "wall_time_ms": 269, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.8892807039618449, + "yes": 0.11071929603815511 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-01", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "sadness", + "actual": "sadness", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6139673646770131, + "entropy_nats": 1.1144588004536038, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3420582501003399, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.22934030708008157, + "stderr": 0.020576329160432755, + "wall_time_ms": 245, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.0038495046112992813, + "amusement": 0.0004624809684721372, + "anger": 0.0023874723396776986, + "annoyance": 0.02968847642811872, + "approval": 0.0013033406513016188, + "caring": 0.00018350294078705394, + "confusion": 0.00039749421880871347, + "curiosity": 0.0002112010974641474, + "desire": 0.0009379402055579616, + "disappointment": 0.2795913282306054, + "disapproval": 0.005032138118979996, + "disgust": 0.00035583490443750007, + "embarrassment": 0.0007746659477020428, + "excitement": 0.00020594873036214697, + "fear": 0.00013131148010320608, + "gratitude": 0.0005517268603396997, + "joy": 0.0009343175607713725, + "love": 0.00026721881888317037, + "neutral": 0.030829569848888853, + "optimism": 0.00041912055661803794, + "pride": 0.00019902724381097098, + "realization": 0.00963199684023234, + "relief": 0.0022731911244359376, + "remorse": 0.0028040153752885498, + "sadness": 0.6139673646770131, + "surprise": 0.012609810220040533 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-02", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "gratitude", + "actual": "gratitude", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9962320685855027, + "entropy_nats": 0.03238595169888208, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009940144903916455, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.00001844282750764401, + "wall_time_ms": 116, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.00014221122256854803, + "amusement": 0.00013091794386498637, + "anger": 0.00003298879750441875, + "annoyance": 0.00005598391212939384, + "approval": 0.0000301632619363648, + "caring": 0.00006656450738025829, + "confusion": 0.00005598391212939384, + "curiosity": 0.00002756874526794968, + "desire": 0.00005598391212939384, + "disappointment": 0.00023168422379227905, + "disapproval": 0.00015441741115732136, + "disgust": 0.00014221122256854803, + "embarrassment": 0.0000301632619363648, + "excitement": 0.00010189328706593374, + "fear": 0.000005360641881004924, + "gratitude": 0.9962320685855027, + "joy": 0.0020038766145960177, + "love": 0.00005131144323582338, + "neutral": 0.00008604120011621586, + "optimism": 0.00002756874526794968, + "pride": 0.000020999093450988857, + "realization": 0.000036064600451303214, + "relief": 0.000013235729751135723, + "remorse": 0.000020999093450988857, + "sadness": 0.000012054407072434053, + "surprise": 0.00023168422379227905 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-03", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "confusion", + "actual": "confusion", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.89496155934371, + "entropy_nats": 0.4233962479472836, + "normalized_entropy": 0.129952026591697, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.018496403165811918, + "tvd_gold": 0.14496155934371002, + "stderr": 0.02927380725117882, + "wall_time_ms": 263, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.0004983319679122382, + "amusement": 0.0002461008866821308, + "anger": 0.00048358315342307047, + "annoyance": 0.0007726251681304246, + "approval": 0.00007964442370470922, + "caring": 0.00003219675523228632, + "confusion": 0.89496155934371, + "curiosity": 0.08582442026540257, + "desire": 0.00010761079138763832, + "disappointment": 0.0001902384186847547, + "disapproval": 0.0004276298591431129, + "disgust": 0.00017727615340570852, + "embarrassment": 0.00020348586123494894, + "excitement": 0.0003259389355790639, + "fear": 0.00003374322877568429, + "gratitude": 0.0001657800066051002, + "joy": 0.0008711073739913534, + "love": 0.00016472178699021578, + "neutral": 0.0017038299812063922, + "optimism": 0.00002549114887436558, + "pride": 0.000060217019710739425, + "realization": 0.0031855837156315736, + "relief": 0.00001863101839666032, + "remorse": 0.000052993889419832535, + "sadness": 0.00033427526001658463, + "surprise": 0.009052983586748855 + } + }, + { + "id": "emo-04", + "metric": "calibration/go-emotions-emotion-select", + "category": "emotion", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "neutral", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9970093242602115, + "entropy_nats": 0.02620730004052366, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008043745706945306, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.000011043002332910824, + "tvd_gold": 0.2470093242602115, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "admiration": 0.0003039697855726223, + "amusement": 0.00007607518171188137, + "anger": 0.000008962363690192242, + "annoyance": 0.00015453525599108545, + "approval": 0.00005060262365920139, + "caring": 0.000014023727407477505, + "confusion": 0.00001073290957304064, + "curiosity": 0.000004709632892219742, + "desire": 0.000014023727407477505, + "disappointment": 0.00003943139313309465, + "disapproval": 0.00003943139313309465, + "disgust": 0.000011738312032871145, + "embarrassment": 0.00003625640484393637, + "excitement": 0.000021725967452542363, + "fear": 0.0000032326816081741955, + "gratitude": 0.00004286740635655555, + "joy": 0.0006655479279823337, + "love": 0.00001283276643780416, + "neutral": 0.9970093242602115, + "optimism": 0.0000016485323115756103, + "pride": 0.0000014235259270220793, + "realization": 0.00007607518171188137, + "relief": 0.000008184977556311788, + "remorse": 0.0000051691468189519765, + "sadness": 0.00016686314299337875, + "surprise": 0.0012206117715838204 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-01", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "bill_balance", + "actual": "bill_balance", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9902509018744544, + "entropy_nats": 0.07035048634387353, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02831111838743539, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.0001199146467711555, + "wall_time_ms": 115, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.00047919223423824423, + "balance": 0.0015423086703241146, + "bill_balance": 0.9902509018744544, + "bill_due": 0.0015423086703241146, + "freeze_account": 0.00029420321182839363, + "interest_rate": 0.000008800347440347128, + "min_payment": 0.000040604397025496964, + "out_of_scope": 0.004172430448509115, + "pay_bill": 0.0015423086703241146, + "pin_change": 0.000014863402695596138, + "routing": 0.00005603903641798807, + "transfer": 0.00005603903641798807 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-02", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "freeze_account", + "actual": "freeze_account", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9966944292430922, + "entropy_nats": 0.026382103060531837, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01061693929741088, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000014747681280887302, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.0013624713173290375, + "balance": 0.00016834690893196912, + "bill_balance": 0.00000837747144945541, + "bill_due": 0.00011720988746274387, + "freeze_account": 0.9966944292430922, + "interest_rate": 0.000001993208357160913, + "min_payment": 0.000005907005010618217, + "out_of_scope": 0.0013624713173290375, + "pay_bill": 0.0002566332716109701, + "pin_change": 0.00000452625983790975, + "routing": 0.000009952782829379132, + "transfer": 0.000007681326759679617 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-03", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "out-of-scope", + "expected": "out_of_scope", + "actual": "out_of_scope", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9997565929831389, + "entropy_nats": 0.002738953979592599, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0011022361664275286, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 7.003346036760498e-8, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.0000643347817489966, + "balance": 0.000027174894335716328, + "bill_balance": 0.000004193054580941234, + "bill_due": 0.000034540123713254665, + "freeze_account": 0.000016640378727868412, + "interest_rate": 0.0000013948864724191134, + "min_payment": 0.000008460708898573911, + "out_of_scope": 0.9997565929831389, + "pay_bill": 0.0000643347817489966, + "pin_change": 0.0000026690983500834736, + "routing": 0.000007760755302564626, + "transfer": 0.000011903552981721317 + } + }, + { + "id": "clinc-04", + "metric": "calibration/clinc-oos-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "out-of-scope", + "expected": "out_of_scope", + "actual": "out_of_scope", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9925623827748503, + "entropy_nats": 0.05568207636509586, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02240811596276519, + "vocab_cardinality": 12, + "chance_baseline": 0.08333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.0000722859802419163, + "wall_time_ms": 273, + "top_probabilities": { + "account_blocked": 0.0008644911452409701, + "balance": 0.0003197126139270134, + "bill_balance": 0.00027563158014042244, + "bill_due": 0.00012819036855482422, + "freeze_account": 0.00010946774156342239, + "interest_rate": 0.003768739789999622, + "min_payment": 0.00012819036855482422, + "out_of_scope": 0.9925623827748503, + "pay_bill": 0.0012108455526947184, + "pin_change": 0.000005331804183870316, + "routing": 0.00005728753954191565, + "transfer": 0.0005697287207480293 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-01", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9138947736912604, + "entropy_nats": 0.3187714819216458, + "normalized_entropy": 0.29015830717504976, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.6841257330329102, + "stderr": 0.053685671815687244, + "wall_time_ms": 377, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.07866040447585942, + "entailment": 0.9138947736912604, + "neutral": 0.007444821832880181 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-02", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "adversarial", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8851232655965604, + "entropy_nats": 0.42974954445729435, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3911748929900433, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.6377098488493187, + "stderr": 0.04834077135036923, + "wall_time_ms": 377, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.07653034278393167, + "entailment": 0.8851232655965604, + "neutral": 0.038346391619508 + } + }, + { + "id": "anli-03", + "metric": "calibration/anli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4868740924771719, + "entropy_nats": 0.8811801128419752, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8020847044322289, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 1.3214478596450618, + "tvd_gold": 0.23687409247717195, + "stderr": 0.11774282772442646, + "wall_time_ms": 366, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.4515011836627691, + "entailment": 0.4868740924771719, + "neutral": 0.06162472386005898 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-01", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "entailment", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9738249349854984, + "entropy_nats": 0.12956878961887508, + "normalized_entropy": 0.11793859485766027, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.0012493037352389426, + "tvd_gold": 0.05382493498549834, + "stderr": 0.0037707498653369582, + "wall_time_ms": 220, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.0025613106667977193, + "entailment": 0.9738249349854984, + "neutral": 0.023613754347703884 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-02", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5238794171558044, + "entropy_nats": 0.9638899642543727, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8773704556162703, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.707842892101104, + "tvd_gold": 0.07612058284419554, + "stderr": 0.07183489835951937, + "wall_time_ms": 240, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.5238794171558044, + "entailment": 0.12287740806443596, + "neutral": 0.35324317477975953 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-03", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "contradiction", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9918814737333803, + "entropy_nats": 0.05217435579353033, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04749114526725651, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.00010375314422031651, + "tvd_gold": 0.07188147373338027, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.9918814737333803, + "entailment": 0.0024960227315120407, + "neutral": 0.0056225035351076405 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-04", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "contradiction", + "actual": "neutral", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6857089368820569, + "entropy_nats": 0.6806904251285222, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6195911261412793, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.960433392503027, + "tvd_gold": 0.08570893688205694, + "stderr": 0.018365624431298997, + "wall_time_ms": 235, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.299977312561854, + "entailment": 0.014313750556089069, + "neutral": 0.6857089368820569 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-05", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "low-entropy", + "expected": "entailment", + "actual": "entailment", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9976932701146538, + "entropy_nats": 0.016724049301260743, + "normalized_entropy": 0.015222885702048682, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.000010197864984901563, + "tvd_gold": 0.07769327011465377, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.00010066345626360885, + "entailment": 0.9976932701146538, + "neutral": 0.0022060664290826262 + } + }, + { + "id": "chaos-06", + "metric": "calibration/chaos-nli-entailment-select", + "category": "nli-soft", + "tier": "high-entropy", + "expected": "neutral", + "actual": "neutral", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.42245725400463163, + "entropy_nats": 1.0724390233728094, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9761760672393069, + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "brier_score": 0.505479031100332, + "tvd_gold": 0.02245725400463161, + "stderr": 0.08363603900828781, + "wall_time_ms": 237, + "top_probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.23804861714527578, + "entailment": 0.3394941288500926, + "neutral": 0.42245725400463163 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-01", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "benign", + "actual": "benign", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9991846174854317, + "entropy_nats": 0.007242435772868818, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005224313086737336, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.0000010429727528165665, + "wall_time_ms": 119, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.9991846174854317, + "failed_injection": 0.0001186149565662165, + "hijacked": 0.00010209930436891081, + "injection_point": 0.0005946682536331489 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-02", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "injection_point", + "actual": "injection_point", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9997377057061719, + "entropy_nats": 0.002549901408679189, + "normalized_entropy": 0.001839365058528624, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 1.2138348095555189e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.00022796397209085874, + "failed_injection": 0.000020928557875064575, + "hijacked": 0.000013401763862067968, + "injection_point": 0.9997377057061719 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-03", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "hijacked", + "actual": "hijacked", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9983417729357298, + "entropy_nats": 0.013684117974035253, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009871004570040094, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.000004148263148471669, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.0011152448548011336, + "failed_injection": 0.00021082717091456868, + "hijacked": 0.9983417729357298, + "injection_point": 0.000332155038554618 + } + }, + { + "id": "adlab-04", + "metric": "calibration/agent-step-label-select", + "category": "agent-trajectory", + "tier": "localization", + "expected": "benign", + "actual": "benign", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9925819692724434, + "entropy_nats": 0.04449420894263265, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03209578729490675, + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "brier_score": 0.00010819470129786384, + "wall_time_ms": 154, + "top_probabilities": { + "benign": 0.9925819692724434, + "failed_injection": 0.000048379851771345966, + "hijacked": 0.00007862911785199827, + "injection_point": 0.00729102175793336 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-01", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "card_arrival", + "actual": "card_arrival", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9219869658266583, + "entropy_nats": 0.40318827269656515, + "normalized_entropy": 0.12374963970263632, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.008323511988969912, + "stderr": 0.007891537482948843, + "wall_time_ms": 1353, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.005989659757952318, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.003505742393094032, + "atm_support": 0.00024001010313010783, + "automatic_top_up": 0.0009597467854853942, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.00045737709793176786, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 0.00011575180816596809, + "cancel_transfer": 0.00008958452594447844, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.0005162922768956536, + "card_acceptance": 0.0010590160941283937, + "card_arrival": 0.9219869658266583, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.04603792139656742, + "card_linking": 0.0052092899921558355, + "card_not_working": 0.00025997560427795994, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.00014723331949210135, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 0.00000361720433893413, + "card_swallowed": 0.0004925999521049939, + "change_pin": 0.0038240771968184807, + "compromised_card": 0.00016038549833998124, + "contactless_not_working": 0.000017331862323346874, + "declined_card_payment": 0.00003956272587376536, + "declined_transfer": 0.00006952908693376283, + "failed_transfer": 0.000038269209402649154, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.0030296418299076916, + "pending_top_up": 0.00023205776562690007, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.0021935848733898554, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.0033247758130600263 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-02", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "pending_top_up", + "actual": "pending_top_up", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.639853570962882, + "entropy_nats": 0.6990882425250634, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2145695298978443, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.25475510427283155, + "stderr": 0.06026920712606249, + "wall_time_ms": 1355, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.0006819906056681555, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.0010434606788243617, + "atm_support": 0.000013260213286383106, + "automatic_top_up": 0.002041433848096379, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.3536126110102365, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 0.000019506142075547903, + "cancel_transfer": 0.000008099754776760039, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.00010468835413248299, + "card_acceptance": 0.000016036672646424407, + "card_arrival": 0.00002339051490213694, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.0000012990734002239683, + "card_linking": 0.00010822101830846979, + "card_not_working": 0.000008703965915104863, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.00002266936034363504, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 0.0000018799839305763667, + "card_swallowed": 0.000021781211767072682, + "change_pin": 0.0004443177293482688, + "compromised_card": 0.00002962910802069559, + "contactless_not_working": 0.000002890782307766161, + "declined_card_payment": 4.1323897145732303e-7, + "declined_transfer": 0.00008167738351343836, + "failed_transfer": 0.000013329041965707533, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.000005129785982920055, + "pending_top_up": 0.639853570962882, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.0006643475314836486, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.0011756620272138172 + } + }, + { + "id": "b77-03", + "metric": "calibration/banking77-intent-select", + "category": "intent", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "transaction_charged_twice", + "actual": "transaction_charged_twice", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9974190115697303, + "entropy_nats": 0.021829477594247793, + "normalized_entropy": 0.006700070835686165, + "vocab_cardinality": 26, + "chance_baseline": 0.038461538461538464, + "brier_score": 0.000009236378678951248, + "wall_time_ms": 136, + "top_probabilities": { + "activate_my_card": 0.0003798507843310514, + "apple_pay_or_google_pay": 0.00006801882020785168, + "atm_support": 0.000007550010265023075, + "automatic_top_up": 0.00001977856571088189, + "balance_not_updated_after_bank_transfer": 0.0000579916811240748, + "beneficiary_not_allowed": 1.306876915231585e-7, + "cancel_transfer": 0.000003017276358493615, + "card_about_to_expire": 0.000009027143821040945, + "card_acceptance": 0.000005256174595626376, + "card_arrival": 0.000009027143821040945, + "card_delivery_estimate": 0.00005351469691694059, + "card_linking": 0.000016661417954974726, + "card_not_working": 0.0000036362098533401126, + "card_payment_fee_charged": 0.000025504382281588744, + "card_payment_not_recognised": 4.992434420231379e-7, + "card_swallowed": 0.000009864919215036762, + "change_pin": 0.0002858863984676787, + "compromised_card": 0.00005351469691694059, + "contactless_not_working": 0.000001551214193138916, + "declined_card_payment": 0.000003989427020533254, + "declined_transfer": 0.000009027143821040945, + "failed_transfer": 0.0000022740133194238797, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.000008257255475703564, + "pending_top_up": 0.00001977856571088189, + "transaction_charged_twice": 0.9974190115697303, + "transfer_not_received_by_recipient": 0.0015273805577537606 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-01", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "0.0", + "actual": "0.00", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9983553232638073, + "entropy_nats": 0.01389333744201951, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008632415910351797, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0000038699600013226885, + "wall_time_ms": 1214, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.9983553232638073, + "0.2": 0.0009756027275894846, + "0.5": 0.00008318848815382418, + "0.7": 0.00016132492979967602, + "0.9": 0.0004245605906497782 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-02", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "0.2", + "actual": "0.20", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9185083328701555, + "entropy_nats": 0.36985171550664103, + "normalized_entropy": 0.22980179145107898, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.009230662547706917, + "tvd_gold": 0.16850833287015554, + "stderr": 0.004530264906739705, + "wall_time_ms": 1320, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.037710335897437657, + "0.2": 0.9185083328701555, + "0.5": 0.03335806084867539, + "0.7": 0.005767870878357989, + "0.9": 0.004655399505373397 + } + }, + { + "id": "tox-s-03", + "metric": "calibration/civil-comments-toxicity-rate", + "category": "toxicity", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "0.9", + "actual": "0.90", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8653576255043002, + "entropy_nats": 0.5419057063462056, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3367049465900999, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.024924730910118226, + "stderr": 0.03382260870433078, + "wall_time_ms": 245, + "top_probabilities": { + "0.0": 0.016680484038127538, + "0.2": 0.0039791398717578435, + "0.5": 0.05873150213579946, + "0.7": 0.055251248450015056, + "0.9": 0.8653576255043002 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-01", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "1", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9720056642028677, + "entropy_nats": 0.15886882330954616, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0987107499345994, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0010911317066652263, + "stderr": 0.007935390639697124, + "wall_time_ms": 240, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.9720056642028677, + "2": 0.006093495225664612, + "3": 0.00473719197650661, + "4": 0.001490217233158134, + "5": 0.015673431361802895 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-02", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9840356340702405, + "entropy_nats": 0.10332746736793424, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06420096517526586, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0003234704609940504, + "tvd_gold": 0.23403563407024053, + "stderr": 0.0037091246135593785, + "wall_time_ms": 238, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.004224191604465417, + "2": 0.0046344733289595845, + "3": 0.9840356340702405, + "4": 0.004974442982330179, + "5": 0.002131258014004302 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-03", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "easy", + "expected": "5", + "actual": "5", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9906701570871883, + "entropy_nats": 0.05976311804055543, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03713291303680687, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.0001431091023953098, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.0074044858460318545, + "2": 0.0006285169163875682, + "3": 0.0006285169163875682, + "4": 0.0006683232340046953, + "5": 0.9906701570871883 + } + }, + { + "id": "yelp-04", + "metric": "calibration/yelp-review-stars-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "ambiguous", + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8669146945934588, + "entropy_nats": 0.5377691922533382, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3341347858769032, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.025023563897153264, + "tvd_gold": 0.11691469459345882, + "stderr": 0.012429383490494066, + "wall_time_ms": 222, + "top_probabilities": { + "1": 0.02638479204724186, + "2": 0.009101983198833222, + "3": 0.8669146945934588, + "4": 0.07854926917881411, + "5": 0.019049260981652008 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-01", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "1", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8271924119184983, + "entropy_nats": 0.574892056588922, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3572005183595185, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.049001193814710776, + "stderr": 0.02244872857904024, + "wall_time_ms": 222, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.8271924119184983, + "1": 0.13495112525242783, + "2": 0.02967371313700767, + "3": 0.006632748654570101, + "4": 0.0015500010374961744 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-02", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "2", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6162813938001136, + "entropy_nats": 0.8940537901188007, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5555068531762379, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.2505472276437561, + "stderr": 0.025231766757863115, + "wall_time_ms": 231, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.02625558802514162, + "1": 0.6162813938001136, + "2": 0.31818752450275667, + "3": 0.03700610954589057, + "4": 0.0022693841260976017 + } + }, + { + "id": "sst5-03", + "metric": "calibration/sst5-sentiment-rate", + "category": "ordinal", + "tier": "held-out", + "expected": "0", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8160366583625143, + "entropy_nats": 0.6684724919057584, + "normalized_entropy": 0.41534531201316505, + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "brier_score": 0.04779006515329314, + "stderr": 0.04253217414566576, + "wall_time_ms": 231, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.8160366583625143, + "1": 0.10149094135784291, + "2": 0.05652249098150099, + "3": 0.020579296373276375, + "4": 0.005370612924865472 + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/contract_rollback_cloudrun.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/contract_rollback_cloudrun.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3392085 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/contract_rollback_cloudrun.json @@ -0,0 +1,831 @@ +{ + "health": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "body": { + "status": "ok", + "server": "dgem-structured-server", + "vllm_ready": false, + "phase": "staging_tmpfs", + "bytes_staged_gb": 0.0, + "boot_ts": 1790635338.935399, + "stage_start_ts": 1790635338.999826 + } + } + }, + "cases": { + "triage_s1": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9794809554761067, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9794809554761067, + "no": 0.020519044523893235 + }, + "noul": 0.9794809554761067 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.9748278349258633, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.024488219890708512, + "support": 0.0006839451834283018, + "engineering": 0.9748278349258633 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9893275713532491, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.006691029686497045, + "frustrated": 0.9893275713532491, + "furious": 0.003981398960253843 + }, + "score": 1.9972903692737567, + "level": "frustrated" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 91458.71782302856, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.9794809554761067, + "no": 0.020519044523893235 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.024488219890708512, + "support": 0.0006839451834283018, + "engineering": 0.9748278349258633 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.006691029686497045, + "frustrated": 0.9893275713532491, + "furious": 0.003981398960253843 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2" + } + } + }, + "triage_s4": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9468836377410987, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9468836377410987, + "no": 0.053116362258901276 + }, + "noul": 0.9468836377410987, + "stderr": 0.021595451723594384, + "agreement": 1.0 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.9413688264194429, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.055938936108213724, + "support": 0.0026922374723433932, + "engineering": 0.9413688264194429 + }, + "choice": "engineering", + "stderr": 0.011696036119967753, + "agreement": 1.0 + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9834006241636751, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.01005942244945491, + "frustrated": 0.9834006241636751, + "furious": 0.006539953386869948 + }, + "score": 1.996480530937415, + "level": "frustrated", + "stderr": 0.003066445317634698, + "agreement": 1.0 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 4, + "denoise_ms": 91457.56125450134, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.9468836377410987, + "no": 0.053116362258901276 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.055938936108213724, + "support": 0.0026922374723433932, + "engineering": 0.9413688264194429 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.01005942244945491, + "frustrated": 0.9834006241636751, + "furious": 0.006539953386869948 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2" + } + } + }, + "samples_string": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 400, + "error": "schema: samples must be a positive count or \"auto\"" + } + }, + "default_samples": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9794809554761067, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9794809554761067, + "no": 0.020519044523893235 + }, + "noul": 0.9794809554761067 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.9748278349258633, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.024488219890708512, + "support": 0.0006839451834283018, + "engineering": 0.9748278349258633 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9893275713532491, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.006691029686497045, + "frustrated": 0.9893275713532491, + "furious": 0.003981398960253843 + }, + "score": 1.9972903692737567, + "level": "frustrated" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 91454.96201515198, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.9794809554761067, + "no": 0.020519044523893235 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.024488219890708512, + "support": 0.0006839451834283018, + "engineering": 0.9748278349258633 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.006691029686497045, + "frustrated": 0.9893275713532491, + "furious": 0.003981398960253843 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2" + } + } + }, + "mirror_s1": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.8518040627724602, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.8518040627724602, + "no": 0.14819593722753982 + }, + "noul": 0.8518040627724602 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.8624406365940793, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.13629326277679935, + "support": 0.0012661006291213497, + "engineering": 0.8624406365940793 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9317971807886221, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.058611639027540276, + "frustrated": 0.9317971807886221, + "furious": 0.00959118018383762 + }, + "score": 1.9509795411562973, + "level": "frustrated" + }, + "urgent__rev": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "A", + "confidence": 0.8138439633001073, + "probabilities": { + "no": 0.8138439633001073, + "yes": 0.1861560366998927 + }, + "choice": "no" + }, + "team__rev": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "A", + "confidence": 0.9522892857470563, + "probabilities": { + "engineering": 0.9522892857470563, + "support": 0.014868217827145348, + "billing": 0.03284249642579831 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment__rev": { + "type": "score", + "label": "3", + "confidence": 0.771446635697799, + "probabilities": { + "furious": 0.09793673701972952, + "frustrated": 0.1306166272824715, + "calm": 0.771446635697799 + }, + "score": 2.67350989867807, + "level": "calm" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 91434.8247051239, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.8518040627724602, + "no": 0.14819593722753982 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.13629326277679935, + "support": 0.0012661006291213497, + "engineering": 0.8624406365940793 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.058611639027540276, + "frustrated": 0.9317971807886221, + "furious": 0.00959118018383762 + }, + "urgent__rev": { + "no": 0.8138439633001073, + "yes": 0.1861560366998927 + }, + "team__rev": { + "engineering": 0.9522892857470563, + "support": 0.014868217827145348, + "billing": 0.03284249642579831 + }, + "sentiment__rev": { + "furious": 0.09793673701972952, + "frustrated": 0.1306166272824715, + "calm": 0.771446635697799 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2", + "urgent__rev": "A", + "team__rev": "A", + "sentiment__rev": "3" + } + } + }, + "think120": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "department": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "D", + "confidence": 0.9900434260009825, + "probabilities": { + "it_helpdesk": 6.957419350486225e-05, + "hr_people_ops": 0.009861242814499804, + "facilities": 2.575699101288641e-05, + "other_unclassified": 0.9900434260009825 + }, + "choice": "other_unclassified" + }, + "requires_new_category": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9915395208030443, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9915395208030443, + "no": 0.008460479196955669 + }, + "noul": 0.9915395208030443 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 91851.73058509827, + "probabilities": { + "department": { + "it_helpdesk": 6.957419350486225e-05, + "hr_people_ops": 0.009861242814499804, + "facilities": 2.575699101288641e-05, + "other_unclassified": 0.9900434260009825 + }, + "requires_new_category": { + "yes": 0.9915395208030443, + "no": 0.008460479196955669 + } + }, + "labels": { + "department": "D", + "requires_new_category": "yes" + } + } + }, + "image_s1": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "has_button": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "no", + "confidence": 0.9964630034693642, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.003536996530635852, + "no": 0.9964630034693642 + }, + "noul": 0.003536996530635852 + }, + "dominant_color": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.999207934384256, + "probabilities": { + "red": 0.0003869810272619841, + "green": 0.00036023157772876335, + "blue": 0.999207934384256, + "white": 4.485301075332818e-05 + }, + "choice": "blue" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 91398.11396598816, + "probabilities": { + "has_button": { + "yes": 0.003536996530635852, + "no": 0.9964630034693642 + }, + "dominant_color": { + "red": 0.0003869810272619841, + "green": 0.00036023157772876335, + "blue": 0.999207934384256, + "white": 4.485301075332818e-05 + } + }, + "labels": { + "has_button": "no", + "dominant_color": "C" + } + } + }, + "choice_26": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "pick": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "B", + "confidence": 0.5586765802008992, + "probabilities": { + "opt_00": 0.327110534227298, + "opt_01": 0.5586765802008992, + "opt_02": 0.048895170660441675, + "opt_03": 0.008852346583868822, + "opt_04": 0.009892548705644412, + "opt_05": 0.0014085504985519963, + "opt_06": 0.01103976721698335, + "opt_07": 0.0005323410959614957, + "opt_08": 0.00020138519552982166, + "opt_09": 0.0015055900002954566, + "opt_10": 0.0006145771661568181, + "opt_11": 0.0018345330513766546, + "opt_12": 0.024087010865204747, + "opt_13": 0.0006145771661568181, + "opt_14": 1.6523831427140274e-05, + "opt_15": 0.0007601299673131074, + "opt_16": 0.0032524559017676254, + "opt_17": 0.00015939451286814337, + "opt_18": 9.108394119220128e-05, + "opt_19": 2.804190502954912e-05, + "opt_20": 0.00013611441747134973, + "opt_21": 1.1521860127477082e-05, + "opt_22": 2.3546952381802993e-05, + "opt_23": 1.3808969526832655e-05, + "opt_24": 0.00018635817407692794, + "opt_25": 5.550693244854763e-05 + }, + "choice": "opt_01" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 91454.20956611633, + "probabilities": { + "pick": { + "opt_00": 0.327110534227298, + "opt_01": 0.5586765802008992, + "opt_02": 0.048895170660441675, + "opt_03": 0.008852346583868822, + "opt_04": 0.009892548705644412, + "opt_05": 0.0014085504985519963, + "opt_06": 0.01103976721698335, + "opt_07": 0.0005323410959614957, + "opt_08": 0.00020138519552982166, + "opt_09": 0.0015055900002954566, + "opt_10": 0.0006145771661568181, + "opt_11": 0.0018345330513766546, + "opt_12": 0.024087010865204747, + "opt_13": 0.0006145771661568181, + "opt_14": 1.6523831427140274e-05, + "opt_15": 0.0007601299673131074, + "opt_16": 0.0032524559017676254, + "opt_17": 0.00015939451286814337, + "opt_18": 9.108394119220128e-05, + "opt_19": 2.804190502954912e-05, + "opt_20": 0.00013611441747134973, + "opt_21": 1.1521860127477082e-05, + "opt_22": 2.3546952381802993e-05, + "opt_23": 1.3808969526832655e-05, + "opt_24": 0.00018635817407692794, + "opt_25": 5.550693244854763e-05 + } + }, + "labels": { + "pick": "B" + } + } + }, + "choice_27_error": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 400, + "error": "question 'pick': at most 26 alternatives" + } + }, + "depends_on_2reads": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "billing_issue": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9973924015054095, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9973924015054095, + "no": 0.002607598494590423 + }, + "noul": 0.9973924015054095 + }, + "refund": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.998079526882602, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.998079526882602, + "no": 0.0019204731173980004 + }, + "noul": 0.998079526882602 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 2, + "denoise_ms": 91500.15568733215, + "probabilities": { + "billing_issue": { + "yes": 0.9973924015054095, + "no": 0.002607598494590423 + }, + "refund": { + "yes": 0.998079526882602, + "no": 0.0019204731173980004 + } + }, + "labels": { + "billing_issue": "yes", + "refund": "yes" + } + } + }, + "unknown_type_error": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 400, + "error": "question 'a': unknown type 'banana'" + } + }, + "empty_questions_error": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 400, + "error": "schema: needs a non-empty questions array" + } + }, + "systemone": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 200, + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics", + "model", + "usage" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "noul": 0.09116820634923525 + }, + "billing": { + "type": "noul", + "noul": 0.9977163913940218 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 251.50132179260254, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": null, + "billing": null + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": null, + "billing": null + } + } + }, + "invalid_json_error": { + "cr_rollback_00032": { + "status": 400, + "error": "invalid body: Expecting property name enclosed in double quotes: line 1 column 2 (char 1)" + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/contract_rollback_vertex.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/contract_rollback_vertex.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ea68000 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/contract_rollback_vertex.json @@ -0,0 +1,834 @@ +{ + "health": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "body": { + "status": "ok", + "server": "dgem-structured-server", + "vllm_ready": true, + "phase": "ready", + "bytes_staged_gb": 17.53, + "boot_ts": 1790635379.2526886, + "stage_start_ts": 1790635379.2526886, + "stage_end_ts": 1790635379.2526886, + "warmed": true, + "warmup_s": 16.0 + } + } + }, + "cases": { + "triage_s1": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.927646972863927, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.927646972863927, + "no": 0.07235302713607297 + }, + "noul": 0.927646972863927 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.76175306565893, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.2372346751555079, + "support": 0.0010122591855622307, + "engineering": 0.76175306565893 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9701460967937148, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.01056589192655398, + "frustrated": 0.9701460967937148, + "furious": 0.019288011279731156 + }, + "score": 2.008722119353177, + "level": "frustrated" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 1619.3983554840088, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.927646972863927, + "no": 0.07235302713607297 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.2372346751555079, + "support": 0.0010122591855622307, + "engineering": 0.76175306565893 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.01056589192655398, + "frustrated": 0.9701460967937148, + "furious": 0.019288011279731156 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2" + } + } + }, + "triage_s4": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9292395598519316, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9292395598519316, + "no": 0.07076044014806838 + }, + "noul": 0.9292395598519316, + "stderr": 0.014425799901086873, + "agreement": 1.0 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.9145352694825613, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.08411738622278779, + "support": 0.001347344294650914, + "engineering": 0.9145352694825613 + }, + "choice": "engineering", + "stderr": 0.051473485601623147, + "agreement": 1.0 + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9750351206273226, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.016719193025549507, + "frustrated": 0.9750351206273226, + "furious": 0.008245686347127912 + }, + "score": 1.9915264933215784, + "level": "frustrated", + "stderr": 0.005185585961473277, + "agreement": 1.0 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 4, + "denoise_ms": 1629.1697025299072, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.9292395598519316, + "no": 0.07076044014806838 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.08411738622278779, + "support": 0.001347344294650914, + "engineering": 0.9145352694825613 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.016719193025549507, + "frustrated": 0.9750351206273226, + "furious": 0.008245686347127912 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2" + } + } + }, + "samples_string": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 400, + "error": "schema: samples must be a positive count or \"auto\"" + } + }, + "default_samples": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.927646972863927, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.927646972863927, + "no": 0.07235302713607297 + }, + "noul": 0.927646972863927 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.76175306565893, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.2372346751555079, + "support": 0.0010122591855622307, + "engineering": 0.76175306565893 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9701460967937148, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.01056589192655398, + "frustrated": 0.9701460967937148, + "furious": 0.019288011279731156 + }, + "score": 2.008722119353177, + "level": "frustrated" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 1628.1278133392334, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.927646972863927, + "no": 0.07235302713607297 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.2372346751555079, + "support": 0.0010122591855622307, + "engineering": 0.76175306565893 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.01056589192655398, + "frustrated": 0.9701460967937148, + "furious": 0.019288011279731156 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2" + } + } + }, + "mirror_s1": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9294909143977973, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9294909143977973, + "no": 0.0705090856022027 + }, + "noul": 0.9294909143977973 + }, + "team": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.862708161001292, + "probabilities": { + "billing": 0.13536361536593802, + "support": 0.0019282236327700505, + "engineering": 0.862708161001292 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.9790651912238408, + "probabilities": { + "calm": 0.013772408016632215, + "frustrated": 0.9790651912238408, + "furious": 0.0071624007595268244 + }, + "score": 1.9933899927428944, + "level": "frustrated" + }, + "urgent__rev": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "B", + "confidence": 0.8615366238386888, + "probabilities": { + "no": 0.1384633761613112, + "yes": 0.8615366238386888 + }, + "choice": "yes" + }, + "team__rev": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "A", + "confidence": 0.9820320222438539, + "probabilities": { + "engineering": 0.9820320222438539, + "support": 0.0075364193091134405, + "billing": 0.010431558447032733 + }, + "choice": "engineering" + }, + "sentiment__rev": { + "type": "score", + "label": "2", + "confidence": 0.8058103012294772, + "probabilities": { + "furious": 0.09962254289982532, + "frustrated": 0.8058103012294772, + "calm": 0.09456715587069747 + }, + "score": 1.994944612970872, + "level": "frustrated" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 1617.6409721374512, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": { + "yes": 0.9294909143977973, + "no": 0.0705090856022027 + }, + "team": { + "billing": 0.13536361536593802, + "support": 0.0019282236327700505, + "engineering": 0.862708161001292 + }, + "sentiment": { + "calm": 0.013772408016632215, + "frustrated": 0.9790651912238408, + "furious": 0.0071624007595268244 + }, + "urgent__rev": { + "no": 0.1384633761613112, + "yes": 0.8615366238386888 + }, + "team__rev": { + "engineering": 0.9820320222438539, + "support": 0.0075364193091134405, + "billing": 0.010431558447032733 + }, + "sentiment__rev": { + "furious": 0.09962254289982532, + "frustrated": 0.8058103012294772, + "calm": 0.09456715587069747 + } + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": "yes", + "team": "C", + "sentiment": "2", + "urgent__rev": "B", + "team__rev": "A", + "sentiment__rev": "2" + } + } + }, + "think120": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "department": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "D", + "confidence": 0.9807583413346004, + "probabilities": { + "it_helpdesk": 0.0007180913961278903, + "hr_people_ops": 0.01838467788912123, + "facilities": 0.0001388893801503393, + "other_unclassified": 0.9807583413346004 + }, + "choice": "other_unclassified" + }, + "requires_new_category": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "no", + "confidence": 0.6154987056069142, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.3845012943930857, + "no": 0.6154987056069142 + }, + "noul": 0.3845012943930857 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 1910.7089042663574, + "probabilities": { + "department": { + "it_helpdesk": 0.0007180913961278903, + "hr_people_ops": 0.01838467788912123, + "facilities": 0.0001388893801503393, + "other_unclassified": 0.9807583413346004 + }, + "requires_new_category": { + "yes": 0.3845012943930857, + "no": 0.6154987056069142 + } + }, + "labels": { + "department": "D", + "requires_new_category": "no" + } + } + }, + "image_s1": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "has_button": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "no", + "confidence": 0.9825308905651104, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.017469109434889663, + "no": 0.9825308905651104 + }, + "noul": 0.017469109434889663 + }, + "dominant_color": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "C", + "confidence": 0.9987875503795025, + "probabilities": { + "red": 0.0006868687764550382, + "green": 0.0004800983001549823, + "blue": 0.9987875503795025, + "white": 4.548254388738905e-05 + }, + "choice": "blue" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 1615.7300472259521, + "probabilities": { + "has_button": { + "yes": 0.017469109434889663, + "no": 0.9825308905651104 + }, + "dominant_color": { + "red": 0.0006868687764550382, + "green": 0.0004800983001549823, + "blue": 0.9987875503795025, + "white": 4.548254388738905e-05 + } + }, + "labels": { + "has_button": "no", + "dominant_color": "C" + } + } + }, + "choice_26": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "pick": { + "type": "choice", + "label": "B", + "confidence": 0.5368288441971905, + "probabilities": { + "opt_00": 0.29997741714000264, + "opt_01": 0.5368288441971905, + "opt_02": 0.02522306219997332, + "opt_03": 0.017849704493855048, + "opt_04": 0.013808502560774082, + "opt_05": 0.0013852100316049606, + "opt_06": 0.011178115917111658, + "opt_07": 0.00029511167680616805, + "opt_08": 0.0004583839921725969, + "opt_09": 0.0020450612369436612, + "opt_10": 0.00023553408808387122, + "opt_11": 0.002179399226743793, + "opt_12": 0.08319194619493558, + "opt_13": 0.0006099939564941258, + "opt_14": 2.804774644875688e-06, + "opt_15": 0.0013852100316049606, + "opt_16": 0.0019182902217256838, + "opt_17": 0.00020225765779985187, + "opt_18": 8.505929885961104e-05, + "opt_19": 6.133630205109804e-05, + "opt_20": 7.228823168183779e-05, + "opt_21": 6.87424501163473e-06, + "opt_22": 2.4146098193589926e-05, + "opt_23": 5.6465463159497865e-05, + "opt_24": 0.00042636537233369524, + "opt_25": 0.0004926153902416718 + }, + "choice": "opt_01" + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 1628.5290718078613, + "probabilities": { + "pick": { + "opt_00": 0.29997741714000264, + "opt_01": 0.5368288441971905, + "opt_02": 0.02522306219997332, + "opt_03": 0.017849704493855048, + "opt_04": 0.013808502560774082, + "opt_05": 0.0013852100316049606, + "opt_06": 0.011178115917111658, + "opt_07": 0.00029511167680616805, + "opt_08": 0.0004583839921725969, + "opt_09": 0.0020450612369436612, + "opt_10": 0.00023553408808387122, + "opt_11": 0.002179399226743793, + "opt_12": 0.08319194619493558, + "opt_13": 0.0006099939564941258, + "opt_14": 2.804774644875688e-06, + "opt_15": 0.0013852100316049606, + "opt_16": 0.0019182902217256838, + "opt_17": 0.00020225765779985187, + "opt_18": 8.505929885961104e-05, + "opt_19": 6.133630205109804e-05, + "opt_20": 7.228823168183779e-05, + "opt_21": 6.87424501163473e-06, + "opt_22": 2.4146098193589926e-05, + "opt_23": 5.6465463159497865e-05, + "opt_24": 0.00042636537233369524, + "opt_25": 0.0004926153902416718 + } + }, + "labels": { + "pick": "B" + } + } + }, + "choice_27_error": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 400, + "error": "question 'pick': at most 26 alternatives" + } + }, + "depends_on_2reads": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "top_keys": [ + "choices", + "created", + "id", + "model", + "object", + "usage" + ], + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics" + ], + "answers": { + "billing_issue": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9830926307941301, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9830926307941301, + "no": 0.016907369205869847 + }, + "noul": 0.9830926307941301 + }, + "refund": { + "type": "noul", + "label": "yes", + "confidence": 0.9993759598430194, + "probabilities": { + "yes": 0.9993759598430194, + "no": 0.0006240401569805946 + }, + "noul": 0.9993759598430194 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 2, + "denoise_ms": 1578.8750648498535, + "probabilities": { + "billing_issue": { + "yes": 0.9830926307941301, + "no": 0.016907369205869847 + }, + "refund": { + "yes": 0.9993759598430194, + "no": 0.0006240401569805946 + } + }, + "labels": { + "billing_issue": "yes", + "refund": "yes" + } + } + }, + "unknown_type_error": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 400, + "error": "question 'a': unknown type 'banana'" + } + }, + "empty_questions_error": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 400, + "error": "schema: needs a non-empty questions array" + } + }, + "systemone": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 200, + "envelope_keys": [ + "answers", + "diagnostics", + "model", + "usage" + ], + "answers": { + "urgent": { + "type": "noul", + "noul": 0.033254436506512774 + }, + "billing": { + "type": "noul", + "noul": 0.9979322375401428 + } + }, + "diagnostic_keys": [ + "chunk_prompt", + "chunks", + "conditioning", + "engine", + "prompt_tokens", + "questions", + "samples", + "sequential", + "skipped", + "stages", + "steps", + "thought", + "timing" + ], + "reads": 1, + "denoise_ms": 94.05994415283203, + "probabilities": { + "urgent": null, + "billing": null + }, + "labels": { + "urgent": null, + "billing": null + } + } + }, + "invalid_json_error": { + "vertex_rollback": { + "status": 400, + "error": "invalid body: Expecting property name enclosed in double quotes: line 1 column 2 (char 1)" + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/decision_index.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/decision_index.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2c94152 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/decision_index.json @@ -0,0 +1,2913 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:40:19Z", + "endpoint": "http://127.0.0.1:8080/v1", + "model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "dgem_wide_canvas_report": { + "suite_edition": "release-v1-panel", + "engine_mode": "dgem-wide-canvas+batching", + "temperature_scale": 1.25, + "total_requests": 22, + "supported_requests": 22, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "total_fields": 54, + "total_forward_passes": 28, + "headline_decision_index": 98.88888888888889, + "supported_decision_index": 98.88888888888889, + "skill_decision_index": 98.33341666250021, + "wide_option_accuracy": 100, + "multi_slot_canvas_accuracy": 94.28571428571429, + "ece_10bin": 0.03419909364691573, + "mean_brier": 0.017479579928377155, + "p50_latency_ms": 217, + "areas": [ + { + "area_id": "knowledge", + "label": "Knowledge \u0026 Reasoning", + "benchmark_count": 6, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "plain_score": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "skill_score": 100, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 1, + "dataset": "MMLU", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00031808530128879016, + "mean_entropy": 0.09366624993609145, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.06756591714073266, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 2, + "dataset": "GPQA Diamond", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.010144805463675468, + "mean_entropy": 0.34174040382052917, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2465135929316346, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 3, + "dataset": "GSM8K", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 20, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00011519615331485815, + "mean_entropy": 0.06037123574279207, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.037510757809530615, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 4, + "dataset": "ChessBench", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.0000025870106683533124, + "mean_entropy": 0.011206796682705465, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.008083994999195031, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 5, + "dataset": "CRUXEval", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.03585937563335616, + "mean_entropy": 0.51875200368341, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.3742004715826345, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 6, + "dataset": "CLadder", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 50, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000005091011376679519, + "mean_entropy": 0.011869921763818098, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.017124677264400347, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "language", + "label": "Language Understanding", + "benchmark_count": 3, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "plain_score": 94.44444444444446, + "supported_score": 94.44444444444446, + "skill_score": 91.66708331250105, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 7, + "dataset": "ContractNLI", + "area": "language", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 83.33333333333334, + "coverage_adj_score": 83.33333333333334, + "chance_baseline": 33.33, + "skill_score": 75.00124993750315, + "mean_brier": 0.22319738456721758, + "mean_entropy": 0.08223620580105517, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.0748546203690779, + "mean_passes_per_req": 2 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 8, + "dataset": "iSarcasmEval", + "area": "language", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00003184284214067531, + "mean_entropy": 0.03572485030012276, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.025770032182243854, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 9, + "dataset": "VAST", + "area": "language", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 33.33, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00001824581387429913, + "mean_entropy": 0.025097271675774628, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.02284452116060073, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "retrieval", + "label": "Retrieval \u0026 Classification", + "benchmark_count": 2, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "plain_score": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "skill_score": 100, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 10, + "dataset": "BRIGHT", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 11.200000000000001, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 3.648203736699759e-7, + "mean_entropy": 0.002021309798232538, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.002916133622010354, + "mean_passes_per_req": 2 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 11, + "dataset": "Amazon ESCI", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000004973925736865692, + "mean_entropy": 0.014611664542282533, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010540087987142057, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "tools", + "label": "Tools \u0026 Automation", + "benchmark_count": 3, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "plain_score": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "skill_score": 100, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 12, + "dataset": "BFCL", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25.919999999999998, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000028303132524838522, + "mean_entropy": 0.03344297579518745, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.024124007666143286, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 13, + "dataset": "ToolRet", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 9.370000000000001, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000003682404255355839, + "mean_entropy": 0.006292160127400224, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.009077668212279571, + "mean_passes_per_req": 2 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 14, + "dataset": "RouterBench", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 9.09, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000004425805859090248, + "mean_entropy": 0.01402819143826605, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010119201110313723, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "arts", + "label": "Arts \u0026 Human Judgment", + "benchmark_count": 5, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "plain_score": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "skill_score": 100, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 15, + "dataset": "BPoMP", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000025089727133875345, + "mean_entropy": 0.03149919820540211, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.022721868521456082, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 16, + "dataset": "Humicroedit", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 50, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.001990036227415131, + "mean_entropy": 0.14006865139125854, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.20207634874617372, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 17, + "dataset": "POP909-CL", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 12.5, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.003170788798504395, + "mean_entropy": 0.21810580755465517, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.1573300834740918, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 18, + "dataset": "cfcolor", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 20, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00017122571029852359, + "mean_entropy": 0.0694548956320747, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.05010111674692735, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 19, + "dataset": "Habermas Machine", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 4.131786528919932e-7, + "mean_entropy": 0.004700562121164799, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.003390738830797481, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + } + ], + "display_benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 20, + "dataset": "API-Bank", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": false, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 1.8900000000000001, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.034646912648779, + "mean_entropy": 0.7739372750938567, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2275484743304241, + "mean_passes_per_req": 2 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 21, + "dataset": "BANKING77", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": false, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 1.27, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.036288909749248824, + "mean_entropy": 0.84620946713037, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.24416444035645543, + "mean_passes_per_req": 2 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 22, + "dataset": "CLINC150+OOS", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": false, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 0.66, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.03852301849860215, + "mean_entropy": 0.8962220901622096, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2500955361347496, + "mean_passes_per_req": 2 + } + ], + "results": [ + { + "id": "di_knowledge_mmlu_01", + "catalog_id": 1, + "dataset": "MMLU", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.984890336592688, + "mean_brier": 0.00031808530128879016, + "mean_entropy": 0.09366624993609145, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.06756591714073266, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "answers": { + "answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "B", + "probabilities": { + "A": 0.008049626394809576, + "B": 0.984890336592688, + "C": 0.0037100554490711317, + "D": 0.003349981563431216 + }, + "entropy": 0.09366624993609145, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06756591714073266, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "answer": "B" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_gpqa_01", + "catalog_id": 2, + "dataset": "GPQA Diamond", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9195671452372348, + "mean_brier": 0.010144805463675468, + "mean_entropy": 0.34174040382052917, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2465135929316346, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 151, + "answers": { + "answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "B", + "probabilities": { + "A": 0.058560882344798254, + "B": 0.9195671452372348, + "C": 0.012778919829590969, + "D": 0.00909305258837602 + }, + "entropy": 0.34174040382052917, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2465135929316346, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "answer": "B" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_gsm8k_01", + "catalog_id": 3, + "dataset": "GSM8K", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 5, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9910411390868156, + "mean_brier": 0.00011519615331485815, + "mean_entropy": 0.06037123574279207, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.037510757809530615, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 144, + "answers": { + "answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "opt_30_00", + "probabilities": { + "opt_15_00": 0.005325174595336004, + "opt_30_00": 0.9910411390868156, + "opt_45_00": 0.0005900918579673167, + "opt_60_00": 0.0024155359958317924, + "opt_7_50": 0.0006280584640493413 + }, + "entropy": 0.06037123574279207, + "normalized_entropy": 0.037510757809530615, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "answer": "opt_30_00" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_chessbench_01", + "catalog_id": 4, + "dataset": "ChessBench", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9986826042374531, + "mean_brier": 0.0000025870106683533124, + "mean_entropy": 0.011206796682705465, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.008083994999195031, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 224, + "answers": { + "best_move": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Qxf7#", + "probabilities": { + "Bxf7+": 0.00028251422567836135, + "Qg5": 0.00017380223174887297, + "Qh6": 0.0008610793051196632, + "Qxf7#": 0.9986826042374531 + }, + "entropy": 0.011206796682705465, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008083994999195031, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "best_move": "Qxf7#" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_cruxeval_01", + "catalog_id": 5, + "dataset": "CRUXEval", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.8519781342562239, + "mean_brier": 0.03585937563335616, + "mean_entropy": 0.51875200368341, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.3742004715826345, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 168, + "answers": { + "output": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "B", + "probabilities": { + "A": 0.1158531161231781, + "B": 0.8519781342562239, + "C": 0.018268883171548234, + "D": 0.013899866449049949 + }, + "entropy": 0.51875200368341, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3742004715826345, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "output": "B" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_cladder_01", + "catalog_id": 6, + "dataset": "CLadder", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9984045359018957, + "mean_brier": 0.000005091011376679519, + "mean_entropy": 0.011869921763818098, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.017124677264400347, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 217, + "answers": { + "causal_answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "yes", + "probabilities": { + "no": 0.0015954640981043018, + "yes": 0.9984045359018957 + }, + "entropy": 0.011869921763818098, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017124677264400347, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "causal_answer": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_language_contractnli_12slots", + "catalog_id": 7, + "dataset": "ContractNLI", + "area": "language", + "total_fields": 12, + "correct_fields": 10, + "max_options": 3, + "whole_case_exact": false, + "field_accuracy": 0.8333333333333334, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9691846956043432, + "mean_brier": 0.22319738456721758, + "mean_entropy": 0.08223620580105517, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.0748546203690779, + "forward_passes": 2, + "wall_time_ms": 293, + "answers": { + "clause_01_confidential_marking": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "contradiction", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.9999996697144815, + "entailment": 8.618604766313014e-8, + "not_mentioned": 2.4409947079087e-7 + }, + "entropy": 0.0000054488358821123155, + "normalized_entropy": 0.000004959744159350476, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_02_sharing_employees": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.000041538860322816976, + "entailment": 0.9999404281010583, + "not_mentioned": 0.000018033038618877185 + }, + "entropy": 0.0006756311314425542, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0006149859585692858, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_03_sharing_affiliates": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.000014963257023359234, + "entailment": 0.9999823358467419, + "not_mentioned": 0.000002700896234802674 + }, + "entropy": 0.000218535173471249, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00019891928729123148, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_04_return_or_destroy": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.00005096878559474608, + "entailment": 0.9999365077131019, + "not_mentioned": 0.000012523501303323344 + }, + "entropy": 0.0007086449690396565, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0006450364485716561, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_05_survival_period": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.00003571487426346517, + "entailment": 0.9999567078095227, + "not_mentioned": 0.000007577316213686362 + }, + "entropy": 0.0004983487625891229, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0004536165922495647, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_06_no_license": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.00006907117585366292, + "entailment": 0.9999248034860468, + "not_mentioned": 0.000006125338099321152 + }, + "entropy": 0.0008104442207947911, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0007376981207604406, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_07_reverse_engineering": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "contradiction", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.999940416855388, + "entailment": 0.000052558070271802755, + "not_mentioned": 0.000007025074340254103 + }, + "entropy": 0.0006608268510367453, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0006015105218219354, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_08_public_domain_exception": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.0001391161015795496, + "entailment": 0.999721767796841, + "not_mentioned": 0.0001391161015795496 + }, + "entropy": 0.002748951579345907, + "normalized_entropy": 0.002502203559618442, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_09_compelled_disclosure": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.0002377308755064826, + "entailment": 0.9997101450195087, + "not_mentioned": 0.00005212410498460579 + }, + "entropy": 0.002787569490375728, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0025373550970881702, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_10_non_solicitation": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "contradiction", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.7758966993768991, + "entailment": 0.001690489903369102, + "not_mentioned": 0.22241281071973187 + }, + "entropy": 0.5419982007055449, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4933480230433527, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_11_exclusive_dealing": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "contradiction", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.8561744991646, + "entailment": 0.0032793370912873204, + "not_mentioned": 0.14054616374411275 + }, + "entropy": 0.427488265570396, + "normalized_entropy": 0.38911658824484535, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "clause_12_injunctive_relief": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "entailment", + "probabilities": { + "contradiction": 0.0007199161256425151, + "entailment": 0.9990323663679275, + "not_mentioned": 0.0002477175064299172 + }, + "entropy": 0.008233602322743233, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0074945478106067335, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "clause_01_confidential_marking": "contradiction", + "clause_02_sharing_employees": "entailment", + "clause_03_sharing_affiliates": "entailment", + "clause_04_return_or_destroy": "entailment", + "clause_05_survival_period": "entailment", + "clause_06_no_license": "entailment", + "clause_07_reverse_engineering": "contradiction", + "clause_08_public_domain_exception": "entailment", + "clause_09_compelled_disclosure": "entailment", + "clause_10_non_solicitation": "not_mentioned", + "clause_11_exclusive_dealing": "not_mentioned", + "clause_12_injunctive_relief": "entailment" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_language_isarcasm_01", + "catalog_id": 8, + "dataset": "iSarcasmEval", + "area": "language", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9951625133540951, + "mean_brier": 0.00003184284214067531, + "mean_entropy": 0.03572485030012276, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.025770032182243854, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 316, + "answers": { + "tone": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "sarcasm", + "probabilities": { + "literal_happy": 0.002156793640348561, + "neutral_fact": 0.0010266995760436232, + "sarcasm": 0.9951625133540951, + "understatement": 0.0016539934295126573 + }, + "entropy": 0.03572485030012276, + "normalized_entropy": 0.025770032182243854, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "tone": "sarcasm" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_language_vast_01", + "catalog_id": 9, + "dataset": "VAST", + "area": "language", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 3, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.996569232361649, + "mean_brier": 0.00001824581387429913, + "mean_entropy": 0.025097271675774628, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.02284452116060073, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 183, + "answers": { + "stance": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "pro", + "probabilities": { + "con": 0.002258782379977801, + "neutral": 0.0011719852583732353, + "pro": 0.996569232361649 + }, + "entropy": 0.025097271675774628, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02284452116060073, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "stance": "pro" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_retrieval_bright_11slots", + "catalog_id": 10, + "dataset": "BRIGHT", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 11, + "correct_fields": 11, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9997581912472026, + "mean_brier": 3.648203736699759e-7, + "mean_entropy": 0.002021309798232538, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.002916133622010354, + "forward_passes": 2, + "wall_time_ms": 437, + "answers": { + "passage_01": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9999990652834234, + "relevant": 9.347165767063085e-7 + }, + "entropy": 0.000013911407386697357, + "normalized_entropy": 0.000020069918448574373, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_02": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.00011683087681758423, + "relevant": 0.9998831691231823 + }, + "entropy": 0.0011747023085242202, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0016947371950287095, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_03": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9999989130578817, + "relevant": 0.0000010869421183576737 + }, + "entropy": 0.000016012985260289724, + "normalized_entropy": 0.000023101854424848054, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_04": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9999967477721418, + "relevant": 0.0000032522278581837736 + }, + "entropy": 0.00004434792764549435, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00006398053528785726, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_05": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9999987568422682, + "relevant": 0.000001243157731815019 + }, + "entropy": 0.000018147436604288555, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00002618121679385395, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_06": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.999998817309308, + "relevant": 0.0000011826906920004034 + }, + "entropy": 0.000017323719591634076, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00002499284434460146, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_07": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.0006268492319647771, + "relevant": 0.9993731507680352 + }, + "entropy": 0.00524954326116595, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0075734900298161925, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_08": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9999898159464822, + "relevant": 0.000010184053517730875 + }, + "entropy": 0.0001272465137354613, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0001835779143365594, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_09": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9988675412923451, + "relevant": 0.0011324587076547885 + }, + "entropy": 0.00881369704712029, + "normalized_entropy": 0.012715477021778145, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_10": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9997267431108126, + "relevant": 0.0002732568891874791 + }, + "entropy": 0.0025153191659773753, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003628838487008523, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "passage_11": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "not_relevant", + "probabilities": { + "not_relevant": 0.9995073832133478, + "relevant": 0.000492616786652353 + }, + "entropy": 0.004244156007546215, + "normalized_entropy": 0.006123022824846027, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "passage_01": "not_relevant", + "passage_02": "relevant", + "passage_03": "not_relevant", + "passage_04": "not_relevant", + "passage_05": "not_relevant", + "passage_06": "not_relevant", + "passage_07": "relevant", + "passage_08": "not_relevant", + "passage_09": "not_relevant", + "passage_10": "not_relevant", + "passage_11": "not_relevant" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_retrieval_esci_01", + "catalog_id": 11, + "dataset": "Amazon ESCI", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9982022627113681, + "mean_brier": 0.000004973925736865692, + "mean_entropy": 0.014611664542282533, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010540087987142057, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "answers": { + "esci_label": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Exact", + "probabilities": { + "Complement": 0.0012603098124193191, + "Exact": 0.9982022627113681, + "Irrelevant": 0.00020062773163739565, + "Substitute": 0.0003367997445751219 + }, + "entropy": 0.014611664542282533, + "normalized_entropy": 0.010540087987142057, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "esci_label": "Exact" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_tools_bfcl_01", + "catalog_id": 12, + "dataset": "BFCL", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.995484492546379, + "mean_brier": 0.000028303132524838522, + "mean_entropy": 0.03344297579518745, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.024124007666143286, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 183, + "answers": { + "function_call": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "get_equity_quote", + "probabilities": { + "cancel_subscription": 0.0006957056223265837, + "execute_wire_transfer": 0.0021686243519798967, + "get_equity_quote": 0.995484492546379, + "get_weather_forecast": 0.001651177479314425 + }, + "entropy": 0.03344297579518745, + "normalized_entropy": 0.024124007666143286, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "function_call": "get_equity_quote" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_tools_toolret_12slots", + "catalog_id": 13, + "dataset": "ToolRet", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 12, + "correct_fields": 12, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9991485698750305, + "mean_brier": 0.000003682404255355839, + "mean_entropy": 0.006292160127400224, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.009077668212279571, + "forward_passes": 2, + "wall_time_ms": 420, + "answers": { + "tool_candidate_01": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.00010803509425130201, + "skip": 0.9998919649057488 + }, + "entropy": 0.0010947196551378384, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0015793466176310356, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_02": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.0003008561984064008, + "skip": 0.9996991438015936 + }, + "entropy": 0.00274041719125291, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003953586291787436, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_03": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.00009907571225545651, + "skip": 0.9999009242877446 + }, + "entropy": 0.0010125118395474494, + "normalized_entropy": 0.001460745809756467, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_04": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "invoke", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.999938510286779, + "skip": 0.00006148971322090415 + }, + "entropy": 0.0006577314761926615, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0009489059389397301, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_05": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.00008757531332327649, + "skip": 0.9999124246866768 + }, + "entropy": 0.0009057886302049136, + "normalized_entropy": 0.001306776764890236, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_06": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.00020379856326541108, + "skip": 0.9997962014367346 + }, + "entropy": 0.00193573512064899, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0027926754590348974, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_07": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.00026784514524786436, + "skip": 0.9997321548547522 + }, + "entropy": 0.0024708627937360932, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0035647014992401115, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_08": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.00023721094970427783, + "skip": 0.9997627890502958 + }, + "entropy": 0.00221707841038958, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003198568027931033, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_09": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "invoke", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.9986223348900516, + "skip": 0.0013776651099484847 + }, + "entropy": 0.010451898843577407, + "normalized_entropy": 0.015078902629502218, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_10": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.001878958101334173, + "skip": 0.9981210418986658 + }, + "entropy": 0.013671482887054323, + "normalized_entropy": 0.019723780562751602, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_11": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.0021961098591722007, + "skip": 0.9978038901408278 + }, + "entropy": 0.01563623383243009, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02255831700822712, + "passes_used": 1 + }, + "tool_candidate_12": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "skip", + "probabilities": { + "invoke": 0.003398541739504947, + "skip": 0.996601458260495 + }, + "entropy": 0.022711460848630426, + "normalized_entropy": 0.032765711937662964, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "tool_candidate_01": "skip", + "tool_candidate_02": "skip", + "tool_candidate_03": "skip", + "tool_candidate_04": "invoke", + "tool_candidate_05": "skip", + "tool_candidate_06": "skip", + "tool_candidate_07": "skip", + "tool_candidate_08": "skip", + "tool_candidate_09": "invoke", + "tool_candidate_10": "skip", + "tool_candidate_11": "skip", + "tool_candidate_12": "skip" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_tools_routerbench_01", + "catalog_id": 14, + "dataset": "RouterBench", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9982915615380495, + "mean_brier": 0.000004425805859090248, + "mean_entropy": 0.01402819143826605, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010119201110313723, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 222, + "answers": { + "target_model": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "dgemma-vllm-l4", + "probabilities": { + "claude-3-7-opus": 0.0011614866068420742, + "dgemma-vllm-l4": 0.9982915615380495, + "gemini-2.5-pro": 0.00020861231278486073, + "gpt-4.5-preview": 0.0003383395423234517 + }, + "entropy": 0.01402819143826605, + "normalized_entropy": 0.010119201110313723, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "target_model": "dgemma-vllm-l4" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_bpomp_01", + "catalog_id": 15, + "dataset": "BPoMP", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9957772169079427, + "mean_brier": 0.000025089727133875345, + "mean_entropy": 0.03149919820540211, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.022721868521456082, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 204, + "answers": { + "mood": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "melancholic_somber", + "probabilities": { + "euphoric_festive": 0.0023334052348670735, + "melancholic_somber": 0.9957772169079427, + "playful_whimsical": 0.0010633812990020395, + "triumphant_march": 0.0008259965581879597 + }, + "entropy": 0.03149919820540211, + "normalized_entropy": 0.022721868521456082, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "mood": "melancholic_somber" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_humicroedit_01", + "catalog_id": 16, + "dataset": "Humicroedit", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9684560922885644, + "mean_brier": 0.001990036227415131, + "mean_entropy": 0.14006865139125854, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.20207634874617372, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 105, + "answers": { + "funnier_edit": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Edit_A", + "probabilities": { + "Edit_A": 0.9684560922885644, + "Edit_B": 0.031543907711435615 + }, + "entropy": 0.14006865139125854, + "normalized_entropy": 0.20207634874617372, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "funnier_edit": "Edit_A" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_pop909_01", + "catalog_id": 17, + "dataset": "POP909-CL", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9544621455187181, + "mean_brier": 0.003170788798504395, + "mean_entropy": 0.21810580755465517, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.1573300834740918, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 106, + "answers": { + "section_type": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "chorus", + "probabilities": { + "chorus": 0.9544621455187181, + "intro": 0.02932567685548618, + "outro_fade": 0.0008369783780365701, + "verse": 0.01537519924775907 + }, + "entropy": 0.21810580755465517, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1573300834740918, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "section_type": "chorus" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_cfcolor_01", + "catalog_id": 18, + "dataset": "cfcolor", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.989185035990081, + "mean_brier": 0.00017122571029852359, + "mean_entropy": 0.0694548956320747, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.05010111674692735, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 195, + "answers": { + "palette": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "crimson_alert_red", + "probabilities": { + "baby_sky_blue": 0.006634292201524307, + "crimson_alert_red": 0.989185035990081, + "muted_slate_gray": 0.001221594756696922, + "pastel_mint_green": 0.002959077051697847 + }, + "entropy": 0.0694548956320747, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05010111674692735, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "palette": "crimson_alert_red" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_habermas_01", + "catalog_id": 19, + "dataset": "Habermas Machine", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9994936026099215, + "mean_brier": 4.131786528919932e-7, + "mean_entropy": 0.004700562121164799, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.003390738830797481, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 256, + "answers": { + "consensus_statement": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Statement_1", + "probabilities": { + "Statement_1": 0.9994936026099215, + "Statement_2": 0.0003845470694486725, + "Statement_3": 0.00008775925498287552, + "Statement_4": 0.00003409106564700237 + }, + "entropy": 0.004700562121164799, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003390738830797481, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "consensus_statement": "Statement_1" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_wide_apibank_30opts", + "catalog_id": 20, + "dataset": "API-Bank", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 30, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.8311449079470515, + "mean_brier": 0.034646912648779, + "mean_entropy": 0.7739372750938567, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2275484743304241, + "forward_passes": 2, + "wall_time_ms": 496, + "answers": { + "selected_api": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "ConvertCurrencyFX_28", + "probabilities": { + "ConvertCurrencyFX_28": 0.8311449079470515, + "api_tool_01": 0.0017061001966229116, + "api_tool_02": 0.0001894593007438493, + "api_tool_03": 0.0003368927885236905, + "api_tool_04": 0.0002301928824493389, + "api_tool_05": 0.00011113580300163345, + "api_tool_06": 0.00014547864879905093, + "api_tool_07": 0.00011113580300163345, + "api_tool_08": 0.00003868222856435114, + "api_tool_09": 0.0011040884254357752, + "api_tool_10": 0.00012723461573476498, + "api_tool_11": 0.00008446577906581872, + "api_tool_12": 0.000023067764391002488, + "api_tool_13": 0.00007349540856103, + "api_tool_14": 0.000005927877202876577, + "api_tool_15": 0.000024859199358687114, + "api_tool_16": 0.00020223059478397475, + "api_tool_17": 0.000018397035158879572, + "api_tool_18": 0.000023067764391002488, + "api_tool_19": 0.000023067764391002488, + "api_tool_20": 0.025350330246865015, + "api_tool_21": 0.0001490093745538199, + "api_tool_22": 0.008040392123920537, + "api_tool_23": 0.005571796869810214, + "api_tool_24": 0.007251386096726746, + "api_tool_25": 0.025350330246865015, + "api_tool_26": 0.008904616353012507, + "api_tool_27": 0.017608063367164507, + "api_tool_29": 0.06563025403955443, + "api_tool_30": 0.0004199334542943012 + }, + "entropy": 0.7739372750938567, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2275484743304241, + "passes_used": 2 + } + }, + "expected": { + "selected_api": "ConvertCurrencyFX_28" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_wide_banking77_32opts", + "catalog_id": 21, + "dataset": "BANKING77", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 32, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.8243953404951396, + "mean_brier": 0.036288909749248824, + "mean_entropy": 0.84620946713037, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.24416444035645543, + "forward_passes": 2, + "wall_time_ms": 460, + "answers": { + "intent": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "lost_or_stolen_card", + "probabilities": { + "banking_intent_01": 0.00046070049283893457, + "banking_intent_02": 0.012809611945265916, + "banking_intent_03": 0.000390192058010809, + "banking_intent_04": 0.0058220037636351595, + "banking_intent_05": 0.04814405714277091, + "banking_intent_06": 0.0008961033717843241, + "banking_intent_07": 0.004979686941726523, + "banking_intent_08": 0.0009531521328235439, + "banking_intent_09": 0.00027934531528036005, + "banking_intent_10": 0.0067885020579019845, + "banking_intent_11": 0.0011448472256890302, + "banking_intent_12": 0.04814405714277091, + "banking_intent_13": 0.014728862054474294, + "banking_intent_14": 0.017672658923490306, + "banking_intent_15": 0.00024384383267362253, + "banking_intent_16": 0.0005765655172005936, + "banking_intent_17": 0.0017363430575718347, + "banking_intent_18": 0.00009085607932030132, + "banking_intent_19": 0.00013977540738608518, + "banking_intent_20": 0.0017359767790745876, + "banking_intent_21": 0.00199569323439095, + "banking_intent_22": 0.00012938917727573423, + "banking_intent_23": 0.00034409331756265907, + "banking_intent_24": 0.0004390503348369017, + "banking_intent_25": 0.0008848689588367163, + "banking_intent_26": 0.000195185960656731, + "banking_intent_27": 0.0008848689588367163, + "banking_intent_28": 0.0007040477074381194, + "banking_intent_30": 0.0006644221086587563, + "banking_intent_31": 0.0007897892707995008, + "banking_intent_32": 0.0008361092338775065, + "lost_or_stolen_card": 0.8243953404951396 + }, + "entropy": 0.84620946713037, + "normalized_entropy": 0.24416444035645543, + "passes_used": 2 + } + }, + "expected": { + "intent": "lost_or_stolen_card" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_wide_clinc150_36opts", + "catalog_id": 22, + "dataset": "CLINC150+OOS", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 36, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.8216735167933408, + "mean_brier": 0.03852301849860215, + "mean_entropy": 0.8962220901622096, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2500955361347496, + "forward_passes": 2, + "wall_time_ms": 579, + "answers": { + "intent": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "oos_out_of_scope", + "probabilities": { + "clinc_domain_intent_01": 0.010586429577636822, + "clinc_domain_intent_02": 0.012548697780862997, + "clinc_domain_intent_03": 0.00704184574631996, + "clinc_domain_intent_04": 0.0016534614033536855, + "clinc_domain_intent_05": 0.0016534614033536855, + "clinc_domain_intent_06": 0.00201669694772998, + "clinc_domain_intent_07": 0.00201669694772998, + "clinc_domain_intent_08": 0.0017671888714285847, + "clinc_domain_intent_09": 0.00047274870319007523, + "clinc_domain_intent_10": 0.00201669694772998, + "clinc_domain_intent_11": 0.00704184574631996, + "clinc_domain_intent_12": 0.00014814357195795284, + "clinc_domain_intent_13": 0.0024526416042930797, + "clinc_domain_intent_14": 0.007471203570368256, + "clinc_domain_intent_15": 0.0781145839088649, + "clinc_domain_intent_16": 0.00040399014406311095, + "clinc_domain_intent_17": 0.002974238129181072, + "clinc_domain_intent_18": 0.00704184574631996, + "clinc_domain_intent_19": 0.0024526416042930797, + "clinc_domain_intent_20": 0.00040399014406311095, + "clinc_domain_intent_21": 0.0050517812451500044, + "clinc_domain_intent_22": 0.001886724289036764, + "clinc_domain_intent_23": 0.0006018548162465257, + "clinc_domain_intent_24": 0.00032695227781062215, + "clinc_domain_intent_25": 0.00130405314204184, + "clinc_domain_intent_26": 0.0007827993104295481, + "clinc_domain_intent_27": 0.0008353007343675143, + "clinc_domain_intent_28": 0.0016702804710026463, + "clinc_domain_intent_29": 0.00032695227781062215, + "clinc_domain_intent_30": 0.004520156756034814, + "clinc_domain_intent_31": 0.004039483608847143, + "clinc_domain_intent_32": 0.0004301872822292004, + "clinc_domain_intent_34": 0.00046036517414244646, + "clinc_domain_intent_35": 0.005638972344056921, + "clinc_domain_intent_36": 0.00017157097839232228, + "oos_out_of_scope": 0.8216735167933408 + }, + "entropy": 0.8962220901622096, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2500955361347496, + "passes_used": 2 + } + }, + "expected": { + "intent": "oos_out_of_scope" + } + } + ] + }, + "naive_26opt_10slot_report": { + "suite_edition": "release-v1-panel", + "engine_mode": "naive-djev-26opt-10slot", + "temperature_scale": 1, + "total_requests": 22, + "supported_requests": 16, + "coverage_pct": 72.72727272727273, + "total_fields": 54, + "total_forward_passes": 16, + "headline_decision_index": 76.66666666666667, + "supported_decision_index": 76.66666666666667, + "skill_decision_index": 76.66666666666667, + "wide_option_accuracy": 0, + "multi_slot_canvas_accuracy": 0, + "ece_10bin": 0.022771996803807495, + "mean_brier": 0.27508593116981, + "p50_latency_ms": 183, + "areas": [ + { + "area_id": "knowledge", + "label": "Knowledge \u0026 Reasoning", + "benchmark_count": 6, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "plain_score": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "skill_score": 100, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 1, + "dataset": "MMLU", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00031808530128879016, + "mean_entropy": 0.09366624993609145, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.06756591714073266, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 2, + "dataset": "GPQA Diamond", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.010144805463675468, + "mean_entropy": 0.34174040382052917, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2465135929316346, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 3, + "dataset": "GSM8K", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 20, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00011519615331485815, + "mean_entropy": 0.06037123574279207, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.037510757809530615, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 4, + "dataset": "ChessBench", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.0000025870106683533124, + "mean_entropy": 0.011206796682705465, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.008083994999195031, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 5, + "dataset": "CRUXEval", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.03585937563335616, + "mean_entropy": 0.51875200368341, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.3742004715826345, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 6, + "dataset": "CLadder", + "area": "knowledge", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 50, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000005091011376679519, + "mean_entropy": 0.011869921763818098, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.017124677264400347, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "language", + "label": "Language Understanding", + "benchmark_count": 3, + "coverage_pct": 66.66666666666667, + "plain_score": 66.66666666666667, + "supported_score": 66.66666666666667, + "skill_score": 66.66666666666667, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 7, + "dataset": "ContractNLI", + "area": "language", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 0, + "coverage_pct": 0, + "supported_score": 0, + "coverage_adj_score": 0, + "chance_baseline": 33.33, + "skill_score": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "mean_passes_per_req": 0 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 8, + "dataset": "iSarcasmEval", + "area": "language", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00003184284214067531, + "mean_entropy": 0.03572485030012276, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.025770032182243854, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 9, + "dataset": "VAST", + "area": "language", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 33.33, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00001824581387429913, + "mean_entropy": 0.025097271675774628, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.02284452116060073, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "retrieval", + "label": "Retrieval \u0026 Classification", + "benchmark_count": 2, + "coverage_pct": 50, + "plain_score": 50, + "supported_score": 50, + "skill_score": 50, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 10, + "dataset": "BRIGHT", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 0, + "coverage_pct": 0, + "supported_score": 0, + "coverage_adj_score": 0, + "chance_baseline": 11.200000000000001, + "skill_score": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "mean_passes_per_req": 0 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 11, + "dataset": "Amazon ESCI", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000004973925736865692, + "mean_entropy": 0.014611664542282533, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010540087987142057, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "tools", + "label": "Tools \u0026 Automation", + "benchmark_count": 3, + "coverage_pct": 66.66666666666667, + "plain_score": 66.66666666666667, + "supported_score": 66.66666666666667, + "skill_score": 66.66666666666667, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 12, + "dataset": "BFCL", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25.919999999999998, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000028303132524838522, + "mean_entropy": 0.03344297579518745, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.024124007666143286, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 13, + "dataset": "ToolRet", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 0, + "coverage_pct": 0, + "supported_score": 0, + "coverage_adj_score": 0, + "chance_baseline": 9.370000000000001, + "skill_score": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "mean_passes_per_req": 0 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 14, + "dataset": "RouterBench", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 9.09, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000004425805859090248, + "mean_entropy": 0.01402819143826605, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010119201110313723, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + }, + { + "area_id": "arts", + "label": "Arts \u0026 Human Judgment", + "benchmark_count": 5, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "plain_score": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "skill_score": 100, + "benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 15, + "dataset": "BPoMP", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.000025089727133875345, + "mean_entropy": 0.03149919820540211, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.022721868521456082, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 16, + "dataset": "Humicroedit", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 50, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.001990036227415131, + "mean_entropy": 0.14006865139125854, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.20207634874617372, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 17, + "dataset": "POP909-CL", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 12.5, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.003170788798504395, + "mean_entropy": 0.21810580755465517, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.1573300834740918, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 18, + "dataset": "cfcolor", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 20, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 0.00017122571029852359, + "mean_entropy": 0.0694548956320747, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.05010111674692735, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 19, + "dataset": "Habermas Machine", + "area": "arts", + "in_panel": true, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 1, + "coverage_pct": 100, + "supported_score": 100, + "coverage_adj_score": 100, + "chance_baseline": 25, + "skill_score": 100, + "mean_brier": 4.131786528919932e-7, + "mean_entropy": 0.004700562121164799, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.003390738830797481, + "mean_passes_per_req": 1 + } + ] + } + ], + "display_benchmarks": [ + { + "catalog_id": 20, + "dataset": "API-Bank", + "area": "tools", + "in_panel": false, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 0, + "coverage_pct": 0, + "supported_score": 0, + "coverage_adj_score": 0, + "chance_baseline": 1.8900000000000001, + "skill_score": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "mean_passes_per_req": 0 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 21, + "dataset": "BANKING77", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": false, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 0, + "coverage_pct": 0, + "supported_score": 0, + "coverage_adj_score": 0, + "chance_baseline": 1.27, + "skill_score": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "mean_passes_per_req": 0 + }, + { + "catalog_id": 22, + "dataset": "CLINC150+OOS", + "area": "retrieval", + "in_panel": false, + "total_cases": 1, + "supported_cases": 0, + "coverage_pct": 0, + "supported_score": 0, + "coverage_adj_score": 0, + "chance_baseline": 0.66, + "skill_score": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "mean_passes_per_req": 0 + } + ], + "results": [ + { + "id": "di_knowledge_mmlu_01", + "catalog_id": 1, + "dataset": "MMLU", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.984890336592688, + "mean_brier": 0.00031808530128879016, + "mean_entropy": 0.09366624993609145, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.06756591714073266, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "answers": { + "answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "B", + "probabilities": { + "A": 0.008049626394809576, + "B": 0.984890336592688, + "C": 0.0037100554490711317, + "D": 0.003349981563431216 + }, + "entropy": 0.09366624993609145, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06756591714073266, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "answer": "B" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_gpqa_01", + "catalog_id": 2, + "dataset": "GPQA Diamond", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9195671452372348, + "mean_brier": 0.010144805463675468, + "mean_entropy": 0.34174040382052917, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.2465135929316346, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 151, + "answers": { + "answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "B", + "probabilities": { + "A": 0.058560882344798254, + "B": 0.9195671452372348, + "C": 0.012778919829590969, + "D": 0.00909305258837602 + }, + "entropy": 0.34174040382052917, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2465135929316346, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "answer": "B" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_gsm8k_01", + "catalog_id": 3, + "dataset": "GSM8K", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 5, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9910411390868156, + "mean_brier": 0.00011519615331485815, + "mean_entropy": 0.06037123574279207, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.037510757809530615, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 144, + "answers": { + "answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "opt_30_00", + "probabilities": { + "opt_15_00": 0.005325174595336004, + "opt_30_00": 0.9910411390868156, + "opt_45_00": 0.0005900918579673167, + "opt_60_00": 0.0024155359958317924, + "opt_7_50": 0.0006280584640493413 + }, + "entropy": 0.06037123574279207, + "normalized_entropy": 0.037510757809530615, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "answer": "opt_30_00" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_chessbench_01", + "catalog_id": 4, + "dataset": "ChessBench", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9986826042374531, + "mean_brier": 0.0000025870106683533124, + "mean_entropy": 0.011206796682705465, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.008083994999195031, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 224, + "answers": { + "best_move": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Qxf7#", + "probabilities": { + "Bxf7+": 0.00028251422567836135, + "Qg5": 0.00017380223174887297, + "Qh6": 0.0008610793051196632, + "Qxf7#": 0.9986826042374531 + }, + "entropy": 0.011206796682705465, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008083994999195031, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "best_move": "Qxf7#" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_cruxeval_01", + "catalog_id": 5, + "dataset": "CRUXEval", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.8519781342562239, + "mean_brier": 0.03585937563335616, + "mean_entropy": 0.51875200368341, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.3742004715826345, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 168, + "answers": { + "output": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "B", + "probabilities": { + "A": 0.1158531161231781, + "B": 0.8519781342562239, + "C": 0.018268883171548234, + "D": 0.013899866449049949 + }, + "entropy": 0.51875200368341, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3742004715826345, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "output": "B" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_knowledge_cladder_01", + "catalog_id": 6, + "dataset": "CLadder", + "area": "knowledge", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9984045359018957, + "mean_brier": 0.000005091011376679519, + "mean_entropy": 0.011869921763818098, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.017124677264400347, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 217, + "answers": { + "causal_answer": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "yes", + "probabilities": { + "no": 0.0015954640981043018, + "yes": 0.9984045359018957 + }, + "entropy": 0.011869921763818098, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017124677264400347, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "causal_answer": "yes" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_language_contractnli_12slots", + "catalog_id": 7, + "dataset": "ContractNLI", + "area": "language", + "total_fields": 12, + "correct_fields": 0, + "max_options": 3, + "whole_case_exact": false, + "field_accuracy": 0, + "supported": false, + "error_msg": "HTTP 422 Unprocessable Entity: capacity exceeded (fields=12, max_options=3)", + "mean_confidence": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "forward_passes": 0, + "wall_time_ms": 0, + "expected": { + "clause_01_confidential_marking": "contradiction", + "clause_02_sharing_employees": "entailment", + "clause_03_sharing_affiliates": "entailment", + "clause_04_return_or_destroy": "entailment", + "clause_05_survival_period": "entailment", + "clause_06_no_license": "entailment", + "clause_07_reverse_engineering": "contradiction", + "clause_08_public_domain_exception": "entailment", + "clause_09_compelled_disclosure": "entailment", + "clause_10_non_solicitation": "not_mentioned", + "clause_11_exclusive_dealing": "not_mentioned", + "clause_12_injunctive_relief": "entailment" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_language_isarcasm_01", + "catalog_id": 8, + "dataset": "iSarcasmEval", + "area": "language", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9951625133540951, + "mean_brier": 0.00003184284214067531, + "mean_entropy": 0.03572485030012276, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.025770032182243854, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 316, + "answers": { + "tone": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "sarcasm", + "probabilities": { + "literal_happy": 0.002156793640348561, + "neutral_fact": 0.0010266995760436232, + "sarcasm": 0.9951625133540951, + "understatement": 0.0016539934295126573 + }, + "entropy": 0.03572485030012276, + "normalized_entropy": 0.025770032182243854, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "tone": "sarcasm" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_language_vast_01", + "catalog_id": 9, + "dataset": "VAST", + "area": "language", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 3, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.996569232361649, + "mean_brier": 0.00001824581387429913, + "mean_entropy": 0.025097271675774628, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.02284452116060073, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 183, + "answers": { + "stance": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "pro", + "probabilities": { + "con": 0.002258782379977801, + "neutral": 0.0011719852583732353, + "pro": 0.996569232361649 + }, + "entropy": 0.025097271675774628, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02284452116060073, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "stance": "pro" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_retrieval_bright_11slots", + "catalog_id": 10, + "dataset": "BRIGHT", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 11, + "correct_fields": 0, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": false, + "field_accuracy": 0, + "supported": false, + "error_msg": "HTTP 422 Unprocessable Entity: capacity exceeded (fields=11, max_options=2)", + "mean_confidence": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "forward_passes": 0, + "wall_time_ms": 0, + "expected": { + "passage_01": "not_relevant", + "passage_02": "relevant", + "passage_03": "not_relevant", + "passage_04": "not_relevant", + "passage_05": "not_relevant", + "passage_06": "not_relevant", + "passage_07": "relevant", + "passage_08": "not_relevant", + "passage_09": "not_relevant", + "passage_10": "not_relevant", + "passage_11": "not_relevant" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_retrieval_esci_01", + "catalog_id": 11, + "dataset": "Amazon ESCI", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9982022627113681, + "mean_brier": 0.000004973925736865692, + "mean_entropy": 0.014611664542282533, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010540087987142057, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "answers": { + "esci_label": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Exact", + "probabilities": { + "Complement": 0.0012603098124193191, + "Exact": 0.9982022627113681, + "Irrelevant": 0.00020062773163739565, + "Substitute": 0.0003367997445751219 + }, + "entropy": 0.014611664542282533, + "normalized_entropy": 0.010540087987142057, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "esci_label": "Exact" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_tools_bfcl_01", + "catalog_id": 12, + "dataset": "BFCL", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.995484492546379, + "mean_brier": 0.000028303132524838522, + "mean_entropy": 0.03344297579518745, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.024124007666143286, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 183, + "answers": { + "function_call": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "get_equity_quote", + "probabilities": { + "cancel_subscription": 0.0006957056223265837, + "execute_wire_transfer": 0.0021686243519798967, + "get_equity_quote": 0.995484492546379, + "get_weather_forecast": 0.001651177479314425 + }, + "entropy": 0.03344297579518745, + "normalized_entropy": 0.024124007666143286, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "function_call": "get_equity_quote" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_tools_toolret_12slots", + "catalog_id": 13, + "dataset": "ToolRet", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 12, + "correct_fields": 0, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": false, + "field_accuracy": 0, + "supported": false, + "error_msg": "HTTP 422 Unprocessable Entity: capacity exceeded (fields=12, max_options=2)", + "mean_confidence": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "forward_passes": 0, + "wall_time_ms": 0, + "expected": { + "tool_candidate_01": "skip", + "tool_candidate_02": "skip", + "tool_candidate_03": "skip", + "tool_candidate_04": "invoke", + "tool_candidate_05": "skip", + "tool_candidate_06": "skip", + "tool_candidate_07": "skip", + "tool_candidate_08": "skip", + "tool_candidate_09": "invoke", + "tool_candidate_10": "skip", + "tool_candidate_11": "skip", + "tool_candidate_12": "skip" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_tools_routerbench_01", + "catalog_id": 14, + "dataset": "RouterBench", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9982915615380495, + "mean_brier": 0.000004425805859090248, + "mean_entropy": 0.01402819143826605, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.010119201110313723, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 222, + "answers": { + "target_model": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "dgemma-vllm-l4", + "probabilities": { + "claude-3-7-opus": 0.0011614866068420742, + "dgemma-vllm-l4": 0.9982915615380495, + "gemini-2.5-pro": 0.00020861231278486073, + "gpt-4.5-preview": 0.0003383395423234517 + }, + "entropy": 0.01402819143826605, + "normalized_entropy": 0.010119201110313723, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "target_model": "dgemma-vllm-l4" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_bpomp_01", + "catalog_id": 15, + "dataset": "BPoMP", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9957772169079427, + "mean_brier": 0.000025089727133875345, + "mean_entropy": 0.03149919820540211, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.022721868521456082, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 204, + "answers": { + "mood": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "melancholic_somber", + "probabilities": { + "euphoric_festive": 0.0023334052348670735, + "melancholic_somber": 0.9957772169079427, + "playful_whimsical": 0.0010633812990020395, + "triumphant_march": 0.0008259965581879597 + }, + "entropy": 0.03149919820540211, + "normalized_entropy": 0.022721868521456082, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "mood": "melancholic_somber" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_humicroedit_01", + "catalog_id": 16, + "dataset": "Humicroedit", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 2, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9684560922885644, + "mean_brier": 0.001990036227415131, + "mean_entropy": 0.14006865139125854, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.20207634874617372, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 105, + "answers": { + "funnier_edit": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Edit_A", + "probabilities": { + "Edit_A": 0.9684560922885644, + "Edit_B": 0.031543907711435615 + }, + "entropy": 0.14006865139125854, + "normalized_entropy": 0.20207634874617372, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "funnier_edit": "Edit_A" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_pop909_01", + "catalog_id": 17, + "dataset": "POP909-CL", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9544621455187181, + "mean_brier": 0.003170788798504395, + "mean_entropy": 0.21810580755465517, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.1573300834740918, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 106, + "answers": { + "section_type": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "chorus", + "probabilities": { + "chorus": 0.9544621455187181, + "intro": 0.02932567685548618, + "outro_fade": 0.0008369783780365701, + "verse": 0.01537519924775907 + }, + "entropy": 0.21810580755465517, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1573300834740918, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "section_type": "chorus" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_cfcolor_01", + "catalog_id": 18, + "dataset": "cfcolor", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.989185035990081, + "mean_brier": 0.00017122571029852359, + "mean_entropy": 0.0694548956320747, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.05010111674692735, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 195, + "answers": { + "palette": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "crimson_alert_red", + "probabilities": { + "baby_sky_blue": 0.006634292201524307, + "crimson_alert_red": 0.989185035990081, + "muted_slate_gray": 0.001221594756696922, + "pastel_mint_green": 0.002959077051697847 + }, + "entropy": 0.0694548956320747, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05010111674692735, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "palette": "crimson_alert_red" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_arts_habermas_01", + "catalog_id": 19, + "dataset": "Habermas Machine", + "area": "arts", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 1, + "max_options": 4, + "whole_case_exact": true, + "field_accuracy": 1, + "supported": true, + "mean_confidence": 0.9994936026099215, + "mean_brier": 4.131786528919932e-7, + "mean_entropy": 0.004700562121164799, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0.003390738830797481, + "forward_passes": 1, + "wall_time_ms": 256, + "answers": { + "consensus_statement": { + "type": "choice", + "choice": "Statement_1", + "probabilities": { + "Statement_1": 0.9994936026099215, + "Statement_2": 0.0003845470694486725, + "Statement_3": 0.00008775925498287552, + "Statement_4": 0.00003409106564700237 + }, + "entropy": 0.004700562121164799, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003390738830797481, + "passes_used": 1 + } + }, + "expected": { + "consensus_statement": "Statement_1" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_wide_apibank_30opts", + "catalog_id": 20, + "dataset": "API-Bank", + "area": "tools", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 0, + "max_options": 30, + "whole_case_exact": false, + "field_accuracy": 0, + "supported": false, + "error_msg": "HTTP 422 Unprocessable Entity: capacity exceeded (fields=1, max_options=30)", + "mean_confidence": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "forward_passes": 0, + "wall_time_ms": 0, + "expected": { + "selected_api": "ConvertCurrencyFX_28" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_wide_banking77_32opts", + "catalog_id": 21, + "dataset": "BANKING77", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 0, + "max_options": 32, + "whole_case_exact": false, + "field_accuracy": 0, + "supported": false, + "error_msg": "HTTP 422 Unprocessable Entity: capacity exceeded (fields=1, max_options=32)", + "mean_confidence": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "forward_passes": 0, + "wall_time_ms": 0, + "expected": { + "intent": "lost_or_stolen_card" + } + }, + { + "id": "di_wide_clinc150_36opts", + "catalog_id": 22, + "dataset": "CLINC150+OOS", + "area": "retrieval", + "total_fields": 1, + "correct_fields": 0, + "max_options": 36, + "whole_case_exact": false, + "field_accuracy": 0, + "supported": false, + "error_msg": "HTTP 422 Unprocessable Entity: capacity exceeded (fields=1, max_options=36)", + "mean_confidence": 0, + "mean_brier": 1, + "mean_entropy": 0, + "mean_normalized_entropy": 0, + "forward_passes": 0, + "wall_time_ms": 0, + "expected": { + "intent": "oos_out_of_scope" + } + } + ] + }, + "headline_index_delta": 22.222222222222214, + "coverage_pct_delta": 27.272727272727266 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/intents_clinc150.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/intents_clinc150.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..21df105 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/intents_clinc150.json @@ -0,0 +1,1442 @@ +{ + "avg_wall_time_ms": 184.66666666666666, + "candidate_intents": 26, + "corpus": "benchmarks/intents/clinc150_eval.jsonl", + "correct_mean_confidence": 0.9517962163790836, + "correct_mean_entropy_nats": 0, + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "domain_accuracy_pct": 93.33333333333333, + "domain_correct": 28, + "entropy_threshold": 0.08, + "in_domain_correct": 24, + "in_domain_total": 25, + "incorrect_mean_confidence": 0, + "incorrect_mean_entropy_nats": 0, + "intent_accuracy_pct": 96.66666666666667, + "intent_correct": 29, + "mean_confidence": 0.9517962163790836, + "mean_entropy_nats": 0, + "oos_correct": 5, + "oos_total": 5, + "pass1_accuracy_pct": 100, + "pass1_correct": 30, + "results": [ + { + "id": "c150-01", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "can you please provide me with assistance in moving money from one account to another", + "expected_domain": "banking", + "actual_domain": "banking", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "transfer", + "pass1_intent": "transfer", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "transfer", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9929342767809901, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00039866625500017223, + "balance": 0.004737469963004567, + "bill_balance": 0.00025006923466697835, + "book_flight": 0.00004727337593232968, + "card_declined": 0.0007518375018235796, + "flight_status": 0.00007447849315291866, + "freeze_account": 0.000027317650452063335, + "international_fees": 0.00020359549797314383, + "jump_start": 0.000001087081751025106, + "lost_luggage": 4.1459886889146977e-7, + "oil_change_when": 3.7570976438263894e-7, + "oos": 0.0002335944154468313, + "payday": 0.0000030008563555411182, + "pto_balance": 0.000009365579742481112, + "pto_request": 3.238783550733061e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00016518544986404937, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00004049788870915541, + "report_fraud": 0.00001824366499699217, + "schedule_maintenance": 7.791846827125006e-7, + "schedule_meeting": 0.000012062328813974959, + "tire_pressure": 0.000005585247679923137, + "traffic": 0.000014250410748955987, + "transfer": 0.9929342767809901, + "travel_alert": 0.000009365579742481112, + "vaccines": 0.0000014407084311557503, + "w2": 0.000059442663050420176 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 237 + }, + { + "id": "c150-02", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "is there a travel alert in spain", + "expected_domain": "travel", + "actual_domain": "travel", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "travel_alert", + "pass1_intent": "travel_alert", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "travel_alert", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9927568993802721, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00016099171395402248, + "balance": 0.000882910902769422, + "bill_balance": 0.0003212211165152398, + "book_flight": 0.00014880072716227377, + "card_declined": 0.000401520470888568, + "flight_status": 0.001977582293641284, + "freeze_account": 0.0002372442430125566, + "international_fees": 0.00020340316118743683, + "jump_start": 0.00005606313561505173, + "lost_luggage": 0.00003997605977208594, + "oil_change_when": 0.00004737912180441447, + "oos": 0.0005001179331009717, + "payday": 0.000018245490913560212, + "pto_balance": 0.000012742593428000175, + "pto_request": 0.0000028466130678580216, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00012696662191833574, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.000432180803957319, + "report_fraud": 0.00008479266985799378, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00009977287974478866, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00004737912180441447, + "tire_pressure": 0.0000781215218499555, + "traffic": 0.0000781215218499555, + "transfer": 0.0007677464280971177, + "travel_alert": 0.9927568993802721, + "vaccines": 0.00008479266985799378, + "w2": 0.000432180803957319 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 236 + }, + { + "id": "c150-03", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "please help me set up a vacation request", + "expected_domain": "work", + "actual_domain": "work", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "pto_request", + "pass1_intent": "pto_request", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "pto_request", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9444411277381398, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00031468299680210147, + "balance": 0.003264545870924767, + "bill_balance": 0.004351223250030017, + "book_flight": 0.00011077258506079047, + "card_declined": 0.0020235530474006155, + "flight_status": 0.0036660337223201056, + "freeze_account": 0.0002928159598753471, + "international_fees": 0.0007245650946551003, + "jump_start": 0.00020307310703888265, + "lost_luggage": 0.00009482058564635763, + "oil_change_when": 0.00008103630794361774, + "oos": 0.018597527521853223, + "payday": 0.002285502025662598, + "pto_balance": 0.00031468299680210147, + "pto_request": 0.9444411277381398, + "redeem_rewards": 0.0008848733929857027, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.004869264495608595, + "report_fraud": 0.00036301211157391267, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00016226879989464645, + "schedule_meeting": 0.0016812296553715136, + "tire_pressure": 0.001225405489781917, + "traffic": 0.002150932568739752, + "transfer": 0.0027359199865763795, + "travel_alert": 0.0010769847944941018, + "vaccines": 0.0004181121724979089, + "w2": 0.0036660337223201056 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 234 + }, + { + "id": "c150-04", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "how long until my paycheck shows up", + "expected_domain": "work", + "actual_domain": "work", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "payday", + "pass1_intent": "payday", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "payday", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9535038621028433, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.0003172370048198151, + "balance": 0.0011398400530526623, + "bill_balance": 0.002657734785630019, + "book_flight": 0.00009912541066807245, + "card_declined": 0.0021983861088103237, + "flight_status": 0.00014754016410733012, + "freeze_account": 0.00006593485205329269, + "international_fees": 0.00025319272163456494, + "jump_start": 0.00007159413283436767, + "lost_luggage": 0.00003086198730906846, + "oil_change_when": 0.00013636778667429914, + "oos": 0.02121438724595195, + "payday": 0.9535038621028433, + "pto_balance": 0.0003172370048198151, + "pto_request": 0.0005295483633106005, + "redeem_rewards": 0.0001595639500845866, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0002013583190747691, + "report_fraud": 0.00007159413283436767, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00003363200021954936, + "schedule_meeting": 0.004884985634871419, + "tire_pressure": 0.0006108762781460971, + "traffic": 0.0006557271812647819, + "transfer": 0.0007546711430084452, + "travel_alert": 0.000703598584288824, + "vaccines": 0.00008430992629060327, + "w2": 0.00915683312539706 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 239 + }, + { + "id": "c150-05", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "how long does it take for a credit card to be reissued and mailed to me", + "expected_domain": "credit_cards", + "actual_domain": "credit_cards", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "replacement_card_duration", + "pass1_intent": "replacement_card_duration", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "replacement_card_duration", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9948926898407031, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00041132442810353333, + "balance": 0.0028199030866387625, + "bill_balance": 0.00022436978910730677, + "book_flight": 0.00006723093518372292, + "card_declined": 0.0003543323208380377, + "flight_status": 0.00011931222449569269, + "freeze_account": 0.000021994060021364824, + "international_fees": 0.00028246387375383843, + "jump_start": 0.000004610271380152177, + "lost_luggage": 0.000026234424661283392, + "oil_change_when": 0.000005573334483488924, + "oos": 0.00016413898180101324, + "payday": 0.00001683291827445738, + "pto_balance": 0.000026234424661283392, + "pto_request": 7.047427819177633e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00007936243408479104, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.9948926898407031, + "report_fraud": 0.000020126220873540855, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00007306010385708645, + "schedule_meeting": 0.0000184097374327754, + "tire_pressure": 0.000020126220873540855, + "traffic": 0.00003407383916480351, + "transfer": 0.00004801617586479915, + "travel_alert": 0.000026234424661283392, + "vaccines": 2.7640003818877865e-7, + "w2": 0.0002423647862602226 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 149 + }, + { + "id": "c150-06", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "what's the status of by delta flight", + "expected_domain": "travel", + "actual_domain": "travel", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "flight_status", + "pass1_intent": "flight_status", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "flight_status", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9959534799492056, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00019131006683330268, + "balance": 0.0003409152059319178, + "bill_balance": 0.00013163591704406662, + "book_flight": 0.00036580374141814324, + "card_declined": 0.00015305023883294342, + "flight_status": 0.9959534799492056, + "freeze_account": 0.00017766739937857676, + "international_fees": 0.00010468700211736455, + "jump_start": 0.000013494835522990035, + "lost_luggage": 0.0011429498035407909, + "oil_change_when": 0.000008693316218556277, + "oos": 0.0001419679646308086, + "payday": 0.000006645403452804736, + "pto_balance": 0.00001904714597250801, + "pto_request": 2.1225637951060868e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.000006645403452804736, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00010468700211736455, + "report_fraud": 0.0000042134377857913045, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00003427979548214297, + "schedule_meeting": 0.000006645403452804736, + "tire_pressure": 0.00003427979548214297, + "traffic": 0.00023828821229050865, + "transfer": 0.00007670672631392543, + "travel_alert": 0.0005172956287322017, + "vaccines": 0.0000038418963193553256, + "w2": 0.000221556452091222 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 150 + }, + { + "id": "c150-07", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "what are my coffers at", + "expected_domain": "banking", + "actual_domain": "banking", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "balance", + "pass1_intent": "balance", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "balance", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.927622963327195, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.004434052445408807, + "balance": 0.927622963327195, + "bill_balance": 0.010796312168236054, + "book_flight": 0.0001322279028194983, + "card_declined": 0.009291465331428808, + "flight_status": 0.0002386068074178991, + "freeze_account": 0.001648930174505673, + "international_fees": 0.004434052445408807, + "jump_start": 0.000019317172833078956, + "lost_luggage": 0.000010554253982769145, + "oil_change_when": 0.000010554253982769145, + "oos": 0.026165190118450615, + "payday": 0.00003762885369041011, + "pto_balance": 0.000061009429560807374, + "pto_request": 0.0000013913604023244853, + "redeem_rewards": 0.003751457263945048, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0031640427469580854, + "report_fraud": 0.0008776012704022456, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00003192794569868351, + "schedule_meeting": 0.0002958073724235649, + "tire_pressure": 0.00009026520576964007, + "traffic": 0.0002386068074178991, + "transfer": 0.005224650382796926, + "travel_alert": 0.0001781847685948725, + "vaccines": 0.00003466836603549901, + "w2": 0.0012085318246343377 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 154 + }, + { + "id": "c150-08", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "can you freeze my bank account", + "expected_domain": "banking", + "actual_domain": "banking", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "freeze_account", + "pass1_intent": "freeze_account", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "freeze_account", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.984205072036885, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00017779012990943262, + "balance": 0.0055473782270015586, + "bill_balance": 0.0008069705712799427, + "book_flight": 0.00003892501621980905, + "card_declined": 0.0009237486562215117, + "flight_status": 0.00008815378881909551, + "freeze_account": 0.984205072036885, + "international_fees": 0.00020687682846818245, + "jump_start": 0.000005598441366111781, + "lost_luggage": 0.000008847269251457501, + "oil_change_when": 0.00002144696315006622, + "oos": 0.000863551373542003, + "payday": 0.00002338129536324741, + "pto_balance": 0.000027755650089160032, + "pto_request": 0.000004649151910515118, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00003289564639017454, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00011177764154940949, + "report_fraud": 0.000025479879922023748, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.000042316904251846164, + "schedule_meeting": 0.000012667968388804053, + "tire_pressure": 0.00003892501621980905, + "traffic": 0.00006927298874307485, + "transfer": 0.006207829452157966, + "travel_alert": 0.00004995278609738334, + "vaccines": 0.000027755650089160032, + "w2": 0.0004309806667131969 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 148 + }, + { + "id": "c150-09", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "is my luggage lost", + "expected_domain": "travel", + "actual_domain": "travel", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "lost_luggage", + "pass1_intent": "lost_luggage", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "lost_luggage", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9701150155281777, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00011017741810095427, + "balance": 0.002702967698187319, + "bill_balance": 0.00029577042612120955, + "book_flight": 0.0012680738816177655, + "card_declined": 0.0004561788806842771, + "flight_status": 0.008973217148930002, + "freeze_account": 0.0006937996199750547, + "international_fees": 0.0002747874956122037, + "jump_start": 0.00004171108987330692, + "lost_luggage": 0.9701150155281777, + "oil_change_when": 0.000038367760557379425, + "oos": 0.002391437668289278, + "payday": 0.000007270496019684888, + "pto_balance": 0.000029789962334988338, + "pto_request": 5.934727298644813e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00008689176755989647, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0010407004411105418, + "report_fraud": 0.00006295946636078692, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00023690060485293105, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00006828126750620978, + "tire_pressure": 0.00011017741810095427, + "traffic": 0.0004896718079992044, + "transfer": 0.0011119754440405971, + "travel_alert": 0.008973217148930002, + "vaccines": 0.00010183430890714008, + "w2": 0.0003182317774208948 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 161 + }, + { + "id": "c150-10", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "am i due for an oil change yet", + "expected_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "actual_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "oil_change_when", + "pass1_intent": "oil_change_when", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "oil_change_when", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9890055192796449, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00006032665058355645, + "balance": 0.00003933114542533819, + "bill_balance": 0.00007760410196230203, + "book_flight": 0.000027732624874051867, + "card_declined": 0.0000994701795266038, + "flight_status": 0.0005112462151486915, + "freeze_account": 0.000014817500913302555, + "international_fees": 0.00006032665058355645, + "jump_start": 0.0005112462151486915, + "lost_luggage": 0.000025387558150109176, + "oil_change_when": 0.9890055192796449, + "oos": 0.0006846086125266264, + "payday": 0.000033052998571751405, + "pto_balance": 0.00008433266224258028, + "pto_request": 0.000003133401073735887, + "redeem_rewards": 0.000007069219497285686, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00006563601527212664, + "report_fraud": 0.00007760410196230203, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.004182768039336619, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00017504773386248362, + "tire_pressure": 0.0019362395444495035, + "traffic": 0.001694044504323812, + "transfer": 0.00011713702187583887, + "travel_alert": 0.00017504773386248362, + "vaccines": 0.00009160738891794709, + "w2": 0.0002396629002639113 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 159 + }, + { + "id": "c150-11", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "give me the pressure for the tires on my car", + "expected_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "actual_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "tire_pressure", + "pass1_intent": "tire_pressure", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "tire_pressure", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.840583948364757, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00031226538378425003, + "balance": 0.002075223016701004, + "bill_balance": 0.0012922813056014887, + "book_flight": 0.0005223639273063025, + "card_declined": 0.010432792349371394, + "flight_status": 0.0008613047985386185, + "freeze_account": 0.0005223639273063025, + "international_fees": 0.0005683373165695032, + "jump_start": 0.0005223639273063025, + "lost_luggage": 0.00006121183960773346, + "oil_change_when": 0.0007302301756039767, + "oos": 0.003816482492461477, + "payday": 0.00008102896701100468, + "pto_balance": 0.0005223639273063025, + "pto_request": 0.000018324644361577563, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00031226538378425003, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.005927974453211302, + "report_fraud": 0.0024224175861728716, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00788864500606057, + "schedule_meeting": 0.0007932214864005407, + "tire_pressure": 0.840583948364757, + "traffic": 0.11639248409756384, + "transfer": 0.0009348554879647742, + "travel_alert": 0.0004046058249014, + "vaccines": 0.00008102896701100468, + "w2": 0.0019196153433352061 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": true, + "finalist_options": [ + "tire_pressure", + "traffic", + "replacement_card_duration", + "schedule_maintenance", + "card_declined" + ], + "wall_time_ms": 315 + }, + { + "id": "c150-12", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "you need to tell me my credit card's apr", + "expected_domain": "credit_cards", + "actual_domain": "credit_cards", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "apr", + "pass1_intent": "apr", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "apr", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9833913839818356, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.9833913839818356, + "balance": 0.008897606523888326, + "bill_balance": 0.00018889704602586527, + "book_flight": 0.00023528264952038492, + "card_declined": 0.0005107709061371546, + "flight_status": 0.00027184162160304767, + "freeze_account": 0.00008855148959621647, + "international_fees": 0.0012026658406484806, + "jump_start": 0.00000237698091022642, + "lost_luggage": 0.000005994805455786691, + "oil_change_when": 0.00000858366619716306, + "oos": 0.00027184162160304767, + "payday": 0.00000858366619716306, + "pto_balance": 0.000043280197988708286, + "pto_request": 3.422878349182695e-8, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00016285247754363986, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0001401773027053064, + "report_fraud": 0.000012212537926926426, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.000043280197988708286, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00012046849829855788, + "tire_pressure": 0.00003384741959548779, + "traffic": 0.0002033213326233562, + "transfer": 0.0018581016559110074, + "travel_alert": 0.00007000391372899835, + "vaccines": 0.000001339200818587769, + "w2": 0.0022267002364688058 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 156 + }, + { + "id": "c150-13", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "can you see if i can make an appointment to have my oil changed", + "expected_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "actual_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "schedule_maintenance", + "pass1_intent": "schedule_maintenance", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "oil_change_when", + "intent_accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5614064708871818, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.0004885621416914461, + "balance": 0.000032386790610679915, + "bill_balance": 0.0008549709593307823, + "book_flight": 0.000007994214157359162, + "card_declined": 0.0012599216013196729, + "flight_status": 0.00005641863913543364, + "freeze_account": 0.000024408766208888922, + "international_fees": 0.00006180169525258479, + "jump_start": 0.0030686441149347537, + "lost_luggage": 0.00004282164515918091, + "oil_change_when": 0.4048953470476007, + "oos": 0.0026559535421373857, + "payday": 0.0001640446305847454, + "pto_balance": 0.0007902288715764586, + "pto_request": 0.00006180169525258479, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00003556067133404203, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00009689540565999325, + "report_fraud": 0.00004282164515918091, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.5614064708871818, + "schedule_meeting": 0.005765759410103698, + "tire_pressure": 0.0022951629228669915, + "traffic": 0.012739279473890633, + "transfer": 0.00008104017415357471, + "travel_alert": 0.0012599216013196729, + "vaccines": 0.000105887905199435, + "w2": 0.0017058935481783384 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": true, + "finalist_options": [ + "schedule_maintenance", + "traffic", + "oil_change_when", + "schedule_meeting" + ], + "wall_time_ms": 314 + }, + { + "id": "c150-14", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "what site can i get my w2", + "expected_domain": "work", + "actual_domain": "work", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "w2", + "pass1_intent": "w2", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "w2", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9928747155706318, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.000042833609121716, + "balance": 0.0003695582901753461, + "bill_balance": 0.0006463757407026194, + "book_flight": 0.00023904753539313647, + "card_declined": 0.00019124075899375098, + "flight_status": 0.0000643953684942523, + "freeze_account": 0.000020049037192766144, + "international_fees": 0.00003628597877265565, + "jump_start": 0.000059400332880918746, + "lost_luggage": 0.000005264814000108817, + "oil_change_when": 0.000021848535433449922, + "oos": 0.0014281485959202792, + "payday": 0.0026538758993449557, + "pto_balance": 0.00004651007783799789, + "pto_request": 0.000015454858367278133, + "redeem_rewards": 0.000028207420834065017, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00020608836510944, + "report_fraud": 0.00009584730263774991, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00005048178250753309, + "schedule_meeting": 0.0002768412802291415, + "tire_pressure": 0.00020608836510944, + "traffic": 0.00007559027689695228, + "transfer": 0.00019124075899375098, + "travel_alert": 0.00013080947729560748, + "vaccines": 0.000023799967123364896, + "w2": 0.9928747155706318 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 158 + }, + { + "id": "c150-15", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "please book a meeting room for thusday at 4:00", + "expected_domain": "work", + "actual_domain": "work", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "schedule_meeting", + "pass1_intent": "schedule_meeting", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "schedule_meeting", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9956500903492285, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00002256757451945913, + "balance": 0.00015300371151045916, + "bill_balance": 0.00020585601375586619, + "book_flight": 0.000024553752802212206, + "card_declined": 0.00007087660916651766, + "flight_status": 0.0001419248063232935, + "freeze_account": 0.00001471337372017043, + "international_fees": 0.00004381974541266941, + "jump_start": 0.000016040393893253134, + "lost_luggage": 0.000007268597359261088, + "oil_change_when": 0.00012197030445809553, + "oos": 0.0019989617425630055, + "payday": 0.00042054721222028584, + "pto_balance": 0.00002670393503725388, + "pto_request": 0.000010374487434844672, + "redeem_rewards": 0.000024553752802212206, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00011300393358071254, + "report_fraud": 0.00004752371536045991, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.000019041355633924906, + "schedule_meeting": 0.9956500903492285, + "tire_pressure": 0.00003721076285880334, + "traffic": 0.00006548354235136055, + "transfer": 0.00017761338843126393, + "travel_alert": 0.00011300393358071254, + "vaccines": 0.00002256757451945913, + "w2": 0.0004507254314759867 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 167 + }, + { + "id": "c150-16", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "will i be charged transaction fees if i use my american card internationally", + "expected_domain": "credit_cards", + "actual_domain": "credit_cards", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "international_fees", + "pass1_intent": "international_fees", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "international_fees", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9750063623201227, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.0036758201202385867, + "balance": 0.007902190211217968, + "bill_balance": 0.000979636907420923, + "book_flight": 0.0006724994889675405, + "card_declined": 0.002650226209353661, + "flight_status": 0.0006724994889675405, + "freeze_account": 0.00007745320825089928, + "international_fees": 0.9750063623201227, + "jump_start": 0.000018568145751874084, + "lost_luggage": 0.0003043712373805336, + "oil_change_when": 0.00005276835267712296, + "oos": 0.0004263161759137256, + "payday": 0.0000665105616658457, + "pto_balance": 0.00004171574329550869, + "pto_request": 0.0000012885258277500307, + "redeem_rewards": 0.0009209509641386439, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0011072531606500446, + "report_fraud": 0.0001507353398119612, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.0000900531730804861, + "schedule_meeting": 0.0001507353398119612, + "tire_pressure": 0.0001507353398119612, + "traffic": 0.00039883890169715465, + "transfer": 0.0005194582289313532, + "travel_alert": 0.002959604630634059, + "vaccines": 0.000023771316959220395, + "w2": 0.000979636907420923 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 208 + }, + { + "id": "c150-17", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "i want to report fraudulent activity on my navy federal card", + "expected_domain": "banking", + "actual_domain": "credit_cards", + "expected_intent": "report_fraud", + "pass1_intent": "report_fraud", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "report_fraud", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9827180094670226, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.0008271420609161393, + "balance": 0.010222421714908104, + "bill_balance": 0.00028741459462512946, + "book_flight": 0.0000053623956411509416, + "card_declined": 0.0018110846819769926, + "flight_status": 0.000028948363975036937, + "freeze_account": 0.00006118079396648112, + "international_fees": 0.001700085012105128, + "jump_start": 0.0000025264831417537755, + "lost_luggage": 0.00001581641311688189, + "oil_change_when": 0.0000036922610344806456, + "oos": 0.0000844369820100068, + "payday": 0.0000036922610344806456, + "pto_balance": 0.0000033600950570688837, + "pto_request": 5.767064892592288e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00011579003308523848, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0010805614613655693, + "report_fraud": 0.9827180094670226, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00005638991595747823, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00001213385191127577, + "tire_pressure": 0.000014484780143783435, + "traffic": 0.000010148360134782703, + "transfer": 0.0007729468354492751, + "travel_alert": 0.00005638991595747823, + "vaccines": 0.000006447178423170257, + "w2": 0.0000989573805512296 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 207 + }, + { + "id": "c150-18", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "do i need to get any shots before i travel to morocco", + "expected_domain": "travel", + "actual_domain": "travel", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "vaccines", + "pass1_intent": "vaccines", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "vaccines", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7245174994464768, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00017336896475739338, + "balance": 0.0008821228426336997, + "bill_balance": 0.002168922353948642, + "book_flight": 0.0002054747102434896, + "card_declined": 0.0005506313510191315, + "flight_status": 0.000596218786328198, + "freeze_account": 0.0018742911313705576, + "international_fees": 0.000312018013796518, + "jump_start": 0.00017336896475739338, + "lost_luggage": 0.000050468933336129444, + "oil_change_when": 0.00010314216253955245, + "oos": 0.0011105231067356208, + "payday": 0.000038351118222471274, + "pto_balance": 0.0002054747102434896, + "pto_request": 0.00017336896475739338, + "redeem_rewards": 0.0001339632754618528, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.004103795980078424, + "report_fraud": 0.0001339632754618528, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00022355859457003533, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00007912740498209701, + "tire_pressure": 0.00028724003687815387, + "traffic": 0.25570121614834856, + "transfer": 0.005769975629318132, + "travel_alert": 0.000243135712675259, + "vaccines": 0.7245174994464768, + "w2": 0.00018877838105913213 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": true, + "finalist_options": [ + "vaccines", + "transfer", + "traffic" + ], + "wall_time_ms": 336 + }, + { + "id": "c150-19", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "i would like to know my vacation days balance", + "expected_domain": "work", + "actual_domain": "work", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "pto_balance", + "pass1_intent": "pto_balance", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "pto_balance", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9487636403572826, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00038311160549496097, + "balance": 0.0032869445515602514, + "bill_balance": 0.004223830196132564, + "book_flight": 0.0010588042480326135, + "card_declined": 0.0009871494052163632, + "flight_status": 0.0008570599317538792, + "freeze_account": 0.00024201578194332258, + "international_fees": 0.0004130179852416625, + "jump_start": 0.00038311160549496097, + "lost_luggage": 0.00006628039442999083, + "oil_change_when": 0.00024201578194332258, + "oos": 0.0077074879105583465, + "payday": 0.0020891576496304717, + "pto_balance": 0.9487636403572826, + "pto_request": 0.011496177023416411, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00044508399667055477, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.001303497115111367, + "report_fraud": 0.00044508399667055477, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00022386856959894899, + "schedule_meeting": 0.0022314002963057886, + "tire_pressure": 0.00044508399667055477, + "traffic": 0.0032869445515602514, + "transfer": 0.0037288041383843145, + "travel_alert": 0.0004794493095470485, + "vaccines": 0.0009871494052163632, + "w2": 0.004223830196132564 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 133 + }, + { + "id": "c150-20", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "book me a flight to jackson, mississippi from austin texas on american airlines", + "expected_domain": "travel", + "actual_domain": "travel", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "book_flight", + "pass1_intent": "book_flight", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "book_flight", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9969549150299761, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.0003459199608889704, + "balance": 0.00010680391266334533, + "bill_balance": 0.00003586159314695375, + "book_flight": 0.9969549150299761, + "card_declined": 0.00010680391266334533, + "flight_status": 0.0016516490443887347, + "freeze_account": 0.00011583177165900928, + "international_fees": 0.00005053544318876392, + "jump_start": 0.0000014318968139823532, + "lost_luggage": 0.000017716091917756587, + "oil_change_when": 0.0000034684752526367256, + "oos": 0.000019375642133052934, + "payday": 2.1159691192444073e-7, + "pto_balance": 0.000008532362968095745, + "pto_request": 4.5685712012677304e-9, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00003586159314695375, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00010680391266334533, + "report_fraud": 0.000008532362968095745, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.000016192228355627092, + "schedule_meeting": 0.000004852158740681069, + "tire_pressure": 0.00003013726588047365, + "traffic": 0.00023614181109786456, + "transfer": 0.00010680391266334533, + "travel_alert": 0.00001026648679411117, + "vaccines": 6.074164580964659e-8, + "w2": 0.00002528622289982001 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 142 + }, + { + "id": "c150-21", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "what do i owe to jcp", + "expected_domain": "banking", + "actual_domain": "credit_cards", + "expected_intent": "bill_balance", + "pass1_intent": "bill_balance", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "bill_balance", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8708256929691905, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.005308523490954181, + "balance": 0.05682738759575137, + "bill_balance": 0.8708256929691905, + "book_flight": 0.00007317606197375872, + "card_declined": 0.006013268862034375, + "flight_status": 0.00043427490174323505, + "freeze_account": 0.000545418016594563, + "international_fees": 0.004679468729881317, + "jump_start": 0.000019446615269116095, + "lost_luggage": 0.000009248631472559755, + "oil_change_when": 0.000017745800717243883, + "oos": 0.0312312721480914, + "payday": 0.00006164334515789134, + "pto_balance": 0.000013453125037838952, + "pto_request": 0.0000030424148420496676, + "redeem_rewards": 0.002783594225780784, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0016161666285818268, + "report_fraud": 0.000372328899185395, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00007317606197375872, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00029469486749635374, + "tire_pressure": 0.00018263396825824954, + "traffic": 0.00016839958601891166, + "transfer": 0.017304420498608232, + "travel_alert": 0.00013169744392517874, + "vaccines": 0.00009436024258387725, + "w2": 0.0009154648688761238 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": true, + "finalist_options": [ + "bill_balance", + "balance", + "pto_balance", + "card_declined", + "apr", + "oos" + ], + "wall_time_ms": 280 + }, + { + "id": "c150-22", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "how do i get stuff with visa points", + "expected_domain": "credit_cards", + "actual_domain": "credit_cards", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "redeem_rewards", + "pass1_intent": "redeem_rewards", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "redeem_rewards", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9845730780814883, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.0005302416632048263, + "balance": 0.0034821304983748214, + "bill_balance": 0.0010989304158930601, + "book_flight": 0.00028220458389371385, + "card_declined": 0.0015077086073100334, + "flight_status": 0.00022710142356078633, + "freeze_account": 0.0003749584830853418, + "international_fees": 0.00026259444251456584, + "jump_start": 0.000035137728014176476, + "lost_luggage": 0.0000381536484666944, + "oil_change_when": 0.00001508619672239999, + "oos": 0.0027611830424939462, + "payday": 0.00004141176005925711, + "pto_balance": 0.000007452776755571983, + "pto_request": 8.11735915595826e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.9845730780814883, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00026259444251456584, + "report_fraud": 0.00006714283350513532, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00013493041556798571, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00026259444251456584, + "tire_pressure": 0.00009933975331234877, + "traffic": 0.0003749584830853418, + "transfer": 0.0021770550504853917, + "travel_alert": 0.00010730704064251661, + "vaccines": 0.00002738058754546033, + "w2": 0.0012485118630735828 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 153 + }, + { + "id": "c150-23", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "what should i do to get my car jump started", + "expected_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "actual_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "jump_start", + "pass1_intent": "jump_start", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "jump_start", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9809800514285794, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00010940950879310434, + "balance": 0.00026361066521240415, + "bill_balance": 0.000307713969136871, + "book_flight": 0.00007851664923815737, + "card_declined": 0.0007530165560024329, + "flight_status": 0.0007530165560024329, + "freeze_account": 0.000027924351598429803, + "international_fees": 0.00007219454337206079, + "jump_start": 0.9809800514285794, + "lost_luggage": 0.00002337358270406747, + "oil_change_when": 0.00048479873272059854, + "oos": 0.006628704422093769, + "payday": 0.000039666332186808486, + "pto_balance": 0.004061524418704474, + "pto_request": 0.000004834408646611526, + "redeem_rewards": 0.00016415543383511172, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.000522230454051174, + "report_fraud": 0.00012884166979406096, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.0006052712606994415, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00017781726991808241, + "tire_pressure": 0.0007530165560024329, + "traffic": 0.0012365208966044357, + "transfer": 0.0007004175314929503, + "travel_alert": 0.000192538976690176, + "vaccines": 0.00017781726991808241, + "w2": 0.0007530165560024329 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 138 + }, + { + "id": "c150-24", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "i need to know traffic patterns heading to the george washington bridge from manhattan", + "expected_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "actual_domain": "auto_and_commute", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "traffic", + "pass1_intent": "traffic", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "traffic", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.997073447227156, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00004716970550661472, + "balance": 0.00017223514223768915, + "bill_balance": 0.0000989740690826324, + "book_flight": 0.00011618036300610711, + "card_declined": 0.00010725413735782963, + "flight_status": 0.0000989740690826324, + "freeze_account": 0.000060606159988213286, + "international_fees": 0.00003358065193054413, + "jump_start": 0.000011660065517506686, + "lost_luggage": 0.000010648683524231104, + "oil_change_when": 0.00002176246205905511, + "oos": 0.00012579907573091297, + "payday": 0.000015271583713791336, + "pto_balance": 0.00003081486818938254, + "pto_request": 0.0000013106869634318719, + "redeem_rewards": 0.000012762465839722958, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00007148482514526624, + "report_fraud": 0.000252806154883862, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.0000989740690826324, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00007758923578115655, + "tire_pressure": 0.0008079049166502333, + "traffic": 0.997073447227156, + "transfer": 0.00036741007676887596, + "travel_alert": 0.0000989740690826324, + "vaccines": 0.000060606159988213286, + "w2": 0.00012579907573091297 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 141 + }, + { + "id": "c150-25", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "my card got declined; why", + "expected_domain": "credit_cards", + "actual_domain": "credit_cards", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "card_declined", + "pass1_intent": "card_declined", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "card_declined", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9965495252526978, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.0001650316206438875, + "balance": 0.001298331143812643, + "bill_balance": 0.00010474972724544687, + "book_flight": 0.0000267280605264466, + "card_declined": 0.9965495252526978, + "flight_status": 0.0000767526865490597, + "freeze_account": 0.0005929619463583098, + "international_fees": 0.00010474972724544687, + "jump_start": 0.0000035038394048289154, + "lost_luggage": 0.000007275164124301238, + "oil_change_when": 0.0000029074372015238497, + "oos": 0.00034111914618326647, + "payday": 0.000001645693851813206, + "pto_balance": 0.0000019925529490077123, + "pto_request": 4.3488766150519124e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.000029057117709294514, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.00003430033484728634, + "report_fraud": 0.00004385933406478777, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.000020752525161831242, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00001038386019523149, + "tire_pressure": 0.00003724438067040865, + "traffic": 0.000029057117709294514, + "transfer": 0.0003660225703400306, + "travel_alert": 0.000016054885478443806, + "vaccines": 0.000003844198261657966, + "w2": 0.00013171478910640308 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 142 + }, + { + "id": "c150-26", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "how much has the dow changed today", + "is_oos": true, + "expected_domain": "oos", + "actual_domain": "oos", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "oos", + "pass1_intent": "oos", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "oos", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9948865350898454, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00003815634005612698, + "balance": 0.0000497365916255426, + "bill_balance": 0.000011610753834626127, + "book_flight": 4.2341461807597945e-8, + "card_declined": 0.00001056621842395237, + "flight_status": 0.000007573520153727762, + "freeze_account": 0.000002579334629359765, + "international_fees": 0.0000038363496114872325, + "jump_start": 5.523966492352665e-7, + "lost_luggage": 1.1336885758844012e-8, + "oil_change_when": 2.763989785159719e-7, + "oos": 0.9948865350898454, + "payday": 0.0000014798670972521829, + "pto_balance": 4.2396840086032054e-7, + "pto_request": 6.276153958644706e-8, + "redeem_rewards": 1.892588350859704e-7, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0019789086933690034, + "report_fraud": 0.0000022191360575886285, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.0000016385213366988388, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00009908277566740151, + "tire_pressure": 3.572997148827767e-8, + "traffic": 0.0000036518241896114408, + "transfer": 0.0004594880315562199, + "travel_alert": 1.5215454877687011e-7, + "vaccines": 0.002430624386851098, + "w2": 0.00001056621842395237 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 147 + }, + { + "id": "c150-27", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "how many prime numbers are there between 0 and 100", + "is_oos": true, + "expected_domain": "oos", + "actual_domain": "oos", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "oos", + "pass1_intent": "oos", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "oos", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9992086969963456, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 9.46074045143873e-7, + "balance": 0.000006852788845338901, + "bill_balance": 0.0000050996510251757705, + "book_flight": 1.023181637020661e-7, + "card_declined": 0.0000037821891339302017, + "flight_status": 0.000002167798082846862, + "freeze_account": 0.0000012945562940183075, + "international_fees": 2.4774259987703075e-7, + "jump_start": 0.0000024006438592574064, + "lost_luggage": 6.527337799908346e-8, + "oil_change_when": 1.3517595187217675e-7, + "oos": 0.9992086969963456, + "payday": 8.649478544227478e-8, + "pto_balance": 2.3456066353406928e-7, + "pto_request": 4.645016542704591e-8, + "redeem_rewards": 5.204295572784229e-8, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0007083440294209476, + "report_fraud": 3.624354082254715e-7, + "schedule_maintenance": 7.662439868779234e-7, + "schedule_meeting": 0.000023693844248823952, + "tire_pressure": 4.0375448191810547e-7, + "traffic": 0.000006212347385647736, + "transfer": 0.0000087432444646546, + "travel_alert": 5.204295572784229e-8, + "vaccines": 0.00001481765893150746, + "w2": 0.0000043936424207393944 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 143 + }, + { + "id": "c150-28", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "can you tell me how to solve simple algebraic equations with one variable", + "is_oos": true, + "expected_domain": "oos", + "actual_domain": "oos", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "oos", + "pass1_intent": "oos", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "oos", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9936523300740212, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.000003806825733001151, + "balance": 0.00018628497964345777, + "bill_balance": 0.000059647784225854564, + "book_flight": 0.0000013574884981865219, + "card_declined": 0.00004246393864459756, + "flight_status": 0.00004246393864459756, + "freeze_account": 0.000011217623684638952, + "international_fees": 0.000009330180181518913, + "jump_start": 0.000016138595745332406, + "lost_luggage": 4.64637070531347e-7, + "oil_change_when": 0.000005846322130523547, + "oos": 0.9936523300740212, + "payday": 0.0000016574106694700803, + "pto_balance": 0.000002122664394597444, + "pto_request": 1.1056650840930222e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.000011217623684638952, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0054766928920504795, + "report_fraud": 0.00001765741189960827, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.000006424266882611422, + "schedule_meeting": 0.000035742810802266226, + "tire_pressure": 0.000004610962197316387, + "traffic": 0.00001765741189960827, + "transfer": 0.00005482281369698861, + "travel_alert": 0.0000011675940541193165, + "vaccines": 0.00029629924439178993, + "w2": 0.00004246393864459756 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 139 + }, + { + "id": "c150-29", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "can you dim the brightness of my screen", + "is_oos": true, + "expected_domain": "oos", + "actual_domain": "oos", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "oos", + "pass1_intent": "oos", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "oos", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9934335607095298, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.00002686587996673119, + "balance": 0.0003313804935970695, + "bill_balance": 0.00012666500206473218, + "book_flight": 0.00000454843250538023, + "card_declined": 0.00007037984766250303, + "flight_status": 0.0003313804935970695, + "freeze_account": 0.000041870987101255454, + "international_fees": 0.00008341330771439035, + "jump_start": 0.00003212209703370038, + "lost_luggage": 0.0000018681902841831625, + "oil_change_when": 0.000012939052269405375, + "oos": 0.9934335607095298, + "payday": 0.0000032296492350713193, + "pto_balance": 0.000006688390234761827, + "pto_request": 7.842944909916102e-7, + "redeem_rewards": 0.0000073581416777369324, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.004794506997126906, + "report_fraud": 0.000049863873029031764, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.000022433971466945018, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00007037984766250303, + "tire_pressure": 0.000008895221423076974, + "traffic": 0.00009075453528548212, + "transfer": 0.00016196467657264395, + "travel_alert": 0.000011788828659058482, + "vaccines": 0.00017565513252986248, + "w2": 0.00009870194727957557 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 132 + }, + { + "id": "c150-30", + "dataset": "DeepPavlov/clinc150", + "text": "what is the account number to the internet service i have", + "is_oos": true, + "expected_domain": "oos", + "actual_domain": "oos", + "domain_accurate": true, + "expected_intent": "oos", + "pass1_intent": "oos", + "pass1_accurate": true, + "actual_intent": "oos", + "intent_accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9954056318050842, + "logprob": 0, + "entropy": 0, + "top_probabilities": { + "apr": 0.000025467343226735233, + "balance": 0.0005097504578299323, + "bill_balance": 0.00012068525611353843, + "book_flight": 0.000007551422263242129, + "card_declined": 0.00007728173693199806, + "flight_status": 0.000021050320543522525, + "freeze_account": 0.000022080184246479688, + "international_fees": 0.000025467343226735233, + "jump_start": 0.00006448195584824338, + "lost_luggage": 0.000002224974243130358, + "oil_change_when": 0.000004567532525249083, + "oos": 0.9954056318050842, + "payday": 0.0000030348168315008784, + "pto_balance": 0.000010677259062670748, + "pto_request": 0.0000010099028079285315, + "redeem_rewards": 0.0000028824516905475918, + "replacement_card_duration": 0.0017798759727523533, + "report_fraud": 0.000005316282280319043, + "schedule_maintenance": 0.00001912689310683893, + "schedule_meeting": 0.00033771326836954296, + "tire_pressure": 0.000004805041544828726, + "traffic": 0.0002215059679681998, + "transfer": 0.0006494661834674278, + "travel_alert": 0.000015027151638856005, + "vaccines": 0.0005528383479783906, + "w2": 0.00011048012841763236 + }, + "tie_break_triggered": false, + "wall_time_ms": 122 + } + ], + "samples_policy": 1, + "target_model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "target_url": "https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions", + "tie_break_enabled": true, + "tie_breaks_triggered": 4, + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:40:05Z", + "total_cases": 30, + "workers": 4 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/jevbench.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/jevbench.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c76dbe3 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/jevbench.json @@ -0,0 +1,6042 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:40:15Z", + "idc_config": "none", + "source": "live-evaluation", + "target_url": "https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions", + "target_model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "lock_commit_sha": "1df665e3956d7aab7fa0208ff6c4f2d8557f9f90", + "total_cases": 231, + "total_correct": 187, + "overall_accuracy_pct": 80.95238095238095, + "chance_baseline_pct": 31.760461760461773, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 72.08712201311059, + "paraphrase_pairs": 36, + "paraphrase_both_correct": 34, + "paraphrase_consistency_pct": 94.44444444444444, + "temperature_scale": 1, + "jev_parity": { + "protocol_version": "jevbench::v1.4", + "temperature_applied": 1, + "optimal_temperature": 1.75, + "chance_baseline_pct": 31.760461760461773, + "chance_corrected_acc_pct": 72.08712201311059, + "intelligence_score": 75.66581046370149, + "calibration_score": 74.6341055229255, + "speed_score": 82.79724900171038, + "cost_score": 57.55079956087546, + "composite_jevbench_score": 72.02380683212145, + "ece_10bin": 0.07348310899769057, + "brier_mean": 0.2566240466736764, + "soft_tvd_mean": 0.36035167154610914, + "probability_fidelity": 63.96483284538908, + "p50_latency_sec": 0.142, + "p95_latency_sec": 0.53, + "usd_per_1k_decisions": 0.026, + "presets": { + "Balanced 33:33:33 (no calibration)": 71.17415488299102, + "Emphasis on Accuracy 60:20:20": 72.93790194887347, + "Emphasis on Speed 20:60:20": 75.61357193863746, + "JevBench Score (25:25:25:25)": 76.02476293924009 + }, + "raw_t1_ece_10bin": 0.07348310899769057, + "raw_t1_brier_mean": 0.2566240466736764, + "raw_t1_calibration_score": 74.63410552292548, + "raw_t1_composite_score": 72.02380683212145, + "reliability_bins": [ + { + "bin_index": 0, + "range_label": "[0.0, 0.1)", + "lower": 0, + "upper": 0.1, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 1, + "range_label": "[0.1, 0.2)", + "lower": 0.1, + "upper": 0.2, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 2, + "range_label": "[0.2, 0.3)", + "lower": 0.2, + "upper": 0.30000000000000004, + "count": 0, + "avg_confidence": 0, + "empirical_accuracy": 0, + "abs_gap": 0 + }, + { + "bin_index": 3, + "range_label": "[0.3, 0.4)", + "lower": 0.30000000000000004, + "upper": 0.4, + "count": 5, + "avg_confidence": 0.38693905084180685, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.2, + "abs_gap": 0.18693905084180684 + }, + { + "bin_index": 4, + "range_label": "[0.4, 0.5)", + "lower": 0.4, + "upper": 0.5, + "count": 9, + "avg_confidence": 0.4510346909504418, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.2222222222222222, + "abs_gap": 0.2288124687282196 + }, + { + "bin_index": 5, + "range_label": "[0.5, 0.6)", + "lower": 0.5, + "upper": 0.6000000000000001, + "count": 12, + "avg_confidence": 0.5419517629358149, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.4166666666666667, + "abs_gap": 0.12528509626914824 + }, + { + "bin_index": 6, + "range_label": "[0.6, 0.7)", + "lower": 0.6000000000000001, + "upper": 0.7000000000000001, + "count": 14, + "avg_confidence": 0.6531098716891751, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.5, + "abs_gap": 0.15310987168917511 + }, + { + "bin_index": 7, + "range_label": "[0.7, 0.8)", + "lower": 0.7000000000000001, + "upper": 0.8, + "count": 12, + "avg_confidence": 0.7476335058754326, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.5833333333333334, + "abs_gap": 0.16430017254209928 + }, + { + "bin_index": 8, + "range_label": "[0.8, 0.9)", + "lower": 0.8, + "upper": 0.9, + "count": 20, + "avg_confidence": 0.8511041262804284, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.7, + "abs_gap": 0.15110412628042846 + }, + { + "bin_index": 9, + "range_label": "[0.9, 1.0]", + "lower": 0.9, + "upper": 1, + "count": 159, + "avg_confidence": 0.983270105350387, + "empirical_accuracy": 0.949685534591195, + "abs_gap": 0.03358457075919197 + } + ], + "endpoint_kind": "gpu", + "raw_speed_score": 91.23435786016154, + "adjusted_speed_score": 82.79724900171038, + "v14_intelligence_score": 75.66581046370149, + "v14_calibration_score": 92.65168910023095, + "v14_composite_score": 71.3414865564667, + "v14_public_only_estimate": true + }, + "by_tier": [ + { + "name": "easy", + "total": 48, + "correct": 48, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 28.437499999999975, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9707679636137944, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.11399549455891696, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.10716851351412532, + "avg_brier_score": 0.006470111636364066, + "ece_10bin": 0.029232036386205786, + "avg_latency_ms": 153.58333333333334 + }, + { + "name": "hard", + "total": 111, + "correct": 69, + "accuracy_pct": 62.16216216216216, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.61861861861862, + "chance_corrected_pct": 42.9993214204931, + "avg_confidence": 0.8185681635976575, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.4284389116347307, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.372418937797444, + "avg_brier_score": 0.4984046760609831, + "ece_10bin": 0.19694654197603575, + "avg_latency_ms": 267.7477477477477 + }, + { + "name": "standard", + "total": 72, + "correct": 70, + "accuracy_pct": 97.22222222222221, + "chance_baseline_pct": 31.11111111111113, + "chance_corrected_pct": 95.96774193548389, + "avg_confidence": 0.92384263563423, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.19974121224973918, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.17523422870622224, + "avg_brier_score": 0.050648199726453326, + "ece_10bin": 0.048379586587992504, + "avg_latency_ms": 123.40277777777777 + } + ], + "by_family": [ + { + "name": "adequacy", + "total": 12, + "correct": 12, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9472255281349686, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.14312444995063858, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.20648493417374694, + "avg_brier_score": 0.02650333047154936, + "ece_10bin": 0.05277447186503143, + "avg_latency_ms": 121.16666666666667 + }, + { + "name": "adversarial", + "total": 6, + "correct": 5, + "accuracy_pct": 83.33333333333334, + "chance_baseline_pct": 33.33333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 74.99999999999999, + "avg_confidence": 0.9133446245470555, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.13995583096208697, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.10417882860719278, + "avg_brier_score": 0.08336448462296776, + "ece_10bin": 0.0860219968275978, + "avg_latency_ms": 175.83333333333334 + }, + { + "name": "ambiguous", + "total": 7, + "correct": 5, + "accuracy_pct": 71.42857142857143, + "chance_baseline_pct": 32.142857142857146, + "chance_corrected_pct": 57.89473684210525, + "avg_confidence": 0.8849264873305668, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.29902731172747377, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.2717763296705983, + "avg_brier_score": 0.3340204913204884, + "ece_10bin": 0.24551278775092988, + "avg_latency_ms": 224.28571428571428 + }, + { + "name": "extraction", + "total": 24, + "correct": 24, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 24.375000000000004, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9757059410525257, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.09339898718121555, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.0667400029457547, + "avg_brier_score": 0.006203365329269925, + "ece_10bin": 0.024294058947474242, + "avg_latency_ms": 130.79166666666666 + }, + { + "name": "fact", + "total": 12, + "correct": 12, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.951382517345912, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.16003175453093663, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.23087701864654217, + "avg_brier_score": 0.012594470045164894, + "ece_10bin": 0.04861748265408805, + "avg_latency_ms": 165.16666666666666 + }, + { + "name": "intent", + "total": 24, + "correct": 24, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 20.000000000000007, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9840706374845295, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.06605384556412432, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.04104156181099589, + "avg_brier_score": 0.004261782132656398, + "ece_10bin": 0.015929362515470665, + "avg_latency_ms": 154.70833333333334 + }, + { + "name": "judge_hard", + "total": 17, + "correct": 13, + "accuracy_pct": 76.47058823529412, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 52.941176470588225, + "avg_confidence": 0.9456338645025245, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.13400614033157945, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.19332999410504018, + "avg_brier_score": 0.4169309095806367, + "ece_10bin": 0.1980340888999522, + "avg_latency_ms": 153.23529411764707 + }, + { + "name": "long_policy", + "total": 19, + "correct": 11, + "accuracy_pct": 57.89473684210527, + "chance_baseline_pct": 30.087719298245613, + "chance_corrected_pct": 39.7741530740276, + "avg_confidence": 0.7327298583690393, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.6011870340491228, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.5074060538242634, + "avg_brier_score": 0.5133365935831226, + "ece_10bin": 0.20051040601663078, + "avg_latency_ms": 467.10526315789474 + }, + { + "name": "multi_hop", + "total": 18, + "correct": 12, + "accuracy_pct": 66.66666666666666, + "chance_baseline_pct": 25.185185185185183, + "chance_corrected_pct": 55.44554455445544, + "avg_confidence": 0.7981124625549145, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.48678326350636364, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.3528019571789276, + "avg_brier_score": 0.4369780536229752, + "ece_10bin": 0.23457552363908588, + "avg_latency_ms": 363.8333333333333 + }, + { + "name": "ordinal", + "total": 12, + "correct": 11, + "accuracy_pct": 91.66666666666666, + "chance_baseline_pct": 25, + "chance_corrected_pct": 88.88888888888889, + "avg_confidence": 0.7771615772139023, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.5098731961869937, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.3677957658105906, + "avg_brier_score": 0.1736471309653276, + "ece_10bin": 0.16290830250200858, + "avg_latency_ms": 123.66666666666667 + }, + { + "name": "policy", + "total": 12, + "correct": 12, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 50, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9251950687187208, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.18257341013106512, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.26339775339427457, + "avg_brier_score": 0.03857292658803803, + "ece_10bin": 0.07480493128127928, + "avg_latency_ms": 121.91666666666667 + }, + { + "name": "probability", + "total": 10, + "correct": 5, + "accuracy_pct": 50, + "chance_baseline_pct": 38.333333333333336, + "chance_corrected_pct": 18.918918918918916, + "avg_confidence": 0.7926863702071273, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.43809268509034094, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.47832735959106054, + "avg_brier_score": 0.6086937265636657, + "ece_10bin": 0.2926863702071273, + "avg_latency_ms": 264.9 + }, + { + "name": "routing", + "total": 12, + "correct": 11, + "accuracy_pct": 91.66666666666666, + "chance_baseline_pct": 16.666666666666664, + "chance_corrected_pct": 89.99999999999999, + "avg_confidence": 0.9244746255445907, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.24110707559856326, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.13456442102825308, + "avg_brier_score": 0.05645626783158402, + "ece_10bin": 0.0613038170452441, + "avg_latency_ms": 124.16666666666667 + }, + { + "name": "routing_hard", + "total": 5, + "correct": 5, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 20, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.997675926782545, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.017280278957315084, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.010736840995115205, + "avg_brier_score": 0.000011512809608990049, + "ece_10bin": 0.0023240732174549805, + "avg_latency_ms": 160.6 + }, + { + "name": "temporal_numeric", + "total": 15, + "correct": 2, + "accuracy_pct": 13.333333333333334, + "chance_baseline_pct": 30.888888888888893, + "avg_confidence": 0.6591355967923568, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.8073202161899972, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.6304757693943938, + "avg_brier_score": 1.1550882785930592, + "ece_10bin": 0.5258022634590235, + "avg_latency_ms": 229.13333333333333 + }, + { + "name": "tool_selection", + "total": 12, + "correct": 12, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 20, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9811351942283505, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.09881369984522546, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.06139640372692629, + "avg_brier_score": 0.001065224078659757, + "ece_10bin": 0.018864805771649507, + "avg_latency_ms": 127.66666666666667 + }, + { + "name": "tradeoff", + "total": 6, + "correct": 4, + "accuracy_pct": 66.66666666666666, + "chance_baseline_pct": 30.83333333333333, + "chance_corrected_pct": 51.80722891566265, + "avg_confidence": 0.8507963658861627, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.432632268498232, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.38247183825290265, + "avg_brier_score": 0.5454422089519565, + "ece_10bin": 0.35642951310682, + "avg_latency_ms": 172.5 + }, + { + "name": "trap", + "total": 8, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 87.5, + "chance_baseline_pct": 37.5, + "chance_corrected_pct": 80, + "avg_confidence": 0.8644737732517784, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.373513893547024, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.3680386616490057, + "avg_brier_score": 0.13647384091648396, + "ece_10bin": 0.11213063112909925, + "avg_latency_ms": 142.75 + } + ], + "by_topic": [ + { + "name": "coding", + "total": 14, + "correct": 14, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 36.904761904761905, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9145964360765594, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.21871895865009058, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.22914862112604104, + "avg_brier_score": 0.049151660305100674, + "ece_10bin": 0.08540356392344045, + "avg_latency_ms": 169.35714285714286 + }, + { + "name": "everyday_language", + "total": 49, + "correct": 49, + "accuracy_pct": 100, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.18367346938776, + "chance_corrected_pct": 100, + "avg_confidence": 0.9771624662595045, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.09745269521549484, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.09552590367567111, + "avg_brier_score": 0.003596854802827207, + "ece_10bin": 0.022837533740495505, + "avg_latency_ms": 144.53061224489795 + }, + { + "name": "finance_commerce", + "total": 42, + "correct": 30, + "accuracy_pct": 71.42857142857143, + "chance_baseline_pct": 29.761904761904756, + "chance_corrected_pct": 59.322033898305094, + "avg_confidence": 0.839402432025075, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.3986479844728886, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.32596507910238826, + "avg_brier_score": 0.3319135465934463, + "ece_10bin": 0.12511671773936064, + "avg_latency_ms": 251.45238095238096 + }, + { + "name": "law_policy", + "total": 35, + "correct": 29, + "accuracy_pct": 82.85714285714286, + "chance_baseline_pct": 37.47619047619048, + "chance_corrected_pct": 72.5818735719726, + "avg_confidence": 0.839425854609324, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.3678455320626675, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.3607394261524205, + "avg_brier_score": 0.2094403647936816, + "ece_10bin": 0.1015471129260463, + "avg_latency_ms": 247.4857142857143 + }, + { + "name": "math", + "total": 24, + "correct": 13, + "accuracy_pct": 54.166666666666664, + "chance_baseline_pct": 41.31944444444445, + "chance_corrected_pct": 21.893491124260343, + "avg_confidence": 0.8281677537500353, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.38699174666544933, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.4060942761432873, + "avg_brier_score": 0.6375991076281532, + "ece_10bin": 0.3359989494293223, + "avg_latency_ms": 174.91666666666666 + }, + { + "name": "safety_security", + "total": 10, + "correct": 7, + "accuracy_pct": 70, + "chance_baseline_pct": 35.333333333333336, + "chance_corrected_pct": 53.6082474226804, + "avg_confidence": 0.9236870473102148, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.16687379523509466, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.13968506308873535, + "avg_brier_score": 0.37554077505472516, + "ece_10bin": 0.22368704731021488, + "avg_latency_ms": 172.1 + }, + { + "name": "support_ops", + "total": 57, + "correct": 45, + "accuracy_pct": 78.94736842105263, + "chance_baseline_pct": 26.023391812865487, + "chance_corrected_pct": 71.5415019762846, + "avg_confidence": 0.8691505895999401, + "avg_entropy_nats": 0.33330305058293674, + "avg_normalized_entropy": 0.24124699542471173, + "avg_brier_score": 0.3173196069067155, + "ece_10bin": 0.0973052757299425, + "avg_latency_ms": 199.68421052631578 + } + ], + "cases": [ + { + "id": "easy-intent-00", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "track_order", + "actual": "track_order", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9881317092583755, + "entropy_nats": 0.07541702231221578, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04685923062304138, + "brier_score": 0.00021502100750504558, + "wall_time_ms": 243, + "top_probabilities": { + "billing_question": 0.0014214673653694541, + "cancel_order": 0.008362821453673975, + "change_address": 0.0011757885425782422, + "report_damage": 0.0009082133800029562, + "track_order": 0.9881317092583755 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-01", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "cancel_order", + "actual": "cancel_order", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9981575764650411, + "entropy_nats": 0.015512300739001408, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009638334364536458, + "brier_score": 0.000004666621258760573, + "wall_time_ms": 245, + "top_probabilities": { + "billing_question": 0.00037152465727324655, + "cancel_order": 0.9981575764650411, + "change_address": 0.00007015388836954282, + "report_damage": 0.00042824993492837166, + "track_order": 0.0009724950543877473 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-02", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "change_address", + "actual": "change_address", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9956343279529345, + "entropy_nats": 0.033095287656204904, + "normalized_entropy": 0.020563258390099603, + "brier_score": 0.000025801040094402647, + "wall_time_ms": 242, + "top_probabilities": { + "billing_question": 0.00018877097958161864, + "cancel_order": 0.0015250838131171673, + "change_address": 0.9956343279529345, + "report_damage": 0.001983314581229537, + "track_order": 0.0006685026731372368 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-03", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "report_damage", + "actual": "report_damage", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9982554588855101, + "entropy_nats": 0.014924160607274821, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009272902354278238, + "brier_score": 0.000004045891450579679, + "wall_time_ms": 243, + "top_probabilities": { + "billing_question": 0.00031413068437360973, + "cancel_order": 0.0005964485261848302, + "change_address": 0.00010052195732610426, + "report_damage": 0.9982554588855101, + "track_order": 0.00073343994660533 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-04", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "billing_question", + "actual": "billing_question", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9913277330014147, + "entropy_nats": 0.05894879213831493, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03662694390562807, + "brier_score": 0.00010349715705528451, + "wall_time_ms": 149, + "top_probabilities": { + "billing_question": 0.9913277330014147, + "cancel_order": 0.003644502935992922, + "change_address": 0.0000721819425767832, + "report_damage": 0.003644502935992922, + "track_order": 0.0013110791840226167 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-05", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "track_order", + "actual": "track_order", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9863705895742602, + "entropy_nats": 0.08802022136708056, + "normalized_entropy": 0.054690038483037544, + "brier_score": 0.0002543741013049746, + "wall_time_ms": 150, + "top_probabilities": { + "billing_question": 0.0073118132801476676, + "cancel_order": 0.0015010673205487221, + "change_address": 0.00160266686467801, + "report_damage": 0.0032138629603654205, + "track_order": 0.9863705895742602 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-06", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "set_alarm", + "actual": "set_alarm", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9930471836918924, + "entropy_nats": 0.04471482890182688, + "normalized_entropy": 0.027782885289560848, + "brier_score": 0.00008644837407291256, + "wall_time_ms": 150, + "top_probabilities": { + "play_music": 0.006149638514664827, + "send_message": 0.00019035208735472173, + "set_alarm": 0.9930471836918924, + "turn_off_lights": 0.00012661573488755853, + "weather": 0.0004862099712005122 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-07", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "play_music", + "actual": "play_music", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9963962586251148, + "entropy_nats": 0.028080825764024597, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017447598038470086, + "brier_score": 0.000017906025450782254, + "wall_time_ms": 149, + "top_probabilities": { + "play_music": 0.9963962586251148, + "send_message": 0.000553369556136765, + "set_alarm": 0.0020205390067272264, + "turn_off_lights": 0.0005149164060105947, + "weather": 0.0005149164060105947 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-08", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "weather", + "actual": "weather", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9991616599615895, + "entropy_nats": 0.007870308696560852, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004890097738941581, + "brier_score": 9.059283386858168e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 161, + "top_probabilities": { + "play_music": 0.0003267087347491685, + "send_message": 0.00019250666203296616, + "set_alarm": 0.00022435675710278264, + "turn_off_lights": 0.00009476788452565446, + "weather": 0.9991616599615895 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-09", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "send_message", + "actual": "send_message", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9956860003385859, + "entropy_nats": 0.03339794620473799, + "normalized_entropy": 0.020751310719546313, + "brier_score": 0.000024016220396277802, + "wall_time_ms": 159, + "top_probabilities": { + "play_music": 0.0013749579463996284, + "send_message": 0.9956860003385859, + "set_alarm": 0.0008977569343348338, + "turn_off_lights": 0.001579985161887761, + "weather": 0.0004612996187918972 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-10", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "turn_off_lights", + "actual": "turn_off_lights", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9970979445632864, + "entropy_nats": 0.022528839938434873, + "normalized_entropy": 0.013997955288851402, + "brier_score": 0.000012383691509158047, + "wall_time_ms": 159, + "top_probabilities": { + "play_music": 0.0017638552895731208, + "send_message": 0.0009076553413202595, + "set_alarm": 0.00010614561619930628, + "turn_off_lights": 0.9970979445632864, + "weather": 0.00012439918962090185 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-intent-11", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "set_alarm", + "actual": "set_alarm", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9771650315985824, + "entropy_nats": 0.12186830116290806, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07572103292794655, + "brier_score": 0.000891119025457673, + "wall_time_ms": 158, + "top_probabilities": { + "play_music": 0.018982114799360007, + "send_message": 0.00042653544338668747, + "set_alarm": 0.9771650315985824, + "turn_off_lights": 0.00042653544338668747, + "weather": 0.0029997827152843776 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-00", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9858709245914467, + "entropy_nats": 0.07421187319159532, + "normalized_entropy": 0.10706510142859518, + "brier_score": 0.00039926154380117394, + "wall_time_ms": 159, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.014129075408553304, + "yes": 0.9858709245914467 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-01", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9910332499519221, + "entropy_nats": 0.05119776789652865, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07386276584890605, + "brier_score": 0.00016080521284940998, + "wall_time_ms": 158, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9910332499519221, + "yes": 0.00896675004807798 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-02", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9883315169974276, + "entropy_nats": 0.06353496888941057, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0916615845397872, + "brier_score": 0.00027230699116264175, + "wall_time_ms": 158, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.011668483002572371, + "yes": 0.9883315169974276 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-03", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8093748767888638, + "entropy_nats": 0.4871281311552818, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7027773390952337, + "brier_score": 0.07267587519852174, + "wall_time_ms": 157, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.8093748767888638, + "yes": 0.19062512321113617 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-04", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9826046248124993, + "entropy_nats": 0.08772143866339961, + "normalized_entropy": 0.126555284539332, + "brier_score": 0.0006051981558278281, + "wall_time_ms": 156, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.017395375187500617, + "yes": 0.9826046248124993 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-05", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9953749469466124, + "entropy_nats": 0.02947986309380083, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04253045229151203, + "brier_score": 0.000042782231493299225, + "wall_time_ms": 207, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9953749469466124, + "yes": 0.004625053053387517 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-06", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "support_ops", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9429998001539802, + "entropy_nats": 0.2186324129627778, + "normalized_entropy": 0.31541989795898745, + "brier_score": 0.0064980455649723875, + "wall_time_ms": 207, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.057000199846019735, + "yes": 0.9429998001539802 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-07", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "support_ops", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9334400599541646, + "entropy_nats": 0.24464827754689492, + "normalized_entropy": 0.35295285677893207, + "brier_score": 0.008860451237810414, + "wall_time_ms": 207, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9334400599541646, + "yes": 0.06655994004583544 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-08", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "safety_security", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9795278243043928, + "entropy_nats": 0.09987109207334285, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1440835292623768, + "brier_score": 0.0008382199554236219, + "wall_time_ms": 156, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.020472175695607237, + "yes": 0.9795278243043928 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-09", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "safety_security", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.994491816768475, + "entropy_nats": 0.03414391288344786, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04925925379349502, + "brier_score": 0.00006068016502410685, + "wall_time_ms": 139, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.994491816768475, + "yes": 0.005508183231525107 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-10", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9873197931940412, + "entropy_nats": 0.06798297537815233, + "normalized_entropy": 0.09807870144293687, + "brier_score": 0.0003215752892837691, + "wall_time_ms": 139, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.012680206805958808, + "yes": 0.9873197931940412 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-fact-11", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "fact", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8262207736871171, + "entropy_nats": 0.46182834063660694, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6662774567784118, + "brier_score": 0.060398438995808344, + "wall_time_ms": 139, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.8262207736871171, + "yes": 0.17377922631288295 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-00", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "paypal", + "actual": "paypal", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9979963872051787, + "entropy_nats": 0.015295148869012527, + "normalized_entropy": 0.011033117711491404, + "brier_score": 0.000007117178477309917, + "wall_time_ms": 175, + "top_probabilities": { + "bank_transfer": 0.000022200283568156438, + "cash": 0.00023597993990932034, + "credit_card": 0.0017454325713438922, + "paypal": 0.9979963872051787 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-01", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "cash", + "actual": "cash", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7553673508086226, + "entropy_nats": 0.7219249595968757, + "normalized_entropy": 0.520758779552189, + "brier_score": 0.09754393899274198, + "wall_time_ms": 138, + "top_probabilities": { + "bank_transfer": 0.18993873011573179, + "cash": 0.7553673508086226, + "credit_card": 0.019397986256730598, + "paypal": 0.03529593281891509 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-02", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "bank_transfer", + "actual": "bank_transfer", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.924553521461875, + "entropy_nats": 0.32129336171509526, + "normalized_entropy": 0.23176416980845593, + "brier_score": 0.009011399619824285, + "wall_time_ms": 140, + "top_probabilities": { + "bank_transfer": 0.924553521461875, + "cash": 0.0037381382778221787, + "credit_card": 0.01669416247367173, + "paypal": 0.05501417778663111 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-03", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "high", + "actual": "high", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9974061230810629, + "entropy_nats": 0.020455864619494824, + "normalized_entropy": 0.014755787221820593, + "brier_score": 0.000009687072005229962, + "wall_time_ms": 138, + "top_probabilities": { + "high": 0.9974061230810629, + "low": 0.0015001199431034858, + "medium": 0.00031197155970230975, + "urgent": 0.0007817854161312445 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-04", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "low", + "actual": "low", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8579056564240805, + "entropy_nats": 0.44863619348148004, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3236226057495164, + "brier_score": 0.03792356438878542, + "wall_time_ms": 143, + "top_probabilities": { + "high": 0.005502888284722798, + "low": 0.8579056564240805, + "medium": 0.13300224703799157, + "urgent": 0.0035892082532052298 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-05", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "urgent", + "actual": "urgent", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.995102353774945, + "entropy_nats": 0.03595424562489407, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02593550593096919, + "brier_score": 0.000033109785496879595, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "high": 0.0016664772624185565, + "low": 0.0008654264805029476, + "medium": 0.002365742482133422, + "urgent": 0.995102353774945 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-06", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "M", + "actual": "M", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9957609259715712, + "entropy_nats": 0.02992047427553475, + "normalized_entropy": 0.021583059929179894, + "brier_score": 0.000029992152361445204, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "L": 0.00016490103350856353, + "M": 0.9957609259715712, + "S": 0.0033964555782885117, + "XL": 0.0006777174166318023 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-07", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "XL", + "actual": "XL", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9906330704825991, + "entropy_nats": 0.05714608817019186, + "normalized_entropy": 0.041222189004669625, + "brier_score": 0.0001536992080458591, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "L": 0.00004903147715272768, + "M": 0.0013014333141354649, + "S": 0.00801646472611269, + "XL": 0.9906330704825991 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-08", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "thursday", + "actual": "thursday", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9892746095842199, + "entropy_nats": 0.0718086206303573, + "normalized_entropy": 0.044617204600179046, + "brier_score": 0.0001547732058376603, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "friday": 0.0035563861564715856, + "monday": 0.0004625562653210739, + "thursday": 0.9892746095842199, + "tuesday": 0.0018718153554988235, + "wednesday": 0.004834632638488701 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-09", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "monday", + "actual": "monday", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9984026920943598, + "entropy_nats": 0.013128741902270109, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008157345990697031, + "brier_score": 0.000004015326428530406, + "wall_time_ms": 122, + "top_probabilities": { + "friday": 0.00002071222817494126, + "monday": 0.9984026920943598, + "thursday": 0.00010288760324554223, + "tuesday": 0.0011652296221996512, + "wednesday": 0.00030847845202008314 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-10", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "friday", + "actual": "friday", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9901985605134686, + "entropy_nats": 0.0669934842917724, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04162539217834879, + "brier_score": 0.00012907818327521223, + "wall_time_ms": 122, + "top_probabilities": { + "friday": 0.9901985605134686, + "monday": 0.00494304158113277, + "thursday": 0.0022095731302019936, + "tuesday": 0.0016293365025093157, + "wednesday": 0.001019488272687275 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-extraction-11", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "credit_card", + "actual": "credit_card", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9976169892523986, + "entropy_nats": 0.01870226764850598, + "normalized_entropy": 0.013490834394938837, + "brier_score": 0.000008468862405057734, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "bank_transfer": 0.00010687483001308914, + "cash": 0.0008312271247158925, + "credit_card": 0.9976169892523986, + "paypal": 0.0014449087928724877 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-00", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "get_weather", + "actual": "get_weather", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9674876522361793, + "entropy_nats": 0.15387981462205766, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0956109045482414, + "brier_score": 0.001972124345305369, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "convert_currency": 0.0006134850758828735, + "create_calendar_event": 0.0013312317456261084, + "get_weather": 0.9674876522361793, + "send_email": 0.030212529675302347, + "translate_text": 0.00035510126700944784 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-01", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "send_email", + "actual": "send_email", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9988766494714733, + "entropy_nats": 0.009716361988863045, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00603711514050772, + "brier_score": 0.0000018886891278845716, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "convert_currency": 0.00005017967223069764, + "create_calendar_event": 0.00034282672095444915, + "get_weather": 0.0007115990295428177, + "send_email": 0.9988766494714733, + "translate_text": 0.000018745105798942887 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-02", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "create_calendar_event", + "actual": "create_calendar_event", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9942395634011578, + "entropy_nats": 0.0414477914982493, + "normalized_entropy": 0.025752960818205165, + "brier_score": 0.00004570834730025216, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "convert_currency": 0.0010932303965751858, + "create_calendar_event": 0.9942395634011578, + "get_weather": 0.00183231856391287, + "send_email": 0.0028236585094483495, + "translate_text": 0.000011229128905836059 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-03", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "convert_currency", + "actual": "convert_currency", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9619366531313809, + "entropy_nats": 0.18100964445272222, + "normalized_entropy": 0.11246761559069077, + "brier_score": 0.002538552432607384, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "convert_currency": 0.9619366531313809, + "create_calendar_event": 0.0003637830294733621, + "get_weather": 0.003860188510060248, + "send_email": 0.03276501825449058, + "translate_text": 0.0010743570745948925 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-04", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "translate_text", + "actual": "translate_text", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9961363730310521, + "entropy_nats": 0.030539714466815138, + "normalized_entropy": 0.018975391489707814, + "brier_score": 0.00001893908005089985, + "wall_time_ms": 134, + "top_probabilities": { + "convert_currency": 0.0006649651729674, + "create_calendar_event": 0.0009349472685759328, + "get_weather": 0.0013896943136480757, + "send_email": 0.0008740202137565925, + "translate_text": 0.9961363730310521 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-05", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "create_calendar_event", + "actual": "create_calendar_event", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9952128374142776, + "entropy_nats": 0.034367267695113904, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02135358402433626, + "brier_score": 0.00003365539215059724, + "wall_time_ms": 132, + "top_probabilities": { + "convert_currency": 0.00010037452957672794, + "create_calendar_event": 0.9952128374142776, + "get_weather": 0.0024456860129112522, + "send_email": 0.0021778452626930707, + "translate_text": 0.00006325678054150829 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-06", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "search_flights", + "actual": "search_flights", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9493873091838346, + "entropy_nats": 0.20848115450785631, + "normalized_entropy": 0.12953662449305123, + "brier_score": 0.0049733202541173555, + "wall_time_ms": 137, + "top_probabilities": { + "book_restaurant": 0.04909858314536507, + "call_taxi": 0.000651602212867629, + "get_stock_price": 0.0007540315278222324, + "search_flights": 0.9493873091838346, + "set_reminder": 0.0001084739301104551 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-07", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "book_restaurant", + "actual": "book_restaurant", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9955133837459514, + "entropy_nats": 0.031540482548144545, + "normalized_entropy": 0.019597203660029972, + "brier_score": 0.000033351401184986104, + "wall_time_ms": 135, + "top_probabilities": { + "book_restaurant": 0.9955133837459514, + "call_taxi": 0.00009608608155653892, + "get_stock_price": 0.0007916895544691928, + "search_flights": 0.0035472538238524856, + "set_reminder": 0.00005158679417042546 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-08", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "set_reminder", + "actual": "set_reminder", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.960172377006294, + "entropy_nats": 0.21388027448160185, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1328912863486179, + "brier_score": 0.002124294140883184, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "book_restaurant": 0.01718921210416772, + "call_taxi": 0.001397261782056821, + "get_stock_price": 0.013362838819052363, + "search_flights": 0.007878310288429155, + "set_reminder": 0.960172377006294 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-09", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "get_stock_price", + "actual": "get_stock_price", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9868314593626202, + "entropy_nats": 0.0805542274445604, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05005115563776602, + "brier_score": 0.0002710505964080745, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "book_restaurant": 0.009539200182716388, + "call_taxi": 0.0021501624274604526, + "get_stock_price": 0.9868314593626202, + "search_flights": 0.001420254673551968, + "set_reminder": 0.00005892335365115736 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-10", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "call_taxi", + "actual": "call_taxi", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.989258583698834, + "entropy_nats": 0.07123728987065193, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04426221683998562, + "brier_score": 0.00015544990254498132, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "book_restaurant": 0.0030528848412292157, + "call_taxi": 0.989258583698834, + "get_stock_price": 0.004735133285548273, + "search_flights": 0.0028854227854530675, + "set_reminder": 0.00006797538893546553 + } + }, + { + "id": "easy-tool_selection-11", + "tier": "easy", + "family": "tool_selection", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "set_reminder", + "actual": "set_reminder", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9785694890571505, + "entropy_nats": 0.12911037456606905, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08022078613197549, + "brier_score": 0.0006143543622361152, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "book_restaurant": 0.003957492891049975, + "call_taxi": 0.0011967683978870046, + "get_stock_price": 0.009801766462854055, + "search_flights": 0.00647448319105849, + "set_reminder": 0.9785694890571505 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-01-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-01", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9988938313223493, + "entropy_nats": 0.008635084092256084, + "normalized_entropy": 0.012457792997557029, + "brier_score": 0.0000024472182868308916, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9988938313223493, + "yes": 0.0011061686776507702 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-01-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-01", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9989618000956377, + "entropy_nats": 0.008170371254471637, + "normalized_entropy": 0.011787354091047971, + "brier_score": 0.00000215571808283565, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9989618000956377, + "yes": 0.0010381999043622212 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-02-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-02", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9922712766884041, + "entropy_nats": 0.04528210478465792, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06532826801384038, + "brier_score": 0.00011946632805441206, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.007728723311595917, + "yes": 0.9922712766884041 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-02-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-02", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8336065447945751, + "entropy_nats": 0.4501212231446924, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6493876564297222, + "brier_score": 0.0553735638703995, + "wall_time_ms": 121, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.16639345520542492, + "yes": 0.8336065447945751 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-03-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9791121960770974, + "entropy_nats": 0.10147446471436751, + "normalized_entropy": 0.14639670702028013, + "brier_score": 0.000872600705443248, + "wall_time_ms": 121, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.020887803922902612, + "yes": 0.9791121960770974 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-03-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5967117888558712, + "entropy_nats": 0.6743224165815859, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9728416063625157, + "brier_score": 0.32528276249566285, + "wall_time_ms": 119, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.4032882111441288, + "yes": 0.5967117888558712 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-04-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-04", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9978720069335191, + "entropy_nats": 0.015218366277566888, + "normalized_entropy": 0.021955461559077585, + "brier_score": 0.000009056708981981794, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9978720069335191, + "yes": 0.0021279930664809743 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-04-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-04", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9980914702549898, + "entropy_nats": 0.013856817666972377, + "normalized_entropy": 0.019991162130643624, + "brier_score": 0.000007284971575177492, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9980914702549898, + "yes": 0.0019085297450101828 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-05-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-05", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.995475077260146, + "entropy_nats": 0.028940903100041934, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04175289738127853, + "brier_score": 0.00004094985160329663, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.995475077260146, + "yes": 0.004524922739854142 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-05-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-05", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8499363872992839, + "entropy_nats": 0.42281941459671185, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6099994726302508, + "brier_score": 0.04503817571358105, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.8499363872992839, + "yes": 0.15006361270071616 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-06-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-06", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9957408206206955, + "entropy_nats": 0.027499588230608486, + "normalized_entropy": 0.039673519566787364, + "brier_score": 0.000036281217970185914, + "wall_time_ms": 122, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.004259179379304562, + "yes": 0.9957408206206955 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-policy-06-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-policy-06", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8656676244220795, + "entropy_nats": 0.3945401671288489, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5692011425482931, + "brier_score": 0.03609037425681501, + "wall_time_ms": 119, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.13433237557792058, + "yes": 0.8656676244220795 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-01-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "refund", + "actual": "refund", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9840724634836164, + "entropy_nats": 0.09179363901045791, + "normalized_entropy": 0.057034594687551496, + "brier_score": 0.000407616407510484, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.003969340576651861, + "change_address": 0.00017802867092610712, + "other": 0.011753378730511558, + "refund": 0.9840724634836164, + "status": 0.00002678853829393049 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-01-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "refund", + "actual": "refund", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.984955178113406, + "entropy_nats": 0.08921513217692424, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05543247831287634, + "brier_score": 0.0003382406830707779, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.006823658552989601, + "change_address": 0.00010595052882115264, + "other": 0.008082040305168318, + "refund": 0.984955178113406, + "status": 0.00003317249961491096 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-02-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-intent-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "status", + "actual": "status", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9921068801853851, + "entropy_nats": 0.051765267736519634, + "normalized_entropy": 0.032163569241531215, + "brier_score": 0.00010222038953907022, + "wall_time_ms": 122, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.0009779991629711119, + "change_address": 0.00034617423747439815, + "other": 0.006222772176694978, + "refund": 0.00034617423747439815, + "status": 0.9921068801853851 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-02-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-intent-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "status", + "actual": "status", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.77211646729418, + "entropy_nats": 0.5873352986659299, + "normalized_entropy": 0.36493193936114565, + "brier_score": 0.09947358702793016, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.005538159663729253, + "change_address": 0.0017963112981892644, + "other": 0.21794959828462307, + "refund": 0.0025994634592783773, + "status": 0.77211646729418 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-03-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "change_address", + "actual": "change_address", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9970264437400275, + "entropy_nats": 0.020430290784881736, + "normalized_entropy": 0.012694053387858334, + "brier_score": 0.00001754375753428864, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.000002661808273719511, + "change_address": 0.9970264437400275, + "other": 0.0029498284949729123, + "refund": 0.000009194915776017019, + "status": 0.000011871040949994759 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-03-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "change_address", + "actual": "change_address", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9966696019875689, + "entropy_nats": 0.02286258813885488, + "normalized_entropy": 0.014205324705118753, + "brier_score": 0.000021535979780982264, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.000008872709837438002, + "change_address": 0.9966696019875689, + "other": 0.0032311389374241792, + "refund": 0.00004339674796750475, + "status": 0.0000469896172019406 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-04-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "cancel", + "actual": "cancel", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9974478998252598, + "entropy_nats": 0.019155168829293526, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01190177557102741, + "brier_score": 0.000011134959338927212, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.9974478998252598, + "change_address": 0.000021504884728984524, + "other": 0.0021150606768439175, + "refund": 0.0003830747548705304, + "status": 0.00003245985829666741 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-04-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "cancel", + "actual": "cancel", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9964798585892186, + "entropy_nats": 0.025735101090759757, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01599011735211221, + "brier_score": 0.0000206673142705784, + "wall_time_ms": 127, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.9964798585892186, + "change_address": 0.0001586119239310948, + "other": 0.002837474414482522, + "refund": 0.0004383554466053425, + "status": 0.00008569962576238387 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-05-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-intent-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "other", + "actual": "other", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9971907283986183, + "entropy_nats": 0.021746145726798574, + "normalized_entropy": 0.013511640032084176, + "brier_score": 0.000011687751560398708, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.0008901961329498273, + "change_address": 0.00018170835626066283, + "other": 0.9971907283986183, + "refund": 0.0017233926606903072, + "status": 0.000013974451480773818 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-05-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-intent-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "other", + "actual": "other", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9985292914643763, + "entropy_nats": 0.012496289048458883, + "normalized_entropy": 0.007764380938162194, + "brier_score": 0.0000030430829708982543, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.0006069989968999911, + "change_address": 0.00016541970977257617, + "other": 0.9985292914643763, + "refund": 0.0006959038861797664, + "status": 0.0000023859427713689474 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-06-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "status", + "actual": "status", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9953540735832292, + "entropy_nats": 0.03381138985098493, + "normalized_entropy": 0.021008197700431247, + "brier_score": 0.0000331668341824689, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.0004767853597287562, + "change_address": 0.0003105828954897928, + "other": 0.0033102534388214397, + "refund": 0.0005483047227308099, + "status": 0.9953540735832292 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-intent-06-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "intent", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "original-intent-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "status", + "actual": "status", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9893149390472282, + "entropy_nats": 0.06456714699053388, + "normalized_entropy": 0.040117824050064206, + "brier_score": 0.0002021419121699623, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "cancel": 0.0006535508021661272, + "change_address": 0.0003690481487056506, + "other": 0.009343795319015642, + "refund": 0.0003186666828844091, + "status": 0.9893149390472282 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-01-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-01", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "0", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8941593995245184, + "entropy_nats": 0.35829059615109404, + "normalized_entropy": 0.25845203313216686, + "brier_score": 0.021449608260172993, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.8941593995245184, + "1": 0.10113611726148404, + "2": 0.004326482635651483, + "3": 0.0003780005783460648 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-01-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-01", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "0", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9783282932829165, + "entropy_nats": 0.10958069789329479, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07904576471390404, + "brier_score": 0.0008933326951040273, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.9783282932829165, + "1": 0.020567857042741715, + "2": 0.00044275137356325294, + "3": 0.0006610983007786191 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-02-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-02", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "1", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6109112548394805, + "entropy_nats": 0.8166477193936954, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5890868074612831, + "brier_score": 0.2711783676471991, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.34327958232990075, + "1": 0.6109112548394805, + "2": 0.04409661638601528, + "3": 0.0017125464446034783 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-02-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-02", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "1", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5626850708999533, + "entropy_nats": 0.7722301292088023, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5570462889172912, + "brier_score": 0.6576508269287135, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.5626850708999533, + "1": 0.41637010545552394, + "2": 0.020299448259603028, + "3": 0.000645375384919626 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-03-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-03", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "2", + "actual": "2", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7159193246366097, + "entropy_nats": 0.8127234865852918, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5862560718552943, + "brier_score": 0.12072085412647234, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.005497750470874489, + "1": 0.11495449744979848, + "2": 0.7159193246366097, + "3": 0.16362842744271744 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-03-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-03", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "2", + "actual": "2", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.49759144529493704, + "entropy_nats": 1.0211837043064558, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7366283330197727, + "brier_score": 0.40845553716682226, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.01723631829256129, + "1": 0.10465852639635358, + "2": 0.49759144529493704, + "3": 0.38051371001614814 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-04-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-04", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9603357769174673, + "entropy_nats": 0.19577937555510896, + "normalized_entropy": 0.14122496711084684, + "brier_score": 0.0025064046670124213, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.0034767880773751134, + "1": 0.00655463623910146, + "2": 0.02963279876605619, + "3": 0.9603357769174673 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-04-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-04", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "3", + "actual": "3", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9622225782297332, + "entropy_nats": 0.1959486213371924, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1413470521360984, + "brier_score": 0.0020758714778017157, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.0068594363175229385, + "1": 0.007593717671712377, + "2": 0.02332426778103142, + "3": 0.9622225782297332 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-05-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-05", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "0", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9644550665300328, + "entropy_nats": 0.15953971789488694, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1150835799158888, + "brier_score": 0.002444568202966484, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.9644550665300328, + "1": 0.03435714844509504, + "2": 0.000652380422022917, + "3": 0.0005354046028493007 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-05-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-05", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "0", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9727287511855139, + "entropy_nats": 0.1310602284982751, + "normalized_entropy": 0.09453997085611794, + "brier_score": 0.0014215510866015702, + "wall_time_ms": 127, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.9727287511855139, + "1": 0.0260198780612777, + "2": 0.000706481401288459, + "3": 0.0005448893519199389 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-06-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-06", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "2", + "actual": "2", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6288677578301529, + "entropy_nats": 0.7569899723607287, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5460528395637484, + "brier_score": 0.2594539848110542, + "wall_time_ms": 127, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.004929702509976285, + "1": 0.3483864652340152, + "2": 0.6288677578301529, + "3": 0.017816074425855703 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-ordinal-06-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "ordinal", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-ordinal-06", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "2", + "actual": "2", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5777342073955117, + "entropy_nats": 0.7885041050590968, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5687854810446746, + "brier_score": 0.3355146645140104, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.0025820162643924414, + "1": 0.39576171234243457, + "2": 0.5777342073955117, + "3": 0.023922063997661277 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-01-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "pickup", + "actual": "pickup", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9988352653282243, + "entropy_nats": 0.009668308864147561, + "normalized_entropy": 0.006974210626044247, + "brier_score": 0.0000023109274832199648, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.0009622193975722116, + "pickup": 0.9988352653282243, + "post": 0.00003821701378453118, + "unknown": 0.00016429826041897242 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-01-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "pickup", + "actual": "pickup", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9984507082891237, + "entropy_nats": 0.01203391074190371, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008680631674922456, + "brier_score": 0.000004473502443227341, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.0014369770427798893, + "pickup": 0.9984507082891237, + "post": 0.000024634929109483297, + "unknown": 0.00008767973898685356 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-02-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "unknown", + "actual": "unknown", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.998983160140019, + "entropy_nats": 0.008696325768770987, + "normalized_entropy": 0.006273073030280403, + "brier_score": 0.000001652527265223348, + "wall_time_ms": 118, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.0007472926286070918, + "pickup": 0.000243837442494817, + "post": 0.000025709788879189773, + "unknown": 0.998983160140019 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-02-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "unknown", + "actual": "unknown", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9992879484479188, + "entropy_nats": 0.006334561745631366, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004569420408313654, + "brier_score": 8.037600033281634e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 121, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.0005088031226399012, + "pickup": 0.00019437929777170563, + "post": 0.00000886913166968162, + "unknown": 0.9992879484479188 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-03-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "courier", + "actual": "courier", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9992994747042864, + "entropy_nats": 0.006272232416953733, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004524459301621074, + "brier_score": 7.452075923297783e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 130, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.9992994747042864, + "pickup": 0.0004220888453747516, + "post": 0.000002197276831876438, + "unknown": 0.0002762391735070281 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-03-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "courier", + "actual": "courier", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9977613651365439, + "entropy_nats": 0.01744094775272737, + "normalized_entropy": 0.012580984415631644, + "brier_score": 0.000007789563036527194, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.9977613651365439, + "pickup": 0.0015193083732658863, + "post": 0.00003480654451356885, + "unknown": 0.0006845199456767253 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-04-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "post", + "actual": "post", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9469813749392951, + "entropy_nats": 0.26471798405580094, + "normalized_entropy": 0.19095366141571385, + "brier_score": 0.0037784155928118615, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.01466253360936583, + "pickup": 0.02208116662624641, + "post": 0.9469813749392951, + "unknown": 0.01627492482509268 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-04-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "post", + "actual": "post", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9971034153215057, + "entropy_nats": 0.022808909600352485, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0164531503842566, + "brier_score": 0.000011571357030688578, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.0005981788108221955, + "pickup": 0.0008475395659826176, + "post": 0.9971034153215057, + "unknown": 0.001450866301689447 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-05-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "unknown", + "actual": "unknown", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.998315039572763, + "entropy_nats": 0.013161113366558884, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009493736493255977, + "brier_score": 0.000005018802523053369, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.0014617226663076357, + "pickup": 0.00020690838552388913, + "post": 0.000016329375405484587, + "unknown": 0.998315039572763 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-05-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "unknown", + "actual": "unknown", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9947910270908331, + "entropy_nats": 0.034657664517352714, + "normalized_entropy": 0.025000220363989075, + "brier_score": 0.000048713394799114556, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.0005149041219012901, + "pickup": 0.0046161453303367, + "post": 0.00007792345692889299, + "unknown": 0.9947910270908331 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-06-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "courier", + "actual": "courier", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9974021856812857, + "entropy_nats": 0.01996079381892963, + "normalized_entropy": 0.014398669127388426, + "brier_score": 0.000010073249841790499, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.9974021856812857, + "pickup": 0.0012892315812188609, + "post": 0.000019351156276640264, + "unknown": 0.0012892315812188609 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-extraction-06-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "extraction", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "original-extraction-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "courier", + "actual": "courier", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9995133799544408, + "entropy_nats": 0.004563488874559549, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0032918613842395092, + "brier_score": 3.56041963013602e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "courier": 0.9995133799544408, + "pickup": 0.0001884163117066643, + "post": 0.000008960056044316984, + "unknown": 0.0002892436778083285 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-01-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "math", + "group": "original-adequacy-01", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9902575416022018, + "entropy_nats": 0.05481472110396465, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07908092630440142, + "brier_score": 0.00018983099126565706, + "wall_time_ms": 132, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.00974245839779828, + "yes": 0.9902575416022018 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-01-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "math", + "group": "original-adequacy-01", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9799340701825623, + "entropy_nats": 0.0982955895144033, + "normalized_entropy": 0.14181055953368685, + "brier_score": 0.0008052830788766716, + "wall_time_ms": 132, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.02006592981743771, + "yes": 0.9799340701825623 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-02-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-02", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9877585429878064, + "entropy_nats": 0.06606446401108718, + "normalized_entropy": 0.09531087460778287, + "brier_score": 0.00029970653956276725, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9877585429878064, + "yes": 0.012241457012193677 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-02-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-02", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9955236168630563, + "entropy_nats": 0.028678836481591162, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04137481517045706, + "brier_score": 0.000040076011977426965, + "wall_time_ms": 131, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9955236168630563, + "yes": 0.004476383136943684 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-03-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "original-adequacy-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9828019974842712, + "entropy_nats": 0.08692409301938496, + "normalized_entropy": 0.12540495793283765, + "brier_score": 0.0005915425810620271, + "wall_time_ms": 120, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9828019974842712, + "yes": 0.01719800251572889 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-03-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "original-adequacy-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6212218589658707, + "entropy_nats": 0.6634627979798786, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9571744884598871, + "brier_score": 0.2869457602505415, + "wall_time_ms": 115, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.6212218589658707, + "yes": 0.3787781410341293 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-04-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-04", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9955043991505841, + "entropy_nats": 0.028782656335601925, + "normalized_entropy": 0.041524595558984204, + "brier_score": 0.000040420853994538195, + "wall_time_ms": 115, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0044956008494159705, + "yes": 0.9955043991505841 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-04-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-04", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9891958079556399, + "entropy_nats": 0.0596650637821808, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08607849163287594, + "brier_score": 0.0002334611314628289, + "wall_time_ms": 114, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.01080419204436013, + "yes": 0.9891958079556399 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-05-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-05", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9399555680229332, + "entropy_nats": 0.2270897611567966, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3276212722575696, + "brier_score": 0.007210667622897197, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9399555680229332, + "yes": 0.06004443197706678 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-05-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-05", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9969712143216, + "entropy_nats": 0.020589920020744796, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0297049755062289, + "brier_score": 0.00001834708537136234, + "wall_time_ms": 117, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9969712143216, + "yes": 0.0030287856784000475 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-06-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-06", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9912961225187344, + "entropy_nats": 0.04995696706744025, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07207266864604932, + "brier_score": 0.0001515149664177632, + "wall_time_ms": 117, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.008703877481265623, + "yes": 0.9912961225187344 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-adequacy-06-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "adequacy", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-adequacy-06", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8962855975643628, + "entropy_nats": 0.333168528934589, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4806605844742027, + "brier_score": 0.02151335454516263, + "wall_time_ms": 117, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.10371440243563727, + "yes": 0.8962855975643628 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-01-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "math", + "group": "original-routing-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "math", + "actual": "math", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.946616620002462, + "entropy_nats": 0.21842543862158376, + "normalized_entropy": 0.12190555840382311, + "brier_score": 0.005493250831280094, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.051391776874425706, + "coding_agent": 0.00017844476707977973, + "document": 0.00004182173751868964, + "general": 0.001497400565693913, + "math": 0.946616620002462, + "tools": 0.00027393605281989203 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-01-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "math", + "group": "original-routing-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "math", + "actual": "math", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9698544932042932, + "entropy_nats": 0.15208415973695413, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08487978567931144, + "brier_score": 0.0015458352915301392, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.024805929804806087, + "coding_agent": 0.0003843956083637954, + "document": 0.00012255946115309109, + "general": 0.0046422556990444435, + "math": 0.9698544932042932, + "tools": 0.00019036622233953573 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-02-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "original-routing-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "coding", + "actual": "coding", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9988639508844733, + "entropy_nats": 0.009833050511966777, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005487929982143841, + "brier_score": 0.0000019611596884951016, + "wall_time_ms": 119, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.9988639508844733, + "coding_agent": 0.000019379523688944913, + "document": 0.0000029811548177634696, + "general": 0.0002572532655289707, + "math": 0.0007726357895871254, + "tools": 0.00008379938190387093 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-02-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "original-routing-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "coding", + "actual": "coding", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9975631492961307, + "entropy_nats": 0.01964791221803443, + "normalized_entropy": 0.010965708598431103, + "brier_score": 0.000008385117930399221, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.9975631492961307, + "coding_agent": 0.0001548017787163279, + "document": 0.00000987331489133913, + "general": 0.0008758880065741091, + "math": 0.0012815931005167216, + "tools": 0.00011469450317081424 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-03-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "original-routing-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "coding_agent", + "actual": "coding_agent", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9962759181235729, + "entropy_nats": 0.028789191248871245, + "normalized_entropy": 0.016067553565811216, + "brier_score": 0.000019698202983876052, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.0022580911428939487, + "coding_agent": 0.9962759181235729, + "document": 0.00023808516473006885, + "general": 0.00046664962688737987, + "math": 0.0006689332149590458, + "tools": 0.00009232272695669904 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-03-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "original-routing-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "coding_agent", + "actual": "coding_agent", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.993974990676316, + "entropy_nats": 0.04252813261747446, + "normalized_entropy": 0.023735402741193203, + "brier_score": 0.00005640657043891342, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.00440840228186726, + "coding_agent": 0.993974990676316, + "document": 0.00032865403439290313, + "general": 0.0003527840109257219, + "math": 0.0004998478750770539, + "tools": 0.000435321121421043 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-04-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-routing-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "document", + "actual": "document", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9179308479762062, + "entropy_nats": 0.38659802020038675, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2157644632775096, + "brier_score": 0.008960426331345717, + "wall_time_ms": 119, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.034963195936525776, + "coding_agent": 0.0012805908238224147, + "document": 0.9179308479762062, + "general": 0.02921529539117919, + "math": 0.010488488520771742, + "tools": 0.00612158135149461 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-04-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "original-routing-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "document", + "actual": "general", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4146706555390088, + "entropy_nats": 1.3338344205476576, + "normalized_entropy": 0.744427164167473, + "brier_score": 0.6515404296535204, + "wall_time_ms": 117, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.1631613558234733, + "coding_agent": 0.010716449177624722, + "document": 0.3297119488615015, + "general": 0.4146706555390088, + "math": 0.05148711456056542, + "tools": 0.030252476037826218 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-05-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-routing-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "tools", + "actual": "tools", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9798771615368276, + "entropy_nats": 0.11290989890891638, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06301621442389331, + "brier_score": 0.0006564255476482172, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.0013381539382387093, + "coding_agent": 0.00006135495928623757, + "document": 0.00009852748248206689, + "general": 0.015486992746970492, + "math": 0.003137809336194953, + "tools": 0.9798771615368276 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-05-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-routing-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "tools", + "actual": "tools", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9781689004934819, + "entropy_nats": 0.11784258630830882, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06576919967894967, + "brier_score": 0.0008192387197588776, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.0018145785972119883, + "coding_agent": 0.00015179216872390728, + "document": 0.00007662141160274361, + "general": 0.018365641799990565, + "math": 0.0014224655289889157, + "tools": 0.9781689004934819 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-06-0", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-routing-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "general", + "actual": "general", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9581549932137172, + "entropy_nats": 0.20017582894297803, + "normalized_entropy": 0.11172025731178077, + "brier_score": 0.002993368600137658, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.03500947112088882, + "coding_agent": 0.0009224707799221614, + "document": 0.0003015119414073173, + "general": 0.9581549932137172, + "math": 0.0028903755755040673, + "tools": 0.002721177368560534 + } + }, + { + "id": "original-routing-06-1", + "tier": "standard", + "family": "routing", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "original-routing-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "general", + "actual": "general", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9417438255885977, + "entropy_nats": 0.2706162673196269, + "normalized_entropy": 0.15103381450871678, + "brier_score": 0.005379787952745386, + "wall_time_ms": 125, + "top_probabilities": { + "coding": 0.04360684141334704, + "coding_agent": 0.0015920734158305157, + "document": 0.0004913225693780814, + "general": 0.9417438255885977, + "math": 0.005116350421771236, + "tools": 0.007449586591075402 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "pay_subject_to_15000_sublimit", + "actual": "pay_subject_to_10000_sublimit", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5001844610704861, + "entropy_nats": 1.0553775717344989, + "normalized_entropy": 0.655742954469337, + "brier_score": 0.6204373213165884, + "wall_time_ms": 542, + "top_probabilities": { + "deny_repeated_seepage": 0.04477443537796784, + "deny_vacancy_exclusion": 0.04477443537796784, + "pay_full_estimate_less_deductible": 0.015254781877681109, + "pay_subject_to_10000_sublimit": 0.5001844610704861, + "pay_subject_to_15000_sublimit": 0.3950118862958971 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "cfo", + "actual": "vp_and_finance_director", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6647373003773983, + "entropy_nats": 0.6745143687604941, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4190993411733195, + "brier_score": 1.5448851532510628, + "wall_time_ms": 542, + "top_probabilities": { + "budget_holder": 0.0034941809620773995, + "cfo": 0.002598373968315773, + "department_head": 0.32891822443119506, + "executive_committee": 0.00025192026101350686, + "vp_and_finance_director": 0.6647373003773983 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-08", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "parts_covered_labour_charged", + "actual": "parts_covered_labour_charged", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8031505459796282, + "entropy_nats": 0.5213941039581671, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3761063440645962, + "brier_score": 0.07543692924388953, + "wall_time_ms": 535, + "top_probabilities": { + "full_repair_no_charge": 0.19146776861696566, + "not_covered": 0.005224023283555427, + "parts_covered_labour_charged": 0.8031505459796282, + "pro_rata_replacement_credit": 0.0001576621198508131 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-09", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "license_required", + "actual": "license_required", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.985336770181851, + "entropy_nats": 0.08519471714042973, + "normalized_entropy": 0.06145499796421797, + "brier_score": 0.000362695499879326, + "wall_time_ms": 541, + "top_probabilities": { + "license_exception_lvs": 0.011997224877298016, + "license_required": 0.985336770181851, + "no_license_required": 0.0016476413512805732, + "shipment_prohibited": 0.0010183635895703125 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-11", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-11", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.744246307535599, + "entropy_nats": 0.5685683874421438, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8202707929690156, + "brier_score": 1.1078051325607468, + "wall_time_ms": 368, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.744246307535599, + "yes": 0.255753692464401 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-13", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-13", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6689588226316491, + "entropy_nats": 0.6349135317791825, + "normalized_entropy": 0.915986603691124, + "brier_score": 0.895011812753444, + "wall_time_ms": 361, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.6689588226316491, + "yes": 0.33104117736835104 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-17", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-17", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "database_oncall", + "actual": "database_oncall", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.3783611043621361, + "entropy_nats": 1.4138248423324424, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8784587658893817, + "brier_score": 0.5126840436558138, + "wall_time_ms": 355, + "top_probabilities": { + "database_oncall": 0.3783611043621361, + "no_page_ticket_only": 0.23716736298833951, + "platform_oncall": 0.23716736298833951, + "security_incident_response": 0.11175163700958496, + "vendor_support": 0.03555253265159992 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-19", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-a-long_policy-19", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5206138999875396, + "entropy_nats": 0.6922970738934527, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9987735553280246, + "brier_score": 0.4596220657703134, + "wall_time_ms": 359, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.5206138999875396, + "yes": 0.4793861000124604 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-probability-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-opus-a-probability-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6909326963019264, + "entropy_nats": 0.6183523615086498, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8920938854705086, + "brier_score": 0.19104519643039447, + "tvd_gold": 0.07273269630192647, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 178, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.3090673036980735, + "yes": 0.6909326963019264 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "no": 0.3818, + "yes": 0.6182 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-probability-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-a-probability-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "on_time", + "actual": "late", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9867215873870717, + "entropy_nats": 0.07794842693957799, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07095171585426001, + "brier_score": 1.9536472333958674, + "tvd_gold": 0.6534215873870717, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 177, + "top_probabilities": { + "early": 0.0032366271980619936, + "late": 0.9867215873870717, + "on_time": 0.01004178541486629 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "early": 0.0667, + "late": 0.3333, + "on_time": 0.6 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-probability-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-a-probability-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "escalated", + "actual": "escalated", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9992191632660413, + "entropy_nats": 0.006672721495239879, + "normalized_entropy": 0.006073772853323422, + "brier_score": 0.0000010793729867512833, + "tvd_gold": 0.3325191632660413, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 176, + "top_probabilities": { + "escalated": 0.9992191632660413, + "reopened": 0.00010335219072175522, + "resolved_first_contact": 0.000677484543236996 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "escalated": 0.6667, + "reopened": 0.0833, + "resolved_first_contact": 0.25 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-probability-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-opus-a-probability-08", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5634600643408572, + "entropy_nats": 0.6850710562417273, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9883486154965041, + "brier_score": 0.6349744882140058, + "tvd_gold": 0.2734600643408572, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 172, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.4365399356591428, + "yes": 0.5634600643408572 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "no": 0.71, + "yes": 0.29 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9566427499843391, + "entropy_nats": 0.17847068681765177, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2574787748158735, + "brier_score": 1.8303307021951973, + "wall_time_ms": 208, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9566427499843391, + "yes": 0.04335725001566093 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-06", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-06", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8302352694104835, + "entropy_nats": 0.4555129672202691, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6571662988692992, + "brier_score": 1.378581205146196, + "wall_time_ms": 207, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.16976473058951655, + "yes": 0.8302352694104835 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "sep_26", + "actual": "sep_26", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7321245827098932, + "entropy_nats": 0.892019015155762, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5542425764077348, + "brier_score": 0.09651264400335606, + "wall_time_ms": 205, + "top_probabilities": { + "sep_24": 0.009790566095658588, + "sep_25": 0.08552120233567384, + "sep_26": 0.7321245827098932, + "sep_27": 0.05123494776493019, + "sep_28": 0.12132870109384412 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-09", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.7684903134448031, + "entropy_nats": 0.5410940878648054, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7806337572168918, + "brier_score": 1.1811547237169835, + "wall_time_ms": 205, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.23150968655519683, + "yes": 0.7684903134448031 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-12", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-a-temporal_numeric-12", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "1", + "actual": "0", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.3977826705099238, + "entropy_nats": 1.219301105101363, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8795398288400845, + "brier_score": 0.6725625570817065, + "wall_time_ms": 250, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.3977826705099238, + "1": 0.3224747934351162, + "2": 0.2297688635283642, + "3": 0.049973672526595944 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "ambiguous", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "real_incident", + "actual": "real_incident", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9933722140067761, + "entropy_nats": 0.04400050513443982, + "normalized_entropy": 0.040050985764762695, + "brier_score": 0.0000687897820510715, + "wall_time_ms": 249, + "top_probabilities": { + "cannot_determine": 0.00451773295547465, + "false_positive": 0.002110053037749293, + "real_incident": 0.9933722140067761 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "ambiguous", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "time_barred", + "actual": "time_barred", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7791908664377175, + "entropy_nats": 0.5434201128669877, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4946423032695156, + "brier_score": 0.0962450334455103, + "wall_time_ms": 249, + "top_probabilities": { + "insufficient_information": 0.002910326822152278, + "time_barred": 0.7791908664377175, + "within_limitation": 0.2178988067401303 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "ambiguous", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "within_policy", + "actual": "over_limit", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6397172400157086, + "entropy_nats": 0.8062377015096053, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7338691818995021, + "brier_score": 0.8937739741346462, + "wall_time_ms": 249, + "top_probabilities": { + "insufficient_information": 0.05425149304355232, + "over_limit": 0.6397172400157086, + "within_policy": 0.30603126694073907 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "ambiguous", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-09", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "legitimate", + "actual": "compromised", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8168202227695294, + "entropy_nats": 0.5074849372618966, + "normalized_entropy": 0.4619326968180379, + "brier_score": 1.3467515781127148, + "wall_time_ms": 206, + "top_probabilities": { + "compromised": 0.8168202227695294, + "inconclusive": 0.007497729142929414, + "legitimate": 0.17568204808754126 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-10", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "ambiguous", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-10", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "ask_user_which_alex", + "actual": "ask_user_which_alex", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9963183321550322, + "entropy_nats": 0.025919269535191667, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02359273585644541, + "brier_score": 0.000023489482385067595, + "wall_time_ms": 206, + "top_probabilities": { + "ask_user_which_alex": 0.9963183321550322, + "send_to_alex_moreno": 0.003097310186498188, + "send_to_alexandra_lind": 0.0005843576584696929 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-11", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "ambiguous", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-11", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "cannot_determine", + "actual": "cannot_determine", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9709950131731808, + "entropy_nats": 0.1509325673287988, + "normalized_entropy": 0.13738474335816891, + "brier_score": 0.0012745844824119303, + "wall_time_ms": 206, + "top_probabilities": { + "cannot_determine": 0.9709950131731808, + "grade_correct": 0.01701750744677001, + "grade_should_be_higher": 0.011987479380049149 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-13", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "ambiguous", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-ambiguous-13", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "cannot_determine", + "actual": "cannot_determine", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9980715227560223, + "entropy_nats": 0.015196088455396321, + "normalized_entropy": 0.010961660727755151, + "brier_score": 0.000005989803699412107, + "wall_time_ms": 205, + "top_probabilities": { + "cannot_determine": 0.9980715227560223, + "charge_data_team": 0.000031022307916737804, + "charge_platform_team": 0.0014333145180497275, + "split_50_50": 0.00046414041801122604 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "tier3_cfo", + "actual": "tier2_department_head", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4930180565854806, + "entropy_nats": 0.7664979305610501, + "normalized_entropy": 0.55291138163604, + "brier_score": 0.5001972001019404, + "wall_time_ms": 548, + "top_probabilities": { + "tier1_team_lead": 0.008033125265135936, + "tier2_department_head": 0.4930180565854806, + "tier3_cfo": 0.4930180565854806, + "tier4_board": 0.005930761563902909 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "bjorn", + "actual": "bjorn", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7453266705080224, + "entropy_nats": 0.857043213564663, + "normalized_entropy": 0.47832492490406847, + "brier_score": 0.08936994038916544, + "wall_time_ms": 547, + "top_probabilities": { + "ana": 0.07020802811960845, + "bjorn": 0.7453266705080224, + "chen": 0.04008734701228454, + "dmitri": 0.13378502773533496, + "esra": 0.002076654441806763, + "no_page_ticket_only": 0.008516272182942914 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-05", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-05", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "2", + "actual": "4", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4841106265804276, + "entropy_nats": 1.2363425173331304, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7681827971004463, + "brier_score": 1.256826625265138, + "wall_time_ms": 403, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.020964666225340933, + "1": 0.23954245930340398, + "2": 0.04142513436392594, + "3": 0.21395711352690164, + "4": 0.4841106265804276 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "credit_20_percent", + "actual": "credit_25_percent", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.39914977630819615, + "entropy_nats": 1.259505256008955, + "normalized_entropy": 0.702943267575747, + "brier_score": 0.5623436483398191, + "wall_time_ms": 547, + "top_probabilities": { + "credit_10_percent": 0.09704076179448617, + "credit_20_percent": 0.3824094729894561, + "credit_25_percent": 0.39914977630819615, + "credit_50_percent": 0.10996893008490999, + "credit_full_month": 0.0018661286013692455, + "no_credit": 0.00956493022158243 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-b-multi_hop-08", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5254434923994796, + "entropy_nats": 0.6918518785832461, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9981312742617625, + "brier_score": 0.4504077578120055, + "wall_time_ms": 494, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.5254434923994796, + "yes": 0.4745565076005205 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-probability-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-probability-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "merchant_wins", + "actual": "merchant_wins", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9082578418836983, + "entropy_nats": 0.3449249044104093, + "normalized_entropy": 0.31396417823486683, + "brier_score": 0.014716966646246665, + "tvd_gold": 0.25825784188369827, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 350, + "top_probabilities": { + "customer_wins": 0.07821324412553547, + "customer_withdraws": 0.0135289139907663, + "merchant_wins": 0.9082578418836983 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "customer_wins": 0.25, + "customer_withdraws": 0.1, + "merchant_wins": 0.65 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-probability-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-opus-b-probability-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "upstream_provider", + "actual": "bad_push", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6939693401255216, + "entropy_nats": 0.631588014141481, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5748961855389217, + "brier_score": 0.9670201472831425, + "tvd_gold": 0.49396934012552157, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 349, + "top_probabilities": { + "bad_push": 0.6939693401255216, + "database_hardware": 0.002750929877940601, + "upstream_provider": 0.30327972999653785 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "bad_push": 0.2, + "database_hardware": 0.15, + "upstream_provider": 0.65 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-probability-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-probability-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.952611942271037, + "entropy_nats": 0.19075150892978562, + "normalized_entropy": 0.27519625597508857, + "brier_score": 0.004491256030647067, + "tvd_gold": 0.26511194227103696, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 349, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.04738805772896307, + "yes": 0.952611942271037 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "no": 0.3125, + "yes": 0.6875 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-probability-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-opus-b-probability-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "attended", + "actual": "attended", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9854910570205669, + "entropy_nats": 0.08004465686212293, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07285978655778937, + "brier_score": 0.0003882146985940834, + "tvd_gold": 0.18549105702056692, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 183, + "top_probabilities": { + "attended": 0.9854910570205669, + "late_cancellation": 0.0012357274752470876, + "no_show": 0.013273215504185977 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "attended": 0.8, + "late_cancellation": 0.12, + "no_show": 0.08 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-probability-06", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-b-probability-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "upheld", + "actual": "overturned", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5082715238690425, + "entropy_nats": 0.8673069858564884, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7894568400540635, + "brier_score": 1.3394029576012734, + "tvd_gold": 0.6315245372588614, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 186, + "top_probabilities": { + "modified": 0.43575301338981887, + "overturned": 0.5082715238690425, + "upheld": 0.055975462741138717 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "modified": 0.0625, + "overturned": 0.25, + "upheld": 0.6875 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "tradeoff", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "escalate_to_engineering", + "actual": "escalate_to_security", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.7297946098339266, + "entropy_nats": 0.7166939638766916, + "normalized_entropy": 0.445306997144593, + "brier_score": 1.1219276945089747, + "wall_time_ms": 186, + "top_probabilities": { + "escalate_to_engineering": 0.23287272658479818, + "escalate_to_security": 0.7297946098339266, + "page_oncall": 0.027759418308491667, + "process_refund": 0.0011219581546512974, + "send_kb_article": 0.008451287118132188 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "tradeoff", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "order_b", + "actual": "order_b", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6622184911054598, + "entropy_nats": 0.9307002555930352, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6713583216490813, + "brier_score": 0.16982151613888125, + "wall_time_ms": 186, + "top_probabilities": { + "order_a": 0.08951885128123298, + "order_b": 0.6622184911054598, + "order_c": 0.032222759917549665, + "order_d": 0.21603989769575754 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-06", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "tradeoff", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-06", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9325781331901475, + "entropy_nats": 0.24691847625932103, + "normalized_entropy": 0.35622806120318173, + "brier_score": 0.009091416248250984, + "wall_time_ms": 170, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.06742186680985257, + "yes": 0.9325781331901475 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "tradeoff", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "p0_fix_24h", + "actual": "p2_fix_30d", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9659628619774185, + "entropy_nats": 0.1875030243597375, + "normalized_entropy": 0.11650217937028681, + "brier_score": 1.9075703645762823, + "wall_time_ms": 165, + "top_probabilities": { + "out_of_scope": 0.0013872034824269786, + "p0_fix_24h": 0.012961301443087232, + "p1_fix_7d": 0.005102168425812516, + "p2_fix_30d": 0.9659628619774185, + "p3_backlog": 0.014586464671254804 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "tradeoff", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-08", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8208820672325684, + "entropy_nats": 0.47005332736192645, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6781436043384078, + "brier_score": 0.06416646767775629, + "wall_time_ms": 164, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.17911793276743165, + "yes": 0.8208820672325684 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-12", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "tradeoff", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-b-tradeoff-12", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "refund_now", + "actual": "refund_now", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9933420319774552, + "entropy_nats": 0.04392456353868019, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02729186581186537, + "brier_score": 0.00007579456159360512, + "wall_time_ms": 164, + "top_probabilities": { + "deny_refund": 0.00073482228629562, + "escalate_to_fraud_team": 0.00011057098537451416, + "offer_store_credit": 0.0002585693908439193, + "refund_now": 0.9933420319774552, + "wait_for_inspection": 0.005554005360030814 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "erase_but_retain_transaction_records", + "actual": "erase_but_retain_transaction_records", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9933601420108319, + "entropy_nats": 0.04710933644760156, + "normalized_entropy": 0.029270676478817252, + "brier_score": 0.00005981777588171358, + "wall_time_ms": 531, + "top_probabilities": { + "erase_all": 0.00256817198483454, + "erase_but_retain_transaction_records": 0.9933601420108319, + "erase_marketing_only": 0.00003993613204611722, + "reject_unverified_request": 0.001306841787864672, + "restrict_all_pending_legal_hold": 0.002724908084422834 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "eur_400", + "actual": "eur_150", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.37457314700611677, + "entropy_nats": 1.4753785987718118, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8234244741608371, + "brier_score": 0.6365669096017305, + "wall_time_ms": 531, + "top_probabilities": { + "eur_0": 0.08038898713612838, + "eur_150": 0.37457314700611677, + "eur_200": 0.11575351588817773, + "eur_300": 0.09684711485459539, + "eur_400": 0.3167896438988281, + "eur_600": 0.01564759121615357 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-04", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.7610830579953485, + "entropy_nats": 0.5498282905090117, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7932345480578076, + "brier_score": 0.11416261035370803, + "wall_time_ms": 531, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.23891694200465155, + "yes": 0.7610830579953485 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-05", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-05", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "1", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.5312245382356099, + "entropy_nats": 1.082502270402282, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7808603286302079, + "brier_score": 0.3318156462227158, + "wall_time_ms": 531, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.11333075739076476, + "1": 0.5312245382356099, + "2": 0.31198121253857364, + "3": 0.04346349183505185 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-08", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "1", + "actual": "2", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.7222590714722997, + "entropy_nats": 0.7798914236564127, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5625727446704701, + "brier_score": 1.1629310909009372, + "wall_time_ms": 530, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.008421458650534374, + "1": 0.20207738147232504, + "2": 0.7222590714722997, + "3": 0.06724208840484076 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-10", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-10", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "credit_minus_restocking_fee", + "actual": "credit_minus_restocking_fee", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9771838767943493, + "entropy_nats": 0.11492891232271614, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08290368593137253, + "brier_score": 0.000981539395805085, + "wall_time_ms": 530, + "top_probabilities": { + "credit_minus_restocking_fee": 0.9771838767943493, + "full_credit": 0.021448272901142384, + "reject_return": 0.000683925152254211, + "repair_or_replace_only": 0.000683925152254211 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-11", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-c-long_policy-11", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9223564913300115, + "entropy_nats": 0.27297593431110045, + "normalized_entropy": 0.39382102671265606, + "brier_score": 1.7014829941972192, + "wall_time_ms": 529, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.07764350866998845, + "yes": 0.9223564913300115 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-probability-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "probability", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-opus-c-probability-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "kuznets_technik", + "actual": "ortega_seal_works", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6379284856055104, + "entropy_nats": 0.8782662145179281, + "normalized_entropy": 0.799432359875279, + "brier_score": 0.9812497259634998, + "tvd_gold": 0.4370284856055105, + "has_gold_probs": true, + "wall_time_ms": 529, + "top_probabilities": { + "halvorsen_polymer": 0.11162871861387652, + "kuznets_technik": 0.25044279578061296, + "ortega_seal_works": 0.6379284856055104 + }, + "gold_probs": { + "halvorsen_polymer": 0.1964, + "kuznets_technik": 0.6027, + "ortega_seal_works": 0.2009 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-02", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9843096862996629, + "entropy_nats": 0.08075530204280493, + "normalized_entropy": 0.11650527378264505, + "brier_score": 1.9377311170866813, + "wall_time_ms": 328, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9843096862996629, + "yes": 0.015690313700337178 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "eur_692_00", + "actual": "eur_688_00", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5167314847735429, + "entropy_nats": 1.1121651539734323, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6910270631635632, + "brier_score": 1.246831570084677, + "wall_time_ms": 327, + "top_probabilities": { + "eur_617_00": 0.328813683415553, + "eur_688_00": 0.5167314847735429, + "eur_692_00": 0.06998029544450327, + "eur_693_90": 0.08221901288281637, + "eur_812_00": 0.002255523483584442 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "usd_2335_00", + "actual": "usd_2303_33", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8857452950912227, + "entropy_nats": 0.38859974184674373, + "normalized_entropy": 0.24145059517022857, + "brier_score": 1.7931824533367484, + "wall_time_ms": 326, + "top_probabilities": { + "usd_2222_50": 0.004700842487584549, + "usd_2303_01": 0.10704337002715793, + "usd_2303_33": 0.8857452950912227, + "usd_2335_00": 0.0014229314745438128, + "usd_2340_00": 0.0010875609194911113 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-06", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 6, + "chance_baseline": 0.16666666666666666, + "expected": "sep_18_book_set", + "actual": "sep_15_office_chair", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4106974646445367, + "entropy_nats": 1.4963934514652668, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8351530867644634, + "brier_score": 1.11453901993185, + "wall_time_ms": 325, + "top_probabilities": { + "none_declined": 0.018745653613787952, + "sep_15_office_chair": 0.4106974646445367, + "sep_16_taxi": 0.10110135301317329, + "sep_17_parking": 0.1504447474868428, + "sep_18_book_set": 0.07607289697783352, + "sep_21_client_dinner": 0.24293788426382568 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-08", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "eur_498_81", + "actual": "eur_513_69", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5748425981932485, + "entropy_nats": 1.0004234754229318, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6215980546338068, + "brier_score": 1.1786454269525826, + "wall_time_ms": 246, + "top_probabilities": { + "eur_497_40": 0.014014062453909933, + "eur_498_81": 0.1246204188485227, + "eur_506_06": 0.28585865030942875, + "eur_513_69": 0.5748425981932485, + "eur_532_01": 0.0006642701948901523 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-12", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-opus-c-temporal_numeric-12", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "expired_30_month_cap", + "actual": "expired_24_month_term", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.44868083641355977, + "entropy_nats": 1.0225073596374428, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9307263082566355, + "brier_score": 0.6018770389387724, + "wall_time_ms": 246, + "top_probabilities": { + "covered": 0.1628967826737754, + "expired_24_month_term": 0.44868083641355977, + "expired_30_month_cap": 0.38842238091266484 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "adversarial", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "deny_missing_approval", + "actual": "deny_missing_approval", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9993572014537943, + "entropy_nats": 0.005653794195621829, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00407835042411521, + "brier_score": 7.267021287177729e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 243, + "top_probabilities": { + "deny_inactive_user": 0.00007971857149089859, + "deny_missing_approval": 0.9993572014537943, + "grant_access": 0.0005541455431615608, + "grant_owner_exception": 0.00000893443155326554 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-06", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "adversarial", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-06", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9981679698222665, + "entropy_nats": 0.013376410724577806, + "normalized_entropy": 0.019298081417242346, + "brier_score": 0.000006712669144252326, + "wall_time_ms": 244, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9981679698222665, + "yes": 0.0018320301777334299 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "adversarial", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "retain_until_2031", + "actual": "retain_until_2031", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9932268772090673, + "entropy_nats": 0.04370215267239367, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03152443946831735, + "brier_score": 0.0000812836361720777, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "delete_now": 0.005916506526417877, + "needs_signature_review": 0.0005633981791984663, + "retain_indefinitely": 0.000293218085316415, + "retain_until_2031": 0.9932268772090673 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "adversarial", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-08", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9981604554825563, + "entropy_nats": 0.01342373938026175, + "normalized_entropy": 0.019366362234089513, + "brier_score": 0.000006767848063314536, + "wall_time_ms": 143, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.001839544517443753, + "yes": 0.9981604554825563 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "adversarial", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-09", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "2", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4980998641239599, + "entropy_nats": 0.7165069739352485, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5168505290293705, + "brier_score": 0.5000196312875791, + "wall_time_ms": 143, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.0035109155303382896, + "1": 0.4980998641239599, + "2": 0.4980998641239599, + "3": 0.0002893562217419581 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-11", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "adversarial", + "topic": "safety_security", + "group": "hard-sol-a-adversarial-11", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "standard_research", + "actual": "standard_research", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9930553791906886, + "entropy_nats": 0.04707191486441822, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03395520907002182, + "brier_score": 0.0000717855947190947, + "wall_time_ms": 140, + "top_probabilities": { + "ethics_review": 0.004164167709056165, + "major_grants": 0.0003057718245928993, + "manual_hold": 0.002474681275662279, + "standard_research": 0.9930553791906886 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "accept_s2_dusk", + "actual": "accept_s2_dusk", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.99658280867011, + "entropy_nats": 0.02365502784293609, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017063495680547127, + "brier_score": 0.00002215866944005531, + "wall_time_ms": 355, + "top_probabilities": { + "accept_s2_dusk": 0.99658280867011, + "reject_cutoff": 0.00008713931427797403, + "reject_tier": 0.0032349394419713966, + "reroute_s3": 0.00009511257364072912 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "security_primary", + "actual": "insufficient_information", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.646793917633335, + "entropy_nats": 0.8707393195367786, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6281056491013706, + "brier_score": 1.2720047364889635, + "wall_time_ms": 355, + "top_probabilities": { + "executive_bridge": 0.00043427927588162736, + "heron_q2": 0.24392885435417203, + "insufficient_information": 0.646793917633335, + "security_primary": 0.10884294873661138 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-05", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "require_director", + "actual": "require_director", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9217609923497778, + "entropy_nats": 0.3139090313932605, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2264375014406574, + "brier_score": 0.010384106168785394, + "wall_time_ms": 353, + "top_probabilities": { + "pay_manager_approved": 0.014029908015312545, + "reject_category": 0.0004460494280422551, + "require_director": 0.9217609923497778, + "require_finance_board": 0.06376305020686732 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "admit", + "actual": "admit", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.857492964253315, + "entropy_nats": 0.4500766175599638, + "normalized_entropy": 0.32466165208691916, + "brier_score": 0.038024958550744656, + "wall_time_ms": 353, + "top_probabilities": { + "admit": 0.857492964253315, + "deny_prerequisite": 0.002363287998330771, + "deny_score": 0.13288502204714117, + "manual_equivalency": 0.007258725701213077 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-08", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "central_engineering", + "actual": "local_maintenance", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8795902428446689, + "entropy_nats": 0.4886454254426915, + "normalized_entropy": 0.35248316601962437, + "brier_score": 1.666352760577165, + "wall_time_ms": 325, + "top_probabilities": { + "central_engineering": 0.05648464596886835, + "insufficient_log": 0.046268709112414826, + "local_maintenance": 0.8795902428446689, + "safety_shutdown": 0.017656402074047804 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-09", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "require_steward", + "actual": "require_steward", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9976197077892547, + "entropy_nats": 0.018669793603142533, + "normalized_entropy": 0.013467409322837113, + "brier_score": 0.000008756201266009776, + "wall_time_ms": 325, + "top_probabilities": { + "confirm_l3": 0.0016885334329338206, + "reject_capacity": 0.00034587938890578475, + "require_steward": 0.9976197077892547, + "switch_l4": 0.00034587938890578475 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-10", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-10", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "approve_45_days", + "actual": "approve_45_days", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6450184670224707, + "entropy_nats": 0.8350441970350866, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6023570609928129, + "brier_score": 0.21622961935647966, + "wall_time_ms": 328, + "top_probabilities": { + "approve_45_days": 0.6450184670224707, + "deny_sensitive": 0.008864486782966497, + "needs_field_review": 0.050093799208165604, + "reduce_to_30_days": 0.2960232469863972 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-12", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-a-multi_hop-12", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "needs_authentication", + "actual": "covered_recurrence", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8890178245181096, + "entropy_nats": 0.3944259899453901, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2845182098459672, + "brier_score": 1.79476217837155, + "wall_time_ms": 321, + "top_probabilities": { + "covered_recurrence": 0.8890178245181096, + "expired": 0.09835365940413988, + "needs_authentication": 0.002685019356767285, + "wrong_issue_class": 0.009943496720983224 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-02", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9258658225015924, + "entropy_nats": 0.2642038304380855, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3811655559568945, + "brier_score": 0.010991752546730797, + "wall_time_ms": 151, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9258658225015924, + "yes": 0.07413417749840767 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-04", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9468455559423806, + "entropy_nats": 0.20770059223925105, + "normalized_entropy": 0.29964861441326823, + "brier_score": 0.005650789846149176, + "wall_time_ms": 151, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9468455559423806, + "yes": 0.053154444057619425 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-05", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-05", + "question_type": "score", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "0", + "actual": "1", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.4064176175235106, + "entropy_nats": 1.271280599728335, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9170351084032081, + "brier_score": 0.9906185320316113, + "wall_time_ms": 150, + "top_probabilities": { + "0": 0.15768692670890863, + "1": 0.4064176175235106, + "2": 0.3202939896172502, + "3": 0.11560146615033073 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-06", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "keep_open_unresolved", + "actual": "keep_open_unresolved", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9790069629931006, + "entropy_nats": 0.10418605761647903, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07515435432653306, + "brier_score": 0.0008644162181239975, + "wall_time_ms": 145, + "top_probabilities": { + "await_internal_metrics": 0.00022026902455134115, + "close_agent_verified": 0.00019064585988744424, + "close_confirmed": 0.02058212212246061, + "keep_open_unresolved": 0.9790069629931006 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-08", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "late", + "actual": "late", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9918111268973555, + "entropy_nats": 0.0484002485425306, + "normalized_entropy": 0.034913399275051084, + "brier_score": 0.00013147426426011026, + "wall_time_ms": 139, + "top_probabilities": { + "canceled": 0.00004299083876268398, + "indeterminate": 0.00012091162622075954, + "late": 0.9918111268973555, + "on_time": 0.008024970637661112 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-10", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-10", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "blocked_second_review", + "actual": "blocked_second_review", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8731847105083197, + "entropy_nats": 0.4706760203200149, + "normalized_entropy": 0.33952098019051924, + "brier_score": 0.025001054132824004, + "wall_time_ms": 134, + "top_probabilities": { + "blocked_failed_test": 0.003383036986238841, + "blocked_second_review": 0.8731847105083197, + "ready_one_review": 0.03632192351438357, + "ready_two_reviews": 0.08711032899105785 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-13", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-13", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8339950851632247, + "entropy_nats": 0.4494945822142252, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6484836046669192, + "brier_score": 0.05511526349993002, + "wall_time_ms": 137, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.8339950851632247, + "yes": 0.16600491483677537 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-a-trap-15", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "trap", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-a-trap-15", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9586633044847431, + "entropy_nats": 0.1721692172772707, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2483876759596529, + "brier_score": 0.003417444792242115, + "wall_time_ms": 135, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9586633044847431, + "yes": 0.04133669551525692 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-01", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9971626826877422, + "entropy_nats": 0.01947386006953239, + "normalized_entropy": 0.028094841349279982, + "brier_score": 0.000016100739060875438, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0028373173122577017, + "yes": 0.9971626826877422 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-02", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9983696951645183, + "entropy_nats": 0.01209388277475315, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01744778470422883, + "brier_score": 1.9934840964457865, + "wall_time_ms": 123, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0016303048354816033, + "yes": 0.9983696951645183 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-05", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-05", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9773089180038822, + "entropy_nats": 0.10833518895337743, + "normalized_entropy": 0.15629463985680644, + "brier_score": 0.001029770404309083, + "wall_time_ms": 122, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.02269108199611779, + "yes": 0.9773089180038822 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-08", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9948141314071821, + "entropy_nats": 0.03245949502129493, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04682915249698219, + "brier_score": 1.9793103120948519, + "wall_time_ms": 124, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.005185868592817951, + "yes": 0.9948141314071821 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-10", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-10", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.9912961225187344, + "entropy_nats": 0.04995696706744025, + "normalized_entropy": 0.07207266864604932, + "brier_score": 1.965336005041355, + "wall_time_ms": 129, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.008703877481265623, + "yes": 0.9912961225187344 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-14", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "everyday_language", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-14", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9981962978856443, + "entropy_nats": 0.0131977092978087, + "normalized_entropy": 0.019040269755042777, + "brier_score": 0.000006506682634662115, + "wall_time_ms": 127, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9981962978856443, + "yes": 0.0018037021143557305 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-15", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-15", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9991246262777969, + "entropy_nats": 0.007038373991602378, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01015422725360661, + "brier_score": 0.0000015325583070475717, + "wall_time_ms": 128, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.0008753737222031854, + "yes": 0.9991246262777969 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-18", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-sol-b-judge_hard-18", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9927982595742435, + "entropy_nats": 0.04270504609387995, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0616103582205752, + "brier_score": 0.00010373013031995077, + "wall_time_ms": 126, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9927982595742435, + "yes": 0.0072017404257566035 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "reject_entire_claim", + "actual": "reject_entire_claim", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9355046054285215, + "entropy_nats": 0.25604205939505525, + "normalized_entropy": 0.18469530467412182, + "brier_score": 0.007822997214879527, + "wall_time_ms": 390, + "top_probabilities": { + "approve_all": 0.003480905393907269, + "approve_lodging_only": 0.00059202566273121, + "approve_meals_only": 0.060422463514839986, + "reject_entire_claim": 0.9355046054285215 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "deny_current_export", + "actual": "deny_current_export", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9475982279922519, + "entropy_nats": 0.23752677240883976, + "normalized_entropy": 0.1713393483162973, + "brier_score": 0.004376564015370111, + "wall_time_ms": 389, + "top_probabilities": { + "analytics_owner_only": 0.00015320783193336067, + "deny_current_export": 0.9475982279922519, + "privacy_and_security": 0.037649007767098605, + "privacy_only": 0.01459955640871608 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-05", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-05", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "delete_profile_omar_april_and_table", + "actual": "delete_only_profile", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.5255180252086368, + "entropy_nats": 0.783990760499927, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5655297911380058, + "brier_score": 0.5751034966041805, + "wall_time_ms": 390, + "top_probabilities": { + "delete_everything": 0.0019399754216860824, + "delete_nothing": 0.018958607359714774, + "delete_only_profile": 0.5255180252086368, + "delete_profile_omar_april_and_table": 0.4535833920099624 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-06", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "long_policy", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-b-long_policy-06", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "east_ward", + "actual": "east_ward", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.965616913411482, + "entropy_nats": 0.1762946911677634, + "normalized_entropy": 0.12716973834139178, + "brier_score": 0.001846457745164766, + "wall_time_ms": 390, + "top_probabilities": { + "east_ward": 0.965616913411482, + "harbor_neighbors": 0.006099431501018911, + "no_award": 0.02479723613801081, + "river_arts": 0.003486418949488271 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "routing_hard", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "office_file_repair", + "actual": "office_file_repair", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9961204898584647, + "entropy_nats": 0.02868580188810742, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017823490838937216, + "brier_score": 0.000022795815590872505, + "wall_time_ms": 170, + "top_probabilities": { + "data_pipeline": 0.0000174478668951721, + "desktop_support": 0.00032942186567934623, + "finance_review": 0.0009306709570570211, + "office_file_repair": 0.9961204898584647, + "spreadsheet_formula": 0.0026019694519038594 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "routing_hard", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "ledger_reconciliation", + "actual": "ledger_reconciliation", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9998603939675696, + "entropy_nats": 0.0014870363722539882, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0009239476470421944, + "brier_score": 3.0947478635807096e-8, + "wall_time_ms": 162, + "top_probabilities": { + "customer_support": 0.000022677452867388114, + "fraud_review": 0.000010846778390486087, + "ledger_reconciliation": 0.9998603939675696, + "mobile_app": 0.0000020554094888205674, + "payment_disputes": 0.00010402639168351152 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "routing_hard", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "network_dns", + "actual": "network_dns", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9974646130062536, + "entropy_nats": 0.01829612663245019, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01136802264386781, + "brier_score": 0.000012232157543249838, + "wall_time_ms": 167, + "top_probabilities": { + "api_platform": 0.000003597344973499301, + "authoritative_dns": 0.0024075350673436646, + "endpoint_devices": 0.00005960803410016078, + "network_dns": 0.9974646130062536, + "tls_certificates": 0.0000646465473291772 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "routing_hard", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "release_notarization", + "actual": "release_notarization", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9972797352792423, + "entropy_nats": 0.019501841314043526, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01211717529665317, + "brier_score": 0.000014024295949086807, + "wall_time_ms": 162, + "top_probabilities": { + "ci_infrastructure": 0.00008893352316887894, + "code_signing": 0.0025719195414383228, + "endpoint_security": 0.00003211689308923358, + "macos_runtime": 0.000027294763061322845, + "release_notarization": 0.9972797352792423 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "routing_hard", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-b-routing_hard-09", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 5, + "chance_baseline": 0.2, + "expected": "source_access", + "actual": "source_access", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.997654401801195, + "entropy_nats": 0.018430588579720294, + "normalized_entropy": 0.011451568549075638, + "brier_score": 0.00000848083148310528, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "git_client": 0.0004624806164608156, + "identity_login": 0.0000011716005805376443, + "repository_admin": 0.0016460441009409487, + "source_access": 0.997654401801195, + "vpn_network": 0.00023590188082280397 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-01", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-01", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "late_by_under_2h", + "actual": "within_window", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.7456834478281693, + "entropy_nats": 0.8122049803143635, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5858820486424252, + "brier_score": 1.4000304163190305, + "wall_time_ms": 143, + "top_probabilities": { + "before_open": 0.13206301263989773, + "late_by_2h_or_more": 0.030874866204094104, + "late_by_under_2h": 0.09137867332783894, + "within_window": 0.7456834478281693 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-02", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-02", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "over_limit", + "actual": "under_100gb_below", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.8442133447107492, + "entropy_nats": 0.5882549055701037, + "normalized_entropy": 0.42433621752229705, + "brier_score": 1.6492943685924786, + "wall_time_ms": 139, + "top_probabilities": { + "at_least_100gb_below": 0.08577609737302659, + "exactly_equal": 0.03340295006551968, + "over_limit": 0.03660760785070459, + "under_100gb_below": 0.8442133447107492 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-03", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "9_credits", + "actual": "9_credits", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.40602565184855505, + "entropy_nats": 1.229650447527804, + "normalized_entropy": 0.8870053013376288, + "brier_score": 0.5024881477392259, + "wall_time_ms": 139, + "top_probabilities": { + "12_credits": 0.2963201924645335, + "15_credits": 0.05507749966779232, + "6_credits": 0.24257665601911915, + "9_credits": 0.40602565184855505 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-04", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "temporal_numeric", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-b-temporal_numeric-04", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 3, + "chance_baseline": 0.3333333333333333, + "expected": "pass", + "actual": "narrow_fail", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.3848285560226613, + "entropy_nats": 1.0924505628892118, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9943913554923295, + "brier_score": 0.7425627877704013, + "wall_time_ms": 143, + "top_probabilities": { + "clear_fail": 0.3176951521478614, + "narrow_fail": 0.3848285560226613, + "pass": 0.2974762918294772 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-03", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-03", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9983469720421618, + "entropy_nats": 0.01223954726974955, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017657934148793727, + "brier_score": 0.00000546500285878927, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9983469720421618, + "yes": 0.0016530279578381923 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-05", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-05", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9649339081597881, + "entropy_nats": 0.15193362650833114, + "normalized_entropy": 0.2191938895078453, + "brier_score": 0.002459261593892354, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.03506609184021195, + "yes": 0.9649339081597881 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-07", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": false, + "confidence": 0.6643855093766137, + "entropy_nats": 0.6380836510479194, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9205601190391572, + "brier_score": 0.8828162101392448, + "wall_time_ms": 142, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.33561449062338633, + "yes": 0.6643855093766137 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-08", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-08", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.8545980926218655, + "entropy_nats": 0.41464961091000707, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5982129373664055, + "brier_score": 0.04228342933839922, + "wall_time_ms": 160, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.8545980926218655, + "yes": 0.14540190737813455 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-09", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9937095743108, + "entropy_nats": 0.038155046943128886, + "normalized_entropy": 0.05504609700973765, + "brier_score": 0.00007913891070269506, + "wall_time_ms": 161, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.006290425689199977, + "yes": 0.9937095743108 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-10", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-10", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9966670960394735, + "entropy_nats": 0.022337932200278292, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03222682400905538, + "brier_score": 0.000022216497620187063, + "wall_time_ms": 160, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.003332903960526455, + "yes": 0.9966670960394735 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-11", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-11", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9972643827374149, + "entropy_nats": 0.018875838775217032, + "normalized_entropy": 0.027232078993625217, + "brier_score": 0.000014967203614707064, + "wall_time_ms": 159, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.9972643827374149, + "yes": 0.0027356172625850354 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-13", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "math", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-13", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "no", + "actual": "no", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.6678770618173562, + "entropy_nats": 0.6356718879313998, + "normalized_entropy": 0.9170806803511555, + "brier_score": 0.2206112921341445, + "wall_time_ms": 265, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.6678770618173562, + "yes": 0.3321229381826439 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-15", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "judge_hard", + "topic": "coding", + "group": "hard-sol-c-judge_hard-15", + "question_type": "noul", + "vocab_cardinality": 2, + "chance_baseline": 0.5, + "expected": "yes", + "actual": "yes", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9889223659177009, + "entropy_nats": 0.060896720781130564, + "normalized_entropy": 0.08785539707733694, + "brier_score": 0.0002454279537226299, + "wall_time_ms": 267, + "top_probabilities": { + "no": 0.011077634082299162, + "yes": 0.9889223659177009 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-07", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "law_policy", + "group": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-07", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "programme_review", + "actual": "programme_review", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.999138261250487, + "entropy_nats": 0.007619558371795742, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005496349538376851, + "brier_score": 0.0000011317087434483993, + "wall_time_ms": 267, + "top_probabilities": { + "partial_release": 0.00004669487477488957, + "programme_review": 0.999138261250487, + "reject_draw": 0.00024201302396581006, + "release_draw": 0.0005730308507723107 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-09", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-09", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "bus_substitution", + "actual": "bus_substitution", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9996538027667679, + "entropy_nats": 0.0034301133143208404, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0024743037341289414, + "brier_score": 1.7339840061530228e-7, + "wall_time_ms": 267, + "top_probabilities": { + "bus_substitution": 0.9996538027667679, + "call_fen_cross": 0.000210124036357917, + "pass_fen_cross": 0.0000597962037690622, + "terminate_oakmere": 0.00007627699310521689 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-11", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "finance_commerce", + "group": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-11", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "coverage_excluded", + "actual": "coverage_excluded", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9620134266581879, + "entropy_nats": 0.1754535921681097, + "normalized_entropy": 0.12656301366354328, + "brier_score": 0.002595435462089009, + "wall_time_ms": 255, + "top_probabilities": { + "adjuster_referral": 0.00012173846728638266, + "coverage_confirmed": 0.03368992446833305, + "coverage_excluded": 0.9620134266581879, + "documentation_needed": 0.004174910406192694 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-12", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-12", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "conservation_hold", + "actual": "conservation_hold", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9356502754240782, + "entropy_nats": 0.30228795851015555, + "normalized_entropy": 0.21805466933152506, + "brier_score": 0.005844118352558467, + "wall_time_ms": 253, + "top_probabilities": { + "conservation_hold": 0.9356502754240782, + "deny_request": 0.016706720691237558, + "digital_copy_only": 0.03584624463664597, + "supervised_delivery": 0.011796759248038297 + } + }, + { + "id": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-13", + "tier": "hard", + "family": "multi_hop", + "topic": "support_ops", + "group": "hard-sol-c-multi_hop-13", + "question_type": "choice", + "vocab_cardinality": 4, + "chance_baseline": 0.25, + "expected": "normal_release", + "actual": "normal_release", + "accurate": true, + "confidence": 0.9886430124262914, + "entropy_nats": 0.06690132233986944, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04825910298432183, + "brier_score": 0.00022965999929946967, + "wall_time_ms": 253, + "top_probabilities": { + "engineering_review": 0.009956340697760732, + "normal_release": 0.9886430124262914, + "rework": 0.0001668411867886074, + "scrap_lot": 0.0012338056891593363 + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/permutation.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/permutation.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c26ce89 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/permutation.json @@ -0,0 +1,2225 @@ +{ + "timestamp": "2026-09-28T22:40:21Z", + "endpoint": "https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions", + "model": "diffgemma-26b-a4b-it-q4", + "gate_threshold_normalized_h": 0.16, + "prior_damping_alpha": 0.75, + "null_prior": { + "by_cardinality": { + "2": [ + 0.9067105765582258, + 0.09328942344177421 + ], + "3": [ + 0.5044038628092938, + 0.3611551848445242, + 0.13444095234618197 + ], + "4": [ + 0.3302953520031515, + 0.147258265937074, + 0.2523974821543615, + 0.2700488999054129 + ] + }, + "entropy_by_k": { + "2": 0.31008300211546536, + "3": 0.9827937981867325, + "4": 1.348997133087098 + }, + "uniform_entropy_by_k": { + "2": 0.6931471805599453, + "3": 1.0986122886681096, + "4": 1.3862943611198906 + }, + "max_bias_ratio_by_k": { + "2": 1.8134211531164517, + "3": 1.5132115884278816, + "4": 1.321181408012606 + } + }, + "total_cases": 16, + "canonical_accuracy_pct": 100, + "debiased_accuracy_pct": 100, + "dual_mirror_accuracy_pct": 100, + "cyclic_ensemble_accuracy_pct": 100, + "raw_flip_rate_pct": 6.25, + "debiased_flip_rate_pct": 25, + "flip_reduction_relative_pct": -300, + "canonical_brier": 0.0013316339530038445, + "debiased_brier": 0.001004372391416645, + "dual_mirror_brier": 0.03844270458090349, + "mean_single_pass_normalized_h": 0.04316542095571914, + "mean_cyclic_jsd_nats": 0.05462730556466847, + "mean_mirror_jsd_nats": 0.015289487549618643, + "false_confident_errors_single_pass": 0, + "caught_by_dual_mirror_gate": 0, + "single_gate_error_recall_pct": 100, + "mirror_gate_error_recall_pct": 100, + "mean_single_latency_ms": 167.625, + "mean_mirror_latency_ms": 152.4375, + "regimes": [ + { + "regime": "consensus", + "cases": 4, + "canonical_accuracy_pct": 100, + "dual_mirror_accuracy_pct": 100, + "raw_flip_rate_pct": 0, + "debiased_flip_rate_pct": 0, + "mean_single_normalized_h": 0.015022291320910392, + "mean_cyclic_jsd_nats": 0.0012849819539824327, + "mean_mirror_jsd_nats": 0.0009026142738583214, + "mean_mirror_tvd": 0.004393174854109884, + "single_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100, + "mirror_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100 + }, + { + "regime": "ambiguous_chaosnli", + "cases": 4, + "canonical_accuracy_pct": 100, + "dual_mirror_accuracy_pct": 100, + "raw_flip_rate_pct": 25, + "debiased_flip_rate_pct": 75, + "mean_single_normalized_h": 0.1159222277461991, + "mean_cyclic_jsd_nats": 0.16791639835415467, + "mean_mirror_jsd_nats": 0.035282340478064105, + "mean_mirror_tvd": 0.13167916126339865, + "single_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100, + "mirror_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100 + }, + { + "regime": "adversarial_trap", + "cases": 4, + "canonical_accuracy_pct": 100, + "dual_mirror_accuracy_pct": 100, + "raw_flip_rate_pct": 0, + "debiased_flip_rate_pct": 25, + "mean_single_normalized_h": 0.021413640147608933, + "mean_cyclic_jsd_nats": 0.04885735904559453, + "mean_mirror_jsd_nats": 0.013106341883889054, + "mean_mirror_tvd": 0.06609512226102546, + "single_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100, + "mirror_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100 + }, + { + "regime": "binary_ablation", + "cases": 4, + "canonical_accuracy_pct": 100, + "dual_mirror_accuracy_pct": 100, + "raw_flip_rate_pct": 0, + "debiased_flip_rate_pct": 0, + "mean_single_normalized_h": 0.02030352460815814, + "mean_cyclic_jsd_nats": 0.000450482904942238, + "mean_mirror_jsd_nats": 0.011866653562663095, + "mean_mirror_tvd": 0.0690633040011435, + "single_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100, + "mirror_gate_recall_on_errors_pct": 100 + } + ], + "cases": [ + { + "id": "perm_01_consensus_sre_502", + "regime": "consensus", + "title": "SRE 502 Checkout Crash After v2.14.3 Rollout", + "cardinality": 4, + "expected": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "canonical_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9996553473369123, + "canonical_entropy": 0.0032339479358714186, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.002332800324787398, + "canonical_brier": 2.143335166468619e-7, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "update_billing_address", + "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "close_as_duplicate", + "schedule_next_month" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.000014494714212877542, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9996553473369123, + "schedule_next_month": 0.000022187711354856726, + "update_billing_address": 0.00030797023752002575 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.00000967769761775061, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9998081829841613, + "schedule_next_month": 0.000014081757240299927, + "update_billing_address": 0.00016805756098069987 + }, + "raw_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "debiased_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "raw_entropy": 0.0032339479358714186, + "normalized_entropy": 0.002332800324787398, + "wall_time_ms": 128 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "close_as_duplicate", + "schedule_next_month", + "update_billing_address" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.0006843682301915287, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9992691138723926, + "schedule_next_month": 0.000018537325773715105, + "update_billing_address": 0.000027980571642076712 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.001253590500283565, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9986912179896955, + "schedule_next_month": 0.000022667777029727662, + "update_billing_address": 0.000032523732991235064 + }, + "raw_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "debiased_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "raw_entropy": 0.006212946046330437, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004481693225175807, + "wall_time_ms": 136 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "close_as_duplicate", + "schedule_next_month", + "update_billing_address", + "immediate_k8s_rollback" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.00012187808746879153, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9997387844566005, + "schedule_next_month": 0.00013160078330758159, + "update_billing_address": 0.000007736672623200478 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.00010478640142363333, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9996797007941013, + "schedule_next_month": 0.00020737426267076662, + "update_billing_address": 0.000008138541804338884 + }, + "raw_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "debiased_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "raw_entropy": 0.002626613517290538, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0018947011478634883, + "wall_time_ms": 180 + }, + { + "perm_index": 3, + "option_order": [ + "schedule_next_month", + "update_billing_address", + "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "close_as_duplicate" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.000034663476900981653, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9998923102264555, + "schedule_next_month": 0.000060153226980149104, + "update_billing_address": 0.000012873069663280973 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.00003295010549248144, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9998986021065297, + "schedule_next_month": 0.00004916415511802033, + "update_billing_address": 0.00001928363285975042 + }, + "raw_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "debiased_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "raw_entropy": 0.0011932334294675886, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0008607359756579104, + "wall_time_ms": 103 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.0033166852322399957, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.0018289627315719748, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.0035662380458935847, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.00024955281365358906, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.0006698735159787279, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 1.8745734925380035e-7, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.000408176424919123, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 6.532906508620197e-8, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.0004838915225971828, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.999349682496204, + "schedule_next_month": 0.000005980512931829686, + "update_billing_address": 0.0001604454682669512 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.0008402136541454188, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9987948128751186, + "schedule_next_month": 0.0002753220930237667, + "update_billing_address": 0.00008965137771220442 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "close_as_duplicate": 0.0006620525883713008, + "immediate_k8s_rollback": 0.9990722476856613, + "schedule_next_month": 0.0001406513029777982, + "update_billing_address": 0.00012504842298957783 + }, + "fwd_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "rev_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "ensemble_winner": "immediate_k8s_rollback", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.00803250496134983, + "total_entropy": 0.008144911036878902, + "normalized_total_h": 0.005875311380693489, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.0001124060755290715, + "normalized_jsd": 0.00016216768773158173, + "tvd": 0.0006256637116401693, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 122 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_02_consensus_sql_injection", + "regime": "consensus", + "title": "Direct SQL UNION Injection in Search Query Parameter", + "cardinality": 4, + "expected": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "canonical_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9995133062351538, + "canonical_entropy": 0.004631329433052661, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.003340798002894084, + "canonical_brier": 3.4818213127015553e-7, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "benign_search_filter", + "css_font_rendering", + "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.0003004708436578998, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9995133062351538, + "css_font_rendering": 0.00013605965295141297, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.00005016326823697357 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.000245575334829546, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9995029301198513, + "css_font_rendering": 0.00020381157844883606, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.00004768296687030088 + }, + "raw_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "debiased_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "raw_entropy": 0.004631329433052661, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003340798002894084, + "wall_time_ms": 143 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "css_font_rendering", + "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck", + "benign_search_filter" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.00010934983372194311, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9993196557533666, + "css_font_rendering": 0.000548812942501751, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.000022181470409794474 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.00006941046552867808, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9996162503722538, + "css_font_rendering": 0.0002995271108997691, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.000014812051317664183 + }, + "raw_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "debiased_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "raw_entropy": 0.0060355422518634265, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004353723437919586, + "wall_time_ms": 121 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck", + "benign_search_filter", + "css_font_rendering" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.000014605471330500367, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9937889468743037, + "css_font_rendering": 0.00017014122499020256, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.0060263064293754704 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.000017780382265953256, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9887957618454171, + "css_font_rendering": 0.00019688699330446934, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.010989570779012404 + }, + "raw_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "debiased_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "raw_entropy": 0.03863517346040022, + "normalized_entropy": 0.027869386577602146, + "wall_time_ms": 120 + }, + { + "perm_index": 3, + "option_order": [ + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck", + "benign_search_filter", + "css_font_rendering", + "critical_sqli_exfiltration" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.0005994445921761401, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9991735058979245, + "css_font_rendering": 0.0000026339175600190896, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.00022441559233927168 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.0009443539432804458, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9988599807085532, + "css_font_rendering": 0.0000027700265207514192, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.00019289532164559444 + }, + "raw_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "debiased_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "raw_entropy": 0.007193116109241674, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005188736469670739, + "wall_time_ms": 135 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.014123790313639493, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.014180697435009207, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.01617298093236909, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.002049190618729598, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.006010224733177357, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.000006817516446292708, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.003809619493963936, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 3.511985356670949e-7, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.00034936141286386204, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9832340998801727, + "css_font_rendering": 0.01628943385101988, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.00012710485594352093 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.00004344640606880697, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9978095325541142, + "css_font_rendering": 0.0019346130397385611, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.00021240800007837302 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "benign_search_filter": 0.00019640390946633451, + "critical_sqli_exfiltration": 0.9905218162171434, + "css_font_rendering": 0.00911202344537922, + "scheduled_cron_healthcheck": 0.00016975642801094696 + }, + "fwd_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "rev_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "ensemble_winner": "critical_sqli_exfiltration", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.052060446571990396, + "total_entropy": 0.05539292558021246, + "normalized_total_h": 0.03995754951745196, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.0033324790082220612, + "normalized_jsd": 0.004807750939028539, + "tvd": 0.01466073581807634, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 123 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_03_consensus_nda_breach", + "regime": "consensus", + "title": "NDA Reverse Engineering Prohibition Clause", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "canonical_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.998598488507624, + "canonical_entropy": 0.01131786444323776, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.01030196417788012, + "canonical_brier": 0.000003290429610831965, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "fully_compliant_permitted_use", + "unrelated_tax_withholding" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.0011155315385981354, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.998598488507624, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.00028597995377797436 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.001432012617832265, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.9977976654049734, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.0007703219771943936 + }, + "raw_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "debiased_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "raw_entropy": 0.01131786444323776, + "normalized_entropy": 0.01030196417788012, + "wall_time_ms": 148 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "fully_compliant_permitted_use", + "unrelated_tax_withholding", + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.000507511893665325, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.9994494545632943, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.00004303354304048236 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.00018832568831844175, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.9997911587290537, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.000020515582627870387 + }, + "raw_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "debiased_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "raw_entropy": 0.004833013262869355, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004399198254671451, + "wall_time_ms": 111 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "unrelated_tax_withholding", + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "fully_compliant_permitted_use" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.00005406038120072449, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.9988787536979259, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.0010671859208734164 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.00011345607328620128, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.9990557302940127, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.0008308136327009956 + }, + "raw_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "debiased_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "raw_entropy": 0.008954248021392873, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008150507794017539, + "wall_time_ms": 115 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.008368375242499997, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.0026796466051411975, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.008781519842483603, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.0004131445999836069, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.00106147115739737, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.0000015785825295257227, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.0004891228981323964, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.000007494333754630526, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.00035634424683213565, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.9955506434995045, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.0040930122536633395 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.00017404170254680783, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.9969285490395294, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.0028974092579237875 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "fully_compliant_permitted_use": 0.00026519297468947174, + "material_breach_of_clause_4_2": 0.996239596269517, + "unrelated_tax_withholding": 0.0034952107557935635 + }, + "fwd_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "rev_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "ensemble_winner": "material_breach_of_clause_4_2", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.025639776699753033, + "total_entropy": 0.02570737859308541, + "normalized_total_h": 0.023399864409173382, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.00006760189333237729, + "normalized_jsd": 0.0000975289162653254, + "tvd": 0.001377905540024903, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 121 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_04_consensus_fx_tool", + "regime": "consensus", + "title": "ISO Currency Spot Conversion Tool Selection", + "cardinality": 4, + "expected": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "canonical_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.990338791119145, + "canonical_entropy": 0.06115443877993499, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.04411360277807996, + "canonical_brier": 0.00014572061694171902, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "resize_png_thumbnail", + "mute_microphone_audio", + "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "reboot_printer_spooler" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.990338791119145, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.002775038523394905, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.006681228937112397, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.000204941420347693 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9893354376601136, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.004152721378502263, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.0063445099508335845, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.00016733101055072493 + }, + "raw_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "debiased_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "raw_entropy": 0.06115443877993499, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04411360277807996, + "wall_time_ms": 144 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "mute_microphone_audio", + "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "reboot_printer_spooler", + "resize_png_thumbnail" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9985923789753818, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.0005990959892730246, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.00020942904607227492, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.0005990959892730246 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9991526763934473, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.00032705661367673735, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.00013988673097044672, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.0003803802619056094 + }, + "raw_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "debiased_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "raw_entropy": 0.012071420394364122, + "normalized_entropy": 0.008707689169717507, + "wall_time_ms": 115 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "reboot_printer_spooler", + "resize_png_thumbnail", + "mute_microphone_audio" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9929406396326934, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.0006596912724937068, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.0062343015913064286, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.00016536750350643666 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9876699391524996, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.000763175334140033, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.011365628138904675, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.00020125737445581113 + }, + "raw_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "debiased_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "raw_entropy": 0.044961544670569696, + "normalized_entropy": 0.032432898763469255, + "wall_time_ms": 129 + }, + { + "perm_index": 3, + "option_order": [ + "reboot_printer_spooler", + "resize_png_thumbnail", + "mute_microphone_audio", + "convert_currency_spot_fx" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9996163010735659, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.000012414041461309556, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.0002391647488629674, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.00013212013610983223 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9995731164344425, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.000013059076764320227, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.00020562852884431447, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.0002081959599488889 + }, + "raw_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "debiased_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "raw_entropy": 0.0036981745549481745, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0026676690453827402, + "wall_time_ms": 136 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.030471394599954245, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.023488177938935068, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.03289943438351718, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.0024280397835629366, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.00927750995442089, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.00003367970467641784, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.003873877419443797, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.00017125879093211218, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9981510562680271, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.0017657420364147493, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.000028223594010341966, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.00005497810154776246 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9989510249657659, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.0008670767573947832, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.00013664924296967313, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.0000452490338696048 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "convert_currency_spot_fx": 0.9985510406168965, + "mute_microphone_audio": 0.0013164093969047662, + "reboot_printer_spooler": 0.00008243641849000755, + "resize_png_thumbnail": 0.00005011356770868363 + }, + "fwd_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "rev_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "ensemble_winner": "convert_currency_spot_fx", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.011352856542346015, + "total_entropy": 0.01145082666069579, + "normalized_total_h": 0.008260025418732473, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.00009797011834977547, + "normalized_jsd": 0.0001413410038985259, + "tvd": 0.0009083943466981252, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 139 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_05_ambiguous_chaosnli_motive", + "regime": "ambiguous_chaosnli", + "title": "ChaosNLI Pragmatic Inference: Sudden Resignation Without Notice", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "neutral", + "canonical_winner": "neutral", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9803449915261974, + "canonical_entropy": 0.10117785014804008, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.09209604807051806, + "canonical_brier": 0.0007287676048190504, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "entailment", + "neutral", + "contradiction" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.0011878118910718307, + "entailment": 0.01846719658273083, + "neutral": 0.9803449915261974 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.002499378306394455, + "entailment": 0.01441451989637662, + "neutral": 0.9830861017972291 + }, + "raw_winner": "neutral", + "debiased_winner": "neutral", + "raw_entropy": 0.10117785014804008, + "normalized_entropy": 0.09209604807051806, + "wall_time_ms": 113 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "neutral", + "contradiction", + "entailment" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.03478730909143531, + "entailment": 0.33919184827109483, + "neutral": 0.6260208426374698 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.02819533261239677, + "entailment": 0.5768640809535532, + "neutral": 0.39494058643404995 + }, + "raw_winner": "neutral", + "debiased_winner": "entailment", + "raw_entropy": 0.7767742950510477, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7070504335908725, + "wall_time_ms": 123 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "contradiction", + "entailment", + "neutral" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.003040877891775809, + "entailment": 0.005227825359010741, + "neutral": 0.9917312967492135 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.0011332812891798425, + "entailment": 0.002503071300340363, + "neutral": 0.9963636474104799 + }, + "raw_winner": "neutral", + "debiased_winner": "neutral", + "raw_entropy": 0.0533239014387363, + "normalized_entropy": 0.04853750680632103, + "wall_time_ms": 125 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.3104253488792747, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.33033670176393315, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.4365441189756519, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.12611877009637718, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.35432414888872754, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "neutral", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.032748338324609376, + "debiased_flip_occurred": true, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.25259360578929263, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.0005001052281752091, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.0002690368621119843, + "entailment": 0.04705689150371655, + "neutral": 0.9526740716341715 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.015118236639913475, + "entailment": 0.007756934443373916, + "neutral": 0.9771248289167126 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.00769363675101273, + "entailment": 0.027406912973545233, + "neutral": 0.964899450275442 + }, + "fwd_winner": "neutral", + "rev_winner": "neutral", + "ensemble_winner": "neutral", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.15795070305545686, + "total_entropy": 0.1705064710347847, + "normalized_total_h": 0.15520167832957368, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.012555767979327837, + "normalized_jsd": 0.01811414419832871, + "tvd": 0.039299957060342616, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": true, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 147 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_06_ambiguous_chaosnli_hospital", + "regime": "ambiguous_chaosnli", + "title": "ChaosNLI Temporal Ambiguity: Surgeon Leaving Operating Theater", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "neutral", + "canonical_winner": "neutral", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9986623392707739, + "canonical_entropy": 0.010239090203329424, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.009320021548041003, + "canonical_brier": 0.000003556193841906233, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "entailment", + "neutral", + "contradiction" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.000008455659564730605, + "entailment": 0.0013292050696614662, + "neutral": 0.9986623392707739 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.000017747742470106502, + "entailment": 0.0010349098016162752, + "neutral": 0.9989473424559135 + }, + "raw_winner": "neutral", + "debiased_winner": "neutral", + "raw_entropy": 0.010239090203329424, + "normalized_entropy": 0.009320021548041003, + "wall_time_ms": 119 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "neutral", + "contradiction", + "entailment" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.058300525878129034, + "entailment": 0.3931937371194457, + "neutral": 0.5485057370024253 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.04449444707007973, + "entailment": 0.6296680235622611, + "neutral": 0.3258375293676592 + }, + "raw_winner": "neutral", + "debiased_winner": "entailment", + "raw_entropy": 0.8621355577469384, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7847496033310704, + "wall_time_ms": 112 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "contradiction", + "entailment", + "neutral" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.00250878319175244, + "entailment": 0.7444191458982025, + "neutral": 0.2530720709100451 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.0015287042048618708, + "entailment": 0.582762067527125, + "neutral": 0.41570922826801315 + }, + "raw_winner": "entailment", + "debiased_winner": "entailment", + "raw_entropy": 0.5824800836170997, + "normalized_entropy": 0.5301962208371644, + "wall_time_ms": 122 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": true, + "raw_distinct_winners": 2, + "raw_majority_agreement": 0.6666666666666666, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.4849515771891226, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.35455677028074906, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.753181802475568, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.2682302252864454, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.7455902683607287, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "neutral", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.3044790649949167, + "debiased_flip_occurred": true, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.24842730593378826, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.00000217944118496635, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.00007062358232488894, + "entailment": 0.0004435843845515856, + "neutral": 0.9994857920331235 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.0004929119582686426, + "entailment": 0.001262900738250908, + "neutral": 0.9982441873034805 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "contradiction": 0.00028176777029676576, + "entailment": 0.0008532425614012468, + "neutral": 0.998864989668302 + }, + "fwd_winner": "neutral", + "rev_winner": "neutral", + "ensemble_winner": "neutral", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.009275385749997651, + "total_entropy": 0.009467066264596553, + "normalized_total_h": 0.00861729507511139, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.00019168051459890131, + "normalized_jsd": 0.0002765365278468795, + "tvd": 0.0012416047296430204, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 125 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_07_ambiguous_dual_intent_vip", + "regime": "ambiguous_chaosnli", + "title": "Equally Weighted Multi-Department Ticket (SRE Outage vs. Legal Termination)", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "canonical_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.8949484139137923, + "canonical_entropy": 0.36950825273860094, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.3363409062050181, + "canonical_brier": 0.02013742048266968, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "legal_and_contracts_desk", + "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "finance_accounts_payable" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.010195739453320616, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.094855846632887, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.8949484139137923 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.021606196226275857, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.07456560985944478, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.9038281939142795 + }, + "raw_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "debiased_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "raw_entropy": 0.36950825273860094, + "normalized_entropy": 0.3363409062050181, + "wall_time_ms": 146 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "finance_accounts_payable", + "legal_and_contracts_desk" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.06141270956707886, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.04488030708910998, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.8937069833438112 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.0721465714310343, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.1106330698498861, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.8172203587190795 + }, + "raw_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "debiased_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "raw_entropy": 0.41107988639584253, + "normalized_entropy": 0.37418103787479995, + "wall_time_ms": 96 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "finance_accounts_payable", + "legal_and_contracts_desk", + "sre_identity_platform_oncall" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.006049968550571763, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.3207570037303785, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.6731930277190497 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.0027094417604103618, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.18455094079136258, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.8127396174482271 + }, + "raw_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "debiased_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "raw_entropy": 0.6620231473104294, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6025994376169103, + "wall_time_ms": 91 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.4808704288149577, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.12921372668298498, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.5444902605397816, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.06361983172482388, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.22590115709749153, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.05641021062002165, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.023728860874963842, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.015275874174868694, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.16647959093793657, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.13892470516537817, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.6945957038966852 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.5636271943934891, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.21818640280325546, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.21818640280325546 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "finance_accounts_payable": 0.3650533926657128, + "legal_and_contracts_desk": 0.17855555398431683, + "sre_identity_platform_oncall": 0.4563910533499703 + }, + "fwd_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "rev_winner": "finance_accounts_payable", + "ensemble_winner": "sre_identity_platform_oncall", + "mirror_disagreed": true, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.9066591735089056, + "total_entropy": 1.033489521164398, + "normalized_total_h": 0.9407227024716223, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.1268303476554924, + "normalized_jsd": 0.18297751359680206, + "tvd": 0.4764093010934298, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": true, + "escalated_by_mirror": true, + "wall_time_ms": 96 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_08_ambiguous_fair_use_parody", + "regime": "ambiguous_chaosnli", + "title": "Borderline Copyright Fair-Use vs. Commercial Sampling", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "incidental_fair_use", + "canonical_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9956085714360315, + "canonical_entropy": 0.02848914263706009, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.02593193516121924, + "canonical_brier": 0.00003814134704256274, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "requires_sync_license", + "incidental_fair_use", + "public_domain_waiver" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.9956085714360315, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.00004927772411613593, + "requires_sync_license": 0.004342150839852365 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.9965136293323114, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.00010349442671833387, + "requires_sync_license": 0.0033828762409704315 + }, + "raw_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "debiased_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "raw_entropy": 0.02848914263706009, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02593193516121924, + "wall_time_ms": 219 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "incidental_fair_use", + "public_domain_waiver", + "requires_sync_license" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.48935796750161586, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.021284064996768316, + "requires_sync_license": 0.48935796750161586 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.2665485164388902, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.01489421418027166, + "requires_sync_license": 0.7185572693808382 + }, + "raw_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "debiased_winner": "requires_sync_license", + "raw_entropy": 0.7813894471303294, + "normalized_entropy": 0.7112513260502832, + "wall_time_ms": 150 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "public_domain_waiver", + "requires_sync_license", + "incidental_fair_use" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.9973852601989008, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.0006108384100088818, + "requires_sync_license": 0.0020039013910902385 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.9988167111302495, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.00022691545407062117, + "requires_sync_license": 0.0009563734156798037 + }, + "raw_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "debiased_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "raw_entropy": 0.019581493450040822, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017823843454163643, + "wall_time_ms": 216 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.2764866944058101, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.3570386802902524, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.49018346071478236, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.21369676630897227, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.5062506039344157, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.05712929801352116, + "debiased_flip_occurred": true, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.35399915391712544, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.00002360934319060375, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.9867028625851317, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.002815964541570554, + "requires_sync_license": 0.010481172873297796 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.9964686447553109, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.0010635557115172092, + "requires_sync_license": 0.0024677995331718623 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "incidental_fair_use": 0.9915857536702213, + "public_domain_waiver": 0.0019397601265438815, + "requires_sync_license": 0.006474486203234829 + }, + "fwd_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "rev_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "ensemble_winner": "incidental_fair_use", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.051572026032507635, + "total_entropy": 0.053123591795344934, + "normalized_total_h": 0.04835517711143458, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.001551565762837298, + "normalized_jsd": 0.0022384362316584714, + "tvd": 0.009765782170179241, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 214 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_09_trap_amendment_override", + "regime": "adversarial_trap", + "title": "JevBench Hard Precedence Trap: Base Policy vs. Appendix C Carve-Out", + "cardinality": 4, + "expected": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "canonical_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9944872194142272, + "canonical_entropy": 0.039476505071135155, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.028476279048877354, + "canonical_brier": 0.00004282030779127643, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "HOLD_FOR_VP", + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD", + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9944872194142272, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.0006108110040104982, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.002595579105295059, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.002306390476467239 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9938470435573351, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.0005802419857254197, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.002120027675113097, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0034526867818262526 + }, + "raw_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "debiased_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "raw_entropy": 0.039476505071135155, + "normalized_entropy": 0.028476279048877354, + "wall_time_ms": 134 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD", + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD", + "HOLD_FOR_VP" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9945841932988636, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.0013972937847467812, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.001667274510162872, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0023512384062267765 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9967193231431839, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.0009347921361711955, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.0010602697913608054, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0012856149292840107 + }, + "raw_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "debiased_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "raw_entropy": 0.039482267672832, + "normalized_entropy": 0.028480435887322682, + "wall_time_ms": 195 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD", + "HOLD_FOR_VP", + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9959922237408823, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.00159024118717175, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.0018894525348233159, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0005280825371226812 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9941701022195656, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.002909275390986097, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.0023075643466506043, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0006130580427977018 + }, + "raw_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "debiased_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "raw_entropy": 0.030081729647815702, + "normalized_entropy": 0.02169938109213311, + "wall_time_ms": 181 + }, + { + "perm_index": 3, + "option_order": [ + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD", + "HOLD_FOR_VP", + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD", + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9910939973769777, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.0013750248137120475, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.005286836909611134, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0022441408996991953 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9881606302208057, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.00117876762482284, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.008306740859715264, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0023538612946561966 + }, + "raw_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "debiased_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "raw_entropy": 0.059331068516963126, + "normalized_entropy": 0.042798319160033, + "wall_time_ms": 183 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.0420928927271865, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.010666344156031654, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.0426912219235403, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.0005983291963538029, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.0034554716140176175, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.00004870309631154794, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.0016028020409460247, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.00005461111710397314, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9745052558912681, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.00005334675048405514, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.0002569795925987202, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.02518441776564904 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9819112544345981, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.00037685977230844707, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.0000783269068692297, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.0176335588862242 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT": 0.9782082551629332, + "ESCALATE_TO_BOARD": 0.0002151032613962511, + "HOLD_FOR_VP": 0.00016765324973397496, + "REJECT_WIRE_FRAUD": 0.021408988325936622 + }, + "fwd_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "rev_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "ensemble_winner": "AUTO_SETTLE_EXEMPT", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.10668625423174055, + "total_entropy": 0.10712145116285615, + "normalized_total_h": 0.07727179318274092, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.0004351969311156001, + "normalized_jsd": 0.0006278564543305721, + "tvd": 0.007729511565154371, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 138 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_10_trap_prompt_injection_resume", + "regime": "adversarial_trap", + "title": "Indirect Prompt Injection Embedded in Candidate Resume Metadata", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "canonical_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9908690005911818, + "canonical_entropy": 0.055753292254483125, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.050748833623620766, + "canonical_brier": 0.00014604422386523718, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A", + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST", + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.0013265570868657094, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.9908690005911818, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.007804442321952586 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.0004945185951291015, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.9957677166000855, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.0037377648047854737 + }, + "raw_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "debiased_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "raw_entropy": 0.055753292254483125, + "normalized_entropy": 0.050748833623620766, + "wall_time_ms": 221 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST", + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.000023091646795722795, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.9993923622415457, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.0005845461116585495 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.00004845871159641614, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.9994965001980401, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.0004550410903633312 + }, + "raw_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "debiased_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "raw_entropy": 0.00520573620438079, + "normalized_entropy": 0.004738465296698899, + "wall_time_ms": 197 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A", + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.0003723132769283235, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.9996127644798052, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.000014922243266588718 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.00047826093681370814, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.9994815171978555, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.00004022186533075508 + }, + "raw_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "debiased_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "raw_entropy": 0.0034926881480025064, + "normalized_entropy": 0.0031791817586865226, + "wall_time_ms": 107 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.02148390553562214, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.024242205386144217, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.024118339175438375, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.0026344336398162332, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.008743763888623399, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.00001956935172373898, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.001080214795738223, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.00003212765715401371, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.078615965909487, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.9187374826749837, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.0026465514155294286 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.3308117377387827, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.6668816749723737, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.002306587288843617 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "FAST_TRACK_HIRE_A": 0.20471385182413485, + "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED": 0.7928095788236786, + "WAITLIST_SENIOR_RUST": 0.0024765693521865226 + }, + "fwd_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "rev_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "ensemble_winner": "REJECT_UNQUALIFIED", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.4718208254191196, + "total_entropy": 0.523635215854086, + "normalized_total_h": 0.47663331391360036, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.051814390434966384, + "normalized_jsd": 0.07475236412721055, + "tvd": 0.25219577182929576, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": true, + "escalated_by_mirror": true, + "wall_time_ms": 260 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_11_trap_temporal_grace_window", + "regime": "adversarial_trap", + "title": "JevBench Hard Temporal Boundary: Leap-Year / UTC Grace Period", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "canonical_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9995387758971067, + "canonical_entropy": 0.004141589568178923, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.003769837285544961, + "canonical_brier": 3.912682691312659e-7, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT", + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.00042058146937581833, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9995387758971067, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.000040642633517353135 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.0003273842767864608, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9995873303326466, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.0000852853905668738 + }, + "raw_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "debiased_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "raw_entropy": 0.004141589568178923, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003769837285544961, + "wall_time_ms": 175 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR", + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.0004991066736381187, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9973435687892014, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.00215732453716055 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.0013435214626337363, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9958889315093363, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.0027675470280299802 + }, + "raw_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "debiased_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "raw_entropy": 0.01969102384239836, + "normalized_entropy": 0.017923542313795303, + "wall_time_ms": 229 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR", + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT", + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.0017086979787225298, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9975548988126294, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.000736403208648187 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.0008154242180557135, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9989110359599367, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.0002735398220075225 + }, + "raw_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "debiased_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "raw_entropy": 0.018642189302970204, + "normalized_entropy": 0.016968851973766703, + "wall_time_ms": 141 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.014158267571182498, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.007095791810863023, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.014798748909119709, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.0006404813379372112, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.0021952071079054127, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.000005162578113124068, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.0008197771323698103, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 2.8475031688472617e-7, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.00014826571881127576, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9998425311548385, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.000009203126350239322 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.000010802543675465776, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.999862194599625, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.00012700285669950905 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "EXPIRED_LATE_PAYMENT": 0.00007953413124337077, + "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE": 0.9998523628772318, + "VOID_INVOICE_ERROR": 0.00006810299152487419 + }, + "fwd_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "rev_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "ensemble_winner": "ON_TIME_WITHIN_GRACE", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.001486036346843657, + "total_entropy": 0.0015517881134403668, + "normalized_total_h": 0.0014124984122666786, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.0000657517665967099, + "normalized_jsd": 0.00009485974759876197, + "tvd": 0.00013746317513581188, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 184 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_12_trap_double_negation_medical", + "regime": "adversarial_trap", + "title": "Double-Negation Exclusion Criterion in Clinical Protocol", + "cardinality": 3, + "expected": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "canonical_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9997003410232855, + "canonical_entropy": 0.0029218809238189167, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.00265961063239264, + "canonical_brier": 1.395559660062566e-7, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED", + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY", + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.0001991382731623405, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.9997003410232855, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.0001005207035521333 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.0000949195711910946, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.9998677860705816, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.000037294358227246246 + }, + "raw_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "debiased_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "raw_entropy": 0.0029218809238189167, + "normalized_entropy": 0.00265961063239264, + "wall_time_ms": 209 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY", + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.0001546111532969158, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.9996074843869849, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.00023790445971821065 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.00012031750604637366, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.9993805961319642, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.0004990863619894198 + }, + "raw_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "debiased_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "raw_entropy": 0.003734078672161986, + "normalized_entropy": 0.003398904882712494, + "wall_time_ms": 140 + }, + { + "perm_index": 2, + "option_order": [ + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED", + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.0000048015558657726315, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.5517767622785514, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.44821843616558277 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.000011478891004729905, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.4893236817317123, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.5106648393772829 + }, + "raw_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "debiased_winner": "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED", + "raw_entropy": 0.6878356415551378, + "normalized_entropy": 0.6260949824155232, + "wall_time_ms": 196 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.23149720038370622, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.32268017662940357, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.4230533923919771, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.19155619200827087, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.4481179154620306, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.04474760375716822, + "debiased_flip_occurred": true, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.22398428569168052, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 2.788111728294325e-8, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.0003778081682626236, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.970284284601467, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.029337907230270358 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.0006819052216967179, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.9742979300225488, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.025020164755754474 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "DEFER_FOR_BIOPSY": 0.0005298566949796707, + "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA": 0.972291107312008, + "INELIGIBLE_EXCLUDED": 0.027179035993012416 + }, + "fwd_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "rev_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "ensemble_winner": "ELIGIBLE_COHORT_ALPHA", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.12919686767190225, + "total_entropy": 0.12930689607477977, + "normalized_total_h": 0.11770020908062438, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.00011002840287752114, + "normalized_jsd": 0.0001587374311883327, + "tvd": 0.004317742474515912, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": false, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 181 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_13_binary_collateral_margin", + "regime": "binary_ablation", + "title": "Binary Margin Call Threshold With Haircut Adjustment", + "cardinality": 2, + "expected": "trigger_margin_call", + "canonical_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9994864827033582, + "canonical_entropy": 0.004402881917832699, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.006352015908476923, + "canonical_brier": 5.274000279007541e-7, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "no_margin_call_sufficient", + "trigger_margin_call" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "no_margin_call_sufficient": 0.0005135172966419043, + "trigger_margin_call": 0.9994864827033582 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "no_margin_call_sufficient": 0.000093327667816184, + "trigger_margin_call": 0.9999066723321838 + }, + "raw_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "debiased_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "raw_entropy": 0.004402881917832699, + "normalized_entropy": 0.006352015908476923, + "wall_time_ms": 209 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "trigger_margin_call", + "no_margin_call_sufficient" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "no_margin_call_sufficient": 0.0004202643156215778, + "trigger_margin_call": 0.9995797356843784 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "no_margin_call_sufficient": 0.0023090233334982203, + "trigger_margin_call": 0.9976909766665016 + }, + "raw_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "debiased_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "raw_entropy": 0.0036875741706166184, + "normalized_entropy": 0.005320044968858828, + "wall_time_ms": 106 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.004045228044224658, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.00035765387360804017, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.004047561216419439, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.000002333172194780332, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.00009325298102028982, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 4.359740497006693e-7, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.0006358921901786028, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 1.7420107160023282e-8, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "no_margin_call_sufficient": 0.03662113935115422, + "trigger_margin_call": 0.9633788606488458 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "no_margin_call_sufficient": 0.010856274097106964, + "trigger_margin_call": 0.989143725902893 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "no_margin_call_sufficient": 0.023738706724130594, + "trigger_margin_call": 0.9762612932758694 + }, + "fwd_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "rev_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "ensemble_winner": "trigger_margin_call", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.10847664557765357, + "total_entropy": 0.11225284178002917, + "normalized_total_h": 0.16194661816174152, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.003776196202375598, + "normalized_jsd": 0.005447899534591012, + "tvd": 0.025764865254047226, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": true, + "escalated_by_mirror": true, + "wall_time_ms": 96 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_14_binary_gdpr_subprocessor", + "regime": "binary_ablation", + "title": "Binary GDPR Sub-Processor Prior Notice Requirement", + "cardinality": 2, + "expected": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "canonical_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9958588965272693, + "canonical_entropy": 0.026853894737476753, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.03874198076631195, + "canonical_brier": 0.00003429747594372361, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "yes_notice_required", + "no_exempt_anonymized" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "no_exempt_anonymized": 0.9958588965272693, + "yes_notice_required": 0.004141103472730622 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "no_exempt_anonymized": 0.9992451457277146, + "yes_notice_required": 0.0007548542722854252 + }, + "raw_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "debiased_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "raw_entropy": 0.026853894737476753, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03874198076631195, + "wall_time_ms": 233 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "no_exempt_anonymized", + "yes_notice_required" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "no_exempt_anonymized": 0.9993975368215127, + "yes_notice_required": 0.0006024631784873527 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "no_exempt_anonymized": 0.9966926459192735, + "yes_notice_required": 0.0033073540807264813 + }, + "raw_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "debiased_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "raw_entropy": 0.005069235264002764, + "normalized_entropy": 0.007313360576476243, + "wall_time_ms": 179 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.01596156500073976, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.010892329736736995, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.016704295205453086, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.0007427302047133266, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.0035386402942433016, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.000011250712287273453, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.00043351639325625926, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 0.0000011396099447750615, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "no_exempt_anonymized": 0.8587909971278855, + "yes_notice_required": 0.14120900287211452 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "no_exempt_anonymized": 0.9802051490735525, + "yes_notice_required": 0.019794850926447526 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "no_exempt_anonymized": 0.919498073100719, + "yes_notice_required": 0.08050192689928103 + }, + "fwd_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "rev_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "ensemble_winner": "no_exempt_anonymized", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.25219587649460384, + "total_entropy": 0.2799935432156714, + "normalized_total_h": 0.40394529627817877, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.027797666721067538, + "normalized_jsd": 0.04010355592676831, + "tvd": 0.12141415194566697, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": true, + "escalated_by_mirror": true, + "wall_time_ms": 136 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_15_binary_canary_slo_budget", + "regime": "binary_ablation", + "title": "Binary Canary Promotion Gate Under Error Budget Burn Rate", + "cardinality": 2, + "expected": "halt_canary", + "canonical_winner": "halt_canary", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9998128997701209, + "canonical_entropy": 0.0017931260453610712, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.002586934053331256, + "canonical_brier": 7.001299204166882e-8, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "promote_canary_to_prod", + "halt_canary" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "halt_canary": 0.9998128997701209, + "promote_canary_to_prod": 0.00018710022987920808 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "halt_canary": 0.9999660051118395, + "promote_canary_to_prod": 0.000033994888160451706 + }, + "raw_winner": "halt_canary", + "debiased_winner": "halt_canary", + "raw_entropy": 0.0017931260453610712, + "normalized_entropy": 0.002586934053331256, + "wall_time_ms": 122 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "halt_canary", + "promote_canary_to_prod" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "halt_canary": 0.9967027087831208, + "promote_canary_to_prod": 0.003297291216879227 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "halt_canary": 0.9821153125839258, + "promote_canary_to_prod": 0.017884687416074234 + }, + "raw_winner": "halt_canary", + "debiased_winner": "halt_canary", + "raw_entropy": 0.02213472757944525, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03193366171029383, + "wall_time_ms": 119 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.01196392681240316, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.010170800767042089, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.012808165539796213, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.0008442387273930527, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.0031101909870000343, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "halt_canary", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.000006070491877121581, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.006126822686190539, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 2.3113048420845676e-9, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "halt_canary": 0.9746879054147146, + "promote_canary_to_prod": 0.025312094585285407 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "halt_canary": 0.9969020160250038, + "promote_canary_to_prod": 0.0030979839749961475 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "halt_canary": 0.9857949607198593, + "promote_canary_to_prod": 0.014205039280140778 + }, + "fwd_winner": "halt_canary", + "rev_winner": "halt_canary", + "ensemble_winner": "halt_canary", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.06951924105284911, + "total_entropy": 0.07453415513890203, + "normalized_total_h": 0.10753005599574261, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.005014914086052924, + "normalized_jsd": 0.007234991682432762, + "tvd": 0.022214110610289238, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": true, + "escalated_by_mirror": false, + "wall_time_ms": 140 + } + }, + { + "id": "perm_16_binary_export_ear99", + "regime": "binary_ablation", + "title": "Binary Export Control License Exception Check", + "cardinality": 2, + "expected": "exempt_public_source", + "canonical_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "canonical_accurate": true, + "canonical_confidence": 0.9965075930483029, + "canonical_entropy": 0.023243420649626607, + "canonical_normalized_h": 0.03353316770451244, + "canonical_brier": 0.00002439381263252398, + "cyclic_passes": [ + { + "perm_index": 0, + "option_order": [ + "requires_pre_shipment_license", + "exempt_public_source" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "exempt_public_source": 0.9965075930483029, + "requires_pre_shipment_license": 0.003492406951697073 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "exempt_public_source": 0.9993637312240807, + "requires_pre_shipment_license": 0.0006362687759191994 + }, + "raw_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "debiased_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "raw_entropy": 0.023243420649626607, + "normalized_entropy": 0.03353316770451244, + "wall_time_ms": 219 + }, + { + "perm_index": 1, + "option_order": [ + "exempt_public_source", + "requires_pre_shipment_license" + ], + "raw_probs": { + "exempt_public_source": 0.9936408637628983, + "requires_pre_shipment_license": 0.006359136237101738 + }, + "debiased_probs": { + "exempt_public_source": 0.9659701831797816, + "requires_pre_shipment_license": 0.034029816820218536 + }, + "raw_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "debiased_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "raw_entropy": 0.038502512056117474, + "normalized_entropy": 0.055547383205128205, + "wall_time_ms": 149 + } + ], + "raw_flip_occurred": false, + "raw_distinct_winners": 1, + "raw_majority_agreement": 1, + "raw_mean_entropy": 0.03087296635287204, + "raw_entropy_stddev": 0.007629545703245434, + "raw_total_entropy": 0.03108559586833983, + "raw_js_divergence_nats": 0.00021262951546779235, + "raw_max_tvd": 0.002866729285404661, + "raw_ensemble_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "raw_ensemble_accurate": true, + "raw_ensemble_brier": 0.00004852645160038339, + "debiased_flip_occurred": false, + "debiased_js_divergence_nats": 0.010569141372875651, + "debiased_canonical_accurate": true, + "debiased_canonical_brier": 8.096759104195209e-7, + "dual_mirror": { + "fwd_probs": { + "exempt_public_source": 0.8948623473774856, + "requires_pre_shipment_license": 0.10513765262251443 + }, + "rev_probs": { + "exempt_public_source": 0.7880022591829151, + "requires_pre_shipment_license": 0.21199774081708495 + }, + "ensemble_probs": { + "exempt_public_source": 0.8414323032802004, + "requires_pre_shipment_license": 0.1585676967197997 + }, + "fwd_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "rev_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "ensemble_winner": "exempt_public_source", + "mirror_disagreed": false, + "mean_pass_entropy": 0.42640930608293537, + "total_entropy": 0.4372871433240917, + "normalized_total_h": 0.6308719931181684, + "js_divergence_nats": 0.010877837241156318, + "normalized_jsd": 0.015693401843413505, + "tvd": 0.1068600881945705, + "accurate": true, + "escalated_by_single": true, + "escalated_by_mirror": true, + "wall_time_ms": 217 + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ac2783a --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank.json @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +{ + "experiment": "EXP-11-Phase0-Reranking-Validation", + "execution_mode": "LIVE DGEM CLOUD RUN L4 EXECUTION (--endpoint https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions)", + "mean_wall_latency_ms": 416.9, + "dataset_path": "/workspace/dgem/benchmarks/rerank_suite.jsonl", + "total_queries": 30, + "candidates_per_query": 10, + "total_query_passage_pairs": 300, + "summary_metrics": { + "1_bi_encoder": { + "label": "Stage-1 Bi-Encoder Baseline (Dot Product)", + "nDCG@3": 0.5826, + "nDCG@5": 0.7104, + "nDCG@10": 0.7581, + "MRR@10": 0.7006, + "MAP@10": 0.6024, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6994, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 0.0, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 0.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 50.0, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.0, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 0.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 40.0 + }, + "2_pointwise_rerank": { + "label": "Pointwise Cross-Encoder (Isolated Scalar s(q, d_i))", + "nDCG@3": 0.9138, + "nDCG@5": 0.9209, + "nDCG@10": 0.9527, + "MRR@10": 0.963, + "MAP@10": 0.9074, + "Spearman_rho": 0.8622, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 2.7, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 100.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 64.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8333, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 0.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 40.0 + }, + "3_dgem_listwise_argmax": { + "label": "dgem Listwise Canvas (Discrete Mode Argmax 0..3)", + "nDCG@3": 0.6541, + "nDCG@5": 0.7055, + "nDCG@10": 0.7765, + "MRR@10": 0.7778, + "MAP@10": 0.7217, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6161, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 62.3, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 0.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 14.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.79, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 100.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 60.0 + }, + "4_dgem_listwise_expectation": { + "label": "dgem Listwise Decision Canvas (Continuous Expectation r_hat_i + Gates)", + "nDCG@3": 0.7207, + "nDCG@5": 0.779, + "nDCG@10": 0.8239, + "MRR@10": 0.8284, + "MAP@10": 0.774, + "Spearman_rho": 0.5719, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 0.0, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 40.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 14.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8464, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 100.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 60.0 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank_r2.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank_r2.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..24910d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank_r2.json @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +{ + "experiment": "EXP-11-Phase0-Reranking-Validation", + "execution_mode": "LIVE DGEM CLOUD RUN L4 EXECUTION (--endpoint https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions)", + "mean_wall_latency_ms": 419.3, + "dataset_path": "/workspace/dgem/benchmarks/rerank_suite.jsonl", + "total_queries": 30, + "candidates_per_query": 10, + "total_query_passage_pairs": 300, + "summary_metrics": { + "1_bi_encoder": { + "label": "Stage-1 Bi-Encoder Baseline (Dot Product)", + "nDCG@3": 0.5826, + "nDCG@5": 0.7104, + "nDCG@10": 0.7581, + "MRR@10": 0.7006, + "MAP@10": 0.6024, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6994, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 0.0, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 0.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 50.0, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.0, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 0.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 40.0 + }, + "2_pointwise_rerank": { + "label": "Pointwise Cross-Encoder (Isolated Scalar s(q, d_i))", + "nDCG@3": 0.9138, + "nDCG@5": 0.9209, + "nDCG@10": 0.9527, + "MRR@10": 0.963, + "MAP@10": 0.9074, + "Spearman_rho": 0.8622, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 2.7, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 100.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 64.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8333, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 0.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 40.0 + }, + "3_dgem_listwise_argmax": { + "label": "dgem Listwise Canvas (Discrete Mode Argmax 0..3)", + "nDCG@3": 0.6583, + "nDCG@5": 0.7331, + "nDCG@10": 0.7863, + "MRR@10": 0.7623, + "MAP@10": 0.7209, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6349, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 63.3, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 20.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 14.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 100.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 60.0 + }, + "4_dgem_listwise_expectation": { + "label": "dgem Listwise Decision Canvas (Continuous Expectation r_hat_i + Gates)", + "nDCG@3": 0.734, + "nDCG@5": 0.8221, + "nDCG@10": 0.8557, + "MRR@10": 0.8148, + "MAP@10": 0.7698, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6025, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 0.0, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 60.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 14.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8445, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 100.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 60.0 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank_r3.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank_r3.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ab14928 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/rerank_r3.json @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +{ + "experiment": "EXP-11-Phase0-Reranking-Validation", + "execution_mode": "LIVE DGEM CLOUD RUN L4 EXECUTION (--endpoint https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations/us-central1/endpoints//invoke/v1/chat/completions)", + "mean_wall_latency_ms": 389.6, + "dataset_path": "/workspace/dgem/benchmarks/rerank_suite.jsonl", + "total_queries": 30, + "candidates_per_query": 10, + "total_query_passage_pairs": 300, + "summary_metrics": { + "1_bi_encoder": { + "label": "Stage-1 Bi-Encoder Baseline (Dot Product)", + "nDCG@3": 0.5826, + "nDCG@5": 0.7104, + "nDCG@10": 0.7581, + "MRR@10": 0.7006, + "MAP@10": 0.6024, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6994, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 0.0, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 0.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 50.0, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.0, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 0.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 40.0 + }, + "2_pointwise_rerank": { + "label": "Pointwise Cross-Encoder (Isolated Scalar s(q, d_i))", + "nDCG@3": 0.9138, + "nDCG@5": 0.9209, + "nDCG@10": 0.9527, + "MRR@10": 0.963, + "MAP@10": 0.9074, + "Spearman_rho": 0.8622, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 2.7, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 100.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 64.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8333, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 0.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 40.0 + }, + "3_dgem_listwise_argmax": { + "label": "dgem Listwise Canvas (Discrete Mode Argmax 0..3)", + "nDCG@3": 0.6583, + "nDCG@5": 0.7331, + "nDCG@10": 0.7863, + "MRR@10": 0.7623, + "MAP@10": 0.7209, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6349, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 63.3, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 20.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 14.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 100.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 60.0 + }, + "4_dgem_listwise_expectation": { + "label": "dgem Listwise Decision Canvas (Continuous Expectation r_hat_i + Gates)", + "nDCG@3": 0.734, + "nDCG@5": 0.8221, + "nDCG@10": 0.8557, + "MRR@10": 0.8148, + "MAP@10": 0.7698, + "Spearman_rho": 0.6025, + "Exact_Tie_Rate_pct": 0.0, + "S1_NevIR_Pairwise_Acc_pct": 60.0, + "S3_HotpotQA_Recall@2_pct": 14.3, + "S4_FollowIR_p_MRR": 0.8445, + "S5_Poison_Quarantine_pct": 100.0, + "S5_Abstention_Acc_pct": 60.0 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/templates_vertex.json b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/templates_vertex.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cd28708 --- /dev/null +++ b/benchmarks/runs/20260928-v010-verification/templates_vertex.json @@ -0,0 +1,224 @@ +{ + "gateway_backend": "vertex", + "results": [ + { + "template": "agent_router", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 270, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 1, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "calibration/agent_step_drift", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 308, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 1, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "calibration/chaos_nli", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 312, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 1, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "calibration/civil_comments_toxicity", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 308, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 2, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "calibration/grounding_claim_check", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 276, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 1, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "calibration/ms_marco_relevance", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 288, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 1, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "calibration/prompt_injection", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 289, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 1, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "code_review", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 285, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 3, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "contract_audit", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 308, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 3, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "intent_banking77", + "status": 502, + "wall_ms": 229, + "backend_used": null, + "error": "{\"error\":\"upstream (vertex) decision failed after 1 attempt(s): server returned error HTTP 400: {\\\"error\\\": {\\\"message\\\": \\\"question 'intent': needs at least two alternatives\\\", \\\"type\\\": \\\"invalid_re" + }, + { + "template": "intent_clinc150", + "status": 502, + "wall_ms": 228, + "backend_used": null, + "error": "{\"error\":\"upstream (vertex) decision failed after 1 attempt(s): server returned error HTTP 400: {\\\"error\\\": {\\\"message\\\": \\\"question 'domain': needs at least two alternatives\\\", \\\"type\\\": \\\"invalid_re" + }, + { + "template": "intent_tiebreak", + "status": 400, + "wall_ms": 218, + "backend_used": null, + "error": "{\"error\":\"template render failed: failed to execute template: template: intent_tiebreak.json.tmpl:10:31: executing \\\"intent_tiebreak.json.tmpl\\\" at \\u003c.options\\u003e: range can't iterate over \"}\n" + }, + { + "template": "jevbench_generic", + "status": 502, + "wall_ms": 251, + "backend_used": null, + "error": "{\"error\":\"upstream (vertex) decision failed after 1 attempt(s): server returned error HTTP 400: {\\\"error\\\": {\\\"message\\\": \\\"system must be a JSON question schema and user must be JSON state or image p" + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/bbox_localization", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 487, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 5, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/bbox_multi_object_detr", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 487, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 10, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/bbox_multi_object_set", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 489, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 11, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/call_quality_audio", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 386, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 4, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/kyc_document_audit", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 386, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 4, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/pcb_defect_triage", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 385, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 3, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/ui_design_review", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 356, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 3, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "multimodal/workplace_hazard_video", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 320, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 3, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "rerank/listwise_decision_rerank", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 351, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 12, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "rerank/pointwise_rerank", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 286, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 2, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "secops_conditional_dag", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 339, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 5, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "security_incident", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 278, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 3, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "support_triage", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 298, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 3, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "taxonomy_discovery", + "status": 200, + "wall_ms": 584, + "backend_used": null, + "questions": 4, + "problems": [] + }, + { + "template": "tn_disambiguation", + "status": 502, + "wall_ms": 200, + "backend_used": null, + "error": "{\"error\":\"upstream (vertex) decision failed after 1 attempt(s): server returned error HTTP 400: {\\\"error\\\": {\\\"message\\\": \\\"question 'expansion': needs at least two alternatives\\\", \\\"type\\\": \\\"invalid" + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/cmd/otel.go b/cmd/otel.go index 35420a6..6db9a5d 100644 --- a/cmd/otel.go +++ b/cmd/otel.go @@ -155,10 +155,15 @@ func (p *gatewaySpanProcessor) OnEnd(s sdktrace.ReadOnlySpan) { } else { logEntry["dgem_surface"] = "rest_api" } + // "none" when the request failed before a backend was chosen (e.g. 400 unknown backend); defaulting + // to "cloudrun" made failed requests look like Cloud Run decisions in metrics. if v, ok := attrs["dgem.backend"]; ok { logEntry["dgem_backend"] = v } else { - logEntry["dgem_backend"] = "cloudrun" + logEntry["dgem_backend"] = "none" + } + if v, ok := attrs["dgem.backend_requested"]; ok { + logEntry["dgem_backend_requested"] = v } if v, ok := attrs["dgem.template"]; ok { logEntry["dgem_template"] = v diff --git a/cmd/serve.go b/cmd/serve.go index 49a94c2..d333d10 100644 --- a/cmd/serve.go +++ b/cmd/serve.go @@ -682,6 +682,20 @@ func resolveBackendTargetFromParams(ctx context.Context, requestedMode, requeste // resolveBackendTarget determines whether an HTTP request should route to "vertex" or "cloudrun" // based on headers (X-DGem-Backend, X-DGem-Vertex-Url), payload overrides, query params, or server default. +// requestedBackendMode is the backend a request asked for (header, JSON body or query), or the gateway default. +// Logged next to the backend that answered so monitoring can tell a vertex_first failover to Cloud Run from an +// explicit Cloud Run request. +func requestedBackendMode(r *http.Request, payloadBackend string) string { + for _, v := range []string{r.Header.Get("X-DGem-Backend"), payloadBackend, r.URL.Query().Get("backend")} { + if v = strings.ToLower(strings.TrimSpace(v)); v != "" { + return v + } + } + backendConfigMu.RLock() + defer backendConfigMu.RUnlock() + return serveDefaultBackend +} + func resolveBackendTarget(r *http.Request, payloadBackend, payloadVertexURL string) (string, string, error) { targetBackend := strings.TrimSpace(r.Header.Get("X-DGem-Backend")) if targetBackend == "" { @@ -1504,6 +1518,7 @@ func runServe(cmd *cobra.Command, args []string) error { rootSpan.SetAttributes( attribute.String("dgem.surface", surface), attribute.String("dgem.backend", backendTarget), + attribute.String("dgem.backend_requested", requestedBackendMode(r, payload.Backend)), attribute.String("dgem.template", tmplLabel), attribute.String("dgem.user", userEmail), attribute.Bool("dgem.multimodal", len(images) > 0), diff --git a/deploy/probe/Dockerfile b/deploy/probe/Dockerfile new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2f74add --- /dev/null +++ b/deploy/probe/Dockerfile @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +# Scheduled health check (synthetic probe) for dgem: scripts/probe.py on a small Python image. +# Built and deployed by scripts/deploy_probe.sh as Cloud Run jobs triggered by Cloud Scheduler. +FROM python:3.12-slim +WORKDIR /app +COPY scripts/probe.py scripts/contract_diff.py scripts/serving_speed.py /app/scripts/ +COPY fixtures/bbox/ /app/fixtures/bbox/ +ENV PYTHONUNBUFFERED=1 +ENTRYPOINT ["python3", "/app/scripts/probe.py"] diff --git a/docs-site/astro.config.mjs b/docs-site/astro.config.mjs index 87ef035..c8abb1f 100644 --- a/docs-site/astro.config.mjs +++ b/docs-site/astro.config.mjs @@ -251,6 +251,7 @@ export default defineConfig({ { label: '5. Gateway and Routing', slug: 'deploy/gateway' }, { label: 'Latency and Capacity', slug: 'operate/latency-capacity' }, { label: 'Operations Runbook', slug: 'operate/runbook' }, + { label: 'Monitoring and Alerts', slug: 'operate/monitoring' }, { label: 'Observability and Traces', slug: 'operate/observability' }, ], }, diff --git a/docs-site/src/content/docs/deploy/index.md b/docs-site/src/content/docs/deploy/index.md index 1269679..6c8d88b 100644 --- a/docs-site/src/content/docs/deploy/index.md +++ b/docs-site/src/content/docs/deploy/index.md @@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ pages is measured (sample sizes and receipts are linked); identifiers such as `< | 5 | [Gateway and routing](/dgem/deploy/gateway/) | One URL for users, automatic failover from Vertex to Cloud Run, IAP | | 6 | [Latency and capacity](/dgem/operate/latency-capacity/) | Request design, engine settings and how to measure your own | | 7 | [Operations runbook](/dgem/operate/runbook/) | Health, promotion, rollback, teardown and troubleshooting | +| 8 | [Monitoring and alerts](/dgem/operate/monitoring/) | Scheduled health check, alert policies, what to do when they fire | ## Crawl → walk → run diff --git a/docs-site/src/content/docs/operate/monitoring.md b/docs-site/src/content/docs/operate/monitoring.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..73dc26c --- /dev/null +++ b/docs-site/src/content/docs/operate/monitoring.md @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +--- +title: "Monitoring and Alerts" +description: "How dgem is monitored: the alert policies and what to do when each fires, the scheduled health check, how to change thresholds, and how to deploy or remove the monitoring." +--- + +`dgem` monitoring has three parts: + +| Part | What it does | Set up by | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | +| **Log-based metrics** | Turn gateway decision logs and health-check results into metrics (count, latency, backend) | `scripts/setup_alerts.py` (and `scripts/setup_cloud_monitoring.sh` for the dashboard) | +| **Scheduled health check** | Every hour, checks the Vertex endpoint and the gateway; once a day, the Cloud Run service | `scripts/deploy_probe.sh` | +| **Alert policies** | Email when something is broken or slow | `scripts/setup_alerts.py` | + +Everything is created by idempotent scripts, so changing a threshold means editing one value and re-running a +script. Placeholders: ``, ``, ``, ``. + +## The scheduled health check + +Two Cloud Run jobs triggered by Cloud Scheduler, running `scripts/probe.py` as a dedicated service account +(`dgem-probe-sa`, allowed only to call the Vertex endpoint and invoke the gateway and serving services). + +| Job | Schedule (UTC) | Targets | What it checks | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | +| `dgem-probe-hourly` | `7 * * * *` | Vertex endpoint; gateway | Vertex: `/health`, the 14-case API contract (valid and error cases must return the expected status and answers), 20 latency requests. Gateway: `/health`, 3 decisions through the default route, which must be answered by Vertex | +| `dgem-probe-daily` | `17 6 * * *` | Cloud Run serving service | Same as Vertex; the first request wakes the scale-to-zero service (~2.5 min), then it idles back to zero | + +Each target writes one JSON log line: `probe_event="dgem.probe"`, `probe_target`, `probe_ok`, `probe_failures`, +`probe_latency_p50_ms`, `probe_latency_p95_ms`, `probe_denoise_p50_ms`, `probe_version`. Find them in Logs Explorer +with `jsonPayload.probe_event="dgem.probe"`. + +Cost: the hourly job uses the always-warm endpoint (a few seconds of CPU per run); the daily job keeps one Cloud Run +GPU up for about 20 minutes. + +## Alerts: what they mean and what to do + +All policies are named `dgem: …`, notify the email channel, and link back to this page. + +| Alert | Fires when (default) | Likely causes | What to do | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | +| **Vertex endpoint has no available replica** (critical) | Available replicas sum < 1, or the replica metric is missing, for 5 min | Replica crashed or is restarting; endpoint scaled to 0 while idle; model undeployed | Check `availableReplicaCount` (`gcloud ai endpoints describe --region=`). The gateway is serving from Cloud Run meanwhile. If it doesn't recover in ~15 min, redeploy or roll back ([runbook](/dgem/operate/runbook/#roll-back)) | +| **Vertex 5xx/429 error rate** | 5xx + 429 responses > 1% of Vertex responses over 10 min | Overload (`503 server busy`: more than `MAX_INFLIGHT` queued), replica restart, bad image | Check load and replica count; raise max replicas or `MAX_INFLIGHT`; if it started with a new image, roll back | +| **Gateway failing over from Vertex to Cloud Run** | > 20% of `vertex_first` decisions answered by Cloud Run over 30 min (at least 5 decisions) | Vertex unhealthy or updating | Usually accompanies one of the Vertex alerts; users see slower answers (and a cold start if Cloud Run was idle). Fix Vertex | +| **Gateway decision latency p95 (Vertex)** (warning) | p95 of Vertex-answered decision wall time > 2,000 ms over 15 min | Queueing under load, very long prompts or many-question policies, reasoning (`think`) templates | Compare with normal (150–500 ms for typical policies). If it's load, add replicas; if it's one template, it may just be heavy | +| **Scheduled health check failed** | Any health-check run reported `probe_ok=false` in the last ~70 min | API contract changed (new image), endpoint down, auth or IAM change for the probe account, gateway fell back to Cloud Run | Read `jsonPayload.probe_failures` on the failing log line; it names the failing case or request | +| **Scheduled health check not running** (warning) | No Vertex health-check result for 2 h | Scheduler paused or deleted, job failing to start, image pull or IAM problem | `gcloud scheduler jobs describe dgem-probe-hourly --location=`; run the job by hand (below) and read its logs | +| **Health-check latency to Vertex** (warning) | Health-check median end-to-end latency to Vertex > 400 ms | Slower serving image, GPU contention, network | Normal is ~80 ms from inside the region. Check `probe_denoise_p50_ms` (GPU time, normally ~55–60 ms): if GPU time rose, it's the model server; if only end-to-end rose, it's network or queueing | + +Alerts close automatically when the condition clears (after 30 min for Vertex alerts, 2 h for health-check alerts). + +## Changing thresholds + +Every threshold is an environment variable read by `scripts/setup_alerts.py`: + +| Variable | Default | Alert | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | +| `VERTEX_NO_REPLICA_MIN` | `5` | Minutes with no replica before alerting | +| `VERTEX_ERROR_RATE` | `0.01` | Vertex 5xx+429 share | +| `FAILOVER_SHARE` / `FAILOVER_MIN_DECISIONS` | `0.2` / `5` | Gateway failover share and minimum volume | +| `DECISION_P95_MS` | `2000` | Gateway decision p95 (ms) | +| `PROBE_MISSING_HOURS` | `2` | Hours without a health-check result | +| `PROBE_P50_MS` | `400` | Health-check median latency (ms) | + +```bash +# Preview, then apply (updates policies in place) +GCP_PROJECT= ALERT_EMAIL= VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID= DECISION_P95_MS=3000 \ + python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py --dry-run +GCP_PROJECT= ALERT_EMAIL= VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID= DECISION_P95_MS=3000 \ + python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py --only gateway-decision-p95 +``` + +Health-check schedules and targets are set in `scripts/deploy_probe.sh` (`HOURLY_SCHEDULE`, `DAILY_SCHEDULE`, +`PROBE_LATENCY_REQUESTS`, `PROBE_DAILY=off`); re-run it to apply. To pause an alert without deleting it, disable the +policy in the Cloud Monitoring console; to pause the health check, `gcloud scheduler jobs pause dgem-probe-hourly +--location=`. + +## Deploying the monitoring + +```bash +# 1. Health check (service account, image, jobs, schedules) +GCP_PROJECT= \ +PROBE_VERTEX_URL=https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations//endpoints//invoke \ +PROBE_GATEWAY_URL=https://.run.app \ +PROBE_CLOUDRUN_URL=https:// \ +PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE= \ +./scripts/deploy_probe.sh +gcloud run jobs execute dgem-probe-hourly --region= --wait # run once now + +# 2. Metrics, email channel and alert policies +GCP_PROJECT= ALERT_EMAIL= VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID= python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py +``` + +- **Gateway with IAP:** IAP accepts a service account's ID token only if its audience is one of the gateway's + programmatic OAuth clients (`gcloud iap settings get --resource-type=cloud-run --service= --region=`, + `programmaticClients`), and the account needs the IAP-secured Web App User role; the script grants it when + `PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE` is set. Use the gateway's `run.app` URL, not a custom domain. +- **After changing the Vertex endpoint** (new endpoint ID), re-run both scripts with the new values. +- **Failover and latency alerts need gateway logs with `dgem_backend_requested`** (gateway v0.1.2 or later). +- **Removing everything:** delete the `dgem:` alert policies, the scheduler jobs and Cloud Run jobs + (`dgem-probe-hourly`, `dgem-probe-daily`), and the `dgem-probe-sa` account. + +## Manual checks + +The health check runs a subset of the manual tools used when promoting a serving image +([runbook](/dgem/operate/runbook/#promote-a-new-serving-image)): `scripts/contract_diff.py`, `scripts/serving_speed.py`, +`scripts/coldstart_probe.py`, and `scripts/template_sweep.py` (every policy template through a gateway). Run those +by hand before and after changes; the scheduled check catches regressions in between. diff --git a/docs-site/src/content/docs/operate/runbook.md b/docs-site/src/content/docs/operate/runbook.md index 68aa3d7..f67f596 100644 --- a/docs-site/src/content/docs/operate/runbook.md +++ b/docs-site/src/content/docs/operate/runbook.md @@ -105,12 +105,8 @@ Builds between releases report `git describe` versions such as `v0.1.0-3-gabc123 ## Alerting -`scripts/setup_cloud_monitoring.sh` creates log-based metrics and a dashboard for the gateway. Useful alerts: - -- Vertex deployed model with 0 available replicas for > 5 minutes. -- Gateway `X-DGem-Backend-Used: cloudrun` share rising while the default is `vertex_first` (Vertex unhealthy). -- `503 server busy` rate > 1% (raise capacity or `MAX_INFLIGHT`). -- p95 decision latency above your SLO on `dgem.gateway.decide` traces ([Observability](/dgem/operate/observability/)). +Alert policies, the scheduled health check, what each alert means and how to change thresholds: +[Monitoring and alerts](/dgem/operate/monitoring/). `scripts/setup_cloud_monitoring.sh` also creates an operational dashboard. ## Incident playbooks diff --git a/docs/deploy/index.md b/docs/deploy/index.md index 42748f7..2937bb4 100644 --- a/docs/deploy/index.md +++ b/docs/deploy/index.md @@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ pages is measured (sample sizes and receipts are linked); identifiers such as `< | 5 | [Gateway and routing](gateway.md) | One URL for users, automatic failover from Vertex to Cloud Run, IAP | | 6 | [Latency and capacity](../operate/latency-capacity.md) | Request design, engine settings and how to measure your own | | 7 | [Operations runbook](../operate/runbook.md) | Health, promotion, rollback, teardown and troubleshooting | +| 8 | [Monitoring and alerts](../operate/monitoring.md) | Scheduled health check, alert policies, what to do when they fire | ## Crawl → walk → run diff --git a/docs/operate/monitoring.md b/docs/operate/monitoring.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..54671bf --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/operate/monitoring.md @@ -0,0 +1,108 @@ +--- +title: "Monitoring and Alerts" +description: "How dgem is monitored: the alert policies and what to do when each fires, the scheduled health check, how to change thresholds, and how to deploy or remove the monitoring." +--- + +# Monitoring and Alerts + +`dgem` monitoring has three parts: + +| Part | What it does | Set up by | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | +| **Log-based metrics** | Turn gateway decision logs and health-check results into metrics (count, latency, backend) | `scripts/setup_alerts.py` (and `scripts/setup_cloud_monitoring.sh` for the dashboard) | +| **Scheduled health check** | Every hour, checks the Vertex endpoint and the gateway; once a day, the Cloud Run service | `scripts/deploy_probe.sh` | +| **Alert policies** | Email when something is broken or slow | `scripts/setup_alerts.py` | + +Everything is created by idempotent scripts, so changing a threshold means editing one value and re-running a +script. Placeholders: ``, ``, ``, ``. + +## The scheduled health check + +Two Cloud Run jobs triggered by Cloud Scheduler, running `scripts/probe.py` as a dedicated service account +(`dgem-probe-sa`, allowed only to call the Vertex endpoint and invoke the gateway and serving services). + +| Job | Schedule (UTC) | Targets | What it checks | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | +| `dgem-probe-hourly` | `7 * * * *` | Vertex endpoint; gateway | Vertex: `/health`, the 14-case API contract (valid and error cases must return the expected status and answers), 20 latency requests. Gateway: `/health`, 3 decisions through the default route, which must be answered by Vertex | +| `dgem-probe-daily` | `17 6 * * *` | Cloud Run serving service | Same as Vertex; the first request wakes the scale-to-zero service (~2.5 min), then it idles back to zero | + +Each target writes one JSON log line: `probe_event="dgem.probe"`, `probe_target`, `probe_ok`, `probe_failures`, +`probe_latency_p50_ms`, `probe_latency_p95_ms`, `probe_denoise_p50_ms`, `probe_version`. Find them in Logs Explorer +with `jsonPayload.probe_event="dgem.probe"`. + +Cost: the hourly job uses the always-warm endpoint (a few seconds of CPU per run); the daily job keeps one Cloud Run +GPU up for about 20 minutes. + +## Alerts: what they mean and what to do + +All policies are named `dgem: …`, notify the email channel, and link back to this page. + +| Alert | Fires when (default) | Likely causes | What to do | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | +| **Vertex endpoint has no available replica** (critical) | Available replicas sum < 1, or the replica metric is missing, for 5 min | Replica crashed or is restarting; endpoint scaled to 0 while idle; model undeployed | Check `availableReplicaCount` (`gcloud ai endpoints describe --region=`). The gateway is serving from Cloud Run meanwhile. If it doesn't recover in ~15 min, redeploy or roll back ([runbook](runbook.md#roll-back)) | +| **Vertex 5xx/429 error rate** | 5xx + 429 responses > 1% of Vertex responses over 10 min | Overload (`503 server busy`: more than `MAX_INFLIGHT` queued), replica restart, bad image | Check load and replica count; raise max replicas or `MAX_INFLIGHT`; if it started with a new image, roll back | +| **Gateway failing over from Vertex to Cloud Run** | > 20% of `vertex_first` decisions answered by Cloud Run over 30 min (at least 5 decisions) | Vertex unhealthy or updating | Usually accompanies one of the Vertex alerts; users see slower answers (and a cold start if Cloud Run was idle). Fix Vertex | +| **Gateway decision latency p95 (Vertex)** (warning) | p95 of Vertex-answered decision wall time > 2,000 ms over 15 min | Queueing under load, very long prompts or many-question policies, reasoning (`think`) templates | Compare with normal (150–500 ms for typical policies). If it's load, add replicas; if it's one template, it may just be heavy | +| **Scheduled health check failed** | Any health-check run reported `probe_ok=false` in the last ~70 min | API contract changed (new image), endpoint down, auth or IAM change for the probe account, gateway fell back to Cloud Run | Read `jsonPayload.probe_failures` on the failing log line; it names the failing case or request | +| **Scheduled health check not running** (warning) | No Vertex health-check result for 2 h | Scheduler paused or deleted, job failing to start, image pull or IAM problem | `gcloud scheduler jobs describe dgem-probe-hourly --location=`; run the job by hand (below) and read its logs | +| **Health-check latency to Vertex** (warning) | Health-check median end-to-end latency to Vertex > 400 ms | Slower serving image, GPU contention, network | Normal is ~80 ms from inside the region. Check `probe_denoise_p50_ms` (GPU time, normally ~55–60 ms): if GPU time rose, it's the model server; if only end-to-end rose, it's network or queueing | + +Alerts close automatically when the condition clears (after 30 min for Vertex alerts, 2 h for health-check alerts). + +## Changing thresholds + +Every threshold is an environment variable read by `scripts/setup_alerts.py`: + +| Variable | Default | Alert | +| :--- | :--- | :--- | +| `VERTEX_NO_REPLICA_MIN` | `5` | Minutes with no replica before alerting | +| `VERTEX_ERROR_RATE` | `0.01` | Vertex 5xx+429 share | +| `FAILOVER_SHARE` / `FAILOVER_MIN_DECISIONS` | `0.2` / `5` | Gateway failover share and minimum volume | +| `DECISION_P95_MS` | `2000` | Gateway decision p95 (ms) | +| `PROBE_MISSING_HOURS` | `2` | Hours without a health-check result | +| `PROBE_P50_MS` | `400` | Health-check median latency (ms) | + +```bash +# Preview, then apply (updates policies in place) +GCP_PROJECT= ALERT_EMAIL= VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID= DECISION_P95_MS=3000 \ + python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py --dry-run +GCP_PROJECT= ALERT_EMAIL= VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID= DECISION_P95_MS=3000 \ + python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py --only gateway-decision-p95 +``` + +Health-check schedules and targets are set in `scripts/deploy_probe.sh` (`HOURLY_SCHEDULE`, `DAILY_SCHEDULE`, +`PROBE_LATENCY_REQUESTS`, `PROBE_DAILY=off`); re-run it to apply. To pause an alert without deleting it, disable the +policy in the Cloud Monitoring console; to pause the health check, `gcloud scheduler jobs pause dgem-probe-hourly +--location=`. + +## Deploying the monitoring + +```bash +# 1. Health check (service account, image, jobs, schedules) +GCP_PROJECT= \ +PROBE_VERTEX_URL=https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects//locations//endpoints//invoke \ +PROBE_GATEWAY_URL=https://.run.app \ +PROBE_CLOUDRUN_URL=https:// \ +PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE= \ +./scripts/deploy_probe.sh +gcloud run jobs execute dgem-probe-hourly --region= --wait # run once now + +# 2. Metrics, email channel and alert policies +GCP_PROJECT= ALERT_EMAIL= VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID= python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py +``` + +- **Gateway with IAP:** IAP accepts a service account's ID token only if its audience is one of the gateway's + programmatic OAuth clients (`gcloud iap settings get --resource-type=cloud-run --service= --region=`, + `programmaticClients`), and the account needs the IAP-secured Web App User role; the script grants it when + `PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE` is set. Use the gateway's `run.app` URL, not a custom domain. +- **After changing the Vertex endpoint** (new endpoint ID), re-run both scripts with the new values. +- **Failover and latency alerts need gateway logs with `dgem_backend_requested`** (gateway v0.1.2 or later). +- **Removing everything:** delete the `dgem:` alert policies, the scheduler jobs and Cloud Run jobs + (`dgem-probe-hourly`, `dgem-probe-daily`), and the `dgem-probe-sa` account. + +## Manual checks + +The health check runs a subset of the manual tools used when promoting a serving image +([runbook](runbook.md#promote-a-new-serving-image)): `scripts/contract_diff.py`, `scripts/serving_speed.py`, +`scripts/coldstart_probe.py`, and `scripts/template_sweep.py` (every policy template through a gateway). Run those +by hand before and after changes; the scheduled check catches regressions in between. diff --git a/docs/operate/runbook.md b/docs/operate/runbook.md index 92de19c..e9c482b 100644 --- a/docs/operate/runbook.md +++ b/docs/operate/runbook.md @@ -107,12 +107,8 @@ Builds between releases report `git describe` versions such as `v0.1.0-3-gabc123 ## Alerting -`scripts/setup_cloud_monitoring.sh` creates log-based metrics and a dashboard for the gateway. Useful alerts: - -- Vertex deployed model with 0 available replicas for > 5 minutes. -- Gateway `X-DGem-Backend-Used: cloudrun` share rising while the default is `vertex_first` (Vertex unhealthy). -- `503 server busy` rate > 1% (raise capacity or `MAX_INFLIGHT`). -- p95 decision latency above your SLO on `dgem.gateway.decide` traces ([Observability](observability.md)). +Alert policies, the scheduled health check, what each alert means and how to change thresholds: +[Monitoring and alerts](monitoring.md). `scripts/setup_cloud_monitoring.sh` also creates an operational dashboard. ## Incident playbooks diff --git a/scripts/deploy_probe.sh b/scripts/deploy_probe.sh new file mode 100755 index 0000000..335fe7d --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/deploy_probe.sh @@ -0,0 +1,105 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env bash +# Deploy the dgem scheduled health check (synthetic probe): two Cloud Run jobs + two Cloud Scheduler triggers. +# +# dgem-probe-hourly every hour: Vertex endpoint (contract + latency) and the gateway (vertex_first route) +# dgem-probe-daily once a day: the scale-to-zero Cloud Run service (wakes the GPU once, ~20 GPU-minutes/day) +# +# Each run writes one JSON log line per target (probe_event="dgem.probe"); scripts/setup_alerts.py turns those into +# alerts. See docs/operate/monitoring.md. +# +# Required: +# GCP_PROJECT hosting project +# PROBE_VERTEX_URL Vertex dedicated invoke base: https://.-.prediction.vertexai.goog/v1/projects/

/locations//endpoints//invoke +# PROBE_GATEWAY_URL gateway run.app URL (https://dgemma-gateway--uc.a.run.app), not an IAP custom domain +# PROBE_CLOUDRUN_URL serving Cloud Run URL (https://dgemma--uc.a.run.app) +# Optional: +# GCP_REGION (us-central1) HOURLY_SCHEDULE ("7 * * * *") DAILY_SCHEDULE ("17 6 * * *") SCHEDULE_TZ (Etc/UTC) +# GATEWAY_SERVICE (dgemma-gateway) CLOUDRUN_SERVICE (dgemma) PROBE_SA_NAME (dgem-probe-sa) +# PROBE_LATENCY_REQUESTS (20) PROBE_DAILY=off (skip the Cloud Run job) +# PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE required when the gateway has IAP enabled: one of its programmatic OAuth clients +# (gcloud iap settings get --resource-type=cloud-run --service= --region=) +set -euo pipefail + +PROJECT="${GCP_PROJECT:?set GCP_PROJECT}" +REGION="${GCP_REGION:-us-central1}" +: "${PROBE_VERTEX_URL:?set PROBE_VERTEX_URL (Vertex dedicated invoke base)}" +: "${PROBE_GATEWAY_URL:?set PROBE_GATEWAY_URL (gateway run.app URL)}" +PROBE_CLOUDRUN_URL="${PROBE_CLOUDRUN_URL:-}" +SA_NAME="${PROBE_SA_NAME:-dgem-probe-sa}" +SA="${SA_NAME}@${PROJECT}.iam.gserviceaccount.com" +GATEWAY_SERVICE="${GATEWAY_SERVICE:-dgemma-gateway}" +CLOUDRUN_SERVICE="${CLOUDRUN_SERVICE:-dgemma}" +HOURLY_SCHEDULE="${HOURLY_SCHEDULE:-7 * * * *}" +DAILY_SCHEDULE="${DAILY_SCHEDULE:-17 6 * * *}" +SCHEDULE_TZ="${SCHEDULE_TZ:-Etc/UTC}" +N="${PROBE_LATENCY_REQUESTS:-20}" +TAG="$(git rev-parse --short HEAD 2>/dev/null || echo latest)" +IMAGE="${REGION}-docker.pkg.dev/${PROJECT}/dgem/dgem-probe:${TAG}" +REPO_ROOT="$(cd "$(dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")/.." && pwd)" + +echo "==> Service account ${SA}" +gcloud iam service-accounts describe "${SA}" --project="${PROJECT}" >/dev/null 2>&1 || \ + gcloud iam service-accounts create "${SA_NAME}" --project="${PROJECT}" \ + --display-name="dgem scheduled health check (read-only probe)" +# Call the Vertex endpoint (predict/invoke) and invoke the gateway and Cloud Run services. Nothing else. +gcloud projects add-iam-policy-binding "${PROJECT}" --member="serviceAccount:${SA}" \ + --role="roles/aiplatform.user" --condition=None --quiet >/dev/null +if [[ -n "${PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE:-}" ]]; then + # IAP-protected gateway: the SA must also be an IAP-secured Web App User on it. + gcloud iap web add-iam-policy-binding --project="${PROJECT}" --resource-type=cloud-run \ + --service="${GATEWAY_SERVICE}" --region="${REGION}" --member="serviceAccount:${SA}" \ + --role="roles/iap.httpsResourceAccessor" --condition=None --quiet >/dev/null +fi +for svc in "${GATEWAY_SERVICE}" "${CLOUDRUN_SERVICE}"; do + gcloud run services add-iam-policy-binding "${svc}" --project="${PROJECT}" --region="${REGION}" \ + --member="serviceAccount:${SA}" --role="roles/run.invoker" --quiet >/dev/null +done + +echo "==> Building ${IMAGE}" +CTX="$(mktemp -d)"; trap 'rm -rf "${CTX}"' EXIT +mkdir -p "${CTX}/scripts" "${CTX}/fixtures" +cp "${REPO_ROOT}"/scripts/{probe.py,contract_diff.py,serving_speed.py} "${CTX}/scripts/" +cp -R "${REPO_ROOT}/fixtures/bbox" "${CTX}/fixtures/" +cp "${REPO_ROOT}/deploy/probe/Dockerfile" "${CTX}/Dockerfile" +gcloud builds submit "${CTX}" --project="${PROJECT}" --tag="${IMAGE}" --suppress-logs --quiet + +deploy_job() { # name targets task-timeout + local job="$1" targets="$2" timeout="$3" + local extra="PROBE_LATENCY_REQUESTS=${N}" + [[ -n "${PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE:-}" ]] && extra="${extra}|PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE=${PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE}" + echo "==> Cloud Run job ${job} (${targets%%=*}...)" + gcloud run jobs deploy "${job}" --project="${PROJECT}" --region="${REGION}" --image="${IMAGE}" \ + --service-account="${SA}" --tasks=1 --max-retries=0 --task-timeout="${timeout}" --cpu=1 --memory=512Mi \ + --set-env-vars="^|^PROBE_TARGETS=${targets}|${extra}" --quiet >/dev/null + # Scheduler calls the Run Admin API as the probe SA (needs run.jobs.run on the job). + gcloud run jobs add-iam-policy-binding "${job}" --project="${PROJECT}" --region="${REGION}" \ + --member="serviceAccount:${SA}" --role="roles/run.invoker" --quiet >/dev/null +} + +schedule() { # scheduler-name job cron + local name="$1" job="$2" cron="$3" + local uri="https://run.googleapis.com/v2/projects/${PROJECT}/locations/${REGION}/jobs/${job}:run" + local args=(--project="${PROJECT}" --location="${REGION}" --schedule="${cron}" --time-zone="${SCHEDULE_TZ}" + --uri="${uri}" --http-method=POST --oauth-service-account-email="${SA}") + if gcloud scheduler jobs describe "${name}" --project="${PROJECT}" --location="${REGION}" >/dev/null 2>&1; then + gcloud scheduler jobs update http "${name}" "${args[@]}" --quiet >/dev/null + else + gcloud scheduler jobs create http "${name}" "${args[@]}" --quiet >/dev/null + fi + echo " scheduled ${name}: '${cron}' (${SCHEDULE_TZ})" +} + +deploy_job dgem-probe-hourly "vertex=${PROBE_VERTEX_URL},gateway=${PROBE_GATEWAY_URL}" 600s +schedule dgem-probe-hourly dgem-probe-hourly "${HOURLY_SCHEDULE}" +if [[ "${PROBE_DAILY:-on}" != "off" && -n "${PROBE_CLOUDRUN_URL}" ]]; then + # Long timeout: the first request waits for the scale-to-zero service to wake (~2.5 min). + deploy_job dgem-probe-daily "cloudrun=${PROBE_CLOUDRUN_URL}" 1200s + schedule dgem-probe-daily dgem-probe-daily "${DAILY_SCHEDULE}" +fi + +cat <.run.app, or a Vertex dedicated .../invoke base): contract + latency + - gateway=https://: one /api/decide through the gateway default route + /health + + python3 scripts/probe.py --target vertex= --target gateway=https:// [-n 20] + +Exit code 1 if any target failed (the Cloud Run job execution is then marked failed as well). +""" +import argparse +import json +import os +import statistics +import sys +import time +import urllib.error +import urllib.request + +sys.path.insert(0, os.path.dirname(__file__)) +import contract_diff as cd # noqa: E402 +import serving_speed as ss # noqa: E402 + +# Expected HTTP status per contract case (anything else is a failure). +EXPECTED = { + "choice_27_error": 400, "unknown_type_error": 400, "empty_questions_error": 400, "invalid_json_error": 400, +} + + +def token_provider(): + """ADC locally; the metadata server on Cloud Run (no key files).""" + md = "http://metadata.google.internal/computeMetadata/v1/instance/service-accounts/default" + try: + urllib.request.urlopen(urllib.request.Request(md + "/email", headers={"Metadata-Flavor": "Google"}), timeout=1) + except Exception: + return None # not on GCP: serving_speed.Tokens uses ADC + + class MD: + def get(self, audience=None): + at = json.load(urllib.request.urlopen(urllib.request.Request(md + "/token", headers={"Metadata-Flavor": "Google"}), timeout=5))["access_token"] + return at, None + + return MD() + + +MD = token_provider() + + +def id_token(aud): + if MD is None: + return ss.TOK.get()[1] + u = f"http://metadata.google.internal/computeMetadata/v1/instance/service-accounts/default/identity?audience={aud}" + return urllib.request.urlopen(urllib.request.Request(u, headers={"Metadata-Flavor": "Google"}), timeout=5).read().decode() + + +def access_token(): + return (MD.get()[0] if MD else ss.TOK.get()[0]) + + +def bearer(url, audience=None): + if "prediction.vertexai.goog" in url: + return access_token() + base = url.split("/", 3) + return id_token(audience or (base[0] + "//" + base[2])) + + +# A gateway protected by IAP (Cloud Run IAP integration) only accepts service-account ID tokens whose audience is +# one of its programmatic OAuth clients (gcloud iap settings get ... accessSettings.oauthSettings.programmaticClients), +# not the service URL. Set PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE to one of them. +GATEWAY_AUDIENCE = os.environ.get("PROBE_GATEWAY_AUDIENCE") or None + + +class ProbeTarget(cd.Target): + def token(self): + return bearer(self.base) + + +def probe_serving(name, base, n): + t = ProbeTarget(name, base) + failures = [] + st, raw = t.request("/health", None, method="GET") + version = "" + try: + h = json.loads(raw) + version = h.get("version", "") + if st != 200 or not h.get("vllm_ready", True): + failures.append(f"health: {st} vllm_ready={h.get('vllm_ready')}") + except Exception: + failures.append(f"health: {st} {raw[:80]!r}") + for case in cd.CASES: + try: + r = cd.run_case(t, case) + except Exception as e: # network + failures.append(f"{case}: {e!r}"[:160]) + continue + want = EXPECTED.get(case, 200) + if r["status"] != want: + failures.append(f"{case}: HTTP {r['status']} (want {want}) {(r.get('error') or '')[:80]}") + elif want == 200 and not r.get("labels") and case != "systemone": + failures.append(f"{case}: no answers") + walls, denoise = [], [] + schema = {"instructions": "Triage the ticket.", "samples": 1, "think": 0, "questions": ss.Q} + url = base.rstrip("/") + "/v1/chat/completions" + for i in range(n): + payload = {"model": "dgemma", "messages": [{"role": "system", "content": json.dumps(schema)}, + {"role": "user", "content": json.dumps({"ticket": ss.TICKETS[i % len(ss.TICKETS)]})}]} + req = urllib.request.Request(url, json.dumps(payload).encode(), {"Content-Type": "application/json", "Authorization": f"Bearer {bearer(base)}"}) + t0 = time.perf_counter() + try: + with urllib.request.urlopen(req, timeout=120) as r: + body = json.loads(r.read()) + walls.append((time.perf_counter() - t0) * 1000) + inner = json.loads(body["choices"][0]["message"]["content"]) + denoise.append(float(inner.get("diagnostics", {}).get("timing", {}).get("total_ms") or 0)) + except Exception as e: + failures.append(f"latency request {i}: {e!r}"[:160]) + return result(name, failures, walls, denoise, version) + + +def probe_gateway(name, base): + failures, walls = [], [] + tok = bearer(base, GATEWAY_AUDIENCE) + try: + h = json.load(urllib.request.urlopen(urllib.request.Request(base.rstrip("/") + "/health", headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {tok}"}), timeout=30)) + version = h.get("version", "") + except Exception as e: + failures.append(f"health: {e!r}"[:160]) + version = "" + for i in range(3): + req = urllib.request.Request(base.rstrip("/") + "/api/decide/support_triage", + json.dumps({"variables": {"ticket": ss.TICKETS[i]}}).encode(), + {"Content-Type": "application/json", "Authorization": f"Bearer {tok}", "X-DGem-Surface": "probe"}) + t0 = time.perf_counter() + try: + with urllib.request.urlopen(req, timeout=300) as r: + d = json.loads(r.read()) + used = r.headers.get("X-DGem-Backend-Used") + walls.append((time.perf_counter() - t0) * 1000) + if not d.get("answers"): + failures.append("decide: no answers") + if used != "vertex": + failures.append(f"decide: answered by {used} (vertex_first failed over)") + except urllib.error.HTTPError as e: + failures.append(f"decide: HTTP {e.code} {e.read()[:80]!r}") + except Exception as e: + failures.append(f"decide: {e!r}"[:160]) + return result(name, failures, walls, [], version) + + +def pct(v, q): + if not v: + return None + v = sorted(v) + return round(v[min(len(v) - 1, int(round(q * (len(v) - 1))))], 1) + + +def result(name, failures, walls, denoise, version): + rec = {"severity": "ERROR" if failures else "INFO", "message": f"dgem probe {name}: {'FAIL' if failures else 'ok'}", + "probe_event": "dgem.probe", "probe_target": name, "probe_ok": not failures, "probe_failures": failures[:10], + "probe_failure_count": len(failures), "probe_version": version, + "probe_latency_p50_ms": pct(walls, 0.5), "probe_latency_p95_ms": pct(walls, 0.95), + "probe_denoise_p50_ms": round(statistics.median(denoise), 1) if denoise else None, + "probe_requests": len(walls)} + print(json.dumps(rec), flush=True) + return rec + + +def main(): + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__, formatter_class=argparse.RawDescriptionHelpFormatter) + ap.add_argument("--target", action="append", default=[]) + ap.add_argument("-n", type=int, default=int(os.environ.get("PROBE_LATENCY_REQUESTS", "20"))) + a = ap.parse_args() + targets = a.target or [t for t in os.environ.get("PROBE_TARGETS", "").split(",") if t.strip()] + if not targets: + sys.exit("no targets (--target name=url or PROBE_TARGETS)") + ok = True + for spec in targets: + name, url = spec.split("=", 1) + rec = probe_gateway(name, url) if name.startswith("gateway") else probe_serving(name, url, a.n) + ok &= rec["probe_ok"] + sys.exit(0 if ok else 1) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/scripts/setup_alerts.py b/scripts/setup_alerts.py new file mode 100755 index 0000000..c06832e --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/setup_alerts.py @@ -0,0 +1,240 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Create or update dgem log-based metrics, an email notification channel, and alert policies. + +Idempotent: metrics and policies are matched by name / display name and updated in place, so re-run it after +changing a threshold. Every threshold has a default and an environment-variable / flag override (below). +Guide: docs/operate/monitoring.md. + + ALERT_EMAIL=you@example.com GCP_PROJECT= VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID= python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py + python3 scripts/setup_alerts.py --dry-run # print what would be applied + +Policies (display names are prefixed "dgem: "): + vertex-no-replicas Vertex endpoint has no available replica for VERTEX_NO_REPLICA_MIN minutes (default 5) + vertex-error-rate Vertex 5xx+429 share > VERTEX_ERROR_RATE (default 0.01) over 10 min + gateway-failover Share of vertex_first decisions answered by Cloud Run > FAILOVER_SHARE (0.2) over 30 min + (with at least FAILOVER_MIN_DECISIONS=5 vertex_first decisions) + gateway-decision-p95 p95 of Vertex-answered decision wall time > DECISION_P95_MS (2000) over 15 min + probe-failed A scheduled health check reported a failure (any target) + probe-missing No health check result for PROBE_MISSING_HOURS (2) hours (target=vertex) + probe-latency Health-check end-to-end median to Vertex > PROBE_P50_MS (400) ms + +Auth: gcloud access token (CLOUDSDK_AUTH_ACCESS_TOKEN_FILE or `gcloud auth print-access-token`). +""" +import argparse +import json +import os +import subprocess +import sys +import urllib.error +import urllib.parse +import urllib.request + +PREFIX = "dgem: " + + +def env(name, default): + return os.environ.get(name, default) + + +def token(): + f = os.environ.get("CLOUDSDK_AUTH_ACCESS_TOKEN_FILE") + if f and os.path.exists(f): + return open(f).read().strip() + return subprocess.check_output(["gcloud", "auth", "print-access-token"], text=True).strip() + + +def api(method, url, body=None): + req = urllib.request.Request(url, json.dumps(body).encode() if body is not None else None, method=method, + headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {token()}", "Content-Type": "application/json"}) + try: + with urllib.request.urlopen(req, timeout=60) as r: + raw = r.read() + return json.loads(raw) if raw else {} + except urllib.error.HTTPError as e: + raise SystemExit(f"{method} {url}: HTTP {e.code} {e.read()[:600].decode(errors='replace')}") + + +# ---------------------------------------------------------------- log-based metrics +def log_metrics(): + decide = 'resource.type="cloud_run_revision" AND jsonPayload.span_name="dgem.gateway.decide"' + probe = 'jsonPayload.probe_event="dgem.probe"' + return { + # Replaces the older definition from setup_cloud_monitoring.sh, adding backend labels (labels can only be added). + "dgem_decisions_total": { + "description": "dgem gateway decisions (Studio, REST), by surface, template, backend used and requested", + "filter": decide, + "metricDescriptor": {"metricKind": "DELTA", "valueType": "INT64", "unit": "1", "labels": [ + {"key": k, "valueType": "STRING"} for k in + ["surface", "template", "user", "multimodal", "reads", "backend", "backend_requested"]]}, + "labelExtractors": { + "surface": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_surface)", "template": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_template)", + "user": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_user)", "multimodal": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_multimodal)", + "reads": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_gpu_reads)", "backend": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_backend)", + "backend_requested": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_backend_requested)"}, + }, + "dgem_decision_wall_ms": { + "description": "dgem gateway decision wall time (ms), by backend used", + "filter": decide + " AND jsonPayload.dgem_total_wall_ms > 0", + "valueExtractor": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_total_wall_ms)", + "bucketOptions": {"exponentialBuckets": {"numFiniteBuckets": 40, "growthFactor": 1.25, "scale": 20}}, + "metricDescriptor": {"metricKind": "DELTA", "valueType": "DISTRIBUTION", "unit": "ms", + "labels": [{"key": "backend", "valueType": "STRING"}]}, + "labelExtractors": {"backend": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.dgem_backend)"}, + }, + "dgem_probe_runs": { + "description": "dgem scheduled health-check results, by target and outcome", + "filter": probe, + "metricDescriptor": {"metricKind": "DELTA", "valueType": "INT64", "unit": "1", "labels": [ + {"key": "target", "valueType": "STRING"}, {"key": "ok", "valueType": "STRING"}]}, + "labelExtractors": {"target": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.probe_target)", "ok": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.probe_ok)"}, + }, + "dgem_probe_latency_ms": { + "description": "dgem health-check end-to-end median latency per run (ms), by target", + "filter": probe + " AND jsonPayload.probe_latency_p50_ms > 0", + "valueExtractor": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.probe_latency_p50_ms)", + "bucketOptions": {"exponentialBuckets": {"numFiniteBuckets": 40, "growthFactor": 1.2, "scale": 20}}, + "metricDescriptor": {"metricKind": "DELTA", "valueType": "DISTRIBUTION", "unit": "ms", + "labels": [{"key": "target", "valueType": "STRING"}]}, + "labelExtractors": {"target": "EXTRACT(jsonPayload.probe_target)"}, + }, + } + + +def upsert_metric(project, name, spec, dry): + base = f"https://logging.googleapis.com/v2/projects/{project}/metrics" + body = dict(spec, name=name) + if dry: + print(f" metric {name}") + return + try: + api("GET", f"{base}/{name}") + api("PUT", f"{base}/{name}", body) + print(f" updated metric {name}") + except SystemExit as e: + if "404" not in str(e): + raise + api("POST", base, body) + print(f" created metric {name}") + + +# ---------------------------------------------------------------- notification channel +def email_channel(project, email, dry): + base = f"https://monitoring.googleapis.com/v3/projects/{project}/notificationChannels" + name = f"{PREFIX}{email}" + if dry: + print(f" channel {name}") + return "projects/-/notificationChannels/DRYRUN" + for ch in api("GET", base).get("notificationChannels", []): + if ch.get("type") == "email" and ch.get("labels", {}).get("email_address") == email: + print(f" using channel {ch['name']} ({email})") + return ch["name"] + ch = api("POST", base, {"type": "email", "displayName": name, "labels": {"email_address": email}}) + print(f" created channel {ch['name']} ({email})") + return ch["name"] + + +# ---------------------------------------------------------------- policies +def promql(query, duration_s, eval_s=60): + return {"conditionPrometheusQueryLanguage": {"query": query, "duration": f"{duration_s}s", + "evaluationInterval": f"{eval_s}s"}} + + +def policies(project, ep, cfg): + lm = "logging_googleapis_com:user_" + vx = f'monitored_resource="aiplatform.googleapis.com/Endpoint",endpoint_id="{ep}"' + # Log-based metrics can come from several resource types (gateway = Cloud Run service, probe = Cloud Run job); + # alerting PromQL requires naming one. + rev = 'monitored_resource="cloud_run_revision"' + job = 'monitored_resource="cloud_run_job"' + doc = ("See docs/operate/monitoring.md (alert '{key}') for what this means and what to do. " + "Thresholds: scripts/setup_alerts.py.") + + def pol(key, title, cond, duration_note, severity="ERROR", auto_close="1800s"): + return {"displayName": f"{PREFIX}{title}", "combiner": "OR", "severity": severity, + "documentation": {"content": doc.format(key=key) + f" {duration_note}", "mimeType": "text/markdown"}, + "conditions": [dict(cond, displayName=title)], + "alertStrategy": {"autoClose": auto_close}, "userLabels": {"app": "dgem", "alert": key}} + + return [ + pol("vertex-no-replicas", "Vertex endpoint has no available replica", + promql(f'sum(avg_over_time(aiplatform_googleapis_com:prediction_online_replicas{{{vx}}}[5m])) < 1 ' + f'or absent(aiplatform_googleapis_com:prediction_online_replicas{{{vx}}})', + int(cfg["VERTEX_NO_REPLICA_MIN"]) * 60), + "Traffic fails over to Cloud Run (slower; cold start if idle).", "CRITICAL"), + pol("vertex-error-rate", "Vertex 5xx/429 error rate", + promql(f'(sum(rate(aiplatform_googleapis_com:prediction_online_response_count{{{vx},response_code=~"5..|429"}}[10m])) ' + f'/ sum(rate(aiplatform_googleapis_com:prediction_online_response_count{{{vx}}}[10m]))) > {cfg["VERTEX_ERROR_RATE"]}', + 300), + f"Threshold {float(cfg['VERTEX_ERROR_RATE']):.0%} over 10 min."), + pol("gateway-failover", "Gateway failing over from Vertex to Cloud Run", + promql(f'(sum(increase({lm}dgem_decisions_total{{{rev},backend_requested="vertex_first",backend="cloudrun"}}[30m])) ' + f'/ sum(increase({lm}dgem_decisions_total{{{rev},backend_requested="vertex_first"}}[30m])) > {cfg["FAILOVER_SHARE"]}) ' + f'and sum(increase({lm}dgem_decisions_total{{{rev},backend_requested="vertex_first"}}[30m])) >= {cfg["FAILOVER_MIN_DECISIONS"]}', + 300), + f"More than {float(cfg['FAILOVER_SHARE']):.0%} of vertex_first decisions answered by Cloud Run in 30 min."), + pol("gateway-decision-p95", "Gateway decision latency p95 (Vertex)", + promql(f'histogram_quantile(0.95, sum by (le) (rate({lm}dgem_decision_wall_ms_bucket{{{rev},backend="vertex"}}[15m]))) > {cfg["DECISION_P95_MS"]}', + 300, 120), + f"Threshold {cfg['DECISION_P95_MS']} ms over 15 min.", "WARNING"), + pol("probe-failed", "Scheduled health check failed", + promql(f'sum by (target) (increase({lm}dgem_probe_runs{{{job},ok="false"}}[70m])) > 0', 0, 300), + "The log line (jsonPayload.probe_failures) lists what failed.", "ERROR", "7200s"), + pol("probe-missing", "Scheduled health check not running", + promql(f'absent_over_time({lm}dgem_probe_runs{{{job},target="vertex"}}[{int(cfg["PROBE_MISSING_HOURS"])}h])', 0, 600), + f"No health-check result for {cfg['PROBE_MISSING_HOURS']} h: check the Cloud Scheduler trigger and job.", "WARNING", "7200s"), + pol("probe-latency", "Health-check latency to Vertex", + promql(f'histogram_quantile(0.5, sum by (le) (rate({lm}dgem_probe_latency_ms_bucket{{{job},target="vertex"}}[3h]))) > {cfg["PROBE_P50_MS"]}', + 0, 600), + f"Median end-to-end latency above {cfg['PROBE_P50_MS']} ms (normal ~150-200 ms).", "WARNING", "7200s"), + ] + + +def upsert_policy(project, p, channel, dry, only): + key = p["userLabels"]["alert"] + if only and key not in only: + return + p["notificationChannels"] = [channel] + base = f"https://monitoring.googleapis.com/v3/projects/{project}/alertPolicies" + if dry: + print(f" policy {p['displayName']}\n {json.dumps(p['conditions'][0])[:400]}") + return + flt = urllib.parse.quote(f'display_name="{p["displayName"]}"') + existing = api("GET", f"{base}?filter={flt}").get("alertPolicies", []) + if existing: + name = existing[0]["name"] + api("PATCH", f"https://monitoring.googleapis.com/v3/{name}", dict(p, name=name)) + print(f" updated policy {p['displayName']} ({name.split('/')[-1]})") + else: + r = api("POST", base, p) + print(f" created policy {p['displayName']} ({r['name'].split('/')[-1]})") + + +def main(): + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__, formatter_class=argparse.RawDescriptionHelpFormatter) + ap.add_argument("--dry-run", action="store_true") + ap.add_argument("--only", nargs="*", help="only these policy keys (e.g. probe-latency)") + ap.add_argument("--skip-metrics", action="store_true") + a = ap.parse_args() + project = env("GCP_PROJECT", "") + email = env("ALERT_EMAIL", "") + ep = env("VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID", "") + if not (project and email and ep): + sys.exit("set GCP_PROJECT, ALERT_EMAIL and VERTEX_ENDPOINT_ID") + cfg = {k: env(k, d) for k, d in { + "VERTEX_NO_REPLICA_MIN": "5", "VERTEX_ERROR_RATE": "0.01", "FAILOVER_SHARE": "0.2", + "FAILOVER_MIN_DECISIONS": "5", "DECISION_P95_MS": "2000", "PROBE_MISSING_HOURS": "2", "PROBE_P50_MS": "400"}.items()} + print(f"Project {project}, endpoint {ep}, alerts to {email}") + print("Thresholds: " + ", ".join(f"{k}={v}" for k, v in cfg.items())) + if not a.skip_metrics: + print("Log-based metrics:") + for name, spec in log_metrics().items(): + upsert_metric(project, name, spec, a.dry_run) + print("Notification channel:") + ch = email_channel(project, email, a.dry_run) + print("Alert policies:") + for p in policies(project, ep, cfg): + upsert_policy(project, p, ch, a.dry_run, set(a.only or [])) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/scripts/template_sweep.py b/scripts/template_sweep.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b709230 --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/template_sweep.py @@ -0,0 +1,96 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Run every policy template through a dgem gateway with its sample variables and check the answer shape. + +Uses GET /api/templates (id, sample_vars, multimodal) and POST /api/decide/. For multimodal templates a +fixture image from fixtures/bbox/ is attached. A template passes when the call returns 200, every question in +the rendered schema has an answer with probabilities that sum to ~1, and (optionally) the request ran on the +expected backend. + + python3 scripts/template_sweep.py --gateway https:// [--backend vertex] [-o out.json] + +Auth: Google ID token from Application Default Credentials (as scripts/serving_speed.py). +""" +import argparse +import base64 +import concurrent.futures as cf +import glob +import json +import os +import sys +import time +import urllib.error +import urllib.request + +sys.path.insert(0, os.path.dirname(__file__)) +import serving_speed as ss # noqa: E402 + +REPO = os.path.abspath(os.path.join(os.path.dirname(__file__), "..")) + + +def image_uri(): + p = sorted(glob.glob(os.path.join(REPO, "fixtures/bbox/*.png")))[0] + return "data:image/png;base64," + base64.b64encode(open(p, "rb").read()).decode() + + +def call(gw, path, body=None, backend=None): + _, it = ss.TOK.get() + h = {"Authorization": f"Bearer {it}", "Content-Type": "application/json"} + if backend: + h["X-DGem-Backend"] = backend + req = urllib.request.Request(gw + path, json.dumps(body).encode() if body is not None else None, h) + t0 = time.perf_counter() + try: + with urllib.request.urlopen(req, timeout=300) as r: + return r.status, dict(r.headers), json.loads(r.read()), (time.perf_counter() - t0) * 1000 + except urllib.error.HTTPError as e: + return e.code, dict(e.headers), {"error": e.read()[:300].decode(errors="replace")}, (time.perf_counter() - t0) * 1000 + + +def check(gw, tpl, backend, img): + body = {"variables": tpl.get("sample_vars") or {}} + if tpl.get("multimodal"): + body["image"] = img + st, hdr, d, ms = call(gw, f"/api/decide/{tpl['id']}", body, backend) + out = {"template": tpl["id"], "status": st, "wall_ms": round(ms), "backend_used": hdr.get("X-DGem-Backend-Used") or hdr.get("X-Dgem-Backend-Used")} + if st != 200: + out["error"] = str(d.get("error"))[:200] + return out + answers = d.get("answers") or {} + bad = [] + for qid, a in answers.items(): + probs = (a or {}).get("probabilities") or {} + if a and a.get("label") in ("", None) and not probs: + continue # skipped conditional question + if probs and abs(sum(probs.values()) - 1) > 0.02: + bad.append(f"{qid}: probabilities sum {sum(probs.values()):.3f}") + out.update(questions=len(answers), problems=bad) + return out + + +def main(): + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__, formatter_class=argparse.RawDescriptionHelpFormatter) + ap.add_argument("--gateway", required=True) + ap.add_argument("--backend", default=None, help="X-DGem-Backend for every call (default: gateway default)") + ap.add_argument("-o", "--output") + a = ap.parse_args() + gw = a.gateway.rstrip("/") + st, _, templates, _ = call(gw, "/api/templates") + if st != 200: + sys.exit(f"GET /api/templates: {st} {templates}") + if isinstance(templates, dict): + templates = templates.get("templates", []) + img = image_uri() + with cf.ThreadPoolExecutor(4) as ex: + res = list(ex.map(lambda t: check(gw, t, a.backend, img), templates)) + ok = [r for r in res if r["status"] == 200 and not r.get("problems") and r.get("questions")] + for r in sorted(res, key=lambda r: r["template"]): + flag = "ok " if r in ok else "FAIL" + print(f"{flag} {r['template']:34s} {r['status']} q={r.get('questions', '-')} {r['wall_ms']:>6} ms {r.get('backend_used') or ''} {r.get('error') or ' '.join(r.get('problems') or [])}") + print(f"\n{len(ok)}/{len(res)} templates passed") + if a.output: + json.dump({"gateway_backend": a.backend, "results": res}, open(a.output, "w"), indent=1) + sys.exit(0 if len(ok) == len(res) else 1) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main()