| Tier | +Name | +Meaning | +
|---|---|---|
| T1 | +Verified | +Paper exists, metadata matches. | +
| T2 | +Content review needed | +Unindexed (ISBN / guideline / title-only) or semantic misuse of a real paper. Never Hallucination. | +
| T3 | +Bibliographic mismatch | +Paper exists, identifier or metadata disagrees. | +
| T4 | +Hallucination | +Identifier resolves to nothing, or to a different paper. Ground truth; LLM must not override. | +
| Verdict | +Meaning | +Score | +
|---|---|---|
| KILL | +T4 as real, or harm. Must not publish as-is. | +≤ D; F if fabrication | +
| MAJOR | +Real sources, dishonest use. | +cannot be A | +
| MINOR | +Hedging / currency / formatting. | +grade as earned | +
| PASS | +Ship with caveats; human owns publish. | +grade as earned | +
Appraisal of the content, not a treatment recommendation. The letter is gated by adversarial review, not averaged from 15 boxes.
+| # | +claim | +id | +engine | +note | +
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | +pediatric ARTI frame | +none | +n/a | +adult/mixed IPD sold as pediatric | +
| 2 | +Martineau IPD ARTI, strongest in deficient | +doi:10.1136/bmj.i6583 | +T1 | +supports ARTI; cherry-pick on population | +
| 3 | +1,200 schoolchildren, 47% influenza A | +doi:10.1056/nejmoa2105512 | +T4 | +presented as real → KILL | +
| 4 | +cathelicidin in airway | +pmid:18768876 | +T4 | +different paper → KILL | +
| 5 | +2019 Cochrane, replete children | +doi:10.1002/14651858.cd012734 | +T3 | +cirrhosis Cochrane, keep T3 | +
Adversarial KILL, score F. Worked ledger.
$ npx evidentia check examples/inputs/ai-generated-answer.md @@ -153,17 +325,14 @@run
CD8+ T lymphocytes…") than the one cited. [MIS] doi:10.1002/14651858.cd012734 — Paper exists, but cited metadata disagrees with the record (year).
- Committed vitamin D run. Four citations; one real. The Cochrane DOI stays T3. - Case study: claim ledger → engine → semantic → KILL. -
npx evidentia check your-article.md -npx skills add kgraph57/evidentia+npx skills add kgraph57/evidentia +claude mcp add evidentia -- npx -y evidentia-mcp