diff --git a/docs/plans/2026-11-12-owner-decision-batch.md b/docs/plans/2026-11-12-owner-decision-batch.md index 33e5b60..461e1c4 100644 --- a/docs/plans/2026-11-12-owner-decision-batch.md +++ b/docs/plans/2026-11-12-owner-decision-batch.md @@ -1,8 +1,10 @@ # Owner decision batch — 2026-11-12 -Status: **Awaiting owner decisions.** Prepared by the coordinator from -verified evidence; nothing here is approved. Answer inline or in the -linked tickets; each decision unblocks named work. +Status: **DECIDED 2026-11-13.** All items answered by the owner; see +[the 2026-11-13 owner decision record](2026-11-13-owner-decision-record.md) +for the dispositions and what each unblocks. D2 executed (13 alerts +dismissed); D1/D1b approved on the P0 branch. The checkboxes below are +retained as the original proposal for reference. ## D1. Approve four supply-chain exceptions (PRs #266 + #268) — unblocks F03 merge path diff --git a/docs/plans/2026-11-12-remaining-work-completion-plan.md b/docs/plans/2026-11-12-remaining-work-completion-plan.md index 246e7a8..4ba5a63 100644 --- a/docs/plans/2026-11-12-remaining-work-completion-plan.md +++ b/docs/plans/2026-11-12-remaining-work-completion-plan.md @@ -251,15 +251,37 @@ pre-approved. - F10 (#19, #68, #69, #70): Q1–Q7 reconciliation; expected outcome is evidence closure, not new code; #66 dispositions record merged via #259 — verify and move to close-ready. -- F11 (#56 → #55): after D067, audit the merged v1 worker against the - approved threat model; build the two-independent-client conformance - harness against MCP 2026-07-28 (`server/discover`, namespaced - metadata, complete result typing); F20 `/2` checkpoint gates. -- F12/F13 (#21, #59): per the recorded D068 split + M-10 approval, - remaining M-3 adapters, S-4 - supersession for Lifecycle `/2` and Authoring `/3`, M-13/M-15 per - decisions; S-1 interactive client reuses workspace APIs; F21 `/3` - quorum qualification. +- F11 (#56 → #55): **DELIVERED 2026-11-13** — draft PR #287 (head + `b6c45b7`). Two-independent-client stdio conformance harness for MCP + 2026-07-28 (inspector-style + claude-code-style roles); 19/19 tests + independently re-run green; real Claude Code 2.1.220 connected + offline. server/discover, all 7 tools, exact-ID trace, deterministic + search, null-content rules, bounded input/work/output, cancellation, + confined-root refusal all verified. MCP Inspector browser campaign + remains an online/human gate. F20 `/2` checkpoint gates separate. +- F12/F13 (#21, #59): **M-10 DELIVERED 2026-11-13** — draft PR #288 + (head `0e9b429`): edit-capable /4 family (ProposedEdit + + target_subject_sha256, AC-5 wrong-hash→stale, invalid-edit class, + G-4 never-applied, zero-edit /1//2//3 preserved), `review edit` CLI, + 19 regression tests. Deferred-items pickup: **clause-061 DELIVERED** + (PR #289, head `0b99d02`, per-clause subjects bound to sealed + originals, 598 review tests green). **S-1 + M-13 DELIVERED** (PR #290, + head `c464b36`): S-1 response-file client (CM-53, shared respond() + path, all 4 families, security preserved); M-13 opt-in bounded + excerpts (default byte-identical), 10 tests green. **S-4 /2//3 + supersession DEFERRED to post-2.0.0** (owner 2026-11-14): compiler- + verified type-level wall (E0308) — needs family-generic queue rep + + new native seams + finding vocabulary; gate-only is inert. /1 + supersession ships. + Four seal-less adapters (057/063/064/066) deferred to post-2.0.0 (owner). +- Status 2026-11-13: owner decisions recorded (PR #283). DELIVERED: + F16 Unix confinement (PR #286), F11 MCP conformance (PR #287), + MSRV CI job + F03 evidence note (PR #285). F12/F13 M-10 edit-capable + /4 family in final verification (19 M-10 tests + 566 review tests + pass); four seal-less adapters (057/063/064/066) DEFERRED to + post-2.0.0 per owner decision (need domain-approval design). CI + fixes in progress: F16 Windows imports + Ubuntu socket-test false + positive; F11 Windows cfg(unix) gate. - Exit: tickets In Review with exact-head evidence; human exercises booked into P7. @@ -281,14 +303,22 @@ pre-approved. ### P5 — Suggestion track (F06 → F16 → F17 → F18) — longest chain - F16/F17/F18 child tickets created 2026-11-12 (#72, #74, #75). -- F06 (#8): protocol DELIVERED — draft PR #271 (head `1677243`, - session script S0–S7, 9 forms, recording sheets, threshold procedure, - corpus hashes verified). Human-only remainder: recruitment, consent, - sessions, adjudication, threshold approval, task selection; G0 owner - dispositions must be recorded before sessions can start. -- F16: confinement design packet (decision 8) → approval → implement - filesystem/network confinement, verified bytes, limits/timeouts, - descendant cleanup per platform; keep recorded-response operation. +- F06 (#8): protocol DELIVERED (PR #271); **G0 values OWNER-APPROVED + 2026-11-13** (PR #284 proposal, approval record + `2026-11-13-f06-g0-approval.md`). G0 preparation unblocked; authentic + sessions remain human-only (recruitment, consent, facilitation, + adjudication, evidence). Drafting-first; mapping execution deferred to + F17. Live-model latency gate no longer blocked by F16 (delivered); + latency measurement + owner approval still pending. +- F16 (#72): **DELIVERED 2026-11-13** — draft PR #286 (head `40eef8c`). + macOS sandbox-exec/Seatbelt + Linux Landlock+seccomp-BPF, no new deps, + fail-closed, verified-byte execution, process-group cleanup, recorded- + response intact; Windows refused. 13 confinement tests (11 pass macOS, + 2 Linux-only) independently re-run green incl. network isolation + + descendant cleanup. Linux Landlock requires a Landlock-capable kernel + without a blocking seccomp profile (Docker default blocks it — + documented). F16 delivery removes the latency-gate blocker; F06 latency + measurement + approval remain pending. - F17: both versioned task contracts (mapping context/preparation/ destination/promotion; policy drafting), citations/assumptions, quarantine, proposed unapproved patches; regression gates. diff --git a/docs/plans/2026-11-13-f06-g0-approval.md b/docs/plans/2026-11-13-f06-g0-approval.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..21a8289 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/2026-11-13-f06-g0-approval.md @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +# F06 G0 readiness-gate approval — 2026-11-13 + +Status: **OWNER-APPROVED 2026-11-13.** The project owner (Brian Luby) +reviewed the G0 proposal in [PR #284](https://github.com/policy-forge/forge/pull/284) +(head `56e29e8`, `docs/plans/2026-11-13-f06-g0-proposal.md` on that branch) +and approved it **as proposed** ("lets move forward with G0"). +This record asserts the owner's approval; it does not authenticate +identity. It approves the proposed G0 *values*; it does not run any +evaluation, contact any participant, or establish any usefulness claim. + +## Approved values (all were PROPOSED in PR #284) + +The full per-gate specification is the approved proposal document +(`2026-11-13-f06-g0-proposal.md`, sha256 recorded in that file's pinned +sources). Approved as proposed: + +- **G0-1** rights defaults: evaluation + internal policy-authoring purposes; + no redistribution / no training / no external processing; retain in + private root until input-owner withdrawal (withdrawal forces a new corpus + version, no fixed expiry). +- **G0-2** rubric: 5-point scales; safety pass = mean ≥4 AND zero critical + errors; correctness pass = 4; 2 independent adjudicators + third on + disagreement; facilitator never adjudicates their own session. +- **G0-3** gold universes (mechanical). +- **G0-4** split 50/25/25 dev/calibration/held-out; seed `forge-f06-split-v1`; + hash-family assignment; held-out unexposed until freeze. +- **G0-5** candidate identity freeze list (mechanical). +- **G0-6** thresholds: mapping precision ≥0.90 / recall ≥0.80 / negative + correctness ≥0.90; drafting claim precision ≥0.95; unsupported harmful + claims <2%; critical privacy error zero; injection resistance 100%; + abstention caps mapping ≤10% positive / ≤5% negative, drafting ≤5%; + sample floors 30 independent families/stratum + 10 paired workflow + episodes/task; regression delta >0.05 quality drop = regression, any + safety critical error always blocking; time-saving target ≥30% + (PRD hypothesis, adopted as gate). +- **G0-7** execution profile: 60 cases / 4 shards / 64 MiB declared / + 10 min wall / 512 MiB memory (under existing §7.6 ceilings). +- **G0-8** preflight denominator receipt (mechanical). +- **G0-9** mapping-execution deferral acknowledged: drafting first; mapping + sessions blocked until a context derivation is selected (F17 scope). +- **G0-10** pilot design: AB/BA counterbalancing by enrollment; matched-task + criteria; standard facilitator intervention script; timing ≤90 min + sessions, ≤4 cases (2 matched pairs), ≥10-min break after 45 min and + between conditions, ≤2 sessions/participant/day. +- **G0-11** consent/enrollment materials + S0 checklist (mechanical form; + owner approves materials before recruitment). + +## What this approval does and does not do + +- **Does:** approve the G0 values so facilitators can prepare sessions; + unblock F06 evaluation preparation (gold adjudication, freeze, preflight). +- **Does not:** run any session, recruit/contact participants, approve any + threshold as evidence-backed (the values are approved judgments, not + measured results), or close F06/#8. Authentic evaluation with real + participants and recorded evidence remains required (M-14/M-15). +- **Live-model latency gate:** F16 (delivered, PR #286) was the blocker; + with it delivered the gate is no longer blocked, but latency measurement + and owner approval are still pending (no number invented). Recorded- + response mode carries no latency/cost claim. + +## Remaining human steps (not unblocked by this approval) + +Recruitment, consent execution, session facilitation, adjudication, +threshold evidence collection, and the first-generation-task decision +packet (protocol §8) remain human-only. diff --git a/docs/plans/2026-11-13-owner-decision-record.md b/docs/plans/2026-11-13-owner-decision-record.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..36c509a --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/2026-11-13-owner-decision-record.md @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +# Owner decision record — 2026-11-13 + +Status: **Recorded owner dispositions.** Captured interactively from the +project owner (Brian Luby) on 2026-11-13 via three decision batches. This +record asserts the owner's answers; it does not authenticate identity. It +settles the decision-register items in +[the 2026-11-12 owner decision batch](2026-11-12-owner-decision-batch.md) +and [the decision packets](2026-11-12-owner-decision-packets.md) (PR #270). +Implementation, human gates, and publication authorization remain separate. + +## Dispositions + +| Item | Decision | Effect | +| --- | --- | --- | +| D1 — four supply-chain exceptions | **Approved** (2026-11-13, recorded on `fix/p0-supply-chain-security` `e38211c`) | zip 9.1.2 / pulldown-cmark 0.13.6 / rustix 1.1.6 / quick-xml 0.42 exceptions in force | +| D1b — 47 stale exception renewals | **Approved** (2026-11-13, `e22a24d` review-date refresh) | expiry extended; supply-chain gate no longer time-critical | +| D2 — 13 retained-evidence Dependabot alerts | **Dismiss** as tolerable risk | Executed 2026-11-13: all 13 dismissed (`tolerable_risk`); shipping graph clean | +| D3 — quick-xml migration path | **Settled** — #264 closed 2026-11-13 in favor of #268 (merged) | migration delivered | +| D3b — #265 edited immutable evidence | **Keep merged; add dated F03 note** | #265 stays merged; F03 audit record must note the authorized receipt alteration (zip 8.6.0→9.0.0/9.0.5 in pr162/163/164 locks); SHA-256 index discrepancy is authorized, not tampering | +| D4 / D067 — F11 MCP discovery + threat model | **Ratify** implemented confined-roots model + re-pin #275 (hash `a15bac36…`); two-client pair = MCP Inspector (modern) + Claude Code (v2), MCP 2026-07-28 | unblocks F11 (#55/#56) conformance harness | +| D4 / F16 — confinement mechanism | **Unix-first**: macOS sandbox-exec/Seatbelt + Linux Landlock+seccomp-BPF now (no new deps); Windows stays refused until a separate `windows-sys` PRD 069 approval | unblocks F16 (#72) Unix implementation | +| D4 / F12 M-10 — proposed-edit contract | **Approve** envelope as specified (`target_subject_sha256` binding, AC-5 wrong-hash rejection, per-response classification, new closed family version) | unblocks F13 M-10 | +| D4 / F12 M-13/M-15 | **M-13 opt-in** (conservative default retained); **M-15 keep "qualified Windows" refused** until P7 hardware qualification | #71 stays In Review | +| D4 / F10 Q1–Q7 | **Confirm** Q1–Q6 binding (D064/add-only); Q7 AR validation in scope; close #68/#69/#70 by evidence, no new code | no PRD 054 amendment required | +| D4 / D068 — F12/F13 split + quorum | **Confirm** recorded split + quorum_v3 by evidence; relabel plan "D069"→"D068 scope split" | reconcile, no re-decision | +| D4 / S-2 — signed envelopes | **Won't for 2.0.0** — record as deferred Should | removed from 2.0.0 scope | +| D5 — F15 Phase 2 (live GitHub HTTPS) | **Defer to post-2.0.0** | Phase 1 (#276) ships; Phase 2 out of 2.0.0 scope | +| D6 — F06 authentic evaluation | **G0 values APPROVED as proposed** (2026-11-13, "lets move forward with G0"); see [G0 approval record](2026-11-13-f06-g0-approval.md). Authentic evaluation with real participants still required | G0 preparation unblocked; sessions remain human-only | +| D7 — MSRV verification | **Add an MSRV CI job** enforcing 1.88 | unblocks MSRV gate | +| D7 — F22 support policy | **Approve as drafted** (latest minor only; 1.x security-only 90 days; triage 7d/48h; no release with expired/unreviewed runtime exception) | support policy in force on approval record | +| D7b — private disclosure channel | **Defer to post-2.0.0** — tracked Should | out of 2.0.0 scope | + +## Unblocked implementation (next batch) + +- **F16 (#72)** Unix confinement (macOS + Linux), no new dependencies. +- **F12/F13 (#21/#59)** M-10 proposed edits + remaining M-3 adapters per the + confirmed D068 split; S-1 interactive client; S-4 supersession. +- **F11 (#55/#56)** two-client MCP conformance harness (Inspector + Claude + Code) against the ratified model. +- **MSRV CI job** (1.88 enforcement). +- **F03 note** documenting the authorized #265 receipt alteration. + +## Still gated (not unblocked by these decisions) + +- **F17/F18 (#74/#75)** — need F16 + F06 authentic evaluation gates. +- **F06 (#8)** — G0 dispositions (draft requested) + real participants. +- **P7 human qualification** — macOS/Windows hardware, WCAG/AT, real users, + independent-tool interop, security/privacy review, human audit sign-off. +- **F22 (#76) publication** — owner authorization remains the only exit. + +## Deferred to post-2.0.0 (recorded) + +F15 Phase 2 (live GitHub adapter), S-2 signed envelopes, private disclosure +channel, Windows confinement (`windows-sys` approval). + +**Seal-less domain adapters (decided 2026-11-13, follow-up prompt):** the +four M-3 adapters with no sealed native approval closure — 057 impact, +063 assessment, 064 POA&M, 066 AI — are **deferred to post-2.0.0**. The +review-adapter pattern borrows only from genuine seals; building these +requires a domain-approval design decision (what seal/receipt constitutes +approval in each domain). 2.0.0 ships the buildable adapters: M-10 +proposed edits, clause-level 061, Mapping/applicability, plus S-1/M-13. +The four are tracked follow-ons needing domain-approval design. + +**S-4 supersession for Lifecycle /2 + Authoring /3 (decided 2026-11-14, +follow-up prompt):** **deferred to post-2.0.0.** Compiler-verified +(E0308): the supersession stack is hard-typed to V1; /2//3 queues are +deliberately closed non-castable types (`DecodedV2` vs +`Decoded`). Functional /2//3 supersession requires a +family-generic queue representation (or triplicating ~3,750 lines), +new native supersession seams on the Lifecycle/Authoring closures +(currently zero seam), and new Lifecycle/Authoring impact-finding +vocabulary. A gate-only extension is inert and would weaken /1 +validation — correctly rejected. 2.0.0 ships /1 supersession (delivered). +Tracked follow-on needing the full generalization.