Skip to content

Commit 699a256

Browse files
committed
Phase F: predictor-corrector with radial return — first cut
Implements the predictor-corrector architecture from the web-advice doc (vep_stress_update_full_latex.md §15 Stage 4) on isotropic VEP. Setup: * Same harmonic shear box, RES=32 * Isotropic Maxwell rheology (no director, no rank-4 tensor) * σ_y(x) from the same fault influence-function used in TI tests — small (0.05) in a 0.06-wide layer at θ=15°, large (200) in the bulk → partial yielding, no global yield catastrophe * Per-step trace files written EVERY step with flush, persist on kill Configurations tested: 1. BDF-1 yield-in-residual (softmin in model) — baseline, works 2. ETD with yield_stress=∞ in model + post-solve J2 radial return on psi_star (predictor-corrector single-shot) 3. ETD with yield_stress=∞ + radial return + outer Picard with σ damping (ω_τ=0.5, max 6 iters) Both 2 and 3 leave η_eff fixed at η_VE between Picard iters — i.e. single Stokes solver per Picard step, just with iterated psi_star. Killer-test results (θ=+15° fault layer, τ_y_fault=0.05, 1.5T): | case | |σ_eq|_max end | |u_y|_max end | |-----------------------------|----------------|---------------| | BDF-1 baseline | 0.81 | 0.036 | | ETD-1 + RR single-shot | 0.42 | 0.021 | | ETD-1 + RR + Picard | 0.41 | 0.021 | | ETD-2 + RR single-shot | 0.41 | 0.286 | | ETD-2 + RR + Picard | runaway @ 60 | runaway | Same first-order vs higher-order signature as before: * ETD-1 + radial return is essentially identical to BDF-1, both single-shot and Picard-equilibrated. The first-order numerical dissipation (lesson #13) carries over to the predictor-corrector architecture. * ETD-2 + radial return drifts in the single-shot case (|u_y| 8× BDF by end) and the outer Picard with σ-damping doesn't damp it — at step 60 the case exits via the runaway guard with |σ|_eq = 18.2 and |u_y| = 10.2. Picard amplifies rather than equilibrates because the σ-damping doesn't address the underlying lack of dissipation in the linear-relaxation factor. The single Stokes per Picard iter (with η_eff fixed at η_VE) is NOT the full architecture from the web advice. The advice's Step 4 explicitly calls for *updating η_eff between Picard iters based on σ_corrected*, which would require either (a) per-quad-point α,φ in the constitutive model (we ruled out earlier — codegen explosion) or (b) a second Stokes solve with viscosity-as-plastic-multiplier treating σ_VE as fixed/explicit (the user's "two-Stokes" idea — not implemented here). Note: ETD-1/ETD-2 yield-in-residual baselines on this isotropic setup hit a separate parent-class issue with spatial yield_stress + softmin (SNES line-search divergence). Filed as a follow-up; sidestepped here by using yield_stress=∞ with external return mapping. Per-step trace files (`_phase_f_<label>.trace.txt`) tracked in git so the comparison plot regenerates from a fresh clone. Underworld development team with AI support from Claude Code (https://claude.com/claude-code)
1 parent 20db685 commit 699a256

7 files changed

Lines changed: 1101 additions & 0 deletions
Lines changed: 123 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,123 @@
1+
# Phase F predictor-corrector trace: bdf1_iso
2+
# integrator='bdf' order=1 apply_radial_return=False in_residual_yield=True
3+
# columns: step, t, V_top, snes_iters_total, picard_iters, sigma_eq_max, sigma_eq_max_after_correction, u_y_max, yielded_fraction
4+
1 0.0500 +0.4985 1 1 4.127208e-02 4.127208e-02 9.910768e-06 0.000000
5+
2 0.1000 +0.4938 1 1 8.038114e-02 8.038114e-02 1.736993e-04 0.046832
6+
3 0.1500 +0.4862 28 1 1.506698e-01 1.506698e-01 9.614702e-03 0.059688
7+
4 0.2000 +0.4755 23 1 2.390412e-01 2.390412e-01 1.853175e-02 0.067034
8+
5 0.2500 +0.4619 20 1 3.495552e-01 3.495552e-01 2.103261e-02 0.074380
9+
6 0.3000 +0.4455 15 1 4.846955e-01 4.846955e-01 2.298590e-02 0.074380
10+
7 0.3500 +0.4263 15 1 6.096305e-01 6.096305e-01 2.423472e-02 0.074380
11+
8 0.4000 +0.4045 14 1 7.198707e-01 7.198707e-01 2.396950e-02 0.076217
12+
9 0.4500 +0.3802 14 1 8.120357e-01 8.120357e-01 2.274448e-02 0.079890
13+
10 0.5000 +0.3536 14 1 8.836892e-01 8.836892e-01 2.156902e-02 0.081726
14+
11 0.5500 +0.3247 13 1 9.348462e-01 9.348462e-01 2.019526e-02 0.081726
15+
12 0.6000 +0.2939 14 1 9.672433e-01 9.672433e-01 1.857488e-02 0.081726
16+
13 0.6500 +0.2612 16 1 9.830292e-01 9.830292e-01 1.680594e-02 0.081726
17+
14 0.7000 +0.2270 17 1 9.840694e-01 9.840694e-01 1.495069e-02 0.081726
18+
15 0.7500 +0.1913 19 1 9.717716e-01 9.717716e-01 1.282147e-02 0.081726
19+
16 0.8000 +0.1545 21 1 9.473505e-01 9.473505e-01 1.052256e-02 0.081726
20+
17 0.8500 +0.1167 25 1 9.120627e-01 9.120627e-01 9.265141e-03 0.081726
21+
18 0.9000 +0.0782 30 1 8.675153e-01 8.675153e-01 8.563905e-03 0.081726
22+
19 0.9500 +0.0392 34 1 8.158198e-01 8.158198e-01 7.559992e-03 0.081726
23+
20 1.0000 -0.0000 19 1 7.630093e-01 7.630093e-01 6.323271e-03 0.074380
24+
21 1.0500 -0.0392 8 1 7.288530e-01 7.288530e-01 5.154964e-03 0.074380
25+
22 1.1000 -0.0782 7 1 6.886855e-01 6.886855e-01 4.095200e-03 0.072544
26+
23 1.1500 -0.1167 5 1 6.462222e-01 6.462222e-01 3.139607e-03 0.054178
27+
24 1.2000 -0.1545 4 1 6.024623e-01 6.024623e-01 2.466041e-03 0.009183
28+
25 1.2500 -0.1913 3 1 5.579514e-01 5.579514e-01 2.282205e-03 0.000000
29+
26 1.3000 -0.2270 3 1 5.130849e-01 5.130849e-01 2.190943e-03 0.000000
30+
27 1.3500 -0.2612 2 1 4.667991e-01 4.667991e-01 2.080320e-03 0.000918
31+
28 1.4000 -0.2939 1 1 4.197769e-01 4.197769e-01 1.930754e-03 0.021120
32+
29 1.4500 -0.3247 2 1 3.722971e-01 3.722971e-01 1.743052e-03 0.033058
33+
30 1.5000 -0.3536 12 1 3.225307e-01 3.225307e-01 3.181995e-03 0.048669
34+
31 1.5500 -0.3802 25 1 2.627879e-01 2.627879e-01 9.008150e-03 0.056015
35+
32 1.6000 -0.4045 22 1 2.470817e-01 2.470817e-01 1.384321e-02 0.056015
36+
33 1.6500 -0.4263 23 1 2.617071e-01 2.617071e-01 1.795609e-02 0.063361
37+
34 1.7000 -0.4455 20 1 3.171074e-01 3.171074e-01 2.084389e-02 0.066116
38+
35 1.7500 -0.4619 16 1 3.720918e-01 3.720918e-01 2.375286e-02 0.072544
39+
36 1.8000 -0.4755 15 1 4.180842e-01 4.180842e-01 2.593457e-02 0.074380
40+
37 1.8500 -0.4862 14 1 5.144363e-01 5.144363e-01 2.754916e-02 0.074380
41+
38 1.9000 -0.4938 13 1 6.484323e-01 6.484323e-01 3.122790e-02 0.077135
42+
39 1.9500 -0.4985 12 1 7.692478e-01 7.692478e-01 3.421500e-02 0.079890
43+
40 2.0000 -0.5000 11 1 8.776854e-01 8.776854e-01 3.577072e-02 0.081726
44+
41 2.0500 -0.4985 10 1 9.753243e-01 9.753243e-01 3.613523e-02 0.082645
45+
42 2.1000 -0.4938 9 1 1.063180e+00 1.063180e+00 3.558671e-02 0.083563
46+
43 2.1500 -0.4862 8 1 1.141797e+00 1.141797e+00 3.439847e-02 0.084481
47+
44 2.2000 -0.4755 8 1 1.211360e+00 1.211360e+00 3.344108e-02 0.084481
48+
45 2.2500 -0.4619 8 1 1.278016e+00 1.278016e+00 3.406503e-02 0.086318
49+
46 2.3000 -0.4455 8 1 1.339710e+00 1.339710e+00 3.373125e-02 0.086318
50+
47 2.3500 -0.4263 8 1 1.389034e+00 1.389034e+00 3.234658e-02 0.088154
51+
48 2.4000 -0.4045 8 1 1.425182e+00 1.425182e+00 3.025302e-02 0.089073
52+
49 2.4500 -0.3802 10 1 1.447622e+00 1.447622e+00 2.745848e-02 0.089073
53+
50 2.5000 -0.3536 11 1 1.456493e+00 1.456493e+00 2.508182e-02 0.090909
54+
51 2.5500 -0.3247 12 1 1.452144e+00 1.452144e+00 2.321883e-02 0.090909
55+
52 2.6000 -0.2939 13 1 1.435099e+00 1.435099e+00 2.117630e-02 0.089073
56+
53 2.6500 -0.2612 14 1 1.408897e+00 1.408897e+00 1.892825e-02 0.089073
57+
54 2.7000 -0.2270 15 1 1.382260e+00 1.382260e+00 1.693459e-02 0.088154
58+
55 2.7500 -0.1913 17 1 1.375198e+00 1.375198e+00 1.496980e-02 0.089073
59+
56 2.8000 -0.1545 20 1 1.361218e+00 1.361218e+00 1.361402e-02 0.089073
60+
57 2.8500 -0.1167 23 1 1.338628e+00 1.338628e+00 1.213324e-02 0.088154
61+
58 2.9000 -0.0782 27 1 1.307413e+00 1.307413e+00 1.046934e-02 0.086318
62+
59 2.9500 -0.0392 33 1 1.267677e+00 1.267677e+00 8.977656e-03 0.082645
63+
60 3.0000 -0.0000 24 1 1.220795e+00 1.220795e+00 7.933386e-03 0.081726
64+
61 3.0500 +0.0392 10 1 1.171966e+00 1.171966e+00 6.959463e-03 0.080808
65+
62 3.1000 +0.0782 7 1 1.112697e+00 1.112697e+00 5.897244e-03 0.071625
66+
63 3.1500 +0.1167 5 1 1.047772e+00 1.047772e+00 4.924303e-03 0.056015
67+
64 3.2000 +0.1545 5 1 9.822068e-01 9.822068e-01 4.021409e-03 0.016529
68+
65 3.2500 +0.1913 4 1 9.166450e-01 9.166450e-01 3.436732e-03 0.001837
69+
66 3.3000 +0.2270 3 1 8.520661e-01 8.520661e-01 3.068158e-03 0.000000
70+
67 3.3500 +0.2612 2 1 7.883038e-01 7.883038e-01 2.865541e-03 0.001837
71+
68 3.4000 +0.2939 2 1 7.247583e-01 7.247583e-01 2.728022e-03 0.019284
72+
69 3.4500 +0.3247 2 1 6.614330e-01 6.614330e-01 2.528061e-03 0.032140
73+
70 3.5000 +0.3536 11 1 5.970971e-01 5.970971e-01 3.228570e-03 0.048669
74+
71 3.5500 +0.3802 25 1 5.245090e-01 5.245090e-01 8.312550e-03 0.056015
75+
72 3.6000 +0.4045 23 1 4.415680e-01 4.415680e-01 1.276039e-02 0.056015
76+
73 3.6500 +0.4263 23 1 3.740465e-01 3.740465e-01 1.660880e-02 0.062443
77+
74 3.7000 +0.4455 19 1 3.769107e-01 3.769107e-01 1.956283e-02 0.065197
78+
75 3.7500 +0.4619 16 1 3.849742e-01 3.849742e-01 2.212255e-02 0.069789
79+
76 3.8000 +0.4755 15 1 4.314492e-01 4.314492e-01 2.585272e-02 0.073462
80+
77 3.8500 +0.4862 13 1 4.569590e-01 4.569590e-01 2.882846e-02 0.074380
81+
78 3.9000 +0.4938 13 1 5.536645e-01 5.536645e-01 3.087855e-02 0.076217
82+
79 3.9500 +0.4985 12 1 6.987001e-01 6.987001e-01 3.270765e-02 0.076217
83+
80 4.0000 +0.5000 11 1 8.300400e-01 8.300400e-01 3.425436e-02 0.078972
84+
81 4.0500 +0.4985 10 1 9.481211e-01 9.481211e-01 3.628425e-02 0.081726
85+
82 4.1000 +0.4938 9 1 1.052744e+00 1.052744e+00 3.772184e-02 0.082645
86+
83 4.1500 +0.4862 9 1 1.143134e+00 1.143134e+00 3.843999e-02 0.082645
87+
84 4.2000 +0.4755 8 1 1.218388e+00 1.218388e+00 3.838852e-02 0.083563
88+
85 4.2500 +0.4619 8 1 1.277964e+00 1.277964e+00 3.765011e-02 0.085399
89+
86 4.3000 +0.4455 8 1 1.322205e+00 1.322205e+00 3.624003e-02 0.086318
90+
87 4.3500 +0.4263 8 1 1.352417e+00 1.352417e+00 3.423680e-02 0.087236
91+
88 4.4000 +0.4045 9 1 1.370249e+00 1.370249e+00 3.178397e-02 0.087236
92+
89 4.4500 +0.3802 10 1 1.378066e+00 1.378066e+00 2.894993e-02 0.087236
93+
90 4.5000 +0.3536 11 1 1.378157e+00 1.378157e+00 2.593349e-02 0.087236
94+
91 4.5500 +0.3247 12 1 1.371909e+00 1.371909e+00 2.340301e-02 0.088154
95+
92 4.6000 +0.2939 13 1 1.359741e+00 1.359741e+00 2.156856e-02 0.089073
96+
93 4.6500 +0.2612 14 1 1.342647e+00 1.342647e+00 1.961159e-02 0.089073
97+
94 4.7000 +0.2270 16 1 1.344674e+00 1.344674e+00 1.743032e-02 0.089073
98+
95 4.7500 +0.1913 18 1 1.336877e+00 1.336877e+00 1.502347e-02 0.087236
99+
96 4.8000 +0.1545 20 1 1.320058e+00 1.320058e+00 1.392546e-02 0.087236
100+
97 4.8500 +0.1167 23 1 1.294622e+00 1.294622e+00 1.297610e-02 0.085399
101+
98 4.9000 +0.0782 28 1 1.260405e+00 1.260405e+00 1.166777e-02 0.083563
102+
99 4.9500 +0.0392 33 1 1.217751e+00 1.217751e+00 1.010702e-02 0.081726
103+
100 5.0000 +0.0000 22 1 1.167237e+00 1.167237e+00 8.388419e-03 0.081726
104+
101 5.0500 -0.0392 9 1 1.111585e+00 1.111585e+00 7.391111e-03 0.081726
105+
102 5.1000 -0.0782 7 1 1.048879e+00 1.048879e+00 5.923332e-03 0.071625
106+
103 5.1500 -0.1167 5 1 9.869192e-01 9.869192e-01 4.702023e-03 0.055096
107+
104 5.2000 -0.1545 4 1 9.244225e-01 9.244225e-01 3.691150e-03 0.013774
108+
105 5.2500 -0.1913 3 1 8.618489e-01 8.618489e-01 3.237655e-03 0.000918
109+
106 5.3000 -0.2270 3 1 8.000484e-01 8.000484e-01 3.031333e-03 0.000000
110+
107 5.3500 -0.2612 2 1 7.381037e-01 7.381037e-01 2.863970e-03 0.001837
111+
108 5.4000 -0.2939 2 1 6.763055e-01 6.763055e-01 2.714261e-03 0.021120
112+
109 5.4500 -0.3247 2 1 6.147766e-01 6.147766e-01 2.540707e-03 0.033058
113+
110 5.5000 -0.3536 12 1 5.518377e-01 5.518377e-01 3.367459e-03 0.048669
114+
111 5.5500 -0.3802 25 1 4.792515e-01 4.792515e-01 8.877937e-03 0.056015
115+
112 5.6000 -0.4045 23 1 3.948926e-01 3.948926e-01 1.378900e-02 0.056933
116+
113 5.6500 -0.4263 23 1 3.537057e-01 3.537057e-01 1.782485e-02 0.063361
117+
114 5.7000 -0.4455 20 1 3.527766e-01 3.527766e-01 2.055281e-02 0.065197
118+
115 5.7500 -0.4619 16 1 3.959641e-01 3.959641e-01 2.324016e-02 0.068871
119+
116 5.8000 -0.4755 15 1 4.349951e-01 4.349951e-01 2.537614e-02 0.073462
120+
117 5.8500 -0.4862 14 1 4.724881e-01 4.724881e-01 2.728828e-02 0.074380
121+
118 5.9000 -0.4938 13 1 5.735626e-01 5.735626e-01 3.131495e-02 0.076217
122+
119 5.9500 -0.4985 12 1 6.955473e-01 6.955473e-01 3.435077e-02 0.077135
123+
120 6.0000 -0.5000 11 1 8.061232e-01 8.061232e-01 3.596882e-02 0.079890
Lines changed: 123 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,123 @@
1+
# Phase F predictor-corrector trace: etd1_pc1
2+
# integrator='etd' order=1 apply_radial_return=True in_residual_yield=False
3+
# columns: step, t, V_top, snes_iters_total, picard_iters, sigma_eq_max, sigma_eq_max_after_correction, u_y_max, yielded_fraction
4+
1 0.0500 +0.4985 1 1 4.227008e-02 4.227008e-02 7.408887e-06 0.000000
5+
2 0.1000 +0.4938 1 1 8.219118e-02 8.219118e-02 1.875342e-05 0.048669
6+
3 0.1500 +0.4862 1 1 1.312133e-01 1.312133e-01 3.499493e-03 0.061524
7+
4 0.2000 +0.4755 1 1 1.847484e-01 1.847484e-01 8.601088e-03 0.072544
8+
5 0.2500 +0.4619 1 1 2.349787e-01 2.349787e-01 1.262241e-02 0.073462
9+
6 0.3000 +0.4455 1 1 2.842488e-01 2.842488e-01 1.517815e-02 0.081726
10+
7 0.3500 +0.4263 1 1 3.303034e-01 3.303034e-01 1.652152e-02 0.081726
11+
8 0.4000 +0.4045 1 1 3.759653e-01 3.759653e-01 1.709990e-02 0.081726
12+
9 0.4500 +0.3802 1 1 4.155843e-01 4.155843e-01 1.717741e-02 0.081726
13+
10 0.5000 +0.3536 1 1 4.482948e-01 4.482948e-01 1.675827e-02 0.083563
14+
11 0.5500 +0.3247 1 1 4.744306e-01 4.744306e-01 1.604408e-02 0.083563
15+
12 0.6000 +0.2939 1 1 4.942698e-01 4.942698e-01 1.508513e-02 0.083563
16+
13 0.6500 +0.2612 1 1 5.083255e-01 5.083255e-01 1.444807e-02 0.083563
17+
14 0.7000 +0.2270 1 1 5.170730e-01 5.170730e-01 1.364595e-02 0.081726
18+
15 0.7500 +0.1913 1 1 5.209158e-01 5.209158e-01 1.265520e-02 0.078972
19+
16 0.8000 +0.1545 1 1 5.200673e-01 5.200673e-01 1.151499e-02 0.074380
20+
17 0.8500 +0.1167 1 1 5.146865e-01 5.146865e-01 1.027186e-02 0.073462
21+
18 0.9000 +0.0782 1 1 5.048434e-01 5.048434e-01 8.898937e-03 0.068871
22+
19 0.9500 +0.0392 1 1 4.906089e-01 4.906089e-01 7.427466e-03 0.065197
23+
20 1.0000 -0.0000 1 1 4.734378e-01 4.734378e-01 5.897057e-03 0.059688
24+
21 1.0500 -0.0392 1 1 4.519180e-01 4.519180e-01 4.329136e-03 0.047750
25+
22 1.1000 -0.0782 1 1 4.264055e-01 4.264055e-01 2.576242e-03 0.021120
26+
23 1.1500 -0.1167 1 1 3.971031e-01 3.971031e-01 1.405211e-03 0.001837
27+
24 1.2000 -0.1545 1 1 3.654972e-01 3.654972e-01 1.189141e-03 0.000000
28+
25 1.2500 -0.1913 1 1 3.321918e-01 3.321918e-01 1.065001e-03 0.000000
29+
26 1.3000 -0.2270 1 1 2.973628e-01 2.973628e-01 9.223411e-04 0.001837
30+
27 1.3500 -0.2612 1 1 2.611811e-01 2.611811e-01 8.630974e-04 0.006428
31+
28 1.4000 -0.2939 1 1 2.234569e-01 2.234569e-01 1.135203e-03 0.029385
32+
29 1.4500 -0.3247 1 1 1.831775e-01 1.831775e-01 2.125745e-03 0.046832
33+
30 1.5000 -0.3536 1 1 1.385713e-01 1.385713e-01 4.241876e-03 0.054178
34+
31 1.5500 -0.3802 1 1 1.181696e-01 1.181696e-01 6.389454e-03 0.059688
35+
32 1.6000 -0.4045 1 1 1.372726e-01 1.372726e-01 8.507503e-03 0.067952
36+
33 1.6500 -0.4263 1 1 1.598838e-01 1.598838e-01 1.072879e-02 0.072544
37+
34 1.7000 -0.4455 1 1 1.810420e-01 1.810420e-01 1.306631e-02 0.074380
38+
35 1.7500 -0.4619 1 1 2.238122e-01 2.238122e-01 1.512466e-02 0.078053
39+
36 1.8000 -0.4755 1 1 2.638722e-01 2.638722e-01 1.687399e-02 0.081726
40+
37 1.8500 -0.4862 1 1 3.133549e-01 3.133549e-01 1.829238e-02 0.081726
41+
38 1.9000 -0.4938 1 1 3.615901e-01 3.615901e-01 1.939778e-02 0.081726
42+
39 1.9500 -0.4985 1 1 4.063672e-01 4.063672e-01 2.028848e-02 0.084481
43+
40 2.0000 -0.5000 1 1 4.473514e-01 4.473514e-01 2.105355e-02 0.087236
44+
41 2.0500 -0.4985 1 1 4.842762e-01 4.842762e-01 2.163985e-02 0.089073
45+
42 2.1000 -0.4938 1 1 5.282834e-01 5.282834e-01 2.193861e-02 0.089073
46+
43 2.1500 -0.4862 1 1 5.772664e-01 5.772664e-01 2.206459e-02 0.090909
47+
44 2.2000 -0.4755 1 1 6.219866e-01 6.219866e-01 2.213212e-02 0.091827
48+
45 2.2500 -0.4619 1 1 6.619491e-01 6.619491e-01 2.224729e-02 0.092746
49+
46 2.3000 -0.4455 1 1 6.969564e-01 6.969564e-01 2.214004e-02 0.092746
50+
47 2.3500 -0.4263 1 1 7.266837e-01 7.266837e-01 2.194797e-02 0.092746
51+
48 2.4000 -0.4045 1 1 7.510734e-01 7.510734e-01 2.152773e-02 0.092746
52+
49 2.4500 -0.3802 1 1 7.702274e-01 7.702274e-01 2.089505e-02 0.092746
53+
50 2.5000 -0.3536 1 1 7.843171e-01 7.843171e-01 2.006671e-02 0.092746
54+
51 2.5500 -0.3247 1 1 7.935401e-01 7.935401e-01 1.905951e-02 0.091827
55+
52 2.6000 -0.2939 1 1 7.981186e-01 7.981186e-01 1.788337e-02 0.090909
56+
53 2.6500 -0.2612 1 1 7.981725e-01 7.981725e-01 1.685370e-02 0.089073
57+
54 2.7000 -0.2270 1 1 7.938056e-01 7.938056e-01 1.579015e-02 0.085399
58+
55 2.7500 -0.1913 1 1 7.851243e-01 7.851243e-01 1.454144e-02 0.083563
59+
56 2.8000 -0.1545 1 1 7.721168e-01 7.721168e-01 1.317253e-02 0.078053
60+
57 2.8500 -0.1167 1 1 7.547879e-01 7.547879e-01 1.169327e-02 0.073462
61+
58 2.9000 -0.0782 1 1 7.332337e-01 7.332337e-01 1.027793e-02 0.068871
62+
59 2.9500 -0.0392 1 1 7.075753e-01 7.075753e-01 8.729184e-03 0.065197
63+
60 3.0000 -0.0000 1 1 6.779846e-01 6.779846e-01 7.188479e-03 0.059688
64+
61 3.0500 +0.0392 1 1 6.465370e-01 6.465370e-01 5.643225e-03 0.053260
65+
62 3.1000 +0.0782 1 1 6.116895e-01 6.116895e-01 3.843751e-03 0.028466
66+
63 3.1500 +0.1167 1 1 5.744340e-01 5.744340e-01 2.409459e-03 0.004591
67+
64 3.2000 +0.1545 1 1 5.350145e-01 5.350145e-01 1.969759e-03 0.001837
68+
65 3.2500 +0.1913 1 1 4.938750e-01 4.938750e-01 1.888315e-03 0.001837
69+
66 3.3000 +0.2270 1 1 4.513645e-01 4.513645e-01 1.724640e-03 0.004591
70+
67 3.3500 +0.2612 1 1 4.077729e-01 4.077729e-01 1.635097e-03 0.009183
71+
68 3.4000 +0.2939 1 1 3.628311e-01 3.628311e-01 1.949322e-03 0.030303
72+
69 3.4500 +0.3247 1 1 3.157002e-01 3.157002e-01 2.924769e-03 0.044995
73+
70 3.5000 +0.3536 1 1 2.653372e-01 2.653372e-01 4.546049e-03 0.055096
74+
71 3.5500 +0.3802 1 1 2.125265e-01 2.125265e-01 6.607843e-03 0.059688
75+
72 3.6000 +0.4045 1 1 1.559260e-01 1.559260e-01 8.480549e-03 0.067034
76+
73 3.6500 +0.4263 1 1 1.598838e-01 1.598838e-01 1.051411e-02 0.072544
77+
74 3.7000 +0.4455 1 1 1.662188e-01 1.662188e-01 1.269594e-02 0.074380
78+
75 3.7500 +0.4619 1 1 1.986397e-01 1.986397e-01 1.494535e-02 0.078053
79+
76 3.8000 +0.4755 1 1 2.455196e-01 2.455196e-01 1.685755e-02 0.081726
80+
77 3.8500 +0.4862 1 1 2.903839e-01 2.903839e-01 1.850313e-02 0.081726
81+
78 3.9000 +0.4938 1 1 3.370835e-01 3.370835e-01 1.973221e-02 0.081726
82+
79 3.9500 +0.4985 1 1 3.880890e-01 3.880890e-01 2.074312e-02 0.083563
83+
80 4.0000 +0.5000 1 1 4.353984e-01 4.353984e-01 2.153348e-02 0.086318
84+
81 4.0500 +0.4985 1 1 4.785444e-01 4.785444e-01 2.212614e-02 0.089073
85+
82 4.1000 +0.4938 1 1 5.167683e-01 5.167683e-01 2.247357e-02 0.089073
86+
83 4.1500 +0.4862 1 1 5.504927e-01 5.504927e-01 2.259279e-02 0.089073
87+
84 4.2000 +0.4755 1 1 5.946387e-01 5.946387e-01 2.243399e-02 0.089073
88+
85 4.2500 +0.4619 1 1 6.372919e-01 6.372919e-01 2.205612e-02 0.090909
89+
86 4.3000 +0.4455 1 1 6.734048e-01 6.734048e-01 2.166966e-02 0.092746
90+
87 4.3500 +0.4263 1 1 7.027984e-01 7.027984e-01 2.121580e-02 0.092746
91+
88 4.4000 +0.4045 1 1 7.257176e-01 7.257176e-01 2.071868e-02 0.092746
92+
89 4.4500 +0.3802 1 1 7.426603e-01 7.426603e-01 2.025395e-02 0.092746
93+
90 4.5000 +0.3536 1 1 7.542223e-01 7.542223e-01 1.969271e-02 0.091827
94+
91 4.5500 +0.3247 1 1 7.609657e-01 7.609657e-01 1.900148e-02 0.089991
95+
92 4.6000 +0.2939 1 1 7.634485e-01 7.634485e-01 1.813807e-02 0.089991
96+
93 4.6500 +0.2612 1 1 7.620670e-01 7.620670e-01 1.713053e-02 0.088154
97+
94 4.7000 +0.2270 1 1 7.570430e-01 7.570430e-01 1.594556e-02 0.085399
98+
95 4.7500 +0.1913 1 1 7.484863e-01 7.484863e-01 1.460595e-02 0.083563
99+
96 4.8000 +0.1545 1 1 7.363491e-01 7.363491e-01 1.314961e-02 0.076217
100+
97 4.8500 +0.1167 1 1 7.204547e-01 7.204547e-01 1.171749e-02 0.072544
101+
98 4.9000 +0.0782 1 1 7.013981e-01 7.013981e-01 1.021931e-02 0.068871
102+
99 4.9500 +0.0392 1 1 6.798032e-01 6.798032e-01 8.675941e-03 0.065197
103+
100 5.0000 +0.0000 1 1 6.539379e-01 6.539379e-01 7.059479e-03 0.059688
104+
101 5.0500 -0.0392 1 1 6.240594e-01 6.240594e-01 5.518673e-03 0.048669
105+
102 5.1000 -0.0782 1 1 5.904925e-01 5.904925e-01 3.551771e-03 0.024793
106+
103 5.1500 -0.1167 1 1 5.535297e-01 5.535297e-01 2.128064e-03 0.001837
107+
104 5.2000 -0.1545 1 1 5.145025e-01 5.145025e-01 1.647455e-03 0.000000
108+
105 5.2500 -0.1913 1 1 4.740482e-01 4.740482e-01 1.587837e-03 0.001837
109+
106 5.3000 -0.2270 1 1 4.323105e-01 4.323105e-01 1.406939e-03 0.002755
110+
107 5.3500 -0.2612 1 1 3.894801e-01 3.894801e-01 1.331123e-03 0.009183
111+
108 5.4000 -0.2939 1 1 3.453496e-01 3.453496e-01 1.591105e-03 0.031221
112+
109 5.4500 -0.3247 1 1 2.989171e-01 2.989171e-01 2.527376e-03 0.044995
113+
110 5.5000 -0.3536 1 1 2.484559e-01 2.484559e-01 4.543657e-03 0.054178
114+
111 5.5500 -0.3802 1 1 1.957117e-01 1.957117e-01 6.666710e-03 0.059688
115+
112 5.6000 -0.4045 1 1 1.414415e-01 1.414415e-01 8.680619e-03 0.067034
116+
113 5.6500 -0.4263 1 1 1.598838e-01 1.598838e-01 1.084531e-02 0.072544
117+
114 5.7000 -0.4455 1 1 1.660375e-01 1.660375e-01 1.310024e-02 0.074380
118+
115 5.7500 -0.4619 1 1 1.951370e-01 1.951370e-01 1.524265e-02 0.078053
119+
116 5.8000 -0.4755 1 1 2.367414e-01 2.367414e-01 1.697206e-02 0.081726
120+
117 5.8500 -0.4862 1 1 2.792419e-01 2.792419e-01 1.839754e-02 0.081726
121+
118 5.9000 -0.4938 1 1 3.291106e-01 3.291106e-01 1.942385e-02 0.081726
122+
119 5.9500 -0.4985 1 1 3.755431e-01 3.755431e-01 2.029558e-02 0.083563
123+
120 6.0000 -0.5000 1 1 4.181972e-01 4.181972e-01 2.101870e-02 0.086318

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)