diff --git a/design/admission-boundary-001/ADMISSION-CONTRACT-ERRATUM-001.md b/design/admission-boundary-001/ADMISSION-CONTRACT-ERRATUM-001.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..54a7c6a --- /dev/null +++ b/design/admission-boundary-001/ADMISSION-CONTRACT-ERRATUM-001.md @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +# ERRATUM 001 — ADMISSION-CONTRACT-v0.1 + +Status: OWNER-AUTHORIZED CORRECTION +Issued UTC: 2026-09-08 +Authorization: CAT-ALIGN-001B / Arkadiy Miteiko / 2026-09-08 + +## Predecessor identity + +- Path: `design/admission-boundary-001/ADMISSION-CONTRACT-v0.1.md` +- Blob: `1128bdbcc42dc47a355551fa230bab6f7420accc` +- SHA-256: `ad4c656831b679a9396b15a8a9ae32448cf63707711916e4f3a8fa5ed34e8cd2` +- Recorded in `docs/capabilities/CAPABILITY_MATRIX.json` under `source_provenance`, with + `source_commit` `3fcdec63b7e546d9b369e0e8664d5d67be6a3b54` + +**The predecessor is not modified.** It is preregistered design evidence, its bytes are +digest-pinned by the capability matrix, and `VERSIONING.md` requires that admitted artifacts are +never mutated in place but superseded. This erratum is a successor record about the predecessor, +not permission to erase or rewrite it. The predecessor's own claim ceiling, +`independent_validation_claim = FALSE`, and `NOT SELF-ADJUDICATED` marker continue to apply to it +unchanged. + +## The corrected statement + +The predecessor contains, in its closing paragraph on downstream stages: + +> A later OCE/runtime stage may compute consequences; OAM/ZTL may constrain operational +> authority; and VEIP may record or verify execution consequences. None is designed or +> implemented here. + +**As to OAM, that sentence is no longer canonical.** It attributes to OAM a constraint on +operational authority. Under the owner disposition of 2026-09-08, OAM's canonical role is +examination-side, not control-side. + +The canonical statement is: + +> ZTL may constrain what is logically warranted for downstream reliance. +> VEIP/runtime enforcement may constrain whether an exact action may execute. +> OAM governs examination/audit disposition and may constrain later institutional reliance on +> examined results; OAM does not authorize exact runtime execution. + +## Why the distinction matters here + +Constraining operational authority and constraining later institutional reliance are not the same +act, and collapsing them collapses two distinct authority planes: the causal authority that +determines whether an action may execute, and the evidentiary authority that determines what an +examiner may later rely on. OAM sits on the second. Attributing the first to it would let an +examination workflow read as a runtime control, which is precisely the kind of authority inflation +this contract's own admission boundary exists to prevent. + +## Scope of this correction + +This erratum corrects the OAM attribution **only**. + +Unchanged and unaffected: + +- every other semantic in `ADMISSION-CONTRACT-v0.1.md`, including the admission states, the + minimum successor bundle, and the rule that only `ADMITTED` may cross into Institutional IR + construction; +- the statement that no other admission state is a denial of the underlying proposition; +- the roles attributed in the same sentence to a later OCE/runtime stage, to ZTL, and to VEIP; +- the predecessor's claim ceiling in full; +- `docs/capabilities/CAPABILITY_MATRIX.json`, including the recorded digest of the predecessor; +- every schema, test vector, and runtime behavior in `design/admission-boundary-001/`. + +Nothing here is designed or implemented in this repository. This erratum records a category +correction; it does not establish legal validity, universal authority semantics, production +readiness, runtime safety, compliance, successful IR compilation, execution authorization, or +independent validation. + +`independent_validation_claim = FALSE` + +`NOT SELF-ADJUDICATED` + +## Provenance + +- Canonical OAM role: `veraxis-protocol/institutional-continuity`, `THESIS.md` §8a, and the + reconciliation record `OAM-ROLE-RECONCILIATION.md` in that repository. +- Canonical public home for the OAM definition: `veraxis-protocol/Open-Audit-Mission`. +- Conflict discovery: the CAT-ALIGN-001B census, which found this sentence and the ICI README's + "standing/examination workflow" definition in material conflict.