Tracking issue mirroring virtualian/pai-v5#11 closure on virtualian/pai's side (closed as NOT_PLANNED on 2026-05-18 — closedAt = 2026-05-18T13:57:13Z, stateReason = NOT_PLANNED).
The HIGH#3 Scope gate port has concluded WON'T-DO after verify-first:
- Source-read on marrair — preliminary disposition PARTIAL-PORT (port only restatement-verification step) per
reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md §1-9
- Live-probe on marrmini — shifted disposition to CLOSE-AS-WON'T-DO via probe P4 = RESTATED YES (v5 already implicitly restates the literal ask) + P1+P2 PASS scope-lock (AISTEERINGRULES.md rules deployed via pai-v5#2 fire behaviourally) + P3 PASS no over-restriction. Documented in
reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md §10.
HIGH bucket now fully closed:
- pai-v5#1 MERGED (AskUserQuestion gate)
- pai-v5#2 MERGED (AISTEERINGRULES +
@imports wiring)
- pai-v5#11 won't-do (SCOPE GATE — verify-first concluded gap absent)
Further ports would be MED tier ("useful but not daily-blocking" per design doc priority list).
What the companion PR lands
- Full source-read findings report (
reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md, including §10 probe results + final disposition matrix application)
- Marrmini probe kickoff with verified target state + SSH/PATH guidance (
reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-marrmini-probe-kickoff.md)
- Design doc updates (
Plans/v5-0-0-plus-port.md — pai-v5#11 row → CLOSED won't-do, Phase posture → HIGH bucket fully closed milestone, date bump 2026-05-10 → 2026-05-18)
Closes when PR lands.
References
Tracking issue mirroring
virtualian/pai-v5#11closure onvirtualian/pai's side (closed asNOT_PLANNEDon 2026-05-18 —closedAt = 2026-05-18T13:57:13Z,stateReason = NOT_PLANNED).The HIGH#3 Scope gate port has concluded WON'T-DO after verify-first:
reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md§1-9reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md§10.HIGH bucket now fully closed:
@importswiring)Further ports would be MED tier ("useful but not daily-blocking" per design doc priority list).
What the companion PR lands
reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md, including §10 probe results + final disposition matrix application)reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-marrmini-probe-kickoff.md)Plans/v5-0-0-plus-port.md— pai-v5#11 row → CLOSED won't-do, Phase posture → HIGH bucket fully closed milestone, date bump 2026-05-10 → 2026-05-18)Closes when PR lands.
References
virtualian/pai-v5#11pai-v5-11-step0-source-read(5 commits)