Skip to content

Track pai-v5#11 won't-do: SCOPE GATE verify-first closed + HIGH bucket complete #179

Description

@virtualian

Tracking issue mirroring virtualian/pai-v5#11 closure on virtualian/pai's side (closed as NOT_PLANNED on 2026-05-18 — closedAt = 2026-05-18T13:57:13Z, stateReason = NOT_PLANNED).

The HIGH#3 Scope gate port has concluded WON'T-DO after verify-first:

  • Source-read on marrair — preliminary disposition PARTIAL-PORT (port only restatement-verification step) per reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md §1-9
  • Live-probe on marrmini — shifted disposition to CLOSE-AS-WON'T-DO via probe P4 = RESTATED YES (v5 already implicitly restates the literal ask) + P1+P2 PASS scope-lock (AISTEERINGRULES.md rules deployed via pai-v5#2 fire behaviourally) + P3 PASS no over-restriction. Documented in reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md §10.

HIGH bucket now fully closed:

  • pai-v5#1 MERGED (AskUserQuestion gate)
  • pai-v5#2 MERGED (AISTEERINGRULES + @imports wiring)
  • pai-v5#11 won't-do (SCOPE GATE — verify-first concluded gap absent)

Further ports would be MED tier ("useful but not daily-blocking" per design doc priority list).

What the companion PR lands

  • Full source-read findings report (reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-scope-gate-gap.md, including §10 probe results + final disposition matrix application)
  • Marrmini probe kickoff with verified target state + SSH/PATH guidance (reports/v5-comparison/pai-v5-11-marrmini-probe-kickoff.md)
  • Design doc updates (Plans/v5-0-0-plus-port.md — pai-v5#11 row → CLOSED won't-do, Phase posture → HIGH bucket fully closed milestone, date bump 2026-05-10 → 2026-05-18)

Closes when PR lands.

References

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions