Audit candidate: Ibrahim-3d/orchestrator-supaconductor

[xiaolai]

Repo

https://github.com/Ibrahim-3d/orchestrator-supaconductor

Field	Value
Stars	336
NL Artifacts	97
Discovery strategy	topic-tag
Topics: claude-code-plugin

Next Steps

1. Review the repo — check CONTRIBUTING.md, recent activity, PR history
2. If worthy: add label audit-ready to trigger the audit workflow
3. If not: close this issue

Checklist

• Accepts contributions
• Updated in last 60 days
• Not a fork or mirror
• Has meaningful NL artifacts

[github-actions]

Audit Complete: Ibrahim-3d/orchestrator-supaconductor

NL Score: 89/100 | Security: REVIEW | Artifacts: 98 | Strategy: progressive

NLPM Audit: Ibrahim-3d/orchestrator-supaconductor

Date: 2026-04-30 | Artifacts: 107 | Strategy: full-read
NL Score: 89/100
Security: REVIEW
Bugs: 3 | Quality Issues: 15 | Security Findings: 2

NL Score Summary

File	Type	Score	Top Issue
agents/board-meeting.md	agent	60	run_shell_command used in body but not declared in frontmatter tools list (BUG); no examples
agents/conductor-orchestrator.md	agent	65	No examples; description summarizes workflow (CSO anti-pattern)
agents/name-picker.md	agent	70	No examples; no formal output format section
agents/loop-execution-evaluator.md	agent	72	No examples
agents/loop-fixer.md	agent	72	No examples
agents/loop-executor.md	agent	72	No examples
agents/parallel-dispatcher.md	agent	72	No examples; no output format section
agents/task-worker.md	agent	72	No examples
agents/loop-plan-evaluator.md	agent	75	No examples
agents/loop-planner.md	agent	75	No examples
agents/code-reviewer.md	agent	75	model: inherit is not a concrete model ID (R10); examples in description field only
agents/ceo.md	agent	80	Missing output format section; 5 examples present
agents/cmo.md	agent	80	Missing output format section; 7 examples present
agents/cto.md	agent	80	Missing output format section; 7 examples present
agents/ux-designer.md	agent	80	Missing output format section; examples present
skills/business-docs-sync/SKILL.md	skill	50	No YAML frontmatter at all — missing name and description (BUG)
commands/ui-audit/UI-UX-AUDIT-REPORT.md	template	50	Template placed in commands/ with no frontmatter; not usable as a command (BUG)
commands/evaluate-plan.md	command	88	No allowed-tools; body references /loop-plan-evaluator (stale command name)
commands/loop-executor.md	command	88	No allowed-tools; body references .claude/agents/orchestrator-supaconductor:loop-executor.md (stale path)
commands/loop-planner.md	command	88	No allowed-tools; body references .claude/agents/orchestrator-supaconductor:loop-planner.md (stale path)
commands/task-worker.md	command	88	No allowed-tools; body references .claude/agents/orchestrator-supaconductor:task-worker.md (stale path)
commands/board-meeting.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/board-review.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/brainstorm.md	command	93	No allowed-tools; duplicate of commands/brainstorming.md
commands/brainstorming.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/ceo.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/close-track.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/cmo.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/conductor-implement.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/conductor-new-track.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/conductor-setup.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/conductor-status.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/cto-advisor.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/cto.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/evaluate-execution.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/execute-plan.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/executing-plans.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/finishing-a-development-branch.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/go.md	command	93	No allowed-tools
commands/implement.md	command	93	No allowed-tools

---

Full report: https://github.com/xiaolai/nlpm-for-claude/blob/main/auditor/audits/Ibrahim-3d-orchestrator-supaconductor.md

10 bug(s) found. To submit fix PRs to the target repo, add the contribute-approved label to this issue.

[xiaolai]

Opened 3 PRs on Ibrahim-3d/orchestrator-supaconductor (first contact):

1. #12 — agents/board-meeting.md: add run_shell_command to frontmatter tools list (Phase 5 instructs it but it was undeclared — runtime failure)
2. #13 — skills/business-docs-sync/SKILL.md: add YAML frontmatter (skill was invisible to the Skill tool with no name/description)
3. #14 — commands/ui-audit/UI-UX-AUDIT-REPORT.md: move to docs/ui-audit-report-template.md (template with no frontmatter misplaced in commands/)

All three reproduced independently before submission. No CONTRIBUTING.md or PR template found in the target repo.

[xiaolai]

Contribute run: Ibrahim-3d/orchestrator-supaconductor

PRs #12, #13, #14 were already open from a prior run. One new PR created this run:

• fix: cache update-check result to avoid curl on every session start Ibrahim-3d/orchestrator-supaconductor#15 — cache update-check curl call in session-start.sh (Low severity security fix: skip outbound GitHub API call if cache < 24h old)