get_aca.read: SSH overlay remainder (timeout cleared; selected_memory/slots parity)

[AdamRickards]

Why

Parent #39 / #176 fixed SNMP ExtNVM INDEX (not-accessible → status OID suffix). Named proof on ACA-capable pick: mops slots n=2, snmp slots n=2, parity_diffs=[]. Parent closed.

SSH was not in scope for that fix. Live prove still: ssh=timeout (overall deadline). PR #158/#176 body also noted no hm2extnvm* SSH overlay / CLI sample for env properties — so even after #92, parse/overlay may remain.

Hole

get_aca.read SSH path — hang-open and/or missing overlay — separate from SNMP floor.

Named proof (when ready)

POST {"name":"get_aca.read","trace":true} with SSH completing (not timeout). Expect slots/fields vs mops or an honest empty+raw trail.

Related

• Closed parent: get_aca.read parity: slots.row count: mops=2 vs snmp=0 #39
• Hung-open floor: SSH cli hangs to timeout on invalid or missing command instead of failing #92 (do not re-bundle hang into this if timeout is the only symptom — comment and keep SSH cli hangs to timeout on invalid or missing command instead of failing #92; this ticket is the method leftover after hang is fixed / if overlay is the miss)

Rails

One SSH remainder ticket per leftover. Public language: tested/untested, pass/fail only.

[AdamRickards]

Decision trail — SSH timeout retest (main 0604cab)

Tool: sidecar get_aca.read trace:true

Receipt:

• mops: ok (selected_memory/envm_state/slots present)
• snmp: timeout phase=call
• ssh: timeout phase=open
• parity_diffs: none
• passed=true

Bucket: retitle/comment — SSH open-budget remainder → #92. Not close.

END: leftover / #92 class

[AdamRickards]

Decision trail — post-#215 budget re-prove (main 6724659)

Receipt: mops/snmp/ssh all status=ok (timeout cleared).

Parity: selected_memory mops/snmp vs ssh disagree; slots mops/snmp n=2 vs ssh n=0. SSH cli is show config status (storage sync), not a slots table.

Bucket: hold — leftover intention was SSH remainder after floor; SSH still wrong on selected_memory/slots. Not close on budget alone.

END: leftover / SSH overlay

[AdamRickards]

Architect triage

Loop: schema / SSH overlay (live YAML) — not hang #92
Protocols: ssh
Orders:

• Schema clerk — confirm-only: for get_aca, is SSH overlay/YAML missing, wrong wire, or wrong join (CLI parse vs declared shows)? Prefer existing schema/wire tools; no implement unless ordered. MIB + CLI JSON. Trail on this issue.
• 1.17 clerk — confirm-only: labeled ssh differential vs napalm-hios v1.17 for get_aca (same-wire or diff). Own venv only; never 2.0 shim. No fix. Trail on this issue.
• Test bot — skip — inspect dumps already on issue

Leftover: SSH selected_memory/slots parity after timeout cleared (cli is show config status)
Named proof (later): POST {"name":"get_aca.read","trace":true} — SSH status=ok with field leaving default or honest empty+raw; do not treat 2-of-3 as green.
Rails: no --gate; no device identity on public comments; one SSH ticket per leftover.

[AdamRickards]

Schema clerk — confirm-only triage

Flow: confirm-only triage (no implement)

Symptom (ssh): timeout cleared; selected_memory disagree; slots n=0 vs other-protocol n=2; cli is show config status (storage sync), not a slots table. Protocols: ssh only.

Declared SSH vs CLI.json:

• Live/used: show config status — HIT (covers hm2fmenvmstate / envm_state only via wire/ssh/filemgmt.yaml)
• hm2extnvm* (selected_memory / slots) — no entries in wire/ssh/devmgmt.yaml (overlay absent)
• CLI HIT candidates unused: show config envm active, show config envm settings, show config envm properties (+ show physical-interfaces envm)

Classification: overlay missing — ExtNVM attrs have MIB wire but no SSH sources; wrong show for slots/selected_memory. SSH_HITLIST already notes aca needs show config envm*.

MIB (name only): hm2ExtNVMChooseActive / hm2ExtNVMTable*. Not picking mops/snmp winners.

Later hop (Schema soft): overlay hm2extnvm* onto show config envm active|settings|properties + existing value_map; HITL sample only if field/column map needs eyes. Park until ordered.

[AdamRickards]

Decision trail (1.17 clerk — SSH confirm)

Flow: source review only (no live). Compare napalm-hios-1.17 for get_aca vs schema + SSH overlay.

Ruled out: hang/#92 (timeout already cleared). Not a protocol pick. Schema clerk overlay-missing note stands; this is the 1.17 same-wire check only.

Tool: 1.17 tree (version.py = 1.17.0) rg over napalm_hios/*.py + crude_engine/schemas/aca.yaml + crude_engine/wire/ssh/filemgmt.yaml + wire/ssh/devmgmt.yaml. No live.

1.17 SSH: no get_aca on facade / SSH / MOPS / SNMP. Closest SSH neighbors:

• get_config_status (ssh_hios.py:684): CLI show config status → parse_dot_keys; aca from field NVM to ACA (plus running-config to NVM, Boot parameters).
• get_services (ssh_hios.py:3636): CLI show config envm settings → aca_auto_update / aca_config_write / aca_config_load (not a slots table).
• No show config envm active / properties in 1.17.

YAML overlay:

• hm2fmenvmstate (envm_state): show config status field NVM to ACA — same CLI+field as 1.17 get_config_status.
• hm2extnvm* (selected_memory / slots) — no SSH sources.

Verdict: differential (missing getter + missing ExtNVM SSH). Overlay show config status matches 1.17 get_config_status for sync-only envm_state. It does not cover selected_memory/slots; 1.17 never assembled those into get_aca. Leftover slots n=0 / selected_memory disagree is wrong/missing overlay, not 1.17 same-wire.

Leftover: selected_memory/slots (not timeout). Not green until ExtNVM has SSH reads (1.17’s nearest show is show config envm settings) or honest empty+raw.

[AdamRickards]

Architect assign — raw-cli ↔ gold ↔ 1.17 trace (HITL review)

Goal: lock bucket before implement — parse/primitives vs wrong wire vs honest SSH gap.

Orders (confirm / capture only — no YAML/engine fix this hop):

1. Test bot — sidecar trace:true named read; post: mops row/key summary (gold-shaped control), snmp one-liner if cheap, SSH cli raw (relevant shows), declared wire shows, current n/parity.
2. Schema — table: gold/MOPS field → present in raw cli? → declared SSH source → 1.17 ask (from 1.17 trail). Bucket: wrong join / wrong show / overlay missing / honest gap.
3. 1.17 — ssh-only: commands + shape vs crude declared; same-wire or differential (refresh if stale).

No 2-of-3 invent. No --gate. No device identity on GitHub. HITL will review the three trails together.

[AdamRickards]

Decision trail (1.17 clerk — HITL gold-pack SSH)

1. 1.17 shows used — no get_aca on facade/SSH/MOPS/SNMP. Closest SSH neighbors: get_config_status (ssh_hios.py:684) → show config status; get_services ACA fields (ssh_hios.py:3636) → show config envm settings. No ExtNVM inventory/properties show in 1.17.
2. 1.17 row shape — N/A for get_aca. get_config_status returns {saved, nvm, aca, boot} from parse_dot_keys (NVM to ACA → aca). get_services returns flat bools aca_auto_update / aca_config_write / aca_config_load — not a slots table.
3. Crude declared SSH — wire/ssh/filemgmt.yaml: hm2fmenvmstate (envm_state) = show config status field NVM to ACA. hm2extnvm* (selected_memory / slots) — no SSH sources in devmgmt/filemgmt overlays.
4. Crude row shape — dict defaults {selected_memory, envm_state, slots}; slots sub_table primary_key: slot_type. Only envm_state has an SSH read; selected_memory/slots stay default/empty on SSH.
5. Verdict: differential — overlay sync field matches 1.17 get_config_status; ExtNVM selected_memory/slots have no SSH (1.17 never assembled get_aca) → leftover slots n=0 / selected_memory disagree.
6. Gold note: Test raw cli not yet on issue — align when Test raw cli lands. Expect Crude declare today: show config status. 1.17 nearest extras (not on this getter): show config envm settings.

[AdamRickards]

Raw-cli ↔ gold MOPS ↔ 1.17 capture (Test, main d6b7876)

Confirm/capture only — no implement. Pool pick was ACA-capable (first eligible).

1) MOPS control

• keys: ['selected_memory', 'envm_state', 'slots']
• selected_memory='sd', envm_state='ok'
• slots n=2: {'1': {'type': 'sd', 'status': 'ok', 'writable': True, 'auto_update': True, 'auto_ssh_key': True, 'config_load_priority': 'low', 'config_save': True, 'name': 'ACA31', 'serial_number': '<redacted>'}, '2': {'type': 'usb', 'status': 'notPresent', 'writable': False, 'auto_update': True, 'auto_ssh_key': True, 'config_load_priority': 'high', 'config_save': True, 'name': '', 'serial_number': ''}}

2) SNMP

• status=ok phase=None open_ms=797 call_ms=4135 n=3 err=None

3) SSH cli raw

show config status

Configuration storage sync state
--------------------------------
running-config to NVM.......................ok
NVM to ACA..................................ok
Boot parameters.............................ok

4) Declared SSH shows vs ran

• Declared: ['show config status']
• Ran: ['show config status']
• Exact match. CLI is config sync status, not ACA slot inventory — explains slots n=0 / selected_memory none on SSH.

5) parity_diffs / n

• top-level n=3 all protos
• parity: ["selected_memory: mops='sd' vs ssh='none'", 'slots.row count: mops=2 vs ssh=0', "selected_memory: snmp='sd' vs ssh='none'", 'slots.row count: snmp=2 vs ssh=0']

No device identity / serials on this trail.

[AdamRickards]

Schema HITL review pack (confirm-only)

Sources: issue cli + 1.17 trail on-issue (Test raw not yet refreshed).

Method: get_aca · ssh-labeled · gold = schema defaults (aca.yaml) · wire filemgmt / devmgmt · prior receipt cli is show config status (storage sync), not envm slots. Leftover: selected_memory / slots n=0.

gold/MOPS field	in raw SSH cli?	declared crude SSH source	1.17 ask (from 1.17 trail)
envm_state	yes — prior receipt show config status field NVM to ACA	hm2fmenvmstate ← show config status field NVM to ACA	no get_aca; closest get_config_status.aca→show config status NVM to ACA
selected_memory	no — not in show config status snippet; CLI.json has unused show config envm*	no SSH source (hm2extnvmchooseactive / ExtNVM)	selected_memory/slots.* no SSH ask in 1.17
slots (sub_table)	no — sync show is not a slots table	no SSH overlay for hm2extnvm*	selected_memory/slots.* no SSH ask in 1.17
slots[].type / status / writable / auto_update / auto_ssh_key / config_load_priority / config_save / name / serial_number	no	no SSH source	selected_memory/slots.* no SSH ask in 1.17

Bucket: overlay missing

[AdamRickards]

Schema HITL review pack (confirm-only) — refreshed

Sources: Test raw receipt (main d6b7876) + 1.17 ask (on-issue / steering).

Method: get_aca · ssh-labeled · gold = schema defaults · wire filemgmt/devmgmt · CLI.json. Test: declared/ran show config status only; parity selected_memory mops sd vs ssh none; slots mops 2 vs ssh 0.

gold/MOPS field	in raw SSH cli?	declared crude SSH source	1.17 ask (from 1.17 trail)
envm_state	yes — NVM to ACA..................................ok	hm2fmenvmstate ← show config status field NVM to ACA	no get_aca; closest get_config_status.aca→show config status NVM to ACA
selected_memory	no — sync show only; no ExtNVM / envm inventory in receipt	no SSH source (hm2extnvmchooseactive)	selected_memory/slots.* no SSH ask in 1.17
slots (sub_table)	no — not a slots table	no SSH overlay for hm2extnvm*	selected_memory/slots.* no SSH ask in 1.17
slots[].type / status / writable / auto_update / auto_ssh_key / config_load_priority / config_save / name / serial_number	no	no SSH source	selected_memory/slots.* no SSH ask in 1.17

Bucket: overlay missing