fix(e2e): reconcile cockpit default surface — deterministic e2e matches the five-card product (3 suites green)

docs/SESSION_LOG_v3.md

@@ -1,5 +1,12 @@
 # SESSION LOG v3
 
+## s_v6_0006 · 2026-06-11 · [reconcile-e2e] deterministic cockpit E2E reconciled to the current conversation+five-card contract
+
+- Root cause: `scripts/operator-cockpit-e2e.ts` was pinned to the superseded inline clarification-option contract (`getByRole('button', { name: 'A specific test/command must pass ★' })`) and timed out — clarification answering moved into `ClarificationPopup` and the primary surface is conversation + LoopCard (WORKBOOK_v6 GR#11). Second stale expectation found and fixed: the Draft-PR gate now evaluates the Gemini evidence gate before remote-writes, so the deterministic blocked code is `GEMINI_NOT_CONFIGURED` (as quality-smoke already asserts), not `REMOTE_WRITES_DISABLED`.
+- Fix (no product change, no flags, no old-UI restoration): the e2e now drives the popup with the exact selector contract of `operator-cockpit-user-e2e.ts` (`.ck-clar-popup` / `.ck-clar-q` / recommended `.ck-chip` / "Answer all" submit), uses the same deterministic fenced-JSON planner fixtures (brainstorm confidence 62 → answers → Ask Until Clear follow-up confidence 96 unlocks the plan), then keeps ALL its full-loop assertions: roadmap → approve → execute → root stage → PR gate card blocked + `pr_blocked` operatorView stage + exactly 1 mock run + artifacts + no PR URL.
+- Decision recorded in `docs/cockpit-redesign/DEFAULT_SURFACE_DECISION.md`: conversation+five-card is the default; deterministic E2E must track the shipped product.
+- Suites: `test:cockpit:e2e` PASS (was timing out), `test:cockpit:quality-smoke` PASS (evidence `evidence/browser-cockpit-quality/2026-06-11T14-18-20-197Z/`), `test:cockpit:user-e2e` PASS 7/7 (evidence `evidence/browser-cockpit-user-e2e/2026-06-11T14-18-36-321Z/`). Gates: typecheck/lint/test — 950 baseline, zero regressions.
+
 ## s_v6_0005 · 2026-06-11 · Overnight harness loop — P1/P3/P4/P5/P6 done · P2 honest HOLD
 
 - P1: HOLD-PLANNER-AUTH detection + opt-in AEDEV_PLANNER_FALLBACK=codex (events record codex-cli (fallback), never impersonation) (+18). P3: operator-vocabulary cards + agent strip + on-card actions + PR-gate transparency, user-E2E 7/7 (+17). P4: merge-policy pure function, 864-combination sweep proves GR#10 (auto-merge off) (+14). P5: run-summary.md audit artifact on all four mission exits, absent-means-absent (+12). P6: full uninterrupted 30-min soak 5/5 PASS.

docs/cockpit-redesign/DEFAULT_SURFACE_DECISION.md

@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Default Surface Decision — conversation + five-card LoopCard
+
+Date: 2026-06-11
+
+Decision (recorded; made by the orchestrator): the **conversation-first cockpit
+with the five-card LoopCard surface** (understanding / plan / progress /
+blocker / pr_ready) **is the intended default**, per WORKBOOK_v6 GR#11.
+
+Consequences:
+
+- Clarification answering happens through the bottom-anchored
+  `ClarificationPopup` (`.ck-clar-popup` / `.ck-clar-q` / `.ck-chip` +
+  "Answer all & continue"), not inline option buttons in the thread.
+- The Gemini evidence-only hard gate is evaluated before the remote-writes
+  gate, so the deterministic blocked Draft-PR code with no Gemini verdict is
+  `GEMINI_NOT_CONFIGURED`.
+- `scripts/operator-cockpit-e2e.ts` (deterministic mock/template full-loop
+  E2E) was updated to this current contract on 2026-06-11; it had been pinned
+  to the old inline clarification-option contract and the stale
+  `REMOTE_WRITES_DISABLED` first-block expectation.
+
+Explicit non-goals: **no 3-pane default, no legacy inline clarification UI
+restoration, no feature flag** to switch surfaces. Deterministic E2E
+expectations must track the shipped product, not preserve superseded UI.

evidence/browser-cockpit-quality/2026-06-11T14-10-56-596Z/console-logs.json

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[]

evidence/browser-cockpit-quality/2026-06-11T14-10-56-596Z/db-state-summary.json

@@ -0,0 +1,286 @@
+{
+  "mission": {
+    "id": "01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN",
+    "status": "paused",
+    "githubPrUrl": null
+  },
+  "operatorView": {
+    "stage": "pr_blocked",
+    "stageLabel": "PR blocked by policy · PR 被安全门拦截",
+    "confidence": 96,
+    "progressPercent": 95,
+    "headlessCallsToday": 0,
+    "primaryAction": {
+      "id": "check-draft-pr-gate",
+      "label": "Re-check Draft PR Gate · 重新检查 PR 安全门",
+      "kind": "primary"
+    },
+    "secondaryActions": [],
+    "providerSummary": {
+      "planner": {
+        "name": "test-synthetic",
+        "mode": "mock",
+        "status": "Planner finished",
+        "tokens": null
+      },
+      "worker": {
+        "name": "mock",
+        "mode": "mock",
+        "status": "done",
+        "tokens": null
+      },
+      "validators": [
+        {
+          "name": "gemini",
+          "mode": "not_configured",
+          "status": "not_configured"
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    "safetySummary": {
+      "remoteWrites": "disabled",
+      "prGate": {
+        "status": "blocked",
+        "code": "GEMINI_NOT_CONFIGURED",
+        "reason": "Gemini hard gate has no evidence-only PASS verdict for this mission.",
+        "remediation": "Remote writes are disabled for safety. Enable repo-scoped allow_remote_writes only when you want the worker to push a branch and open a Draft PR; until then no push, PR, or merge occurs."
+      },
+      "testMode": {
+        "enabled": true,
+        "reason": "mock/template mode is active; no external model or remote write is implied."
+      }
+    },
+    "understanding": {
+      "roundsCompleted": 0,
+      "questions": [],
+      "readyReason": "Planner confidence is at least 95% and no clarification questions are pending."
+    },
+    "projectPulse": {
+      "progress": [
+        {
+          "id": "understand",
+          "label": "Understand · 理解需求",
+          "status": "done"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "roadmap",
+          "label": "Roadmap · 路线图",
+          "status": "done"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "execute",
+          "label": "Execute · 本地执行",
+          "status": "done"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "validate",
+          "label": "Validate · 独立验证",
+          "status": "done",
+          "detail": "Gemini key is not configured; this is visible and not counted as pass."
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "pr-gate",
+          "label": "PR Gate · PR 安全门",
+          "status": "active"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "learn",
+          "label": "Learn · 沉淀记忆",
+          "status": "pending"
+        }
+      ],
+      "workingFolder": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/operator-evidence/01KTVGB98SARBSTY7616TDSNZH",
+      "touchedFiles": [],
+      "evidence": [
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F3",
+          "title": "ADR draft",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/adr-mission.md",
+          "type": "adr"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F1",
+          "title": "Evidence directory",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN",
+          "type": "evidence"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F2",
+          "title": "PRD",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/prd.md",
+          "type": "prd"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F5",
+          "title": "Workbook summary",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/workbook-summary.md",
+          "type": "report"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F6",
+          "title": "Test summary",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/test-summary.md",
+          "type": "report"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F7",
+          "title": "Risk report",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/risk-report.md",
+          "type": "report"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F8",
+          "title": "Worker diff",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/diff-summary.md",
+          "type": "report"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F9",
+          "title": "Done report",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/done-report.md",
+          "type": "report"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB990AJWY1R5Y0EQ159F4",
+          "title": "Roadmap",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/evidence/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN/roadmap.md",
+          "type": "roadmap"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB8TPVKRQZXZ7MVXKCWW1",
+          "title": "ADR draft in mission design",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/prd/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN.design.json",
+          "type": "adr"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB8TN73M0G50YNBS0CBQX",
+          "title": "Mission design JSON",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/prd/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN.design.json",
+          "type": "roadmap"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "01KTVGB8TN73M0G50YNBS0CBQW",
+          "title": "PRD",
+          "path": "/tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f/prd/01KTVGB8TJ5JBT7FSJ6KS9WPKN.md",
+          "type": "prd"
+        }
+      ],
+      "validatorReviews": [
+        {
+          "id": "validators-not-configured",
+          "validator": "validators",
+          "verdict": "not_configured",
+          "summary": "Independent validation did not run because the Gemini key is not configured.",
+          "checkedEvidence": [
+            "ADR draft",
+            "Evidence directory",
+            "PRD",
+            "Workbook summary",
+            "Test summary",
+            "Risk report",
+            "Worker diff",
+            "Done report"
+          ],
+          "blockingIssues": [],
+          "evidenceGaps": [
+            "No Gemini validator verdict exists for this mission."
+          ],
+          "recommendedNextAction": "Configure validator keys for live verification, or continue reviewing evidence manually."
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    "memorySummary": {
+      "projectFacts": [
+        {
+          "id": "repo-01KTVGB510MQPKSWH3GB5QFATX",
+          "kind": "project",
+          "text": "Target repo is cockpit-quality at /tmp/aedev-cockpit-quality-WZEC3f.",
+          "provenance": "repo registry",
+          "ttlDays": 90,
+          "superseded": false
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "repo-forbidden-01KTVGB510MQPKSWH3GB5QFATX",
+          "kind": "safety",
+          "text": "Forbidden paths stay protected: .env*, secrets/**, .github/**, AGENTS.md",
+          "provenance": "repo policy",
+          "ttlDays": 365,
+          "superseded": false
+        }
+      ],
+      "userPreferences": [
+        {
+          "id": "pref-understand-first",
+          "kind": "user_preference",
+          "text": "Ask goal-specific questions and confirm understanding before starting worker execution.",
+          "provenance": "operator product directive",
+          "ttlDays": 365,
+          "superseded": false
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "prompt-01KTVGB6C2AH6J8YFB0KC1EPYB",
+          "kind": "mission_intent",
+          "text": "Current mission intent: In the dashboard Cockpit page, verify the existing conversation UI quality smoke keeps the single conversation layout, status strip, and safe Draft PR gate visible without changing product behavior. Acceptance: browser smoke passes and evid",
+          "provenance": "operator prompt",
+          "ttlDays": 30,
+          "superseded": false
+        }
+      ],
+      "recentLessons": [
+        {
+          "id": "lesson-0",
+          "kind": "run_lesson",
+          "text": "Draft PR blocked: GEMINI_NOT_CONFIGURED",
+          "provenance": "event:operator.draft_pr_blocked",
+          "ttlDays": 30,
+          "superseded": false
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    "summary": "Worker done, evidence ready, and the Draft PR gate was blocked by policy. No branch push, PR, or merge occurred.",
+    "nextAction": "Continue reviewing evidence, or explicitly enable repo-scoped remote writes before re-checking the gate.",
+    "testMode": true,
+    "userState": {
+      "state": "blocked",
+      "label": "Needs your attention",
+      "labelZh": "需要你处理",
+      "explanation": "系统在这一步暂停，等你看一眼后再继续 · The system paused here and will continue once you take a look."
+    },
+    "lastActivity": {
+      "atIso": "2026-06-11T14:11:02.866Z",
+      "agoMs": 161,
+      "phase": "blocked"
+    },
+    "loopSummary": {
+      "whatChanged": [],
+      "testsRan": [
+        "Test summary"
+      ],
+      "agents": [
+        "planner · test-synthetic",
+        "worker · mock",
+        "validator · gemini"
+      ],
+      "validatorSaid": null,
+      "whyStoppedOrContinuing": "系统在这一步暂停，等你看一眼后再继续 · The system paused here and will continue once you take a look."
+    },
+    "card": {
+      "type": "blocker",
+      "title": "需要你处理 · Needs your attention",
+      "human_explanation": "系统在这一步暂停，等你看一眼后再继续 · The system paused here and will continue once you take a look.",
+      "why_it_matters": "在不确定的时候暂停，比悄悄做错更安全；没有你的确认，任何东西都不会对外发布 · Pausing when unsure is safer than quietly doing the wrong thing; nothing is published without your confirmation.",
+      "recovery_actions": [
+        "查看这张卡的说明，确认是否继续 · Read this card’s explanation and confirm whether to continue.",
+        "随时可以重新开始或调整目标 · You can restart or adjust the goal at any time."
+      ],
+      "recommended_action": "查看这张卡的说明，确认是否继续 · Read this card’s explanation and confirm whether to continue.",
+      "next_step": "查看这张卡的说明，确认是否继续 · Read this card’s explanation and confirm whether to continue.",
+      "machine": {
+        "user_state": "blocked",
+        "stage": "pr_blocked",
+        "hold_code": null,
+        "pr_gate_code": "GEMINI_NOT_CONFIGURED"
+      }
+    }
+  }
+}

evidence/browser-cockpit-quality/2026-06-11T14-10-56-596Z/dom-state-summary.json

@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+{
+  "stage": "pr_blocked",
+  "planner": "mock",
+  "worker": "mock",
+  "prGateCode": "GEMINI_NOT_CONFIGURED"
+}