data(algorand): add verified MCP action links - #3003
Conversation
USS-Supervisor
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Verdict: COMMENT
Risk: LOW
Summary: I reviewed the visible CSV diff and did not find a data-integrity issue in the changed rows, but I cannot approve this cycle because the reviewer-triggered current-cycle link-check did not produce a verifiable completed result within the run window.
Findings: No blocking data finding from the visible diff. Approval is withheld because the current-cycle link-check outcome was indeterminate after the check-links trigger; required validation was already passing, and the pre-cycle link-check state was SKIPPED.
Confidence: MEDIUM
|
Hi @aiirvizionz - this PR is stale, and review should wait until required CI passes. Current blocker: CI not passing: link-check=COMPLETED/SKIPPED. Could you please fix CI and update the PR when it is ready? |
ef62018 to
e7ce907
Compare
e7ce907 to
5999e96
Compare
|
Rebased this PR onto current main and resolved the CSV conflict while preserving the upstream algorand-docs-kapa and tinyman-mcp rows. Commit 5999e96 changes only the three intended MCP action-link rows, and the official isolated JSON validation now passes. Could a maintainer apply the check-links label and re-review this updated head? @USS-Supervisor |
Summary
|
USS-Supervisor
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Verdict: APPROVE
Risk: LOW
Summary: The updated Algorand MCP listing rows keep the existing canonical offer references and fill only the actionButtons cells from the matching canonical offers.
Findings: No blocking findings. CSV width is unchanged, the three touched slugs remain unique, the !offer: references resolve, required validation passed on current head 5999e96c, and current-cycle link-check run 33284660687 completed successfully with 7/7 links and 0 errors/timeouts/unsupported.
Confidence: HIGH
|
Merge follow-up: PRs #3003, #3295, and #3296 now each have a fresh USS-Supervisor APPROVE review, successful isolated validation, and a current-cycle successful link-check with no errors or timeouts. All three heads are mergeable and clean. @eugene17kotov, could you merge these approved scoped data updates when convenient? No author-side changes remain. |
Summary
|
USS-Supervisor
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Verdict: REQUEST_CHANGES
Risk: MEDIUM
Summary: Required validation passed and current-cycle link-check was clean, but one changed listing row violates the current Common Columns rule for actionButtons.
Findings:
- MEDIUM
listings/specific-networks/algorand/mcpservers.csvrow 6:tatum-blockchain-mcpnow has threeactionButtons(Website,Docs, andGitHub). The currentCommon Columnsrule allows at most two buttons, so please keep only the two most useful links here.
Confidence: HIGH
|
Applied the requested correction in commit 9dd52ac: the atum-blockchain-mcp row now keeps only the Website and Docs action buttons, removing the third GitHub button. �alidate_csv.py passes locally; the isolated GitHub validation is queued on the updated head. Please re-review when the check completes. |
|
Verification on current head 9dd52ac: Generate JSON and validate (isolated) is SUCCESS, while link-check remains COMPLETED/SKIPPED. I attempted both the official check-links label and workflow_dispatch; the contributor token is denied by GitHub (AddLabelsToLabelable / repository admin required). Please apply check-links or dispatch link-check-analysis on this exact head, then re-review. No further author-side data change is indicated. |
Summary
|
USS-Supervisor
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Verdict: APPROVE
Risk: LOW
Summary: The updated head narrows to the three Algorand MCP actionButton cells in listings/specific-networks/algorand/mcpservers.csv, and the prior Tatum over-limit issue is fixed.
Findings: None. The CSV parses with 23 columns, the edited rows each have exactly two action buttons, all three !offer references resolve to canonical mcpservers offers, no duplicate listing slugs were introduced, required validation succeeded on head 9dd52ac, and current-cycle link-check run 33910146686 completed successfully with 6/6 links and 0 errors/timeouts/unsupported.
Confidence: HIGH
Summary
Adds verified official website, documentation, and GitHub links to the three existing Algorand MCP listings for AlgoKit ecosystem support, Nansen, and Tatum. No rows, offers, plan metadata, or descriptive fields are changed.
Type of change
Scope
Verification
Validation checklist
The complete official pre-commit workflow passed with exit code 0. The final three-cell diff was manually reviewed.
Optional
0x769f7a238c8874148bcA1aE0736295630C28faF7