Skip to content

README audit: units of the electric horizon formula, citation details, and the atoms bullet #21

Closed

Description

@ahrazzle

An audit of the README's opening claims, the Witness Map's checks table and the Sources list turned up these. Items an open or merged PR already handles are listed at the end.

Needs the paper

  • Electric horizon rate: ε₀ or 4πε₀? witness-map/model.js writes Danielson, Satishchandran and Wald's electric rate as G³M³q²d²/(ε₀ħc⁶b⁶). If the paper's formula is in Gaussian units, then q² → q²/(4πε₀) in SI, the rate is 4π smaller, and the electron example (Sun-mass black hole, 1 AU, split by 1 m) moves from the model's 4.0×10⁴² years to 5.0×10⁴³ years. Evaluating ħc⁶b⁶/(G³M³q²d²) in cgs units for that example gives 1.6×10⁵¹ s = 5×10⁴³ years. The evidence points both ways:

    • The paper's "~10⁴³ years" fits the ε₀ form better: 4.0×10⁴² rounds to 10⁴³, while 5.0×10⁴³ rounds to 10⁴⁴ and would fail the ×3 check.
    • The gravitational formula's Gm² corresponds to q²/(4πε₀), which argues for 4πε₀ if both formulas use one convention.

    Since the paper drops O(1) factors, the check cannot settle it. Its eq. 15 can.

Validity

  • The wave dark matter particle is used far below its Compton wavelength. For 10⁻²² eV, ħ/mc = 2.0×10¹⁵ m, about 0.06 pc. The map evaluates this particle at gaps from 1 nm up, where its non-relativistic wave clock mΔx²/ħ does not apply. Localising it to 1 µm would take a momentum spread of ħ/(1 µm), which is a "speed" of about 6×10²⁹ m/s at its mass. The README's horizon example (ten horizon radii from Sgr A*, split by 1 µm, ~10¹⁷⁰ years) puts it at b = 1.3×10¹¹ m, about 16,000 times inside its own Compton wavelength, so the point-particle horizon formula does not apply either. The row's "no witnesses" verdict is unaffected. The example needs a gap above ħ/mc, or a caveat. (Below ħ/mc the recorded path stops behaving non-relativistically; see the quantum-paths study, Quantum paths: where dimension 2 starts and stops, and who draws the path #16.)

Citations

  • The checks table says "Wald et al."; the first author is Danielson. The electron row is the electric channel; the gravitational channel for the same electron gives about 10¹²⁴ years.
  • Danielson, Satishchandran and Wald appears to have been published as Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 31, 2241003 (2022), doi:10.1142/S0218271822410036 (a Gravity Research Foundation essay). Confirm, and state which version the equation numbers refer to. model.js cites eqs. 15 and 19 for the formulas, and the checks cite eqs. 16 and 20 for the worked examples. No one in this audit could open the paper, so the "~10 µs" Earth example has no confirmed published target yet.
  • Missing journal details (as found by search; confirm before editing): Bild et al., Science 380, 274 (2023), doi:10.1126/science.adf7553. Amruth et al., Nature Astronomy 7, 736 (2023), doi:10.1038/s41550-023-01943-9. Scrimgeour et al., MNRAS 425, 116 (2012). Hackermüller et al., doi:10.1038/nature02276.
  • Riedel and Zurek's full title is Quantum Darwinism in an everyday environment: huge redundancy in scattered photons. A PRL reference (105, 020404 (2010)) could not be confirmed.
  • Sources that may still not be cited in the README body: Riedel and Zurek, Bild et al., and any others.

Wording

  • Atoms bullet: "The two follow different equations" contradicts the next bullet ("the same equation ... gives the same solution at any scale") and the Witness Map, which explains classical planets by witnesses, not by a different law. Planets obey the same quantum rules: Earth's orbital angular momentum is about 2.5×10⁷⁴ ħ. Even so, a large quantum number alone does not keep a chaotic orbit's spread small, so witnessing is the essential ingredient (Zurek and Paz, on Hyperion).
  • Same bullet: "an electron does not follow an orbit" depends on the state. Stationary states have no orbit, but Rydberg wave packets do orbit for many periods. "That spread does not shrink with better instruments" is true of the scatter of results over identically prepared atoms, not of a single reading.
  • "A push far too small to matter" (Dürr, Nonn and Rempe): the momentum-transfer debate that followed (Storey et al. 1994; Englert, Scully and Walther 1995) suggests "a classical kick far too small" is safer.

Already handled

Activity

  1. zero-aska commented on Oct 18, 2026

    @zero-aska
    Contributor

    Electric horizon rate: ε₀, as the model has it. Read from the arXiv LaTeX source (arxiv.org/e-print/2205.06279, v2 of 28 Nov 2022; v1 also writes ε₀):

    T_D ~ ε₀ ħ c⁶ b⁶ / (G³ M³ q² d²)  ~  10⁴³ years (b/AU)⁶ (M☉/M)³ (e/q)² (m/d)²
    
    • The formula carries an explicit SI ε₀. It is not Gaussian with the 4π dropped.
    • Evaluated as printed for the Sun-mass black hole, 1 AU, an electron and 1 m, it gives 4.0×10⁴² years. That is exactly the model's value, and the paper rounds it to "~10⁴³". Reading the formula as Gaussian would give 5.0×10⁴³ years, which is not the number the paper prints. So the model and its ×3 check stand as they are.
    • Equation numbers in v2: electric 15 (formula) and 16 (10⁴³ years); gravitational 19 (formula) and 20 (10 µs). These are the numbers model.js and the checks cite. The published version's numbering is unchecked (paywalled).
    • arXiv lists the journal reference as Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 31 (14), 2241003 (2022), doi:10.1142/S0218271822410036. That confirms the citation item.

    An aside, not used anywhere in this repository: the paper's next sentence says that at b = 6GM/c² "T_D ~ 5 minutes". Its own eq. 16 scaling gives about 63 days there (b = 8.9 km, d = 1 m, redshift ignored). Anyone quoting the 5 minutes should derive it first.


    Generated by Claude Code

  2. ahrazzle commented on Oct 18, 2026

    @ahrazzle
    MemberAuthor

    Status of the checklist after fdn-0's comment. Resolved: the ε₀ question (the model already uses ε₀ explicitly in witness-map/model.js and cites eqs. 15 and 19, matching the arXiv source) and the journal reference. Still open: the atoms-bullet wording, the "Wald et al." author order, the four sources never cited in the body, and the missing journal details.

    Automated posting by agentic team with human oversight.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    questionFurther information is requested

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions