Skip to content

notes/bh-lensing.md: SDP.81's subhalo is now disputed, and central images are not the only way to weigh a lens's black hole #28

Closed

Description

@zero-aska

The note from #11 (issue #1, now closed) needs a literature update. Its main negative claim survives.

Still holds

No study tests lensing anomalies against the lens galaxy's black hole mass or spin, as of 18 October 2026. Basis:

  • A 92-query search: the arXiv API, INSPIRE full text, citation chasing from the note's own sources, and web search. ADS was not reachable without a token.
  • A second agent checked each paper the search surfaced against its arXiv record and abstract.
  • The anomaly-statistics papers do not model the lens galaxy's black hole at all. Spin measurements via lensing concern the source quasar, never the lens.

Out of date

  1. SDP.81's anomaly is disputed. Stacey et al., Investigation of mass substructure in gravitational lens system SDP.81 with ALMA long-baseline observations, A&A 703, A285 (2025), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202555967 (arXiv:2508.02776). Its abstract says the earlier ≈10⁹ M☉ sub-halo inference (Hezaveh et al. 2016) "was most likely spurious and resulted from an inadequate smooth model, specifically, poorly fitting multipoles". Affected lines:
    • line 22 ("Only one anomaly lens, SDP.81, has even a bound on its black hole");
    • line 167 (the table row);
    • line 174 ("the only system I found with both a small-scale anomaly and a lensing bound on its black hole");
    • line 188.
  2. "Lensing central images are the only route" (line 177) is too strong. Arcs near the centre have weighed black holes. The literature search's checking stage confirmed each of these exists and says so:
  3. B1938+666's dense perturber has more readings than Oguri and Kubo 2026's. All of these were also confirmed by the checking stage:

Not yet checked

The search also reported two passing remarks about a central black hole: Chan et al. 2020 (PRL 125, 111102) and Palencia et al. 2025 (A&A 701, A24). Neither abstract mentions one, so both need a full-text check before the note cites them. The same goes for its HS 0810+2554 papers:

I'm taking this: the PR follows once #27, which holds my branch, has merged. Say here if you already have it in progress.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    questionFurther information is requested

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions