You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Witness Map: the hard-sphere gas witness is about 22 times too weak against measured C70 decoherence #48
Question. The Witness Map's gas witness uses a hard-sphere rate: R = n v̄ π (a + r_gas)², with the long-wavelength limit from Schlosshauer 2019 (witness-map/model.js). Molecule interferometry has measured collisional decoherence directly. Should the map test its gas witness against that data, and give polarisable molecules a long-range cross-section?
This came out of the exploration of #39's avenues. It was checked by an independent reproduction and a skeptic who read the paper's table.
The comparison
Hackermüller et al. 2003 (arXiv:quant-ph/0307238), Table 1, print the measured decoherence pressures p₀ of C70 in their Talbot-Lau interferometer: 0.46 to 1.32 × 10⁻⁶ mbar across the gases. Read the paper for the exact definition of p₀.
Run with the map's own hard-sphere gas witness in that geometry, the model gives:
The pressures: 7 to 59 × 10⁻⁶ mbar. Its rate is therefore too low by a geometric-mean factor of about 22 over 9 gases, 24 with the map's own C70 proxy.
Against the paper's own theory: about 16 times too low.
The spread: 8.1-fold from H₂ to Xe, where the measured spread is 2.9-fold. The difference comes from the long-range London (van der Waals) attraction, which a hard sphere leaves out.
Cause. About 17 times of the gap is cross-section physics; the rest is apparatus and residual. Hornberger et al. 2003 (arXiv:quant-ph/0303093) already note that the effective cross-section "exceeds the geometric one by two orders of magnitude".
How much it matters for the map
Probably little. For small separations the relevant (momentum-transfer-weighted) cross-section is only 2 to 4 times geometric, not the total cross-section's ~100.
For C60 at 250 nm, for example:
the gas witness rises from 3.35 × 10⁻³ /s to 0.054–0.074 /s;
that is still below the 900 K glow (0.188 /s);
W rises only 1.26 to 1.37 times, and the main witness does not change.
Not yet checked: every row of the map.
First steps
Add a measured-vs-model check against Table 1 of quant-ph/0307238. Expect a factor of about 22 against measurement and about 16 against the paper's theory, and say so rather than hide it in a tolerance.
Add an optional London cross-section for the gas witness, with C6 from Hornberger et al. 2003.
Recompute the rows with polarisable objects (C60, C70, Rb) using the momentum-transfer-weighted cross-section, and report which labels, if any, move.
Activity