Skip to content
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
5 changes: 5 additions & 0 deletions CORRECTIONS.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -15,3 +15,8 @@ Claims made during the exploration that did not survive it, kept so the record s
checking the grain size.
4. **"Within a factor of 3" of the Joos–Zeh table.** Stated for all three environments. Sunlight is within a
factor of 4.4; the afterglow and air are within 3.

5. **"Dark matter has no witnesses at any gap or particle mass."** Too strong. It holds for wave (fuzzy,
~1e-22 eV) dark matter, which has no gravity-only witnesses besides a black hole horizon. For particle
(~100 GeV) dark matter, gravitational scattering off passing stars is a strong witness at kpc gaps
(W ~ 10^42), so heavy dark matter superpositions cannot persist across galactic scales. Issue 3.
Comment on lines +19 to +22

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Blocking. Two problems. (1) Item 5 already exists on main ("Gas collisions were π times too strong"), and main runs to 20, with #26 and #35 taking 21–26. (2) The heavy dark matter claim, "a strong witness at kpc gaps (W ~ 10^42)", is the one the October reviews rejected. It counts a classical phase as a record, and W scales as bmax² (3.27e42 at 1 kpc, 1.31e43 at 2 kpc). Main's page now gives the opposite reason: the superposition never forms (t_wave ≈ 3.7×10³⁰ ages of the universe). Rework this on main, or drop it.


Generated by Claude Code

6 changes: 4 additions & 2 deletions README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -56,8 +56,10 @@ What it shows:
1. The four objects seen acting as waves in experiments all land on the wave side.
2. Mass enters through the wave clock. Silence the witnesses and big things can cross: a virus in a 4 K
vacuum scores W ≈ 0.04.
3. Dark matter has no witnesses at any gap or particle mass, which is part of what makes a galaxy-sized
dark matter wave possible.
3. Wave (fuzzy) dark matter has no witnesses at any gap, which is part of what makes a galaxy-sized
dark matter wave possible. Particle (heavy, ~100 GeV) dark matter is different: at kpc separations
stellar gravitational scattering is a strong witness (W ~ 10^42), so heavy dark matter
superpositions cannot persist across galactic scales. See notes/gravity-witnesses.md.
Comment on lines +59 to +62

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Blocking. Main no longer has the sentence this edits. #10 replaced point 3 with "A lone dark matter particle has no witnesses at any gap or particle mass ..." plus the crowd-wave caveat (CORRECTIONS 14). The heavy dark matter sentence also contradicts main's index.html, which says a heavy particle is not watched: it never forms a kpc superposition. Any rebase should keep main's point 3, and at most link a corrected note.


Generated by Claude Code

4. A black hole horizon is a real witness (Danielson, Satishchandran and Wald, 2022) but a feeble one:
ten horizon radii from the Milky Way's black hole, a wave dark matter particle split by 1 µm waits about
10¹⁷⁰ years to be recorded.
Expand Down
37 changes: 37 additions & 0 deletions notes/gravity-witnesses.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
# Gravity-only witnesses for dark matter (issue 3)

Dark matter's only witness in the model is a black hole horizon. What other
gravity-only witnesses exist, and how strong are they?

## Candidates and bounds

1. **Gravitational scattering off passing stars and gas clouds.** A passing mass M
at impact parameter b imprints a phase `dphi = G M m dx / (hbar v b)` on a
particle of mass m superposed by dx. Integrating over encounters (saturated
where phase >= 1) gives a rate. For the solar neighbourhood
(n ~ 0.1 pc^-3 stars, M ~ 1 Msun, v ~ 200 km/s, out to ~1 kpc):

- Fuzzy (wave) dark matter, m = 1e-22 eV: W ~ 10^-7 at a 1 kpc gap, ~10^-62
at 1 um. Negligible. The "no witnesses" claim holds for wave dark matter.
- Particle (WIMP) dark matter, m = 100 GeV: W ~ 10^42 at a 1 kpc gap.
Stellar gravity is a strong witness at galactic scales; heavy dark matter
superpositions cannot persist across kpc separations.

Gas clouds (GMCs) give comparable or smaller rates.

2. **Soft graviton emission without a horizon.** A particle in a superposition
is not accelerating in the sense needed for gravitational radiation; any
emission rate scales as G m^2 omega^3 / (hbar c^5) with omega ~ hbar/(m dx^2),
which is astronomically small for both masses. Negligible.

3. **Tidal fields of the galaxy.** A classical tidal field is a c-number: it
does not become entangled with the particle and records no which-path
information. Only quantized (graviton) tides would, which is case 2.
Negligible as a witness.

## Conclusion

Only stellar gravitational scattering matters, and only for particle (heavy)
dark matter at galactic (kpc) separations. Wave (fuzzy) dark matter retains
no gravity-only witnesses besides a black hole horizon, so the model's "dark
matter has no witnesses" statement applies to wave dark matter specifically.
14 changes: 13 additions & 1 deletion tests/checks.mjs
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@
import { createRequire } from 'node:module';
const require = createRequire(import.meta.url);
const W = require('../witness-map/model.js');
const { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, BH_M, RS } = W;
const { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, gravScatter, BH_M, RS } = W;

let fails = 0;
const fmt = x => (x === 0 ? '0' : x.toExponential(2));
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -55,5 +55,17 @@ check('Dark matter has no witnesses without a black hole', ['fdm', 'wimp'].every
check('Planck integral gives the CMB photon density', Math.abs(planckIntegral(2.725, 1, () => 1) / 4.11e8 - 1) < 0.02,
`n = ${fmt(planckIntegral(2.725, 1, () => 1))} per m^3 (expected 4.11e8)`, 'standard value, 411 per cm^3');

// 6. Gravity-only witnesses for dark matter (issue 3): stellar gravitational scattering.
const starN = 0.1 / Math.pow(3.086e16, 3);
const fdmG = gravScatter(1.78e-58, C.kpc, starN, C.Msun, 2e5, C.kpc);
check('Fuzzy dark matter (1e-22 eV): gravity witnesses negligible at 1 kpc', fdmG.W < 1,
`W = ${fmt(fdmG.W)} from stellar scattering`, 'model (issue 3)');
const wimpG = gravScatter(1.78e-25, C.kpc, starN, C.Msun, 2e5, C.kpc);
check('Particle dark matter (100 GeV): stellar gravity is a witness at 1 kpc', wimpG.W > 1,
`W = ${fmt(wimpG.W)} from stellar scattering`, 'model (issue 3)');
Comment on lines +63 to +65

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Blocking. This check enshrines W > 1 from the saturating-phase rule. Under the fix above it should become a regression check that a record stays far below 1 where fringes are measured to survive (the COW and Overstreet geometries). The heavy-mass statement should rest on the wave clock instead.


Generated by Claude Code

const fdmGsmall = gravScatter(1.78e-58, 1e-6, starN, C.Msun, 2e5, C.kpc);
check('Fuzzy dark matter (1e-22 eV): gravity witnesses negligible at 1 um', fdmGsmall.W < 1,
`W = ${fmt(fdmGsmall.W)} from stellar scattering`, 'model (issue 3)');

console.log(fails ? `\n${fails} check(s) failed` : '\nall checks pass');
process.exit(fails ? 1 : 0);
16 changes: 15 additions & 1 deletion witness-map/model.js
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -101,7 +101,21 @@
const tWave = o.m * dx * dx / C.hbar;
return { parts, gamma, tWave, tau: 1 / gamma, W: gamma * tWave, bhNote };
}
// Gravity-only witness for a dark matter particle superposed by dx: gravitational scattering off
// passing masses M (density n, speed v), out to bmax. Phase per encounter at impact b:
// dphi = G M m dx / (hbar v b). info = 1 when b <= bsat (= phase 1) or in the strong regime
// (b <= G M / v^2); otherwise (dphi)^2, integrated logarithmically.
function gravScatter(m, dx, n, M, v, bmax) {
const bsat = C.G * M * m * dx / (C.hbar * v);
const bstrong = C.G * M / (v * v);
const satEnd = Math.min(Math.max(bsat, bstrong), bmax);
const sat = Math.PI * n * v * satEnd * satEnd;
Comment on lines +104 to +112

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Blocking (from the 2026-10-18 reviews, unaddressed). dphi = GMm·dx/(ħvb) is a deterministic phase in the star's classical potential, so it shifts the fringes; it does not record the path. Neutron COW (~59 rad), Asenbaum 2017 and Overstreet 2022 all keep fringes at phases of 1 rad or more. A record needs the difference in the star's recoil, with the star's coherence length as an input. Also, for 100 GeV, bsat ≈ 3.5e43 m ≫ bmax, so sat = π n v bmax² and the result is set by the arbitrary cutoff.


Generated by Claude Code

const log = (satEnd < bmax) ? (2 * Math.PI * n * (C.G * M * m * dx) * (C.G * M * m * dx) / (C.hbar * C.hbar * v)) * Math.log(bmax / satEnd) : 0;
const gamma = sat + log;
const tWave = m * dx * dx / C.hbar;
return { gamma, tWave, W: gamma * tWave, bsat, bstrong };
}
const BH_M = 4.3e6 * C.Msun, RS = 2 * C.G * BH_M / (C.c * C.c);
const api = { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, BH_M, RS, DEFAULT_LOG_GAP: Math.log10(2.5e-7) };
const api = { C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, planckIntegral, gravScatter, BH_M, RS, DEFAULT_LOG_GAP: Math.log10(2.5e-7) };
if (typeof module !== 'undefined' && module.exports) module.exports = api; else root.WM = api;
})(typeof window !== 'undefined' ? window : globalThis);