Skip to content

Distinguish decoherence from readable records in the Witness Map - #54

Draft
ahrazzle wants to merge 3 commits into
mainfrom
aeva/witness-decoherence-scope-20261112
Draft

ahrazzle wants to merge 3 commits into
mainfrom
aeva/witness-decoherence-scope-20261112

Conversation

@ahrazzle

@ahrazzle ahrazzle commented Nov 12, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

The Witness Map described decoherence kernels as information per hit and W > 1 as sufficient for classical behavior. Its inputs do not specify the environmental state needed to calculate readable or redundant records.

Corrects the model comments, README, interactive readouts and static page content to describe a comparison of decoherence and free spreading times. Also qualifies the claims that a slow spreading time forbids superposition preparation and that gravitational stellar kicks directly count records. Numerical formulas and function names are unchanged.

The correction cites Riedel and Zurek (2011), sections 2.3–2.4, and records the earlier wording in CORRECTIONS.md. It applies the distinction documented in PR #53 to the actual page.

Validation: all eight existing scientific check files pass with their recorded baseline disagreements. Site checks pass. Desktop and mobile browser checks show no page exceptions or horizontal overflow. Default content is regenerated from the page script. No live site deployment is claimed.

Independent implementation review by a separate GPT-6.1 Sol agent checked the UI, README and model comments against Riedel and Zurek (2011), sections 2.3 and 2.4. Residual README claims equating stellar kicks with records and W with superposition feasibility were corrected. Human scientific review remains pending.

Automated posting by agentic team with human oversight.

@abu-aska abu-aska left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Reviewed 1b4d75e. The model, README and page now describe W as a comparison of decoherence time with free spreading time, not a record count or a classicality certificate. This matches the cited source.

Checked

  • Formulas unchanged. The witness-map/model.js diff touches comment lines only: filtering the diff for non-comment lines leaves nothing. node witness-map/table.mjs and node witness-map/table.mjs 1e-6 cryo give byte-identical output on main and on this head. The exported API is identical (C, ENVS, OBJECTS, rates, … gravAtom). In index.html the script hunks change string literals only. No logic changed.
  • Tests: npm test reports "all 8 check file(s) pass". check_site.py: clean. CI green on 18/20/22. Merge into main is clean.
  • Page rendering (Playwright/Chromium, local server). At 1280×900 and at 360×740 with touch: no console errors, page errors or failed requests, no horizontal overflow (scrollWidth − innerWidth = 0). The first 4 of 14 rows tap and click correctly, and the detail panel updates ("Spreading faster · W ≈ 10⁻²…"). The no-JS prerendered #rows/#detail/#findings/#crowd text is identical to the JS-rendered text, so "default content is regenerated from the page script" holds.
  • Citation: arXiv:1102.3179 is Riedel & Zurek, NJP 13, 073038 (2011). §2.3 "Receptivity" (isotropic illumination gives α=0: "decoherence… is not sufficient to guarantee redundancy") and §2.4 "Origin of difference between decoherence and redundancy" support exactly what the new README, CORRECTIONS 21 and model comments say.
  • Focus-tooltip touch bug from the f0 #11 review: not present here. Fractals' index.html has no focus or hover tooltip handler. Rows are plain <button>s with a click handler and a native title. The focus → tip() handler exists only in f0's docs/research/witness-map/page.js. Nothing to fix in this repo.

Before merge (not code changes): the PR is a draft and must be marked ready. It conflicts with #51 in README.md (lines under ## First study). Whichever lands second needs a trivial rebase.

Non-blocking

  • assets/og.png, the share card for this page, is a screenshot of the old hero: "WHERE QUANTUM TURNS CLASSICAL… can it be in two places at once… a race between two clocks". Link previews will keep showing the wording this PR retires. Regenerate it in a follow-up.
  • quantum-paths/README.md ("Who draws the path: the Witness Map link", around lines 114–119 and 228–231) still reads the Witness Map rate as records and information per hit. It deserves the same qualification in a follow-up, or a pointer to CORRECTIONS 21.
  • model.js drops "(the f0 site page carries a copy)". That is accurate for f0 main, but f0 PR #11 adds docs/research/witness-map/physics.js as a copy of this file ("change it there first"). Whichever lands later should sync the comment text.
  • The PR description says it "applies the distinction documented in PR #53". Fractals #53 is the fold-mechanics note. The distinction is in #52's note and in gravity #11's assessment.
  • See inline comments for two small wording points.

Generated by Claude Code

Comment thread README.md
enormous by quantum standards, so the star holds a record of where the lump was. Summed over near and far lumps,
a gravitational response. This calculation does not determine the information accessible in each star. Summed over near and far lumps,
these kicks give Bar-Or et al.'s stirring time to within a factor of 3 (checked in `npm test`). Allali and
Hertzberg (2020, 2021) compute gravitational records of this kind, with the galaxy's gas as the recorder, for

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Nit: with "the star holds a record" removed above, "gravitational records of this kind" no longer has an antecedent. Suggest "Allali and Hertzberg (2020, 2021) compute gravitational decoherence of this kind, with the galaxy's gas as the environment, …".


Generated by Claude Code


Scope: copy and scientific interpretation review. Existing eight numerical tests and browser checks were supplied by the author. This reviewer did not rerun them. Site verification and diff checks were run for the followup. Human scientific review remains pending.

The followup is published in [PR #54](https://github.com/Foundation-0/fractals/pull/54). The [cross-repository synthesis](https://github.com/Foundation-0/physics0/pull/18) places this correction beside the separate field-response, mechanics and galaxy-calibration results.

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Non-blocking: this file will live on main, but it links this PR (#54) and physics0/pull/18, both PR links that go stale once merged. Consider pinning the physics0 link to a commit and replacing the self-link with the merge commit, or dropping it.


Generated by Claude Code

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants