Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension


Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
6 changes: 6 additions & 0 deletions README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -46,3 +46,9 @@ All Python scripts use only the Python 3 standard library. Each certificate file
- `METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md` -- Numerical methods, parameter assumptions, error-model caveats (`M-01`..`M-10`), and canonical checksum table.
- `RESEARCH_NOTEBOOK_AND_REASONING.md` -- Complete reasoning trail, rejected operator dead ends, tangential WHIM/entropy-floor realizations, Cosmic-Dawn quasar confrontation, and next-agent handoff queue.
- `CHANGELOG.md` -- Reconciled chronological history across Waves 1-12 matching `CLAIMS.md` and code identifiers.

## AeST response benchmark and independent checks

The [AeST response benchmark](research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md) constructs allowed field preparations on a specified expanding background and a flat-space control. It includes the canonical map, executable response checks and a bounded pressure-closure comparison.

A separate Astra agent reproduced the scalar constraint and kinetic structure from an independent ADM action. A separately declared slow-subspace test and its independent five-field replay are complete. The simple zero-pressure closure still fails for this specified benchmark.
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion SHA256SUMS
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ a44b03375f26452e66aac5324199e41aeb77092c668dbc2adf0342caccb32a7c results/wave3_
dd37a45adcb3c815d1a2d44bbbb58ac0235b9ea30d58d6b5a3438a46d91c874e results/wave10_covariant_jeans_certificates.json
fed7d58b8959cc68073bbf2020c7dca895fb4bac0b07adb9d95c3bee56d1c94b results/wave11_machian_pairing_certificates.json
78b988c2a6a83f23a8dc637626fdc63b9122579c2c3e37eaf9365deb2539ca79 results/wave12_cosmic_dawn_quasar_certificates.json
4e582635e017f1c5c6183e1b9aead3689d73472c2fa09d2f88480ae2f6161e90 README.md
0b347aed25506d2f489946ff54277df30522ec4f142963725a10503f1e4592c1 README.md
10c8b2afeb2837e8b3f031c3da92c6460fa09b23ef27e3f9971b2f8a908ae1a4 CLAIMS.md
ecdb12077d8ddfb1b8a787064f07e5028adcd308c6a11274600e596f8e4a6bd7 METHODS_AND_PLAYBOOK.md
3e512058fd3107ccd904bb8bfa58ea0c2e168fd053b0c05b0b891030d10e701f RESEARCH_NOTEBOOK_AND_REASONING.md
Expand Down
3 changes: 3 additions & 0 deletions research/aest-response-gate-20261112/.gitignore
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
__pycache__/
*.py[cod]
.venv/
95 changes: 95 additions & 0 deletions research/aest-response-gate-20261112/README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,95 @@
# AeST constraint and response benchmark

This benchmark constructs physical scalar perturbations of one specified AeST action. On an expanding background, states with the same initial density, momentum and metric produce different pressure and later gravitational potentials. A flat-space control explains why the same field freedom has no linear gravitational response at zero background density.

**Status:** action-derived calculation checked by a separate Astra agent using an independently reduced ADM action. [The review](independent-review/REVIEW.md) found no blocking error. This is internal project review, not external peer review or a nonlinear collapse, thermalization or observational result.

The complete action, conventions, constraints and equations are in [derivation.md](derivation.md). The test choices and the approximation threshold are in [protocol.md](protocol.md). The equations build on published AeST work listed in [sources.json](sources.json). No new propagating mode or new Minkowski stability bound is claimed.

## What was calculated

The full function is \(\mathcal F=(2-K_B)\lambda_s\mathcal Y-2\mathcal K_2(\mathcal Q-Q_0)^2\), with \(K_B=1\), \(\lambda_s=1\), and \(\mathcal K_2=2\). The expanding background has \(Q=Q_0+0.01Q_0a^{-3}\), no matter and no cosmological constant. Evolution covers \(a=1\) to \(a=2\).

For five wave numbers \(k/Q_0=6,9,12,18,24\), three preparations were evolved. One changes scalar and vector velocities while compensating their initial density source. A second changes the field phase while also matching initial pressure. The third is a held-out linear mixture of the first two.

All three initially match effective density and momentum. They satisfy the lapse, momentum and unit-vector constraints. The scalar auxiliary field changes consistently. Gauge-invariant field data distinguish the preparations.

The first preparation has \(\Delta\gamma_i=\epsilon Q_0\), \(\epsilon=10^{-6}\). Define \(D=8\pi\widetilde G\delta\rho\), \(m=K'\varphi\) and \(p=8\pi\widetilde G\delta P\). Their units are \(Q_0^2,Q_0,Q_0^2\), respectively. Maximum responses over the interval are:

| \(k/Q_0\) | \(\max|D|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)\) | \(\max|m|/(\epsilon Q_0)\) | \(\max|p|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)\) | \(\max|\Phi+\Psi|/\epsilon\) |
|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| 6 | 0.099124 | 0.0077392 | 0.040067 | 0.0043004 |
| 9 | 0.103737 | 0.0052054 | 0.040031 | 0.0019747 |
| 12 | 0.105312 | 0.0039056 | 0.040005 | 0.0011240 |
| 18 | 0.106352 | 0.0025971 | 0.040000 | 0.0005040 |
| 24 | 0.106641 | 0.0019431 | 0.040000 | 0.0002844 |

These are transfer amplitudes for the declared preparation. They are not predictions for an astrophysical perturbation spectrum. The metric sum is the potential combination entering weak gravitational lensing, not an integrated light-ray observable.

The second preparation has \(D_i=m_i=p_i=0\), but a nonzero pressure derivative. At \(k/Q_0=12\), it reaches \(\max|D|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)=0.527669\) and \(\max|\Phi+\Psi|/\epsilon=0.00903245\). Its field-phase amplitude is \(\chi_i=\epsilon Q_0/\sqrt{3k^2/4+2Q_0^2}\).

Thus density and momentum do not predict every allowed preparation. Adding instantaneous pressure still leaves an independent preparation that changes its future derivative. The four-state variables \((D,m,\chi,Z)\), where \(Z=E+\chi\) for this branch, supply an exact linear evolution law.

## Checks and limits

| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Action lapse equation and canonical compensation | Symbolic residual zero |
| Constraint propagation | \(\dot C+3HC=0\), symbolically |
| Effective energy balance and spatial Einstein equation | Symbolic residual zero |
| Fifteen expanding preparations | Largest normalized constraint residual \(5.20\times10^{-12}\) |
| Five-field versus four-state evolution | Largest normalized difference \(5.49\times10^{-11}\) |
| Integrator tolerance \(10^{-8},10^{-10},10^{-12}\) | Constraint residual falls from \(2.82\times10^{-10}\) to \(2.86\times10^{-14}\) |
| Amplitudes \(10^{-7},10^{-6},10^{-5}\) | Normalized response agrees within recorded numerical error |
| Flat-space exact matrix exponential versus ODE | Relative error below \(1.6\times10^{-10}\) over ten periods |
| Flat-space quadratic energy | Relative drift below \(1.3\times10^{-12}\) |

The exact expanding solution for \(a(t)\) is checked independently. The scalar kinetic Hessian and short-wavelength characteristic have the required positive signs in the author derivation.

The separate review reproduces the scalar kinetic Hessian and integrates the ADM equations, matching eight reconstructed observables to 1.06e-12 normalized error. The test does not prove nonlinear stability or stability of an observationally fitted cosmology.

For \(q_i=0\), the compensated field mode oscillates but its linear density, momentum, pressure and metric response vanish identically. The scalar shift current remains nonzero. It must not be identified with stress-energy momentum.

At a fixed duration \(Q_0t=1\), reducing the initial density gives the following velocity-preparation response at \(k/Q_0=6\):

| \(q_i/Q_0\) | \(\max|D|/(\epsilon Q_0^2)\) | \(\max|\delta\rho/\bar\rho|/\epsilon\) | \(\max|\Phi+\Psi|/\epsilon\) |
|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| 0.01 | 0.0991240 | 3.05744 | 0.00316730 |
| 0.001 | 0.0119935 | 3.21476 | 0.000349006 |
| 0.0001 | 0.00127788 | 3.26705 | 0.0000360307 |
| 0.00001 | 0.000130421 | 3.28381 | 0.00000364003 |

Absolute sources tend to zero. The density-contrast response stays finite because its background denominator also tends to zero. A claim that small background sound speed suppresses preparation effects must state which field amplitudes and which observable normalization are held fixed.

## A bounded approximation test

Two unfitted prescriptions were tested: zero pressure perturbation and \(\delta P=c_{\rm ad}^2\delta\rho\). Both keep the exact expanding background. Initial density contrast is \(10^{-5}\), with the explicitly defined dust-inspired momentum in the protocol. This is not an exact AeST growing eigenmode.

Independent hidden velocity and phase data have relative amplitudes \(\eta=0,0.01,0.1,1\). Each comparison uses the same initial retained density and momentum. The 1% target for density contrast and metric potential was fixed before evaluating the approximations. Errors are divided by the maximum corresponding observable in the zero-pressure reference over \(1\leq a\leq2\).

| Hidden amplitude \(\eta\) | Distinct preparations | Worst density error, zero pressure | Worst metric error, zero pressure | Worst density error, adiabatic pressure | Worst metric error, adiabatic pressure |
|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| 0 | 5 | 28.67% | 28.67% | 127.97% | 184.67% |
| 0.01 | 10 | 37.41% | 43.79% | 188.18% | 216.20% |
| 0.1 | 10 | 627.24% | 627.39% | 765.66% | 785.69% |
| 1 | 10 | 6530.40% | 6531.65% | 6668.82% | 6670.95% |

Neither prescription passes the declared 1% criterion for any of these 35 preparations. Large percentages compare small linear perturbations. They do not imply nonlinear amplitudes or a failure of all dust approximations. A different action, a colder background or a verified slow-mode initial ensemble requires its own test.

## Reproduce

Create an isolated Python environment, install [requirements.txt](requirements.txt), and run:

```sh
python response.py --output results.json
```

The [script](response.py) includes assertions. The [results](results.json) retain all preparation values, residuals, amplitude controls and approximation errors. No network request, downloaded dataset, fitting stage or graphical dependency is needed.

The bounded result supports retaining the additional scalar/vector response data before a nonlinear solver is attempted.

The [slow-subspace continuation](slow-mode/RESULTS.md) removes initial fast components and tests controlled leakage. Its zero-pressure baseline errors remain 24.6–27.4% for this fixed benchmark.

A [separate review](slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md) reproduces all 65 preparations and 130 closure errors using the original five-field equations. This closes the specified same-action test. A three-dimensional collapse experiment remains unstarted.

The derivation is retained byte-for-byte at its reviewed hash, including its original pre-review status. The review linked above supersedes that status. Run `python independent-review/adm_check.py` for the separate action reduction and comparison.
23 changes: 23 additions & 0 deletions research/aest-response-gate-20261112/SHA256SUMS
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
22bc478fc0eb97818e8c2efd9a6c8f9dce55490bdd8074a3f2b6b8653c5c12d5 .gitignore
b23164c524bfe6a8da825eb6fdb8512305d8bacbdd92dee0ac8959c674eb6c1b README.md
5700296d3d35b09b6101f8695dd57abfc86863a3287f9f050beb2828513a93fe derivation.md
58f56124bef156d5a8e22d0bd4eaab695c4ac0540f0e211e63f5e99ff4bc10e7 independent-review/REVIEW.md
ab32294e143f463d1d80026f3d70ee23dff22facd159bcdf86889a236aea8def independent-review/adm-evidence.json
0e46bfdf9f34b8f0be33b9c3f465e5c1eb2730a254f5f27a7b02f1216456c4c6 independent-review/adm_check.py
f90522170c4ea67d2601e8c099216ff992a5d3b94a43c0322da87c03f6e9facc protocol.md
ebab51ac1b6420faa2394d3deaba33637ddfff96456fe15406991f12d5a227f2 requirements.txt
e28c8f4ada1e41924e6317f8932de4d065307516cd57c5ff83a0cf23b72397ef response.py
c82b4e1c64da797e5a701f698808b7074c780778306cb6622721011403573602 results.json
e18a17694fd46609e2574f680d6fd5a0d870295cf3f030b2a1da3d5d0187c9a9 slow-mode/GROWING-MODE-PROTOCOL.md
efe19e6cb78f46af8d612b4ab0188981f711604b6aa4755cf287e62a540d1fc7 slow-mode/PROTOCOL.md
4db8ba576047fcc296e7f99556ba2ab31121fb93d31ac7d9cd81c30296a2883e slow-mode/RESULTS.md
a911f5403aba4de34603c457e6ea2edf452b036c9116cb183993c08eae629f22 slow-mode/checkpoint.json
cc1e24085ca282198798514f01946c338b3df4f715ff7a694b0d8402f567d054 slow-mode/evidence.json
a6fcac897f513934a9f7d8ed837f4d7a35842a607adc06368b15fbfef4297b2f slow-mode/independent-review/REVIEW.md
108ab8738016ea097ac7a190a1ec501b50b1ddc261c7b7530b221607aba62b03 slow-mode/independent-review/check.py
81ccf47780b498c11361895361bb296cabda437648b9b025216bea6427ee393d slow-mode/independent-review/checkpoint.json
e86be2518a2b7fa9c3debbc4536feb7008299efea05a83ce3537e45c6a6a9def slow-mode/independent-review/evidence.json
af9d4443c45298d723384ad0283bb8a635944fe347fd2067e3f4699ea94b2151 slow-mode/probe.py
71a3187c110e66993bd3fd035b0f4abd041146c5ca74e983cbed2aa29ea46098 slow-mode/selection-failure.json
368230772939461a5a10c6ff0552c5aeb6375068660f45efd8a8403992ebd605 slow-mode/selection_failure.py
6f11f6b728915532867b3d61ac4d2eb34dc40fd090dd29e4e177406065a277c4 sources.json
Loading