You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
On my NK3 PIV I would like to import a P12 which contains a private key and an S/Mime Cert. This is currently not possible (denied with operation not supported).
While I understand that a private key should live and die on a device only, this is not very budget friendly. It forces me to buy multiple S/Mime certs for one email address as I need a private key and certificate request per device. Assume that I like to have my S/Mime cert on multiple devices for backup and convenience reasons.
Yubikeys allow the user to import P12 files with cert and private key which originates elsewhere. So I only have to pay for one cert and can use it on multiple devices.
found another one requesting this feature - leaving this comment here to underline that..
others: please +1 the initial post to show your support for such a feature
given importing keypairs is part of the piv spec I'm a bit surprised this isn't supported by nitrokey yet - as in: nitrokey is around 10 years providing hardware following a 20 year old spec
nothin against nitrokey - but for the time its around I expected it a bit closer to what yubico provides with thier keys - but I got fooled already by investing in a solokey (which is dead and had thier piv disabled/removed because they only ever got a beta stage) - currently have my eyes on swissbit and token2 (via the latter I found the fido-bridge app which allows fido2 resident token via nfc on android - somthing android and the chrome browser should provide out of the box but doesn't due to some google foo)
It appears that FIPS 201 prohibits external key generation, at least for auth and sig keys. This may be one reason for Yubico to offer FIPS compliant yubikeys also.
Activity
daringer commentedon Jan 27, 2026
found another one requesting this feature - leaving this comment here to underline that..
others: please +1 the initial post to show your support for such a feature
n0xena commentedon Jan 27, 2026
given importing keypairs is part of the piv spec I'm a bit surprised this isn't supported by nitrokey yet - as in: nitrokey is around 10 years providing hardware following a 20 year old spec
nothin against nitrokey - but for the time its around I expected it a bit closer to what yubico provides with thier keys - but I got fooled already by investing in a solokey (which is dead and had thier piv disabled/removed because they only ever got a beta stage) - currently have my eyes on swissbit and token2 (via the latter I found the fido-bridge app which allows fido2 resident token via nfc on android - somthing android and the chrome browser should provide out of the box but doesn't due to some google foo)
orolhawion commentedon Jan 27, 2026
It appears that FIPS 201 prohibits external key generation, at least for auth and sig keys. This may be one reason for Yubico to offer FIPS compliant yubikeys also.