Skip to content

feat: [V3 PM] Ship CLI/MCP PM harness parity and conformance benchmarks#883

Merged
StatPan merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
issue-868-v3-pm-ship-cli-mcp-pm-harness-parity-and-conformance-benchmarks
Jul 18, 2026
Merged

feat: [V3 PM] Ship CLI/MCP PM harness parity and conformance benchmarks#883
StatPan merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
issue-868-v3-pm-ship-cli-mcp-pm-harness-parity-and-conformance-benchmarks

Conversation

@StatPan

@StatPan StatPan commented Jul 18, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Closes #868

@StatPan

StatPan commented Jul 18, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Check

Self-review packet for ticket #868 and PR #883.

  • PR readiness: ready_for_finish
  • Finish ready: true
  • Diff summary: 19 files changed, +958/-18
    • docs-site/command-capabilities.md: +2/-0
    • docs-site/command-reference.md: +64/-0
    • docs/cli-mcp-workflow-parity.md: +19/-0
    • docs/mcp-agent-workflow-best-practices.md: +6/-0
    • docs/mcp-read-only-surface.md: +20/-4
    • docs/pm-operating-policy.md: +24/-2
    • docs/v3-pm-harness-release-readiness.md: +72/-0
    • internal/cli/cli.go: +120/-1
    • internal/cli/pm_compile_cli_test.go: +16/-0
    • internal/cli/pm_harness_cli_test.go: +52/-0
    • internal/gira/command_registry.go: +14/-0
    • internal/gira/mcp.go: +18/-0
    • internal/gira/mcp_auth.go: +49/-11
    • internal/gira/mcp_auth_test.go: +3/-0
    • internal/gira/mcp_test.go: +24/-0
    • internal/gira/pm_compile.go: +3/-0
    • internal/gira/pm_compile_test.go: +13/-0
    • internal/gira/pm_harness.go: +364/-0
    • internal/gira/pm_harness_test.go: +75/-0
  • Acceptance mapping candidates:
    • MCP remains an adapter and cannot invent lifecycle or PM semantics absent from the core. -> manual verification required
    • A caller cannot apply a stale or uncompiled PM plan through supported V3 paths. -> manual verification required
    • Bootstrap provides enough bounded context to resume without hidden thread memory. -> manual verification required
    • Conformance reports distinguish protocol compliance from semantic answer quality. -> manual verification required
    • Human CLI operation remains complete without MCP or an LLM. -> manual verification required
    • Two AI host/model runs complete the same fixtures with recorded failures and no unsafe mutation. -> manual verification required
    • Privacy rules prohibit secrets, private transcript capture, worker ranking, and token-spend productivity scoring. -> manual verification required
    • V3 release checklist includes compatibility, docs, dogfood, and rollback evidence. -> docs-site/command-capabilities.md, docs-site/command-reference.md, docs/cli-mcp-workflow-parity.md, docs/mcp-agent-workflow-best-practices.md, docs/mcp-read-only-surface.md, docs/pm-operating-policy.md, docs/v3-pm-harness-release-readiness.md
  • Risk areas: Go runtime code changed, distribution or release path changed, documentation changed, security-sensitive files changed
  • Full diff: gh pr diff 883 --repo StatPan/gira

Reviewer notes:

  • Findings: none recorded by this self-review command.
  • Test gaps: verify local and CI evidence before finish.
  • Recommended action: continue normal review/check/finish flow.

Context:

@StatPan
StatPan merged commit ad41e76 into main Jul 18, 2026
11 checks passed
@StatPan
StatPan deleted the issue-868-v3-pm-ship-cli-mcp-pm-harness-parity-and-conformance-benchmarks branch July 18, 2026 18:46
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

[V3 PM] Ship CLI/MCP PM harness parity and conformance benchmarks

1 participant