Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
12 changes: 10 additions & 2 deletions docs/brains/repo/MOC.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -47,6 +47,16 @@ reads this section to seed the autotrain hypothesis loop and prunes it as
space + complete bridge supervision? (see valid-edit flow project)
- [[recursive-depth-supervision-objective]] — arithmetic/compatibility contract
is supported; real-suite mode selection remains open.
- [[recursive-recurrence-health]] — **updated 2026-07-25 (SLM-421)**: the n=2
SLM-282 negative was underpowered noise, not a robust contraction
violation. A powered n=20 Wilson-interval rerun (fresh disjoint seeds,
preregistered `min_pass_rate=0.5` locked before observing them) found
`recursive_core_positive` (18/20, Wilson 95% CI [0.699, 0.972]). This
satisfies only one of PR #853-#856's two LAR3 reopening conditions; LAR3
stays closed pending a powered rerun of SLM-317's value gate (blocked —
that harness is not yet merged to `main`). Next open question: land
SLM-317's harness on `main` (via its own PR #852) so its value gate can
get the same powered-rerun treatment.

## Dead ends (do not re-propose)

Expand All @@ -55,5 +65,3 @@ hypothesis loop's novelty audit can exclude them.

- _(seed)_ E249 / E252 local-preference chain — negative; see
[`research-lineage.md`](../../design/research-lineage.md) "Exact-state local decision preference".
- [[recursive-recurrence-health]] — negative: seed 1 / R=4 / example `b`
regressed at the final depth, so the LAR3 activation prerequisite failed.
41 changes: 32 additions & 9 deletions docs/brains/repo/recursive-recurrence-health.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,10 +1,11 @@
---
type: concept
status: dead-end
status: active
tags: [recurrence, diagnostics, fixture]
created: 2026-07-23
linear: SLM-282
design: docs/design/iter-slm282-recurrence-health-20260723.md
updated: 2026-07-25
linear: SLM-282, SLM-421
design: docs/design/iter-slm282-recurrence-health-20260723.md, docs/design/iter-slm282-recurrence-health-powered-rerun-20260725.md
sources: "[[deeploop-source]], [[training-free-looped-transformers-source]], https://arxiv.org/abs/2106.14342"
---

Expand Down Expand Up @@ -32,9 +33,31 @@ non-finite, or if matched initialization/data/optimizer controls diverge.

## Status & next step

Negative. Only seed 0 passed. For seed 1 / R=4 / example `b`, CE regressed from
`17.487688` at depth 3 to `17.855324` at depth 4, so the two-seed prerequisite
failed even though the token-weighted aggregate improved. All required
telemetry was finite, but several local directional gains also exceed one.
Do not activate LAR3 from this result; no ship, checkpoint, or
production-default claim follows.
**SLM-282 (n=2, 2026-07-23): negative.** Only seed 0 passed. For seed 1 / R=4 /
example `b`, CE regressed from `17.487688` at depth 3 to `17.855324` at depth
4, so the fixed two-of-two-seed prerequisite failed even though the
token-weighted aggregate improved. All required telemetry was finite, but
several local directional gains also exceed one. This n=2 record is immutable
and remains the historical evidence — PR #853/#854/#855/#856 correctly cited
it (alongside SLM-317's inconclusive value gate) to gate-close LAR3-01..04 as
`not_authorized`.

**SLM-421 (n=20, powered rerun, 2026-07-25): `recursive_core_positive`.** The
fixed 2-seed rule could not distinguish a real contraction violation from
fixture-scale noise, so SLM-421 added an additive Wilson-interval `power_rule`
to the same unchanged harness/model/data recipe and reran on 20 fresh seeds
(2..21, disjoint from SLM-282's 0/1) with a preregistered `min_pass_rate=0.5`
locked before any of those seeds were observed. Observed: 18/20 passed
(rate 0.90, Wilson 95% CI [0.699, 0.972]) — the lower bound clears 0.5, so the
`recursive_core_positive` LAR3-reopening condition is now satisfied for this
`as_is` shared_recursive-tower fixture configuration. The seed-1 regression
that drove the SLM-282 negative reads as fixture-scale noise at n=2, not a
systematic property of the core.

**Net effect on LAR3**: only one of the two PR #853-#856 reopening conditions
is now met. LAR3 stays closed — the second condition (a passing SLM-317-style
valid-state repair advancement screen) is untouched by this issue; SLM-317's
own harness is not yet merged to `main`, so its powered rerun is a separate,
not-yet-landable follow-up. No ship, checkpoint, or production-default claim
follows from either record; residual_delta remains a fixture-only
counterfactual, never a production default.
Loading
Loading