Skip to content

[TM23] Geoscience - deprecations - #1120

Open
aothms wants to merge 10 commits into
ifc4.4-mainfrom
tm23
Open

[TM23] Geoscience - deprecations#1120
aothms wants to merge 10 commits into
ifc4.4-mainfrom
tm23

Conversation

@aothms

@aothms aothms commented Jun 4, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator
tm23

Description: "Joint with point 22 above, some existing entities were deprecated."

Scrope: "ENTITY IfcGeomodel, ENTITY IfcGeoslice, ENTITY IfcGeotechnicalAssembly, ENTITY IfcGeotechnicalElement, ENTITY IfcGeotechnicalStratum, TYPE IfcGeotechnicalStratumTypeEnum"

(Personal note: seems drastic to deprecate such a large tree of elements with associated property sets. Have all these psets/qsets been reviewed so that their semantics have found a new place? For export, deprecation essentially means deletion, the compatibility folks are not going to like this. I think there needs to be more guidance on how to migrate. Just a statement to use IfcGeoScienceModel/-Element/-Feature seems insufficient.)

@evandroAlfieri evandroAlfieri added 4.4 Identifies PR in scope for 4.4 update ready-for-review Identifies PR for 4.4 update that are ready to be reviewed labels Jun 4, 2026
@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Jun 4, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

PR Validation -- schema generators

Checks:

  • ✓ EXPRESS schema valid
  • ✓ New entities present in structure.json
  • ✓ MD docs for new entities
  • ✓ PEnum convention
  • ✓ New UML Psets/Qtos emitted
  • ✓ Modified psets emitted
  • ✓ Schema SHACL validation

Detected:

  • New entities: (none)
  • New PEnums: (none)
  • New UML Psets/Qtos: (none)
  • UML files changed (1): IfcSharedInfrastructureElements.uml
  • MD docs changed (5): IfcGeomodel.md, IfcGeoslice.md, IfcGeotechnicalAssembly.md, IfcGeotechnicalElement.md, IfcGeotechnicalStratum.md
📋 EXPRESS schema diff (baseline vs PR head)

Express schema differences

0 items

Missing data

🎉 No issues 🎉

Type definitions

🎉 No issues 🎉

Entity definitions

🎉 No issues 🎉

Constraints

🎉 No issues 🎉

SHACL validation report

DefinitionForEnumLiteral

  • The resource 'IfcBridgePartTypeEnum.SURFACESTRUCTURE' has no definition
  • The resource 'IfcRailwayPartTypeEnum.DILATIONTRACK' has no definition

DefinitionForPropertyOrQuantity

  • The Property 'Pset_AirSideSystemInformation.AirFlowSensible' has no definition
  • The Property 'Pset_AirSideSystemInformation.TotalAirFlow' has no definition
  • The Property 'Pset_AirTerminalBoxPHistory.AirFlowCurve' has no definition
  • The Property 'Pset_AirTerminalOccurrence.AirFlowType' has no definition
  • The Property 'Pset_AirToAirHeatRecoveryTypeCommon.PrimaryAirFlowRateRange' has no definition
  • The Property 'Pset_AirToAirHeatRecoveryTypeCommon.SecondaryAirFlowRateRange' has no definition
  • The Property 'Pset_SpaceThermalPHistory.ExhaustAirFlowRate' has no definition
  • The Property 'Qto_WallBaseQuantities.GrossFootPrintArea' has no definition
  • The Property 'Qto_WallBaseQuantities.NetFootPrintArea' has no definition

DefinitionForResource

  • The resource 'IfcSurfaceFeature' has no definition
  • The resource 'IfcURIReference' has no definition

LeafEntityHasPredefinedType

  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcAlignmentCant' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcAlignmentHorizontal' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcAlignmentSegment' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcAlignmentVertical' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcAsset' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcBorehole' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcBuilding' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcBuildingStorey' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcCivilElement' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcDistributionCircuit' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcGeomodel' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcGeoslice' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcSite' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralCurveConnection' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralCurveMemberVarying' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralLinearAction' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralLoadCase' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralPlanarAction' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralPointAction' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralPointConnection' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralPointReaction' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralResultGroup' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralSurfaceConnection' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcStructuralSurfaceMemberVarying' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcWallStandardCase' has no PredefinedType attribute
  • Leaf IfcObject 'IfcZone' has no PredefinedType attribute

PropertyForDefinition

  • For document 'AcidityConcentration.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'ActualWork.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AdjustmentRange.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AdjustmentRangeStepValue.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AdjustmentValues.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AdmixturesDescription.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AffectsSurroundings.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'Aggregation.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AirflowCurve.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AirflowSensible.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AirflowType.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AlkalinityConcentration.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AppearanceGrade.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'ApplicableStructuralDesignMethod.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'Area.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'Arrangement.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'AssessmentOfRisk.md/a/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'BaseChamfer.md/b/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'BearingStrength.md/b/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'BoilingPoint.md/b/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'BottomCover.md/b/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CO2Content.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'COContent.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CarbonContent.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CenterCoreBaseHeight.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CenterCoreBaseWidth.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CenterCoreMiddleHeight.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CenterCoreSpacing.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CenterCoreTopHeight.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CenterCoreTopWidth.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CentreOfGravityInX.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CentreOfGravityInY.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CombustionTemperature.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CompStrength.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CompStrengthPerp.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CompactedVolume.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CompressiveStrength.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'Condition.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CoreBaseHeight.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CoreBaseWidth.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CoreMiddleHeight.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CoreSpacing.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CoreTopHeight.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CoreTopWidth.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'Count.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CrossSectionArea.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'CurrentCarryingCapasity.md/c/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'DefinitionType.md/d/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'DimensionalChangeCoefficient.md/d/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'DissolvedSolidsContent.md/d/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'DraftBaseOffset.md/d/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'DraftSideOffset.md/d/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'DynamicViscosity.md/d/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'EavesHeight.md/e/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'EdgeDraft.md/e/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'ExhaustAirFlowRate.md/e/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'Exponent.md/e/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'FinishCeilingHeight.md/f/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'FinishFloorHeight.md/f/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'FlangeBaseFillet.md/f/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'FlangeChamfer.md/f/properties/docs' a property cannot be found
  • For document 'FlangeDepth.md/f

SHACL report truncated -- full report in the workflow artifact bundle.

See workflow run for failure details.

@evandroAlfieri evandroAlfieri moved this from RESOLVING to SOLUTION | PUBLIC REVIEW in IFC4x-IF | 4.4 update Jun 9, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

4.4 Identifies PR in scope for 4.4 update ready-for-review Identifies PR for 4.4 update that are ready to be reviewed

Projects

Status: SOLUTION | PUBLIC REVIEW

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants