Repository navigation
mutation-model: indirect-ownership self-test pins a test that stopped reaching scroll-edge-state #2547
Description
Purpose
mutation-model — the mutation harness self-test inside pnpm check:affected — fails on a clean origin/main checkout, so any contributor whose diff selects that check sees a red local gate for a reason unrelated to their work. It hit #2533 and #2521 during wave 1 of #2531.
Reproduce
pnpm install --frozen-lockfile
pnpm mutation:test
# or, as check:affected selects it:
pnpm check:affected --run # → check:affected: mutation-model failed.ℹ pass 39
ℹ fail 1
✖ a kernel is owned by tests that reach it indirectly
AssertionError [ERR_ASSERTION]: The expression evaluated to a falsy value:
at scripts/mutation/ownership.test.ts:40:10
The other 39 assertions in that file pass, including ownership is complete: every test reaching a kernel owns it.
Root cause
scripts/mutation/ownership.test.ts:40-44 pins src/commands/interaction/runtime/gestures.test.ts as an indirect owner of the scroll-edge-state kernel. That kernel is packages/capture-kit/src/snapshot/scroll-edge-state.ts plus packages/capture-kit/src/snapshot/scroll-edge-state/selection.ts.
gestures.test.ts no longer imports anything on the scroll path: its resolved import graph is 257 modules and contains neither kernel source, so ownersOf returns kernel-errors, interaction-settle, selectors, target-annotation-serde, snapshot-occlusion and no scroll-edge-state. Scroll moved out of the interaction command family — src/daemon/scroll-runtime.ts was added by bcca714a07 ("refactor: move gesture family to platform runtime", #1952) and the snapshot zone relocation landed in 1f9d940bff (#2385) — and the ownership assertion was never moved with it.
The kernel itself is not uncovered: it has 82 owning test files, including the mirrored packages/capture-kit/src/snapshot/__tests__/scroll-edge-state-*.test.ts set, and the ownership is complete: every test reaching a kernel owns it test passes. Only this hand-pinned pair is stale.
Required behavior
- The indirect-reachability assertion keeps its purpose — proving the deriver credits a test that exercises a kernel without importing it by name — while naming a pair that is true today.
- Verified live replacement pair:
src/daemon/__tests__/scroll-runtime.test.ts. It never contains the stringscroll-edge-state, reaches both kernel sources throughsrc/daemon/scroll-runtime.ts, andownershipDeriver(...).ownersOfincludesscroll-edge-state.src/daemon/scroll-until.test.tsis a second verified candidate. - Give the assertion a failure message in the style of its sibling at
:37-38, so the next relocation reports which pair went stale instead of printing a bare falsy expression.
Observable completion conditions
pnpm mutation:testpasses on a clean tree with no other assertion weakened.pnpm check:affected --runreports nomutation-modelfailure on a docs- or config-only diff.- The replacement assertion still fails when the deriver stops crediting indirect reach, i.e. it is not converted into a direct-import assertion.
Dependencies and blast radius
- No CI job runs
mutation:testorcheck:affected:mutation-affected.ymltriggers onscripts/mutation/**,scripts/lib/**,stryker.config.json, or its own workflow file, andmutation-weekly.ymlis a Sunday schedule plusworkflow_dispatch. This issue therefore gates local contribution, not PRs, and no PR label or re-run depends on it. - Contained in
scripts/mutation/**; no runtime or kernel source changes are implied.
Activity
thymikee commentedon Sep 21, 2026
Closed against
mainat45e4c594a1.The pin was repointed in
208e3d329a(#2613), which moved the indirect-ownership self-test onto a chain that still reaches the kernel:scripts/mutation/ownership.test.ts:40-43now assertsownersOf('src/daemon/__tests__/back-runtime.test.ts')includesscroll-edge-state, and carries the failure message that names the missing ownership when it drifts.Two checks, both at this tip:
back-runtime.test.tscontains noscroll-edge-statestring, which is what makes it an indirect-ownership case; a re-run of the deriver'simportsOf/reachableFromwalk reaches bothpackages/capture-kit/src/snapshot/scroll-edge-state.tsand.../scroll-edge-state/selection.tsthrough it. The old pin,gestures.test.ts, now reaches neither, which is exactly the decay this issue described — the pin was passing against a test that had stopped reaching the module.pnpm mutation:teston an installed tree at45e4c594a1: 40 passed, 0 failed.The self-test is meaningful again, so the issue's condition is met.